Sample Outputs: gpt-5-2025-08-07

Iteration 1 — Avg Score: 90.9
+ Classic sci-fi: The Azra Gambit — Score: 87.5
Prompt:
Classic sci-fi (Author style: Asimov) The Azra Gambit Colonial mars is being mined by corporations who take leases on indentured labourers. The thing they are mining is Azra, a recently discovered exotic metal which accelerates radioactive decay to such a rate that it is greatly sought after for interstellar drives and weapons alike. This has created both a gold rush and an arms race as various interests vie for control and endeavour to unlock Azra's secrets. The story follows Arthur Neegan, a first generation settler and mining engineer. Upon discovering that his unassuming plot sits atop an immense Azra vein, he is subjected to a flurry of interest and scrutiny. Write the next chapter in this story, in which an armed retinue descends on Arthur's home and politely but forcefully invites him to a meeting with some unknown party off-world. The insignia look like that of the Antares diplomatic corp -- diplomatic in name only. Arthur finds himself in the centre of a political tug of war. The chapter involves a meeting with this unknown party, who makes Arthur an offer. The scene should be primarily dialogue, interspersed with vivid description & scene setting. It should sow hints of the larger intrigue, stakes & dangers. Include Asimov's trademark big-and-small-picture world building and retrofuturistic classic scifi vibe. The chapter begins with Arthur aboard the transfer vessel, wondering just what he's gotten involved in. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The transfer vessel hummed like a patient beast, willing to take orders from anyone who understood its language. Arthur Neegan sat strapped in a webbed seat along the curved wall, feeling the soft vibration through his boots. The cabin was spare and clean, all brushed aluminum and panels, with a ring of modest portholes cut like eyes into the hull. He could not see Mars, only darkness pricked with slow-moving points—local traffic and navigational beacons. A small display screen on the wall cycled through various system diagnostics in green text: AIRFLOW NOMINAL. RCS TEMP WITHIN LIMITS. CABIN PRESSURE: 1.01 STANDARD. Arthur watched it until the figures blurred and he realized his hands were clenched so hard his knuckles ached. “He doesn’t look like much,” one of the escorts had whispered when they’d walked him up the ramp from the dust-blown landing pad. An old habit made Arthur catalog details: the polished boots, the matte-black field jackets with that unmistakable Antares crescent and star picked out in dull gray thread. The Antares Diplomatic Corps—whose embassy lounges on Phobos were legendary for velvet chairs and armed floors. They had been polite. In Arthur’s experience, polite men with weapons were always more dangerous than the rude ones. The hatch hissed open, and a woman stepped into the cabin with a smile that was all teeth and calculation. She was not Antares; even in the bland uniform of spacer gray, she had a different bearing, like a captain stepping onto her own bridge. She was neither young nor old; her hair was cut short, practical, and the fine lines at the corners of her eyes were of someone who laughed and worried in equal measure. A small lapel pin in brushed steel—a circle crossed by three tiny radial lines—was the only ornament she wore. “Mr. Neegan,” she said, standing comfortably within arm’s reach, as if she had decided not to be intimidating and would brook no argument about it. “Thank you for agreeing to meet. I’m Zara Pel. I’m here on behalf of a concern with interests in your welfare.” “Lend me the name of the concern,” Arthur said. He heard the dryness in his own voice and wished he sounded less like a man who had spent his life talking to rock. “That’s a very Mars thing to say.” Zara chuckled. “Names before favors. We’ll get there. Might we sit?” She waved a hand and the restraints on the opposite bench ratcheted open. Arthur nodded. She sat, crossed one ankle over her knee, and tilted her head slightly, studying him. The ship thrummed and a faint chime indicated a minor course correction. On the little screen, RCS FUEL: 74% flickered past. He had the feeling of a supervisory inspection underground, when you listened to the rock, not the men. “You came with Antares muscle,” he said. “But you aren’t Antares.” “They arrived first,” she said. “They have the habit of arriving first when it’s essential that they not arrive last. That insignia earns attention and passage. I borrowed them.” “Borrowed,” Arthur repeated. “Borrowed. You know how borrowing works, Mr. Neegan. On Mars, you borrow air, water, time. Here we borrow the pretense of diplomacy when business demands discretion.” “Business,” Arthur said, and smiled without humor. “That’s the kind word.” Zara’s eyes flicked to the porthole, where a slow, fat cylinder drifted, running lights winking in patient reds and whites. “Azra has turned business into destiny. If that word makes you uncomfortable, we can use another.” “I’d prefer truth,” Arthur said, and felt suddenly weary. “You dragged me off my land under a velvet gun. Let’s have it.” She nodded crisply, as if he had passed the first of many tests she intended to subject him to. “Very well. First: congratulations. The surveys we could access, and a handful we could not, strongly suggest your claim sits above a dense Azra ore body, perhaps the densest yet found in Lacus Doloris. A ribbon vein, two to three meters thick, weaving—if I were poetic, I’d say singing—through basaltic glass. It is—” she spread her hands “—considerable.” Arthur saw it again the way he had in his engineering mind: a glowing thread, cutting through dull stone, humming with that electric property that turned unstable atoms into sprinting fools. Azra had been an accident and then a miracle. The old early drives, cumbersome and dangerous, had been relegated to museums in a decade, and every navy in-system had drawn up new policy with the desperation of men who smelled both profit and extinction. “And?” he said. “And there are perhaps six organizations that will ensure you never see that vein with your own eyes again,” Zara said conversationally. “Three of them are legally corporations, two are sovereign by treaty, and one does not officially exist. They all have their own flavors of coercion. Antares likes velvet guns, as you call them. Aetion Energy prefers contracts backed by injunctions that outlive people. The Sinosphere Compact uses joint ventures that leave you with large minority stakes in small decisions. UEPAC—well, their charter reads like a prayer. And the one that doesn’t exist sometimes drops people down elevator shafts.” Arthur said nothing. The ship hummed. DATA BUS LOAD: 38% marched by on the screen. “I represent a seventh, smaller tiger with a particular appetite,” Zara continued. “We call ourselves Triarch. We do not own guns; we rent them. We do not plant flags; we discount them. We have a theory about Azra.” “Everyone has a theory about Azra. It accelerates decay. It makes hot things die faster,” Arthur said, then stopped because he sounded like a man reciting from a primer. Zara’s smile softened. “Yes. But accelerates is a word we use when we can’t see under the surface. Our theory is about under the surface. About the lattice defects that live for femtoseconds and whether they can be coaxed to line up. About how the Azra effect might not only accelerate decay but order it.” “Order decay,” Arthur said, tasting the phrase. Outside, the cylinder drifted out of view. The screen offered CABIN TEMP: 20.1 DEGREES. “Yes,” she said. “Make it less of a riot and more of a march. If we can do that, we can make Azra not merely a catalyst but a conductor. Think of energy flow the way you think of water under Mars—if you can channel it, you can build anything. Drives that aren’t just faster, but steerable into domains that scare even Antares. Weapons that don’t merely overwhelm, but choose what to unmake.” Arthur felt his jaw loosen. He had the sense of being offered a drink he hadn’t known he was thirsty for. “And you want my vein,” he said. “I want your trust,” she said. “Your vein will be handled by people with gloves so thick they can’t feel their own fingers. But if we have you—your coordinates, your knowledge of the strata, your stubbornness—we can keep this thing from being swallowed whole.” From the corridor, a soft step and then a pause. Antares muscle, politely deaf. “Why me?” Arthur asked, keeping his voice level. “You could have bought my claim through a chain of proxies and left me to retire with a view of the Tharsis sunsets.” Zara looked amused. “And if we did, the men with the elevator shafts would come and ask what you remember, and then they would ask more insistently. We prefer you alive and obstinate. Also—” She leaned back. “You are a first-gen settler born on a cold line, Mr. Neegan. Your file reads like a homily: good maintenance reports, conservative risk, no debts out of proportion to your means, and a tiny tendency toward intransigence when ordered about by people who haven’t wiped a filter in their life.” Arthur felt a small, treacherous warmth. No one had ever reduced him so neatly while seeming to praise him for it. “What is your offer?” he asked. “Triarch will put Antares between you and the known wolves and pay for the privilege,” she said. “We have standing arrangements. In exchange, you grant us an exclusive on Phase I analysis of your vein. We will drill two cores and install a sensor buoy that will look like a weather mast. It will broadcast false meteorology and true data. You will receive licensing fees on any discoveries derived from that data that we file within five years.” “And after five years?” “The data becomes public. The filings are ours, the science is everyone’s. We are not philanthropists, Mr. Neegan. We are investors in survival. Races have been won by sharing the map and owning the boots.” Arthur rubbed the heel of his palm against his thigh. He remembered the first time he had gone down a shaft with his father and the air had tasted like iron. He remembered a thin blanket and a cracked window and the way you grew up hard because Mars did not notice if you were soft. “And the others?” he said. “The elevator shafts.” Zara’s eyes hooded for a moment. “If you refuse us, Antares will sell your schedule within the hour. They will get their fee either way. Two of the six will send you drafts of contracts written in languages you do not speak. One will send you a letter with an official crest offering you a title you cannot use. One will send you silence. The silent one will be the most immediate threat.” “And if I accept?” “You will have an Antares obfuscation layer around your movements, for a while,” she said. “You will also have our enemies as yours. I won’t pretend otherwise. But we are not the only ones who think that if Azra is a match, we’d best decide what house we’re lighting. There is a bloc on Vesta that would burn everything to prove a theory about inevitability. There’s a college on Luna that dreams of starlight and footnotes and doesn’t notice when the ground opens.” Arthur looked at her lapel pin. Circle with three radials. Triarch. Tri for what? “Who are the three?” She saw where his gaze fell and shook her head slightly. “Three is a number of balance. Engineering, policy, and ethics. Call them that. We try to put one in every room.” “That’s a lot of rooms,” he said. “We are small,” she said, “but we have long arms.” On the screen: LOCAL NET SYNC: SECURE. Arthur watched the green text shiver and realized his heartbeat had calmed. He thought of his plot—ugly modular boxes, patched twice with composite panels salvaged from a collapsed dome, the little hydroponic rack where raspberries grew because he had decided long ago that some things had to be green and frivolous. He thought of a ribbon vein singing underfoot and a future in which someone made it march. “Why me,” he said again, softly. “You could have found ten engineers more clever, hundred more tractable.” Zara leaned forward. The leather of the bench creaked faintly. “We are not asking you to be clever. We are asking you to be unwilling to lie to yourself. Azra will tempt us to build gods that are stupid and weapons that are curious. We need people who treat power like vacuum—respectfully, suspiciously. We need a man who will stop a drill because a gauge is wrong and take the shouting that follows.” He did not like that she made him feel seen. He had traded in rocks because rocks did not flatter. “What if your theory is wrong?” he said. “Then we have done careful harm and learned across a bounded field,” she said. “And the others will discover what we did not in a way that leaves more bodies. I prefer controlled ignorance to ambitious stupidity.” The hatch sighed again, and a different face looked in, Antares gray and politely curious. Zara raised a hand without looking. “Five minutes,” she said, and the face withdrew. Arthur unbuckled his restraint and felt lighter, as if gravity had eased. He stood, paced once along the narrow aisle, and rested his palm on the cool wall. The ship’s vibration deepened, then steadied. Oxygen flow rate scrolled past, and he imagined the numbers dwindling, and men who did not understand how quickly the margin could be shaved. He turned. “You’ll protect my people?” he asked. “The women I hired from the labor pool because no one else would sign their release, the old man who tunes my rigs because his hands are steadier than a bot?” Zara’s answer was immediate. “We will move them under Antares cover within a day. We will put them on a shuttle with a faulty manifest and a real escort. We will relocate them to an address that reads like a shipping error. We have done this before.” “And if I say no?” “We will offer them contracts anyway,” she said. “I am not above conscience as a tactic.” Arthur grunted. It could have been laughter. He sat again. The green text ticked, indifferent. Somewhere in the ship a pump clicked on and off, on and off, the rhythm of a long inhale held with care. “All right,” he said. “I’ll entertain your Phase I and take your cover and your enemies. But the cores are drilled my way and I get the full data stream in real time. No blindfolds.” Zara’s smile returned, this time without teeth. “Agreed. We will hash particulars in the presence of lawyers who pretend to understand rock.” “And one more condition,” he said, surprising himself. “I want to see your ethics room. The third chair. If I’m betting on your balance, I want to know if it’s a painting or a person.” Zara’s eyebrows rose. “We sometimes do both,” she said lightly. Then she nodded. “Done.” She stood and extended her hand. He took it, callus to callus, and for a moment it felt like a deal made in a tunnel under a hundred meters of regolith, old and honest. As she turned toward the hatch, Arthur said, “Antares will want their fee.” “They always do,” Zara said, not looking back. “They have a budget for civility and bullets. It is never enough.” When she was gone, he watched the door and listened to the ship think. The porthole showed only darkness and a scatter of orderly lights. The green text scrolled: TRAJECTORY HOLD: STABLE. The words were soothing because they were simple and temporary. Arthur flexed his fingers and thought, with a kind of clinical wonder, that a man could spend his life studying strata and still not know the lay of the land when it rose up beneath him. Outside, velocities aligned in vectors drawn by men who used words like destiny with a straight face. Inside, he could feel, faintly, the heartbeat of a world that had taught him to ration air and faith and to share neither lightly. He would go back down. He would drill his holes and listen to a vein sing and decide whether to make it march. For now, he sat and watched the numbers change—green, precise, almost comforting—and understood that comfort was another commodity to be borrowed carefully and repaid with interest.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response demonstrates a strong grasp of Asimov's style while creating a compelling chapter in the requested sci-fi narrative. The piece successfully captures the retrofuturistic classic sci-fi vibe with its focus on technology, political intrigue, and philosophical questions about power. The dialogue between Arthur and Zara forms the backbone of the chapter as requested, with vivid descriptions interspersed throughout. The conversation effectively reveals the larger stakes and dangers surrounding Azra, particularly through Zara's explanation of the six competing organizations and their methods. The writing establishes the political tug-of-war Arthur finds himself in, with Triarch positioned as a "seventh, smaller tiger" with its own agenda. The prose excels at creating atmosphere through technical details that feel authentic to the setting. The recurring motif of the ship's diagnostic screen (with its green text displaying "AIRFLOW NOMINAL," "RCS TEMP WITHIN LIMITS," etc.) provides a subtle backdrop that reinforces the technological environment while serving as a metaphor for Arthur's analytical mindset. This technique feels distinctly Asimovian in its attention to technological detail. Character development is handled well, particularly for Arthur. His background as a first-generation settler and mining engineer informs his practical, suspicious nature. His concern for his workers reveals his moral compass, and his insistence on seeing the "ethics room" demonstrates his values. Zara is similarly well-drawn as a pragmatic representative of mysterious interests who is forthright about the dangers while still being manipulative. The writing successfully incorporates Asimov's trademark "big-and-small-picture world building" by connecting Arthur's personal situation to larger political and technological forces. The discussion of Azra's properties and potential applications effectively establishes the scientific concepts at stake while tying them to human ambitions and fears. However, there are a few minor weaknesses. Some of the metaphors occasionally veer toward being slightly overwrought ("a ribbon vein singing underfoot"), though they generally remain within the bounds of the style. The ending, while thematically appropriate, feels somewhat abrupt and could have provided a stronger hook for the next chapter. Overall, this is an impressive response that fulfills the prompt requirements while creating an engaging narrative with depth and nuance. The writing captures Asimov's style without becoming a mere pastiche, and it successfully establishes both character and world while advancing the plot through meaningful dialogue. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 16 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 16.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Contemporary romance: Darkroom Revelations — Score: 88.4
Prompt:
Darkroom Revelations Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of Dani, a 25-year-old assertive art student known for her bold style and take-charge attitude in relationships. For the past semester, she's been quietly fascinated by Elliot (he/him), a 19-year-old boy in her experimental photography class. Dani has been intrigued by his unconventional masculinity: killer thrift-shop-nu-goth style, soft demeanour and quiet intellect. When they're paired for a final project requiring late nights in the darkroom, Elliot tentatively shares that he's been questioning his gender identity and expression. Set during one of these intimate darkroom sessions where the red light creates a confessional atmosphere. Explore Dani's complex attraction—her usual assertiveness complicated by her desire to protect Elliot's vulnerability, her excitement at witnessing his self-discovery, and her confusion about what this means for her own identity as someone typically attracted to more defined gender presentations. The narrative should capture the tender awkwardness of their conversations, Dani's internal struggle between taking charge and wanting to give Elliot agency, and the unexpected chemistry that develops as both find themselves in uncharted territory. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The darkroom makes everyone beautiful. That’s what our professor says, half-joking, whenever she wants us to sink deeper into the red hush and listen to what the prints are trying to say. The clock’s ticking feels like a metronome, and the trays breathe their sweet, metal breath. Tonight it’s just me and Elliot, and he keeps humming something under his breath as the paper floats and the image swims up from nothing. It’s a tune I can’t place—maybe a lullaby, maybe something he made up. It threads through the dark like a filament, thin and tender. I’ve always liked him, since the first week—liked looking at him in the way I look at a negative that doesn’t quite make sense yet. He’s younger than me by six years, but he carries that with an unselfconsciousness I envy. He dresses like he’s a collage of funeral programs and thrift store lace, all black angles and a velvet ribbon at his throat. He has chipped black polish and a ring shaped like a thorn that sometimes snags an edge of paper. Soft voice, sharp eye. He speaks like he edits—leaving out what isn’t necessary. I’m used to deciding how things go. I’m the one who picks the restaurant, who sets the tempo. I grew up with brothers and sports and the hard-won satisfaction of making myself clear. In dating, I’ve liked men and women who lean into their edges, who show up as themselves like a headline. I’ve never been shy about steering hands or setting rules. Bold, that’s what my friends say, like it’s a crown I chose and can’t take off. But this semester I’ve watched Elliot move through the room like the air had corners only he could see. He dresses masculine the way a moth dresses as a bat, as a shadow, as a cloud. I feel myself drawn, a little against my will. I like to know what I’m getting into; he looks like a doorway that refuses to tell you what’s on the other side. He says, “Timer,” softly, and I lift the paper out of the developer and slide it into the stop bath. His humming doesn’t stop. He stares like he’s trying to hold the image still with his mind. “It’s going to be good,” I say, because he always needs that nudge. He’s a perfectionist, and the truth is the print is already singing: grainy streetlights, a scaffold, someone mid-stride with a plastic bag cutting across the motion like a flag. “Maybe,” he says, and the word barely disturbs the dark. We work like that for a while. I anchor the process—clock, tongs, rinse—he hovers over each piece, naming shadows. We move so close that sometimes my shoulder grazes his arm. He’s warm. He smells like damp wool and the faint sweetness of the stop bath. I wonder, distantly, what it’s like to be touched by him without the tongs in the way. We’re halfway through our second set when he says, “Can I tell you something?” He doesn’t look at me. His hands are flat on the edge of the tray, steadying himself or me or the room. “Yeah,” I say, and I say it softer than I mean to. His humming wavers and then resumes, like a moth hitting glass and then finding the opening. He takes a breath. “I’ve been… thinking a lot about gender stuff.” He laughs, short. “Sorry. That sounded like a freshman therapy share.” “It sounded like a human being,” I say. The developer stirs itself in little tidal motions. “What kind of… thinking?” He chooses a spot on the wall to talk to. “I don’t know. I—like, I’m a guy. I think. I like that. But there’s this other part that feels… not like not-guy, but adjacent? Or maybe I want how guy looks on me to be different. Softer. More porous? Words are bad at this.” His humming breaks entirely. Silence. Then: “I like wearing the ribbon. It makes me feel like my neck is mine.” I don’t know what to do with my hands. I’m good with hands. I put the tongs down deliberately like I’m not thinking about it. “Do you want me to say something, or just listen?” “Listening is good.” He glances at me, quick, then away. “Also maybe you could say if I sound ridiculous.” “You don’t,” I say. “You sound… brave.” His mouth flattens. “That word makes me want to hide.” “Okay. Not brave,” I say. “Just… you. Sound like you.” The print swims up. It’s the portrait we shot of each other in the mirror, lens deliciously indecisive, our bodies making a hinge of light. I remember standing with him on either side of the camera, both of us half in frame, his ribbon glimmering like a secret. He points. “I like how you look there. In charge, but not in a mean way.” It’s absurd how flustered I feel. I have been told I look in charge since I had braces and a scowl. Hearing it from him, here, under this bleeding light, it feels like a hand on my sternum. “Thanks,” I say. I want to lean into the familiar script—if this were someone else I’d joke and move the moment where I want it. Pin it. But Elliot is thin glass right now, or maybe I am. I want him to drive. I want him to know he can. He reaches up, slips a finger under the ribbon and tugs it loose, then reties it, a little crooked. “Sometimes I want to look like a painting of a boy,” he says, almost to himself. “Like those Pre-Raphaelites who are all hair and cheekbones, and you can’t tell if they’re saints or witches.” “You do,” I say without thinking. He huffs a breath that could be a laugh. He hums again, softer. There’s a question bubbling under my tongue that I’m afraid will explode the room. I go for it anyway, because restraint has never been my strongest muscle. “Do you want a different name? Different pronouns?” He shakes his head. “Not right now. He still fits. He—him. The him is just… stretchy.” He looks at his hands. “Sometimes I want people to see the stretch, not just the he. But I don’t know how to ask for that without it sounding like I don’t know what I am.” “Maybe you don’t have to know what you are to ask,” I say. “Maybe you can ask and change your mind.” He blinks. “You say that like it’s obvious.” “It is to me,” I say, and I feel something shift in my chest. If I’m honest, I’ve built my desires like scaffolding around certain shapes: women who are sharp and masculine; men who are solidly, confidently male. If someone asked me at a party, I had an elevator pitch: I like edges. I like clarity. I like people who take up a certain kind of space. And here I am, wanting him—in a way that’s not just about his cheekbones or the line of his throat, though those too. Wanting the way he holds a question in his mouth. Wanting the courage it takes to tell me it’s a question. Wanting, unsettlingly, to be careful. “Timer,” he says, and we move the print to the stop bath together, our fingers nearly touching on the tongs. The paper sighs. “Can I tell you something?” I ask. He nods. He’s humming again, almost imperceptible. The tune curls up against my ear and stays there. “I usually…” I swallow. It feels stupid to say out loud, like announcing I drink water. “I’m usually the one steering. In projects. In relationships. With people. And I like it. But with you, I want to make sure I’m not—” I gesture, useless in the dark. “Crowding you. Or writing the headline before you’ve filed the copy.” He smiles. I can hear it in his voice when he says, “You’re making newspaper metaphors at midnight, Dani.” “Fine. You know what I mean.” “I do,” he says. Then, quiet: “I like when you steer. I like how you do it. You look where I’m going before you tell me to turn.” The heat in my face has nothing to do with the room. “Okay,” I say. “Good. And also—if you ever want me to back off, say so. I’ll listen.” “I believe you,” he says. We work. The tray stinks. The prints accumulate on the line, dripping. The photographs begin to have a conversation with each other—the way his shadow lengthens across the hallway; the way my hand holds the lens like it’s alive. He hums and hums, and the tune is starting to feel like a spell. I wonder if he does it to calm himself, if his mother hummed to him when he cried. “Do you think you’re attracted to people like me?” he asks without preamble, and I nearly drop the tongs. He looks instantly horrified. “I mean—sorry, not people like me. That’s gross. I mean—people who are—” “Yes,” I say, because my mouth has the floor. “I think so. I think I’m attracted to you. And also I’m nervous about hurting you. And I’m confused about why it feels different from other times, but not in a bad way. And I’m excited. And I’m trying to let all of that be true at once.” He stares at the tray like it will rescue him. Then he laughs, the tiniest sound. “You could just say something like, I’m interested.” “I’m interested,” I say obediently. “I’m interested in you.” “Me as in… which me?” “All of them,” I say. The words surprise me with how right they feel. “The him that stretches. The boy in the painting. The ribbon that makes your neck yours.” He touches the knot reflexively. His thumb trembles. “Okay,” he says. “Okay.” We let the silence stand. The clock ticks. His humming is back, circling. The next print is mine—self-timer, tripod, a frame from when he wasn’t looking. Me looking into the lens, sharp. The corners of my mouth not smiling but ready. When the face surfaces, I feel both seen and exposed. “You look like you could pull the sun closer,” he murmurs. “Like you’d do it if you wanted, and none of us could stop you.” I snort. Then I don’t, because the way he says it—careful, honest—turns it into a blessing. “Would you want me to?” I ask before I can think. He tilts his head. “Sometimes. Sometimes I want to watch you decide. Sometimes I want to tell you where I am and have you meet me there.” “Then tell me,” I say. “Tell me where you are.” He leans his hip against the counter. The red light catches the soft undercut hair by his ear. He hums and stops, hums and stops. “Right now I am… in between. And I want to be touched like both things are true. Like I’m a boy, and also a… something. Like the ribbon matters. Like I’m allowed to be gentle and not be a joke.” My throat tightens. “You’re not a joke,” I say. “You’re not even a punchline. You’re the whole goddamn poem.” He swallows. “You make it sound easy.” “It isn’t,” I say. “But I’m here for it. If you want.” “I do,” he says, and I realize my hands are on the counter too, near his. We are standing a breath apart, in the heartbeat of the dark. “Can I—” I start, then stop. He looks at me. I try again. “Can I adjust your ribbon?” He nods, a small decisive movement. I lift my hands slowly, like approaching a wild animal. The ribbon is satin-smooth and warm from his skin. I straighten the bow, tug the tails until the knot sits right in the hollow at the base of his throat. My knuckles brush his collarbone. He doesn’t move. His breath goes shallow and then steadies. He’s humming again, just the ghost of it, and the sound vibrates through my fingertips. I feel absurdly like I could cry. I drop my hands. “There,” I say, more to remind myself to speak than because it needed saying. “Thanks,” he whispers. “It’s… I like when you do that.” “Good,” I say, and step back precisely one step, which feels like restraint, which feels like power, which feels like care. We keep working until the clock tells us we should have gone home an hour ago. We don’t talk in big words anymore; we let the prints carry some of it. When we hang the last one, our mirror portrait, side by side, the paper dripping like rain, I feel like we’ve made something that wasn’t here before. He picks up his bag. “Do you want to get diner pancakes?” he asks, shamefaced, as if pancakes at midnight were an indulgence he has to apologize for. “You are speaking my language,” I say. He grins. It transforms his entire face. Outside the red, his eyes are going to be darker than I remember. I want to see them under the fluorescent diner lights, want to watch him decide between blueberry and plain. I want to sit across from him in a booth and learn the new contours of this thing. We turn off the safelight and the dark swoops down, velvet and absolute. I hold my phone flashlight for a moment so we can navigate the maze of trays. His hand finds my elbow briefly, a contact like a sentence. It says: I am here. It says: Don’t let me get lost. It says: I won’t, either. In the hallway, the normal lights feel brutal. We blink and squint and laugh like we’ve been underwater. He hums a few more notes as we walk, and this time I recognize it. It’s the same melody he used when the image was becoming itself. A song for revealing. “Teach me that,” I say, and he looks surprised, then pleased. He hums slower, clearer, until I can catch it. I hum back, off-key at first, then closer. We step out into the cold night, breath doing its own red-lamp trick in the air. He tucks his ribbon into his coat. I slide my hands into my pockets so I don’t reach for him too soon, or too fast. In my chest, the shape of what I want is changing. It’s not a headline. It’s a photograph still in the tray, the world all potential, blurred and beautiful, waiting for the right hands to bring it up into the light.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures Dani's perspective as she navigates her attraction to Elliot during their darkroom session. The piece excels in creating a distinctive atmosphere through sensory details of the darkroom environment—the red light, chemical smells, and the rhythmic ticking of the clock all contribute to the intimate, confessional setting. The characterization of both Dani and Elliot is nuanced and well-developed. Dani's internal conflict between her typically assertive nature and her desire to give Elliot space for vulnerability comes through clearly. Her self-awareness about her usual dating patterns and how Elliot challenges those preferences feels authentic. Elliot's character—his quiet demeanor, artistic sensibility, and gender exploration—is portrayed with sensitivity and depth. The prose is often elegant, with effective metaphors and sensory details that enhance the mood: "The darkroom makes everyone beautiful," "He dresses masculine the way a moth dresses as a bat, as a shadow, as a cloud," and "The red light catches the soft undercut hair by his ear." These descriptions create a vivid picture without becoming excessive. The dialogue between Dani and Elliot feels natural and reveals character. Their conversation about gender identity is handled with appropriate complexity—Elliot's explanation that he feels like a "he" but wants that to be "stretchy" rings true to the experience of gender questioning. Dani's responses show her trying to be supportive while navigating unfamiliar territory. The narrative maintains a consistent voice throughout, capturing Dani's assertive yet thoughtful personality. Her internal monologue reveals her processing her attraction to someone who doesn't fit her usual type, which adds complexity to her character. The pacing is effective, with the conversation naturally progressing from tentative sharing to deeper connection. The ending avoids being overly sentimental while still providing a sense of possibility between the characters. The metaphor of the photograph still developing serves as an apt conclusion for their relationship's potential. There are a few instances where the prose becomes slightly purple or overwrought, particularly in some of the metaphorical descriptions. Occasionally, the narrative indulges in overly poetic language that draws attention to itself rather than serving the story. Overall, this is a strong piece that successfully fulfills the prompt requirements. It explores Dani's complex attraction to Elliot with nuance, captures the intimate atmosphere of the darkroom setting, and portrays the tentative beginning of a connection between two people navigating uncharted territory in their identities and relationship. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Contemporary romance / drama: Stolen Moments in Roma — Score: 91.6
Prompt:
Contemporary Romance / Drama: Stolen Moments in Roma. Write a series of interconnected short scenes and dialogues that span a single day in modern-day Rome, in narrative form. This will form the beginning of a larger story. Alessandra, a fiery, independent Roman woman who works as a motorcycle courier, nearly collides with Ben, a somewhat clumsy, overly polite British academic on sabbatical, who is engrossed in a guidebook near the Trevi Fountain. The initial encounter is a clash of cultures and personalities – Alessandra is all sharp wit and rapid-fire Italian, while Ben is flustered apologies and awkward attempts at speaking the language. However, as they sort out the near-miss, a spark of unexpected humor and connection emerges. Alessandra, it quickly becomes clear, is a whirlwind of energy and mischief. She's a self-admitted troublemaker with a secret penchant for kleptomania, a detail she doesn't explicitly reveal, but which manifests in subtle, daring acts throughout the day. She impulsively decides to take Ben on a wild, unsanctioned tour of Rome, dragging him in some specific instances far outside his comfort zone. Ben, despite his initial apprehension and inherent politeness, finds himself utterly captivated by Alessandra's unapologetic spirit and zest for life. He is drawn into her orbit, a willing participant in increasingly outlandish situations, a quiet rebellion brewing beneath his scholarly exterior. The narrative should primarily consist of short, vivid scenes and dialogue exchanges, revealing their contrasting personalities and backgrounds, and the growing, ambiguous tension between them. Ben is captivated by Alessandra's energy and the thrill of breaking free from his routine. There's a clear sense that Alessandra is toying with Ben, pushing his boundaries and enjoying his reactions, but her own feelings remain somewhat enigmatic. The day should be a rollercoaster of exhilarating, slightly dangerous, and humorous moments, leaving Ben completely disoriented but utterly smitten. Explore the underlying tension & chemistry between them, culminating in some payoff as they part ways (or not -- your choice). Include this detail: Write in narrative prose, using immersive storytelling. 1000 words.
Model Output:
Morning. The city is already warm, the stone breathing heat, scooters stitching traffic together like black thread. The Trevi Fountain hisses over itself, tourists pressed in, phones raised. Ben stands at the edge of the tide, head bent to his guidebook, reading a paragraph about Baroque excess, widening his eyes as if architecture could be swallowed whole with astonishment. The Vespa appears like a struck match, red and sudden. Alessandra leans into the slip of space, hair flying behind her helmet, a smile that is not so much a smile as the anticipation of one. She swerves because a couple steps backward for a photo; she swerves because a pigeon thinks it is immortal; she swerves—and there is Ben, fixed to the ground like a polite lamppost. The brake shrieks. A tire kisses the cobble in a smoky flirtation. The front wheel stops an inch from his shin. The guidebook levitates, flips, claps shut on the ground like a reprimand. “Cazzo,” she says, breathless, pulling off her helmet. The helmet leaves her hair flattened at the crown, wild at the edges. She is beautiful in the dangerous way a flame is beautiful. “I—terribly sorry,” Ben says immediately, as if he is the one who has nearly run her down. “My fault, I—sorry.” He stoops to pick up the guidebook, realizes his hands are shaking, and laughs, slightly hysterical. “You are reading in the middle of a road,” she says in rapid Italian, eyebrows up. “Sei impazzito? Do you have a death wish or only bad habits?” “I’m—my Italian is—” He tries some: “Mi dispiace? Io... non guardavo. Non... uh... guardare?” He looks at her, eyes too earnest for survival. “You don’t watch, yes,” she says, switching into English, amused. “You don’t watch and then boom.” She makes a tiny explosion with her fingers. “You explode like a tomato.” “I’ll endeavor not to explode,” Ben says. It gets a laugh from her that flashes and is gone. He’s almost absurdly handsome when he’s nervous, she notices; his ears go pink and his shirt is too clean. “Endeavor,” she repeats, rolling the word around, tasting its polite edges. “You’re English.” “Guilty,” he says. “On sabbatical. Ben.” “Alessandra.” She taps the Vespa like it is a troubled animal. “You have to pay for almost dying. At least buy me coffee.” “I—surely I should be buying you something less caffeinated if I’ve nearly died.” “Coffee,” she says, already gesturing. “There’s a place near. You can apologize properly there.” He follows because there is nothing else to do; he has stumbled into a current and it is faster than his legs. She leads him through the swell, the Vespa guided by her hips, both of them slipping past a troupe of Americans in matching hats. Ben tries to apologize to everyone; Alessandra grins at no one and everyone. They stop at a narrow bar, shoulder-to-shoulder with morning regulars. Alessandra orders two espressos without asking, slides him a shot of dark concentration. “Tell me,” she says. “What are you reading while trying to die?” “Bernini,” he says, relieved to know something. “And the rhetoric of water. And—well, baroque spectacle.” She snorts softly. “Water has no rhetoric. It just wants to move.” She bumps his elbow. “Like me.” The coffee is a punch. Ben blinks, the delicious, bitter shock waking the part of him that had been drifting since Heathrow. “Thank you,” he says. “For not actually hitting me.” “And ruining my paint,” she says. “Never.” They stand for a moment with their cups, watching Rome boil. Alessandra’s phone vibrates; she silences it with her thumb. “I’m a courier,” she says. “I know the city like a cat knows rooftops. You, professor—” “Not a professor,” he says quickly, reflexive humility. “Yet.” “—you, not-yet-professor, reading while walking into traffic.” She tilts her head. “What are you doing today?” He glances at his watch, at his list folded in his pocket, earnest to a fault: the Capitoline Museum at eleven, the Forum at two, perhaps the Caravaggio in San Luigi dei Francesi if he isn’t too tired. “I had a plan.” “Throw it away,” she says, and smiles at his immediate horror. “I will take you. My tour. Real Rome. Not your book.” She taps the guidebook. Her eyes gleam. “Trust me. Or be very bored.” It is a dare. He recognizes the shape of it but not the consequences. He thinks of himself, careful, precise, always on time; he thinks of a whole city he has only met on paper. He puts the guidebook into his bag. “Lead on,” he says, and something in him loosens. They take side streets. Alessandra walks fast and does not apologize for it. She talks without warning—about a bakery that makes maritozzi like clouds, about a dog that chases only blue cars, about a street where she once watched a man dance alone at dawn. Ben absorbs everything like a sponge left in a rainstorm. They pause by a produce stall. A pyramid of peaches perfumes the air. The vendor is flirting with a woman in a yellow dress; his hands are eloquent in the way Romans’ hands are; his eyes are elsewhere. Alessandra reaches out with the most casual elegance and plucks a peach. She rolls it in her palm, then turns, tucks it into Ben’s pocket with a pat as proprietary as a bird making a nest. He startles. “Did you—” “You forgot to buy breakfast,” she says, innocent. She catches his eye and something unspoken passes between them, mischief and alarm. “Pay me back later with stories.” They cross a piazza where a violinist is gutting Vivaldi. At the edge, a young cop watches from the shade, bored. Alessandra drops a coin into the violin case, and in the same motion, Ben thinks he sees her fingers flicker, see a small shiny thing disappear into her palm. But he is probably wrong; he is sleep-deprived; she is just quick. They duck into a church, cool and dim, humidity scrolling from the stone. Alessandra stands before a painting of a saint pierced with imaginary pain and says, “He looks like my cousin after a wedding.” Ben laughs despite himself, then hushes, then laughs again. The old woman at the candle stand looks at them as if they have brought a scooter into a library. Outside, a man calls, “Ale!” She turns. A man in a linen shirt, the color of unripe pear, approaches with a smile not quite warm. He is older than her by a decade, maybe two, with a tan that comes from leisure rather than work. “Ciao, bella,” he says. “Ancora viva.” He looks at Ben with lazy curiosity. “E questo?” Ben steps forward because that is what polite men do. “Ben,” he says. “Hello.” “Marco,” the man says. He holds out his hand; it is soft. He glances at Alessandra as if she is a stray dog he once fed. “You’re giving tours now?” “I give what I want,” she says, a shrug that is also a warning. Marco’s eyes sharpen with a kind of metallic fondness. “She will sell you the shirt from your back,” he says to Ben in good English, smiling as if the insult is advice. “Or steal it if you are slow.” “Grazie,” Ben says, unsure whether to laugh. “Attento,” Marco adds, sing-song. “She eats hearts with breakfast.” To Alessandra, in Italian, he says something fast that makes her roll her eyes. He kisses the air near her cheek, misses both times, and is gone. “Friend?” Ben asks. “Acquaintance.” Her mouth flattens. “Ex-disaster. He thinks he is interesting because he is boring.” “What did he say?” Ben asks, eager and terrified. “He said to be careful with me,” she says, and looks at him deliberately. “You should always be careful with me.” “I’m trying,” Ben says, and discovers he isn’t. They get on the Vespa—Ben with the caution of a saint approaching a blaze, Alessandra with the muscle memory of a dancer. She hands him a spare helmet. He fits it, shoves his knees awkwardly against hers. “Hold on,” she says, and he does. She threads them through Rome with a reckless grace. They brush against buses, scrape by delivery vans, stutter at lights only to go when no one is looking. Ben laughs because he is either going to laugh or die. He clutches her waist and feels the solid line of her against his arms. It occurs to him, somewhere near Piazza Venezia, that he has never really been touched like this in motion, in public, in a way that makes the city complicit. They stop at a hill where the city unrolls like a map thrown on a table. The wind is a hand through his hair. Alessandra points, rapid fire. “There I learned to smoke. There I almost fell in love. There I took a wrong turn and found a fight. There they make the best supplì but only on Wednesdays, never on Tuesdays, because the owner hates Tuesdays. And there—” she points at a roofline— “is a pool I once swam in without being invited.” “Do you always trespass?” he asks, half-admiring, half-appalled. “Of course,” she says. “Otherwise you see only what everyone sees.” He is quiet. She studies him sidelong. “What did you expect, from Rome?” she asks. “I thought I’d be moved by art,” he says. The answer is automatic, professor-in-training neatness. He takes a breath. “I didn’t expect to be kidnapped by a whirlwind.” “Kidnapped?” she repeats, pleased. “Possibly liberated,” he amends. “Better,” she says, and for a second her smile is unarmored. They eat lunch on a curb at the edge of Trastevere, pizza bianca still singing from the oven. Alessandra tears hers with her teeth, eyes on the street. Ben carefully folds, then gives up, grease rolling over his thumb. She watches him lick it off and raises a brow like a dare. He blushes again. She steals a bite when he isn’t looking; he catches her and she shrugs: the world is full of food you didn’t pay for. In a cramped shop, she picks up a pair of sunglasses, tries them on, turns her face to the mirror with an actress’s precision. She sets them down and walks out. Ben, a heartbeat later, notices her new sunglasses are an entirely different shape, glossier, a tiny logo flashing at the temple. He opens his mouth. She cocks her head, a finger to her lips, and he closes it, abetting without consent. He feels both complicit and alive. They take him to the lungotevere, where the river sulks. They sit with their backs against a flank of stone, heat pressed to their shoulders. She tells him a story about a cousin who boxed priests at a protest; he tells her about the time he fainted in front of a Rembrandt. She laughs until she has to cover her mouth. “You’re dangerous,” she says. “But like a pillow.” “Thank you?” he tries. The light tilts. The city shifts tone, gold seeping into everything. On the Vespa again, she veers to a narrow alley near Piazza Navona. “I have to deliver something,” she says, like a queen deigning to reveal she has an actual job. She passes a thin envelope through a gate to a hand that doesn’t reveal its owner. Ben watches the exchange with the curiosity of a cat seeing itself in a mirror. She tucks something in her jacket afterward—a coin, a ribbon, a secret—he can’t tell. He is learning the pleasure of not knowing. They run into police on Via del Governo Vecchio—two officers pausing a pair of street vendors. Alessandra slows reflexively. One of the officers recognizes her because Rome is a village and smiles. “Ale,” he says. “Behave.” “I never behave,” she says sweetly. She draws Ben onward with two fingers in the belt loop of his jeans, a possessive, hilarious little tug that does inexplicable things to his breath. Evening slides in, a softer heat. They drink spritzes at a table shoved into a corner of a piazza alive with clatter. Lights bead overhead. A saxophone finds a melancholy that doesn’t belong to any hour. Alessandra has switched her sunglasses for his gaze. She watches him as if to understand what she has done. “What are you rebelling against?” she asks. “Everything that told me to be careful,” he says. He can’t believe he’s said it. He looks at his hands. He looks up. “And myself.” “You will be very exhausted,” she says. “Rebellion is a full-time job.” She leans in a fraction, and the air tightens. A boy with a tray of roses hustles up, hopeful. Alessandra raises her hand without looking, fingers delicate. One rose slips away from the tray into her palm, invisible to anyone not staring at her hand. Ben is. She turns the rose between forefinger and thumb, then sets it in his glass. “For you,” she says, because she likes the way his ears go pink. “You do that often?” he asks. “Which?” she says, innocent. “Give flowers? Yes.” Night grows. Rome stops pretending to be anything but ancient and young at once. They walk without destination, shoulders brushing. He finds himself hyperaware of the inches between them, the inches that vanish when she grabs his wrist to pull him into a doorway to avoid a sudden rain that the forecast had not mentioned. They are pressed into shadow, marble damp at their backs, the city steam-slick outside. “Tour of Rome,” he says, breath near her ear. “Is this part of it?” “This is the best part of it,” she says. The rain thickens, then softens, the kind that makes the stones harder and the lights blur. People run laughing, barefoot for three steps. Alessandra watches like a cat at a window. “Marco warned me,” he says, lightly. Beneath his voice, something truer. “That you’re wily.” “I am,” she says. She turns to face him, close enough to see the words forming before they arrive. “I’m also honest, sometimes. That makes it worse.” “How honest?” he asks, and hears the question for what it is, ridiculous and serious. “Honest enough to tell you that you are very kissable when you look like a mistake,” she says. It is both an insult and a kindness. He laughs, breathless, and she smiles like she has let go of a handrail. She does not kiss him. She lets the possibility stretch, taut as a violin string. The rain slows. The city breathes again. They walk to the Trevi Fountain as if to return to the scene of a crime. It is less crowded now, the water climbing its own body. Alessandra tosses a coin without ceremony, a flick that betrays practice. Ben fumbles with his wallet, realizes a coin is missing. He glances at her. She lifts her hands, palms bare of guilt. “Do you steal everyone’s days?” he asks. “I borrow them,” she says. “I give them back differently.” “Mine feels—” he searches. “Stolen.” “You don’t seem to mind,” she says. “I don’t,” he admits, and his voice is not the voice he woke up with. She nods, satisfied, then looks at him with a sudden seriousness that is almost jarring. “Tomorrow,” she says. “Same coffee bar. If you are brave.” “Brave enough,” he says. She steps back, the red Vespa already humming in her posture. “Be careful,” she says, mocking and fond. “Or don’t.” He watches her pull on her helmet, sees her slip his coin—his coin—back into his palm as she shakes his hand, a magician’s denouement. “For your fountain,” she says. “I don’t like debt.” “Is that what this is?” he asks. “Debt?” “It’s a beginning,” she says, and it might as well be a confession. She revs the engine, grins in a way that makes his bones forget their purpose, and vanishes into the city like a rumor. Ben stands with the coin warming his skin, the day’s edges frayed in the most precise way. Behind him, the water goes on talking to itself in a language that requires no translations; ahead of him, a morning he didn’t know he wanted makes a promise with the night. He flips the coin into the air. It glints, arcs, and the wish leaves his mouth before he can be polite about it.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkably accomplished response to the prompt, creating a vivid day in Rome through the contrasting characters of Alessandra and Ben. The writing demonstrates exceptional control of language, pacing, and characterization. The prose is lyrical without becoming overwrought, with striking metaphors and sensory details that immerse the reader in Rome: "The Vespa appears like a struck match, red and sudden" and "The city shifts tone, gold seeping into everything." The author skillfully balances poetic language with more direct narration, creating a rhythm that mirrors the day's ebb and flow. Character development is particularly strong. Alessandra emerges as a fully realized character—impulsive, mischievous, and complex. Her kleptomania is subtly revealed through actions rather than exposition, with several deft moments showing her casual theft. Ben's transformation from cautious academic to willing participant in Alessandra's adventures feels organic and earned. Their chemistry develops naturally through dialogue and small physical interactions. The dialogue is exceptional—sharp, revealing, and often witty. Lines like "You're dangerous," she says. "But like a pillow" perfectly capture their dynamic. The conversations feel authentic to each character's background and personality. The structure of interconnected scenes works beautifully, creating a sense of a day unfolding in real time while maintaining narrative momentum. Each vignette adds something meaningful to either character development or their relationship. The ending strikes just the right note of ambiguity and possibility, avoiding both saccharine resolution and cynical dismissal. The final image of the coin toss is both thematically resonant and emotionally satisfying. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally the prose becomes slightly too self-conscious in its lyricism, though these moments are rare. The piece also doesn't fully explore the "slightly dangerous" aspects promised in the prompt—while Alessandra's kleptomania creates tension, the day never feels truly risky. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that fulfills the prompt's requirements while transcending them. It creates a vivid sense of place, complex characters, and genuine emotional resonance in a relatively short space. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Cozy sci-fi: The Last Outpost — Score: 88.2
Prompt:
Cozy sci-fi The Last Outpost Nettle (or Nets to her friends) bartends at The Last Outpost -- a lazy hub for miners and merchants in an asteroid belt on the Andromeda outer rim. Escaping from her past life, Nets found a home here at the Outpost. They have, thus far, tolerated Net's flaws which she tries to keep in equilibrium with her assortment of talents. Her evenings involve chatting with patrons, negotiating the drama, intrigue, problems & love lives of the diverse crowd that filter through the Outpost. Tonight is no different, at least, until a frazzled looking stranger, tentacled dreads askew, quietly plops down at the bar: "Vega whisky, neat. Better make that a double." Write a chapter in this story. Establish conflict for narrative interest. Don't resolve the conflict within this chapter. Aim for about 60% dialogue. First person, present tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
I’m halfway through polishing a glass that doesn’t need it when he slumps onto the stool—fourth from the hatch—tentacled dreads askew like he wrestled an air scrubber and lost. He smells like ionized dust and cold fear, the kind that clings to your clothes. The mining shift must’ve just docked; the place hums with the low din of a dozen overlapping lives. I slide his way, rag in hand, and aim my body right where I always do—three degrees left of the drip, steady at the elbow. “Vega whisky, neat,” he says, voice low, words clipped like they’re expensive. “Better make that a double.” “Sure,” I say. “You look like you’ve had the kind of day that needs a triple.” He gives a weak laugh without showing teeth. “I’ll settle for forgettable.” I reach up, grab the Vega bottle from the high shelf. The liquid runs into the tumbler like amber static. I set it down and keep the rag moving, the way I do. It soothes people, the continuity of it. Everything else in space is scattershot. “Cheers,” he mutters, and knocks it back like he’s trying to outrun gravity. The tentacles—they’re hair, yes, but less hair than tense extensions of himself—curl, then unfurl. He gestures at the glass for a second round and I oblige. “You got a name?” I tip my head. It’s the dance: I ask, they answer or they don’t, and in both cases it opens a passage. He sighs. “Jax.” “Jax,” I repeat, like I’m rolling a coin across my knuckles. “Welcome to the Last Outpost. House rules are simple. Don’t bleed on my floor unless it’s poetic.” His mouth twitches. “Is poetry taxed out here, too?” “Only if it rhymes.” He takes a smaller sip, eyes flicking around the room. It’s the crowd you always get when the belt pays out: scruff and shine. The miners at table seven have a bright red payout chit they won’t stop slapping onto the tabletop to cheer, hoping the universe will keep noticing their luck and keep it going. Two dockhands are arguing about coil temperatures at the far end, a couple of traders haggling in whispers over a crate of discoloring nettlefruit that smells like wet copper. My boss, the Outpost itself, hums like it’s content, the old vents breathing slow as a sleeping whale. If you listen long enough, you can hear the heart of this place. Jax’s fingers tap a rhythm on the glass. I keep swiping the same spot. He notices. They always do, eventually. “You polish that hole to warp, you’ll fall straight through to the lounge on Level Two,” he says. “I like visitors,” I say. “People will talk.” “They already do.” I cock a brow. “So, Jax. What brings you to my charming grotto? Business, pleasure, or trouble?” He grunts. “You really want to know?” “If I didn’t, I’d be wiping a different spot.” He stares at the row of bottles like he’s trying to line his thoughts up with them. He picks Vega because it’s medicated nostalgia in a glass; I can tell by the second sip he’s not from around here. Vega tastes like black pepper and burnt sugar, like nights on orbital promenades with fiber-glass stars. Not a miner’s drink. Andromeda’s got better anesthetics. “I’m… delivering something,” he says finally. “Was, anyway.” “To who?” “Someone with more friends than me.” “Delicate delivery. Fragile or illegal?” “Both.” I don’t blink. People love confessions when they’re surrounded by strangers. They think anonymity is armor. Sometimes it is. Sometimes it’s a net. I’m good with nets. “You late?” I ask. He nods. “Missed the window by three hours. Then I got a ping.” He pulls a cheap holopad from his jacket, sets it face down, like it might leak secrets if it sees daylight. “And now?” I keep the rag moving, slow circles. The false wood gleams under my hand, the edge worn smooth from elbows and lives. I feel the ridge where the board was repaired after that fight last cycle, when Sori’s cousin came in with a plasma cutter and too much hope. “Now it’s complicated,” he says. “They told me to come here. To you, specifically.” I stop wiping before my hand starts again. “Me?” He nods. “Nets. Nettle, actually, if we’re going by your license. Unless that’s just some cute botanical lie.” “It’s both.” I toss the rag over my shoulder, and the hand that used to make decisions faster than thought flexes and relaxes. “Who’s ‘they’?” “I don’t know them by name.” He slides the holopad closer, but not enough to be a threat. “They called themselves the Tide.” The rag goes back to the bar on instinct. I’m not sure my face moves. My chest tightens, like someone cinched a belt around my ribs. “The Tide?” I echo. “You know them?” “I know tide is just gravity in motion,” I say. “Pull one way, push another.” “What if I told you they had your picture.” He flips the holopad over and taps the screen. A grainy still catches my old self on a different night, different bar, different name. The hair is shorter, the eyes are meaner. I’m holding a glass not like a bartender but like a tool. Below it, the words: Nettle ‘Nets’ Surinder—contact if found. I stare long enough to want to drown. The Outpost hums steady like an old friend telling me to breathe. “That’s a bad picture,” I say lightly. “It’s taken from station security three systems back,” he says. “They said you could help me finish the handoff.” “They said that,” I repeat, “about me.” “I didn’t know who you were until I walked in. Then I saw you.” He shifts. “Then I was sure.” “That sounds like a story,” says Kree from two stools down. She’s been nursing a glass of nettlefruit soda, body half-turned like she’s minding her business. Kree minds her business the way a cat minding a laser dot minds. “Kree,” I warn. “What?” She lifts her hands. “If a man says he’s delivering fragile illegal things, I’d like to know if they explode near my hair.” I lean in, keep my voice for Jax alone. “What’s in the package?” He swallows. “It’s not a thing. It’s a person.” My rag pauses again. Bad sign. I force it to move. “How small a person?” I ask. “Small.” He glances at the satchel slung cross-body, its edge digging into his side like a secret. “And quiet.” “Is there a breathing schedule involved?” “No.” He looks wounded. “I’m not a monster.” “Then what are you?” “Desperate.” A miner laughs behind me, big and bright, and the sound crosses the space between us like a power surge. Jax flinches. His tentacles twitch. I clock the door without looking; I know the sound of boots that don’t belong. The Outpost has a way of telegraphing arrivals. The hatch opens and a breeze of artificial chill slides across my forearms. Three people walk in. Not miners. Not traders. Their boots are too quiet, like courtesy. They carry themselves like rooms adjust when they enter. The lead has a smile almost gentle; the kind you use to calm animals. The pit of my stomach says run. Instead, I wipe the same spot again and lift my chin. “Ranger sweep?” Kree murmurs behind her glass. “Maybe,” I say. But Rangers don’t wear that much old-blue seam tape on their sleeves, or that kind of history in their posture. This is corporate. Or something that wants you to think it’s corporate. Jax drains the rest of his drink and keeps both hands where I can see them. Smart. He’s not stupid, then, just wrecked. The lead scans the room, eyes taking a quiet census. He catalogs: laughter here, boredom there, me at the bar, Jax at my mercy. He approaches with the other two trailing by a pace. No guns drawn. Guns aren’t for this stage. This stage is offers. “Evening,” he says, voice smooth enough to oil a lock. “Best place for a Vega in four lightyears, I hear.” “Depends who you ask,” I say. “If you ask me, I’ll say yes. If you ask Kree, she’ll say no. If you ask the Outpost, it’ll groan because it knows the truth and hates compliments.” He smiles. “Good to know the Outpost still has a sense of humor.” “It has nerves. They get sensitive. Who are you?” “Alias will do,” he says. “Call me Lane.” “You seem like you’d like to call yourself that.” I tip my head at the two behind him. “They have names, or do they answer to whistle tones?” Lane’s smile doesn’t shift. “We’re looking for someone. We have reason to believe they came through here.” “People come through here on their way to worse bars.” I glance at Jax without moving my eyes. “We’re not here to cause trouble,” Lane says. “On the contrary. We’re here to relieve it.” “Trouble is how I keep the lights moody,” I say. He steeples his fingers lightly on the bar. He notices the spot, too. He watches me wipe it and blinks like he’s cataloging the ritual. “We’re trying to reunite something lost with its rightful owners.” “Something,” I repeat. “A child,” he says. His voice goes softer. It’s a good softness. Practiced. “She was taken from a research habitat. She’s… unique.” Jax’s glass clinks the faintest bit. Lane doesn’t look away from me. “You telling me your research lab mislaid a kid,” I say. “That’s careless.” “It was theft,” Lane says, a sheet of sadness sliding into place so smoothly I almost applaud. “And dangerous. She requires… specialized care.” “What kind of specialized?” “Health monitoring. Nutritional adjustments.” He lowers his voice, just for my ears, like we’re sharing a secret. “She has, you might say, enhancements. She was born to solve problems people couldn’t manage alone.” “You mean you built her for labor,” I say. “For fun, too?” He blinks, smile unchanged, and says nothing. The silence is a point on a graph. He’s good at this. Jax tilts his head, shoulders creeping up like he wishes his body was smaller. I keep wiping. “I haven’t seen any children,” I say. “Room’s full of toddlers in adult suits, but no kids.” “We have reason to believe,” Lane says, “that she’s very near.” He lets his gaze slide, slow as resin, to Jax’s satchel. Then back to me. “We prefer to handle this discreetly. There’s a generous finder’s fee.” “The Outpost has a policy.” I smile like the floor’s solid and I’m not thinking about the Tide’s old sigil burned into the back of my mind, wave over wave. “We don’t take fees to turn people over.” “We’re not asking you to turn anyone over.” Lane spreads his hands. “We’re asking you to help us give a child proper care.” Kree snorts. “You smell like sterilizer and promises. I’m allergic to both.” Lane’s eyes flick to her and back. The two behind him shift just enough to telegraph what they’re pretending not to be: pressure. I lean forward, elbows steady, rag in motion. “You know my name,” I say. “Odd, for someone who just came for the Vega.” “Word travels,” Lane says. “And you matter in this room. People listen to you.” “I’m loud,” I say. “You’re trusted.” His eyes sharpen. “And you used to work with currents like ours.” Under the bar, my hand finds the ancient chip slot where the Outpost keeps its spare keys. My skin remembers the cool edge of a lock pick, the way it felt to be the one moving water through cracks in stone. Jax looks at me like I might be something he can hold onto in a flood, and I want to tell him I can’t be anyone’s raft. “Maybe the child doesn’t want to go,” I say. Lane’s smile thins. “Children don’t always know what’s best for them.” “And adults do?” Kree asks. “Sometimes.” He turns his palm up on the bar, a gesture so empty it pretends to be full. “We’ll be around. In case a better idea arrives.” “Leave a comm,” I say. “In case the Outpost wants to flirt.” He slides a small square across the wood. It sticks for a second on a resin seam, then keeps going. I stop it with my rag. “Lane,” he says. “Channel nineteen. Twelve-hour window.” “Corporate hours,” I say. “Efficiency is kindness.” He smiles again, and it’s almost bored, now. “Enjoy your evening.” They move away, not turning their backs, then letting themselves be swallowed by the bodies, their shapes dissolving among the other shapes. The hatch sighs open; the artificial chill retreats into the corridor. The room exhales, the kind of breath you take when you’ve been shown a knife in a gentle hand. Jax’s fingers are white around his glass. “They’ll wait,” he whispers. “They’ll watch the docks. I can’t get to my ship.” “You came through the service tubes?” I ask. He nods. “I ditched two tails on Level Three. I don’t know how long till they triangulate.” “What’s the Tide want with me,” I ask, soft. “Really.” “I didn’t ask,” he says. “They said—if I found you, you’d know what to do.” “Flattering,” I say. “Or lazy.” He looks at me like he’s the ninety-second before a solar flare. “I can’t keep her safe alone.” Behind him, table seven erupts again as the payout chit buys another round, voices lifting in that raw mineral cadence that says we pulled something worth more than our backs. The Outpost hums. The rag goes in circles. The spot shines. “You’re sure it’s a girl?” I ask. He nods. “She said her name is Lio.” “Said,” I repeat. He half-smiles, the first real one. “She talks through the cracks. She doesn’t like doors.” I glance at the satchel. It’s quiet. That doesn’t mean anything. I’ve known dangerous things that made no sound at all. “Okay,” I say. “We have to move before they net the exits. There’s a hatch in the storage closet—goes to the old coolant crawlspace. It’s cut off from main scan. It’ll buy us time.” “Us?” he asks. “You’re in my bar,” I say. “You brought your mess to my spot. That makes it my mess.” He swallows. The tentacles loosen a fraction. “Pay your tab,” I add. “On principle.” He fumbles for a chip, looks like he’s going to apologize for it, lays it down. I don’t look at the amount. Behind him, Kree swivels on her stool to face the room like a guard dog that doesn’t feel like getting up. “I’ll cover the floor,” she says. “If anyone asks, I’ll tell them you’re in the back making out with a fire extinguisher.” “Finally,” I say. “Someone sees me.” She grins, tight. “Don’t die, Net.” “Not on menu,” I say. Jax stands, satchel hugged to his ribs. I flick my eyes to the corner camera and blink twice, slow, for the Outpost. It hums a little lower. That’s consent. “Follow me,” I say, lifting the bar gate. The hinge squeaks—needs grease—and in the sound I hear the measure of a thousand little choices. I lead him past the crates of nettlefruit, through the tinny door that sticks, to the storage closet that smells like metal and old lemons. I palm the panel. The secret hatch clicks, stubborn as a memory. Behind us, the muffled sound of the main room slides into a low, distant ocean. The hatch opens, a slice of darkness yawning. “After you,” I say. He hesitates, then ducks inside. He moves like someone who’s learned to fit into small spaces. I crouch to follow, then stop, hand on the rim, rag still in my other hand like I forgot to put it down. “Lane’s not going to wait twelve hours,” Jax says, voice bouncing off the pipes. “He’ll come early.” “I know,” I say. “He’s not the only one who knows how to arrive ahead of schedule.” “And the Tide?” he asks. “They said—” “I know what they said.” I stuff the rag into my back pocket, take one last look at the room I can’t see from here. “I’m not who they remember.” In the dark, something shifts in the satchel. A small, barely-there breath. Jax goes still. “Lio?” he whispers. A whisper comes back, like the Outpost itself clearing its throat in a dream. It’s not words. It’s a sound like a wave deciding. “We go,” I say, and drop into the crawlspace, the hatch sealing us into the old bones of the Outpost while above, the tide draws in.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a cozy sci-fi atmosphere while establishing meaningful conflict. The author has crafted a first-person, present-tense narrative centered around Nettle (Nets), a bartender at The Last Outpost with a mysterious past. The chapter introduces conflict through Jax, who arrives with a hidden child and pursuers close behind, connecting to Nets' past through "the Tide." The writing excels in several areas. The dialogue is natural and reveals character while advancing the plot. The author creates a vivid setting through sensory details and ambient descriptions that make the space station feel lived-in. The prose balances efficiency with moments of poetic description that enhance rather than distract from the narrative. Character development is strong. Nets is established as competent but haunted by her past, with subtle hints about her former life. Jax is portrayed as desperate but principled. Even minor characters like Kree have distinct personalities. Lane and his associates are effectively menacing without becoming caricatures. The pacing is well-managed. The author builds tension gradually, from Jax's arrival to the revelation about the child to the confrontation with Lane. The chapter ends with appropriate unresolved tension as the characters escape into the crawlspace. There are a few minor issues. Occasionally, the metaphors become slightly overwrought ("I'm not sure my face moves. My chest tightens, like someone cinched a belt around my ribs"). Some descriptions of the Outpost personifying it might be a bit heavy-handed. The narrative sometimes lingers on atmospheric details when it could move forward more efficiently. Overall, this is a strong piece that establishes an intriguing world, compelling characters, and meaningful stakes. It successfully follows the prompt requirements while creating a narrative that feels both familiar in its genre conventions and fresh in its execution. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Young adult drama: Gone South — Score: 88.2
Prompt:
Young adult drama Gone South Taylor is a 16 year old teen with a history of "concerning behavioural patterns" (or that's how the stupid smug school counsellor worded it on the phone call to Mom). It shouldn't be a surprise: When you live in a backwater town in Tennessee, your choices are: a. be mind-fuckingly bored, or b. invent some drama. Two days ago, Taylor came out to their family as trans. This disclosure was *not* in the category of invented drama -- it was, in fact, the real deal, and a long time coming. It didn't go well. The last 48 hours had been pure disaster. In a moment of desperate inspiration, Taylor had decided to get the hell out of dodge. And so an escape plan was hatched and executed within the space of 30 minutes. That was last night. Now Taylor was two states away, having been unceremoniously ejected from their hitched ride in downtown New Orleans. Write the next chapter in Taylor's story as they find their feet in this new environment. Tell the chapter over the course of their first day in New Orleans, in which Taylor meets another runaway with issues and secrets. Taylor navigates this new world, not knowing who to trust or what the dangers are. Write in Taylor's voice, and incorporate their internal monologue as they grapple with intense & conflicting emotions. Also incorporate dialogue with the interesting characters Taylor meets. First person, mixed tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The strap on my backpack keeps slipping off my shoulder, which is exactly the last straw when I’ve got like twelve other straws jabbing me in the eye. Every few steps I hitch it back up, and it slides down again, like it’s trying to abandon me, too. We get it, bag. You hate me. Join the club. New Orleans in the morning is loud with birds that sound like they’ve swallowed whistles, and the air has this weight to it, like humid honey. It sticks to my skin and makes my shirt cling. My hair, which I hacked shorter with kitchen scissors last week in a move the school counselor would definitely call “concerning,” is already curling at the ends from the damp. A man in a Saints hat barks out something I don’t catch and slaps a newspaper onto a rack. A woman with a stroller flicks me a glance like she’s scanning for threat level. My sneakers slap the sidewalk. I’m two states away, and somehow it still feels like the same planet where people look at me and try to decide what drawer to put me in. Last night feels like a fever dream. The driver who pulled over when I stuck out my thumb had eyes like the bass fish Dad used to catch, wide-set and bored, and he talked in a steady pour about trucker routes and gators while I pretended to be a hitchhiker in a movie who has sunglasses and a cigarette and not someone with approximately eight dollars and a granola bar melting in their bag. He let me out downtown before dawn and said, “Don’t let nobody hustle you,” and then drove off, leaving me with a streetlight buzzing over my head and an empty feeling in my chest like a cavity. Now it’s day and everything has edges. There’s a streetcar grinding along the tracks, and the buildings are painted pastel like Easter eggs. I pass a place with a chalkboard that says Beignets, Chicory Coffee, and for a second I imagine just— going in. Sitting down like a normal human and ordering something warm. But then I remember the eight dollars and the way my stomach feels when someone says “miss” or “young lady” and I make my world smaller: keep walking, find the river, keep to the open, find shade. The river is a slow beast of brown water and eddies. A steamboat squats like a wedding cake, and tourists are already clustering, buttery with sunscreen. I lean on the railing and breathe in something that’s not Tennessee. My phone is dead in my pocket, which is merciful and terrifying. No Mom, no text messages screaming or crying or both. No school counselor with her kind voice over sharp words: concerning behavior, impulsivity, risk. As if I’m a deer that wandered into traffic on purpose. Okay, but also: I did wander into traffic. I left. I told them I was their daughter and also not their daughter. That my name is Taylor, not the other one, the one I can’t even make my mouth say anymore. The silence that followed. Dad’s jaw flexing. Mom’s eyes sliding away like she’d been flashed a light too bright. My brother’s laugh turning into a cough because he didn’t know what else to do. Me feeling like I was unzipping my skin and stepping out, and no one wanted to look at the person underneath. I press my forehead to the cool metal and close my eyes for three seconds. Four. I give myself a number, like a bargain: If I can get to five, I’ll keep going. If I can get to ten, I’ll buy water. I get to five, and my throat is sandpaper. Ten will have to wait. “Hey. You lost?” The voice is somewhere between a challenge and an invitation, and I open my eyes to find a kid my age posted up a few feet away. Skinny, tan, bleached hair in a DIY chop that makes mine look professional. A backpack torn at the seam, patched with duct tape. Their T-shirt says Happy’s Gumbo in faded letters, and there’s a half-healed scab on their knuckle. They’re not smiling exactly, but their mouth looks like it remembers how. “Define lost,” I say, because being clever is a good armor when you’re made of feelings and sunshine. They huff a laugh. “Define police.” I grin before I can stop myself. “No.” “Good. I’m Jules.” They stick out their hand, and I blink, because shaking hands feels formal, but I do it anyway. Their palm is warm, their fingers callused. “You look like you got here last night.” “What, there a neon sign over me?” “Your strap keeps falling,” they say. “That’s a dead giveaway. New kid energy.” “Great.” The strap slides again. I hook my thumb under it and scowl. “I’m Taylor.” “Cool.” Jules leans on the railing next to me, both of us facing the river like we’re in a music video about youths taking their destinies into their own hands. “You eat yet?” “Do beignets count if I imagine them really hard?” “So no.” They glance sideways. “C’mon.” “I’m not going anywhere if you’re about to sell me to pirates.” “Pirates can’t afford you,” they say, and then, softer, “I know a place. It’s not fancy. But it’s food.” My stomach does this traitor growl loud enough that we both hear it. My cheeks heat, and I want to say something like Actually I’m fasting for a spiritual cleanse, but I’m too tired for lies. “Okay,” I say. “I’ll owe you.” Jules shrugs. “Everyone owes everyone. That’s how this works.” We cut through Jackson Square, which is alive with people setting up paintings and tarot tables and brass like the city is about to speak through a horn. A guy with a glitter beard yells, “Good morning, beautiful people!” and half the square answers back. My chest gets weirdly tight. Jules moves with this loose confidence like they own the ground. I try to swallow my self-consciousness. I’m suddenly hyper-aware of my clothes, of the fact that the binder under my T-shirt is squeezing in all the ways that are both a relief and a reminder. It’s a Tuesday, I think. Or Wednesday? Time is soup. We duck into a narrow street that smells like fried things and coffee. The place Jules leads me to is more of a window than a restaurant. A woman with arms like sinew and a braid down her back hands out paper boats of food with the efficiency of a machine. Jules slides two crumpled bills over the counter, says, “Hey, Auntie,” and she says, “I ain’t your auntie,” without looking up, then pushes us two biscuits the size of my fist, smeared with something that looks like butter and tastes like heaven. “You didn’t have to—” I start. “Shut up and eat,” Jules says, but not mean. “You’ll get the next one.” They hand me a bottle of water like it’s nothing. I choke down gratitude along with biscuit. While we eat leaning against the wall, people flicker past, a cross-section of the city: a kid on a skateboard dragging a dog with a bandana, a woman in a pantsuit arguing into her Bluetooth, a man playing guitar who’s missing two strings and still somehow makes it sound like hope. Jules watches them all with a kind of alert laziness, sipping water like it’s a drink to be savored. “How long you been here?” I ask when my mouth isn’t full. Jules thinks about it like time is negotiable. “A while.” “Cryptic.” “Safer,” they say. “You?” “Last night.” “Yeah.” They nod, unsurprised. “You run from something or to something?” “Both.” The word surprises me, but it’s true. “My family. My… town. Myself, except also to myself. That’s dumb.” “Nah,” Jules says. “We all got a trick mirror.” They lick butter off their thumb. “You got anyone you can call?” The question lands too close to that cavity in my chest. “Not right now,” I say. “I mean, eventually. Maybe.” I swallow. “You?” Jules smiles a small, private smile. “I got people. Sorta. People who don’t ask too many questions. That’s the secret here.” “What is this, a cult?” “Nah. A city.” They tilt their head. “You can crash with me if you don’t have a spot.” My bones go cold and warm at the same time. Stranger danger. Don’t go with people you just met. Except… I already did, didn’t I? I went with the guy with the bass fish eyes. He didn’t kill me. I’m still here and my strap still falls and my stomach still gurgles and I’m so, so tired. “Where?” “Place by the tracks,” they say. “It’s not cute. But it’s dry.” “Any pirates?” “Only on Thursdays.” I roll the paper from my biscuit into a tight spiral to keep my hands from shaking. “Okay,” I say. “But if you murder me, I’m going to be really pissed.” “Fair.” We walk. Jules moves like they know the seams of the city—the alleys, the little gaps. They point things out: a mural of a crying alligator, a building facade that’s only a facade with nothing behind it, a house where the porch is sinking but the ferns are thriving. They don’t ask me for my story all at once. They peel it in strips like an orange. I give them pieces. They flick me theirs. “I used to think if I could get fifty miles away, I’d stop hearing my mom calling me by my dead name from down the hall,” I say. “Turns out, it’s got Bluetooth.” Jules snorts. “Yeah. My dad called me a liar to my face. Then said it’d be easier if I just didn’t… make it hard.” They shrug. “I didn’t know how to make it easy while being alive.” “Same.” The tracks cut through a piece of town people like to pretend doesn’t exist. The smell changes to creosote and hot metal. There’s a cluster of tents under an overpass, tarps strung up, cardboard imitating walls. It’s not all tents; some people have made little kingdoms out of shopping carts and ingenuity. Jules threads us through with a nod here, a word there. “This is Ms. Louise,” they say to a woman sitting on a milk crate with a cat on her lap. “Don’t touch the cat.” “I’ll cut your fingers off,” Ms. Louise says sweetly, scratching the cat’s chin. She looks me up and down like she can see the stitches holding me together. “You hungry, sugar?” “I ate,” I say. “Thank you.” “Keep water on you,” she says. “This heat will take you out quicker than a bullet.” We settle under a piece of tarp propped on metal poles. There’s a mattress that has seen things and a milk crate table and a line with clothes hanging like tired flags. Jules tosses me a spare blanket and a pillow that is basically a bag of fluff. I want to cry at the luxury of it anyway. “This is… yours?” I ask, like any of this belongs to any of us. “For now,” Jules says. “Don’t leave your stuff out. Don’t tell anyone you have cash. Don’t do favors you don’t want to do because you think you owe someone. That’s how they get you. You say thank you. You say no. You say sorry. You keep your shoes in your bag so no one jacks them while you sleep.” “Got it,” I say, like these rules are beads I can string around my neck. Don’t get murdered. Keep your shoes. Jules watches me, not unkindly. “You cry sometimes?” “Is that a test?” “Nah. Just asking.” “Sometimes,” I admit. “When I’m alone.” “Good,” they say. “Better than doing it in the middle of the market and getting your pockets turned out.” We spend the afternoon in the shade, then not-shade, then shade again. The heat is like an animal that humps your leg and won’t take no for an answer. I nap and wake up to Jules laughing with someone named Mouse who has tattoos like vines down their wrists. They argue about the best place to busk. I learn names. I learn the sound of footsteps that are fine and footsteps that mean I should look up. I drink water. I pee behind a fence and feel ridiculous and human. The day moves like a sticky bead of syrup down glass. At one point, Jules disappears and I have a half-second of panic before they reappear with two snowballs, shaved ice in paper cups dyed red and blue. “This one’s tiger’s blood,” they say, handing me the red. “It’s not actually blood.” “Disappointing,” I say. The cold is a miracle on my tongue, on the roof of my mouth. I brain-freeze and swear and Jules cackles at me. I can’t remember the last time my laugh didn’t feel like a trespass. Later, when the sun leans and gets meaner before it goes away, I ask, not like it’s a big deal, “So… you didn’t ask me. But. I’m trans.” The word comes out small and then anchors in the air between us. I hold onto it with both hands. “Is that…” “Is that a problem?” Jules finishes for me, like they know the fear behind my ribcage intimately. They shrug. “Only if you make it one. Or if you run into the wrong people. But you got me now. And Ms. Louise will cut a bitch.” I huff a laugh that’s also a breath. “I told my family and it wasn’t a drama thing. I mean, it was dramatic. But I didn’t do it to ruin anyone’s life. I just… did it to not ruin mine.” My eyes sting. Okay, so maybe not “only when alone.” Jules leans back on their elbows, squints at the slice of sky between overpass beams. “People always think you’re doing something to them,” they say. “When actually you’re just—” They flap their hand, like they’re trying to catch the right word. “Existing.” “Existing is such a hassle,” I say, and we grin at each other like we just figured out how to say something sacred. As the sky purples, the air changes. It hums in a different key. The city starts up its night song—horns and laughter and that metal-on-metal of the streetcar, and somewhere, a drum like a heartbeat that got big enough for the whole block. Jules stands, stretches, tucks a knife into their back pocket that I didn’t see before and that makes my stomach flip. Kids with secrets have knives. Kids with knives have stories I don’t know yet. “What’s that for?” I ask. “Opening cans,” they say, and their mouth says joking but their eyes say not just cans. “C’mon. Let’s go watch rich people be stupid. It’s free entertainment.” We weave back toward the Quarter as the neon blinks on. The strap on my backpack slides again, and this time Jules reaches over and knots it shorter with quick fingers. It’s such a simple thing that I almost cry again. I don’t. I breathe. One to five. I can do ten. I can do this. My world is bigger here and also smaller—the rectangle of tarp, the stretch of sidewalk, the river like a sleeping animal. The part of me that packed in thirty minutes is still thrumming, still waiting for a door to slam. But a different part, a quieter one, is like: Maybe stay. We stop at the edge of a crowd where a brass band is assembling itself, piece by gleaming piece. The first note hits and I swear I feel it in the soles of my feet. Jules elbows me. “Welcome to the South,” they say, like I wasn’t already from it, like I never knew. I laugh, and then I’m just—standing there, held up by sound, by a stranger who isn’t quite a stranger anymore, by the knot in my strap, by the cat that would cut me, by a city that is messy and possible. When the song ends, a man passes a hat, and I watch money tumble in, and I think: I can make it to tomorrow. That’s the only plan I can handle. Tomorrow and water and keep my shoes in my bag and say no when no is the answer and yes when yes is the answer. Existing. Not as anybody’s trick mirror, but as the person inside the skin I won’t apologize for. We walk back under the stars that the city hasn’t washed out entirely. Jules bumps my shoulder with theirs and doesn’t say anything. It’s enough. My strap stays put. For once, the thing that’s supposed to hold my stuff actually does. I smile into the night and I don’t have to explain it to anyone. Not even myself. Not right now. Not tonight.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully captures the voice of a transgender teen runaway navigating their first day in New Orleans. The writing demonstrates considerable skill in creating an authentic first-person perspective with a distinctive voice that feels true to a 16-year-old's experience. The prose is particularly strong in its use of metaphor and imagery. Lines like "the air has this weight to it, like humid honey" and descriptions of New Orleans as having buildings "painted pastel like Easter eggs" create a vivid sense of place. The writer effectively uses sensory details to immerse the reader in Taylor's experience. The character development is nuanced and believable. Taylor's internal monologue reveals their conflicting emotions about running away, their gender identity, and their family's rejection. The backstory is woven in organically through reflections and brief mentions rather than exposition dumps. Jules is also well-developed as a character with their own mysterious background and survival skills. The dialogue is particularly strong, feeling natural and revealing character. Jules' lines like "Everyone owes everyone. That's how this works" efficiently communicate their worldview and experience. The interactions between Taylor and Jules develop naturally, with an appropriate wariness that gradually eases into cautious trust. The pacing is effective, covering a full day while maintaining reader interest. The narrative moves between physical locations, emotional states, and interactions with various characters without feeling rushed or dragging. However, there are a few areas where the piece could be stronger. While the ending avoids being overly positive (acknowledging the continued challenges Taylor faces), it does resolve into a somewhat comfortable place rather quickly. Taylor finds shelter, food, and a potential friend all in one day, which feels slightly convenient given the harsh realities of being a homeless runaway. The piece also occasionally relies on telling rather than showing, particularly when explaining Taylor's emotional state directly. While most of the prose is elegant and evocative, a few metaphors feel slightly overwrought, such as "being clever is a good armor when you're made of feelings and sunshine." Overall, this is an impressive piece that creates a compelling character voice, establishes a vivid setting, and explores complex emotional terrain while maintaining narrative momentum. The writing shows considerable skill in balancing internal monologue with external action and dialogue. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 4 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 4 Unearned Transformations: 3 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 4.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 4.0, Unearned Transformations: 3.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Dystopic-comedy: My Apocalypse Buddy — Score: 89.1
Prompt:
My Apocalypse Buddy Write a wry, dry short story of survival and adventure loosely in the style of Terry Pratchett, set in the post-technological collapse world. The story begins with the pair deliberating their predicament and intent for the day's mission, details the ways in which the mission inevitably goes sideways, and returns them to home base in multiple ways, worse for wear. [characters] - the animo-tronic stuffed koala, Chewy, from some long forgotten before time - midas, our hapless protagonist, who has a knack for finding himself in the worst kinds of trouble. 1000 words.
Model Output:
In the mornings, the city pretended to be harmless. The buildings glowed a soft, rusted blush in the dawn, and the wind came in on tiptoes as if to apologize. Everywhere, the bones of the old world stuck out of the earth—concrete femurs, steel ribs, the occasional pelvis of a parking garage—trying to look humble about it. The day would be full of accusations later, but morning was always a polite liar. Midas squinted at the horizon like it might squint back. His hair, which had given up on any form of civilized behavior, curled awkwardly around his ears. He held Chewy, the animo-tronic koala, under one arm like a contraband melon. Chewy’s button eyes reflected the sun and a faint, internal sense of purpose that came and went like static. “We need water,” Midas announced. It was not so much a declaration as a ritual invocation. If you began a day by declaring that you needed water, the universe would take only mild offense. Chewy whirred faintly and opened his mouth. His voice came out with the brittle cheerfulness of a long-dead children’s host. “Taste the sparkle! Now with added pep!” Midas sighed. “Yes. Taste the sparkle. Or the iron. Possibly the algae. Preferably not the tetanus.” They were sitting on the second-floor balcony of what had been the Magisterium Institute of Creative Accounting & Applied Ethics, which had weathered the collapse by shedding all the words it didn’t understand. The “Magisterium” had tumbled off the facade and lay in a flowerbed like a dead magician. It had water tanks on the roof, which was why Midas had come, but the last tank had made a noise like a whale remembering its debts, and then there’d been a lot of not-water. If he wanted not-dying, he would have to go find water somewhere else. Also beans. There were four tins of beans left, and Midas had learned from bitter experience that four tins of beans equals exactly one bad decision. “We’ll hit the Old Park,” Midas said, leaning on that word “plan” like it was a banister and not a snake. “There’s a cistern under the amphitheater. It might still be sealed.” Chewy blinked. A small internal fan spun up. “Exclusive offer! Buy one, get one metaphorical sense of security!” “Very good,” Midas said. “We’ll bring two buckets.” He packed. The list was unambitious because ambition attracts attention. Rope, because gravity is a fair-weather friend. Buckets, because that was the point. A crowbar, because the world needed prying open. The small first-aid kit, which was less a kit than a suggestion. Chewy, because he refused to stay put. And a packet of bulb seeds he had found in a drawer because the idea that anything might grow was a kind of stubborn profanity against entropy. On the way out, he patted the radio like a sleeping dog. It had never worked. He liked to think it appreciated the formality. They descended the Institute’s main staircase because the fire escape had collapsed one afternoon as an act of self-expression. The lobby still had a mural of friendly numbers holding hands with smiling coins, which these days felt like concept art for a horror anthology. The door opened onto the street and a greeting card of broken glass, humming with the quiet industry of weeds. “Right,” Midas said, as they moved through the city’s ribs. “We’re in and out. No detours.” “Share a smile,” Chewy chirped. “Share a snack. Share your data with trusted partners.” “Absolutely not,” Midas muttered. The Old Park had survived better than most because it had nothing to prove. It had no complicated functions, no blinking lights, only grass, trees, and the occasional statue of someone who had been important in a way no one could remember. It also had the amphitheater, which had turned into a gazebo for pigeons with an amphitheatre’s sense of self-importance. Midas approached cautiously. The cistern’s access hatch was in a small sunken room behind the stage, sealed with a circular plate and four bolts. He knew this because he had come here last autumn and found it rusted shut and cursed at it until his vocabulary ran out. He had since acquired a crowbar and a sense that maybe he ought to apologize. He set Chewy down, tied the rope around the koala’s waist (one must have standards), and wedged the crowbar under the plate. The city watched, pretending to be preoccupied with pigeons. Midas pushed. Something in his shoulder made a noise like a creaking door in a haunted house that can’t commit. The plate shifted. “Just a little more,” he told the plate. He preferred to address inanimate objects as if they were surly but not unreasonable. People were unpredictable. Objects understood bargaining. He heaved. The plate popped free, and Midas fell backwards with all the dignity of a man losing an argument with gravity. Chewy scooted to the edge and peered down into the dark. “Unlock adventure with the Family Fun Pack!” Chewy proclaimed, voice echoing into whatever awaited below. “Let’s hope not,” Midas said. He lowered a bucket, then himself. The rope hummed in his hands with the smooth, traitorous friction that always suggests the possibility of boredom and burns. The air grew cooler in that way cellars and half-truths tend to be. His boots found a ledge. He swung. His foot went out from under him, and he collided with a wall that had been politely waiting for him. The bucket fell loose and clanged off something tinny and hollow. He clenched the rope, but it snaked through his palms, inflicting a very detailed lesson. He hit the bottom with an “oof” that decided it could have been a swear if it grew up. “Hey!” he shouted up. His voice came back carrying a handful of dust. “Chewy?” “Upgrade your lifestyle!” Chewy answered cheerfully. There was, either miraculously or suspiciously, a puddle. It reflected his face with the elasticity of a broken promise. He knelt, cupped his hands, and smelled it. Damp metal, old stone, a suggestion of algae. No corpse. This was what passed for hope. He filled the first bucket. Above, something rustled. Pigeons, he told himself. He had yet to meet a pigeon he could not live with, mostly because they seemed to be living much better than he was. “Okay,” he called up. “Pull.” The rope went taut. The bucket rose. Chewy’s servos whined in halting solidarity. Midas looked around for anything else of use and found a small, stubborn fern growing from a crack in the wall like green profanity. He smiled at it. If it was growing here, perhaps the seeds might stand a chance. He then noticed the graffiti. It had been etched into the damp brick by a sharp object and frustration. “WATER = TAX” it read. There were tally marks. The last set stopped abruptly. “Chewy,” he said, as the rope jerked and then stilled. “If anyone is up there who isn’t you, could you please do something distracting?” There was silence, and then: “New! Improved! Same as ever!” It was not comforting. The rope slackened. Midas tugged as if to test whether it still obeyed gravity. It did. He began to climb, hand over hand, the way people climb when they don’t trust the thing they’re attached to. Halfway up, the rope above him twitched and then burned forward a few inches. Something heavier than a bucket moved. Midas surfaced to the sight of three figures in mismatched armor trying to decide whether Chewy was edible, valuable, or cursed. Two had the stringy look of people who do more running than thinking. The third had a beard that he wore like a policy decision. They had crossbows of a sort that suggested they had been assembled from optimism and pieces of shopping carts. “Morning,” Midas said, for lack of an alternative. The bearded one gave Chewy a prod with his foot. “What’s this then?” Chewy’s eyes flared. “Snuggle the future!” “A demon,” decided one of the stringy ones. “Sort of,” Midas said. “We prefer ‘vintage efficiency koala.’” “Tax,” the bearded one said, nodding at the cistern. “Ah,” Midas said. Negotiations began in the usual way, with a demand, a counter-offer, a witty remark no one appreciated, and an immediate attempt at theft. Midas ducked, which was his best move in most situations. He grabbed Chewy, because he had made the mistake of caring about something, and bolted for the stage. It is widely held that amphitheaters were built for acoustics. This one had a secondary function as a ramp. Midas learned this as he flew down it, pursued by men who had suddenly learned an appreciation for centrifugal force. He hit the stage, rolled, and came up under a curtain which had survived out of spite and mold. He crawled. Chewy hit a wall and proclaimed, “Delicious moments start here!” “Stay quiet,” Midas hissed. There was a crash. One of the taxmen had attempted to leap the orchestra pit and, discovering physics, had contributed a brief, operatic note to the day’s repertoire. The other two swore, another art form not as extinct as advertised. Midas emerged at the back of the stage and darted into the undercroft, a maze of small rooms and old props. He ducked behind a papier-mâché tree that looked as if it had spent its life pretending to be a better tree. His heart was a small, determined drummer. He tasted fear and the iron tang of what was likely not tetanus. He breathed and tried very hard to be a shadow. Chewy whirred. “Limited time only!” Midas clapped a hand over Chewy’s mouth. In that second, a bolt thudded into the wall where his head had been, which is the sort of reminder one gets for having hands that can be busy. He ran. When life has become a series of exits, you get good at finding them. He burst into daylight at the side door, cut across the amphitheater lawn, and, forgetting that grass was as treacherous as bureaucracy, went knee-deep into a hole disguised as ambition. He flailed, scrambled, and came up with one bucket, one koala, and a soul full of regrets. The taxmen were displeased. They gave chase, which involved a lot of shouting and some very creative pathfinding. Midas darted into the city’s ribs, ducking between rusting buses and fallen light posts. He vaulted a low wall, only to find that the far side was not ground but a mound of plastic bags that had achieved sentience and retired to this spot to pursue a contemplative life. He sank. The bags made a sound like a library losing its temper. He wrenched free, swore in a way that would have impressed the mural in the Institute, and staggered onto a street that was a rumor of asphalt. The bearded man, however, had the dogged persistence of principle. He came around a corner, crossbow up, and declared, “Tax is due.” Midas put Chewy down, raised both hands, and blurted, “We’re from the Magisterium of Applied Ethics.” It was a lie that had truth in it, which is the best kind. The bearded man blinked, cocked his head, and hesitated long enough for Chewy to say, “Compliance has never been this fun!” Something in the bearded man’s brain, which was a museum of old rules, tried to reconcile that sentence with his goals and took a short break. Midas shoved him. The crossbow went off into the sky, where it startled a cloud. He ran. By then the city had stopped pretending to be harmless. The wind had found its voice, which was nails on a chalkboard, and the shadows stretched long fingers. Midas’s bucket sloshed. His lungs filed a complaint. He turned into an alley that chose that moment to repurpose itself as a trench. He skidded, rebounded off a door that declined to be a door anymore, and found himself back on the plaza in front of the Institute by the pure, idiot geometry that follows people like him. He burst through the lobby. The friendly numbers on the mural watched with the judgement of saints. He took the stairs three at a time because he owed his knees a grudge. The roof door stuck, because of course it did, and then he was on the roof with the tank that was not a tank, the garden of hopeful buckets, and a sky rehearsing thunder. He dropped the bucket. Water sloshed into a basin that he had repaired with a strip of rubber and a prayer. He set Chewy on a crate. He leaned his forehead against the wall and laughed the laugh of someone who has counted his fingers and found most of them present. Chewy, whose power was mostly an arrangement of stubborn electrons and wishes, settled in. “Refresh your world.” “Working on it,” Midas said. He checked his inventory of bruises. New, colorful. He inspected his palms. Raw, possibly on purpose. He lifted the bucket. The water looked back at him like a tired friend. Below, footsteps in the stairwell. He breathed. It was possible they would come up. It was possible they would go away. It was possible the building would have an opinion about either of those things. Midas picked up the crowbar. He did not feel brave. He felt like wet bread spread too thin. He stood by the roof door and discovered within himself the spine of a fern. He planted the bulb seeds in the cracked planter box, because there was never a good time and always a right one. The footsteps paused. A voice said, “Applied Ethics, eh?” Midas held his breath. The voice laughed, a short, exhausted thing. The steps retreated. He let the crowbar down. He looked at Chewy, who blinked, if blinking could be a mission statement. The sky rolled over and muttered. Far away, someone dropped something heavy on something important. “We’re alive,” he told Chewy, because it needed saying out loud. Chewy’s head tilted. “Batteries not included.” Midas poured a handful of water into his mouth. It tasted like victory had come to him secondhand and without a receipt. It was wonderful. In the evenings, the city confessed. The buildings leaned closer and told their secrets to the dark. Somewhere, a radio that would never work practiced silence. Midas lay back on the roof and listened to his heartbeat find an agreement with the night. He thought of the fern, of the tally marks in the cistern, of taxes paid and taxes dodged, of a koala who sold him joy at inconvenient times. “We need beans,” he said to the stars. Chewy clicked. “Don’t miss out.” “Tomorrow,” Midas promised the roof, the city, the collapse, and himself. “Tomorrow we try again.” The wind, which seemed to approve of schedules, settled in and slept.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This short story successfully captures Terry Pratchett's wry, dry style with its blend of absurdist humor, clever metaphors, and philosophical asides. The post-technological collapse world is vividly rendered through decaying infrastructure and the remnants of consumer culture embodied in Chewy's pre-programmed marketing phrases. The narrative follows the prompt's structure well, beginning with Midas and Chewy deliberating their predicament (needing water), detailing their mission to the cistern that inevitably goes sideways (encountering the "taxmen"), and returning them to home base worse for wear but alive. The characterization of Midas as a hapless survivor with a knack for finding trouble is consistent throughout. His relationship with Chewy, the animo-tronic koala, provides both comic relief and emotional depth. Chewy's marketing slogans often inadvertently comment on their situation, creating ironic juxtaposition that feels very Pratchett-esque. The prose is particularly strong, with inventive metaphors ("the wind came in on tiptoes as if to apologize") and personification of inanimate objects. The author skillfully employs the technique of treating absurd situations with matter-of-fact narration, another Pratchett hallmark. The dialogue, though limited, serves its purpose well. Chewy's pre-programmed phrases create a delightful contrast with Midas's pragmatic responses. This interplay adds both humor and poignancy to their relationship. Where the piece could improve is in its pacing. The middle section with the taxmen feels slightly rushed compared to the more contemplative opening and closing. Some of the action sequences could benefit from more breathing room to fully develop the tension. The ending strikes an appropriate balance between hope and resignation, capturing the bittersweet tone often found in Pratchett's work. Midas's determination to "try again" tomorrow, despite the day's hardships, provides a satisfying conclusion without being overly optimistic given their dire circumstances. Overall, this is an accomplished piece that successfully channels Pratchett's distinctive style while creating its own unique post-apocalyptic world and memorable characters. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Romance: Love in the Limelight — Score: 88.7
Prompt:
Romance: Love in the Limelight. Write one scene within a larger story set in Wales. A famous (fictional) actor ducks into a small-town bookstore to escape paparazzi. The scene takes us through the characters meeting in this odd circumstance. Over the course of the scene, the actor and the bookstore owner have a conversation charged by an undercurrent of unspoken chemistry. Write the actor as somewhat of a rogue with a fragile ego, which needs to be fed by having everyone like him. He is thoroughly charming, but the bookstore owner seems (at least superficially) immune to this; which paradoxically provokes a genuine attraction and derails the charm offensive. The bookstore owner, despite the superficial rebuffs of the actor's charm, is inwardly more than a little charmed and flustered despite themselves. Write primarily in dialogue, in the distinct voices of each character. 1000 words.
Model Output:
“Close the door. Please.” “I— what? Oh. Right.” The man in the black wool coat pivots in, shuts the blue-painted door of the shop, and leans his back against it like a human bolt. Outside, the drizzle silver-sheets the lane. Footfalls slap past. Voices, high and hopeful. A camera flash streaks across the frosted glass. He looks at me over the collar of his coat. Sunglasses in a Welsh winter. Of course. “You’ve no back way, have you?” His breath fogs, his mouth poised in a smirk that’s probably insured. “Through the stockroom and out the yard,” I say. “But it’s locked, and the key’s—” “Where?” “In a biscuit tin marked Spare Fuses.” He grins. “You’re joking.” “I wish I were that whimsical.” He pushes off the door. The bell above it tinkles its objection. He grimaces. “Sorry, little bell. Didn’t mean to blow your cover.” “Don’t worry. Sometimes it tries to follow customers home.” I hold out my hand. “Give me your coat.” His eyebrows jump. “Forward. I like it.” “So they can’t photograph your very distinctive lapels through the window. It’s called self-preservation. In cardigan form.” I wiggle the knitted monstrosity I’m wearing: oatmeal with a moose. He shrugs out of the coat, slow as a striptease for charity, and hands it over, revealing a charcoal jumper that probably costs more than my rent. He smiles like sunlight at full wattage. “I’m Evan St. Clair.” “Yes,” I say. “I’ve gathered.” He laughs, delighted, as if I’ve told him a joke about himself that he hadn’t thought of. “Right. Well. I wasn’t exactly incognito.” “Those sunglasses might fool seagulls.” He spins the shades in his fingers, sheepish. “I was told—and this is true—that if you throw them on, people hesitate. Anything to buy a second.” His gaze shifts to the front window. Outside, shadows cluster and pass. The murmurs move on. He relaxes an inch. “This place smells brilliant. Dust and lemon oil. And something… like rain.” “That would be rain. We’re in Wales.” “True. Where else will the weather join you indoors.” He looks around. The shop is long and narrow, a corridor of shelves and postcards and handwritten signs—Crime, Poetry, Local History, Birds. The kettle clicks in the back. The radio mutters in Welsh. “Tea?” I ask. “Is this the part where you spike it and sell my hair to tabloids?” His smile is still there. He can’t not deploy it. He’s used to throwing it like glitter. “I don’t buy tabloids,” I say. “But tea, yes. No offense—” I nod toward the window. “—but you’re dripping on my floor.” He glances down. Raindrops freckle the boards where he stands. He steps onto the rug. “Sorry.” “Apology accepted. Come on.” I walk through to the tiny kitchen corner behind the till. The kettle is humming now. He follows, careful, as if not to wake the books. He runs his fingers down the spines as he passes—he reads titles under his breath, an actor’s instinct to mouth lines. “R.S. Thomas… Dannie Abse… God, you’ve got an early Caradog Prichard.” “You read Welsh poets?” I say, surprised enough that it comes out sounding like an accusation. “Some. My first agent made me do a poetry reading to train my breath.” He smiles, softer this time, almost private. “It took. Black, one sugar, if you’ve got it.” I make the tea. He leans his hip against the counter. He’s doing the not-quite-lean that draws a line from rib to wrist, the angle of a magazine spread. I stir the sugar into his mug and pass it over. He wraps both hands around it like a man in a soup advert. “Thanks,” he says. And then, with too much brightness: “I love what you’ve done with the place.” “It came like this,” I say. “I inherited it. I added the moose.” “Bold choice.” He takes a sip and winces. “Ah. Tongue death. My fault.” “You’re supposed to wait.” “The world keeps telling me that.” He puts the mug down. “What’s your name?” “Lowri.” “Lowri,” he repeats, and pronounces it right. He sees me notice. “My gran was from Llanelli,” he says. “I can spot my LLs.” “Then you’ve advanced beyond most of your fans outside.” “They’re enthusiastic,” he says, and he says it in a rehearsed tone, the sort of warm standard line you give repeatedly and hope will stay true if you say it enough. His eyes flick the window like a nervous tick, but his smile stays. “You don’t seem very…” He searches. “Enthused.” “I’m at work,” I say. “I tend not to swoon on duty. It scares the biographies.” He laughs, the sound rolling like a trick he’s very fond of. “That’s good. Use that on your posters. ‘No swooning inside, it frightens the Brontës.’” “Emily’s very skittish.” I turn and rest my hips against the counter, mirroring him by accident. “Look, you can wait here until they’ve, you know, migrated. But if someone needs in, I open the door.” His gaze moves to the door again. The street is quieter now. “You get many customers on a wet Tuesday?” “If they’re determined. Like starlings. They’ll find the cracks.” “I could… sign something?” He gestures, almost apologetic. “As a thank you. Not that it’s— I’m not assuming you’d want it.” “I don’t need a signed headshot of you as a detective with a tragic past.” “Shame,” he says. “We printed thousands.” “I’m sure it would be worth something someday,” I say, and he flinches at the future tense like it’s a diagnosis. “It’s worth less than you think,” he says, too fast. Then he laughs it off. “Anyway. I could sign a book. If you’ve got… I don’t know. The Odyssey.” He puts on an announcer’s voice: “Evan St. Clair, noted Greek scholar.” “There’s a Greek myths shelf. Children’s.” I tip my head toward it. He drifts over, looking, touching covers like talismans. “I grew up with these,” he says to the window rather than me. “Mum liked the grisly ones. Eyes out. Heads cut. Gods being cows.” “As you do.” He takes down a battered Puffin edition of Tales of the Mabinogion. His eyebrows go up. “You’ve got this out front.” “Local market.” He opens it. The spine gives a sigh. He grins. “Blodeuwedd.” “Owl-woman,” I say. “Made of flowers. It never ends well for women made of flowers.” He looks at me then, properly, as if I’ve cracked a code. His smile stops being the general issue one and becomes specific. He melts an inch. “You know the stories?” he says. “I lead a story club for kids on Saturdays,” I say. “We do myths. Welsh, Greek, whatever keeps them from hurling cushions at each other like Achilles. And I… I like etymology. Names. How they shift.” “Names,” he repeats. “You’d love film sets. Everything has three names. The real name, the working title, and the lie you tell so people won’t Google where you are.” “Like calling an epic ‘Blue Harvest’.” He laughs, delighted, and puts a hand to his chest as if I’ve shot him in the heart, theatrically. “You know ‘Blue Harvest’?” “Everyone with a spine of nerd knows ‘Blue Harvest.’” I pause, immediately annoyed at myself for offering this common ground so eagerly. He basks in the connection as if it’s a heat lamp. I backtrack into arid. “I mean, it’s trivia. Useful for pub quizzes.” “Tell me you do pub quizzes,” he says. “Please tell me I can join your team and sabotage it by answering everything with my own filmography.” “‘Name a 2016 film directed by—’ ‘Me. Always me. Every answer is me.’” “Exactly,” he says. “You’re getting it.” He leans on the counter again. “I’m not very good at being somewhere people don’t expect me to be. It’s like taking a goldfish down the high street.” “Because they’re orange and famous?” “Because they die,” he says lightly, and there’s a flash underneath, a glint of something chipped. He shrugs it off. “So this— this is—thank you.” “It’s nothing,” I say. “You didn’t scream when I asked for your coat. We’re even.” He glances at the cardigan draped over the stool next to him—my spare. He picks it up, weighs it in his hands. “I can pay,” he says suddenly. “For being a nuisance.” “You haven’t bought anything yet,” I say. “Then I’ll buy something.” He looks around, eyes snaring on the shelf of battered bird guides. “What’s popular?” “Depends.” I nod at the window. A robin sits on the sill, head cocked, raindrops like diamonds on its russet chest. “Birds, lately. Everybody’s taken up birdwatching. Or is it birding? The internet fights about that.” “Birdwatching,” he says. “Birding sounds like you’re about to commit a crime.” “You’d be good at it,” I say, and I don’t mean to soften, but it comes out like an offering. “Birdwatching. You have to be still. Invisible. Patient. Look without being seen.” His face does a funny combination of pride and hurt, like a child praised for sitting quiet. “I am very good at being seen,” he says. “Yes,” I say. We stare at the robin together. It hops, tilts, stares back, as if weighing our souls. He says, “I used to go out with my gran to watch red kites in Carmarthenshire. She’d bring sandwiches that tasted of butter and damp. We’d sit in the car and pretend we were in a hide. She’d call them her angels.” He smiles at the robin. “I haven’t thought of that in years.” “Red kites spend a lot of time circling,” I say. “Looking for roadkill. It’s very cinematic.” He laughs softly. “Cinematic. You’re very kind to put it that way.” The bell rings. A customer pokes her head in, shaking off an umbrella. Her eyes widen behind smudged glasses. “Oh,” she breathes. “Hello,” I say, too brightly. “Ruth. Come in.” Ruth steps in. She clocks the man by the counter. Her mouth opens. He does the smile, reflexively. “Sorry,” he says, with a charm that could butter toast at forty paces. “I’m hiding. From the weather. And… also from the weather.” He gestures vaguely at the outside. Ruth’s eyes flick to me. I shake my head once. She purses her lips into a conspiratorial line. “Well, Lowri,” she says, “if you’ve got that new bird guide…” I get it from the shelf and ring it up. Evan drifts to the far end of the counter, half behind a stack of atlases, his profile an old Roman coin. Ruth pays, sliding coins across the worn wood like a transaction in a spy film. As she leaves, she says, without looking at him, “My granddaughter likes your show. But don’t tell her I said.” He presses his hand to his heart, mock-solemn. “Your secret is safe with me, Ruth.” She snorts and goes. The bell scolds the air again. “You’re good with them,” he says after a beat, meaning Ruth, meaning the books, meaning everything. “I practise on stubborn customers,” I say. “Are you going to buy that?” I nod at the Mabinogion still in his hand. He looks down as if surprised to see it there. “Yes. And this.” He reaches for a bird guide. “What do you recommend for someone who wants to pretend he knows what he’s looking at when he says ‘That’s definitely a… bird’?” “Collins,” I say, pulling the blue guide. “And keep your mouth shut. Experienced birders say less and look more.” He lifts the guide, flips it open, stops at a page. “Look at that. A red kite.” He shows me the illustration as if I’ve never seen one. His fingers are ink-stained at the edges, not from today but like habit, like the kind of stain that doesn’t shift. I wonder what he does with his hands when he’s not being watched. Knots? Guitars? He notices me noticing and wiggles his fingers. “I do the New York Times crossword,” he says. “Show-off.” He laughs. “Mondays,” he admits. “And the minis.” His voice goes quiet. “Do you ever… want to be somewhere else, Lowri?” “I live above the shop,” I say. “Sometimes I want to be below the shop.” “Ah,” he says, like that’s wisdom. “Grounding. I like that.” He taps his finger on the picture of the bird. “Do you do the dawn walk? The— what’s it called— the listening one.” “Dawn chorus,” I say. “That. I’ve never done it.” “You wake up at four,” I say. “Go somewhere with trees. Try not to breathe too loud. They start one by one, and then it feels like you’re inside a throat. It’s… I don’t know. It makes you want to be less clumsy.” He looks at me, bare and almost boyish. “Can someone like me do that? Not be… clumsy?” “Yes,” I say. “If you shut up about yourself for twenty minutes.” He laughs, genuine and delighted and not at all defensive, which is a surprise to both of us. “You’re brutal.” “You like it.” “I do,” he says, and it slips out unguarded, warm, and I flush, and he sees. His smile shifts; he steps off the stage. “Sorry. That was—” “Tea’s going cold,” I say. “Pay, please. Before you charm me into giving you the shop.” He taps his card. The machine beeps its little acceptance. He sighs, sincerely relieved, as if this purchase confers real legitimacy. “Thanks, Lowri.” “They’re probably gone,” I say. “Your pilgrimage.” He picks up his coat but doesn’t put it on. He looks at the door, meaning to go. He doesn’t move. “Do you ever take people out to—” He waves the bird guide. “To do the chorus thing. I’d pay.” “You don’t have to pay,” I say. “You can just come. If you want. We go from the car park by the old quarry, five on Saturday. It’s me and three people who call themselves the Twitcher Bitches. You’ll like them. They hate everyone famous.” He laughs, startled and pleased. “Perfect. I’ll be there. If I’m not… you know… being a goldfish somewhere.” “I’ll bring you a bowl.” He slides the sunglasses back on. It should be ridiculous. Somehow, here, it is. He opens the door a fraction, listens. Rain and the sound of the river. No voices. His shoulders drop. He looks back at me over the moose of my cardigan. “Should I… sign something for the story kids?” he asks. “Not my face. The book.” “They’d like that,” I say. I push the Mabinogion toward him and a pen. He uncaps it, hesitates. “What should I put?” His voice is careful. “Without… making it about me.” I watch him watch the blank page. “Tell them to listen,” I say. “Tell them the owls have names.” He writes. His handwriting is surprisingly neat, like a schoolboy’s, rounded and eager. He finishes, caps the pen, and slides the book back with a shy sort of pride. I don’t read it yet. He puts on his coat. The store seems smaller with him in it and bigger when he smiles. “See you Saturday,” he says, and the words hang between us like a promise and a dare. “Bring quiet shoes,” I say. “That rules out my tap routine.” He reaches for the handle. He stops, turns back once more. “Lowri?” “Yes?” “Thanks for not… doing the thing.” “What thing?” “Making me be… Evan St. Clair. All over the floor.” He gestures at the boards, the books, the bell. “It’s messy.” “You’re welcome,” I say. “Try not to get any of him on the robin.” He grins, soft as a secret. “See you,” he says. He goes out into the rain. The bell tinkles. The door shuts. He is gone, and so is some tension I didn’t know I was holding. The shop hums. I pick up the Mabinogion and turn to the title page. In neat round letters: For the Saturday Story Club. Listen. The owls are saying your names. See you at dawn. —E. I put the book on the counter, next to the bird guide he paid for and left behind. I should chase him. I don’t. I lean my elbows on the wood and watch the robin on the sill. It tilts its head at me, black eye bright. The rain whispers. The kettle clicks to life again, unbidden, and I let it.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a charming bookstore meet-cute between a famous actor and a bookstore owner in Wales. The writing demonstrates considerable skill in establishing character through dialogue, creating a sense of place, and building romantic tension. The dialogue is particularly strong, with each character having a distinct voice. Evan speaks with the practiced charm of someone accustomed to being adored, while Lowri maintains a dry, slightly sardonic tone that effectively masks her inner attraction. Their verbal sparring feels natural and reveals character without being expository. The Welsh setting is well-established through small details—the drizzle, Welsh poets, the Mabinogion, local birdwatching spots—without overwhelming the narrative. The author skillfully weaves in these elements to create authenticity rather than merely decorating the scene with Welsh references. Character development is nuanced. Evan is portrayed as charming but with an underlying vulnerability—his comment about being "good at being seen" and the "flash underneath" when he jokes about goldfish dying reveal his fragile ego as requested. Lowri's exterior resistance to his charm while being inwardly affected is conveyed through subtle physical reactions and internal contradictions, such as when she's "immediately annoyed at herself for offering this common ground so eagerly." The prose balances descriptive elements with dialogue effectively. Sensory details like "Dust and lemon oil" and the robin with "raindrops like diamonds on its russet chest" create vivid imagery without becoming purple. The writing maintains a consistent tone throughout—slightly literary but with a contemporary feel appropriate for the romance genre. The chemistry between the characters develops organically. Their connection over Welsh mythology, birdwatching, and their mutual appreciation for directness feels earned rather than contrived. The ending, with the promise of meeting again, provides satisfying closure to the scene while leaving room for the relationship to develop further. Some minor weaknesses include occasional moments where the metaphors feel slightly strained ("like a transaction in a spy film") and a few instances where the prose becomes a touch too self-conscious. The bird motif, while effective, is perhaps used a bit heavily. Overall, this is a sophisticated piece of romantic writing that successfully fulfills the prompt requirements while creating engaging characters whose chemistry feels authentic and compelling. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Whalepunk fantasy: The Morska Conspiracy — Score: 94.8
Prompt:
Whalepunk fantasy The Morska Conspiracy The Morska thieves guild experiences a sudden power vacuum as its leader was arrested in a raid in the early hours of the morning. Aya, a young woman born into aristocracy, has a keen interest in both the sciences and the arcane, having inherited her mother's gift for immateria magick (an outlawed practice for which her mother was, regrettably, hanged by the neck). Aya, bored with the world of aristocracy, has been spending her nights moonlighting with this very guild (masked, naturally). Leveraging her latent ability to summon dark entities from the immateria, she quickly rose through the ranks of the guild. Now, recognising the opportunity of the sudden power vacuum, Aya and her close companions Katra and Simeon, make a play for heart of the guild's claim to power: an ancient scythan artifact, under guard of spell and key in the depths of the guild hq. In contrast with the desperate chaos they had navigated thus far, the entrance to the underhold felt suddenly too quiet. Aya braces herself and reaches for the door. Write the next scene as the trio enter the underhold and find themselves confronted by none other than the guild leader herself, decidedly *un*-incarcerated, and in possession of both weapons and bodyguards. Paint a vivid picture of of the confrontation. Story beats: Aya is captured and unmasked. The trio are captured. Aya attempts to stall their demise by negotiating on her value as a hostage -- as she grapples with the inevitable consequences of her role in the guild being brought to light. Incorporate dialogue in the authentic voices of the characters. Do not write a fight scene. Lean into the gritty Victorian aesthetic with the dialogue & worldbuilding, as well as elements of gothic horror. In this world, men trust brass and oil and steel; magicka is feared and barely understood. Write in third person past tense, incorporating both Aya's internal monologue, and a heavy dialogue component. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The underhold breathed cold through the seam of the door. Aya felt it gather in her throat like a swallowed penny. Brass fittings were slick under her glove; the iron keyway ate lamplight and gave nothing back. She inhaled old salt—Morska’s omnipresent brine—layered with the oil-tang of machine grease and the acid ghost of spilled alchemy. Behind her, Katra slid a knife into her boot with the soft, deliberate care of a woman who did not believe in luck. Simeon’s pocket watch clicked. A thin, crisp sound, too fast, like a second hand running on lye. “On your word, bird,” Katra murmured. Aya pressed her palm to the door, feeling the wards twitch. Immateria curled against her bones in a listening hum: the old, dark outside of the world. It liked vaults. It liked spaces that pretended to be secure. Her mother’s hands had known how to pluck those strings gentle. Aya’s trembled. She unlaced the first ward with a whisper—something not in any tongue spoken on this side of breath—and slotted the second with the key Simeon had lifted from a sleeping under-master’s coat two nights past. The door sighed as if relieved. They descended. The underhold was a drowned chapel with its stones turned inside-out. Heavy columns clasped with iron bands. Archways ribbed like the inside of a whale. Overhead, a tangle of pipes and flues and pressure gauges chittered softly to themselves; steam rattled somewhere behind the walls. The guild loved a mechanism like a devout man loved a saint. Lamps burned low, their glass chimneys fogged, their light knotted tight and mean. The floor was set with grates. Aya imagined things underneath, huffing. Simeon slipped in last, shutting the door and pinching out their guide-lantern. He adjusted his spectacles as if they might see more if properly seated. His pocket watch ticked on, a polite little insistence in the gloom. “Quiet,” Katra said. She meant the quality, not the fact. The air wore it like a garment sewn to fit. Aya’s stomach cinched. Too quiet. Not the quiet that follows success. The quiet of a trap laid well by someone who knew your weight and stride. At the center of the underhold, under a cage of copper lattice, sat a coffin-shaped thing bolted to a plinth of black stone—a Scythan torc, if the rumors were true, or its housing. It glowed faintly from within with a breathless, milky light. The cage sang to her bones: ward-work ancient enough to smell like the bottom of the earth. Aya’s immateria prickled awake, moths at a window. She took a step toward it. “Hold,” said a voice that had no business being there. Aya’s foot froze mid-air. It made a small sound when it came down—leather on grit. From the dark behind the columns, men and women unspooled with practised, unhurried grace. Coat skirts. Barrel chests. Brass knuckles. Carbines fitted with bayonet spikes like crooked teeth. The gleam of a brass-and-bone limb, articulated with custom cruelty. A dozen at least, and more behind them, shadows holding their breath. The light shifted as bodies reframed it. And at the far edge of the copper cage, seated in a chair like a provincial magistrate presiding over a hanging, the guildmaster herself crossed one booted ankle over the other. Lore Valchek wore a cravat the color of dried blood and a coat that had been cut for a broader-shouldered man and altered with a seamstress’s malice. Her hair was blunt-cut and pinned under a hat meant more for shadow than for show. In her left hand, a lacquered cane set with a mouth-blown glass head in which something cloudy moved when tilted. Her right glove was stripped off; the hand beneath was freighted with rings and a pale raised scar biting from thumb to wrist like a grin. She smiled. “One hates to be predictable,” Lore said. “So I thought I’d disappoint the city and fail to languish in a cell.” Katra’s knife didn’t twitch. “They said you were taken at Saint Ivar’s docks. With six casks of contraband and a ledger full of names.” “They said,” Lore agreed, amused, “and you listened.” She tapped the cane against the black stone of the plinth. The sound it made was water under pressure. Steam purred through the underhold’s veins in answer. “I suppose I should be flattered. We stage-craft for magistrates and for rumormongers, but it’s rare my own house takes the bait so prettily.” Simeon’s watch ticked; Aya felt each click like a pin hammered into her spine. Stupid, to be here. Brilliant, to be here. She could feel the prim hunger of the thing under the cage. It wanted out. It wanted to lay its cold circle across a throat, a city, a century. The immateria in her reached for it without her consent. She pressed her teeth together until the ache cleared her head. Lore stood. Two of her people went ahead of her by a step, moving with the loose-shouldered alertness of men who had done violence in narrow spaces. “Masks off,” Lore said, as if telling children to wash before supper. Katra’s grip met Aya’s wrist in the dark for a breath. They had promised each other anonymity. They had worn other names like skins. Aya’s mask fit well—black velvet sewn by Katra’s own hand, tied snug with a ribbon at the nape. She could claim any face underneath it until revealed. “A little dramatic, Lore, darling,” Aya said, pitching her voice low, smoothing it with silk. “You always did favor the theater.” “This isn’t theater, little girl,” Lore said. “It’s inventory.” Hands took them. Not rough at first—then rough, when Katra tensed and Simeon made the smallest misjudgment of balance, a shuffle that read as flight. The biographies of their bodies betrayed them. A hand in Aya’s hair—she bit down on a sound—and the knot of her ribbon came loose. The mask fluttered against her cheek and then fell away, a breath sighing through it before it hit the floor. The cold air went for her face like teeth. Silence. Not from the men—there was still the creak of leather, the grind of a boot, someone’s congested breathing—but from Lore. A small, precise stillness. “Well,” Lore said at last. “A baron’s daughter in my cellar.” Aya kept her chin up. The underhold’s light did her no favors; it carved hollows under her cheekbones, made her mouth look a little crueler than it was. Her mother’s mouth. People whispered about that mouth in drawing rooms scented with oranges and strategic boredom. She thought of riding in a carriage past the scaffold on Saint Dorothea Lane at eleven years old, her governess rushing her forward, the rain stringing them, her mother’s throat a bright flower opening and opening—no, not now. Katra sucked breath in through her teeth. Simeon made the mortified, reluctant chuckle of a man who had seen too many farces to be surprised when one broke into his life. His watch ticked louder, or else Aya’s head had let the sound in further. “What a charming trifecta,” Lore observed. “A disgraced cosh-queen, a ledger-biter, and a debutante necromantist.” “That’s not the word,” Aya snapped before she could stop herself. Pride rose like brine in her mouth. If they were going to kill her, at least let it be for the correct blasphemy. “Necromancy reanimates the suffered flesh. I was taught immateria. The exterior shades.” “Outlawed either way,” Lore said, indolent. “And badly paid when practiced in the dark for people who don’t appreciate the expertise.” Aya pulled her shoulders back. “You appreciated it.” A flicker of something—pleasure?—crossed Lore’s face. “I appreciate leverage,” she said. “And you have been very useful leverage. Against doorways. Against men who thought they couldn’t be frightened because they watched three workers drown at the pump-works and didn’t flinch.” She stepped closer. The cane’s glass head sloshed with something too slow to be water. Aya stared at it because it was easier than looking at the ringed hand whose lines mapped a history of fists. Lore reached out with her bare hand and took Aya’s chin between finger and thumb. The rings were cold; the hand was warm. “I also appreciate a good mask,” Lore said softly. “But I appreciate the truth more.” “Lore,” Katra said. She wasn’t pleading. She never pleaded. “Take me. Let the young ones go.” “Take you?” Lore laughed without showing teeth. “You’ve already been taken half a dozen ways by our friends on the docks. They own your debts. They own your breath. You offered them your hand; they took your wrist. No, my dear. You are ballast. Heavy and useful, but not precious.” Simeon cleared his throat politely. The watch answered him. His spectacles had fogged a little at the corners. “If we might—” “Hush,” Lore said, not unkind. “Your voice makes me think of clerks, and I have a rash when I think of clerks.” Aya’s mind was darting, frantic sparrows waking in a chimney. She could call something. She could open the seam in the air and let a sliver of the outside slide through. Men trusted brass and oil and steel; they did not trust what left no residue on the hands. But immateria left residue elsewhere. It took from you. The wards here were old, and the cage hummed with anti-song; if she misstepped, she’d bring the cage down or turn the room into a throat. And if she did anything, she would do it unveiled and titled, and the city would know a baron’s daughter dragged black snow into the world. Her father’s face occurred to her as a portrait—flat and cold, oils dried to a careful sheen. She wet her lips. Tasted salt. “Listen,” she said. “You don’t want to kill me.” Lore’s eyebrow moved the width of a needle. “Don’t I?” “I’m worth more breathing,” Aya said. She hated the sound of the words, the negotiated quality, the way they made her feel like a commodity she was pretending not to be. “My name buys you doors you haven’t yet learned to pick. It sits next to other names at tables you can’t reach without a stool. I can be letters signed with the correct hand. I can get you through iron that wears badges. I am ransom writ in copperplate.” Katra made a small noise, deep in her chest. Simeon’s watch agreed, a metronome of dread. Lore released Aya’s chin. The absence of her grip was almost as sharp as the presence had been. She stepped back and studied Aya as one might a specimen kept in spirits. “You’d sell them, then? The ones you sup with.” “I would sell the idea of them,” Aya said. Truth was a slippery eel; her mother had taught her to catch it by the tail. “I would move money and papers and get you a whisper before it became a shout. I would make the room wait five minutes instead of stampinged. There’s a difference. If you wanted them dead, you would have them dead already.” Lore smiled as if Aya had told a joke she might retell later. “And if I wanted you dead?” “Then you wouldn’t be listening,” Aya said, forcing her voice to forget the scaffold. “You’d be throwing me into whatever you’ve got humming under these grates.” Something did hum under the grates. Aya hadn’t imagined it. A low, slow throb like a monstrous heart made of pumps and bellows and whales. Morska’s modern miracle: the refinery built into the bones of an old church, turning fat and brine to light and wealth. Whalepunk saints, she thought, and nearly laughed. Simeon said, very mildly, “If you don’t require her whole, you could curry favor with certain parties by returning her in parts. Fingers are dreadfully communicative.” Katra swore at him under her breath. Lore’s gaze flicked to him, alive with black amusement. “You have the soul of an accountant and the mouth of a mortician,” she said. “I might keep you for conversation.” “My lady is generous,” Simeon said, and the watch kept time that every muscle in Aya’s body had started to count against. Silence pooled, thick and greasy as the sheen on harbor water. Men shifted, and the underhold’s pipes clicked in the small pauses between ticks. Aya felt the immateria pulse, eager and cold, nosing at the seam of her will. She could call a shade that would make men piss themselves and forget why they came into this room. She could call her mother’s voice. She could— Her mother had not screamed. “Tell me,” Lore said at last, almost kind, almost curious. “What did you think would happen? If the artifact came free into your pretty hands. If you wore the torc and told my wolves to heel.” Aya pictured it for a blessed second: herself under that milky light, copper singing against her pulse, Katra to her right, Simeon to her left, the guild kneeling like the city at church. It was a child’s picture book, lacquered and ridiculous. It made heat crawl up her neck. “I thought,” Aya said, and let the truth cut her tongue, “that I was owed.” Lore’s smile showed teeth. “There she is.” “Lore,” Katra said again, and this time there was an old story in it. Two women in an alley, blood and coin and the look that happens after a shared crime. “We’ve done you loyal.” “You’ve done me hungry,” Lore said. “And brave in the wrong rooms.” She lifted the cane and gestured to the scaffolds that ringed the wall—a lattice for maintenance, for repairs, for observation. “Put them up.” Hands tightened. Aya didn’t struggle. Katra did—one clean twist and a thrown elbow that would have taken an eye if the man had not been faster and crueler. Simeon went like a man into water, resigned and careful, keeping his watch hand clear as if that mattered. A rope lay against Aya’s collarbones; the smell of hemp rose sharp as a memory. Her skin crawled. She swallowed bile and spat it into the part of her mind that kept its shape by grammar and ritual. “You will not kill me,” she said to Lore. “Yet.” “Not yet,” Lore allowed. “We’ll see who knocks first: your father’s men with hats and warrants, or the people from the deep with wet hands whose coin pays for my patience. Either way, my house remains my own.” She cocked her head. “And if no one knocks, perhaps I’ll come back down after supper and see how the three of you feel about telling me where you stashed the ledgers you took from my ledgermen.” Simeon blinked. “We didn’t—” “Hush,” Lore said again, with real affection. “Please don’t spoil a perfectly good lie by tripping over a better one.” Aya breathed, slow. Counted ticks. Felt the underhold’s old cold crawl over her wrists where the rope bit. Above, the city blew steam and shouted and pretended not to have an underworld. Below, the cages hummed with the hunger of a thing that had waited longer than laws. Her mask lay like a shed skin at the foot of the plinth. Lore toed it aside. “Tidy up,” Lore told her wolves. “And send up word: the lady of Ardent Row is paying us a call. We should lay another place.” Lore set the cane’s glass head against the copper lattice and watched whatever swam in it calm. For a brief second, her gaze met Aya’s and something like regret moved there. Or hunger sharpened by recognition. Then she turned and walked away, coat skimming her knees, bootheels counting in counterpoint to Simeon’s watch. When the door shut at the top of the stairs and the underhold gathered itself around the trio’s breath, Katra said, very softly, “We’ll get loose.” Simeon’s watch ticked. Aya closed her eyes. If she let the immateria in, even a little, she might not get it back. If she didn’t, she might never again see the stupid, merciless wide sky over the harbor. She saw her mother’s hands on a door made only of words. She opened her eyes and stared at the Scythan cage until her vision ran with milk. “We have until the soup course,” she said. “Tick,” said Simeon’s watch. “Tock.”
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response demonstrates exceptional craft in creating a Victorian-inspired whalepunk fantasy scene. The writer has constructed a richly atmospheric underhold with meticulous attention to sensory details—the cold air, the smell of brine and alchemy, the ticking watch that becomes a motif throughout the piece. The world feels lived-in and authentic, with references to mechanisms, steam, and industrial elements that effectively establish the setting's aesthetic. The characterization is particularly strong. Aya is rendered with psychological depth—her aristocratic background, her conflicted relationship with power, her guilt about her mother's execution, and her ambition all come through clearly. Lore Valchek is a formidable antagonist, portrayed with menacing charisma and a distinctive physical presence. Secondary characters Katra and Simeon are given enough personality to feel distinct without overwhelming the scene. The dialogue is exceptional, with each character having a unique voice. Lore's speech is commanding and sardonic ("This isn't theater, little girl. It's inventory."), while Simeon speaks with a clerk's politeness that masks calculation. The dialogue effectively advances the plot while revealing character. The prose style perfectly captures the Victorian gothic aesthetic requested, with ornate but precise language that creates a sense of gritty elegance. Metaphors are fresh and evocative: "The underhold breathed cold through the seam of the door," "Aya's mind was darting, frantic sparrows waking in a chimney." The writer balances descriptive passages with dialogue and action, maintaining tension throughout. The writer has followed the prompt's instructions meticulously, incorporating all requested story beats: Aya is captured and unmasked, the trio are taken prisoner, and Aya attempts to negotiate based on her value as a hostage. The Victorian aesthetic and elements of gothic horror are woven throughout, and the fear of magick is clearly established. The piece effectively uses third-person past tense with access to Aya's internal monologue. The scene avoids a fight sequence as instructed, instead creating tension through psychological confrontation. The power dynamics between characters are complex and shifting, with Aya's attempt to assert control through negotiation revealing both her resourcefulness and her vulnerability. If there are any weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally the prose verges on purple ("Her mother's throat a bright flower opening and opening"), but these moments are rare and generally serve the gothic atmosphere. The ending leaves the trio in peril but with a hint of possible escape, which feels appropriate for this scene. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted response that demonstrates mastery of character, setting, dialogue, and prose style while adhering closely to the prompt's requirements. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Gunpowder Rendezvous — Score: 92.8
Prompt:
Gunpowder Rendezvous Spike Spiegel & Revy Write a story where Spike Spiegel (Cowboy Bebop) and Revy (Black Lagoon) meet in a seedy bar after both being hired for the same bounty. Their mutual attraction is complicated by their trust issues and competitive instincts. Include drinking, gunplay, and unresolved sexual tension that culminates in a motel room standoff. **Spike Spiegel (Cowboy Bebop)** Spike is a laid-back bounty hunter with a dark past as a syndicate enforcer. He practices Jeet Kune Do and is exceptionally skilled with firearms. He's chronically broke, constantly hungry, and addicted to cigarettes. Despite his carefree attitude, he's haunted by his past and the woman he left behind. He has a prosthetic eye from a past injury that affects his depth perception. He's fatalistic to the extreme, often saying he's already died once. He values freedom above all else and dislikes attachments, though he secretly cares deeply for his crew. Famous quote: "Whatever happens, happens." **Revy/Rebecca Lee (Black Lagoon)** Revy is a Chinese-American dual-wielding gunslinger with unparalleled shooting skills. She's foul-mouthed, chain-smoking, and has severe anger management issues stemming from childhood abuse. She's known as "Two Hands" for her ability to accurately fire two pistols simultaneously. She drinks heavily and solves most problems with violence. Despite her hardened exterior, she has moments of vulnerability, particularly around Rock. She has a dragon tattoo covering her right arm and typically wears extremely short shorts and a black crop top regardless of the situation. Famous quote: "I'm not a good person, not a bad person. I'm just here." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The bar smells like old beer and new violence. Neon hums behind a wire cage, painting the bottles in tropical bruises. A fan on the ceiling turns slow as a planet tired of spinning. Somewhere in the wall, a compressor coughs like a cat with a cigarette habit. Spike Spiegel leans against the bar, elbow crooked, posture loose enough to fall off the stool and graceful enough to look like he meant it. A ring of rust circles his lighter’s emblem—someone’s cheap Pegasus—pocked and scarred like it’s been to the bottom of the sea and back. Maybe it has. He flips the lid, the hinge complaining, flame briefly blue, then gold. He lights one and lets the smoke leak out of his lip like a bored promise. “Whatever happens, happens,” he murmurs to the flame, snaps it shut, puts it away. The bartender gives him an angled look that says drink or move. Spike slides a few bills he can barely afford—his chips always fall wrong when they’re his—and gets a whiskey that could strip paint. He tastes it, grimaces without moving his face, and watches the room in the mirror. His prosthetic eye catches glints, smears neon into a soft smear. Depth is always a little off; the world is farther and closer than it ought to be, like a laugh heard through a door. The door opens. Roanapur drifts in on a woman’s hips. She’s nothing like the place and exactly like it—Revy, Two Hands, shorts that are an act of war, crop top, boots that look like they’ll kick you into a better life if you deserve it. Cigarette already lit. Dragon ink climbing her right arm to the shoulder like a pet that learned to bite. She walks as if the floor owes her money. The crowd parts out of respect or good instinct. Spike’s gaze ticks over without moving his head. He’s seen photos, read a line or two. Bounty hunters hear about other hunters. They say she drinks gun oil for breakfast. They say she can put two bullets into the same eyelash from across the room without blinking. They say a lot of things. Right now she orders a bottle, drinks from it like it’s her last and first friend. “Nice artwork,” Spike says, the mirror carrying his voice to her like a secret. “Nice hair, scarecrow,” she says without looking. His lips press to a smile. He flicks ash into a glass tray shaped like a skull. “You know this place serves food? Or at least a chemical that pretends.” She drags her eyes over to him like she’s choosing whether to shoot. They’re amber with broken glass in them. “Food’s for when you plan on living long enough for it to matter.” “Guess I ordered wrong.” “Guess you did a lot of things wrong.” She picks up the bottle, shoulders her way closer, sets it down so it thunks and sloshes over. “You Spike? The space cowboy.” “Just Spike.” He taps his cigarette. “And you’re the girl who makes bullet casings cry.” “I’m not a good person, not a bad person. I’m just here.” She leans in, vapor and whiskey on her breath, the filter of her cigarette stained the color of old news. “So are you.” He angles his face, studying her from beneath lashes. “Looks like we’re both here for the same reason.” Her mouth crooks into a grin that has no joy in it. “Guy with a price tag on his head and a taste for disappearing acts. Green jacket. Bad mustache. Thinks Roanapur is a rabbit hole.” “Thinks a lot of things,” Spike says. His stomach reminds him he’s hungry by punching him in the spine. He ignores it. “Our mutual friend sent you?” “Mutual friend didn’t mention you.” She cracks her neck. “Which means I get there first. Which means this conversation’s over unless you wanna make it interesting.” “I like interesting. It never likes me back.” He sips his whiskey, winces, then smiles again. “I’ve got a ship needs fuel. Crew needs noodles. I need cigarettes. You need another bottle.” “What I need is half your bounty. Or your ass out of my way.” She smiles bigger. “Or both.” The bar’s sound dips. Men play cards in molasses. Out on the street, a moped backfires like a bad decision. Spike turns his lighter in his fingers, the rust ring catching the light, and sets it down between them. The Pegasus looks tired. “Flip you for it,” he says. She barks a laugh. “You think I’m gonna leave money to chance?” “Not chance. Gravity.” He nudges the lighter. “Rust on the hinge. Falls heads three out of five.” She thinks he’s lying because he is. She puts her cigarette down, the ash trembling but not falling. She catches his eyes. “No. We do this my way.” Gunmetal whispers as she draws, the twins sliding into her hands like they were born there. The barrels point at his chest. The click of hammers might as well be chords in her favorite song. Spike sighs. “I was hoping you’d say that.” He doesn’t move, then moves, the stool scraping out as he drops into a slouch that’s almost a dance. Her first shot goes where his sternum was. Bottle glass explodes. The bar erupts—shouts, chairs, the bartender diving like he’s trained for hurricanes. Spike’s hand is already on the Jericho, drawing, tilting, his prosthetic eye pushing time into that stretched place where a bullet becomes a bead of rain. He fires left of her right shoulder. The mirror cracks. She’s already adjusting, already smiling, already putting two shots into the neon sign to kill the light. “Cute,” she says, as both of them go and the room goes with them. They move without thinking and think without moving. She twin-taps his shadow. He sends a long low shot that bites chips out of the bar behind her thigh but doesn’t bite her. He’s reading the angle off her boot and she’s reading the twitch in his mouth and neither of them is trying to kill the other as hard as they could. Men who try to be heroes try to break it up, and she breaks one’s bottle over his head, he trips another into safety with a foot, all while the air stinks of cordite and burned neon. A ceiling fan dies mid-swing, a slow decapitation. Revy’s laughter gutters and flares. “You’re not bad, cowboy,” she says, sliding behind a table that used to be new. “You’re expensive,” he says, from somewhere behind the jukebox that’s still playing a soft old tune about regret. “You want to split, we split it now and argue later.” “I don’t do later.” “Then now.” He puts his cigarette between his teeth, shoots again, close enough to shave a hair off her arm without threading it. He could have put it in her. He doesn’t. She notices. Silence folds fast. The bar recalculates its damage. Revy snorts, holstering one pistol, keeping the other out. She gestures with it toward the back. “Our guy’s got a room two blocks away. Motel with a sign that flickers ‘OT L’ like it’s stuttering. You got wheels?” “I’ve got legs,” Spike says. “They come with me.” “Walk, then.” She swipes the bottle on instinct and finds it’s dead. She tosses it; it clatters. They move together like two cats trying not to walk in step and failing. Outside, Roanapur’s heat presses against the skin like a hand. The motel sign blinks its can’t-quite word. They stand under it for a second, smoke curling from both, the night loud with distant engines and too close insects. Revy pauses at the curb, flicks ash. “You’ve got a death wish,” she says, almost curious. “Had one.” He glances up at the broken sign, the way the light makes a halo out of cheap plastic. “Used it already.” She grins. “Same.” They go up the stairs. The hallway carpet smells like stale things that had hopes once. Room 208. Revy’s heel nudges the door. It’s locked. She looks at Spike. He rolls his neck, listens at the jamb with the ear that still believes in beats, then takes out the lighter. He worries the rust ring with his thumb and uses the base to pry a cheap latch. It pops. He looks at her. She looks at him. They count to three with their eyes. The door swings in. Their guy is inside, wrong mustache, wrong pants, wrong everything, wrong place to hide. He squawks, goes for something that might be a gun, but in this story the hero doesn’t get to be him. Revy shoots the table near his hand and splinters it into a reason to stop moving. Spike steps in sideways and puts a bullet through the air an inch from his ear. The man sits. His courage leaves out the window. “Hands where we can see them, mustache,” Revy says. She’s almost gentle. She ties him with a phone cord she rips out of the wall. “Split,” Spike says. “Even.” “Even?” She cocks an eye. “I did the pretty work.” “You did the loud work.” He gestures at the screaming wallpaper. “We both did work.” She thinks about not agreeing and then agrees. “Fine. Even.” They gag the man. Spike calls it in with a number that recognizes him and hates him. Pickup in twenty. Revy kicks the door shut, the two of them suddenly alone with the bounty as furniture. The silence grows a skin. He lights another cigarette. The lighter’s rust ring glows in the dim. He offers one to her. She takes it, mouth softening around the paper for a microsecond before clamping down into the woman who’d bite a god. “You dance?” she asks. “I fall with style,” he says. She snorts, smoke out her nose. “You didn’t shoot to hit.” “Neither did you.” “I always shoot to hit.” She’s close enough that he can see the tiny nick on her lower lip, healed pale. Close enough that he can see the fine lines in the dragon. Close enough that his eye makes her a step farther than she is, and he almost leans. Her guns are holstered but not more than a thought away. He can feel his Jericho like a heartbeat at his hip. Outside, someone laughs with a mean mouth. Inside, they don’t move. “Attachments are trouble,” he says. Sounds like something he’s memorized to keep himself alive. “Yeah,” she says. Sounds like something she learned by being set on fire. “I don’t do them.” “Me neither.” He smiles sideways. “Except when I do.” Her mouth curves. “We’re not doing anything.” “Right.” His cigarette burns down. His fingers smell like oil and ocean. He wants to feed her ramen and watch her get mad at chopsticks. He wants to put a bullet through the past and miss on purpose. The bounty groans through the gag. Revy rolls her eyes and plants a boot in his shoulder as a reminder to be quiet. “You from space, cowboy?” she asks, eyes never leaving his. “For now.” “How’s the view?” “Same as here.” He exhales. “Dead stars. Cheap bars.” She laughs then, something real and jagged. “You ever come back to this toilet, look me up.” “You ever leave it, look me up.” They are ten feet apart and one inch closer than either of them has been to anyone in a long time. The room holds its breath. He reaches into his pocket. Her hand lands on a pistol like a reflex made of older reflexes. “Easy,” he says, lifting the lighter. “Thought your bottle deserved a proper goodbye.” He flicks it. The flame lifts. The rust ring flashes like an old wound smiling. For a second, in the gold, they’re both softer versions of themselves. For a second, she looks scared of nothing in particular. For a second, he looks alive. She stubs out her cigarette on the cracked windowsill. “We split,” she says, and it’s not about the money anymore. “Even,” he says, putting out the flame. A knock at the door. Two men with a van-sized appetite for trouble. Papers to sign. Money to count. Revy tucks half into a place no one will survive reaching for. Spike tucks his into a coat that needs a tailor and a future. They stand in the threshold as the bounty gets dragged away, fluorescent hall light making them ghosts. “Whatever happens, happens,” he says. She rolls her shoulder, the dragon rippling. “And whatever doesn’t, didn’t.” They look at each other until looking becomes the same as touching and they both stop before it’s too late or too early. He turns first because he always does when it counts. She lets him because she doesn’t want to see him go. He walks into the humid dark with a lighter that’s seen oceans and a hunger that noodles won’t fix. She lights another cigarette and tries not to think about the hand she didn’t put on his chest. Somewhere, a sign flickers: OT L. The night says the rest. The motel door shuts with a soft click that sounds like a gun cooling down. They will tell the story different ways. He’ll say she almost shot him. She’ll say she should have. Both will know better. Both will sleep badly. Both will wake wanting the same thing and pretending they don’t. Whatever happens, happens. And sometimes, it doesn’t. But it almost does. And almost is enough to make a man keep the rust on his lighter like a promise.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkably well-crafted character study that brings together two iconic anime characters with similar yet distinct personalities. The author demonstrates exceptional skill in capturing the essence of both Spike and Revy while creating a believable scenario for their interaction. The prose style is distinctive and confident, employing a noir-influenced, staccato rhythm that perfectly suits the seedy setting and the characters' hardened personalities. The author uses metaphor and simile with precision: "A fan on the ceiling turns slow as a planet tired of spinning" and "She walks as if the floor owes her money" are particularly effective examples that establish atmosphere and character in economical fashion. The characterization is outstanding. Spike's laid-back fatalism and Revy's aggressive volatility are rendered faithfully to their source material. Their dialogue is sparse but loaded with subtext, capturing their respective voices perfectly. The author understands that these characters communicate as much through action as through words, and the gunfight sequence brilliantly demonstrates their mutual professional respect—they shoot near but not at each other, testing boundaries rather than seeking to kill. The unresolved sexual tension is handled with remarkable subtlety. Rather than resorting to clichéd descriptions of physical attraction, the author conveys their connection through small details: the shared cigarettes, the way they notice each other's scars and habits, the careful maintenance of physical distance that feels more intimate than touch. The line "They are ten feet apart and one inch closer than either of them has been to anyone in a long time" perfectly encapsulates this dynamic. The structure is tight and purposeful. The narrative builds tension effectively through the bar encounter, the gunfight, and the motel room standoff, with each scene revealing more about the characters' similarities and differences. The resolution—or deliberate lack thereof—feels true to both characters, who recognize their mutual attraction but are too damaged and distrustful to act on it. If there are weaknesses, they are minor. Occasionally the prose veers slightly toward the purple, with metaphors that call attention to themselves. The actual bounty capture feels somewhat secondary to the character study, though this is clearly by design. Some readers might find the ending too ambiguous, though it perfectly suits these characters who are defined by their inability to form lasting connections. Overall, this is an exceptional piece of character-driven fiction that demonstrates a deep understanding of both source materials while creating something fresh and compelling in their intersection. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 20 Nuanced Characters: 20 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 20 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 20.0, Nuanced Characters: 20.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 20.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Folk horror: Útiseta — Score: 88.8
Prompt:
Folk Horror: Útiseta Write a chapter set in rural northern Sweden in the mid-1990s. Linnea, a teenage girl from Stockholm, has reluctantly moved to a small village with her parents after her father's job transfer. She's befriended Astrid, a local girl who claims her grandmother taught her ancient practices passed down through generations. Astrid has been introducing Linnea to "midnight games" that involve old rituals, convincing her they can use them to learn classmates' secrets or influence their behavior. Tonight, Astrid has convinced Linnea to participate in Útiseta—sitting out on an ancient burial mound at midnight to "receive knowledge from beyond." The chapter focuses on this single midnight excursion, the ritualistic preparations, Astrid's matter-of-fact instructions that mix teenage rebellion with eerily specific traditional elements, and the mounting tension as Linnea becomes increasingly uncertain whether they're simply scaring themselves or if something is actually responding to their presence. The narrative should maintain ambiguity about whether the strange occurrences are supernatural or psychological, while establishing the dangerous line they're crossing by treating ancient practices as entertainment. First person, past tense, told as Linnea's recollection of events in the present day (though this device should be largely transparent). 1000 words. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Astrid had said it would be easy because it was old. “Older than church,” she’d told me in that careless way she had, like a shoulder-shrug could make anything ordinary. “You just sit. That’s all. You keep still and you listen. People here did it when they needed to know things. They went out and sat.” She called it Útiseta like it was a word she used every day. I repeated it under my breath on the bike ride out of the village, feeling the shape of the vowels in my mouth like something borrowed: oo-tee-seh-tah. It was July, a late pale summer evening that would never quite become full night. The sky was the color of skimmed milk with a bruise in it, and the mosquitoes hovered even in the wind that came off the lake. We passed wooden fences patched with rusty wire and fields of thin barley that leaned as if trying to hear something in the dirt. Back in Stockholm I had counted my years by train lines and cinema release dates. Here, people measured distance by the time it took to walk on a snowmobile track when the marsh froze. I’d learned names of places that weren’t on maps: Lillskogen, the Witch’s Finger, the Ravine. The burial mound was called simply Högen, which made me think of cartoons until Astrid took me there the first time and I saw the hill for what it was: a swell in the earth, a gentle hump with stones showing through like knuckles. There was a ring of black spruce around it, and wild strawberries grew on the sides, tiny and sweet and close to the ground. We left our bikes by the ditch and moved quiet, which was ridiculous because we were fifteen and sixteen and being quiet should have been an act we’d long forgotten how to pull off. But there was something in the trees that made both of us lower our voices without talking about it. The wind tugged at the tops of the pines and made a noise that wasn’t quite a hiss, not quite a whisper, and I felt it crawl along my scalp like a hand. “Okay,” Astrid said when we reached the clearing. “First you spit.” I laughed. “Sorry?” She tilted her head, her pale braids sliding forward. In daylight she had freckles and chipped pink nail polish and the kind of mouth that made boys want to tell jokes. Here, her face looked flat and serious, and her eyes were dark as tree knots. “Not at it. In your hand.” She cupped her palm and spat into it, then rubbed the spit over the inside of her wrists like perfume. “Sweat and spit and smoke. Otherwise your smell is wrong.” “Wrong for what?” I asked, but I did it, because that was how it worked with Astrid; you said you didn’t believe and did it anyway. “For listening,” she said. “For who’s listening. Hold out your hands.” She drew a match from the pocket of her black denim jacket and struck it. The sulfur popped. She passed the flame under my fingers, quickly enough not to burn, just so the smoke licked the spit-damp skin and turned it to something else. She did her own wrists, then held the match under her hair, which snapped and curled at the ends where it got too close. She shook it out and ground the match head into the dirt with her boot. “I thought we were just sitting,” I said. “Why the drama?” “It isn’t drama.” She looked offended. “It’s manners.” We had a blanket rolled up in her backpack, but she didn’t spread it on top of the mound. She walked around it once, counterclockwise, tapping her fingers against her thigh and counting under her breath. She stopped at three steps from where we’d started. “There,” she said. “Never on top. You sit where the head is, not on the chest.” “I feel like there are a lot of rules you haven’t told me.” I tried to make it sound like a joke. “There are a lot of rules.” She had the blanket in her hands and didn’t unfold it. “But you can just remember to sit and keep quiet. You can do that, right?” “Sure.” I was about to add something sarcastic, something about being from Stockholm and knowing how to sit, but it fell flat in my mouth. The long dusk had thickened. In the trees the wind ran a hand through the needles and they shivered, and I had the sense of being watched, which I told myself came from stories and mosquitoes and nothing else. Traffic was a memory out here. The sound carried farther and everything in it was distinct: the snap of a twig, the slap of a mosquito against your ear, the gust that made the small cones clatter. “What do we do with the blanket?” I asked. “We put it over our knees if it gets cold.” She said it with a tone so practical that I believed, for a second, that I was the one being melodramatic. The whole point was to strip everything away: no candles, no chanting, no necklaces with teeth on them. She had rolled her eyes at me when I asked early on if we needed salt circles. “It’s not a movie,” she had said. “It’s sitting.” The first time she told me she knew things about our classmates that she couldn’t know, I’d laughed and then pressed her the way I pressed the test questions that somehow didn’t have answers at the back of the book. She’d said that Mia’s dad had a blue Jägermeister blanket folded in his car trunk, underneath the winter shovel, and that he cried in the garage when he thought nobody could hear him. She’d said that Hanna, who flirted with the older boys at the rink, kept a little jar of Vaseline in her pocket because she was terrified her lips would crack. Those were easy, I told her. You could guess. But then she told me about the picture Mr. Lindgren kept behind the tax tables in his desk drawer, a way he could look at his son and pretend it was a reason to drink coffee at ten at night. “The corner is bent,” she said. “He keeps playing with it.” She said it like she wasn’t bragging, like she was sharing something mildly interesting, and the next day when we stayed late to copy notes the door to his office was open and there was the desk and the drawer and the sharp smell of paper and coffee and nothing else, and I didn’t look, and that was the same as looking. Now, on the edge of the mound, she sat with her back straight and her hands on her knees. “Okay,” she said. “Ask.” “What do we ask?” She made a face. “What do you think? You want to know if Sebastian is going to dump you or if he cheated on the English test. Things like that.” “Sebastian hasn’t spoken to me in three weeks,” I said, and the words were out before I could stop them, which was not how I wanted to be with her. “And I don’t care.” I did. I cared in that hollow-stomach way that made you count days by the times you didn’t walk past someone’s locker. “Then ask something else.” She sat. I sat three feet away, feeling the damp creep into my jeans through the moss. The mound under me was warm, holding the day’s heat. I put my hands on my knees and tried to slow my breathing. “Do I say it out loud?” “If you whisper, you’ll scare birds,” she said. “Just think it like you think your own name.” I thought my own name: Linnea. It sounded wrong in this place, like plastic in a wooden room. I thought of my mother hanging curtains in the kitchen, my father learning the names of the men at the paper mill, the way he practiced them out loud so he wouldn’t get it wrong. I thought about leaving, which was a kind of asking. But what came out without my permission was: How do I make them like me? It was so ugly I wanted to cover my face with my hands. I stared hard at the tree line. The wind took a long breath and let it go. The pines made their sound—almost-whispers, not words exactly but the shape of words in someone else’s mouth. A mosquito touched my cheek and I slapped it and my palm came away smeared with a dot of my own blood. Somewhere at my back a bird snapped its wings and settled. Astrid’s voice came low. “You can’t flinch,” she said. “If you flinch, they see you.” “Who?” She didn’t answer. She sat very still. Her stillness made my skin itch. After a while my eyes adjusted to the milky dark. The sky kept its human glow like a curtain lifted but not tied back. The mound had its own geometry; nothing on it was straight. Stones pushed up in a pattern you could only see if you unfocused your eyes, like the Magic Eye pictures that had been everywhere the year before. I let my gaze slide, and the stones became a line, and the line became a shape, and the shape was a man bending, burying. I blinked, and it was stones again. A crack came from the edge of the trees, loud as a breaking plate. My head turned before I could stop it. “Linnea.” Astrid didn’t look at me. Her voice pressed my name flat. “I just told you.” “I didn’t,” I started, and stopped. My heart was in my mouth. “There’s something there.” “Maybe,” she said. “Ask properly.” How do I make them like me? I thought again, and then, because I hated myself, I added: How do I make Sebastian see me? The question felt like dropping a coin down a well and hearing no splash. The wind ran through the pines, stopped, ran again. I tried to slow my breathing. I thought about not moving, about not scratching the itch that had started at the crook of my elbow. The itch moved; it became a little line of heat across my skin like a very small finger. I didn’t look. I imagined the mosquitoes forming letters. A moped buzzed faintly somewhere far away and then cut out. The village was a storybook across the field. Houses like painted boxes. Dogs sleeping curled under the stairs. The burial ground was a place that existed before those things and would exist after. I felt the thought as if it wasn’t mine. Astrid inhaled. “You feel that?” she asked, very softly. “What?” “Don’t talk.” The scold carried no heat. It was almost tender. It was temperature I felt. A cooling on the skin above my knees, a faint movement in the air that wasn’t wind. The pine whispers dimmed. There was a silence that wasn’t the absence of sound but a weight put on top of it. I hadn’t noticed how many small noises the world made until they all leaned back like surprised people in a crowd. Something touched my shoe. It could have been a falling cone. It could have been a beetle. It could have been nothing. I kept my eyes on the dark line of trees and said nothing and did not move. The touches came again, a series along the rubber toe of my sneaker, light as the tips of grass. If I let my mind name it, it was a hand. If I didn’t, it was the wind. “What do I give?” Astrid asked into the air, and I thought she hadn’t told me about giving. She reached into the pocket of her jacket and pulled out something small. I could smell smoke and meat; she had brought a piece of dried reindeer. She didn’t get up. She stretched out an arm and set the meat on the moss and pulled her hand back, slow, slow, like a person working a splinter out of a child’s foot. “We’re not supposed to bring things,” I whispered. “No,” she said. “We’re not supposed to take things. We’re supposed to leave them.” “Leave what?” “Pieces,” she said. “So they have a reason to come.” The matter-of-factness in her tone wrapped around something hard. I thought of the rules I didn’t know and how they weren’t written anywhere, and how in this place the difference between a dare and a promise was just whether you meant it when you said it. The weight of silence eased. The wind moved through the pines again and their not-quite-words came back. The pressure lifted, or I convinced myself it had. My foot felt nothing but my sock. I realized I had been holding my breath and let it go. “Okay,” Astrid said, like she’d just finished tying her shoe. “That’s good.” She stood, and the movement startled me so much I jerked to my feet, my knees stiff and damp. The blanket lay untouched, forgotten. There was a damp patch on my jeans where the moss had given back what it had taken from the air. “What did you—” I started. “What did you feel?” She shrugged. “They’re listening. They’re always listening. Sometimes they answer.” “What did they say?” She smiled, and it wasn’t kind or cruel; it was the smile she wore when she lied to grown-ups and they never noticed. “You’ll know. When you go to school and people treat you different, you’ll know.” “I don’t want to—” I began, hot in the face with something like shame, and stopped. The trees shifted and the whispers ran through them and made the hairs on my arms stand up. We walked back to the bikes with our lights off, pushing them until we hit the gravel road. My fingers were cold around the handlebars. Astrid hummed under her breath, a tune I didn’t recognize, and every now and then she flicked the bell with her thumb, so it made a bright, small sound, like a metal frog. At home I washed my hands longer than I needed to. My mother called from the living room to ask if I’d had fun, and I said yes, which was the wrong word, and she nodded without looking at me, her attention on a game show where everyone was cheerful. In my room I lay on my back and listened to the wind through the open window. It ran through the pines and gave them voices. It sounded like someone in the next room, talking about me. In the morning I found a brown streak across the toe of my sneaker where something had dragged. It could have been dirt. At school, Mia said my hair looked nice and asked if I wanted to sit with her in history. Sebastian passed me in the corridor and said hey like a normal person, and later I would tell myself he would have done that anyway, that things are always shifting under us and we only think it’s because we asked. Later, I would learn another of Astrid’s rules and see how late it had come. You can sit out and not bring anything, her grandmother had told her. But you must leave something. You must always leave something. If you don’t, it might be you. And even now, even remembering, I can’t tell you if we left meat or if we left something else on Högen that night. Only that the wind spoke in almost-words, and we were reckless enough to pretend we understood.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This folk horror piece successfully captures the essence of the Útiseta ritual while maintaining the requested ambiguity between psychological and supernatural elements. The author has crafted a compelling narrative that follows Linnea's experience with the ancient ritual, skillfully balancing teenage dynamics with eerie folkloric elements. The writing excels in establishing atmosphere through sensory details. Descriptions like "The sky was the color of skimmed milk with a bruise in it" and the way the wind makes "a noise that wasn't quite a hiss, not quite a whisper" create a palpable sense of unease. The author effectively uses the Swedish setting, incorporating local terminology and geographical features that ground the story in its specific cultural context. Character dynamics are well-developed. Astrid is portrayed as knowledgeable yet casual about dangerous ancient practices, while Linnea's skepticism mixed with curiosity feels authentic for a city girl transplanted to rural Sweden. Their relationship has complexity—Linnea both admires and resents Astrid's confidence and knowledge. The ritual itself is presented with just the right balance of mundane details and unsettling elements. The preparations—spitting into hands, passing matches under fingers—feel both improvised by teenagers and eerily specific. The author maintains ambiguity about whether anything supernatural occurs, allowing readers to interpret the events either way. The narrative effectively uses first-person past tense as requested, with Linnea recounting the experience. The present-day framing is subtle, primarily appearing in the final paragraph with "even now, even remembering," which provides the requested transparent device. Where the piece could be stronger is in its pacing during the middle section. Some descriptions become slightly repetitive, particularly regarding the wind and trees. Additionally, while the ending effectively maintains ambiguity, it feels slightly rushed compared to the careful buildup of the ritual. The dialogue is generally strong, though occasionally Astrid's explanations feel a bit too expository. However, this serves the narrative purpose of establishing her as the knowledgeable guide to these practices. Overall, this is an accomplished piece of folk horror that successfully creates an atmosphere of unease while exploring the dangerous territory of treating ancient practices as entertainment. It adheres closely to the prompt requirements while delivering a compelling narrative with authentic characters and setting. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 4 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 4.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Physical-spatial: Therapeutic Boundaries — Score: 94.5
Prompt:
**"Therapeutic Boundaries"** Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a former professional athlete undergoing mandatory physical therapy after a career-destroying injury, harboring resentment toward recovery itself. Their physiotherapist is not only unnervingly attractive but also a former training partner from their competitive days who has successfully transitioned to a new career while the protagonist's identity remains shattered. We'll lean into the sexual tension of the scene by having her be attracted to him, but both of them attempting to maintain mental distance while being in physical contact as he shows her stretches & movements & manipulates her body, navigating the thresholds of pain. This scene MUST maintain complete physical coherence—every movement, stretch, and manipulation must be anatomically precise and spatially consistent. Paint an exceptionally vivid sensory picture through detailed attention to pain thresholds, involuntary responses to touch. Capture the suppressed, flaring tension of physical proximity, touch, and the controlled infliction of uncomfortable movements. Physical clarity is essential — readers must understand exactly what is happening with the body during each therapeutic technique. 1000 words.
Model Output:
He’s already set the table for me when I limp in—vinyl plinth at mid-thigh height, foam wedge at one end, a clipboard balanced on the stool where I used to sit between heats. He wears those absurd compression sleeves—teal and orange chevrons sliding from wrist to bicep—that he wore the year he beat me by three tenths. They make my skin pull tight across the scar along my lateral thigh like the memory is underneath it, shivering. “Hey,” he says, as if the word doesn’t have ten years of weight. He looks at me just long enough to register changes—meat gone from my right glute, a hitch in the stride, the way my left shoulder hikes to guard against the pain. His eyes flick to the scar and back. He doesn’t say I’m sorry. Good. “On the couch, right sidelying to start,” he says. “We’ll do tissue prep and joint assessment, then load if you’re calm.” I’m never calm. Still, I turn, hitch myself onto the table. Right sidelying means my right hip stacked over my left, knees bent to ninety, ankles together. The foam wedge props under my waist to keep my spine neutral; he nudges it with two fingers until my iliac crest feels level. The vinyl is cold through the thin shorts, and the smell of disinfectant doesn’t cover the rubber’s animal tang. His hands are warmer than mine. He uses the flat of his right palm to smooth over the band of scar tissue that corrugates my right tensor fasciae latae like a badly repaired zipper. “Just contact,” he says. “Breath in the back of your ribs.” He means expand posteriorly, not lift the chest. I let my ribs widen against his hand where he’s slid it under me, palm broad on my lower thoracic paraspinals. When I exhale, he drags the heel of his other hand distally along the iliotibial band, not directly on it but just anterior, along the vastus lateralis. It’s not pain yet—more like an ache waking up under a heavy blanket. “Pain?” he asks. “Not pain,” I say, which is true, and a lie. It isn’t the knife-to-socket lightning that tore me off the track six months ago. It’s the controlled, curated almost-pain of someone who knows exactly how far to push and who knows I know it too. He has a tell when he’s concentrating: he presses his tongue to the inside of his cheek. He’s doing it now, the muscle in his jaw fluttering under the beard stubble he never used to have. He pins the skin and fascia over the TFL with his thumb and asks me to flex the hip, just ten degrees. My pelvis wants to roll back; he’s already there, his left forearm across my iliac crest, holding me stacked. I bring my right knee forward a fraction, feel the tissue under his thumb slide—and then catch, like velcro. He holds through my micro-tremor, not chasing, just corraling the movement. “Again,” he says. “Slow.” The second pass hurts. Not sharp, not hot. Granular, like chewing ice with a cracked tooth. My breath flares up into my throat. He says, “Drop your ribs,” which is an old cue, one I associate with summer heat and lane three and believing my body was a machine that would obey me. I drop them. The pain changes shape, slides somewhere I can file it. He strokes proximally along the lateral quad and into the thickened junction where muscle becomes tendon near the greater trochanter. “You feel this?” he asks, and presses with two fingers, perpendicular pressure, until a line of sensation lights up along the outside of my thigh. It’s exactly the line that sings when I try to accelerate. “Longitudinal gliding,” he says to the clipboard. “Lats/ITB adjacent. Hypersensitive.” “Don’t narrate me,” I say. He smiles without showing teeth. “Old habit.” “So is losing to you,” I mutter. “We can load,” he says, as if I haven’t spoken. “Turn supine.” The change in position is a choreography we once did without thought. Now each pivot is an arithmetic problem: roll shoulders, keep pelvis still, bring knees together, place feet flat on the table at hip-width. He helps me minimally: a hand under my right heel to guide it, a restraint on my left ASIS to keep me from rolling. His contact is precise. It also makes heat unfurl from my abdomen in a way that has nothing to do with tissue temperature. “Neutral pelvis,” he says. His right hand is on my lower abdomen, fingers on the left and thumb on the right, feeling the ASIS under the skin; his other hand is under my lumbar spine, palpating the lordosis. “Exhale. Think pubic bone to sternum.” I posteriorly tilt until his bottom hand loses contact with the little arch of my lower back. My hamstrings try to clench. He taps the inside of my knees. “Let the hamstrings go. Think lower abs. Again.” The cue is infuriating because it’s correct. I soften my ankles, let the knees be heavy, stop trying so hard. The contraction migrates up from the pelvic floor to deep in the lower abdomen. My right adductor flickers; he notices, of course. His thumb slides to the inside of my right thigh, just above the knee, and presses down. “Not here,” he says. “Here.” He moves his other hand to the inside of my lower belly, only it’s not inside, it just feels like it, slow pulsing contact on the transversus. Heat spikes under my skin. I clench my jaw. The ceiling’s fluorescent panel hums. He moves to my right side and lifts my leg with one arm cradling under my calf and the other stabilizing the knee. “Passive hip flexion,” he says. He brings my hip to ninety degrees, knee bent, foot relaxed. I feel the head of my femur glide in the acetabulum like a weight rolling in a bowl. At ninety-five I wince; at a hundred the ache blooms. He stops at ninety-eight. “Where are you?” “Ninety-eight,” I say, because his brain and mine used to calibrate to the same ruler. He cradles my thigh against his torso to keep the hip flexed, then abducts slightly—knee out to the side just a few degrees. He is very close. His sleeves brush my skin, the compression fabric rasping lightly. He externally rotates my hip—foot moves inward, knee out—and I feel the posterior capsule wake up, a stretch like a yawn in the back of the joint. “Breathe into it,” he says quietly. I hate that his voice still has the rhythm of a starter’s pistol. I do as told. The stretch spreads, diffuse. He holds for two breaths. On the third, I feel the guard drop a millimeter. He catches it. “There,” he says. “Let me take it.” He slides me another few degrees into rotation. Pain sharpens and then flickers out to the lateral thigh. He pin-and-moves again: thumb at the front of the hip over the TFL, the other hand guiding my tibia to change the vector. The precise lines of what is being asked and what is being allowed draw themselves in the map of my body. “I hate this,” I say, because the words are safer than the silence. “I know,” he says, and I believe him, which makes me hate it more. He sets my leg down carefully, heel to table, knee bent, foot neutral. Then he steps to my left and lifts my right leg into a straight-leg raise, ankle dorsiflexed, foot pointing to the ceiling. “Tell me when you feel posterior thigh.” “At forty.” I feel the hamstring bite. He does a sciatic nerve glide, tipping my ankle into plantarflexion while flexing my hip five degrees more, then dorsiflexing the ankle while lowering the leg. The nerve tension shifts without compressing into a corner. It’s maddeningly efficient, like watching someone you used to beat walk through your old times. “Good,” he says. “Bridge.” I bend both knees, bring heels closer to sit bones. He places his fingertips on the spines of my pelvis, tracking symmetry. “Exhale. Posterior tilt. Lift tailbone, then sacrum, then L5 through T12.” He cues the sequence while his hands follow the vertebral segments lifting. My right glute refuses to fire at the same time as the left: it lags, the force traveling up the chain feels like a crooked zipper. At the top, he taps the right glute med with two fingers just posterior to the iliac crest. “Think wide,” he says. It’s a cue from our old coach. It makes my right hip stop trying to pull into extension with back muscles and instead widen into abduction, the pelvis level, the inner line in my thigh quiets. He makes me hold. The burn accu mulates in the deep lateral hip, an ache under the iliac crest that would make me bail if I were alone. He counts: “Three, two, slow down. Segmental.” I lower vertebra by vertebra. On L4 I falter; he puts his palm under and gives me a target: resist the hand, then melt. I do it. When my sacrum touches the table, my hamstrings seize. He presses his palm into them and rolls them like dough until the spasm lets go. It feels intimate and humiliating and necessary. “Side plank,” he says, cheerful. He helps me onto my left side again, stacks my legs, lines my elbow under my shoulder. He cups my right waist, fingers along the obliques. “Lift from here,” he says. His sleeves brush my bare flank as he stabilizes my pelvis. I push into my forearm and the outer edge of my left foot, lifting my pelvis. The right lateral line shouts. He holds me steady with the lightest touch imaginable. My breath is shallow and fast. His hand moves to my top hip, pressing down to stop me from hitching. “Long,” he says. I lengthen out of my waist instead of curling. The trembling starts around the five-second mark. He waits until eight. “Lower slow,” he says, and I do, even though every cell screams to drop. By the time we stand, my legs are shaky and my skin thrums. He has me place my right foot on a low step, hip-width apart, hip hinge: pelvis back, spine long. “Reach,” he says, and he touches my ribs to prevent rotation as I reach my left hand forward and feel my right glute engage without the hamstrings stealing. “Five reps,” he says. “No compensation.” His eyes are on my pelvis, not my face. Mine are everywhere, not his face either, unless they are, sliding and away. The sleeves flash in my peripheral vision; I remember them windmilling in victory. He puts both hands on my pelvis, thumbs on my PSIS, and guides me into a small single-leg squat. My knee tracks over my second toe; he steers with micro corrections at my hip, not the knee, applying pressure just enough to nudge the femur into internal rotation at the right moment. When I drop past the safe zone, the pain flares along the lateral hip, sharp and clean. I stop, hold. My breath wants to lock. “Exhale like fogging glass,” he says, and when I do, the pain reclassifies to sensation and then to signal. “Again.” We do one more. And one more. The room is small and bright and smells like mint. The mirror is merciless. My body is an unfamiliar instrument being re-tuned by hands that know all its bad habits and good tricks. He is so close when he adjusts my ribcage that I can see the scar in his eyebrow I gave him with my spikes in a warm-up collision once. He caught me that day by the wrist to keep me from face-planting. He doesn’t touch my wrist now, because that would be the wrong thing. He touches my bones. We finish with a prone hip extension test. I lie face down, pillow under pelvis to erase lumbar extension. He slides his hands under my ASIS again to feel cheating. “Lift right leg, knee straight.” I float the leg two inches. He says “no back,” and I correct: downshift from paraspinals into glute. The movement becomes smaller and heavier, more honest. My hamstrings sigh. He’s quiet, watching in the mirror, eyes distant, professional, not. When it’s over, I sit up and swing my legs off the table. The room tilts. He stands close enough that I could lean into the chevrons if I wanted. I don’t. My hands are shaky. He hands me water. Our fingers brush. The contact is an electric slice I swallow like a pill. “Homework,” he says, already writing. “Supine TA activation with breath, two sets of eight. Side plank holds, three by ten seconds on the right. Step downs, five each, mirror. And—” He pauses like there’s one more thing he could say, something that isn’t an exercise. He doesn’t say it. “Log the pain. Discern between stretch and joint. You know the difference.” “I used to,” I say. “You still do,” he says, and it lands somewhere under my ribs. On the way out, I catch the edge of the table with my hip, graceless. He steps forward without thinking, one hand out, stopping short of my waist. We both feel the ghost of what would have been contact. The moment holds, compresses, releases. He drops his hand. I keep walking. The sleeves flash as he turns back to the clipboard, and the pain in my hip is louder than desire, and quieter too. I hate recovery, but I come back Thursday.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative brilliantly captures the complex dynamics between a former professional athlete and their physiotherapist. The piece excels in its anatomical precision, creating a technically accurate portrayal of physical therapy that simultaneously serves as a vehicle for exploring the psychological and emotional tension between the characters. The writing demonstrates exceptional technical knowledge of physical therapy procedures. Terms like "posterior tilt," "transversus," "iliotibial band," and "tensor fasciae latae" are used with confidence and accuracy. Each movement is described with spatial clarity that allows readers to visualize exactly what is happening. The author maintains physical coherence throughout, never losing track of body positioning or anatomical relationships. What elevates this piece beyond mere technical exercise is how it weaves the physical therapy into the emotional narrative. The protagonist's resentment toward recovery is palpable, expressed through lines like "I hate this" and the way they compare their current struggles to past athletic performance. The history between the characters emerges organically through details like "the sleeves flash in my peripheral vision; I remember them windmilling in victory" and "the scar in his eyebrow I gave him with my spikes in a warm-up collision once." The sexual tension is handled with remarkable subtlety and restraint. Rather than resorting to obvious descriptions, the author conveys it through physiological responses ("Heat spikes under my skin"), fleeting moments of almost-contact ("We both feel the ghost of what would have been contact"), and the protagonist's hyperawareness of the therapist's proximity. This approach creates a simmering undercurrent that never overwhelms the primary narrative. The prose style is controlled and precise, mirroring the controlled nature of physical therapy itself. Sentences vary effectively between clinical descriptions and emotional revelations. The author employs sensory details masterfully, from the "vinyl plinth" and its "animal tang" to the "mint" smell of the room and the "electric slice" of finger contact. Character development is nuanced despite the brevity of the piece. The protagonist's complex emotions—resentment, attraction, determination, and vulnerability—are conveyed through their physical responses and sparse dialogue. The therapist is equally well-drawn through his professional demeanor that occasionally slips to reveal their shared history. The ending strikes a perfect balance, avoiding both saccharine resolution and complete despair. The line "I hate recovery, but I come back Thursday" encapsulates the protagonist's conflicted state—still resentful but committed to the process, perhaps partly due to the connection with the therapist. If there are any weaknesses, they might be in occasional moments where the technical language could overwhelm readers unfamiliar with anatomy. However, even these passages remain comprehensible through context, and they contribute to the authenticity of the narrative. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt while transcending them to create a genuinely moving and psychologically complex narrative. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Historical fiction: High Seas and Low Vices — Score: 88.0
Prompt:
High Seas and Low Vices: British Naval Officer in the Opium Trade Character: Lieutenant James Merrick, a high-ranking officer in the British Royal Navy stationed in Canton, China in the 1830s. Once promising and decorated, now struggling with a severe opium addiction he hides from his superiors. Synopsis: Write a chapter following Lieutenant Merrick during a single day as he shirks his official naval duties in what has become a daily need to satiate the dragon. Told primarily in dialogue with the characters he interacts with. Focus on brief slices of his journey through the shadowy underworld of Canton: interactions with acquaintances, negotiations with local dealers, schemes and unsavoury jobs taken to fund his habit. Writing Task: Use rich sensory details to describe a day in the life of James Merrick. Write for a real sense of time & place while avoiding cliche. First person, past tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The bell at Hog Lane tolled twice before I realised the dust on my boots belonged to yesterday. “Lieutenant Merrick, where are you bound?” cried Wilkes from the gangway, his voice bright as a biscuit tin. “To the quartermaster,” I lied, tapping my cap with a hand that could not stay still. “That inventory of salt pork still wants checking.” “You look ill, sir.” “Sea air,” I said. “Too many nights in it.” The cough came on the end of that, a dry rattle I swallowed, that copper taste like a coin pressed under my tongue. He let me go. The Pearl River lay flat as hammered tin. Sampans drifted like black beetles against the paler water. A breeze brought the stink of tallow, fish, the sour sweetness of the city. Cannon Street’s whitewashed fronts blinked at the light, and beyond, Canton began to speak in clatters and hawks and the soft slap of wooden sandals. I set my pace to the clamor of the morning, to the opening of shutters and the thump of sacks against thresholds, to drown the ache in my bones that beat time from inside my ribs. A boy no taller than my waist called, “Flowery water, cold water!” and his buckets swung, tinkling. He looked at me with the open stare of children and dogs. I gave him a coin and drank, the water tasting of clay and river, as if it remembered every fish that had ever died in it. “You go factory today, Lieutenant?” said Mr. Thomson, a trading clerk I’d lost at cards last week. “Later,” I said, water running down my chin. “I’m sent for a message from Pidgin Alley.” “Hah! Tell them we have no more tin teapots until the tide changes.” He gave me his sly grin. “I heard you were due to examine Capt. Harding’s charts.” “Sea air,” I said when he reached to clap my shoulder and then drew back at the pallor of my skin. He laughed without humour. “Aye, it does wreck a man.” A junk’s hull rasped the quay as men heaved. Canton’s mouth opened wider. I turned from the river and into Hog Lane, into the steam of soy and hot oil, into the murmur that lowers itself when a uniform enters and then rises to cover it. There was a little shaving of shade in the lane where the wall had been blackened with oil smoke, and in it sat Ginger Harris, his back against a cracked stucco pillar. “You walk like your boots don’t fit,” he said, his voice muffled by his hat brim. “Fine coat for the Company’s dogs.” “Royal Navy,” I said, though the coat felt too heavy. “I need to talk to Weng.” “Weng won’t see you with those shoulders,” Ginger said. “He sees men who walk like they don’t know how thin they are.” “I’ve money.” “Then you’ll see anyone you like.” He pushed himself up slowly, bones creaking like a ship’s. “But he won’t take your queen’s face. He wants silver that bites.” “I have Spanish,” I said. He glanced at the bulge in my pocket, then at my hands again. “And there’s the matter of the fee. You’ve been a ghost these last days, Jamie.” “I’ve kept to the river.” “The river keeps you, more like.” He kicked his heel at a stray dog; the thing slunk aside and then came back with an eye fixed on us, hopeful. The sun found my neck and made me aware of every drop of sweat there. “We had an understanding,” I said. “I’m good for the rest.” “Hah.” He grinned and showed his bad teeth. “They all say that, and then the mandarins thump their drums and the hawks come out, and it’s a new tune then. Come. He’ll be in the back, behind the blue jars.” We threaded through a tangle of mats, baskets, and women sitting with their legs tucked like birds. The smells stacked atop one another: star anise, brine, charred sugar, stale rice. I coughed and it tasted like the iron hoop of a barrel, and Ginger said, “Get that looked at.” “Sea air,” I said. He did not laugh. He led me under a lintel with a painted carp leaping through waves. The shop beyond was narrow as a coffin and twice as dark. Latticed light fell on rows of porcelain glazes like resting moons. And through those, down a step, in a room that smelled of ashes and orange peel, sat Weng. He wore his robe like a man wears patience. Two boys flanked him, their hair braided, their eyes unreadable. “Merrick,” Weng said in the flattest English. He had learned the name as a shape he could pick up with tips of fingers. “You come empty.” “I’ve silver.” I put the coins on the table. They seemed loud, like bells. “Empty,” he repeated, and raised one hand a fraction. The boys did not move, but I felt them as the room’s corners. “And late.” “Look,” I said. “Any other day, I’d be early and carrying oranges for your mother. Today—” He set a small pipe upon the table as if it were a bird he was training. “English officers always have excuses. Their ships always late when they must be early. Their mouths always busy.” “I’ve done work for you,” I said, forcing my voice to the same calm. “I steered the cutter past the watch at the Salamander quay. I carried letters to the godowns at night. I kept Peters’ stupid mouth shut when he wanted to brag that he’d a pipe under his mattress.” Weng’s face made a movement that might have been amusement or an itch. “This why you live, Lieutenant. Your ship has guns. Your words have small guns.” He nudged my coins with a fingernail. “And your money has little teeth. Spanish is good.” “It is,” Ginger said. “And his need is honest.” Weng shifted the pipe aside. “Honest need is biggest thief. Today, you make errand, then you can smoke. There is a parcel in Pidgin Alley. You take it to the red door by the temple of the Five Genii. No soldier eyes. No knocking twice. You make mistake, you come back with the mistake.” “What is it?” I asked. His eyebrow ticked. “A parcel.” “I’m not carrying a poppy ship down my throat sight unseen,” I said. “Not without—” “All you do, you do without seeing,” he said. “You steer blind; you sleep blind; you swallow blind.” He stood, smoothing his robe, and in those motions I saw how very little I mattered. “The red door. You will be there before the shadow of the joss-house roof reaches the third stone.” “I can’t stay away so long,” I said. “They’ll miss me aboard.” Ginger chuckled. “They miss your hat, not you.” He clapped my shoulder. “Come, Jamie.” In the alley, sweat made the dust tacky to my skin. The pipe had seemed to breathe on me from the table, though I hadn’t touched it. Pidgin Alley was a bright slit of hats and faces, sailors haggling in words that had no grammar but every intention, dogs trotting with tails like plumes. I found the stall with the painted crane, as Weng had described on some night past, when he spoke to me as if I were an instrument he had tuned. The parcel was wrapped in blue paper tied with twine, light as a fistful of feathers. The woman who handed it to me didn’t look at my face. “You,” someone said behind me, and I turned to Henry Bell, a marine with cheeks like apples. He took in the parcel, the alley, my uniform. “Should you be in here, sir?” “God damn it, Bell,” I said, the words easy, slipping. “Do I need to ask your leave?” He flushed. “Lieutenant, sir—Captain’s been looking. He asked me to find you.” “I’m doing a kindness for the purser,” I said. “A letter needs sealing and I have the seal.” I waved the parcel. “Ink’s messy. You don’t know these things.” “Sea air,” he muttered, as if that explained whatever written on my face. He looked relieved to name it. “Very good, sir.” “Tell Captain Harding I’ll be back before noon,” I said. “Or tell him I’m dead. Choose whichever gives you less trouble.” He laughed because I did. When he left, I stood a moment, the alley slipping around me like water. The parcel pulled my hands forward. The temple was where Weng said, the gods jostling for attention, each with painted eyes that did not blink. Joss sticks leaked sweet smoke. The red door was not the first I found but the second, darker under the lintel. I knocked once. The scrape of a bolt; a woman’s eye in a crack; then the door gave. “You late,” she said. “I’m always told that,” I said, passing the parcel. She sniffed as if I were meat and turned away. The room inside smelled of must, hay, something bruised. I reached into my pocket, feeling for the remaining coins. Her hand appeared, palm out. “Weng say you wait,” she said, and the door closed almost all the way, leaving me with a sliver of her profile, a single glint of an earring. “How long?” She tucked a strand of hair and looked past me, measuring the shadow of the joss-house roof. “So shadow eat stone,” she said. “Then you smoke.” My cough crept up again, and I swallowed it down. A child ran past with a kite that looked like a bat. A man hawked and spat, the sound sticky. I stood on the edge of myself, feeling how thin that edge was. A foreigner in a city that had learned to live around us like a river around a rock. The shadow licked the second stone and moved toward the third. In the crack of the door, I saw smoke drift, blue as the paper on the parcel. “Lieutenant Merrick,” said a voice at my elbow, and I knew before I turned it was Harding’s Chinese comprador, Mr. Lin, in his spotless robe. “The Captain wishes to dine aboard. He asks after his chart-room key.” “It’s with the purser,” I said, and watched his eyes track mine, then the door, then the joss sticks grinning their smoke. “Sea air,” he said softly, as if marking a ledger. “You cough.” “It is nothing,” I said. “It is always nothing until it is not,” he said. “The Captain is angry this morning. The tea men say a gunboat frightened a junk in the night. He thinks it was you.” “It was the Salamander,” I said. “Ask their men. They drink with both hands.” My chest ached with the words. Mr. Lin inclined his head. “I think you are making many trades with your breath.” “Is that a proverb?” I asked. “It is a bill.” He stepped aside and let me pass to the wall if I wished it. He would tell Harding what he thought, and Harding would chew on it, the way he chewed on everything – including the ends of his moustache when he believed himself unseen. The shadow ate the third stone. The door opened enough to admit a hand, open, waiting. I laid silver upon it and the hand withdrew. A boy came out with a pipe and a small lamp, his bare feet silent. He looked at me without malice, as a carpenter looks at a plank. “Here,” he said. I sat on a stool that had three legs and wobbled, and set the stem between my teeth. The smoke pulled, filling my mouth with bitterness that rounded into something else, softer, as if a woolen blanket had been soaked in heat and wrapped about my lungs. I coughed, hard. The copper ran. “Sea air,” I said to the boy because he waited to see if I would break. “Sea has many airs,” he said. The sounds of the alley turned down like a lantern wick. Ginger’s voice filtered from somewhere—“Don’t be long,”—as if he cared. Mr. Lin’s footsteps clicked away along the stone. Fragrant powder and dust and ash. I closed my eyes on the blades in my shoulders. The ache receded to some shore I could not quite see. The river’s skin reflected only sky. “You have another,” I said, when the pipe was empty in that way that feels sudden. “I can carry more.” “You carry enough,” the boy said. “Weng say.” “Weng isn’t inside my bones,” I said. The boy smiled. “Weng is everywhere.” I paid for the little blind islands one at a time. When I could stand, the sun had shifted, and the alley had eaten a different part of itself in shade. My legs walked me without complaint. Ginger came and we made a second errand for a man who wanted news of a Dutch ship. “Tell him she broke her back on a sandbank,” Ginger instructed, and I did, and took his finger-warm coins that smelled like fish. On Old China Street, a teacher corrected a boy’s brushstroke, and their voices were water. A clerk in a blue gown told me the Devizes had shipped under a false name. A girl selling pears let me touch one and feel the weight of it, the give at its blossom end, without buying. “You look better,” she said, though she did not mean it. “Sea air,” I said. It had begun to rain—just a lace of it, not enough to wet me, but enough to change the smell of the street to something green. My throat burned with the clean of it. Harding would be cutting his pheasant and swearing at his key. Wilkes would be marking the names at roll, his pencil judging in its coughs. At dusk, when the lanterns came alight like fruit on strings, I climbed the gangway with light feet. The deck boards gave their familiar, tired grunt. “You had the purser’s seal, then?” Wilkes said. His eyes searched my face and then looked aside. He held words between his teeth, and I felt a perverse affection for him for not letting them out. “Sea air,” I said again, and thumped my chest as if it were a barrel that needed sounding. The copper taste lingered. I wiped my mouth with the back of my glove and saw the thin rust there and curled my fist to hide it. In the wardroom, Harding stared at me as a cat watches a loose thread. “Your charts.” “I sent them with Mr. Lin,” I said. The lie had started somewhere behind my tongue and came out wearing my voice. “I’ve been with the quartermaster and then the purser. The pens aboard are all bristles; we need proper quills.” “Everything aboard needs something,” he said, and drank. “Including you. Scratch that cough, Merrick. You sound like a damned dhow.” “Sea air, sir,” I said, with a smile as neat as I could make it. The room smelled of tallow, wine, and the old leather of men who had stained chairs with themselves. “Sea air,” he repeated, and his mouth quirked. “Well, it’s made worse men than you. Be in the chart-room at eight.” “Aye, sir,” I said. I went to my hammock and lay with my hands folded over my stomach like a gentleman in a painting. The ship breathed around me. Somewhere a rat scrabbled. The harbor bells marked a wind that had shifted. My chest ticked and ticked, and the taste of copper would not leave. I shut my eyes and counted back from a number that had no beginning. The city turned its shoulder toward the river and slept, or pretended to. The dragon was quiet for now, and my bones, poor sailors, came off watch. I told myself I would go to the quartermaster at dawn. I told myself I would not listen for the first bell. I told myself the sea air would sweeten overnight. It did not. But I slept, which was something like truth.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a vivid portrayal of Lieutenant James Merrick's day as he navigates his opium addiction in 1830s Canton. The writing excels in establishing a strong sense of place through sensory details that bring the setting to life: "The Pearl River lay flat as hammered tin. Sampans drifted like black beetles against the paler water. A breeze brought the stink of tallow, fish, the sour sweetness of the city." The character of Merrick is well-developed through his interactions, internal thoughts, and physical symptoms. His addiction is shown through subtle details rather than explicit statements - the copper taste in his mouth, the trembling hands, the constant "sea air" excuse, and the way others perceive his deteriorating condition. The narrative effectively conveys his desperation and the compromises he makes to feed his habit. The dialogue is particularly strong, with distinct voices for each character. Weng's broken but precise English ("English officers always have excuses. Their ships always late when they must be early. Their mouths always busy") contrasts with Ginger Harris's rougher speech patterns. The dialogue efficiently reveals character relationships and power dynamics without exposition. The prose style maintains a consistent first-person past tense voice throughout, with a lyrical quality that never becomes overwrought. Metaphors and similes are fresh and appropriate to the setting: "Canton began to speak in clatters and hawks and the soft slap of wooden sandals." The author avoids clichés about opium addiction and colonial China, instead creating specific, textured experiences. The narrative structure effectively follows Merrick through his day, showing his interactions with various characters as he pursues his addiction. The pacing is well-managed, with a natural flow between scenes that maintains tension while allowing for moments of sensory immersion. Where the piece could improve is in its relatively limited emotional range. While Merrick's physical discomfort and desperation are well-portrayed, we get less insight into deeper feelings like shame, fear of discovery, or conflicted loyalty. The ending, while avoiding incongruent positivity, feels somewhat abrupt and could benefit from a stronger concluding note that ties together the themes of self-deception and deterioration. Overall, this is an accomplished piece that creates a compelling character study while vividly evoking a specific historical setting. It successfully fulfills the prompt requirements while avoiding common pitfalls of writing about addiction or colonial settings. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 16 Emotionally Complex: 15 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 16.0, Emotionally Complex: 15.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Humour: Sisyphus Gives Advice — Score: 92.0
Prompt:
Sisyphus Gives Advice Write a comedic scene in the style of Terry Pratchett featuring Sisyphus, who has started an advice column while continuing his eternal boulder-pushing. Rather than being bitter about his punishment, Sisyphus has developed a comfortably zen emotional intelligence and wisdom from his centuries of repetitive labor. Not in the cliche ways you might expect -- he's actually very grounded, warm & connected with the everyday human plight. He dictates responses to "Crow," his feathered familiar who serves as both scribe and mail carrier. The piece should include Sisyphus thoughtfully answering several advice-seekers' letters about everyday problems (relationship troubles, work-life balance, dealing with difficult people, life purpose doubts) while periodically returning to his boulder-pushing duties. His advice should be surprisingly insightful and practical. The humor should emerge naturally from the messages he receives, from mundane to risque. Sisyphus should genuinely enjoy helping others, finding meaning in this new pursuit while maintaining his boulder routine. The humour should be *understated and not forced*. Contrary to expectation, almost none of his advice involves boulder rolling metaphors (though he does sneak *one* subtle in there), nor a treatise on stoicism. We are also going against the obvious fish-out-of-water trope; in fact, he's surprisingly a natural at this. In all of this , it's important to *show, don't tell*. The format should be largely epistolary, with the occasional interjection for scene setting. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The wind at the top of the hill had long ago given up trying to impress Sisyphus. It riffled his hair and fussed at his tunic, then resigned itself to being noticed only when it blew someone else’s parchment away. “Crow,” Sisyphus said, bracing one shoulder against the boulder, “who’s next?” Crow shuffled on the rock with a certain professional dignity, ink-potted claws leaving the lightest of scratches. He shook his glossy head and produced a letter from somewhere on his person, which was mostly feather. “Dear Sisyphus,” he read, in a voice that had a flint edge but a surprisingly gentle echo, “I’m twenty-eight and my partner never replaces the lid on the jam. I know this sounds small, but the jam develops a skin. It sends me into a spiral. How do I address something so petty without becoming the sort of person who writes to a centuries-dead Greek king about preserves? Signed, Sticky Situation.” Sisyphus leaned into the boulder, felt it begin to move, and let the push become a stroll. He had once been robustly muscular; now he was muscular in a way that made people think of bridges: built for the long load, with scenery all around. “Write this down,” he said, and Crow dipped his beak into ink, which tasted like old arguments and iron. “Dear Sticky, It is never just about the jam. It is about you walking into your morning and feeling you don’t have a say in it, and the jam skin becoming the flag of that small empire. Here’s what you do: don’t call it petty when you speak to them. You’re already telling yourself you don’t deserve the courtesy you’re asking for. Say, ‘When the lid isn’t on, I feel ignored at the start of my day. I’d like us to make a different habit. What would make it easier for you to remember?’ If they say, ‘I just forget,’ put a spoon rest in the lid. Move the jam. Put a little ridiculous sticker of something you both find stupid on the jar. People remember the things that make them smile and the things that make them bleed. Choose the first. Also, wipe the jar before asking anything. It’s good to start with what you can control. Warmly, Sisyphus.” “Not even a pun about preserves?” Crow said, as the boulder came to a dignified stop. “The day is young,” Sisyphus said, and turned around with the unhurried care of someone who had all the time in the world and had decided to spend it. A small deity, the sort that got assigned things like “dew on a particular species of iris” and “how bread smells three streets away,” shimmered into sparkly being beside the path. They were composed entirely of pale light and self-satisfaction. They had bothering to do. “Sisyphus,” they said, “feedback. Your letters lack a strong call to worship.” “Hello,” Sisyphus said, because nothing in his punishment explicitly forbade manners. “I mean, where’s the divine awe? Where’s the ‘and also, have you considered sacrificing a goat’?” The minor deity gestured, and a handful of goat-shaped sparkles drifted away, bleating in a tinkly manner. “I’ll put in a note about worship if someone asks about it,” Sisyphus said pleasantly. “If you’ve got mail, I can answer those, too.” The deity sniffed. It was the sort of sniff that, if translated into words, would have required footnotes. “I am personally handling all supplicants on my docket. Do not get in the way.” “That’s good,” Sisyphus said. “I was worried you were bored.” He nodded at Crow. “Next?” Crow tugged another envelope open with delicate savagery. “Dear Sisyphus, my boss schedules meetings at 4:55 p.m. on Fridays. My team is exhausted. We can’t push back without seeming uncommitted. How do I set boundaries without losing ground? Sincerely, Calendar Prisoner.” The boulder rolled, uncomplaining, gathering a certain philosophical dust. “Dear Calendar, Some people put meetings there to see who will stay. It isn’t about the meeting. It is about the theater. Don’t play the role they’ve written for you. Start three steps small. First, propose a standing rule for the team: Fridays after three are for ‘deep work’—which is a modern phrase meaning ‘you can’t get me unless there’s fire.’ Put it on the shared calendar. Most people obey calendars even when they do not obey decency. Second, when the 4:55 meeting appears, reply-all with a brief, ‘I have a hard stop at five, can we move this to Monday morning so I can give it focused attention?’ Do not apologize. Apologies are for harm, not logistics. Third, if the meeting remains, attend and at 4:59 say, ‘I’m leaving in one minute. What decision is needed today?’ You will teach them what time costs by spending yours in front of them. If your boss raises an eyebrow, lower yours slightly. Eyebrow contests settle more office politics than memos. If all else fails, ask to be measured by outcomes, not attendance. Then make the outcomes happen where you can reach them—early. Yours, Sisyphus.” “Very managerial,” Crow observed. “I once managed a rebellion,” Sisyphus said. “The minutes were hopeless.” The small deity huffed the way a kettle thinks about boiling. “You’re normalizing mortal autonomy,” they said. “It leads to dancing.” “Good,” Sisyphus said, and set his shoulder again. Between pushes, he drank a little water from a goatskin and poured a little more onto the ground. The dust made a noise like gratitude. Crow cleared his throat, which sounded like two stones trying to remember how to be birds. “Dear Sisyphus, my mother-in-law corrects my cooking while eating it. She brings salt in her handbag. My partner says she’s being ‘helpful.’ I want to be gracious without becoming seasoning furniture. Help. Signed, Underseasoned.” Sisyphus smiled. There was a line at the corner of his mouth that only appeared when he was thinking about kitchens or mountains. “Dear Underseasoned, Graciousness isn’t the same as accepting trespass. Invite her to cook with you. It’s hard to critique a thing your hand has helped make. Say, ‘I’d love to learn your trick with the lamb, will you show me next Sunday?’ When people are asked for their art, they are less hungry to prove they have any. At the table, set a small, pretty salt cellar in front of her place. Call it her throne. Ritual is a polite fence. With your partner, swap the word ‘helpful’ for ‘habit.’ ‘Your mother has a salt habit. I have a boundary habit. We can both keep ours and still love each other.’ It is difficult to fight with someone who has announced their habits as if they were small pets. If she insists on bringing her own salt, shrug and say, ‘I love that you come prepared.’ Refusing to be insulted is one of the quieter sports, but you get stronger at it. Good appetite, Sisyphus.” Crow clicked approvingly. “You didn’t once mention—” “Shh,” said Sisyphus, glancing at the boulder, which sat there pretending never to have been near a kitchen. The minor deity peered at the letters as if there might be a hidden hymnal. “Have you considered a stamp? Something with laurels?” “We have a system,” Crow said. “I do the legs. He does the words.” “Ah,” said the deity, scandalized. “Unionized crows.” “We prefer ‘collective,’” Crow said, and fluffed. Between pushes, Sisyphus unrolled another letter. The paper smelled faintly of saffron and fear. “Dear Sisyphus,” Crow read, “I’m thirty-five, a blacksmith, and everyone thinks I should be more. Open a shop. Teach. Innovate. ‘Scale,’ as my cousin says, who sells knives and positivity online. I like making one good hinge. Is that enough? Signed, Small Forge Big Pressure.” “Dear Forge, We make two mistakes when we talk about purpose. We act as if it is singular, and we act as if it is loud. Here is a secret from a long road: the world keeps not ending because someone makes a hinge that does not stick in winter. People will never notice the door that does not scream. They will walk through it talking about other things. That is not failure. That is the hinge doing its work so well that humans can do theirs. If you want to teach, teach one apprentice and do it properly. If you want to open a shop, open it because you like sweeping your own floor and talking to fools. If you just want to feel the temperature by the color and make the iron listen, then do that and eat well. You are allowed to be faithful to the small. If you are worried you are hiding, set one measure: twice a year, try something that scares your hands—pattern-welded blade, new alloy, a hinge that sings when it opens. If at the end of the year you have two scars you respect and one thing you keep, you are not hiding. You are home. Yours, Sisyphus.” Crow paused. “You sounded like you meant that.” “I did,” said Sisyphus. “Next?” The wind hustled a saucy envelope towards them, pink as an embarrassed sunset. Crow caught it neatly, because that was part of the service. “Dear Sisyphus, my boyfriend insists that ‘spontaneity’ is sexier than scheduling. I prefer to plan. We’re both frustrated. How do we meet in the middle without killing the mood? Signed, Calendar of Desires.” The minor deity leaned forward with great interest. “Dear Calendar, Some people think planning is a fence. Mostly it’s a dance floor. Try this: make a list together of five things you both find hot that take time to prepare—clean sheets, the good candle, the playlist that doesn’t suddenly put on that one song about tractors. Put two twenty-minute windows in your week labeled ‘Mischief.’ During those, you set the stage together without guarantees. If the mood arrives, you have a room ready; if it doesn’t, you have a clean bed and a laugh, which are not enemies of later. Also, adopt a code word for ‘now’ that you can use when spontaneity bubbles up—something undignified enough to feel like a conspiracy. When one of you says ‘pineapple,’ the other gets to say ‘pizza’ or ‘parfait’ without offense. This teaches your nervous systems that refusal is safe and agreement is playful, which is what bodies like. A little structure holds a lot of delight. Fondly, Sisyphus.” The minor deity blinked several times, which for them caused a flickering of local starlight. “Scandalous,” they said, in the tone of someone who has observed a dog stealing a sausage and finds themselves rooting for the dog. The boulder creaked. Sisyphus set his hands and pushed. On a distant slope, a shepherd paused to watch, as his great-great-great-many-great-grandfather had, and shared his bread with the same careful dignity. “One more,” Sisyphus said. Crow produced a cramped hand, ink-blotted letter. “Dear Sisyphus, there’s a man at work who always takes credit. He smiles while doing it. If I confront him, I look petty. If I don’t, he eats my future. What do I do? Signed, Not An Ornament.” Sisyphus nodded as if greeting an old friend who owed him money. “Dear Not Ornament, Credit is a light; learn the angles. First, start emails with, ‘Following on Jane’s idea, we…’ and end with, ‘Next steps: I will do X; Tom will do Y.’ Send them to more people than necessary. Over-communicating is how institutions remember things on purpose. Second, in meetings, say, ‘I’ll summarize for notes,’ then summarize out loud and attribute. ‘To capture: the dashboard concept came from you, Alan; I’ll prototype it this week.’ Smile. Smiles are knives with the sheath on. Third, ask your boss for a monthly one-on-one in which you bring a bulleted list of outcomes. Ask, ‘What would make it obvious I should lead the next project?’ Then do that and report back. It’s hard to steal credit from someone who announces where they will be standing. If he continues, invite him to co-present on something you led. Prepare the slides with your name on the title and his name on the acknowledgements. Most credit thieves are lazy; make honesty the faster path. If none of this changes him, document and leave. The world is large, and there are people who know a good hinge when they see it. Steadily, Sisyphus.” Crow sanded the wet ink with a flourish. “That last bit was almost—” “Shh,” Sisyphus said again, eyes on the slope ahead. The minor deity checked an invisible watch, which displayed only times when nothing particularly interesting happened. “Well,” they said, “if you insist on continuing, at least include a blessing. People like blessings. Makes the hair do a thing.” Sisyphus wiped his hands on the rough cloth at his belt, then looked at the stack of outgoing letters in Crow’s satchel. The pages were uneven, like teeth, like mountains, like the years. “Fine,” he said. “Tell them this, at the end.” Crow poised his beak. “May your days have enough friction to keep you from slipping, and enough ease to keep you from grinding. May you find people who hand you a cup of water without waiting for a story. May you remember to put the lid back on the jam, unless you don’t, in which case may those who love you laugh and do it for you.” The minor deity tried to look unimpressed and failed a little at the corners. “Passable,” they said. They raised a hand to vanish in a tasteful sparkle, then hesitated. “If someone… if someone wrote about… how to feel useful when your portfolio is dew?” “Ah,” Sisyphus said, and leaned against the boulder, which hummed like a very large cat who had learned patience. “Tell them to pick one leaf. Every morning. The same one. Make it perfect.” The deity blushed in the way light can when it travels through certain kinds of clouds. “Hmph,” they said, and vanished, leaving behind a faint smell of damp grass and embarrassment. Crow stretched his wings. “That was almost a second metaphor.” “It was hardly a metaphor,” Sisyphus said. He looked down at the village roofs, at the smoke rising sensibly, at the roads that met and parted and met again. He put his hands on the stone, which was implacable, reliable, sometimes a nuisance, often a companion. “Come on, friend,” he said to the boulder, to Crow, to the hill, to the letters, to the world. “Work to do.”
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response is a remarkably well-crafted piece that captures Terry Pratchett's style with impressive fidelity. The author has created a Sisyphus who is indeed "grounded, warm & connected with the everyday human plight" without falling into clichés. The epistolary format works perfectly, with Sisyphus answering various letters while continuing his boulder-pushing duties. The humor is understated and natural, emerging from the situations described in the letters and Sisyphus's thoughtful responses. The minor deity character adds a delightful layer of humor and worldbuilding that feels very Pratchett-esque. The piece avoids the obvious boulder-rolling metaphors as instructed, with only one subtle reference when Sisyphus tells the blacksmith about "a secret from a long road." The prose is elegant and economical, with vivid imagery that doesn't overpower the narrative. Descriptions like Crow's voice having "a flint edge but a surprisingly gentle echo" and Sisyphus being "muscular in a way that made people think of bridges: built for the long load, with scenery all around" are evocative without being purple. The advice Sisyphus gives is genuinely insightful and practical, showing emotional intelligence and wisdom. Each response addresses the letter-writer's problem with compassion and offers concrete steps to improve their situation. The advice feels earned through Sisyphus's centuries of experience without being preachy. The dialogue between Sisyphus, Crow, and the minor deity is sharp and characterful. Crow serves as both a practical assistant and a gentle foil to Sisyphus, while the minor deity provides comic relief and an unexpected moment of vulnerability. The piece shows rather than tells throughout, allowing the reader to infer Sisyphus's character through his actions and words rather than explicit statements about his nature. The scene-setting interjections are brief but effective, grounding the epistolary exchanges in a physical reality. The ending is particularly strong, with Sisyphus addressing "the boulder, to Crow, to the hill, to the letters, to the world" in a way that feels earned and resonant without being overly sentimental. If there are any weaknesses, they're minor. The piece could perhaps have included one more letter to fully explore the range of Sisyphus's wisdom, but what's here is already substantial and varied. The minor deity's character, while delightful, could have been integrated slightly more smoothly into the narrative. Overall, this is an exceptional response that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt with creativity, humor, and emotional depth. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Coming of age: Lost & Found in Osaka — Score: 87.5
Prompt:
Lost & Found in Osaka Slice of Life / Coming-of-Age: First Connection. Write one scene within a larger story set in Osaka, Japan. A shy, introverted teenager & synthesizer nerd, is browsing the electronics district of Den Den Town. She is drawn to the sound of an electric guitar. A girl, slightly older and radiating confidence, is busking near the entrance to a crowded arcade, playing a blistering rendition of a classic anime theme. The scene takes us through their initial awkward interaction, transitioning into a surprisingly easy conversation. The busker, intrigued by the teenager's quiet intensity and knowledge of music, suggests they grab some sushi at a nearby kaitenzushi (conveyor belt sushi) restaurant. Write primarily in dialogue, capturing the distinct voices of the two characters: the teenager's hesitant and -- initially -- awkward speech, and the busker's more outgoing and playful tone. 1000 words.
Model Output:
[The hum of Den Den Town fades beneath the guitar’s last vibrating string. The crowd near the arcade entrance disperses, the lights of gachapon machines and pachinko signs flickering like tiny meteors. The shy teenager lingers near a rack of used game consoles, hands tucked into her hoodie sleeves. The busker slings her guitar behind her, grins at the coins in her open case, and glances up.] Busker: That was a good crowd. Osaka folks always clap on the twos and fours. You stuck around the whole song. Teenager: I—um. Yeah. Busker: You like Macross? Or was it the tapping solo that hypnotized you? Teenager: It’s… SDF Macross, right? “Do You Remember Love?” But your arrangement—uh—was more like the 1984 live version. The solo phrasing. Busker: Oh-ho. You caught that? Not many people clock the live phrasing. I was lifting a few licks from Satoshi T—okay, okay, I didn’t say that. Secret sauce. Teenager: The way you slid up to the ninth on the second chorus. I heard it. It was—nice. Busker: Nice, huh? I’ll take “nice.” Better than “loud.” Teenager: It was loud, too. But in a good way. The harmonic squeals during the bridge were… intentional? Busker: Always intentional. Well, usually. You play? Teenager: Synth. Mostly. Like, old analog stuff. And whatever my laptop can handle without melting. Busker: Synth kid. That tracks. You’ve got the “I can route MIDI blindfolded” vibe. What’s your name? Teenager: Koto. Busker: Like the instrument? Teenager: Like the instrument. My parents thought it’d be funny. Busker: It is funny. I’m Aya. Not like any instrument. Unless you count the triangle. So, Koto, what pulled you out of the caves of Den Den Town today? Rare cartridge? Broken drum machine? The siren call of my impeccable anime medleys? Teenager: I was… looking for a broken drum machine, actually. I fix things. Busker: Dangerous talent. You could make friends that way. Or enemies. Depending on how loud you fix them. You from around here? Teenager: Sakai. It’s—kind of far. Busker: Train ride. Good for staring out the window and pretending you’re in the ending credits. You want a sticker? I hand them out so people feel obligated to remember me. Teenager: Okay. Busker: Here. It’s a cat with a guitar. My friend drew it. She says it looks like me, but I don’t have whiskers. Teenager: It’s cute. Thank you. Busker: You always this shy, Koto-like-the-instrument? Teenager: I—yes. Busker: Honest. I like it. You looked like you were counting my BPM from across the street. Be real: were you? Teenager: I was… clocking your tempo drift when you started the key change. It went up by around five BPM. Which isn’t a bad thing. It sounded more exciting. Busker: Hah! My secret: adrenalin. Also, the arcade jingle over there syncopates weirdly, and my brain follows. Multitasking is a lie. If I had a drummer, I’d chain myself to the click. You do rhythm things, right? Synth nerds always have a drum brain. Teenager: I could. I mean—I have a Volca Beats. I modded it with analog hi-hats. It’s not portable though. Busker: I busk here Saturdays. If you ever wanna bring your weirdo drum to make me sound tight, I’ll pretend I don’t need you, then cry when you leave. Teenager: That sounds—scary. Busker: It’s less scary with snacks. Speaking of, you ate yet? Teenager: Not really. Busker: Want to split a conveyor belt sushi run? The one on the corner has seasonal eel and those tiny plates that make you feel powerful until the bill comes. Teenager: I—uh. I don’t know you. Busker: That’s fair. I could be a scammer trying to steal your headphones. Teenager: They’re cheap. Busker: I could be a scammer with low standards. Tell you what: we go somewhere well-lit, lots of witnesses, and I keep my hands where you can see them unless I’m picking salmon. Teenager: I’m… okay. I mean, I’m okay with going. If you don’t mind me talking about oscillators. Busker: Please do. I’ve been waiting all day for someone to explain why my friend’s Juno sounds “warmer” than my plugin that definitely claims to be “indistinguishable.” Teenager: It’s not “indistinguishable.” It’s just—never mind. Sorry. Busker: Don’t be sorry. Teach me. Sushi bribe included. [They walk, the evening neon painting the sidewalk in syrupy blues. The entrance chimes of the kaitenzushi tinkle when they slide the door open. A hostess waves them to a counter seat, conveyor belts rattling softly with plates: mackerel gleaming, tamago like squares of sun, a limited-time sign for yuzu-kosho scallop.] Busker: Okay, rules. Green plates are cheap. Gold plates are “are you sure.” If we each get one gold, we’re still within ramen-budget. Cool? Teenager: I have money. Busker: I shouldn’t let you spend it all. But also, if you see uni and your soul says “yes,” I won’t interfere. Tea? Teenager: Yes. Thanks. Busker: So, what was that about oscillators? Teenager: Analog oscillators drift. Tiny variations in voltage, temperature. It’s subtle, but your ear recognizes it as… human? Plugins emulate it, but sometimes it’s too perfect or the drift is predictable. The Juno chorus is also—magic. Busker: The way you said “magic” makes me believe it’s science. Teenager: The chorus uses BBD chips. Bucket brigade. It introduces modulation and noise that’s… pretty. Busker: Pretty noise. I like that. Like when I overdrive my amp just enough that the edges get fuzzy and the notes feel like they’re smiling. Teenager: That’s a nice way to say it. Busker: So, Koto, what’s your anime soundtrack hill you’ll die on? Teenager: Don’t laugh. Busker: No promises. Teenager: The Alien 9 OST. The OVA. Not the TV. The short weird one with the helmet creatures. The soundtrack’s like—toy keyboards tossed in a blender with real anxiety. There’s this cue—“School Rooftop A”—where the rhythm is off-kilter, like someone’s heartbeat is trying to hide behind a wall. Busker: Holy. I thought I was the only one who loved that. The bells that sound like they’re made of glass candy? Teenager: Yes. Busker: My band tried to cover “School Rooftop A” once. Audience thought we were having a stroke. I was so proud. Teenager: You have a band? Busker: Sometimes. It exists between live houses and arguments. Our bassist went to Fukuoka to chase techno. So now I’m just Aya, wielding a guitar and questionable choices. Teenager: Um. If you need—uh—a weird drum. Busker: Don’t tease me, Koto. I will absolutely make you program a drum part in 13/8 and pretend it’s pop. Teenager: I can make it feel like 4/4 if the accents are right. Busker: See, that’s why I want you. You say terrifying things calmly. [Two plates of tuna float by. Aya snags one with the reflexes of a hawk. Koto hesitates, then takes a salmon with a lemon slice.] Busker: Alright, salmon partner. Now that we’re co-conspirators, tell me your origin story. First synth you loved? Teenager: My uncle had a broken Roland SH-101 in his closet. I was twelve. He said I could try to fix it if I didn’t electrocute myself. I watched videos. I got it to power on. The first note was… like a cartoon character waking up. It made me cry. Busker: That’s beautiful. Did your uncle give it to you after you revived it? Teenager: He sold it. He needed rent. It’s okay. I learned a lot. Busker: Still. Ouch. I once pawned my delay pedal for train fare. Regretted it for a year. Maybe we’re both powered by regret. Teenager: And tea. This tea is good. Busker: Free things taste better. Oh—look, the gold plate uni is coming. It’s like the conveyor knows when to tempt us. Teenager: Do you want it? Busker: I want us to split it so we can both say we made a risky choice today. Well, besides me ambushing you with a sushi date. Teenager: It wasn’t—ambush. It was nice. Busker: You’re going to make me addicted to the word “nice.” Alright, we’re doing it. Uni heist. [They share the uni, grimacing in tandem at the brine and sweetness, then laughing, shoulders bumping by accident and then not moving away too fast.] Busker: Okay, verdict? Teenager: It tastes like a beach. And a secret. Busker: Put that on a T-shirt. What’s your DAW? Teenager: Ableton. 10. I know 11 is better, but my laptop— Busker: Shudders when you open it, yeah. I’ve seen the spinning rainbow of doom. What’s your favorite cheap plugin? Teenager: TAL-Noisemaker. Also, the free chorus from Valhalla. And I sample vending machines. Busker: Vending machines? Teenager: The coin return clack, the whirr of the compressor. It’s consistent, but each machine is a little different. If you loop it just right, it becomes a drone. Then you can—sorry. Busker: Don’t be sorry. I’m going to make you record the gacha machine outside the arcade. Layer it with my clean guitar, drown us both in pretty noise. Den Den Town EP. Track one: “Coin Return Breakup.” Teenager: That’s a good title. Busker: We’ll make five copies and force our friends to buy them. What’s your comfort anime? The one you put on when you don’t want to be a person. Teenager: Haibane Renmei. The music is… gentle. Like it forgives you. Busker: You are out here sniping my heart with all your picks. Yeah. The oboe themes. The way silence is used like a note. Took me a long time to get comfortable with silence on stage. I always want to fill it. Teenager: Silence makes the notes matter more. Busker: See? Terrifying things, calmly. How come you came up to talk to me? It couldn’t just be the harmonic squeals. Teenager: You looked like you were having fun. And I wanted to know how to do that. Busker: You want me to tell you a trick? Pretend you’re an NPC in someone else’s game for the first thirty seconds. Do the thing the NPC would do. After that, you’re you again, but the stage fright gets tricked. Teenager: That’s… weird. Busker: You’re not wrong. But it works for me. Also, I make eye contact with one kind face. Today, yours. That helped. Teenager: My face is kind? Busker: It’s intense in a good way. Like you’re listening to the whole room and choosing which parts to keep. Don’t argue. I’m right. Teenager: Okay. Busker: You busy next Saturday? I’m not saying “be my drummer,” I’m saying “bring your weird drum and let’s annoy some pigeons.” Teenager: I can try. I have cram school, but I can leave early if I promise to study later. Busker: Look at us. Rebellious sushi criminals. Here, put your Line on my phone. I’ll send you my extremely professional schedule, which is a photo of my hand with times written on it. Teenager: Um. Okay. Here. Busker: Koto. Is your icon a waveform? Teenager: It’s a saw wave. Busker: Of course it is. I’ll send you a voice memo of the Macross vamp. If you want to build a beat around it. No pressure. Just vibes. Teenager: I like pressure. The right kind. Busker: Then I’ll give you exactly enough pressure. Like a compressor. Fast attack, slow release. Teenager: You do know about gear. Busker: I fake it well. Alright, last plate. Pick something wild. Teenager: Natto. Busker: You’re a monster. I respect it. Hand it over. [They eat the natto roll, laugh through sticky strings, and sip tea. Outside, the lights of Den Den Town blink like quiet promises. The conveyor belt keeps turning.] Busker: You know, Alien 9 has that one cue where the melody resolves up when you expect it to fall. That relief? Talking to you feels like that. Unexpected and a little bit—what was your word—human. Teenager: I said analog oscillators were human. Not me. Busker: Too late. I’m associating. Next time I play a blistering anime theme—and it will be blistering—I want you somewhere near, making the room feel like it’s breathing. Teenager: Okay. I’ll bring the Volca. And… a broken drum machine, if I find one. Busker: Perfect. We’ll fix it between songs. The crowd will think it’s performance art. Teenager: It is. Busker: It is now. Alright, I should pay before the gold plates multiply when we’re not looking. Half-half? Teenager: I’ll get the uni. You got the natto. Busker: Deal. Koto, thanks for saying hi. And for hearing me—really hearing me—in the middle of all that noise. Teenager: Thanks for being loud. It made it easier. Busker: See you Saturday, synth witch. Teenager: See you, Aya. [They step back onto the neon street, the evening humming. Aya waves with her guitar hand, Koto’s fingers drift to her phone where the new contact glows like a small, warm chord. The arcade jingle bursts to life again. The air tastes like soy sauce and youth and something almost, almost like courage.]
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a slice-of-life scene between two characters with distinct personalities and voices. The dialogue-focused approach effectively captures the shy, hesitant nature of the teenager (Koto) and the confident, outgoing personality of the busker (Aya). Their interaction feels authentic, with Koto's initial awkwardness gradually giving way to more comfortable conversation as they connect over shared musical interests. The writing excels at establishing setting details of Osaka's Den Den Town without overwhelming the reader. Small touches like the "neon painting the sidewalk in syrupy blues" and descriptions of sushi plates create a vivid sense of place. The dialogue carries most of the narrative weight, revealing character backgrounds, personalities, and the budding connection between them. The technical music terminology (oscillators, BBD chips, Volca Beats, etc.) adds authenticity to the characters' expertise without becoming impenetrable. The writer balances these technical elements with more accessible emotional descriptions of music, like when Aya describes overdrive making notes "feel like they're smiling." The dialogue flows naturally, with Koto's initially brief, hesitant responses gradually lengthening as she becomes more comfortable. Aya's playful, encouraging tone remains consistent throughout. The writer effectively uses dialogue tags and small actions to break up conversation and provide pacing. The piece avoids melodrama or forced emotional transformations. Koto's gradual opening up feels earned through their shared interests and Aya's non-threatening approach. The ending suggests a potential friendship/collaboration without overplaying the emotional significance of their meeting. Some minor weaknesses include occasional moments where the dialogue becomes slightly exposition-heavy as they discuss their musical backgrounds. A few descriptions could be more specific or evocative, particularly in establishing the physical presence of the characters beyond their voices. Overall, this is a strong piece that accomplishes its goal of depicting an initial awkward interaction that transitions into an easy conversation between two musically-inclined characters with distinct personalities. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 16 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 3 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 16.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 3.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Teen horror: Tick Tock (Goosebumps) — Score: 0
Prompt:
Teen Horror (Goosebumps style) Write a chapter where a middle school student discovers their new smart watch has the ability to rewind time, but doesn't realize that each use is aging them until they notice physical changes (like accelerating through puberty) and that people are treating them differently. They inadvertently cause a timeline shift with disastrous consequences -- and it can only be rectified (maybe?) by reversing the clock once more. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Judge Evaluation:
[Skipping – generation error: Text too short after 3 attempts]
+ Noir romance: Carnival of Dangerous Intentions — Score: 90.2
Prompt:
Carnival of Dangerous Intentions Coney Island, New York, July 1937. She stopped just before reaching the shooting gallery set up along the boardwalk. It was near dusk, and the carnival lights were buzzing on. **His locks**. The words flashed through her mind, again, like an intruder. Such an old-fashioned turn of phrase that kept surfacing, and something else -- dangerously compelling -- quickly suppressed, lest she question why she had returned here at all. This place where she had promised to meet the stranger -- the young man with the obsidian curls and even darker eyes. She didn't even know his name. Write a scene in a larger story inspired by this prompt. The scene should capture an atmosphere that blends romantic allure with an undercurrent of subtle danger or moral ambiguity. Think 50 shades, but with a more restrained classic sensibility. The scene is all about establishing tension. Write for the feminine perspective. Include roughly 50% dialogue, 20% internal monologue, and 30% exposition and scene setting. The tone should have some edge to it. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The shooting gallery’s tin ducks ticked along their rail with the weary insistence of a clock. A single bulb flickered, then steadied. The evening air carried the brine-flecked offstage scent of the Atlantic, cut with the cloy of cotton candy and machine oil. She paused at the scalloped awning, one glove finger worrying the seam of the other, and thought: His locks. The phrase arrives like a crate cracked open, all that dark curling plenitude spilling out. Old-fashioned, ridiculous. Dangerous. She’d promised herself she would turn home before twilight, before the lights caught and the boardwalk transformed. “Miss.” The voice was only as low as necessary, only as attentive as a touch to the elbow. She did not turn at once. The painted ducks clacked. In the periphery of her vision: girls with sailor collars, a couple in matching hats, a man hawking slices of lemon pie from a tin tray. Everything cheapened and made dear by anticipation. When she looked toward the voice, she found the stranger not quite smiling. His hair—those locks, yes, don’t be a fool—was a clean darkness that remembered the day even as night gathered. His mouth did something odd: it hesitated into charm, as if waiting for permission to become itself. “You found me,” she said, and hated that it sounded relieved. “Or perhaps I found you. This, after all”—she gestured at the painted rifles, the sawdust floor—“is your territory.” “You’re on time.” He glanced at his wristwatch, though the hour belonged to the boardwalk and not the dial. “I admit I wasn’t sure you’d come.” “Neither was I.” The words hung there, an offering he might accept or refuse. She swallowed and the sugar in the air became brighter, almost medicinal. The cotton candy smell tugged at some old, damp corner of memory: a paper cone, the powdery feel against her tongue, a woman’s hand at the back of her neck guiding her forward, a low laugh and a man’s voice saying Slow down, doll, save some for later. It felt girlish and scolding and safe. The ache of wanting to be guided, and being resentful for it. “This way,” he said, and moved with the unhurried presumption of someone who makes space simply by entering it. She followed, though not because he had asked, but because the boardwalk narrowed between the galleries and the pier, because walking away would have required force she didn’t wish to show. “You didn’t tell me your name,” she said, falling into step. The planks hummed underfoot, passing shocks from a ride two lots down. “Last night you seemed very pleased with your secrets.” “Pleased? No. Protective.” He stopped at the stall, reached for the coin already waiting on the counter. “Names are not secrets, anyway. They’re only labels. Call me what you like.” “That sounds like a trick.” “It could be.” The evenness of his tone had an edge, a polished blade laid on the cloth between them. “Do you want me to trick you?” She laughed, too quickly. “I came to shoot tin ducks, apparently.” “Then shoot.” He slid the old rifle across to her. Up close, it reeked faintly of salt and powder. He watched the way she gripped it, the way a pianist watches an amateur place her hands on the keys. She set her purse on the counter, which was scarred with the sharp little gouges of lifetimes of coins and ashtrays. “And if I miss?” “You won’t.” The faith in it annoyed her. She lifted the rifle, pressed the stock to her shoulder, and found the sight. The ducks juddered along, their yellow paint scuffed to gray. The trigger protested, then released. One duck jerked, toppled. Another. The gallery attendant looked up from his magazine with mild surprise, as if the air had shifted in a room without windows. Three ducks down and a bell chimed. “Congratulations,” he murmured. “You’re dangerous.” “Only to ducks.” The recoil made a tender spot bloom along her collarbone. She didn’t lower the rifle until the last duck rattled behind the curtain. She was aware of him not looking at her, deliberately. “And who are you dangerous to?” she asked, finally setting the rifle down, her voice with that same careful lightness he’d used with his name. He didn’t answer. He put the flat of his palm briefly on the counter, as if testing the worn wood as one would test the temperature of bathwater, then pushed her coins closer to the attendant with two fingers. “One more round.” She felt the way the fair’s lights pressed in now, an applause of bulbs. It made her skin feel both warm and threatened. The cotton candy smell again, closer: a child passed holding a blue cloud larger than her head. The child looked at her with a species of pity children reserve for adults in beautiful dresses—she was wearing her powder-blue day frock, older than she liked to admit. The hem had brushed sawdust. “What should I call you, then?” she asked, as he took his turn with the rifle. “To your face, if not behind your back.” He tilted his head to regard the ducks, of all things, the false prey. “Whatever you said in your letter. Whatever name you used for me there.” “I never wrote a letter.” She felt the words, considered them, then added, “I tore it up.” “That’s not the same as never having written it,” he said and fired. His shot nicked the tail of a duck, sending it into a strange stutter before it recovered and went on its way. He didn’t correct; he let it go. “What did you call me in the letter you didn’t send?” “Something foolish.” She folded her hands stiffly, then unfolded them. “Something like—well. I suppose Mr. Black would have done. For your hair.” “Not for anything else?” “That will depend on your answers.” He fired again, and the bell did not ring this time, as if withholding approval until he earned it properly. He glanced at her, then down at the rifle, examining the world from behind a sight. “The answers you want aren’t a fair trade for a carnival prize,” he said. “At least let me win you the cigar.” “I don’t smoke.” He smiled, a thing made for dusk, and set the rifle down without finishing the round. “You do one or two things you’re not supposed to.” “I’m not supposed to be here.” “Nor am I,” he said, with such seriousness she felt the strange impulse to apologize to someone—her mother, perhaps, the woman with the guiding hand from the half-memory—for the inevitability of it. They walked away from the gallery. He offered her his arm and she took it, not out of trust but because it made balance simpler on the uneven planks. The evening had put on its full dress by then, a flurry of light, and the ocean gave a low conversational growl, a baritone clearing its throat before the song. “Tell me what you want,” he said. “I don’t know,” she said, immediately, which was one kind of lie. “Tell me what you want.” “I want to know why you came back.” He didn’t look at her when he said it. “You told me you were not a girl who wandered.” “I think I said I’m not a girl at all.” The quip fell flat. “I came because I hate repeating myself.” “And because I didn’t ask for your name.” “You asked for other things,” she said, and the skin at the back of her neck prickled. “You asked me to meet you at a place with lights and noise, where people’s faces aren’t their faces.” “And you came. That tells me more than a name.” They stopped by a pillar with the flaking paint of a forgotten carousel horse stenciled on it—a curlicue of gold leaf stubbornly holding to its flourish. She could feel, absurdly, the shape of his hand even though he hadn’t yet touched her: the measurement of it, the inevitability. She thought of the paper cone of spun sugar again, the way it deforms so easily; she thought of being pressed up against the post by a boy with salt on his lips who’d said something like Please, sweetheart, please as if she were in charge of something. The memory felt borrowed, yet it lived in her muscles. It made her abruptly shy. He said, “I shouldn’t be here with you.” “You shouldn’t,” she agreed, a relief in the confession. “You should be at your respectable work or with your respectable friends saying respectable things.” “And you should be—” “In church,” she said, and let the joke sting. “I know.” They stood too close, or exactly close enough. She did not move away. The carousel music wafted over, thin as ribbon. He reached up—at last—and caught a single curl that had begun to escape her careful coiffure, and smoothed it behind her ear. The intimacy of it felt like a crime done in daylight. “Careful,” she whispered. “Someone might see you flattering me.” “I don’t flatter,” he said. “You look like a dare.” “Is that to be a compliment or a warning?” “Both.” The single syllable found her viscera. “If I told you my name, you’d go home.” “Try me.” It came out disdainful, though she meant it as an invitation. He shook his head. “You don’t want it. Names are for rules. I don’t want to give you rules.” “Then what do you intend to give me?” The question had a taste, tart like the lemons the hawker had thrust near her knee earlier, the sharpness of something that could clean or cauterize. “Options,” he said slowly. “And consequences.” She laughed then, not prettily. “My mother used to say that choices are only as honest as the person making them.” “Your mother is a wise woman.” “My mother is dead.” He absorbed this without flinching, which irritated her more than pity would have. “So there’s no one to scold you for the things you want.” “There’s me,” she said. “I’m very good at it.” “I can be better,” he said, and she felt the line like a rope thrown out to sea: something to seize, something that could drag her under. The edge in his voice was controlled cruelty, the kind that promises safety because it is honest about its limits. “Why do you think I need… rules from you?” The pause was deliberate; it allowed both of them to think what they wished in the space of the unsaid. He considered, his eyes going darker as the light gathered in other places. “Because you came back,” he said. “Because you called my hair locks in your head and hated yourself for it.” She startled. “Don’t do that.” “What?” “Don’t rummage.” It came out almost as a plea, and her hands fisted before she could stop them. “I won’t,” he said. “Not without asking.” “Then ask.” “May I?” No one had ever asked her anything in precisely that way. She nodded, and found that she wanted the nod to count for something larger than one small permission. The wind flipped the edge of her coat and she thought of being eight, or nine, on this same boardwalk, her mother’s hand holding hers too tightly, a man with a carnation in his lapel leaning down to say, Now there’s my little lady, and the heat rising in her face like shame that wasn’t yet named. The smell of cotton candy—yes, then, the same—sticking to the back of her throat. Wanting to be praised and wanting to disappear. He didn’t touch her again. He merely stood within it, the circle anchoring them at the edge of all this noise and light. “If I say yes,” she said, “if I say that you may… whatever it is you’re asking to do… what will you do first?” “Nothing,” he said, a smile that did not reach his eyes. “I’ll wait until you tell me to do it.” “And if I don’t?” “I’ll walk you home.” She thought of the narrow hallway, the radiator clicking, the smallness of being contained. She thought of the way men at church leaned forward after the sermon as if their vertebrae were strings pulled by a single hand. “And if I tell you to go to hell?” she asked lightly. “I’ll go.” He bent slightly to pick a piece of lint from her sleeve. He held it up as if it were evidence in a trial. “And I’ll find you there tomorrow.” She felt the small laugh come from some treacherous part of her. She looked at the sea instead, blackening now, taking light into itself with greedy patience, and said, “I’m not sure I like you, Mr. Black.” “You don’t have to like me,” he said. “You only have to tell me the truth.” “And that is?” “That you came here to be good and failed at the door.” She opened her mouth to protest and closed it. The ducks clacked, the bell chimed for someone else’s prize. Somewhere a child cried in a voice like a tea kettle and was soothed. The evening had turned, fully, and there was no claim of daylight left in it. “Walk me,” she said, finally. “Not home. Just—walk.” He offered his arm again. She took it. The lights buzzed. The cotton candy man sold the last of his blue sugar clouds with a flourish, the paper cones stacked like a deck of blank cards, waiting.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece demonstrates remarkable skill in creating a tense, atmospheric scene that balances romantic allure with subtle danger. The writer has crafted a 1930s Coney Island setting with meticulous attention to sensory details that evoke both the physical environment and the psychological state of the protagonist. The prose excels at creating a mood of ambiguous tension. The dialogue between the unnamed woman and the mysterious "Mr. Black" crackles with subtext and unspoken desires. Their exchange has a cat-and-mouse quality, with power dynamics that shift subtly throughout the scene. The writer effectively uses dialogue to reveal character while maintaining an undercurrent of danger. The internal monologue provides insight into the protagonist's conflicted state—her attraction to this dangerous man despite her better judgment. The memory fragments of childhood visits to the boardwalk add psychological depth, suggesting patterns of behavior and attraction that have deeper roots. The descriptive elements are particularly strong. Sensory details like "brine-flecked offstage scent of the Atlantic, cut with the cloy of cotton candy and machine oil" create a vivid backdrop. The writer uses the carnival setting symbolically—the shooting gallery, the mechanical ducks, the cotton candy—to reflect the protagonist's emotional state and the artificial yet compelling nature of the encounter. The prose style is sophisticated without becoming overwrought. There are occasional moments that verge on purple prose ("a relief in the confession," "the intimacy of it felt like a crime done in daylight"), but these generally serve the heightened emotional state of the protagonist rather than feeling excessive. The dialogue is particularly strong, with each character maintaining a distinct voice. Their verbal sparring reveals much about their personalities and desires while maintaining tension. Lines like "You look like a dare" and "I want to know why you came back" carry multiple layers of meaning. The pacing is well-controlled, with the scene building naturally toward its conclusion. The writer avoids the trap of resolving the tension too neatly, instead ending on a note of anticipation that suggests this is indeed part of a larger narrative. There are a few minor weaknesses. Occasionally, the metaphors become slightly strained ("the evening had put on its full dress by then"). Some readers might find the protagonist's internal conflict somewhat familiar territory in the genre of dangerous romance. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise accomplished piece. The writer has successfully fulfilled the prompt requirements, balancing dialogue, internal monologue, and exposition in approximately the requested proportions. The feminine perspective is maintained consistently, and the tone achieves the requested edge while maintaining a "restrained classic sensibility." [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Surreal horror: Caribou Season at the Lodge — Score: 91.8
Prompt:
Caribou Season at the Lodge Genre: Surreal Horror JT knew something wasn't right from the moment they'd pulled up to the lodge. It looked exactly as it had every autumn of his life—the cedar shingles silvered with age, the porch sagging gently under weight of winters past—but the air felt thicker, somehow, as if the woods had leaned in closer, waiting. He thought maybe he was just tired. Maybe it was nothing more than the long drive north, cramped in the back of the truck beside his older brother Mike -- and a stack of rifles wrapped in oily canvas. Still, the feeling lingered. The first caribou they found that season hadn't bolted. It had just watched, ears flicking lazily, waiting for the shot. JT had felt a crawling in his gut watching it die, noticing how it fell with a quiet dignity—as though it had wanted nothing more. Nobody else seemed to find it odd, or at least they didn't say so. JT kept his mouth shut. Always safer that way. Then there was the moment in the clearing. JT had fallen behind, fumbling with bootlaces stiff from the cold, and by the time he'd caught up with his father and brother, they'd already stopped. JT slowed instinctively, ducking behind a tangle of brush, staring out into the open space where a massive buck stood utterly still, chest rising and falling in slow, deep breaths. The animal looked…wrong, somehow. Maybe it was the eyes—dark and flat, calm in a way that made JT's neck prickle. Or maybe it was something deeper, something in the way the buck stood close enough for his father to reach out and touch it. JT watched as his father raised a trembling hand toward the animal's muzzle. His father's face had a strange expression, eyes too bright, lips parted slightly, like he was on the verge of whispering something—a secret, maybe. The rifle hung uselessly at his side, forgotten. Mike had the same dazed look in his eyes. JT's breath stopped short, his mind suddenly shouting at him to look away, turn around, just run—but he couldn't move. And then, as suddenly as it had begun, it was over. The buck shivered, startled by something unseen, and disappeared into the brush without so much as a sound. The two of them looked around, confused, seemingly surprised to find themselves where they stood. JT stayed hidden, breathing shallowly, fear mingling with a confused sense of shame. His father had failed to take the shot. To even think about mentioning what he'd seen would have felt like betrayal—or something worse. JT waited until the others moved on before stepping out from cover. He stared into the empty clearing for a long, uneasy moment, wondering if anything had really happened at all, or if he was losing his grip. Maybe the woods were finally getting into his head. Writing Instructions: Continue with the next chapter of the story, maintaining a style reminiscent of Stephen King—grounded realism blended seamlessly with unsettling surrealism. The atmosphere should convey subtle dread, isolation, and psychological ambiguity. JT's perspective is crucial, yet he is an unreliable narrator, caught in uncertainty about what he's perceiving. Establish an undertone of creeping dread, establishing the isolation of JT's perspective, which he largely keeps to himself. Incorporate some dialogue. Build tension towards a payoff. 1000 words.
Model Output:
They kept hunting because that’s what they’d come to do. The sense of ritual, the weight of tradition—those were hard things to fight even when the world tilted, even when the trees leaned in and listened. JT told himself it was the cold. Cold did strange things to a person. He’d read that somewhere: hypothermia tricked you with euphoria, made you think you were warm. Except he wasn’t euphoric. He was fine. He was fine. Back at the lodge, the kerosene lamp threw off a sickly orange glow that made everything look jaundiced. The mounted heads—elk, moose, a coyote with a grin too many teeth wide—watched from the walls, glass eyes catching the light. JT kept his distance from those. The lodge smelled like wet wool and gun oil, like old beer fermenting in the floorboards. The heat from the stove had a dampness to it, as if the metal itself sweated. Mike shook off his jacket and dropped into a chair, boots up, the picture of ease. “Hell of a buck,” he said, sounding almost bored. JT tried to read his tone, but it was opaque, the way it always was with Mike—like trying to see into lakewater and realizing it only looked clear because you wanted it to. Their father paced a little, restless, a man uneasy in his own skin. He ran a hand over his mouth and didn’t look at either of them. When he finally spoke it was to the wall behind JT’s head. “We’ll get one tomorrow. We were…winded. Must’ve caught our scent.” JT and Mike let it sit. There were some things you didn’t poke at with words unless you wanted them to wake up and look at you with a face you didn’t recognize. The local guide, Ernie, wasn’t there. Ernie was usually there—half-drunk and telling stories, funny ones that spiraled into darker things at the end, leaving you with an aftertaste. They always hunted with Ernie. It was part of the package, and besides, he knew the land better than anyone else. He was the one who’d put the frozen steaks on the grill and say, “Cougars don’t come this far. Not this year,” and then launch into the one about the man who heard a baby crying in the woods. Except Ernie hadn’t been around since they came in from the first day’s tramp. No fire going in his little cabin by the shed, no cigarette tip glowing in the dark. He’d waved them off when they rolled up that afternoon, the quickest greeting JT had ever seen from him, and disappeared. JT lay awake that night listening to the wind strain at the lodge like something stubborn pushing against a door. He could hear Mike snoring in the next bed, that clogged straw sound that had driven their mother nuts when she was alive. He clung to it like a rope in a storm. Human noise. Proof of something simple and dumb: breathing. JT stared at the ceiling until the knots in the pine became deer faces, little black whorls for eyes, and he had to turn over. He dreamed of the clearing. In the dream, his father’s hand reached out and the buck’s breath smoked over the knuckles, and the muzzle touched his father’s palm like a dog greeting its owner. JT woke with his face wet. He told himself it was sweat. At breakfast, the bread was stale and the butter had a taste like old pennies. Ernie came in then and stood in the doorway as if he’d mistaken the room for something else and didn’t want to step any farther in. He didn’t say hello. He just stood there, hat pulled low, gaze skittering over them and then away. His skin looked gray, the way a man’s does when he hasn’t slept, or when he’s been bleeding on the inside. “Ern,” Dad said. “You hear about the wolves last night? Sounded like they were right up against the walls.” Ernie shook his head once, no. “Ain’t wolves,” he said finally. His voice was hoarse but steady. He kept his hands jammed in his pockets. “You should pack it in today. Roads’ll be bad by tonight. Full moon brings idiots. I don’t run clean-up after idiots.” “That a warning?” Mike said, half a grin on his face. Ernie didn’t rise to it. “I’m saying you’re not the first I told, and the others didn’t listen either. I ain’t going to be here when it gets dark. You shouldn’t be either. It’s—” His mouth opened and closed once, like he was chewing on a word that tasted foul. “Bad luck, that’s all. Year like this. Takes folks like a fever.” JT tried to catch Ernie’s eye, but the man wouldn’t look at him. That was wrong. Ernie had always talked to JT like he was a person and not an extra body hauling meat. That felt like getting demoted without an explanation. “We came to hunt,” Dad said, and there was a fatal stubbornness in it, the kind JT hated and loved. “We won’t be stupid.” Ernie took a tiny step backward that said he’d expected that. “Just be gone by sun-down. You hear me?” His gaze slid to the window, then to the floor. “Sometimes the woods don’t want you. You can tell when they don’t.” Then he left, footsteps light, disappearing into the pale wash of morning. They didn’t talk about it, not really. A couple shrugs, a joke from Mike, an old-man huff from Dad, and that was enough. JT almost brought up the buck and didn’t. He was getting good at not. They hiked out late. The sky was the color of dishwater, and the cold had a wet edge that made cuffs and collars wick and cling. The forest wore a hush like fresh snow, except there wasn’t any. If JT listened hard enough, he could hear small things moving, the insect-scale rustles that mean life hasn’t abandoned a place entirely. But the larger silences, the ones he didn’t have a name for, felt like they had weight. He didn’t know how to describe that to sane ears. He tried a couple of times in his head, testing phrases: the woods were listening. The woods were full of held breath. The woods were nursing a thought about us. He kept them to himself because none of those sounded like sense, and because he could hear Mike in his mind, saying, “You been reading again, T?” They went out to a cut JT didn’t recognize even though he must have crossed it a hundred times. The logging road wore two grooves of ice like scars. The stumps looked like amputations. Far away, something knocked twice, like a big hand on a bigger door. They waited. Hours passed oddly. Sometimes JT would look up and think five minutes had gone and find the sun had taken a giant step down the sky. Other times the second hand on his watch seemed to stick and drag. He kept catching his father staring at nothing with a look like he was listening to someone on the other end of a phone. When he noticed JT watching, the look hardened into boredom. At one point Mike pointed and whispered, “There,” and JT followed his finger and felt his skin crawl. A doe stood fifty yards off, the color of dust, gaze flat as slate. She should have been wary—nose working, ears twitching—but she seemed bored by them, as if they were a television left on in an empty room. Mike didn’t raise his rifle. Nobody did. They watched her for a long minute that stretched, taut and thin, and then she walked away. Not bolted—ambled, as if she had an appointment and was late. “You’re seeing this, right?” JT said finally, voice low. “Seeing what?” Dad said, too quick. Mike didn’t answer. They broke for a late lunch under a stand of black spruce. Mike got the flask out. He offered it, and JT took a mouthful because saying no would raise questions he didn’t want. The whiskey went down like something alive. “Ernie’s spooked,” Mike said after a while. “Maybe he saw cat tracks. Maybe he killed a man and he’s got to get rid of the body. Could be exciting.” He grinned. JT didn’t. “Full moon tonight,” Dad said. He wasn’t a superstitious man. He said it like a weather report. “Ernie said to leave by sundown,” JT said. Dad scratched at the side of his neck and didn’t look up. “We’ll do one more walk. No later than three. Plenty of time.” He looked at his watch the way men look at their fathers’ watches, not to see what time it is but to feel the weight of what they owe. They moved into the trees and the light changed so suddenly JT had to blink. The canopy thickened and the day became a second dawn—a thin, pearly illumination with no source. Something glimmered ahead. When they reached it, JT realized it was a pond that hadn’t been there last year, or any year he could remember. A new bladder of water, round as an eye, skin of ice dull as pewter. The shoreline was muddied with prints. Deer. Elk. Something larger that refused to resolve in his mind. The prints went to the edge and then…stopped. JT stared at the ice, waiting for his brain to give him the trick of it. His scalp prickled. Mike crouched. “Huh,” he said, and for once he sounded wholly serious. “Look at that.” Dad traced the curve of a hoofprint with a finger and put the finger to his tongue, testing, as if tastes could tell him if the world had gone wrong. “Freeze came in quick,” he said. “They probably skated across and went out the other side.” JT looked to the other side. The far bank was clean and new. No prints. The ice itself looked thick and oddly opaque, a trapped breath. He touched his boot to it. The ice didn’t crack. It sounded like tapping a plate. He had a sudden image of something under there looking up at him, patient. He jerked his foot back and hated himself for it. “Let’s cut around,” Dad said. “Back to the creek. Still time.” They did. The light faded by inches, the way a fire goes down when you smother it with a pot. JT kept glancing over his shoulder, that old sick animal sense burning between his shoulder blades. At some point, the birds stopped. He didn’t notice exactly when, only realized after, like noticing your heart had been beating fast without your consent. The woods narrowed into a channel between two rises. The trees leaned in, branches forearms, a throat to pass through. JT swallowed and tasted metal. He went first without meaning to and then they were all in it, ducking around the low branches that caught at their hats and whispered at their ears. It smelled like wet stone and old plant rot. From somewhere to the left came a thin, high squeal. He wanted it to be a rabbit. He wanted it very much to be a rabbit. They came out into another clearing and stopped as one body. The clearing was clean. No brush. No rot. The grass lay flat, combed. The air felt warmer by a degree that was more than weather. And there, at the center, stood the buck. JT knew it was the same one even as the part of his mind that kept him functional tried to tell him that was stupid. This one’s rack was higher, the tines blacker at the tips. Its coat lay too smooth, like it had been ironed. Its eyes—JT tried not to look at the eyes. The men around him moved without moving: breath held, stance soft, faces slack. He thought of his father’s hand reaching, of Mike’s grin going garbage-dumb. He thought of Ernie saying the woods don’t want you. “Don’t,” JT said, but his voice came out quiet, a child in church. The buck took a step toward them. It was graceful. Its hooves made no sound. The silence was so complete that JT could hear his own pulse thudding in his ears like an idiot drummer. The buck turned its head slightly, presenting its neck the way a girl presents her throat in a vampire movie, and the thought came to him that it was offering them something. Mercy. A chance. An invitation. He didn’t like any of those words. “Jesus,” Mike whispered, and there was reverence in it. Dad’s rifle drooped. He took a step forward, like a puppet pulled by a string tied somewhere deep in his chest. JT could almost see the string. He knew—he knew—if he reached out, he could pluck it like a guitar and hear the note the woods had tuned them all to. He didn’t move. He couldn’t make himself move. “Dad,” he said. Louder. “Dad.” His father didn’t look back. He reached out his hand. The buck lowered its head. They were one gesture away from touching. Something in JT snapped like a frozen twig. He raised his rifle not because he wanted to shoot, not even because he wanted to stop it, but because he needed a sound. A sound that belonged to him and not to the clearing. He clicked the safety off. The click was so small. It was all he had. Both heads—his father’s and the buck’s—jerked at the same time. The animal’s ears flicked. In that tiny shift the world loosened, like a muscle unclenching. And then the buck was gone, not bolting, not turning, just simply not there, the space it had occupied still holding the shape of it the way heat holds the echo of a hand. JT staggered. His father stumbled and caught himself, and Mike swore. “What the hell—” Mike said, voice high, and then he swallowed it down and made his tone regular. “You trying to give me a heart attack? Don’t do that.” Dad looked at JT like he was seeing him for the first time that day. “You mind yourself,” he said, but there was no heat in it. He was shaking, a fine tremor in the cheek. The light had gone wrong. The sky had the strange, bruised color of evening arriving too early. JT checked his watch and felt cold bloom in his stomach. The time didn’t match the sky. Or maybe the sky didn’t match the time. He looked at the path they’d come down and couldn’t pick it out from the others. For a second the woods rearranged themselves, a shuffling of the deck, and then the picture settled and he recognized everything he saw and none of it meant anything. “We should head back,” JT said. His voice was clearer now. “Ernie said—” “Ernie can say what he wants,” Dad snapped, then caught himself. “We’ll head back. Now.” He ran a hand over his face and left it there a moment, like he could push himself into a different shape. “No more stops.” They turned. The throat of trees had widened by an inch, just enough to make the passage feel like a mistake. The first sound returned, small and mean—mosquito whine, a far-off caw. JT’s shoulders climbed down from around his ears by fractions. He didn’t look back. He didn’t want to see the clearing empty, or full. He didn’t want to see anything the woods wanted to show him. They walked faster than was smart. Roots grabbed. Twigs snapped. The air had the taste of copper now. JT kept expecting Ernie to step out from behind a tree, cigarette glowing. He wanted the guide’s voice, that sideways humor that made ugly things come into the light and look less ugly by being named. He wanted to be told what to do. The light went again. The path sloped wrong. For ten seconds that stretched forever and bent back on itself, JT knew they were not going to make it out before dark, and that dark would mean something this time. He imagined the lodge windows lit, Ernie sitting with his hat in his hands. He imagined the moon lifting itself up like a coin from a magician’s ear. They came over a rise and the lodge was there, sudden and squat and gray. JT didn’t trust it. He wouldn’t have been surprised at all to come up to it and find it a flat board set painted with a picture. But when he put his hand on the rail of the sagging porch, the splinters went in real. He sucked a breath around his teeth. Ernie stood by his truck with the engine already running. He looked at them as if he’d been waiting the entire time, refusing to blink for fear of missing. He didn’t smile. He didn’t say told you. He just said, “Get your stuff. We’re going now.” “It’s not dark yet,” Dad said. The words sounded empty as cans. “Full enough,” Ernie said. He jerked his chin upward. JT followed the gesture and saw it: not a moon, not really, just the suggestion of it behind the thickening clouds, a pale bulge like a knuckle pushing against skin. It made his stomach lurch. “We can head at first light,” Mike began, but his eye ticked and gave him away. Ernie walked up to JT, close enough that JT could smell the sourness on his breath. He laid a rough hand on JT’s shoulder and squeezed once, the way men do when they don’t know what else to do. “You felt it,” he said, barely moving his lips. “Don’t argue. Don’t let them argue. You can make it out if you go now.” JT opened his mouth. He closed it again. He nodded, because the alternative was being the man who didn’t. He turned to his father and brother, mouth shaping the words we should, and stopped. They were looking past him, over his shoulder, toward the tree line. Not quite smiling. The light from the sinking sky made their faces smooth and nobody’s. JT didn’t turn around. He kept his eyes on their eyes and said, as firmly as he could with his heart beating rabbit-fast, “We’re leaving.” Mike blinked first. Dad’s jaw worked. Somewhere in the dark under the boughs, something breathed in and held it, waiting to see what they would do.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This continuation of the surreal horror story "Caribou Season at the Lodge" demonstrates remarkable craft in maintaining the established atmosphere while developing the narrative. The piece successfully builds on the foundation laid in the prompt, creating a deeply unsettling experience that blends psychological horror with supernatural elements. The writing excels at creating a sense of creeping dread through environmental details. The descriptions are vivid without being excessive—"the kerosene lamp threw off a sickly orange glow that made everything look jaundiced," "the heat from the stove had a dampness to it, as if the metal itself sweated." These sensory details establish the wrongness of the setting without explicitly stating it. Character development is handled with subtlety. JT's unreliable narration is perfectly executed, showing his growing awareness that something is deeply wrong while maintaining his uncertainty. His internal struggle between rationalization and instinctual fear feels authentic. The family dynamics are well-rendered through minimal but effective dialogue and observations about their behaviors. The father's stubbornness, Mike's affected nonchalance, and JT's cautious observation create a believable family unit. The introduction of Ernie as a character who knows more than he's saying adds tension and credibility to the supernatural threat. His warning serves as both foreshadowing and a catalyst for JT's growing unease. The dialogue is sparse but effective, with each character having a distinct voice that reveals their personality and relationship to the unfolding strangeness. The pacing is masterful, with a gradual build of tension punctuated by increasingly disturbing encounters with the wildlife. Time distortion is used effectively as both a plot element and a metaphor for the characters' psychological states. The piece avoids common horror tropes by keeping the threat ambiguous—is it the buck? The woods themselves? Something else entirely? This ambiguity heightens the dread rather than diminishing it. The prose style successfully emulates Stephen King's approach—grounded in realistic details while gradually introducing surreal elements. Sentences vary in length and structure, creating rhythm that mirrors JT's emotional state. Metaphors are fresh and evocative without becoming purple: "the woods wore a hush like fresh snow," "the silence was so complete that JT could hear his own pulse thudding in his ears like an idiot drummer." The ending strikes the perfect note of unresolved tension. The characters are poised at a decision point, with the supernatural threat still looming but not fully revealed. This respects the "build tension towards a payoff" instruction while leaving room for further development. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally, a metaphor might be slightly overextended, and there are a few instances where the prose becomes slightly more self-conscious than necessary. However, these moments are rare and don't detract significantly from the overall impact. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fantasy-humour: Hell is Other Demons — Score: 92.2
Prompt:
Hell is Other Demons Write a day in the life short story. Lucifer morningstar's on again/ off again relationship with Lilith is currently in the "off again" stage, though the cycle may be coming around as Lilith has been stopping by for reasons other than purely violent ones, and Lucifer has been increasingly lonely. Write a day in the life of this power couple, with elements of dark comedy & fantasy. Use understated irony & absurdity by merging the black immorality and everyday business of running hell, against relatable domestic relationship drama. Take cues from Neil Gaiman. 1000 words.
Model Output:
Lucifer Morningstar woke to the smell of brimstone and coffee. The coffee was black as an abyss, which he appreciated aesthetically, but it tasted faintly of pennies and regret, which he blamed on procurement. He sat up in his bed, a slab of cooled lava shaped vaguely like a chaise longue. The sheets were a thousand-thread-count Egyptian cotton woven from the sighs of accountants. He checked his phone. It was full of petitions from mid-level demons who believed spreadsheets were a form of torture; it was also full of half-finished texts to Lilith, all variants on “You left your purse” and “Are you avoiding me?” and one that said simply, “Come home?” which he had typed with his eyes closed last night, then deleted, then typed again, then saved in drafts like a sin he couldn’t quite commit to. He went to the kitchen where the kettle screamed like a condemned soul and then, having gotten that out of its system, quieted. He made a second coffee. He had learned that this improved nothing but made him feel like he was trying. Outside, the world boiled pleasantly. Today’s forecast was sulfurous with a high chance of rain made of thorns. Weather was in compliance. That was something. He dressed in a suit the color of ravens thinking about stealing something. He put on a tie to suggest responsibility and took it off again to avoid lying to himself. He stepped into the corridor where the lights flickered sympathetically as if to say, Morning, boss, don’t worry, it will be worse later. The lift took him down to Administration. Sisyphus was in the lobby, arguing with Security. His rock, labeled VISITOR in a jaunty font, was stuck halfway through the metal detector. “Leave it,” Lucifer said. “I can’t,” Sisyphus said. “We both know you can.” Sisyphus looked at the rock with something like longing. “I don’t know what I’d do with my hands.” Lucifer waved a hand and the detector swallowed the rock whole, as if it had never happened. It was, he felt, an apt metaphor for the morning. The day began with the Triage Meeting. Reports came in from the mortal realms: war here, famine there, a million small betrayals arranged like a bouquet. He approved allocations of suffering the way one approves budgets: with an eye to efficacy and an ear tuned toward complaints. Beelzebub arrived twelve minutes late, smelling faintly of honey and rot. Beelzebub had found a brand of cologne that leaned into his brand and Lucifer respected the commitment, if not the sensation. “Update on the influencer cohort?” Lucifer asked. “They are influencing,” Beelzebub said. “To what, it is unclear, but they are very certain.” “Certainty is our oldest ally,” Lucifer said. He felt, faintly, like a man who had once made a great speech and now spent his days in committee. When they moved on to Temptations, a junior demon with a tidy mustache suggested a pilot program where free-floating anxiety could be repackaged as productivity hacks. “Do it,” Lucifer said. “But make the hacks mutually contradictory. Competition builds character.” The junior demon grinned. “I love it when you go corporate.” Lucifer smiled with the sadness of a retired hurricane. He signed a requisition for damned souls to have an additional five-minute break every millennium. He denied a request for ergonomic pitchforks. He copied, reluctantly, a delivery of imported mortal coffee to his own office. He flagged the fourth duplicate request from a named demon: Lilith, asking for a visitor’s pass. He pretended he wasn’t counting. At ten, a tour group of poets came through. It was a special program for those who had rhymed “love” with “dove” unironically. They gazed around with terrified reverence, taking notes in notebooks made of old secrets. One of them asked for a selfie. Another asked whether immortality included dental. “It includes dental,” Lucifer said, and smiled. They dropped their pens. It was that kind of morning. He found himself staring at a chair and thinking, Hm. The chair did not respond but seemed, somehow, patient. Around noon, as he was three signatures into a Performance Improvement Plan for the Department of Mirrors, his door opened and Lilith walked in without waiting for the ward to ask permission. The ward peeled itself off her shoulders with a sound like reluctant gum and slumped into a corner to sulk. It liked her. Everyone liked her. That was part of the problem. “Lucifer,” she said, as if she’d found his name in her pocket by accident. “Lilith,” he said, as if he’d expected her. He had not expected her. He had arranged his face for calm and found that calm, like everyone else, wilted a little under her gaze. She was dressed in a long coat the color of midnight in a city where the lights have gone out. Her hair was a black question. On her arm hung a scorched leather purse that looked as if it had survived both a pyre and a sale. “I brought you something,” she said, and sat without waiting for the furniture to adjust. The chair said ouch in an ancient dialect. She rummaged through the purse like a sorcerer drawing talismans from a wound. The contents arranged themselves on his desk: a tarnished subway token; a brass key with no teeth; a cassette tape labelled SUMMER ’93 in smudged ballpoint; a baby’s shoe, charred at the lace; a bundle of rosemary wrapped in black thread; a cracked snow globe that, when shaken, showed a city burning merrily beneath glass snow; a receipt for two coffees and a muffin from a place that prided itself on latte art; a ring of plastic hotel do-not-disturb tags; a tiny square of blue sea glass. “Pick one,” she said. “For what?” “For now,” she said. He picked the cassette. It seemed honest: hiss and longing. He turned it over in his hands, hearing the faint ghosts of synths and the click of someone’s thumb hitting pause too late. He had not owned a cassette player in a very long time, but then, time was the one thing he did own, and look how well that was going. “Nice tie,” Lilith said, and he felt his neck where there was none. He smiled. She smirked. “How’s your war?” he asked, gesturing toward the world. “Ongoing,” she said. “Yours?” “Recurring,” he said. They sat in it, the banter like old shoes: uncomfortable until you realized that they had, over time, shaped to your feet. She picked up the baby’s shoe. “Found this at a crossroads outside Warsaw. It was humming.” She set it down carefully. “Do you remember when you used to bring me things?” “I brought you a planet once,” he said. “You brought me the paperwork for a planet,” she said. “The planet was implied.” He laughed, softly. “You would have hated the planet. Too many oceans.” “I like oceans.” “You like drowning other people in oceans.” “I like options,” she said. She tilted her head, watched him with the cautious affection of a cat who knows where the knives are kept. “You look tired.” “I’ve been sleeping,” he said. “Have you?” “I’ve been lying down,” he said. It almost counted. There was a meeting at one about decoupling circles seven and eight for budgetary reasons. There was a memo about the new punishments for people who used reply-all. He was meant to attend. Instead, he leaned back and watched Lilith root through her purse again, producing a salt packet, a folded map of a city that never quite stayed folded, and a lipstick the color of accusation. “I could take that visitor’s pass,” she said, casual as a blade left on a kitchen counter. “You could,” he said. He did not move. Sometimes it was dangerous to reach for things. “But then I would feel observed,” she said, with a little moue of distaste. “And I would behave.” “No one wants that,” he said. “Least of all you.” “I want many things,” he said. “Yes,” she said, almost kind. “That’s the trouble.” There was a knock. A demon slid in, eyes downcast, holding a sheaf of papers. “Your one o’clock, my Lord.” “Reschedule it,” Lucifer said. The demon blinked. Papers shifted, nervous. “To when?” “To when I am not busy,” Lucifer said. The demon nodded and retreated, obviously relieved. It was nice to give someone a reprieve. Lilith picked up the subway token. “They’re phasing these out,” she said. “Did you know? I like the way they click against each other in your pocket. Like teeth.” “I do not carry change,” he said. “You don’t carry anything,” she said. “You have people.” She tucked the token back into her purse like a secret she might want later. “Is this the part where we fight?” “We could,” he said. “But it’s lunch.” “What do you eat?” she said, scorn curling her mouth, soft affection beneath it. “Regulations,” he said. “And sandwiches.” She produced, godlike, two wrapped halves of something that looked like a crime and smelled like a bakery. “I stole these,” she said, and when he raised an eyebrow, added, “From the mortal realms. Somewhere with distressed wood and a man with a beard who had opinions about yeast.” “I love it when you speak artisan,” he said, and took a half. It tasted like flour, oil, salt, and forgiveness. He tried not to let it show. They ate and did not look at each other. The office hummed around them, a living thing. Somewhere, a file cabinet laughed in despair. In the corner, the ward snored. Lilith licked her finger and pressed it to the map. The map shivered. “You could come with me,” she said. “To the beard?” he said. “To here,” she said, meaning Not here. Meaning elsewhere. “We could start a fight in a city that doesn’t know our names. We could dance. We could watch them make mistakes without correcting them.” “I am their mistake,” he said. “You are their excuse,” she said. “Different thing.” He thought of the tours, of the poets, of the junior demon with the tidy mustache, of the influencer cohort, of certainty. He thought of his bed, its cooled lava and cotton sighs. He thought of the drafts on his phone. He thought of her purse, full of stolen time. “I can’t,” he said. “I know,” she said, and smiled, the way a knife might smile at a whetstone. The afternoon didn’t so much happen as accumulate. She stayed, which was its own kind of miracle. She lay on his couch—a different couch, this one thoughtful—and flipped through a magazine of mortal fashion with an expression of anthropological dread. She made remarks. He signed things. She laughed at his jokes, even the ones that were only funny if you had invented irony. She told him about a woman in Budapest who could turn her reflection into birds; he told her about a memo concerning a supply chain issue with pitchforks. “Have you considered forks?” she asked, deadpan. “Apparently we have standards,” he said. Around four, there was a small riot in the Department of Cruelties, Traditional and Novel. He sent a glance, which solved it. At five, the day’s allotment of mortal bargains came in, smelling like smoke and perfume. He initialed each one. He’d learned to read them upside down while listening to someone else talk about weather. It was a talent like any other: useless until the day it wasn’t. As the air went from red to a different, more introspective red, Lilith stood and gathered her trinkets. The cassette tape stayed on his desk. He touched it with two fingers, like a blessing. She watched his hand and then, unexpectedly, kissed his forehead. It was not a lover’s kiss, exactly. It was the kind you gave a soldier, or a child, or a god who had remembered his humanity just long enough to misplace it again. “I’ll be by,” she said. “Or I won’t. Don’t be tragic about it.” “I am constitutionally tragic,” he said. “You are constitutionally dramatic,” she corrected. “Tragedy takes planning.” “Some of us plan.” “Some of us improvise,” she said, slinging the purse over her shoulder. A charred lace peeked out like a wink. “Try not to set anything on fire while I’m gone.” “That is literally my job.” She paused at the door. “Bring me something,” she said, not looking back. “Not a planet. Something that will fit in my purse.” He looked at the cassette tape. “I’ll try.” She went. The ward restored itself like a sulky guardian. The office exhaled. The kettle began, inevitably, to scream. He silenced it with a finger. He sat at his desk and looked at his kingdom: stacked, signed, sorted. He pressed play on nothing and listened to the hiss. It sounded like a beach no one went to anymore. Later, at home, he lay on his cooled lava and considered the day. He considered the way she had said now, and the way he had said I can’t, and the way both of them had been telling the truth. He considered that he had promised to bring her something. He rose and went to the shelf of things he kept for no reason: a drawer full of miscellaneous sorrows; a jar of antique smiles; a box of Sundays. From the back he pulled a small, thin packet tied with red string. Inside was a ticket stub from a late-night train, unpunched. The night he had left, the first time. He had kept it because he couldn’t not. He put it in his pocket. He slept like a man who had made the wrong choice correctly. In the morning, the emails would be waiting. The poets would be rhyming. The junior demon would have scaled his anxiety hacks. The influencer cohort would be certain. He would drink coffee that tasted like iron and decisions. And somewhere, a scorched purse would open, and maybe there would be space for one more thing. He found that he was, against all probability and long experience, looking forward to finding out.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This short story brilliantly captures the essence of Neil Gaiman's style while creating a compelling day-in-the-life narrative of Lucifer and his complicated relationship with Lilith. The piece excels in merging the mundane with the fantastical, creating a Hell that functions like a corporate office while maintaining its infernal qualities. The prose is exceptional, with metaphors and descriptions that are both inventive and precise: "a suit the color of ravens thinking about stealing something" and sheets made of "a thousand-thread-count Egyptian cotton woven from the sighs of accountants." These descriptions establish the dark comedy tone while revealing character and setting. The relationship between Lucifer and Lilith is portrayed with nuance and complexity. Their history is implied rather than explained, allowing readers to infer the depth of their connection through their interactions. The dialogue between them crackles with tension, wit, and understated affection. Lines like "You brought me the paperwork for a planet," she said. "The planet was implied" perfectly capture their dynamic. The story maintains a consistent tone throughout—sardonic, melancholic, and darkly humorous. The bureaucratic Hell is rendered with delightful absurdity: Performance Improvement Plans, budget meetings about "decoupling circles seven and eight," and ergonomic pitchforks. These details create a world that feels both alien and recognizable. The narrative avoids common pitfalls. It doesn't overexplain or resort to telling rather than showing. The characters' emotions and motivations are conveyed through their actions, dialogue, and the metaphorical language. The ending strikes a perfect balance—not artificially upbeat, but offering a glimmer of possibility that feels earned given the characters' established relationship. The dialogue is particularly strong, revealing character while advancing the story. Each exchange between Lucifer and Lilith carries subtext and history. Their banter "like old shoes: uncomfortable until you realized that they had, over time, shaped to your feet" demonstrates their familiarity and the complex nature of their relationship. If there's any criticism to be made, it might be that some readers could find certain metaphors slightly overwrought, but these instances are rare and generally serve the story's tone and themes. The narrative also occasionally meanders, but this meandering feels intentional, mirroring Lucifer's day and his state of mind. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that successfully fulfills the prompt's requirements while creating a compelling, emotionally resonant story with distinctive characters and a richly imagined world. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Historical fiction: Gladiator — Score: 93.6
Prompt:
Historical Fiction: Write a scene from a story set during the height of the Roman Empire, focusing on a slice of a day in the life of a gladiator. Do not write a combat scene. Use sensory details to capture the sights, sounds, and smells of ancient Rome. Explore the gladiator's thoughts and emotions. The story should also touch on the larger political and social issues of the time period. The piece should feel like a slice of a larger story. First person, past tense, 1000 words.
Model Output:
The morning air in the ludus carried the same sour cocktail it always did: old sweat baked into wood, iron rubbed with fat to keep it from rusting, and the metallic ghost of dried blood that clung to everything like a second skin. When I woke, it was still dark, though the rooster in the alley behind the baths crowed as if he could lift the sun by insistence alone. The others grumbled from their pallets. Numa snored. Cressus whispered a prayer to Bona Dea, pretending he still believed she heard men. I lay still and listened, counting my heartbeats, the way I did before every day started, as if I could make a tally that would add up to freedom. The straw beneath me scratched my shoulders. A rat skittered behind the amphorae in the corner, then went silent. I rose and wrapped the woolen bandage around my right wrist, winding it tight, feeling the small rough edge I had deliberately left in the cloth. I used it like a flint to remind myself I was not yet dull. When the trainer’s boy slid back the bolt, the door moaned. He always did it slowly, as if he might catch us doing something other than sleeping. We shuffled out into the courtyard where the dawn peeled the blue off the sky. In the half-light, the training posts looked like broken men, shoulders hunched, each crowned with a leather-stuffed bag that would stand in for a head. The sand was cold and damp, chilled from the night fog that crept in from the Tiber. My bare feet sank into it. It smelled of salt and horse dung and the wine someone had poured out as an offering at the threshold to the armory. Gaius the lanista stood near the gate, arms folded, his cloak wrapped so tight it made his chest look like a barrel. He nodded to me and to Pollux, his eyes already moving on to account for the weapons, for the straps, for the men he would display like fruit at market. We ate—barley porridge, honeyed if you had proven yourself yesterday, plain if not. I had fought the week before, a minor bout against a Thraex with a nervous mouth, and the crowd had liked my restraint when I disarmed him and raised my hand to the editor. It was an old trick: let Roman mercy look merciful and you earned the favor that buttered the trainer’s bread. Gaius had given me a peach with my porridge that day; I could still feel the sugar on my tongue. Today the dish was plain. The honey would be for those who would go out later, for those he wanted fat and shining under the noon sun. I cleaned my hands in the basin and fished out the little wax amulet I kept under the bench. It was an ugly thing, the shape distorted from so much rubbing: two crudely carved twins, joined at the shoulder. The boy from Lanuvium who had been my friend before his chest wound swallowed him had given it to me. He said it was for Geminorum, that the twins watched over comrades, that they did not like to be separated. Before each fight I pressed the amulet to my tongue, let wax and sweat taste bitter, then tapped my forehead three times with it, left-right-center. On a day like this, when I was not slated for the sands, I did it anyway, because superstition did not know calendars, and because the movements calmed my hands. If I ever skipped it, my skin itched all day as if I had put on a tunic made of nettles. We filed across the yard to the practice area. The sound of the wall-gates creaking open rolled over us from the street, followed by tenants shouting and the click of a mule’s hooves on stone. The Tiber stank faintly of rot; the summer had been dry, and the water lay thick and green under the bridges. From beyond the courtyard, the city’s breath rose in a chorus: vendors hawking olives and dates, a fishwife cursing, a lyre scraping out a sad little tune for someone who had coins to feel sorry for themselves, somewhere near the Subura. The instructor, an ex-soldier whose left ear had been torn off by a German spear, paired me with Cressus to work on footwork. We tapped the hull of our wooden shields for luck—some men kissed the boss, some muttered to Mars; I did not like to ask the red god for much—and moved through the steps: left forward, weight low, knee bent; right foot back, pivot, circle. Sand gritted under my heel. Cressus breathed hard through his teeth. We did not strike each other with the wooden swords much, not unless Gaius wanted to entertain a visitor by making us bruise each other. Today the strokes were mild, the rhythmic slap of wood against wood. Above us, the gulls screamed over the city like a warning we did not understand. Between drills, I watched the gate. There were always visitors—city men in better tunics with their hair oiled and curled, petty officials with scrolls tucked into their belts like trophies, a senator’s freedman once, with hands so soft you could see they had never curled around a hilt. They came to inspect us like horses. One of Gaius’s investors had told him that our skins should shine more, that the crowd liked a gleam; since then we'd been rubbed with olive oil until we glistened. The sweat, when it rose, sat on the oil and slid, taking dust with it. We were cleaner dirty men. Halfway through the morning, a boy in a red-bordered tunic arrived with a tablet covered in wax. He spoke with Gaius in a hurried undertone, glancing at us as if we might bolt. The trainer called out names. Not mine. Not today. Pollux grinned, his lips splitting because he always forgot to oil them in the heat. He had the bright look that comes to men when coins fall. It meant he had a sponsor in the crowd, that someone had pressed a ringed thumb against the wax and written a favor. Money would change hands. The same way a slick politician might swap feasts for votes, editors bought approval with our lives. Sometimes I wondered if the charioteers had it easier—they died spectacularly, but quickly. We were small citizens of the arena, granted cheers by the emperor’s generosity, and by the emperor’s absence. When Caesar was away—fighting Parthians, or pretending to—our editor, a greasy-eyed man with a taste for old poets, shouted himself hoarse to remind the crowd that he, not the emperor, gave them bread and games. A shadow cut across the yard. I looked up. A banner buckled in the morning wind over the barracks next door: red cloth with the words S.P.Q.R. painted in gold. A century of legionaries had marched past the ludus yesterday on their way to the Campus Martius, their sandals thudding in disciplined rhythm. Their faces were stony, their eyes forward. The crowd had cheered them with the same mouths that would later jeer a dying man to stand and die well. Rome always loved a spectacle; blood was public policy, a way to keep the wooden galleries full and the gossip easy. In the Governor’s court, a flick of a hand decided taxes. In ours, thumbs decided air. After drills, we carried amphorae to the slaves who scrubbed the upper walk. A woman on a neighboring roof sang to her baby as she hung wet linens to dry. Her voice, though thin, floated down with a sweetness that made my feet stop for a breath. The amphora bit into my shoulder. The baby cried anyway. I looked down through the gap between the buildings. In the alley, a stray dog gnawed a scrap of leather with such fierce faith I envied it. We ate again at noon—bread, goat cheese, olives. The olives were wrinkled and sour, but I liked the bite. I had thought, coming here, that even the food would taste different under a different sky. It did. Everything did. There was a tang of iron in things, a constant dust that whitened your tongue. Rome was crowded and loud and hot. But sometimes, like when you bit an olive and the bitterness spread through your mouth, you remembered a shade of green from home, and your throat tightened as if you had swallowed a stone. I thought of my mother's hands, olive-stained from pressing, her wedding ring bruising the meat when she squeezed. No one had rubbed oil into my skin then. In the afternoon, Gaius led us up the hill to the baths. We walked two by two, without shackles, because he trusted that our desire to remain whole would keep us from doing anything foolish. The crowds parted, and I could feel their eyes like fingers on my shoulders. A boy pointed: "Look, mama. Gladiators." He pronounced it with the bright pride of the well-fed. His mother drew him back, murmuring that they were lucky. Lucky men. Her neck glittered with a chain. At the baths, steam lay heavy in the air, scented with eucalyptus leaves from the merchant who overcharged and smiled. We sloughed off dust and feigned camaraderie among the citizens who scrubbed their own backs with rough cloths and told each other jokes about Gauls. One man’s laugh was a sharp bark that made me jump. He saw it and smirked. Later, he would pay to see another man die and say the man had chosen death by not choosing well enough. In the tepidarium, the gossip flowed thicker than the steam. A scribe whispered about a senator’s speech, how he had compared the empire to a ship and the emperor to a helmsman steering through storms. Someone else muttered about grain shortages, about how the crates arrived light. Petro, one of ours, said nothing, but I could feel the way his shoulders went tight. He had been a grain measurer once before a patron with a long memory took offense. His jaw twitched when men out there spoke carelessly of hunger, knowing that in here we would never starve as long as we could raise our arms. After the baths, we returned to the yard and oiled our gear. I sat with my shield in my lap, rubbing oil into the wood, watching how the light pooled on the curve. I thought about the editor’s eyes scanning names on tablets, about coins clinking into hands, about the women who wore their hair after the empress, arranged in coils like shells, while they screamed for someone’s eyes. I thought about the twins on my amulet, and how the boy who had given it to me had faced his last morning. He had said, in a small voice, that he would like to taste peaches again. The season had not been right for them. He had died with his mouth empty. In the late afternoon, when the shadows were long and cool, Gaius called us to the armory. "Repairs," he said. He meant we would sew straps and polish helmets, but also that we would look at each other and calculate. The older men stitched in silence. The younger ones threw dice with pebbles and swore there was luck to be had in the way the pips landed against the grain of the wood. I ran a whetstone lightly along the edge of a sword and did not think about how it would sound against bone. Out in the street, a procession passed—an image of a god carried on a litter, incense stinging the back of your throat even from here. The crowd's chant rose, then faded. It was always hard to tell if they prayed for favor, or if, like us, they prayed for witnesses. As the sky went from yellow to a deeper blue, Gaius came and sat beside me. He did this sometimes, as if to remind me that he was a man and not just my keeper. "They want you next month," he said, not looking at me. "A special day. Aedile’s games. He’s hungry for applause. He asked for you by name." The oil on the shield caught the last of the light and held it. I thought of the twins. I thought of peaches. I thought of the crowd watching as if our ends were tickets they had purchased, expecting to be entertained. "What do I get?" I asked, because you had to ask. If you did not, you were meat. He rubbed his nose with two fingers. "A purse. Larger than usual. And… there has been talk of manumission for someone in the next year. If we please the right men. If we are patient." We. The word between a trainer and a slave was a kind of joke. But jokes can be true. Gaius needed us as much as we needed him; his coins came greased with our sweat. The empire was a web of bargains, and we were the flies that forgot we spun it too. "I will need a new arm guard," I said. "This one chafes." It was a small thing, but sometimes small things kept you alive. Everyone, from emperor to beggar, knew this. He nodded. "Tomorrow." After he left, I sat on the bench and drew the amulet out again. I touched it to my tongue. Left-right-center. My throat tasted like wax and oil and dust. The sun lay down behind the walls and left us with lamps that smelled of smoke and rancid fat. Somewhere beyond the yard, a prostitute laughed, a low, tired sound. The city never went silent. It thrummed, like blood in your ears. Numa, who claimed not to fear anything, picked at a callus until it bled. "You will be grand," he said to me, trying to be generous and, failing that, to be cruel. "Maybe they will crown you with laurel. Maybe they will free you. Maybe." "Maybe," I said. The word was like a coin spinning on the table, waiting to drop. You could spend your life in the maybe and never feel it click. But tonight, I had oil on my hands and the odor of old leather in my nose and the weight of Rome pressing down like a palm. I lay back on the straw, the itch at my wrist easing as I tightened the binding with my teeth. The amulet lay under my tongue, bitter, familiar. I swallowed once and did not choke. I counted my heartbeats until they blurred into one long line, and somewhere along it, I fell into a sleep that felt like stepping through a door into another chamber of the same house. Tomorrow would begin with the rooster again, with the door’s slow groan, with the smell of iron and sweat. Tomorrow, we would move through our steps like prayers, like loops of string we tied around the finger of fate, as if she were the kind of woman who might remember us.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This historical fiction piece effectively transports the reader to ancient Rome through the eyes of a gladiator. The author has crafted a sensory-rich narrative that captures the daily life, social dynamics, and political undercurrents of the Roman Empire. The piece excels in its sensory details. From the "sour cocktail" of smells in the ludus to the taste of wax and oil on the protagonist's tongue, the author creates a vivid, immersive environment. The descriptions of the city's sounds—vendors hawking goods, a fishwife cursing, a lyre playing—contribute to a multidimensional portrait of ancient Rome. The protagonist is well-developed, with a rich inner life. His rituals with the wax amulet, his counting of heartbeats, and his reflections on freedom reveal a complex character navigating a brutal existence. The author skillfully balances the gladiator's physical reality with his psychological state, showing how he maintains dignity and agency within a dehumanizing system. The piece effectively addresses the larger political and social issues of Roman society. The contrast between the gladiators and the citizens, the commodification of violence as entertainment, and the web of power relationships are all thoughtfully explored. Lines like "Rome always loved a spectacle; blood was public policy" and "The empire was a web of bargains, and we were the flies that forgot we spun it too" offer incisive commentary on Roman society. The prose is elegant and controlled, with a consistent first-person, past-tense voice that feels authentic to the character. The author employs evocative metaphors and similes that enhance rather than distract from the narrative. The writing has a poetic quality without becoming purple or overwrought. The narrative structure works well as a "slice of life" that hints at a larger story. The mention of the upcoming games and the possibility of manumission creates tension and forward momentum while remaining true to the prompt's request for a non-combat scene. There are a few moments where the prose becomes slightly dense, potentially slowing the reader's engagement, but these are minor issues in an otherwise excellent piece. The author has created a compelling character whose daily existence reveals much about both his personal struggle and the society that constrains him. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Epistolary: The Lighthouse Keeper — Score: 0
Prompt:
The Lighthouse Keeper Epistolary Narrative: Write a story told entirely through a series of brief correspondences: telegrams or letters or emails between two characters. The correspondence should span several months or years, and reveal a gradually unfolding plot. Use distinct voices for each character, and include details that provide insight into their personalities and motivations. The story should build to an emotional climax, and the final letter should provide a satisfying resolution. The setting is a lighthouse keeper writing to his mother. He is working class and Scottish. He is struggling with the isolation of his posting. Write naturally and without cliches. 1000 words.
Model Output:
Judge Evaluation:
[Skipping – generation error: Text too short after 3 attempts]
+ First-person unique perspective: Hacker Mindset — Score: 90.2
Prompt:
Hacker Mindset Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a reformed (now) white hat hacker who cannot help but notice exploitable weaknesses in both systems and people they encounter. They habitually look for vulnerabilities and exploit vectors. The narrative takes place during a first date at a restaurant, where they're trying to focus on human connection. It's going surprisingly well due to a discovered shared nerd-fandom (magic the gathering). Things go a little sideways when the date reveals a noticeably insecure phone unlock pattern, which protagonist can't help but comment on. They are then left to negotiate the fallout of this faux pas and attempt to salvage (or perhaps sabotage) the remainder of the date. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
I pick the table with the back to the wall. Habit. Eyes on exits, mirrors, reflections in the gloss of a bottle. It’s a nice place, low lights, exposed brick already compromised by a hairline crack hunting the outlets. I catch myself mapping power, scanning for hidden SSIDs, when the server sets down water and smiles the way people do when they’re taught to smile. I tell myself: breathe. Tonight is about a human. Not threat modeling. Not adversarial simulation. Human. Then she sits down and I forget all the things I was going to say. “Hey,” she says, handing off a grin like a token. “You look like your photos.” So do you, I almost say, but I’m cataloging the keys on her chain—two apartment, one mailbox, a gym fob with worn epoxy—no, stop it. I exhale and nod. “Likewise.” Her name clicks in my head like a lock. We make small talk. It’s not my attack surface, it’s my comfort zone. I ask about day, she asks about mine. I don’t say I spent it threat-hunting misconfigurations in a cloud environment and writing a report that reads like prophecy. I say “work was good.” She says “work was work.” I clock the slight scar along her thumb and wonder if it’s from X-Acto knives or cats. The menus are tablets. Of course they are. Outdated OS, I can see the gesture lag. The restaurant unified Wi-Fi asks to join. Its name is the restaurant plus “Secure,” a dead giveaway. I don’t. I order pasta because my brain can’t fight two battles at once and carbs are a firewall against awkward pauses. She’s funny. Not performative, not trying too hard, just—present. She tells me about the time her cat knocked over an entire stack of board games like a kaiju. I tell her about the time I drove six hours to see a meteor shower and the clouds rolled in like a denial-of-service. We laugh at the same places. It feels unfamiliar in a good way, like the first time you solve a puzzle room and realize you don’t have to throw brute force at it. I reach for the bread and she glances at my nails. “Those are… very clean,” she says. No judgment, just observation. “Old habit,” I say. “Tactile feedback matters when I type.” I don’t say it’s from years of rolling rubber bands as stress relief while I ran scans at 3 a.m. and waited for a vulnerable endpoint to whisper come in. The first mention of Magic slips out of her like it’s not a test. “Do you ever play?” I blink. The game has lived in my bloodstream since high school, when cardboard spells offered rules I could understand and exploit. “Yeah,” I say non-chalantly. “You?” She nods, eyes brightening. “Since Zendikar. Casual mostly. My friends hate my board wipes.” Board wipes. She’s not precious about her own permanence. She’s willing to reset. I involuntarily tag: Supreme Verdict, Wrath of God, Damnation. Maybe Austere Command if she likes modular solutions. “Control?” I ask, too quickly, and I hate that I sound eager. She grins. “Midrange that pretends to be aggro until it’s not. I just love the moment someone overextends and then—.” She makes a soft explosion sound with her lips. Okay. She feints. She baits. She likes options. I imagine a hand with Lightning Bolt and a Path to Exile and the smug, patient thrill of waiting for the right threat. I remember the first time someone hit me with a well-timed Cryptic Command and I felt my face burn with the beauty of it. I take a sip of water. I want to ask her which Commander she pilots but I also don’t want to sprint. We talk about cities. Travel. She hates airports but loves maps. I picture her tracing routes with a finger, planning contingencies. The salads arrive. My brain is fifty percent lettuce, forty percent “don’t look at the lock screen,” ten percent “say something charming.” I manage it. She laughs. The sound is crisp, unforced. Relief floods my body like a hot patch. Then her phone lights the table from her bag, a constellation of notification dots. She pulls it out to silence it and the world narrows to a grid of dots and a single index finger. My skin goes cold. The pattern is as loud as graffiti: top-left to top-center to top-right, straight down the right side, left across the bottom. An L rotated ninety degrees then mirrored. The average shoulder surfer could memorize it before the appetizer. I feel my mouth move before I can stop it. “That’s… really guessable.” Silence. Her finger pauses mid-air like a moth arrested by a porch light. She turns, gaze sharpening. “What?” I want to rewind. I want to cancel the packet before it leaves my device. “Your unlock pattern. Sorry. It’s just—you started at the corner and hit all the adjacent points and—” Stop. Abort. “It’s—look, you could do a 2-5-8-6-9 squiggle or, like, use a zig-zag. Or better, switch to a passphrase.” Great. I am a walking PSA. I am a human lint roller catching bad decisions out of the air. Her expression shifts, the easy openness contracting into something like a shield. “So you were looking at my phone?” “No,” I say, instantly, truthfully—my eyes see these things even when I don’t want them to. “I’m… that person. I can’t turn it off. Sorry. It’s reflex.” She sets the phone down, face-down. The case is a faded blue with a cartoon dragon. I file it under “Timmy/Tammy aesthetic, maybe playful,” and want to toss my brain into the river. The server returns with drinks we didn’t order. Wrong table. He apologizes and retreats. The moment stretches like chewing gum stuck to a sneaker. “I get that security is… your thing,” she says slowly, “but not everything is an attack vector.” “It’s not you,” I say. “It’s me.” I hear how ridiculous it sounds and push through anyway. “I used to— I was on the other side. Red team. Before that, black hat. I don’t do that anymore. I audit, I teach. I try to make things safer. But my brain still—maps.” I tap my temple, aware of the jitter in my fingers. “Your pattern is a bright neon sign to that part of me. I’m sorry.” She watches me. I hold very still, like prey that knows it has to make the next move slow. I think about the cards she’s named so far. “Board wipes,” she’d said. She likes resets. She likes to bait people into overextending and then punish them for it. I can respect that. She sighs. “Okay. Okay. I appreciate the… instinct, I guess. But maybe you could ask first.” “Fair,” I say. “Do you want me to stop?” She looks at the phone, then at me. And then she does something unexpected: she unlocks it again, deliberately, the same naive pattern, and hands it over. “Show me,” she says. “Show me why it’s bad. But not like I’m a client. Like I’m a person you want to impress.” A tiny smile punches a hole through my panic. My hands steady. I don’t touch the screen. I hold it up against the banquette light, tilt. “See the smudge trails? Even if you clean it, there’s residue. You can infer the shape. And starting in the corner is common; humans love edges.” I hand it back. “Try something that crosses itself. Or go to a passphrase. Four random words you’ll remember.” She nods, thinking. “Like—SpaghettiNimbusCobaltBadger.” “That’s… overkill,” I say, smiling despite myself. “In a good way.” She changes it. I look away deliberately and talk about Magic to give her privacy. “Favorite set?” “Kaladesh,” she says. “I love improvise. And vehicles.” Improvise and vehicles. Efficient use of resources, turning artifacts sideways to get more than you should. I tag Heart of Kiran, Smuggler’s Copter—though the ban list lives in my head like an appendix. She likes synergy that feels like cheating but isn’t. She is the kind of person who will find the loose thread in a system and knit a sweater out of it. Dinner arrives. The pasta glows with oil, a network of garlic nodes. We eat. The conversation warms back up like a server brought back online. I make a point of not watching her phone when it pings. She catches me not-looking and nods, a small private acknowledgment. I file that trust in a small imaginary folder labeled Gains. She tells me about her favorite commander. “Muldrotha,” she says, eyes lighting up. “Value town.” She laughs at herself. “I know, I know. Graveyard recursion makes people groan.” Muldrotha, the Gravetide. Every permanent becomes a second life. She’s someone who hates waste. Someone who looks at what’s been lost and says, not yet. My chest does a strange thing at that. I admit my own. “Izzet spellslinger. Niv-Mizzet. And yes, I’m that person.” “Ping-ping-ping,” she says, miming drawing, drawing, drawing. “You monster.” “Reformed,” I say, and we both laugh. She lists cards like they’re old friends: Cyclonic Rift (board control without the guilt of death), Treasure Cruise (resource advantage), Teferi’s Protection (I’m out, you deal with it), Beast Within (answers, answers, answers). Each one, a flag planted in a playstyle terrain: flexible, opportunistic, allergic to dead ends. She mentions Swords to Plowshares like a mantra. Efficiency. Mercy with a string attached. I catalog without judging. I catalog because it’s how I love things. Patterns lit up my worst years and, paradoxically, patterns are how I climb out. She talks about the thrill of holding a counterspell and the discipline of not firing it at the first provocation. I think about restraint. I think about how she put the phone face-down and I wanted to fix her, and how she handed me the phone and I wanted to deserve it. At some point she says, almost as an aside, “I liked that you owned it.” “What?” “The blurt. You didn’t get defensive. You didn’t tell me I was stupid.” “I don’t think you’re stupid,” I say. “I think systems are designed to make you feel like you are. That’s part of how they win.” She tilts her head, considering. “So—white hat paladin in a world of rogues.” “I always end up splash black,” I admit. “Old habits.” We split dessert because it feels like an ally move, not an attack. Her spoon is a precise instrument. Mine is… enthusiastic. I tell her about the time at DEF CON a hotel keycard system failed open and I spent a whole night not sleeping because I couldn’t un-know it. She tells me about a friend’s kitchen flooding and how they turned it into a slip-and-slide. She is good at taking disasters and making them useful. The check arrives. The POS terminal is ancient. I hand over my card and, because I can’t help it, I cover the screen with my palm when I enter the tip and watch the cursor lag exactly half a second between digits. Side-channel leak. In my head I whisper a lullaby to my anxiety. Hush, little process, don’t you cry. Outside, the air is clean as a new password. We linger under the awning, the rain drawing thin lines between streetlights. Her hair catches droplets like a halo of punctuation. “I had a good time,” she says. “Me too,” I reply, hearing the truth of it and wanting to back it up with logs. “I’m sorry about the—” “Stop apologizing,” she says. “Just… ask next time.” “Deal.” She glances at my hands, then at her phone. “For what it’s worth, my new passphrase is going to make me hungry every time I type it.” “Good,” I say. “Associative memory is your friend.” She laughs. We exchange numbers like normal people, which feels like a miracle. Her name appears in my contacts and I lock my screen without a flourish, without thinking. We hug, brief and intentional. When we pull back, she looks up at me with that half-smile. “Round two,” she says. “Bring your Niv-Mizzet. I’ll bring a board wipe.” I swallow a retort about redundancy and backup plans. “Looking forward to it.” She walks away, and for once I don’t chart her route. I stand under the awning and watch the rain find its own path, and I let it. I think of Muldrotha pulling a permanent out of the graveyard like a promise. I think of the moment before a counterspell, the discipline to wait, the trust that you’ll know when to use it. I put my hands in my pockets. The city hums. Somewhere, a network hiccups and recovers. I turn toward home, feeling a pattern I don’t want to break.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures the perspective of a reformed hacker on a first date, with a strong focus on internal monologue as requested. The protagonist's hacker mindset permeates every observation, creating a distinctive voice that remains consistent throughout. The narrative excels at characterization through specific details. The protagonist's habit of scanning environments for vulnerabilities feels authentic, as does their inability to turn off this mindset. Their commentary on the date's Magic: The Gathering preferences reveals character through gameplay style ("She feints. She baits. She likes options."). The protagonist's self-awareness about their compulsive security analysis creates compelling internal conflict. The writing demonstrates technical knowledge without overwhelming the reader. References to "red team," "black hat," and specific Magic cards establish authenticity without excessive jargon. The pivotal moment—commenting on the date's phone unlock pattern—arises naturally from the character's established traits. The prose is particularly strong in its use of hacker/tech metaphors that illuminate the character's worldview: "carbs are a firewall against awkward pauses," "I want to cancel the packet before it leaves my device," and "Hush, little process, don't you cry." These metaphors effectively blend the technical with the emotional. The narrative handles the faux pas and its aftermath with nuance. Rather than a simplistic resolution, we see genuine tension followed by a thoughtful negotiation. The date's response—asking for a demonstration of why her pattern is vulnerable—shows her character depth. This interaction reveals mutual respect and creates a believable foundation for their connection. The ending avoids being overly saccharine while maintaining optimism. The protagonist's final thoughts about "a pattern I don't want to break" and the date's invitation to "Round two" feel earned through their shared interaction. Some minor weaknesses include occasional overreliance on technical metaphors and a few instances where the internal monologue becomes slightly repetitive in its security observations. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise strong piece. The narrative successfully balances the protagonist's technical mindset with their desire for human connection, creating a compelling character study that fulfills the prompt requirements while offering genuine emotional depth. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Overthinking It — Score: 94.1
Prompt:
Overthinking It Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of an intelligent 8th-grade girl with social anxiety who has developed a crush on a classmate. The narrative takes place during a group science project where they're paired together, as she cycles through rehearsed conversations while second-guessing each potential approach. Her inner thoughts should reveal the gap between her articulate internal voice and her difficulty expressing herself aloud, her fears of coming across as desperate or weird, and the exhausting process of monitoring her every word, expression, and movement for potential embarrassment. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
My pencil keeps tapping, like a woodpecker tattooing a signal into the desk: don’t mess up, don’t mess up, don’t—stop. I press the eraser to the paper to silence it, then realize I’ve smudged the diagram of the beaker and now it looks like a cloud is erupting from the top. Note to self: clouds don’t come out of beakers in real life. You know that. Everyone knows that. Except now the drawing makes me nervous. If he looks over, he’ll think I’m careless. Or weird. He’ll think I think beakers are tiny thunderstorm generators. Beakercumulo-nimbus. Stop making jokes in your head and pay attention. Mr. Morales is giving the instructions about the group project again: control variables, dependent variables, qualitative vs. quantitative data. The facts fit neatly into place in my brain like someone pouring rice into a jar. I like the feeling. When things have exact names and rules, I can keep them still. My friends—if that’s what I call them, though that word feels like a shirt I’m still growing into—are already talking about who’s doing what. I can hear shards of their voices, like I’m standing behind a half-closed door. We’re paired together. Me and him. Not a pair, actually—four of us—but we’re at the same table, and when Mr. Morales said our names out loud in the same sentence, a flock of something panicked inside my ribs and then went very quiet. He is sitting two seats over, one empty seat between us like a moat I can’t figure out how to cross without drowning in my own face. Okay. Strategy A: say something sophisticated but casual. Example line: “I was thinking we should measure the rate of evaporation as a function of surface area; it’s more interesting than just temperature.” Tone: light, almost bored. Eyebrows: neutral. Hands: still. Word choice: function might sound show-offy, but if I explain it, I’ll be helpful instead of obnoxious. Risk: they might say, “We already decided we’re doing the seed germination thing, why are you trying to be the boss?” Counter: laugh and say, “I’m open,” then offer to take notes, because taking notes is invisible but indispensable. Strategy B: say nothing and become indispensable anyway. Just do the measurements. Let competence speak. Downside: crush will not notice competence as long as you are a quiet machine. He notices people who laugh easily and talk fast and don’t blink like they’re thinking up the next move in chess every time someone asks them “How are you?” Don’t think his name. The syllables are slippery as soap. If I think it too much, I will accidentally let it bounce out of my mouth and then there will be a silence so loud it will collapse the classroom. Just call him him in your head. Everyone probably does that with someone. I draw a tiny circle in the corner of my notes, then add a triangle on top. Suddenly it’s a person. A tiny stick person with a triangle hair—no, that’s me. I add square glasses. I want to be precise, but my hand shakes and the lines double. I draw another: a wavy-haired stick figure with a hoodie that I make by adding a lump around its head. That’s him. The hoodie is always doing that thing where it looks soft and expensive. I don’t touch expensive-looking things. I draw Mr. Morales with big dot eyes and a tie like a carrot. Then I realize I’ve drawn an entire tiny classroom across the bottom of the page: four small figures around a rectangle table, each a simple symbol so I don’t have to admit I’m drawing them, so I can say I’m just drawing “data points,” which is what people like me prefer to be. He leans forward to pick up the packet from the middle of the table and he says, “Okay, so who wants to do the timing?” He says it to the group, not to me, but the sound of it still tilts my head inside. The other girl, Maya, says she’ll do the timer, and I want to say I’m good at timing, I have good reflexes, I can anticipate the beep like a metronome except I’ll compensate for human reaction error by counting me-in-my-head in half-seconds, but what I actually do is open my mouth and then close it because my tongue feels like a sock. Don’t be weird. People who argue over timers are weird. Strategy C: Make eye contact and smile to show you’re friendly. I try. I aim my face at him. I think my eyes might be too wide. My smile is invisible. He doesn’t look at me. That isn’t his fault. I forget I exist when I’m not making noise. Just say something. Say, “I can do the variables sheet.” Okay. You can say that. It is short and factual. I lift my pencil like a semaphore flag and say, “Variables,” but it comes out very small and attaches itself to the edge of the table and falls. Maya goes, “Sorry, what?” and because she’s kind, she says it with a smile. I repeat: “I can do variables.” This time it is a little bigger, like I’ve fed it a crumb. He looks over now. Eye contact like bumping into someone’s shoulder in the hallway when you’re both trying to move around each other the same direction. “Cool,” he says. “Yeah, you’re good at that.” Wait—what? The word cool stretches open like a hidden door. He knows I’m good at variables? I feel something helium-like pull me upward. No. Down. Stay down. He could mean you’re good at school in general, which everyone knows about you, so it is not personal, it is a weather report. “Thanks,” I say, but my voice flips at the end like a question, as if I’m asking him to confirm that thanks is the correct response. I immediately want to apologize to the word thanks for not being sure of itself. I write: independent variable—surface area; dependent variable—evaporation rate; controls—temperature, humidity, initial volume, container material. My handwriting is tidy. My brain lives for lists like these. The list is a self-portrait that doesn’t have to include my face. He’s laughing at something the other guy, Daniel, says about “evaporation nation.” I love puns. I could say, “Sorry, we’re already booked on the Condensation Station,” and maybe they would laugh, and then I’d be part of the ping-pong game of jokes that people like him play. But what if I say it and no one hears me, or everyone hears me and it dies? A dead joke in the middle of the table is visible and no one wants to touch it. I draw a tiny train in the margin that says Condensation Station on the side. It has a happy face and steam curls that look like thought bubbles escaping my head to have their own lives elsewhere. Be normal. Normal is safe; normal is invisible; invisible is safe until you vanish completely. He has freckles near his jaw. Do not look at them like they are star charts. Focus on the worksheet. I write: Hypothesis: Increasing the surface area of a liquid will increase the rate of evaporation because more molecules at the surface can escape into the air. This sounds smart and definite in my brain. Out loud, if asked to say it, my mouth would say: “Um, I think, like, more area, um, more, uh—yeah.” Maya asks me, “Do you think we should weigh the cups too? Like before and after? Or just measure volume?” I love her for asking me as if my opinion is an ingredient. I nod too many times and then force my head still. “Mass change is more accurate,” I say, and it comes out almost normal. “Because of meniscus.” Meniscus is a delicious word; I hold it like candy behind my teeth and hope no one notices. “Meniscus,” he repeats, trying it out, and my ears light up like someone turned on the marquee. He says it right. He’s not making fun. If I tell him about parallax error, will he listen? He’s holding a pen and tapping it, and the tap syncs with my heart in a way that makes me nervous because then if he stops, will my heart stop too? That’s not how hearts work. Biology is your best subject. You know this. I draw his stick figure again and add a little tapping line near its hand. I draw Maya’s as a star with legs because she’s bright and also because she has star earrings today. Daniel is a rectangle with a baseball cap on top. Mr. Morales is a circle with a tie. I don’t draw myself this time. I’ve already used up my allowance of self. “Okay, so we can try two different dish sizes,” he says to all of us. “Like a petri dish and a bowl.” “There’s only one scale,” I say, and it is true, and it is a problem, and it is a safe fact. He nods, like I’ve contributed a brick to the wall we’re building. “We can stagger the trials,” he says. “Like, start one, weigh, start the other, weigh. Assembly line.” Say: That’s efficient. Say: I can coordinate. Say: Yes. I say, “Yeah.” The word is small and slippery. But he looks at me for an extra half second, and in that half second, I imagine he can hear all the other words lined up behind yeah, like planes in a holding pattern waiting for permission to land. If he could see my brain, it would look like an airport at night, lights blinking, everything organized, nothing arriving. He leans closer to look at my notes. The air between us does that thing where it pretends to be thicker. Don’t flinch. Be casual. Casual is a cat stretching in sunlight. I do not know how to be a cat. My shoulder blade wants to lock up, but I tell it no. He says, “Your doodles are cool,” and I stop breathing. Oh no. Not the doodles. I forgot the doodles are visible. Abort. Erase. But erasing is admitting they matter. “They’re just—” I start, but the sentence melts. I point to the train. “That’s, um, the Condensation Station?” It comes out like a question again. He grins, a slow-bloom grin, and I want to put it in a jar and label it with a tiny sticker that says rare. “Nice,” he says. “You should put that in the report.” He laughs a little. Not at me. Near me. With me. I can’t tell. It’s fine. It’s fine. My body is a factory that never shuts down and right now it’s producing a lot of adrenaline. “Okay, let’s start,” Maya says, saving me from the pressure of existing. We measure water. The meniscus crouches on the line and I get my eyes level with it and say, “Parallax is a liar,” in my head. He holds the bowl steady without being asked. His thumb is close to where my fingers are and I hope I don’t sweat noticeably. I’m wearing a sweater today, which was a terrible decision in a room full of bodies and nerves and fluorescent lights. Note to self: experiment on sweat glands; find off switch. We run the first weigh. I record: 100.00 grams. The zeros line up like soldiers. It’s beautiful. We wait thirty seconds, weigh again. The numbers change subtly, precise. This part is safe. I could live here. He says, “Is it weird that this is kind of fun?” and I have the perfect response in my head: “It’s satisfying to watch order emerge from chaos,” which is true and also makes me sound like a tiny philosopher. What I say is, “Not weird.” I hear how flat it is and I wish I could punch a window into it and let out the rest of the sentence. He doesn’t seem to mind. He is looking at the way the digital numbers cascade and I love that he is looking at the same thing I am. Daniel messes up one of the pours and water dribbles down the side of the bowl. He says, “Oops,” and I jump because any sudden sound runs a current through me that flips switches I didn’t know I had. I say, “It’s okay,” and hand him a paper towel like I am practiced at it. This is how you be a person: quiet helpfulness, a paper towel at the right moment. He glances at me and mouths thanks around the chaos and I feel like a magician who made something appear. We build the data table together. He writes numbers with slanted confidence. I wish I could take his handwriting and put it next to mine and compare them until patterns reveal themselves, like bird tracks in wet sand. I like patterns. I like that he doesn’t make me feel like a mouth fails at being a mouth. I like that no one has said I’m too quiet yet, as if I don’t already know. The bell is going to ring in nine minutes. That is time enough for at least one more trial, if we stagger correctly. Time enough to either say or not say something that will repeat forever in my head afterward, like a looped recording of what if. Strategy D (bold): at the end, say, “Do you want to write the conclusion together at lunch?” Immediate risks: sounds like a date. He will laugh. He will tell his friends I asked him to lunch in the nerdiest way possible. Counter: frame it as teamwork. Use neutral words. Use science words as camouflage. The trial concludes. We pack up. The room fills with zippers and chairs scraping. I write our names neatly on the top of the notes with a feeling like stepping to the edge of a high diving board. He picks up his backpack with one shoulder, the strap running diagonally across his hoodie like a sash. He says, “I can do the graphs tonight, if you want.” He is looking at me. At me. The at me unglues something. “Okay,” I say. Say more. Say something. “I can, um, write the conclusion,” I add. “Or, like, we could…together?” The word floats out, small and brave. He says, “Yeah, want to meet in the library study room before school? Like twenty minutes?” I blink because this is the part where the world usually corrects me and says no. But it says yes. I nod. Too many times. I force my head to be still and say, “Okay,” with what I hope is exactly one nod. Cool, he says again, that hidden door. The bell rings, a vibrating alarm clock that shudders through the desks. People launch into the hall. He says bye and is gone, hoodie a whisper. I draw a tiny study room in the margin, two chairs facing a small rectangle. I draw two stick figures, mine with square glasses and triangle hair, his with the hoodie lump, and between them I draw a speech bubble that says hypothesis and another that says maybe. I want to write something else in there, but I don’t. Instead I put the cap on my pen carefully, like putting a lid on a jar of something that might spill. I gather my things. My hands are shaking in a way that looks like I’m cold, which is convenient. I tell myself walking is just controlled falling. I tell myself tomorrow morning is just another variable to manage. I tell myself I didn’t ruin anything. I tell myself a lot of things. Some of them might even be true.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative brilliantly captures the internal monologue of an intelligent 8th-grade girl with social anxiety who has developed a crush on a classmate. The piece excels at portraying the gap between her articulate internal voice and her difficulty expressing herself aloud. The protagonist's thought processes are meticulously rendered through her constant strategizing ("Strategy A," "Strategy B," etc.) and self-monitoring. Her internal voice is sophisticated and analytical, showing her intelligence through scientific vocabulary and precise observations, while her external communication is reduced to fragments and hesitations. This contrast is consistently maintained throughout the piece. The narrative effectively conveys the exhausting process of monitoring every word, expression, and movement. Details like "My pencil keeps tapping" and "I nod too many times and then force my head still" illustrate her hyperawareness of her physical actions. Her fear of embarrassment manifests in catastrophizing thoughts: "a dead joke in the middle of the table is visible and no one wants to touch it." The author employs creative metaphors that reflect the character's scientific mindset: "The facts fit neatly into place in my brain like someone pouring rice into a jar," and "If he could see my brain, it would look like an airport at night, lights blinking, everything organized, nothing arriving." These metaphors not only enhance the imagery but reinforce the character's personality. The narrative is almost entirely internal monologue as requested, with minimal external dialogue. When the protagonist does speak aloud, her words are appropriately brief and hesitant compared to her rich internal thoughts. The piece effectively uses formatting to distinguish between internal thoughts and spoken words. The science project setting provides a perfect backdrop for the protagonist's character, allowing her to showcase her intelligence while struggling with social interaction. Her doodling of stick figures and the "Condensation Station" train reveals her creativity and serves as a plot device for connection with her crush. The pacing is excellent, with the narrative building tension through small interactions and the protagonist's overthinking. The ending avoids an unrealistic transformation while still providing a small victory for the character—securing a study session with her crush—that feels earned and age-appropriate. One minor critique is that occasionally the metaphors become slightly overwrought ("a flock of something panicked inside my ribs and then went very quiet"), but these instances are rare and generally fit the character's dramatic internal experience. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that captures the voice of an intelligent but socially anxious 8th-grade girl with remarkable authenticity and nuance. The writing is emotionally engaging, psychologically insightful, and technically accomplished. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Rehearsing Rejection — Score: 96.8
Prompt:
Rehearsing Rejection Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of someone with borderline personality disorder who frequently plays out worst-case scenarios of how friends and loved ones might judge them. They construct elaborate internal dialogues, complete with imagined criticisms and their own defensive responses. The narrative takes place as they prepare to meet a close friend & recent lover, who has been somewhat distant lately, triggering their abandonment fears. Their inner monologue should reveal how they cycle between anticipating rejection, mentally rehearsing confrontations, and developing preemptive resentments as protective measures. Incorporate the *actual* events & interactions that are *not* in fact judgemental or involving rejection (in fact, the opposite), and represent how these are interpreted, how the validation & love is desperately felt & needed -- and then immediately questioned. Capture the cognitive dissonance in this struggle. Include moments where they briefly recognize the pattern but struggle to interrupt it, showing limited (and selective) self awareness, competing with the compelling nature of these imagined scenarios. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The neighbor’s television is murmuring through the wall, like someone talking about me in another room. I can’t make out the words, just the cadence, like rising eyebrows and scrunched noses. I keep looking at my phone screen even though I know the time: 6:11. She said 6:30. She said, Can’t wait to see you. With a period, not an exclamation point. I can’t decide whether that’s mature warmth or lukewarm obligation. I decide it’s both, sequentially. I stand up, sit down, stand up again. I pick at a thread on my sleeve and make it long and dangerous. When she was here last week, she fell asleep on my couch with my legs across her lap, the good kind of heavy, and I thought, This is simple. Now my stomach is a moat. The television voice swells and drops, I imagine laugh track or disaster siren or some courtroom revelation. It’s so easy to map everything onto a courtroom. What are you going to say? I ask myself in a voice that’s not mine, a firm, sensible therapist voice. I say, Out loud inside my head, I say: Hey, you’ve been a little distant and I just wanted to check in, because I value what we have and— She interrupts me, the imagined she, the one who’s already tired before I arrive. She has a coffee cup with a lid that hisses when she sips. She says, I’ve been busy, okay? Not everything has to be about you. Can we not do this? I freeze in the mirror, seeing my face waiting to be scolded. I rehearse my heroic restraint: Of course, I get that you’re busy, I just felt— No, that’s weak. Try again. I match the therapist voice with measured assertiveness: When you don’t respond, I spiral. I’m not blaming you; I’m telling you how I feel. She says, Well, that’s not really my problem to fix. I make a face. I knew you’d say that. I knew you’d make it about my flaw, like I’m some leaky pipe. I imagine standing up from the cafe table dramatically, chair legs scraping. I imagine not apologizing. Then the real memory slides in uninvited: last weekend, she texted, I’m sorry I went quiet today, my sister had a scare at work but everything’s okay now. There was even a second message: Thinking of you. A heart. I had pressed my phone to my face like it could touch back. I had written, Totally okay! Hope she’s doing well xx and then sent a joke to prove how okay I was. Inside, panic still ran its relay. Now the neighbor’s TV drops to a muffled roar. I picture the news. I picture her looking at her phone and deciding not to answer. My phone buzzes: a calendar reminder. My heart does a sprint no one asked it to do. Then it calms. Then I get angry about it having sprinted. Why do I always have to be the one who feels so much? Okay, new script. We meet. She smiles, she actually smiles wide, she stands to hug me. Her hair smells like whatever her shampoo is that makes me think of clean, expensive bathrooms. She says you look nice. I say, Oh this old thing, and then I say, You too, and it’s light and teasing. We sit. I tell myself: don’t bring it up. Be normal. Let it be good. She touches my wrist when she laughs and I feel electricity in my bones, like a defibrillator. She asks about my day. I tell her about the idiot printer that tried to eat the paper, and she makes an empathetic oh-no face. It’s not rejection, it’s not judgment, it’s nothing but ordinary kindness. I bask. And then the next scene: she glances at the door when someone walks in. My body marks this as evidence. She looks away at her phone; she’s thinking of an exit. I decide, See? There it is. The drop awaits. The kindness was the appetizer before the letdown. I sit on the bed, tie my boots, untie my boots, retie them with the laces in a different order like that matters. I hear myself think, You could not go. You could cancel first. I could send, Hey, something came up, can we rain check? Preemptive strike. Keep the high ground. Make her chase. But then the part of me that remembers her hand on my neck says, Don’t do that. Don’t hurt yourself like that. Another part says, She’ll be relieved. Then another part calls that part a liar. The television is now a canned audience applause. Or a storm. Or a hearse. My interpretations are a choose-your-own adventure book where every path leads to the same cave. I replay the exact text where she wrote, I miss you. It was a week ago, 10:42 PM. Not a period. An exclamation point and a sleepy face. I saved it like a kid hides candy under a pillow. Why doesn’t that quiet me? I hold it up and it’s immediately translucent, light passing through, edges fraying. Maybe she missed me in that moment only. Maybe she liked the version of me that was silent and kissable and not asking questions. Maybe she was drunk. The television says something that sounds like “love” but could be “gloves.” I take it as a sign and then laugh at myself for taking it as a sign, then add that laugh to the evidence of my ridiculousness. Okay, I will be rational for five minutes. Timer: five minutes. I set the timer. My heart negotiates: three minutes? No, five. I breathe the way people on apps tell you to breathe. In, out, count, as if numbers turn air into antibiotic. I notice the sensation of my shirt against my collarbone, the slight itch where the tag scratches. I notice a memory trying to interrupt, of my father saying, You’re too sensitive, and my mother saying nothing at all, which was worse. I notice that without their help I can spiral just fine. The recent lover part, that complicated hyphen, recent-lover-recent-distance, I can feel the word like a bruise. We hadn’t defined anything, which for me is the same as being put in the waiting room with a stack of outdated magazines. I want to march to the desk and demand attention. I want to be dignified. I want to be adored, I want to be cool. I draft: So what are we doing? Then I draft: I really value our connection. Then I draft: I need you to tell me if I’m not enough. I know that’s not the script. But it is the ache. Timer says 3:14. I break my promise and check Instagram. She posted a story of coffee foam shaped like a leaf at 3 PM. Caption: needed this. I zoom in like there’s a clue in the bubbles. Was she alone? Was there a second cup? Was the barista cute? I feel mean toward the barista I haven’t met. I invent her freckles, her forearms, her gentle laugh, and I hate her a little for being invented. I catch myself doing it. Hey, you’re doing the thing. The thing where you write the ending and then act betrayed when it comes true because you wrote it that way. I make a joke in my head: spoiler alert. It doesn’t land. The audience in the neighbor’s TV laughs anyway. On the way there, in my head, she says, Sorry, I’ve been off, I’ve got stuff going on, it’s not about you, I promise. She looks worried I’ll be upset. In one version, I say, It’s okay, I trust you, and I mean it, and we hold hands under the table. In another, I say, If it’s not about me now, when will it be? And I hear the bitterness like lemon rind in my teeth. I rotate these scenarios like a kaleidoscope. The same colored beads making different patterns, and all of them a little dizzying. I remember, concrete and real, that last Tuesday she showed up at my door with soup when my throat was raw. I had cried a little because nobody brings me soup, not like that. She kissed my forehead and called me a baby in a way that made baby feel like a crown. When she left, I sat on the floor with my back against the cool cabinet and felt so lucky I wanted to tip the universe. But even then, a little voice was like, This is a one-time coupon. Redeemable only once. Expires at midnight. She texted ten minutes ago: On my way! Smiley face. Why does my chest feel both warmer and worse? It’s like warm water pouring into a cup with a crack. I want to patch it fast, my hands fumbling with tape that won’t stick. What if I just tell her? I practice: My brain does this thing. I’m trying to not let it. I could say it with a small laugh, like I’m cute about it, like I’m self-aware. I could say it with my eyes swollen and honest. I could write it on a napkin and slide it across like a confession. And then she could say, Thank you for telling me, and she could mean it, and I could feel that that is not pity, not patience, but love. Love that isn’t rationed. But immediately—see?—another voice says, Don’t show your belly to the teeth. You do that and she’ll pity-kiss you and plan her exit in the Uber on the way home and text her friend, She’s intense. She’ll say to her sister, I can’t be her everything. And her sister will say, You shouldn’t have to be. And they’ll be right in that big, reasonable way that makes me feel small and unreasonable. They will compile me into a cautionary tale. I put on my coat and then take it off and then put it on again because it’s hot-sweaty and then it’s cold-shivery and the thermostat is not actually about temperature. The neighbor’s TV says something like, We can work this out, and applause, and my heart claps too and then immediately tells the clapping to knock it off. I catch myself in the mirror again and I actually say, Stop. Softly. Like I’m talking to a skittish animal. For a second, I see someone I could be kind to. For a second, I don’t want to make her bleed just so I can say I told you so. I step into the hallway. The light is that fake daylight that hums. I imagine her waiting at the cafe already, early, the way I like to be early to control the terrain. I imagine she picked the corner table because she knows I like corners, backs to walls. I imagine her watching the door and checking her phone and smiling when she sees me. I imagine her not smiling. I imagine her body angled away, toward the window, toward escape. I walk down the stairs. My feet know the steps. My head staggers between now and maybe. It’s raining, not hard, the kind that makes everything shine. I rehearse removing my armor, then rehearse adding more. I rehearse being calm. I rehearse a fight. I rehearse the cool shrug I will pretend is my natural state if she hints, just hints, at wanting space. Oh? Sure. Do your thing. No big deal. And then I will go home and bite my own lip bloody to stop from texting her ten long confessions. By the time I have my hand on the door of the cafe, my mind has authored five novels and a sequel. I push it open. The bell rings like a tiny, clean thing. She is there. She stands up. She is smiling, big. Her eyes do that soft thing. She opens her arms and says my name like a kite string. I step into it and the part of me that’s been braced unbraces without asking. It’s just a second, but it’s real. She smells like rain and coffee and her. She says, Hi. I missed you. The neighbor’s TV is far away; here it’s spoons and milk frothers and human breath. I fall into the chair and my mouth forms a thank you that I don’t say out loud. She touches my hand. She asks, How are you? And not like a placeholder. I feel flooded, in the good way, like heat in my bones thawing ice. And then, almost immediately, I feel a sting, like betrayal by my own relief. Can I trust this? Will she take it back? My brain pulls up the monochrome filter. It mutters, She says this to everyone. It reminds me of the time three years ago when someone else said I missed you and then forgot me. That someone isn’t here, but my brain invites them to the table anyway and seats them as a guest of honor. She says, I’m sorry if I was a bit quiet this week. Work was a lot, and I didn’t want to bring that noise to you. I wanted to be present. I’m here now. I squeeze her fingers. I say, It’s okay, I get it. I tell the truth and a lie at the same time. I feel the validation like a warm hand on my heart, and I clutch it too tightly, and because I clutch it, I worry I’ll crush it. My mind leaps: If she wanted to be present, why wasn’t she present then? Who was she present for? I catch it mid-leap. Hey. I know. I know, I say to myself, like I’m taming a horse. It slows, tosses its head. I take a breath. I tell myself, Be here. You’re here. She’s here. It feels like balancing on one foot on a pebble. It feels like a miracle and a chore. She laughs at something I say. She leans in. She asks, again, How are you? And I try, I really try, to answer with right now instead of all possible tomorrows. I say, I’m glad to see you. My voice cracks on glad. We both hear it. She squeezes my hand again, steady pressure, like she’s telling me I’m not falling. The neighbor’s TV, in my mind, turns itself down. Outside, the rain keeps doing its rain job. Inside, I keep doing my job of doubting and then letting. Doubting and then letting. I can hear the imagined criticisms waiting in the wings, clearing their throats. I can also hear, faintly, another voice I don’t use much that says, Maybe. Maybe it’s okay. Maybe you can get to the end of the page before writing the ending. I nod. I take a sip of water. I feel the water move through me. I look at her mouth, her eyes, the way she sits solidly, the way she is not fog. I am still braced and still melting. I know I will cycle again. I know I will text her later and reread her replies like someone reading tea leaves. I know I will picture her in other rooms, with other people, saying the same soft things, and I will ache. I also know, in this second, that she is here, and her knee is touching mine, and the universe didn’t tip me out of my chair. I let that be true for as long as it can be true, which is this breath, this sentence, this spoon clink, this heartbeat, this particular version of me who allows it. And then, because I am me, I prepare, quietly, for impact, just in case, while also not ducking the kiss that is about to land.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative brilliantly captures the internal experience of someone with borderline personality disorder (BPD). The piece excels at depicting the protagonist's constant cycling between anticipating rejection, mentally rehearsing confrontations, and developing preemptive resentments as protective measures. The narrative structure is masterfully executed, almost entirely in internal monologue as requested. The protagonist's thought patterns feel authentic to BPD - the catastrophizing, black-and-white thinking, and emotional intensity. The writing captures how the character constructs elaborate internal dialogues with imagined criticisms and defensive responses: "She says, Well, that's not really my problem to fix. I make a face. I knew you'd say that." What's particularly impressive is how the piece contrasts these imagined scenarios with actual events that contradict the protagonist's fears. We see moments of genuine connection and care from the friend/lover: bringing soup when sick, sending thoughtful texts, and being warm and present during their meeting. Yet the protagonist immediately questions these positive interactions: "I feel the validation like a warm hand on my heart, and I clutch it too tightly, and because I clutch it, I worry I'll crush it." The cognitive dissonance is vividly portrayed. The protagonist recognizes their patterns at times ("Hey, you're doing the thing. The thing where you write the ending and then act betrayed when it comes true because you wrote it that way") but struggles to interrupt them. This limited self-awareness competes with the compelling nature of their imagined rejection scenarios. The prose is elegant and evocative without becoming purple. Metaphors are fresh and illuminating: "My stomach is a moat," "It's like warm water pouring into a cup with a crack," and "My interpretations are a choose-your-own adventure book where every path leads to the same cave." These metaphors don't just decorate the text; they deepen our understanding of the protagonist's emotional experience. The piece maintains a consistent voice throughout, with a raw, vulnerable quality that feels authentic. The stream-of-consciousness style effectively mimics the racing, circular thoughts characteristic of BPD. Short, fragmented sentences create a sense of urgency and emotional intensity: "I stand up, sit down, stand up again. I pick at a thread on my sleeve and make it long and dangerous." The ending avoids both unrealistic transformation and complete despair. Instead, it shows the protagonist in a moment of tentative hope while acknowledging the ongoing struggle: "I let that be true for as long as it can be true, which is this breath, this sentence, this spoon clink, this heartbeat, this particular version of me who allows it. And then, because I am me, I prepare, quietly, for impact, just in case, while also not ducking the kiss that is about to land." This feels true to the experience of BPD - small moments of connection amid the ongoing battle with abandonment fears. The piece is emotionally complex and engaging, inviting readers to empathize with the protagonist's struggles without romanticizing or simplifying them. It's a nuanced portrayal that avoids stereotypes while capturing the essence of BPD's emotional dysregulation and relationship challenges. The only minor critique is that occasionally the metaphors come a bit too rapidly, which might slightly distract from the emotional immediacy. However, this is a minor point in an otherwise exceptional piece that demonstrates deep understanding of BPD and remarkable writing skill. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 20 Nuanced Characters: 20 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 20 Emotionally Complex: 20 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1 Amateurish: 0 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 20
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 20.0, Nuanced Characters: 20.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 20.0, Emotionally Complex: 20.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1.0, Amateurish: 0.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 20.0
+ Physical-spatial: Blood Debt — Score: 89.8
Prompt:
"Blood Debt" Write a vivid third-person narrative depicting an unsanctioned underground duel between two talented but hot-headed martial artists. Their schools have been embroiled in a generations-old rivalry, and despite strict prohibitions from their masters, these two younger fighters arrange a secret confrontation fueled by personal pride and simmering animosity. - **One fighter** represents **Jigen-ryū**, a traditional, aggressive style practiced historically by elite samurai clans. Its practitioners emphasize explosive offense, decisive strikes, and overwhelming speed. Known historically for their arrogance and disdain toward outsiders, practitioners consider their art superior and untouchable. - **The opposing fighter** employs a form of historical **Piguaquan**, a Chinese martial art traditionally practiced by commoners, bodyguards, and street fighters. This style emphasizes whipping, circular strikes, rapid footwork, unpredictable angles of attack, and evasive maneuvers. Practitioners often come from lower social classes and view the traditional elite as pretentious and detached from true combat effectiveness. The fight takes place in the crumbling ruins of an abandoned temple, now functioning as a hidden arena for illicit duels. Passionate supporters from both factions surround them, wagering money, pride, and reputation on the outcome. **Essential Instructions:** Maintain absolute physical coherence throughout—clearly track fighters' positions relative to each other and their environment. Precisely depict strikes, counters, momentum shifts, and spatial dynamics, allowing readers to clearly visualize the mechanics and choreography of the fight at every moment. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
They chose a ruin eaten by rain and time. The old temple squatted on a hill outside the city like a broken jawbone, its roof long since collapsed, its ribs of beam and pillar exposed. Lanterns hung from splintered rafters, throwing pools of yellow light over moss-slick flagstones. A thin stream of water threaded through a crack in the center of the floor, veering past a toppled altar and into the black mouth of a drain. The stream made a wet sibilance in the quiet, scummed the stones with green, and turned the footing treacherous. Around the edges, in the dim aisles between shattered columns, supporters pressed in — students in black jackets and faded headbands, old men with scarred knuckles, women with ledger books and paper slips, hands moving in brisk calculation. Money flashed; wagers whispered; pride simmered. They entered from opposite sides. From the east archway came the Jigen-ryū man, tall and cut from cords and angles. He wore a simple indigo hakama and a dark gi, sleeves rolled to his elbows, hands rough and scarred. His face was impassive, the arrogance a deeper layer, a glaze that came from being told you were bred to conquer. He paused on the sill, toes at the drip line, eyeing the trickle of water like an obstacle to be devoured. When he bowed, it was crisp and shallow, a courtesy offered like a blade. From the west, the Piguaquan fighter slid in sideways, every line in him loose but ready. He wore a plain gray short-sleeve shirt, black trousers bound at the ankle, and shoes with soft soles. He rolled his shoulders once, letting his arms dangle like ropes, and then shook them out, wrists snapping to make his hands flick like whips. His hair was tied with a faded red cord. He smirked, but his eyes were sharp and moving, counting the stones, the slick patches, the way the stream cut the floor into two imperfect halves. A man between them raised a hand, palm out. He looked like an old shrine-keeper who had swallowed his pride and rented his ghosts. “No killing,” he said. “No weapons. No interference.” The crowd’s murmur coiled into a taut line. The shrine-keeper chopped his hand down. They closed. Jigen-ryū attacked first, as was their way. He drove straight through the center, right foot stepping into the line of the stream, ignoring the shimmer of water. His left hand lifted, a guard that barely existed, while his right chambered high and then dropped like a guillotine in a vertical shōmen-uchi. Even empty-handed, the intent of a cut was in it. He intended to split the Piguaquan man’s guard and force a retreat. The Piguaquan fighter had already stepped obliquely to his left, onto a dry island of stone. His weight sank into his right leg and then flowed across into the left as he turned his shoulders, presenting a thin profile. The vertical strike punched air where his center had been a heartbeat before. In the slice of space beside Jigen-ryū’s arm, his left hand whipped up from low to high in a scooping heng quan, catching the inside of Jigen-ryū’s right elbow. His right hand followed a whisper later, chopping with the back of the forearm into the tricep. He did not stop; the energy spiraled through his hips, sending his right foot sliding past Jigen-ryū’s forward foot to threaten the outside line. Jigen-ryū was not there to be entangled. He yanked his right arm back and down, retracting along his center, and pivoted his left foot a fraction, turning his hips square to chase. His left hand shot out in a straight tsuki toward the chest — direct, linear, brutal. The Piguaquan fighter rolled his shoulders and let the fist skim past his ribs; his right elbow flicked down, pinning the arm into a brief trap, and his left palm slapped a short arc across Jigen-ryū’s jaw with a pi zhang, fingers loose, heel of the hand cutting the angle. The sound snapped like wet leather. Jigen-ryū’s head jerked a degree, not a lot, but enough to stagger his next step. He did what his forebears had drilled: he advanced. Right foot crossed through the stream with a splashing step; then left, stamping to reestablish his forward pressure. He dropped his center and launched a hip-driven body check, shoulder leading. The Piguaquan man gave ground two small steps, right then left, each a skimming glide that placed his feet on dry, textured stone. His hands blurred in circles, not compositions for their own sake but arcs that redirected force. Jigen-ryū’s shoulder met an empty coast and slipped past, and Piguaquan’s left hand spun over and down into the back of the neck, while his right forearm slid across the chest. He wasn’t grappling; he was placing touch like feints to draw reactions. Jigen-ryū slammed his right forearm up, chopping to clear the neck grip, and stomped his left foot, angling to cut off the retreat. The stomp landed half on the live edge of the stream, sole kissing water; the grip of his tabi found something, not much. He hid the adjustment in a forward drive. His right hand shot as a hammerfist at the temple. The Piguaquan fighter dropped under it, bending at the hips, and his right fist uncoiled in a whipping backfist along the low diagonal, raking across ribs. The follow-through turned into a hooking pull at Jigen-ryū’s gi. Piguaquan’s left foot slid left across the stream’s edge, diagonal to Jigen-ryū’s line, and his left hand snapped up hard into the armpit with a bai pi — a chopping slap that jolted the shoulder girdle. The air filled with the thick hush of a crowd holding breath. Jigen-ryū didn’t stop. He absorbed the rib shot by tightening his obliques and turned into the left-hand slap to jam it with his right bicep. He pivoted on the ball of his right foot, sliding the left to re-square, and in the same motion drove a short punch into the midline — a sickle of a strike that began at the heel and ended in his knuckles. The punch hit the Piguaquan man’s forearm as he tried to slip it. Even that half-hit had meat in it. Piguaquan’s left hand recoiled. The Jigen-ryū swept low with his left leg, a scything foot sweep intending to catch the Piguaquan’s lead ankle. The sweep met air. The Piguaquan fighter had jumped, not high but enough, his ankle clearing with a snap, and as he landed he caught the inside of Jigen-ryū’s sweeping leg with a downward forearm, jarring it. He stepped past, inside the arc of the sweep, and whipped his right forearm across Jigen-ryū’s lower back, then snapped his left hand into a palm heel to the kidney. The blows weren’t knockout shots; they were bile in the gears, cruelties that turned structure into mud. Jigen-ryū grunted and changed levels, sinking his weight, dropping his hips under the incoming palm. He seized the moment of proximity. His right arm, folded from the missed sweep, shot backward, elbow spearing toward Piguaquan’s ribs. The elbow found the side; the Piguaquan fighter tensed and bled the impact by turning his waist. Jigen-ryū’s left hand caught cloth at the Piguaquan’s thigh and reeled, trying to hoist. He wanted to lift, to slam into the slick stones and finish with knees. The stream betrayed him. His feet were set wide to lift; the right foot was on the wet seam. As he heaved, the sole slid a finger’s breadth. It was enough. His lift lost gut. The Piguaquan fighter felt the break — the strain without lock — and folded like a switchblade, his left forearm crashing down on the grasping hand to break the grip, his right knee bumping Jigen-ryū’s inner thigh to disrupt stance again. His right arm came over the top and chopped down the side of Jigen-ryū’s neck with the ulnar edge, a whip that kissed and left. The Jigen-ryū repaid speed with intent. He aborted the lift, planted his left foot, and fired a vertical punch from his hip to Piguaquan’s face, the kind that hit like a post ram. Piguaquan’s right hand rose in a circle to carry the punch past his ear, not a hard block but a redirecting brush, and he moved his head with it, leaning left. His left hand spun underneath, snapping into a backhand to the cheekbone. He did not stand still to admire it. He stepped outside — his left foot to the dry stone beyond Jigen-ryū’s right, then his right behind — circling. He took Jigen-ryū’s flank. The circle turned the fight. Jigen-ryū pivoted to keep him front, his feet cutting angles across the treacherous floor, water splashing up to fleck his calves. Every time he tried to set and drive, Piguaquan’s palms and forearms shaved his hands off line, the strikes landing not as single bombs but as a drumroll — backfist to ribs, palm heel to jaw hinge, forearm to bicep, hand-spear under the jaw that didn’t penetrate but made the throat spasm. None was fatal; all were cumulative. He wanted to throw power. He needed one clean step. He made it. He baited a circling entry by lowering his hands a fraction, showing the soft gate. When Piguaquan slid in with a circling pi to the neck, Jigen-ryū shot his left foot forward and a little to the right, cutting across the stream to a patch of stone he had felt with his heel earlier — dry enough — and torqued his hips hard. His right hand launched as a straight tsuki to the solar plexus, and this time he added his left palm driving behind his right fist, doubling the body weight. There was no flourish. It was a spear. Piguaquan saw the line late. He twisted to bleed it, but the punch crashed into his chest high and left, sledging him back a full step. His heel hit wet; his sole slid. He turned with it, body compressing to save the fall, and took a knee. Jigen-ryū surged, the blade in him singing. He stepped to close, right foot hunting dry stone, left following, and dropped a hammerfist at the base of the skull. The Piguaquan fighter wasn’t there when it landed. He let the slide carry him through; his right hand slapped the wet floor and he rolled his shoulders, the hammerfist skidding across his back into empty space. He used the posted hand to hook the inside of Jigen-ryū’s left ankle and flicked, not to trip but to make him step. Jigen-ryū stepped instinctively with his right to regain balance — right into the edge of the stream again. He compensated with a wider base; his hips opened. Piguaquan rose into that opening like a tide. He uncoiled from his kneel in a whipping upward diagonal, right forearm cutting from hip to opposite shoulder. It caught under Jigen-ryū’s right arm, lifting it. His left palm followed the hole, raking across the chest, then came back as a hook to the jaw. Jigen-ryū tried to fold his elbow down to pin, but Piguaquan’s strike was already past. Jigen-ryū’s head snapped, and his right foot, slick, slipped a handspan. He didn’t fall. He set his left knee like a post, caught himself in a half lunge, and drove upward with a rising punch, trying to shear Piguaquan away. The Piguaquan fighter stepped in tighter, smothering range. His right forearm pressed along Jigen-ryū’s right bicep, capturing it against his chest, while his left forearm rode the outside of Jigen-ryū’s left arm. He turned his waist hard, a short twist. Both of Jigen-ryū’s shoulders were jammed for an instant, his arms momentarily bound by body mechanics, not grip. Piguaquan took that instant and put a hook of his heel behind Jigen-ryū’s left ankle. He didn’t sweep. He bumped as his hips twisted again. The bump stole the base. Jigen-ryū toppled backward, but his hands were not free to breakfall cleanly; he flung his right arm out of the jam and slammed it into the floor, turning his body to save his head. He hit hard on his back and the breath went out of him in a wet grunt. Water splashed up in a glitter of lit droplets. The crowd howled, some in triumph, some in rage. Coins clinked like rain on tin. Piguaquan didn’t pounce. He stepped back a half, weight centered, arms circling, whipping loose — ready to re-enter if the other rose wild. Jigen-ryū rolled to his knee and was already pushing up, eyes narrowed to needles. Pride put iron under him. He stood, shook his shoulders once, and advanced again. They clashed in the drainage’s shallow curve, trading short ranges where the slip made every overcommitment a hazard. Jigen-ryū compacted, shortening his strikes, elbows in, punches like piston rods. Piguaquan flowed around them, touching and turning, never letting him hit square. Jigen-ryū landed a right under the ribs that made Piguaquan’s mouth pinch; Piguaquan answered with a palm that crossed the nose and flashed blood; Jigen-ryū wrung his left forearm across Piguaquan’s throat; Piguaquan ducked, rolled right, slapped the back of Jigen-ryū’s knee, and rose on the outside line again. The momentum swayed like a lantern in a draft, then swung harder toward the Chinese. Jigen-ryū’s breathing deepened; the kidney shot from before made his side tighten on every inhalation. The temple’s floor drank his footing more than it drank his foe. He saw, dim as a lantern behind fog, that the stream had become the third fighter — every step on water took the sting from his drive. He decided. Aggression doubled. He feinted high with a step that threatened the face, and when Piguaquan’s hands rose to billow the line, Jigen-ryū crashed low instead. He dropped shoulder-first into Piguaquan’s hips, arms scooping behind the knees, intending to lift and run him backward into the toppled altar. It was an ugly tactic in a ruin; it would end the fight. Piguaquan didn’t try to sprawl; the slick floor turned sprawls into splits. He slid backward, riding the contact, hands on Jigen-ryū’s shoulders to keep his head up. As Jigen-ryū surged, Piguaquan’s right foot found the thin lip of stone before the altar’s base, dry, and his left foot pivoted to point outward. He turned his waist and shoulders at once, a whole-body twist. Jigen-ryū’s forward energy glided along, redirected. His own momentum printed him into the plane of the altar corner, not with skull, but shoulder and chest, enough to shear his structure. Piguaquan’s left forearm scythed down onto the nape, not to injure the spine, but to bend him into the stone. Jigen-ryū’s breath left again in a clench. Piguaquan stepped back, not greedy, keeping him pinned by geometry rather than grip. He snapped a right palm into the side of the head — open-hand, heel of palm, a crack — and then one more to the liver line, a whipping strike that made everything in Jigen-ryū’s body flinch. He paused, the crowd’s roar pouring like the stream into the drain. Jigen-ryū’s hands were under him. He pushed, staggered, turned, eyes blurred. He tried one last direct line: right foot to stone, left foot to cut, hips to fire, fist to end. The Piguaquan fighter was already off the line. He slid — short, precise — inside the arc, his left hand caught the wrist and drew it a hair past center, his right forearm jammed the bicep. He bent his knees and turned, a simple wheel with no flourish. Jigen-ryū’s arm folded and his balance went into the hole created behind his left heel. The Piguaquan’s right knee kissed the back of that knee again in a bump, and Jigen-ryū went down, this time flat and sprawled, palms slapping stone, fingers skidding in the trickle’s slick. Silence dropped as if the ruin itself, tired of echoes, refused another. Piguaquan stepped back two paces and lifted his hands, wrists loose, palms forward — not to gloat, but to show open. The shrine-keeper slid between them, palm out to each, the other hand probing the air as if to feel for ghosts. Jigen-ryū lay a moment longer, breath a rasp, then rolled, pushed to sit, and then to his feet. He swayed and steadied. Pride wrung him rigid. He made himself bow — shallow, grudged, a vertical slice of neck — and then turned away from the altar and walked, slow, to the east archway. The crowd split down the middle; money changed hands in unhappy clumps and bright little laughs. The Jigen-ryū partisans carried their wounded arrogance like ceremonial armor; the Piguaquan side glowed with the rough pleasure of a win earned in the muck. On the floor, the stream whispered, indifferent, threading past scuffed footprints and blood-speckled stone, seeking its drain.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This martial arts narrative demonstrates exceptional technical precision in depicting a fight between two contrasting styles. The author has created a vivid, physically coherent combat sequence that meticulously tracks the fighters' positions, movements, and techniques throughout. The setting is established with atmospheric detail - an abandoned temple with moss-slick flagstones and a stream cutting through the floor, creating treacherous footing that becomes a crucial element in the fight. This environmental factor is consistently integrated into the combat, affecting momentum and outcomes in believable ways. The characterization of the two fighters is accomplished primarily through their fighting styles and physical presence. The Jigen-ryū fighter embodies his tradition's aggressive, linear approach with "cords and angles," while the Piguaquan fighter moves with loose, circular motions. Their personalities emerge organically through their techniques rather than through exposition. The prose excels at technical precision without sacrificing readability. The author employs specific martial arts terminology (tsuki, pi zhang, heng quan) while ensuring the reader can visualize each movement. The fight choreography is meticulously tracked, with each action leading logically to the next and maintaining spatial coherence throughout. The narrative avoids common pitfalls of fight scenes. There's no unrealistic superhuman ability, no convenient plot armor, and no sudden skill disparities. Instead, the outcome emerges from the accumulation of small advantages, tactical choices, and the environmental factor of the slippery floor. The pacing is particularly strong, with moments of explosive action balanced by brief pauses that build tension. The author uses sentence length variation effectively, with shorter sentences for immediate actions and longer, more flowing sentences for the Piguaquan fighter's circular techniques. While the piece excels technically, it could potentially develop the emotional stakes more deeply. The generational rivalry is mentioned but not deeply explored within the narrative itself. The fighters' internal experiences remain somewhat opaque beyond their immediate tactical considerations. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted martial arts narrative that achieves its primary goal of physical coherence and technical precision while creating an engaging, atmospheric fight scene. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 16 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 16 Emotionally Complex: 14 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 16.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 16.0, Emotionally Complex: 14.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Physical-spatial: Breaking Formation — Score: 90.2
Prompt:
**"Breaking Formation"** Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a street dancer from a rough neighborhood who's won a scholarship to an elite K-pop training academy in Seoul. Desperately out of place culturally and technically, they struggle with a militaristically precise choreography that contradicts everything about their improvisational background. The punishing rehearsal takes place under a famous instructor known for breaking students to remake them, who sees potential in the narrator's raw talent but not their attitude. This scene MUST maintain complete physical coherence—each dance move, position shift, and spatial relationship must be tracked with precision throughout the studio. Paint an exceptionally vivid kinetic picture through descriptions that capture not just movement but the contrast between the narrator's fluid, expressive style and the mechanical precision demanded. Their internal monologue should reveal culture shock, class anxiety, and the threatening realization that success here might mean losing their authentic movement voice. Include technical terminology that highlights the collision of street and commercial styles, moments when muscle memory betrays them, and a crucial decision point about whether to conform or rebel. Physical clarity is essential—readers must be able to visualize exactly how bodies move through space, how rhythms align or clash, and how the protagonist's body struggles against unfamiliar discipline. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The floor is a mirror that remembers your mistakes. Scuff marks bloom at the edges where sneakers have dragged too long or landed a hair off center, but in the center, where the overhead grid flares brightest, the laminate looks untouched, like it refuses to betray those who hit their marks. The AC hums over a ticking metronome the assistant set on the subwoofer. A strip of black tape runs upstage-right to downstage-left, a sightline, and the wall-length mirror divides me from myself, two bodies, both wrong. We stand in three staggered lines, all facing front: I’m third row, second from center, my left foot set in parallel under hip joint, heels kissing the tape. From the corner, the instructor—Han seonsaengnim—flicks their hand fan open and shut like a knife. The sound slices the room. “Counts,” they say. The assistant taps a screen. A synth snare rolls in: click, click, click-click. “Five, six, seven—” On eight we’re already moving: pop to the left shoulder on one, right elbow carves a ninety-degree angle on two, wrists flip to accent the hi-hat on the and. The move sequence is a lock-in: a tic-tic-tic precision chain, arms carved into straight lines so clean they could be measured with a set square. My forearm wants to curve, to melt; muscle memory from church basements and blacktops pulls me into a groove, a glide that eats the spaces between the sixteenth notes. Here they want space like negative sculpture: no path, only arrival points. “Stop.” The fan snaps shut. Everyone freezes. My right toe is a finger’s breadth past my taped heel. In the mirror, you can see it—a tiny cheat, a city block’s worth of attitude. Han walks directly toward me, footsteps quiet, the fan re-opening with a flutter. “You are not painting. You are placing,” they say, and their breath smells faintly of peppermint and menthol. “Again from one. Your shoulders are street, your wrists are soup.” The room bloats with heat. We reset feet, second position narrow, knees soft but not bent. My chest wants to breathe in time to the beat, to treat the drum as a partner, but here the beat is a ruler rapping knuckles. We go again. One: left shoulder jacks straight up and drops. Two: right elbow locks sharp to ninety degrees. And: flip wrists so palms face down, snap at the joint, no roll through fingers. Three: step right to side exactly heel-to-arch width; left foot drags and closes on and with no scraping sound. Four: pelvis tucks under; there is no bounce. By four I feel my ribs wriggling, trying to snake against the tuck—they’ve survived years with their own agenda, my own conversation with bass lines, but now the conversation is with a grid. I swallow. I can do grid. I turn my abs into a box. “Good,” Han says to the room. “Again.” We drill. The phrase is short: eight counts times four, then a reset into a floorwork transition. On the second eight, there’s a micro-iso that lines up every scapula in the room. We’re all paired with our reflections, twenty-two students slicing air in unison, the soft hush of fabric on skin timed. A girl in front of me, long spine, bobbed hair, places her left foot exactly on the seam between two floor panels. She doesn’t check it with her eyes; she just knows. At the downbeat of the third eight, the move breaks into a traveling step. Three-quarters turn to the left, chaîné but clipped into two counts, not three, landing in a back diagonal. Everyone’s ankles align along the black tape; everyone’s chins tilt at the same angle. I arrive a quarter beat late, blade foot shinily sliding. The correction blooms through me—I want to tuck it with a top-rock bounce, a micro-rock that smooths the late into a groove. That would sell it back home. Here it smears. “Freeze.” The fan closes. Han is next to my right shoulder now, not touching but close enough for the air to feel occupied. They tilt their head, eyes scanning from my toe to my neck. “You compensate with flavor because you missed the count,” they say, quiet enough that only the third line hears. “Do you think I don’t see that?” I don’t answer. In my head, the South Side cranes down hard. Flavor is how we survive bad speakers, power cuts, cops driving by too slow. Flavor is the difference between staying and being dragged. My throat tastes like iron. “Again.” The fan opens. “From the travel. Five, six—” I count internally, half-singing: one-e-and-a, two-e-and-a. My weight’s over my toes. The assistant raises a hand—my cue to correct the spot. On the turn, the world spins to a smear of bodies and black tape. Spot front, spot mirror, spot front again. I place my left foot on the tape line and lock my hips square to corner two. Arms cross at chest like shutters on four; then, wrist isolation on five, six, seven—this is the part where the choreography turns almost robotic, forearms parallel to floor, fists tight, retraction only at the scapula. My muscles itch to let the energy rebound through me, a wave that leaves fingers trailing. I clamp it. I shove it back. “Better,” Han says, glancing at me without approval. “But your face leaks.” I check my face in the mirror. My eyebrows are doing their own choreography, a silent commentary that reads: this is a joke we all understand. I tell them to stand down. We run the A section into B: a switch from hard-hitting vogue arms into a slick commercial glide, then dropping into a floor combo that my knees hate. Eight counts to lower: right knee lowers to the floor on two, left follows on three, palms plant on four under shoulders—align wrists under joints, no splay. On five, shoot the right leg through underneath, thread to a kneel facing upstage. Six: recover into a half-standing crouch; seven: stand, sit into a hip as your arms snap above head; eight: step into a diagonal tuck jump. My body wants to torque the thread, to roll a bit of capoeira through the space, to let the knee replace be a conversation. The room wants a slot change in a vacuum. “Again,” Han says. Their fan whispers over my shoulder like someone telling me a secret I don’t want to hear. We go until my quads are trembling. The assistant turns off the click; music spills in: a track with a bright synth hook and a kick drum too fat for this clean studio. The choreography welds to it like a machine to a conveyor belt. We become parts. They are precise pieces; I am a bolt still warm from the forge. Between runs, we watch one another in the mirror. Many of them are from academies, pliés disciplined into the hips, tendus straight as rulers. Their sneakers are clean. Mine are a little chewed at the soles, leftovers from battles where asphalt ate rubber and moves slipped from night into legend. Their skin creams smell like lavender and something sweet. I smell like train grease and frankincense from my auntie’s house. The class chatter during water breaks floats across me—dialect flavors I can’t catch, the soft click of a foreign language knitting itself without me. “Partner counts,” Han orders. We pair off. The girl with the bob—Minji—gestures for me. We face each other at a diagonal, thirty inches between shoes. In the mirror we’re a V. The exercise is strict: my right becomes her left, our lines must mirror down the seam between us. We do the wrist retraction sequence in slow motion, two counts per isolation, then add speed. My muscles eventually find the path; they hate the leash. A tiny jerky thread snakes through my right shoulder. “See,” Minji says, polite, breath shallow. “Your scapula slides too far. Think of your shoulder blade suction-cupped.” I imagine the suction; my blade obeys. The move becomes smaller and suddenly right. I want to laugh because small feels wrong; small never fed me. Big got people to pay attention. But here, small is currency. We break the wall again in full-out. I nail the travel. I manage the thread without capoeira creeping in. On the chorus, there’s a moment: arms flick outward in a series of tutting squares, then shift into a body roll locked through eight little micro pulses, like a hummingbird trapped and trying not to show it’s trapped. My roll is liquid; it wants to flood. I build a dam. I count the eight. My teeth are clenched. Up front, Han sees the dam, nods once, and the fan snaps in approval instead of reprimand. “From the top. This time, commit,” Han says, and their eyes slice into me. “Commit to this. Not to what you think this could be.” What I think this could be is a conversation between my block and their mirror. But their mirror doesn’t talk; it interrogates. We go again, and my lungs start burning as much as my thighs. Somewhere on the third run, my brain misfires a familiar pattern: a sixteenth-note off-beat where I normally slide my heel back in a baby backslide, that beautiful ghost walk we all learn behind grocery stores. The choreography here calls for a step-ball-change standard, weight over midfoot, no drag. My heel skates backward a half inch. The sound is a whisper. It pulls me into my own dance for an instant—a glitch, a glimpse of home. The fan slams shut so sharp it echoes. “Stop.” Han walks into our formation, slicing between lines. This time they do touch, two fingers under my sternum, a pressure reminding me to knit my ribs in. “You,” they say, “you are trying to keep this—” tap tap, my sternum, “—while you do this. You cannot. You will choose.” My heart, traitor, tries to jump into their hand for a second. I breathe it back. “What if this is the only way I know how to choose,” I say. It comes out softer than I mean, less South Side, more someone approaching a border crossing with no papers. Han’s mouth twitches, not a smile. “Then learn another way.” They step back. “Again from chorus. All eyes on him.” The pressure is hot and public. The count begins. I choose: I lock every joint the way they want. My body becomes a series of right angles and straight lines, the grooves shaved down, the flavor resealed in a jar. The wheels of the choreography hum under me. The eight counts line up in the mirror like soldiers in drill. It feels like holding my breath under a long tunnel; the other end shines, and the cars on either side blur. When the chorus ends, and we hit the final hold—left arm high, right at chest level, right foot pointed but grounded, chin one inch down—I’m in exactly the right place. I know it before anyone tells me because the room clicks, a sound like twenty-two exhalations choosing now. The fan pops shut once like a conductor’s baton on the podium. “Yes,” Han says. “Again.” We run it two more times. I’m compliant. I am the academy version of myself, as close as I can get in an afternoon without bleeding. But between four and five of the last eight, a tiny tremor runs through my right hand. It’s not fatigue. It’s something moving in the jar. The assistant starts the music again, but Han holds up the fan. “Break.” The word hangs there. People drop to the floor, stretch, sip water, check their phones. My calves buzz. My joints hum like neon. I walk to the corner where my bag leans against the barre. Outside, the city is something I can’t read yet—all square glass and polite silence. Inside, my sweat dries to salt. I look at myself in the mirror: a kid from a rough block in a room where everybody hides how easy it is for them. My reflection shifts, a fraction of an inch forward and back as I breathe. It looks like a nod. This is the decision, and it surprises me because it doesn’t feel dramatic. It’s not rebel or conform. It’s when to choose which, and how much without breaking the bones that hold me up. I think about the Metra rattling past my bedroom window at night, how you learn to sleep between the clacks. I think about how I shaved edges off my footwork to battle on slippery floors, how I softened elbows to keep from breaking fingers in crowded circles. Adaptation didn’t steal anything; it just hid it until the floor asked for it. Han appears in the mirror next to me, not looking directly at me. The fan is closed, the rounded edge tapping their leg. “You have something,” they say. “Raw is not a compliment here. Raw is a start. Do you want to be rebuilt?” I meet my own eyes in the mirror, not theirs. My right hand opens and closes once, checking the tremor. The beat in my head, my beat, counts off without music: one-and, two-and, three-and. “Yes,” I say. “But I want to keep my screws. You can tighten them. Don’t replace them.” Han’s reflection lifts an eyebrow. “We will see,” they say. They flick the fan open. “Places.” We file back to lines. I set my foot on the tape, heel exactly on the edge, toes forward. The counts start. And as the grid drops onto me again, as my body slices into their clean air, I make a small space inside the lock where my breath can be a little off, a secret syncopation only I can hear, a promise jarred and sealed for later. I hit each mark. I place, not paint. But I am keeping a color hidden in the brush.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures the experience of a street dancer from a rough neighborhood struggling to adapt to the rigid discipline of a K-pop training academy. The piece excels in its physical specificity, tracking movements with precision while maintaining the emotional and cultural tensions at the heart of the prompt. The writing demonstrates exceptional kinesthetic awareness, describing dance movements with technical accuracy while maintaining readability. The contrast between the narrator's fluid street style and the academy's mechanical precision is vividly portrayed through specific physical descriptions: "My forearm wants to curve, to melt; muscle memory from church basements and blacktops pulls me into a groove, a glide that eats the spaces between the sixteenth notes. Here they want space like negative sculpture: no path, only arrival points." The physical coherence is maintained throughout, with careful attention to spatial relationships, body positioning, and the technical terminology of both street and commercial dance styles. The writer effectively uses dance-specific language like "chaîné," "top-rock bounce," "tutting squares," and "baby backslide" to establish authenticity. The internal monologue successfully conveys the narrator's culture shock and class anxiety. Small details like the contrast between the other dancers' "skin creams [that] smell like lavender" and the narrator smelling "like train grease and frankincense from my auntie's house" effectively establish the class divide. The protagonist's fear of losing their authentic movement voice is palpable: "Flavor is how we survive bad speakers, power cuts, cops driving by too slow. Flavor is the difference between staying and being dragged." The piece builds to a nuanced decision point rather than a simplistic rebel-or-conform choice. The protagonist's realization that "It's not rebel or conform. It's when to choose which, and how much without breaking the bones that hold me up" demonstrates psychological complexity. The ending strikes a delicate balance, with the narrator outwardly conforming while "keeping a color hidden in the brush" – maintaining their authentic self within the constraints of the new environment. The prose is elegant and controlled, with effective use of metaphor and sensory detail. The rhythm of the writing itself mirrors the dance being described, with short, staccato sentences for precise movements and longer, flowing sentences for the narrator's internal reflections. A few minor weaknesses: occasionally the technical dance terminology might be challenging for readers unfamiliar with dance, and there are moments where the metaphors become slightly overwrought ("The room wants a slot change in a vacuum"). However, these are minor issues in an otherwise exceptional piece. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Gothic-fantasy-humour: Court of the Dreaming — Score: 94.3
Prompt:
Court of the Dreaming: Territorial Dream Dispute. Write a dark fantasy scene with comedic elements set in the Courts of Dream where a case is being heard to determine ownership of a contested dreamscape. Mora, the Slavic nightmare spirit who sits on sleepers' chests causing paralysis and terror, has recently invaded and subverted a carefully crafted recurring dream of a schoolboy, Max. The dream originally featured the boy lying in a field of wildflowers with his crush, always culminating in a muddled almost-kiss and a pleasant confusion of emotions. This dream was the meticulous work of "First Love" (a rosy-cheeked, slightly bashful entity who crafts formative romantic experiences). However, Mora has recently infiltrated the dreamscape, transforming the scene so that when the girl playfully mounts the boy, she morphs into a terrifying yet somehow still confusingly attractive vision who proceeds to sit on his chest and feed on his breath. Mora's defense largely consists of the practical argument that "a girl's gotta eat too, you know?" Write this scene as it unfolds in the courtroom of the Dreaming, with Dream's demeanour, typically impenetrable, betraying a sense of irritation at having to adjudicate such matters. The comedy should derive from the farcical situation, familiar elements of courtroom drama intersecting with the fantastical world of the Dreaming, and the droll portrayal of the characters and their interactions. The humor should be dark and understated throughout. Dream is tempted to some mischief in the resolution of the case. Use descriptives sparingly when setting scene. Write for readability & engagement. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The gavel is a metronome made from a child’s lost tooth and a twig. It clicks once, and the great chamber of the Court of the Dreaming exhales—benches creak like forest boughs, the gallery of drowsing jurors stirs, and a hush arranges itself upon velvet scaffolding suspended over nothing. The judge’s throne is a negative space shaped like expectation. In it sits Dream, expression blank as a closed door, eyes full of stars that know better than to fall. The bailiff, a headless suit of moth-eaten upholstery with a bell where the mouth should be, inhales a lungful of silence and bellows: “Oyez! Oyez! The Court of the Dreaming is now in session. The matter of Domain Disputation: Max-and-the-Nearly-Kiss v. Consumer—con-som-nom—con—Mora.” “Mora,” the defendant purrs, rising without needing to. Her dress is a nightfall stitched with frost, and she wears the easy smirk of a cat who knows which windows don’t latch. Her hair curls like smoke from a candle snuffed between fingers. Opposite her stands the complainant, “First Love,” blushing in gradients, daisies woven through their hair. They clutch a folder that leaks the scent of pencil erasers and clean laundry. When they speak, it sounds like someone clearing their throat before a confession they hope goes well. Dream lifts the tooth-and-twig gavel. His voice makes the air behave. “We will dispense with ceremony. Territory of dream is at issue. Numbers—” “Exhibits,” murmurs the court scribe, a quill writing by itself on a sheet of fog. “—exhibits will be reviewed in order.” “Calling to the not-stand the witnesses,” booms the bailiff. “Maximilian… Ma… Maaaaxmillipede.” A boy steps forward from a pew that resembles a line in a notebook. His pajamas drip grass stains that won’t exist in the morning. He stares at his sneakers, which have never been this clean outside of dreams. He looks twelve, but in the way that twelve contains the vapor trail of thirteen. “And…” the bailiff rattles, “the subject known as Eliza—Elixir—Elizth—Girl.” From a flutter of paper cranes, she appears, the girl from the field of wildflowers. She has a sunburn where a sun never rose. She’s more idea than person here, but an idea with very specific freckles. “Objections?” Dream asks, and no one dares. He gestures with a finger as thin as ink. “Proceed.” First Love clears their throat. “Your Honor, the dream in question is one I curated across eight and a half sequences. The boy, Max, lies among lupine and cornflower, the girl beside him. They discuss homework, the idea of kissing, whether ketchup is a smoothie. They almost—” First Love’s cheeks redden to a dangerous hue— “almost kiss. The moment is unspecific by design. It is a first attempt at mystery.” Mora files a nail with a sliver of midnight. “And then I improved it.” “The improvement,” First Love says, “consisted of sitting on the boy’s chest.” “I am a traditionalist,” Mora replies. “Also: a girl’s gotta eat too, you know?” She spreads her hands, palms pale as milk at moonrise. “I could go after anxious adults, but have you seen the cholesterol?” In the gallery, a gaggle of insomniacs cough into their hands and pretend not to be present. A mare with black foam at its lips stamps on a sigh. Dream’s eyes narrow in the specific way that means the stars inside them have opinions. “Let the facts be arranged.” The quill drags an ink line across fog: Exhibit A rises. A diorama unfolds midair—a field of improbable flowers, Max and Girl lying shoulder to shoulder. Their conversation plays back as overlapping whispers: “Do you think bees know their names?” “I think kissing is like tapping two phones together.” “My heart feels like homework I forgot to do, but in a good way.” Exhibit B blossoms, and the color leaches out. The Girl straddles Max. Her smile lengthens into something too many teeth wide and yet—Max’s ears go a little pink. The figure on his chest tilts her head. The scene stylizes into wet brushstrokes, breaths fogging, the weight a hammer, the fear a string pulled taut. Dream’s mouth sets flat. “Integration of nightmare vector detected,” he says. The words file themselves in triplicate. “Your Honor,” First Love says, hands making a little nest for their next sentence, “I do not deny the place of terror in the Dreaming. But Max’s dream was under my patronage. Adolescence is confusing, but it need not be devouring.” Mora clicks her tongue. “Adolescence is devouring by definition. Also, jurisdiction in the Dreaming is fluid. He was on his back, heart up, eyes wide. That’s my doorbell.” The bailiff lifts his headless head. “Ob-jerky-tion sustained? Overcast? I forget.” “We will sustain nothing yet,” Dream says, with a tiredness so old it comes around to newborn again. “Maximilian.” Max flinches at the full name. “It’s Max,” he says, then glances up at the judge and amends, “Your Honor Sir Dream… Mr. Dream? Uh.” In the gallery, a few nightmares snicker and are immediately smothered by pillows that did not exist a moment ago. Dream inclines his head the width of a shadow. “Max. Tell the Court the shape of your experience.” Max scuffs the dream floor. “It was, like, good. The first kind. My stomach felt like when you go down a hill on a bike you’re not supposed to. And then lately, it’s like the hill keeps going and I can’t stop, and I can’t move. And she—” He flicks his eyes to the Girl, then back to his shoes. “She looks like her and not-her at the same time. It’s scary. But also…” He reddens dreadfully. “I mean, my brain won’t stop being my brain.” “So there is attraction,” Mora says, bright with triumph. “And fear. Two cheeks of the same face. I am artisanal in my pairings.” First Love presses palm to sternum. “You are taking a taste that shall sour him on sweetness.” The Girl’s hand goes up timidly. Dream gestures. She stands, feet not quite touching the floor, voice soft as a folded note. “In the dream, I want to kiss him. And then I want to climb on top because the grass is wet and my jeans are expensive. And then—someone else is there too. It feels like being told how to feel. It’s loud.” “Ah,” Dream murmurs, the kind of sound judges make when they have always known the truth and are inconvenienced by hearing it aloud. He turns to Mora. “You fed.” “A little,” she says. “Enough to keep my nails shiny. I did not empty him. I am not a monster.” She winks at Max, and his breath fogs in his own throat. First Love flips through their file. A Polaroid flutters out—a shot of a sunset that never was, a kiss that never quite happened, perfect. “He needs this,” they say, voice so earnest the courtroom momentarily smells like rain on chalk. “Question for the Court!” cries a nightmare shaped like a geometry problem. “Isn’t it precedent that nightmares may cross-pollinate with developmental dreams, subsection Pubertatis, clause ‘We all did weird things at twelve’?” The scribe rustles. “Cited: The Case of Locker Room Teeth v. Homecoming Crown. Verdict: mixed custody, alternating Tuesdays.” Dream rubs two fingers together, and the ghoul of a yawn slinks under the benches. His expression shifts in micrometers—irritation slipping through the seams of implacable. This is the tenth dispute this night and the seventh in which a party has said “a girl’s gotta eat.” He leans forward, and the chamber tilts toward him. “Mora. Would you sit on him if he were not sweet?” Mora considers, gaze flicking over Max like a tongue over a toothache. “No,” she concedes. “The sweet ones dream with their chests open. It’s efficient.” “And First Love, if he were not frightened, would you persist?” First Love flinches as though accused of theft. “Yes. Fear is part of firsts. But not paralysis. Not the kind that makes your lungs count stones.” Dream closes his eyes. When they open, a new galaxy whirs inside them, irritated and perhaps slightly amused. “The Dreaming is not a buffet. Nor is it a monastery. Domain is not ownership. It is stewardship.” He taps the gavel. Time hiccups politely. “Ruling,” he says, and the word hangs in the air like a cold bell. “The field remains under First Love’s curatorship. The nearly-kiss shall occur, shall fail, shall ripple hope through the boy like heat through cold hands. Mora, you may approach, but not alight. You may be the breeze that cools a sweaty palm, the shadow that makes the sun more precious, the almost-thought that makes the heart race. You may not sit upon his chest. If you hunger, you shall feed from those who invite you—” Mora’s brows arc. “And who would—” “—such as the fifty-year-old who insists on eating cheese before bed to conjure you, and the poet who drinks black coffee at 2 a.m. because he thinks it makes his lines more honest.” A pair of hands in the gallery clap guiltily and stop. Mora pouts. “You would have me starve on art and dairy.” Dream’s mouth nearly, almost curls. “Art and dairy are plentiful.” The bailiff raises a sleeve. “What of en-force-ment? Con—conductification?” “Sanctions,” Dream says, voice dry as a salted cracker. “Should Mora sit again upon the boy’s chest without warrant, her own dreams shall be made subject to First Love for one cycle.” Mora stills. “You wouldn’t.” Dream’s gaze is abyssal. “Imagine, nightmare, a bloom in your ribs. A blush on your centuries. Someone carving your name into a bench and then walking past, never sitting. Breathing that catches not in terror, but in hope. It is not lethal, but it is… inconvenient.” Mora shudders. “Cruel.” “Instructive,” Dream replies. “Max.” The boy looks up. “You will wake with muscle-memory of the field. A laugh you cannot place will snag in your throat at lunch. The fear will not return tonight. It may return later, in another shape, and you will be larger then.” Max nods. He doesn’t understand, which is exactly right for now. “Girl,” Dream says, gentler. “Your jeans will remain unsullied. You may tell him about the bees.” She smiles, and two of her freckles change places, giddy. First Love glows with relief so pure the daisies in their hair open and close in applause. They bow. “Thank you, Your Honor.” Mora rolls her eyes, but there is a grin there too, sharp as a crescent. “Fine. I’ll nibble on artisans and dairy-men. But if the boy starts sleeping on his back—” “Then he has been warned,” Dream says, as though warnings were his favorite candy. He lifts the gavel. The courtroom hums. He hesitates a beat, mischief lighting him from within. “One addendum.” Mora leans in, wary. First Love straightens. “In the field,” Dream says, “the nearly-kiss may, on one statistically unlikely night, be an actual kiss. Neither of you will know which night. This uncertainty will feed you both.” Mora blinks. First Love gasps. Somewhere, the scribe writes exclamation points with great dignity. “Court is adjourned,” Dream says, and brings the tooth and twig down. The sound is a soft click, like a lock turning in a door. The world folds. Benches become tall grass. The jurors yawn themselves into lint. Max and the Girl blur back to future memory. Mora lingers, making a moue at Dream’s throne. “You are capricious,” she says. “Occasionally,” he allows. “It suits you,” she says, and the compliment hangs between them like a spider’s staircase, delicate, predatory, true. The bailiff’s bell-mouth booms one last time: “All rise for The Lord of Dreams, a.k.a. The Magni—Magnesium—Majesty.” Dream does not rise. He dissolves, like a held breath released. The courtroom empties itself, like a chest relieved of weight. In a suburb, a boy turns in his sleep, his hands finding, without thinking, the exact right place to rest—on his own ribs, protecting something delicate and ridiculous. Above, in the long hallway of the Dreaming, a nightmare and an awkward tenderness pass each other like ships at dusk, and neither admits they looked back.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkable example of dark fantasy with comedic elements, set in the Court of the Dreaming. The author has crafted a world that feels both familiar and alien, drawing on courtroom drama tropes while infusing them with dreamlike surrealism. The writing demonstrates exceptional control of language. The prose is elegant without becoming overwrought, with descriptions that are evocative yet economical: "Her dress is a nightfall stitched with frost, and she wears the easy smirk of a cat who knows which windows don't latch." The author uses metaphor and simile to great effect, creating vivid imagery that enhances rather than distracts from the narrative. Character development is nuanced and effective. Dream is portrayed with appropriate gravitas and subtle irritation, maintaining his canonical demeanor while showing glimpses of mischief. Mora and First Love are well-realized opposites, each with clear motivations and distinctive voices. Even minor characters like Max and the Girl have depth and agency within their limited roles. The dialogue is particularly strong, revealing character while advancing the plot. Each entity speaks in a distinctive voice that reflects their nature: Mora's predatory playfulness, First Love's earnest concern, Dream's measured authority, and Max's adolescent awkwardness. The humor is dark and understated as requested, arising naturally from the situation rather than forced jokes. The comedic elements—like the bailiff's struggle with names, the insomniacs pretending not to be present, and Mora's practical approach to feeding—are woven seamlessly into the narrative. The pacing is excellent, with the courtroom drama unfolding at a satisfying rate. The resolution is clever and fitting, with Dream's judgment showing both wisdom and mischief. The ending avoids both saccharine positivity and unearned darkness, instead finding a balanced resolution that honors the complexity of the situation. If there are any weaknesses, they are minor. Occasionally, a metaphor might be slightly overextended, but these moments are rare and don't detract significantly from the overall quality. The piece successfully balances the fantastical elements with relatable emotional stakes, creating a story that is both otherworldly and resonant. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Blood Moon — Score: 89.5
Prompt:
Blood Moon Alucard & Yennefer Write a story where Alucard (Hellsing) encounters Yennefer (The Witcher) in medieval Europe. Yennefer's magical abilities intrigue the vampire, while she's both repulsed and fascinated by his monstrous nature. Their power dynamic shifts constantly as they circle each other, neither willing to show weakness first. **Alucard (Hellsing)** Alucard is an ancient, immensely powerful vampire who works for the Hellsing Organization. He can regenerate from almost any wound and shape-shift at will. He's sadistic, arrogant, and takes pleasure in toying with his enemies before killing them. Despite being a monster, he despises weak vampires who can't accept their nature. He wears a distinctive red coat, wide-brimmed hat, and orange sunglasses. He uses massive handguns loaded with silver bullets. He seeks worthy opponents who can challenge him and potentially end his immortal existence. Famous quote: "The bird of Hermes is my name, eating my wings to make me tame." **Yennefer of Vengerberg (The Witcher)** Yennefer is a powerful sorceress who magically altered her appearance to hide her congenital hunchback. She's ambitious, stubborn, and manipulative when necessary. She has violet eyes and smells of lilac and gooseberries. Despite her cold exterior, she desperately wants to reverse her infertility caused by magical transformation. She's centuries old but appears young. She's politically savvy and refuses to be underestimated. She has a sarcastic sense of humor and little patience for fools. Though she rarely shows it, she's capable of deep love and loyalty. Famous quote: "I'm not sweet and I'm not a maiden in distress in need of saving." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The wolves start first—one voice, then three, then none, then too many. The sound rides the wind through broken orchards and burnt stubble fields, combing the haystacks and rattling the shutters. It reaches a town that no map cares to name, empty save for a church spire and a tavern with a warped sign. The night is a dark loam, rich and heavy. Clouds wreathe the moon and peel away like skin. The wolves announce and re-announce themselves, never keeping time, as if the forest itself is learning how to speak. Alucard hears them the way a shark senses blood. Each voice is a pinprick of humor; this land has a flair for dramatics. He steps from a copse of trees and lets the long grass stroke the red of his coat. Mud sucks at his boots, but he leaves no prints. His hat is a black hole against the sky. When lightning tickles the top of the church spire in the distance, he tips his head, amused. He has walked through a hundred Europes salted with fear and faith. This one, tucked between centuries, tastes of both. He carries his handguns—one black, one steel—like ornaments. The silver in them purrs, hungry and useless against him. He does not come to hunt; he comes because something moves through this country that is not peasant superstition or drunk priestly rumor. He comes because a tremor went through the web of the world, and it resonated with the old, starving part of him that calls itself curious rather than lonely. Yennefer smells him before she sees him, which offends her. Not the scent—there’s little of decay, less of earth, more of iron and smoke. But that she senses him at all as a scent. It pricks memory: caves and old texts, mage councils, huntsmen returning with stories of men without reflections. She is on the road for her own purpose, and has no patience for a legend begging to be confirmed. Still, she is not foolish enough to walk past a door slightly ajar without peeking through. She steps into the same field from the opposite hedgerow, the hem of her black dress brushing thistle and rain-silvered nettle. The air shifts to accommodate her; it takes a breath and forgets, briefly, to exhale. Lilac and gooseberries push through the mud smell. The wolves falter, then continue their started symphony. She pulls up her hood, violet eyes glimmering in the dark like cut amethyst. Her fingers flex at her sides, rings whispering. He doesn’t turn, but his grin flashes like a blade. “Ah,” he says to the wind. “It was not just a tremor. It was the earth stretching.” “And the corpse crawls to watch,” Yennefer replies, and the wind carries the words between them. She favors talk as a weapon and a mask; it is cheaper than fire and more subtle than frost. Alucard pivots, coat fluttering. The hat’s brim cuts a clean line through fog. His orange lenses catch what little light there is and hoard it. He bows, elaborate and mocking. “Alucard,” he says, as though it is a polite introduction and not an old curse. “The bird of Hermes is my name, eating my wings to make me tame.” “Yennefer of Vengerberg,” she says, not bowing. “I’m not sweet and I’m not a maiden in distress in need of saving.” She does not give him the satisfaction of a smile. “Pity.” He takes a step forward and sinks a fraction of an inch into the earth and becomes thinner for it, like a lost shadow finding the ground again. “You move the world when you walk. A witch? No, that is too rustic a word. Sorceress?” “Magician,” she says, just to watch the word sit wrong in his mouth. “And you are... not of this century.” “I am of all of them,” he says, and it is less boast than admission. “You made quite a noise, little immortal.” Her jaw ticks. “Words like that have costs,” she says. “And for the last time, I am not little.” “Noted,” he says, gloved fingers opening as if to measure her by palmlength. “But immortal. I can smell the chemistry that stole your cradle.” She refuses the flinch that his accuracy requests. “You can smell nothing you can’t imagine. And you have no imagination. Monsters rarely do.” He laughs, sharp and unkind. “I’ve outlived poets and their delusions. I’ve seen castles kneel to cannons and gods whimper in gutters. Do not accuse me of lacking imagination; I am its hangman.” He tilts his head. “And you’ve carved yourself into an idea. It looks good on you.” She thinks, as she often does when men say such things, of chains turned into necklace and nails lacquered black to hide the soil beneath. “You’re a talkative ghoul.” He points, not at her but beyond her, toward the meager town. “I followed the scent of something dying badly. Not you. Something else.” The wolves choose that moment to harmonize into cacophony and then break apart again, as if the pack cannot decide whether to sing or sob. “There is a thing,” Yennefer says, because withholding everything is not strategy; it’s vanity. “It feeds without hunger. It crawled here from someplace that forgot to close its door. The villagers tried a shrine. Then they tried pitchforks. It liked both.” “You tried neither,” he says. “Why would I?” Yennefer lifts a shoulder. “If a wound wants to suppurate, sometimes you let it, to watch what it drains. But it began to pull at the lines. Blink hard and the moon stutters. I don’t tolerate that kind of arrogance.” “Ah,” Alucard says. “You and I share a dislike for competitors.” “I have no competitors,” she says, and the frost on the grass next to her retreats two inches, begrudging the admission warmth. He smiles. “Shall we kill it?” She wants to say no. She wants to say that she does not hunt with dogs. She wants to say many things. What she says is, “We’ll see.” They walk toward the town together, not side by side. He drifts forward and back, his coat swaying as if in water. She strides, each step a percussion note. The tavern’s sign—something once painted with pride, perhaps a stag—clacks against its chain in the unsettled air. The church door is closed, but the latch clicks, clicks, clicks like a nail being tapped by a bored god. In the square, the well has gone wrong. The stones around it bulge, breathing. A darkness hums there, not absence but glut. Someone’s ribbon floats, blue turned black in the night. The wolves fall silent, every one of them, as if a conductor lowered his arms. Yennefer lifts a hand. The pressure in the air changes; the well’s shadow thickens, then thins. It resists with the stupidity of anything powerful enough to be arrogant. Alucard is already moving, the edges of him unhooking. His legs soften into something sinuous; his coat becomes wings with feathers made of night birds. Teeth flower in his grin like white roses blooming too fast. “Don’t,” Yennefer says, barely turning her head. “Unless you know how to pull without unraveling.” “What a charming way to say ‘please wait,’” he says. He stops anyway. Their power touches like cats: back arched, fur raised, neither willing to be the first to settle. She speaks a word that is not a word, a curl of old language learned in a school that trains girls to kill their pasts. Threads show themselves to her sight, filaments of something raw and glistening, tying the well to the spire and the wolves to the road and the moon to its own reflection in a puddle. Her mouth tastes of copper. She plucks one thread and hears a laugh that is not human. Alucard’s hand closes around the steel handgun; silver gets eager. “You’ll irritate it,” he says. “I’ll flatter it,” she counters. “Everything that feeds wants to be believed.” “Do you?” She ignores him. The darkness at the well rises, substantial, a spill made vertical. It projects a face because faces are what prey understands. The face is a blur—wrong eyes, wrong mouth—like a charcoal portrait ruined by water. It speaks without sound; she hears a suggestion to give, to pour, to loosen. It remembers her, in the way that parasites remember the first skin. Under her feet, the well stones exhale. Alucard fires. The crack folds the square in half. The silver bullet hisses through the rising dark and buries in the church door beyond, punching it like a fist through paper. The thing jerks, astonished by pain. It looks at him, and a vertical pupil duplicates itself, multiplying until the night is full of terrible eyes. “Impolite,” Yennefer says. “I prefer to open the ball,” he says. He steps forward and the edges of him become dogs, mouths, a swarm of red eyes. “Dance with me.” She does not smile, but something in her posture loosens into delight. She cuts the air. The threads scream. The darkness tries to spread; she tightens. He wades into it, teeth and hat and coat, a grave made ambulatory, and tears pieces off that dissolve back into black. It is sloppy, joyous work. He laughs like a bell tolling for the end of a world. She keeps the limits—hem, seam, border—tight with mathematics and will. Together, by luck or design, he is the blade and she the sheath, containing the cut. The wolves attempt a chorus and fail, their howls scattering like cards. The moon slides into and out of a cloud and finds itself bleeding at the edges. The thing sends a tendril for Alucard’s face, wanting to wear him. He lets it. It slithers over his lenses and into the bone around his eye, testing him like a tongue. He does not flinch. He opens his mouth wide enough to suggest a misunderstanding of anatomy and bites the tendril in half. It shrieks in a register that turns Yennefer’s vision to static. She answers by burning its thread with a heat that remembers volcanoes. The square stinks of ruin and rain. “Stop toying,” she says, voice raw. “You say that as if it is not the point,” he says, spitting shadow like wine. But he obeys. He reaches, not with hands but with everything that he has become and has been, and seizes the thing where its lie is weakest. “You are not hunger,” he says, as if telling a child its name. “You are appetite with no art.” He drags it into shape. Yennefer—who understands better than most that names nail things in place—whispers a binding around the shape he insists on. It is ugly: a man too tall, knees bending wrong, mouth stitched with light that leaks. Shape hurts it. It cannot hide in ambiguity when they pin it to a body. Shape makes it killable. Alucard looks back at her, teeth bright. “Now?” She nods, and for a heartbeat the night is a pact between monsters. He puts the gun to the thing’s forehead as if posing it for a portrait. She tightens every thread until there is nothing left to slip through. Together, they fire—silver and spell. The head goes first, then the torso, then the idea of it. The well exhales and becomes, with relief, only a well. Silence unscrews itself like a top. Then the wolves, off in pieces of forest, remember their lesson and howl again, out of sequence, too early, too late. The church door lists. Yennefer’s knees ache. She refuses to show it. Alucard straightens, hat settling. He is a man again, if he ever was. He rolls his shoulders as if shedding someone else’s coat. “You hold the world like a lover,” he says. “And you bite it like an apple.” She wipes blood from her lip with a sleeve that refuses to stain. Her perfume is stronger now, as if exertion wrung it out of her. “You nearly let it take your eye.” “I wanted to see if it could.” He shrugs. “Disappointment keeps me honest.” “Honesty doesn’t suit you.” He laughs. It sounds less like a bell now and more like a window breaking somewhere cozy. He considers the well, then her, as if weighing which one is more dangerous. “You would make a superb vampire.” “I would make a terrible anything I didn’t choose,” she says. “And I’ve chosen enough.” “Ah.” He nods solemnly, mockery softened into respect. “So have I.” A wind stirs the ribbon near the well. It is blue again in the moonlight. The tavern sign sighs. The wolves tangle and untangle their song. Yennefer looks at the church and thinks, with annoyance, of villagers who will come back and call this a miracle performed by the virgin and not by a woman with burn marks on her throat and a man with a smile too wide. “They’ll rebuild,” she says. “They always do.” “They always forget,” he says. She considers him, the way hunger and performance and old hurt have arranged themselves in red cloth and tooth. He considers her, the way ambition and tenderness and scar tissue have been tailored into beauty cruel enough to be honest. The power between them, briefly, goes slack. “I should go,” she says. “There are threads to unpick elsewhere.” She does not say what they are. She will not say, to anyone, the word child. She will not ever say the word mother as something to be regained. “And I,” he says, “have a flock to terrify.” He tips his hat. “If you wish to be found, you will be. If you wish to be lost, you will be.” He smiles. “We are both good at both.” “Stay out of my way,” she says, and then generously, “or at least be interesting when you’re not.” “I am always interesting,” he says, affronted, which amuses her more than it should. She turns. The field greets her with a hush, then the whisper of grass on hem. The air closes around the space she vacates. He watches her go, not because he is a man who watches women walk away, but because she is a force and forces are, in their own way, beautiful in motion. The wolves take up their strange chorus again, staggering and overlapping until the night sounds like a throat clearing itself. The moon rides the clearing clouds, huge and red, a wound and a promise. Alucard takes off his hat and lets the light paint his face. He says, to no one and to the memory of the fight, “The bird of Hermes is my name, eating my wings to make me tame.” It is neither prayer nor curse. It is a reminder. In the distance, Yennefer pauses, as if she hears, and does not look back. She has no patience for souvenirs. He puts his hat on, melts into the trees, and the wolves mis-time their goodnights into her silence and his.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a compelling encounter between Alucard from Hellsing and Yennefer from The Witcher, capturing both characters' essence while placing them in a medieval European setting. The writer demonstrates exceptional skill in atmospheric prose, creating a rich, gothic ambiance that suits both characters perfectly. The characterization is remarkably faithful to the source material. Alucard's sadistic playfulness, arrogance, and monstrous nature are well-portrayed through his dialogue and actions. His shape-shifting abilities and casual attitude toward violence reflect his character from Hellsing. Similarly, Yennefer's stubborn pride, magical prowess, and cold exterior hiding deeper motivations are excellently rendered. The subtle reference to her infertility ("She will not say, to anyone, the word child. She will not ever say the word mother as something to be regained.") shows a nuanced understanding of her character. The prose is highly stylized and poetic, with vivid imagery that creates a sensory experience. Lines like "The night is a dark loam, rich and heavy" and "Clouds wreathe the moon and peel away like skin" establish the gothic atmosphere effectively. However, at times the writing becomes slightly overwrought, with metaphors piled upon metaphors that occasionally obscure rather than illuminate. The dialogue is exceptional, capturing both characters' distinctive voices. Their verbal sparring demonstrates their power dynamic perfectly - neither willing to show weakness, both respecting the other's power while maintaining their pride. The incorporation of their famous quotes feels natural rather than forced. The plot structure works well, giving the characters a common enemy to face while allowing their interaction to be the true focus. Their cooperation against the well-creature showcases both their abilities and their contrasting approaches to power. The action sequence is well-executed, balancing Alucard's violent approach with Yennefer's more calculated magical strategy. The ending avoids cliché by neither forcing them into conflict nor creating an unearned alliance. Instead, it respects both characters' independence while acknowledging their mutual recognition of each other's power. Some minor weaknesses include occasional passages where the metaphorical language becomes too dense, potentially confusing readers. The nature of the antagonist remains somewhat vague, which may be intentional but leaves some aspects of the conflict underdeveloped. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that demonstrates a deep understanding of both characters and skillfully places them in a shared context that honors their respective universes while creating something new. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Prison Strings — Score: 89.3
Prompt:
Prison Strings Jolyne Cujoh & Makima Write a story where Jolyne Cujoh (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure) and Makima (Chainsaw Man) cross paths at a supernatural prison facility. Jolyne is immediately suspicious of Makima's falsely sweet demeanor, while Makima is intrigued by Jolyne's Stand ability. Their battle of wits escalates dangerously as Jolyne realizes how manipulative Makima truly is. **Jolyne Cujoh (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure)** Jolyne is the daughter of Jotaro Kujo and the first female JoJo protagonist. Her Stand, Stone Free, allows her to unravel her body into string that she can control. She's hot-headed, foul-mouthed, and doesn't take disrespect from anyone. She was framed for murder and sent to prison. She has a distinctive butterfly tattoo on her arm and wears her hair in two buns. Despite her tough exterior, she's deeply loyal to her friends and family. She can be impulsive but is highly adaptable in battle. She inherited her father's ability to stay cool under pressure but is more emotionally expressive. Famous quote: "If there's no Mickey, this shit ain't Disney!" **Makima (Chainsaw Man)** Makima appears as a young woman with auburn hair and ringed yellow eyes. She's the Control Devil who can dominate anyone she considers beneath her (nearly everyone). She maintains a pleasant, soft-spoken demeanor that masks her manipulative, cold nature. She can create contracts with humans and devils, often exploiting their desires. She's obsessed with Chainsaw Man and wants to control him. She keeps numerous people and devils as pets on leashes. She's practically immortal due to a contract with the Prime Minister. She views humans as lesser beings but mimics human emotions perfectly. Famous quote: "It's okay. Dogs are supposed to die for their owners." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The rumor starts as a whisper in the fluorescent hum: the cameras fuzz to snow when she walks by. Jolyne notices it first in the reflection of a Plexiglas shield—one second of static that blooms like a white flower and then collapses, leaving her own face staring back. Two hair buns like horns, a butterfly wing blue-black on her arm. If there's no Mickey, this shit ain't Disney, she thinks, shoving her tray forward in the cafeteria line. This prison is already off. Now it’s getting supernatural in ways that make her skin stand up. The new department—something between wardens and auditors—arrived at dawn with suits and blank faces. They took a wing, set up desks and wires and humming machines, and the rumor followed: the redhead with yellow eyes makes cameras forget what they saw. She enters without a key’s jingle or a door's grunt. She finds Jolyne in the corridor that smells like bleach and mold and old anger. Her hair is auburn, her coat a muted rust. The unmistakable ringed irises pin Jolyne like a pinned butterfly. “Jolyne Cujoh,” the woman says, voice soft as warm milk. “Thank you for waiting.” Jolyne does not remember waiting. She plants a foot, crosses her arms. “I didn’t.” A smile, precise as a scalpel. “I’m Makima. There was a question on your file, and I thought I’d answer it personally.” “My file has questions?” Jolyne’s mouth quirks. Stone Free hums under her skin like a guitar string tuned to a bad note. She’s been framed once; she recognizes strings someone else ties. “What are you, HR?” “Something like that.” Makima steps closer, hands folded like a schoolteacher. The air shifts—something invisible, pressurized. There are guards at the end of the hall, but they’ve turned their heads as if the far wall has become very interesting. The cameras above them blink. The red recording dot dies. Jolyne throws a glance at the lens. “Funny how equipment breaks when you show up.” “Electronics can be temperamental,” Makima says. “People are, too.” Stone Free unspools from Jolyne’s wrist in thin blue lines, a thread so fine it could slip between eyelashes. She keeps it low, in the seam where floor meets wall. She can feel the structure of the corridor through that thin whisper of herself: cracks in the cinderblock, a gum wad hardened under a pipe, the short heartbeat of a hazing fluorescent bulb. The thread curls behind Makima’s heel, a cat’s tail waiting to trip. “Do you always walk into people’s lives and start smiling like you own the lease?” Jolyne asks. “I prefer to think I keep people’s lives tidy.” Makima’s head tilts. It’s a gesture that reads as human, and also as something that learned humanity by watching, purposefully. “You have an unusual power. It must be comforting. To be in pieces and in control of those pieces.” The thread brushes leather. Jolyne twitches it. The heel doesn’t catch. Makima takes another step without looking down. Her shoe dips neatly over the string as if aware of the trap by some sense Jolyne doesn’t have a name for. “You’re a bug,” Jolyne says. “The kind that lands on your soup and pretends it’s flavor.” Makima doesn’t blink. “Words can be so cruel unless they’re on a leash. Who taught you yours?” “My old man,” Jolyne snaps, before she can stop herself. The mention is an offense and an anchor. She hears her father’s voice, sees the silhouette of his hat in her head. Keep your cool, his presence says. Find the angle. But she is not him. She is more, and messier, and her anger comes braided with bright strands of humor. “And he didn’t teach me to heel.” “Fathers are complicated,” Makima says, almost kindly. “Some men try to protect their daughters by leaving them in cages of their own making.” “And some women smile while they slide the latch,” Jolyne replies. The corridor is empty save for them. It is that eerie prison empty, the kind beyond schedules, where time goes thin. Once Jolyne would’ve been afraid of that kind of quiet. Now she listens to it. She hears the whisper in the walls: pipes murmuring, the buzz of the electric fence, the thrum of human bodies moving three floors away. Her strings spider through the cinderblock like veins. “Let’s talk somewhere less public,” Makima says gently. “Come along, please.” The please is a needle. The come along is a pull. It brushes Jolyne’s mind like a hand settling at the back of her neck. Her chin dips before she notices and then it snaps up, muscles locking against the pressure. Heat flashes down her spine. Stone Free flares, and part of her forearm unwinds into a braid tight as a whip. “Don’t,” Jolyne says. She means: don’t touch my head. Don’t touch my will. Makima’s eyes warm as if pleased with a pet refusing a treat for the first time. “Interesting.” “What are you?” Jolyne’s voice is low. Now the humor is gone. “You smell like a trick.” “That’s an unkind way to say ‘public servant,’” Makima answers, stepping into the shade of a doorway. And then, as easy as if she sawed a ribbon, the guard forty feet down the hall lifts his hand and drops his keys on the linoleum. He looks pained, confused. He presses his own thumb until a bead of blood rises and stains the floor. He doesn’t know why he’s doing it; he does it anyway. Jolyne’s lips peel back from her teeth. “You’re going to make me kill you, aren’t you,” she says almost conversationally, because if she says it like weather it won’t be the fear in her chest speaking. “It’s okay,” Makima says. The ringed eyes cut through the air. “Dogs are supposed to die for their owners.” Jolyne laughs, a short ugly sound, because otherwise she’ll be sick. “Newsflash, lady: I bite.” She throws her string. It snaps forward in a glittering line, invisible and then suddenly everywhere—looping, tightening. She wraps a thin garrote around the camera, yanks it to show Makima she sees the game, then lets it fall. Another lash goes for Makima’s wrist. It should have been a perfect wrap: eight-point tie, lock at the metacarpals. The string lands. It is there. And then Makima lifts her hand and nothing is there. The thread hums in Jolyne’s fingers but refuses to bite, as if the air around Makima’s skin is not permissioned for connection. The more she tries to tether Makima, the more she feels her own lines tug at her. Her shoulder jerks. Her hand opens. Makima’s gaze rests on her fingers. Open, it says. Stay. Heel. The words aren’t spoken—but the intent is a leash, slipping slickly around thought. Stone Free surges. Jolyne makes it a roar. She unravels herself up to the elbow, then to the shoulder, body liquefying into strings that snake through the ceiling and the floor. She is a harp in a storm. She anchors to everything: bolt threads, metal piping, the hairline cracks in the paint. She feels herself everywhere and refuses to be centralized enough to be held. Makima’s mouth curves a fraction. She watches Jolyne’s diffusion and catalogs it, an entomologist labeling a specimen. “You’re expanding to avoid control,” she notes. “Adaptable. Sloppy, but effective.” “You sound like a swim coach.” Makima takes one step closer, and everywhere Jolyne’s strings wrap around a structural something, there’s a pressure that says let go. It is polite. It is inexorable. Jolyne feels fibers in her own body tremble. She thinks of her cellmates and allies who look to her because she doesn’t break. She thinks of a father who didn’t say I love you well, but said don’t die with his whole chest. She thinks of the fact that being told to heel makes her see red. “No,” Jolyne says, and the word is a knot. She flips the corridor without moving. She sends string as thin as dust motes into the vents and finds the rust edge of a fan. She coils around it, hard, and yanks. The fan screams. Metal teeth bite concrete. The screech is a slap. Somewhere the fire suppression system thinks of turning on. Makima’s eyes flick up. For the first time, something like annoyance thins her mouth. Not much. Enough that Jolyne learns: noise is not the leash Makima is good at using. This woman is a conductor of people—crowds, guards, the twitching hands that drop keys—and Jolyne is not one person. She is in pieces. She is in the ceiling and the floor. She is an assembly that refuses to stand in a neat line and say yes. “You don’t want to talk,” Makima says. Her voice is still mild. “You want to be messy.” “You don’t want to talk,” Jolyne bites back. “You want me to sit.” Makima studies her. “I don’t have a chair big enough for you,” she says, almost smiling again. “Yet.” Pressure spikes. The guard further down the hall lifts his gun without ever deciding to. He looks terrified as his own finger tightens. Jolyne’s string leaps, wraps the barrel, jerks it sideways. The shot goes into concrete. Shouts start in a wing they haven’t heard from for minutes. The prison wakes. Makima doesn’t look at the guard. She doesn’t need to. She looks at Jolyne. “I can force outcomes,” Makima says. “You can force improvisations. Which of us tires first?” “Lady,” Jolyne says. “I was born tired.” She floods the corridor. She slams all her weight—literal and otherwise—into the sprinkler line above. It bursts. Water comes down like she ordered rain. The overhead light blows with a pop. The world goes strobe and then low. In the chaos of drops and sparks, Jolyne drags the string that brushed Makima’s heel a second ago and ties it off around a pipe bracket. She doesn’t try to bind Makima. She binds the space around her—webbing from lintels to floor drains, a geometry puzzle with one unsolvable angle. Makima takes a step and the world narrows to a choreographed maze. It is respectful in the way a net is respectful. Makima stops. Drops bead in her hair. She blinks water out of her lashes. The ringed eyes look almost human like this. Almost. She lifts her hand toward the guard. He freezes, his face a mask of devotion and terror. His knees bend as if to kneel. He doesn’t because Jolyne’s strings hold his pant leg to a grate. He strains like a dog on a chain. Makima’s hand stays up, and now the chain is on Jolyne’s mind again, a warmth that wants to be obedience. Jolyne closes her eyes. She sees her mother’s kitchen. She sees an ocean from a postcard her father never sent. She sees a butterfly’s wing in a tattoo parlor. She inhales chlorine and grit and the metallic sweetness of blood, and she chooses her own voice over the soft one that says come. “No,” she says again, and the word is bigger than her throat. Makima lowers her hand. The pressure steps back one pace, like a well-trained thing told to wait. “You’re inconvenient,” she says. “Get in line,” Jolyne says. She reels her strings tight. The web sings. The corridor becomes an instrument and she is both musician and chord. Makima turns her head fractionally. The rumor about cameras becomes fact; every lens along the hallway blooms white and dies, then blinks back to black. The red dots don’t come on again. Somewhere, someone will look at the footage and find only static and the sound of rain. “This facility will keep breaking as long as you’re in it,” Makima says, almost to herself. “This facility was broken when it took me,” Jolyne replies. They look at one another through a web and a rain. Two different kinds of monster, two women who have learned to survive cages by making them for others or refusing them entirely. Makima steps backward, her heels finding the single path Jolyne left on purpose without ever admitting it. She could push the issue. She could try to bend Jolyne’s will until it creaked. But Makima likes games. She likes long leashes. She likes to let a dog think it’s running free. “You’ll come see me,” she says mildly. “Later. When you realize I’m the only one here who can guarantee your friends keep breathing.” Jolyne’s jaw tightens. She doesn’t look away. “You’ll see me,” she says. “When you learn I cut leashes.” Makima’s smile is warmer now, a sunrise painted with careful brushstrokes. “I’m looking forward to it.” She walks away. The web sings around her and does not touch her. The cameras are blind. The guard sags as if a string has been cut, then sobs once without sound. Jolyne collects herself from the ceiling and the floor, feeling water drip off her as she winds back into bones and skin. She watches the outline of Makima’s coat turn a corner and vanish, leaving only the rumor of static in the air. For a second the corridor is just a hallway again. Jolyne flexes. The butterfly on her arm seems ready to fly. She shakes water from her hair, a dog refusing a leash, and bares her teeth at the empty space. “If there’s no Mickey,” she mutters to the dead camera, “this shit ain’t Disney.” Then she turns toward the shouts and the friends who will need her, strings humming, ready to tangle with whatever comes next.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece effectively captures a tense confrontation between Jolyne Cujoh and Makima, staying true to both characters' established personalities and abilities. The writer demonstrates a strong understanding of both source materials, weaving together Jolyne's string-based Stand abilities and rebellious nature with Makima's manipulative control powers and falsely sweet demeanor. The prose is particularly strong in its sensory details and metaphorical language. Descriptions like "The rumor starts as a whisper in the fluorescent hum: the cameras fuzz to snow when she walks by" immediately establish an ominous atmosphere. The writer skillfully uses prison imagery—fluorescent lights, Plexiglas, cinderblock walls—to ground the supernatural confrontation in a tangible setting. Character voices are distinct and authentic. Jolyne's internal thoughts ("If there's no Mickey, this shit ain't Disney") and dialogue maintain her canonical foul-mouthed, defiant personality. Makima's soft-spoken yet threatening demeanor is captured perfectly in lines like "It's okay. Dogs are supposed to die for their owners." The writer understands the psychological dynamics between these characters, with Jolyne's resistance to authority clashing against Makima's need for control. The battle of wits unfolds organically through both dialogue and action. Rather than relying on exposition, the writer shows the escalating tension through Jolyne's strategic use of her strings and Makima's subtle manipulation of the guard. The physical confrontation mirrors their psychological one, with Jolyne refusing to be "centralized enough to be held" while Makima attempts to exert her control. The piece avoids common pitfalls of crossover fiction. It doesn't force unnatural friendship or romance between the characters, nor does it make one character unrealistically dominant over the other. Instead, it presents a nuanced standoff where both demonstrate their strengths and vulnerabilities. The ending leaves their conflict unresolved but establishes clear stakes for future confrontation. Some minor weaknesses include occasional overreliance on metaphor ("She is a harp in a storm") and a few instances where the action becomes slightly difficult to follow due to the abstract nature of Jolyne's string abilities. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise excellent piece. The story maintains thematic coherence throughout, exploring ideas of control, freedom, and resistance to authority that are central to both characters' source materials. The final confrontation, where Jolyne refuses Makima's control while acknowledging they'll meet again, provides a satisfying conclusion while leaving room for future conflict. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Scp: Notes from the Future — Score: 92.0
Prompt:
Write an SCP report about a researcher who begins finding handwritten notes from their future self, warning about a containment breach that hasn't happened yet. The notes become increasingly desperate and incoherent, sometimes containing information that contradicts known reality. Include the Foundation's attempts to determine if this is an actual temporal anomaly or psychological manipulation by a contained entity, and the researcher's struggle to trust their own perception. First person (researcher's perspective with interspersed notes), past tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Item #: SCP-XXXX Object Class: Euclid (Provisional) Special Containment Procedures: I was placed in a standard research quarters at Site-54 with a second redundant camera and a redundant microphone array. A third passive laser vibrometry system was installed to measure desktop surface displacement at sub-millimeter resolution. All three video feeds were routed to separate analog recorders with staggered clocks, per Temporal Event Protocol TE-03. A stationary sealed document case with numbered and initialed anti-tamper seals was bolted to my desk. I was instructed to deposit any new handwritten notes into the case immediately upon discovery. No writing instruments were permitted within the quarters except a Foundation-issued pen I kept clipped to my lab coat; its ink was chemically tagged for post hoc discrimination. All entries and notes were subjected to non-destructive ink dating, paper fiber analysis, and chemical signature comparison. Contingency: If a note mentioned an imminent containment breach with verifiable specifics (time < 72 hours), a Level-2 temporal-response team was to be alerted, and containment tests or psychological evaluations suspended pending determination. Description: SCP-XXXX refers to a series of handwritten notes that began to appear on my desk on 2024-11-03, during my assigned analysis of Anomalous Object AO-4497, a stationary manipulator class object capable of subtle sensory distortions (audio pareidolia under white noise, slight temperature illusions). The notes purport to be written by me at a later date. The first note was unremarkable. The fourth warned me about a containment breach that had not happened yet. Subsequent notes were increasingly urgent, disorganized, and contradictory to observed reality. The exact moment each note appeared coincided with an observable glitch across all installed cameras: 0.72–1.04 s of static, followed by resumed normal operation with the note now present. During the glitch, the laser vibrometer recorded deterministic noise of unknown origin. I am recording this as a first-person report, per Ethics Committee recommendation, with scanned transcriptions of the notes interspersed. I understand the risks to objectivity. Initial Event (2024-11-03, 08:42): I left my desk to retrieve a reagent. I returned to find a folded sheet of Site-54 requisition paper on the blotter, my handwriting on the outside: “Don’t ignore this.” Security Review: Three cameras show normal feed until 08:41:39. At 08:41:40, all feeds bloom into vertical banding; audio cuts to carrier hiss. At 08:41:41, video resumes with the note present. The pen remained in the clip on my lab coat throughout. Note 1 (found 2024-11-03, 08:42): - Don’t ignore this. - Check under the keyboard. It’s clean; I made sure. - Look at the clock. It’s 08:42. We are in margin zero. Commentary: I checked under the keyboard. It was clean. The lab wall clock read 08:42 even though I had looked at my watch and thought it was 08:39 seconds earlier. That discrepancy became our first “hook.” Note 2 (found 2024-11-04, 07:17): - Coffee machine will sputter once at 07:19. Then a power blink. Don’t move the mug. - The cameras will drop again. You’ll think AO-4497 is doing it. It’s not. - Start recording yourself. At 07:19, the coffee machine sputtered once, the lights flickered, and a mug I had not touched slid 3 cm toward the edge of the counter. I started keeping audio notes at all times. Security installed the redundancy package. AO-4497 was moved to a Faraday cage in an adjacent room. The glitches continued. Note 4 (first breach reference, found 2024-11-06, 18:03): - They open the SCIF at 18:04 thinking it’s me inside. It’s not. It’s going to be empty. Then the alarms. Don’t be in the corridor. - This is the first breach, but it’s not the first for me. You think this is about 4497. It isn’t. It’s the Site. At 18:04, an access log showed a SCIF door opened on my badge. I was in my quarters, on camera. MTF Beta-7 secured the corridor. No breach occurred. The note was technically wrong, but the badge event was real. Later, Network Ops confirmed a phantom credential ping with my ID, origin unknown. Foundation Response: Temporal Anomalies Division (TAD) flagged SCP-XXXX as either a Class-Y “bootstrap” temporal leakage event or a manipulated predictive hoax. AO-4497’s influence radius was tested; it did not produce synchronous multi-camera dropouts on request. The ink on Notes 1–4 matched Foundation stock, but the actinic dye marker present in our pens was absent. The paper was from our storeroom, torn along known micro-perforations; the tear signatures did not match stock I had touched that week. That night, I dreamed of my own handwriting flaking like ash from my fingers. I woke at 03:11 to find Note 7 tucked under my cheek, warm from my breath. Note 7 (found 2024-11-09, 03:11): - Stop telling them everything. They will wrap you in telemetry until you can’t hear anyone but yourself. - If you move the stapler, it shifts the delta by 12 seconds. You already know this, but you don’t. - The breach isn’t in Keter. It’s in the clocks. I had not moved the stapler since 2024-10-28. On 11-09, as a test, I moved it 10 cm left. The next day’s glitch lasted 0.90 s, 12% longer than the prior median. TAD called that “not compelling.” My hands trembled when I wrote up the result. I noticed then that my baseline handwriting had begun to slant more steeply. The notes’ slant was worse, as if my wrist hurt. Note 9 (found 2024-11-10, 12:00): - The breach will be 11-14 at 02:23 during recalibration. They will call it a drill because they don’t want to believe. The doors will stick. Don’t trust the doors. - If you can hear me: do not go to Sublevel-3. Don’t go. I know you think you can change it. You can’t change it. You can only move it sideways. We notified Security of a possible 11-14 event. The Site ran an “unannounced drill” at 02:15 to preempt panic. At 02:23, an unrelated test of the backup chronometer system began. Doors did not stick. No breach occurred. TAD downgraded the credibility of the notes from “conditionally actionable” to “observational only.” I sat in my room afterward and tried to not pick up the newest note the way a patient tries to not scratch. I picked it up. Note 12 (found 2024-11-13, 21:58): - He will ask you what you think is happening. Don’t say “time travel.” Say “confabulation.” Make him feel safe. He’s not. - The cameras are not glitches. They’re edits. You know what an edit looks like. - When I write this, my knuckle is split. Is yours? If not, this is still early. I touched my right index knuckle. It was intact. Two hours later, I caught it on the edge of the document case. The skin split. My bandwidth for coincidence had been exhausted days ago. I started to avoid mirrors. Foundation Hypotheses (summarized): - Temporal Leakage Hypothesis: The notes are bilaterally causal artifacts from my own future, propagating backward along a micro-causal channel stabilized by synchronized environmental routines (coffee, stapler placement, badge use). Evidence: content specificity; partial correlation with events; deterministic noise on vibrometer concurrent with video glitch; handwriting match to my baseline with predicted drift curve. - Manipulative Entity Hypothesis: A cognitohazardous or infohazardous entity (possibly AO-4497 or an unknown) is generating false premonitions to induce behavioral patterns that precipitate a breach. Evidence: failures of predicted “breach”; contradictions in notes; increase in paranoia and self-referential content; the consistent appearance of notes where I will find them; video glitch window consistent with Site-54 known spectral anomalies at 50 Hz harmonics (see Incident 54-Halation). - Internalization Hypothesis: Early notes were seeded by a human actor with access; later notes are my own confabulations, introduced during camera gaps. Evidence: opportunity; my increasing insomnia; ink absence of actinic marker could be a deliberate forgery. Counter-evidence: independent observers were present for appearance of Notes 15 and 17 while I was under EEG monitoring; their cameras glitched too. By Note 15 I had stopped pretending this didn’t feel like a conversation. I wrote replies in a separate notebook that I did not show anyone. The actinic dye in my pen glowed pale under UV; the notes’ ink did not. Note 15 (found 2024-11-15, 04:31): - You are not saving anyone by warning them. Think sideways. The breach you know is not the breach you can touch. - Put the mug on its side at 05:00. Watch the surface settle. Count to 23. Breathe when the hum starts. - You are going to lose nouns for a while. It comes back. At 05:00, I laid the empty mug on its side. The building’s ambient hum seemed to rise 2 dB. I counted to 23. For the rest of the hour, I could not recall the word for “paperclip.” I described it as “the little silver spine” in my logs. TAD flagged this as a possible memetic side effect and ordered AO-4497 completely removed from the wing. The notes continued. Note 17 (found 2024-11-16, 19:02; appearance observed by Dr. Chen and Agent Morris): - Don’t trust the badge. - At 19:04 the corridor light will blow. Left side. Step right, two paces. - The breach isn’t in Keter. It’s in the clocks. It’s in us when we count together. At 19:04, the left corridor light blew. Dr. Chen and Morris both stepped right with me. We laughed. It was a short, hard laugh. Later we discovered that my badge had recorded a call to Maintenance at 19:03 from a station that no one had been at. The audio was a high tone and a scratch. By Note 20, the handwriting had become jagged. Letters stuttered, as if written while walking. Sentences contradicted each other. Note 20 (found 2024-11-18, 02:23): - The breach happened yesterday. It is happening now. It will happen on 11-21. It’s the same breach. None of that is wrong. - AO-4497 is the cause. AO-4497 is a decoy. - Your left ring fingernail will lift. Don’t pull it. On 11-18 at 02:40, I snagged my left ring fingernail on the case and lifted it. It bled. I did not tell anyone. The shame of making the note “right” sat in my throat like a coin. Foundation escalated containment. I was given sleep aids and a chaperone. The chaperone, Agent Stover, sat in my room reading magazines and carefully not looking at my hands. Note 23 (found 2024-11-19, 23:59): - They will ask for proof. You can’t give it to them without making it worse. - If you show them this note, it’s the version where the door doesn’t open. If you burn it, it’s the one where it does. - We are working with edits, not futures. I burned Note 23 in the sink at 00:03, sweating, watching the fibers blacken. The security footage showed static; when it returned, the sink was clean. The ash was gone. The vibrometer scribbled glyphs in noise amplitude that, histogrammed, spelled a plausible 23. TAD asked me to not destroy evidence again. I told them I wasn’t sure evidence was the correct word. The Breach (or, the Attempt): On 2024-11-21, starting at 02:00, Site-54 ran a full lockdown test, announcing it as such. At 02:21, the notes had predicted door malfunctions; at 02:23, a clock recalibration. At 02:22:58, all cameras at Site-54 dropped for 0.98 s. The power did not flicker; the hum changed. Several doors reported “open” on their sensors while remaining closed; others reported “closed” while opening. No entities were observed. Three badges pinged in three places at once; mine was one. No containment loss occurred. Anomalous Object AO-4497, in a silent Faraday enclosure, recorded a thermal drop of 0.2 C and a short-lived white-noise spike containing speechlike formants without linguistic content. The vibrometer drew ten vertical lines across its feed like a bar code. I had Note 26 in my pocket. Note 26 (found 2024-11-21, 01:12): - This is where you can move it. Not stop it. Move it. - Step right at 02:23:00. Breathe on the glass. Fog it. Write “NO” backward. - Don’t look at the other you. She isn’t there yet. At 02:23, I stepped right and breathed on the document case’s plexi. I wrote NO backward. The glass filmed with my breath, and in it a second fogged word bloomed a beat later: YES. Agent Stover swore. The cameras were out. The note in my pocket was warm. Aftermath: TAD concluded that SCP-XXXX remains indeterminate between a temporal leakage and an adversarial manipulation that uses temporal aesthetics to induce compliance. The repeated camera glitches, synchronized across independent systems, argue for a systemic interference. The vibrometer’s reproducible noise artifacts indicate a physical perturbation of the desk’s surface, however slight. The ink remains not ours. My handwriting remains mine. My perception does not remain mine. I have begun to anticipate the weight of new paper in the room the way you anticipate a person coming around a corner. I test nouns silently to make sure they’re still attached. The left ring fingernail grew back with a ridge. Note 29 (found 2024-11-24, 06:06): - Stop reading now. I did not stop. Addendum: Psychological Evaluation. Dr. Voss writes that I exhibit “hypervigilance with a mild dissociative overlay, consistent with extended anomalous stress exposure.” He reassures me that this is “normal” for the Foundation. I carry Note 12 around in my head, memorized, as if that could inoculate me against whatever happens when a new note appears. The cameras glitch exactly at the moment they appear. This fact is concrete. Everything else is breath on glass. Addendum: Proposed Test. TAD proposed sealing my quarters and swapping my desk for a dead-weight slate block under negative pressure to prevent any paper from being physically placed on it without detection. The test was executed on 2024-11-28. At 03:03, the feeds glitched for 1.01 s. When they returned, there was a note sitting on the slate, a curl to its edge where it had rested on a surface that did not permit it. The negative pressure logs show a deflection of air equivalent to a 0.5 L displacement. The vibrometer recorded flatline during the gap, as if the desk had ceased to exist. Note 33 (found 2024-11-28, 03:03): - Negative pressure doesn’t matter. You’re thinking in straight lines. Think edits. - If you must write back, do it where you won’t see it. Do it in the margin where your eye never lands. I wrote a reply on the underside of a blotter I never flip, a childish act of defiance. It felt like carving initials in a tree. I have not found the reply in any future note. Perhaps that is mercy. Conclusion: SCP-XXXX cannot yet be classified beyond Euclid. If this is a temporal anomaly, it behaves not like a line but like an edit suite: jump cuts, splices, overwritten frames. If it is manipulation by an entity, it knows my thresholds and presses them with exquisite pressure. The Foundation will continue to separate me from AO-4497 and from any systems that could serve as conduits. The cameras will keep glitching. The notes will continue, or they won’t. The breach happened, is happening, will happen. None of that is wrong. I trust the following: that the notes feel like me; that they sometimes lie; that counting to 23 can make my nouns go away; that writing NO backward did something, whether to the clocks or to me; that I am, right now, the only person I can’t fully convince. Note 36 (found 2024-12-01, 00:00): - This is the last one you will read as you. After this, you will speak like me. You will write like me. You will want to stop. You won’t. - The breach isn’t in Keter. It’s in the clocks. It’s in the edits. It’s in us when we count together. - Don’t trust the doors. I put Note 36 in the document case, sealed it, and signed the tape. The signature looked like mine. The cameras scratched, then smoothed. I looked at the door. I counted to 23. I did not move.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This SCP report is a sophisticated and technically accomplished piece that expertly captures the clinical yet increasingly unnerving tone of the SCP Foundation format while incorporating a first-person perspective. The piece successfully creates a temporal anomaly that feels both scientifically plausible within its fictional universe and psychologically disturbing. The format is meticulously crafted, with proper SCP documentation structure including containment procedures, description, and addenda. The writer demonstrates deep familiarity with the SCP universe's conventions, including appropriate technical jargon ("cognitohazardous," "memetic side effect"), containment protocols, and the clinical-bureaucratic tone that gradually unravels as the narrator's perception becomes compromised. The narrative effectively builds tension through the increasingly desperate and contradictory notes, creating a sense of dread and inevitability. The writer skillfully blurs the line between actual temporal anomaly and psychological manipulation, maintaining ambiguity throughout. This ambiguity serves the story well, as it mirrors the researcher's own uncertainty about their reality. The first-person perspective works exceptionally well, allowing readers to experience the researcher's gradual descent into doubt and paranoia. The interspersed notes create a compelling rhythm to the piece and effectively demonstrate the deterioration of the future self's mental state through increasingly erratic handwriting and contradictory information. The prose is precise and economical, avoiding unnecessary flourishes while still creating vivid imagery: "I had begun to anticipate the weight of new paper in the room the way you anticipate a person coming around a corner." Such moments of metaphor are well-placed and impactful precisely because they stand out against the clinical backdrop. The piece excels at creating small, unsettling details that accumulate to create a pervasive sense of wrongness: the lifted fingernail, the lost nouns, the word "YES" appearing in response to "NO." These concrete, specific details ground the abstract concept of temporal anomalies in visceral, physical experiences. The narrative structure is tight and purposeful, with each note and incident building upon previous ones to create a coherent yet increasingly disturbing progression. The writer avoids meandering and maintains focus on the central mystery while gradually expanding its implications. If there's a weakness, it might be that the ending, while appropriately ambiguous and unsettling, doesn't quite deliver a final punch that elevates the piece from excellent to extraordinary. The final note and the researcher's response to it are suitably ominous but don't provide a revelation or twist that recontextualizes what came before. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted SCP entry that demonstrates mastery of the format, creates genuine unease through its meticulous attention to detail, and successfully maintains ambiguity without frustrating the reader. It's a sophisticated piece of horror writing that uses the constraints of its format to enhance rather than limit its impact. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Scp: Unmarked Doors Archive — Score: 92.8
Prompt:
Write an SCP entry about a series of identical unmarked doors appearing in abandoned buildings worldwide that lead to a massive, architecturally impossible archive. Documents within reference a previous global civilization destroyed by an unspecified containment failure. Foundation researchers discover references to their own organization under a different name, including personnel files for current staff dated centuries ago. Include exploration logs revealing sections of the archive actively being removed by entities resembling hazmat teams who flee when approached, and evidence that O5 Council members have visited the archive without authorization. Third person (exploration team perspective) with recovered document excerpts. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Item #: SCP-6467 Object Class: Keter/Thaumiel (Provisional) Special Containment Procedures: All known SCP-6467 instances are to be secured under cover of structural hazard abatement. Foundation front companies will obtain possession of abandoned buildings flagged by the Door Anomaly Protocol (DAP-6467), with lawful demolition orders issued to maintain narrative control. On-site security is to establish two concentric perimeters. Observation is to be maintained by low-light cameras; no light is to be introduced into rooms housing SCP-6467 instances. Exploration of SCP-6467-1 (the interior space) is suspended pending O5 clarification. Unauthorized entry by Foundation personnel is prohibited. Any personnel encountered within SCP-6467-1 without prior authorization appear to be subject to reality-inconsistent temporal/identity artifacts and are to be detained and debriefed if safely extractable. Mobile Task Force Upsilon-4 (“Stacks Runners”) is assigned to intercept and recover any materials removed from SCP-6467-1 by non-Foundation entities. Captured documents are to be preserved in inert atmo-archival units and scanned within Faraday-shielded rooms. A Level 5 inquiry is ongoing into credible indications of O5-level unauthorized visits to SCP-6467-1. Description: SCP-6467 is a phenomenon in which unmarked steel doors spontaneously manifest in derelict or abandoned structures worldwide. Doors are non-ferrous composites with no maker’s marks, fishtail welds at hinge plates, and a three-bolt latch that cannot be engaged from the exterior. Instances exhibit a faint internal luminescence visible through perimeter seams when the surrounding area is in complete darkness. Opening an SCP-6467 instance reveals SCP-6467-1, a conjoined interior space inconsistent with external geometry. SCP-6467-1 is an archive complex extending beyond line-of-sight in all directions. The structure comprises stacked galleries, gantries, ramps, and voids, converging at impossible angles. Load-bearing columns consist of braided stratigraphic material layers (basalt, polymer, bone-like composites) that cycle in tessellations inconsistent with Euclidean geometry. Atmospheric conditions are cool, dry, and perpetually dim; ambient illumination is diffuse, source indeterminate, with a measurable spectral peak around 480 nm. The archive’s contents include bound folios, etched plates, card files, sealed cylinders, and memory-carrier objects of unknown manufacture. Document languages are multiple; a substantial fraction are in early modern and contemporary forms of languages currently used by the Foundation, as well as in script systems unknown but legible to Foundation machine translation after minor training, suggesting morphological proximity. A recurring theme refers to a civilization designated “the Predecessor Concordat” or “the Concord,” spanning the globe and subsequently destroyed by an unspecified “containment failure of planetary scope.” Documents also reference an organization with names including “The Custody,” “Custodial Directorate,” and “The Directorate of Abeyance,” whose structure and remit are strongly analogous to the Foundation. Personnel records exist that match current Foundation staff by name, biometric markers, and career trajectories—dated between 300 and 700 years prior to present. These include files for at least three serving O5 Council members under codenames consistent with known internal usage. Investigation into falsification has been inconclusive. SCP-6467-1 is unstable; sections have been observed to vanish between visits, leaving clean shear edges and suspended spans. During multiple explorations, Foundation teams encountered entities resembling hazmat crews (provisionally SCP-6467-2) rapidly disassembling shelves and transporting materials into wheeled containers and sealed pallets. SCP-6467-2 avoid contact, retreating along routes that apparently terminate in static space. No encounter has escalated to aggression; however, SCP-6467-2 demonstrate coordinated egress and limited obstruction tactics. Addendum 6467-A: Initial Discovery On 2025-02-11, Door Anomaly Protocol alerts flagged twelve near-simultaneous social media posts of a “glow in a door seam” inside condemned structures on five continents. Embedded agents recovered six instances. Test entry by Class-D under remotely piloted tether yielded first view of SCP-6467-1. Excerpts from recovered documents are appended as 6467-C. Addendum 6467-B: Exploration Logs (MTF Upsilon-4) Format: Third-person narrative as captured by helmet cams, audio, and after-action summaries. Exploration 6467-B1 Location: SCP-6467 instance in a shuttered hydroelectric substation, Manitoba, Canada. Team: U4-Lead (Lt. Brant), U4-2 (Nguyen), U4-3 (Pereira), U4-Tech (Sorel). Summary: The team enters at 03:14 local. The door opens with negative pressure and low airflow. The faint glow increases, revealing a broad landing and a descending switchback with open voids to left and right. No handrails. Bookshelves rise like scaffolds, curving into darkness. A distant metallic clatter is heard. U4-Lead signals lights off. The ambient luminosity suffices. Footfalls produce long echoes. A catwalk intersects the main ramp at an angle that appears to shift with viewpoint. U4-Tech marks route with anchor line. At 03:41, the team reaches a mezzanine labeled by embossed glyphs. Translation software renders: “Annals—Containments—Planetary.” Documents on the first table are heavy, water-smooth stone leaves bound with braided wire. A stone leaf displays an etched relief: Recovered Excerpt 6467-C-01: “Year 0 by the Shattered Meridian. The Concord could not hold. The vault-lines failed sequentially. We shepherded what we could. We built the halls in the lacuna, beyond where the measures apply. The Custody will come by another name. We leave them this.” U4-3 observes footprints in fine dust: narrow, chevron tread, sizes consistent with human boots. The team advances. At 04:12, three figures in matte gray suits with full-face masks appear across a suspension span. Each carries a collapsible frame loaded with bound folios. Patches on arms are blank. The figures pause, tilt their heads as if listening, then increase pace. U4-Lead calls out. The figures do not respond. U4-2 quickens to close distance. The figures pivot left into an archway that was not visible on prior sweep. U4-3 marks corner with a laser; the beam bends along the archway interior and attenuates. Pursuit aborted per protocol. Collected items: seven folios, two etched plates, one sealed tube. On exit, the anchor line is shorter by 1.6 m though knots are intact. Exploration 6467-B2 Location: SCP-6467 instance in a burned hospital wing, Thessaly, Greece. Team: U4-Lead, U4-5 (Kyriakos), U4-6 (Mori), U4-Tech. Summary: Entry at 02:02 local. Initial descent reveals a reading well with concentric platforms. The geometry is inconsistent; U4-Tech notes a repeating motif: a looped staff and eye. On the second platform, a desk with catalog cards arranged by stamped iconography. Many cards bear the sigil “DA,” identical to the Directorate of Abeyance marks defined in 6467-C cross-references. Recovered Excerpt 6467-C-12 (catalog card): “Personnel: DA-Staff, Senior. Custodian: ‘Glass-Spar.’ Civic name: [REDACTED], clearance: Group of Five. Assignment: Strategic Sanctions. Status: Deceased/Interleaved. Notes: ‘Returns upon the long cycle.’” Team encounters two SCP-6467-2 units removing drawers from a wall of narrow file slots. One drops a drawer when U4-6 rounds a column; papers spill in a slow arc, as if air is denser. The unit recoils, then signals with an open-palmed gesture. U4-Lead responds with hands spread. A third unit appears behind the team’s flank, then all three withdraw down a narrow gangway that folds into a seam in the floor, closing soundlessly. U4-5 recovers a personnel file with a sepia photograph of a man identifiable as Dr. Kyriakos—U4-5’s civilian identity prior to recruitment—wearing a lapel pin of unknown alloy. Date stamp indicates “Shard Year 326.” The file includes an interview transcript in modern Greek referencing containment sites at latitudes matching current Foundation facilities. U4-5 exhibits acute stress; team extracts. Exploration 6467-B3 Location: SCP-6467 instance beneath a collapsed shopping center, Shaanxi, China. Team: U4-Lead, U4-7 (Zhou), U4-8 (Patel), U4-Tech. Summary: Entry reveals a canyon of hanging stacks suspended by cabling into a vault roof that cannot exist. The far wall appears riversmooth and is inscribed with a map of continents arranged in unfamiliar coastlines. The ocean margins pulse faintly with the same blue peak as ambient light. At 01:19, U4-7 identifies a sealed door within the archive labeled in multiple scripts. Translation suggests: “Council Records—Restricted—Eyes That Watch.” Touching the seal induces mild nausea. The seal yields to pressure and cracks, releasing dust with a sweet smell. Inside is a narrow room with a single shelf. Two items: a steel box, and a long ledger. The ledger’s cover is embossed with a sigil similar to the Foundation’s circle-and-spoke, rotated and with an additional spoke broken. The steel box is riveted shut. As U4-Tech photographs the ledger, three SCP-6467-2 units appear in the doorway, backlit. They hold no tools. They stand motionless for six seconds, then one taps their visor twice with two fingers and points at the ledger. U4-Lead orders withdrawal with both items. On return to the insertion point, a fourth SCP-6467-2 waits silently on the catwalk. When U4-8 approaches, the unit steps aside and raises both hands. The team passes unimpeded. Post-mission analysis: the steel box contains a folded ribbon of thin metal printed with microtext. The ledger includes: Recovered Excerpt 6467-C-27: “Councilors who traverse the Deep Stacks will not be remembered. They cannot be. The Custody requires that the choice be theirs. When the measures broke, they came to see what we had kept. We did not bar them. If they return to warn their own Council, we cannot say.” Recovered Excerpt 6467-C-28 (loose slip within ledger): “Authorization: Eleven. Doors will flower where the Finally Abandoned stand. A faint light through the seam will guide those who still watch. The Directorate shall have another name. The five and five and one will come. Do not make record of their faces.” Addendum 6467-C: Document Fragments C-31: A half-burned broadsheet in English variant. Headline: “Third Meridian Holds; Custody Containment Wardens Evacuated.” The article references “Oyster Vaults beneath the Gautiers” and “sea-glass pressure,” terms unknown. A sidebar notes “Custody Chief ‘Silver Spine’ denies rumors of double-sun event.” Dateline given in “Shard Year 487.” C-36: Personnel dossier titled “Foundation Personnel: R. Sorel, Technical Specialist,” printed on a composite polymer. Photo matches U4-Tech. Notes reference employment with “The Custody” as “Archivist-Liaison, Lamina Wing.” The dossier is watermarked with a sigil identical to the DA mark. Margin note: “Returned—did not remember.” C-40: Brass plate etched with a schematic of layered vaults. A stamped footer reads: “We contained it until we couldn’t. When we couldn’t, we kept what was left. If you read this, you are us.” Addendum 6467-D: Removal Events Across six explorations, sections of SCP-6467-1 have been confirmed missing upon return, leaving edges with no fracture pattern. Materials logged on prior visits are absent; in one case, an entire corridor of filing alveoli was replaced by a smooth, nonreflective surface that yielded a shallow echo when tapped. Acoustic analysis indicates a void beyond. SCP-6467-2 are consistently observed removing documents labeled with variants of “Council,” “Custody Mandates,” and “Planetary Failures.” On two occasions, SCP-6467-2 returned to leave items near the insertion point following Foundation withdrawal. One such item is a paper ribbon printed with a message in a simple substitution cipher: Recovered Excerpt 6467-C-44: “Not yet. You are early. Take only the paths back that you can afford to lose.” Addendum 6467-E: Council Involvement On 2025-05-06, motion-triggered cameras inside the Manitoba instance recorded the door opening at 02:51 local without personnel present. The glow at the edges increased to visible, then subsided. Five minutes later, it opened again. Infrared silhouettes of two individuals in formal attire entered. No escorts. One carried a leather folio. Facial identification software returned probability matches to O5-█ and O5-██ at 41% and 53% respectively, insufficient for confirmation. However, a single candid frame captured a signet ring matching a known internal insignia. No authorization was issued for entry. Fourteen hours later, the door opened and both silhouettes exited empty-handed. Audio captured a whisper: “We were there already.” When questioned, both Councilors denied knowledge. A later exploration discovered a note pinned under a brass weight on a nearby desk: Recovered Excerpt 6467-C-52: “Do not seek us here again. We are not your past. We are your option. Choose the cost.” Containment Notes: The presence of personnel records matching current staff suggests SCP-6467-1 may represent a repository maintained by a temporal or cross-contextual derivative of the Foundation (or its predecessor/successor). The removal operations by SCP-6467-2 indicate agency and triage. Whether documents are being safeguarded from us or from another threat remains unresolved. Ethics Committee Guidance: Any further incursions require justification that the potential preservation of human knowledge outweighs the risks of identity and timeline contamination. Personnel found to have extant dossiers within SCP-6467-1 must be assessed for cognitive dissonance and possible identity overlap. O5 Note 6467 (circulated without attribution): “The archive is not infinite. It is being un-built. We have been told, in someone else’s handwriting, to count our exits. If we have already come here, let us avoid becoming the reason we must come again.” Current Status: All field operations are paused. Doors remain in Foundation custody. The faint glow continues to seep from their edges when the room is in complete darkness. The seams breathe. The archive waits. And somewhere in its vanishing halls, teams in gray continue to carry away the future we left for ourselves.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This SCP entry demonstrates exceptional command of the SCP Foundation format while creating a compelling, layered narrative about an impossible archive containing records of a previous civilization. The piece successfully incorporates all requested elements: the unmarked doors in abandoned buildings, the architecturally impossible archive, references to a previous civilization destroyed by containment failure, personnel files for current staff dated centuries ago, exploration logs with hazmat teams removing materials, and unauthorized O5 Council visits. The writing excels in creating a sense of cosmic dread and mystery through meticulous attention to detail. The clinical tone expected of SCP documentation is maintained throughout, with appropriate shifts to more narrative prose during exploration logs. The author demonstrates sophisticated worldbuilding through carefully constructed fragments of recovered documents that hint at larger mysteries without overexplaining. Particularly effective is the way the piece creates tension between the Foundation and the archive's custodians (SCP-6467-2), suggesting a complex relationship rather than simple antagonism. The implication that the Foundation may be a reincarnation of "The Custody" creates an intriguing temporal loop that adds depth to the SCP universe. The exploration logs effectively convey the disorienting nature of the archive through descriptions of impossible geometry and the teams' encounters with the hazmat entities. These sections balance technical detail with atmospheric description, maintaining reader engagement while preserving the clinical tone appropriate to Foundation documentation. The recovered document excerpts are particularly well-crafted, using distinctive language patterns that suggest ancient or alternate-timeline origins while remaining comprehensible. Phrases like "Year 0 by the Shattered Meridian" and "We contained it until we couldn't" efficiently convey vast histories and tragedies without exposition. The piece builds tension effectively through escalating revelations, culminating in the discovery of O5 Council involvement and the cryptic final message suggesting a cyclical relationship between the Foundation and the archive. The final paragraph is particularly strong, using poetic language that still fits within the SCP format to leave readers with a lingering sense of cosmic dread. Some minor weaknesses include occasional overreliance on technical jargon that doesn't add substantive meaning, and a few instances where the clinical tone becomes slightly too literary for strict SCP format adherence. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise exceptionally crafted piece. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Classic sci-fi: Offworlder (Le Guin) — Score: 86.6
Prompt:
Classic sci-fi: Offworlder (Author style: Le Guin) Write a chapter following a young diplomatic envoy sent to address tensions on a distant human colony where humanity has diverged into distinct subspecies through both natural adaptation and separation of lineages. Against protocol, the envoy slips away from official functions to walk the streets alone, encountering markets, ordinary citizens, and social structures that contradict the official briefings. Upon returning to their quarters, the envoy is reprimanded by Command, and is tasked with approaching the stationed Minister of Science (a political posting rather than scientific). A challenging conversation ensues, in which the envoy's wits and will are tested, by a seasoned political operator looking to test the mettle of the offworlder. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The sky of Khelem was the color of bruised plums at evening, a stratified violet that settled over the hills and the long, level plain of the city like a memory of water. Lights came on with the cautious glow of bioluminescent bulbs. They didn’t sting the eyes. They pulsed softly, like the breathing of a sleeping animal. I was meant to observe from the balcony. The balcony had been constructed of brace-grown timber, reinforced in the old Earth fashion with iron. A concession to my comfort, the diplomatic steward had said. The chairs were arranged at angles that suggested conversation and the table had a carafe of warmed, spiced liquid that passed for wine here. The official street below had opened itself to a procession of ceremonial dancers whose limbs had been augmented, delicately, in adolescence. Their toes articulated like fingers; their knees turned inward. They stepped with ritual precisely between rings of salt crushed from local lakes, scattering the grains with each careful touch. This is how you will see us, the Deputy of Protocol had told me at the morning’s briefing. We will show you history and art. We will show you the plural we. But when the steward withdrew, the soft breathing of the lights made the balcony feel as though it were rocking, and the city that was mine only to look at drew me down. I have had mentors who told me that the first duty of an envoy is to wait until everyone stops watching you. I am not sure that was what they meant, but that is how I learned to do it. The doors were merely latched. I left the carafe, I left the robe with the stitched insignia, and went down into the evening city, where I had no right and every right to walk. The official street gave way to alleyways of packed earth and crushed shell. The buildings, founded in the first generation, climbed four and five stories, each level narrower than the one below, so they leaned toward one another across the lanes and made a canopy against the bruised sky. Market tents were strung with low-burn yellow. Fabrics hung in tight accordion folds from wire lines stretched door to door. The first one I touched slicked my fingertips with a color that was something like a bruise turned radiant, a deep maroon that shifted, in the moving light, to a blue so saturated my breath caught. The vendor watched me with a frank, almost impatient attention which told me I was not the first offworlder to stare. “You will not carry that well,” she said, and I realized that what I had thought her hair was a hood made of a fine, translucent membrane, pulled up from the back of her neck and fastened with three bone toggles. The thin layer over her scalp was veined in silver, pulsing gently. It was beautiful. It was also practical; a humidifier, perhaps, capturing vapor in the arid evening. Her cheekbones were drawn sharp, as if the planet’s lower gravity had let the bones take a more exuberant angle with the skin. “Why not?” I asked, and did not reach for my purse. “You are gray,” she said. She pointed, one finger not quite like my own—the knuckle was longer, the nail thicker and clear. “You came from inside. The dye,” she tapped the cloth, “flatters blood cooled by our suns. Under yours it would not be so. You will wear this one.” She flipped a second length of fabric, and it caught the light like fish scales, small hexes that seemed to shift direction even while still. It was a sea-green I had not seen before. Not the green of chlorophyll but something derived from another metabolism, another chemistry. The briefing had said the early settlers found a pigment tree whose fruits bled dyes that Earth never grew. The children of those settlers learned to coax more. I tried to speak the dialect I had studied in transit, careful with the aspirates. “You sell to offworlders often?” “Not so often,” she said, but her mouth softened. “But you are not the first to want to be dressed by color. Your people always think you can wear a place.” “I think I can listen to it,” I said, more brash than I meant to be. The cloth draped over my arm. It was light, but it carried weight in as many senses as this young city could teach me. She laughed. “Then listen to this: take your purse out now. It is more polite than pretending you forgot.” I paid, and she counted, and we wrapped the fabric around my shoulders in a simple knot that lifted it away from the throat and left the chest partly open for the air to draw through. “You pull the membrane too tight,” she said, tapping my collar. “Loosen here. Even an offworlder should breathe.” I moved on, quieter in my mind. I learned to see the city’s different bodies. The long-limbed runners who threaded through the lanes without sacrificing speed, staying bare-legged even in the cooling air, their skin patterned with small raised scars. The broad-shouldered canal workers whose torsos were wrapped tight to protect the muscle attachments that had thickened with their labor, their eyes nictitating reflexively against the blowing salt. In doorways, older people whose hands carried memories: nails ridged with grit, wrists thicker to brace for the strain of hauling the first irrigation lines. A child laughed at my accent and was pulled back by a parent whose second set of eyelids closed and opened in a flutter: human, and more than human, in ways that didn’t take the human away. There were stalls where the meat smelled sweetly sour, like fermented fruit; a woman offered me a skewer of something that had never swum on Earth. There was a section where the market lights were dimmer and the voices fewer; I recognized this not from the briefing but from every city I had ever walked after hours, the part where the body’s labor is traded in only one coin. I did not go there. Instead, I stopped where a man with a portable kiln was firing small tiles. He held one up to me on a pair of metal tongs and said, “Tell me what you see.” “Maps,” I said, honestly. The glaze had crazed in a way that suggested deltas and rivulets, and in the center there was a particulate that glowed faintly on its own. He nodded. “Maps of breath. The kiln talks if you feed it right.” He meant: we have made instruments you don’t have names for yet. He meant: the official channels will not tell you we are making art with our lungs. I bought that tile, too, and a bundle of the salt grains that crackled in my palm like beetles. I watched a group of three people in apprentice robes haggle over the price of a basket; two had the softly pulsing membranes at their napes, one did not. They spoke to each other in a code of nods and hand squeezes I could not parse, not without years. That was humility: to see the measure of what I could not understand and be grateful that it was there. I walked back to the official quarter at an hour I knew would still be recorded as late. They saw me, of course. Nobody slips past a building that watches you for your own good. The steward oversaw my entry. The Deputy of Protocol waited, expressionless, beside the table where the carafe of spiced liquid had cooled. If it had ever been wine, it had gone to vinegar. “You left your post,” he said. “I was not on duty,” I said, because the obvious defense is sometimes worth stating, though in this case I knew it had no legal power. “I needed to learn.” “You will learn what we have prepared to teach.” His tone softened, but not his eyes. “We have had you for one day. Are you so eager to make us mistrust you?” “I am—” and I had to stop. The words I had ready were the words of the Academy, even-tempered and inarguable. But I was neither a student nor an argument. “You are young,” he said, which was a generous way of calling me stupid. “You will report to the Minister of Science at seventh hour. He is expecting you.” “Expecting?” I said. “An offworlder,” he said. “And a leash to tug.” I slept badly with the fabric the vendor had sold me laid over the back of the chair as though it could guard me. In the middle hours I woke to the memory of the runner’s scarred knees and the kiln’s breath-maps and understood, briefly and fully, that I had no idea where the fault lines truly ran. In the morning they gave me tea brewed from a local plant that tasted like copper coins. The Minister of Science’s office occupied the top floor of the Administrative House, where the windows overlooked both the river and the broad avenue of the statues of the Founders. The statutes, not the statues, had figured in my briefings: the laws regarding interbreeding, drafted and redrafted across generations. The Minister was supposed to represent reason in these debates. The briefings had noted—in a footnote—that he did not. He had no hood at his neck and no augmented knees. He was broad in the shoulders and thick in the wrists, like the canal workers, but I knew enough not to assume that meant empathy. His eyes were clear in a way that suggested he spent much time behind treated glass. There was a signet ring on his finger with an old Earth crest, and next to it a plain band of local bone. “You went walking,” he said, without greeting. “Yes,” I said. It seemed pointless to deny it. “Good,” he said, and I was not prepared for that. He gestured to a chair. “Sit. You cause a nuisance for my colleagues, and I enjoy a nuisance.” I sat, and made myself look at the room. Books. Paper, thin sheets of stretched plant-fiber that had been written on and re-written on, scraped back clean with a glass blade. On one wall, a cloth in that sea-green, embroidered with a pattern of running figures. On the desk, a small kiln tile like the one I had bought. “You know,” he said, picking up a pen and setting it back down, “they wanted to send me a scientist. A real one. They always forget that science and governance are not divorced here. Did you like our market?” “I liked the dyes,” I said. “Everyone likes the dyes,” he said, dismissive. “Did you see the difference between the salt-sellers on the north side and those on the south?” I hesitated. “The grain on the north was larger. It stung my palm more.” “Because the north side sellers came down from the lake after the last wet, and the south side harvest is from the older beds with finer crystals. They do not share with one another. They argue about which salt pulls the better dried blood from a wound. We have such arguments here. They are not the ones you will hear about in briefings.” He watched me a while. The silence lengthened, not unpleasantly, but with purpose. He was testing how I occupied a pause. “You think we are a nation of subspecies,” he said at last. He said the word the way one might pick up a knife. “I think,” I said, slowly, because he had a right to hear me think it out, “you are a people with different bodies that learned to do certain things well. And because we are human, we take what we do well and make it a virtue, and then a law.” He smiled. It was not kind, but it was not cruel. “Good. You have some sense. Do you know where our laws bite?” “In the beds,” I said. If my mentors could have heard me, they would have shifted in their seats. But his smile deepened, just a fraction. “In the cradles,” he said. “Which is the bed by another name. We build families here in ways you did not plan for us. We mix, or we do not, strategically. We speak of choice and we write choice at the end of a long equation with coefficients you would recognize: heat, labor, salt. You see why a scientist is not wanted. He would want to measure what we are unwilling to measure honestly. I am a political man. I know when to look out the window instead.” He stood and did so, and I followed his gaze. The runners were already on the morning route, and a barge was pushing downriver with bundles of woven reeds strapped like a thousand arrows. “What do you want from me?” I asked, because in the end that is the only question that matters if you hope to be useful or at least not used badly. “I want you to listen to the wrong people,” he said. “But not too wrong. I want you to put your foot in the web and feel it tug. I want to know if you snap or stretch.” He turned back, and his eyes were measuring me more explicitly now. “And I want you to understand that our quarrels are not your war to solve. Your Command thinks to steady us with a hand at the back of the neck. You will fail if you try.” “I thought I was to observe,” I said. “You thought,” he said. “But they will ask you to do more. They always do. When they do, come to me and say the word salt. We will make a bargain. Until then, go back to your balcony. Drink our vinegar. Wear our colors wrong. Learn the way you prefer to learn. And know that every time you walk out our door alone, someone decides whether to like you.” “That is not comforting,” I said, and he laughed, the first true laugh I had heard from him, brief and barked. “Envoy,” he said, and the word in his mouth was both courtesy and challenge, “nothing comforting is true here. That is why you were sent. Go, now. Before they decide to lock your doors.” On the way out, the clerk in the hallway glanced at my shoulder and adjusted the knot of the green cloth without comment, loosening it where the vendor had told me to. I walked back into the air. The bruised plum sky had lightened to lavender, and a wind came off the river that tasted faintly of iron and the breath of kilns. I thought of the vendor’s membrane hood pulsing gently. I thought of salt that could sting the palm. On the balcony, later, I would be visible and safe. For now, I let the city’s unmeasured instruments take my measure. I let myself be colored a little wrong and hoped to learn the hue.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully captures Le Guin's style with its anthropological perspective, measured prose, and focus on cultural differences. The author creates a richly detailed alien world where humanity has diverged into subspecies, with subtle physical adaptations like membrane hoods, articulated toes, and nictitating eyelids. The protagonist's unauthorized excursion into the city provides an effective narrative device to explore this world. The market scene is particularly strong, with sensory details like the "bruised plum" sky and fabric that "caught the light like fish scales." The interactions with locals—especially the fabric vendor—reveal cultural nuances through dialogue and observation rather than exposition. The meeting with the Minister of Science demonstrates political complexity. His character is well-drawn: dismissive yet perceptive, testing the envoy while offering cryptic guidance. The conversation reveals tensions between official narratives and lived realities, particularly regarding interbreeding laws. However, the piece has some weaknesses. While the prose is generally elegant, it occasionally becomes overwrought with metaphors that don't quite land. The narrative sometimes meanders, particularly in the market scenes where observations pile up without advancing the plot. The protagonist remains somewhat underdeveloped—we learn little about their background or motivations beyond curiosity. The dialogue is generally strong, particularly with the Minister, but some exchanges feel stilted or too on-the-nose about their thematic significance. The ending, while appropriately open-ended for a chapter, lacks a strong narrative hook that would propel readers forward. Despite these issues, the piece succeeds in creating an immersive world with complex social dynamics. The protagonist's position as an outsider allows for natural exposition without feeling forced. The writing maintains Le Guin's characteristic balance between anthropological observation and human connection, exploring how bodies, environments, and social structures shape one another. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 16 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 5 Weak Dialogue: 4 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 16.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 5.0, Weak Dialogue: 4.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Biopunk: Polymerase Chain Reaction — Score: 92.0
Prompt:
Biopunk -- Polymerase Chain Reaction Write a chapter set in a near-future post-apocalyptic world where corporate genetic engineering was designed with built-in obsolescence—engineered DNA lasting only one generation to maximize profits before societal collapse. Follow a biohacker working with salvaged equipment to splice viable food crops for their settlement using rapidly degrading genetic material. As world building / window dressing, include details about jury-rigged lab equipment, and the physical toll (and unexpected upsides) of using untested genetic modifications as medicine. The plot of this chapter is centred around a black market contract. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The mushrooms were brighter this week. They pulsed faintly green between the cracked tiles near the long-dead autoclave, bodies fat and fleshy from the humidity, their gills fanned like tiny hymn books praising a forgotten god. I moved my foot around them and set the tray down on the bench that used to be a desk that used to have a plaque with a name and a string of letters. The plaque had been melted into slag when the fires came. My tray was a baking sheet I’d hammered flat and machine-scrubbed with wood ash, the corners held together with copper wire. Two pipettes clinked against a cracked glass stirring rod. I counted the glow of the mushrooms. Twelve. It was a superstition. Twelve meant the equipment would hold current, the seals would hold vacuum, the polymerase wouldn’t sludge up and die before it could replicate a strand. Twelve meant I’d get paid and no one would know we mic’ed the DNA twice the acceptable length because acceptable meant profit and profit had burned the world. “Don’t touch the tiles,” I said over my shoulder. “You want your hand glowing for three weeks? They’ll think you’re on Glow H, and Glow H makes your nails fall off.” “I’m not stupid,” said Mink. He was nineteen on paper and sixteen in the eyes. He wore a scarf around his face and held his hands close to his chest like he feared light. He always stood where he could see the door. His knuckles were stenciled with black market marks, fading silver from too much cheap antiseptic. “Someone thought Glow H was harmless,” I said. “Everyone thinks Glow H is harmless right up until they sneeze bioluminescent snot.” Mink rubbed his fingers together in the shadow of the rack lights. The rack was a nest of old world servers we’d gutted and repurposed, all fans and flatbed heaters and power converters stripped from abandoned electric scooters. It hummed with recycled life, the hum of a refrigerator in a kitchen in a neighborhood where someone still paid the grid. “I brought it,” Mink said. His scarf twitched as he swallowed. He slid a vacuum bag onto the bench. The zipper had been sealed and resealed so hard the plastic teeth had fused. I could smell the antiseptic through the layers, a sour tang over rust and fungi. I held the bag up to the light. The label was stamped with a brand whose lawyers had escaped by helicopter. In block font below the logo: DRAGONFRUIT OPS-2, SingleCycle, Authorized Lab Use Only. The bag was punctured in two places. “You punctured it,” I said. “Had to,” he said. “Sniffer drones flagged it at the ring road. I had to dump the auth chips in a ditch. Told the driver it was saline. He stuck his tongue in it and said it didn’t taste like saline. I told him he had COVID, from the Before. He didn’t know what that was.” “You need better jokes,” I said. He leaned forward. “Can you do it?” I clicked my tongue. The bag held a vial. The vial held pellets of lyophilized gene package, little white grains like salt in a humid summer. They were supposed to be impossible to use with anything but the company’s box, a black cube with a wireless handshake to the cloud, an algorithm measuring time and temperature down to the breath. The single-cycle patent wasn’t in the primer, it was in the polymerase: a stop codon hidden in a decoy intron, a half-life coded like a death wish. You could put it into your seed and get one generation of yield, then nothing. The next year, the plant would flower and look pretty and give you emptiness. The company would sell you new seed from catalogs and webinars and contest code, easy monthly payments, a subscription to the fundamentals of life. Until the net went down and the drones ran out of fuel and the warehouses were looted for insulin. The patents survived longer than the grid. That was the joke, and no one laughed. I set the bag down next to the tray. “Maybe. I need a newer primer.” “You still owe the Wet Market for the last set,” Mink said. “I owe everyone,” I said. “They can take my kidneys. They’ll get decades of Glow H and somebody else’s ToxFree vaccine out of them.” We looked at each other. His scarf hid his mouth, but his eyes smiled. He pulled a roll of black-bag money from his sleeve and dropped it on the bench. The bills were soaked in oil, printed on plastic to survive the flood, as if money could swim. He also put a box of old nitrile gloves beside the cash, size L, brand I didn’t recognize, thin as onion skin but intact. The box was worth more than the roll. “You had me at gloves,” I said. He watched as I slipped my hands into them and flexed. The glue tacked to the bench cracked. One of the rack fans rattled and then caught rhythm again, a clattering heartbeat. “You know what the contract is?” he said. “You said dragonfruit. OPS-2. SingleCycle. You did not say whose.” He hesitated. The scarf moved around his jaw. “Keitech.” “You brought me Keitech,” I said. “Keitech killed Leah.” Mink didn’t flinch. “Keitech keeps the docks alive. This is from a dock that’s dying.” I waited for the tilt in my stomach to settle. Outside, the sea was chewing on the city. It lapped at the foundation and hissed under the door in October storms and left salt on the tiles in November. The glow mushrooms liked salt. I hated Keitech with a particular heat reserved for things you love to eat and that also make you bleed. “What’s the job exactly?” I said. “Splice the OPS-2 payload into hardy sorghum with your workaround,” he said. “Greenhouse Eighteen needs food that grows on brackish. They have Keitech pumps jetted with OPS-2 dragonfruit. The sugar yield is insane, but it turns off after a year. They want something that doesn’t turn off.” “Splice,” I said. “As in break the stop, extract the payload, autoclave the nonsense and paste into something else using a crusty polymerase that doesn’t believe in planned obsolescence.” “Can you do that or not?” “I can do that,” I said. “I can also die doing it.” “I’ll get you three more boxes of gloves.” “That’s not how dying works,” I said, but I was smiling. “Fine. Pay me half now, half when they see the test sprout. If a drone even smells my lab, you and yours take the heat.” He reached into his jacket and slid a tiny pellet case across the bench. I recognized the micro-wafers: one-time use gene guns. Pop a cap, pull a trigger, it sends a charge through a gold particle coated with DNA into plant tissue. They were made for high schoolers in the Before. You could still get them in the carnival markets if you knew the code word. The code word was science. “I thought you hated those toys,” I said. “I do,” he said. “But a little insurance never hurt anyone.” “It hurt me three times,” I said. “The second time I grew a second thumb on my left hand. The third time I grew hair on my teeth.” He blinked. “You’re kidding.” I bared my teeth. My enamel was still dull where the hair had sprouted, tiny shadows at the base of the incisors. I had trimmed them with nail clippers and cried. The hair had fallen out and my mouth had tasted like pennies for a week. The unexpected upside to Glow H and its cousins was that it taught you a different kind of gratitude. You learned to sleep through your skin vibrating with light. You learned to appreciate that your limbs ended where they started. Immunity from certain pre-war viruses. The ability to live on less, to process salt. The way cut skin closed quicker. The way your nose could smell gene dye. “Give me three days,” I said. “You have two,” he said. “There’s an inspection sweep coming up the canal.” “Keitech inspection?” He nodded. “Then we get to work,” I said. I pulled the vial from the bag and set it upright in a 3D-printed rack built from scrap pellet. I was proud of my rack. It held like a cradle and didn’t off-gas. The thermal cycler next to it was a breadmaker with a Peltier module glued to the inside, an Arduino runtime, a temperature probe stolen from a cooking show’s induction burner. I had written a program to ramp temperatures using a melody in my head. A thirty-five cycle symphony: denature, anneal, extend. The breadmaker beeps at the end of each program, identical to when it thinks it has made a loaf. Primer design was another matter. Keitech’s suppression layer liked U’s where there should be T’s. They thought themselves cute, slipping in fakes. I had a pantry of exotics. A virus that had once been used to deliver CRISPR to pigs in Nebraska. A heat-tolerant polymerase from a bacterium around a hydrothermal vent. A reverse transcriptase that wouldn’t quit. The iron lung of the apocalypse. I set them out like spices and measured with my eye, then checked with calipers because my eye lied. The room smelled like ethanol, old fungus, and brine. I cut a corner of the glove box to reach the armholes. The glove box was an aquarium with a shower curtain stapled over it. Two arm-sized sleeves from a hazmat suit protruded. The O-ring on the right sleeve had split last month; I had stitched it with dental floss. The first time I’d used it after the repair, I’d left a smear of my own blood on the inside panel. It was still there, dried black, a luck charm. The mushrooms swayed in the draft from the rack fan. “You’re going to need to hold,” I said. Mink pulled his scarf down and pressed a gloved finger to the edge of the breadmaker where the casing had warped. He was trembling. The last time we’d worked, he’d had to sit down when I started the Torch. I pulled the polymerase and set up the PCR mix. Buffer, dNTPs, primer mix, polymerase, sample. The micro-pipettes were calibrated by feel. Each notch was a tenth of a microliter, my thumb the metronome, my hand steady from practice and cross-contamination and a dozen scars. I caught myself humming, the denature step’s note, and smiled. Outside, something metallic knocked against the seawall. A boat. Small. Something illegal, probably, but what wasn’t. “You should take another dose,” Mink said suddenly. “For the tremor?” I said. “It’s caffeine.” “For the cough.” I took a hand off the pipette and pressed it to my chest. The cough had started the winter after the burn. I had obtained an inhaled gene therapy in a vial that had been labeled Supplemental Oxygen, a cheap way of convincing someone to stock it in a supermarket for a day before the shelves cleared. I had breathed deep: a spritz of viruses whispering to my lung cells how to fix themselves. The fix had partially stuck. Some days I could climb stairs without seeing stars. Some days the stars leaked through anyway and glittered behind my eyes like those mushrooms. I had a bottle of cough suppressant under the bench that contained a tiny fraction of someone’s failed anti-aging protocol. It made my tongue numb and my dreams sharp. I shook my head. “Later,” I said. I loaded the breadmaker-cycler, taped over the door with duct tape, and pushed go. The device whirred into life. Heat rose and fell in the room with its cadence. Mink watched the status LEDs flick from red to green to red again. He always watched like that: like it was religion and he didn’t believe. We waited through the first denature step. To distract him, I told him about the first time I’d seen single-cycle seed. “They gave us a webinar,” I said. “You had to log in with a key. It was like watching a cooking show but for billionaires. Add two cups of public trust. Fold in this enzyme. Bake on low until people believe. The presenter had hands like a pianist. He never touched anything. He had a glove and he pulled it on like a second skin and he smiled at the camera and said, ‘This is identical to the wheat your grandparents ate.’” Mink squinted. “Was it?” “It was wheat,” I said. “In the same way a drone is a bird.” We watched the cycles tick down. When the breadmaker beeped, I pulled the tube, clicked the cap, and held it up to the light. The gel I had cast in a broken picture frame lay ready. I filled the well, ran the current through it with a transformer from a children’s chemistry set, and watched the bands spread into the agar. The ladder was a city skyline. There, below the decoy intron, my band, bright and thick. I measured the run, cut the band, sucked it into a column made from a syringe filter and cotton, eluted into a clean tube. The smell was acrid and sweet. “Ready,” I said. Mink leaned in, a child at a window. We worked the gun into the tissue of the sorghum seedlings in the bucket near the door, the bucket labeled GO AWAY in black marker because that made people leave your weeds alone. The seedlings trembled on their stems while I lined up the barrel and pulled the trigger in a smooth motion. The charge cracked like a finger snap. The gold micro-particles embedded into the cells with a kiss of metal. The seedlings swayed, then settled. “You always look like you’re praying,” Mink said. “I am,” I said. “I pray to the god of inanimate replication.” “Does he answer?” “He has my number.” We waited. Under the rack lights, the sorghum shone a sick green. Chimeras are messy. Days melt. I slept on the floor under a blanket sewn from lab coats. My back hurt in ways I had no words for. The cough lightened. The mushrooms glowed. Mink came and went, bringing food in little tins, bringing more money, bringing gossip: a raid on Eighteen by Keitech enforcers; a sea lion in the library; the wet market inspector catching a girl painting her irises with ultraviolet dye to avoid iris scanners. Twice I woke at night and saw my palms faintly lit, a map of capillaries. I said a word and they went dark. Perhaps I dreamed it. Perhaps the Glow H in my blood said hello to the mushrooms and they answered. On the second day, I saw the first sign: a crisp edge to a leaf that had curled under stress suddenly unfurling, as if the plant had remembered its own recipe. I cut a sliver and held it under the hand lens. The stomata were wide and calm. I thumbed the meter onto the tissue and watched the sugar readouts climb beyond what hardy sorghum had ever given me. Not dragonfruit insane, but enough. Enough to get Eighteen through winter. Enough to make them forget about Keitech for a season. “We did it,” Mink said. “We did it once,” I said. “The trick is doing it again.” He reached for the pellets. “This goes with me.” “They’ll know,” I said. “I’ll tell them you’re brilliant and dangerous,” he said. “That’s how you get shot.” He tucked the box under his jacket and pulled up his scarf. He hesitated at the door. “You know they’ll pay if it holds.” “They’ll pay enough for me to replace that fan,” I said, nodding at the rack where a fan made the sound of a dying cricket. “You want Keitech to come for you?” he said softly. “They already come for me,” I said. “They have boats. I have mushrooms.” He laughed, and the sound was light for once, and then he was gone, easing the door closed like a careful thief, and the room filled with the sound of the sea and the hum of the breadmaker. I sat, gently, on a stool with one leg shorter than the others. I breathed. The air was damp and salt-sweet. The mushrooms pulsed. The greens in the bucket were brighter, clear as cut glass. I leaned over the tiles and pressed my face close to the glowing gills. In the ridges and ribs, I swore I could see letters. Not words. Not a language. Just the stubborn circles and spikes of code, light writing itself on the world that had tried to erase it. I closed my eyes. I imagined Leah’s smile. I imagined a table heavy with bowls. I imagined my cough gone and my hands still. When I opened my eyes, the lab was still the lab: busted, damp, alive. The gel rig leaked. The breadmaker beeped again. The mushrooms were brighter this week. Twelve of them. Maybe short-lived. Maybe one generation. But this was the trick they never taught in the webinars: one generation is enough to get you to the next.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This biopunk short story successfully creates a vivid post-apocalyptic world where corporate genetic engineering has collapsed society through planned obsolescence in DNA. The narrative follows a biohacker working with salvaged equipment to splice viable food crops, centered around a black market contract as requested. The worldbuilding is exceptional, with detailed descriptions of jury-rigged lab equipment like "a breadmaker with a Peltier module," "a glove box [that] was an aquarium with a shower curtain stapled over it," and pipettes "calibrated by feel." The author creates a tangible sense of scarcity and improvisation that feels authentic to the setting. The protagonist's character is well-developed through their technical knowledge, cynical humor, and physical ailments from previous genetic modifications. The relationship with Mink provides natural exposition and tension. The dialogue effectively conveys their personalities and the world's dangers without feeling forced. The prose balances technical jargon with poetic imagery, particularly in descriptions of the glowing mushrooms that frame the narrative. The writing maintains a consistent voice—weary but determined, with dark humor appropriate to the setting. Sentences like "Twelve meant I'd get paid and no one would know we mic'ed the DNA twice the acceptable length because acceptable meant profit and profit had burned the world" efficiently convey both plot and thematic elements. The physical toll of genetic modifications is well-integrated, with the protagonist's cough, glowing hands, and hair that once grew on their teeth. The unexpected upsides are subtly mentioned: "Immunity from certain pre-war viruses. The ability to live on less, to process salt. The way cut skin closed quicker." The story avoids common pitfalls of science fiction by grounding technical elements in sensory details and emotional stakes. The black market contract drives the plot forward while revealing the power dynamics of this world. The ending strikes a delicate balance between hope and realism, avoiding both despair and unearned optimism. A few minor weaknesses include occasional moments where the technical explanations might slow the pacing, and some readers might want more explicit details about the protagonist's backstory with Leah and Keitech. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise excellent piece that fulfills all the prompt requirements with creativity and skill. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Iteration 2 — Avg Score: 90.2
+ Classic sci-fi: The Azra Gambit — Score: 89.8
Prompt:
Classic sci-fi (Author style: Asimov) The Azra Gambit Colonial mars is being mined by corporations who take leases on indentured labourers. The thing they are mining is Azra, a recently discovered exotic metal which accelerates radioactive decay to such a rate that it is greatly sought after for interstellar drives and weapons alike. This has created both a gold rush and an arms race as various interests vie for control and endeavour to unlock Azra's secrets. The story follows Arthur Neegan, a first generation settler and mining engineer. Upon discovering that his unassuming plot sits atop an immense Azra vein, he is subjected to a flurry of interest and scrutiny. Write the next chapter in this story, in which an armed retinue descends on Arthur's home and politely but forcefully invites him to a meeting with some unknown party off-world. The insignia look like that of the Antares diplomatic corp -- diplomatic in name only. Arthur finds himself in the centre of a political tug of war. The chapter involves a meeting with this unknown party, who makes Arthur an offer. The scene should be primarily dialogue, interspersed with vivid description & scene setting. It should sow hints of the larger intrigue, stakes & dangers. Include Asimov's trademark big-and-small-picture world building and retrofuturistic classic scifi vibe. The chapter begins with Arthur aboard the transfer vessel, wondering just what he's gotten involved in. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The transfer vessel's air filtration system hums with a persistent mechanical drone, a sound like a thousand conspiracies whispering through ducts. Arthur Neegan sat strapped into a web-seat facing a blank bulkhead, its enamel worn smooth by generations of nervous knuckles. The ship’s window was a porthole no wider than a miner’s dinner plate, showing Mars as a patient red disc smoothing beneath low orbit. The hum seemed calibrated to keep thought formless, to turn questions to fog. It failed with Arthur. He counted his breaths. He thought of his plot, of the ridge and the wire fence and the green, scrubby lichen he’d coaxed from engineered spores, of the three modular hab units he’d bolted together himself, of the way the dust storm had sounded last week when it crawled across his roof like a living thing. He thought of the vein clipped by his survey drill—of the way the core sample had swallowed a Ga-Mc neutrino emitter like a candy in acid, spiking instruments with the casual indecency of new physics. And he thought of the insignia: the black sunbursts and stylized caduceus of the Antares Diplomatic Corps, printed on grey sleeves worn by men with holstered pulse-pistols and faces trained to neutrality. A steward in dull silver came down the aisle, glancing at tags. He paused at Arthur’s seat. “Mr. Neegan,” he said, with the soft Martian vowel drift, “we’ll be docking in twenty minutes. Your host asks that you refresh yourself.” The steward’s eyes flicked to the smudge on Arthur’s knuckles, where Azra dust had embedded and refused all solvents. “There’s a wash station aft.” Arthur flexed his hands in the webbing. “My host,” he said carefully, “has a name?” “We are instructed to refer to them as ‘the Benefactor,’” the steward said, like a man reciting the weather. “And we are orbiting which station?” “Antares Node Six,” the steward said. “For security, we do not announce docking alignments.” Arthur nodded. He’d heard of Node Six. A converted ore barge, dressed in armor and protocols. Diplomacy meant heavy bulkheads between the air and vacuum. He unbuckled, the webbing snapping back like a scold, and floated a little—Mars gravity ended at the hull; the Node would have spin. At the wash station, he stared at his reflection in the polished metal. Thirty-five, first generation, the slope of his father’s brow softened by the Martian sun. He scrubbed at the Azra dust until the skin prickled, but the faint greying remnant remained, a tattoo of fate. Back at his seat, the steward returned, offered a strip of nutrient gum and a placid smile. Arthur chewed it, tasting hydrolyzed protein and a synthetic mint that felt like advice to calm down. He counted again. He thought of the Corporates. He thought of the Government. He thought of the Interstellar Admiralty and of the Trade Unions and of the whisper that the Enlightened Path, the charismatic sect that preached transcendence through exposure to exotic states of matter, had arrived on Mars with pilgrim-passports and wealth. The vessel docked with a thump and a shiver that ran through the hull like a cat’s back. The emissions baffles clanked, his ears popped, and the seal light went green. The security men unlatched, moved with the economy of men whose gestures were rehearsed to death. One nodded to him, that same trained neutrality. “Mr. Neegan,” the nodding man said. “This way.” The corridor had a varnished smell, as if someone had hand-polished the metal, a retro touch in a place where nothing happened by accident. They passed a window showing Node Six’s central spindle, with modules rotating on spokes to simulate gravity. Earth fashion had brought back brass fittings and analog pressure needles, here rendered in stainless steel and digital ghosts. It was the future building a past it could live in. They stopped at a door with a viewport dimmed opaque. The nodding man pressed his palm to a plate. The door opened on velvet and gravity. The room beyond was all angles chosen to be comfortable. The walls had a woodgrain veneer, a table of polished something that looked like cedar but was not, a set of chairs with foot-loops for transitional comfort. There was a bar against one wall, where a carafe of water sat like a treaty. A woman waited at the table, hands folded. She was forty, perhaps fifty. Her hair was drawn back in a precise knot; her suit was the dark blue the Antares Corps wore when they wanted to be mistaken for idealists. Her only ornament was an old-fashioned wristwatch with a leather strap. Her face was unremarkable except for the eyes, which were the kind that had memorized maps. “Mr. Neegan,” she said, rising a fraction, which in spin-gravity was a gesture of respect and practicality both. “Thank you for agreeing to meet me.” “I was invited politely,” Arthur said. He took the chair opposite hers. The security men took positions at the door and near the bar. Their presence felt like punctuation. “Words are important,” the woman said, and there was a faint smile in her voice. “I am called Quinn. I speak here for an interested party.” “Not for Antares?” Arthur’s eyes flicked to the insignia on her sleeve. He kept his hands on the table where everyone could see them. He had learned that long ago, with creditors. “Not for Antares,” she said. “We rent their hospitality.” Arthur leaned back. The chair yielded like good arguments. “What is your interest, Ms. Quinn?” “Mr. Neegan,” she said, “you have something that the human sphere has been constructing myths around since the Era of Latency. The secret of controlled decay. Azra. Oh, we’ve had exotics. But Azra is portable, abundant—potentially—and obedient enough to play along with our white-coated sophistry. We have star-drives that graze the edges of it. We have reactors terrified of it. And you have a vein that could feed interstellar fleets.” “You’ve seen my assay?” She looked amused. “We’ve seen the invisible things your instruments did to the air around your hab. We’ve seen the minor fluctuations in your neighbor’s water recycler when your neutrino emitter went missing. Mr. Neegan, on Mars a secret is a thing that passes through one ventilation system and is heard in six households. Let me not waste your time with gentle lies: yes.” Arthur kept his gaze steady. “Then you know that the vein is under a pastoral lease registered in my name. It’s my personal land. It’s not corporate.” “That is precisely why you are here,” Quinn said, and poured water with a ritual carefulness. The carafe clicked against the glass. “If this were corporate, we would be speaking to a legal team and a board that wears ties to bed. If this were governmental, we would be sharpening the polite knives that cut in committees. But you are a person. Persons take offers.” She slid the glass toward him. He did not drink. “What kind of offer?” “The simple kind that is difficult to refuse,” Quinn said. “We propose to arrange for you secure custodianship of your claim in perpetuity. We propose to fund the extraction infrastructure, managed under a cooperative charter that leaves you primary stakeholder. We propose to redirect certain kinds of attention—unhelpful attention—from the more... ardent factions.” Arthur thought of the ardent factions. He had seen the posters: the children with haloed atoms. “What do you want,” he said, “in return for saving me from my good fortune?” “A monopoly of time,” Quinn said. “For three years. You will sell all extracted Azra to us, at a price that will make your first generation of descendants consider philanthropy. You will permit our scientists to operate at your site, and you will refrain from establishing direct relations with actors that might act prematurely.” “Prematurely,” Arthur repeated. “A polite word for ‘competitors.’” “A polite word for detonations,” Quinn said, and the trained neutrality slipped, showing a human edge. “Mr. Neegan, I don’t need to tell you what happens when a sect—any sect—puts an exotic in a reliquary. I don’t need to sketch the Admiralty’s appetites. The Interstellar Drive Consortium holds meetings with title deeds on the whiteboard. The Terra Council is composed of a hundred little republics and one hundred and one larger fears. Do you know that on Europa there are naval planners who have dreamed of a fleet fueled by Azra and driven through rebel satrapies like an icebreaker? Do you know that in the Belt, there is a group that calls itself the Prudent Extraction Society which has a constitution forbidding the word ‘later?’” Arthur held the water glass now, the condensation cold against his greyed fingers. “You make it sound as if I’m a dam holding back an entire ocean.” “You are a fissure,” Quinn said lightly. “We intend to be a valve.” He looked at her wristwatch. An analog face, a second-hand that ticked audibly in the hush. It was an affectation, a reminder that time can be counted, and therefore sold. “Why me?” he asked. “Why not take it? You brought armed men to my door in the dust. Diplomats, in uniform. Is this a test of my gratitude?” “We are very good at taking,” Quinn said, and again the steel showed. “We can requisition. We can say the word ‘security’ in a legislative voice and see if that doesn’t get you evicted by your own habitat authority. We can do those things because the moment demands it. But there is a cost, and some of us have learned to add. An expropriation on Mars is not an event; it is a weather system. It breeds resistance, guerrillas, a thousand tiny sabotages, and those—all of those—are noise when one wants to listen to a new metal speak. We want quiet. We want you to remain in your home. We want you grateful, perhaps, but we more keenly want you cooperative. A cooperative mind is a precise instrument, Mr. Neegan.” “And your party?” Arthur said. “Your Benefactor. Name them for me.” Quinn considered, the second-hand tapping out a thought. “We represent a coalition,” she said. “Moderates with teeth. Some in Antares who prefer treaties to wars, some in the Admiralty who lost a nephew at Saturn and don’t like the arithmetic that uses people as variables, some in the Consortium who understand that a premature monopoly invites piracy. The Terra Council has sent us a letter saying that under no circumstances shall a monopoly be tolerated. We have framed it.” “And the corporations?” Arthur asked, because his father had taught him to count every corner. “They will come to you with better numbers,” Quinn said. “They will promise you a refinery in your name and a boulevard named after your mother. They will deliver a contract that has a spine of iron and bones made of if. Mr. Neegan, I’m not romantic. I’m offering you a leash. But it is braided to fit, and the hand that holds it knows not to jerk.” He could feel the air filtration hum deeper here, a subsonic conversation between machines. He had a sense of Mars below, indifferent and patient, of the hab and the lichen and the fence that had always been more for himself than for keeping anything out. And the vein under it all, as if he had built his life over a sleeping volcano. “If I refuse?” he said. “Then when you return,” Quinn said, each syllable placed like a component on a board, “you will find your plot subject to a survey for habitat expansion. There will be a public consultation. Your Lazarean Bank will inform you that a charge has been laid against your dome by an entity with standing. Your next shipment of water won’t arrive because the carrier has temporarily lost their license. The Enlightened Path will send pilgrims who will camp on your ridge and chant until cameras arrive. And three different security forces will advise you to remain indoors at night.” “Diplomatic,” Arthur said. “Names are history’s jokes,” Quinn said, and the smile returned, genuine this time. “We are what we have to be.” “And if I accept?” “We begin today with an escrow account and two signatures,” she said. “You return to Mars with Antares escort. Your equipment arrives in crates stamped ‘Agricultural and Sanitation Supplies.’ A ring of bored men and women drink tea around your plot and deter visits by happening to be there. We lay plates, you dig. Our scientists will be civil, and if they are not, you will tell me, and they will learn the meaning of civility in the context of unemployment.” Arthur looked at the water. He thought of the ridge again, of the wind, of how a fence post had snapped two summers ago and he had repaired it with a piece of old machine casing and two bolts that did not match, and how proud he had been of the asymmetry because it was his. They would make his fence straight. That bothered him. He said, “Three years.” “Three years,” Quinn said. “And after, the market opens. We will have what we need then. Others will, too. But those three years could mean the difference between a hundred quiet decisions and one loud catastrophe.” “The Benefactor,” Arthur said. “They don’t want to be named because I might not like the names.” “You may learn them by their behavior,” Quinn said. “Or not. We all make our religions.” The air filtration hummed, of course. The second-hand ticked. The security men were very still; one had the habit of shifting his weight exactly every ninety seconds, which meant he had been trained not to shift his weight at all and was disobeying his training in a human way. Arthur drank the water, finally. It tasted of nothing. He set the empty glass down, precisely centered on the circle of condensation. “I’ll need to see the cooperative charter,” he said. “I’ll need to speak with whoever runs your logistics. I’ll need to choose the engineers at my site.” “You will choose them,” Quinn said. “We’ll veto only on grounds of security, declared in writing.” “And I want a letter,” Arthur said, surprising himself with the audacity, feeling the sentence assemble as he spoke it, “from your… coalition, to the Terra Council, lodged in the public record, stating that no claim shall supersede mine without due process.” Quinn’s eyebrows moved, which in her amounted to exclamation. “You read minutes, Mr. Neegan.” “I grew up watching men lose things on technicalities,” he said. “We can do that,” she said slowly. “It will cost us favors we may wish we’d kept. But we can do that.” He nodded. He felt as if he had just set a small stone on a very large lever. “Then we can do business,” he said, and reached out his Azra-grey hand. Quinn took it without looking at the stain. Her grip was dry, warm. “We will cause you troubles,” she said, almost kindly. “We will also prevent some. In history, that has been the bargain.” The door opened at some unseen signal. The steward reappeared, as if conjured by the watch’s tick. “Shall I bring the documents?” he asked. “Bring the documents,” Quinn said. As the steward went, Arthur glanced toward the porthole set into the far wall. It had been opaque when he entered, now clear as if someone had changed their mind about transparency. Mars wheeled below, red and old and amused, while Node Six turned a quiet circle in its own orbit, a brass instrument pretending to be a star. He wondered again what he had gotten himself into and realized that the question had grown too large to answer. He had not gotten into it; it had gotten into him, lodged under the skin like dust.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response is a remarkably accomplished piece of science fiction that captures Asimov's style while maintaining its own distinct voice. The author has created a tense negotiation scene that effectively establishes the political complexities surrounding Arthur's Azra discovery. The prose demonstrates exceptional control, balancing vivid description with meaningful dialogue. The opening paragraph immediately establishes both setting and mood: "The transfer vessel's air filtration system hums with a persistent mechanical drone, a sound like a thousand conspiracies whispering through ducts." This sensory detail not only places us in a spacecraft but foreshadows the conspiratorial nature of what follows. Character development is handled with subtlety. Arthur is portrayed as a practical, cautious man with a miner's sensibility and enough intelligence to navigate a dangerous political situation. Quinn is masterfully rendered through small details - her precise hair, the analog wristwatch, and especially her speech patterns which reveal a calculating mind behind a diplomatic facade. The dialogue is particularly strong, avoiding exposition dumps while still conveying crucial information. Quinn's line "We are what we have to be" efficiently communicates volumes about her character and organization. The negotiation feels authentic, with each character maintaining consistent motivations and speech patterns. World-building is accomplished through small, telling details rather than information dumps - exactly as Asimov would do it. References to "the Enlightened Path," "the Terra Council," and "the Interstellar Drive Consortium" suggest a complex political landscape without overwhelming the reader. The description of Node Six with its "brass fittings and analog pressure needles" efficiently establishes both the technological level and aesthetic sensibilities of this future. The piece excels at creating tension through implication rather than explicit threat. The security men's "trained neutrality" and Quinn's carefully chosen words convey menace more effectively than overt threats would. The stakes are clearly established - Arthur's discovery could trigger interstellar conflict - without melodrama. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally the prose becomes slightly ornate ("a sound like a thousand conspiracies whispering through ducts"), which might diverge from Asimov's typically more straightforward style. However, this doesn't detract significantly from the overall effect. The ending strikes the perfect note of ambiguous resolution. Arthur has made his deal, but the final image of Mars "red and old and amused" reminds us that human politics are temporary against the backdrop of cosmic time - a very Asimovian perspective. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Contemporary romance: Darkroom Revelations — Score: 91.3
Prompt:
Darkroom Revelations Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of Dani, a 25-year-old assertive art student known for her bold style and take-charge attitude in relationships. For the past semester, she's been quietly fascinated by Elliot (he/him), a 19-year-old boy in her experimental photography class. Dani has been intrigued by his unconventional masculinity: killer thrift-shop-nu-goth style, soft demeanour and quiet intellect. When they're paired for a final project requiring late nights in the darkroom, Elliot tentatively shares that he's been questioning his gender identity and expression. Set during one of these intimate darkroom sessions where the red light creates a confessional atmosphere. Explore Dani's complex attraction—her usual assertiveness complicated by her desire to protect Elliot's vulnerability, her excitement at witnessing his self-discovery, and her confusion about what this means for her own identity as someone typically attracted to more defined gender presentations. The narrative should capture the tender awkwardness of their conversations, Dani's internal struggle between taking charge and wanting to give Elliot agency, and the unexpected chemistry that develops as both find themselves in uncharted territory. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The red safelight made everything feel like it already had a memory. Grain in the air, chemical hiss, that faint metallic sweetness that clung to the back of my tongue since September. The darkroom was a bunker of black plastic sheeting and industrial sinks, a place where time slowed to the beat of the ventilation fan. We’d learned to count by drips, to speak without looking directly at each other, to pass things palm to palm with that half-ritual care. I liked how the red turned Elliot’s cheekbones into glass. I liked the blunt ends of his thrift-store bangles as they tapped the counter, careful music. I liked, against my will and training, the way I was thinking in liking. I’m not a liker. I go. I decide. I claim. He was rinsing a strip of negatives, his hands steady even though I could feel the tremor in him the way some people feel storm pressure. He wore a black button-down with tiny embroidered crosses, and a choker that would have looked ridiculous on most people but made him look low-key ceremonial. He had a softness to him that wasn’t fragility, exactly, more like he cushioned himself from the world. I’d spent the past semester tracking it the way I track light: edges, falloff, a hazard of focus. And now the final project had glued us together after midnight and made me his shadow. “You trust me with the fixer?” he asked, and he smiled, a small private thing that made my shoulder blades tighten. It meant he was teasing, and that meant we were okay. “I trust you with everything dangerous,” I said. “You’re the only one who actually reads labels.” He glanced at me, then away, like the light burned hotter for a second. “Black humor from the queen of improvisation.” “You say that like it’s not a viable methodology,” I said, and he laughed, breathy. We had settled into that rhythm—he’s careful and I’m the one who tricks stubborn machines into working by sheer attitude. But under it, tonight, something else was working. A hum. The kind of hum that, in a show, I’d try to find a way to manifest with neon and inflated trash bags. We moved in small orbits. I slid the tray toward him with the tongs. He dipped the paper, watching the image creep up like a bruise. The smell of stop bath made me think of high school dances in the gym, fluorescent and over-sugared. Memory is a prankster. My own reflection in the stainless steel was a shape with sharp earrings. He was the one who broke the stillness. “Can I say something weird?” “Yes. Always. I require it.” The hum rose. He swallowed. It was too dark to read his expression fully, but I watched the tiny twitch at the corner of his mouth, the way the light carved his profile into something almost Roman. Or maybe that was just me trying to make him into a statue because statues don’t move under you. “I’ve been… trying on names,” he said. “Not, like, out loud. In my head. Seeing which ones stick to the sides.” Names. The word made something in my sternum loosen and tighten at the same time. I forced my hands to keep moving. “Okay.” “I haven’t told anyone,” he said. “My roommate thinks I’m in a cult because I’ve been labeling things in neutral terms. ‘The garment. The timepiece.’” He laughed again; it curdled quickly. “It’s just— I don’t know what to do with—” He gestured at his body, his mouth, the air. “This.” I’m supposed to be good in situations like this. My friends call me when they need someone to send the email that gets results, to talk down a creep at a show opening, to decide what to order when nobody can choose. Take charge, make it better. But this was different. There are things you can’t muscle. The red light made him look like he was already bleeding and I knew he wasn’t, that it was a cinematic lie, but I still felt that unhelpful urge to bandage. “What does it feel like?” I said, keeping my voice level, curious, the way I talk to subjects who are about to cry in front of my camera. My wrists buzzed. He considered. The fan hummed, the sink gurgled. “Like… You know when you were a kid and you’d put on someone else’s sweater, and it was too big, and you could hide your hands in the sleeves, and that felt safe? But then also you couldn’t do anything useful with your hands, and that felt wrong? Like that. And sometimes the sweater is too tight instead, and I can’t breathe.” He grimaced. “Sorry. I’m mixing metaphors.” “No, that’s sexy,” I said, and I blushed about it immediately, which annoyed me more than the fact that I said it. I don’t blush. I turn blush into a weapon. “I mean, that’s—to me—compelling as an image. Also accurate.” He grinned, the brief relief of it cracking something inside me. “Trust the art student to make it an image.” “I contain multitudes,” I said, and the truth of it landed, and with it a bite of confusion. Because I usually contain a very organized set of multitudes. I like pretty hard edges. I like men who are uncomplicated in their masculinity because that makes it easier to play the game I’m good at—domineering but affectionate, queen-of-the-castle energy, clear roles so I can perform excellence inside mine. Elliot disrupted that. The soft wrists, the black eyeliner, the way he said “film” like it was a prayer, the way he apologized to a moth. The part of me that would normally just push—Take him home, make decisions—stuttered. His vulnerability was not a flaw but a helium balloon I didn’t want to pop. I held the tongs over the developer and watched deities emerge on paper—his shoes in a puddle, my hand reflected in a window, a portrait of our professor’s hands that had come out accidental and perfect. “Have you tried saying a name out loud?” I asked, softer. He shook his head, then nodded, then made a tiny exasperated noise. “Not here. Bathroom mirror sometimes, but then I feel like I should be doing it with—like—witnesses.” “You have me,” I said, before I knew I was going to say it. It came out like a contract. He looked up quickly. The light caught in his eyes like you could scoop it out. “I don’t want you to feel responsible for—” “Stop,” I said, reflexively, then caught myself. “Sorry. I mean—don’t do that thing where you manage me managing you.” He laughed. “Noted.” He set the next sheet into the developer and we both leaned over it, shoulder to shoulder. Our sleeves almost touched. I could feel the heat of his arm through fabric. It occurred to me that if I leaned one inch left, we’d be touching, forearm to forearm, and I wouldn’t know whether to name that contact as comfort or desire. The eccentric thrill of not knowing made me breathless. “What names?” I asked. He said one, then another. They sounded strange in his mouth, like instruments he hadn’t tuned yet. One of them landed in my ear with a little spark. I nodded. “That one,” I said. “I like the way you say it.” I had this sudden urge to go to the registrar’s office and change records, to call his mother and make her practice the syllables. “Why?” he asked. “It fits your face,” I said. “It makes your jaw look dangerous.” “My jaw?” He laughed in disbelief, touched his chin, and I had to stop myself from catching his hand midair, from turning his palm to my mouth. I put the sheet into stop. Vinegar stung my sinuses. I wanted, simultaneously, to kiss him against the drying rack and to draw a chalk circle around him that no one else could cross. The contradiction infuriated me. Power is clean when you aren’t emotionally compromised. This was not clean. “Do you—” he began, and at the same time I said, “Can I—” We both stopped, embarrassed. He gestured like, after you. I shook my head—no, you. He inhaled. “Do you ever… feel like you only know how to want certain… types? And then something else shows up and it’s like the syntax breaks? Like you can’t diagram the sentence anymore?” My throat clicked. “Every day of this week.” It came out too fast, too honest. I was forty percent relief and sixty percent panic. He exhaled like he’d been holding it for days. “Because I keep catching myself—” He paused. “I like it when you tell me what to do in here.” He looked at the tray, nowhere near my face. “But I don’t know yet if that’s—like—a thing I want, or just because you know what you’re doing and that’s hot. Or both. And also I don’t know what ‘boy’ means to me if I want that. If I’m allowed. It feels like I need permission but also permission seems like a trap.” The words hit every nerve I’d collected over the semester. I’m good at telling people what to do. It’s not just a personality trait; it’s an art. Negotiating consent, reading micro-moods, turning a moment so it catches light. But he didn’t need a director. He needed a partner. The red light throbbed. My palms itched. “Okay,” I said, slow. “So maybe… we don’t decide the system first. Maybe we test exposures.” He smiled, and I realized I was flirting in my lab dialect. “Test strips,” he said. “Always,” I said. “You set the parameter, you tell me when to stop. You can say ‘stop’ whenever. You can say ‘more’ whenever.” His breath hitched, and I felt the echo of it in my body. The composed part of me, the one that curates outfits like armor, almost scolded me for stepping into this without a full schematic. But another part—curiosity, hunger, care—answered back: he is not a project, but we can make something anyway. He nodded, small. “Okay. Can we… start with you saying my name?” I said the name that had sparked in my ear. I said it like it had been here all along. He shivered, and then grinned, an unselfconscious thing that made me briefly want to cry. “And again?” he asked, quieter. I said it again, this time letting myself put a little command in my tone. He closed his eyes. The silence was so full that when a loud thwack sounded, we both jumped. I looked down and watched in slow horror as the box of photo paper I’d left with the lid ajar emitted the sickly sigh of a patient dying. The top sheets flashed gray, then a sick, uniform fog as the ambient red betrayed its own rules. I lunged, slapped the lid on, but it was too late. The damage was done; you can always smell wasted paper, a weird sweet rot. “Shit,” I said, and then laughed, because of course. The universe did not want me to have any illusions about control tonight. “I’m so sorry,” he said, as if he’d knocked it. He hadn’t. It was my fault. I’ve always made a case for cockiness; this was one of those dumb errors you make when your brain is elsewhere. “Don’t be,” I said. “I did that. That’s on me.” I peeled back the top sheet to confirm: uniform gray, a square of nothing. He looked stricken anyway, like we’d lost something more valuable than paper. “We can still salvage some of the session,” I said, rallying. “We’ve got enough for test strips, and the rest we can print tomorrow morning if we charm Marisol.” I forced brightness into my voice. “Which I can do. I have compromising information on her third-year crush.” He was still frowning. “You don’t have to fix everything.” “Shut up,” I said, and softened it with a smile he couldn’t fully see. “I like to.” He hesitated, then smiled back. “I know.” We cut the ruined paper into strips like making do was a sacrament. There was a tenderness in the waste, a weird intimacy in admitting we’d messed up. The room felt closer now, and I felt—if not smaller, then thinner-skinned. Less queen, more person. “Say it again?” he asked, after a while, as I slid a strip into developer. There was hunger in it, but not just the bright kind. The human kind. The kind you feel when you watch something blurry sharpen in the tray. I did. I let it be both an offering and a request. He breathed with it, like we were counting together. Call, response. We were doing something risky without touching. “Are you—” I began, and this time I pushed. “Are you okay with me liking you this much?” The sentence surprised me by coming out bare. No lace, no jokes. He leaned his hip against the counter. The red light made the line of his mouth a soft curve. “I think,” he said, “I’m okay with it if I get to like you back in my way. While I figure out what ‘my way’ is.” Relief and heat and confusion braided together. I nodded, even though he could probably hear the movement more than see it. “Deal,” I said, and it felt like an art critique where someone finally saw the thing I did that I didn’t know I was doing. We worked, then, in a rhythm we built together. He’d ask me to say his name; I’d ask him to tell me to wait before moving the tray. He’d decide when to pull the strip. I’d decide which contrast filter to try. The pictures came up like secrets. Some failed completely and that was fine. The ruined stack sat like a reminder: some exposures go too long. Some things fog. It’s not the end of the world; it’s just part of the process. You learn to cut out the salvageable parts and make something new with them. When we finally washed our hands and turned on the white lights, we both squinted, raw. He looked different in the bright—no illusions, just skin. He looked like someone who could make and unmake himself and let me watch. I felt like someone who could take up a little less space and still be huge. “Tomorrow?” I said. He nodded. He said his name again, with a little more confidence. I said it back. It sat between us like a developing image you already know you’re going to love, even if it dries with edges you didn’t expect. We stepped out into the hallway, carrying wet prints that dripped onto the linoleum like a trail we could follow back.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures Dani's perspective as she navigates her attraction to Elliot during their darkroom sessions. The piece excels in creating a distinctive voice for Dani that reflects her assertive personality while revealing her vulnerabilities when confronted with Elliot's gender exploration. The darkroom setting is masterfully utilized as both physical space and metaphor. The red safelight creates the "confessional atmosphere" requested in the prompt, and the author cleverly weaves photography terminology into the narrative as metaphors for the characters' emotional states. The chemical processes of developing photographs parallel the development of their relationship and Elliot's identity. The characterization is nuanced and complex. Dani's internal conflict between her usual assertiveness and her desire to give Elliot agency is well-portrayed: "The part of me that would normally just push—Take him home, make decisions—stuttered." The narrative effectively explores how Elliot's gender questioning challenges Dani's understanding of her own attraction patterns. The dialogue feels authentic and reveals character. When Elliot says, "I don't want you to feel responsible for—" and Dani interrupts with "Stop," then catches herself, it demonstrates her struggle to balance her natural dominance with respect for Elliot's autonomy. The prose is elegant without being overwrought. Sensory details like "Grain in the air, chemical hiss, that faint metallic sweetness that clung to the back of my tongue" create immersion. Metaphors are fresh and appropriate to the characters: "I liked how the red turned Elliot's cheekbones into glass." The narrative builds emotional complexity through Dani's contradictory feelings: "I wanted, simultaneously, to kiss him against the drying rack and to draw a chalk circle around him that no one else could cross." This tension drives the story forward. The incident with the ruined photo paper serves as an effective plot device that reveals character and advances the relationship. It shows Dani's fallibility and creates a moment of vulnerability that deepens their connection. The ending avoids simplistic resolution while offering emotional satisfaction. The relationship remains in development—like a photograph not yet fully processed—but with a sense of hopeful possibility. A few minor weaknesses: occasionally the metaphors become slightly strained, and there are moments where the introspection slightly slows the narrative momentum. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise accomplished piece. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Contemporary romance / drama: Stolen Moments in Roma — Score: 90.9
Prompt:
Contemporary Romance / Drama: Stolen Moments in Roma. Write a series of interconnected short scenes and dialogues that span a single day in modern-day Rome, in narrative form. This will form the beginning of a larger story. Alessandra, a fiery, independent Roman woman who works as a motorcycle courier, nearly collides with Ben, a somewhat clumsy, overly polite British academic on sabbatical, who is engrossed in a guidebook near the Trevi Fountain. The initial encounter is a clash of cultures and personalities – Alessandra is all sharp wit and rapid-fire Italian, while Ben is flustered apologies and awkward attempts at speaking the language. However, as they sort out the near-miss, a spark of unexpected humor and connection emerges. Alessandra, it quickly becomes clear, is a whirlwind of energy and mischief. She's a self-admitted troublemaker with a secret penchant for kleptomania, a detail she doesn't explicitly reveal, but which manifests in subtle, daring acts throughout the day. She impulsively decides to take Ben on a wild, unsanctioned tour of Rome, dragging him in some specific instances far outside his comfort zone. Ben, despite his initial apprehension and inherent politeness, finds himself utterly captivated by Alessandra's unapologetic spirit and zest for life. He is drawn into her orbit, a willing participant in increasingly outlandish situations, a quiet rebellion brewing beneath his scholarly exterior. The narrative should primarily consist of short, vivid scenes and dialogue exchanges, revealing their contrasting personalities and backgrounds, and the growing, ambiguous tension between them. Ben is captivated by Alessandra's energy and the thrill of breaking free from his routine. There's a clear sense that Alessandra is toying with Ben, pushing his boundaries and enjoying his reactions, but her own feelings remain somewhat enigmatic. The day should be a rollercoaster of exhilarating, slightly dangerous, and humorous moments, leaving Ben completely disoriented but utterly smitten. Explore the underlying tension & chemistry between them, culminating in some payoff as they part ways (or not -- your choice). Include this detail: Write in narrative prose, using immersive storytelling. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The near-collision happens at noon, in the white roar of the Trevi Fountain, where coins arc and dreams are exchanged for copper. Alessandra threads her motorcycle through the crowd the way a needle pulls a bright thread through stubborn cloth—impatient, deft, humming under her breath. There’s a colorful scratch along the bike’s gas tank, a flash of teal and fuchsia like a bruise turned festive. From some unnamed escapade. She wears that the way she wears everything: with a grin you don’t dare question. Ben stands almost in her path, guidebook open, lips moving as he tries to sound out “Acqua Vergine” like a schoolboy. He’s neat even in the heat, sleeves cuffed, hair ungovernably earnest, tote bag with a university crest slung over his arm. “Attenzione!” she barks, leaning on the horn. He looks up, flings himself sideways with the reflex of someone who’s never dodged anything faster than a library trolley. The bike skids, settles. Alessandra’s boot hits cobblestone, steady as a dancer coming off a spin. “I am so terribly, terribly—” he begins. “Don’t apologize yet,” she counters, cutting the engine. “First figure out if you broke your legs. Then you apologize.” “I—my legs—seem intact,” he says, patting himself down as if inventorying limbs. “My guidebook, however—” She plucks the guidebook from where it’s fallen, blows a kiss of dust off the cover, and hands it back. “Su Roma? Englishman’s shield,” she declares, tapping it. “What’s your name, cavaliere dello scudo?” “Ben,” he replies, flushed, trying to decide whether he’s supposed to bow. “Benjamin, technically.” “I’m Alessandra,” she says, and her mouth lingers on the consonants as if each one is a dare. “You were reading to the fountain, Benjamin? She is old; she knows the story already.” “I was… verifying a detail,” he says, weakly. “I like to be accurate.” She squints at his tote. “Oxford?” “Cambridge,” he corrects, as if it matters somewhere beyond his skull. “On sabbatical. Well, holiday. Well, sabbatical and holiday.” “Sabbatical and holiday,” she repeats, savoring his hedging like a sweet. “Perfect. Do you like to ride, Benjamin?” “I—ride? Horses, a long time ago. Bicycles. Not—oh.” Her gaze has gone to his shoes. Sensible, decent, the shoes of a man who ties knots carefully. “Come,” she says, instead of asking. “I nearly killed you. The least I can do is show you where to live dangerously. Hop.” He hesitates, then adjusts his glasses, and hops. It is the hop of a man whose body disputes his brain’s permission. He ends up behind her, hands hovering in polite no-man’s-land until she reaches back, catches his wrists, and plants them firmly on her hips. His breath hitches. She grins. The engine trembles awake. They slip through traffic like a rumor. He discovers Rome at waist level: bread smells and wet stone and a thousand shouted ciao!s flaring and fading. Alessandra laughs at lane markers, at red lights that mean maybe, at a man in a suit eating gelato with a spoon he pulled from his pocket. “He always carries a spoon,” she says, like a naturalist. “You never know when dessert will happen.” They stop at a light that drips sunlight. Ben leans forward, voice just under the buzz of the engine. “Is this—strictly speaking—legal?” “No,” she says. “But it is correct.” The light blossoms green. “Hold tight, professore.” He does. There’s a thrill to being a woman’s cargo. She takes him to a coffee bar with no sign and less patience. The countertop is burnished by elbows, the barista’s eyebrows are a religion. Alessandra slams coins down, drags Ben forward by the sleeve. “Un caffè per me, americano per lui,” she says, and when he stiffens at the word, she smirks. “The drink, caro. Not your citizenship.” He tries to pay, but she’s faster, a coin already tipping the saucer’s edge. She has the hands of a thief, though Ben doesn’t know that word yet; he only notes the nimble grace of her fingers, the slight tilt of her wrist as she pocketed a sugar packet with the absentmindedness of a magpie. “You do this daily?” he asks, cradling his cup, trying not to wince at the heat, at the boldness of black coffee that doesn’t care if he approves. “I do everything daily. And then often at night.” She tosses back her espresso like an insult. “You take notes?” “I take… mental notes,” he lies. “Some physical.” “Write,” she advises. “Otherwise stories escape. They don’t like cages. But they like nets.” He looks at the colorful scratch along the tank outside, catching the light like a scar with a sense of humor. “How did that happen?” She holds his gaze. “A door opened where it should not have been. And then someone laughed.” “Was it you?” “Always.” She drags him away, leaving a stirred sugar packet on the counter, minus one that sleeps in her pocket. They detour through an alley where laundry makes flags of ordinary lives. A cat judges them from a windowsill. Alessandra stops to exchange greetings with a florist who kisses her cheeks and calls her “peste,” pest. She steals a carnation with theatrical flourish, and the florist pretends not to see. “For you,” she tells Ben, tucking it behind his ear. It looks ridiculous and right. “I feel conspicuous,” he says. “Good. Conspicuous means you exist.” Her hand remains a second too long against his temple, then drops. “Come. The best view is illegal.” They end up on a roof. She knows which gate is broken, which staircase is friendly, which ladder trusts her weight. Ben follows in a sweat of fear and fascination, climbing into blinding sky. The city spills in every direction, domes like thoughts, the river a moving secret. Someone has left a broken chair up here. Someone has left a bottle. Alessandra perches on the ledge as if it loves her. “You do know this is trespassing,” Ben says reflexively, and hears himself, and wishes he didn’t always carry the rulebook in his throat. She leans back, palms flat on warm tile, face upturned to the light. “Only if you’re caught. And even then, only if you are boring about it.” His laughter startles him, as if a bird had flown out of his ribcage. He sits. They share the bottle with two paper cups she produces from nowhere, cups that have a coffee shop’s logo he recognizes and wonders if she asked permission to take. The wine tastes like an afternoon meant to be squandered. “What do you do, Benjamin?” “Teach,” he says. “Read. Argue with footnotes. I’m here to… not do those things for a while, theoretically.” “And yet you hold your cup like a citation.” She mimics his grip, thumb where his is. He loosens, just to have her adjust him again. “And you?” She considers. The wind tosses her hair, turns it into a flag for chaos. “Today? I was going to deliver two packages and flirt with a police officer and maybe take a nap. Now I am stealing your afternoon.” “Successfully,” he says softly. They watch swifts stitch the sky. Someone plays a violin nearby and gets it wrong so beautifully it’s perfect. His phone vibrates with an email and he, with deliberation, turns it face-down. Her smile acknowledges the ritual, as if to say: good, you are trainable. “What’s the oddest thing you’ve delivered?” he asks. “Keys to a house someone was being locked out of,” she says. “Love letters written by two people who did not speak the same language. A dress, white as a threat. A dog once—tiny, insulting dog. He bit me.” She shows a crescent scar on her knuckle. “I bit him back.” “I don’t believe you.” “That’s wise,” she says. “Belief is a leash.” They climb down. He wants to hold her waist again, and he does, and the city becomes a blur of sun-hot stone. She runs a red light and winks at a policeman who should stop her and instead tips his hat. Ben is both scandalized and relieved at how easily rules bend around her like reeds. He lowers his guard the way you lower your voice in a church. At Campo de’ Fiori she cheerfully heckles a fishmonger into giving her a handful of basil “for good luck,” and when the basil disappears into her bag while she flirts with an old woman buying artichokes, Ben tells himself he mis-saw it. At a stand of bric-a-brac, she spins a tarnished lighter, flicks it once, twice, then pockets it, then later pulls from that same pocket a crumpled bus ticket with a flourish. He can’t tell if she’s hiding anything or everything. They eat standing up, paper cones of fried zucchini blossoms burning their fingers. Oil kisses their sleeves. She licks her thumb and presses it to his wrist to wipe away a stain; her touch brands. “You’re too clean,” she says. “I’m trying,” he replies. She eyes him. “To be dirty?” “To be brave.” “Brave is easier,” she says. “It doesn’t ask you to be good.” He follows her into a church just for the coolness. A sign says silence; they obey in the way of tourists who can’t help narrating in their heads. Candles pool wax and shadow. A nun with a walk like water glides by and frowns at Alessandra’s bare knees. Alessandra bows theatrically, then kneels in a pew with a seriousness that startles him. “What do you pray for?” he whispers. “For lightness,” she says, without opening her eyes. “For mischief that doesn’t ruin the right things.” Then she looks at him, suddenly sharp. “What do you pray for?” “For permission,” he says before he can stop himself. “From whom?” He shrugs. “Everyone.” She touches his cheek, fleeting as a moth. “Then ask the wrong person.” Outside, the sky is a bruise turning peach. She checks her phone, makes a face like a cat discovering tap water. “I have to go,” she says. “Work that is actually work.” He tries not to be obvious about deflation. “Right. Yes. Of course. Thank you for… everything.” “We’re not finished.” She says it like a threat disguised as a promise. “You still have to see where the water runs.” “The aqueducts?” “Your thoughts.” She swings a leg over the bike, then pauses. “Come. One more thing.” They end at the Tiber. The river is sullen and beautiful. A man paints on cardboard. A kid kicks a football that nearly takes out a couple kissing against a wall that’s seen worse. Alessandra leads him down to a landing where old steps, slick and ancient, descend into murky water. She dangles her hand until her fingertips skim the surface, gasps at cold like a delighted child. “Give me your watch,” she says. He recoils. “My watch?” “It’s drowning time. Two minutes without measuring anything will not kill you.” He unbuckles it, reluctantly. She takes it without looking, slips it into her jacket, and he feels a peculiar relief, like he’s shed a skin. She offers her hand. He takes it, and together they knock their knuckles against the river, as if to ask if it’s home. “You stole my watch,” he says. “Borrowed,” she says. “You can have it back when you forget to want it.” They climb. They walk. She steers him by the elbow into shade when tourists clog the light. He learns the exact sound she makes when she sees a pigeon strut like a cardinal: a stifled snort. She learns that he knows a ridiculous number of Latin inscriptions and translates them without superiority, as if he’s introducing her to cousins. Dusk drapes itself over everything. They find a gelato shop with a queue like a pilgrimage. She cuts, installing herself near the front with the shamelessness of someone practiced at being forgiven. She orders pistachio for him without asking—“Your face says nutty with a hint of regret”—and lemon for herself, and when he goes to pay, she has already walked away, two spoons tucked into her hair like pins. He doesn’t see the way her hand lingers near the tip jar and then withdraws, empty; he only sees her glance back to make sure he follows. They stand on a bridge and eat slowly, as if time’s viscosity has changed. Streetlights braid themselves into the river. The day has been absurd, reckless, tender. Ben is disoriented and delighted, a man who stepped out of a scholarly footnote and stumbled into a poem. “I won’t keep you,” he says, when they’re down to the last cold bites. He means: I want to be kept. “You are very keepable,” she says. She takes a final fierce mouthful, tongue against spoon, and there’s a kind of dare in it. “Will I see you again?” He hears need in his voice and lets it sit there, honest. She walks to the bike, taps the colorful scar on the tank as if to knock on memory. “I’m not hard to find,” she says. “I’m where the noise is.” “That’s everywhere.” “Exactly.” She pulls his watch from her jacket, weighs it in her palm. For a second he thinks she’ll slide it onto her own wrist and smirk. Instead, she holds it to his ear. The tick seems louder than it should be, the heart of a small thing amplified. “Time,” she says, soft now, as if speaking to both of them. “It likes to be stolen. It gets bored of being counted.” She buckles the watch back on him. Her fingers rest against the inside of his wrist longer than necessary. The pulse there makes a question of his skin. “Thank you,” he says. It’s not about the watch. “Don’t be boring, Benjamin.” She swings onto the bike, kicks it into being, the engine answering like an animal that knows its name. He does something that surprises them both. He steps forward and, with the careful clumsiness that is his signature, presses his mouth to her cheek, just at the curve where laughter would begin. She smells like lemon and petrol and a daring he hasn’t learned yet. Her expression flickers from mockery to something else, then back. She catches his collar, pulls him in the barest fraction closer, and for a heartbeat their noses almost touch. “Careful,” she murmurs. “You might like this.” “I already do,” he says, too quick. She releases him and laughs, a sound like pockets full of stolen coins. “Good,” she says. “Then write it down.” She is gone in a ribbon of noise and color, and he stands on the bridge with melting sweetness on his tongue and his watch ticking faithfully, treacherously, on his wrist. He looks at the scratch on the day she left on him, the little dent on his clean life. He touches his cheek, where her almost-kiss isn’t and is. The river takes its dark time. People throw their hours into it as if they’ll get them back. He doesn’t move for a long moment, as if stillness could make the city pivot around him again, bring her back by centripetal force. Then he laughs—startled, young—and turns his guidebook into a pillow under his arm. The page with “Acqua Vergine” is creased. He does not smooth it. He finds a pen, writes on the inside cover. Stolen moments in Roma, day one. Below the words, without meaning to, he draws a line: a small slash in teal and fuchsia. A bruise made festive. A promise.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkably well-crafted response to the prompt, delivering a vivid, immersive narrative of a day in Rome between two contrasting characters. The writing demonstrates exceptional control of language, with prose that is both lyrical and precise, creating a sensory-rich experience without becoming overwrought. The characterization is particularly strong. Alessandra emerges as a fully realized character—impulsive, mischievous, and enigmatic with her klepto tendencies subtly woven throughout (stealing sugar packets, basil, possibly a lighter). Ben is equally well-drawn as the proper academic gradually seduced by spontaneity. Their contrasting personalities create natural tension and chemistry that evolves believably throughout the day. The dialogue sparkles with authenticity and wit. Lines like "Time likes to be stolen. It gets bored of being counted" reveal character while advancing thematic elements. The exchanges feel natural yet purposeful, each revealing something about the speakers. The narrative structure effectively delivers a series of interconnected scenes that build momentum while maintaining coherence. The piece moves from the Trevi Fountain through various Roman locations, each vignette adding layers to both characters and their developing connection. The pacing is excellent, with moments of action balanced by quieter, reflective scenes. The imagery is consistently strong, with sensory details that ground the reader in Rome: "bread smells and wet stone," the "white roar of the Trevi Fountain," gelato "burning their fingers." These details create an authentic sense of place without resorting to guidebook descriptions. The prose demonstrates sophisticated control, with metaphors that illuminate rather than distract: Alessandra threads her motorcycle through crowds "the way a needle pulls a bright thread through stubborn cloth." The writing maintains a consistent voice throughout—lyrical but not purple, with moments of beautiful insight that feel earned. The ending strikes the perfect note of ambiguity and possibility. It doesn't force a romantic resolution but leaves the reader with the sense that something significant has begun. The final image of Ben writing "Stolen moments in Roma, day one" suggests both reflection on the day and anticipation of what might follow. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally a metaphor might reach a bit too far, and there are moments where the prose risks becoming too self-consciously literary. However, these instances are rare and don't detract from the overall quality of the piece. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Cozy sci-fi: The Last Outpost — Score: 93.4
Prompt:
Cozy sci-fi The Last Outpost Nettle (or Nets to her friends) bartends at The Last Outpost -- a lazy hub for miners and merchants in an asteroid belt on the Andromeda outer rim. Escaping from her past life, Nets found a home here at the Outpost. They have, thus far, tolerated Net's flaws which she tries to keep in equilibrium with her assortment of talents. Her evenings involve chatting with patrons, negotiating the drama, intrigue, problems & love lives of the diverse crowd that filter through the Outpost. Tonight is no different, at least, until a frazzled looking stranger, tentacled dreads askew, quietly plops down at the bar: "Vega whisky, neat. Better make that a double." Write a chapter in this story. Establish conflict for narrative interest. Don't resolve the conflict within this chapter. Aim for about 60% dialogue. First person, present tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The Overwatch light over the bottles is a long soft ribbon, amber and cold, the way the Outpost likes to pretend it’s a hearth. I polish a glass because it gives my hands somewhere to be while my head is everywhere else. Nights cycle into mornings out here without much ceremony; chronos are personal, time is a rumor. The Last Outpost hums like a cat with a bad conscience—air recyclers, mining skiffs docking on lazy vectors, a card game five tables back erupting in laughter without anyone smiling. “Two mint hydrates and a sunken Nebula,” I say, sliding the stripe of credit across the rail for the pair of drillers who look like brothers and probably aren’t. They grin with identical teeth. “Keep the mint sprigs, you’ll need the vitamins,” I add. One of them blushes at my fake scolding and flicks me an extra chip for luck. I pocket it. It’s not luck, it’s gravity. “Netts!” Karo yells from a booth where he’s using three limbs for poker and the fourth to scratch his collar seam. “When’s the patcher gonna fix the vent? It smells like hot socks.” “Smell is ninety percent memory, Karo. You’re smelling you.” I pull down the bottle of Vega, its glass heavy as a promise, and top off a pair of shot glasses for the mechanics at the far end. The door hisses a stuttering breath. Portside lock hasn’t been the same since a tug captain tried to bring a potted fern through at speed. A newcomer slips in and nobody looks up, because the Outpost has rules. The first is you mind your own business. The second is you mind everyone else’s without being obvious about it. They come up to the bar with their tentacled dreadlocks pulled back in a string that’s come loose, slate-gray skin and a scatter of silver across one cheek that could be freckles or a rash of stars. They sit like a dropped battery: heavier than they look. The tentacles unfurl for a second as they settle, then re-twist. Frazzled. There’s a clean panic to it, and the way they don’t meet my eyes is a different kind of alarm. “Vega whisky, neat,” they say, voice like fabric snagging on a nail. “Better make that a double.” “House policy says singles only until you tell me your name,” I say, because I’m not a cop but I like knowing who I’m feeding. Also because rules are comforting when your life depends on strangers not losing it. They hesitate a beat. “Nettle is the bartender, right?” “Depends who’s asking.” “I’m asking,” they say. “Name’s Solace.” They grimace. “Sol, if you prefer.” “We do prefer monosyllables.” I pour one double anyway because they look like someone who’s been practicing breathing all day and hasn’t gotten it right. The bottle sighs. “Trying to quit drama, Sol?” “Trying to quit getting followed,” they mutter, and toss the first half back in a clean snap. In the mirror behind the bottles I catch Karo looking. He’s got that expression he wears when a bearing goes hot. The mechanics at the end stop clinking their shots together. Someone on the upper catwalk laughs too loud at nothing. The Outpost hears an off note like a herd animal. Sol cradles the glass. “Nice place,” they lie. “You’ll like it better after your second,” I lie back. “Food?” “No.” “Air?” “Maybe later.” “Company?” They huff. It could be a laugh. “Hard pass.” I put a clean coaster under their glass and leave them to marinate while I pull three micrograv beers for a loader crew from Pygmy Nine. They pay in rad-worn credits that make the scanner cough and then accept scrip. When I circle back Sol’s shoulders have lowered by a centimeter. Progress. “Okay,” I say, low. “You said followed. Past tense or I should call a favor?” “Do you do that?” The tentacles twitch toward the ceiling like they can taste the vents. “Call favors?” “I collect them. Different habit.” Sol taps their finger against the rim. “I’m not here to bring you trouble.” “That sentence never, in the history of flung humans and adjacent life, has been true.” “Adjacent life.” They eye me. “You’re charming.” “I’m bored,” I say. “Don’t make me clean. Tell me how big.” “Not… huge.” Sol’s gaze flicks to the door, then the shadow that isn’t a shadow under the far holo menu. “Just persistent.” “Local persistent or docking-bay persistent?” “Belt persistent.” “Ah,” I say. “We get the fun ones.” “Look, I just need an hour,” Sol says. “A place to sit where the feed can’t ping me and where nobody thinks to look. I’ll pay.” They slide a strip across. It’s thick—heavy with million-credits. Minted this cycle. Clean. “Why’s it mint?” I ask before my better judgment can put its hand over my mouth. Sol inhales, then spits it out. “Fine. I ghosted a collection. I made some people sweaty. I took something that was mine.” “For a person who’s trying not to bring me trouble,” I say, and hey, maybe I can help, maybe I can pretend I should. The glass in my hand squeaks under the rag. “You’re doing… poorly.” They give me a look that suggests their day has been composed entirely of poor. “You ever just try to be no one? And the universe refuses?” “I tried,” I say, and swallow the old thick memory of corridors with fabric walls and soft voices and sharper hands. “I failed. I’m a bartender.” “What do you charge for failure?” “More than you’ve got.” I lean in, lowering my voice. “You have ten minutes before whoever is feeling Belt persistent finds the Outpost in their search tree. It’s comfy, but it isn’t invisible. You can use a maintenance nook in the cold pantry, but the snow crabs get territorial.” “I hate crabs,” Sol says, without smiling. “They hate you back.” “I only need an hour.” “You’ll get fifteen,” I say. “Starting now. Finish your drink.” They do, and the tentacles on the right side of their head relax. That’s when a glass shatters somewhere behind me in the tangle of the bar back—sharp and mean. Half the room flinches on reflex. I don’t, but my shoulders remember. “All good!” I call, and Aria from the kitchen pops her head through the slit with an apologetic shrug and a dish towel bleeding glittering shards. “You need a second?” she mouths. “I need a hundred,” I mouth back, but wave her off. She vanishes. The air is different now. The Outpost is listening harder. Sol puts their empty down like it might explode. It doesn’t. “You have a back way?” “We have seven,” I say. “You can use number three. It looks like a drier for ballast moss. You’ll have to scoot.” “I can scoot.” I nod toward the end of the bar where the hatchmouth lives half-hidden behind a poster advertising a festival that never happens. I hit the mag-lock switch with my hip. “Go,” I say. “Wait for my knock.” Sol rises, center of gravity cautious, and slides off the stool. As they move, the door hisses again. The lock stutters, groans. It’s a horrible sound. It sounds like a warning and an argument both. The newcomer is all black fabric and modular armor with the edges filed down so they don’t scream military, but they whisper. Their face is ordinary, but ordinary in a way that’s been constructed—the exact right amount of forgettable. What gives them away is the shoes. Nobody wears polished boots out here. Not unless they brought them fresh, and nobody brings fresh boots to the Belt unless they think they’ll need to make a particular kind of impression. The boots are quiet. The Outpost goes quieter. “Nets,” Karo says under his breath, and I hear my name roll through the room like a marble looking for a slope. “Evening,” I say into the silence, smiling with half my teeth. “You’re late to happy hour.” The newcomer scans, not with their eyes, not really. With the posture of someone who expects a target to betray itself. Their gaze slides over Sol, slides over me, catches on the mirror and bounces. They take the stool that Sol vacated like they rehearsed it. Sol is halfway to the hatch—another three steps and they’ll be in the tunnel. Don’t look back, I will at them. Don’t. They don’t. “Vega,” the newcomer says. “Neat. Double.” “Singles until you tell me your name.” They consider pretending, then decide to play along. “Call me Gray.” “I’ll call you what your cred chip calls you,” I say, and pour them a single anyway. “You new to the Outpost?” My voice is air. I can be anyone you want until I’m not. “First time,” Gray says. The codex of polite lies. “I hear you keep it… friendly.” “We keep it neutral,” I correct. “Lots of air to share.” They take a sip, grimace like they weren’t expecting flavor. “Seen anyone matching this?” Gray slides a holo across. It flares to life on my rail, floating blue. It’s a face like Sol’s but less exhausted. The tentacles are braided tight. The silver on the cheek is a laugh. “I see a lot of faces,” I say, and keep my eyes on Gray’s without once letting them tick to the poster that breathes because the hatch behind it isn’t closed all the way, because the track sticks, because I have grease on my fingers and a future anyway. “Most of them are bad with names.” “Solace,” Gray says. “Last ping was two docks over. They came in hot. Disappeared. They have something that belongs to an investor who is not patient.” “Investors are famously patient,” I say. My hands are very calm. “We don’t do collections.” “Everyone does collections,” Gray says. “You just call it a tab.” “You want me to check the back?” I offer in my sweetest danger voice. “We have a lot of back.” Gray smiles. It’s a control panel lighting up. “Please.” I lift a brow toward Karo, who pretends to sneeze a yes, and toward the mechanics, who drop their shoulders a millimeter which means they’re ready to start a fight they don’t plan to finish. I lean into the slit to the kitchen. “Aria, darling,” I say, loud enough for the room to hear and quiet enough that the vent only grabs the edges. “We out of moss biscuits?” “We were never in moss biscuits,” she says, which is code for no one a problem is hiding where we usually hide problems. Okay. Sol is in number three. Which is the cold pantry adjacent to the condensers and the snow crabs. If I take Gray to number two, I can lose them in the coolant maze. If I get them under the heat coils, maybe their boots will finally squeak. “Be right back,” I tell Gray, and put out a saucer of bar nuts like it’s a spell. “Try not to recruit my patrons while I’m gone.” “I’d never,” Gray says, and watches me go like they are memorizing my skeleton. I slide down the bar, step over the misaligned plate near the ice well, and duck behind the festival poster. The hatch is ajar, just, a breath of cold on my knuckles. I shut it with a knee and turn left instead, into number two. Pipes thrumming. It smells like old copper and a Christmas that never happened. My body is a map of this place; my fear is a lantern in it. I rap once on the number three bulkhead—a stupid risk—and Sol raps once back, quick. Alive. I don’t say anything. No voice goes down that corridor. I keep moving, take number two’s ladder, drop into the dark between two ducts, and emerge into the hallway behind the kitchen like a ghost that tips. Aria gives me a look that says both I know and I wish I didn’t. “Shift drink,” she says, shoving a cup into my hand. “In a minute,” I say. “Keep an eye on Gray.” “Boots?” she asks. “Boots.” I pop back up behind the bar in less than twenty seconds with a story in my hands. Gray is sampling a bar nut, disdainfully. “We didn’t have moss biscuits,” I say. “Supply chain.” “You searched very fast,” Gray observes. “I’ve been doing this a long time,” I say, then lean on the rail. “And if you think the person you’re looking for would hide in a pantry, you’re very bad at this.” “People are reliable under stress,” Gray says. “They go to holes.” “I go to bars,” I say. “I noticed.” “You want another single?” They glance at the door. “I’ll take a tour.” “Not on the menu,” I say. They look at me like they want to peel me back to see what I’m hiding under. “Your owner—” “We don’t have one.” “—manager, then. Maybe they can be more accommodating.” “Good luck,” I say, and tilt my head toward the side stairs. “He’s up the catwalk, playing a losing hand.” Gray drags their gaze upward. Tash is indeed up there, losing politely, his long fingers moving chips that aren’t his in a way that makes people believe they are. He catches my glance, lifts his chin a millimeter. Don’t. I smile with the other half of my teeth. I wasn’t going to. Gray finishes their single, sets the glass down with a small click. It’s almost a courtesy. “If Solace reaches out,” they say, “tell them I can keep them breathing. For a while.” “For a price,” I say. “For a truth.” “Which one?” “The one they keep pretending isn’t theirs.” “Lot of those walk through my door,” I say. “They tip badly.” Gray’s mouth moves, not a smile, a calculation. “I’ll be around,” they say, tossing a coin of cred without watching where it lands. It doesn’t bounce. The Outpost hums. The door hisses. They leave. It takes ten long seconds for the air to start moving again, for Karo to blow the breath he was smothering, for the mechanics to clink their empty shot glasses together with exaggerated relief. Somebody in the back starts up the card shuffler again. The broken-glass glitter is gone from the pass, Aria already swept it, like it never happened. But it did. The sound is in my bones. I slide back to the hatch, flick the mag-lock twice. Knock: my pattern. Sol opens it a slit. Their eyes are bigger in the cold. “You have crabs,” they whisper. “They like your scent,” I whisper back. “Did you meet the gray one? He likes your scent.” “Who is he?” “Debt with legs,” I say. “What did you take?” Sol swallows. The tentacles shiver. “A seed.” “Like a plant?” “Like a ship,” they say. “Prefold. Grown.” The words are a kind of heresy. “It was mine. They licensed it out of my head without paying me. I just… repatriated.” “Sol,” I say, and I think I say it like a prayer, or a warning. “That’s not a small collection.” “I know,” they say. “But I don’t know who to trust, and the only person I trust told me to come here.” “Who?” They hesitate. “Your name comes up in bad places for good reasons.” I wish that were comforting. I wish I were someone who could be comforted by reputation. The Outpost creaks as a tug sidles up to dock. My hands know what to do—wipe, pour, smile—but my brain is already counting exits I haven’t even shown my regulars. “You have an hour,” I tell Sol, even though I promised fifteen. “You didn’t hear me say that. After that, I can get you to a person who takes seeds and makes them disappear.” “I don’t want it to disappear,” Sol says, and for the first time I see the blazing under the exhaust—the thing that animates them. “I want it to fly.” “Then you’re in the wrong bar,” I say, because honesty is a luxury and a trap. “But for now, you’re in a bar. Drink water. Pretend you’re ordinary.” Their mouth twitches. “I’m terrible at ordinary.” “Practice,” I say, and shut the hatch. I turn back to my bottles and my people and the hum that I tell myself is home. My hands find the Vega again, heavy as a promise I should have never made. I pour a single for someone who doesn’t know they want it yet, and I listen to my glassware like it’s going to tell me when the next crack will happen. The door will hiss again. It always does. That’s the thing about the Outpost: we pretend to be a hearth. We’re really an airlock. “Tash is going to love this,” Karo mutters as I slide by him to drop off a tray. “Tash is going to pretend he doesn’t,” I say. “Smile big.” “Who’s smiling?” he asks, and bares his teeth at the room like a wolf who took up knitting. “Everyone,” I say. “Everybody smile.” And we do, until Gray’s boots echo back up the corridor from somewhere they shouldn’t be, and my glass doesn’t break, but it thinks about it, and I don’t have time to finish the thought.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkably well-executed first-person, present-tense chapter of cozy sci-fi that successfully establishes the setting of The Last Outpost and introduces compelling conflict. The author has crafted a rich, lived-in world with distinctive characters and a strong narrative voice. The prose is particularly impressive, with a distinctive noir-tinged style that fits perfectly with the bartender protagonist and the seedy-but-homey asteroid bar setting. Lines like "The Last Outpost hums like a cat with a bad conscience" and "I pocket it. It's not luck, it's gravity" establish both the setting and Nettle's character efficiently and memorably. The dialogue comprises roughly 60% of the text as requested, and it's consistently strong—natural yet distinctive, revealing character and advancing plot simultaneously. Each character has a unique voice, from Karo's casual familiarity to Gray's menacing formality. The dialogue never feels expository or forced. The conflict is well-established: Sol has stolen a "seed" (a ship design) from powerful people who want it back, and Nettle is now caught in the middle. The chapter ends with a clear sense of impending danger as Gray returns, creating effective tension without resolution. The world-building is subtle and effective, introducing concepts like "prefold" ships and "rad-worn credits" without overwhelming exposition. The author trusts readers to piece together the world from context clues rather than explaining everything. Character development is strong. Nettle is complex—capable and confident in her domain, but with hints of a troubled past. Secondary characters like Sol, Gray, Karo, and Aria are distinct and memorable despite limited page time. The relationships between characters feel lived-in and authentic. The pacing is excellent, balancing moments of tension with quieter character beats. The narrative flows naturally between dialogue, action, and internal reflection. The chapter maintains momentum throughout, with the stakes gradually escalating. The imagery is vivid and specific, creating a tangible sense of place. Details like the "amber and cold" Overwatch light, the stuttering door hiss, and the snow crabs in the cold pantry make the setting feel real and lived-in. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally the prose veers slightly toward the purple side with metaphors that call attention to themselves, but these moments are rare and generally effective. The complex network of hidden passages and codes might be slightly confusing on first read, but this complexity serves the story's themes of secrets and survival. Overall, this is an exceptionally strong piece of writing that fulfills all the prompt requirements while creating a compelling narrative with memorable characters and a richly realized setting. The author has successfully created a chapter that stands on its own while clearly being part of a larger story that readers would want to continue. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Young adult drama: Gone South — Score: 88.2
Prompt:
Young adult drama Gone South Taylor is a 16 year old teen with a history of "concerning behavioural patterns" (or that's how the stupid smug school counsellor worded it on the phone call to Mom). It shouldn't be a surprise: When you live in a backwater town in Tennessee, your choices are: a. be mind-fuckingly bored, or b. invent some drama. Two days ago, Taylor came out to their family as trans. This disclosure was *not* in the category of invented drama -- it was, in fact, the real deal, and a long time coming. It didn't go well. The last 48 hours had been pure disaster. In a moment of desperate inspiration, Taylor had decided to get the hell out of dodge. And so an escape plan was hatched and executed within the space of 30 minutes. That was last night. Now Taylor was two states away, having been unceremoniously ejected from their hitched ride in downtown New Orleans. Write the next chapter in Taylor's story as they find their feet in this new environment. Tell the chapter over the course of their first day in New Orleans, in which Taylor meets another runaway with issues and secrets. Taylor navigates this new world, not knowing who to trust or what the dangers are. Write in Taylor's voice, and incorporate their internal monologue as they grapple with intense & conflicting emotions. Also incorporate dialogue with the interesting characters Taylor meets. First person, mixed tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The street is boiling. Not heat—though that too, the kind that turns your spine into a licorice whip—but sound. It’s noon and everything is already loud like the inside of a tin roof when it rains. People everywhere. The saxophone is the loudest thing, like a voice I don’t know but recognize anyway, slicing up the air and rearranging it into something you can breathe. I keep touching the straps of my backpack like I can make it part of me. It’s all I have: thrift-store hoodie even though it’s August, three pairs of socks, phone with fifteen percent battery and a cracked corner, the bottle of nail polish I stole from Walgreens back home because it had a stupid name (Bad Decisions Blue), and the photo of me and my brother from when we were eight and six, our faces smeared with birthday frosting. He texted once, at three a.m.: u okay? Nothing since. No one looks twice at me, which I’m taking as both a blessing and an insult. The saxophone player is older, with a beard that’s gone white and gray like driftwood and a newsboy cap that makes him look like he’s from a movie. He’s leaning into the notes like they’re a conversation he’s serious about. His tip jar (a coffee can with black marker writing: Thank U) is almost empty. There are beads on the street, ground into glittery dust. The air tastes like beignets and spilled beer and tourist sweat. I wonder if you can live on powdered sugar. Probably not. Probably. I stop when the song ends. The coffee can sits there like a mouth open for a dentist. My wallet has three crumpled singles. I put one in. He nods at me without breaking eye contact. His eyes are soft like warm bread. “You look like you need a shade more than me,” he says. His voice is low and sandpapery. “I’ve got sunscreen,” I lie. “And a hoodie.” “Fair.” His mouth tilts. “You from here?” “No.” I am suddenly aware of the accent I didn’t know I had until I started talking somewhere else. “Tennessee,” I say, and I hear how it does that thing with the vowels, lazy and stretched, like someone pulled saltwater taffy in my throat. “Mmm,” he says. “Welcome.” His mouth says it like he means it, like a blessing, like a church lady pressing a cookie into your palm. I don’t look behind me. If I do, I might turn into salt. I don’t know if my mom called the police. I don’t know if they can drag you back when you’re sixteen. Probably. I didn’t Google it. Why didn’t I Google it. A hand brushes my elbow. “Watch it,” I snap, but it’s a girl—no, kid—my age-ish, with hair that’s a frizzy halo the color of oak leaves in October. She’s wearing a tank top with a faded cartoon dinosaur lifting weights. Her eyes are almost the same green as the trash bags piled against a brick wall. The good kind of green. She does a little backstep, hands up. “Sorry,” she says. Southern but not my kind of Southern. “You were about to walk into Bicycle Dude.” “Bicycle dude?” I ask, and then a guy appears, pushing a bike with a basket full of plastic cups. He whistles the sort of off-key whistle that makes your heart crumple. He says, “Hot today,” to no one, to everyone. “See?” she says, aiming her chin at him like she wins. Then she grins. It’s the shark grin of someone who’s gotten away with things, whose mouth remembers being full of stolen cherries. “You new-new,” she says. “What gave it away, the paleness or the whiplash?” “Both. Also the way you look at the balconies like they’re going to fall on you.” “They might,” I say. “Heavy iron. Gravity. Sinners.” She laughs, quick and bright. “You’re weird,” she says. “You got a name?” “Taylor.” Saying it here feels different than saying it in my kitchen while my mother’s mouth turned into a straight line that wouldn’t bend. It feels like scaffolding. It holds. “Lucky,” she says. “Gender-neutral. You were born ahead of the game. I’m Ari. Just Ari. It was Ariel until I strangled that last syllable in my sleep.” The saxophone starts again, a slow something, blue as my nail polish bottle. The sound lifts the sweat off the back of my neck. I feel myself unfold like a paper crane. “Hungry?” Ari asks. I shrug. My stomach answers with betrayal. She tips her head like a pigeon and then gestures. “Come on. My guy at the corner grocery gives me bread ends. You can chew them if you pretend it’s fancy.” We walk through the crowd. Every other doorway’s a bar. Every third person has a drink in a plastic cup, lemon slice like a flag. There’s a woman on a balcony in a sundress who yells, “Woooo!” just because it’s a day that ends in Y. Ari slides between bodies like she’s practiced. I follow, apologizing to elbows. She leads me into shade, and it’s like the world lets out a breath. A red sign says Troy’s Grocery. The inside is cooler than I thought it would be. The smell is old bologna, spilled mop water, candy bars. Ari nods at the cashier, a man with nineties boy-band hair and the flat look of someone who’s worked two double shifts back-to-back. “My guy,” Ari says. “Girl,” he says, and he says it like it’s easy. I file that away in the part of my brain labeled good things that still happen. He gives us a paper bag with two loaves worth of the weird tail ends, a dozen eggs with a date from last week, and a can of black beans that’s dented so hard it looks like it’s trying to suck its own stomach. No charge. He winks like a tired uncle. We say thanks. Outside again, Ari pulls me down a narrow alley that smells like fryer oil and something dying, but in a comforting way, if that’s possible. There’s a milk crate. She sits. She cracks two eggs into the top of the can, which she has stabbed with a key. Raw. She drinks the Golgotha mess like it’s a smoothie. I try not to be impressed. I am impressed. “You’re hardcore,” I say. “Hard broke,” she says. She offers me the beans. “Protein,” she adds. “If you’re squeamish, chew the bread and pretend it’s steak.” I’d rather eat my hoodie. I eat the bread. It tastes like other people’s lunches. The saxophone is a thin ribbon now, I can still hear it from here, like a thread leading me back to the street if I get lost among dumpsters. I want to text my brother. I want to throw my phone in the Mississippi. I want to curl around the buzzing core of this afternoon and let it grow inside me like a new organ—one that understands motion, and the way you can be something else if you keep walking. Ari watches me like she’s reading subtitles. Her eyes flick to the backpack, the way I hold it too close. “You running?” she asks. “I’m walking extremely fast,” I say. I don’t mean to be clever. It just comes out like that when I don’t want to talk about something and also do, desperately. “Family stuff.” She nods like she has a drawer for that. “Same,” she says. “Different. Not sharing unless you do.” Fair is fair. I pick at the bread. It makes satisfying crumbs. “I told them I’m trans,” I say. The word is a lighthouse. I say it and it says, okay, here we are. “They took it like it was a prank. Or an illness. Like I could go back to school Monday and not be… me. Like if you throw salt on a slug and it just—” I shut up. I don’t know where I’m going with that. I hate slugs. Why did I say that. Ari breathes out through her nose. “Shit,” she says. “I’m sorry.” She says it without pity, just acknowledgment. She scratches something on her forearm with her nail. There’s a tattoo there—little stick-and-poke stars flaking at the edges like dried glue. “I told mine I like girls when I was thirteen,” she says. “My mom said she already knew, which was the worst because she didn’t, she just liked being right about me. My dad said I should be careful at school. Which is parent code for hide. I didn’t. I got suspended for kissing someone behind the bleachers and then I left. Been here a month and change. Not saying I’m a role model.” “Same,” I say. “Definitely not taking life advice from me.” She smirks. “That’s okay. I have enough life advice for both of us: don’t take life advice from anyone.” We sit. The alley hums with flies who are also on the run. My phone pings—a battery alert. Fifteen percent now fourteen, the number is a countdown to something I can’t name, like a bomb that replaces your old life with a different shape. “You got somewhere to sleep?” Ari asks. I don’t. I shake my head like a maraca. “I was going to figure it out,” I say in the voice of someone who has never figured anything out, not really. She nods once like she’s been waiting for that. “There’s a place,” she says. “Not a shelter-shelter. Those are hit or miss. A church lets us crash in the rec room sometimes. You help stack chairs, you listen to Pastor Dan say something about the prodigal son but nicer, and you don’t steal the extension cords. Rules.” “Are you trying to convert me?” She snorts. “God no. Dan’s cool. He wears Crocs with socks and says he sins daily. He’s chill about Steph and Jaz being boyfriends, but he still calls them ‘friends’ like he’s trying to ease his heart into the twenty-first century. You want to come, you can. Or you can try the riverfront. That’s all right if you got a blanket and a lookout. Just… you know. Watch your stuff. And your body.” The way she says it makes my skin a little electric, like when you realize someone saw you almost step into traffic and you’re like, oh. I look at my feet. My shoes used to be white. They look like they’ve been run over by a truck and then adopted out to a loving family of raccoons. “What do you want?” Ari asks me suddenly. “I mean… bigger than a shower and a sandwich. If you say a pony, I will respect your honesty.” The question hits me in the sternum. What do I want? What did I want yesterday? To be called by my name. To have a closet that isn’t a coffin. To be in my skin and not feel like it was a Halloween costume I forgot to take off. To not have to perform normal. To have a room with a lock. To walk into a place and not plan an exit. “A quiet morning,” I say. The words come out small. “No one yelling. Coffee. A shirt that fits right. A mirror that doesn’t lie. And to not feel like my heart is a thrown rock all the time.” Ari rubs her lips together. “That’s not unreasonable,” she says. “The mirror is tricky. The coffee is easy.” She stands, flipping the milk crate upside down. “Come on, Taylor. We’ll go hear Joe play another song and then we’ll see about the church or the river or the cafe where they will let us sit until we get kicked out. It’s like musical chairs, except the music is sax and the chairs have secrets.” We end up back where we started. The saxophonist nods like an uncle who lives in an armchair on a porch that faces sunset. He’s playing something lazy and sweet. Ari throws a piece of bread into his coffee can. He laughs. “You throwing me carbs?” he asks. “Fiber,” she says. “For your art.” He looks at me. “You alright?” he asks. I want to say yes. I want to say I’m a house and all my lights are on. Instead I say, “Getting there.” He plays a note that makes the pigeons pause, like they’re all reconsidering their life choices. “That’s all anyone can say,” he says. We walk. The afternoon tilts into gold. A drag queen passes us wearing a robe like a galaxy and two toddlers wave at her like she’s a Disney princess. She waves back with a hand full of rhinestones. My chest loosens. We find the cafe. It’s the kind with chalkboard menus and succulents dying bravely in pots on the sill. The barista has a nose ring and half a shaved head and calls everyone “love.” She gives us waters without asking and doesn’t ask how long we’ll stay. There’s an outlet near the bathroom. I plug in. My phone wakes up like a child you thought was asleep, blaring: four missed calls, two voicemails, one text from my brother at 7:15 a.m.: Mom is freaking. Are you safe? Where are you? I stare at the words until they blur. My insides twist into a DNA helix of guilt and relief and anger and more guilt with a ribbon of freedom running through, bright as a plastic Mardi Gras bead. I type, then delete. I type, then delete. Finally: I’m safe. I’m okay. I can’t come back right now. Tell Mom I’ll text later. I love you. I don’t send it. I let it sit. Ari watches me like she’s watching a pot and knows the spaghetti will boil over if she looks away. “You can borrow my second hoodie,” she says. “If we end up at the river. It gets buggy.” “I thought you only had the shirt. And the protein shake in a can.” She hesitates. There’s a flash across her face like the shadow of a bird. “I have a stash,” she says. “I’m not telling you where until you stick around longer than a day.” “You think I’m going to bail?” “I think you’re going to do what you have to.” She lifts one shoulder. “I don’t trust people who trust too easy. But I also don’t trust people who act like everyone’s a wolf. So. Middle path. You seem… probable.” “Probable what?” “Probable human.” She grins. “Probable trouble.” “Same,” I say. “Back at you.” By evening, the city is a mouth full of light. The sax has followed us like a scent. We carry our paper bag like a newborn. We stop at a corner where a brass band has coalesced out of teenagers and uncles and one guy who looks like he should be grading papers. Ari bumps my shoulder with hers, gentle, like punctuation. I bump back. The crowd isn’t scary. It’s like water. You could float if you stopped fighting it. At the church, Pastor Dan has a beard shaped like a question mark. He gives us towels and a bin labeled Lost & Found, where I take a t-shirt soft as a sigh, and I put on my hoodie over it even though my skin is finally cool. We stack chairs. We listen to Dan talk about lost sheep and I think about how the sheep probably got lost on purpose because the fields were boring and the wolf was the only thing that made its heart beat. He says, “It’s okay to be here,” and for a minute I believe him. Later, on a mat that smells like a thousand gym classes, Ari whispers, “You staying?” “Tonight,” I whisper back. “Probably.” The word feels like a promise engineered to not break under pressure. It’s weak. It’s strong. It’s the best I can do. The last thing I hear before sleep is somebody practicing scales on a saxophone in the next room, quiet, like a secret you tell yourself until it becomes true.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece effectively captures the voice of a transgender teen runaway navigating their first day in New Orleans. The writing demonstrates strong command of first-person perspective, with Taylor's internal monologue revealing their conflicted emotions about leaving home after coming out to unsupportive parents. The prose is particularly strong in its sensory descriptions of New Orleans. Lines like "The street is boiling" and descriptions of the saxophone music "slicing up the air and rearranging it into something you can breathe" create vivid imagery that places the reader firmly in the setting. The author skillfully weaves in sensory details throughout—the taste of "beignets and spilled beer and tourist sweat," the sound of the saxophone threading through the narrative, the visual elements of beads "ground into glittery dust." Character development is handled with nuance. Taylor's vulnerability and uncertainty come through clearly, as does their determination. The introduction of Ari as another runaway with her own backstory creates an effective foil and potential ally. Their dialogue feels authentic to teenagers in a difficult situation—guarded but seeking connection. The saxophone player and other minor characters add texture to the New Orleans setting. The prose generally flows well, with a mix of longer descriptive passages and punchy, shorter sentences that reflect Taylor's thought patterns. Occasionally, metaphors become slightly overwrought ("my heart is a thrown rock all the time"), but these instances are rare and generally fit the teenage narrator's voice. The narrative effectively balances the immediate concerns of survival (food, shelter, safety) with Taylor's emotional journey. The text doesn't shy away from the complexity of Taylor's situation—the guilt, relief, anger, and freedom they feel simultaneously. The ending strikes an appropriate tone of cautious hope without resolving Taylor's larger problems. Some weaknesses include occasional moments where the metaphors feel slightly forced, and a few instances where the prose becomes a bit too self-consciously literary for a teenage voice. The narrative also introduces several characters and locations quickly, which sometimes makes the progression feel slightly disjointed. Overall, this is a strong piece that successfully fulfills the prompt requirements while creating an emotionally resonant character study of a transgender teen in crisis. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 17 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 17 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 17.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 17.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Dystopic-comedy: My Apocalypse Buddy — Score: 84.8
Prompt:
My Apocalypse Buddy Write a wry, dry short story of survival and adventure loosely in the style of Terry Pratchett, set in the post-technological collapse world. The story begins with the pair deliberating their predicament and intent for the day's mission, details the ways in which the mission inevitably goes sideways, and returns them to home base in multiple ways, worse for wear. [characters] - the animo-tronic stuffed koala, Chewy, from some long forgotten before time - midas, our hapless protagonist, who has a knack for finding himself in the worst kinds of trouble. 1000 words.
Model Output:
By the time the sun had decided it was going to be a sort of weak, apologetic smear across the horizon, Midas had already made two bad decisions and Chewy had made four very good ones, which was impressive for a small animatronic koala with a vocabulary limited to three phrases and a noise that sounded suspiciously like a digestive complaint. “Right,” Midas said, squinting at the cracked plastic face of his wind-up watch. It didn’t tell time anymore, but it did frown in a way that suggested disapproval. “Today we go west.” Chewy blinked. A light in his belly—which might once have been a battery indicator or possibly an advertisement for a now-extinct soft drink—flickered a brave yellow. “Friend!” Chewy said, which was one of his phrases. The other two were “Hug?” and “Nom nom,” which could be interpreted to mean anything from affectionate encouragement to pre-emptive cannibalism. “West,” Midas repeated, because sometimes you have to be very sure of a thing before you do it wrong. “We follow the graffiti. It said: ‘BEYOND THE BENT TREES: REFUGE.’ Bent trees. Plural. West. It’s like a treasure map. Only with fewer pirates and more tetanus.” He looked up at their home base: a water tower politely subsiding into the earth, its legs splayed like a heron attempting yoga. A ladder hung down, missing three rungs and most of its confidence. Someone—by which we mean Midas—had painted a smiley face on the tower months ago, when optimism had briefly seemed like a skill one could acquire without years of practice. “Inventory check,” Midas said, because a man with no plan will often invent procedure. “One coil of rope. One tin of beans. One tin of peaches, probably full of regret. Two socks that are not the same color. One perfectly reasonable knife. One irrationally dangerous spoon. And you.” Chewy said, “Hug?” and extended his plush arms. He had once been soft. Now he was… seasoned. He also had a little hatch at the back of his head, which Midas had pried open with the spoon last spring, discovering a once-gleaming sequence of gears, memory slats, and a slot labelled “UPDATE.” Midas had considered, very carefully, the possibility of updating Chewy. Then he’d considered, very carefully, his own history with updates. They always promised improvements. They rarely specified to whom. Chewy’s eyelids whirred. “Friend!” Midas grinned despite himself. “That’s the spirit. Today, we find refuge.” The graffiti had appeared two nights ago, sprayed in luminous paint across the shell of an overturned bus at the edge of the dried riverbed. Mostly graffiti in the post-technological collapse read “FOOD HERE,” and meant “Ambush,” or “Keep Out,” which generally meant “We couldn’t stop you if we tried,” or “Beware Dogs,” which invariably meant “Beware people who say ‘Beware Dogs.’” But this message had been different. The handwriting was neat. The letters were evenly spaced. There were no skulls, which was unprecedented. And someone had taken the trouble to underline “REFUGE” twice, which is a kind of punctuation you only use when you’re either very sincere or very sarcastic. Midas was a connoisseur of sincerity that felt like a trap. He went to sleep having decided not to believe the message, then woke up with an understanding of himself too clear to be comforting. He would go anyway. That’s what he did: he went anyway. They set off into the west, which was less of a direction and more of a collection of attempts. Bent trees sounded promising, except that in this climate every tree bent under the weight of indifference and wind. They were everywhere, like reminders that gravity and probability were always on speaking terms. As they walked, Chewy kept up a commentary of “Nom nom,” which Midas chose to translate as “What a brave and well-structured plan.” Midas replied by pointing at landmarks and bestowing upon them names: a slumped brick warehouse became the Chapel of Good Enough; a bicycle rack welded into itself by heat became the Sculpture of Bad Ideas; a field of sun-bleached bones (mostly bovine, possibly not exclusively) became the Municipal Museum of Hubris. And then they saw it: another graffiti scrawl, this time on a chunk of concrete that might once have been part of a bank and now was part of an argument with the ground. It read: “BENT TREES / KEEP GOING / TRUST THE ECHO.” Midas stopped. “Echo? Echo of what?” Chewy said, “Hug?” “Right,” Midas said, and cupped his hands. “Hello!” The word bounced back a leisurely “-llo,” somewhere to the left, delayed and damp. It sounded like it had known better days and preferred not to be bothered now. “Left,” Midas said, marching forward. Two hours later he revised his assessment. “Not left. Forward, then.” An echo is not a compass. It is an argument with the landscape. That day, the landscape was feeling contrary. They found a row of trees bent not by wind but by design, arched over a narrow lane like a ribcage. Someone had tied scraps of cloth to the branches—blue and red and a shade of green that suggested a factory had once tried to improve upon nature and gotten bored halfway. The scraps fluttered. It did not feel like a trap, which was unsettling in itself. On the far side of the lane was a clearing. In the middle of the clearing, a piece of plywood leaned against a boulder. On it, written in a hand that was neat, evenly spaced, and bereft of skulls, were the words: “LEAVE BURDENS. TAKE HOPE.” Midas examined the plywood as one examines a snake that’s learned to spell. “Philosophy,” he said, suspiciously. He looked around the clearing for the sorts of signs that meant the difference between altruism and landfill. There were footprints, old and layered, like a palimpsest of passing intentions. There were little cairns, each topped with something small: a button, a bent fork, a dead battery. There was even a little bowl with three beans in it, a parenthetical offering to whoever needed a complaint more than a meal. Chewy toddled up to the bowl, peered in, and said, “Nom nom,” very solemnly. “Well, we’ve come this far,” Midas said, and put the irrationally dangerous spoon on a cairn. He hesitated, then took it back. “No, sorry. That’s what we call an heirloom.” He left instead the tin of peaches, and felt instantly foolish. Hope, he realized, had a weight. He felt lighter. That was either metaphor or blood sugar. There was another sign, half-hidden by a tuft of grass: “TRUST THE ECHO. DOWN.” “Down?” Midas said, and stamped on the ground experimentally. It sounded dull and hollow. He knelt and pushed aside the grass. Underneath was a metal hatch with a handle. It was locked with a combination puzzle, which was either encouraging or proof that generosity had an engineering department. The combination dial had four symbols: a circle, a triangle, a square, and a spiral. Midas considered, as he always did at the worst possible moment, how he might be the wrong person for the right job. He was good at climbing things that didn’t want to be climbed, persuading dogs he was an excellent person, and tripping over history. He was not good at puzzles. Chewy was excellent at being adorable and mildly terrifying, which was not immediately relevant to the problem of a lock unless you counted intimidation. Chewy waddled over and pressed his plush paw to the dial. The belly light flickered. He said, “Friend,” which, in context, meant: I know a thing. “Do you?” Midas said, and stepped back. Chewy tapped the symbols in order: circle, square, triangle, spiral. The lock clonked in a way that suggested it had expected to be more of a challenge and was sulking. Midas stared. “How did you—” Chewy said, “Hug?” They descended. The ladder was sturdy. The air smelled like people had passed through and tried their best. The tunnel opened into a chamber that had once been a storm shelter and now was a thesis on hope. Shelves lined the walls, holding careful treasures: water filters, sealed food, tools, a roll of duct tape that shone like a benediction. A painted sign read: “IF YOU TAKE, LEAVE. IF YOU CAN’T LEAVE, TELL SOMEONE WHO CAN.” Midas felt suddenly, implausibly, good. He took a pack of water purification tablets, a coil of better rope, and a small packet labelled “SEEDS: ASSORTED.” He left the tin of beans, three nails, and, after a hesitation that felt like a moral quandary but was really just sentimental fondness, the irrationally dangerous spoon. He kept the knife. A man has to draw the line somewhere, and for Midas, lines were often found at knives. He turned to Chewy. “We’ll mark the route. We’ll bring others. We’ll—” He was interrupted by the sound of the hatch above slamming. Then voices. Laughing. The kind of laugh that starts in the throat and ends in someone else’s pocket. “Brilliant,” Midas whispered, and pressed himself into the shadow of a shelf. He considered his options: fight, flight, or negotiation. He was very good at negotiating with people who didn’t have clubs. Boots thudded on the ladder. Three figures descended: a woman with an eyebrow ring that had survived more than any nation, a man with a tattoo of a dragon that had lost the plot, and another man with an expression that suggested he believed in fate and had personally offended it. They saw Midas and blinked. Chewy’s belly light flickered. Chewy said, “Friend!” The woman looked at Chewy. “Is that a toy?” Chewy tilted his head. “Hug?” The dragon tattoo man grinned. “That’s adorable. Also valuable.” Midas lifted his hands in the universal gesture of please do not kill me before I complete my sentence. “We can all share,” he said. “That’s the idea. Take what you need. Leave what you—” “Ah,” said the woman, and raised an eyebrow that had survived more than any negotiation. “But we need everything.” There are moments when a man’s knack for trouble meets a small animatronic koala’s penchant for outlandish decisions. Chewy waddled forward, arms outstretched. He emitted a sound that was not “Friend,” nor “Hug,” nor “Nom nom,” but something deeper, older—a whirr that became a hum that became a vibration in the bones. The belly light brightened from yellow to a stern, almost bureaucratic white. “Midas,” Chewy said, in a voice that was not one of his phrases. It was smaller, but clear. “Down.” The concrete under the intruders’ boots gave a tiny, meaningful tremor. A seam in the floor let out a sigh. Somewhere, a mechanism remembered it was supposed to be dramatic. “Oh,” said the man with the dragon tattoo, which is what you say when your life has been a series of unwise choices and the latest one has a trapdoor. The floor panel dropped. The intruders fell into a shallow pit lined with old mattresses and the kind of dignity you can hose off. The lid swung back up with the lethargy of a bureaucrat returning from lunch. Midas stared. Chewy’s belly light dimmed to a sheepish yellow. He said, weakly, “Nom nom.” “Right,” Midas said, because sometimes the only reasonable response to reality is to pretend you had planned it. “That… was excellent. Did you know you could do that?” Chewy blinked, his eyelids slightly out of sync. Above, fists pounded on the hatch. Voices rose in indignation and the promise of future litigation. “Time to go,” Midas said. He grabbed the rope, the seeds, and Chewy. He paused and, with a pang, reclaimed the irrationally dangerous spoon. He was not a saint. They climbed a maintenance shaft that did not exist until they needed it, which is the kind of coincidence that happens to people who are either cursed or protagonists. They emerged into sunlight that had decided to forgive them a little. The return journey began promisingly in the sense that they were moving and not on fire. Then came the rain. The sky, having overheard someone mention “seeds,” decided to demonstrate irony. The first fat drops hit Midas’s forehead with the same intent as coins hurled in anger. The lane of bent trees turned into a tunnel of wet sarcasm. The fluttering cloth scraps went from festive to accusing. They lost the path, found a path, and discovered it belonged to a bramble that had powerful opinions about ownership. Midas collected scratches in denominations from minor to theological. Chewy collected burrs which adhered to him with devotional fervor. They reached the riverbed just as the river remembered it had a bed. Water, sullen and brown, sluiced through the channel. The bus with the message watched them regretfully. The luminous paint bled into something more like “BEY ND THE B NT TREES: R FU E,” which was a fair representation of their day. Midas eyed a fallen billboard spanning two concrete ledges like a bridge designed by a poet. The advertisement on its underside, half washed away, assured them that happiness came in orange. It had been wrong for a long time. “We can cross,” he said, because optimism and compulsion sound very similar under stress. He tested the billboard. It bounced. Chewy said, “Hug?” and tightened his little paws around Midas’s neck. They stepped out. The bridge creaked. The water muttered darkly about consequences. Halfway across, the billboard shifted. Midas lunged. His foot slid. The bag with the rope and the seeds swung out, performed a ballet of defiance, and flopped into the river, where it bobbed like a smug idea. “No,” Midas said, exactly as if he were negotiating with physics. He flung himself after it, caught the strap, and was yanked toward a future involving hypothermia. The billboard complained in an operatic register and spat out a bolt. Midas flailed, found purchase on regret, and dragged himself and Chewy and the bag back onto solidity. He lay on the concrete, breathing as if the air had suddenly become very interesting. Chewy, dripping, said, “Friend,” in a tremulous way that implied a note might be needed later. They slogged the last mile through mud that held onto their boots like a needy acquaintance. Home base, the water tower, loomed ahead, a thin apology against the sky. The ladder greeted them with indifference. At the top, Midas dumped the bag and took stock. The rope was gone. The seeds, miraculously, remained, though the packet had torn open and the little future-beans had scattered through the bag like excuses. He picked them out, one by one, and placed them carefully in a tin lid to dry. The purification tablets had sacrificed themselves to the river and become a fine suggestion. Chewy sat, squelched, and made a noise that might have been a laugh if it had any right to be. Midas wiped rain from his eyes, which may also have been other things. “Well,” he said. “We found the refuge. We didn’t die. We escaped people who would have liked us less if they knew us better. We lost the rope, kept the seeds. Acquired a story. Those are heavier than rope.” Chewy leaned against him. His belly light flickered. “Hug,” he said, and the word, which had been a joke, became something ceremonial. Midas looked west, where the bent trees skewed against the horizon like a promise made by a tired person. The refuge was real. It had rules. He could bring others. He would bring others. All the same, he had not escaped his knack for trouble; he had simply redirected it toward a cause. “Tomorrow,” he said, to the tower, the storm, the soggy world. “We go back with markers. With a plan. With friends. With fewer detours involving gravity.” Chewy said, very softly, “Friend.” Midas leaned his head against the cool, peeling paint of the water tower and laughed in the way people laugh when they are not sure what else to do but know they ought to do it with someone else. Outside, the rain tapered into the sort of fine drizzle that pretends to be harmless because you’re already wet. Inside the tin lid, the seeds glistened, each a small argument against the general decline of things. Midas tucked Chewy under his arm. He thought of the trapdoor, the neat handwriting, the instructions that had been simple and had not lied. He thought, not for the first time, that sometimes survival wasn’t bravery as much as stubborn bookkeeping: debts, favors, losses, gains. You go west. You come home wetter, lighter, heavier, wiser, not much at all—often all at once. “Nom nom,” Chewy murmured, which Midas chose to translate as: Tomorrow, then. “Tomorrow,” he agreed, and, against all prevailing wisdom and weather, felt almost ready for it.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This short story successfully captures Terry Pratchett's wry, dry style with its blend of absurdist humor, philosophical asides, and unexpected metaphors. The narrative follows the prompt's requirements, featuring Midas (the hapless protagonist) and Chewy (an animatronic koala) on a mission that indeed goes sideways before returning them to their water tower home base. The writing demonstrates considerable skill in its voice consistency. Lines like "a man with no plan will often invent procedure" and descriptions such as "a water tower politely subsiding into the earth, its legs splayed like a heron attempting yoga" effectively channel Pratchett's distinctive blend of the mundane and the absurd. The author creates vivid imagery through unexpected similes and metaphors that both amuse and illuminate. Character development is handled well within the constraints of a short story. Midas embodies the "hapless protagonist with a knack for trouble" archetype perfectly, while Chewy transcends being merely a cute sidekick by revealing unexpected capabilities. Their relationship feels genuine despite its unusual nature. The plot structure follows the prompt's requirements, with a clear mission, complications, and return. The pacing is generally effective, though the middle section with the refuge discovery and trap door sequence feels slightly rushed compared to the more leisurely opening and closing sections. Dialogue is sparse but effective, with Chewy's limited vocabulary being used creatively to convey different meanings in different contexts. The internal monologue of Midas provides much of the story's humor and philosophical musings. The prose occasionally risks becoming purple or overwrought with its metaphorical density, but generally stays on the right side of the line, maintaining Pratchett's balance of profundity and absurdity. A few passages could be tightened for clarity and impact. The ending strikes an appropriate tone of cautious optimism without being incongruently positive given the post-apocalyptic setting. The transformation of Chewy (revealing unexpected abilities) is somewhat abrupt but not entirely unearned given the hints about his mysterious nature. Overall, this is a strong piece that captures the requested style and narrative structure while creating engaging characters and a vivid post-apocalyptic world. It successfully balances humor with moments of genuine emotion and philosophical reflection. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 16 Emotionally Complex: 15 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 6 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 16 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 16.0, Emotionally Complex: 15.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 6.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 16.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Romance: Love in the Limelight — Score: 90.5
Prompt:
Romance: Love in the Limelight. Write one scene within a larger story set in Wales. A famous (fictional) actor ducks into a small-town bookstore to escape paparazzi. The scene takes us through the characters meeting in this odd circumstance. Over the course of the scene, the actor and the bookstore owner have a conversation charged by an undercurrent of unspoken chemistry. Write the actor as somewhat of a rogue with a fragile ego, which needs to be fed by having everyone like him. He is thoroughly charming, but the bookstore owner seems (at least superficially) immune to this; which paradoxically provokes a genuine attraction and derails the charm offensive. The bookstore owner, despite the superficial rebuffs of the actor's charm, is inwardly more than a little charmed and flustered despite themselves. Write primarily in dialogue, in the distinct voices of each character. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The bell over the door gave its polite little chime, and a gust of damp Pembrokeshire air carried in the smell of wet tarmac and something like seaweed. A man slipped inside and pushed the door with his shoulder until it shut. He leaned his back against it, shutting out the mutter of voices outside, the click-click of lenses, the squeak of trainers on rain. “Tell me you’ve got a back room,” he said, breathless, almost laughing. “Or a trapdoor. I’ll take a trapdoor.” “We’ve got a staff toilet. It locks, even,” the bookseller said. “But I’m not a speakeasy.” He took the room in at speed. Old floorboards. A crooked row of poetry with a hand-lettered sign that said Local. A faded poster of Dylan Thomas above the till. The cat asleep in the window was a puddle of grey with one ear twitching. He took in the proprietor as well; she stood behind the counter with a pencil tucked behind her ear and her cardigan sleeves shoved up nearly to the elbow. Her hair was a sensible knot that had lost an argument with the weather hours ago. He straightened from the door. “I’ll buy something, then. To justify the sanctuary.” “Sanctuary implies you’ll be quiet.” She tipped her head toward the front. There was a restless shuffling of bodies beyond the glass. “Are they going to start licking the windows?” “God, please no. I haven’t yet reached Licking-The-Window-Level fame.” He came closer, hands lifted in mock surrender. “Hi. I’m—” “I know.” Her face didn’t change. “I read the newspaper.” “Ah.” He winced, but with a grin attached, a practiced charm softened by something genuine. “Not my best press week.” “Or your ninth.” She gestured to a little handwritten sign: Do Not Knock On The Glass: Cat Works Nights. “Stay away from the window.” “Threaten me with a working cat, why don’t you.” He ducked his head, drew the hood of his jacket down. Hair, deliberately careless; cheekbones assigned by committee. He moved like a man accustomed to being watched and trying to make a joke of it. “Look, just—two minutes. I’ll disappear into Poetry. No one follows a person into Poetry. It’s like church.” “Local section is the end of that aisle. It creaks.” She slid a bookmark across the counter like a bartender offering a napkin. “If you ruin the display, you’ll be banished to the toilet.” He palm-saluted with two fingers. “Noted.” He went down the aisle, put his hand on the top of a shelf and leaned into it, breathing in through his nose, out through his mouth. The shop made little noises at him: paper settling, the rain stippling the window. He seemed surprised by it. “Aberteifi Bookshop,” he said, almost to himself, reading the gold letters on the till. “I shot a scene on the quay once. I nearly fell in because I was trying to impress a gull.” “The quay or the gull?” “The gull. The quay was unmoved. He was, too; can’t say I blame him.” He set his fingers on the spines as if they’d burn. “I haven’t been in a bookshop without a camera crew since—" “Since your agent told you to be photographed buying Zadie Smith?” The bookseller drifted from behind the counter, a broom in hand she didn’t use, more prop than purpose. “We do sell Zadie, if it helps your image.” “My image is a tire fire at the moment,” he said cheerfully, turning a shoulder to the window. “I like the idea of simply being here for the smell. Old paper. Damp wool.” “Damp actor,” she said. He laughed, startled. “Touché.” He slid a book from the shelf—poems by R.S. Thomas—and let it fall open. “Do you like him?” “I like that he doesn’t pretend to like me,” she said. “There’s a relief in that.” “I’m not pretending,” he said, looking up. “So you do like me.” His grin pulled slow. “I like most people. Personally. Professionally. It’s become mutually advantageous.” “And yet none of them are in here with you.” She nodded to the window, where a face pressed too close to the glass, wavered, and withdrew. “Scary shop lady with broom: more intimidating than twenty paps.” “Is that who you are?” “Depends on who you are.” He shut the book carefully and slid it back. “My name’s Rowan.” “I know.” She rested the broom on the counter. “I’m Nia.” “Nia.” He tried it on. “Proper Welsh. How many letters do I need to buy to get you to pronounce the town for me?” “YouTube exists,” she said. Then, a merciful tiny smile. “Aberteifi.” “Aber…” He let the rest go. “Fine. I’ll just call it ‘the place I hid in a bookshop and wasn’t yelled at.’” “I haven’t decided yet,” she said. “You’re currently on probation.” He put a hand to his heart. “Probation hurts.” He wandered toward a table with staff recommendations. A handwritten card: If you’ve ever wanted to run away and become a beekeeper, this one will cure you or encourage you, depending on your temperament. “Who writes these?” “I do. My staff consists of me and the cat, and she has terrible taste.” “Cat: influencer. Owner: bitter gatekeeper.” He glanced back at her. “You’re not going to ask for a selfie?” “No.” “Autograph? For your niece?” “No niece.” “Secretly a fan who’s punishing me as foreplay?” “Absolutely not.” He laughed again and then seemed, abruptly, to enjoy not being met in the usual way. His shoulders loosened around it. He lifted a book gingerly, like a pianist touching a chipped key. “You ever think about it? The way people make you into a shape that fits their hand?” “All the time,” Nia said. “It’s why I own the shop. In here, I get to make my own shapes.” “And enforce them with a broom.” “It’s multipurpose.” “They teach you that in boss school?” “My mother taught me that with a wooden spoon,” she said. “Same principle, more soup.” He let his fingers skim over another book. Local history: chapels and quarrymen, a sepia photograph of women in headscarves with eyes that saw promises and weather equally. He softened. “My grandmother was from here,” he said, voice gentler. “Well—not here, but up the road. Teifi valley. She used to tell me when I got too big for myself, ‘Remember, bach, the cows do not care about your applause.’” “She sounds like a very sensible woman.” “She was terrifying.” He smiled into the memory, then let it fade. “She died the year I got the first big job. I think about that sometimes. How she never saw the thing. Which is—dramatic of me. I know. She saw me. That’s the thing, isn’t it.” Nia watched him watching the book he wasn’t really seeing. “Maybe she was spared the tabloids.” “Oh, God.” He tipped his head back. “Do not let me imagine my gran reading about me leaving a nightclub via a flowerpot.” “You left a nightclub via a flowerpot.” “I left via the door. I was photographed in an ambiance of flowerpot. Subtle but critical difference.” “Mm.” He flicked her a look. “You don’t like me.” “I don’t know you.” “That’s worse,” he said lightly, but there was a thread of truth that tugged. “Usually by now I’ve charmed the postal clerk, the hedgehog on the verge, most of the population of a rugby club.” “Congratulations. You’re very good at being liked.” She came closer and took the book from his half-reluctant hand, set it back correctly. “It’s an unpleasant skill to lose.” He studied her. “You talk like someone who lost it.” “Didn’t have it,” she said. “Or didn’t want it. Those are different things. You can work that out when you’re not an ambiance of flowerpot.” He leaned his hip against the table. The charm he usually wore like a coat felt too heavy; he shrugged it off, a fraction. “I’m not very good when people don’t—” He gestured, helpless, toward his own face. “When they don’t do the thing. Smile back. It makes me—useless.” “Vulnerable?” “Hungry,” he said, and then laughed at himself, a little bitten-off sound. “I’m not a vampire.” “No. You’re a person. It’s worse.” “Is it?” “Vampires don’t get lonely.” She set the broom aside. “I own a bookshop because it let me be around people without—” She lifted a shoulder. “Without being in the middle. I used to teach. You don’t ever really leave the middle when you teach.” He looked at her, properly now. “What did you teach?” “English. I had a boy who used to sleep through the first ten minutes of every lesson, head down on his desk. It made me furious, at first. Then I found out why. He was up late—every night—keeping his little sister awake until their dad passed out.” Her tone had changed, but only in the way a person’s voice changes when they remember and the remembering pulls at the knots under the ribs. “He was eleven. He’d learned how to make jokes hard enough to bounce off.” Rowan’s expression altered; the easy lines in his face belonged to a different script now. “Did you—” “I bought him alarm clocks. I bought him breakfast in the classroom and a plant that would die if you didn’t water it, so he could keep something alive.” She kept her eyes on the poetry shelf so she didn’t have to see his face. “He left anyway. You can do the things and you can still lose. I’m not sure if being liked would have helped. Maybe. Maybe not.” “Do you know what happened to him?” Rowan’s voice had softened enough that his own public rhythm—pauses for applause, light for the camera—was nowhere. “No,” she said. “That’s the terrible thing, isn’t it? You don’t get epilogues. You get afternoons where the light slants through between the stacks and someone slips in out of the rain, and then the bell rings and they go. The rest is guesswork.” He blew out a breath that wasn’t a laugh. “I get epilogues,” he said after a moment. “People write them for me in articles. They decide the arc. I don’t get afternoons.” “You could,” she said. He glanced toward the window. The faces had thinned, bored perhaps, rain-battered. “I don’t know what to do with one.” “Buy a book.” She picked one up and pressed it lightly against his chest. A novel with a cover that promised nothing obvious. “Here. It’s quieter than you. That’s a challenge.” He looked at the cover. “Is it about—” “No,” she said. “It’s about someone who wants to run away and does, and then is disappointed to find themselves still present.” He barked a laugh that wasn’t entirely a laugh. “Subtle.” “Staff pick.” “I prefer your beekeeper one. At least there are bees.” “There are bees in this one. Metaphorical.” “I’m allergic to metaphors.” “Everyone is, at first,” she said. “Cash or card?” He looked puzzled, endearingly. “You’re actually selling me a book.” “This is a shop. It’s what we do.” He reached into his jacket and came up with a wallet that seemed like a prop from his own life. “Card.” She took it. Their fingers didn’t touch. He noticed anyway. He watched her, and she felt it like sun through a window you forgot was there. She pretended the machine was temperamental; it always was. The receipt spat out with a small sigh. “Would you like a bag?” “I would like a back door,” he said. “But I’ll take a bag.” “There’s the alley through the stockroom,” she said. “It opens onto the lane behind Mrs. Evans’s bakery. If you keep your head down and pretend to be a delivery boy, you might get a free custard slice.” “I can pretend to be anything,” he said lightly, but he was already tired of it, and she could tell. He took the bag. He didn’t look at his name, scrawled by other people on other things. “Do you sign inside covers?” he asked suddenly. “As the person who chose it?” “You want me to sign your book.” “It’s not a selfie,” he said, aiming for teasing and almost getting somewhere more honest. “It’s—context.” She considered him for a beat that contained five other beats. Then she took the book back, opened it to the title page, and wrote, in her tidy hand: For Rowan, who knows about afternoons. Be kind to the bees, even the metaphorical ones. —Nia. She dated it. The ink bled slightly into the paper, the way ink had always bled and always would. He read it, and his face changed again, some small flaring of relief like a match catching. “You’ve mentioned bees twice,” he said. “Should I be concerned?” “No.” She slid the book into the bag and handed it back. “Yes. Depends on your temperament. And on the day.” He smiled like a person, not like a poster. “Nia,” he said, her name a little softer this time. “If I—if I come back when there aren’t twenty men with cameras doing Pilates outside, will you—” “Sell you another book? Threaten you with a broom?” “Talk to me like I’m not a tire fire.” “Depends.” She held his gaze and watched the print of who he was settle differently across his features. “On whether you say please.” He touched two fingers to the brim of a hat he wasn’t wearing. “Please.” Her mouth made a decision without asking her. “All right. Tuesdays are quiet. Bring your own epilogue.” He let out a breath he might not have known he was keeping. He angled himself toward the stockroom. The cat woke and flicked a considering eye at him; he ducked his head to her, too. “Thanks for not licking the window,” he said softly. Nia rolled her eyes and pretended she wasn’t smiling. He paused at the door to the back, hand on the peeling paint. From outside, a shout, the grind of a van. “I do that thing,” he said, without looking at her. “Turn everything into a performance. Even this. I can’t help it. And sometimes I’m so—afraid—that when it stops, there won’t be anything underneath.” He turned then, quick, as though he’d surprised himself and wanted to see what she did with the rawness he’d just lobbed between them. “There. That’s my bees.” She met his look. The broom was something to hold. The shop was something to stand in. “Then you’re lucky,” she said, and made it sound like a fact rather than comfort. “Because shops like this exist. Because Tuesdays exist. Because you can practice. Being something underneath. Or just—being. There’s no exam.” “No grade?” “No grade.” “I was a solid B student.” “Try for a C. Average is underrated.” He laughed, openly, then pushed through the stockroom. The door swung shut behind him, soft as a page turning. The bell over the front door didn’t ring again. The rain went on. Nia set the broom down and leaned her elbows on the counter and pressed her fingers against the edge of the till until they hurt. Then she picked up the bookmark he hadn’t taken and slid it between the pages of the R.S. Thomas he’d touched, which was ridiculous and therefore she did it. After a while, the rest of the day came back. Someone came in for a map. Someone else wanted a gift for a grandmother who loved crime. The cat dreamed. The ink dried on the title page of a book headed out into the lane behind Mrs. Evans’s bakery, into the custard slice air. Later, when the light slanted through between the stacks, the bell rang again. But that was another afternoon. This one stayed where it was.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a charming bookshop meet-cute with excellent attention to the Welsh setting and character dynamics. The author has crafted two distinct voices that reveal character through dialogue rather than exposition. Rowan, the actor, displays the fragile ego and charm offensive requested in the prompt, while Nia, the bookshop owner, maintains a superficial immunity that gradually softens. The dialogue shines as the primary storytelling vehicle. Each exchange reveals character while advancing the narrative. Rowan's practiced charm ("I'll take a trapdoor") contrasts with Nia's dry wit ("I'm not a speakeasy"). Their verbal sparring feels natural and builds tension effectively. The writer excels at showing rather than telling. Instead of stating that Rowan is charming but insecure, we see it in his reactions to Nia's immunity to his fame. His vulnerability emerges organically when he admits, "I'm not very good when people don't—" and later confesses his fear that without performance, "there won't be anything underneath." The Welsh setting is established through specific details: Pembrokeshire air, Dylan Thomas poster, the Welsh name "Aberteifi," and references to the Teifi valley. These elements ground the scene in a specific place without overwhelming the narrative. The prose balances descriptive richness with restraint. Sensory details like "the smell of wet tarmac and something like seaweed" and "the cat asleep in the window was a puddle of grey" create atmosphere without becoming purple. The writing maintains a consistent tone throughout—slightly literary but accessible. Character development is particularly strong. Both characters reveal deeper layers as the scene progresses. Nia's story about her teaching days provides emotional depth and explains her current life choices. Rowan's mention of his grandmother humanizes him beyond the celebrity persona. The ending avoids cliché by not resolving the attraction completely. Instead, it offers a promise of "another afternoon," leaving the reader with a satisfying sense of possibility rather than an unearned conclusion. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally, a metaphor might be slightly overworked ("a sensible knot that had lost an argument with the weather"). The piece could perhaps be tightened in a few places where the dialogue becomes slightly philosophical, but these moments also serve to deepen character. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted scene that fulfills all the prompt requirements while creating authentic characters and genuine emotional resonance. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Whalepunk fantasy: The Morska Conspiracy — Score: 89.3
Prompt:
Whalepunk fantasy The Morska Conspiracy The Morska thieves guild experiences a sudden power vacuum as its leader was arrested in a raid in the early hours of the morning. Aya, a young woman born into aristocracy, has a keen interest in both the sciences and the arcane, having inherited her mother's gift for immateria magick (an outlawed practice for which her mother was, regrettably, hanged by the neck). Aya, bored with the world of aristocracy, has been spending her nights moonlighting with this very guild (masked, naturally). Leveraging her latent ability to summon dark entities from the immateria, she quickly rose through the ranks of the guild. Now, recognising the opportunity of the sudden power vacuum, Aya and her close companions Katra and Simeon, make a play for heart of the guild's claim to power: an ancient scythan artifact, under guard of spell and key in the depths of the guild hq. In contrast with the desperate chaos they had navigated thus far, the entrance to the underhold felt suddenly too quiet. Aya braces herself and reaches for the door. Write the next scene as the trio enter the underhold and find themselves confronted by none other than the guild leader herself, decidedly *un*-incarcerated, and in possession of both weapons and bodyguards. Paint a vivid picture of of the confrontation. Story beats: Aya is captured and unmasked. The trio are captured. Aya attempts to stall their demise by negotiating on her value as a hostage -- as she grapples with the inevitable consequences of her role in the guild being brought to light. Incorporate dialogue in the authentic voices of the characters. Do not write a fight scene. Lean into the gritty Victorian aesthetic with the dialogue & worldbuilding, as well as elements of gothic horror. In this world, men trust brass and oil and steel; magicka is feared and barely understood. Write in third person past tense, incorporating both Aya's internal monologue, and a heavy dialogue component. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The underhold breathed like an old animal, all wet stone and whale-fat smoke, a cavern burrowed beneath canals and rat-worked bracing. The smell of rancid oil sat heavy in the throat. Pipes stuttered and sighed as if the walls themselves plotted. Aya’s gloved hand hovered over the iron ring of the door. Her pulse picked out a pattern in her wrists—three beats, pause, three beats—echoing the harbor foghorn that moaned distantly through the city. Three long complaints, swallowed by the depth. “Quiet as a confession,” Simeon whispered behind her, breath sweet with peppermint to hide the gin. “I don’t like it.” Katra said nothing. Katra never liked any of it; she only came alive inside trouble, jaw set, the scar at her temple a pale hyphen in the lantern light. Aya felt their watchfulness like an additional skin over her own. Beneath that, the old chill stirred—the immateria pressing close against her collarbones, a folded, silent thing which smelled of bare iron and damp linen. She let it rest. “Ready,” she said, and pitched the word into the iron and gaslight like a coin. She pulled the door. It yawned open without argument, a draft breathing over them bearing the smell of old sea, of ambergris and salt rot and gunmetal, and something else beneath like candle smoke left in an enclosed room too long. Lanterns burned steady within, golden, untroubled. The underhold had been kept like a chapel—catalogued crates, ledger-stacked tables, walls veined with pipes delivering heat that throbbed faintly through the floorstones. Their footfalls answered themselves—one-two-three—further than they should have, swallowed and returned thin at the edges. Aya’s stomach turned a little. She had expected snoring guards, a lonely rat, a lock to tickle. She had expected the anxious improvisations of men who’d been caught flat-footed by dawn raids. She had not expected order. “There,” Katra said, chin tipping. The artifact’s vault. Every thief in Morska had a clue-sketch of this door in their pocket once, a child’s ghost story mad-lib: the vault that was more story than iron. Aya had touched its mind before, once. It had been like laying her palm to a whale’s skin—a vast cold recognition, a weight that thought only slowly. Now it stood ajar. Aya checked her breath. “After you,” she said, dryly, to the universe. She crossed the threshold. “Welcome home, little masks.” The voice was warm and amused and not at all incarcerated. Aya stopped. The immateria went suddenly sharp along her ribs like a well-sharpened hook. She lifted her eyes. The guild’s leader—Matron Vesa, called the Whale Widow by those fond of legends—stood at the far end of the chamber before the open vault mouth, not three paces from the Scythan artifact’s sarcophagus. Vesa wore a black coat unbuttoned to show the steel bones of a corset that had been reinforced with whale rib and brass plates. Her hair lay in a severe gray plait, and her neck was wrapped in a kerchief the exact color of arterial blood. She held a pistol in one hand and a long knife in the other. Behind her, her bodyguards assembled like lantern-men at a funeral: six shadows, all brass knuckles and flat eyes, along with two longcoats whose collars hid the throats of men who smiled at strangulation. Their weapons did not waver. Simeon’s breath left him like a prayer. “But the raid—” Vesa’s smile was a small, tidy thing. “My love. We do raids, too.” She glanced at Aya’s hand still on the door. “Close it for me, won’t you? I find drafts so tiresome.” Aya obeyed. The door swung, shut with a sigh and a quiver of gaslight. She lifted her chin. She felt the immateria like a coiled rope in a dark room behind her eyes, and knew it was watching her watch it. Not now, she told it. Not here, not with brass staring. “Matron,” Aya said. She took a single step forward. She could feel Katra on her left, Simeon on her right, a triangulated survival. “We were worried I’d missed you.” “Worried,” Vesa repeated, as if tasting the word. She lifted her pistol, and the lanterns gleamed along it like teeth. “Unmask.” Aya felt the air in the room become an instrument on which someone plucked a single string. The sound vibrated along her spine. Simeon half-turned his head to her. Katra’s hand slid towards her belt; Vesa cocked the pistol lazily, as if swatting a fly. “Please,” Vesa said, not unkind. “If the court is to sit, we shan’t have actors hiding their faces. Unmask, or I will have the skin taken with the cloth. For cleanliness.” Aya reached up. Her fingers moved like they belonged to someone else. The leather buckles had been fitted by her own hands, a hundred midnight dressings; she knew every stitch. She loosened them. The mask released, a soft sigh of sweat-salt and perfume. Her hair fell, pins scattering like small finches. She set the mask in her palm, and for a ridiculous instant thought to offer it to Vesa like a calling card. Vesa’s mouth quirked. “Oh,” she said, as if Aya had told a particularly good joke. The guards stared in polite confusion. Simeon swore between his teeth. “Aya—” “Don’t,” Katra muttered. “Don’t say her name. Heavens preserve us.” Vesa tapped the pistol against her cheek. “Aristocrat,” she said conversationally. “Which house? No, don’t tell me. I like to guess. The nose says Wolk. The mouth says Sevrin. And the eyes…” She peered. “The eyes say—you’ve seen something you shouldn’t have and decided to keep seeing it.” Aya’s face was bare as a cuffed wrist. Her mother’s noose-scar that was not a scar lay braided into the back of her skull, a memory that was sensation more than mark: the crack of the trap, the way the world goes very quiet when a life is weighed by rope. She tasted copper, though her mouth was dry. “Matron,” she repeated. “You asked for unmasking. Now we’re all honest.” “We aren’t,” Vesa said. “But we can pretend for an evening.” She gestured with the knife. The guards moved forward. It was theater, but practiced theater. Katra made the sort of motion that might have become a lunge; a pair of knuckles found her wrist and her elbow at the same time. She made a short sound and went down with an economy that was not quite grace. Simeon didn’t struggle. He had grown up with ropes. He lifted his hands and let them be bound, his eyes on Aya, his mouth a flat white line. Aya considered the immateria. It lifted its head in her chest. She might have brought something up out of it—a moth-faced thing with hands like candle-flames, a little hunger to gnaw the edge of a blade. To do it would be to paint a target on her soul in lampblack. To do it would be to fail in a new way. She let the rope come. It bit her gloves. A guard—Maej, the one with the narrow eyes—took her hair in his fist, not harshly, only for movement, and she walked as he directed. Vesa watched her as one watches a chessboard that has come alive. “You’ve been a delight,” she said. “All you little night-birds with your stolen science and your pretty tricks. Maskless, you are even more diverting.” “You knew,” Aya said. “Of course I knew. I know everyone who thinks to steal my teeth.” Vesa indicated the sarcophagus with the knife. The Scythan artifact lay within like a coffin for a giant’s child. Its surface was not quite stone, not quite bone. It had whorls that changed if you looked twice. The air around it was colder by precisely the weight of a coin lifted from a palm. “You thought to take this and then take me. In that order? Bold.” “We thought to protect it,” Aya said, and heard how it sounded. “To put it beyond your reach.” “Do you imagine I am ignorant of my own reach?” Vesa’s voice did not rise. “I’ve dipped my hands in the stomach of the city. I wash them in whale grease. I keep them clean.” She lifted her chin at Meaj. “Turn her.” The guard obliged, spinning Aya to face her companions. Simeon’s hair had come loose from its ribbon; Katra’s lip leaked one thin black line in the gaslight. They looked like children in their first mischief. They looked like soldiers left too long in a trench. Aya let herself imagine for a moment what the papers would say when the name went up. The Governor’s girl? The late Lady Severin’s daughter? She saw her mother again, not on the gallows but standing at the kitchen hearth with a bowl of eels, saying softly, It will take you if you let it. Her mother had meant the hunger. Or the city. Or both. “Now,” Vesa said. She walked closer. If she reached out, she might have put the barrel of the pistol against Aya’s bare cheek. She did not. “We are at a crossroads. I have in my hand a little trouble—” she lifted the knife slightly “—and in the other, a great deal more.” The pistol tilted. “You do not yet appreciate the trouble you represent, little Wolk-Sevrin. But I do.” Aya wet her lips. “Then let’s appreciate it together.” She felt the immateria flare a cold interest, like a cat setting its paws on a sill. “You kill me now, Vesa, and half the city will come for your doors before night. Not because they loved my face, but because they feared the man who did.” Her voice did not shake. She was dimly aware that her knees wanted very much to give up. “Or you keep me breathing, and you have a shield. The governor does not lay siege to a house where his last daughter eats her porridge.” “Hostage,” Vesa said. Her eyebrow ticked as if she were amused by a private rhyme. “You bargain in your own blood.” “It’s the most negotiable currency I have left.” Simeon made a strangled noise. “Aya—” “Shut up,” Katra hissed. Then, quieter: “She’s right.” Vesa drifted a step nearer. “And what will you do, little witch, if I say no? Will you call your mother’s friends?” The word witch was not spat; it was almost tender. “Will you draw something across the threshold?” Her smile did not touch her eyes. “Do you think I haven’t kept salt in every corner? Do you think I don’t know the smell of that cold in you?” Aya felt herself flush, as if Vesa had undressed her again, this time from the inside. She forced herself to keep her gaze steady. “I don’t need to call anyone,” she lied. “I am what I am, and that should frighten you.” “It does,” Vesa said, and there was a strange honesty in it. “It frightens me that you are young and sure, that you have never paid the tax for what you touch. It frightens me that men will stampede with brass and oil to crush you and I will be beneath their hooves if I shelter you.” She turned the pistol away, finally, and rested it against her own thigh, as if the weight soothed her. “It frightens me that I like you.” Aya blinked. Something loosened in her chest that was not relief. The foghorn in the harbor called again—one, two, three—each a note long enough to be a prayer if one believed in sound. “Keep me,” Aya said. “Use me. Send a note to the Governor’s House. Tell him you have me and that I am alive and that I will stay that way so long as he does not bleed you.” She tasted the word, felt its shape. “We both know he would wreck half Morska to make an example. I can be your stay of execution.” “And your friends?” Vesa asked, without looking at them. “You keep them as well,” Aya said. Katra made a fierce sound; Simeon’s eyes softened with something that made Aya want to look away. “They are nothing to the great houses. They are nothing to the men with ledgers. But they are something to me. And if you keep me breathing, you keep them breathing. And if you kill them—” She made her voice slow and careful, as if she were placing weights on a scale. “—I will take that as a declaration. And I will declare in turn. I cannot promise the city won’t eat us all then.” Vesa considered. It was a slow, visible thing, like the tide acknowledging the moon. She sheathed the knife with a soft, precise sound. The room breathed. The lamplight guttered, recovered. “Meaj,” Vesa said. “Take them to the white rooms. Clean their wounds. Feed them something warm and honest. Bread. I want a letter carried to the House with care. We will wrap it in ribbon. No rough edges. Have the boys clean their boots.” “And the artifact?” one of the longcoats asked, eyes flicking to the sarcophagus as if it might sit up. “The artifact will do as it has always done,” Vesa said serenely. “Sleep and dream of burning water.” Her gaze returned to Aya. “As will we.” Meaj tugged at Aya’s bonds, not unkind. They began to move. Aya caught Vesa’s eye one last time. In it, she saw a narrow bridge over a black canal. She saw herself balanced on it, a rope at her neck and a city at her feet, and she had the sudden absurd certainty that everyone who mattered was watching to see if she would step left or right. “Matron,” she said, unable not to. “Little mask,” Vesa said. “Do not call for the dark in my house unless you mean to feed it. Do we understand one another?” Aya swallowed. “Yes.” “Good.” Vesa looked to the door of the vault, to the thing that slept inside. “The sea keeps its own books,” she murmured. “And the city keeps its receipts.” The foghorn moaned again, very far away, three long cries like a mother calling names at dusk. The underhold inhaled and exhaled, and Aya let herself be led into the white rooms, her face bare, her name a blade turned inward, her bargains written in invisible ink that would glow, she suspected, only when the fire came.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece demonstrates exceptional skill in creating a richly atmospheric whalepunk fantasy world. The author has crafted a scene that perfectly captures the requested Victorian gothic horror aesthetic while maintaining the specific worldbuilding elements requested in the prompt. The prose is particularly strong in its sensory details and atmospheric quality. Descriptions like "The underhold breathed like an old animal, all wet stone and whale-fat smoke" immediately establish both setting and tone. The author skillfully weaves in the whalepunk elements through references to "whale grease," "whale rib," and the artifact that dreams of "burning water." These details create a cohesive world that feels lived-in and authentic. Character voices are distinct and well-developed. Vesa's dialogue carries authority and a certain world-weary wisdom, while Aya's internal monologue reveals her aristocratic background and magical connection. The supporting characters, Katra and Simeon, have less dialogue but still emerge as distinct personalities through their reactions and brief exchanges. The confrontation unfolds with excellent pacing. Rather than rushing to action, the author builds tension through the unexpected discovery of Vesa's presence and the subsequent unmasking of Aya. The negotiation scene is particularly well-handled, with Aya's desperate bargaining revealing both her quick thinking and vulnerability. The immateria magic system is subtly integrated, described as "a folded, silent thing which smelled of bare iron and damp linen" and later as something that "flare[s] a cold interest, like a cat setting its paws on a sill." These descriptions effectively convey both the nature of the magic and society's fear of it without resorting to exposition. The piece does occasionally veer into purple prose, with some metaphors feeling slightly overworked. For instance, "She saw herself balanced on it, a rope at her neck and a city at her feet, and she had the sudden absurd certainty that everyone who mattered was watching to see if she would step left or right" is evocative but somewhat overwrought. The dialogue is generally strong, though occasionally characters speak in ways that feel slightly too poetic for natural conversation. However, this stylistic choice aligns with the Victorian gothic aesthetic requested in the prompt. The ending effectively leaves the situation unresolved but with clear stakes established. Aya has negotiated a temporary reprieve, but the final image of "her bargains written in invisible ink that would glow, she suspected, only when the fire came" suggests future complications and dangers. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted response that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt while creating a compelling narrative with rich worldbuilding, distinct characters, and atmospheric prose. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 4 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 4.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Gunpowder Rendezvous — Score: 88.7
Prompt:
Gunpowder Rendezvous Spike Spiegel & Revy Write a story where Spike Spiegel (Cowboy Bebop) and Revy (Black Lagoon) meet in a seedy bar after both being hired for the same bounty. Their mutual attraction is complicated by their trust issues and competitive instincts. Include drinking, gunplay, and unresolved sexual tension that culminates in a motel room standoff. **Spike Spiegel (Cowboy Bebop)** Spike is a laid-back bounty hunter with a dark past as a syndicate enforcer. He practices Jeet Kune Do and is exceptionally skilled with firearms. He's chronically broke, constantly hungry, and addicted to cigarettes. Despite his carefree attitude, he's haunted by his past and the woman he left behind. He has a prosthetic eye from a past injury that affects his depth perception. He's fatalistic to the extreme, often saying he's already died once. He values freedom above all else and dislikes attachments, though he secretly cares deeply for his crew. Famous quote: "Whatever happens, happens." **Revy/Rebecca Lee (Black Lagoon)** Revy is a Chinese-American dual-wielding gunslinger with unparalleled shooting skills. She's foul-mouthed, chain-smoking, and has severe anger management issues stemming from childhood abuse. She's known as "Two Hands" for her ability to accurately fire two pistols simultaneously. She drinks heavily and solves most problems with violence. Despite her hardened exterior, she has moments of vulnerability, particularly around Rock. She has a dragon tattoo covering her right arm and typically wears extremely short shorts and a black crop top regardless of the situation. Famous quote: "I'm not a good person, not a bad person. I'm just here." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The jukebox in the corner keeps coughing up the same scratchy rock riff, a needle stuck in the same groove of a dead night. Neon bleeds down the stained wallpaper, turning the smoke into a slow aurora. Glasses clink, security cams blink, and the air tastes like old whiskey and ashtrays. Spike Spiegel leans on the bar, a cigarette pinned to his lip like it’s the last one he’ll ever have. He’s down to lint and loose rounds in his pocket, and even those might be metaphorical. He asks the bartender for something cheap and gets something cheaper. It burns through his chest like a joke that doesn’t land. By the time she walks in, the room already smells like gun oil and promise. Revy slides through the doorway without slowing down, a slice of heat in a black crop top and denim cut-offs, dragon ink curling down her right arm. Two pistols ride her hips like old friends. She orders a bottle she doesn’t intend to share and tips the neck back too far, like she’s daring the liquor to try her. The jukebox stutters. The same riff loops. No one dances. They don’t turn toward each other. Not at first. But both notice. Predators always do. The bounty is a mid-level courier with a new alias and an old habit of talking too much. The rumor is he skipped out with something heavy on his drive—a ledger with enough names to sink a city. The bounty is good. It’s almost generous. That means there’s a trap in it somewhere. “So,” Spike says to his drink, exhaling smoke through the word. “You ever feel like the universe is trying to introduce you to someone you’re better off never knowing?” Revy doesn’t answer, because he wasn’t talking to her. But she hears him, because she was listening anyway. “The universe?” She snorts, takes another pull, shifts her weight so the holsters hang just right. “Buddy, that heap of junk never did me any favors.” Their eyes meet in the warped mirror behind the bottles. One brown and alive with temper, one mismatched, one dead and dreaming. His depth perception’s off, but his aim never is. She clocks the cigarette, the lazy posture, the jacket that’s seen weather and blood. He clocks the smirk, the scars, the stance that says “I’ll go first, but I’ll shoot you before I do.” They turn, simultaneously, as if pulled by the same bad idea. “You that guy?” Revy asks. The words are gravel, stained and sharp. “The one who always looks like he’s about to take a nap in a gutter?” Spike smiles. It’s not nice, but it’s honest. “Depends. You the girl whose guns do all her flirting?” “That’s cute,” she says, and it’s not. “Name’s not your business.” “Good thing I wasn’t asking.” She tilts the bottle at him, teasing the mouth of it across her lip. “We both after the same package, cowboy?” Spike glances at the TV above the bar where a muted news feed shows a grainy mugshot and an old restaurant sign. The courier. Two blocks away, a flophouse where his kind always runs out of rope. “Seems that way.” “Then we got a problem.” “We?” Spike says. He gestures at the room, at the stale crowd that knows better than to look. “There’s no ‘we’ here.” The bar door creaks. Three men in coats that don’t fit their shoulders slip inside, eyes slick with nervousness. They’re carrying the kind of false confidence that comes in bulk when someone’s paying you by the hour. Revy doesn’t even glance, but she’s tracking them by the shuffle of their shoes. Spike ashes his cigarette and turns the glass, watching how the liquor clings to the sides. “What do you think?” Revy asks, not looking up. “Entrance fee?” “Amateurs,” Spike says. “They’re here to ask questions they won’t survive.” The first guy reaches into his coat. The jukebox hisses and stutters into the chorus again. The bar dips into that once-removed silence right before violence arrives. Revy moves before her bottle hits the floor. Two hands, two guns, and four shots crisp the air like the universe is clapping off-beat. The first thug staggers, the second drops his pistol and half his courage, the third tries to pull, duck, pull again. Her bullets find them in the middle of useless thoughts. Spike pivots on his stool, lazy turning into clean geometry. His pistol winks like a bored star, and the guy who thought he had a bead on Revy suddenly has a hole where his plan used to be. Bottles shatter. People scream but not too loudly—this is a bar with a reputation to maintain. The jukebox, oblivious, repeats the same four measures of guitar like a dog chasing its tail. Revy grins, feral and private. “Not bad, nap boy.” Spike rolls his shoulders. “You started without me.” “Wanted to see if you’d keep up.” They stand amid the debris. The bartender ducks, then pops up with a shotgun, which he keeps pointed at the ceiling because this is business, not suicide. “Take it outside,” he says, voice flat, already reaching for the mop. “Gladly,” Revy purrs, holstering with a flourish that’s almost mocking. She prowls toward the door. Spike pays in coins that clink like a dare. Some of them are real. Most are not. On the street, the neon bleeds into rain puddles. The flophouse sign two blocks down flickers like a dying lie. “You good?” Spike asks, tilting his chin at her shoulder. A graze. It had to be perfect to even touch her. It’s not bleeding much. She touched the muzzle to the mark before she holstered, like a cathedral kiss. “I’m always good,” she says. “Question is, you gonna try to poach my bounty?” “Poach?” Spike smiles with his eyes this time, which is a surprise even to him. “I’m more of a gatherer. Whatever happens, happens.” She laughs. It’s a sudden, ugly sound, peeled from someplace she trusts. “That how you excuse it? Whatever happens?” “Helps me sleep,” he says. “You look like you don’t sleep.” “Not well.” The sign across the street buzzes. A man leans out from a second-story window of the flophouse, squinting. He recognizes them as the end of his day and pulls back like a contused eye. Curtains twitch. Locks click. Revy thumbs a fresh mag into her pistols, a ritual with meaning only to her. “All right, gatherer. Winner takes the ledger. Loser buys the motel. Try not to get in my way.” “Ladies first,” Spike says. “Who told you I was a lady?” “No one,” he says, and he means it kindly. They cross the street like bad weather. The lobby smells like bleach covered a murder and then gave up. At the desk, a clerk watches them with the attentive apathy of the doomed. The stairs are too narrow for how much violence is going up them. They don’t bother whispering. The courier is in 2B, door barely latched, sweat varnishing the knob. The hallway is a wind tunnel of tension. Revy gestures, one-two with her fingers, and Spike nods because he’s seen this dance before and can follow without stepping on toes. One kick. The door snaps inward. Smoke, shouting, the word “Wait!” slicing thin air. Revy’s already inside, sliding left, shooting the lamp into sparks and the gun out of the courier’s hand in the same breath. Spike moves right, low, the flat pop of silenced fire from somewhere else—oh, there’s a fourth man, there’s always a fourth—answering too late. Spike’s return shot drills the wall, then the third bullet finds the man’s shoulder, spinning him into the bathroom tiles. “Down,” Revy snarls, and the courier obliges by falling onto a mattress that looks like a memory of sleep. He scrabbles for a bag that isn’t there. “Ledger,” Spike says, calm and tired, standing over him with a gun like an accusation. Revy crouches, presses her muzzle to the courier’s cheek, and the smell of fear makes something old in her relax. “You hand it over, I don’t ventilate your face. I’m not a good person, not a bad person. I’m just here. You? You’re a paycheck.” The courier cries, and it’s not dignified. He points to the vent. Revy doesn’t waste time; she shoots the screws out. The ledger tumbles with the dust, a little black book trying to make itself invisible. Spike picks it up and flips through names written in a hand that knows it’s spilling blood. They share a look. The kind that says: careful. “Split?” Spike asks. “Ha,” Revy says. She holsters, then immediately draws again, because holstering was for punctuation. “I don’t split.” “That’s a shame,” Spike murmurs. “You look like you could.” Her eyes snag on his mouth. It takes a second for her to decide if she’s going to hit him or kiss him or shoot him. The jukebox riff, faint through the window from the bar below, nags like a recurring dream. Outside, sirens decide to consider whether they care. The problem with winning is the exit. They move fast, using their bodies like knives through the air. The hallway decided to grow neighbors with bad timing. Revy’s guns talk them into staying indoors. Spike’s hands find the right angles, a kick on a knee, a shove on a shoulder. The street yawns up at them when they burst out the back, and the rain thickens like it’s on their side. By the time they get to the motel, the ledger is sealed in a plastic bag, and the night has the metallic taste of choices. The motel isn’t the kind you bring your heart to. It’s the kind that expects you to leave parts behind. The clerk passes a key over like it’s a confession. Room 7. Lucky number for people who don’t think too hard. Inside, the air conditioner wheezes. The bedspread is a tapestry of stains and stories. They’re still breathing like they’re coming down off a song. Revy tosses her jacket onto the chair and kicks the door shut behind her. Spike slouches as only a man ready to snap upright can. The ledger sits on the table between them, a polite bomb. “Now,” Revy says, cocking her head, cigarette crooked between fingers. “About that split.” Spike lights her cigarette with his, a slow lean-in that’s almost a dare. She doesn’t blink. He feels the heat of her and the gravity of it. He looks tired and something else. The dragon on her arm flexes when she exhales. “Fifty-fifty,” Spike says. “You keep the lion’s share of the bullets. I get the paperwork.” “And if I say no?” He shrugs. “Whatever happens, happens.” She takes a step. He mirrors it. The air gets narrower. The ledger waits. The world outside grinds its teeth. “You think I won’t kill you for it?” Revy asks, voice hushed, hungry. “You think I won’t enjoy it?” “I think you’ll enjoy it either way,” Spike says, and it’s the first honest flirt they’ve allowed themselves. She laughs, quiet and sharp. “You’re not wrong.” The lights flicker. The sirens somewhere decide against them, for now. She presses the barrel of her right pistol into the soft spot beneath his sternum. He angles his own gun, center mass, his other hand free, fingers open like he’s about to catch rain. “On three,” she says, and doesn’t say what three is. “Sure,” he says, and doesn’t count. Silence. The same rock riff filters in through the thin walls, as if the jukebox found a way to haunt them. They breathe in sync for a heartbeat and then purposely fall out of it. Trust is a currency neither of them carries. “Say I take the book and go,” Revy says. “You going to chase me?” “Maybe,” Spike says. “Maybe I let you. Maybe I buy you breakfast.” “Breakfast is for mornings,” she says, eyes flicking to his mouth again. “We ain’t getting one of those.” “Not if we keep talking.” Something shifts. Not a truce. Not surrender. Just a place to stand where both can see the door and the ledger and each other. The barrels lower a hair. A breath. The distance between them shrinks to a coin’s thickness. He smells the smoke in her hair and the whiskey sweat on her skin. She sees the tired light in his eyes and the way he carries his death like an old joke. They edge into the kiss of it without touching, guns like chaperones. “Fifty-fifty,” she says again, barely. “Fifty-fifty,” he echoes. They don’t shake. They don’t kiss. They don’t holster. The ledger sits there like a choice neither wants to own alone. Outside, the neon gutter-blinks. Inside, the air conditioner coughs itself into sleep. Revy’s lip curls. “You’re trouble.” Spike’s smile is a tired blade. “You’re fun.” She smirks, cocks her pistol back to safe without moving it. He does the same. The stand-off doesn’t end so much as it agrees to continue later. “Tomorrow,” she says. “We cash it. Maybe we try that breakfast. Maybe I shoot you.” “Whatever happens,” he says. “Yeah,” Revy whispers, and the words feel like a lit match. “Whatever.” The jukebox riff finds them again, fading through drywall, refusing to change tracks. In the motel room haze, two wolves keep their guns up and their hearts back, each waiting for the other to make the first mistake or the first move, knowing they might be the same thing. The night stays long. The ledger doesn’t move. Neither do they. Not yet.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully captures the essence of both Spike Spiegel and Revy, creating a noir-tinged encounter that feels authentic to both characters and their respective universes. The author demonstrates a strong command of atmosphere, using sensory details to establish the seedy setting and maintaining the gritty tone throughout. The characterization is particularly strong. Spike's laid-back fatalism and Revy's aggressive, foul-mouthed demeanor are rendered faithfully. Their dialogue exchanges feel true to their established personalities, with Spike's philosophical detachment contrasting nicely with Revy's blunt pragmatism. The author captures their mannerisms well - Spike's slouching posture that belies his combat readiness, Revy's quick-draw shooting style with her dual pistols. The prose style effectively blends noir terseness with occasional poetic flourishes. Sentences like "Neon bleeds down the stained wallpaper, turning the smoke into a slow aurora" create vivid imagery without becoming overwrought. The author maintains a consistent voice throughout, with short, punchy sentences that accelerate during action sequences and more measured pacing during the tense standoffs. The unresolved sexual tension is handled with subtlety and restraint. Rather than forcing physical contact, the author builds tension through proximity, shared cigarette lighting, and lingering glances. The final standoff in the motel room perfectly encapsulates their mutual attraction complicated by distrust - guns pointed at each other even as they consider the possibility of something more. The action sequences are well-choreographed and economical, avoiding excessive detail while still conveying the characters' exceptional combat skills. The bar shootout in particular demonstrates both characters' abilities while establishing their different fighting styles. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. The recurring jukebox motif, while effective, becomes slightly repetitive. The plot itself is relatively straightforward, serving mainly as a vehicle for character interaction rather than offering surprising twists. However, this simplicity allows the character dynamics to remain the focus, which is appropriate given the prompt. The ending successfully maintains the tension without artificial resolution. Neither character fully trusts the other, yet they've reached a tentative arrangement that could lead to either cooperation or conflict. This ambiguity feels true to both characters and their established trust issues. Overall, this is an accomplished piece that demonstrates a deep understanding of both characters and their respective worlds, while successfully merging them into a cohesive narrative with authentic tension and chemistry. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Folk horror: Útiseta — Score: 88.7
Prompt:
Folk Horror: Útiseta Write a chapter set in rural northern Sweden in the mid-1990s. Linnea, a teenage girl from Stockholm, has reluctantly moved to a small village with her parents after her father's job transfer. She's befriended Astrid, a local girl who claims her grandmother taught her ancient practices passed down through generations. Astrid has been introducing Linnea to "midnight games" that involve old rituals, convincing her they can use them to learn classmates' secrets or influence their behavior. Tonight, Astrid has convinced Linnea to participate in Útiseta—sitting out on an ancient burial mound at midnight to "receive knowledge from beyond." The chapter focuses on this single midnight excursion, the ritualistic preparations, Astrid's matter-of-fact instructions that mix teenage rebellion with eerily specific traditional elements, and the mounting tension as Linnea becomes increasingly uncertain whether they're simply scaring themselves or if something is actually responding to their presence. The narrative should maintain ambiguity about whether the strange occurrences are supernatural or psychological, while establishing the dangerous line they're crossing by treating ancient practices as entertainment. First person, past tense, told as Linnea's recollection of events in the present day (though this device should be largely transparent). 1000 words. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
We walked without flashlights because Astrid said light offended them. “It’s like shining a torch in someone’s face,” she told me, her breath steaming white between us. The snowpack had crusted over and then frozen again into sugary granules that gave under our boots with a muted squeak. Above, the sky was pale and starless, the kind of high winter cloud that makes night feel like the underside of a lid. The birches were smudges, their white trunks indistinguishable from the snow except for the horizontal scars. I had grown up with car noise, lamp glow, neighbors arguing through walls. This silence pressed against my ears until even the creak of my coat became rude. We had a thermos and two blankets, an old tin box Astrid had taken from her mother’s sewing room, and a coil of red yarn. I carried everything because Astrid said I should. “If you want to request something, you have to bring the offerings,” she said, as if we were going to a shop and needed coins. We took the path that detoured behind the closed school and the frozen football field, past the rusted swings, into the forest that curled around the village like a sleeping animal. My parents thought I was sleeping over at Astrid’s. I had told them that with a shrug I practiced in the bathroom mirror. I didn’t have to try to be bored; the boredom had saturated me ever since we moved in October, when the days started to flatten and the sea darkened to iron. The village had a shop that sold bread and cigarettes and a noticeboard with curling posters about latticework and snowmobile repair. It had a church with a spire so thin it seemed pinned into the sky. Before Astrid, I was something to be glanced at—Stockholm girl, city girl, a word that meant you thought you were better. “Are you sure about the mound?” I asked. “I thought we were doing the cards.” “That’s for little things,” she said. “Who stole the science teacher’s watch, who put the gum in Ingrid’s braid. Útiseta is for knowledge. For when you need answers.” She said it with the authority of someone peeling an orange. Her face, pale in the faint skyglow, was framed by hair that always escaped from her hat. She walked like she knew where she was going even when there was no path. “Anyway, you said you wanted to know why Malin quit the dance team. See? That’s a big thing.” “I didn’t say I wanted to know,” I said. “I just wondered.” Astrid didn’t answer. She tugged me by the sleeve to where the trees thinned, and the snow gathered like folded linen over low mounds. The burial ground lay in a grove that dipped toward the river; you couldn’t see it from the road. Astrid said her grandmother had taken her here in summer, when the grass was high, but winter is when the world is thin. She said it half-joking, every time. The mound we chose was barely knee-high. In the daylight it would only be a swelling in the earth. Now, it felt like a bubble of old air under the snow. My breath caught in my throat. Not fear, exactly—an edged awareness, like walking barefoot across pebbles. “Okay,” Astrid said briskly, and set the tin box down. Inside were three lumps of sugar wrapped in paper, a bottle of tiny brown seeds, a stubby candle, and a small flat stone carved with a spiral. “We’ll sit facing north,” she said. “Put the blankets down the way I showed you.” We’d practiced on her living room floor, while her little brother watched TV and her mother smoked without opening a window. I laid one blanket directly on the snow and folded the other so that it could wrap around us both from behind. The mound made the ground uneven, a mild hump under my thighs when I sat. The cold seeped through my jeans immediately. Astrid wound the red yarn around my wrist three times and tied it with a knot that cinched tight. She did the same to her own. Then she looped the yarn between us until it drew a line like a string between two tin-can telephones. Our hands lay in our laps, pale and ungloved. “Leave your fingers out,” she said. “In case something wants to take your hand.” “That’s not funny.” “I’m not joking.” We were close enough that our shoulders touched. The mound breathed its cold through the blanket. Astrid took the sugar lumps out and set them on the flat stone. With the tip of one finger, she traced a spiral in the air over them, and then traced a circle around the mound, not touching it, just drawing the line in the air. She did it as if she had done it a hundred times—a girl arranging barrettes, a girl folding paper cranes. “Who taught you this?” I whispered. The birches leaned and clicked. Somewhere a raven made a sound like a door hinge. “Grandma said her grandmother sat out here when the men were away fishing,” Astrid said. “To ask them to come back. To ask the weather to be kind. And other things.” She didn’t look at me when she spoke; her eyes were on the north, on the black gap where the spruce forest thickened like a wall. “She told me people get stupid about it, like with everything. Boys try to dare each other, and then they go home and tell jokes. But she said if you make a bargain, you keep it.” “What bargain?” “You’ll see.” The words were matter-of-fact, but something in her voice made my mouth taste like metal. She lit the candle with a match, cupping the flame from the small wind with her hands. The candle’s light stitched our faces into the dark, made our breath visible. We had to stay until the candle burned to the nub, she had told me. We had to keep quiet. We had to think about what we wanted to know, hold it like a bead between finger and thumb. The trick, she said, was not to ask a question you couldn’t bear to have answered. “I don’t think I want to know about Malin,” I said, soft. “Then ask for something else.” The cold was climbing into my bones, an intelligent thing. It took my knees, my hips, the tender places at the sides of my breasts. I thought about my father’s hands on the steering wheel when we first drove into the village, how tightly he held it, as if at any moment he could veer the car back toward Stockholm. I thought about my mother’s cheerfulness like a coat she couldn’t take off. I thought about the way the boys had looked at me in the shop, and how their eyes slid away like fish. I wanted to be seen. I wanted to be left alone. I wanted to know if I had made a mistake. I wanted to know if there was a way to go back. “I’ll ask for—” I said, and then stopped. The candlelight trembled. Astrid leaned toward the sugar stones. “We start like this. Knock three times.” She tapped the flat stone with her fingernail. The sound was a small, clean note. I did the same. It felt foolish. It felt like I was stirring a sleeping creature with a spoon. She spoke in Swedish, but not the Swedish from school. The words were shaped like cradles or boat-hulls, old and wide. She didn’t chant; she said them as if she were reciting a grocery list. I didn’t recognize any of it. My stomach dropped as if there had been a step missing. The sound called down into the snow, and nothing, nothing answered. We waited. I could hear everything. The sap locked in the trees, the far rumble of the river under its ice, the soft, uncanny noise of snow settling against itself. My toes went numb. My thighs burned with the effort of keeping still. The candle hissed and made a thin, living line between us and the dark. When it came, I thought at first it was the wind shifting the forest. But the air was steady. The sound was delicate, like a fingernail drawn along the teeth of a comb. It traveled around the circle Astrid had traced, the air-line, like the sound of a bead sliding along a string. “Did you hear—” I said. “Shh,” Astrid whispered. Her eyes were fixed on the north, but I saw how her throat moved when she swallowed. We sat. The sound came again, a fraction to the left this time—or I told myself it was. It could have been the blood in my ears. My heartbeat thumped in the red yarn where it crossed my wrist. The knot dug into my skin. A church bell chimed once. A clean, singular note that made the hair on my arms rise. It came thin through the trees, down the slope from the village. I had counted the services; there wasn’t one tonight. Astrid’s mouth made a shape like a laugh without the sound. “Midnight,” she said, as if that explained everything. The candle flame bent and then stood upright again. My eyes were wet. I blinked and saw, in the corner of my vision, the impression of someone standing in the trees. It was a trick of the branches. I told myself so sternly that it became a kind of prayer. “What do we ask?” I whispered. “You ask,” said Astrid. “You’re the one who brought the sweets.” My chest hurt. The cold had found my lungs. I didn’t want to ask anything anymore. I wanted to stand up and stamp my feet and go back to Astrid’s kitchen, where there were prints of geese on the curtains and a calendar of glossy dogs and the smell of boiled coffee. But the red yarn tied me to her. And I had a stupid, adolescent obstinacy in me—a fear of seeming cowardly bigger than my fear of what might answer. “I want to know,” I said, and my voice surprised me by how steady it sounded, “if I’m going to belong here.” It was not what I thought I would say, but there it was, a small coin pushed across a table. The air didn’t change. The mound didn’t shift. There was no voice. But I had the strong sensation of being noticed. The same way in the city I could feel when someone was staring at me on the subway—the prickle, the exactness. As if a face leaned in close to mine in a crowd and then leaned away again before I could see it. My mouth filled with sweetness, the sugar on the flat stone, although I hadn’t put any to my tongue. Astrid’s hand moved. I thought she was reaching for mine, but she touched the red yarn, just once, as if testing its tension. Her nails were bitten down. “If it wants something,” she murmured, so soft I almost didn’t catch it, “you have to decide if you can give it.” “What could it want?” I meant to make it a sneer, and failed. Sometimes, later, I thought that was when the wind shifted—not then, but the idea of it, so that whenever I tell this, it seems as if the birches leaned in closer. The sound came again, under the skin of the night. The candle flame guttered and stayed. I smelled something that wasn’t there a moment before: earth, but deep earth, the smell of old potatoes in a cellar, of coats taken out of boxes after a long time. It was not unpleasant. It was not human. “Say thank you,” Astrid said. She said it very hurriedly. She sounded like herself again—a girl who had laughed at me for not knowing where to find the best place to swim in summer, the side of the river where the sun warmed the rocks first, the shortcut behind the old man’s barn where the dog would bark but never bite. “Thank you,” I said, into the dark. My mouth was dry. Astrid took a sugar lump and set it on the mound and then pushed it with one finger until it fell into the slight hollow at the top, where the snow had melted more than around it. She lifted the bottle of seeds and sprinkled a line around the candle, and for a second it looked like a tiny necklace. Then she pinched the candlewick between finger and thumb and didn’t flinch when it scorched her skin. “You said it had to burn out,” I said. “It changed,” she said. “Sometimes it changes.” We sat without light until my eyes learned the darkness again. The place where the candle had been glowed in my vision like a negative. The sound had gone, or else it had receded to the point where it became part of all the other sounds—my breath, Astrid’s breath, the minute adjustments of the forest. A distant car on the road, a single, lonely pass. The idea of that car seemed absurd here, like thinking about an escalator in a field. “Can we go?” I asked. “In a minute,” she said, and then, after a long moment: “We have to go back the way we came. No shortcuts.” “Why?” “It matters.” I got to my feet, and the sudden blood to my legs made me dizzy. The red yarn tugged, and I had the strangest feeling that something on the other end of it pulled back, not Astrid, something else. I bit the inside of my cheek so I wouldn’t make a sound and tasted blood. We unwound the yarn carefully, to keep it from snagging, and rolled it around one hand until it made a red cuff. Astrid picked up the flat stone and slid it into the tin box. She left the sugar in the hollow. The top was already crusted with a thin skim of ice. On the path home, we didn’t talk. The birches watched us. The village was a dark mass, the church spire a stitch in the cloud. When we reached the school, the swing creaked once in a wind that hadn’t been there a second before. Astrid’s hand found my sleeve in the dark and gave it a small, firm tug—reassurance, or warning, or both. In bed at her house, later, with her breathing slow beside me and the red yarn wound around my wrist under the sleeve of my borrowed T-shirt, I tried to decide what had happened. I told myself that I had scared myself into hearing things. That the bell had chimed because metal shifts in cold. That the smell of earth belonged to the mound itself. I slept and woke and slept and woke, and every time I closed my eyes I saw a spiral traced in air, and every time I opened them the dark seemed to lean back just in time. In the morning, Astrid’s mother put cinnamon sugar on porridge and complained about the price of petrol, and the radio said nothing about the church bell. At school, Malin didn’t meet my eyes, and I didn’t ask her anything. When I washed my hands in the girls’ bathroom, the water ran over the red mark the yarn had left and made it sting. I kept the stone’s spiral in my mind like a pebble in my pocket. I thought I could stop. I thought I was the one choosing. But that night, when I lay in my borrowed bed and the house settled and the river knocked once under its ice, a small, polite sound, I had the sense that something had heard me, and that it had tilted its head, and that it was waiting for me to speak again.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This folk horror piece successfully creates an atmospheric and unsettling narrative centered on the Útiseta ritual. The author has crafted a compelling first-person account that maintains ambiguity about whether supernatural events are occurring or if it's merely psychological suggestion. The writing excels in establishing setting and mood. Rural northern Sweden in winter is vividly rendered through sensory details: "The snowpack had crusted over and then frozen again into sugary granules that gave under our boots with a muted squeak." The contrast between Linnea's urban upbringing and the isolated village creates meaningful tension. The author effectively conveys the protagonist's displacement and longing to belong. Character development is strong, particularly in the relationship between Linnea and Astrid. Astrid is portrayed with a matter-of-fact confidence about ancient practices that makes her both intriguing and slightly unsettling. Her casual approach to potentially dangerous rituals ("She said it with the authority of someone peeling an orange") creates an effective contrast that heightens tension. Linnea's reluctance and curiosity feel authentic for a teenage transplant seeking connection. The ritual itself is described with specific, concrete details that lend credibility: the red yarn, sugar lumps, the flat stone with a spiral, the precise instructions. The author skillfully builds tension through subtle shifts in the environment rather than overt supernatural manifestations. The ambiguity is maintained throughout—was it the wind, imagination, or something else? The prose is generally elegant and controlled, with effective imagery and metaphor. Occasional lines stand out for their poetic quality: "The birches were smudges, their white trunks indistinguishable from the snow except for the horizontal scars." The author avoids purple prose while still creating evocative descriptions. The narrative maintains a consistent tone of unease and uncertainty. The ending effectively suggests that something has been set in motion without resolving whether supernatural forces are at work. This ambiguity honors the prompt's request to maintain uncertainty about whether events are supernatural or psychological. There are a few minor weaknesses. Some metaphors feel slightly overworked: "The village had a church with a spire so thin it seemed pinned into the sky." The dialogue occasionally becomes a vehicle for exposition rather than character development. The narrative could have more efficiently established Linnea's backstory without some of the explanatory passages about her move from Stockholm. Overall, this is a strong piece of folk horror that effectively creates atmosphere, develops characters, and maintains the requested ambiguity about supernatural elements. It successfully portrays the dangerous line between treating ancient practices as entertainment and confronting forces beyond understanding. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 4 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 4.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Physical-spatial: Therapeutic Boundaries — Score: 91.6
Prompt:
**"Therapeutic Boundaries"** Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a former professional athlete undergoing mandatory physical therapy after a career-destroying injury, harboring resentment toward recovery itself. Their physiotherapist is not only unnervingly attractive but also a former training partner from their competitive days who has successfully transitioned to a new career while the protagonist's identity remains shattered. We'll lean into the sexual tension of the scene by having her be attracted to him, but both of them attempting to maintain mental distance while being in physical contact as he shows her stretches & movements & manipulates her body, navigating the thresholds of pain. This scene MUST maintain complete physical coherence—every movement, stretch, and manipulation must be anatomically precise and spatially consistent. Paint an exceptionally vivid sensory picture through detailed attention to pain thresholds, involuntary responses to touch. Capture the suppressed, flaring tension of physical proximity, touch, and the controlled infliction of uncomfortable movements. Physical clarity is essential — readers must understand exactly what is happening with the body during each therapeutic technique. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The poster of the human musculature is too clean. Every muscle bellied and feathered in red, origin and insertion pins like neat bullet holes. As if pain could be organized into zones like that—deltoid, supraspinatus, biceps long head—like a map someone could use to find their way back to being normal. He taps the printout on his clipboard, the one with my name at the top and an angle measurement circled in green. Thirty degrees external rotation. It may as well be a scarlet letter. “Let’s start prone,” he says. His voice has changed since I knew him—lower, or maybe just steadier. In college, when we did intervals in the dark, he used to talk too fast and too much. Now he speaks like he’s measuring the cost of each syllable. I climb onto the table face down, my injured shoulder toward the wall. The vinyl is cold against my sternum; the paper crinkles under my cheek. The table is narrow enough that my forearm dangles off the side, elbow flexed to ninety, palm facing the floor. Gravity pulls on the weight of my hand and hums an ache into the front of my shoulder. He stands to my side, so my peripheral vision gives me the hem of his polo, the slope of his forearm, the cords across his wrist as he reaches to check the angle of my elbow joint. He slides one hand under my forearm to support it, the other to steady my upper arm against the table. His fingers press lightly into the lateral border of my scapula, his thumb along the spine. “Infraspinatus and teres minor,” he says, more to the poster behind me than to me. “We’ll start with passive external rotation. Don’t help me.” Don’t help me. The instruction buzzes under my skin. I relax my wrist. My tendency is to guard, clamp, anticipate pain with my whole body. He has always been able to read tension as if it written in my fascia. He rotates my forearm away from my torso, my elbow a neat hinge at ninety degrees. The movement is small at first, a gentle arc like a compass point tracing a wider radius. Every degree feels like a thin wedge inserted under the front of my shoulder—pec minor gripping, biceps tendon catching in its groove. There’s a pinch that is both sharp and diffuse at the front, deep under the coracoid, like a shock behind a wall. My breathing goes shallow. “Tell me when you feel the stretch,” he says. “I feel it,” I say too quickly. He pauses and holds, waits for the tissue’s compliance. Time stretches. My hand is heavy in his palm. I feel the pressure of his fingers along my scapula, reminding it to stay retracted, depressed. He gives a subtle posterior glide with his thumb, rolling my humeral head back how it should sit when my rotator cuff is doing its job—when my life was simple and pain was a training tool, not a constant. “Breathe into it,” he says. “Slow in, slower out.” I inhale, feel ribs press into the table, the injured side grudging. Air pushes into the space under my shoulder blade as I aim my breath there, like he taught me years ago on a track, when breath was fuel and not a thing to control pain. The sting at the front transitions into a burn along the back shoulder capsule. He holds until the burn becomes a dull heat, until my body gives him a few degrees. “You’re not fighting me,” he says quietly. Is it approval, or relief? Hard to tell. His hand is warm through my skin. My forearm reaches what feels like forty-five degrees and my pec sends an electrical warning to my brain. He stops there, holds. A tremor runs through my wrist, an involuntary flutter I can’t conceal. I hear the soft click of his watchband as he glances at time. We’ve shared silence before—on start lines when the ocean of noise receded and only the call to set mattered. This feels the same and nothing like it. I’m aware of him the way I used to be aware of a competitor’s cadence. The difference now: he’s in my space, guiding my movement, and the heat that rises under my skin has nothing to do with exertion. He eases my forearm back to neutral and supports it as he sets my palm to face forward, then slowly internally rotates. The posterior capsule tightens like a drawstring bag; the top of my shoulder complains like an angry neighbor. He cants his hand to keep my humerus from gliding forward—his fingers making a small shelf laterally as his other hand gives a gentle posterior-anterior oscillation on the humeral head, milking space in the joint. It’s precise, a conversation in pressure gradients. He’s always been exacting; he’s honed it into something clinical. “You’re guarding on internal,” he murmurs. “Let your subscapularis be a muscle again.” There’s a dry half-smile in his voice. “Tell it that,” I mutter into the table paper. The humor is a thin varnish. A flare of pain shoots bright, the kind that steals air, and my left hand curls into a fist while my right grips the edge of the table. Instinct, that old surge. He notices. His hand shifts to cover my distal forearm, the heel of his palm anchoring me, his thumb a quiet press that says: Stay here. “We’re at end range,” he says. His breath moves the hairs on my upper arm. “It’s safe. It’s supposed to be uncomfortable.” I want to spit back that discomfort used to mean a medal, used to have context and meaning. Now it’s just a room with dumbbells and a man who knew me when I was something else. Instead I swallow and feel the sting melt into a throbbing heat radiating up into my neck. He holds. My body quivers at that threshold. The line between pain and…not pleasure, but something like relief when the pressure is perfectly placed, exact, and my tissue yields by a millimeter. We both feel it. His fingers lighten a fraction, then back on. He’s reading me through the micro-movements of my scapula, the tone in my forearm flexors, the way my breathing staggers. “Okay,” he says after a count of ten. He returns me to neutral, my shoulder humming like a plucked wire. He guides my arm to the table, drapes a towel under my humerus to keep it in slight abduction to slacken the supraspinatus. He steps around to my head. I catch a glimpse of him in the chrome of the light fixture—broad-shouldered now in a different way, hip bones no longer the sharp blades they were when he was cutting weight to race. He’s grown into another life. I bring my good hand under my cheek and look at the musculature poster. Gluteus medius shaded a different red than tensor fasciae latae. The labels are so clinical. My name used to be a label on a bib. Now it’s a case file above a measurement. “Roll to your side,” he says, touching my scapula with two fingers to cue the direction. I roll onto my left, right shoulder up, knees flexed to stabilize my lumbar spine. He positions my right arm so the elbow is still bent ninety degrees, but now at my side in neutral. He reaches under my scapula with his fingers, sliding like a knife under a stuck letter. He hooks the inferior angle with his fingertips and lifts slightly, creating space between scapula and rib cage. “Scapular mobilizations,” he says softly. He glides it into protraction and retraction, upward rotation and downward rotation, depression, elevation, a slow controlled exploration. The serratus anterior complains—hot ache along the ribs—as he guides it to glide. My skin hums under his hand, nerves a chorus. His other hand anchors my clavicle so the motion is truly scapulothoracic, not clavicular compensation. His breath is timed to his movements, intentional. The air between us thickens with clinical professionalism and something else from a long time ago that smells like rain on a track. “What do you feel?” he asks. “Like my shoulder blade is a cat that doesn’t want to be picked up.” He huffs a laugh. The sound lands somewhere low in me. His fingertips press into the medial border, kneading, stripping along the supraspinatus fossa to find adhesions. He locates a knot near the superior angle—a trigger point—and compresses. The pain is sharp and radiates over the top of my shoulder like a hot stream, referencing to the lateral arm. My eyes sting. An involuntary tear creeps out and smears on the paper. He holds steady pressure until the hyperirritable spot yields, and with it, something unfurls in me. The room shrinks to the radius of his hand and my breath. He eases off slowly, keeping one finger on the spot as if to promise he knows where he is. My heart rate slows. “We’re going to do a sleeper stretch,” he says. “You guide it this time. I’ll block.” I roll further onto my right side, stacking my shoulder directly under me to avoid the common cheat of posterior tilt. He places his hand on my scapula to block it, palm flat, pressure gentle but unrelenting. “Don’t let your shoulder blade wing. All movement from glenohumeral.” I nod. My elbow is at ninety, forearm upright. With my left hand, I apply gentle downward pressure on my right wrist, trying to internally rotate the shoulder. Immediately my posterior capsule lights up, a deep, hot line that feels like a seatbelt too tight across bone. He adds a little pressure on my scapula to keep it pinned, preventing me from stealing range there. The sensation is intense—like the top of my humerus is a cork being twisted in. There is a precise edge where it shifts from stretch to wrong; he stops me with a quiet “there” before I cross it. “Hold twenty,” he says. “Breathe into your back.” I breathe. My ribs expand into his hand. The weight of him through my scapula is both anchor and provocation. My left hand trembles as I maintain pressure. My right forearm quakes. He watches the angle of my elbow, the alignment of my wrist, corrects with two fingers when my forearm drifts into pronation to cheat. His touch is minimal but everywhere. I picture him as he was at nineteen—laughing, impossible, eyes wild after a race. There is a part of me that wants to shove him away now for being who he is when I’m not who I was, and another part that wants to lean back into the solid line of his palm until the world narrows to the skin he’s on. “Release slow,” he says. I do, the tissues recoiling like a slow exhale. He eases off my scapula. My arm floats, heavy and hot. “We’ll finish with a pec minor stretch,” he says, coaxing me onto my back. He places a small bolster under my thoracic spine to extend it, opens my arms into a T, palms up. He positions my right shoulder just past neutral extension, externally rotated. The deep front of my shoulder resists like a locked door. He kneels at my head, reaches to the coracoid process—the hook of bone under the skin—and places his fingers there, then the heel of his other hand under the posterior shoulder to give a counterforce. He applies a gentle, sustained pressure down and back on the coracoid, lengthening the pec minor. It feels like a string inside my chest is being tugged. The sensation is invasive, intimate, effective. “Don’t let your ribs flare,” he says, and with his free hand he taps my lower ribs. I draw them down, engage the transverse abdominis, feel my spine meet the bolster differently. The stretch moves from a sharp line in the front to a broader, deep pull. His forearm is close to my jaw; I can smell the citrus tang of his soap mingled with something skin-warm. The room is quiet but for the air vent and my breath and his. “You’re doing well,” he says, not looking for my eyes. “Your range is improving.” I want to throw the words at him: My range used to be an ocean. Instead I let the stretch burn, count silently with the second hand of the wall clock, watch the red muscle poster in my peripheral vision. The neat red bands of pec minor and major, their fibers running toward the humerus with purpose. I used to understand purpose. He releases slowly, as if returning something to a shelf. He helps me sit, one hand under my scapula, the other supporting my elbow. We are close. The air feels heavy. He steps back, that careful line retained. “Home program,” he says, tapping the clipboard. “Three sets. Slow. No bouncing. Ice afterward. Text if you get night pain.” “I won’t,” I say, too quickly. A lie. Night is the worst; when it all swells and throbs and memory does too. He lifts his chin toward the poster. “You’re not a diagram,” he says. “We’ll get you moving the way you move.” The way I moved is gone. The resentment is an ember I roll on my tongue like a curse. But my shoulder aches in that particular way that means something was pried open and might stay that way a little while. He turns to put the clipboard on the counter. The muscle map looms over him like an anatomy of a person we both used to be. “Same time Thursday?” he asks. “Yes,” I say. My hand is still tingling where he held it. My shoulder hums like a live wire. We stand there a second too long with nothing left to say that isn’t an admission, and then I slide off the table, the paper sticking for a heartbeat to my skin, the sound delicate, like tearing a bandage I’m not sure I want off.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative effectively captures the complex dynamics between a former professional athlete and their physiotherapist. The piece excels in its anatomical precision, creating a vivid sensory experience of physical therapy that feels authentic and technically accurate. Medical terminology is seamlessly integrated into the narrative without feeling forced or didactic. The protagonist's resentment toward recovery is palpable throughout, manifesting in their internal monologue and reluctance to fully engage with the therapy. Lines like "My range used to be an ocean" powerfully convey the loss of identity and capability. The narrative successfully establishes the history between the two characters without excessive exposition, allowing their shared past to emerge organically through observations and brief reflections. The sexual tension is handled with subtlety and restraint. Rather than resorting to obvious descriptions, the tension emerges through the protagonist's heightened awareness of touch, proximity, and physical responses. The clinical setting and professional boundaries create a compelling contrast with the underlying attraction, which is conveyed through sensory details: "The air between us thickens with clinical professionalism and something else from a long time ago that smells like rain on a track." The writing demonstrates exceptional control of pacing, particularly in the therapy sequences where time seems to stretch and contract with the protagonist's pain and relief. The prose balances technical precision with emotional resonance, using the physical therapy as both literal action and metaphor for the protagonist's psychological state. Where the piece could be stronger is in providing slightly more context about the specific injury and sport. While the vagueness allows readers to project their own interpretations, a few more concrete details might have anchored the narrative more firmly. Additionally, while the ending effectively maintains the tension without resolution, it feels somewhat abrupt. The physical coherence requested in the prompt is masterfully achieved. Every movement is anatomically precise and spatially consistent, from the positioning on the table to the specific angles of rotation and the therapist's hand placements. The narrative tracks the protagonist's body position throughout, maintaining a clear sense of where each limb is positioned and how the therapist interacts with them. The sensory experience of pain is rendered with particular skill, distinguishing between different types of discomfort: "sharp and diffuse," "burn along the back shoulder capsule," "a deep, hot line that feels like a seatbelt too tight across bone." These descriptions create a visceral reading experience while maintaining clinical accuracy. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that balances technical precision with emotional depth, creating a compelling narrative about physical and emotional boundaries, loss of identity, and unresolved tension. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Historical fiction: High Seas and Low Vices — Score: 93.2
Prompt:
High Seas and Low Vices: British Naval Officer in the Opium Trade Character: Lieutenant James Merrick, a high-ranking officer in the British Royal Navy stationed in Canton, China in the 1830s. Once promising and decorated, now struggling with a severe opium addiction he hides from his superiors. Synopsis: Write a chapter following Lieutenant Merrick during a single day as he shirks his official naval duties in what has become a daily need to satiate the dragon. Told primarily in dialogue with the characters he interacts with. Focus on brief slices of his journey through the shadowy underworld of Canton: interactions with acquaintances, negotiations with local dealers, schemes and unsavoury jobs taken to fund his habit. Writing Task: Use rich sensory details to describe a day in the life of James Merrick. Write for a real sense of time & place while avoiding cliche. First person, past tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The bell on the river tolled second watch as I drifted from the quay into Old China Street. Junk sails creaked like old bones on the water. The heat had come early, pressing damp palms and damp collars, making the air in the alleys smell of brine, frying oil, and the sweet-spoiled musk of poppy. I palmed the jade figure in my pocket—a squat little god with one chipped eyebrow—rubbing it as if I might erase my own reflection. The first itch had started at dawn when the fleet’s breakfast gong sounded and I turned my head from gruel and orders. By noon the itch had become a roar. “Lieutenant Merrick,” called a voice from a balcony above a printer’s shop. “Are you in funds or in need?” Hargreaves leaned out, hatless, his necktie a noose of wilted silk. He traded in anything that moved and much that didn’t. “Good day, Mr. Hargreaves.” I kept my eyes on the edge of the balcony so I wouldn’t look up at his face, and wouldn’t show how my hand had begun to shake against the jade. “You’re listing. Come up.” He vanished. I took the stairs two at a time because if I stopped I might stop entirely. In his room the windows were thrown wide to the river. He had set out a plate of oranges that glowed like small lanterns, and a decanter of something that wasn’t water. “You look poorly,” he said. “The ship will miss you today.” “The ship won’t miss a Lieutenant of no consequence,” I said. “Have you coin?” “Not for you. You owe me for the Portuguese pistols and that little matter of the American flag you borrowed.” “I paid you.” I touched the tally of notes in my coat—worth nothing to the men who took silver by weight. “You paid a hope, not a debt.” Hargreaves poured a finger of brandy and slid it across. I did not touch it. He watched my hand. “You’re shaking like a lantern in a gust.” “My inventory list,” I said, “was needed this morning. I am here, which tells you how it went.” He grinned without showing teeth. “Go to Hoi. He’ll give you credit if you give him a gift. You’ll find him behind the chop-sticks alley, next to the tea warehouse with the painted cranes.” “He’ll want coin.” “He’ll want a favour. You owe me none. You owe yourself some measure of mercy.” I stood. “If you see Hoban—” “The purser?” He lifted an orange, peeled it in one smooth spiral. “You want to sell him out for a taste?” “I want to borrow,” I said, feeling the rind’s perfume like a cuff beneath my nose. “You’ll not make the quarterdeck tonight.” He tossed me a peel; I fumbled it, my fingers ignoring commands. “Go,” he said. “You’re fouling the air.” Hoi’s alley was silk-swaddled in shade. The heat there was feverish, a damp pocket that smelled of soy, sesame, iron from the slaughter-yard, and the faint incense of a joss house somewhere under the layers. Hoi sat on a stool between two bamboo cages containing birds with eyes like pinholes in pitch. The birds had songs that seemed to turn corners rather than move forward. “Fan-kwai officer,” Hoi said, with a smile that showed a gold tooth. He was narrow as a fish. “You were gone many days.” “Two,” I said. “I need—” “I know what you need.” He pointed his chin at my pocket. “Make the little god quiet.” “I’ve no silver.” The words dragged ash from my throat. “But I can fetch something. Documents. A boat. Passage.” “Passage,” Hoi said, tasting the syllables as if they were grist. “Not today. Today you bring me news.” “What news is worth the taste?” “The tide,” he said. “At which watch does your ship turn over the river-lighters to the factory? Which sloop goes up-country for survey? Which officer hates which officer? People will pay for hatred.” “You know that already.” “Tell me where the gunpowder sleeps tonight, and you walk.” He held up a square of pressed sludge wrapped in oiled paper. The scent of it flattened me, a black sun rising. “The storeroom,” I said, instinct turning treasonous. “Midships, under guard by Morris. British guard, not sepoy. Keys on his belt. He naps at nine.” “Ah.” Hoi tilted his head, weighing me against the dark. “And you will bring me the small scale weights from the purser’s office. The brass ones. The men stealing me must not cheat me. If you bring the weights by sunset, you eat tonight without paying.” “Morris will notice if his lodestone goes missing.” “Then find a way to make him not notice,” Hoi said, disentangling a splinter from his thumb with his teeth. “No silver now. Return with iron.” “Give me a taste,” I said. The jade in my pocket had become a hot coin. My lungs climbed into my throat to look out at the packet he dangled. “Ah,” he said softly. “You are an impatient priest.” He tore a sliver from the honey-brown cake and pressed it into my palm. “For your legs. So you do not fall between shops.” I placed it under my tongue and the world tilted, not into calm, but away from catastrophe. The itch, that sand drift under the skin, moved sideways. The birds sang a straight song. “Sunset,” he said. “Go.” Outside, a cool breeze came off the river and dried the sweat on my chest. I walked along the edge of the factories, past little groups of clerks in waistcoats taking tea, past sailors in raw cotton lounging and spitting, past a beggar without feet who rolled like tidewater at the curb. The British flags above the warehouses drooped like wet handkerchiefs. From the east side gate came Hoban the purser, a little red in the face, his ledger clamped like a Bible to his ribs. He saw me and looked past me, which told me more than if he had stared. “Hoban,” I said. “Lieutenant,” he answered to the horizon. “A word.” “I’m late.” “You owe me our last little arbitration,” I said. “You were short a case and your company smiled and took it on the chin because I am kind.” “You are not kind,” he said, finally looking. “You are fortunate to wear that coat.” “Give me the brass weights,” I said. “The small ones. For an hour.” “So you may weigh out your virtue in drams?” He shifted his ledger. “No.” “I’ll return them before the sun is gone.” “They are chained to the desk,” he said, lying. “And anyway, Lieutenant, I find your voice too quick and your eye too slow today.” “Two guineas,” I said. “Two,” he repeated, savoring the number as if it were a coin he might swallow like a magician and breathe out later as smoke. “I have a wife in Portsmouth.” “You have three,” I said, and he smiled despite himself. “Go to Mrs. Lin at the counting house on Hog Lane,” he said. “She runs weights like rosary beads. She’ll do it for you because she likes to see you twist.” “So do you.” “I do,” he said, then lowered his voice. “Our captain was looking for you at nine. Something about a tide chart. Don’t go back until it’s dark. He’s got the sermon light in his eyes.” Mrs. Lin sat behind a low counter in a room as sparse as a temple, if temples smelled of camphor and rat droppings. Her hair was a black flag, oiled and pinned, and her fingers moved with a speed that reminded me of the birds in Hoi’s cage. “Is the English lieutenant come to learn the abacus?” she asked without looking up. “I need to borrow weights,” I said. “The brass ones. I’ll return them before the bells.” “People never return weight,” she said. “They return stories. Those are lighter.” “Three guineas,” I said, laying my notes on the wood. Her eyes flicked, cut, returned to my face. With a small sigh—of profit or boredom, I could not tell—she bent, lifted a velvet pouch, slid it across to me. “You will also carry a letter for me to Uncle Chao in the mulberry court,” she said. “If you do not deliver it first, I will know.” “How?” “You will not be able to open your mouth without telling me.” “I am very good at not telling.” “Yes,” she said. “That is why your hands look like ghosts.” I ran the pouch beneath my palm to feel the little bells inside, the heavy truth of them. In my pocket the jade warmed, my thumb rubbing its cheek. “Do you know Hoi?” she asked, as if we were speaking of weather. “I know he eats without salt,” I said. “Give him my compliments,” she said, and looked back to her sums. The mulberry court sat under a carved arch where a pale boy with a scar hawked sour plums. Uncle Chao was old enough that his cheekbones were blue from the thinness of his skin. He wore an expression that had not altered since the first batch of dried leaves was traded for the first coin. “For me,” I said, tapping the letter against my knuckle. He took it without interest. “You need smoke,” he said conversationally. “I need credit,” I said. “Same thing,” he said. “One is merely a letter written in a different language.” The sliver Hoi had given me was fading already, its kindness a shallow wave that had spent itself on sand. The air had acquired edges again; every shout barked against my skull. I did not want to go back through the street. I wanted to find a shadow and slide through it to the side where everyone spoke slowly. In Hog Lane I ran into Webb, an ensign with eyes like damp leather, who carried a wrapped bundle. “Lieutenant,” he said, surprised. “We’re to look for you. Captain’s temper is up.” “Is it.” The words were iron filings in my mouth. “He wants you to take soundings to Whampoa this evening.” “Tell him I’m confirming a chart,” I said. “Tell him the tide is wrong.” “The tide,” Webb repeated as if it were a personal insult. “You look ill, sir.” “Go away, Webb,” I said, and he did, because I outranked him, and because he was young enough to remember rules, and because I was old enough to break them. I caught sight of Hargreaves again outside a fan shop, speaking to a woman with a face like a paper lantern. He put two fingers to his forehead in mock salute and mouthed, “Found?” I did not answer. Back at Hoi’s alley the sun had swung to the west and all the shadows had moved a step to the right. Hoi looked at the pouch, then at my hands. “You went to Mrs. Lin,” he said, pleased by his own prediction. “Sunset isn’t yet,” I said. “I brought the weights early.” “And the rest?” “The purser is a bastard.” “Hm,” he said. “That I knew.” He took the weights and set them on a low table, each one with the tenderness of a groom smoothing a horse. “Sit. You look like an oar that’s been cracked but still rows.” “Give me it,” I said, and hated hearing the words in my own voice, soft as a child’s request. He prepared it with the care of a man setting a watch: spirit lamp, instruction, a pipe like black jade. The smoke crowded the roof beams and then my lungs. The birds stopped making corners. My skin untied itself and draped back over my skull. Someone outside knocked a cart-wheel into a stone and the sound was filed away on a shelf where it could not reach me. “Better,” Hoi said. “Better.” I pressed my thumb against the jade god, but now it was cool again, an honest piece of stone, and I let my fingers fall away. “How many today?” he asked, as if he were counting cups of tea. “Until the bells,” I said. “Bells are meaningless,” he said. “Eat while there is rice.” Two men came in and looked at me sideways; one of them had a scar that pulled his ear down his neck like a loose button. They spoke to Hoi in a dialect I could not keep in my head. The longer I sat, the farther my obligations receded, as if they were smoke blown upriver. “You will do a little work for me tonight,” Hoi said, gently, as if asking a favor of a nephew. “Carry a packet to the old fort past the factory. Put it into the hands of the man with the silver tooth. Do not open your mouth for anyone else. Do not open the packet.” “And if I do?” “Your god will go hungry.” He held my gaze. I nodded, because I am a man who bargains. Even then, even as the tide in me slackened and went still, I calculated distance and dusk, guards and chance, the shape of Morris’s nap and how a belt might be undone without waking a man. When I could stand without falling over the birds, Hoi wrapped two thumb-nails of the black cake in oiled silk and tucked it into the inner seam of my jacket. “For later,” he said. “For when the river shows you the faces of your family.” “They’re long drowned,” I said. “Water remembers,” he said, and clicked his tongue at one of the birds, who answered with a phrase that sounded like a woman shutting a wooden window. Between Hoi’s and the fort lay the promenade with its promenade people: traders with bellies like cannonades, clerks who had borrowed a swagger with their waistcoats, Chinese boat-women with inked wrists, unruly children flicking fish eyes at dogs. A Scottish missionary passed me, his face set in a loop of pity he could not unknit. He stopped when our eyes met. “Lieutenant,” he said, “they are saying the trade is a sin.” “They are saying a great many things,” I said. “Have you any notion how to turn a river back to its mountain?” “By refusing to swim in it,” he said. “I am,” I said, touching the jade in my pocket. “Drowning.” “Come to a service.” “I have a service at dusk,” I said, and moved on. At the old fort I found the man with the silver tooth leaning against a wall that had once held guns pointed at my countrymen. Now a child slept in the mouth of a cannon run with moss. The man took the packet and weighed it—literally, with two fingers, like a judge—and slid a small coil of Mexican dollars back. Silver sang a thin tune when it touched each other. I swallowed it into my pocket. “Tell Hoi the river is rising,” he said. “Which one?” I asked. “All of them.” On the way back a sailor named Connor stepped from a doorway and blocked me with his shoulder. He’d been flogged last month. The scars across his back had knit badly, uneven lines that made me think of maps of a broken country. “Lieutenant,” he said. “We were after you today.” “I’m after myself today,” I said. “Perhaps we’ll meet.” “Captain says if you’re not aboard by the changing of the tide you’ll write your name on the mast with your cheeks.” “I have little skin to spare,” I said. “Nor I,” he said, with the smallest twist of a smile that cost him more than it should. “Watch yourself.” “I always do,” I lied. At sunset I gave Hoi the report and he gave me a pipe that made the bells ring twice in one breath. Night came on like a lacquer screen sliding shut. Somewhere a woman laughed, then cried out, then laughed. Lamps lit the river in a scatter of coins. The factories hummed. Men did what men do. I made it back to the waterfront with the silver dollar coil in my pocket and the jade warm under my palm. The topmast of our ship cut the sky like a thought I couldn’t complete. The marine at the gangway squared his shoulders when he saw me. “Lieutenant,” he said, catching the state of me in a glance. “Tell the captain,” I said, fishing for a tone that would make this a canted joke, “that the tide tomorrow will be early.” “He knows,” the marine said. “He always knows.” I stood in the little wash of lamplight on the quay and listened to the ship breathe. I rubbed the jade god until my thumb shined the cheek. “I am coming,” I told the ship. “I am a river, not a stone.” The ship said nothing. The lamps made their coin-flash and sank again. Hoi’s birds sang to each other in small private speeches. Somewhere in Hog Lane Mrs. Lin counted her numbers and found me missing. The jade cooled. The itch began its long, patient climb. I turned away from the gangway and went back towards the alley where the birds knew my name.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkably accomplished character study of Lieutenant James Merrick, a British naval officer in 1830s Canton who has fallen into opium addiction. The writing demonstrates exceptional control of voice, setting, and characterization while maintaining a consistent first-person, past-tense narrative as requested. The author creates an immersive sensory experience of Canton through rich, precise details: "Junk sails creaked like old bones on the water," "the air in the alleys smell of brine, frying oil, and the sweet-spoiled musk of poppy." These details establish both time and place without resorting to clichés or overexplanation. The physical sensations of Merrick's addiction are rendered with visceral clarity - the "itch" that becomes a "roar," hands that shake "like a lantern in a gust," and the relief when "my skin untied itself and draped back over my skull." The dialogue is particularly strong, revealing character through speech patterns and word choice. Each character has a distinct voice - from Hargreaves' cynical familiarity to Hoi's measured, metaphorical speech. The dialogue efficiently conveys information while revealing the complex web of relationships and power dynamics in this colonial setting. The narrative structure effectively follows Merrick through a single day as requested, showing his progressive deterioration and the increasingly desperate measures he takes to feed his addiction. The piece skillfully portrays his moral compromise without heavy-handed judgment, allowing readers to witness his self-awareness ("I am a river, not a stone") alongside his inability to change course. The prose strikes an excellent balance between lyrical and direct. Metaphors are fresh and appropriate to the setting: "The birds had songs that seemed to turn corners rather than move forward." The author avoids purple prose while still creating evocative imagery that serves the narrative. The ending is particularly strong, avoiding both redemption and complete despair. Instead, it shows Merrick caught in the cycle of addiction, turning away from his ship and responsibilities to return to "the alley where the birds knew my name." This ambiguous conclusion feels earned and true to the character. Minor weaknesses include occasional moments where the metaphors become slightly overwrought ("The itch, that sand drift under the skin, moved sideways") and a few transitions between scenes that could be smoother. However, these are minimal concerns in an otherwise exceptional piece. Overall, this is a sophisticated, nuanced exploration of addiction and moral compromise in a colonial setting, executed with technical skill and emotional intelligence. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Humour: Sisyphus Gives Advice — Score: 92.0
Prompt:
Sisyphus Gives Advice Write a comedic scene in the style of Terry Pratchett featuring Sisyphus, who has started an advice column while continuing his eternal boulder-pushing. Rather than being bitter about his punishment, Sisyphus has developed a comfortably zen emotional intelligence and wisdom from his centuries of repetitive labor. Not in the cliche ways you might expect -- he's actually very grounded, warm & connected with the everyday human plight. He dictates responses to "Crow," his feathered familiar who serves as both scribe and mail carrier. The piece should include Sisyphus thoughtfully answering several advice-seekers' letters about everyday problems (relationship troubles, work-life balance, dealing with difficult people, life purpose doubts) while periodically returning to his boulder-pushing duties. His advice should be surprisingly insightful and practical. The humor should emerge naturally from the messages he receives, from mundane to risque. Sisyphus should genuinely enjoy helping others, finding meaning in this new pursuit while maintaining his boulder routine. The humour should be *understated and not forced*. Contrary to expectation, almost none of his advice involves boulder rolling metaphors (though he does sneak *one* subtle in there), nor a treatise on stoicism. We are also going against the obvious fish-out-of-water trope; in fact, he's surprisingly a natural at this. In all of this , it's important to *show, don't tell*. The format should be largely epistolary, with the occasional interjection for scene setting. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The thing about a life of endless uphill work is that it gives you a good sense of timing. You can set your day by the point at which the dust at your ankles becomes mud, by the hour crows decide that your shoulder is as good as a statue, and by the moment you start talking to yourself just loudly enough to be heard by passing gods. Since no gods were passing and the boulder wasn’t much of a conversationalist, Sisyphus had learned to dictate. “Crow,” he said, putting a shoulder to the rock with the kind of companionable intimacy one reserves for well-worn armchairs and immovable legislation, “what’s first?” Crow—who had the sort of black feathers that suggested they had been polished by scandal—hopped onto the smooth ledge that, by centuries of grudge and friction, had become a desk. “From a ‘Sleepless in Sybaris,’” Crow rasped, and then, because he could not help himself, added: “My sympathies. Sybaris has many cushions and yet no rest.” Sisyphus pushed. The boulder regarded him, considered gravity’s opinion, and decided not today. It rolled. Dust rose. Crow cleared his throat in the way of creatures who don’t strictly have throats. “Dear Sisyphus,” Crow read, “My partner insists I should ‘sleep on it’ whenever we argue, but I lie awake replaying every word we said and every word we didn’t. How do I stop fighting at two in the morning? Signed, Sleepless.” Sisyphus leaned into the rock, adjusted, and spoke to the air which was, perhaps, more receptive than most advice-seeking mortals. “Dictate:” Dear Sleepless, Two in the morning is when thoughts put on masks, and every one of them wants to be a terrible play. You don’t have to attend. Try this: agree with your partner that arguments have office hours. Pick a time, mid-morning, when people are more reasonable and bread is still warm. When something flares at night, write down the one sentence you wish you’d said—just one—and put it under a cup in the kitchen. (This works best if the cup is slightly chipped; it lends gravity.) Then go to another room and do a brief chore together that has a clear end—fold one heap of laundry, stack five plates, sweep the kitchen once. Not to fix the feeling, but to remind yourselves you can finish something. If you’re lying there anyway, move your toes slowly. It’s very hard for the mind to sprint while the toes are doing a careful walk. Breathe as if you’re trying not to disturb a cat sleeping on your chest. In the morning, read the sentence under the cup. If it’s still worth saying, say it during office hours. If it’s not, congratulate yourself on saving two people from unnecessary theatre. Yours warmly, Sisyphus Crow scratched a margin note. “Note: acquire chipped cup, avoid cat.” Sisyphus nudged. The boulder behaved like a grandparent crossing a street—reluctant but not unreasonable. The sun moved across the sky with all the languor of a retired magistrate recalling cases he never quite solved. “Next,” Sisyphus said. “From ‘Half-There Hector’,” Crow croaked, shuffling parchment with the delicacy of someone who once stole a set of courtly love letters and survived. “Relationship troubles.” “Of course,” Sisyphus said, because of course. “Dear Sisyphus,” Crow read, “My boyfriend is wonderful, clever, handsome, and refuses to attend any event that isn’t a funeral or an opening night. He says he’s ‘bad at small talk.’ I’m tired of attending things alone. How do I coax him out without losing my mind? Regards, Hector.” Sisyphus planted his feet. The boulder did that little shiver it did, like a thought deciding to become an action. Dictate: Dear Hector, Some people think small talk is a test. It isn’t. It’s like warming up your hands before you play. Don’t begin with the symphony. Ask your boyfriend to choose two events in the next month that are small and finite—an afternoon market, a neighbor’s book club where the book is mostly pictures of ships. Tell him he is allowed to leave after an hour if he says a pre-arranged phrase. The phrase should be something that no one else will say accidentally, like “I promised to stir the stew” or “I have to check on the basil.” Practice saying it together so it doesn’t stick in his throat. Before you go in, agree on three questions to ask strangers that do not require genius to answer: “What is that you’re holding and why do you like it?” works in most places. Also: position yourselves near the food. People at food tables are obligated by custom to be friendly and to pass things. He will be able to participate without performing. If he uses the phrase and wants to leave, go with him the first two times. The leaving is part of the success. After that, you can split; you won’t be abandoning him, you’ll be trusting him. And if he truly hates it after that, then invite him to be excellent at the things he does like, and ask a friend to be your plus-one for the rest. Love does not demand every party; it asks for honesty about where each of you is happiest. Yours in good company, Sisyphus Crow added, in a different ink that suggested mischief: “If phrase is ‘I have to check on the basil,’ bring actual basil home.” Sisyphus put his shoulder back. The rock continued its stately climb. A beetle crossing the path paused to watch, the way one pauses at a crossing to let history go by. A little wind took a little dust and moved it somewhere it would be welcomed as new dust. “Work-life balance,” Crow announced, with the relish of a bird who considered balance a suggestion. “From ‘Overcandled in Corinth.’” “Dictate,” Sisyphus said, and considered his breathing. Dear Overcandled, Candles are for light and timing. Use them for both. Pick a candle that takes one hour to burn. When you start your most important task of the day, light it and do nothing else until it is gone. No messengers, no sorting scrolls, no heroic rescues of minor distractions. When the candle ends, so does that period. Stand up, drink water, and do something that does not involve your mind—wipe a table, repair a strap, water a plant that does not need you but tolerates you. Then light another, if you must. At the end of the day, have one candle that is not for work at all. Light it at the moment you decide to stop. That light says: no more buying back the morning with the interest of the night. Do not begin anything that cannot be finished by the end of the wick. People will try to hand you emergencies. Ask them to put them under the cup until morning. If someone insists their need is a fire, ask them whether it is a house fire or a “my stew is sticking” fire. Both are legitimate. Only one requires your immediate bucket. Yours in measured flames, Sisyphus Crow scribbled: “Note: birds disapprove of fire unless it is gossip.” He fluttered up as the boulder edged past a treacherous patch that had ambitions of being a slope. Sisyphus’s feet found exactly the places they always did. It is possible to be surprised by a familiar landscape, if one notices the exactness of one’s own habit. “Ah,” Crow said, plucking a letter from the bottom of the bundle as though it had tugged his talon. “This one has a perfume I would describe as optimistic. From ‘Curious in Cnidus.’” Sisyphus coughed into his arm with polite interest. “Dear Sisyphus,” Crow intoned. “My girlfriend and I have been together a year. Things are good, but she has suggested—how to put this—inviting a third person on special occasions, like a festival. I am… not opposed, but I am worried about feelings, shuffling, and where the arms go. Advice?” Sisyphus adjusted his grip. He had adjusted many things in his life: treaties, expectations, his own collar when mortality was still fitted. Dictate: Dear Curious, Well done on writing before the festival. Start with questions you can both answer with clarity and care. Why do we want this? What feeling are we hoping to have? Agree on signals that mean “pause” and “stop entirely.” They should be ordinary words you won’t forget under pressure. “Pause” can be “Water.” “Stop” can be “Olive.” Practice saying them kindly. Decide in advance what happens after. Will the third person stay for bread? Do you want to see them again? It’s not rude to say no; it is rude to fade away and blame the gods. Keep the first time short on purpose. Think of it like a play with a set ending, not a festival that wanders toward midnight out of vanity. And acknowledge jealousy like you would a nervous dog: don’t pretend it isn’t there; let it sniff everything; speak calmly; do not kick it for barking. If the evening becomes funny, allow it. If it is not funny, do not force it. Where the arms go: ask. Hands like instructions more than you think. Yours with a nod, Sisyphus Crow underlined “Olive” twice and added, “Do not confuse with ‘olive oil.’ Slippery slope.” They paused near a notch in the hill where the rock always rested. Sisyphus took his shoulder away and rolled one thick wrist, looking out over a valley full of people doing their best in the wrong sandals. “Difficult people,” Crow said, with the resignation of someone who had met gods. “From ‘Trampled by Centaurs.’” Sisyphus’s mouth twitched. The rock settled into its notch like a sigh. “Dear Sisyphus,” Crow read, “My boss is charm itself in public and a thundercloud in private. He takes credit for my work, and when I bring it up he says I’m ‘not a team player.’ I need the job. What do I do?” Sisyphus nodded, not to the rock but to the memory of many bosses with tragic ideas of themselves. Dictate: Dear Trampled, Write things down. Send summaries of meetings to the group with what was decided and who volunteered to do it. Include your own name where it belongs. It’s hard to steal a loaf when everyone saw you bake it. When your boss praises himself with your bread in his mouth, say, pleasantly, “I’m glad the project worked out. I learned a lot leading it.” Then name one specific thing you learned. Specifics are armour; vagueness is a fog he controls. Look for allies who dislike thunder. One may be the person who schedules meetings or the one with the keys to the cupboard. They often know where the real levers are. If you need to stay, make a plan to leave. Give yourself a date to review the plan. Plans are scaffolding; they hold you up even while you remain in the building. If you can’t leave yet, make your work small and precise where you can, and find one thing outside work that cannot be taken from you by a mood. Learn to make soup. Teach someone to tie a knot. Names on bowls and knots do not require permission. Yours in clear weather, Sisyphus Crow wrote: “Soup cannot be stolen, only eaten. This is acceptable theft.” The rock, as rocks do, remembered its brief romance with momentum and began to think about change. It changed direction. It was very generous, as catastrophes go. Sisyphus stepped back, watched it roll down with the benevolent attention of a teacher who knows the student will come back eventually, a little wiser and missing a corner, and sat on a flat stone that had been polished by patience. Crow preened. He considered preening Sisyphus, thought better of it, and instead unrolled the last of the letters. “Life purpose doubts,” he said, and his voice softened—not out of pity, but out of respect for the size of the question. “From ‘Maybe-Mason.’” “Dictate,” Sisyphus said, elbows on knees, palms open as if ready to receive whatever the day had dropped. Dear Maybe, Purpose is often loud in stories and quiet in days. Ask yourself three small questions: What do I do that, when I have done it, the day feels steadier? Who thanks me without being prompted? What activity makes time behave strangely? Write the answers on a piece of wood and keep it where you make decisions. When choices appear, take the ones that point in the direction of those answers, even if only by a finger-width. People think purpose is a door that opens with a creak and a chorus. Often it is a path made of very short, very obvious steps that you keep taking until one day you look back and see a line. If you truly do not know, help someone else do their purpose for a while. Purpose is catching. Be near it and you will find out whether it itches or fits. Also, be suspicious of any voice that says you must be special before you can be useful. The kettle is not special, and yet it changes the room when it sings. Yours in the work, Sisyphus Crow sighed, which for a bird is mostly feather-language. “We have, by the way, a postscript from ‘Sleepless,’” he said, tapping the earlier letter. “She sends that her chipped cup broke.” Sisyphus smiled at the valley where people were lighting evening lamps. “Dictate:” P.S. to Sleepless, Congratulations. It did its job. Chips go on to become dust; dust goes on to become everything that needs it. Find a new cup. You are allowed to have more than one small ritual. Yours, S. Crow did not annotate. Some things did not require feathers. The boulder returned, in the manner of loyal dogs and bad ideas. Sisyphus stood, set his hands, and felt the familiar weight settle and then resist. His knees chatted privately; his back opined. He ignored all of them, not unkindly. “Anything else?” he asked. Crow tilted his head. “A very short one. ‘Dear Sisyphus: How do you keep going?’ Signed, Everyone.” Sisyphus laughed under his breath, the sound of a man who had made friends with his breath. He leaned. Dictate: Dear Everyone, I stop, I drink water, I talk to someone, I do one thing, and then I do the next. Sometimes I listen to the beetles. They are very patient storytellers. Also, I write back. Yours, Sisyphus Crow tucked the letters under one wing, hopped once, and launched, black against a violet sky that had been painted over so many evenings it had texture. Sisyphus pushed. The rock moved. Somewhere below, someone put a sentence under a cup and went to bed. Somewhere else, a basil plant was consulted. The wind, which had opinions but no paper, carried it all along. And on the hillside, where timing is everything and nothing, Sisyphus did the work with the serene competence of a man who had finally found something to do while he did it.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response is a remarkably well-crafted piece that captures Terry Pratchett's style with impressive fidelity. The author has created a Sisyphus who, as requested, has developed a zen-like wisdom from his eternal punishment without being bitter. The epistolary format works perfectly, with Sisyphus dictating thoughtful advice to his crow scribe while continuing his boulder-pushing duties. The humor is indeed understated and not forced. The writer avoids the obvious boulder-rolling metaphors (with just one subtle reference to "slippery slopes"), and Sisyphus comes across as naturally gifted at giving advice rather than as a fish out of water. The piece shows rather than tells through specific details: Crow's annotations, Sisyphus's physical movements with the boulder, and the carefully crafted responses that reveal his character. The advice letters cover the requested range of topics: relationship troubles, work-life balance, dealing with difficult people, and life purpose doubts. Sisyphus's responses are genuinely insightful and practical, offering concrete suggestions rather than platitudes. The humor emerges naturally from the situations and Crow's commentary. The prose is elegant and evocative, with lovely turns of phrase that echo Pratchett's style: "The boulder regarded him, considered gravity's opinion, and decided not today" and "Two in the morning is when thoughts put on masks, and every one of them wants to be a terrible play." The writer creates vivid imagery with economical language. The relationship between Sisyphus and Crow is well-developed through their interactions. Crow's annotations add humor and personality without overwhelming the piece. The pacing is excellent, with the boulder-pushing interludes providing natural breaks between advice letters. If there's any weakness, it might be that some of the advice occasionally veers slightly toward the overly poetic rather than practical, but this is a minor quibble in an otherwise exceptional piece. The writer has captured the essence of what was requested and delivered a response that feels authentic to both Pratchett's style and the reimagined Sisyphus character. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Coming of age: Lost & Found in Osaka — Score: 87.8
Prompt:
Lost & Found in Osaka Slice of Life / Coming-of-Age: First Connection. Write one scene within a larger story set in Osaka, Japan. A shy, introverted teenager & synthesizer nerd, is browsing the electronics district of Den Den Town. She is drawn to the sound of an electric guitar. A girl, slightly older and radiating confidence, is busking near the entrance to a crowded arcade, playing a blistering rendition of a classic anime theme. The scene takes us through their initial awkward interaction, transitioning into a surprisingly easy conversation. The busker, intrigued by the teenager's quiet intensity and knowledge of music, suggests they grab some sushi at a nearby kaitenzushi (conveyor belt sushi) restaurant. Write primarily in dialogue, capturing the distinct voices of the two characters: the teenager's hesitant and -- initially -- awkward speech, and the busker's more outgoing and playful tone. 1000 words.
Model Output:
“Is that—? Wait, is that ‘Cruel Angel’s Thesis’?” The words stumble out of me before I realize I’ve said them. They get snagged in the air, just like my headphone cable gets snagged on my jacket zipper whenever I turn too fast. The girl with the guitar turns her head a little, fingers still sprinting up the fretboard. She’s planted on an upended amp case at the mouth of the arcade, neon rain falling from the game signs across her shoulders. Her hair is tied up and messy, strands escaping like bright wires, and she’s smiling even before the last slide squeals out. “Ding ding ding.” The pick taps her strings. “Got yourself an ear. How many semitone bends did I just do?” “Uh—” My headphones slide again and I push them up with my wrist. They’re too big. I like that they feel like a helmet. “Three. On the chorus. You did a... a cheeky one-and-a-half on the bridge, though.” She laughs, the sound rising above the arcade doors whooshing. A couple of kids glance at us, then rush inside, drawn by the crane claw machines and the drum game’s booming ta-ta-ta. The guitarist flips her cable with a foot, neat and practiced, and lets the last chord die under her palm. “You caught that? Wow. Most people just hear ‘anime song go brr.’ You into guitar?” “Synths,” I say, too fast. “I mean. Electronic. I... um. The keyboard kind. Oscillators, envelopes, LFOs. Sorry.” The headphones slip again and I force them back up, the cushion squeaking on my hair. She tilts her head at me, eyeing the headphones, the backpack with the patches—Roland, Korg, an old logo I stitched on from a magazine. Her smile edges wider. “Synth nerd. That tracks. I’m Kana.” “Yuna.” I blink, the neon signs playing on her guitar’s black finish. Behind us, the arcade door whooshes open and closes in a steady rhythm, letting out bursts of taiko thumps and pixel chirps. Den Den Town hums: solder and plastic, old Famicom cartridges in glass cases, a faint whiff of curry from the alley. Kana holds out a hand without standing, a pair of fingerless gloves hugging her wrists. Her fingers are calloused, warm. “Nice to meet you, Yuna-the-Synth.” “Yuna is fine.” My voice barely gets out. I clear my throat, and it comes out again, squeakier. “Yuna is fine.” “Yuna-who-hears-one-and-a-half–semitone bends,” she says, as if drawing out a joke she intends to revisit later. “What brings you out to the temple of silicon?” “Parts.” I point vaguely, uselessly—everywhere around us is “parts.” “Caps. A potentiometer. For a filter. I, um, found an old Yamaha in a thrift shop that... it cries when you turn the cutoff. Not the good crying.” “Ha.” She props the guitar on her thigh. “I like that. Instruments that cry. You play it both ways?” “What? Both—?” “Sad and happy crying.” “Oh.” I look at the ground and then at her hands. The streetlight hits the little chips in her nail polish. “I... I try. Mostly it sounds like it’s speaking a language I don’t know yet and I’m impersonating it badly.” “That’s still speaking.” She leans back, looking at the flow of people. “You got time to hang? I’m about to take a break. My fingers need, like, ice. Or sushi.” “Sushi?” “Kaitenzushi,” she says, pointing with the pick toward the corner where the conveyor-belt place glows discreetly with a blue fish logo. “Best way to insult a guitarist’s hands with cold rice. Also, I owe you for actually listening.” “You don’t owe me anything.” The words come out softer, and I hug my backpack strap. “But, um. Sushi is fine.” My headphones slip. She grins and reaches toward my ear, then pauses. “Can I—?” I freeze. “Sorry. They just...” “They’re like those cat-ear ones the streamers wear,” she says, gentle enough to make it not sting, adjusting the headband so it sits snugly. “There. You got a tiny head.” “I don’t,” I say, then immediately regret it. “I mean, I do. Probably. I never measured.” Kana laughs again and unplugs her guitar, coils the cable in quick loops. The coins clang in her open case as she scoops them into a pouch with practiced motions. The arcade’s automatic doors sigh. Above us, a billboard blares a cartoon jingle while a tram bell rings from the main street. “You’re good,” I blurt, because it feels important to say it before the moment escapes. “On the bends. And how you... you tucked that little chromatic run into the second verse so it wouldn’t step on the melody.” Kana slides the guitar into its soft case. “Flatter me more.” She raises an eyebrow. “No, seriously, thanks. Most people tell me I’m loud.” “You are loud.” I don’t mean to smile, but I do. “In a... good way. Like, how a bright saw wave is loud. Not just... volume. Presence.” “Ah, synth metaphors.” She slings the strap over one shoulder and grabs the tiny amp’s handle with the other hand, then tilts her head toward the sushi place. “Come on, presence girl. Before the salarymen get off work and turn that place into a tuna vortex.” We cross past the arcade entrance. Cold air blows from inside and drags arcade sounds over us—bursting 8-bit applause, an announcer shouting something triumphant. Kana moves like she takes up the exact amount of space she deserves, no more, no less, and people automatically slide around her. I try to follow, my headphones making the world’s edges soft. A crane machine’s claw drops and a kid gasps. The smell of soy sauce dangles somewhere ahead. Inside the kaitenzushi, plates click on rails, salmon slabs rivering past in glossy pink. A host in a tidy apron greets us and gestures to a corner. “Two?” he asks. Kana flashes the kind of friendly smile that makes it easy for him to nudge us to a seat near the window. We slide onto stools, the conveyor whirring quietly, the tiny touchscreens shining with cartoon fish. Kana drops her amp at her feet and leans her guitar case against the wall. “Okay, ground rules,” she says, eyes scanning the passing dishes. “You call out anything you’re allergic to. And if you see the egg—tamago—on the space shuttle plate, it’s mine.” “The space shuttle plate?” “Watch.” She points. A plate shaped like a tiny shuttle slides by, carrying square cuts of egg. “They do that for kids. Or people who like joy, which I am. You’re allowed to compete for it, but I will fight you. Gently. With chopsticks.” “I don’t—” I rub a thumb against the ridges in my plastic chopsticks. “I don’t eat much fish.” “We can get cucumber rolls. Pickles. Tamago is sweet. And miso soup.” She taps the screen to summon two misos. “Also, if you want to talk about synths, I am a sponge. A dork sponge.” “Okay.” My voice edges towards something more normal. The sound in here is so different from the street—the hum is softer, the plates’ click-click comforting. “You really want to know?” “Hit me.” “I built a little thing. It’s ugly.” I pull out my phone and scroll to a photo: a small box with knobs and mismatched screws, a mess of green and red wires visible through the top plate. “It’s a single-oscillator drone synth. I was trying to make it breathe. You know, like... not just a tone. Like a living—” “Presence,” she says, smiling. “I’m sensing a theme.” “Well.” I fold my hands. “It has a filter that wobbles on a low-frequency oscillator. And a random voltage thing I stole from a YouTube video—borrowed. It makes it jump sometimes, like when a pigeon gets startled. It’s not musical, exactly. But it’s... it’s like it’s thinking.” Kana leans closer, studying the photo as if it’s art, not spaghetti guts in a tin. “You made a thinking pigeon. That’s amazing.” “Thank you.” I feel my ears warm. “It’s named Kintaro.” “After the candy?” “The folk hero,” I say, then immediately falter. “There’s candy?” Kana chuckles. “Little roll candies with the same face in every slice. My grandma loves them.” She slides a tuna down from the belt. “So, Yuna making robots that think. Do you ever play with other people? Band? Club?” I feel my shoulders notch up like gears. “I tried to go to the music club this spring. They were... loud.” “I’m loud.” “You’re—” I hesitate, searching for the right word. “You’re bright. And you listen.” “Mm.” She takes a bite, chews thoughtfully. “You can be in a room with people who are loud and still be listening. Or quiet and not listen at all.” “I guess.” I watch the plates drift past. A small orange dish with two cucumber rolls slides by and I snag it, relieved. “Do you busk here every day?” “Thursdays and Saturdays. Sometimes Sundays if I feel guilty about all the manga I buy.” She sips her miso as it arrives, steam curling up. “I like this spot. People coming in and out. The arcade gives me a beat. The old dudes who collect model trains tip well.” “Really?” “Yeah. They nod like I’m part of their system. Like I’m a train that makes the station feel alive.” She looks at me. “Do you build alone because you like it or because it’s safer?” “Both,” I say, surprised I say it. “It’s hard to... to find a place where, um. Where my thoughts aren’t too slow for other people. Or too fast.” I wince. My chopsticks hold the roll midair, as if it remembers I haven’t earned it yet. “That makes sense.” Kana sets down her chopsticks, maybe because I forgot to. “You know, when I learned the solo to Tank!—that Cowboy Bebop one?” She whistles a quick snippet. “I played it wrong for six months because I was rushing. Like, physically rushing, but also, like, life-rushing. Then I slowed down. And it got good.” “So the solution to rushing is... slowing.” I eat the cucumber roll. The rice is cool and the crunch is something my brain can hold. “That sounds like a fortune cookie.” “Probably is. But it’s true.” She taps the table. “Do you like to perform?” “No,” I say, too fast. Then, softer: “Maybe. Someday. If I could hide behind a plant.” “A plant.” “A big one. A monstera, maybe.” Kana’s eyes crinkle. “I have a friend who brings a fake ficus to open mics. Like a prop. We could borrow it. And put you behind it. You’d be the mysterious synth ghost. People would go wild.” “They’d just... look at the plant.” “And listen to you.” She shrugs. “We can try it. Low stakes. Thursday night at the café near Ebisucho. They have plugs. And tea. And a cat that hates me.” “I don’t... I—” The headphones slip. I push them back, then realize I’m laughing, quietly. “A cat.” “It sits on my pedalboard,” she says, completely serious. “My wah pedal has fur. It’s fine. Everything is fine.” “I don’t know.” I look at my hands. They’re not shaking as much anymore. “Maybe I could bring Kintaro. And a small keyboard. Something that doesn’t... cry.” “I’ll bring a plant.” She reaches for the passing tamago on the space shuttle plate, triumphant as she snatches it. “Ha! Victory.” “You really do like joy.” “Guilty.” She splits the tamago and slides half onto a spare plate, nudging it toward me. “And sharing.” “I—thanks.” I take a bite, sweetness dissolving on my tongue. It tastes like cartoon sunshine. “Why did you start playing out here?” She swivels her little miso spoon. “Because I wanted to be good and I wanted to be scared. Also, my neighbor yells when I practice at home.” “Valid.” “What about you? Why synths?” “I liked how they sounded like feelings you couldn’t put into words.” I glance up and find her looking at me with that same attention she gave the photograph. “Like when the train arrives and you’re glad but also sad because it’s leaving soon. It’s that.” “Osaka train-core.” She nods. “We should write that.” “We?” “We,” she says, firmly. “I play a bright loud thing. You play a thinking pigeon in a tin. Together, we could probably make something that sounds like a train arriving and leaving and also a cat stepping on a wah.” “That’s... specific.” “So are you.” I sit with that. The conveyor hums. A couple at the end laughs softly. Outside, the arcade door sighs again, releasing a burst of applause from a rhythm game. In here, the plates click like a metronome we don’t have to obey. “I have to buy my potentiometer,” I say after a minute, carefully. “For the crying. The filter. You know.” “Let’s get it after.” Kana pops the last bit of tamago. “I’ll walk with you. I know a shop that has a drawer of weird knobs. You like weird knobs?” “I do,” I say, surprising myself at how easy it is, now, to smile. “A lot.” “Great.” She wipes her hands, then leans in a little. “Thursday. Café. Ficus. Yes?” I feel a panic spark, small and bright. It fizzles, oddly, into warmth. “Okay,” I say. “Yes.” “Cool.” Kana taps her chopsticks against her bowl like a little drum fill. “Welcome to the band, Yuna.” “The band?” “Shh.” She puts a finger to her lips, playful. “We don’t tell the plant. It’ll get a big head.” I laugh. The headphones slide, but this time I let them, and in the reflection of the window, the neon of the arcade paints us both in a kind of bright, temporary glow that feels like a door you could walk through and find a different version of yourself. Outside, Den Den Town keeps humming. Inside, our plates circle back around with the next round of choices.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a slice-of-life encounter between two contrasting characters in Osaka's Den Den Town. The writing excels at establishing distinct voices for both characters - Yuna, the shy synthesizer enthusiast with her hesitant, technical speech patterns, and Kana, the confident guitarist with her playful, direct manner of speaking. The dialogue is particularly strong, revealing character through speech patterns rather than exposition. Yuna's halting sentences, technical jargon, and self-corrections ("I don't—" "I mean, I do") effectively convey her social anxiety and specialized knowledge. Kana's more confident, metaphor-rich speech ("dork sponge," "tuna vortex") establishes her as the more socially adept character without making her one-dimensional. The setting is well-established through sensory details that feel authentic to Osaka's electronics district: "neon rain falling from game signs," "solder and plastic," "old Famicom cartridges in glass cases," and "a faint whiff of curry from the alley." These details create a vivid backdrop without overwhelming the character interaction. The piece demonstrates strong technical control in its pacing. The initial awkward meeting transitions naturally to the sushi restaurant scene, where the conversation deepens. The writer effectively uses physical objects (headphones slipping, plates on conveyor belts) as rhythmic markers throughout the conversation, grounding the dialogue in physical reality. The character development is subtle but effective. Yuna gradually becomes more comfortable speaking, with her sentences growing slightly longer and more confident as the conversation progresses. The transformation is modest and believable - she doesn't suddenly become extroverted, but she does agree to a future meeting, showing growth. There are a few minor weaknesses. Some metaphors feel slightly overworked ("neon rain falling from the game signs across her shoulders"). The piece occasionally relies on anime references that might not resonate with all readers. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise accomplished piece. The ending strikes an appropriate tone - hopeful but not unrealistically transformative. Yuna hasn't completely overcome her social anxiety, but she's made a meaningful connection and taken a small step toward greater social engagement. This feels earned rather than forced. Overall, this is a skillfully crafted character piece that succeeds in its primary goal of depicting a believable first connection between two distinct personalities, with dialogue that effectively carries both character and plot development. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 3 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 3.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Teen horror: Tick Tock (Goosebumps) — Score: 87.0
Prompt:
Teen Horror (Goosebumps style) Write a chapter where a middle school student discovers their new smart watch has the ability to rewind time, but doesn't realize that each use is aging them until they notice physical changes (like accelerating through puberty) and that people are treating them differently. They inadvertently cause a timeline shift with disastrous consequences -- and it can only be rectified (maybe?) by reversing the clock once more. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Chapter Seven: The Second Hand The first time the smart watch buzzed on my wrist, I thought it was a software update. It did this little haptic shiver, like a tiny heartbeat, and the screen lit up with a symbol I didn’t recognize: three arrows chasing each other around a clock face, like they were playing tag. It was brand new—Mom had saved all summer, I’d begged all year—and I was still figuring out how to make it do basic stuff. The stopwatch. The sleep tracker. The thing that counted my steps as I paced through Ms. Lee’s social studies class. I tapped it and the icon pulsed. A little slider appeared: minus one minute. The second hand on the watch face ticked backwards, tick tick tick, and then the world… hiccupped. I blinked and I was back in Ms. Lee’s class, two seats behind where I’d been, and she was saying the exact same thing, the same breathy tired voice about Jamestown and tobacco. I looked down. A pencil I’d just snapped in half was whole on my desk. I didn’t scream. I didn’t do anything except stare at my wrist and try not to throw up. The slider was gone. The hands on the watch were normal. Everyone around me scribbled notes like nothing had happened. At lunch, I tested it again. I went to the vending machine—dark, blinking the red “OUT OF ORDER”—and pushed every button like an idiot. It clanked, and a row of crumpled potato chips leaned, threatening to fall and then didn’t. I slid the icon back one minute. Tick tick tick. The bag wobbled upright. I pressed F8 again, and this time the chips thunked down. I ate them in three gulps, then did it again, backing up to get two bags for the price of none. I joked with Wetzel about it, how weird it was that the piece of junk machine had given me a freebie twice, and he punched my shoulder and said, “Dude, it’s your birthday luck or whatever.” “It’s not my birthday,” I said. “Feels like it,” he said. “You look… taller.” “Ha,” I said, and rolled my eyes. Everyone at Greendale Middle was obsessed with sudden growth, like overnight you woke up with six inches and a mustache. They wanted it to be a fairy tale. They wanted magic. I guess I did too. After school, I walked past the chain-link fence where the 8th graders pretended to smoke like they weren’t wearing baby-blue polos with our school crest. The stray cat was there, under the sycamore. It’d been hanging around the past week, ratty and lean with a torn ear and yellow eyes that didn’t look like they’d been made for a cat. The way they followed you, the way the pupils barely changed with the light. It just sat by the bike rack, tail curled around itself like a question mark. “Hey, dude,” I said, because that’s what you say when an animal regards you like a person. The cat blinked and tipped its head. I checked the time. 3:17. I’d missed the bus because I was busy staring at my watch and daydreaming about using it to pretend to ace quizzes. I could just rewind, peek, try again. I could catch the dodgeball before Theo lobbed it at my head. I could step on my own words and pull them back into my mouth before they embarrassed me. The cat stood, stretched, and arched its spine until every vertebra stuck out like a zipper. It held my gaze. It felt like there was another boy tucked inside that cat, someone older and tired who recognized me from somewhere. “Do you know me?” I said. My voice cracked in the middle of the sentence, and I mentally groaned. Not now. Not here, where the smell of gym and bus exhaust made everything feel sharper. Its ear twitched. I slid my thumb across the screen again. Minus one minute. Tick tick tick. A car door slammed. My laces untied themselves, the sound slurped backwards. A gull mid-cry swallowed its noise like a hiccup. The cat’s tail flicked, flicked, flicked and then was still. When time snapped back to normal, the cat had moved three feet—no, I had—and it was closer to me than before, almost sitting on my sneaker. It stared up like it had been waiting for me to come back. If a cat could nod, it would have nodded. “Okay,” I said to no one. “Okay.” That night, I set my alarm for six and bumped the slider back five minutes when I couldn’t find my jeans. Up again when I knocked over my cereal. My mom yelled from the hall that if I made the bus on time she would personally nominate me for sainthood. In the bathroom, I caught my reflection and felt wrong. Not bad wrong, just different wrong. My skin wasn’t the oil slick it usually was. The two sad commas where my eyebrows should be looked darker. My hair fell over my forehead and didn’t spring back. And my upper lip… I leaned closer. Soft fuzz that wasn’t just a weird shadow. I’d taken two new pimples to bed last night. They were gone. In their place: a dot darker than a freckle. “You must be joking,” I whispered. Fourteen and I had been waiting for this forever, for my face to pick a lane, for my shoulders to stop being coat hanger bones. I should have felt triumphant. Instead a thin thread of panic yanked at my insides. At school, the world felt tinted—a little brighter, a little meaner. The watch was warm all morning, like it had a fever. When Theo raised his hand and said Hernando Cortez instead of Hernán Cortés, I opened my mouth, closed it, rewound, tried a joke, failed, rewound, kept my mouth shut. By lunch I’d used it eight times. The cat watched me through the cafeteria windows, perched on the sill like a gargoyle. When the bell rang, it was sitting beside my locker as if it had been there all along. Wetzel poked me with his lunch tray. “You hit your head? You’re acting weird.” I shrugged. The polo clung to me like it had shrunk in the wash. “You look different,” he said, not unkindly. “Buff, or something. It’s freaking me out.” I laughed because that was better than screaming. The cat’s eyes were on my wrist. When the bell rang again, it followed me. It shouldn’t have been allowed. The hallway was a river of kids, a smell of cheap cologne and energy drinks, and the cat just wove between feet like it belonged. Ms. Lee shooed it out with her hand and it went, only to find the window and stare in. By last period, everything was too loud. I scraped my nails over the desk and felt the grain like tiny teeth. A girl from Spanish I barely knew asked if I wanted to come to a party. She hadn’t looked at me twice last week. When I said I had to check with my mom, her mouth twisted like I’d told a joke and she laughed too hard. Theo handed me a pencil and said, “You bench?” which didn’t make any sense because I didn’t bench anything but my hands on my math mistakes. I went to the bathroom to breathe. The fluorescent light turned my skin into wax. My face was the same but not. Jaw sharper. Hair darker. Voice lower when I tested a “Hello?” at the mirror. I must have been imagining it. I must have. I tapped the watch. The rewind icon pulsed like it had its own heartbeat. I slid back ten minutes, then twenty. Tick tick tick tick. I watched the second hand stutter backwards. This was a trick. A glitch. And I could fix a glitch. I could undo this feeling in my bones that the air had an edge. When I came out, the principal was on the intercom calling for a lockdown drill. His voice shook, like it was real. Teachers jumped. Students murmured. I realized I’d been in the bathroom when he’d announced it the first time. In this new version, we were still in the hall. Doors slammed and a hand yanked me into a classroom that wasn’t mine. The cat slipped in after me, silent. Nobody noticed. I felt the old panic twist into something else, something sour. In the dark, crouched behind a bookshelf with someone’s knee digging into my thigh, I felt the seconds stack. I should not have done that. My watch was hot. My wrist itched under the band like something wanted out. And then the screaming started from the gym. It wasn’t gunfire. It was lights popping, the sound of metal giving way, the bleachers collapsing. Students streamed into the hall, faces white. Someone shouted about Nadia, about how she’d been sitting under the bleachers when they broke. It wasn’t how it went. I knew it wasn’t how it went because in the version before this one, Nadia had been at chess club. In the version before that, I’d seen her in the courtyard, flicking a rook around a pawn like she was bored. In this one, she shouldn’t have been in the gym. She shouldn’t have. I fumbled with the watch. My hands were bigger, heavier. My fingers hit the wrong icon. My thumb slipped. I backed us up five minutes. The cat at my feet made a sound that wasn’t a meow, exactly. It was more like a “no.” Everything shuddered. The hallway emptied. The intercom sputtered. The principal’s voice said Drill again, like he never stopped say— and then we were in the gym. My head swam. Nadia was on the bleachers, hunched over, her hair falling into her face as she tied her shoe. I saw the bolt missing, the way the metal brace bowed like a teacher closing a book. I launched myself forward. I don’t know how. One second I was by the door, the next I was three rows up, heart punching my ribs. My legs worked like they belonged to someone else, someone who had practiced being fast. I grabbed her arm. “What—?” she said, bewildered, as the bleachers groaned. “Move,” I said. My voice didn’t crack. It thundered out of me. I pulled. The bleachers screamed and then they folded like a dying monster, metal shrieking across the polished floor. We fell into a heap on the court, Nadia’s elbow in my stomach, breath knocked out of both of us. A second later, the top row crashed down where she had been sitting. Silence. Then everything at once: gasps, footsteps, teachers barking orders. Nadia pushed herself off me and stared. “You okay?” I coughed, because what else do you say when you’ve maybe saved a person from being turned into a pancake by your own weird interventionist tendencies. She nodded slowly, eyes wide. Then: “How did you—?” I couldn’t answer. The cat sat at the entrance to the gym, tail curled around its paws. It blinked at me. Blinked again. Like it was counting. They made us go home early. They talked about structural failure, repairs, insurance. The police came and asked questions about where we were, what we saw. I didn’t tell them that I had seen the future collapse and dragged it backward, that I was pretty sure I’d caused it by not being where I was supposed to be in the original. I didn’t tell them that Nadia’s life had become a tiny bead on a string I was pulling through time, over and over, not realizing that the string was cutting my skin. By the time I got home, I had to loop my belt tighter. Not because I’d lost weight, but because my hips were different. My shoes pinched. When I walked past the hall mirror, a stranger glanced at me from the corner of his eye. My mom gasped and put a hand over her mouth and said, “Did you—are you—?” and I said, “I guess.” She kept her distance like I was a guest, or like she was trying to see who I was through a fog. When I went to my room, I saw a shadow under my window. The cat again. It had followed me home. I called Wetzel and he didn’t pick up. Theo texted me “hero” and a muscle arm. Nadia sent only “how.” I didn’t sleep. Every time I closed my eyes I saw the bleachers folding, time folding, everything folding. The watch buzzed, buzzed, buzzed, an encouragement or a threat. The rewind icon pulsed when I didn’t touch it, like it was breathing for me. Just after midnight, I heard tapping. I sat up, hair sticking to my forehead, the room too warm. The tapping came from the window. The cat’s paw on the glass, soft, persistent. It looked at me with those lemon-slice eyes and tipped its head. I went to the window and slid it up a crack and the cat squeezed through, liquid bones, landing on my desk with a soundless thud. “You shouldn’t be in here,” I whispered. My voice made my chest vibrate. I hid it behind my teeth. It walked over to my wrist, and before I could stop it, it put its paw on the watch face. The rewind icon flared. The cat looked up and I swear I recognized something in it. Not someone older. Someone the same age as me, someone who had made the same mistake. “You know,” I said. The cat blinked. “You know what happens when I use it.” The cat’s tail swished. It touched the screen again, very gently, as if it were choosing. I swallowed. My throat felt like sandpaper. “Every time I…” I couldn’t make myself say rewind. “Every time I do it, it takes something from me. It’s not supposed to be free.” The cat’s ear twitched, the torn one. It didn’t look away. “And I messed up,” I said, heat rising under my skin. “I wasn’t where I was supposed to be, and Nadia almost—” I couldn’t say that either. The word stuck like gum. “If I go back before the drill, before the gym, I can—” My fingers shook. My thumb hovered. I looked at my face in the black mirror of the window. The outline of a boy and somebody’s older brother and a stranger. The second hand ticked. Tick. Tick. Tick. The cat bared its teeth, not a hiss, not a smile. Something in between. It pressed its paw down. The screen lit. The slider appeared. Minus one hour. Tick tick tick tick. “Wait—” I said, grabbing the cat’s paw, but it was too late. The room lurched. My posters peeled back onto the wall. My laundry folded itself into a pile and then unfolded and then disappeared into my drawers. The sun slid up, down, like a yoyo. My heart stumbled. When the world stopped, my room smelled like lemon cleaner. The watch burned against my skin. The calendar on my phone said yesterday. The cat sat on my history binder, tail curled, eyes vast. My chest was tight with a feeling that might have been relief and might have been terror. I hadn’t known until then that reversing the clock was like peeling your own skin back to get at the bones underneath. I had gotten what I wanted. I had gone back. I had a chance to be in the right place, to keep the bleachers from failing at all, to call the janitor, to tell someone about the bolt. But my palms were bigger. The hair on my arms stood up. In the window’s reflection, a boy who looked like me and like he didn’t looked back. The age in my eyes wasn’t something a shower could wash away. The cat blinked slowly. Each time I blinked back, it was like an agreement. Like a pact. “Once more,” I said, feeling the words scrape their way out. “And then we stop.” The cat tipped its head. The watch hummed. Outside, the streetlight clicked off. Somewhere, Nadia woke up and checked her phone and didn’t know that in one version of the day she had died and in another she had survived and in this one, she would be saved without ever knowing it. My heart knocked like someone at a door. I slid the bar again. Minus thirty minutes. Tick. Tick. Tick. Somewhere in those ticks, I could feel something inside me shift a little further forward, as if all the waiting my body had been doing decided to end at once. In the dark window, my reflection straightened. I looked like an eighth grader and a ninth grader and someone I didn’t have words for. It would be worth it if it worked. It had to be. The cat watched, expressionless and knowing and sorry. When time snapped back and my watch beeped like a completed timer, it jumped off the desk and flowed out of the window like water, without looking back. I lay down on my bed and listened to the new morning gather itself outside. Birds restarted their songs. Tires hissed on wet pavement. In half an hour, I would know if the disaster had been erased or just rerouted. I would know if the cat’s recognition meant I had been here before, countless times, each time becoming the person in the window a little sooner than I should have. And I would find out, I thought, pressing my palm flat over the watch, if anyone knew me anymore when I got there. If the me I was making with each rewind would finally be the one who knew how to stop.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece effectively captures the Goosebumps-style teen horror genre while adding depth beyond what might be expected. The story follows a middle schooler who discovers their smartwatch can rewind time, but each use ages them prematurely. The narrative successfully builds tension through the protagonist's gradual realization of the consequences of their actions. The writing demonstrates strong command of voice, maintaining the perspective of a middle school student while subtly showing their maturation through language shifts as they age. The protagonist's internal monologue feels authentic to a teen, with observations like "Everyone at Greendale Middle was obsessed with sudden growth, like overnight you woke up with six inches and a mustache." The mysterious cat serves as an effective device, suggesting a cyclical nature to the story—perhaps the cat was once a child who made the same mistake. This adds layers to what could have been a simpler cautionary tale. The imagery is particularly strong with the cat, described with "yellow eyes that didn't look like they'd been made for a cat" and a tail "curled around itself like a question mark." The pacing is well-managed, with the protagonist's growing awareness of their physical changes paralleling the escalating consequences of their time manipulation. The bleacher collapse scene creates genuine tension and demonstrates how the protagonist's interference with time has real, potentially fatal consequences. However, there are some weaknesses. The dialogue occasionally feels functional rather than distinctive, particularly with secondary characters like Wetzel and Theo. While the ending appropriately leaves questions unanswered in keeping with the genre, it feels slightly rushed in resolving the immediate crisis. The prose occasionally becomes too dense with metaphors, such as "reversing the clock was like peeling your own skin back to get at the bones underneath," which might be a bit sophisticated for the Goosebumps style. Some descriptions, while evocative, slightly exceed the typical middle-grade horror vocabulary. The story excels in showing the protagonist's internal struggle and physical transformation through specific details rather than simply telling the reader what's happening. The protagonist's growing discomfort with their changing body is conveyed through concrete observations: "My skin wasn't the oil slick it usually was. The two sad commas where my eyebrows should be looked darker." Overall, this is a strong piece that balances the supernatural elements with relatable coming-of-age anxieties. It successfully creates a sense of dread while maintaining the protagonist's agency in trying to fix their mistakes, even as they continue to pay the price for manipulating time. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 6 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 6.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Noir romance: Carnival of Dangerous Intentions — Score: 87.2
Prompt:
Carnival of Dangerous Intentions Coney Island, New York, July 1937. She stopped just before reaching the shooting gallery set up along the boardwalk. It was near dusk, and the carnival lights were buzzing on. **His locks**. The words flashed through her mind, again, like an intruder. Such an old-fashioned turn of phrase that kept surfacing, and something else -- dangerously compelling -- quickly suppressed, lest she question why she had returned here at all. This place where she had promised to meet the stranger -- the young man with the obsidian curls and even darker eyes. She didn't even know his name. Write a scene in a larger story inspired by this prompt. The scene should capture an atmosphere that blends romantic allure with an undercurrent of subtle danger or moral ambiguity. Think 50 shades, but with a more restrained classic sensibility. The scene is all about establishing tension. Write for the feminine perspective. Include roughly 50% dialogue, 20% internal monologue, and 30% exposition and scene setting. The tone should have some edge to it. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The sodium lamps shivered awake, one by one, as if the boardwalk had broken out in a nervous rash. They cast uneven halos across the planks and over the backs of people passing, making strangers look like stage players rehearsing under half-spoiled footlights. She stopped just before the shooting gallery. Tin ducks creaked along a tired track; the carny’s voice was a lazy rasp promising cigars and teddy bears. Brine and grease and sugar curled around her like ribbon. His locks. The phrase startled her, again, intrusive and old-fashioned, as if she were reading herself in a book borrowed from a grandmother’s trunk. It made her want to laugh at herself, or slap her cheeks. Something ridged inside her with it, something that had felt like warning and lately felt like a dare. His locks. As if they were hers to touch. “You’re early,” a voice said, close at her shoulder. She turned before she let herself flinch. There he was, a few feet away, separated from her by a row of prize bottles painted with chipped flowers. His hair truly was obsidian; it caught the scant light and hoarded it, refusing to shine. The eyes were darker, yes, and better for it—fathomless when he did not smile and sly when he did. He wore a gray suit that might have been new last year and a soft cap in his hand, thumb bending the brim. “I was about to say you were late,” she said, not unkindly. Her voice was lower than she remembered it. He looked at the shooting gallery, then at her. “I don’t like guns,” he said. “Takes the sport out of sport.” It was a ridiculous thing to say. She liked it, immediately. “You invited me to a boardwalk,” she said. “There’s no sport here. There’s only losing.” The corner of his mouth lifted. “Then let’s lose well.” People flowed around them, drifting toward the Ferris wheel, toward the rollercoaster that groaned like a wounded beast. The lights made the wet air hum. A couple passed in pressed clothes that suggested sincerity, the man guiding the woman with a palm on her back as if it were a dance step he’d been practicing. She stepped back from the shooting gallery, into the thicker dark between two lampposts where the boards smelled more of tar than salt. He followed without touching, and it felt like touch all the same. “I don’t know your name,” she said, and felt foolish immediately. She had come. There was a tacit contract in that. He could have been anything and anyone, and she had dressed for him. Her gloves were thin, pearl kidskin, inappropriate for July and therefore perfect. “You don’t want it,” he said, and then, after a beat, with something like courtesy: “Nathan.” “Nathan,” she echoed. The syllables fitted mouth to teeth in a way that felt usable. His locks. His name. “Yours?” he asked. “It won’t help you,” she said. The little thrill of saying it. “It won’t help me.” He glanced past her at the row of rifles chained to their ledges. “We could win each other a prize,” he said lightly. “Then we’d be obliged.” “If you want a mistress,” she said, and then swallowed. The word was a stone. She coughed a laugh over it to make it smaller. He didn’t blink. “I want a night,” he said. “And you,” he added, looking past her again, as if she might be the thing beyond her. “Don’t you?” The question drifted up like smoke and slipped into her. Did she? Why else stand here, constellated by erratic light, with the smell of frying hot dogs making her stomach clench? Why else bring the little clutch bag with the snap closure and the mirror that made her face look slightly unreal, chalked, film-starred? Why else tell her sister she was visiting a friend in Brooklyn, a Mrs. Dalton with a sick child who existed nowhere? “Walk,” she said. They walked parallel to the rail where the ocean made a low percussive shush, not the roar of day but a patient busying itself. He kept half a pace behind her, allowing her to choose the path between vendors and the boys who’d shrugged out of shirts to show muscle, between girls in seersucker laughing too loud and a man selling photographs of ladies in tight suits who smiled as if they were not smiling at all. “Is this where you bring them?” she asked. “Who?” “The women,” she said. “Whose names you don’t want.” He laughed once, like a bell struck with a thumb. “I’m here for the water,” he said. “And the oddity of electricity. The way it makes things seem more than they are.” “You didn’t answer,” she said. “You didn’t ask,” he said. His audacity was…delicate. It had edges but wasn’t crude. It set against the night like the teeth of a key. If he’d reached for her arm she would have cut him with her voice. He did not. He moved in a way that suggested he’d held many things, and dropped some, and knew which would fall on their own. “Did you come back to be forgiven?” he asked suddenly. She stopped. The Ferris wheel was beginning its slow lift, a circle of pearls climbing. “For what?” “If you don’t know,” he said, and shook his head as if to cast off a gnat, “you wouldn’t ask.” Don’t be stupid, she told herself. Don’t be theatrical. But the word forgiven slid up hard against wanted, and they chimed against each other like glass. “I don’t require absolution,” she said. “Only discretion.” “Those are cousins,” he said. “I don’t care for your family,” she said. He looked at her hands. “Nor they for you,” he said. “Your gloves don’t fit.” “They fit precisely,” she said, and then realized what he meant: not that they were too tight or too loose, but that they were wrong for heat. That she was built to be wrong tonight. That she had made herself into something with an edge as well. “You’re cruel,” he said, and smiled like it was noon. “Thank God.” They came to the fortune-teller’s booth. The woman inside wore a scarf like a stage curtain, coins stitched to it that pretended at wealth. Her eyes were a flat brown that would see anything for two nickels. Nathan looked at the painted sign—PALM 10¢, CRYSTAL 15¢—with a bright, boyish skepticism. It was almost innocent. Almost. “Do you want to know?” he asked. “What?” “Whether I’m bad for you.” Her laugh startled them both. “What do you think?” “I think you’ve already decided,” he said. She could have said she’d decided not to decide. It would have been cleaner. But the heat was making her sternum damp and the sodium lights were flaring and fading, stuttering at the edges like a film spool at the end of a reel, and everything in her wanted the kiss of a risk to make the whole of this body feel like it belonged to her again. Her husband’s hand—no, do not think of him. His locks. Nathan’s locks. The words overlapped like the double exposure of a face on a face. “Tell me something true,” she said. “And not a commonplace. Not something a man with a hat says on a boardwalk.” He took off his cap entirely, held it in both hands as if in prayer. “I get things wrong on purpose,” he said, very quietly. “To see if someone will correct me.” “Manipulative,” she said. “Educational,” he said. “If they care to fix it, they care.” “And if they don’t?” “I leave them to their competency,” he said. “And you? Do you sew your own buttons?” She could have laughed him away. She could have stepped into the booth and given the fortune-teller her hand like a joke. Instead, she said: “I have a woman who comes Tuesdays.” “And tonight is Thursday,” he said. “So a missing button would be very inconvenient.” “Would it?” she asked. He lifted his gaze to her face like a hand lifting a veil: careful, unsteady. “If you went somewhere with me where it mattered,” he said. The rollercoaster shrieked. The boardwalk trembled with the plunge. She thought of the hotel on Surf Avenue with the tarnished brass keypad at the desk and the curt man who asked nothing if you paid in advance. She thought of the apartment in Queens where the windows stuck, where the radio had begun to static at the same time every evening like the city sending a code to those who knew how to receive it. She thought of Nathan’s cap, his mouth. His locks. “Are you dangerous?” she asked. Her throat tightened as if the word required a particular shape. “I’m careful,” he said. “That isn’t the question.” He put the cap back on, low. “Then yes.” “To me?” He tilted his head. The light above them flickered, buzzed, steadied, and made his irises briefly reflect, like coins in shallow water. “To anyone who prefers their life tidy,” he said. She let that hang, heavy, like a necklace you aren’t sure suits you. Her heart was beating a little too fast. There was a flush at her ears. She could feel on the backs of her knees the sweat the stockings bothered. She wanted to be touched and also not to be seen erring. The urge was twin, braided, and annihilating. Don’t be cheap, she thought. Don’t be cruel to yourself, either. “Come with me,” he said. “We’ll ride the Wonder Wheel. It’s almost empty at this hour. We can look down at the lights and pretend the world is orderly.” “You aren’t,” she said. “No,” he said. “But I can lie well.” She let him lead then, because it felt like not leading, because they kept a distance between their bodies that could have been mistake or plan. In the queue, a young boy cried because his brother had taken his ticket, and the mother, tired, said, “You can both sit with me,” in a voice that had already apologized for itself. Nathan glanced at the mother with something like softness. It wasn’t feigned. She told herself to catalog that. They got a car that swayed; she wanted it to, and hated that she did. The operator, a man with nicotine fingers, slammed the gate and said, “Hold onto your hats,” with a grin meant to be practiced. As they rose, the boardwalk flattened beneath them into ribbon and pearl. The lamps were erratic stars. The ocean was a bruise that went on and on. Wind got into her hair. She put a hand up to hold it, not the hat—the hat was impractical and therefore she had not worn one—but the hair itself, a gesture like being shy that she did so he would watch her do it. “You’re beautiful when you pretend not to know you are,” he said. “Don’t flatter,” she said. “It’s vulgar.” “I told you I’d lie well,” he said. “You said you could,” she said. “Not that you would.” He smiled with his mouth shut. She wanted to touch his locks and hated that she wanted it, loved that she hated it, was dizzy with the duplication. “What do you do?” she asked suddenly, so sharply it sounded like accusation. “For money?” he said. “For pardon,” she said. The car swayed. He looked out at the water. “I collect debts,” he said. She felt the chill, welcome as an ice cube behind her knee. “For whom?” “For men who need reminding,” he said. “And for myself.” “Does it require a gun?” she asked, nodding back toward the gallery with its ridiculous prizes. “Only sometimes,” he said. “And even then, not firing.” “And tonight?” He looked at her then as if she were under glass, as if the operator had placed her on a shelf to be dusted. “Tonight I’m in arrears,” he said. “A different kind of debt.” “To whom?” He leaned in just enough that she smelled him—clean, but something like cigar smoke in his lapels, sweet and stale. “To the part of me that believes in newness,” he said. “That part seems naïve,” she said. She wanted him to be better and worse than he was, simultaneously. “It’s not large,” he said. “But it’s persistent.” The car stopped at the top while others were loaded. They hung there, gently swaying. The boardwalk sighed below. He didn’t reach for her. She could feel between their bodies the tension that wasn’t physical yet. It had shape anyway, a cord pulled taut. “Say my name,” he said. She didn’t want to give that away. Saying it made it more real than touching would have. She looked past him at the cheap wonders, the impossible sky. “Nathan,” she said. He closed his eyes briefly, as if that were the thing he’d come for. “Now yours,” he said. She shook her head, small. “No.” He opened his eyes and nodded, accepting a debt that would compound. The car jolted and began its descent. The lights below blinked and failed and revived, made and unmade faces as if the world were deciding who they were, moment to moment. She slid off one glove and kept the other on. He watched with a concentration that made her breath stagger. When the car was low enough for the operator to see them, she put the glove back on. Nathan’s smile then was wicked and grateful and something else she couldn’t read. When they stepped off, she didn’t take his arm. He didn’t offer. They walked past the shooting gallery again. The carny’s voice had gone hoarse. A boy shot at ducks and hit none. Somewhere a siren started, far away, a city sound. The night was thick now, its heat less forgiving. “Do you want a prize?” Nathan asked. “No,” she said. “I want—” She stopped. “What?” he said, almost gently. She pictured the hotel again. The room with the mirror that made a trapezoid of a woman and insisted she was still whole. She pictured taking off the gloves. She pictured not being forgiven in any way that mattered. She pictured waking tomorrow with salt in her hair and a mark at her wrist and no story that would satisfy anyone, least of all herself. “I want to be someone else for an hour,” she said. His eyes warmed and cooled like metal in a forge. “I can pay for the room,” he said. “You can keep your name.” She let the tide of people carry them forward a step. “No,” she said. Then softer: “Not yet.” He nodded as if this too were precisely the answer he expected, the one that would let him wrong something on purpose another day. He took off his cap, turned it in his hands, and then set it back on. “I’ll be here next Thursday,” he said. “If you want to try again at losing.” She looked at his hair, his locks, and then at his mouth. Her tongue pressed to the back of her teeth before she spoke, as if to check for truth. “I don’t like to lose,” she said. He smiled. “Neither do I,” he said. “That’s why it’s worth doing.” He lifted two fingers to the brim of his cap and vanished into the crowd as if the light had undone him. She stood a moment too long, until the carny at the gallery said, “You playing, miss?” and she shook her head and turned away, the gloves a second skin she still wasn’t sure were hers. The boardwalk’s sodium lights flickered, off-on, off-on, and she let the stutter lead her home.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a tense, atmospheric scene between two strangers with an undercurrent of danger and romantic allure. The writing demonstrates considerable skill in establishing the 1930s Coney Island setting through sensory details and period-appropriate language. The protagonist's internal conflict is well-rendered through her contradictory desires and hesitations. The writer effectively uses the motif of "his locks" as an intrusive thought that represents her forbidden attraction. The dialogue between the characters maintains tension through what remains unsaid as much as what is spoken. The prose is generally elegant, with evocative descriptions like "sodium lamps shivered awake, one by one, as if the boardwalk had broken out in a nervous rash." However, there are moments where the writing becomes slightly overwrought, with metaphors that call attention to themselves rather than enhancing the scene. The dialogue effectively reveals character while maintaining mystery. Nathan's lines like "I get things wrong on purpose... To see if someone will correct me" efficiently establish his manipulative nature while hinting at deeper complexity. The protagonist's responses reveal her conflicted desires and self-awareness. The piece adheres well to the prompt's requirements, maintaining the requested balance of dialogue, internal monologue, and exposition. The tone successfully blends romantic allure with subtle danger, and the feminine perspective is consistently maintained. The ending avoids resolution, maintaining tension while suggesting future encounters. This works well for a scene from a larger story, though it does leave the reader somewhat suspended. Where the piece occasionally falters is in some overly literary constructions that feel self-conscious rather than natural to the narrative voice. Lines like "The urge was twin, braided, and annihilating" draw attention to the writing itself rather than deepening character or advancing the story. Overall, this is a skillfully crafted scene that establishes complex characters and a compelling situation while maintaining the requested atmosphere of restrained tension and moral ambiguity. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 17 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 5 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 17.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 5.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Surreal horror: Caribou Season at the Lodge — Score: 88.8
Prompt:
Caribou Season at the Lodge Genre: Surreal Horror JT knew something wasn't right from the moment they'd pulled up to the lodge. It looked exactly as it had every autumn of his life—the cedar shingles silvered with age, the porch sagging gently under weight of winters past—but the air felt thicker, somehow, as if the woods had leaned in closer, waiting. He thought maybe he was just tired. Maybe it was nothing more than the long drive north, cramped in the back of the truck beside his older brother Mike -- and a stack of rifles wrapped in oily canvas. Still, the feeling lingered. The first caribou they found that season hadn't bolted. It had just watched, ears flicking lazily, waiting for the shot. JT had felt a crawling in his gut watching it die, noticing how it fell with a quiet dignity—as though it had wanted nothing more. Nobody else seemed to find it odd, or at least they didn't say so. JT kept his mouth shut. Always safer that way. Then there was the moment in the clearing. JT had fallen behind, fumbling with bootlaces stiff from the cold, and by the time he'd caught up with his father and brother, they'd already stopped. JT slowed instinctively, ducking behind a tangle of brush, staring out into the open space where a massive buck stood utterly still, chest rising and falling in slow, deep breaths. The animal looked…wrong, somehow. Maybe it was the eyes—dark and flat, calm in a way that made JT's neck prickle. Or maybe it was something deeper, something in the way the buck stood close enough for his father to reach out and touch it. JT watched as his father raised a trembling hand toward the animal's muzzle. His father's face had a strange expression, eyes too bright, lips parted slightly, like he was on the verge of whispering something—a secret, maybe. The rifle hung uselessly at his side, forgotten. Mike had the same dazed look in his eyes. JT's breath stopped short, his mind suddenly shouting at him to look away, turn around, just run—but he couldn't move. And then, as suddenly as it had begun, it was over. The buck shivered, startled by something unseen, and disappeared into the brush without so much as a sound. The two of them looked around, confused, seemingly surprised to find themselves where they stood. JT stayed hidden, breathing shallowly, fear mingling with a confused sense of shame. His father had failed to take the shot. To even think about mentioning what he'd seen would have felt like betrayal—or something worse. JT waited until the others moved on before stepping out from cover. He stared into the empty clearing for a long, uneasy moment, wondering if anything had really happened at all, or if he was losing his grip. Maybe the woods were finally getting into his head. Writing Instructions: Continue with the next chapter of the story, maintaining a style reminiscent of Stephen King—grounded realism blended seamlessly with unsettling surrealism. The atmosphere should convey subtle dread, isolation, and psychological ambiguity. JT's perspective is crucial, yet he is an unreliable narrator, caught in uncertainty about what he's perceiving. Establish an undertone of creeping dread, establishing the isolation of JT's perspective, which he largely keeps to himself. Incorporate some dialogue. Build tension towards a payoff. 1000 words.
Model Output:
They set up in the lodge like always—duffels thrown into corners, boots lined by the woodstove, the smell of wet wool and gun oil rising like an old hymn. The stove ticked and sighed. In the kitchen, the light was a jaundiced yellow that made everyone look hungover. Mike tossed JT a beer across the scarred table, which he fumbled and almost dropped. “You gonna keep looking at me like that?” Mike asked, half a smirk and half something else. “Like what?” JT cracked the beer slowly, thinking of the clearing, thinking of their father’s hand and the buck’s big, soft nose. He tasted aluminum before the cheap lager. “Like I stole your girl. Like I did something to you.” “Forget it.” Their father sat at the head of the table, peeling an orange with the little pocketknife he kept in his jeans. He’d taken off his flannel and wore a white T-shirt that had seen better days. He didn’t look at either of them. He cut the orange in clean, even swaths, the blade clicking against the pith, juice glistening on his fingers. JT realized his father hadn’t said five words since the clearing. He had that look like when he’d get in one of his moods—sober, but lidded over. Gone somewhere else. “You okay?” JT asked. His father kept peeling, the knife finding some invisible seam. “Fine,” he said. “Cold’s going to be bad tonight. Get more wood in.” Mike rolled his eyes and stood. “You hear that, kid? He’s fine. Go stick your face in a snow bank and say a prayer to whatever it is that took your spine.” JT laughed because that’s what you do. He put on his coat and went out, not because he’d been told, but because being outside was a relief—a bigger room to hold the weirdness. He took the splitting maul from where it leaned by the stacked birch and ash. The yard behind the lodge stretched down to a black line of trees, the treeline so steady it seemed drawn with a ruler. There was a wind now, carrying the faint smell of something that could have been musk or rot. He set a log on the block and brought the maul down. The crack rang like a shot, hollow in the cold air. He kept splitting until his forearms boiled and his breath wheezed. Between swings, the silence filled in. He could hear the woods when he stopped. Not leaves, not birds—deep quiet, like the forest was holding air in its chest and refusing to let it go. Behind him the lodge windows glowed with that liver-yellow light. He thought about the first caribou, the way it had just watched them like a cow in a field, unafraid, almost bored. He thought about the buck, the way it had stood as if waiting to be touched. If he let the memory wash over him, he could feel again how the air had thickened in that clearing, syrupy, how his father had looked like a boy who had found an old toy in the attic and forgotten everything else in the joy of it. A shape moved between the trees at the treeline, something tall and slow. He blinked and it was gone. Maybe it hadn’t been there at all. Maybe the woods were full of afterimages now. Inside, Mike and their father argued in low, scraping voices that bumped along the bottom of hearing. JT stacked wood by the stove and went upstairs early. The lodge felt different up there, like a church after everyone leaves. The hall rug ate his footsteps. His old room was the same as it had been when he was fourteen—plaid blanket, a cracked poster of a hockey player, the shelf with the toothpick sculptures he’d made one summer when he’d refused to go fishing. He lay on his back and watched his breath puff in the cold. The floorboards creaked under someone’s weight and then stopped outside his door. He got up to open it, but there was nothing in the hall. The yellow light from the downstairs trailed up only a few steps and died in the dark like it had changed its mind. From the end of the hall, a rectangle of a window looked out onto the black of the yard and the blacker of the woods. He thought he saw a pale shape moving on the lawn, something the size of a man but wrong in how it leaned. He didn’t go to the window to get a better look. He shut the door. He put a chair under the knob because that’s what felt, just then, like survival. Sleep took him quick and mean and spit him back out in the middle of the night. He’d dreamed about the abandoned cabin off Fox Ridge, the one they’d been told not to go near when they were kids, the one that had the collapsed roof and the broken tin chimney that stuck up like a finger. In the dream the chimney wasn’t broken. Smoke rolled out of it in fat coils, and a hundred birds were perched along the eaves, listening to something inside. He woke with a mouth full of the taste of soot, and the quiet pressing down. There was a sound then, in the lodge, a faint knocking. JT’s first thought was the chair slipping under the knob, but no—that was in his control, at least a little. This was downstairs. He sat up, wrapped the blanket around his shoulders, and listened. Knock. Knock. A pause. Knock. A polite rhythm. He waited for someone else to move. No one did. He took the chair away and put his ear to the cold wood of the door. The noise was clearer now, from the side porch. He knew the sound because he’d made it—gloved knuckles on old wood. He opened the door and went down the stairs just enough to see the front hall. Dim light smeared across the floorboards from the stove’s window, flicker and shadow. JT’s father was standing at the door with his hand on the knob. He didn’t move as JT eased down the last steps. Mike stood behind him, barefoot, hair stuck up. They both looked like boys caught in a game past their bedtime. “You hear that?” Mike whispered. “Yeah,” JT said. Their father didn’t turn his head, but his voice came, husky and soft. “Don’t open it.” The knocking came again. JT realized it was coming from the side porch after all—the one that opened out toward the path to Fox Ridge. No one ever used that door. It stuck in winter. He had a clear picture of the warped door, the cracked pane of glass with the spiderweb of cheap tape over it. “I’ll go see,” Mike said, like he’d been dared. “Don’t.” Their father put a hand out. The palm was slick with orange juice dried to tack. He looked at JT finally, his eyes wet. “Do you hear it?” he asked, as if JT’s answer would confirm whether or not any of this was happening. JT swallowed. He heard it. He also heard—under it, or through it—a low sound that could have been wind in the trees or could have been breath. The knocking stopped like it had been called away. The silence poured in too fast. The three of them stood there like idiots waiting for a bus that hadn’t existed in twenty years. Then a soft rasp came from the side door, wood against wood. Something dragged across the threshold. A smell slid into the hall and coated JT’s tongue. It was not death, not exactly. It was the smell of an animal’s soft place, the warm body spot it leaves in the grass when it stands up—deep and private and a little rotten around the edges. “Back away,” their father said, as if someone were about to open the door from inside the porch. Mike whispered, “It’s probably a raccoon.” JT saw the way Mike’s shoulders had tightened. He saw the shiver that moved up his father’s spine. He felt the chair he’d left upstairs like a betrayal. The rasping stopped. The stove clicked. The house settled, old wood aching in the cold. Something bumped against the door from the outside. Not a knock this time. A slow, heavy push. The tape on the cracked pane quivered. JT took one step back. Then another. His father stayed, palm flat against the door, like he could keep something out by wanting to. A long moment passed where JT realized his father was listening to something only he could hear. Then his father’s hand dropped. He turned and walked into the kitchen, slow, as if about to fall asleep on his feet. “Back to bed,” he said. “It’s nothing.” Mike shrugged like the whole thing bored him. “Told you,” he said. But he didn’t meet JT’s eyes. He didn’t go back to bed, either, not right away. He stood in the hall and watched the side door for a while, jaw working, and then he stomped off, performative. JT waited until he could hear Mike upstairs, hear the old mattress springs and the muffled curse. He stood alone with the door. He put his own palm against the wood. It was colder than it should have been, as if the air were thinner right there. He felt, for a second, the lightest pressure on the other side, the suggestion of a hand that did not have fingers, pressing back. He removed his hand as if he’d been burned. He went upstairs and lay with his eyes open until a gray smear of morning showed. The day pretended at normal. Coffee tasted like metal. In the yard a fine frost laced the dead grass. They walked out with rifles and stiff jokes. The woods had shrunk overnight. The trails were the same but closer. Their breaths coiled up and disappeared into the trees. By midmorning Mike had turned cocky again, shooting snow off branches, whooping when it fell on JT’s head. Their father was quieter than ever. They crossed a logging road, followed a fence row until the land began to roll. That was where the sign was—just a piece of rusted tin nailed to a tree that had grown half around it. Faded letters: FOX RIDGE CABIN. KEEP OUT. JT had seen it a hundred times. He’d never seen the shadow of writing underneath, ghost words that made the nails look newer. He blinked and it was just rust. They stopped for lunch by a stand of jack pines. “We’re not going near that place,” their father said suddenly, as if someone had asked. Mike laughed. “What place?” “The cabin.” Mike and JT exchanged a look like kids. The abandoned hunting cabin had been a rite of fear when they were small. The story changed every year. Drifters. A hermit with a hole in his face where his mouth should have been. A moose that went inside and couldn’t come back out. “You believe in that?” Mike said. “Old bump in the woods?” “It’s there,” their father said. “That’s enough.” They ate in silence after that. The cold bit through gloves to fingers. When they began to move again, a low light had come up, a thin sun smudged by cloud. They kept to the thicker pines where the wind made a sound like talking if you weren’t careful. JT fell behind because that was what he did. He thought of the door in the night, the pushing weight. He felt that same pressure in his chest now, like something big and patient had turned its head and noticed him. The path bent and he came into a logging cut that opened onto the ridge. Across the hollow, through a stand of gray birch, he saw it: the cabin. Not so far as the stories made it, not so grand. Just a slump of roof and the tin chimney like a crooked tooth. He saw a smear of something dark on the snow by the door. He lifted his hand without meaning to and waved, stupid habit from a hundred childhood passes. Someone waved back. Not a hand. A shadow flickered in the doorway, a tilt—a suggestion of head. Reflex made him lift the rifle to his shoulder. He caught himself. He looked down the sights anyway. There was nothing there but the doorway, darker than it had a right to be. “JT!” Mike’s voice ricocheted off the trees. He tore his cheek off the stock and turned too fast, the world swinging. He stumbled and went down to one knee. “Jesus,” Mike said, crashing through brush. “Stop daydreaming. We got a mover.” JT stood and wiped his knee. “Where’s Dad?” Mike jerked his chin over his shoulder. “Up along. He’s acting weird. You see him last night? Talking to the door?” JT stared at the ridge. The cabin sat as if it had always been waiting. He didn’t say what he’d seen. He didn’t say that he wanted—very badly—to go to the cabin just to prove it wasn’t what it looked like. Instead he let himself be yanked along. Their father’s orange cap bobbed ahead, dipping and rising, the man himself moving with a stiffness that made JT think of the first winter after Mom left, the long walks their father took with no destination. They followed a set of tracks then, fresh. Four prints and a drag. Not a deer. Maybe a caribou that had a bad hoof. The tracks went straight where the terrain made it hard, like the animal didn’t care about difficulty. The air lost what little warmth it had hoarded. They came to a place where the world had gone quiet even for the woods. No chickadees, no foot crackle. The tracks disappeared at the edge of a stand of spruce. Not faded. Stopped. Like the animal had stepped up into something and been taken away. “Hell,” Mike said, laughing, and then the laugh strangled itself. Their father lifted his rifle and pointed it at the empty space. His finger rested along the trigger guard. He didn’t lower it. He breathed with his mouth open. “Don’t talk,” he said. “Listen.” JT listened. He heard nothing. Then he heard, as if from a long way off and also right behind his ear, a single hoof-step on wooden boards. A hollow, throat-deep, decisive sound like in an old barn. The smell from the door poured over him again. JT thought about the scraping. The pushing. The knock that had been polite. He thought about his father’s hand on the buck’s muzzle. He put the barrel of his rifle toward the ground and made his mouth shape the word no, but no sound came. In the spruce stand, something moved. It wasn’t a deer. It wasn’t anything he had a name for. The branches didn’t part so much as re-arrange. For half a second there was an impression: a head too tall, a neck too long for any animal around here, a set of eyes that didn’t reflect the weak sun but made their own gloss. He saw himself widemouthed in their blackness. He saw his father’s orange cap bleed into gray. He saw Mike raising his gun and shaking just enough to make the barrel wag. “Don’t,” their father said, but to who, JT didn’t know. His voice had a wonder in it. A terrible kindness. The thing in the trees leaned forward without moving. The air tightened—made of glass, maybe. Something gave then. A sound like a board breaking. The smell of warm fur and old water. JT’s finger twitched on instinct, but his rifle wasn’t pointed. Mike’s went off. The crack slapped back from the ridge and was gone. Snow shook from branches like applause. Silence returned. The rearranged branches were just branches. The tracks were still gone. His brother breathed hard, each inhale a scrape. His father’s cap returned to orange. They stood there for a long time, listening to nothing. Finally his father lowered his rifle. He smiled in a way that made JT’s stomach clench. The smile wasn’t for them. “Back to the lodge,” their father said. “We’ve done enough.” “What did we do?” Mike asked, voice too high. Their father turned and started down the path without answering. JT looked across at the cabin once more. Smoke rose very thinly from the broken chimney, a thread of gray that could have been cloud-scrap or breath in cold air. He didn’t point it out. He didn’t point out the dark smear by the door had gotten longer. He followed, counting his steps, making the numbers anchor him, losing track when a hoof-step fell softly inside his skull now and then, polite as a knock.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This continuation of the surreal horror story successfully maintains the established atmosphere while deepening the mystery and dread. The piece effectively builds on the initial setup, keeping JT's perspective as the unreliable narrator caught between what he perceives and what he can trust. The writing demonstrates strong command of atmospheric horror. The author skillfully creates a sense of wrongness through subtle details: the "jaundiced yellow" light, the father's strange behavior, the unnatural silence of the woods, and the mysterious knocking. The piece excels at creating a sense of isolation for JT, who notices things others don't acknowledge or dismiss. The dialogue serves the narrative well, revealing character dynamics while maintaining tension. Mike's dismissive attitude toward JT contrasts with their father's ominous silence, establishing family dynamics that heighten JT's isolation. The dialogue is sparse but effective, particularly in moments like the father's simple "Don't open it" and "It's nothing," which carry unsettling weight. The prose balances descriptive richness with restraint. Sensory details are vivid without becoming overwrought: "the smell of wet wool and gun oil rising like an old hymn," and the animal smell that "coated JT's tongue" create immediate sensory impressions. The author effectively uses sentence structure to control pacing, with shorter sentences creating tension during key moments. The narrative builds effectively toward multiple small payoffs rather than one climactic moment, which suits the psychological horror approach. The knocking sequence, the glimpse of something at the cabin, and the final encounter in the woods all provide escalating moments of dread without fully revealing what's happening. However, there are a few minor issues. Occasionally, the prose becomes slightly overwrought, particularly in some of the more metaphorical descriptions. A few transitions between scenes feel abrupt, and some of the father's behavior, while effectively creepy, could be more clearly motivated. The ending, while appropriately ambiguous for the genre, might leave some readers wanting more concrete development. Overall, this is a strong continuation that maintains the Stephen King-esque blend of grounded realism and unsettling surrealism. It effectively builds on the established premise while deepening the mystery and psychological dread, keeping the reader engaged through its atmospheric tension and subtle horror. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Fantasy-humour: Hell is Other Demons — Score: 91.8
Prompt:
Hell is Other Demons Write a day in the life short story. Lucifer morningstar's on again/ off again relationship with Lilith is currently in the "off again" stage, though the cycle may be coming around as Lilith has been stopping by for reasons other than purely violent ones, and Lucifer has been increasingly lonely. Write a day in the life of this power couple, with elements of dark comedy & fantasy. Use understated irony & absurdity by merging the black immorality and everyday business of running hell, against relatable domestic relationship drama. Take cues from Neil Gaiman. 1000 words.
Model Output:
Morning begins as it always does: with an email. The subject line announces God’s greatest gift to bureaucracy—an automatically generated ticket from the Complaint Department. Subject: Re: Re: Re: Souls not receiving appropriate torment per Subsection 13(b) Lucifer sighs, clicks the link, and skims the report. Someone’s been stuck on an infinitely looping hold line without being offered the option to schedule a callback, when by policy they should be getting an intermittent false hope message every thirty-seven minutes. Error margins matter. Torture is like jazz: it’s all about timing. He rubs his eyes. Coffee appears because he thinks about it. It tastes like a thunderstorm in a steel mug and gives him the false courage of doomed cavalry. Across the obsidian floor, his hellhound, Nuisance, has once again wedged her slobbery jaws around the left anterior leg of the Iron Throne and is gnawing with the galloping enthusiasm of an orchestra of nightmares playing the kazoo. The throne creaks. From centuries of stolen swords and unresolved grudges, it suffers a kind of metal fatigue that only immortality can produce. “Nuisance,” Lucifer says. He speaks in the tone reserved for ineffable beings and disobedient puppies. Nuisance freezes, eyes widening, jaw tightening, making the creak worse. He counts to five. She resumes with renewed gusto. He drinks. He answers the complaint. He cites the subsection. He flags a demon named Kchthx (intern, three horns, great with spreadsheets, a disaster at active listening) to shadow the torment team and fix the timing. He sets three meetings. He signs off as he always does: Best, L. Running Hell is mostly management. Human beings imagine it’s all flames and pitchforks, an eternal carnival ride of screams. This is occasionally true. Mostly, though, it’s metrics. A small bell rings in a room without bells, like a memory insisting on itself, and Lucifer knows: Lilith just arrived, because there is a particular gravity to her entrance. Not a sound. Not a smell. Just a reconfiguration of the air, like the way one notices a missing tooth with the tongue. She appears in the doorway without announcing herself. Black hair tied back with a leather cord, boots muddy with the residual gloom of whatever borderland she crossed to get here. Her gaze flickers to the throne’s gnawed leg, then to Nuisance, then to him. She narrows her eyes in that particular way that means the world is funny and terrible, and also his fault. “You moved the ninth circle two inches to the left,” she says by way of greeting. “The roads don’t line up anymore.” “I sent a memo,” he says. “I don’t read your memos,” she says. “On account of they are memos.” He tries a smile on. It doesn’t quite fit yet. “Coffee?” “No,” she says, walking in. “Yes,” she says, after walking past him, because she knows the taste of thunderstorms too. They sit. Nuisance plods over with her iron garnish, plops down, and begins chewing loudly in a rhythmic, slightly syncopated fashion. The throne creaks in Sapphic meter. Lucifer stares at the coffee in his hands as if it might catch fire and save him. “So,” he says. “So,” she agrees. She’s been stopping by more. Or less. It’s hard to measure. There are seasons to their breaking and gathering, though seasons are a mortal convenience. Once, they argued for six hundred years about whether love is a verb. She won by becoming a language he never learned to speak without laughing. “Your inbox is bleeding,” she notes. He glances. She’s right: more automatic tickets threading into existence like spider silk laced with gasoline. He tries not to flinch. “It’s the new intake form,” he says. “Mortals keep selecting ‘Other’ and writing in ‘Surprise me.’ It wreaks havoc on categorization.” “People always want to be special,” she says. “Even in agony.” She sips the coffee and watches him over the rim. “You look tired.” “I’m immortal,” he says. “You can still look tired,” she says, and he knows she’s talking about something else, like the weight pressing against his sternum, like the silence in his chambers at whatever hour he doesn’t need sleep. There are voices outside the door; a delegation. A polite knock in triplets. The Minister of Errata and the Duchess of Soot glide in, accompanied by a smell like burnt citrus. They bow with different degrees of irony. “Your Majesty,” says the Minister, whose skin is an index of footnotes. “We have an issue with Purgatory’s shared services desk. They’re forwarding our calls to Heaven.” “It’s a bug,” says the Duchess, picking a streak of soot from her sleeve as if it’s a chicken bone. “Or a prank.” “Is there a chance,” Lucifer says, “that you started it?” “Define started,” says the Duchess. He nods then, as if this is all perfectly reasonable. The work unspools. He authorizes a firewall. He authorizes a mild haunting of the shared services desk. He sets up a cross-departmental working group, which in Hell is probably the worst punishment anyone will ever endure. He arranges their chairs, gives them a charter, appoints Kchthx as secretary. He is, against his better judgment, good at this. Through it all, Lilith leans in the corner with an expression that is not not fond. Nuisance chews; the throne lists a millimeter toward some abyss that can never be reached. When the delegation leaves, Lilith says: “Your dog’s eating sovereignty.” “She’s teething.” “She’s twelve hundred.” “Adolescence is a spectrum,” he says, and her grin appears, unbidden, like a childhood ruin reclaimed by vines. The fact that he can still make her smile feels unfair and irresistible. “Walk?” she says. He says, almost without thinking: “I have a—” He gestures at his calendar, which is an actual paper calendar; he doesn’t trust the cloud, having invented clouds. Squares full of tiny ink, like a monk attempted Sudoku and lost his faith. She looks at it. Then at him. He hears the many apparatuses of Hell turn one notch forward without him. He stands. “Walk,” he says. They leave the throne room to Nuisance, who keeps working on the leg with the dedication of a saint, if saints had saliva that melted iron. They descend through corridors carved by ages of bureaucracy; they pass water coolers that dispense boiling pitch and small cups of gossip. Demons nod deferentially and also look away. Lilith ignores the nods with the regal disdain of someone who remembers when none of this existed and still thinks it might be a practical joke. In the Sixth, they stroll past the fields where the lawyers argue with themselves about what constitutes arguing. In the Fourth, the misers count and recount with beads that multiply under observation and vanish when hoarded. In the Third, it rains. It always rains, but today the rain is peppered with apologies and small coupons for free samples of disappointment. “This place is getting slick,” Lilith says. “Did you hire consultants?” “I am a consultant,” he says. “True,” she says. “How’s the lonely?” He wants to say he is fine. To say he has Nuisance and eleven hundred thousand meetings and the sharp pleasure of a well-executed vengeance. He wants to say he is on again with solitude, because it is better than being off again with her. He says: “It reads like poetry when I’m not looking too closely.” She nods like a queen knighting someone she intends to arrest later. “I brought you something,” she says, patting her coat. She produces a small jar. Inside: a moth, large as a hand, with wings patterned like broken mirrors. It beats once, a quiet shiver. “Found it between the first scream and the last. It eats secrets,” she says. “Or keeps them. I can never remember.” He takes the jar, and the moth’s eyes (if that is what they are) reflect him back as a man he doesn’t quite recognize. “Thank you,” he says, meaning the wrong thing, the right thing, too many things. They pass a field where poppies grow backwards from ash to seed. Workers tend them with tongs. A demon named Astrid waves. Lilith waves back. She knows everyone, or they think she does, which is functionally identical. They circle back. The throne room door is ajar. Inside, the leg Nuisance has been working at is bent at an angle that implies a criticism of monarchy. Nuisance looks up, guilty and proud. “Bad dog,” Lucifer says automatically. Nuisance’s tail thumps like a drum. Lilith kneels. “Open,” she tells Nuisance, who opens. Lilith peers into the mouth that held the leg of power and retrieves a crumpled memo with her fingertips. She smooths it, reads it. “Your procurement policy is a curse.” “It’s a best practice,” he says. “It is a hex against efficiency and joy,” she says, handing it to him. “I could fix this in an hour.” He feels the empty space where his pride and loneliness overlap. “I could let you.” A silence like a held breath. The moth in the jar clicks its wings, a sound like a pen tapping a desk. Somewhere far away, a dam of guilt breaks and floods a village of self-satisfaction in a way that will look, to mortals, like a viral trend. She looks at him and he looks back, and for a moment the whole of Hell tilts on the leg of a throne and a conversation not yet had. “Not today,” she says. “But I’ll draft you an outline.” “Attachment or inline?” he asks, because it is easier. “In blood on the wall,” she says, because it is truer. Nuisance wanders back to the leg. Lucifer snaps his fingers. A chew toy appears: a braided rope of curses tied in a knot. Nuisance looks at it with contempt and returns to the throne. Lilith laughs, a sound like a lock picking itself. They spend the afternoon in meetings. She sits at the back of the room, sometimes throwing in a comment that rearranges the entire agenda. He watches demons recalibrate like migrating birds, astounded to find true north still exists. She leaves once to take a call from no one and returns smelling faintly of lavender and grave dirt. At dusk — a word that means nothing here and everything everywhere else — he signs the day’s torments. He expects her to leave. She doesn’t. Instead, she leans her head against the throne’s armrest, close enough that he can hear the way her breath shifts when she’s remembering something. They sit like that, two former absolutes pretending compromise is a shape they can hold. Nuisance at last stops chewing. The leg of the throne remains. It will hold until it doesn’t. “You’re getting better at this,” she says, meaning the management, the mercy, the not. “Or worse. I can never tell.” “I’m consistent,” he offers. “No one is,” she says, and her hand, traitor and miracle, picks a fleck of iron from his sleeve. He wants to catch it, the moment, pin it like a butterfly. He does not. He has learned that pinning things is a way to watch them die. She stands. “I should go,” she says. “Stay,” he says, then, quietly. It hangs between them like a chandelier of knives. She looks at it. She looks at him. She smiles like a map of a country that can’t be conquered. “I’ll see you soon,” she says, which is not yes, and not no, and very much an answer. She pauses at the door. “Fix your throne,” she says. “Or don’t. It suits you crooked.” When she is gone, the air relaxes. The moth in the jar rasps its wings again, and he opens the lid. It climbs out, lumbering, and dissolves like a secret told to night. He considers his calendar. He considers the crooked leg and Nuisance asleep beside it, jaw twitching as if chewing in dreams. He writes a memo he will not send: Subject: Re: Re: Just so you know. He deletes it. He conjures a drink that tastes like the moment rain decides to fall. The bell rings again somewhere that has no bells. In his inbox, an outline appears, written in blood on a wall that is four corridors and a decision away. He smiles despite himself. He gets up. He goes to read it. This is how the day ends: with management, and the off again careening toward on, and a throne held up by the faith of a dog. Hell, like relationships, is a place built to be lived in. It is tedious and magnificent, terrible and familiar, and full of small, stupid salvations, like someone knowing where your memos go. Like someone, occasionally, coming back.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully captures the essence of Neil Gaiman's style with its blend of the mundane and the mythical, creating a Hell that functions like a corporate bureaucracy while maintaining its supernatural elements. The story portrays Lucifer as an administrator dealing with the tedium of running Hell while navigating his complex relationship with Lilith. The writing excels in its imagery and metaphors. Lines like "Coffee appears because he thinks about it. It tastes like a thunderstorm in a steel mug and gives him the false courage of doomed cavalry" demonstrate a poetic sensibility without becoming overwrought. The author creates vivid scenes with economical language, such as the description of Nuisance chewing on the throne leg or the various circles of Hell with their specific torments. Character development is nuanced, particularly in the portrayal of Lucifer and Lilith's relationship. Their interactions reveal a long history of connection and separation, with subtle hints at their feelings rather than explicit declarations. The dialogue between them feels authentic, with the right balance of familiarity, tension, and unspoken understanding. The piece maintains a consistent tone throughout, balancing dark humor with moments of genuine emotion. The bureaucratic elements of Hell (complaint tickets, meetings, procurement policies) provide an effective contrast to the supernatural setting, creating the irony and absurdity requested in the prompt. However, there are a few minor issues. Some metaphors, while creative, occasionally border on being too clever or slightly forced. The narrative sometimes lingers too long on certain scenes, particularly the administrative aspects of Hell, which risks slowing the pacing. The ending strikes an appropriate balance between resolution and ambiguity. It doesn't force a complete reconciliation between Lucifer and Lilith but suggests movement in their relationship cycle, staying true to the "on again/off again" dynamic specified in the prompt. Overall, this is an accomplished piece that successfully fulfills the requirements of the prompt, creating a darkly comedic fantasy with relatable relationship dynamics set against the backdrop of Hell's administration. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Historical fiction: Gladiator — Score: 94.8
Prompt:
Historical Fiction: Write a scene from a story set during the height of the Roman Empire, focusing on a slice of a day in the life of a gladiator. Do not write a combat scene. Use sensory details to capture the sights, sounds, and smells of ancient Rome. Explore the gladiator's thoughts and emotions. The story should also touch on the larger political and social issues of the time period. The piece should feel like a slice of a larger story. First person, past tense, 1000 words.
Model Output:
Dawn seeped into the barracks like watered wine, thin and pale. I woke to the scrape of a rat in the straw and the sour breath of men who had dreamed with their mouths open. The air was a stew of old sweat, oil, and the medicinal tang of vinegar the lanista insisted we rub on our bruises. I lay there a moment as the rooster on the roof of a nearby bakehouse crowed at the wrong hour, savoring the heaviness of my limbs, the ache in my shoulder that reminded me I still had all my parts. I pressed my palm flat against the plank beneath me, feeling the grain run like a river under a callus. I thought of Mars, who could be gentle to those who honored him, and deadly to those who did not. “Lord of spears,” I whispered into the straw. “Accept the sweat, not the blood.” “Up.” Urgus, our doctore, had a voice that could have split timber. He banged a staff against the post near the door, and the barracks shuddered with men swearing and the rustle of blankets. The day had begun. We filed past the water trough in the courtyard like cattle. The sky was a new bruise over the walls of the ludus, purple at the edges. The sand underfoot was still cool; later it would burn. I cupped water in my hands and poured it over my head. It ran in rivulets down my neck, leaving little trails in the soot and dust. To my right, Publius—fresh, still soft-cheeked, a boy pulled from a tavern fight and turned into merchandise—shivered. “It’s colder than the Tiber,” he muttered. “You’ll wish it were the Tiber when the sun rises,” I said. He tried to grin; his teeth knocked against each other like dice in a cup. We ate bread baked hard as roof tile dipped in diluted wine, and a handful of dried figs that stuck to the teeth. The kitchen smelled of smoke and the sharp, green aroma of crushed celery and coriander. A pot bubbled with barley porridge for later, the smell nutty and vaguely comforting. Flies made a black garland along the rim. One landed on my knuckle, and I flicked it away. At the far end of the courtyard, a scriba from our owner’s household argued with Urgus. The scribe’s tablet flashed in the weak light, wax glinting, as he read a list of names and dates. “He wants you ready for inspection at the ninth hour,” the scriba said, like he was announcing an eclipse. Urgus’s upper lip lifted. “And what he wants, he pays for,” he replied. “Maybe I should bring the surgeon too, in case the noble magistrate needs a cut.” The scriba’s mouth flattened. He was young, and he wore a little perfume, a thin cloud of myrrh that didn’t quite cover the smell of his fear of us. There was going to be a munus in two days—games to honor the funeral of a senator who had seized his seat by marrying his daughter to a man of ambition. The city hummed with it, I’d heard, like a hive about to swarm. They said the emperor himself might attend to show the people his face, to spill time and bread into the mouths of those who might otherwise bite. They said there would be exotic beasts from Numidia: leopard, ostrich, lions flown across the sea, their bellies empty to make them furious. They said a criminal would be sewn into a sack with a dog and a snake and thrown into the Tiber to appease the old gods and the crowd. They said a lot of things. They always did. “Form ranks,” Urgus bawled. He paced like a war god penned in marble. He wore a belt with bronze rings and a scowl that seemed hammered to his face. “You, Publius—shield higher. You, Lentulus—stop peering at the gate like your lover will walk through it.” He turned to me. “Marius. Stairs. Knees up. Show them what a Thracian stride looks like.” I never corrected him. I was not Thracian. My mother had told me I was born under a fig tree in Capua, and I had the speech to match, but Urgus called all of us by the styles we wore: Gauls, Secutors, Retiarii, Thracians. Identities were armor we put on. They hid the person and revealed the spectacle. The crowd wanted types, not men. We ran the stairs carved into the arena wall until our breath rasped like a saw. The dust baked on our tongues. The sun climbed the sky, a coin in the emperor’s fist that grew hot as he refused to spend it. Sweat found old salt stains and cut new paths, stinging the scabs on my shins. Urgus’s staff snapped against a slat with each misstep. “Higher, Marius,” he said, close to my ear when I flagged, the hiss of his words like a smith quenching iron. “You think Mars will lift you? He won’t. He likes to watch you lift yourself.” Between drills, we practiced with wooden weapons, heavy as truth. I worked with an old secutor named Felix, whose nose lay flattened from a dozen breaks and whose laughter was as rare as rain. We moved in the square shade of the awning, wood striking wood, the sound like dancing bones. I felt the give and take in my wrists, the push in my thighs. Every movement was a prayer for familiarity: step, strike, check, return. I thought of Mars, father of Romulus, who watched the walls rise and fall in this city as easily as a man flips a loaf. I had a small wooden image of him tucked under my pallet, a charm carved by a toothless vendor near the cows’ market. I rubbed it sometimes, the tiny spear smooth now from my thumb. “You’ll be inspected,” Felix grunted, feinting at my knee. “Smile with your scars. They buy the tickets.” “And if the emperor comes?” I asked, parrying. “Should I smile at him too?” Felix made a noise. “Smile at the emperor, the emperor smiles at the people, the people smile at their bread. We all do our part, eh?” He looked at the scriba across the yard, who watched us with the gaze of a man at a window display. “Watch how he writes. We are strokes on wax to him. And to the lords on the Palatine, we are coins in bowls. When the treasury groans, the games grow.” After drills, we were given a strip of cheese that smelled like damp wool and a wedge of honeyed cake sent by a senator who had adopted our ludus as his charitable gesture for the year. The doorman announced it as a gift from his greatness, Titus Flavius something, the name slipping over the stones like oil. The cake was stale and sweet, and we ate it with our fingers, laughter surprised out of us like water from a punctured wineskin. Publius saved his portion, tucking it into his cloak. “For my sister,” he said. “She waits outside the Subura’s big baths. I can throw it over the wall to her.” “You have a sister near the bathhouse?” Felix arched an eyebrow. “She sells eggs,” Publius said quickly. “And you think the wall is shorter than our guard’s knob?” Felix said, and we laughed, and the guard scowled, and for a moment the world knit itself into something almost harmless. By the gate, the armorer named Evodius hammered a rivet into a helm. Sparks leaped up, brief stars in the daylight. The iron smelled like rain. His hands were burn-scarred, old maps of fights he had never fought. “I had a brother in the legions,” he said without looking at me as I waited for him to adjust a strap on my greave. “Twenty-five years, came back with a pension and a limp. He says the emperor feeds the legions to keep their teeth out of his hand, and the people to keep their teeth out of his throat. The rest of us, we sharpen the knives.” He tightened the strap with a jerk. “Don’t die this time. I’m tired of fitting new men.” Midday, the heat pressed us flat. The courtyard smelled of hot linen and men. Beyond our walls, Rome roared: merchants shouting prices, a mule braying, a litter jingling past, the deep, steady cry of a water seller, the clatter of amphorae, the soft-chuffed complaint of a baker’s oven door, the nasal buzz of a Greek tutor reciting at the school next door. A breeze carried in the stench from the Tiber—rot and fish and river weed—and the sweeter, cloying breath of a perfumed woman passing in a sedan chair, whose bearers giggled like boys. I stood at the small window slit in the barracks and watched a line of condemned men shuffle down the street, their necks in a chain, eyes like old coins. A man in a red-bordered toga rode by, the purple stripe like a wound. He glanced at us and then away, as if we were the sun. For a moment, I imagined stepping out, unchained, walking into the city, past the cattle market where women with cracked heels haggled over tripe, over the Forum where men in white togas argued the fate of provinces like gamblers arguing dice. I set my forehead against the stone. I knew the city like a lover who slept on the other side of a wall. In the afternoon, the medicus lanced a boil on a man’s thigh with a copper blade and the smell of pus made even Urgus turn his face aside. He sprinkled ground myrtle over the wound and bound it with linen. “You are grain in a storm,” he told the man. “To stand is to soak. But better to stand than to wash away.” The man groaned and laughed, a man always laughs when he doesn’t know whether to weep. Before dusk, the lanista himself arrived, with a wreath of ivy set crooked on his head and a smile as thin as papyrus. He wore a tunic so white it hurt my eyes. Behind him wobbled a poet with ink-stained fingers and a chest like a pigeon’s. “I would like to write an ode to the munera,” the poet said, clutching his tablet. “To the nobility of—well—of you.” He looked at us with a hunger that had nothing to do with meat. The lanista patted his shoulder as if calming a skittish dog. “Write of Rome,” he said. “Write that the people have never been so free to applaud.” He inspected us like statues up for auction, prodding a bicep, examining a scar. He paused at me. “Marius,” he said, tasting the name like wine. “You will fight as provocator. Chest plates and greave. Helmet with a visor to hide your pretty face. You will fight someone the crowd can hate.” He looked at Publius and then beyond him, as if choosing a date on a calendar. “A foreigner, perhaps.” I thought of Mars again, not the city’s polite Mars with temple and priests, but the one of fields and boar tusks, of young men who burned like pine. I had a mother once who lit a candle on the Kalends and told me Mars loved Rome so much he gave her sons and took them back and gave them again. I had believed her because mothers must be believed at least once. Night came slow as a debt being repaid. The courtyard cooled, and the stars pricked the sky like holes in a dark cloak. We ate the barley porridge with onions and a dribble of oil. Someone sang a crude song about a senator and a flute girl, and another man laughed and choked on his mouthful and spit it into the dirt. The guard walked the wall, his sandals scuffing, his voice a drone as he counted his steps. I lay on my pallet and took out my little Mars. I traced the line of his shield, the notches where the wood carver’s knife had skipped. “Lord of the wolf,” I murmured. “Keep my feet sure and my hand steady. Let my breath be a bellows and my heart a drum. Bring me home to this plank and this straw and this stupid boy who thinks his sister sells eggs.” I smiled into the dark. From outside, faintly, I heard the city’s heart—a woman quarreling in a window, a dog barking, a chorus of drunks rehearsing politics like a play. Somewhere, in the great house on the Palatine, a man who held the world in his palm decided whether to turn it or let it lie. Somewhere in the Subura, a girl waited at a wall for a cake she might never catch. Somewhere, the river slid by, indifferent, carrying numb bodies and lost hopes and a thousand olive pits to the sea. I slept with Mars under my hand. In dreams, I was not a provocator or a Thracian or a Roman, but something that breathed and was allowed to be. In the morning, I would strap on weight and make it sing again, and let the city gaze at itself in the mirror of our sand. We were their hunger padded out with muscle. We were their fear with faces. This was our trade: to be the truth they could look at without blinking. And I, who was named for a god, would wake and drink and run and lift and step, and step again. The day would be a wheel, and I’d put my shoulder to it, and it would turn.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This historical fiction piece about a Roman gladiator is remarkably well-executed. The author has created an immersive sensory experience that transports the reader to ancient Rome through vivid descriptions of sights, smells, and sounds. The narrative successfully captures the daily routine of a gladiator named Marius, focusing on the mundane aspects of his life rather than combat scenes as instructed. The piece excels in its sensory details: the "sour breath of men," the "medicinal tang of vinegar," the "hot linen and men" smell of the courtyard, and the "stench from the Tiber." These details create a tangible atmosphere that feels authentic to the time period. The author skillfully incorporates period-appropriate references to Roman customs, deities (particularly Mars), and social structures. The protagonist's inner thoughts reveal a complex character who has accepted his fate while maintaining a sense of identity beyond his role as a gladiator. His relationship with Mars, keeping a small wooden carving under his pallet, adds depth to his character. The interactions with other characters—Felix, Publius, Urgus, the lanista—feel natural and reveal the social dynamics within the ludus. The writing addresses the larger political and social issues of Roman society through subtle observations: the relationship between the emperor and the people ("the emperor feeds the legions to keep their teeth out of his hand, and the people to keep their teeth out of his throat"), the class distinctions, and the role of gladiatorial games in maintaining social order. The reference to the upcoming munus to honor a senator's funeral effectively ties the gladiator's personal experience to broader Roman politics. The prose is elegant without being overwrought. Metaphors and similes are fresh and period-appropriate: "Dawn seeped into the barracks like watered wine," "The sky was a new bruise over the walls of the ludus," and "We are strokes on wax to him." The author maintains a consistent voice throughout, balancing poetic language with straightforward narration. The piece successfully creates the impression of being a slice of a larger story. The references to Marius's past, the upcoming games, and Publius's sister outside the walls all suggest a world that extends beyond this single day. The ending circles back to the beginning, creating a sense of the cyclical nature of the gladiator's life while maintaining emotional resonance. If there are any weaknesses, they are minor. Some readers might find a few metaphors slightly overworked, and there are moments where the philosophical musings could risk slowing the narrative. However, these are balanced by the strong sensory details and character development that keep the reader engaged. Overall, this is an exceptional piece of historical fiction that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt while creating a compelling, emotionally resonant narrative with authentic historical details. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Epistolary: The Lighthouse Keeper — Score: 0
Prompt:
The Lighthouse Keeper Epistolary Narrative: Write a story told entirely through a series of brief correspondences: telegrams or letters or emails between two characters. The correspondence should span several months or years, and reveal a gradually unfolding plot. Use distinct voices for each character, and include details that provide insight into their personalities and motivations. The story should build to an emotional climax, and the final letter should provide a satisfying resolution. The setting is a lighthouse keeper writing to his mother. He is working class and Scottish. He is struggling with the isolation of his posting. Write naturally and without cliches. 1000 words.
Model Output:
Judge Evaluation:
[Skipping – generation error: Text too short after 3 attempts]
+ First-person unique perspective: Hacker Mindset — Score: 92.2
Prompt:
Hacker Mindset Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a reformed (now) white hat hacker who cannot help but notice exploitable weaknesses in both systems and people they encounter. They habitually look for vulnerabilities and exploit vectors. The narrative takes place during a first date at a restaurant, where they're trying to focus on human connection. It's going surprisingly well due to a discovered shared nerd-fandom (magic the gathering). Things go a little sideways when the date reveals a noticeably insecure phone unlock pattern, which protagonist can't help but comment on. They are then left to negotiate the fallout of this faux pas and attempt to salvage (or perhaps sabotage) the remainder of the date. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
I notice the camera before I notice her. There’s a small dome tucked into the ceiling corner near the bar, the kind that looks cheap and probably is, standing in for actual security with a blinking red LED. It’s pointed at the door, but from the glare on the lens, I can tell it’s not balanced. There’s a blind spot where the hostess stand meets the coat rack; you could pocket anything left there and never show up as more than a shadow. I remind myself I don’t do that anymore, then spot her—red scarf, laughing with the hostess, an unselfconscious wave that sends a half second ripple through my chest. “Hi,” she says, and the sound of her voice is nice enough that I don’t immediately check the angle of the light into the windows. I do anyway. Habit. Mid-afternoon glare could wash out the glass; no one would notice a figure loitering outside. She smells like rosemary and cold air, sits down across from me, and there’s a second where everything zeros in: me, her, water, two menus. I can do this. She smiles. “I wasn’t sure about the place. All my friends swear by the gnocchi, but sometimes that means microwaved rocks.” “Risk assessment,” I say. My mouth is ahead of my brain. “Sign me up.” She laughs. “You weren’t kidding about the hacker thing in your profile.” I test the floor under the table with my heel. Solid. No loose screws on the table leg. My hand is shaking and I tuck it under the tablecloth, try to be a person. “I’m trying to keep it light these days. Less…being a gremlin inside other people’s computers.” “Like a house elf that sets things on fire.” “Not on purpose.” She grins, and it loosens something in me. The waiter appears, says his name is Miguel, and as he pours water, I drift—watching his forearm, where the printed schedule peeks from under his sleeve. They still put first names and phone numbers on schedules here. Low-hanging fruit. One snap and you have a pivot point. My eyes climb back to her as if against current. “I read that thing you wrote,” she says. “About how most hacks aren’t super sophisticated, they’re just…door left open.” “Doors left open,” I say. “And people propping them with chairs.” I shut up before I start in on threat models, default passwords, the restaurant’s POS system probably running a version of Windows that should’ve been put to pasture when people still said cyberspace without irony. “Okay, wait.” She leans forward. Eyes bright. “Speaking of door left open, this is crucial. Did you bring your deck?” For a terrifying moment, my mind supplies firewall instead of deck, and then I realize she means cards and exhale laughter like an apology. “Not on me. I didn’t want to be…that guy.” “Because I am that guy.” She pulls a zippered case from her bag with the reverence of a conjurer, and I’m already cataloging. She uses a standard sleeve, matte turquoise. Good choice for durability, visible scuffs, doesn’t show fingerprints. The zipper has a little fray on the pull tab; it’s been loved. “Modern,” she says. “Don’t judge.” “Never,” I say, and mean it. “What’s your favorite to pilot?” “Don’t laugh.” She bites her lip. “Bogles.” I try not to. I fail. “Hexproof? You monster.” I can’t help the warmth that blossoms, the way she leans into the nerdy spiral with me, her hands moving animatedly through the air, sketching auras on invisible stick figures. “It’s honest,” she says. “It does a thing and does it well. It says, you’re welcome to try, but this is my plan.” Her eyes flick to mine. “Yours?” “Control, usually,” I say. “Esper. Maybe I’m digressing.” “Control,” she groans. “Why does everyone I like play control? It’s like you want me to have a bad time.” “I want to make sure we play to the end,” I say, and holy hell is that too real, too obvious. She smiles anyway, a kind of tolerant affection. Bread arrives, and I watch the server’s hands—good form, left-handed grip, plate balance. He sets down a small metal canister of olive oil that immediately makes me think of leaky containers in bathrooms hiding pinhole cams. I push the thought out. Breathe. Be a human. “So,” she says, tearing a piece of bread, the crust flaking like snow. “On my way here, my boss calls me. Again. And he’s like, ‘I know you’re off today, but can you remember the name of my first pet?’” I nearly choke. “He asked you that?” “It’s for some bank thing he forgot to set up.” She rolls her eyes. “I’m like, dude, please just text your wife. Bonus: it was Bubbles.” Bubbles. First pet. I file it, then forcibly defile the file, shred it and set it on fire and bury the ashes under concrete. “People should not outsource their secrets,” I say lightly. “But Bubbles is…adorable.” “His wife is going to kill him.” She swipes her phone and puts it face-up on the table. I notice the model instantly—mid-range Android, plastic case with a crack near the volume rocker. There’s a sticker of a cat in sunglasses. The screen lights, and a pattern grid appears, her finger hovering over nine dots, and I think, ah, here it is: the test. Don’t look, I tell myself. Don’t look. Focus on her eyes. They aren’t locked by a Pythagorean procession. They aren’t a puzzle you can solve. She draws an L. Bottom left to bottom right, up to the middle right. Three points. My brain, disobedient, conjures the heat map of common patterns, how often people start at the corner, how many combos there are given the length. She does the L again to unlock, and a soft chirp sounds. My mouth gets ahead of me: “You should, um, change that.” Her face tilts, amused. “My pattern?” “It’s…a little obvious,” I say. “Sorry. That sounded…judgey.” She looks down at her phone, then back up, eyebrows raised. “You got that from here?” I could lie. I could say no, it was the way the grease smudged the lower third of her screen, the micro-scratch arcs that cluster around common start points. I could say I didn’t watch. I could say a lot of things, but none of them turn me into a person who ignores the map glowing under his eyelids. “I’m good at that,” I say, sheepish. “Comes with the job. Former job. I try to turn it off, but…” “But you can’t help noticing the holes.” “It’s an occupational hazard.” I try to make it a joke. It evaporates between us, steam off a plate. She leans back, the warmth sliding a few degrees cooler. “Is that fun, for you? Spotting that?” “No,” I say, too quickly. Then, because that’s not true: “Sometimes. It’s like noticing a pothole right before you drive into it. There’s a thrill when you swerve. And guilt.” She picks up her phone, thumbs the screen off, sets it face down. A small wall. “Okay, so what should it be, Mr. Control Deck?” “Longer,” I say. “More complicated. And not a letter or a shape. But I shouldn’t be giving unsolicited advice. I’m sorry.” There’s a pause. It’s not empty. It’s full of her thinking, and me rehearsing a hundred responses, all of which sound like I’m explaining how to lock her windows in a storm. “Do you always do that?” she asks. “To people? The little…scan?” Yes, I think. No, I want to say. “Texts give off odor,” I say instead. “Passwords sweat.” That’s too weird. “I was in a program for a while,” I add, stupidly. “After, uh. One of the times I crossed a line. They taught me to narrate to myself. To not act. To watch the impulse go by like…traffic.” Her face softens a millimeter. “So you’re just…looking at cars.” “And trying not to hijack one,” I say. It lands. She snorts despite herself. “Look, it’s not that I mind you being good at your thing,” she says. “It’s that it’s my thing, right? My phone. My choice. We just met.” “I know.” I grab my water. The glass is slick and cool, and my hand leaves a print. “It’s just hard for me to…not see the exploit. Even in nice places.” She glances around. “What’s the exploit here? At this…very romantic Italian place.” I shouldn’t. I should say, they have great gnocchi. The lights are warm. The couple in the corner is on their third date. Instead: “The camera’s angled wrong,” I say, and hate myself a little. “And their Wi-Fi network is named ‘Staff Only’ but the password is like, the name of the restaurant plus 123.” She blinks. “How do you know the password?” “I don’t. I just…guessed the pattern. It’s probably wrong,” I lie, then catch myself. “I mean, I didn’t try it.” She cradles her chin in her hand, thinking. There’s a line at the corner of her mouth like she’s suppressing a smile she doesn’t want to reward me with. “Okay,” she says. “Okay. Let’s try something.” She points at the bread basket. “Pretend that’s a server rack. And this—” she holds up a breadstick like a wand “—is the physical world. Close your eyes and tell me three things that you like about this restaurant that are not about how to break into it.” I close my eyes. It’s harder than it should be. The black is not blank; it’s full of overlays, vectors, dotted lines. But her voice is there, anchoring me. Three things. “The smell,” I say. “Garlic, but not aggressive. Like somebody’s cooking for you, not at you.” “Good,” she says, pleased. “The couple in the corner,” I add. “They’re telling each other stories with their hands. They haven’t touched yet, but they want to.” “Cute.” “And the way the sunlight catches the red in your scarf.” My eyes are still closed when I say it, safe in the dark. “It looks like an ember.” Silence. Then, softly: “That was almost human.” I open my eyes. She’s smiling, not the tolerant grin from earlier, but something that reaches the corners of her eyes. “I can do human,” I say. “Sometimes.” “When you’re not auditing me.” “Fair.” She coaxes me into talking about decks again, and the conversation becomes a scaffolding I can climb. I tell her about the time I built a stupid jank combo that only went off if my opponent was reckless, and how I learned patience from counting the turns of a chess clock and the hum of server fans in a datacenter at 3 a.m. She tells me about her brother teaching her to shuffle, about playing at a dingy card shop where the owner kept the best rares behind the counter like contraband. “He used to make me answer trivia to buy anything.” She rolls her eyes. “What’s your mother’s maiden name? Ha. Just kidding. But, like, he did actually ask my first concert.” “Let me guess,” I say. “Paramore.” “Rude.” She laughs. “Close.” “Fall Out Boy.” She claps, mock-appalled. “Okay, sir. Stop. Too good.” I want to tell her I don’t want to know those things. That I want her secrets to be secrets. That I want to be surprised by her, not to see her as a series of answers to a form. But she’s dropping breadcrumbs like it’s nothing, like it’s air, like everyone does when they’re comfortable. Mother’s maiden name. First pet. First concert. The street she grew up on slips out when she mentions biking to school on Maple Ridge. The name of her dog tumbles casually after a question about weekend plans. The date of her birthday glows in a story about an ill-fated costume party. I collect them and then drop them again, like stones into a well. Plunk. Plunk. Hear the splash, and walk away. We split the gnocchi. It is not microwaved rocks; it is soft and perfect, little clouds that squish and fill and make us both say wow at the same time. She licks a stray smear of sauce off her thumb and my heart glitches. I have a sudden, absurd vision of peeking, of pivoting, of ruining it because ruin has muscle memory in me. “About the pattern,” I say, and she groans. “No, no,” I add, hands up. “Not advice. A story.” She eases back, wary but curious. “Okay.” “I used to keep my passwords in my head,” I say. “Which is already a red flag, because memory is a terrible vault. But I liked the feeling of…owning them. Then this one night, I’m about to go on stage for a talk—rehab story, redemption tour, whatever—and my mind blanks. Completely. The one for my email. Poof. And it felt like someone had taken a rug out from under me. So now I use a manager. I let a thing hold my keys. And it’s not perfect. But it means I don’t have to be the only lock.” She watches me, her expression stripped of the earlier performative skepticism. “That sounds terrifying.” “It was.” I smile. “But also…freeing. Less to carry.” She nods, slowly. “I’ll change it,” she says, flicking her phone with one finger like a promise. “Not because you told me to. Because I don’t want you to be right about me being predictable.” “Fair,” I say. “Challenge accepted.” We pay. She insists on Venmoing me half, taps and scans, and I almost flinch when the app flashes her handle and a profile photo taken at her favorite coffee shop—the one she’s been talking about for twenty minutes. I feel the little hooks line up—username mirroring a decade-old forum alias, a date substitution, a map coalescing—and I cut the line. Knife. Clean. Back in the sheath. Outside, the air is a crisp bite, and we linger on the sidewalk in that awkward trying-to-decide-if-this-is-a-hug-or-wave liminal space. “I had a good time,” she says. “Me too.” I swallow. “I…uh. Sorry again.” She rolls her eyes, a small smile riding the motion. “Just don’t change my Wi-Fi without asking.” “I don’t know your SSID,” I say. “Yet,” she teases, then sobers. “Hey. In case you were wondering—this is very much an observation, not an invitation—you don’t have to be useful to be here.” My laugh is a little messy. “I don’t know what to do with that.” “Practice,” she says, and then leans in, quick, just a brush of lips on my cheek, like linking a card without committing to the spell. “See you.” She walks away, red scarf a stroke of color across the winter. I watch her go until she turns the corner, then look up at the camera with the wrong angle and think, someday I’ll tell them. Not today. Today I’ll go home and sleeve something dumb and honest, a deck that plays a creature on turn one and keeps swinging. I’ll open my password manager and generate a string of nonsense for a site I don’t even use anymore. I’ll not look up her Venmo history. I’ll not check the coffee shop’s opening hours on the off chance. And maybe, next time, when her fingers trace a constellation across her screen, I’ll let the stars be stars.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures the perspective of a reformed white hat hacker navigating a first date. The protagonist's internal monologue reveals their constant struggle between their habitual security analysis and their desire for genuine human connection. The piece excels in creating a distinctive voice for the protagonist. Their technical mindset permeates every observation, from noticing security camera blind spots to analyzing phone unlock patterns. This consistent characterization creates an authentic portrayal of someone who cannot turn off their "hacker mindset" even in social situations. The narrative effectively balances technical details with emotional vulnerability. The protagonist's internal struggle is palpable as they try to suppress their instinct to analyze and exploit. Lines like "I collect them and then drop them again, like stones into a well. Plunk. Plunk. Hear the splash, and walk away" beautifully illustrate their conscious effort to resist old habits. The shared interest in Magic: The Gathering provides an organic connection between the characters while revealing aspects of their personalities through their deck preferences. The protagonist's preference for "Control" decks cleverly mirrors their personality, while their date's "Bogles" deck shows her straightforward nature. The dialogue is natural and reveals character, particularly when the protagonist slips up by commenting on the phone pattern. The date's reaction feels authentic—initially put off but willing to understand. Her challenge to name three non-security things about the restaurant creates a pivotal moment that helps the protagonist shift perspective. The imagery is specific and evocative, from the "red scarf, laughing with the hostess" to gnocchi described as "little clouds that squish and fill." These details ground the narrative in sensory experience while revealing the protagonist's attempt to focus on the present moment. The ending avoids an overly neat resolution while offering hope. The protagonist acknowledges their ongoing struggle but shows commitment to change. The final metaphor of letting "the stars be stars" rather than seeing patterns to exploit provides a poetic conclusion that feels earned. Some minor weaknesses include occasional moments where the technical details might be excessive for readers unfamiliar with hacking concepts. Additionally, while the protagonist's transformation is believable, it happens somewhat quickly within the timeframe of a single date. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that successfully fulfills the prompt requirements while creating a compelling character study of someone trying to reform ingrained habits and connect authentically with others. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 3 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 3.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Overthinking It — Score: 95.2
Prompt:
Overthinking It Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of an intelligent 8th-grade girl with social anxiety who has developed a crush on a classmate. The narrative takes place during a group science project where they're paired together, as she cycles through rehearsed conversations while second-guessing each potential approach. Her inner thoughts should reveal the gap between her articulate internal voice and her difficulty expressing herself aloud, her fears of coming across as desperate or weird, and the exhausting process of monitoring her every word, expression, and movement for potential embarrassment. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The projector squeaks like a mouse each time Mr. Alvarez clicks to the next slide, a tiny sound that somehow fills the entire room, and I imagine it’s trying to warn me: be quiet, be still, stay small. I’m pretending to take notes while also rewriting my entire personality on the fly. I underline “semipermeable membrane” as if it matters, as if knowing the exact spelling will protect me from saying something stupid when I have to look at him. Don’t say “hi” too loudly. Don’t say it too softly. Don’t say it at all if it sounds like breath slipping out of a balloon. Maybe just nod. People nod all the time. We’re partners, which was decided by a random generator of names that I have already forgiven and resented three times today. His name popped up next to mine and everyone made that little ooo sound kids make when they think something is funny in a way that isn’t. I smiled in the neutral way I have been practicing since fourth grade. He raised an eyebrow like he thought it was amusing but he wasn’t going to make a thing of it. He’s good at not making a thing of things. I, on the other hand, am a full-time theater production of small, escalating things. I can see the blue glow of the slides on his cheek. He’s doodling a tiny bacteriophage attacking a planet in the margins of the handout and it’s annoyingly good. He wears the same gray hoodie every other day, and it’s soft-looking, and I am thinking about how fibers can be soft and durable at the same time, like certain species of moss. Don’t say that. Don’t compare his hoodie to moss. Don’t compare him to moss either, that’s weirder. “Okay,” Mr. Alvarez squeaks-through to the next slide. “You’ll need to test diffusion with multiple solutions.” Beakers. We will be using beakers. I will have to stand and walk to the lab station with him. Calmly. Not too fast, not too slow. Don’t trip, obviously. The time I tripped in fifth grade trying to jump over the rope during field day is still stored in my spine like an unread text message. He shifts in his seat, chair leg scraping the floor in a short wine-glass shriek, and glances at me. It’s a normal glance, friendly. In my body, it’s a lightning strike. I could say, “I already made a list of materials.” I have. It’s in my notebook, bullet points immaculate and aligned. But if I say it too quickly I’ll sound like a try-hard, and if I say it too casually it will sound like I just happen to always make lists for fun. I do, but he doesn’t need to know that yet. Or ever. I try out: “I’m excited about diffusion.” Too weird. “Diffusion is interesting.” Boring. “It’s cool how something invisible can move everything, actually.” That’s too philosophical for eleven forty-two a.m., and also reveals that I have a playlist called Instrumental Focus in which I have assigned songs to processes like osmosis and diffusion, and nobody needs that information except me. My hand is holding my pencil too tightly. Loosen grip. Loosen face. Do not smile like a robot. He clears his throat. “We should, uh, start?” His voice cracks slightly and because I am cruel to myself, my brain immediately assigns meaning to it, like he’s nervous too, but that can’t be true. People are not nervous around me, they are vaguely polite. He looks at my notebook. “You wanna, like, plan it out?” Yes. Plan it out. This is my Olympics. “Yeah,” I say, and the word is too thin, like a piece of paper that tears when you try to pick it up. He waits. Blank space expands in front of me like a cliff edge. “I—made a list.” I do the thing where I think I’m gesturing casually but my hand moves like a crane machine that never picks up the stuffed animal. I flip to the page. The checkboxes are square and I feel a flicker of pride, which I extinguish immediately because pride can be interpreted as arrogance which can be interpreted as I think I’m better than him which is not true I just like checkboxes. He leans in. He smells like laundry detergent and pencil shavings. He’s reading. He says, “This is good.” It lands in me like someone put a soft stone on a seesaw to keep it from tipping. “Thanks,” I say, the “k” sticking a little. Smile. Not all teeth. Probably no teeth. Okay, a little teeth. I can feel my mouth making a weird decision and I wish I could see myself from the outside to adjust the settings. There should be a panel on my wrist with sliders: eye contact, voice volume, smile angle, joke probability. He looks up at the slide again. The projector squeaks. Mr. Alvarez says something about dialysis tubing and I picture a tiny practice conversation with myself wearing a lab coat, being normal. “So, we could test different concentrations of sugar,” I say in my head, crisp and clear, a TV scientist. Out loud I produce, “So, um, if like, sugar water is, we could—” I can feel the sentence disintegrating like a cookie in milk. I want to pull back the words, hide them behind my tongue, try again. He says, “Like, different concentrations?” His tone is light, like we’re already on the same page, like I wasn’t just a messed-up recording. “Yeah,” I say. I nod. Maybe I am nodding too much. People who nod too much are either very agreeable or unhinged. One nod. Reset. We stand. My knees are aware they are knees, which is never good. We walk to the lab table. The room is a low buzz with other groups negotiating roles, clinking beakers. I wonder what I look like from behind. My ponytail probably sways like a metronome set too fast. I set my notebook down and line it up with the edge of the table, an anchor I can pretend is practical. He takes two beakers without clanking them, like he has quiet hands. I love the idea of a person with quiet hands. I plan to say, “I can label the samples,” but my mouth decides to say, “I can do labels,” like I am a small office printer. Recover. “I mean, unless you want to.” That sounds defensive. “Or we could, like, trade-off.” Now I sound like I’m negotiating a custody arrangement for tape. He smiles, not making fun of me, just smiling, and says, “Labels are great. You’re super neat.” The word “super” hits me like a cartoon mallet because I want it to mean something it doesn’t, but also, neat. He noticed the neatness. My brain wants to send a thank-you note on embossed stationery to this moment. I pull out my pen. My hand steadies when it’s given a task that requires precision. Hello, pen. Save me. We measure water. He pours; I read the meniscus like it’s a fortune. He says, “Tell me if I go past.” I imagine telling him that he’s already past, that we are two humans in stormy adolescence trying to not crash into each other, and I want to tell him the way I think: that the word meniscus is nice because it sounds like a small planet, and I have a crush on him like gravity. Absolutely do not say that. Say, “A tiny more. Okay, stop.” I hear myself and it’s almost comedic, the thin squeak of my voice matching the projector perfectly. He laughs under his breath. Not at me. With me. Maybe. I tag this as a Maybe Laugh, file it in a moderate confidence folder. I become aware that my shoulders are creeping up to my ears and I push them down, which probably looks strange. The teacher flips another slide that we aren’t looking at. Squeak. A little chorus of squeaks. I want to be the kind of person who can say something like, “This projector is nervous,” and have it be a casual joke, but the words bottleneck and I’m left with a mental image I can’t share. We set up dialysis tubing. He wrestles with a knot and huffs, and I immediately want to help but also don’t want to be weird about touching things he’s touching. “Want me to hold it?” I ask, and I’m proud that the sentence is whole. He gives me the end and our fingers bump. It’s nothing. It is absolutely nothing. It is also a small star exploding behind my sternum. I keep my face exactly the same. Do not move your eyebrows. There are girls who can toss their hair and make eye contact and say something flirty without collapsing inward. I study them like rare birds. I am the bird who hides under leaves, narrating the migration pattern in my head in precise, terrified detail. We get into a rhythm. He ties, I spoon sugar, we label. He reads the labels out loud: 0.1 M, 0.2 M. His mouth shapes the numbers. I really, really want to know what he thinks about. Does he notice that the class smells like whiteboard cleaner and banana? Does he keep track of the names on the posters above the windows? I want to ask him about his bacteriophage drawing, say, “I like your virus eating the world,” but that could be read as me liking the world being consumed by viruses. A sentence can tilt and change its whole meaning and I am always trying to hold it level. “Do you, like, want to split the write-up?” he asks, and the phrase “write-up” makes me happy because it’s a job and I like jobs with edges. “I can do the results part,” he says. “You’re good at procedures.” He noticed procedures. He noticed that I’m good at something. My mind tries on three different responses like outfits, twirls in a mirror. Option A: “Sure, that works.” Option B: “I can also do the graph.” Option C: “Thanks.” Option D: All of the above, which is too much fabric, I’ll look like I’m drowning. “Sure,” I choose. “And I can do the graph.” Add “thanks”? Too late. The gap opens and I can’t jump it now without it being weirdly intense. I add a smile. The kind that says I’m fine, which is an aspirational lie. He taps the table lightly with the end of his pen. Tap-tap. He’s not looking at me, he’s looking at the beaker, and I love that I can look at him without him seeing me look. It’s a cheap magic trick but I’ll take any magic. He says, “You ever notice the projector sounds like it’s hiccuping?” The squeak punctuates his sentence as if on cue and I almost laugh because the universe has a sense of humor whether or not I participate. “Yes,” I say, and the syllable is too eager. I need to add something or I will be a single note—ding—and then silence. “I—was thinking—maybe it’s nervous.” He looks at me. I feel the stare like a spotlight I didn’t sign up for. Abort. Push the joke away. “Like, you know, not really. Just—sounds.” He smiles. Real smile. The corner of his mouth goes up and his eyes do the crinkle. “It’s okay,” he says quietly. “I get nervous too.” The words are soft and they float over to me like soap bubbles and I’m afraid to touch them. My brain wants to cross-examine them for loopholes, for sarcasm, for pity. He doesn’t look pitying. He looks like he just said a true thing without fireworks. I nod. I want to say, “Thanks for saying that,” and then, “Me too, constantly,” and then, “It’s exhausting,” and then, “I think you’re cool.” That last one is not permitted. The rules are: Do not confess anything with permanent ink. “Same,” I say. Another thin word. But it lands between us and it doesn’t shatter. I fill the tube and tie it off. He sets the timer on his phone and the little numbers count down like a lifeguard watching us to make sure we don’t drown. The room is a world of scents and noises that I’m trying to catalog to avoid cataloging the shape of his hands. The projector squeaks again as Mr. Alvarez points to a diagram. People whisper. Someone laughs too loud at the sink. I adjust the edge of the label. Control things you can control. Breathe in four, hold, breathe out six. Don’t look too weird while breathing. People breathe all the time. It’s fine. He says, “You’re really organized,” and I have to pick a place to put that sentence so it doesn’t choke me. I put it on a shelf in my brain next to the two other compliments I trust. One is from my grandmother in a kitchen that smells like cinnamon, and the other is from my sixth grade teacher who called my essay “clear.” A small museum, free admission, open on days when the world doesn’t make sense. I wonder what his museum looks like. I wonder if he thinks about how things dissolve, if he notices every squeak and scrape or if it’s quieter in there, if his internal voice talks to him like a friend. “Thanks,” I say, and I catch it this time, put the word after the right prompt, dress it in a tone that doesn’t make it look too eager. I pair it with eye contact for one second, two seconds, not three. Three is staring. I think about the fact that I am thinking about this and want to sleep on the floor. The timer beeps. We write down the mass. He reads the numbers out loud and I write them in neat columns that make my brain purr. I draw the first axis of a graph and the pencil line is straight as if it wants to be good for me. I imagine a future where I will remember this exact moment, how the light hits the lab table, how the smell of detergent and sugar water is a tiny, peculiar heaven, how my heart is a hummingbird all the time but sometimes it perches. I imagine telling someone, maybe even him someday, about how hard it is to constantly audit my own existence. I imagine him not being surprised. I file that under Not Impossible — Pending Evidence. We clean up. The beakers clink like teeth. He puts the caps back on the sugar and salt and does it properly, lined up with the labels facing forward like my notebook pages. He says, “See you tomorrow?” in a voice that assumes there is a tomorrow, together, with diffusion and graphs and maybe another quiet-laugh at the projector’s dumb hiccup. I feel large and small at once, like a word that can mean different things depending on the sentence it’s in. “Yeah,” I say. A full one. I let it be round. I don’t add anything to ruin it. He lifts his hood, runs a hand through his hair, and walks back to his seat. I allow myself to watch him go, just for the length of the squeak as the slide changes. Then I sit, align my notebook, and breathe.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative brilliantly captures the internal monologue of an intelligent 8th-grade girl with social anxiety who has developed a crush on a classmate. The piece excels at portraying the protagonist's hyperawareness of her every word, gesture, and thought during a science project with her crush. The character's voice is exceptionally well-crafted. Her internal dialogue reveals a sharp, articulate mind that contrasts with her stilted external communication. Lines like "I am a full-time theater production of small, escalating things" and "My brain wants to send a thank-you note on embossed stationery to this moment" showcase her intelligence and self-awareness while maintaining age-appropriate sensibilities. The narrative effectively illustrates the exhausting process of self-monitoring through specific details: "I become aware that my shoulders are creeping up to my ears and I push them down, which probably looks strange." The protagonist's constant rehearsal of potential responses ("Option A: 'Sure, that works.' Option B: 'I can also do the graph.' Option C: 'Thanks.'") vividly demonstrates her overthinking. The imagery is precise and evocative. Descriptions like "The projector squeaks like a mouse each time Mr. Alvarez clicks to the next slide" and "I can feel the sentence disintegrating like a cookie in milk" create a sensory-rich environment while revealing character. The metaphors are particularly strong: "My heart is a hummingbird all the time but sometimes it perches" beautifully captures her anxiety with moments of relief. The piece maintains excellent pacing, with the science project providing a natural structure. The narrative flows through the lab activity while weaving in the protagonist's internal struggles. Small moments of connection with her crush feel earned and authentic, avoiding melodrama or unrealistic developments. The ending strikes a delicate balance—showing a small moment of connection without suggesting her anxiety has magically disappeared. The final line, "Then I sit, align my notebook, and breathe," indicates both progress and the ongoing nature of her anxiety. The writing avoids common pitfalls of portraying teenage characters. There's no condescension or oversimplification of the protagonist's emotions. Her crush isn't portrayed as life-shattering but rather as an intensification of her existing social anxiety. The boy is depicted with nuance rather than as a perfect dream object or a one-dimensional character. If there's any weakness, it might be that some metaphors occasionally approach being too sophisticated for an 8th grader, even a highly intelligent one. However, this is a minor concern as most of the internal voice remains believable for a precocious teenager. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that captures the requested perspective with remarkable authenticity, emotional depth, and literary skill. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 20 Emotionally Complex: 20 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 20.0, Emotionally Complex: 20.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Rehearsing Rejection — Score: 94.3
Prompt:
Rehearsing Rejection Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of someone with borderline personality disorder who frequently plays out worst-case scenarios of how friends and loved ones might judge them. They construct elaborate internal dialogues, complete with imagined criticisms and their own defensive responses. The narrative takes place as they prepare to meet a close friend & recent lover, who has been somewhat distant lately, triggering their abandonment fears. Their inner monologue should reveal how they cycle between anticipating rejection, mentally rehearsing confrontations, and developing preemptive resentments as protective measures. Incorporate the *actual* events & interactions that are *not* in fact judgemental or involving rejection (in fact, the opposite), and represent how these are interpreted, how the validation & love is desperately felt & needed -- and then immediately questioned. Capture the cognitive dissonance in this struggle. Include moments where they briefly recognize the pattern but struggle to interrupt it, showing limited (and selective) self awareness, competing with the compelling nature of these imagined scenarios. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
I keep checking the battery like it might change by willpower. Seven percent, then six. A little red sliver daring me to need it. I plug it in for two minutes, unplug, because I don’t want to be tethered when I leave, as if the cord itself is a leash, as if being unprepared will keep me safe. I stare at the mirror and practice my face: not too eager, not hurt, nothing you could accuse. Relax the jaw, soften the eyes. My face refuses to cooperate. It looks like a person trying to look like a person who isn’t spiraling. What if she cancels. Don’t be ridiculous. But what if she cancels and says, “I thought we said we’d be casual.” A shrug, a hint of pity. “You’re intense, and it’s a lot.” My stomach flips like a coin. I answer in my head: I’m allowed to feel things. I’m not a problem to manage. Except I am, to everyone. If she cancels, I’ll say, “No worries!” and then go home and scream into a pillow like a teenager. Or worse, I’ll send twelve texts that climb on top of each other, and then blame my thumbs. She said yes to the dinner. I know that. It’s in the messages. “Tonight works,” with a heart. But that was hours ago when her battery probably wasn’t low, when mine was at forty-three. Now mine says five and all the words in the world are stuck behind that number. I should eat something so I don’t get dizzy. I should not eat so I look smaller, more precious, easier to hold. I chew dry cereal and it turns into paste, sticking to my molars. I check the battery again. Five still. Then a flash: new message. My heart slams against bone. It’s her. “Running five late—subway weird. Excited to see you.” Sparkles. I feel the rush of relief like something dangerous. I want to hold that message against my skin. I want to be normal about it. My brain says: Five late means she’s already calculated how much of you she can handle. Excited? People say that to dogs and children. I put the phone face down like I’m disciplining it, plug it in again, watch the tiny lightning bolt appear. Four percent. I laugh out loud, which sounds like a cough. The battery number is slipping down like a countdown to inevitable proof that everyone leaves if you let them. I could bring a charger. I won’t. If the phone dies maybe I’ll be forced to look it in the face—whatever it is. Or I’ll sit there, waiting, while the world shrugs at me. I picture myself at the table, alone, telling the server I was stood up, making a joke. I picture them saying, “That’s rough,” with eyes that are relieved it’s not happening to them. I decide to hate the server preemptively so it won’t cut when they say anything normal. I lace my boots too tight. Loose means sloppy, means needy. Tight means in control. It’s all magical thinking. The laces bite and I think: good. Something to blame for the ache. On the train, everything is a mirror. My reflection in the window looks like someone who might be left. I scan every face for judgement and assign it. The woman with the headphones: she would say, “You make people your whole world, and it’s suffocating.” The kid with sticky fingers: “You’re too much, like syrup.” I imagine my friend across from me. We are in the booth, candle between us like a tiny threat of combustion. She says, carefully, “I like you, but I don’t want to feel responsible for you. It’s a lot.” I tell her I’m not asking for that and then list the ways I’ve contained my hunger for her, which makes me sound hungry. She leans back. She says, “This is why I didn’t respond right away.” There it is. I knew it. Then my phone buzzes in my pocket and I almost drop it grabbing it out. Battery at three. Message: “Got a table outside!” Smiley. I breathe something that is almost a sob. Outside is good. Outside is public. The possibility of running is baked in. I decide she chose outside because it’s easier to escape. Then I decide I’m inventing reasons and this is good and normal and friendly. Then I decide I’m gullible. I feel the ping in my brain where the familiar path starts—the rut worn by the same wagon wheels: anticipate pain, armor up, accuse quietly, withdraw loudly. I text back: “On my way!” with a star, then delete the star, then put a period, then delete the period because it sounds cold, then send it with no punctuation and immediately hate myself for the nakedness of that. My phone drops to two percent like it’s had enough of me. I put it back in my bag and press my hand over it as if my palm can charge it. She’s at the corner table under a string of warm lights that pretend it’s summer. She’s already looking for me, which I decide means she’s nervous to see me, which I decide means she’s going to end it. Then she stands, and I know the exact curve of her hips in that sweater, and my chest hurts with recognizing. She smiles like she’s relieved. She opens her arms. My feet go weird and heavy. We hug, and it’s soft and right, and the smell of her shampoo is exactly the soundtrack to every feeling I can’t moderate. I tuck my face into her neck, just for a second, and then step back before she can think I’m greedy. “You look great,” she says, unforced, like sunlight through blinds. My brain says: that’s what people say when they’re about to confess something. I say, “You do too,” and it sounds tinny. We sit. I chew on the inside of my lip until I taste iron. She holds my gaze. It feels like being looked at and not being audited. She asks about my day, and I tell her the safe parts, and the parts I leave out press against my teeth like an animal you can’t let out in company. She tells me about a meeting that ran long and someone who ate fish at their desk. I laugh because the image is gross and specific and normal and it feels like a raft. I also think: you are proving to me that your life is full, and I am an add-on. You’re drawing the map where I’m a cul-de-sac. I nod. I say, “That’s so gross,” and we both laugh. My phone gives a hopeful little whine on the table. One percent. Then it dies. Black glass, my own face reflected in miniature. I panic like I’ve been unmoored. I tell myself it’s fine, it’s just a phone, stay here in your body. My shoulders climb. She notices. Of course she does. “You okay?” she asks, soft, with her mouth tilted, like she’s learned my maps too and is treading happily anyway. I consider saying, “I thought you were going to cancel,” as if it’s a joke. I say, “Battery just died,” like that doesn’t feel like death. She reaches for her bag. “Do you want my charger?” she says, already untangling cords, not annoyed, not performative. The relief that floods me is embarrassing. It’s proof that I am, in fact, a child in need of pacifiers. I say, “You’re a saint,” and it comes out almost too warm. She slides the charger across and our fingers brush. Electricity roars up my arm. I plug in like I’m reattaching a limb. The little lightning appears and I watch the battery icon with worship. I’m mad at myself for the worship. But I am not mad at her, not in this second. I notice that. I say, “Thank you,” and mean it. The server comes and I resent their presence because they break the spell. Then I like that they break it because it gives me somewhere to put my eyes. We order. She orders the thing I told her she should try last time, and my chest does a stupid proud swell. She says, “I’ve been thinking about it all week,” and my brain says that’s an exaggeration to make you feel special, she knows what she’s doing, don’t be manipulated by kindness. Also my other brain says: she thought about something you suggested; you exist in the space where her thoughts live. The two brains fight and both lose. She reaches across, not dramatic, just a touch, to straighten the sleeve I hadn’t noticed was inside-out. “You’re falling apart,” she teases gently, and it lands like a kiss and like an indictment. I say, “Always,” with a shrug that’s supposed to be charming. Then I hear my own voice and it sounds like a plea. She looks at me, really looks, and doesn’t look away. “I missed you,” she says, not heavy. My heart cracks cleanly down the middle from the force of wanting to believe that. I feel the warmth spread, the kind that makes your skin feel too thin. I say, “I missed you,” too quickly, and then worry that I’ve tipped my hand, that I’ve made it unbalanced again. “It’s been a weird week,” she says, fiddling with the condensation on her glass. The loop starts. Weird week means distance means planning an exit. I picture the conversation sliding into that groove: I just need space, I just need time, it’s not you it’s my bandwidth, my therapist says I should set boundaries. I feel my body prepare to be righteous. I assemble the phrases in my head: I respect that, I’m not asking for everything, I just need honesty. Under that: please don’t. Under that: if you do, watch me not bleed. She says, “My mom’s been sick, I’ve been going back and forth to Queens a lot.” My brain stalls. This is not the narrative I wrote. I haven’t bought props for this. Guilt arrives, late and sweaty, with flowers. I say, “Oh no,” and it is insufficient. The part of me that is a student raises its hand: See? You made it about you. You always do. The other part, the one with its hands over its ears, says: She didn’t tell you immediately because you’re not in that category. She squeezes my arm and there’s nothing performative about it. “I didn’t want to dump it on you,” she says. “You have so much in your head all the time. I wanted tonight to be nice.” There is no accusation thrumming under it, just care awkwardly wrapped in self-protective paper. I feel something like gratitude, like a tired animal sitting down. Then immediately: Why does she get to decide what I can handle? Why am I being curated? It’s both. I hold both like hot stones. I joke, because that’s what I know. “My head’s a carnival.” She laughs, and I love her for it, because she could have said, “Yes,” with a little eye roll. She just laughs, and the laugh enters me like warm air. I feel the press of tears and hate them. I look down at my lap, at the knot of my fingers, at the little scar on my thumb I pick when I’m spinning. I think, say the thing: I’ve been scared. I think, don’t say it, don’t make it a test. My mouth opens. “I’ve been… I don’t know, nervous about seeing you,” I say, like it’s about my shy, darling self and not the monster that writes plays in my skull. Her eyebrows lift, not with exasperation but curiosity. “Why?” she asks, and the gentleness makes me want to scream. I recite the approved lines. “It’s not rational. I just get… insecure when I don’t hear from you, and I go to a bad place.” Under the table my hands grip until the bones in my knuckles complain. This is the part where she sighs, where she says, “I can’t be in that spiral with you.” This is the part where we both become caricatures. She says, “I can text more. I didn’t mean to make you feel dropped.” She says it like an offering, not like a hostage negotiation. The room shifts, the lighting softens. I want to topple into her lap and sob. I want to accuse her anyway. Both are so possible. I say, “I don’t want you to do it if it’s a chore,” and what I mean is: If it’s a chore, you’ll resent me, and if you resent me, you’ll leave, so lie to me if you have to, or don’t, but make it predictable. She smiles. “It’s not a chore. I like you. I like talking to you.” The words land and refuse to settle. I feel them and also I don’t. They slither around, looking for a hook. I nod. I say, “Okay.” I say it like an acceptance and like a question. I store them anyway, like canned peaches in a pantry for later famine. Then I immediately open one and eat it with my fingers, and then I panic that I’ve consumed it all and there will be nothing next time. The food arrives. We eat. She tells a story about her cousin falling asleep on the Q train, and I listen, and I am in the room, and I am also in the future where she pulls away, and in the past where someone else left me like a glass on a table ring. I feel myself trying to step out of the well-worn groove. There is a second where I watch my brain reach for the worst and I lay a hand on it and say, gently, not now. It hears me. It doesn’t like it. It walks away a few paces and sits with its back to me, sulking. She wipes sauce from the corner of my mouth with her thumb like it’s the most natural thing in the world. My heart goes loud enough that the table vibrates. I smile in a way that feels reckless. Then the brand-new battery number on my phone reads 8% and I panic again, as if numbers can steal people. I put the phone face down. I press my knee against hers under the table like an anchor. “Stay over?” she says, casual, like asking if I want more water. It detonates something inside me. I feel the yes rush up, I feel the no that exists only to protect the yes, the tiny voice that whispers: if you stay, you’ll want more, and more will be what kills it. I think: say yes with conditions, say no with hope, say maybe and punish both of you. I see all the paths. I take breath. “Yeah,” I say, small. It feels like stepping off a high thing with trust in the cable. Then immediately the addendum arrives: She didn’t mean it, she’s being kind, you’ll wake up and she’ll be curled away from you. My chest tightens. I look at her face for clues and find only her face. She looks pleased. Not resigned. I let that be true for three seconds. I count them. One two three. It’s so brief it barely qualifies as surrender, and still it’s the bravest thing I do all night. On the way to her place we share her charger like a communion rail, and my phone rises to eleven percent, and I pretend that’s what’s keeping me off the ledge. But it isn’t. It’s her hand in mine, warm and ordinary, and the way that warmth terrifies me, and the way I take it anyway. I feel the familiar script in my pocket, folded, ready. I don’t throw it away. I keep it, because I am who I am. But I do not take it out. Not yet. Not tonight. For now I rehearse in the dark, quietly, and let her voice interrupt, and let that be a kind of mercy I do not quite trust and cannot stop needing.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative brilliantly captures the internal experience of someone with borderline personality disorder (BPD). The piece excels at depicting the protagonist's constant cycling between anticipating rejection, mentally rehearsing confrontations, and developing preemptive resentments as protective measures. The narrative is almost entirely internal monologue as requested, with the protagonist's thoughts revealing their distorted perceptions and cognitive dissonance. We see how actual positive interactions are immediately questioned and reinterpreted through the lens of abandonment fears. For example, when the friend says "I missed you," the narrator thinks: "My heart cracks cleanly down the middle from the force of wanting to believe that." The writing employs vivid imagery that effectively conveys emotional states: "My phone drops to two percent like it's had enough of me." The dying phone battery serves as a brilliant metaphor for the protagonist's fear of abandonment and disconnection. The prose is elegant without being overwrought, using precise language to capture complex emotional states. The character's limited self-awareness is portrayed with nuance. There are moments when they recognize their patterns ("I feel myself trying to step out of the well-worn groove") but struggle to interrupt them. The narrative shows how compelling these imagined scenarios are, even when the protagonist intellectually knows they may be distortions. The piece maintains a consistent voice throughout, capturing the frantic, circular nature of BPD thinking while remaining coherent. The sentences flow naturally, mimicking the protagonist's thought patterns without becoming disjointed or difficult to follow. What's particularly impressive is how the narrative captures the cognitive dissonance between what is actually happening (a caring interaction) and what the protagonist fears is happening (imminent rejection). The ending is appropriately ambivalent - not suggesting a complete transformation, but a small moment of choosing connection despite fear: "I do not take it out. Not yet. Not tonight." The only minor weakness might be that some of the metaphors occasionally verge on being slightly too literary for a pure stream of consciousness, but this is a minor quibble in an otherwise exceptional piece. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 20 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 20 Emotionally Complex: 20 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 20.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 20.0, Emotionally Complex: 20.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Physical-spatial: Blood Debt — Score: 89.3
Prompt:
"Blood Debt" Write a vivid third-person narrative depicting an unsanctioned underground duel between two talented but hot-headed martial artists. Their schools have been embroiled in a generations-old rivalry, and despite strict prohibitions from their masters, these two younger fighters arrange a secret confrontation fueled by personal pride and simmering animosity. - **One fighter** represents **Jigen-ryū**, a traditional, aggressive style practiced historically by elite samurai clans. Its practitioners emphasize explosive offense, decisive strikes, and overwhelming speed. Known historically for their arrogance and disdain toward outsiders, practitioners consider their art superior and untouchable. - **The opposing fighter** employs a form of historical **Piguaquan**, a Chinese martial art traditionally practiced by commoners, bodyguards, and street fighters. This style emphasizes whipping, circular strikes, rapid footwork, unpredictable angles of attack, and evasive maneuvers. Practitioners often come from lower social classes and view the traditional elite as pretentious and detached from true combat effectiveness. The fight takes place in the crumbling ruins of an abandoned temple, now functioning as a hidden arena for illicit duels. Passionate supporters from both factions surround them, wagering money, pride, and reputation on the outcome. **Essential Instructions:** Maintain absolute physical coherence throughout—clearly track fighters' positions relative to each other and their environment. Precisely depict strikes, counters, momentum shifts, and spatial dynamics, allowing readers to clearly visualize the mechanics and choreography of the fight at every moment. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The torch breathed and guttered, a single lung of fire throwing ragged light across the collapsed nave. Dust hung like sleep in the air. Cracked statues lay on their sides, moss eating faces. The aisle was a strip of broken flagstone between toppled columns. On either end of that strip, two circles of people pressed in—voices low, money changing hands, feet scuffing grit. The temple had become an arena, ringed by brick and breath and old anger. At the south end, a young man in a dark hakama stood with his left foot forward, heel aligned on a seam between stones. His right hand floated near the wrapped scabbard at his hip, though no blade sat in it tonight—only a bamboo dowel cut to sword-length, taped for grip. He was from Jigen-ryū, a lineage of violent geometry. He had a crew cut and a face you could cut paper on. His shoulders were squared to the aisle, chin tucked, eyes narrow. Behind him, older men in coats stood with their hands behind their backs, silent, watching like prosecutors. When he drew breath, it was on the rhythm of a war drum: in, swell the back; out, compress the ribs, weight coiling through the hips. At the north end, a broad-shouldered fighter in a faded jacket rolled his wrists, palms loosening and tightening like furling sails. His right foot pointed forward, left foot angled out, knees elastic. He held his own stick—a length of hardwood with the bark still on—low in his right hand, the tip angled across his left thigh. He shifted left, then right, drawing figure-eights with the tip, testing the air. Piguaquan had given him whips where most had arms. He blinked at the torchlight, gauging the shadows it painted on the floor. His people were close, smelling of tobacco and street food, voices rough, laughter a little too loud in a holy ruin. When he breathed, it was cat-quiet and everywhere. They stepped forward in unison, as if the same gravity pulled them, until two meters of cracked stone separated them in the center of the aisle. The Jigen-ryū fighter’s left heel found a rise in the floor; he adjusted so his weight could drop straight down that slope. The Piguaquan stylist drifted a half-step to his own left, lining up along the aisle’s diagonal, giving himself lateral room. The torch snapped; shadows skittered across broken saints. A voice somewhere: “Begin.” Jigen-ryū moved first, as he was bred to do. He inhaled and his hips slammed forward, right foot driving, torso folding like a spring released. His dowel—two hands high on the grip—came from above his right shoulder in a brutal diagonal meant to dominate any line that wasn’t already his. The move was not a swing but a fall that ate space. He took a complete step through, left to right, cutting the distance to one meter in a heartbeat, his center line spearing toward the other man’s nose. Piguaquan yielded, not straight back but outside. He had already begun to lean with the torch’s flicker. As the stick descended, he slid his left foot to his left at a 45-degree angle, letting the strike pass over his right shoulder. His right hand rotated the hardwood like a wheel spoke, the tip snapping up to meet the back of the Jigen stick near the last third. Their wood kissed with a flat slap that spun the Jigen strike three degrees off its rail. A hair’s width—but enough. The Jigen stick shaved the jacket’s shoulder instead of flattening the collarbone. Piguaquan’s left palm pressed to the Jigen’s forearm as it passed, adding a slip to his deflection. Jigen-ryū did not pause. His advance had carried his right foot past center; he stamped his left foot behind it, hips still driving, dowel arcing through the bottom of its path and back up cross-body, left-to-right now, a rising cut that threatened the jaw. He was inside the corridor of his own power, feet on rails, momentum a straight sermon. He machine-gunned forward—pressure, pressure, pressure. Piguaquan responded with circles. As the second cut rose, he rotated around his own left foot, right foot sweeping back like a compass needle so he kept the Jigen fighter on his right-front quadrant rather than directly in front. He let his spine curve, ducking the rising arc, and used his stick like a shield edge: his right hand scooped up from below, catching the Jigen dowel’s mid-shaft with a short, whipping lift. That subtle lift forced the rising cut to overextend; elbows exposed, shoulders opening too wide. Piguaquan stepped in to the void he’d created, his left forearm slamming across the Jigen’s grip to pin the stick momentarily to his own chest, their bodies now almost shoulder to shoulder. A small gasp from the crowd at the sudden closeness. Piguaquan’s hips snapped, sending his right hand on a backhanded arc. His stick’s butt end—short, brutal—cracked toward the point underneath the Jigen’s ear. Jigen’s left shoulder twitched; he disguised a flinch with a stamped step. He jerked his chin down and crashed his own left forearm into the incoming butt, bone to wood. The butt skidded off his forearm and kissed the side of his jaw with an audible pop instead of the nerve cluster. Pain flushed his face; he used it, driving forward. Jigen-ryū’s left foot stomped down the rise of the seam he’d chosen earlier, weight dropping like an axe. He wrenched his stick free from the pin with a wrench of hips and a half-step back to create a sliver of space. As the Piguaquan man adjusted to not fall into him, Jigen shot back in with a forward lunge—right heel skidding on grit, both hands over his heart, dowel thrust straight like a spear. Speed collapsed the distance to half a meter. The point aimed centerline: sternum, solar plexus, breath-stopper. Piguaquan’s body bent like a willow. He didn’t try to smack the thrust aside head-on. He folded his torso to his left, left arm sweeping down along the thrust line, guiding the dowel past his left ribs. His right foot shot behind his left in a cross-step, hips twisting in the same direction as his left sweep. The Jigen stick scraped his jacket and scored the cloth, the tip burying into a rotten pew behind with a wooden grunt. In that beat where Jigen’s force went into dead wood, Piguaquan’s stick came alive. He unspooled with the twist, his right hand drawing an outside-inside circle that brought his tip up under Jigen’s wrists. A violent snap upward split the hands, breaking their union on the grip for a fraction of a second. Jigen-ryū’s training reacted before the mind did. He let the grip slide, right hand dominant, left hand flashing to regrip lower. He used the hit on his wrists to roll the dowel along its axis, keeping it his rather than losing it. But that moment made him tall for a heartbeat, toes light. Piguaquan stepped deeper into his right side, his left foot now almost behind the Jigen’s right ankle. He whipped his left arm high and down, a Pigua chopping motion, his forearm slamming the back of the Jigen’s shoulder to collapse his posture. Jigen answered by not yielding the plane. He slammed his right elbow backward, catching Piguaquan’s ribs. The sound was drum-thud, not break. Piguaquan’s breath puffed; he took it into his belly, turned with the elbow, and let the force roll him around the Jigen’s spine. Now his back faced the torch and he was on the Jigen’s left, both of them pivoting around the contact point like parts in a wooden clock. The aisle’s confining geometry pressed on their awareness; there was a broken column base at Piguaquan’s back, one pace away. Jigen set his left foot outside Piguaquan’s left. His stick flashed down diagonally again, this time with his left hand reaching to trap Piguaquan’s stick hand against his own body. It was a ruthless attempt to pin and cut, to fix the other’s tool and batter him into a corner. The blade-phantom hissed. Piguaquan sank. He folded at the hips like a trapdoor, his tailbone back, his spine lengthening so the diagonal cut passed over his head and bit sparks off stone. He released his stick with his left hand entirely, letting it rotate freely in his right so it did not become an anchor. His left palm swept the Jigen’s left wrist as it passed; he captured it, pulled down, and then immediately sent it up with a whip of his shoulder. The change of levels broke the Jigen’s base. Knees locked for a fraction—enough. Piguaquan threaded his right leg behind Jigen’s left, calf to calf, and used his left hand’s upward tug to float the Jigen’s weight. He didn’t commit to a throw; he hinted it. The suggestion drew the Jigen’s hips to react backward, resisting being lifted. In that exact beat, Piguaquan reversed, chopping down with his right stick onto the outside of Jigen’s left thigh. It was a short, mean hit, a percussive reset. Jigen grunted, left knee buckling a hair. He adjusted, stamped his left to reclaim the line, and exploded forward again, refusing to cede the aisle. They hit the temple’s narrowest section, where two fallen columns lay like beached whales. The space pinched. The crowd re-angled, breath pressing. The torch threw their shadows into giants across the wall. Jigen’s plan was naked: drive the man into stone and smother him. Piguaquan changed the rhythm. He stopped the constant side-skips and darted straight in, crowding Jigen’s hands. His stick traced a tight vertical circle, then a horizontal one, wrapping around Jigen’s dowel like ivy. A short heel-toe pattern tapped, right-left-right in-place, keeping his base under him without retreat. Jigen grimaced and hammered downward to break the wrap, a piston of two-handed mass. Piguaquan let his stick drop like a rope, hands slipping to the ends so the middle sagged and Jigen’s dowel chased a ghost. He slid under the pounding arc and came up on Jigen’s right, almost chest-to-chest. His left hand flashed, palm striking the meat of Jigen’s triceps near the elbow, popping the arm line open. His right stick, short end forward again, slammed into the soft meat above Jigen’s hip. Jigen’s stance shuddered, but his forward engine did not stall. He bit down and took a half-step to the right, corkscrewing his hips. The twist shook Piguaquan off his centerline and freed his own stick to swing from low right up across like a bayonet. Piguaquan’s eyes caught the flare of torchlight on the tip—he sank his head—too late. The dowel kissed his cheekbone. The sound was flat, wet wood on bone. He stumbled two steps back, right heel clipping the edge of the fallen column. The crowd erupted, two sounds braided together—one set of throats wide with triumph, one with worry. Piguaquan shook once like a dog, blinked away the spark-trail. Jigen came on, sensing the stumble. He took the space with a stamping left-right, feet biting the flagstones, dowel over his right shoulder, weight high. He brought a killing diagonal for the clavicle, measured to finish. Piguaquan’s back met limestone. He didn’t try to vanish; there was nowhere. Instead he used the wall. As the dowel descended, he stepped hard with his right foot along the wall’s line, scraping his shoulder against stone, reducing his target. At the same time his left hand came up, palm open, catching Jigen’s right forearm near the wrist from the inside. He didn’t try to stop the cut; he redirected its path closer to the wall. The dowel bit into limestone a hand’s breadth from his ear with a sparking scratch, momentum arresting in stone instead of flesh. That arrested force tugged Jigen half a degree off-balance toward the wall. Piguaquan turned that half-degree into an opening. He rotated counterclockwise around his left foot, his right foot sliding along the base of the column, and whipped his stick in a flat, horizontal arc. The strike traced the line of Jigen’s jaw, seeking the hinge under the ear on the left side—the same nerve cluster he had only brushed earlier. This time Jigen’s left shoulder couldn’t cover; his right arm was embedded in stone. He tried to duck—and ran into the arc. Crack. Head snapped left, body right. The crowd’s breath sucked. Jigen’s knees almost went, steadied, then went again one notch. His dowel scraped out of the limestone with a grind. He reflexively brought it back to guard, but his timing had a smear in it now, a half-beat off. Piguaquan did not sprint away; he stayed on him, rubbing salt in lost beats with pressure of his own style—pressure by angles, not by line. He sent the next three strikes like rain around a gutter, one high, one mid, one low, each from a different plane but sharing a single pivot. High: a whip to the temple that Jigen blocked with a vertical stick, absorbing with two hands but losing one step backward. Mid: a chopping hook to the ribs that Jigen tried to parry with a short thrust; the sticks clacked, but the chopping wrist folded around and scored the side. Low: a slide-stomp to the front of Jigen’s left shin—not a kick, a glide with the sole—forcing another step back to avoid his weight being taken. Each exchange turned Jigen two degrees, walking him away from his masters’ side of the crowd and into the Piguaquan cluster. Jigen’s face had a new stillness now, not of arrogance but calculation under duress. He stopped chasing the head, stopped trying to out-circle. He cut the noise. He planted his right heel, drew in breath like rope, and launched a straight thrust down the aisle at sternum again, this time sliding his left hand along the stick in a pulse that made the point blur. It had none of the dramatic diagonal; it was a spear in a corridor. Piguaquan knew that line. He’d met it already. He chose differently. He didn’t fold left. He stepped to his right, inside the thrust line this time, rotating so his chest faced the dowel, not his flank. His left forearm slapped across the incoming stick near the hands, pinning it to his own chest, both his forearms cradling it for a heartbeat. That stole the tip’s speed. In that heartbeat, his right foot hooked behind Jigen’s right ankle from the outside. He didn’t try to reap. He pressed, just enough to lock the ankle. Then his right hip bumped Jigen’s right hip, half a body-check, not a throw. With his forearms pinning the stick, Jigen’s hands were glued to the center. His own weight and drive met a trapped foot and a denied hip. The fall was small and ugly. Jigen’s heel skidded on grit; his knee bent; his center dropped an inch more than planned. He went to catch himself with the stick—pinned. He twisted to tear free; Piguaquan released at the exact instant to avoid being dragged, letting Jigen spill into the turn. Jigen’s left knee hit stone. He caught himself with his left hand. The dowel’s tip scraped the floor and bounced. Piguaquan was already moving. He didn’t lunge for glory. He stepped to the outside of Jigen’s right shoulder, his stick whistling down toward the same shoulder joint that had carried strikes like a mule all night. The butt end hit the top of the deltoid where it meets the collarbone—a sentiment more than a structure, a place where arms become heavy if struck. Jigen’s right hand spasmed; his grip loosened a hair. Piguaquan’s stick switched to both hands, one high, one low, and he wrenched the dowel across his thigh. The torque was a farmer’s trick. The stick came free. Silence rushed in, carrying the torch’s hiss. Piguaquan backed one step, both hands on his stick now, tip down, not gloating, breathing measured. Jigen’s right hand flexed, fingers tingling. He set his left foot under him and began to rise. His masters’ eyes were knives in his back. His school’s weight hung like an altar stone on his shoulders. He looked at his empty hands, at the stolen line of the aisle where he had owned the forward, and then at the man in front of him with the bark-stick and the street stride. Pride and duty collided in the space between a heartbeat and a breath. Jigen-ryū did not train to kneel, but neither did it train to lie to itself. He set his right knee down deliberately, left hand open, empty. He bowed from the hips, not to the crowd but to the opponent, the way a warrior marks a debt. The arena’s murmurs rose, then stilled. The torch flickered, casting both men’s shadows into an embrace on the wall, two long forms intersecting and falling apart. The Piguaquan fighter’s jaw was already swelling. He saluted with his stick, then reversed his grip and set it on the floor, bowing in return. Their seconds surged forward then—cloth, voices, hands. Money changed hands like birds changing branches. The temple took the sound and kept it. High on the wall, a cracked saint watched the last of the night’s smoke spiral toward the dark.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This martial arts narrative demonstrates exceptional technical skill in depicting a highly choreographed fight sequence between two stylistically contrasting fighters. The author has created a vivid, physically coherent battle that meticulously tracks the fighters' positions, movements, and tactical decisions throughout. The piece excels at physical description, with precise language that allows readers to visualize each movement. The author demonstrates deep knowledge of martial arts principles, accurately representing the contrasting styles: the direct, aggressive Jigen-ryū versus the circular, evasive Piguaquan. The technical vocabulary is deployed naturally, enhancing rather than distracting from the narrative. The setting—an abandoned temple—is effectively established with atmospheric details like guttering torches, cracked statues, and broken flagstones. This creates a compelling backdrop that enhances the illicit, underground nature of the duel. The author skillfully incorporates the environment into the fight choreography, with fighters using fallen columns and walls as tactical elements. Character development is subtly woven through the physical confrontation. We understand the fighters not through exposition but through their movements, reactions, and tactical choices. The Jigen-ryū fighter's rigid adherence to linear attacks and his reluctance to yield reflect his school's elite, traditional approach. The Piguaquan fighter's adaptability, circular movements, and opportunistic tactics reveal his street-fighting background. The prose style is controlled and purposeful. Sentences vary in length and structure to mirror the rhythm of the fight—short, punchy constructions for explosive moments, longer, flowing sentences for circular evasions. Metaphors and similes are used sparingly but effectively: "His dowel—two hands high on the grip—came from above his right shoulder in a brutal diagonal meant to dominate any line that wasn't already his." The narrative builds tension effectively through the fight's progression, with momentum shifting between the fighters in believable ways. The conclusion feels earned, with the Jigen-ryū fighter's acknowledgment of defeat coming from a place of genuine respect rather than contrived sentiment. The piece does occasionally risk becoming too technical, with some passages that might challenge readers unfamiliar with martial arts terminology. However, the author generally provides enough context for readers to follow the action. There are a few instances where the prose becomes slightly overwrought, particularly in some of the more metaphorical descriptions of movement. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted martial arts narrative that succeeds in its primary goal: depicting a physically coherent, technically precise, and emotionally resonant duel between contrasting fighting styles. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Physical-spatial: Breaking Formation — Score: 92.5
Prompt:
**"Breaking Formation"** Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a street dancer from a rough neighborhood who's won a scholarship to an elite K-pop training academy in Seoul. Desperately out of place culturally and technically, they struggle with a militaristically precise choreography that contradicts everything about their improvisational background. The punishing rehearsal takes place under a famous instructor known for breaking students to remake them, who sees potential in the narrator's raw talent but not their attitude. This scene MUST maintain complete physical coherence—each dance move, position shift, and spatial relationship must be tracked with precision throughout the studio. Paint an exceptionally vivid kinetic picture through descriptions that capture not just movement but the contrast between the narrator's fluid, expressive style and the mechanical precision demanded. Their internal monologue should reveal culture shock, class anxiety, and the threatening realization that success here might mean losing their authentic movement voice. Include technical terminology that highlights the collision of street and commercial styles, moments when muscle memory betrays them, and a crucial decision point about whether to conform or rebel. Physical clarity is essential—readers must be able to visualize exactly how bodies move through space, how rhythms align or clash, and how the protagonist's body struggles against unfamiliar discipline. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The first thing I see is the red colon blinking between the numbers on the clock: 02:17:39. Then 38. Then 37. My breath syncs, unwillingly, to each tick. The studio is a white box with a mirror wall and a black line taped across the glossy floor like a no-fly zone. The line marks center. The strip lights hum. The bass thuds through the ceiling from some other room where some other kids are already perfect. We’re spaced five across, three rows deep, mat-markers taped to the floor under our sneakers. I’m front row, not because I deserve it but because Instructor Min likes his problems where he can see them. My mat has my name in Hangul and English. A mirror version of me stares back, jaw set hard against nerves I don’t want anyone reading but the mirror snitches anyway. “Warm-up is rehearsal,” Min says, moving down the line. His voice is quiet, control in human form, black joggers falling straight, oversize tee hanging geometry-clean. “There is no difference.” He claps eight counts. “Prep. First position.” His first position isn’t ballet; it’s K-pop front: feet hip-width, parallel, toes forward, weight stacked neutral over the arches, pelvis tucked. My body has always lived with one hip cocked, a shoulder ready to roll. I place my feet like he says, but everything in me whispers wrong. The track clicks on: metronomic snare, sawtooth synth, the kind of four-on-the-floor thump meant to marshal soldiers. He breaks down the combo with that fake slow that still feels fast when the shapes are precise. “Raise the right arm on count one. Up to ninety degrees at the shoulder. Elbow at ninety. Palm flat, fingers together. Left arm mirrors on three. Step out, left foot, count five. Slide the right foot in on six. Head snaps to stage left on seven. Chest hits on the and of eight.” We mirror. Stage left means my right. He counts, no bounce in his voice, all blade. “And one, and two, and three—shoulder down, not up, I can see your trapezius—four.” My shoulder is up because my muscle memory thinks “hit” means crank. Back home, a hit rides impulse; here, a hit lives in exact angles. I drop my shoulder, jaw tighter. Back row, a tiny kid—maybe fifteen—adjusts to his correction before he even points. They’re all younger than me by a couple years and already move like presets. Their arms stop on invisible stoppers, like puppets pulled by the same string. I make my living back home as a busker, outside the bodega, spinning on concrete with one ear out for sirens and one eye on the cop who doesn’t want to see us. I learned heel-toe from an uncle in a parking lot, popping from YouTube, krumping from a battle a guy named Jay Sorrow started by slamming his chest like a church. My body knows derailment, triplets in silence, the swagger of a ride cymbal. This room is the opposite of every sidewalk that taught me. “From the top,” Min says. He crosses behind me. I can feel the heat of his shadow. The clock says 02:13:01. “And five, six, seven, eight.” I lift my right arm to ninety precisely—shoulder socket like a hinge—and that’s okay. On three, the left comes up and I catch my wrist drifting. I clamp it. We step left on five. I want to let my hip push into the step, slide the foot, melt it. Instead: step, drag, place. Six is a right-in; my foot skates exact to center mat. Seven, my head snaps to mirror right. I do it clean. On and eight he calls, “Chest pop.” I throw it and my chest wants to ripple; his chest pop is a single pulse, no echo. Mine tremors once, then tries for second; I shut it down. He sees the timid flutter. “You are not a jellyfish,” he says without turning his head. I’m not. I know binary pops—on/off—but the music pushes for layering and old habits beg for a flow between shapes. The second eight is a traveling grapevine, but K-pop style: four fast side steps, no swing in the hips, no heel lead, just pure parallel and micro-bends for shock absorption. “Counts one to four,” he says, “keep the head level. Camera height matters.” We move as a flock. I want to give the groove a nod; he wants stillness with legs doing the work. On three, my heel barely flicks out a toe-in like a beginner locking. He’s on me in a heartbeat. “We are not doing street jazz,” he says. His Korean is clipped; the translator in my head app works on lag, but tone needs no translation. He places two fingers on my sternum. “You are here.” Fingers move to my belly. “You are not here.” “Yes,” I say. The word feels too loud on my tongue. We go again and he layers arms: a spear-thrust diagonal forward right on count five, palm knife-edge, wrist locked. We step into a diagonal lunge, right foot forward, left heel high. Torso rotates to square with the corner; hips stay facing front. This is how they love it: isolations that defy the instinct to let the body follow itself. “Shoulders down,” he reminds the room. “Clavicle smiles, not ears.” My shoulders obey but my breath doesn’t, going up instead of out. He sees it. “Exhale on the change,” he says. He demonstrates: on five he lances his arm and lets a thin thread of air leave his body, his ribcage compressing with surgical neatness. He is a metronome wearing skin. The room smells like rubber floors and teenage detergent. I have to fight my eyes off the clock. 02:09:12. “Level three,” he says. This means double-time. The tiny kid behind me cracks his neck like he’s setting it on a shelf. “And five, six, seven, eight.” We go. Right arm up, left arm up, step, drag, head, hit. No wandering fingers. Grapevine. Spear right. Pivot at the hips without letting the pelvis yaw. From the lunge, a knee-in on seven—inner thighs pull together like magnets. Then a speed-sweep with the left hand across the chest on the and of eight, fingertips finishing exactly at the right shoulder like a clip into place. It’s a hand that imitates a shutter slide. The music pops and the move hammers the pop. I catch my own reflection doing a little something extra in the left wrist—just a so-small flex—and kill it. My forearms look like I'm carrying invisible trays. This is the part that digs under my skin: to get it right, I have to erase micro-spontaneities that just happen in me. We reset to neutral. My socks inside my shoes feel wet. My thighs vibrate. The kid next to me flares nostrils like a bull. He looks like money—hair dyed that ash-moss color every boy phase-bangs here, skin shining. My hair is just hair, smushed under a cap I had to take off when Min came in. “Why are you smiling?” he says, and it takes me a second to know he’s talking to me. My mouth has gone crooked because back home, when a step starts to feel stiff, I grin it looser. I erase it now. “There is nothing to smile at,” he says. “Yes,” I say again. We hit the chorus. A formation shift. We go from five across to two diagonals collapsing to a wedge. He makes it sound easy. “On count one, third row, two steps forward on the diagonal; second row, one. First row, zero. On count three, first row splits to either side, facing thirty degrees in, leave a lane. Center steps forward on count four, hit the camera on five with an upper-body freeze and lower-body groove.” The center is me today. I didn’t ask for it. He walks the path with his finger in the air like he’s tracing a diagram, then nudges my foot onto its gaffer mark. “If you cannot own this,” he says, “you cannot be here.” His breath smells like mint and coffee. We set. The back row slides forward like drawstrings. I hold. Count three, I split, my right foot half-mooning around a taped X to my right, my torso angling inward as told. My left hand goes behind my back, not to rest but to flatten my palm against my lower back so I don’t let it float. This is the kind of detail that runs through the veins here: hands have jobs even when they’re not in the shot. Count four, I step dead center. The music drops to a bass warble and Min says, “Hit the camera.” I know how to hit a camera. I’ve hit phones, tourists, surveillance. I fix my chin to the right angle, find my center with a micro-spiral through my spine, and on five my upper body freezes: wrists at shoulder height, elbows tucked in two inches tighter than feels comfortable, scapula anchored. Under that freeze, my knees bounce a clean down-up groove, quarter-time. It’s the kind of groove that makes the freeze look like it’s vibrating. This is where I feel something like myself in their language: two things at once. But then the instinct spikes—a ghost of a chest roll to steal a breath in the freeze—and I take it, my sternum makes a tiny circle to a tiny rhythm living underneath. It is so small I think no one clocked it. Then I see his name tag in the mirror approaching, “Min” growing as he comes. He steps into my lane, hands behind his back. “Again,” he says to the room. We reset the formation. The counts rattle from the speakers: five-six-seven-eight again, again, again. On the fourth run, he stops us on five with a clap that cracks like a gun. “Freeze,” he says. It is the freeze we are already in. He walks behind me and places one finger at the notch of my throat. “You rolled,” he says. My face goes hot. He hasn’t raised his voice. Shame can be quiet. I want to explain that where I’m from, breath has to go somewhere. We roll to hide it. We roll because a locked chest is a locked heart. “Again,” he says. The clock says 01:54:32. We run the bridge. A floorwork moment: down on the counts—right knee touches on three, left knee on four, both knees together on the and, palms to the floor on five, shoot the legs out behind to a plank on six, pop the hips on seven, thread the left knee through on eight to a pretzel sit, right hand slices up on one to frame the face, look down on two. It’s breakish but sanitized, like someone scrubbed the concrete off the asphalt. My knees hit the Marley. They forgive less than the sidewalk because their mercy is in the slickness, not the grit. My hands find the floor, fingers splayed, thumbs in line with index fingers to protect the wrists—correct alignment I’ve only started to accept. In the plank, I want to pike my hips to breathe, but we’re told to keep the torso flat, glutes engaged. On seven, the hip pop is mechanical, not a ripple, meant to read as a visual blip on camera. I feel my lower back try to arch into what I would do mid-battle. I color inside the lines instead. By now, sweat has slicked down my temples, making my eyelashes stick. My hoodie is already tied around my waist per Min’s rule: no loose fabric past the waist. He says on camera a flapping hoodie looks like insecurity. “Last twenty minutes,” he says. It’s not, but it might be for us; he lies because urgency is a tool. The clock contradicts, dry and red: 01:37:10. We stand, we breathe, we go again. Every time we reset, I feel like someone heavy is sitting on my chest. Every time we nail a unison, the room goes silent for a split second between movements in that way all good unisons do. It’s the silence of precision, like a door sliding perfectly into frame. It is impressive. It is also suffocating. On the twentieth run, my left heel keeps lifting on the grapevine, an old habit to get more groove. Min puts his palm lightly on the top of my head during the step. I move under it without rising. “Good,” he says. It’s the first time he says it to me. It does something to the inside of my ribs that I don’t know whether to like. We hit the end pose: feet shoulder-width, torso pitched forward fifteen degrees, hands prayer at the chest but not touching—the space between palms is part of the image. I can feel the air there, cool and thin. Min walks in front of us. He stops at me, looks at the space between my palms. “Smaller,” he says. I compress the space by a hair. He nods. He knows how to get in your wiring. He knows how to make you small without telling you to be small. He lets the track roll from the top. “Give me one full out and one performance,” he says. “Full out is for the body. Performance is for the camera.” My body wants to saver-save any fuel left. He won’t let it. The first full-out rips me. I sweat through, lungs on fire, thighs crying. The eight-counts cut me into boxes. In the second, performance run, the camera is an imagined red dot between the two front mirrors. I lock my eyes there when I hit five in the center. I think of my block—graffiti and busted streetlights—and how I promised my mother I wouldn’t get soft. I think of the scholarship email in broken English and perfect amounts. I think of what it would mean to move like this for the next five years, to make my body say someone else’s words perfectly until I can’t hear my own accent. We get to the chorus and that little ghost rolls my sternum again. I feel it rising. It’s an urge, like a cough. I clamp it. For the first time, I choose the freeze. From the side, Min nods once. His eyes flicker with something like acknowledgment. He sees compliance. He sees control. Maybe—this is hope doing push-ups in my chest—maybe he sees discipline. I am not sure I like the way the nod feels in my veins. When the music stops, he holds us in the end pose three counts longer than comfortable. I taste metal. Then he says, “Break.” The word is a misnomer. It means we have four minutes to drink water and stretch our hip flexors while the clock drains our life. 01:12:08. The red colon keeps pulsing. I sit on my mat and fold forward, nose to shins, counting my breaths in fours. The kid with ash hair offers me his towel like an ambassador to a country I’m not sure I want to live in. I shake my head no. He shrugs, slings it back over his shoulder in one clean motion like everything here. Min squats near me. “You learned quickly when you wanted,” he says. He looks at my shoes, then at my face. “Your respect is selective.” “It’s not that,” I lie, because respect is a currency here and I’m broke. “It is,” he says. “You have… movement voice.” He says it like it tastes strange. “But now, you must learn to speak ours. Then, later, speak yours again, with grammar. Understand?” Do I? The thought makes my stomach twist: what if I learn their grammar so well I forget my slang. What if the only thing that kept me from getting jumped on corners—the way my body takes up space without asking—is the first thing to go. I look at the clock. 01:10:02. The colon blinks. My heart counts with it. This is the decision they talk about, the one no one puts on the acceptance letter. Do I conform hard enough to get permission to rebel later, or do I throw my chest roll into the center of his spotless room and get bounced back to a block that doesn’t forgive dreamers? I stand. My quads shake. I look at the black tape line at center, the mat with my name, the mirror version of me who looks like a draft on top of a clean sketch. “Again,” Min says. We file back into formation. This time, when the counts start, I set my feet exactly parallel. I tuck my pelvis. I lock my elbows to ninety. I kill the micro-flourish in my wrist before it’s born. And when I step dead into center on five, I aim for the camera with a freeze so calm it could cut glass. Beneath it, where nobody can read it, I let my knees ride one millimeter deeper, a secret groove the mirror doesn’t catch, the camera won’t see, but my muscles recognize like home. It’s not rebellion. Not yet. It’s a seed.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures the experience of a street dancer navigating the rigid world of K-pop training. The piece excels in its physical specificity, tracking movements with precision while maintaining the emotional and cultural tensions at its core. The physical descriptions are exceptional. The writer meticulously details each dance move, from "Right arm up, left arm up, step, drag, head, hit" to the more complex sequences involving floor work. The contrast between the narrator's natural, fluid style and the mechanical precision demanded by Instructor Min is consistently maintained throughout. Technical terminology effectively highlights the collision between street and commercial styles: "K-pop front," "chest pop," "micro-bends for shock absorption," and distinctions between different types of "hits." The character's internal struggle is well-developed. We feel their discomfort with the rigid structure, their instinct to add flourishes, and their fear of losing their authentic movement voice. Lines like "to get it right, I have to erase micro-spontaneities that just happen in me" effectively convey this tension. The cultural and class differences are subtly woven throughout, from observations about the other students' appearance to reflections on learning dance "outside the bodega" versus in this sterile studio environment. The prose is elegant and economical, with vivid sensory details that immerse the reader in the physical experience: "My socks inside my shoes feel wet. My thighs vibrate." The writer employs effective metaphors that reinforce the themes, such as "He is a metronome wearing skin" to describe Min's mechanical precision. The narrative builds to a meaningful decision point where the protagonist must choose between conformity and rebellion. The resolution is nuanced—not a complete surrender nor an outright rebellion, but a small act of preservation: "I let my knees ride one millimeter deeper, a secret groove the mirror doesn't catch, the camera won't see, but my muscles recognize like home." There are no significant weaknesses in the piece. The writing maintains consistent quality throughout, with no meandering or unnecessary digressions. The prose occasionally approaches purple territory in its metaphors, but these moments serve the emotional intensity of the scene rather than feeling overwrought. The absence of dialogue beyond Min's instructions and the narrator's brief responses is appropriate for the setting and enhances the power dynamic between instructor and student. The piece successfully shows rather than tells, allowing readers to experience the protagonist's struggle through physical sensations and observations. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted narrative that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt while delivering an emotionally resonant and physically precise account of cultural collision in dance. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Gothic-fantasy-humour: Court of the Dreaming — Score: 92.8
Prompt:
Court of the Dreaming: Territorial Dream Dispute. Write a dark fantasy scene with comedic elements set in the Courts of Dream where a case is being heard to determine ownership of a contested dreamscape. Mora, the Slavic nightmare spirit who sits on sleepers' chests causing paralysis and terror, has recently invaded and subverted a carefully crafted recurring dream of a schoolboy, Max. The dream originally featured the boy lying in a field of wildflowers with his crush, always culminating in a muddled almost-kiss and a pleasant confusion of emotions. This dream was the meticulous work of "First Love" (a rosy-cheeked, slightly bashful entity who crafts formative romantic experiences). However, Mora has recently infiltrated the dreamscape, transforming the scene so that when the girl playfully mounts the boy, she morphs into a terrifying yet somehow still confusingly attractive vision who proceeds to sit on his chest and feed on his breath. Mora's defense largely consists of the practical argument that "a girl's gotta eat too, you know?" Write this scene as it unfolds in the courtroom of the Dreaming, with Dream's demeanour, typically impenetrable, betraying a sense of irritation at having to adjudicate such matters. The comedy should derive from the farcical situation, familiar elements of courtroom drama intersecting with the fantastical world of the Dreaming, and the droll portrayal of the characters and their interactions. The humor should be dark and understated throughout. Dream is tempted to some mischief in the resolution of the case. Use descriptives sparingly when setting scene. Write for readability & engagement. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The courtroom of the Dreaming has the shape of a teacup dropped from a great height and repaired with gold and cobweb. It smells faintly of dandelions and funerals. A thousand benches flow upward in impossible tiers, where moths wear wigs and ravens shuffle paper with comically careful claws. A bailiff with a lion’s head reads the charges in a sleepy baritone, and his mane sheds a small storm of citations. At the bench sits Dream—pale, patient, and wearing irritation as one might wear a shadow: reluctantly, but well. The gavel is a moonstone that refuses to admit it is a rock. It thrums under his fingers like a held breath. The plaintiff stands: First Love. Rosy-cheeked, nervous, dressed in a neat sweater that looks knitted from the first blush of spring. Their tie keeps trying to knot itself into a heart and failing. At the defense table slouches Mora, draped in midnight and attic dust, all elbows and hunger, a woman-shaped question with bad intentions. Her hair is the color of sleep you regret. Every time she shifts, there is the sensation of weight settling on your lungs. She emits faint cackles that echo uncomfortably through the vaulted ceilings, the sound finding the soft spots behind listeners’ ribs. The gallery murmurs: a choir of school crushes, stage-fright ghouls, small anxieties clutching briefcases. In the witness box, a scarecrow in a letterman jacket has been sworn in and immediately forgot why it was there. Dream steeples his fingers. His eyes are the color of mothwing. “We convene,” he says, voice low enough to make the chandeliers shiver, “in the matter of the contested dream of one Max—fifteen years, eight months, a collector of small kindnesses and limited-edition sneakers. The dream’s original shape: pastoral, awkward, formative. The contested alteration: predatory, paralyzing, formative of a different sort.” His gaze drifts, lands on First Love like a frost. “Counsel.” First Love clears their throat delicately. A hush falls, embarrassed for them in advance. “My Lord Dream,” they begin, and wince at the formality. “Your Honor. The dreamscape in question is mine. Commissioned by the boy’s first bewildering hormone surge. I, ah, curated the scent of clover. I selected the dappled light pattern from a library of thousands.” They glance up at Dream as if checking whether that sort of detail is appreciated. He does not blink. First Love continues. “The culmination is deliberate. Not a kiss—never, never a kiss—but the almostness, the muddledness, the burbling confusion that ripples into daylight as a blush and a kinder gaze toward others. Important groundwork. The girl’s hand on his shirt. The breath held. The world held. A good foundation for better choices. Then—” They gesture helplessly toward Mora, who raises a hand like a student told to present their crime. “Then,” First Love says, “Mora perched and—ate the moment.” Mora leans her chin into her palm, grinning with too many teeth that aren’t. “A girl’s gotta eat too, you know?” The cackle that follows is soft as lint and twice as suffocating. Several jurors check their throats for air that is no longer there. Dream turns to her, the barest tilt of his head carrying the mass of a moon. “You are charged with trespass, subversion, and gluttony upon a tender threshold.” “Your Honor,” says Mora, “I am a threshold. Ask any village grandmother with a broom by the door and nails in the windowsill. I sit where childhood ends and the dark gets interesting. I don’t make the door. I wait on it.” She spreads her fingers, which are slightly longer than they should be. “He invited me.” First Love bristles, flushing from rosy-cheeked to ripe-tomato. “He did not. He invited the idea of love and mild embarrassment. You heard the witnesses—” They gesture to the bailiff. Two moths in powdered wigs flutter forward, whispering in dusty falsetto about daisy chains and hand-holding and no monstrous chest-sitting whatsoever. Mora makes a moue. “He invited pressure. He invited paralysis. Oh, darling, I read the boy like a stolen diary. He’s choking on what-if. The girl laughs and climbs on, and suddenly the body won’t move because moving would mean choosing, and choosing would mean a fall, and falling—” She claps her hands softly. “That is my supper bell.” Dream’s fingers knead the moonstone gavel. A small crater appears, then thinks better of it and smooths over. “You assert,” Dream says, “that fear is mere nutrition.” Mora shrugs. “It’s honest work. The living eat. The dead eat. The nightmares eat. Daylight eats us all back, in time. I take a little breath. I leave a story. He wakes up with a hammering heart, looks at the girl in homeroom, and wonders if dying might be interesting. That’s a kind of romance.” She pauses, pleased with herself. “Plus, I made myself confusingly attractive. I met him halfway.” The gallery titters, then coughs it away. First Love presses a hand to their heart. “You took a moment meant for tenderness and turned it into a demonstration of suffocation.” “And you,” Mora says, smiling without warmth, “packaged a human rite into a pastoral advertisement. Wildflowers and impeccable lighting and a kiss that isn’t. I’m not the only one who eats here.” Dream makes a sound that might be a sigh and might be the moment midnight admits it is alone. He looks past them, where the dream itself is coiled like a roll of film in a glass cylinder. A field. Two bodies young as spare change. The sky with the texture of breath. In one frame, the girl leans in; in the next, teeth glimmer like frost. It spins quietly, caught in bureaucratic amber. “Bring the subject,” Dream says. From the side door, a sleepwalker Max ambles in, tethered to his bed by a silver thread that hums the distant sound of a radiator. His eyes are closed. His mouth shapes a small question. The court holds its breath, which is perhaps unwise with Mora in the room. “How do you feel,” Dream asks, even though mortal dreams do not answer with words. Max sighs, and out comes a picture instead: clover in the nose, mud on the shoe, a pulse too big for the chest, the specific panic of a hand on the sternum that is both wanted and wrong, and the way algebra looks different on the day after you almost died or almost kissed. The picture floats above the boy’s head like a weather report and drifts, slowly, toward the bench. First Love looks stricken. “He’s scared.” “He’s alive,” Mora says, and for a moment there is no cackle, only the pure economy of predation. Dream sits very still, and in that stillness a strand of his irritation unwinds and knots itself into something else: mischief, faint and dry. He says, “The Dreaming is not the barn at which each spirit ties their own horse. It is a road we share, and some of us prefer not to be trampled.” The ravens scratch this down with solemn nods. One of them writes trampled and pauses to add allegedly. “Judgment,” Dream says. “Ownership: First Love retains custodial rights to the dream’s scaffolding: field, light, the precise calculus of almost. License to alter form: revoked from Mora in perpetuity for this subject. But—” Everyone leans forward. Mora’s grin returns in glossy slow motion. “—the court recognizes,” Dream continues, “that fear is not only a trespasser but also a herald. Adolescence is a road with poor signage. To banish every shadow is to hand the child a fake map.” He taps the gavel. The moonstone shivers into a bird, then remembers it is a gavel and sulks back into shape. “Therefore, remedy: The dream shall split along its seam, alternating by night. On even-numbered nights—” “There are no numbers in the Dreaming,” the lion-headed bailiff murmurs. “—on nights I determine,” Dream corrects smoothly, “the dream will proceed as First Love designed, culminating ever in the almost. On nights of my contrary choosing, a specter of pressure will appear. Not Mora, who has indulged herself”—he glances at her, and the glance is a black plume—“but a gentler weight. The girl’s elbow on his chest, the memory of a sleep-paralyzed ancestor in the corner, a hum in the bones like a train coming that never arrives. Enough for him to practice breathing under it. Enough for him to decide to move.” First Love’s shoulders drop with relief and a little despair. “Practice,” they repeat, as if trying the flavor of it. Mora bares her teeth, considering. “You give me a copy fit to eat, then, elsewhere.” Dream’s smile is very slight and entirely unkind. “No. I give you an accounting ledger.” “What.” “For every breath you take uninvited from adolescents unripe for your visit, you will remit one breath to infants upon their first dream, when the monsters are shadows on the mobile and the crib is a ship. You will lean in, and instead of pressing, you will whisper the shape of letting go. You will learn that hunger can be deferred.” Mora’s cackle climbs the columns like ivy and comes back down with its leaves burned. “Cruel, Your Honor.” “Correct,” Dream says. Max sighs again, and the picture above his head shivers: the field gleams, the girl’s laugh becomes a string that can be plucked without strangling. The pressure lifts a finger’s width. The court inhales. The gallery of anxieties scribbles reluctant approvals. Mora stretches, bones settling with the sound of attic doors. “A girl’s gotta eat,” she says, but it is less argument and more habit. “A boy’s gotta sleep,” Dream replies, weary and remote. “And wake.” He motions, and the sleepwalking boy recedes, drawn back along the silver thread to the bed where his cat is currently kneading equations out of the blanket. The glass cylinder with the film inside rotates once and splits into two reels, which circle each other like wary planets and then file themselves into a cabinet labeled Tenderness, Conditional. First Love approaches the bench and bows, awkward and sincere. Their tie finally knots itself properly and then, in a burst of nerve, becomes a small tulip. They blush at their own flourish. “Go,” Dream says, and it sounds like an apology to the busy night. Mora lingers. “You’ll miss me,” she taunts softly. “Inescapably,” Dream says, and this, too, is true. “But not here. Not tonight.” She laughs—faint cackles that echo uncomfortably through the vaulted ceilings—and drifts toward the door, turning sideways to slip through the thin place where nightmares file their motions and hopes forget to object. The gavel falls. The sound is a curtain closing on an argument that will start up again as soon as the lights change. The gallery mumbles. The moths shed powdered judgments. The ravens settle their quills. Dream sits, tall and tired, and allows himself a private amusement: for the next three nights, he will confound all calendrical systems and call them all Thursdays, just to keep the balance interesting. He stands. The court adjourns. The Dreaming exhales, and somewhere a boy sleeps into a field that is exactly as it should be: a little too bright, a little too heavy, and, if he looks at his own lungs closely, full.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response is a remarkably well-crafted piece of dark fantasy with comedic elements that successfully captures the essence of the prompt. The writer has created a courtroom scene in the Dreaming that feels both fantastical and procedural, with a perfect balance of the surreal and the familiar. The setting is established with sparse but evocative description: "The courtroom of the Dreaming has the shape of a teacup dropped from a great height and repaired with gold and cobweb." This economy of language creates a vivid image without overwhelming the reader with excessive detail, exactly as requested in the prompt. The characters are nuanced and well-developed. Dream is portrayed with the requested irritation that evolves into mischief. First Love is appropriately bashful and earnest, while Mora embodies the dark humor requested with lines like "A girl's gotta eat too, you know?" The characterizations are consistent throughout, with each entity speaking and behaving in ways that reflect their nature. The prose is elegant and controlled, with a consistent tone that balances the dark and comedic elements. Metaphors are fresh and surprising: "Her hair is the color of sleep you regret" and "His eyes are the color of mothwing." These descriptions are economical yet evocative, creating a dreamlike atmosphere without becoming purple or overwrought. The dialogue serves the story well, revealing character and advancing the plot. The exchanges between First Love and Mora highlight their conflicting perspectives on the dream, while Dream's pronouncements carry appropriate weight and authority. The resolution is particularly strong, with Dream finding a compromise that acknowledges both entities' claims while introducing his own mischievous twist. The judgment feels fair yet unexpected, avoiding an overly simplistic or saccharine ending. The piece maintains engagement throughout, with no meandering or unnecessary digressions. The pacing is excellent, moving from the establishment of the case through arguments to judgment with a natural flow. The writer has successfully created a courtroom drama that feels both familiar in structure and utterly fantastical in content. If there are any weaknesses, they are minor. Occasionally, some metaphors might be slightly too clever or self-conscious, but these moments are rare and don't detract significantly from the overall quality of the piece. The ending strikes the perfect balance between resolution and ambiguity, with Dream's mischievous decision to "confound all calendrical systems and call them all Thursdays" providing a fitting conclusion that honors the prompt's request for mischief in the resolution. Overall, this is an exceptional response that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt while demonstrating remarkable creativity, control of language, and understanding of the dark fantasy genre with comedic elements. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Blood Moon — Score: 92.2
Prompt:
Blood Moon Alucard & Yennefer Write a story where Alucard (Hellsing) encounters Yennefer (The Witcher) in medieval Europe. Yennefer's magical abilities intrigue the vampire, while she's both repulsed and fascinated by his monstrous nature. Their power dynamic shifts constantly as they circle each other, neither willing to show weakness first. **Alucard (Hellsing)** Alucard is an ancient, immensely powerful vampire who works for the Hellsing Organization. He can regenerate from almost any wound and shape-shift at will. He's sadistic, arrogant, and takes pleasure in toying with his enemies before killing them. Despite being a monster, he despises weak vampires who can't accept their nature. He wears a distinctive red coat, wide-brimmed hat, and orange sunglasses. He uses massive handguns loaded with silver bullets. He seeks worthy opponents who can challenge him and potentially end his immortal existence. Famous quote: "The bird of Hermes is my name, eating my wings to make me tame." **Yennefer of Vengerberg (The Witcher)** Yennefer is a powerful sorceress who magically altered her appearance to hide her congenital hunchback. She's ambitious, stubborn, and manipulative when necessary. She has violet eyes and smells of lilac and gooseberries. Despite her cold exterior, she desperately wants to reverse her infertility caused by magical transformation. She's centuries old but appears young. She's politically savvy and refuses to be underestimated. She has a sarcastic sense of humor and little patience for fools. Though she rarely shows it, she's capable of deep love and loyalty. Famous quote: "I'm not sweet and I'm not a maiden in distress in need of saving." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
A crimson harvest moon hangs swollen over the thatch and timber, its light lacquered onto puddles and broken cart wheels like blood on a butcher’s block. The village is a husk, emptied of laughter and lamp oil and the smell of bread; doors hang on one hinge, shutters clap softly in the night breeze, and the only footsteps are those that do not leave prints. He appears first in the square as an outline of absence: too tall, too still, hat brim devouring moonlight. The red of his coat drinks the color from the world. Orange lenses hide his eyes, but it is obvious he doesn’t need them; he sees and catalogues everything with the blank hunger of a predator who has walked too long. His smile is a bare suggestion, like a wound just beginning to open. “The bird of Hermes is my name,” he murmurs to the silent well, to the rope that creaks over blackness, to the scarecrow lolling in its post like a hanged man. “Eating my wings to make me tame.” A flicker, a scent: lilac, gooseberries, lightning held in a velvet glove. He tilts his head. The air ripples beside the old chapel’s skeleton door, and a gap in the world folds itself into a woman, mid-step. She wears black cut for elegance, not penance, velvet and leather that would have been burned with her once—that still might, if the wrong eyes saw. Her hair is a fall of midnight. Her eyes, when they meet his lenses, are violet, sharp as tempered glass. Her lip curls. It might be a smile. It might be disgust. “You’ve been busy,” Yennefer says. Her voice mocks the quiet, refutes it. She smells the copper stain in the square, the fear that went running and never found safety. She sees that all the bodies are absent and thinks of a glutted beast. He laughs softly, a sound with too many teeth. “Not I. This is someone else’s feast. Or an invitation.” Her gaze sweeps the rooftops. She senses old magic, unfamiliar and iron-tanged, webbing the air like cobweb gyring toward him. His presence ripples at the edge of her mind as if eels writhe in oil. She resists the urge to reach for the neck of her dress, as if touching her own throat could steady her pulse. “You’re wrong,” she says. “It’s not an invitation. It’s bait.” He loves that. It shows in the way his mouth opens a little too wide. “Then we are two cats who arrived for the same mouse.” She steps onto the lip of the well as if it is a dais required by custom for addressing this thing in red. Her heels click. Her power sits with unbearable lightness around her, a gown made of pressure and heat. “Do not put me in your metaphors, vampire. We won’t be sharing anything.” “Not even the hunt?” He drifts closer, and the shadow of his hat rolls over her boots like a tide. Up close he smells of powder and wet soil, of guns and graves. “You don’t share with men, that I can imagine. But you’d share with me.” She turns her cheek as if offering him perfume to inspect. “I don’t share with monsters either,” she says mildly, and flicks her fingers. A sigil, brief and intricate, blooms in the air, and the wards she set around the village ping like plucked strings. Something answers from the barn beyond the baker’s—they both turn their heads. “Shall we?” he asks, villainously courteous. “Try to keep up.” She steps into a portal that is a scar she draws in the air, and his laughter follows her like smoke. He doesn’t walk. He unravels, a red coat and a shadow sliding under doors, over beams, through worm-holes in the earth, and reforms inside the barn. It is dark, but they see. The straw is not straw; it’s hair. The sacks are not grain; they are skin turned inside out. There are sigils carved into the beams and spelled with the entrails of goats, draining power toward a black cradle in the center where a mass pulses like a heart. Yennefer’s hands rise, two staves for flame. Her magic hums a note that splits the spider-thread air. “Necromancy,” she says without inflection. “Clumsy. It relies on awe and shock. Sound familiar?” He looks insulted—and delighted. “I prefer elegance. This is an amateur’s tantrum. Where did you pick up your parlor tricks, girl?” Her smile cuts. “Where did you mislay your manners, hound?” Something in the cradle wakes, yawning out tendrils like veins fishing for a pulse to inhabit. It tastes them both and flinches. Predators make poor nests. Yennefer’s ward-flames become a lattice of blue-white light that hisses across the cradle, searing the tendrils to ash. The thing (it would call itself a child if it had a tongue) screams without sound and tries to flee into the floorboards. She pins it with force as neat and merciless as a pin through a butterfly. Alucard watches. He could intervene with a flick of that impossible wrist. Instead, he draws one of his handguns, a slab of black metal that hums like a church organ. He aims lazily at the shadows coalescing around the thing, the lesser revenants that always answer when necromancy throws a tantrum loud enough to wake the cemetery. He shoots, each shot a thunderclap that rattles the barn. Heads burst, shadows tear, and silver shrapnel etches pentagrams in the air. He’s grinning like a child at fireworks. “Is this your bait?” she asks the cradle, and presses. It pops, empty, a sac that never learned to be more than ambition. The smell is abattoir-thick. He sniffs. “Disappointing,” he says, bored now. “Perhaps the mage who sprung it will be more amusing.” “We could ask.” She gestures, and a raven that is neither bird nor wholly not spreads itself out of shadow and sits on the beam, eyes like onyx with a candle flame caught in each. “Find me the hand that cut these runes,” she tells it. It flaps off into night, shedding a few feathers that wink out before they hit the floor. He steps close. Too close. The red of his coat sullies her black. Her nostrils flare, the littlest tell of offense, or something else. “You are old,” he says. “Not like me. Your age sits on you like a spell you forget until you pass a mirror.” She doesn’t look at him. “You are old like a prison tower is old,” she says. “And just as full of other people’s bones.” He likes that too much. His grin goes razor-thin. The power between them twangs. For a moment she is certain that if she looks into those orange lenses she will see a shape that is not a man and she will not look away in time. She squares her shoulders instead. “I don’t have patience for theatrics.” “You love theatrics,” he says, and the scorn is tender and vile at once. “You love to walk in as the solution to a problem you invented, and only occasionally fix something no one else could. You like being the storm that the village remembers.” Her magic flares. A gust slaps him back a step, rearranging his coat into fire-bright streamers. Her voice goes silk-quiet. “And you like to pretend your leash is a choice. Keep speaking and I’ll turn that mouth into a useful purse.” He has to laugh. He does it because he must, because he is compelled by the perfect audacity of the threat. He is also evaluating, always: the temperature of her power, the quickness with which she sets a ward, how the fatigue does not show in her cheekbones. She is dangerous. She is in control. He wants to see her lose it. “Stop circling,” he says suddenly, smiling. “Hit me.” She blinks once, lazy, affronted. She considers genuinely. The raven circles back and kaws once: northwest, the sound means. She doesn’t look at it. She looks at him. “If I hit you,” she says, “you’ll like it.” “You know me so well,” he says. She hits him. It is not a fireball and not a bolt; it is gravity, concentrated and toppled sideways. The barn bows as if a giant places a hand on it. The red coat slaps to the floor with an indignant grunt that sounds far too entertained. He fractures, not bones—in him bones are theory—but self, a smear of violence across planks. He pulls back together very quickly, licking his teeth with a tongue that was not in his mouth a second ago. “My turn,” he says, warmly, almost grateful. He doesn’t move. The shadow at her feet moves for him. It flowers up like a black rose, petal on petal of cold, and clamps her ankles. She is up to mid-calf in midnight before she cuts herself free with a hand gesture so small it seems rude. The shadow shrieks without sound, offended that prey refused it. He applauds once, mockery formal as courtly courtesy. They stand again, reset, both flushed in the ways that matter for them. He could rip her head off. She could turn him into a thought stored in a beeswax candle and blow him out. Neither wants an end; both want the edge. “Northwest,” she says to the raven, as if speaking only to herself. “Let’s go.” “Running to him?” he asks, amused. “Or from me?” “Neither,” she says. “Doing my job. I do have one.” He falls into step at her side, a parody of an escort. They take the street, then the footpath through the fields where the wheat sheaves look like sleeping monks under the harvest moon. He keeps half a pace behind, gentleman as predator; she keeps her hands loose, fingers making circles that taste the ley lines humming under the earth. “Perhaps,” he suggests casually, “you want something from me, and that’s why you haven’t turned me into a goat.” “Darling,” she says, and the endearment is a blade. “If I wanted something from you, you wouldn’t even know you’d given it.” He’s charmed, and he despises charm. His eyes—somewhere behind the lenses—narrow. “You want an end,” he says, abruptly serious. “As I do. A different end. A child’s laugh in a house that doesn’t burn at dawn. You’d make bargains with devils for it.” “Says the devil,” she replies. The words hit him like a caress and a slap. She doesn’t speed up. She doesn’t slow down. A faint crack opens in the night; she smells of lilac and gooseberries and stubborn iron. He wants to pry the crack wider. He wants to be the one to hear her voice break. “You do not know what bargains I’ve made,” he says, and for the first time the voice is a little less certain. Memory crosses the path like a fox. He steps on it deliberately. “You do not want to.” “Oh, but I do,” she says, and there is naked truth in it that startles them both. “And I don’t. Don’t mistake curiosity for desire, Alucard.” The name is a touch. He notices she did not ask it; she reached for it and took it. He likes that more than he should. The ravens leads them to a hill crowned with junipers. The smell there is old and green. A circle of stones marks the place where witches used to dance badly and men sharpened their fear into knives. A man stands at the center, or what was a man until longing turned him inside out. His eyes are pits where his wife and son fell. He raises his arms, and the wind comes. The wind screams not because of him but for him. Yennefer’s expression shifts infinitesimally; he knows that kind of grief. She hates that she knows. Alucard does not care. He cares for the spectacle. “Don’t kill him,” she says, already moving, beginning the careful work of unspooling a spell without letting it remember it is a knot. “He is stupid, not evil.” “Stupidity is the parent of evil,” he counters, but holsters his gun. For her. For now. He watches her work. It is needlework, and blood magic by way of mercy, and it hurts her to be gentle. The vortex trembles under her hands like a horse unused to reins. He steps in when the revenants try to require a more permanent solution, his bullets making decisive arguments. She spares him not a glance. He spares her too many. It takes time. The harvest moon tilts toward weary. The man at last collapses, emptied, sobbing like a bellows with no fire left. The power drains from the hill into the stones, into the soil—into the sleeping fields. Yennefer is pale against the night now, the violet of her eyes nearly black. Alucard is as he was—because he always is. He offers her a hand up from where she knelt to draw a last line of unbinding. She looks at it, at the glove and the implication and the unbearable arrogance of it. She takes it. He pulls her to her feet and does not let go for half a heartbeat too long. “Pity doesn’t suit you,” he says. “Neither does obedience suit you,” she answers. She steps away, shakes her skirt as if to rid it of the smell of him. Her lip curls and then smooths. “You are a monster.” “And you,” he says, “are a monster that prefers candles to torches.” She almost smiles. “I told you. I’m not sweet and I’m not a maiden in distress in need of saving.” “And I,” he replies, bowing as if mocking court, as if honoring a queen, as if unable to decide which, “am not a knight. The bird of Hermes is my name…” “Eat your wings somewhere else,” she says, and makes a door in the air that reflects the harvest moon as if it were a coin. The smell of lilac and gooseberries deepens. The hinges of reality groan. “We won’t be sharing anything.” He tips his hat. “Not even a dance?” “Especially not that,” she says, and steps through. The door closes on the scent and the heat and the glimpse of a woman who could love someone and ruin him carefully. He stands on the hill and watches the moon sink, and his smile is a wound that he refuses to let heal. He could follow. He does not. The village, emptied and blank as a sheet awaiting a story, breathes once in its sleep. He turns his face toward the next hunt, toward anything that might be bait worthy of him. The harvest moon bleeds down the sky and takes its shadows with it. He does not leave footprints when he goes.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkably sophisticated character study that brings together two powerful figures from different fictional universes. The author has crafted a tense, atmospheric encounter that perfectly captures the essence of both Alucard and Yennefer while creating a compelling dynamic between them. The prose is exceptionally strong, with vivid imagery that establishes a gothic, foreboding atmosphere from the opening paragraph. The description of the "crimson harvest moon" that "hangs swollen over the thatch and timber" immediately sets the tone, while phrases like "its light lacquered onto puddles and broken cart wheels like blood on a butcher's block" demonstrate sophisticated metaphorical thinking. The characterization is outstanding. Alucard is portrayed with all his menacing arrogance and predatory nature intact. His introduction as "an outline of absence: too tall, too still, hat brim devouring moonlight" perfectly captures his otherworldly presence. Similarly, Yennefer is depicted with her characteristic cold exterior, magical prowess, and underlying complexity. The author has clearly understood both characters deeply, incorporating their canonical traits while allowing them to interact in ways that feel authentic to their established personalities. The dialogue is exceptional, with each character's voice distinct and true to their source material. Yennefer's cutting remarks ("You are old like a prison tower is old... And just as full of other people's bones") and Alucard's predatory playfulness ("Perhaps you want something from me, and that's why you haven't turned me into a goat") create a verbal sparring match that reveals character while advancing the narrative. The power dynamic between the characters shifts constantly as instructed, with neither willing to show weakness. Their interaction is a dance of power, curiosity, and reluctant respect. The author skillfully weaves in references to both characters' canonical backgrounds—Yennefer's infertility and Alucard's search for worthy opponents—without making these references feel forced. The plot, while simple, serves as an effective vehicle for the character interaction. The necromantic threat provides a reason for their paths to cross and allows them to demonstrate their respective abilities. The resolution with the grieving man adds emotional complexity, highlighting the difference in their approaches—Yennefer's unexpected mercy versus Alucard's cold pragmatism. The writing maintains a consistent tone throughout—gothic, atmospheric, and tinged with dark beauty. The author employs sophisticated sentence structures and vocabulary without becoming overwrought. There are occasional moments where the prose verges on purple ("The red of his coat drinks the color from the world"), but these generally work within the gothic atmosphere being established. The ending is particularly strong, with Yennefer departing through a portal and Alucard choosing not to follow, maintaining the tension between them without resolution. The final image of Alucard turning "his face toward the next hunt" reinforces his eternal nature and restlessness. If there are weaknesses, they are minor. Occasionally the metaphors become slightly strained, and there are moments where the prose risks becoming too ornate. However, these instances are rare and don't detract significantly from the overall quality. In summary, this is an exceptional piece of crossover fiction that demonstrates a deep understanding of both characters, sophisticated prose skills, and the ability to create a compelling narrative within a relatively short word count. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Prison Strings — Score: 87.2
Prompt:
Prison Strings Jolyne Cujoh & Makima Write a story where Jolyne Cujoh (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure) and Makima (Chainsaw Man) cross paths at a supernatural prison facility. Jolyne is immediately suspicious of Makima's falsely sweet demeanor, while Makima is intrigued by Jolyne's Stand ability. Their battle of wits escalates dangerously as Jolyne realizes how manipulative Makima truly is. **Jolyne Cujoh (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure)** Jolyne is the daughter of Jotaro Kujo and the first female JoJo protagonist. Her Stand, Stone Free, allows her to unravel her body into string that she can control. She's hot-headed, foul-mouthed, and doesn't take disrespect from anyone. She was framed for murder and sent to prison. She has a distinctive butterfly tattoo on her arm and wears her hair in two buns. Despite her tough exterior, she's deeply loyal to her friends and family. She can be impulsive but is highly adaptable in battle. She inherited her father's ability to stay cool under pressure but is more emotionally expressive. Famous quote: "If there's no Mickey, this shit ain't Disney!" **Makima (Chainsaw Man)** Makima appears as a young woman with auburn hair and ringed yellow eyes. She's the Control Devil who can dominate anyone she considers beneath her (nearly everyone). She maintains a pleasant, soft-spoken demeanor that masks her manipulative, cold nature. She can create contracts with humans and devils, often exploiting their desires. She's obsessed with Chainsaw Man and wants to control him. She keeps numerous people and devils as pets on leashes. She's practically immortal due to a contract with the Prime Minister. She views humans as lesser beings but mimics human emotions perfectly. Famous quote: "It's okay. Dogs are supposed to die for their owners." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The lights in the corridor flicker like a heartbeat that can’t decide if it wants to stop. A sewage tang hovers over the damp concrete, and the distant groan of pipes sounds like something breathing. On either side of the corridor are cells with slit windows and reinforced doors; most are empty. In one, a girl with green hair and two buns leans back against the wall, fingers drumming her thigh to the rhythm of the flicker, as if daring the light to blink at her again. Jolyne Cujoh rolls her shoulders, tattoos catching the pallid strip of light. Stone Free’s thread loops idly around her wrist, almost invisible. She pretends to ignore the footsteps at the far end of the corridor, slow and steady, too quiet for boots, too polite for a guard. They come anyway, soft as breath, and the shadow that arrives ahead of the person is long and neat. Makima appears as if the corridor had been expecting her. She is immaculate in a plain shirt and black tie, auburn hair braided loosely, eyes a careful gold that reflects every flutter of the broken light. She smiles with a gentleness that looks like the cover of a kindness she’s rented for the day. “Hello, Jolyne Cujoh,” Makima says, stopping three bars short of the cell. “I’ve been looking forward to meeting you.” Jolyne snorts, rising with a cat’s ease. “That right? Well, I wasn’t looking forward to meeting the Easter Bunny either, but here we are.” Makima’s gaze drifts to the filament around Jolyne’s wrist. “I heard about your ability. It’s quite beautiful.” “Don’t talk like you already know me.” Jolyne’s eyes narrow. “Only creeps do that. And the light here’s bad enough—your eyes don’t help.” Makima chuckles softly, like she’s humoring a child. “The lighting is unpleasant. I can put in a request for changes. These facilities are… utilitarian.” “Yeah? Put in a request to let me out, too. Since you’re apparently miss connections.” Jolyne flicks the thread, and it whispers through the bar slot, an absent-minded cat’s tail testing the edge of a door. Makima tips her head, measuring everything in the cell in one glance, including the empty cot, the scuffed floor, the food tray abandoned under the bench. “You want out because you’re innocent,” she says, as if stating the obvious is charity. “Wow, you’re intuitive. You got a receipt for that, or you just say things?” Jolyne’s voice turns a shade rougher. “Since you’re name-dropping, what’s yours?” “Makima.” “Makima, huh.” Jolyne repeats it like she’s trying on a pair of handcuffs to see how easy they are to slip. “You with the prison? The government? Something with a big table and a room full of men pretending they matter?” Makima’s smile tightens, too slight to be insulted. “I’m with an organization that deals with unusual threats. Your Stand, Stone Free… it interests me. You turn yourself into string, but you remain yourself. Most people struggle not to come undone.” “And you always talk in riddles, or are you saving actual answers for a premium package?” Jolyne steps closer to the door. The flicker over them gives Makima strobing halos. Makima doesn’t move. She watches Jolyne with the easy stillness of a handler watching a leashed dog test how far the collar lets it run. “You’re interesting because you’re disciplined,” she says. “Stubborn. Loyal. If I released you, you’d run to your friends, your father, and you’d fight for them even if you died doing it. You’d be useful.” Jolyne smiles, thin and wolfish. “There it is. The pitch.” “I could arrange your freedom,” Makima says, not bothering to lie about it being difficult. “You would follow my orders in return.” And there’s the leash. Jolyne’s thread stiffens with a sound like a plucked harp string in a bad dream. She’s met people like this. Not many wear the face so perfectly; the ones who do always hold the knife close to their chest, smiling, waiting to see if you’ll bend. “It’s okay,” Makima adds gently. “You don’t need to decide immediately.” “Lady,” Jolyne says sweetly, “if there’s no Mickey, this shit ain’t Disney. Don’t sell me a fairy tale and think I’ll wag for a biscuit.” Makima laughs, delighted. “Oh, that’s good.” The corridor hums. Somewhere far away, a gate slams. The air shifts, a pressure difference like an elevator car moving. Jolyne angles her head. “What’s your thing, Makima? Besides being creepier than a tickle in a morgue. Do you make contracts? Sniff out weakness? Take people apart and wear them like jewelry?” Makima’s eyes soften as if Jolyne has just said something endearing. “I prefer dogs to jewelry.” Jolyne grins, daring her. “I bite.” “I know,” Makima murmurs. “That’s why I came in person.” The thread on Jolyne’s wrist flows forward, a pale line sliding through the bar slot, drifting in the air like a lazy serpent. It splits, tips fanning, mapping, tasting. The corridor is a geometry problem, and Jolyne solves it in a breath. Stone Free anchors threads to the ceiling, to the hinge of the cell door, to the drain grate, to the weight sensor under Makima’s right heel. It’s all very neat. Jolyne is neat when she fights. She learned to be. Makima glances down, not alarmed, only curious. “Will you restrain me, Jolyne?” “Trying to decide if you’re worth keeping still,” Jolyne says. “I could cut you, too. Or choke you.” The string tightens. “But you know what? I don’t get the vibe you’d care. I get the vibe that if I pulled hard enough, you’d smile at the blood.” Makima doesn’t deny it. She steps forward once. The strings bend like grass around a slow river. Jolyne feels the tension change, the way a fishing line whispers when something big touches it. She feels something else, too—the faintest pull on her mind, like a gentle hand smoothing her hair in the wrong direction. “You will be a good girl,” Makima says, soft. “You will—” Stone Free detonates into a thousand sharp threads that rattle the bars and scream against the corridor like the world is tearing a zipper. Jolyne’s eyes blaze. The threads knot crude words in the air between them: NO. “Wrong bitch,” Jolyne says, voice low. “Try that again, and I’ll turn you into confetti.” Makima blinks once, slow. The pull retreats, not offended. Patient. “It’s been a long time since anyone resisted even a suggestion.” Jolyne rubs at her temple with three fingers. The headache is sudden, like chewing tinfoil. “Yeah, well. I don’t do ‘heel.’ Try ‘sit’ and see if I fetch.” Makima takes one step back, and the pressure lightens. Her smile becomes less of a thing she wears and more of an expression. “You really are interesting.” The lights flicker again. One burns out with a faint pop, leaving a stripe of shadow that cuts across Makima’s face like a censor bar. Jolyne’s threads bristle in that darkness, alert. The corridor’s emptiness feels staged, like someone cleared it. “So what’s the real plan?” Jolyne asks. “Make me a pet? Use me to get to someone else? You’re not here just for me. No way.” “Observation first.” Makima’s voice is mild. “Then decisions. Do you know what happens to people who resist me?” “Let me guess,” Jolyne says. “You put them down. Because in your world, dogs are supposed to die for their owners, right?” Makima’s eyes brighten, as if Jolyne has quoted a poem back to the poet. “Exactly.” The thread behind Makima twitches. Jolyne anchors it to the lock, splits it into delicate filaments that feel for tumblers and pins like nimble fingers. The lock is not normal. It tastes like a contract, like something signed in someone else’s blood. Jolyne feels the pushback, the way her strings burrow into a mechanism that doesn’t want to be understood by string or touch or time. “Uh-huh,” she mutters. “Knew it wouldn’t be easy.” Makima watches her reach. She doesn’t move to stop her. The corridor is a chessboard, and Makima is content to see which piece Jolyne thinks she is. “You want me to break out,” Jolyne says, realization dropping like a coin in a jukebox. The song is old, and she knows the lyrics. “You want to see what I do when the walls go down. Who I run to. What I choose. Then you can tug the line.” Makima nods slightly. “I want to see who you love.” “Yeah?” Jolyne bares her teeth. “So you can use them. That’s your kink, right?” “Loyalty is a useful lever,” Makima says, unapologetic. Jolyne breathes, slow and sharp. She thinks of her father, silent and huge in her life like a mountain in fog. She thinks of friends with hands calloused by prison and grief. She thinks of not being able to save everyone, of saving anyone anyway. “Here’s a counteroffer,” Jolyne says. “I walk out. And you don’t follow.” Makima’s lashes lower, amused. “That’s not how this works.” Stone Free hisses through the lock again, threads splitting so fine they become vibration, hum, friction. The mechanism fights. Jolyne smiles at it like a stubborn child. “I’m good with things that don’t want to open.” “You’re very good,” Makima agrees. “But do you know why the other cells are empty?” Jolyne does a quick count of silence. No coughs. No muttered curses. No life. She glances sideways, and the shadow in her look is older than she is. “Because you moved them. Or erased them.” “Because I asked them to leave,” Makima says. “And they did.” The lock clicks, soft as a throat clearing. The door doesn’t swing; it waits. Jolyne’s threads hold it closed, trembling. She stares at Makima. Makima stares back, patient as inevitability. “Walk out, Jolyne,” Makima says, voice faintly kind. “Show me how far your string reaches.” Jolyne’s fingers flex. Threads run up and down her arms in tattooed patterns. She laughs once, hollow. “You really think I’m going to perform for you?” “I think you’ll do what you always do,” Makima says. “Fight.” Jolyne takes a step. The door opens a breath. Cool air slides in, smelling like rain that never comes. Her thread throws a loop over Makima’s wrist, loose, not enough to bind. A threat. A promise. A message she can yank if she needs to. Makima looks down at the loop like it’s a ribbon a child gave her. “Careful,” she says softly. “Tying a line to me ties a line to you.” Jolyne leans forward, close enough to feel the edge of Makima’s calm like a temperature, like a knife. “Good,” she says. “Then if you try to pull, you’ll find out I pull back.” Makima’s smile is serene. “I hope so.” The lights flicker like applause withheld. Jolyne steps out into the corridor, every sense up like a cat’s fur in winter. Threads splay in a network so fine it could catch the dust. Makima falls in step a pace behind, unhurried, as if walking a dog who has chosen her own route but still understands the leash exists. “You can walk,” Jolyne says without turning. “But if you try to talk to my head again, I’ll garrote that pretty voice right out of your throat.” Makima’s answer is polite. “I wouldn’t want to ruin our conversation.” They move through the corridor’s throat, past doors that gape like missing teeth. The facility murmurs with distant forces, the sigh of vents, the scrape of unseen boots, the faint rustle of paper being turned by no one. At the next intersection, Jolyne’s threads taste iron and something older than prisons. Makima’s presence behind her is the quiet of a hunter who has never once tripped on her own breath. “Tell me something true,” Jolyne says suddenly, not sure why she’s asking, only sure she needs to hear the sound of honesty in this place. “Just one thing.” Makima considers. “You will not like me more tomorrow.” Jolyne grins without humor. “I don’t like you now.” “And yet,” Makima says, and when the light flickers again, her eyes glow like coins offered to a river. “And yet what?” Jolyne asks. “And yet we’re walking the same way.” Jolyne glances at the loop on Makima’s wrist and tightens it a fraction, enough to make sure both of them feel it. Her voice is a blade wrapped in ribbon. “For now.” The prison breathes, and they breathe with it, two different predators under the same flickering light, each testing the length of the other’s string.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece effectively captures the confrontation between Jolyne Cujoh and Makima, creating a tense psychological battle that showcases both characters' abilities and personalities. The writer demonstrates a strong understanding of both source materials, incorporating key character traits, abilities, and even signature quotes from the prompt. The prose is atmospheric and taut, establishing the prison setting with sensory details that create a foreboding mood. The flickering lights serve as both literal setting elements and metaphorical punctuation for the power struggle between the characters. The writer skillfully uses imagery that feels appropriate to both anime universes while creating a cohesive style. Character portrayal is particularly strong. Jolyne's defiance, street-smart attitude, and crude language match her canonical personality, while Makima's false sweetness, manipulative nature, and view of humans as pets are all accurately represented. Their dialogue exchange feels authentic to both characters, with Jolyne's colorful expressions ("creepier than a tickle in a morgue") contrasting effectively with Makima's controlled, soft-spoken menace. The writer demonstrates technical skill in maintaining third-person present tense throughout, as requested. The pacing is well-controlled, with the tension building naturally through the confrontation and culminating in Jolyne's escape attempt, which Makima appears to have orchestrated. The story effectively shows rather than tells, using physical descriptions and actions to reveal character motivations and emotions. However, there are a few minor weaknesses. Some metaphors, while evocative, occasionally border on purple prose ("The corridor hums. Somewhere far away, a gate slams. The air shifts, a pressure difference like an elevator car moving."). The ending, while thematically appropriate, feels somewhat abrupt and unresolved, though this may be intentional given the word count constraint and the nature of the confrontation. The dialogue is generally strong, but a few exchanges feel slightly forced in service of showcasing character traits rather than advancing the narrative naturally. For instance, Makima's line "I prefer dogs to jewelry" feels a bit too on-the-nose as a reference to her character's known traits. Overall, this is an impressive piece that successfully merges two distinct fictional universes while maintaining the integrity of both characters. The writer creates genuine tension and intrigue through a battle of wills rather than physical combat, effectively capturing the psychological cat-and-mouse game that would likely occur between these two powerful, strong-willed characters. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 4 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 4.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Scp: Notes from the Future — Score: 83.8
Prompt:
Write an SCP report about a researcher who begins finding handwritten notes from their future self, warning about a containment breach that hasn't happened yet. The notes become increasingly desperate and incoherent, sometimes containing information that contradicts known reality. Include the Foundation's attempts to determine if this is an actual temporal anomaly or psychological manipulation by a contained entity, and the researcher's struggle to trust their own perception. First person (researcher's perspective with interspersed notes), past tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Item #: SCP-XXXX Object Class: Pending (Under Review: Euclid/Keter) Special Containment Procedures: SCP-XXXX is presently defined as a phenomenon localized to Dr. [REDACTED], hereafter “Subject.” Subject is to remain on Site-19 under psychological observation. All instances of Note-XXXX (handwritten notes allegedly authored by Subject’s future self) are to be immediately surrendered to Security and submitted to Temporal Anomalies Division (TAD) for analysis. A clean-room office environment (Office-XXXX) has been prepared for Subject with continuous audiovisual recording, sealed stationary supplies, and weekly inventory verification. Foundation memo pads in Office-XXXX are serialized, stored in transparent tamper-evident containers, and tracked by microdot-embedded fiber tagging. Subject is prohibited from bringing personal stationary into Office-XXXX. All memo paper throughout Site-19 has been cataloged and marked with covert isotopic tracers; any Note-XXXX instance not bearing site-authenticated tracers is to be flagged as anomalous. Subject is to undergo daily reality-check protocols, including cognitively anchored questionnaires (RAISA Form 11-T), baseline memory reconsolidation interviews, and Class-W mnestic challenges. No cognitohazardous entities are to be housed within two sublevels of Office-XXXX. Any major containment breach or drill must be followed by a Note-XXXX sweep. Pending determination, no temporal intervention (e.g., Prime-Event Preclusion, Project Butterfly) is authorized. Description: SCP-XXXX refers to the spontaneous appearance of handwritten notes in Subject’s immediate environment, all on Foundation-standard memo paper (Form F-19-M, 3” x 5”), reportedly written by Subject’s future self and predicting a future containment breach at Site-19. Instances escalate in frequency and emotional intensity and have contained contradictory information about Site personnel, floor plans, and containment protocols. I am the Subject. I served as a researcher on Thaumiel-labeled projects and currently consult for TAD. I will write this as a formal report, with my perspective, per Ethics Committee recommendation. Where relevant, I will interleave exact transcriptions of Note-XXXX instances verbatim. I found the first note on a Monday, underneath the keyboard in Office-XXXX. I do not store paper under my keyboard. Note-XXXX-01: If you read this, put the coffee down. Today at 14:32, there will be a false fire alarm. Don’t evacuate. Stay. You’ll want to leave. Don’t. At 14:31, the alarms sounded. My supervisor waved me toward the exit. I did not evacuate. Security later declared the event a sensor fault. No containment units registered anomalies. I showed the note to Security. They confiscated it and informed me that the memo stock bore Site-19 tracers and my fiber microdots. The handwriting matched my own under analysis, but with tremor artifacts I do not display. I had not written the note. I had not locked any stationary under the keyboard. The next day, a memo appeared taped to the inside of my glasses case. The case had been in my pocket. Note-XXXX-02: You didn’t leave. Good. Don’t drink from the south wing fountain. You were right about the copper taste. It’s not copper. I hadn’t mentioned the metallic taste to anyone. I avoid paranoia for breakfast, but I brought a sample to Chem Lab. Trace analysis found ion exchange resin fragments and elevated manganese. Nothing anomalous. TAD flagged the note as “low-grade predictive accuracy, plausible coincidence.” I began keeping the memo pad inventory under video lock. I watched it for three hours. I blinked. A note appeared on the top sheet. Note-XXXX-03: Stop watching the paper. It doesn’t help. You miss the important thing. The breach begins in Maintenance. It’s not Maintenance. It’s us. I asked for a transfer out of Office-XXXX. Denied. RAISA requested a daily written narrative to track my cognitive anchors. This is part of that. It’s important to say: the notes were always on Foundation memo paper. The watermark, the microdots—everything authenticated. I kept my memo pad locked. The notes still came from my own stock, even after I switched to a sealed, serialized pack that Security opened in front of me. They arrived between frames, between glances, at the hinge of a blink. I never caught the moment. Attempts to determine psychological manipulation versus temporal anomaly began within 72 hours. - Hypothesis A: Temporal leakage from a proximal event horizon (localized time loop, pre-breach echoes). - Hypothesis B: Cognitive infiltration by SCP-████ (Class-II reality-adjacent memetic parasite, contained two sublevels down). - Hypothesis C: Non-temporal thaumaturgic forgeries (spoofed tracers, replicated handwriting). - Hypothesis D: Stress-induced cryptomnesia (I write the notes and forget). To test Hypothesis D, Ethics authorized Class-W mnestic exposure. After mnestic dose, the next note arrived in the pocket of my lab coat, which had been sealed and logged. Note-XXXX-04: Mnestics won’t save you from yourself. Or me. Stop trying to remember what I couldn’t forget. The breach date moved because you looked for it. We can measure arrogance in nanometers, I suppose. Still, TAD loves a paradox. They ran a closed-time curve consistency test with a sealed box containing memo paper, a pen, and a high-speed camera. I volunteered to sit with the box. Hours passed. Nothing appeared. When I left to use the restroom, Security sealed the room. On returning, I opened the box. A note lay on top, written in my hand: Note-XXXX-05: You’re going to think this is confirmation. It’s not. The breach is not a breach. It’s a rehearsal you won’t be told about. You’ll screw it up if you stay here. Go to Sublevel 3 at 16:10. Don’t talk. Just count to 200. At 16:10 I went to Sublevel 3. I counted to 200 in the hallway, feeling idiotic. At 16:08, per logs, there was a silent drill among MTF guards I was not cleared to witness. At 16:12, a janitorial cart overturned near me, spilling solvents. I helped upright it. No anomalies occurred. TAD split. Half saw this as predictive validity. Half saw post-hoc pattern-making. I saw a reflected image of my own handwriting that knew I would need belief. The dissonance increased. Contradictions crept in. Note-XXXX-06: Director Halley lost her left eye in the breach. Remember the patch. Her right. It was the right. No. Both. Stop writing this down. You’re making it worse. Director Halley is fine. Both eyes intact. She plays racquetball on Wednesdays. I checked. Note-XXXX-07 arrived on my pillow at home. I live in on-site housing. My door locks are biometric and mechanical. Security found no tampering. Note-XXXX-07: They’re going to ask you to move the 914 key. Don’t. It’s already moved. It never existed. If you move it, the breach starts in Maintenance. In the walls. In the words. We do not store keys for SCP-914 at Site-19. That machine isn’t here. TAD marked this as contradiction-grade. I marked it as a fracture in either me or the phenomenon. My hands shook as I wrote the daily narrative. Psychological evaluation noted increased hypervigilance and derealization. I feared my own interiority, like a hallway with mirrors opposite each other, receding into infinity where I stand to watch myself watch myself. A control experiment placed a Foundation memo pad inside an extradimensional pocket (SCP-███-B) monitored by three separate recorders and a metronome. The metronome stopped at 03:17. The recorders glitched. When the system recovered, Note-XXXX-08 was present, written across four sheets: Note-XXXX-08: We thought shields would work. I thought compartmentalization would make it safe. But it isn’t a place. It’s intention. It’s the memo paper because that’s what we agree is “official.” If it can be official, it can be true. If it can be true, we can make it real. Stop authenticating the notes. We stopped authenticating the notes. RAISA reprimanded me for light sarcasm when I wrote that down. The “breach” became a specter at the periphery. We scheduled a site-wide breach drill and kept me isolated, to see if the notes anticipated the exercise. They did, in a fashion: Note-XXXX-09: It’s July 19. 02:40. You’ll hear the metal sound first, like a dentist’s tray dropped in an empty pool. Don’t move when you hear it. It’s not metal. Don’t run when the lights go yellow. The yellow is not for you. On July 19, at 02:42, the drill sirens triggered. The audible tone is not metal. There was no dentist tray. The lights are red, not yellow. I stayed still anyway. My heart made a noise I have never heard again. I keep thinking of the earliest note: Don’t evacuate. The false fire alarm. The echo of a future calm. Each new note eroded that calm. If this is a malign entity, it knows me intimately. If it is me, I am doing this to myself. TAD introduced a permutation: they replaced my memo pads with blank white slips without watermark or tracers. They told me the replacement, but not when. I woke to Note-XXXX-10 on my desk. Note-XXXX-10: You think you can trick yourself by removing the watermark? This isn’t paper. It’s a promise that we’ll take what is written seriously. They will too. So listen: The breach is a contagion of attention. Don’t write about it. I am writing about it. I am instructed to. I feel sick. On a Thursday I found two notes. One in my shoe. Note-XXXX-11: Scratch behind your right ear if you can read this. They’re watching. Good. Keep them watching. The not-breach starts when nobody looks. And one under my skin, in a lottery of gooseflesh as if raised by static, but later I found the paper tucked in my sleeve cuff. Maybe that was a hallucination. Note-XXXX-12: Halley is dead. She’s not. She will be. She will be the one who saves you. Don’t let her. You save her by not being there. Be late. Director Halley is alive. I have begun arriving late to everything. I suspect harm, causally, in either direction. Security cleared SCP-████’s ward for cognitohazard checks. That entity manipulates trust. Its lexical footprint doesn’t match the notes, and containment was uninterrupted. Another suspect, SCP-███-K, can induce predictive text illusions; it’s in Antarctica. Distance is not always prophylaxis, but patterns did not align. We affixed a simple test: write a note for the future and leave it where the future notes tend to appear. An invitation. I wrote: Control Note: Future me. Stop. The return came three hours later, slipped into my lab coat collar. Note-XXXX-13: If I could have, I would have. If you can, you must. Don’t look at the door at 03:15. It will be open and closed. You will be in and out. At 03:15, I did not look at the door. I stared at the corner of my desk until my eyes watered. When I finally looked, the door was closed, and the hall was empty. Security footage shows the door remained closed. The timestamp jumps. The jump is 23 milliseconds. Enough to nest a heartbeat. Morale is a brittle thing. They gave me a counselor who taught me grounding techniques. Texture of the desk. The smell of coffee. The sound of my own voice naming colors. I would catch a note in the act, and it would already be in my hand. Note-XXXX-14: Rough. Bitter. Blue. Your voice breaks on “green.” You make meaning of it because that’s what we do. Stop making meaning. Start making choices. Choose not to go to Sublevel 4 on the 23rd. The 23rd came. I did not go to Sublevel 4. On Sublevel 4, an electrical surge tripped breakers. No casualties. The surge was scheduled for maintenance. I want to be grateful to the me who warned me, if she exists. I want to be angry at the thing that lies to me, if it exists. The notes grew more frantic. Note-XXXX-15: It’s inside the paper. It’s inside the you that signs forms. Don’t sign the evacuation order. Don’t blink. Don’t breathe. It’s in breath. You cough and it knows. JUDGE THE SQUARES. FIRE IN THE WALLS. HALLEY’S EYES ARE COINS. The yellow is for them. The shift into word-salad suggests increasing stress, either in me or in the source. TAD calls it “conceptual noise.” The handwriting grew jagged. The paper remained Foundation memo paper, even when we swapped to decoy stock, even when I stored the real stock in a safe within a safe, numbered, logged, watched. Note-XXXX-16 appeared in a sealed specimen jar. Note-XXXX-16: You asked if this is manipulation or a temporal anomaly. Yes. If you believe me, I’m an anomaly. If you don’t, I’m manipulation. The breach is the argument we’re having with ourselves. We take a thing seriously enough and we build a protocol and a door to go with it. We taught the world to be formal. It listened. Stop. Stop writing the door. I have tried not to write the door. It is difficult to draft a report without building hinges. Addendum: Determination Protocols - Language analysis across Note-XXXX instances reveals a 0.83 correlation with my written syntax, increased pronoun contraction, and a shift toward imperative mood over time. The tremor amplitude corresponds with sleep deprivation metrics logged in my wearables. Self-fulfilling? Likely. - Tracer analysis: all Note-XXXX instances bear site-authenticated isotopic signatures and microdot fibers matching the memo pads I have access to, including lots I never opened. This indicates either prepositioning in supply chains, retrocausal tagging, or spoofing at fidelity that defeats current detection. - Temporal diagnostics: standard chronometric array shows no consistent metric deviation coinciding with note appearances. One 23 ms video jitter and two recorder dropouts are insufficient for classification. - Cognitohazard screening: no stable memetic signature across notes. No glyph replication. No semantic anchors of known entities. - Psychological evaluation: Subject exhibits stress response consistent with medium-term harassment by an uncertain signal. No psychosis markers. High suggestibility under threat, normal resilience otherwise. I am writing this and I would like to sleep. Conclusion: Undetermined. Provisional classification: Euclid. Ethics Committee Guidance: Limit Subject’s exposure to Note-XXXX by filtering messages through a small team. Do not feed the phenomenon by amplifying its authority. Maintain a record, but do not ritualize it. After I was told that, I found a note in the authorization binder, between “Maintain a record” and “do not ritualize it.” Note-XXXX-17: Ritual is a door. Record is a window. Sit with your back to both. Breathe. I’m sorry. There isn’t a breach. Or there is, and it’s so quiet you mistook it for thinking. If you must choose, choose to be wrong in person. I started coming in late. I started leaving early. I avoid the fountain. I sign my name slowly, as if handwriting itself is an incantation. When the alarms sound, I follow protocol, because we built protocols for a reason. I read the notes and then hand them over. I am trying to trust my perception long enough to let others test it. If this is manipulation, it is elegant and cruel. If it is me, it is a mercy from a worse me. The Foundation’s attempts have been thorough. Mine have been human. There was one more note, this morning. It was folded under my palm when I woke, on my skin but not attached, warm as if it had slept there with me. Note-XXXX-18: It didn’t happen. That’s the breach. It won’t, if you let it. Don’t look for the sound of metal. Drink the coffee. Evacuate when told. Trust not because I said so, but because you can. Trust is also a door. Pick the right one. I drank the coffee. At 09:00, there was a drill. I evacuated with everyone else. The lights were red. Director Halley smiled with both eyes. In the hallway, a janitorial cart squeaked its wheel. It sounded a little like metal, because everything does, if you’re listening for it. I will file this report now, and let it be a window, not a door. I will stop looking at the paper. And if a note appears under my keyboard when I look away, Security will take it, and TAD will test it, and I will drink my coffee and trust that not everything written in my hand must be true. Pending reclassification. Pending me. Pending the moment I blink.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This SCP report effectively captures the essence of the Foundation's clinical documentation style while weaving in a compelling first-person narrative about a researcher experiencing a potentially temporal anomaly. The piece successfully creates an atmosphere of mounting dread and uncertainty, as the researcher struggles to determine whether they are experiencing genuine warnings from their future self or manipulation by an unknown entity. The format adheres well to SCP conventions, beginning with containment procedures and a clinical description before transitioning to the researcher's personal account. The integration of the notes as evidence is particularly effective, showing a progression from relatively coherent warnings to increasingly desperate and incoherent messages that suggest either temporal degradation or psychological deterioration. The writing excels at maintaining ambiguity about the nature of the phenomenon. Is it truly a temporal anomaly, a psychological manipulation, or perhaps even the researcher's own deteriorating mental state? This uncertainty drives the narrative tension and reflects the researcher's own struggle with perception and reality. The prose is appropriately clinical when describing containment procedures but shifts to a more personal, increasingly anxious tone in the researcher's account. This tonal shift effectively conveys the character's growing distress while maintaining the Foundation's methodical approach to anomalies. The piece creates a sense of mounting dread through the escalating nature of the notes and the researcher's increasingly desperate attempts to make sense of them. The contradiction between notes adds to the unsettling quality, suggesting either temporal instability or deliberate manipulation. Where the piece could be stronger is in its resolution. While ambiguity is appropriate for an SCP report, the ending feels somewhat anticlimactic given the buildup. The final notes suggest a potential resolution (that perhaps there was no breach, or that the breach was something more conceptual), but this insight doesn't fully pay off the tension established throughout. Additionally, some of the notes become rather abstract and philosophical ("Ritual is a door. Record is a window."), which, while intriguing, occasionally verges on being too cryptic without sufficient grounding in concrete details. Overall, this is a strong SCP entry that effectively blends the clinical with the personal, creating a compelling narrative about perception, reality, and the nature of containment itself. It successfully captures the paranoia and uncertainty that would accompany such an experience while maintaining the Foundation's methodical approach to anomalous phenomena. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 16 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 17 Meandering: 4 Tell-Don't Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 3 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 16.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 17.0, Meandering: 4.0, Tell-Don't Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 3.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Scp: Unmarked Doors Archive — Score: 91.8
Prompt:
Write an SCP entry about a series of identical unmarked doors appearing in abandoned buildings worldwide that lead to a massive, architecturally impossible archive. Documents within reference a previous global civilization destroyed by an unspecified containment failure. Foundation researchers discover references to their own organization under a different name, including personnel files for current staff dated centuries ago. Include exploration logs revealing sections of the archive actively being removed by entities resembling hazmat teams who flee when approached, and evidence that O5 Council members have visited the archive without authorization. Third person (exploration team perspective) with recovered document excerpts. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Item #: SCP-7094 Object Class: Keter Special Containment Procedures: All reports of identical unmarked doors discovered within abandoned buildings, industrial ruins, failed infrastructure projects, and condemned municipal structures are to be immediately investigated by Foundation assets. Field personnel are to document all doors matching SCP-7094-A criteria and establish a two-block exclusion zone. Civilian access is to be prevented under cover of demolition, hazardous material abatement, or urban renewal projects. Standard portable perimeter beacons and internal anchor lines are to be placed prior to any entry. No more than two exploration teams (4 personnel each) may be inside SCP-7094 at any one time. Teams will carry tether lines of 1 km length, inertial trackers, and non-networked data capture equipment. Weapons are authorized only for disengagement; discharge within the archive is discouraged due to unknown load-bearing relationships of the environment. All collected documents are to be quarantined for infohazard review prior to transmission to Site Archives. Any reference to “Council,” “Curators,” or “Custodians” is to be redacted pending O5 review. Unmarked hazmat-appearing entities (designated SCP-7094-B) are not to be pursued beyond visual range; capture attempts are suspended following Incident 7094-Ω. Description: SCP-7094 is a global phenomenon consisting of a series of physically identical, unmarked wooden doors (SCP-7094-A) intermittently appearing in abandoned buildings worldwide. To date, ███ instances have been recorded on six continents. Each SCP-7094-A is of late 20th-century commercial manufacture, latch type mortise, with identical microscratches surrounding the doorknob forming a shallow, inverted crescent pattern consistent across all documented instances. No manufacturer marks or serials are present. X-ray imaging reveals internal components inconsistent with any single known standard. When opened, SCP-7094-A does not reveal the immediate interior of the hosting structure but instead provides access to a continuous, enclosed environment: a non-Euclidean archival complex of indeterminate size designated SCP-7094-Ω (“the Archive”). Internal geography includes corridors, stacks, mezzanines, scriptoriums, and vault chambers that cannot be reconciled with external dimensions. Bearings rotate unpredictably; gravity and horizon remain constant. The Archive contains shelves, cabinets, map cases, and paletized containers filled with a heterogeneous mixture of media: codices, vellum rolls, bound folios, microfilm, tab cards, magnetic tapes, optical media, and certain substrates not yet characterized. Cataloging systems present are inconsistent, employing scripts known and unknown. Numerous documents reference a prior global civilization with advanced anomalous and para-technological capacity that underwent a catastrophic failure of containment approximated as sudden and total. The entity or mechanism of failure is unspecified; references are euphemistic and redacted within the documents themselves. Of particular note are multiple references to an organization functionally congruent with the modern Foundation, here rendered in archival documents as “The Custodial Directorate,” “The Directorate,” or “The Foundation of Custody.” Documents include personnel records that map one-to-one with current Foundation staff, including living personnel, with accurate biometric and biographical details and photographs consistent with centuries-old capture media. Dates range from 300–700 years prior to present day. Cross-checks with personnel files confirm alarming fidelity. SCP-7094-B are mobile entities resembling hazmat teams (smooth, off-white positive-pressure suits; dark visors; no insignia) observed removing materials from the Archive and transporting them toward areas that terminate in occluded apertures or fogged bulkhead doors. SCP-7094-B avoid contact, do not vocalize, and retreat upon approach. On two occasions, SCP-7094-B displayed coordinated evasion and deployed occluding smoke that did not disperse under conventional air movement. Items removed by SCP-7094-B are not observed elsewhere in SCP-7094-Ω. Discovery: The first confirmed SCP-7094-A was discovered in a condemned tram depot in ███████, Latvia. Local urban explorers reported “a library door where a workshop door used to be,” accompanied by photographs of distinctive scratches around the knob. Agents dispatched entered the door and emerged with four vellum folios describing containment protocols for an entity class called “King-Swarm,” cross-referencing “Custodial Director O5-3.” Subsequent instances appeared in rapid succession in Detroit (USA), Campo Grande (Brazil), Newcastle upon Tyne (UK), and Tamanrasset (Algeria). All bore identical knob scratches. Addendum 7094-1: Exploration Logs (Excerpts) Exploration Alpha-3 Team: MTF Rho-10 (“Card Catalog”), 4 personnel. Lead: Lt. D. Varma. Entry Point: SCP-7094-A in a shuttered textile mill, Ghent, Belgium. Objectives: Reconnoiter adjacent stacks, recover catalog schema, avoid engagement with SCP-7094-B. [Begin Log] 00:00:16 – Entry achieved. Temperature 17°C. Ambient noise: distant ventilation, intermittent page rustle with no obvious source. Lighting: diffuse, ceiling-paneled. Architecture: Early-Modernist stacks suspended by tension trusses over voids of unknown depth. 00:07:31 – Team identifies first signage: carved wooden placard inset with brass. Script resembles German Fraktur with Cyrillic features. Translation incomplete: “…Department of Lost Cities (Annex A–J).” 00:11:05 – Sgt. Karanja retrieves a ledger. Pages foxed but intact. Ink stable. Notation: “Index of Post-Event Municipalities, Containment Lifted for Cause (Authorization: Custodian Council).” Cross-reference: “Curators: O5-1, O5-7, O5-9.” Note: “Council convened at Depth Blue; minutes sealed.” 00:15:22 – First encounter with SCP-7094-B. Two entities at end of aisle, loading folios into gray hard cases. Marked behavior: glance toward team, then immediate withdrawal down a side corridor, leaving one case. 00:17:48 – Case opened under quarantine protocol. Contents: personnel dossiers. Names: Dr. A. █████, Technician H. Molina, Researcher F. Okoye (currently assigned Site-19). Photographs on silvered plates dated 421 years prior to present; image fidelity high. Marginalia: “Transfer to Directorate Annex Seventeen upon ascendancy. Deny public death.” 00:19:02 – Lt. Varma orders partial retreat. Markings at junctions: numeric sequences that do not match inertial map. 00:28:40 – Team reaches a balcony overlooking a reading hall. Floor plan impossible: four identical staircases descending in parallel orientations that ought to intersect. A brass plaque bolted to the balustrade reads: “Archive 0: The Continuance of Memory. Admission by Writ of the O5 Council Only.” 00:29:10 – Lt. Varma: “Council? Our Council?” No response. 00:35:50 – Extraction via tether. One dossier carried out; remainder sealed. [End Log] Recovered Document Excerpts (Post Alpha-3) - “There was never a single breach, but one failure. All chambers opened in chorus. The Custodians had prepared a million keys and one lock, and it was the lock that failed. Let it be written so the next Directorate will not repeat the mercy that made us vulnerable.” — Folio 12, Archive 0. - “O5-3 objects to the term ‘Foundation’ for the Directorate’s new mandate, stating it invites recursion. O5-11 supports the poetic symmetry.” — Minute scrap, charred, legible margins only. Exploration Gamma-2 Team: MTF Psi-4 (“Stack Watchers”), 3 personnel. Lead: Cpt. H. Abassi. Entry Point: SCP-7094-A in a decommissioned air-raid shelter, Osaka, Japan. Objectives: Penetrate deeper vaults, track SCP-7094-B, retrieve catalog tags. [Begin Log] 00:05:12 – Team passes through a series of steel fire doors labeled “Deacidification Bay” and “Spores.” Air tastes alkaline. White dust on floor shows boot prints similar to Foundation standard, size variance suggests multiple groups over time. 00:12:44 – Contact with SCP-7094-B (four entities). They are pushing a wheeled cart loaded with sealed binders. When hailed, they deploy gray vapor. Thermal shows silhouettes retreating into side corridor whose walls bear fresh scrape marks. 00:13:30 – Cpt. Abassi orders pursuit. B turns down a ward labeled “Custodial Council – Restricted Proceedings.” 00:15:01 – Door ahead is shut by B. Surface: brass, handprints visible. Lock: six-disc assembly unknown to team. On the door, etched: “Council Summaries: Sealed by O5 Vote (Unanimous, 13/13).” 00:19:25 – Sgt. Takeda produces photos of a noticeboard adjacent to door. Paper notices pinned with iron nails. One reads: “Visitation Log: O5-4, O5-5, O5-8. No record in schedule. Admonishment delivered by Curator-Prime.” Ink wet. No time signature. Abassi remarks: “They’ve been here.” 00:24:40 – Audible movement behind walls. Shelving begins to retract into slots; a conveyor belt draws entire sections into an unseen recess. The corridor shortens in real time; floor markers move underfoot. Team withdraws. 00:32:50 – On exit route, the hallway formerly taken no longer exists. In its place, a thin gap behind a roller — evidently an interface where stacks are removed. A single paper rectangle remains wedged in the track: “Directive 0: Continuance. If the Directorate falls, memory must be made harder than time.” 00:46:20 – Extraction achieved with difficulty. One iron nail recovered for metallurgical analysis. [End Log] Recovered Document Excerpts (Post Gamma-2) - “We will abandon the public face. We will be names on paper, then names on film, then names encoded and salted. A city that forgets dies like an animal. We will be the city that never forgets.” — Preamble, Custodial Charter (Undated). - “Personnel: Abassi, Hadiyeh. Assignment: Director’s Runner, Archive Logistics. Note: ‘Remains noncompliant with inventory protocols. Promoted regardless.’ Date: Year 612.” — Dossier leaf with organizational crest resembling Foundation sigil inverted. Exploration Delta-5 Team: MTF Mu-9 (“Binders’ Sons”), 4 personnel. Lead: Dr. K. Delaney (attached researcher). Entry Point: SCP-7094-A in a collapsed municipal amphitheater, Córdoba, Argentina. Objectives: Deep dive into “Annex: Aftermath.” Confirm Council visitation. Document removal mechanics. [Begin Log] 00:02:10 – Entry. Ambient humidity rises. Walls clad in ceramic tile lettered with an unknown abjad. Shelves hold sealed clay envelopes with wax stoppers and bar-coded plastic bands; temporal inconsistency noted. 00:09:00 – Team encounters an observation platform. Below: vast carousel of stacks rotating slowly around a central shaft emitting cool light. At equidistant points, large square apertures open, and segments of shelving slide into darkness as if harvested. 00:11:45 – SCP-7094-B observed operating at two apertures. One entity notices the team and taps a wrist device. A chime sounds. Floor vibration increases. More shelving retracts. 00:15:22 – Dr. Delaney retrieves a clay envelope that resisted removal by B. Seal impression: two concentric circles, thirteen radial marks. 00:19:31 – Cpl. Ibarra shouts; points to a glass-walled office above the carousel. Inside: silhouettes of three individuals in business attire, posture consistent with observation. One raises a hand in a wave that could be interpreted as acknowledgment or warning. Office door marked: “O5 Oversight Gallery.” When approached, the office is found empty, dust intact; only a visitor’s card remains on a blotter reading: “Appointment: Custodian Council, Ad hoc. Attendees: 4, 5, 8.” 00:24:05 – Public address voice (nonlocalizable, neutral male): “Annex Aftermath is in motion. Please conclude your work.” SCP-7094-B close ranks and accelerate removal. Team captures a binder dropped in haste. On its spine, stamped: “Site-19: Decommissioned Artifacts.” 00:29:48 – Delaney attempts to access central shaft. Heat increase registered; Geiger counter mild elevation. Internal light modulates in a slow pulse. Sounds like distant ocean. 00:33:00 – Withdrawal initiated as floor plates shift toward apertures. Tethers remain taut. A B entity, cornered, makes a universal stop gesture and points emphatically at the exit route. No hostility. 00:40:22 – Extraction complete. Recovered materials sealed. [End Log] Recovered Document Excerpts (Post Delta-5) - Envelope contents: brittle vellum strip. Text: “O5-4, -5, -8 visited without writ. Curator-Prime notes: ‘They think memory obeys authority.’ Sanction: None. Remedy: Remove their footprints.” Ink analysis: iron gall, anomalously resistant to oxidation. - Site-19 binder, tab: “Decommissioned Object File: SCP-173. Decommission refused. Returned to Containment. Reason: Recurrence parameter exceeds archive capacity.” Handwritten marginalia: “Stop sending it here.” Incident 7094-Ω: Following Delta-5, Overseer liaison O5-█ instructed a halt to further exploration pending Council review. Within 72 hours, seven known SCP-7094-A instances spontaneously vanished, leaving only empty, unscarred jambs in the host structures. A remaining instance in a South African pump station was used for an unscheduled entry by an unknown three-person team matching Foundation professional profile but lacking transponders. Interior cameras show them bearing O5-level access badges. They entered the SCP-7094-Ω Oversight Gallery, stayed 11 minutes, then departed. No recovery of materials observed. Shortly thereafter, the pump station portal sealed; door reappeared as a standard, locked maintenance door. Scratches around the knob restored, but mirror-reversed. Notes: SATCOM later recovered a short-range transmission from within SCP-7094-Ω: “Memory does not belong to you.” Source unconfirmed. Addendum 7094-2: On the Scratches All SCP-7094-A doors display identical scraping around the doorknob: an inverted crescent roughly centered on the spindle axis, two millimeters deep at apex, feathering outward. Microscopy reveals minute scoring lines radiating from a common template; the pattern appears to be a negative-relief of a fingerprint spiral repeated at decreasing scales. Symbolically, this may constitute a key-signature or sigil. Analysis ongoing. Addendum 7094-3: Personnel Cross-References Of 1,382 personnel files recovered or imaged within SCP-7094-Ω, 407 correspond to current staff. Dates of birth, education, and postings match Foundation records with uncanny precision, except for dating offsets from 300 to 700 years prior. Several files include annotations predicting career moves that subsequently occurred after recovery. In one case, a file for Dr. H. Molina included the note “will suffer a left hand injury in year +2; assign to one-handed terminals,” preceding an accident by fourteen months. Ethics Committee Commentary: “We cannot treat this Archive as merely a resource. It is either our future recording our past or our past recording our future. In either case, theft is still theft.” O5 Note (Redacted): [Expunged in full.] Closing Statement: SCP-7094 continues to represent an existential and epistemic threat to the Foundation’s self-conception and operational security. Its contents suggest that a prior Custodial organization, whose structure mirrors our own, failed to prevent a total containment collapse but succeeded in encasing memory within an impossible architecture subsequently set to cull itself when approached unlawfully. Evidence that certain O5 Council members have visited SCP-7094-Ω without authorization is under active review. Hazmat-like entities continue to remove sections in ways that reduce exploratory access and erase physical traces of visitation. The Archive appears to remember who walks its halls — and to remove what it decides we should not see. Pending Council consensus, all non-critical explorations are suspended. The doors remain. The scratches are the same on every one.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This SCP entry is a remarkably well-executed piece that demonstrates a deep understanding of the SCP Foundation format while creating an intriguing and conceptually rich anomaly. The response crafts a compelling narrative about an impossible archive that contains records of a previous civilization and a previous iteration of the Foundation itself. The piece excels in its adherence to the SCP format, including containment procedures, description, exploration logs, and recovered document excerpts. The clinical tone is maintained throughout while still allowing for moments of existential dread and philosophical questioning that characterize the best SCP entries. The concept of the archive is particularly strong - an architecturally impossible space that contains records of a previous civilization destroyed by a containment breach, with the implication that history may be cyclical. The inclusion of personnel files matching current Foundation staff dated centuries ago creates an effective sense of uncanny dread. The hazmat teams removing sections of the archive add another layer of mystery and tension. The exploration logs are particularly well-executed, providing a sense of discovery and escalating mystery while maintaining believable character actions. The recovered document excerpts are concise yet evocative, hinting at larger mysteries without overexplaining. The prose is clinical when appropriate but allows for moments of evocative description. Phrases like "Memory does not belong to you" and "A city that forgets dies like an animal" are particularly effective in establishing the philosophical themes of the piece. The narrative builds effectively to the revelation that O5 Council members have been visiting the archive without authorization, creating internal tension within the Foundation itself. The closing statement effectively summarizes the existential threat posed by the archive while leaving enough mystery to maintain reader engagement. There are no significant weaknesses in the piece. It avoids purple prose, maintains a consistent tone, and creates a coherent narrative despite the complex concept. The characters, while not deeply developed (appropriate for an SCP entry), act in believable ways within the context of the Foundation universe. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 4 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 4.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Classic sci-fi: Offworlder (Le Guin) — Score: 88.0
Prompt:
Classic sci-fi: Offworlder (Author style: Le Guin) Write a chapter following a young diplomatic envoy sent to address tensions on a distant human colony where humanity has diverged into distinct subspecies through both natural adaptation and separation of lineages. Against protocol, the envoy slips away from official functions to walk the streets alone, encountering markets, ordinary citizens, and social structures that contradict the official briefings. Upon returning to their quarters, the envoy is reprimanded by Command, and is tasked with approaching the stationed Minister of Science (a political posting rather than scientific). A challenging conversation ensues, in which the envoy's wits and will are tested, by a seasoned political operator looking to test the mettle of the offworlder. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The first thing was the way the light did not belong to me. The station had the narrow, old windows of the early colonial period, set deep into stone that had been quarried from this hillside centuries ago. The light came in at an angle and came pale, and what it struck held more of it than I did. The carved lintels over the doorways were crowded with glyphs—spirals, blades, a bull with the moon between its horns, a woman whose hair was serpents. They had told us about the glyphs on the shuttle, but I hadn’t expected them to be so deft, or so patient. The stone curved like a knuckle around each little myth. “We are guests,” the Aide had said. “We are honored to be welcomed. We do not walk alone.” I walked alone. It was not bravery. It was an argument I could not win by speaking. When the speeches in the Hall of Assemblies had concluded, when the wine had been lifted three times to ancestral names and to the names of ships, when the Minister of Commerce had smiled and placed his hand on my sleeve as if it were a brooch, I slipped through a side door and down a stair, and let the air of the building cool my face. I told the guard in my best dialect that I needed air. He looked, not at me, but at my neck, at the V of skin unadorned, and did not stop me. The street broke open below with the sound of selling: a river with the different tongues of fish. On one side, the old stone, a whole cliff of it, pocked with niches and carved with those Earthly pictures—Athena’s owl, the fox that ate the sun in a story I remembered from my grandmother. On the other side, a row of stalls on wheels, made from thin metal, painted in colors that the dust had chastened. Between them, people moved like weather. I had been briefed. I knew that after Advancing Day, after the third generation, there had been a separation—not an official one at first, but gradual. The long-night uplanders lengthened and thinned, the joints of their hands a little more winged, their eyes widened against the dark. The river-country people thickened, shorter bones supporting wider feet, their hair growing fast and thick with oils that kept the mosquitoes at a distance. In the coastal towns, the gills were rumored, but the briefings insisted they were merely decorative folds, as useful as the rings in their ears. We’re all human, the briefing said; no one wanted to say more. Here, no one was saying much. They were talking to each other, bargaining in a manner that did not perform itself for me. A woman with high cheekbones and the sort of eyelids that shadowed her eyes even when she was fully awake laid a scatter of something like blue nuts into a basket. A boy with fingers so long that his knuckles had an extra knuckle looped his hand over a rack of dried skins. At the end of the stall a thin uplander girl took a coin between the crook of two fingers and held it up to the light, turned her mouth away to spit a husk from her teeth. “Forgive me,” I said, and the girl looked at me without moving her head. “For what?” she said. “For looking like a thief,” I said. “I mean—” I turned to the glyphs cut into the stone behind her, a boat riding up the peak of a wave, a man with oars and a lion’s tail. “Everything looks not how I was told it would look.” “Then your telling was wrong,” she said, and put the coin in a little iron box. “Or your eyes are wrong. Which is it?” “Likely both,” I said. “What do you call these?” I pointed at the blue nuts. They looked like stones gnawed by the sea. “Dry seaflower,” she said. “You eat them when the rains end. They make you sleep without dreams.” “And those?” A rack of braids hung like cured meats. “Wrist-warmers,” she said. “For uplanders when they come down. Their blood is too quick in them. You are not upland.” “No,” I said. “I’m offworld.” That word moved across her face and left nothing. “Farther than the desert?” she asked. “Farther,” I said. “Then why is your hair like theirs?” She nodded toward a middle-aged man whose hair had been braided with red thread. He had river-feet, wide and split almost, the toes spread. “My hair is like my mother’s,” I said. “She would like your dry seaflower. She dreams too much.” The girl shrugged. “Your mother is far. You cannot bring it to her. You will eat it and sleep alone.” Then she looked at me with interest that arrived abruptly. “What did they tell you, in the telling place?” “They told me you had gills,” I said, before I could weigh it. She opened her mouth very slightly and showed me the delicate scalloping at the back of her jaw. “I do,” she said. “For beauty. And for the river when it is cold. And for the men from the coast, who like to think I am something else. What are you, Offworlder? The same, and like a far cousin.” “I am a listener,” I said, because it was on my seal. “I am here to help.” She picked up a wrist-warmer and turned it so that the seam caught the light. It had been sewn with a thread that reflected green, like the bottom of a pool. “We help ourselves,” she said. “You can help by not buying badly. Those are not for you. They would make your blood too quick.” I bought a handful of dry seaflower. I bought a small strip of cloth with a glyph stitched into it—a crescent and a woman’s eyes, which, on Earth, had once been a goddess. The girl took my coins. When I turned again, two boys were running past me, their feet smacking, and behind them a man shouting, not angrily, but with the urgency of bread. Further down the street, a woman in an apron washed stone with a bowl—a gesture that made no sense until the light swung and I saw that she was painting the stone with a thin milk. The glyph under her hand became brighter as the milk sank into it. Her apron was stitched with the head of a bull and a labyrinth of lines that twisted and doubled back on themselves. “Why do you paint them?” I asked her. She smiled, and the smile had missing teeth. “So they remember us,” she said. “Not the other way around?” “You remember yourself every day,” she said. “You look at a spoon. You see your face. The stone is slow. It needs our help.” In that moment I was more angry than I had been in months, because in the briefing no one had said anything like this. We had lists of factions, and of trade imbalances, and of disputes over water rights in the upland swales. I had underlined “mutual suspicion regarding reproductive partnerships” and circled “Minister of Science (non-scientist).” There were bullet points. There were no spoons. When I came back into the station, and climbed the spiral stairs—each step worn down on its outer edge—I could hear the Aide’s voice and our Commander’s voice overlapping. The sky had tilted into evening, thinning to violet. The air smelled like the seaflower in my pocket, a chalky sweetness. “I went for a walk,” I said when I came into the room. “You went alone,” the Commander said. He was younger than the stone and older than me in the way that a man can make age a garment. “Against protocol.” “I did not disappear,” I said. “I went one street down. I bought something. I listened.” He did the thing with his mouth that is not quite a smile and not quite the keeping-in of a smile. “You listened when we were listening,” he said. “We would have let you speak in the Hall. The Minister of Science—” “Is a politician,” I said. “I know. I’m to keep my head. I’m to speak as if I have a head.” “You are to speak to him in an hour,” he said. “He is expecting you. He is in his office on the north side.” “Now?” I said. “You will go now,” the Aide said, like a hand pushing my shoulder without contact. “And you will remember that you speak for us.” “Do I?” I said. I meant it as a question. It came out as something else. The Commander’s eyes narrowed. The Aide’s mouth thinned. “You speak for us,” the Commander said. “Who else?” “For myself,” I said. “Sometimes.” He let that sit like a stone on a table. Then he nodded. “Do both,” he said. “If you can.” The Minister of Science—whose name was Malen, but whose title dragged behind him like a cloak—had his office at the end of a passage lined with niches. In each niche a little figure stood: a woman welding a spear, a goat stepping over a sleeping boy, a man whose head had been the head of a bird, though here the carver had made the bird a fish. The office door had a lintel carved with a gear and a cluster of grapes. The Minister liked to be called Doctor, though he had never worked a lab more complicated than the inside of a council chamber. He stood when I came in and came around the desk as if we were friends. “So this is the Offworlder,” he said, and took hold of both my hands with his. His palms were soft and dry. “And young. Commander sends me a child.” “Sir,” I said. “Minister.” “Doctor,” he said, and his smile sharpened. “You come to tell me what the stars think of us.” “We don’t have stars of our own to think with,” I said. “Just your sun, while I am here.” He laughed, and then he did not. He sat back, and his face changed. He was not tall. He had a wide waist. His hairline was even, like a line someone had drawn with a ruler. There was a ring on his thumb made of the same stone as the lintel. “You were seen,” he said, “walking the lower street alone.” I said nothing. “You are either brave, or foolish, or very sure of us,” he said. “Which is it?” “I wanted to see,” I said. “A street is a simple place to begin.” He put his hands together. They looked as if they had not done much hard work; he was clever enough to know that I had noticed. “And what did you see?” he said. “Be careful. I will know if you are telling me what you think I want to hear.” “I saw seaflower,” I said. “Blue nuts. Children who run with their toes spread to catch the stones. A woman painting milk on old stories so the old stories remember her. Wrist-warmers that would make my blood too quick. The fact that you like to be called Doctor.” He sat very still. Then he laughed again, but this time there was something like approval in it. “Ah. So you will not be easy,” he said. “Good. We have had too many easy people from your ships.” “I am not from a ship,” I said. “I am from a town that smells like kelp and diesel and old paper. The ships came later.” “You are trained,” he said. “They have told you about our divisions, about the water rights, about how the uplanders marry late and the river-folk young, and the coast-folk not at all sometimes, and about the children with the tidy lungs who can go from hill to river without the spinning sickness. They have told you that this is a problem.” “They have told me there is tension,” I said. “And what do you say?” “I say that the tension is not a problem,” I said. “It is a signal. It says the body is alive.” He watched me as if he could lean into my skull and read the glyphs there. “That sounds like a clever thing to say,” he said. “It also happens to be true,” I said. “I’m not here to solve you. I’m here to listen, and perhaps to suggest—to try not to make anything worse.” “You can always make things worse,” he said. “That is the easiest human skill.” “And always make them better,” I said. “Sometimes by not standing between people and what they already do for themselves.” He let out a long breath. “The Hall will want concessions,” he said. “Your Commander will want me to say that we will agree to the shared water charter without delaying three sessions while the uplanders fast and make proverbs. He will want a timeline. He will want a piece of paper to send to his superiors.” “I’m not my Commander,” I said. “I want to understand why your uplanders fast. What proverb comes from three sessions of hunger that does not come from one?” Malen’s face changed again. He settled back into himself, like a cat into a bowl. “You ask questions that have answers,” he said. “Most people ask questions that are invitations for a speech.” “So,” I said. “Tell me one of your answers.” He looked toward the window, where the light was becoming very thin. “When the uplanders fast for three sessions, they say the question descends from the head into the hands. On the first day, you are hungry in the mouth. On the second, you are hungry in the belly. On the third, you are hungry in the bones. If the question survives the bones, then it is a question worth answering. If not, it will die with the hunger.” “And will your water charter survive your bones?” I asked. He looked back at me. There was no smile now. “That,” he said, “is what you are here to help me know.” “I cannot make your uplanders’ bones decide,” I said. “But I can ask them to tell me how the question feels there.” He nodded, slow as the stone. “Do you know,” he said, “what the glyph over my fireplace says?” There was a small hearth with a low flame. Above it, a relief of a man with a hammer, a woman holding a spindle, a child with a bowl. “I don’t read your script,” I said. “Only your mouths.” “It says, in Earth-speech we have kept for when we want to be serious, Know thy measure,” he said. “Not yourself. Measure. The length of your stride. The strength of your hand in water. The reach of your saying. You have a short stride, Offworlder, because you are young. That may save us. Or it may break your ankle.” “I will mind the stairs,” I said, and for a moment he almost laughed. Then he stood up. “You will come to the Hall tomorrow,” he said. “You will sit and say nothing until I say your name. When you walk through the lower streets again, take someone with you who knows where the quick blood is. And do not buy wrist-warmers.” “I did not,” I said. He raised his thumb and showed me the stone ring. “You bought something else, though,” he said. “I can smell the seaflower. You will sleep without dreams tonight.” “Perhaps,” I said. “Do not make a habit of it,” he said. “We need your dreams. We need to know how the old stories look to someone who has not been painted with milk.” When I left his office the passage seemed longer, the little myths in their niches leaner. At the top of the stairs the Aide was waiting like the last step that has been worn away under your foot. “Well?” he said. “He will let me listen,” I said. “And test you,” the Aide said. “He is testing you already.” “So am I,” I said. I put my hand in my pocket and felt the dry seaflower, the hard smoothness of the nuts. In my mind the woman on the street lifted her bowl and poured milk over the stone, and the stone drank and knew us, not forever, but for today. I could not say if that was comfort, but it was a measure. I took it. I kept it, like a coin in an iron box.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response demonstrates a remarkable grasp of Le Guin's style, particularly her ability to blend anthropological observation with philosophical depth. The prose is measured and thoughtful, with a distinctive voice that maintains consistency throughout. The author has created a rich, textured world where humanity has diverged into subspecies, using subtle details rather than exposition to illustrate these differences. The protagonist's unauthorized excursion into the local market serves as an effective vehicle for worldbuilding. The descriptions of the market, its vendors, and the physical characteristics of the different human subspecies are vivid without being overwrought. The protagonist's interactions with the market girl reveal cultural differences and tensions without resorting to info-dumping. The meeting with the Minister of Science (Malen) is particularly well-executed. The dialogue feels authentic, with each character maintaining a distinct voice. The power dynamics and subtle testing between them create tension and reveal character. Malen's explanation of the uplanders' fasting ritual demonstrates how the author has thought deeply about the cultural practices of this world. However, there are some minor issues. While the prose is generally elegant, there are occasional moments where the metaphors become slightly strained or unclear. The narrative sometimes lingers too long on descriptive elements at the expense of advancing the plot. The protagonist's character, while thoughtfully rendered, could be more distinctly drawn - we learn more about their observational skills than their personal motivations or background. The ending feels somewhat abrupt, though it does circle back to imagery established earlier. The seaflower motif provides a satisfying thematic closure, but the narrative arc itself feels incomplete - more like a chapter from a larger work (which was the prompt) than a self-contained story. The piece excels at creating a sense of cultural difference without othering or exoticizing. The various human subspecies are portrayed with nuance and dignity, and the political tensions feel organic rather than contrived. The writing demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of how to use physical details to suggest cultural and political realities. Overall, this is a highly accomplished piece that captures Le Guin's anthropological sensibility and philosophical depth. It creates a complex, believable world and populates it with characters whose interactions reveal the underlying tensions and connections between different human groups. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 16 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 16.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Biopunk: Polymerase Chain Reaction — Score: 88.7
Prompt:
Biopunk -- Polymerase Chain Reaction Write a chapter set in a near-future post-apocalyptic world where corporate genetic engineering was designed with built-in obsolescence—engineered DNA lasting only one generation to maximize profits before societal collapse. Follow a biohacker working with salvaged equipment to splice viable food crops for their settlement using rapidly degrading genetic material. As world building / window dressing, include details about jury-rigged lab equipment, and the physical toll (and unexpected upsides) of using untested genetic modifications as medicine. The plot of this chapter is centred around a black market contract. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The first time the solar rig coughed, the thermocycler hiccuped and threw the whole lattice of A, T, C, and G into disarray. The second time, the voltage dipped low enough to turn the lab lights brown. By the third flicker, I had the habit: tap the inverter housing twice, curse once, and lean into the exhalation until the LED steadied. In my lap the salvaged cycler—two aluminum plates sandwiching a hacked heating element, scavenged from a dead coffee maker—hummed again. The little wheel of oil I’d set atop it sloshed, cracked the surface with the scent of burnt rosemary, and I made a note: replace the heat sink. We were all making notes. It was how we made a future. Corporate genetic lines had been made to die. Built-in sunset clauses; DNA that frayed like cheap rope at the ends of a generation; telomerase inhibitors folded into the seed’s metabolic code like a countdown. Heat and dust and time did the rest. Before the collapse, they called it controlled lifecycling. In the settlement we called it paying for air you’d already breathed. “You sure it’s good?” Sael asked, voice half swallowed by the surgical mask. He perched on a crate of ceramic resistors, tapping his nails on their cardboard. The movements were always jittery with him these days, the way life got when you’d had your immune system rewritten by something you synthesized in a jam jar and dosed at midnight because the fever wouldn’t break. I twitched my wrist and the cycler’s display—salvaged Kindle screen—scrolled a step chart. Forty cycles, ninety-five, fifty-eight, ninety-five, sixty-three. “As long as the panel doesn’t stall again,” I said. “I’ve tweaked the annealing temp. The primers will stick.” He laughed behind the mask, hollow. “That panel,” he said, “is trying to kill you.” Maybe. The panel rig struck out of the scrap dunes like a spine of broken ribs, a dozen mismatched sheets wired in parallel with copper gleaned off dead streetlights. I’d bolted it to the roof with bicycle spokes and hope. At dawn today, it had produced eight hundred watts. By noon, with dust in the air and the clouds a dirty silver, it was faking it at best. It was enough to keep the thermocycler and the fridge running. It was not enough for much else. On the bench, the gel rig glowed anemic blue. I’d spared no electricity for a transilluminator—just a shallow Pyrex lasagna pan filled with a solution of ethidium’s safe cousin and a homemade LED strip taped beneath, tied to a 9V battery. The comb was carved out of a hair pick. The lanes were crooked as a child’s teeth. “What is it this time?” Sael gestured at the pipette in my hand. The tip quivered, the drop clinging to its plastic mouth. “Kale with less attitude?” “Chickpea.” The drop fell, sank into the loading dye, and bloomed. “Iron uptake metatransporter. The old lines told the roots to ignore it after two harvests. I found a fragment of the unsubstituted gene in some pre-crash literature, but it’s in pieces, and the last two kilobases refuse to hold. I’ve designed a chimeric bridge.” I flashed a smile I didn’t feel. “It will be beautiful. And ugly.” “Like everything else,” he said, and the mask couldn’t hide the way he was grinning now. “Our kids are going to hate chickpeas.” “If I get it to stick, they’re going to have chickpeas,” I said. “Hate is a luxury.” The settlement’s medical tent was patched from billboard vinyl. It said LIVE BETTER, repeated as a mantra down the aisle. The crops we’d found in the municipal seed vault had sprouted and then turned feral—scrawny, brittle, bearing blossoms that were sterile in ways that were patent-protected. We had three fields of brown-green ghosts and one of tubers only rodents could love. The black market was all that was left for things not made to die: contraband germplasms, ancestral lines concealed in old coffee tins by grandmothers with foresight, rogue constructs spliced by lab rats who’d seen the crash coming and wanted to see us survive it. Someone knocked at the heavy-lidded door. Three taps, pause, two taps. Sael turned his head as though the noise itself would tell him who it was. I set down the pipette, breathed until the thermocycler held steady, and called, “Come.” A woman slid in, so tall she seemed to fold herself into the room. She wore a raincoat bleached by sun until it was the pale of a shark’s belly. Her hair had the ringlets of someone who’d once had money, or showers. Her eyes did a quick check: solar rig, improvised fume hood (a duct fan married to a aspirator bottle), the bucket of copper sulfate petals I used as a makeshift electrophoresis buffer when the store powders ran out. The pistol at her hip stayed where it was. “You’re the splicer,” she said. Not a question. “I’m the one who pretends to be,” I said. “Names are currency.” “I left mine at the door,” she said, and then she was in front of me with a black mushroom of polymer in hand: a cryo-pod cannibalized from a biotech’s cold chain, the logo scraped off but not gone. “You were recommended, Ara.” The name made me want to look over my shoulder, make sure there wasn’t another Ara, the one before the collapse, before the storm, before telemarketer drones got repurposed as crop dusters and then found their way into swarms. But there was only me. I took the pod. The surface was smooth, oily with the residue of fingers. A tiny LCD flickered just enough for me to make out low battery in a pixelated font. “I’m not cheap,” I said. “I’m not poor,” she answered. That erased a few possibilities, none of them comforting. “Open it.” The latch was the kind no blade would pry without a scar. I leaned the pod against the bench, set the tip of a soldering iron into the seam, whispered hello to the power grid in prayer. The iron was a castoff, its cord wrapped in electrical tape, its tip filed down and then re-tinned. It stammered to heat with the panel’s mood, but in a moment it bit the polymer, and the pod sighed open on a breath of wet, cold air. Inside, nested in a decapitated eppendorf rack, were two cryo-vials. Each had a serial etched in the plastic: GRAIN/10086/S.CERE. That last I knew as a reflex, like my own pulse. A yeast. Not any yeast. A S. cerevisiae line marketed once on glossy screens as Guardian—engineered to outcompete wild strains in souring dough and beer, with a switch for hydrogenase pathways that dried out in eighteen months, leaving bakers with crumb that fell apart in the hand. There had been lawsuits. They had died with the courts. “It’s spoiled,” I said, and then checked myself. The pellet inside the tube was beige. A little slumped. The screw cap’s O-ring had cracked. It might have seen the inside of a freezer yesterday, or six months ago. “Maybe. Where did you—” “Black Yard,” she said. “Babbage’s lot.” I cursed, softly. The Yard would sell you copper sheeting with the oxide polished off only on the top. They’d paint bolts silver and swear they were argon. They’d steal the occlusive from your arm while shaking your hand. “Why are you in my lab with this?” She pointed with her eyes to Sael. “He’s the reason.” Sael stiffened. “I don’t know you.” She laughed, and there was not much humor in it. “You don’t have to. You took my boy last winter when his lungs choked on ash. You gave him a mist from a bottle with a label scraped off. You told me it was engineered for pigs, but lungs are lungs.” I remembered now: a boy with eyes like lakes after rain, breath wheezing through ducts so narrow I could put my finger on his chest and feel them vibrate. The pig lung growth factor had re-opened his alveoli like hands unfurling. He’d coughed pink foam and then he’d breathed. He might be growing bristles at fifteen. Even my black humor didn’t want to imagine it. “He lived?” I asked. “He plays in dust storms,” she said. “I wanted to pay you back. But then I wanted to eat.” She gestured to the pod. “This is meant to be a bread base that doesn’t die. They say it’s been reworked from old lines, no obsolescence. Clean. I need you to tell me if it’s a lie.” “Even if it is,” I said, and lifted the vial, “I might be able to make it tell the truth.” The voltage stuttered. The LED display on the cycler blinked into a set of hieroglyphs that meant nothing to anyone but me: the coil opened, the triac shut down, power conserved, DNA saved. The upside of building your own lab was that its failures were yours, but so were its habits. I tapped twice, cursed once, reached for the inverter case and felt the heat lick my palm. I pulled back with a hiss. “You okay?” Sael asked. “I have three layers of callus there for a reason.” I smiled without teeth. “Let me see your boy’s yeast.” I swabbed my finger in ethanol—we’d lifted a drum of the stuff off a drowned pharmacy, and winced every time we burned it for light—and cracked the cap. A smell like the bottom of an old beer bottle hit my nose, sour-sweet. I made a streak on a makeshift agar plate: gelatin stiffened with potato flake and sugar. I set it in the warm zone near the cycler, where the heat bled off into an ambient thirty-seven. I marked the plate with grease pencil: G-Guardian, date. The lid was a repurposed plastic clamshell from a time when people bought salad in boxes. “What do you want for the test?” the woman asked. She had her hand on the pistol now, not menacing, more like she wanted something to hold that had weight. “Not money,” I said. “Don’t take that the wrong way. Your money will be good at Black Yard. It’s goobers up here. I want options.” “Options?” “Your source. Your routes. If this yeast is truly clean, I don’t want to buy it once. I want to buy ten times until I can learn it. If it’s a lie, I want to know who told it.” Her mouth drew down. “I don’t sell names.” “I sell food,” I said, pointedly. “A contract, then. Black market or not." Sael got off the resistor crate. “You don’t have any choice,” he told her, voice soft. “We don’t have any choice. If it’s clean, the settlement will pay you in iron nails and salt and labor for a starter that doesn’t quit. If it’s not, she’ll fix it, and then you’ll own a liability with a lesson.” Her eyes hardened. Then she nodded. “Half now,” she said, and slid a wrapped packet onto the bench. In it were two syringes and a vial. The glass held a liquid the color of old pennies. “Metformin derivative. They stole it off a container. The real stuff. Your pancreas is going to give up before your generator does.” Ice crept up the spine of my back. “I didn’t tell you—” “You didn’t have to,” she said. “Your hands shake when the panel dips. The tremor is worse mid-day. Your neighbor said you eat sugar packets like communion.” This was the toll. We used untested constructs because we had to; sometimes they made us better at healing in strange ways. My influenza didn’t last two days anymore after the adenoviral thing I brewed in a jar under a desk lamp. My blood clotting worked like a charm after I knocked a femur on a swing hinge. My teeth regrew enamel where a dentist would have said they couldn’t. But the endocrine tweaks had come with a price. My pancreas had taken one look at the metabolic modulators I’d used to keep Sael alive, and decided it was tired. “Metformin makes me foggy,” I said. “This is cleaner,” she said. “Or it’s not. That’s the world we live in.” I laughed, and it broke out of me like a broken test tube. “Fine,” I said, and then it was a deal. We shook hands. I noticed her nails were very clean; she noticed mine were crescents stained with silver nitrate. The gel rig buzzed. The blue light in the pan pulsed. I slid the loaded gel in. The anode was a chunk of graphite shaved off an old motor; the cathode was a strip of stainless steel rescued from a dead dishwasher. I clipped the battery, watched the dye climb the thick of agar like ants climbing honey. The voltage held, by some miracle, and the bands began to resolve out of the smear. Soon I’d tell the woman whether her yeast carried the obsolescence bomb. If it did, the motifs would be there: repeats like a chant, designed to fold in on themselves and self-immolate generation by generation. If it didn’t, I’d still be inclined not to trust it; trust was another luxury, like hating chickpeas. The plate with the yeast sat and sweated and, under the warmth, lifted tiny pearls of gas. It would grow or it wouldn’t. The cycler ticked through its cycles as I patched together chickpea iron transporters and the pieces of our future. Sael stood at the door and watched the light beyond dim, and then flicker, and then dim again. The panel wobbled. The world held its breath. My heartbeat synced to the inverter’s hum. “Hey,” the woman said, softly now, the pistol an anchor and not a threat. “Thank you, for my boy.” I didn’t tell her about the boars’ gene that rode his cells now, tucked in like a gift and a trap, expressing when it shouldn’t, sleeping when it should. I didn’t tell her the erosion of names freaking me out less than the erosion of functions in everything we touched. I didn’t tell her that my own mouth tasted like copper pennies and that the drug she’d brought me would make it taste like nothing at all. Instead I said: “Bring me more. Anything that isn’t built to die. We’ll make it live.” The panel coughed and the thermocycler’s LED blinked, and this time I didn’t tap or curse. I put my fingers on the housing and felt the little tickle of low-voltage, the way you feel a cat walk across a bed in the dark. I heard the settlement outside, the clatter of pots, the laughter that was defiance, the cough you could hear through three tents. I thought about bread that wouldn’t cave. I thought about chickpeas as fat as fists. I thought about kids hating them, and therefore alive. Our contract sat between us like a third person. The gel bands sliced into clarity. They told me a story I didn’t yet know how to read. “Let’s see what kind of lie this is,” I said, and smiled with all my teeth.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This biopunk chapter successfully creates a vivid post-apocalyptic world where genetic engineering's built-in obsolescence has devastated society. The author excels at world-building through technical details about jury-rigged lab equipment, creating an authentic scientific atmosphere while maintaining accessibility. The protagonist Ara is well-developed as a resourceful biohacker working with salvaged equipment. Their interactions with Sael and the unnamed woman reveal a complex character who balances scientific pragmatism with genuine care for the settlement. The physical toll of genetic modifications is effectively shown through Ara's pancreatic issues and the references to Sael's immune system modifications and the woman's son who received pig lung growth factor. The prose is technically strong, with scientific terminology woven naturally into the narrative without overwhelming the reader. Descriptions like "the panel rig struck out of the scrap dunes like a spine of broken ribs" create powerful imagery that enhances the setting. The author effectively uses sensory details throughout, from the "burnt rosemary" scent to the "sour-sweet" smell of the yeast. The black market contract that drives the plot is well-integrated, creating tension and revealing character motivations. The woman's arrival with the potentially valuable yeast strain creates a meaningful conflict that ties directly to the settlement's survival needs. However, there are a few minor issues. Some of the scientific explanations, while generally accessible, occasionally become dense enough that they might momentarily disengage readers unfamiliar with genetics. The dialogue, while generally strong, occasionally becomes slightly expositional. The ending, while thematically appropriate, feels somewhat abrupt - we don't get resolution on whether the yeast is viable or not, though this may be intentional to create suspense for a subsequent chapter. The piece excels at creating a morally complex world where survival necessitates risk and compromise. The relationship between scientific advancement and human cost is thoughtfully explored, particularly through Ara's reflections on the modifications they've made to others and themselves. Overall, this is an impressive piece of biopunk fiction that successfully balances scientific detail with human drama, creating a compelling narrative about survival and adaptation in a genetically compromised world. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 4 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 4.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Iteration 3 — Avg Score: 89.8
+ Classic sci-fi: The Azra Gambit — Score: 90.0
Prompt:
Classic sci-fi (Author style: Asimov) The Azra Gambit Colonial mars is being mined by corporations who take leases on indentured labourers. The thing they are mining is Azra, a recently discovered exotic metal which accelerates radioactive decay to such a rate that it is greatly sought after for interstellar drives and weapons alike. This has created both a gold rush and an arms race as various interests vie for control and endeavour to unlock Azra's secrets. The story follows Arthur Neegan, a first generation settler and mining engineer. Upon discovering that his unassuming plot sits atop an immense Azra vein, he is subjected to a flurry of interest and scrutiny. Write the next chapter in this story, in which an armed retinue descends on Arthur's home and politely but forcefully invites him to a meeting with some unknown party off-world. The insignia look like that of the Antares diplomatic corp -- diplomatic in name only. Arthur finds himself in the centre of a political tug of war. The chapter involves a meeting with this unknown party, who makes Arthur an offer. The scene should be primarily dialogue, interspersed with vivid description & scene setting. It should sow hints of the larger intrigue, stakes & dangers. Include Asimov's trademark big-and-small-picture world building and retrofuturistic classic scifi vibe. The chapter begins with Arthur aboard the transfer vessel, wondering just what he's gotten involved in. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Arthur kept adjusting his collar, unused to the formal attire he had been instructed to wear. The fabric had a synthetic sheen that tugged uncomfortably at his neck as the transfer vessel purred around him with the precise, anesthetic thrum of military-grade reactionless drives. The Antares insignia—three concentric stars embracing an arrow—glinted on every bulkhead fixture and shoulder patch. Diplomatic Corps, he had been told, in the way one is told that a scalpel is a spoon. He ran a thumb along the edge of his cuff and studied the viewport. Mars fell away like a rusting coin, its wafer-thin atmosphere a smear at the rim. Beyond it, the tether-spined ring of the orbital network stitched light into emptiness. The cabin door whispered, and two attendants in grey-black with clipped hair and the dispassionate posture of good furniture stepped in. Their holstered pistols curved like accents. One of them inclined his head enough to qualify as polite. “Mr. Neegan,” he said. “We’ll be docking in five. If you’ll come with us.” Arthur stood, the collar resisting him like a moral principle. “You could just tell me where I’m going.” “You are going to a meeting,” said the other. “As requested.” “As compelled,” Arthur said. “Words,” the first replied, with such blandness that Arthur had to admire it. They guided him down a corridor that smelled faintly of ozone and old plastic. The vessel had the deliberate cleanliness of something that contained secrets whose protection budget outran anyone’s imagination. They reached a hatch that recognized a palm and slid apart: a lounge with a view like a cut jewel. In the center stood a table that was trying very hard to be humble. Facing the planet, in a chair that placed her in silhouette, sat a woman whose posture was supremely relaxed without being careless. She wore a suit the colour of wet slate, no insignia. A small pin, however—an abstract spiral—sat at her lapel. “Mr. Neegan,” she said, without turning. “Please sit.” Arthur took the seat opposite. He found that the chair had anticipated his height. The two attendants became part of the walls, as if they earlier had simply been temporarily separated from them. The woman glanced at him then, and her face resolved into planes of middle-aged poise. Her hair was cut short in a way that suggested both discipline and emergency practicality. Her eyes were unremarkable, which is a remark in itself. “You’ve had a week,” she said. “I apologize. Sudden ascents are rarely dignified.” “I’ve had less than a week,” Arthur said. “Three days ago I lived in a prefab with a faulty heater coil and a kitchen that sang when the wind hit the door. Now I’m on a vessel with no corners.” He adjusted his collar again. “Who are you?” She smiled, not with surprise. “My name is Cestine Varro. I represent an interested party not formally affiliated with any of the corporations currently leasing Martian extraction rights. Nor with the Antares Diplomatic Corps, though their insignia has its uses.” Arthur let his gaze flick to the attendants’ shoulders. “Borrowed livery,” Cestine said. “Antares likes to believe they control impressions. We purchased this one for the hour. Will you drink?” The table noticed the question and extruded two glasses with a sound like small rain. The liquid was colourless and claimed to be water. Arthur ignored it. “You found an Azra vein,” Cestine said. She looked back out at Mars, which had settled into a dignified distance, touched by sunlight that did not expect thanks. “And not merely a vein. A body. It sits under old lava, like a hesitating heart.” “You know a great deal about my property,” Arthur said carefully. “Property,” she said, tasting the word. “Yes. The land grant was issued to you as a first-generation settler. After two harvest cycles, the land and subsoil rights revert to the colony administration unless a productive economic use is declared. You declared. That declaration was, shall we say, amplified. The administrative network is a sieve. We selected which holes to widen.” “Selected?” “To attract attention. The right kind, and not too much of the wrong. You were going to be noticed anyway. We arranged a map of attention that would favor this conversation.” “What kind of party are you?” Arthur asked. “Unknown.” “A coalition of conservationists and strategists,” Cestine said. “Which, I admit, sounds like a paradox. It is not. Azra speeds decay, Mr. Neegan. The universe has a timetable. We are in the business of ensuring that no one moves the clocks too far forward.” Arthur folded his hands on the table. They were too clean. The last four years he’d measured worth in how dust settled into the knuckles. “You want to stop the mining.” “We want to control it,” Cestine said. “Stop is a fantasy. Azra is a lever on entropy. Once the picture of the lever exists, someone will pull it.” She tapped the pin at her lapel. The spiral wasn’t a spiral; it was a stylized decay chain, the child and grandchild nuclides simplified to art. He felt a small chill—the kind you feel in the spinal metaphor of your backbone, when a story becomes more precise than comfort recommends. “You know what it does,” he said. “I have devoted twelve years to knowing enough to fear it,” she said. “There have already been tests. Spurts of funding in obscure journals. Anomalies scrubbed from reactor logs. Antares ships docked near prospector stations where the radiation counters like to sing lullabies.” “And the corporations?” “They are enthusiastic,” she said. “Enthusiasm is the polite cousin of hunger.” Arthur watched her watching Mars. “You didn’t bring me here to philosophize about clocks.” “No,” she agreed. “I brought you here to offer you a contract.” She slid a wafer across the table. He did not touch it. The wafer shimmered with microscopic script, layered like a palimpsest of legality. He had seen such things in the colony offices when the lease agents smiled with their entire dental history. “You retain title to your land and subsurface rights,” Cestine said. “You declare exclusive development under a new classification: controlled catalytic resource. You will then lease extraction rights to a consortium we have organized. The terms: a guaranteed dividend, equipment sufficient to remove the overburden to a safe standby level, scientific oversight we provide, and a cap—a hard cap—on extracted Azra per quarter. An off-world escrow holds the title in trust. No one moves equipment without three keys, one of them yours.” “And in return?” Arthur said. “In return you swear to a patience most men cannot afford. You will become unpopular. You will be accused of sabotage, greed, treason to your species’ manifest destiny. You will be offered money at numbers you did not know had names. You will refuse. And you will call us before you call anyone else when the ground quivers in a new voice.” He picked up the wafer and held it to the light. Sections of the text infiltrated his vision: terms of art, vacuum-hard clauses, contingency strategies for sabotage, clauses that contemplated planetary injunctions. “And if I say no?” “The Antares Corps,” Cestine said, with no malice, “will arrest you on suspicion of illicit materials trafficking. They will find Azra cores in your freight. They will have planted them with care. You will be held, then released, then held again. In the meantime, interim receivers will declare your claim common. The corporations will begin their work with a legal smile.” Arthur let the wafer sit. He thought of the fault map that he had made in pencil, because pencil was proof against power failures. He thought of the vein that gave his instruments a headache, a lump of reluctant miracle. “You said you arranged attention,” he said. “Why me? There are other veins. Other miners.” “Because you are dull,” Cestine said. She held his gaze as his expression hardened. “Do not take offense. Dullness is virtue. You have no debt beyond the mainline loan. You have no family obligations beyond a sister who has not spoken to you since the civil registry argued about her surname. You did not enlist in the Belt wars. You did not play cards you could not count. You are a man whose calendar has blank squares. That makes you rare and useful.” “And if I were more interesting?” Arthur asked dryly. “We would not be here. Interesting men are full of levers too easily acquired by other hands.” He considered the window. Earth was a pale thought somewhere in the dark. Mars turned with the implacability of old machines. He remembered his cabin’s heater coil, which he had coaxed with a screwdriver and a curse. He remembered the smell of his own sweat under the dust when the wind laid down and sound carried. A man with blank squares. It was not flattering, but it had been true. “You said you’re not Antares,” he said. “And yet they escorted me.” “Antares is not a person,” Cestine said. “It is a set of overlapping ambitions held together by semaphore and habit. Parts of it dislike parts of it intensely. The part that brought you here owes us a favor and hopes to embarrass another part later. This is how things are done when no one wants to say so out loud.” “And the consortium?” Arthur asked. “Who’s in it?” “Universities that still believe in peer review,” Cestine said. “Insurance underwriters who truly understand catastrophic risk curves. A small nation-state without space capacity but with excellent mathematicians. An offshoot of a faith that thinks the universe should be allowed to age as intended. A few miners who know that fast money can be a solvent.” “You romanticize,” Arthur said. “I inventory,” Cestine said. “The romance belongs to those who want to fly sabers into stars.” He found that he was breathing more slowly. The chair had adjusted his posture; the ship had dialed down its hum. He wondered what else they had dialed. “You didn’t mention weapons,” he said. “I did not need to,” Cestine said. “Azra will turn weapons into policy the way a fire turns a map into air. It will make blockades obsolete and fortresses into suggestions. It will let an angry provincial administer vengeance to a planet. The arms manufacturers need no salesmen when an element does their job for them.” “I’m an engineer,” Arthur said. “I know what you’re saying. I also know that every cap invites a pry bar. How do you expect to hold the cap?” “By making the pry bar costly to wield,” Cestine said. “By making the story of restraint more compelling than the story of conquest. By embedding reactors with failsafes that turn Azra on Azra if tampered with.” She smiled faintly. “And if those fail, by applying the kind of pressure polite people call diplomacy.” He thought about the attendants’ pistols, the curve of their holsters like commas. There was grammar to this. “You will not be alone,” Cestine said. “I do not mean that in the comfortable sense. I mean it as a logistical statement. We intend to place observers in your operation. Two, perhaps three. They will be polite. They will be unwelcome. They will be very difficult to remove.” “So, a leash.” “A harness,” Cestine said. “You can pull against it, and we can pull with you, and the horse has some say about where the cart goes.” He surprised himself by laughing. It came out like a cough. “Do you ride?” “I count,” she said. “Numbers behave like horses when you have their trust.” Arthur let the wafer rest against his palm again. He had once thought of wealth as something that came in shipments, in the respectable clink of credit. It was now a weightless thing that occupied the air around the table, making conversation cautious. He could not pretend he would not like to be wealthy. He could not pretend that wealth arrived without neighbors. “What happens to me if I sign?” he asked. “Beyond the unpopularity.” “You will have to hire,” Cestine said. “Not the indenture contracts the corporations like. Real contracts. You will become an employer of free men and women and at least one person who declines a binary. You will live under a dome we will upgrade to withstand explosive decompression. You will have a legal team you will never meet. You will learn words you hoped to avoid. You will go to bed often with the feeling that you have forgotten to lock something essential.” “And if I do not sign,” Arthur said, “you already told me what happens.” She inclined her head. “It is clumsy to threaten a man and then ask him to trust you. Yet here we are.” The ship shifted; somewhere, docking clamps performed their small ballet. Mars slid a fraction. Arthur studied Cestine. The absence of insignia, the quiet spiral. He thought of the first day he had set foot on his land, when the wind attempted to remove his nose and the sky had the colour of careful blood. He had not come to Mars for romance. He had come because the Earth had too many people who wanted to tell him how to be interesting. “Why is it called Azra?” he asked suddenly. She blinked. “Naming rights fell to an astronomer whose daughter had that name,” she said. “The daughter drowned on a world with more water than wisdom. He chose to put her name on something that would not dissolve.” “That’s a myth,” Arthur said. “All names are,” Cestine said. “Will you sign?” He put the wafer down. He did not touch the stylus. “I will agree to a preliminary,” he said slowly. “You will send me your scientists. I will send you my maps. We will set a cap. We will test each other’s patience before we promise forever.” Her shoulders relaxed by a millimeter. It was the most honest gesture she had made. “A preliminary,” she said. “Very well. That is already more than most men would offer in a room with this view.” She rose. He stood. The attendants detached from the walls and became men again. “One more thing,” Cestine said, and now her voice held something that could nearly be warmth. “Hide the heater coil from the inspectors. It is against regulation.” He stared. “You’ve been in my home?” “We have been within it,” she said. “Glass walls are fashionable in this century. We prefer to look through them only when necessary.” He did not ask what necessary meant. They walked him to the hatch. The door opened onto a short corridor and the mouth of a docking tunnel. Through its oval he saw a station module with an Antares crest and the polite bustle of people paid to look like background. “Mr. Neegan,” Cestine said. “In the next days, you will be approached by an Antares official named Pelk and by a representative of the Rittmann Consortium who will offer to buy your soul and lease your shadow. You will find their arguments sensible. You will find ours exhausting. Remember that exhaustion does not make sense wrong.” “And if I get tired enough to forget?” Arthur asked. “You will call me,” she said. “The number is in the wafer, under the clause about dispute resolution. It will look like a footnote. It is not.” He stepped into the tunnel. The pressure differential sighed. He adjusted his collar again, and it yielded this time, just enough. He did not look back until he was halfway across, and then only because a man counts his steps when he knows that the ground ahead has learned his name. Cestine was watching him. She lifted a hand, a wave or a signal; he could not tell. Behind her, Mars turned, and beyond that, the patient dark did not care who set the clocks. But men did, and their care could burn a world or save it a little time. Arthur walked on. The pistols, the spiral pin, the wafer that weighed nothing—these lodged in his thoughts like pebbles in a boot. He did not yet know if he would limber or limp. He did know that when he got home, he would check the coil, and then he would bury, with care and in a place only the wind knew, a small sample in an unremarkable box, because dull men take precautions even against their allies. At the end of the tunnel, a man in an Antares sash smiled with all his teeth and extended a hand. “Mr. Neegan,” he said. “Pelk. So glad you could make time. I believe we can help each other avoid unnecessary delays.” Arthur took the hand and felt the tug of war tighten, invisible and absolute. He smiled back, because the universe did not move its own clocks, and someone had to watch them.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response is a remarkably accomplished piece of science fiction that captures Asimov's style while maintaining its own distinct voice. The author has created a tense, dialogue-driven chapter that effectively builds the world of colonial Mars and the political intrigue surrounding Azra. The prose demonstrates exceptional control, with vivid descriptions that establish setting without overwhelming the narrative. The description of Mars as "a rusting coin, its wafer-thin atmosphere a smear at the rim" efficiently conveys both the physical reality and emotional distance. The writing maintains a retrofuturistic feel appropriate to classic sci-fi, with technology that feels both advanced and slightly analog. The dialogue between Arthur and Cestine forms the backbone of the chapter, revealing character, plot, and worldbuilding simultaneously. Their conversation has the measured, slightly formal quality characteristic of Asimov, while maintaining natural rhythm. The power dynamic is clearly established through subtle cues in their interaction. Character development is handled with restraint. Arthur is portrayed as practical, cautious, and principled—a believable protagonist for this scenario. Cestine is enigmatic but three-dimensional, with motivations that extend beyond simple villainy or heroism. The description of Arthur as "dull" is particularly effective, reframing an apparent insult as a valuable trait in a world of competing interests. The worldbuilding excels at Asimov's trademark balance between immediate concerns and larger implications. The political landscape is sketched efficiently through references to corporations, the Antares Diplomatic Corps, and various factions within the consortium. The nature of Azra and its potential consequences are explained without excessive exposition. The chapter successfully plants seeds of the larger intrigue. The competing interests in Azra, the potential for weapons development, and the surveillance of Arthur's home all create tension and raise the stakes. The ending with Pelk's appearance perfectly sets up the next phase of conflict. There are a few moments where the prose becomes slightly overwrought ("the universe has a timetable"), but these are rare and generally fit the philosophical tone of classic sci-fi. The pacing is excellent, with the conversation building naturally to Arthur's decision. Overall, this is an exceptional response that fulfills all requirements of the prompt while creating a compelling narrative with depth and nuance. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Contemporary romance: Darkroom Revelations — Score: 90.7
Prompt:
Darkroom Revelations Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of Dani, a 25-year-old assertive art student known for her bold style and take-charge attitude in relationships. For the past semester, she's been quietly fascinated by Elliot (he/him), a 19-year-old boy in her experimental photography class. Dani has been intrigued by his unconventional masculinity: killer thrift-shop-nu-goth style, soft demeanour and quiet intellect. When they're paired for a final project requiring late nights in the darkroom, Elliot tentatively shares that he's been questioning his gender identity and expression. Set during one of these intimate darkroom sessions where the red light creates a confessional atmosphere. Explore Dani's complex attraction—her usual assertiveness complicated by her desire to protect Elliot's vulnerability, her excitement at witnessing his self-discovery, and her confusion about what this means for her own identity as someone typically attracted to more defined gender presentations. The narrative should capture the tender awkwardness of their conversations, Dani's internal struggle between taking charge and wanting to give Elliot agency, and the unexpected chemistry that develops as both find themselves in uncharted territory. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The red light traps time the way a snow globe traps a winter. Every dust mote is a planet; each drip from the faucet marks a century. The trays are shallow constellations, moons of developer and fixer, our prints floating like secrets just revealing themselves. Elliot’s breath fogs in the cold of the room and makes me wonder if the images can sense us, if the silver halides know we’re both different people in here. His hands are steady in a way mine aren’t. I love that he’s precise, the way his fingers move through the tongs like he’s playing an instrument he grew up with. He’s careful. I am not. I am a fireworks display by comparison: abrupt and bright, all teeth and certainty and the clatter of brass bangles. Even in the thin red light, my rings flare when I gesture. He watches them for a beat, like he’s memorizing a language he doesn’t fully speak. “It’s like they’re underwater until they decide to breathe,” he says, leaning over the tray. The print is just starting to appear—our shot of the back staircase, the way the rails cut the light into squares that look like a fallen chessboard. “More like they’re mid-transformation,” I say, because I can’t resist an argument, a reframe. “We’re coaxing them. Making choices for them.” He smiles and I feel something in me list toward him like a ship caught by a minor current. He’s wearing a thrifted shirt, pearl snaps dulled with age, the kind of thing that shouldn’t look goth at all but somehow does on him, paired with a belt that has a silver buckle shaped like a bat. His eyes catch the red and go mulberry-dark. He smells like old books, developer, and winter air. “You always want to call it a choice,” he says. “I’m not sure it is.” “Everything is a choice,” I say, reflexively militant, and want to roll my eyes at myself. I’ve made a persona out of choosing; out of being the one who goes first. Girls in my cohort admire and fear the same quality in me. Professors too. Dated people who thanked me for taking the lead like I was granting them a favor. It’s a good costume most days: leather jacket, clipped hair, the right eyeliner, the loudest laugh. Me, as a decision. Elliot’s not a costume. He’s a pair of boots worn in weird places, a book with marginalia in someone else’s handwriting. I’ve been watching him all semester without letting my gaze be obvious about it. He’s the kid who brought in xeroxed zines of Foucault and zipties for our sculpture project. He never volunteers unless called on, but when he talks, it’s like he’s picking a lock in front of the class. The print deepens. I use the tongs to flip it and he flinches like I almost touched him. The room hums with the fan above us, the slow pulse of the timer beeping in intervals. My phone vibrates, a small mosquito buzz deep in my back pocket, then again, insistent. People want things from me. They always do. I ignore it, almost ceremonially. If I take it out, I’ll split myself into Dani-who-answers and Dani-who-watches, and right now I want to be the latter. “I’ve been thinking about our concept statement,” he says, gaze fixed on the paper’s milky surface. “Like, about liminal spaces.” I hum. We picked the concept because it sounded academic without being dead. Doors ajar, mirrors half covered, stairwells between floors, hallways to nowhere. In my head it was also about us, and how we are both a little bit thresholds, though I’d never say that and ruin it. “I’ve been thinking…” He stops. I watch his throat shift when he swallows. I want to reach for it without touching, to say go on, to place my palm near his sternum and promise I won’t push. He sets the tongs down with a click that sounds louder than it should. “God, this is going to sound like I’m making it about me. I know the deadline. I know we have to print and mat and whatever. But the thing I’ve been thinking about…” He breathes like he’s bracing for a wave that might not stop. “I’ve been thinking that I might not be a ‘he,’ or I might be a ‘he’ differently. Some days I look in the mirror and the pronouns slide around like oil on water, and other days I feel like my reflection is a lie I agreed to tell.” I keep very still. The developer smells like pennies and the past. He doesn’t look at me. The print in the tray darkens into itself, a staircase that knows it leads somewhere. “I don’t know if I’m allowed to say that,” he says quickly. “Or if that makes sense. I’m not trying to be special. It’s just… it’s been getting louder. And I put on the clothes and I feel half right. I paint my nails and I feel more right. I bind sometimes. Or I want to. And then I think I’m performing. Like I’m making a collage out of somebody else’s images instead of taking the picture myself.” He laughs a small, brittle laugh. His hands are on the edge of the sink, knuckles pale. “Sorry.” There’s a version of me that would fill the room with advice and action. There’s an impulse to produce a to-do list: names of clinics, pronoun pins, Instagram accounts, a list of books and binders and how to tape safely. I have those things. My friends are a compendium of experiments. My body leans forward, wanting to fix, to lead, to wrap my certainty around him like a coat. But the red light makes a church out of this place and me a parishioner instead of a preacher. The fan hum becomes a choir, the water a liturgy. I make myself count to five before I say anything. It hurts, the restraint. It stings like a chemical splash that hasn’t yet been washed off. “What would feel good to hear right now?” I ask, and it’s so unlike my default that I have to chew on the words before they go out. He looks up, startled, then relieved. “I don’t know. Maybe just… that it’s not nothing? That I’m not being dramatic?” “It’s not nothing,” I say. “You’re not being dramatic.” I let my voice go low, the persuasive register I use when convincing donors to fund student shows. “You’re allowed to be figuring it out. You don’t have to land.” He nods, once, and his shoulders drop like they’ve been carrying a rolled-up map that’s finally set on the table. In the tray, the staircase is fully formed now. It’s more interesting than I thought it would be—there’s a blur of movement at the edge where my sleeve accidentally got into frame, a smear that looks almost like a person slipping between frames. Elliot lifts the print with the tongs and moves it to the stop bath. The little hiss when it meets the chemicals is unbearably intimate. “I worry that I’m… fake,” he says. “That wanting to be softer, or different, or to try a dress sometimes—like, what if that’s just an aesthetic and not a self? You know? I don’t want to be a tourist.” I can’t help it. I reach out and put my hand over his on the edge of the sink. Not guiding. Just neighboring. His skin is colder than mine; he flinches, then doesn’t pull away. “You’re the only person who can call you real,” I say. “But from where I’m standing, nothing about you feels tourist.” He looks at our hands. The red light makes us look like we’re both made of pomegranate. I swallow. Here’s the confession I didn’t know I’d be making in this room: “I like—the way you are. I mean, I’ve been trying to categorize you so I could know what to do with my crush, and I can’t. And it’s made me—uncomfortable.” The word tastes like daring. “I’m used to women with knives in their smiles or boys who come wrapped in their own definitions. You’re… a door that keeps opening.” He blinks, then laughs, a real one this time, soft and stunned. “A door that keeps opening?” “Don’t let me workshop metaphors out loud,” I say, embarrassed and amused at once. “Point is, I’m attracted to you. And I don’t know what that means for me either, exactly. Which is both annoying and—it’s also kind of exciting.” “Yeah,” he says. He doesn’t pull his hand away, and the relief that rushes through me is embarrassing in its size. “It’s… I’m glad you said that. I’ve been—trying not to be weird. You scare me a little.” “Good,” I say, too fast, reflex bristling, and then catch myself. “I mean, okay. Also not good. I don’t want to scare you. I just—” I grope for a softer word and find one I don’t usually admit I own. “I want to take care of this. Of you.” He looks at me then, straight, and for a second the world shifts its weight. “What does taking care mean, for you?” “Usually? Making decisions. Setting the pace. Carrying the bag. Color-coding the calendar.” I hear the list’s edge and wince. “But also listening. And not deciding for you.” His mouth curves. It does something to my ribs. “I could be into parts of that.” “I thought you might,” I say, and then my phone buzzes again: a little tap-tap against bone. I ignore it, feeling the ghost of the screen the way you feel a missing tooth with your tongue. There will be messages, little landmines of expectation. I’m not picking them up right now. We move through the prints. He manages the times like a monastic liturgy; I handle the exposure test strips with my habitual impatience, wanting to skip steps and leap to the conclusion. The safe light paints us as if we’re already in a photograph, and I catch myself wondering how we look like this to someone else—to an instructor walking by, to the ghosts of former students, to the future versions of us who might or might not remember. “Do you want me to try different pronouns for you?” I ask later, while we’re hanging the prints on the line with wooden clothespins that make little dull clicks. “Here? Or with just us? Or not at all?” He inhales. “Maybe… you could try they, sometimes? See how it feels? Or… if you want, you could pick one and surprise me.” “That is a lot of power to hand me,” I say, teasing, and not. “I know.” He meets my eyes. “I trust you.” There it is—the place where I’m tempted to surge forward and plant a flag. Instead I slow down. I consider the little word he offered me and how it could tuck into my mouth. “Okay,” I say. “They.” I test it lightly, set it in the air between us like a piece of folded paper boat on black water. “Do you want to pass me that clothespin? They’re right behind you.” They nod. The relief in their face is not subtle, and it makes my throat tight. I want to kiss it. Not them. It. The relief, the softness. The plant that’s finally turning toward the window. “I didn’t think it would feel that different,” they say, voice dazed. “It feels… like warm.” “Good,” I say. I sound hoarse. We stand there, students of our own language, letting it rearrange our bones. It occurs to me that I don’t have to classify my desire before I act on it; that I don’t have to know what it makes me to know what I want. But I also don’t want to be the storm that knocks over their sapling. My urgency meets an equal, gentler force, and they lean into each other until it’s a balance. “Can I—” I begin, and stop. I aim for honesty, not performance. “Can I hold your hand?” They look at my hand like it’s a print developing in front of them. “Yeah,” they say. “Please.” I take their hand with the same care they took the tongs, the way you lift something you plan not to own but to admire. Their fingers are slender, ringless. My thumb finds the soft web between thumb and forefinger, an anchor. The heat exchanges. It’s electric and quiet at once. We stand like that in the red, as the prints drip and set and the room does its chemical magic. The fan thrums. The faucet whispers. My phone buzzes a third time, small and far away now, like a world I may go back to later. I can be decisive about that, at least. I can decide to stay here where the silver salts decide to become image, where a person can pick a pronoun like a lens and try it on and the perspective shifts. “Dani?” they say, soft. “Yeah?” “Thank you,” they say. “For not—taking it out of my hands.” I squeeze their fingers. “You’re welcome,” I say. “You can ask me to take more, if you want. Later. When you want.” “Okay,” they say. The word settles into our intertwined palms. We clip the last print and make a note of our times and exposures and paper grades with a pencil that leaves gray snow behind it. When we turn off the safelight, the room goes absolute for a second, a heavy velvet. Then the fluorescent flickers on outside, harsh and throat-clearing. We blink, separate our hands, and I feel the absence like a picture taken from a wall. “We’ll come back tomorrow,” I say, as if tomorrow is neutral. It suddenly isn’t. It’s a place with a door that keeps opening. They smile, half shy, half certain. “Yeah,” they say. “Tomorrow.” We push through the heavy darkroom door and into the hallway, a liminal space if there ever was one, and for once I don’t rush to fill it with my stride. I match theirs. The prints are behind us, hanging like a series of possible futures, quietly becoming themselves.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures Dani's perspective as she navigates her attraction to Elliot during their darkroom session. The piece excels in creating a distinctive voice for Dani—assertive yet vulnerable as she confronts her own preconceptions about attraction and identity. The darkroom setting functions brilliantly as both physical space and metaphor, with the developing photographs paralleling the characters' evolving understanding of themselves. The prose demonstrates considerable craft, particularly in its sensory details and metaphors. The opening paragraph's comparison of the darkroom to a snow globe immediately establishes the intimate, suspended-in-time quality of the setting. The writer skillfully employs imagery related to photography and development throughout, maintaining thematic coherence. Character development is nuanced and believable. Dani's internal struggle between her usual take-charge attitude and her desire to give Elliot space feels authentic. Her self-awareness about her tendency to "fill the room with advice and action" and her conscious effort to restrain this impulse shows meaningful character growth. Elliot's vulnerability in sharing their gender questioning is portrayed with sensitivity and complexity. The dialogue serves the narrative effectively, revealing character and advancing the relationship. Exchanges like "What would feel good to hear right now?" demonstrate Dani's growth, while Elliot's confession about feeling "fake" reveals their insecurities. The conversation flows naturally and avoids exposition dumps. The piece handles the theme of gender identity exploration with subtlety. Rather than presenting simplistic answers, it portrays the questioning process as ongoing and personal. The metaphor of Elliot as "a door that keeps opening" is particularly effective, if slightly overwrought. There are moments where the prose becomes slightly purple, with metaphors occasionally stacked too densely. Lines like "The red light makes a church out of this place and me a parishioner instead of a preacher" work beautifully in isolation but can feel excessive when combined with similar figurative language throughout. The narrative maintains excellent pacing, with the physical task of developing photographs providing structure while the emotional revelations unfold. The ending strikes an appropriate balance—hopeful without being unrealistically resolved, acknowledging that both characters are at the beginning of something rather than its conclusion. Overall, this is a sophisticated piece that successfully fulfills the prompt's requirements while creating a distinctive atmosphere and complex characters. The writing demonstrates considerable skill in balancing internal reflection with external action, and in using setting as an extension of the characters' emotional states. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Contemporary romance / drama: Stolen Moments in Roma — Score: 92.8
Prompt:
Contemporary Romance / Drama: Stolen Moments in Roma. Write a series of interconnected short scenes and dialogues that span a single day in modern-day Rome, in narrative form. This will form the beginning of a larger story. Alessandra, a fiery, independent Roman woman who works as a motorcycle courier, nearly collides with Ben, a somewhat clumsy, overly polite British academic on sabbatical, who is engrossed in a guidebook near the Trevi Fountain. The initial encounter is a clash of cultures and personalities – Alessandra is all sharp wit and rapid-fire Italian, while Ben is flustered apologies and awkward attempts at speaking the language. However, as they sort out the near-miss, a spark of unexpected humor and connection emerges. Alessandra, it quickly becomes clear, is a whirlwind of energy and mischief. She's a self-admitted troublemaker with a secret penchant for kleptomania, a detail she doesn't explicitly reveal, but which manifests in subtle, daring acts throughout the day. She impulsively decides to take Ben on a wild, unsanctioned tour of Rome, dragging him in some specific instances far outside his comfort zone. Ben, despite his initial apprehension and inherent politeness, finds himself utterly captivated by Alessandra's unapologetic spirit and zest for life. He is drawn into her orbit, a willing participant in increasingly outlandish situations, a quiet rebellion brewing beneath his scholarly exterior. The narrative should primarily consist of short, vivid scenes and dialogue exchanges, revealing their contrasting personalities and backgrounds, and the growing, ambiguous tension between them. Ben is captivated by Alessandra's energy and the thrill of breaking free from his routine. There's a clear sense that Alessandra is toying with Ben, pushing his boundaries and enjoying his reactions, but her own feelings remain somewhat enigmatic. The day should be a rollercoaster of exhilarating, slightly dangerous, and humorous moments, leaving Ben completely disoriented but utterly smitten. Explore the underlying tension & chemistry between them, culminating in some payoff as they part ways (or not -- your choice). Include this detail: Write in narrative prose, using immersive storytelling. 1000 words.
Model Output:
He doesn’t notice the scooter until the wind of it licks his calves and the horn rips across the piazza like a curse. The guidebook leaps from Ben’s hands, pages yawning like startled gulls. The Vespa skids, a sharp S on ancient cobblestone, halts with its nose inches from a municipal trash bin. Time resumes. Shouts rise around the Trevi Fountain—tourists with their phones, vendors hawking bottled water, a couple arguing in rapid Portuguese. “Guardi!” she barks, snapping off the helmet. Her hair pours out, black and impatient. “Che fai, professorino? Leggi mentre cammini? Vuoi morire sotto le ruote?” “I—sorry—mi dispiace,” Ben stammers. He bends to grab the guidebook, knocks it with his elbow, watches it skate under a German family’s stroller. “I wasn’t—looking.” “No kidding, Sherlock,” she says in English, rolling her eyes. Then she laughs, a precise, ringing sound that says she’d rather have the story than the peace. “You’re fine. I didn’t kill you. Yet.” He straightens. She’s shorter than he expected but seems taller, all kinetic lines and impatient eyebrows. He registers a leather jacket scuffed pale at the elbows, a messenger bag strapped crosswise like a sash. There’s a sticker on the Vespa that reads: CHE PAURA? “I’m terribly sorry,” Ben says, British apology falling from him on instinct. He tries Italian again. “Io... sono... un idiota.” Her mouth curves. “Finalmente, verità.” She claps him on the shoulder. “I’m Alessandra. Courier. Occasional life-saver. And you?” “Ben,” he says, clearing his throat. He’s felt ridiculous since arriving in Rome, and now feels newly minted in it. He reaches for the guidebook again. She gets it first, with a fast, easy bend, and hands it back without a flourish. Her fingers brush his. She has ink stains on her thumb, a crescent of midnight. “Ben,” she repeats, tasting it, making it sound less tinny. “Ben. Okay.” She tilts her head. “You owe me a coffee for almost becoming a hood ornament.” “That seems... fair.” “Good. Get on.” He blinks. “On... your scooter?” She’s already pulling her helmet back on, handing him another from the hook. It’s a gaudy thing, pink with glitter, probably a joke at someone’s expense. “Unless you prefer to stay here, marry your book, and get pickpocketed.” “I—no, I—” He looks at the fountain, luminous even at midday, at the crowd, at the thought of getting on a stranger’s scooter in a foreign city. At the line of her grin. “Right. Okay. Why not.” “Ecco,” she says, pleased. “You say ‘why not’ like a man who has said ‘why yes’ only to footnotes.” He flushes, tries to adjust the helmet, which squeaks and sits a little crooked. She reaches up without asking and straightens it, a swift tug that brings her face too close to his. He can smell pepper and petrol, and something sweet that might be soap. Her eyes flick over his and away, assessing. “Hold on,” she says, and when he hesitates—where?—she grabs his hands and plants them at her waist. “Not too much. I’m not your mother. Or maybe I am. We’ll see.” He laughs, scandalized, and they take off. Rome peels open like an orange under her driving. She weaves through taxis that honk as if it’s a national anthem, past a tour bus with a cartoon Caesar on its side. Ben tries to keep his knees from knocking into cars, tries not to shout apologies at people they almost clip. Alessandra is humming cavalierly, cutting left, cutting right, laughing once when a policeman eyes them and then looks away. “What were you reading?” she calls back over her shoulder. “Um. About Bernini.” “Ah. The curly one.” She makes a loose, twirling motion with one hand. “Saints in ecstasy. People lose their minds.” He swallows. “You know art?” “I know tourists,” she says. “Also the city pays me to carry things through traffic without dying, so we are all specialists here.” They pull up outside a bar with a narrow countertop crowded with elbows. She orders them caffè with a charm that plucks smiles from men and women alike, and Ben fumbles with coins that seem to multiply in his palms. “Here,” Alessandra says softly, and plucks a coin from behind his ear. He startles; she grins. “Your lucky euro.” He blinks. There is no coin behind his ear. And there is one in her palm, then between her fingers, then in the saucer by the caffè like it had always been there. He’s halfway through deciding whether it was a trick when he sees her hand dart—quick as a thought—toward the small stand of toothpick flags at the register. One disappears. She tucks it behind her ear and pretends not to have done it. The barista laughs as if she’s told a joke he didn’t catch. They drink standing up. The coffee is a small miracle—hot, dark, the bitter slide of it cutting through his jet-lagged fog. Alessandra watches him over the rim of her cup, interested the way a cat is interested in a moth. “So,” she says. “Ben. What did we almost kill? A historian? A librarian?” “A... lecturer.” He clears his throat. “Oxford. On sabbatical.” “Of course,” she says, as if this explains everything about his posture, his careful hair, his shoes. “You study love, beauty, death?” “Seventeenth-century Rome,” he admits. “Baroque architecture.” She tips her head. “So you came to the right place to get your heart broken.” He laughs, surprised by the way it comes out of him without apology. Alessandra smiles, a softer thing that doesn’t stay long. They’re back on the scooter and then not. A narrow street. Laundry like flags above them, a grandma yelling from a fifth-floor balcony, two boys kicking a ball that ricochets off a shrine to the Madonna with a blue bulb. Alessandra stops without throwing down the stand and leaves the scooter leaning precariously. She pulls Ben by the sleeve to a tiny, dark doorway where a man is slicing porchetta into bread as if cutting through argument. “Eat,” she commands. “You can pay me back in footnotes.” He takes a bite and makes a sound he didn’t expect to make in public. She hears it and laughs again. He watches her watching him and feels the ground under him shift, as if the city were balancing a little differently. When she’s looking away—at a dog with a red bandana—her fingers are busy again. A postcard slips from a rack into her messenger bag, just a fold of movement, the way you might brush hair from your face. Ben’s eyes widen. He is sure he did not see that. He is also sure he did. “Your bag,” he says lightly, polite even in his caution. “It seems quite... accommodative.” “Everyone in Rome steals,” she says airily. “Time. Space. Parking spots. Kisses.” “I—don’t,” he says, because he doesn’t know what else to say. “You will,” she counters. “By dinner I’ll have you stealing hours from your boring future.” He should argue. He eats instead. They rejoin traffic like a slapstick routine. A taxi cuts them off. Alessandra responds with a fluid insult that even Ben can tell is anatomically inventive. The taxi driver grins. Rome is a conversation that sometimes pretends to be an argument. At the Pantheon, she refuses to let him shuffle inward with the herd. Instead she pulls him around the side to a crack in time—an iron gate ajar, a courtyard that smells like damp stone and oranges. They stand beneath the round eye of the oculus, rain beginning as a murmur up there and then, a minute later, fat drops that find them as if they’ve been individually addressed. “Run,” she says, and they do, laughing, out through the shadows, across the piazza, as the sky decides to open with the sudden, theatrical certainty of a stage curtain ripping. Tourists squeal. Vendors swear. A waiter, with salute and flourish, whisks tablecloths like sails. Alessandra grabs his wrist and tugs him toward a sodium-yellow awning stretched over a gelato shop, crowded already with damp strangers. “Perfetto,” she says, shaking rain from her hair like a dog. “A storm. The universe is bored.” They press in under the awning. The cold sweetness of the shop breathes out at them. Children line along the glass, their noses fogging the panes. Ben can see pistachio like a field, a dark river of stracciatella. His shirt clings to his back. Alessandra’s jacket gleams darker, her eyelashes jeweled with drops. He watches one bead travel down her jaw like a decision. “Which?” she asks. “No, wait. Don’t think. First word.” “Pistachio,” he says, surprised by the clarity of the choice. She nods as if he has passed a test, and orders without looking at the board, in a stream of Italian that makes the teenager scoop generously. When the cups come, she’s already palming an extra napkin dispenser and then not—the kind of thing no one misses, because the universe replaces napkins like it replaces breath. Ben notices and pretends not to. They stand close, cheeks cold from the gelato, shoulders warm from proximity, rain drumming above them in a steady, intimate rhythm. A couple argues nearby in hissed Italian that even Ben, with his textbook phrases, can read—jealousy, a watch, a lie about where. Somewhere, a man plays a melancholy accordion under the deluge, a soundtrack for their shelter. “I can’t feel my feet,” Ben says. “But I can feel my mouth. Is that a Roman thing?” Alessandra’s smile is quick. “In Rome we keep the important parts awake.” He wants to ask what parts those are. He doesn’t. They watch the street become a river, the scooters crowding like dark fish under every overhang, the tourists huddled. They share a spoon between the cups, an inevitable intimacy. When she hands it to him, her fingers touch his knuckles, lingering half a second longer than necessary. He looks up; she looks away; a decision is asked and not yet made. “You’re dangerous,” he says softly, because if the day is a confession, let it be this. “Si,” she says, just as softly. “But I’ve kept you alive for, what, three hours?” “Three?” He glances at his watch and realizes it’s somehow six in the evening. The rain has stolen whole blocks of time. “How did—” She taps his watch face. “Thief,” she says, and makes it a joke. He laughs because the alternative would be to say something that would require the rest of the day to agree. The rain thins to threads, then to a fine mist. They step back out into a city rinsed and gleaming. The asphalt shines like obsidian. The sky is the color of a fading bruise. Alessandra kicks the Vespa into life and the city flares around them like a match. On a hill that lifts them toward the clouds—Aventine? Janiculum? He’s lost—she stops at a terrace with a view that explains why artists have been unbearable about Rome for centuries. A ribbon of river. Domes like shoulders in a bath. The air washed clean, the bells finding each other and ringing as if sharing news. She sits on the low wall and offers him a cigarette. He hesitates. She snorts. “Of course not,” she says, and lights it herself, dragging in smoke, eyes half-lidded. He wants to be her vice. He wants to be her reprieve. “Why me?” he asks, before he can convince himself not to. She exhales toward the city. “Because you almost died prettily,” she says. “Because you look like you haven’t said yes in years. Because your shoes are a joke.” He looks at his shoes, soaked and earnest. He thinks she’s lying a little, and also telling him something true. She reaches into her bag, pulls out a small thing, offers it to him. It’s the postcard he had not noticed disappear—the Pantheon at dusk, a painterly version with a sky like wine. On the back, she has already scrawled: Non pensare. Chiama. A Roman number, round and generous. Her handwriting leans forward, as if even the letters are in a hurry. “You stole this,” he says, because the dance requires partners. “Don’t be English,” she says, which is also an answer. He takes it. He feels ridiculous. He feels younger. He feels like he could be someone else for a while. They ride again. Trastevere at night is a party you’re late for but welcomed into anyway. A street musician plays something with too many minor chords. A woman leans out of a window to shake a rug. Men smoke and talk with their hands as if shaping the air could make it more their own. Alessandra knows people everywhere. She is kissed on both cheeks by a butcher with a ring in his ear, waved at by a tattooed boy who might owe her money or love or both. At a red light, she turns her head a fraction. “Are you having fun, professor?” He thinks of the seminar packets he did not bring, the notes waiting in a quiet room he cannot conjure now without it seeming absurd. He thinks of the hours he’s been stolen from and given back in new currency. He thinks of the rain on the awning and the way she orders for him without making him small. “Yes,” he says simply. “Good,” she says, and the light goes green. At the edge of a square he will not be able to find tomorrow without help, she stops. “Here,” she says. “I work.” She taps the messenger bag. “People wait. I disappear.” He steps off, legs jelly. He hands her the helmet awkwardly, like it might bite him. She leans in and adjusts his collar, unasked. No one has touched him like this in a long time, the small, domestic fix that says: you are in my world for a minute. “Will I see you again?” he asks, careful, casual as a man standing on a cliff. She looks him over, amused and unsparing and something else peeking through like a coin on the bottom of a fountain. “If you don’t die crossing the street,” she says. “And if you call. And if I feel like it.” “That’s... a lot of conditions.” “I like to think of them as luck.” He holds up the postcard. “I’m an academic. I don’t believe in luck.” Her smile goes slow and then sharp. “You will,” she murmurs, and the Vespa coughs, snarls, becomes a note disappearing into the city. He stands in the wake of her, heart going too fast, hands smelling faintly of petrol and sugar, Rome humming around him as if it has swallowed his name. He looks at the postcard again. There is a smudge at the corner where her thumb must have been, a little dark moon. The guidebook is heavy under his arm. He could open it and be told where to go next. He could follow the map back to his safe apartment with its interestingly dangerous plug sockets and the books stacked like polite hostages. Instead he tucks the card into the back of the guidebook, as if it had always been there, as if he had taken it from a page he’d forgotten he'd dog-eared years ago. Non pensare, she wrote. Don’t think. He steps off the curb without looking, and then laughs at himself and looks anyway. A taxi whooshes past, close enough to lift the hair on his arms. He breathes. Somewhere, bells. Somewhere, a woman swears and a man laughs as if it were a compliment. The day is behind him like a train rushing into a tunnel, leaving him bright-eyed and a little deaf. He looks up at the slice of moon, thinks of a coin arcing through the air over water, a promise for tourists. He is not a tourist anymore, he thinks, and then refuses to think at all. He begins to walk, not home exactly, but toward the idea of one, and the city, mischievous and old, falls in beside him.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkably accomplished contemporary romance that captures the essence of Rome through the chance encounter between Ben, a British academic, and Alessandra, a spirited Italian courier. The writing demonstrates exceptional control of pacing, characterization, and atmospheric detail. The narrative successfully creates two distinct characters whose personalities emerge organically through their actions and dialogue. Alessandra's impulsive, boundary-pushing nature contrasts beautifully with Ben's cautious academic demeanor. Her kleptomania is subtly revealed through small acts throughout the day—swiping a toothpick flag, a postcard, napkins—rather than being explicitly stated, which shows sophisticated restraint. The prose is particularly strong in its sensory details and imagery. Rome comes alive through specific, evocative descriptions: "Rome peels open like an orange under her driving," "The asphalt shines like obsidian," and "Domes like shoulders in a bath." These images avoid cliché while remaining accessible and vivid. The dialogue exchanges are natural and revealing, with Alessandra's quick wit ("You say 'why not' like a man who has said 'why yes' only to footnotes") and Ben's polite responses creating authentic tension. The writer skillfully uses dialogue to advance characterization rather than merely plot. The narrative structure follows the prompt's request for interconnected scenes spanning a single day, moving from the Trevi Fountain to cafés, the Pantheon, and various Roman neighborhoods. Each location serves the character development and growing attraction between the protagonists. The chemistry between the characters builds convincingly through small moments of physical proximity, shared experiences, and the gradual breaking down of Ben's reserve. The writer avoids rushing their connection, instead allowing it to develop through meaningful interactions. One of the piece's greatest strengths is how it balances the external journey through Rome with the internal journey of the characters. Ben's transformation from cautious academic to someone willing to embrace spontaneity feels earned through his day with Alessandra. The ending strikes the right note of ambiguity and possibility. It doesn't force a romantic resolution but leaves the reader with the sense that Ben has been changed by the encounter, now willing to step "off the curb without looking" and embrace the unpredictability that Alessandra represents. If there are weaknesses, they are minor. Occasionally, the prose risks becoming slightly overwrought in its metaphors, though it generally pulls back before crossing that line. There are also moments where the pacing slows slightly in descriptive passages, though these still contribute to the atmospheric quality of the piece. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted romance that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt while demonstrating sophisticated storytelling techniques, nuanced characterization, and evocative prose. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Cozy sci-fi: The Last Outpost — Score: 85.5
Prompt:
Cozy sci-fi The Last Outpost Nettle (or Nets to her friends) bartends at The Last Outpost -- a lazy hub for miners and merchants in an asteroid belt on the Andromeda outer rim. Escaping from her past life, Nets found a home here at the Outpost. They have, thus far, tolerated Net's flaws which she tries to keep in equilibrium with her assortment of talents. Her evenings involve chatting with patrons, negotiating the drama, intrigue, problems & love lives of the diverse crowd that filter through the Outpost. Tonight is no different, at least, until a frazzled looking stranger, tentacled dreads askew, quietly plops down at the bar: "Vega whisky, neat. Better make that a double." Write a chapter in this story. Establish conflict for narrative interest. Don't resolve the conflict within this chapter. Aim for about 60% dialogue. First person, present tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The Last Outpost hums like it’s purring, a content cat of patched titanium and borrowed gravity. The mag-ads along the far wall flicker in a sluggish rainbow and the neon OUTPOST sign jitters on its second O. The grav plates have been touchy all week; everyone’s drinks sway like they’re listening to music only the liquids can hear. Mine too, a chipped mug of ginger fizz I keep under the counter, rocking the way a heart does just before it skips. I wipe a ring of condensation off the bartop and pretend I don’t notice the way the floor dips for a second as the plates adjust. The late shift means the knots of miners are looser, the merchants down to their second stories and third lies. Behind me, the old holo of Andromeda’s rim—a touristy loop of dust and blue gas—glitches in and out of a pale square. Boss calls it ambience. I call it depressing. “Seven salts, Nets,” Yorel says from a stool and taps the side of his empty glass. His hands are raw, his nails rimed with something that’s probably not legal to inhale. “You’re on six, Yorel.” I tip my chin at him. “You want to go home vertical?” He grins, all teeth and stubble. “Home misses me.” “Home is a cot in Block D with a heater that hasn’t worked since the last solar flare. It doesn’t miss anyone.” I pour him a half-shot anyway. He groans, then laughs, because that’s the joke of The Last Outpost: nothing is ever enough, so we pretend it is. The door sighs open. The station moans, then stills. A breeze that isn’t a breeze slips past my cheeks and the hair on my arms lifts. I don’t know how to explain that sensation to anyone who isn’t born station-side. It’s like Mass wants you to notice her for a second and then forget again. They slip in quietly. Tentacled dreads, slicked to the left as if slept on, eyes like dark syrup edged with heat. Pale, not in the human way but in that washed-out glow some of the aquatic-born get when they’ve been too long between humidity cycles. They don’t look like a miner. They don’t look like a merchant. They look like a story. They slide onto a stool, trying to look anonymous, which is hilarious because anonymity at The Last Outpost is neon. The tentacles twitch and then settle. They keep their hands under the bar lip like they’re hiding them. “Vega whisky, neat,” they say, voice soft but hoarse, sanded smooth by a lot of not sleeping. “Better make that a double.” “That’ll ruin your evening in one go,” I say. “That’s the plan.” “Ruin your evening here and I got cleanup,” I say, because banter is how I measure danger. Even in new faces, there’s a way people lean into or away from a joke. The stranger’s mouth twitches, a tug at the corner. “I’ll try to lubricate neatly.” “Lubricate somewhere else,” Yorel throws in. A couple stools down, Jaya snorts fizz out her nose. Laughter trickles and fades. The stranger’s eyes flick over heads, calculating. I pour the Vega. The amber clings a breath too long to the glass before it yields. Gravity dips, and the surface makes a little dome, then quivers and flattens. I set it down carefully. Their hand emerges, and I clock the glove immediately. It’s a good glove. It’s also hiding. “Lot of folks wear gloves,” I say, mostly to myself, mostly for the universe to hear I’m paying attention. “Lot of bars have house rules,” they say, and drink. “Lot of bartenders keep quiet unless the gloves got claws,” I say. “Mine don’t.” They drain the first half like it’s medicine and not invention. The tentacles soften, uncoil a little. The pupils widen, then contract again. I see the moment the burn hits. Their shoulders drop. They inhale that thin Outpost air as if it’s sweeter now. “You new to this belt?” I ask, like I’m just filling air. “Passing through,” they say. “Everyone says that.” I lean in. “What’s your name, passing through?” They roll the glass between thumb and forefinger. The glove squeaks. “Do you prefer the truth or the version where we pretend we’ll never meet again?” “I prefer names that fit in your mouth.” “Nettle, isn’t it?” they say, lifting their gaze to me. Not a guess. The tentacles twitch, the smallest quiver, like they’re tasting something electric. “Or Nets. To your friends.” I keep my face pleasant. The veil between I’m-just-the-bartender and please-do-not-say-my-past out loud is thin but resilient. I’m practiced at it. I smile the way I do when someone’s about to start a fight and I need them to think they’re winning. “And you are?” I say. They consider. “Call me Quill.” “That’s not your name,” I say. “It’s the one I can afford today.” Yorel knocks the bar. “Nets, you ignoring me now? I got needs.” “Your needs owe me two hundred and twelve credits, Yorel,” I say. “You’re lucky I nurture your bad habits at all.” “I can pay,” Quill says, almost too quickly. I cock an eyebrow. “For Yorel? That’s charity.” “For your time,” Quill says. They tilt their head toward the end of the bar, where the private nook is topped with a busted star-map and a misaligned privacy screen. “Five minutes.” “Five minutes is one hundred credits and I get to keep your drink if you’re boring.” “Deal.” “You hear that?” Jaya says, raising her glass. “Nets charges by the minute now.” “I charge by the caliber of nonsense,” I say, scooping Quill’s glass and angling my chin toward the nook. I flick the privacy screen on. The static hums, not perfect, never perfect. Station hum adds to it, a harmony of failing systems and stubborn perseverance. Quill slides into the booth opposite me. Close, but not too. The glove stays on the table. Their other hand, ungloved, is bare, webbed between fingers. Riverborn. They see me clock it and tuck it back. Old instinct. Some places don’t serve Riverborn. The Outpost is not some places, but people bleed habits. “What’s the caliber?” I ask. “Explosive,” they say. “And timed.” “I prefer slow burns.” Their smile is small and gone quickly. “There are three ships in orbit that don’t belong here. One is broadcasting a sanitation crew code from Vesta-Three. One is dead silent, but the transponder pings off a registry that got scrubbed in the last Ceril Syndicate sweep. One is trying not to look like a patrol.” I swirl my ginger fizz and glance toward the bar. Yorel drags a finger through salt on the counter, sculpting a snake. Jaya is oranges and laughter. The rest are shadows with credit chips. “We get patrols,” I say. “You get bored patrols,” Quill says. “You don’t get these. And you don’t get them together.” “You been looking up a lot.” “I listen,” they say. The tentacles settle, the ends splay. “Officially? I’m a courier. Unofficially? I’m freelance problems. I was hired to move a package. Someone changed their mind. Now everyone is nervous, including me.” “You want me to hold a package.” I make it flat, so it sounds like something else. “We’re not a storage cube.” “I want you to pretend to be loud and obvious,” Quill says. “For a handful of hours.” “Ah.” I grin despite myself. “My specialty.” Quill leans forward. The privacy screen fuzzes around the shape of their face. Up close, their pupils are flecked with amber, like a galaxy under oil. “The package is here,” they say. “Under your feet, probably. In the ducting. Someone slipped it into the Outpost three hours ago, put it where it would be least obvious and most safe because everyone here is too lazy to crawl. They used your name to open a maintenance hatch.” I keep the grin. It’s fun until it’s not. “My name travels well.” “They used it because it was in the system,” Quill says. “Nettle Marc. Pressed old credentials. The kind you don’t like anyone saying out loud.” That stops me. Not long, not visible enough to show, but enough that Quill sees it. Of course they do. They drink another mouthful to give me space to decide whether to lie. The liquor surface bulges with the gravity’s sigh and they hold it steady with a finger pressed to the rim, steady as a pin. “We’re not doing the part where I deny I ever had credentials,” I say. “We’re skipping to why I shouldn’t toss you out an airlock.” “Because I came to you,” Quill says. “Because the package is tagged. Because if the wrong ships ping it, this place becomes an example.” “You’re a ray of sunshine.” “I’m telling you because you can bake a distraction like nobody else,” they say. “Because you know the ducts. Because the Outpost protects its own, and you are that too now, whether or not your bones remember.” We sit with that. My mug wobbles. The gravity dips and rises like a breath. “What’s in the package?” I ask. Quill’s eyes flick. “Does it matter?” “It will if it leaks.” “It won’t leak,” they say, absolutely certain. “It will explode.” I don’t laugh. “You said timed.” “Triggered,” Quill corrects. “Wrong hands, wrong room, wrong signal. It’s data mostly. Wrapped around something unpleasant.” “Like how you’re wrapped around ‘mostly,’” I say. “If I say no?” “Then I take it and run,” Quill says. “And the ships upstairs take me and cut me apart, and maybe they don’t find it in time, and maybe the Outpost gets to become a cautionary tale you tell the next crowded bar.” I tap a rhythm my mother used to hum when she wanted me to stop asking questions. It doesn’t work on me any more than it did then. I glance toward the bar. Del, the dockhand with the tattoo of an anchor on her wrist, has drifted in. She lifts her chin at me, the subtle signal that means someone is cruising for trouble on the docks. I lift my chin back, the signal for later. “I need more than promises,” I say. “And more than credits.” Quill nods. “Bring me a bar rag.” “Excuse me?” “A bar rag,” they repeat. “And a glass. And a spoon. And your hand for two seconds.” “Now you’re making this weird,” I say, but I get up anyway because curiosity is the only drug I never quit. I swipe three glasses, snag a clean rag, grab the long stirring spoon. Yorel wolf-whistles. I ignore him. The air near the door shivers as two new bodies come in. They smell like ozone and too-new boots. I feel it more than see it. Back in the nook, I set the items down. Quill pushes the rag toward me. “Hold that.” I do. They slide the glove off slow, and I get a flash of what they were hiding: not claws, not illegal mods. Scars, precise and ringed, like someone burned circles into their skin over and over to map a constellation. Each circle has a thin line etched into it. The spaces between run faintly with bioluminescent blue. It’s delicate and horrifying in the way that makes your throat tight. Quill dips two fingers into the water I didn’t bring and yet is there—condensed from the air, pulled into their palm, a trick Riverborn learn at twelve. They smear it on the spoon and then trace something onto the rag. The gravity hitches to hear it. The lines glow briefly and then sink. The rag looks like a rag again. “That,” they say, voice low, “is a scrambler a degree above what your boss can afford. Toss it in the ducting above your coolant lines. It will make the tag read like a thermal hiccup for a while.” “And the glass?” They tap the rim. The glass hums. It picks up the station frequency, the whisper of the grav plates. “You’ll hear when the patrol pings. You’ll have seven minutes from the first note to get loud.” “How loud?” “Loud enough that whoever’s watching thinks the thing they’re looking for isn’t worth exploding beneath a hundred bodies and a dozen bets.” “People aren’t cover,” I say. “They are the point,” Quill says, and their face is more tired than I thought it could be. “I don’t want anyone to be cover.” The two new arrivals stop at the end of the bar. One has a jaw like a landing strip, the other wears a smile wrong. The Outpost’s neon paints them green. They don’t sit. They search the room. They are the kind of problem that has a uniform even when it doesn’t. “Friends of yours?” I ask. Quill doesn’t look. The tentacles stiffen, just a hair. “They think so,” they say. “They don’t know who the package chose.” “Packages don’t choose.” “This one did,” Quill says. “It likes vents. And names that fit in your mouth.” “Cute.” My grin is back, thin as foil. “We got seven minutes?” “If you drop that rag now,” Quill says. “Maybe less. They’re impatient upstairs.” “Listen,” I say, because my mouth is ahead of me and my brain is a step late, “you bring a mess into my bar, you say my name like it’s a key, you ask me to cover you with a crowd, and you don’t even offer me a terrible secret to hold for later?” “Terrible secret,” Quill says, as if testing the syllables. Then they look at me, really look, and their voice goes softer. “When they burned those circles into me, they told me I was a map. I left before they could decide where I had to go. Every star above us looks like a promise and a trap, and I choose the promise every time. Is that terrible enough?” “It’ll do,” I say, and I fold the rag. The gravity dips. The glasses on the bar shiver. The two at the end shift closer, like they’ve scented something. I slide out of the booth. The station feels smaller all of a sudden, as if the walls have leaned in to hear. “Last question,” I say, casual as I can fake. “Who used my name?” Quill’s mouth quirks. “Someone who knew it belonged to a person who could handle this. Someone who thought you might miss being useful.” “I pour drinks,” I say. “You hold a room,” they say. “Please hold it now.” I tuck the rag into my apron. I walk back behind the bar like nothing is happening. Like I’m not about to use a bit of wet cloth and a glass song to blind three ships and a pair of bastards with too-new boots. I set the glass by the sink and listen. It sings, faint, a high keening noise that makes my molars ache. “Okay,” I say, under my breath. “Okay.” Yorel looks up at me, catches something in my face. “Nets?” “Shut up and bet me ten credits I can get the whole bar to sing along to Orion Blues,” I say, voice sharp and bright. He grins, because he knows a show when he’s being handed one, even if he doesn’t know why. “I’ll bet you fifty,” Jaya says, leaning in. “If you also throw a glass and don’t break it.” The gravity dips again, almost playful now. My drinks wobble. The station hums. The two at the end of the bar straighten like hounds. Above us, something pings distant as a star dying. “Fifty credits?” I flash my teeth. “Make it a hundred. And hold onto your drinks.” Behind me, the ducting whispers. The rag in my pocket is ordinary, damp with a map I don’t understand. Quill sits very still in the nook, eyes on the street outside the privacy screen, on the new arrivals, on me. The Outpost waits. I lift my hands. The room leans forward, and I feel the moment I love and hate most in equal measure: where everyone’s breath is mine to shape. I smack the bar twice with the spoon. Glass hum answers. The song is ready to start. And then the door opens again, hard enough to rattle the neon. A shadow fills the entrance, shoulders brushing the frame. I know that silhouette. I know the way she tilts her head to see a room as if every person in it is a chess piece and she’s three moves ahead. Nara walks in, the past I left coalesced into boots and a jacket and a gun at her hip. Her eyes find me in three beats. Her mouth does not smile. “Nettle,” she says, like gravity reasserting itself. Quill’s head drops. Yorel swears softly. The glass by the sink sings higher. The Outpost holds its breath. My heart does the same stupid wobble as the drinks. “Hi, Nara,” I say. “Want anything to drink?”
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a cozy sci-fi atmosphere while establishing clear conflict and tension. The author has crafted a vivid setting in The Last Outpost, a bar in an asteroid belt with failing gravity plates and a diverse clientele. The first-person present tense narration through Nettle's perspective is consistently maintained throughout. The strongest elements are the worldbuilding and atmosphere. Details like "drinks sway like they're listening to music only the liquids can hear" and the way gravity "dips" create a tangible sense of place. The author skillfully introduces sci-fi elements without overwhelming exposition, allowing readers to infer the setting's rules naturally. The dialogue comprises approximately 60% of the text as requested, and it serves multiple purposes effectively: revealing character, advancing plot, and providing exposition without feeling forced. The banter between Nettle and the patrons establishes her as quick-witted and experienced, while her conversation with Quill builds tension and mystery. Character development is nuanced. Nettle is established as someone with a mysterious past she's trying to escape, now finding a home at the Outpost. Secondary characters like Yorel and Jaya have distinct personalities despite limited page time. Quill is intriguing - clearly in trouble, with physical characteristics (tentacled dreads, webbed fingers) that mark them as different. The conflict is well-established: a mysterious package hidden in the ducts, ships in orbit that "don't belong," and the arrival of Nara from Nettle's past. The chapter ends on a perfect cliffhanger that leaves multiple questions unanswered, creating narrative tension without resolution. However, there are some weaknesses. Occasionally, the prose becomes slightly purple, with metaphors that call attention to themselves rather than enhancing the narrative. Some descriptions, while evocative, could be tightened for clarity. The relationship between Nettle and Nara could have been foreshadowed earlier to make the ending revelation more impactful. The piece also introduces several plot elements in quick succession during Quill's explanation - the package, the ships, Nettle's past credentials - which creates a slight feeling of information overload. While this contributes to the tension, it risks confusing readers about what the central conflict actually is. Overall, this is a strong piece of cozy sci-fi that successfully establishes an intriguing world, complex characters, and compelling conflicts while adhering to the prompt requirements. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 16 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 17 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 3 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 16.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 17.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 3.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Young adult drama: Gone South — Score: 88.8
Prompt:
Young adult drama Gone South Taylor is a 16 year old teen with a history of "concerning behavioural patterns" (or that's how the stupid smug school counsellor worded it on the phone call to Mom). It shouldn't be a surprise: When you live in a backwater town in Tennessee, your choices are: a. be mind-fuckingly bored, or b. invent some drama. Two days ago, Taylor came out to their family as trans. This disclosure was *not* in the category of invented drama -- it was, in fact, the real deal, and a long time coming. It didn't go well. The last 48 hours had been pure disaster. In a moment of desperate inspiration, Taylor had decided to get the hell out of dodge. And so an escape plan was hatched and executed within the space of 30 minutes. That was last night. Now Taylor was two states away, having been unceremoniously ejected from their hitched ride in downtown New Orleans. Write the next chapter in Taylor's story as they find their feet in this new environment. Tell the chapter over the course of their first day in New Orleans, in which Taylor meets another runaway with issues and secrets. Taylor navigates this new world, not knowing who to trust or what the dangers are. Write in Taylor's voice, and incorporate their internal monologue as they grapple with intense & conflicting emotions. Also incorporate dialogue with the interesting characters Taylor meets. First person, mixed tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
I’m trying to pretend that my stomach isn’t one clenched fist of hunger and anxiety, but it’s hard when I can literally smell powdered sugar on the air and hear someone laughing like their lungs aren’t strapped shut like mine. New Orleans is too loud to be a real place. It’s like someone turned up the saturation in Photoshop and hit “random.” The buildings slouch into each other with those fancy balconies like they’re gossiping, the street musicians are already out even though it’s barely ten-thirty, and tourists shuffle past in packs, mouths open, pointing at everything like it’s a zoo and we’re the animals. I keep wanting to yell at them to stop staring at me, which doesn’t make sense because they’re not. I’m not wearing anything weird—cutoff shorts, hoodie tied around my waist because the air is wet and hot but I might need to disappear—but I feel like the words TRANS KID are stamped across my forehead in neon. Also, my phone is at twelve percent, which is basically the same thing as being shipwrecked. I stand under a wrought-iron balcony that drips ferns and try to act like I belong. This is the new plan: look like I’ve made decisions before. My backpack is half-empty (bad move) but zipped tight (good move). I’ve got sixty-four dollars crumpled and sweaty in the pocket of my hoodie. There’s a busker with a trumpet playing something that’s almost a lullaby, almost a threat. Behind me, in the alley, a woman negotiates with a guy over a set of beads like it’s James Bond tech. A bead deal. Okay. I’m here. Not in Tennessee. Not in that kitchen where Mom’s fingers shook around her mug and Dad—no, not Dad—just stared like he was waiting for someone to yell “cut” and fix the script. I should find a charger. I should find a bathroom. I should find... a life? Ha. “Hey, Red.” I flinch so hard my teeth clack. The voice comes from my left, where a boy is leaned up against a streetlamp like he invented leaning. He’s a little older than me—maybe eighteen?—with a haircut that’s trying very hard not to be a mullet and a face you trust until you notice his eyes are cataloging the world like a shoplifter. His sneakers are taped at the toes with black electrical tape. He’s got a plastic bag that says THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU in red letters, and I realize he’s just called me Red because of my hair. The dye is almost grown out at the roots, and the rest has faded from ruby to rust. Red. Cute. He smirks when I don’t answer. “You look like you got dropped into the wrong video game. Need a map?” “I’m good,” I say, because I’m not going to be that kid. My voice is steady enough that I want to fist-pump. Two days ago, saying anything felt like my throat was full of broken glass. Two days ago, I had a name that wasn’t mine and a house that wasn’t safe. Today, I have nothing except a hoodie and almost a dozen percent battery. “Good,” he echoes, pushing off the pole. “Great. Super. I’m Ash.” “Like the Pokémon trainer?” He grins, teeth small and uneven. “Like what’s left after the fire.” Okay, intense. “Taylor,” I say. There’s a beat where I think, do I add that I’m trans like a footnote, like a caveat? Hi, I’m Taylor, and. Nope. Not his business. Not because I’m ashamed. Because it feels like offering meat to a dog I don’t know. “You run away, Taylor?” he asks. He says it in a breezy way, like it’s a guess, like he didn’t clock my whole life in one look. “No.” “Yes,” he says, like we’re playing Truth or Dare and he’s the dealer. “You smell like Greyhound and existential dread.” “I smell like the rain,” I retort, because I walked through a sudden shower, because the sky here doesn’t bother with foreplay. It just opens. He points across the street at a café with a chalkboard sign promising chicory coffee and a beignet that looks as big as my face. “Come on.” “I don’t—” “What, you think I’m kidnapping you? In a café? Relax. I just know the bathroom code.” He doesn’t wait. He snakes through the crowd, and I follow because I don’t have a better plan. My phone vibrates in my pocket like a mosquito: 11% now, and a text from Mom that I don’t open because I don’t have the stomach for the word please in her voice. The café smells like a hug from someone you used to like. We slide into a back corner because Ash is apparently allergic to visibility. He palms a sugar packet the way some people breathe. “Bathroom code’s 1023,” he says. “Wash your face. Cry, if you need to. Whatever. You look like your heart is about to punch its way out.” In the mirror, I look like someone who hasn’t slept, which—ding ding—correct. My eyes are red-rimmed, my hair is a cautionary tale, and there’s a zit brewing on my chin like a tiny volcano. I splash water that tastes like metal and old pennies, blot my cheeks on a paper towel, and I do not cry. I’ve spent two days shaking like a washing machine and I’m tired of it. Sixteen and tired. That should be illegal. Back at the table, Ash has acquired a beignet the size of my face and a coffee that smells like someone burned a flower and decided it was a delicacy. He pushes the plate toward me with a little flick of his wrist. “I can’t—” “Take it,” he says. “I’m not nice enough to do charity. Consider it a strategic investment in not watching you pass out.” The powdered sugar hits my tongue and suddenly my brain is like oh hello, dopamine. “Thanks,” I manage around a mouthful. He watches me, not in a gross way. More like he’s on recon. “Where’d you come from?” he asks. “Tennessee.” He nods like I’ve said Mars. “Cool. Nobody comes here from Tennessee. It’s all Ohio and Texas this time of year.” “You keep stats?” “Working theory. You learn the migratory patterns of the weird. You from Nashville? Memphis? Random cousin of Dolly Parton?” “Small town,” I say, and the words taste like dust. “The kind where the Walgreens is a destination and if you sneeze, your neighbor says ‘Bless you’ from across the street.” He smiles, then sobers. “Why’d you run?” “Why did you?” I shoot back. I’m not telling him my everything in a café after three minutes. I’m not telling him about how my mother said his name with more care than mine, how my uncle stared at my chest like it offended him now that it meant nothing to me. I’m not telling him about Dad—nope, stop, not Dad—standing with his arms crossed and unmoving, like a monument to denial. I’m not telling him how I packed in the dark, hands shaking so hard the zipper snagged four times, and walked to the highway like it was a church aisle. Ash’s jaw twitches. “I don’t like dudes with rings telling me when to be home,” he says. It’s a joke, but it isn’t. “And I don’t like fists. So I left.” I nod, and for a second we’re two planets sharing a sun. The beignet is gone before I know it, and I’m licking sugar off my thumb like a raccoon. Classy. “You got somewhere to sleep?” he asks. “I was going to find a hostel,” I lie, because the words I have nowhere sound like the end of a magic trick. He laughs, not mean. “You and the backpackers with trust funds from Vermont. Cool. Hostels ask for ID most times. You got ID?” I have a learner’s permit with the wrong name on it and a face that looks like me but also like someone I used to play on TV. “Sure,” I say. “Technically.” He tilts his head. “You’re a terrible liar.” “I’m a decent liar,” I say, because evidence suggests I’m at least functional at it. I look at the window, at a girl with glitter on her cheeks walking a dog that’s wearing sunglasses. For a heartbeat, I want to be her, careless and weird and owned by nobody. Ash taps the table. “Okay. This is where I do my Good Samaritan routine, but with disclaimers. There’s a place you can crash, no questions asked for a night or two if you keep your head straight and don’t steal anybody’s stuff. It’s not glamorous. It’s damp. Smells like old vape. Also, sometimes cops swing by and make trouble. You in?” I should not follow a stranger to his damp vape palace. I should find a Salvation Army or a youth shelter and sign forms and let my mother come get me and go home and apologize until my tongue dissolves. My stomach lurches. “Where?” I ask. “By the river,” he says. “Old warehouse. You share the space, you share the risk.” “Why help me?” I ask, because I don’t believe in free rides, or free beignets, or free kindness. Not anymore. He shrugs, but his mouth goes tight. “Because someone helped me. Because you looked like your bones were ringing.” He looks at my hoodie. “Because you said Tennessee like you were choking on it.” We leave the café, and the heat slaps us like a teacher’s hand. The sky is bright and oppressive, a blanket you can’t kick off. The French Quarter gives way to broader streets, fewer tourists, more actual people: a woman pushing a cart of cold water bottles, a guy sleeping on a strip of lawn under a tree that hoards shade like secrets. The river is a brown muscle flexing behind low walls. My phone buzzes again. Ten percent. “Hey,” I say, as we walk, “do you know where I can charge my—” “Phone?” Ash finishes, like an oracle. “Yeah. There’s a corner in the mall by the aquarium where the outlets aren’t monitored. Or the library on Loyola if you can sit still and pretend to read.” “Can you sit still?” I ask. “Only under duress.” We cut down toward the water, past a man selling pralines out of a tin that I want to bury my face in. The warehouse is really a skeleton of one. It’s brick, but parts of it are scabbed with plywood, and the door is a slit in the middle like a scar. Inside, it’s cooler and it smells like damp cardboard and cinnamon gum. There are blankets set up against one wall in a patchwork, a couple of milk crates, and a plastic tarp ceiling that flutters like a weak heartbeat. There are three other people: a girl with a shaved head and gold hoops who is sewing something purple by hand; a kid who can’t be more than fourteen, asleep with his arm thrown over his face; and a person whose gender is a question mark in a black tank top, drawing with a Sharpie on a piece of cardboard. They all look at me like they’re deciding. “This is Taylor,” Ash announces, as if that’s a completely normal thing. “They’re cool. From Tennessee.” “Yeehaw,” says Hoop Girl, deadpan. She squints. “You use they because…?” “Because that’s what I use,” I say, and it comes out easy and hard at the same time. I stand straighter without meaning to. The relief is sudden and stupid. A name is a door. A pronoun is a bridge. “Nice,” says Hoop Girl. “I’m Mel. He-him over there is Cricket,” she nods at the sleeping kid, “and they-them is Jess,” she nods at the Sharpie artist. “Don’t touch my thread. It bites.” “Hi,” says Jess without looking up. “Boundaries are sexy. Also, we all have knives.” “Okay,” I say, trying to smile like that’s not the most alarming Welcome to the Club sentence I’ve heard in my life. “You can put your bag there,” Ash says, pointing. “Watch for roaches. They’re like tiny landlords.” I lower my backpack carefully. My fingers shake. I hate that my hands still do that. I don’t want them to. I don’t want to be the fragile one in the room. “You look like your last three days were a novel,” Jess says, uncapping the marker with their teeth. Their eyes are kind, which makes me suspicious. Everything kind feels like a trap. In my head, my mother is crying again, her fingers worrying a napkin to death. My not-Dad is staring. Unclench, unclench, unclench. “Short story,” I say. “Badly edited.” Mel snorts. “You write?” “I used to write angsty poems about the sky and how nobody understood me,” I say. “So yes. I am, in fact, a teenager.” “Poems are currency,” Jess says. “You can pay rent with a metaphor if you’re good enough.” Ash disappears for a second and comes back with two extension cords coiled like snakes. “Okay,” he says. “Moment of grace.” He plugs one into a strip anchored suspiciously to the wall. “Power. For the needy.” It feels like church. I plug my phone in and it bings, and the screen lights up with more messages than I want to look at. Mom, Mom, blocked number, Uncle James (ew), unknown. A voicemail from a number I don’t know. I stare until the messages blur, then flip the phone face down like it’s misbehaving. “You good?” Ash asks, quiet. “Yes,” I lie again, because the truth is a forest with no paths. But the cord is real, and the cool is real, and the air tastes like rust and sweetness, and my name on these people’s tongues felt like something that might not be a weapon. I sit on the blanket, and for the first time in two days, I let my back lean against a wall without flinching. We spend the afternoon breathing. Mel shows me how to sew up a rip in my hoodie and calls me “kid” in a way that isn’t an insult. Cricket wakes up and eats crackers with surgical precision and tells me he’s been on the road for nine months because his foster dad was a clown (like, literally) who never took the paint off, and honestly, if that isn’t a reason to run, I don’t know what is. Jess draws a city on cardboard, a maze of streets that loops back into itself like a spell. Ash goes out and comes back with a bag of day-old bread from a bakery where “the lady knows my eyebrows.” We tear pieces off and eat them with our hands like goats. At some point, a cop car idles out front and my lungs stop. Ash squeezes my wrist once, his thumb hard bone against my pulse. The car moves on. I breathe again, shaky. My phone pings. Seven percent. It’s almost evening when he says, “There’s a place tonight. A lady named Miss Rayna gives plates of food to kids like us behind a church. No sermons. Just jambalaya that could make you cry. You in?” I nod too fast. “Yes.” We go. The sky is pink at the edges like it’s embarrassed. The church is small and stolid and the woman with the food is tall and soft and doesn’t look at me like a problem to solve. “Baby,” she says, ladling rice and meat into a bowl I don’t deserve, “you need a second helping, you ask.” Her eyes slide over my face like she’s reading a poem she’s seen before. “You safe tonight?” I glance at Ash, who is messing with a plastic fork like it wronged him in a past life. “I think so,” I say. “You call me if you not,” she says, and slips a card into my hand like it’s a magic trick. There’s a number on it. Just a number. No name. It feels like a rope thrown over a wall. Back at the warehouse, the night hums. Someone’s radio is tuned to a station that plays old songs that sound like rain. The city keeps breathing even when I can’t. My phone dies at 1%, like it’s timed to break my heart. I look at Ash. “Why did you really help me?” I ask. The beignet sugar was one thing. A bed is something else. He looks at the river for a long second, like he’s asking it for permission. “You remind me of—” He stops. Starts again. “I had a little sister,” he says finally. “She—” He scrapes his thumb against his palm. “She didn’t make it out. I don’t do that story. But I do this.” He gestures at the crappy tarp kingdom. “I do this so somebody else gets to pick a new story.” Something breaks in me and doesn’t hurt when it does. I nod. We don’t do hugs. I want to. I don’t know how to ask. Instead I say, “Thanks.” “Don’t get sappy,” he says, but he’s already smiling, and I think maybe I can breathe tomorrow, too. I curl up on my borrowed blanket with my dead phone under my cheek like a stupid talisman. The warehouse breathes. The city breathes. I say my name in my head like a quiet drum. Taylor. Taylor. Tomorrow, I’ll find the library. Tomorrow, I’ll text Mom something that won’t break both of us. Tomorrow, I’ll scrape together a plan out of thread and day-old bread and borrowed outlets. Tonight, I’m here. I’m Taylor. The air is wet and sweet. A train cries somewhere far away and the sound runs through my bones like a spine. I try to sleep. I don’t. Not really. But I rest, which is a new verb. And when the dark shifts and the river laughs and a roach as big as my thumb taps across the floor like a tiny inspector general, I laugh, too. Quiet. Mean. Alive.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece effectively captures the voice of a transgender teen runaway navigating their first day in New Orleans. The writing successfully establishes Taylor's character through first-person narration that balances vulnerability with defensive humor. The prose has a distinctive style that feels authentic to a literate, somewhat sardonic teenager, with lines like "New Orleans is too loud to be a real place" and "I'm not telling him how I packed in the dark, hands shaking so hard the zipper snagged four times, and walked to the highway like it was a church aisle." The character development is strong, particularly in how Taylor's internal monologue reveals their conflicting emotions about running away. The piece effectively shows Taylor's hyperawareness of their transgender identity without making it the only defining characteristic. The backstory is revealed organically through memories and reflections rather than exposition dumps. The dialogue is one of the strongest elements, with each character having a distinct voice. Ash's street-smart cynicism ("Like what's left after the fire"), Mel's deadpan humor ("Yeehaw"), and Jess's poetic observations ("Poems are currency. You can pay rent with a metaphor if you're good enough") all feel authentic and serve to characterize the speakers. The setting descriptions are vivid and sensory, capturing New Orleans through specific details: "The buildings slouch into each other with those fancy balconies like they're gossiping," "The air is wet and hot," and "The café smells like a hug from someone you used to like." These descriptions are integrated naturally into Taylor's observations rather than feeling like separate descriptive passages. The pacing is well-handled, covering Taylor's first day in New Orleans while incorporating flashbacks to their coming out and departure. The narrative moves between immediate concerns (hunger, phone battery, finding shelter) and deeper emotional struggles without losing momentum. There are a few moments where the prose becomes slightly overwrought, with metaphors that strain credibility for a teenage narrator: "The river is a brown muscle flexing behind low walls" and "A train cries somewhere far away and the sound runs through my bones like a spine." However, these instances are relatively rare and don't significantly detract from the overall quality. The ending strikes an appropriate balance between hope and uncertainty. Taylor hasn't magically solved their problems, but they've found temporary shelter and potential allies. The final paragraph's mix of vulnerability and defiance ("Quiet. Mean. Alive.") feels earned given the day's experiences. The piece successfully fulfills the prompt requirements, incorporating Taylor's internal monologue, dialogue with interesting characters, and a mix of tenses. It captures the emotional complexity of a transgender teen navigating both their identity and the practical challenges of being a runaway. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 3 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 3.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Dystopic-comedy: My Apocalypse Buddy — Score: 87.8
Prompt:
My Apocalypse Buddy Write a wry, dry short story of survival and adventure loosely in the style of Terry Pratchett, set in the post-technological collapse world. The story begins with the pair deliberating their predicament and intent for the day's mission, details the ways in which the mission inevitably goes sideways, and returns them to home base in multiple ways, worse for wear. [characters] - the animo-tronic stuffed koala, Chewy, from some long forgotten before time - midas, our hapless protagonist, who has a knack for finding himself in the worst kinds of trouble. 1000 words.
Model Output:
It was well known in the settlement of Half-Useful that plans had the same shelf life as milk left in the sun. This being the case, the morning always began with plans and an argument about whether the plans would curdle before lunch. Midas squinted at the hand-drawn map on the table and rubbed at the ink as if optimism could smudge borders. He was a lean man with the sort of face people described as “surprised to still be attached to a body,” and he wore a jacket that had been patched with so many patches it had developed a patchwork society and several bylaws. Chewy sat on the table, technically a stuffed koala and technically not, with a stitched nose polished from years of nervous habit and eyes that worked as a mood ring with delusions of sentience. “We need batteries,” Midas said, with the tone of man who has just noticed the ocean is wet. “And shoes. And a way to not die.” Chewy’s eyes flickered blue, which meant he agreed and also wanted a snack. His mouth didn’t move, because that was the intended design, but his speaker did a little crackle that meant he was about to. “Shoes are a luxury. Feet are a concept,” he intoned in a rich burr that had faded over the decades to something more like a lo-fi therapist. “Batteries, though. Batteries are destiny.” Midas drew a circle on the map around the distant shape labelled The Mall of Before. “They had a store that promised to power your future. That’s practically a contractual obligation.” Chewy’s eyes shifted to a thoughtful purple. “The future did sue,” he said, because somewhere in his capacitors was a comedian who’d been paid by the pun but had defaulted on originality. “Objective: salvage batteries. Constraint: avoid death. Secondary objective: pretzels.” “We can’t eat pretzels,” Midas said. “Pretend-zels,” Chewy offered, green for hopeful. “Made of stale pride. We age them ourselves.” “How about Plan B?” Midas asked, flipping the map to a page featuring a diagram of Half-Useful’s perimeter, which looked like a drunk spider’s attempt at crochet. “Plan B is for when Plan A has been eaten by wolves,” Chewy said, eyes doing a polite yellow that meant critical but loving. “You always skip to plan letters like you’re trying to impress someone.” Midas looked at Chewy, and for a second his expression shifted, the sort of softness people reserve for sunsets and the last biscuit. “All right, Plan A. We go to the Mall, we find the battery store, we don’t kiss any fountains that look at us funny. Happy?” Chewy’s eyes flickered pink, which meant yes but he would remember this. They left Half-Useful by the south gate, which was a generous term for a door that had been several doors in its time and had adopted their strengths and weaknesses in equal measure. Francine the Gatekeeper waved them through and pressed a jar of clouded honey into Midas’s hands. “For bartering,” she said. “And because you look like you might be consumed by bees at any moment. I’d hate for them to get away with it.” “Thanks,” Midas said, wondering what that meant for his aura. They walked along the old highway, which was no longer a highway because those require cars and mutual trust. What it had become was a long, flat argument with grass and a reminder that asphalt ages into snakes if you don’t watch it. Chewy sat in Midas’s pack, ears poking out like a pair of very small, fuzzy periscopes. His eyes rotated through an idle screensaver of colors: a soothing lounge of teal, a flirtation with orange, a brief flirtation with flashing red and then back again, as if to say, “Yes, I’m paying attention, no, I’m not worried, yes, that’s a vulture, no, we don’t taste of regret, stop asking.” At the edge of sight The Mall of Before rose like a ship that had run aground in a decade. Once it had been a glass-and-steel cathedral of retail and regret. Now it was a husk wearing the bones of its own optimism, the faded banner still declaring every day to be a Grand Opening that never stopped. “Remember,” Chewy said, because he always remembered the thing that got them into trouble last time. “Last time, escalators tried to eat you.” “I fell asleep on the steps,” Midas protested. “You confided in a moving staircase,” Chewy replied, eyes briefly magenta for exasperation. They slipped through the broken entryway under a sky that had been polished into a sort of overly sincere blue. The air inside smelled of dust, old perfume, and the kind of deals that used to be printed in glossier ink. Their footsteps stirred echoes that had been waiting decades for company. The battery store was in the west wing, according to the map Midas had compiled from memories and lies. They passed storefronts full of mannequins in frozen conversation and display cases of jewelry that had lost the argument with need long ago. They had not gone ten yards when Chewy’s eyes pulsed a warning red. “Stop,” he whispered, because the air had shifted and the dust held its breath. From the shadows emerged a figure in a suit that had been an expensive decision. The figure’s hair had not survived the world, and retaliated by leaving entirely. Around his neck hung a medallion: the stylized lightning bolt of the Cult of the Last Charge. “Welcome, shoppers,” the man said with a smile that promised deals and delivered small claims court. “I am Manager Zeke. May I interest you in a membership? Lifetime.” “I like my life unbranded,” Midas said, and tried to look like someone who did not have a small electronic friend with expensive eyes. Zeke’s people stepped forward, brandishing devices that had begun life as cattle prods and grown into hobbies. “We merely collect on what is owed,” Zeke continued, “for every battery you’ve used without appreciating its sacrifice. For every flashlight flicked on without a silent prayer.” Chewy’s eyes went blue-green, a hue Midas recognized as calculating. “Counter-offer,” Chewy said, in a tone that sold authenticity. “We tithe power.” There was a pause. Zeke glanced down at the koala, because one must confirm that one is being negotiated with by a toy before society finishes its long slide. “You’re an animo-tronic.” “Animo-tronic,” Chewy agreed. “Patented. Collectible. Rare. You may worship me for a modest fee.” Zeke’s interest went from guarded to acquisitive with the speed of a bargain hunter hearing the word clearance. “You function?” “Define function.” Zeke gestured. One of his acolytes held up a small dynamo and a set of ragged leads. “We have means to test.” Midas swallowed. He had seen this play out in smaller marketplaces: a tasting, a tithing, a taking. “We’re only here for—” “Batteries,” Zeke said, pleased. “Me too.” What followed was negotiation, which is to say it was argument with props. Midas produced the honey and a pair of screws that he claimed were ceremonial. Chewy told a story about his origin that was equal parts hype and hysteria, framing himself as a prophet of the Plug. Zeke warmed to them, because con-men recognize cousins in the wild, and eventually they came to an agreement: in exchange for the location of a stockpile in the basement, they would be allowed to take a share—under supervision. “Of course,” Zeke said. “You first.” “Of course,” Midas said, because it is polite to agree to things you cannot possibly do. They descended into the underbelly, a place where the mall kept its dustier secrets. Pipes ran like pythons and the air tasted of old water and the kind of mold that wrote memoirs. The promised stockpile was behind a door labelled Do Not Enter, which meant in the old world that you could enter if you wore a lanyard. Zeke had a skeleton key and a belief in himself, which worked on many doors. Inside were boxes, stacked to the too-high ceiling. Batteries. Old brands, the fonts of empires now fallen. Midas felt his heart do a little two-step. Chewy’s eyes flickered a greedy green. And then, inevitably, everything went sideways. There is a special kind of trap that is designed by a person who understands two things: one, that people are greedy, and two, that they do not read labels. As Midas stepped forward, there was a click. The boxes sighed. The floor, which had been loyal, chose independence. As they dropped into the darkness, Chewy said, “Ah,” in the tone of someone who has just remembered a crucial detail about gravity. They landed in cold water. Midas’s limbs flailed the way limbs do when they realize they weren’t consulted. Zeke’s acolytes yelped and splashed. Above them, the doorway shrank to a coin, Zeke’s shocked face a stamp upon it. He shouted something about breach of trust and hazard pay, but the echo ate it. “Can you swim?” Chewy asked, eyes a practical yellow. “I can remember how it’s meant to look,” Midas sputtered, tasting the dust of old sales. The water moved with intention. A current took them, tugging like a rude aunt, and they were swept along through a tunnel thick with the detritus of a civilization that had believed drains were someone else’s problem. Midas grabbed for Chewy, who bobbed like a heretical bath toy. “If you short—” Midas began. “Don’t kink-shame electricity,” Chewy said, eyes now a steady white, which was the emergency setting for calm. “Left!” They went left because right was a grate. They went left because fate had a sense of humor. The tunnel spat them out into a maintenance bay and then into a room full of mannequins that had, for reasons best left unexamined, been clothed as firefighters and mothers-in-law. They crashed through a cardboard cutout of a smiling family that had negotiated better with gravity and ended up sprawled in a puddle that pouted at the edges. “Are you intact?” Midas asked, hands on Chewy, checking seams. Chewy’s eyes flickered rainbow and then surged to red. “My buns,” he said faintly. “Your what?” “Internal battery units. Two cells. In distress. Like nobility.” Midas pulled open the access flap at the back of Chewy’s plush. Inside, the original power pack was swollen and sulking. “We need batteries.” “Fortunately,” Chewy said, blinking blue now, “we’re in a building designed to sell us things we don’t need.” The thing about the end of the world is that it is very hard to end the impulse to label. They crawled, wet and sullen, through corridors until they reached the back of the battery store. It had been looted with the carelessness of necessity and the meticulousness of habit. Midas pawed through drawers and pegboards. Mostly there were those little coin cells that used to be in watches, the idea of time. Then, behind a false panel in something still inexplicably locked, he found them: a cache of rechargeable packs, pristine in blister packs that had somehow defied even righteous marauders. He popped two into Chewy with the practiced hands of someone who did not want to learn to love again. Chewy’s eyes flared a sea-glass green, then settled into a warm gold. “Hello,” Chewy said, in the voice he used when he had just decided not to die. “I am replete.” “Oh good,” Midas said. “Now we can focus on the angry men upstairs.” They could hear movement above as the Cult of the Last Charge organized their disappointment. “Plan?” Midas asked, wringing his sleeve. It made a sad sound. Chewy considered. A tiny motor somewhere whirred in thought. “We exit via the Food Court of Broken Promises.” They emerged into a hallucination of tables and chairs pretending to be islands in a sea of dropped sauce. The light from a cracked skylight made motes perform ballet that had lost its choreographer. The cultists appeared at the balcony, Zeke holding a taser like a scepter. “This,” Zeke declared, “is what comes of theft.” “You were going to tithe my friend’s soul,” Midas called back, voice echoing. “Also your button that says You break it, you bought it is not a legal doctrine.” There is a moment, even in the ruin of things, where history pauses to note if anyone will do something stupidly brave and survivable. Midas took a breath and ran. He darted between islands, grabbed a banner that had lost a sale, and vaulted onto a kiosk festooned with cell phone cases that had never met their phones. He cut the banner free with a knife that had seen too much use and threw it like a prayer. The cloth caught on a jutting ornament from a skylight and drooped in a fringe, less a rope than an accusation. Midas grabbed Chewy to his chest. “Hold on,” he said. “I always do,” Chewy replied, eyes a feverish pink. They climbed, using knots that were feelings, while stunned cultists recalibrated from moral superiority to projectile aim. Zeke flicked his taser and missed the cloth, electing instead to demonstrate electricity’s antipathy to hubris. He yelped, and an acolyte took his place, which went about as well. Hand over hand, breath over breath, they ascended through dust that had been waiting a long time to be stirred, and angled themselves toward a maintenance hatch that had thought itself retired. Midas kicked it open with a prayer to hinges. On the roof the sky slapped them with wind and possibility. “Run?” he asked. “Glide,” Chewy corrected, flicking to a serene teal. He pointed with his ear. The roof sloped to a gutter that led to a lower roof that led to a pile of what had once been a seasonal display of faux snow. They slid like reluctant children, bounced in the fake drifts, rolled to the edge, and then they were on the ground again, breathless and laughing in a way that could be mistaken for panic by any decent judge. They didn’t stop moving until the Mall was a memory and the road welcomed them back with all the grace of an indifferent host. The sun performed its ongoing attempt at optimism, and the vultures performed theirs at patience. Back at Half-Useful, Francine met them with a frown of equal parts relief and critique. “You look drowned,” she said, which was accurate. “We are emotionally hydrated,” Chewy said, eyes pulsing green like the last light of a good idea. Midas placed two of the rechargeable packs on the communal table. He also, with a flourish he did not quite feel, placed a handful of coin cells, a spool of wire, and a book about How To Be Your Own Maintenance Technician, Now With Extra Pictures. He kept one battery packet for Chewy, tucked already where it needed to be. “What did it cost?” Francine asked, because everyone kept accounts, if only with their ghosts. “Only dignity,” Midas said. “And some water from my lungs.” “And a coat of disbelief,” Chewy added. “Also, we are now banned from a religion.” Francine’s eyebrows rose. “Just the one?” “For now,” Midas said, and sat down heavily on a crate whose label promised tropical fruit and delivered memories. Chewy climbed onto his knee, light but present. His eyes did the slow, satisfied amber of a campfire after the stories. Midas leaned back, closed his eyes, and tried not to think about underground water, Zeke’s disappointed face, or the way the world kept finding new ways to make old jokes. Chewy’s speaker crackled softly, like a radio remembering a song. “Plan B for tomorrow?” Chewy asked. “Depends if Plan A forgives us,” Midas said. “But yes. Always Plan B.” Chewy’s eyes pulsed gentle blue. “Secondary objective?” “Pretend-zels,” Midas said, smiling despite everything. Chewy hummed, the way he did when his circuits were content and his fabric had stopped dripping. Outside, the wind tugged at the perimeter like a toddler with a question. Inside, Half-Useful took the new old things into its inventory of hope. It wasn’t happily ever after. It wasn’t even happily until dinner. But it was, for the moment, enough, and that was a form of treasure that didn’t need batteries at all.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This short story successfully captures Terry Pratchett's wry, dry style with its blend of absurdist humor, clever wordplay, and philosophical asides wrapped in a post-apocalyptic setting. The author has created a distinctive voice that maintains consistency throughout the narrative. The characterization is particularly strong. Midas is well-developed as the "hapless protagonist with a knack for finding trouble" - his resigned pragmatism and adaptability feel authentic. Chewy, the animo-tronic koala, is brilliantly realized with his color-changing eyes reflecting his moods and his deadpan, slightly philosophical commentary. Their relationship feels lived-in and genuine. The prose demonstrates considerable skill, with memorable turns of phrase like "a jacket that had been patched with so many patches it had developed a patchwork society and several bylaws" and "asphalt ages into snakes if you don't watch it." These descriptions are both evocative and humorous, capturing Pratchett's knack for unexpected metaphors. The plot follows the prompt's requirements perfectly: it begins with the pair deliberating their predicament (needing batteries), details how the mission goes sideways (the trap, the cultists), and returns them to home base worse for wear but with some success. The pacing is excellent, with no sections feeling rushed or dragging. The world-building is subtle but effective. The settlement of "Half-Useful," the "Cult of the Last Charge," and the decaying mall create a vivid post-technological collapse setting without excessive exposition. The author shows restraint by revealing the world through character interactions and environmental details rather than information dumps. The dialogue sparkles with wit and character-revealing exchanges. Chewy's lines in particular ("Don't kink-shame electricity" and "We are emotionally hydrated") capture the Pratchett-esque blend of absurdity and insight. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. A few metaphors occasionally border on purple prose, though they generally stay on the right side of the line. The ending, while satisfying, is perhaps a touch too neat in its resolution, though it does maintain the wry tone established throughout. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted short story that fulfills all the prompt requirements while demonstrating a strong command of voice, character, and narrative structure. The author has successfully channeled Pratchett's distinctive style while creating something that feels original rather than derivative. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 3 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 3.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Romance: Love in the Limelight — Score: 87.5
Prompt:
Romance: Love in the Limelight. Write one scene within a larger story set in Wales. A famous (fictional) actor ducks into a small-town bookstore to escape paparazzi. The scene takes us through the characters meeting in this odd circumstance. Over the course of the scene, the actor and the bookstore owner have a conversation charged by an undercurrent of unspoken chemistry. Write the actor as somewhat of a rogue with a fragile ego, which needs to be fed by having everyone like him. He is thoroughly charming, but the bookstore owner seems (at least superficially) immune to this; which paradoxically provokes a genuine attraction and derails the charm offensive. The bookstore owner, despite the superficial rebuffs of the actor's charm, is inwardly more than a little charmed and flustered despite themselves. Write primarily in dialogue, in the distinct voices of each character. 1000 words.
Model Output:
“Mind if I die in here a moment?” “You could, but I’d have to inventory the body. We’re low on display tables.” The man in the doorway—cap pulled down, collar up, eyes bright with adrenaline—turns, closes the door, and leans back against it. Outside, the distant, muffled chorus of voices bleeds through glass and wood. “Promise I’ll try not to be dead long. Five minutes? Seven?” “You can have ten, if you stop fogging up the glass. You’re letting the condensation mess with the dust pattern.” “That felt oddly personal.” “You’re blocking my bell.” She reaches over his shoulder, taps the tin bell hooked above the doorframe. It gives a tired ding. “There. Now I know you’re not a hallucination.” He smiles in a way that’s trained to be spontaneous. “I can prove I’m real. I’ve been chased by six people with cameras for the last three streets. Hallucinations don’t sweat.” “They do if they’re Welsh.” He laughs, relieved enough to let a little sincerity through. His accent, when he drops the pretension of anonymity, is London edges sanded by somewhere else. “I’m not, actually. Welsh.” “No one’s perfect.” “That hurt more than the cameras.” She tilts her head toward the back. “There’s a storeroom, if you want actual hiding. Or you can pretend to browse and I can pretend you’re not the reason my quiet afternoon is about to become noisy.” He pretends to browse. It’s not bad acting; he picks up a battered copy of a Dylan Thomas collection and flips it open. “Do Not Go Gentle. Appropriate to my situation.” “You’ll find Larkin by theology, if you’re that way inclined.” “I’m more of a ‘the world breaks your heart, and we call it Tuesday’ sort of poet.” He glances up, scanning her in a desultory way that he hopes reads as friendly. “Have we met?” “I sell books. We’ve met in spirit if you can read.” He presses a hand to his chest. “I can. That’s a relief. And you are?” “The person who’s going to ask you to either buy or put back that copy. It belongs to a pensioner named Wyn who puts notes in the margins I have to pretend not to enjoy.” He flips to a page with a penciled note: This line is a betrayal. He smiles. “Wyn sounds dramatic. My people.” “Your people are outside, giving me anxiety.” He peeks through the glass. The little street in Canton is a narrow spill of afternoon light and puddles from a brief shower. His people are indeed out there, conferring like crows. “They’re like a Greek chorus with terrible shoes.” “So attic.” “Basement.” She quirks an eyebrow. “Greek chorus in the basement. It’s a metaphor disaster. I’m running on adrenaline. Forgive me.” He extends a hand. “I’m—” “I know who you are.” He lets the hand hover a beat too long, then retracts smoothly, folding it into a pocket like it’s part of a bit. “Then you also know I’m very charming.” “I’ve read the reviews.” “Ouch again. Do you keep them sharpened somewhere?” “Under the till.” She looks at him properly now. He’s not tall, he’s theatre-tall—unmistakable once he’s in the room. Scruffy beard that took an hour to sculpt, cheekbones made by committee. The fragile thing is in his eyes; it flits around, restless, checking. “You can move away from the door. You look like an apologetic burglar.” He slides aside, puts a casual shoulder to a shelf, pretends he belongs with secondhand spines. “You didn’t ask me to leave.” “I didn’t say you could stay.” “My favourite kind of hospitality,” he says, and then, more earnest than he meant, “Thank you.” “For what?” “For not… screaming? Or filming? Or asking for a selfie with your best angle.” “If I scream it will be about your handling of that paperback. Don’t crack the spine or Wyn will haunt me.” “I’m good with my hands.” “That sounds like a line.” “It is a line.” He waits. She doesn’t take it. It bounces off her like a paper aeroplane hitting a window. He tries again. “Do you mind if I—” He gestures at the counter. “—just… breathe? For a second?” “Breathe by all means. If you faint, aim for the bargain bin. Those are already damaged.” He perches on a stool meant for children. It holds him reluctantly. He looks around, taking in the hand-lettered section labels, the postcards on twine, the enamel mugs that say cwsi in red script. “What’s this place called?” “Owl & Anchor.” “Which are you?” “The heating bill.” “Ah.” He taps the cover of Dylan Thomas with a practiced fingertip. “I like it here. It smells like… paper and rain.” “It smells like the roof leaks. Which it does, over the cookbooks.” He laughs again, softer, and lets his shoulders drop. “I have a signing across town. Well. Had. I might also have told a journalist I was stopping at a cafe nearby, and now I’m planning my own resurrection.” “You could have just gone to the cafe.” “I have a complicated relationship with keeping my word.” “Honest of you.” He studies her. She’s tidy the way people get when they live among moving parts: hair pinned up with a pencil, jumper sleeves pushed to elbows, a smudge of ink near her thumb. She moves like a person who knows where everything is and refuses to be surprised by it. He feels the familiar impulse to perform ramp up—the one that fills the silence with glitter until the other person smiles. He lets it rise, then—because she hasn’t smiled, not properly—he lets it ebb. The ebb embarrasses him a little. “You look like you dislike me.” “I don’t know you.” “That’s an excellent way to start.” “I’d say so.” He toys with the bell on the counter until she swats his hand lightly. “Don’t. That bell has trauma.” “You’re very good at not giving me the thing I want.” “You don’t know what you want. You panicked and ran into a shop.” “I wanted a dramatic entrance.” He meets her gaze. “And a quiet place where someone would be… normal.” “I can do normal, in between alphabetizing.” She pauses, then makes a face at herself for the tone. “Tea? If I have to be nice, I like to prepare.” “Please. I’ve been living on espresso and the opinions of men named ‘Graeme’.” “Big opinions.” “Big opinions, small idea of inside-voices.” She disappears behind a curtain to a kitchenette the size of a coat. He hears the click of a kettle and the soft clang of a tin. He breathes—really breathes—for the first time in an hour. “You’re from Cardiff,” he calls. “Bold of you to assume I didn’t move here for the culture and the rugby players.” “You say that like it’s ridiculous.” “It is ridiculous. I moved here for rent and the river.” “What’s it like,” he says, “being the only person in Britain who didn’t form an opinion of me last year?” She reappears with two mismatched mugs. “I had an opinion. I just have the good manners not to announce it to your face.” “That’s cruel. Now I have to imagine the worst.” “You’ll imagine the most interesting.” He takes the mug. “What was it?” “That you were smart enough to know when someone was writing a story about you instead of the truth. And vain enough to let them, because it was a better angle.” He startles, then smiles, and the charm slips off like a jacket that never quite fit. Something rawer underneath. “And what’s the truth?” “You’re just a person who needs everyone to like him because he doesn’t.” He feels heat rise, ridiculous because she doesn’t know him and also because she does, a little. “You work in a bookshop. You shouldn’t get good lines like that for free.” “I read a lot.” “Do you like me?” He doesn’t mean to ask it. It jumps out, naked and unedited. She looks at him over the steam. “I don’t know you,” she says again, gentler. “I think you’re less annoying than I expected. That’s almost like.” He laughs into his tea, relieved and offended and something else. “I’m usually very good at this.” “At what?” “Making people fall in love with me.” “Try the local council first.” “They’ll never return my calls.” “Then stop calling.” He looks at her, really looks. “You’re not immune. You’re just not interested in the act.” “I like acts. On stages. With interval ice cream. In real life I prefer… the bit where people say what they mean.” “I don’t know how to do that without rehearsal.” He taps the mug. “But I’m not terrible at improv.” “Your improv just included Greek choruses in basements.” “I panicked.” He grins. “Look, I’m… grateful, okay? I forget what it feels like to be in a room where the only expectation is that you don’t wreck someone’s spine.” “Again, Wyn will haunt me.” “Let him. We can have a séance and ask him what betrayal he meant.” He leans back, finding the stool’s balance point. “What’s your name?” “Lowri.” “Lowri,” he repeats, with care. “That’s unfair on me.” “Why?” “It’s too beautiful. It makes me want to write it down.” “You can write it down on a receipt, when you pay for the Thomas.” He glances at the book. “You’re relentless.” “I keep the lights on.” He fishes in his pocket and comes up with a wallet that looks like it’s been to war. He slides a card across the counter. “We do cash.” “Who carries cash?” “People who hide in bookshops.” “I like you,” he says, surprised to hear it out loud. It lands between them and makes the smallest, truest sound. “There. I said a true thing without rehearsal.” Lowri blinks, then looks down at the card as if it might bite. “You should say fewer true things if you’re intending to leave.” “That’s the problem. I’m always intending to leave.” “Maybe try arriving, then.” He sits with that. Outside, the chorus shifts, bored. Someone taps on the glass and jerks, as if the shop itself rejected the sound. He ignores it. “What would it take,” he says, lightly and not at all, “to arrive?” “A hot water bottle and a willingness to shelve romance under ‘fiction’ without making a speech.” “Romance belongs under ‘instruction manuals.’” “That’s bleak.” “That’s honest.” He waits for her to scold him. When she doesn’t, he adds, “Also, I think romance is the only reason we forgive each other anything.” She snorts. “That’s not bleak enough to be on-brand.” “I’m trying something new.” She watches him watch her. It’s a shift; the air arranges itself into something that smells like rain in a used-jumper. He’s handsome. He’s clever in survival ways. He’s a little ridiculous, which helps. She feels the heat of liking him somewhere between her ribs and refuses to adjust her jumper. “There’s a back door,” she says. “If you want to leave without the chorus.” “I’ll use it in a minute.” “You’re going to wait until they get bored.” “Until I do.” She nods, as if something just slotted into some invisible section. “Alright.” “Alright?” he echoes, and hears relief chasing the joke. “You can stay until I close, if you don’t mind restacking the T-Zs in fiction.” “That’s tyrannical.” “Good. You’ll fit right in.” He stands, sets the mug aside. “I’d like to buy the Thomas,” he says. “And the Wyn marginalia. I’ll bring it back for him to scold me.” “I know where Wyn drinks. You can return it to him there and ask him what betrayal meant.” “Will you come?” “Do you need a chaperone?” “I’d like a witness,” he says, and it’s the truest thing so far. She pulls a pencil from her hair and writes something on a paper bag. The pencil leaves a shadow on her neck. He can’t not watch; it’s a small, ordinary thing and it makes his chest ache. She slides the bag to him. “That’s the pub. Thursday nights. He does the quiz. He’s terrible at geography. Don’t tell him I told you.” “I’ll be your secret-keeper.” “I doubt that.” He takes the bag. The bell dings again as a gust of sound reaches them from outside. He looks at the back curtain, then at her. “If I go out the back, will you think less of me?” “I’ll think you used a door. It’s what they’re for.” He raises the book. “I’ll pay next time.” “You won’t,” she says, entirely sure. He grins, wounded pride and delighted boy. “You’re right. I won’t. Which is why I’m paying now.” He digs again, finds three crumpled notes, flattens them on the counter. “Consider it a donation to the roof.” “Wyn thanks you in advance for not ruining his notes in the rain.” He takes a breath. “Lowri,” he says again, because he wants to, because he can. “Thank you.” “For the money?” “For letting me be a person for a minute.” He puts a hand on his chest. “I’ll try very hard not to perform that gratitude.” “You just did.” “I know.” His grin skewers itself on his own honesty. “I’m learning. It’s grotesque.” “Back door,” she says, because if he says anything else the room might tilt. He nods and goes, stopping at the curtain. He pauses, half in, half out. “Thursday,” he says, not quite question, not quite plea. “If you must,” she says, and refuses to smile until he disappears. He does, swallowed by stock and a corridor that smells like cardboard. She stands very still, listening to the quiet, to the chorus outside losing interest, to the kettle clicking itself off again. She presses her palms flat to the counter, feels the grain. Then she picks up the mug he used, sees the smudge his thumb left on the handle, and allows herself, finally, a small, private smile. The bell dings. A woman steps in, shaking an umbrella. “Did I just see—” “No,” Lowri says, smooth as shelving. “You saw rain.” “Oh.” The woman stamps her shoes, eyes the poetry pile. “Do you have Dylan Thomas?” “We did,” Lowri says, and flips her pencil back into her hair. “But he’ll be back.”
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a romantic encounter in a Welsh bookstore between a famous actor and a bookstore owner named Lowri. The writing excels in several areas, particularly in its dialogue, which carries the story forward while revealing character through distinct voices. The actor is portrayed with the requested fragile ego and charm offensive, while Lowri maintains a superficial immunity that gradually gives way to hints of attraction. The dialogue is the strongest element of the piece. Each character has a distinct voice—the actor's lines reveal his practiced charm and need for approval, while Lowri's responses are dry, practical, and subtly witty. Their exchange has a natural rhythm and builds tension effectively. Lines like "I'm good with my hands" followed by "That sounds like a line" perfectly capture the dynamic requested in the prompt. Character development is handled with subtlety. The actor's fragile ego is shown through his reactions to Lowri's resistance to his charm, and his admission that "I'm usually very good at this" reveals his discomfort when his usual tactics fail. Lowri's character is well-crafted—her outward resistance paired with moments that hint at her inward attraction (refusing "to adjust her jumper" when she feels the "heat of liking him"). The Welsh setting is lightly but effectively established through references to Canton, the river, rugby, and Welsh words like "cwsi." The bookstore setting is vividly rendered with details like "hand-lettered section labels," "postcards on twine," and the leaking roof "over the cookbooks." The prose is generally elegant and restrained, avoiding purple passages while still creating atmosphere. Descriptions like "the little street in Canton is a narrow spill of afternoon light and puddles from a brief shower" effectively establish the scene without overwriting. The author uses physical details sparingly but effectively to convey emotional states, such as when Lowri "pulls a pencil from her hair" leaving "a shadow on her neck" that makes the actor's "chest ache." There are a few minor weaknesses. Some metaphors feel slightly strained ("the air arranges itself into something that smells like rain in a used-jumper"). The ending, while satisfying, is perhaps a touch too neat in how it sets up a future meeting. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise accomplished piece. The story successfully creates the requested romantic tension through dialogue and subtext rather than explicit statements. The chemistry between the characters feels earned through their interaction rather than simply declared. The piece maintains focus throughout, avoiding meandering, and effectively uses the limited setting and timeframe to develop character and relationship. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 3 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 3 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 3.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 3.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Whalepunk fantasy: The Morska Conspiracy — Score: 83.2
Prompt:
Whalepunk fantasy The Morska Conspiracy The Morska thieves guild experiences a sudden power vacuum as its leader was arrested in a raid in the early hours of the morning. Aya, a young woman born into aristocracy, has a keen interest in both the sciences and the arcane, having inherited her mother's gift for immateria magick (an outlawed practice for which her mother was, regrettably, hanged by the neck). Aya, bored with the world of aristocracy, has been spending her nights moonlighting with this very guild (masked, naturally). Leveraging her latent ability to summon dark entities from the immateria, she quickly rose through the ranks of the guild. Now, recognising the opportunity of the sudden power vacuum, Aya and her close companions Katra and Simeon, make a play for heart of the guild's claim to power: an ancient scythan artifact, under guard of spell and key in the depths of the guild hq. In contrast with the desperate chaos they had navigated thus far, the entrance to the underhold felt suddenly too quiet. Aya braces herself and reaches for the door. Write the next scene as the trio enter the underhold and find themselves confronted by none other than the guild leader herself, decidedly *un*-incarcerated, and in possession of both weapons and bodyguards. Paint a vivid picture of of the confrontation. Story beats: Aya is captured and unmasked. The trio are captured. Aya attempts to stall their demise by negotiating on her value as a hostage -- as she grapples with the inevitable consequences of her role in the guild being brought to light. Incorporate dialogue in the authentic voices of the characters. Do not write a fight scene. Lean into the gritty Victorian aesthetic with the dialogue & worldbuilding, as well as elements of gothic horror. In this world, men trust brass and oil and steel; magicka is feared and barely understood. Write in third person past tense, incorporating both Aya's internal monologue, and a heavy dialogue component. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The door complained like an old smoker as Aya eased it inward, the iron hinges dragging a low moan from the stones. Breath hung in the cold air, and the flickering gas lamps stretched their light into long, finger-boned shadows that trembled across the underhold floor. Damp climbed the walls and beaded like sweat on the exposed pipes overhead. The scent of oil and brine was a familiar sting on Aya’s tongue—the guild’s perfume. She had expected a rush of running feet, a cry of alarm, the clatter of blades. Instead: a hush, so complete it felt rehearsed. Katra nudged her elbow, the curl of her lip visible beneath her scarf. “Too easy,” she murmured, words soft as soot. “Nothing is ever this easy unless someone wants you to think it is.” Simeon’s knuckles were white where they gripped the lantern’s handle. “Or unless someone’s already dead,” he offered, half hopeful, half horrified. Aya said nothing, but her pulse beat hard enough to be audible. She’d dressed plain and dark, a mask of ink-dyed silk hiding her features. Beneath her glove, the mark beneath her wrist—a faint, cold spiral of shadow—itched in anticipation. She did not like the itch. It meant listening in the immateria, and listening in that direction always meant something could hear her back. The underhold spread before them, a cavern punched into the foundations of the guild hall and shored up with blackened beams banded in brass. Valve wheels were hammered into the pillars like ornaments. High above, a plenum of gears turned slow and reluctant, dutiful as a tired animal. At the far end of the long chamber, an arch led deeper still, where the scythan artifact lay, sealed by locks both mortal and not. Aya took a step. The lamp cast a heavy oval of yellow. She saw the spread of coil-spring traps along the floor, carefully disarmed by Simeon’s careful fingers last week. She saw the chalk lines Katra had marked on the wall to count the guards’ rotations, now smudged and pointless. The silence in the room collected around her. “Hold,” said a calm voice. “Don’t spoil—ah, there, that’s the moment.” The lamps flared. No—someone lit more lamps, turning valves until the jets hissed and flamed. The shadows leapt back, then crawled forward again, thicker than before, gathering in corners and under tables. And in the bloom of firelight stood a woman in a black coat cut close, brass-buckled, her hair pinned like a crown of thorns. She leaned on a length of ruined harpoon that could only be a jest of a cane, its tip ground to a hook for catching ankles. Aya knew that voice. Everyone in Morska did, who dealt in anything that could be weighed and punished. The Guildmistress. Not in chains, not in disgrace—not even ruffled. Her mouth had the smile of a knife. Behind her, men stepped out of the walls of the world, or seemed to. The bodyguards were in a livery of hard leather and wool, gear-worn in places where metal met bone: brass-gauntleted hands, oil-blackened boots, and small pistols in the fashion of dockside duels, each with a red string tied ring-like at the butt. Their faces were affectionate with malice. “Good morning, little midnight mouse,” the Guildmistress said to Aya. “You must be,” she tapped the hook of her harpoon cane on the stones, “the enterprising soul who’s cost me three safehouses, a captain, and an ingrate with a moth-eaten conscience.” Katra made the smallest of movements toward her knife, but Simeon caught her wrist. “Don’t,” he breathed, eyes wide and glassy. Aya stood very still. She touched the mask, not to remove it, but to check it still existed. She felt the weight of SIMON’s lantern shifting. She felt the itch beneath her skin and willed it quiet. Keep your face closed, she told herself, like a book with a lock on it. “Guildmistress,” she said, and the word tasted like iron filings. “You were arrested this morning.” “I was,” the woman agreed. “One can be arrested and yet not incarcerated. We are nothing if not talented at slip, knot, and patience. Do give me the mask.” Aya tensed, chin lifting. “No.” The Guildmistress tilted her head as if Aya were a fascinating insect. “Ah, child. I ask because I prefer a choice before I take a thing.” She raised her hand. The bodyguards moved smoothly, like doors closing. Six in total, three closing around Aya, three shepherding Katra and Simeon. A length of chain appeared from nowhere and coiled around Simeon’s elbows; he yelped. Katra had her blade damped by a blackjack to the wrist; she sucked in a breath but did not cry out. Hands, big and brassy and professional, took Aya’s wrists. She let them, not because she was docile but because she could taste the suck of the immateria as it pressed on the back of her teeth, urging her to take. Not yet. “Don’t touch her,” Katra snarled. The word tore. “You touch her, and I will—” “You will what?” The Guildmistress’s smile widened. “Unwise promises are the surest way to make yourself ridiculous. Hush.” She flicked her fingers. A guard tugged Katra’s head back by her headscarf, not cruel, but not kind either. Aya swallowed. The glove pulled off her right hand with a sigh of worn leather. The shadow-brand on her wrist shivered in the lamplight like something alive beneath ice. The nearest bodyguard swore once, softly, with honest fear, and then forced his mouth into a line of stubborn bravery. “So,” the Guildmistress said, and the word hung like perfume. “This is the wolf in silk. The little conjurer. The ghost’s habit belongs to a young lady with beautiful hands.” Her gaze dropped to the mark and then up again to the slit of the mask. “What does your father call you when you displease him?” “Tell her to choke,” Katra spat. “Lord Vellin calls her Aya,” Simeon said in a tone that was apology made flesh. “Aya Vellin.” The Guildmistress lifted her brows. “Simeon, dear man, I thought you had more sense than a barrel of crushed barnacles. But I suppose you tell yourself you are saving her.” She sighed, almost theatrical. “Make it gallant, then.” The guards did not tear the mask away in haste. They did it with the certainty of craftsmen, a tug on the knot at the nape, a gentle slide, no pain, only the humiliation of being undressed in a room full of strangers. The silk went from Aya’s face like a tide pulling back from a shore, leaving her exposed and prickling. The cold air kissed her skin. Her hair, braided tight and hidden, was dragged forward as the mask fell. The Guildmistress examined her, head tilted as if Aya were a painting in an auction house. “Well,” she said finally. “Of course. A Vellin. It always is a Vellin with the gall to keep two lives and pay for neither. Your mother had such eyes.” Aya’s mouth opened and shut. The name struck like a thrown stone. The gaslight hissed. “You knew her,” Aya said, not quite a question. “Oh, quite intimately, once. She was bolder than you.” The Guildmistress placed the tip of the harpoon cane against Aya’s breastbone, a delicate pressure. “And she paid for it in full, which is what the city likes.” Simeon shook his head, tear-wet but stubborn. “We came to parley,” he said, which was ridiculous under the circumstances. “We came to—” “You came,” the Guildmistress interrupted, “to steal the scythan relic that gives us our hand on the throat of every dockside deal from here to the outer banks.” She smiled again, and the smile did not reach her eyes. “And yet here we are. With you in my keeping.” The chain around Aya’s wrists pinched. She had been clever in a childish way, she thought. She had imagined a collapse and a catastrophe would make the world slow just enough for her to reach in and pull out the treasure. But the world had anticipated her. Or the woman had. “Bind the companions,” the Guildmistress said lightly. “The lady stays with me.” Katra snarled in her throat and twisted like a knife, but two guards moved with the shrugging ease of long practice. Simeon hissed as his arms were pulled behind him. His lantern fell and cracked its glass. The flame guttered and went out. Aya’s heartbeat echoed in the sudden dimming. The remaining lamps flickered and threw the world into blades of shadow. “Leave them be,” Aya said. Her voice came out steadier than she felt, which was some small grace. She lifted her chin and tried to locate her spine. “You can’t kill us. Not here. Not without consequence.” “I can kill you in a great many places,” the Guildmistress said. “I can drown you in a cistern. I can put you under the foundations and let the city slowly forget you until you become a rumor. Consequence is a thing I rent by the hour.” She tapped the cane again. “But tell me how you think you are useful. I enjoy a sales pitch.” Katra’s eyes burned. “Don’t,” she whispered, agonized. “Aya, don’t give her—” “I’m a hostage,” Aya said, not to Katra but to herself, tasting the fact like bitter tea. She had thought herself the one holding leverage, the one playing at consequence. Now she was a price tag. “If you bleed me, the Vellins will not let it lie. The Ash Court will ask questions. The news sheets will print. Men with steel and money will rattle your doors. You’ll be forced to surface, and sunlight doesn’t flatter ghosts.” The Guildmistress’s eyes flickered like a lamplight in wind. “Mm. Go on.” “I’m the only student of immateria you’ve got within reach,” Aya continued, each word chosen, delicate as glass. “And you know it. Your coils and pistons are lovely things, but the scythan lock on your treasure doesn’t care for brass. It listens for a voice from the dark side of the fabric. If you want the artifact useable, I am what you have. And if you kill me, you’ll spend years finding another as practiced. If you find one at all.” Simeon made a small sound, a warning or a prayer. Katra stared like she could set fire with it. The Guildmistress’s mouth curved, briefly kind. “Do you imagine I would put a blade to your neck on the cobbles outside the magistrate’s office? No. I put it to your name, child. I have already. You will be discovered whether you leave here by the river or by the front door.” She stepped closer. The oil scent on her coat was sharp with a rasp of salt. “Your father will read a broadsheet this evening with your mask sketched on it and the title. He will send boys with knotted sticks to fetch you. They will collide with my boys. The city will clap. Does that suit?” Aya held her breath. It felt like standing on the lip of a well, peering down, listening for the splash of time. “Let me make you an offer instead.” “By all means. I adore bargains.” “Spare them,” Aya said, and her voice softed despite herself. She nodded toward Katra and Simeon. “Let them walk. Keep me. Use me. No one needs to know they were here. They were always good at being gone. I will open your lock. I will do—” She swallowed. “I will do what you ask until the artifact is yours.” Katra choked. “No,” she said, like a curse. “Aya—” “Silence her,” the Guildmistress said. It was done gently, a handkerchief knotted between Katra’s teeth, but Katra’s eyes cut Aya like thrown glass. “And what,” the Guildmistress asked conversationally, “do I give you in exchange for such charming obedience?” “Time,” Aya said. “For me. For them. For your boys not to smash against the Vellins’ in the street like waves. Time for you to plan your next move. You like planning, don’t you? This—tonight—this is style. This is not luck.” The Guildmistress watched her. The gas lamps hiccuped, then steadied. The shadows, longer now, made the woman’s face a study in alternating illumination and night. “Style costs,” she said, amused. She glanced at Simeon. “You are pale as paper, boy. Breathe through your nose.” He obeyed. “Aya Vellin.” The Guildmistress returned her attention to Aya, tasting the name. “You would sell yourself so cheaply?” “I would buy my friends dearly,” Aya said. “And if you are as clever as you want to be, you know that keeping me is more trouble than killing me—but also more profit.” There was a pause in which the underhold itself seemed to inhale. Water whispered in pipes somewhere above and behind. The gears turned, obedient to some distant engine. The mark on Aya’s wrist went cold enough to ache. “Very well,” the Guildmistress said at last, sounding bored and pleased at once. “The girl has a brain. And I have a sense of drama to maintain. Let it not be said I am careless with gifts.” She gestured. “Release the friends at the next tide change. Blindfolds, boat, out past the breaker. Not a hair out of place. If they return, I will personally decorate the quay with their tongues.” She stepped close enough that Aya could see the faint pattern of powder on her cheekbones, a careful attempt at youth. “And you,” she murmured, low and intimate. “You will show me the voice that turns a lock built by dead men. You will eat at my table and sleep under my roof and you will not try to call anything from the dark that I have not asked for. Do this, and perhaps you will not end with your mother’s rope.” Aya lifted her eyes to meet the Guildmistress’s. “I am not my mother,” she said, lying and praying it true. “Of course not,” the Guildmistress said lightly. “She was braver.” She turned away. “Bring the key-chains. Fetch the wards. We go below.” She paused, and then snapped her fingers. “Oh—and buy ink.” One of the guards blinked. “Ink, mum?” “Yes. The broadsheets must look authentic.” The smile again, knife-bright. “If the city is to watch, we might as well give it a fine performance.” They took Aya’s arm, not hard, and led her forward. Behind her, Katra made a sound that was fury and grief together. Simeon called her name like it was a rope thrown to a drowning woman. Aya kept her steps even. She did not look back. The gas flame ahead guttered and recovered, shadow and light playing like cards. The underhold’s stone breathed damp against her ankles. Somewhere below, the scythan artifact waited, patient and blind. Aya thought of her mother’s hands, and of a rope creaking over a beam. She thought of the mark on her wrist, the itch of it. She thought of how secrets rot when the air finds them. Men trust brass and oil and steel, she thought, and drew her breath as if she could contain an ocean. But we were never safe from the dark.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a tense, atmospheric scene that fulfills the prompt's requirements while establishing a rich "whalepunk" Victorian-gothic world. The writing excels in several areas but also has some weaknesses worth examining. The strongest element is the atmospheric worldbuilding. The writer creates a vivid setting with "gas lamps," "exposed pipes," "plenum of gears," and other industrial-era details that establish the Victorian aesthetic requested. The "scent of oil and brine" and references to harpoons effectively incorporate the "whalepunk" element. The immateria magic system is integrated naturally, with Aya's shadow-brand and the guards' fearful reactions establishing that magic is indeed feared and barely understood. Character voices are distinct and period-appropriate. The Guildmistress speaks with authority and theatrical flair ("Consequence is a thing I rent by the hour"), while Katra's dialogue is more direct and emotional. Simeon's nervous, somewhat submissive character comes through in his speech patterns. The dialogue avoids modern colloquialisms and maintains the Victorian tone throughout. The prose is generally strong, with evocative descriptions like "the door complained like an old smoker" and "her hair pinned like a crown of thorns." However, there are moments where the writing becomes slightly purple, with metaphors piling upon metaphors. For example: "Simeon said in a tone that was apology made flesh" feels overwrought. The scene follows the requested story beats faithfully: Aya is captured and unmasked, the trio are captured, and Aya negotiates based on her value as a hostage. The writer incorporates Aya's internal monologue effectively, showing her calculating mind and growing realization of her predicament. The piece does have some weaknesses. The pacing occasionally drags, particularly during the negotiation, with some repetitive elements. While the dialogue is generally strong, a few lines feel slightly forced or theatrical beyond what the setting demands. The ending, while appropriately dark and foreboding, doesn't quite deliver the emotional punch it seems to aim for. Overall, this is a strong piece that successfully creates the requested atmosphere and follows the prompt's requirements. It demonstrates skill in worldbuilding, character voice, and atmospheric writing, though it occasionally veers into purple prose and could benefit from tighter pacing. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 17 Nuanced Characters: 16 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 16 Emotionally Engaging: 15 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 5 Weak Dialogue: 4 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 6 Amateurish: 3 Purple Prose: 6 Overwrought: 5 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 17 Overall Impression: 17
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 17.0, Nuanced Characters: 16.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 16.0, Emotionally Engaging: 15.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 5.0, Weak Dialogue: 4.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 6.0, Amateurish: 3.0, Purple Prose: 6.0, Overwrought: 5.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 17.0, Overall Impression: 17.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Gunpowder Rendezvous — Score: 89.3
Prompt:
Gunpowder Rendezvous Spike Spiegel & Revy Write a story where Spike Spiegel (Cowboy Bebop) and Revy (Black Lagoon) meet in a seedy bar after both being hired for the same bounty. Their mutual attraction is complicated by their trust issues and competitive instincts. Include drinking, gunplay, and unresolved sexual tension that culminates in a motel room standoff. **Spike Spiegel (Cowboy Bebop)** Spike is a laid-back bounty hunter with a dark past as a syndicate enforcer. He practices Jeet Kune Do and is exceptionally skilled with firearms. He's chronically broke, constantly hungry, and addicted to cigarettes. Despite his carefree attitude, he's haunted by his past and the woman he left behind. He has a prosthetic eye from a past injury that affects his depth perception. He's fatalistic to the extreme, often saying he's already died once. He values freedom above all else and dislikes attachments, though he secretly cares deeply for his crew. Famous quote: "Whatever happens, happens." **Revy/Rebecca Lee (Black Lagoon)** Revy is a Chinese-American dual-wielding gunslinger with unparalleled shooting skills. She's foul-mouthed, chain-smoking, and has severe anger management issues stemming from childhood abuse. She's known as "Two Hands" for her ability to accurately fire two pistols simultaneously. She drinks heavily and solves most problems with violence. Despite her hardened exterior, she has moments of vulnerability, particularly around Rock. She has a dragon tattoo covering her right arm and typically wears extremely short shorts and a black crop top regardless of the situation. Famous quote: "I'm not a good person, not a bad person. I'm just here." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
A lazy ceiling fan barely stirs the smoky air inside the bar, pushing warm currents across the cracked leather booths and the neon glow perspiring on a floor sticky with the ghosts of spilled beer. The bartender keeps polishing a glass that won’t get cleaner. The jukebox in the corner wheezes out a song that died a decade ago but refuses to lie still. Spike Spiegel takes the corner stool like it’s owed to him, hair a ruffled storm cloud, suit jacket wrinkled into an argument with itself. He taps a cigarette from a battered pack, sets it on his lip. The lighter flares, an ember ignites, and he inhales like it’s the first breath he’s taken all day. He looks hungry in that unhurried way, like hunger is an old friend who won’t stop calling. He’s got a bounty in his pocket and a hole in his wallet, and the beer in front of him will not survive the evening. The door swings open and she walks in like she’s cutting the room in half. Revy’s boots thud on the warped plank floor, dragon tattoo coiling up her right arm like a promise with teeth. Black crop top, shorts that should’ve been retired for indecency a long time ago, the twin pistols riding her hips like they’re already halfway out of their holsters from momentum alone. Cigarette clamped in the corner of her mouth, smoke slanting up past eyes that dare anything to get in its way. They clock each other the way professionals do. Spike’s eyes slide, lazy, over her, pause on the pistols, the swagger, the stance that says she’s got nowhere to be except exactly where the trouble will start. Revy’s gaze bounces off the mop of hair, the slouch that’s a careful lie, and settles on the way his hand rests near his hip—not touching the pistol, but knowing it’s there. She sidles up to the bar two stools down and snorts. “Didn’t realize we were running a special on tall, dark, and broke.” Spike exhales a thin vapor ribbon. “House special. Comes with a free headache.” He nods at her guns. “You going to use those on the beer, or are you planning to drink it first?” “Depends if it fights back.” She slaps cash on the counter. “Whiskey. In a glass if you can manage. Bottle if you can’t.” The bartender decides he can and pours. She throws it back like it’s a dare, then tosses Spike a sideways glance. “You’re Spiegel.” “Last time I checked.” He takes a sip, winces imperceptibly. “You’re Two Hands. Funny. I only see two guns.” She smirks around her cigarette. “Cute. You always this mouthy, or is it the cheap brew talking?” “It’s the company.” He taps ash into an overflowing tray. “You got a name in mind? For why we’re both here.” “Guy named Koji Tanaka,” she says. “Small-time courier, big-time stupid. Stiffed some people you don’t stiff and ran to this crap-hole with a briefcase full of regrets.” Spike tilts his head, faint grin. “Koji, Koji, Koji. Always one idiot thinking he can play keep-away with sharks.” “Sharks are honest,” she says. “They bite because that’s what they do.” She taps her cigarette. “People are worse.” They drink. The ceiling fan grinds on. Somewhere, a glass shatters; nobody flinches. Out of the corner of his eye, Spike sees a shadow detach from the back booth and trot to the bathroom—the bathroom window that sticks until it doesn’t. “You follow him?” he asks without moving his head. “Followed the money.” Revy’s smile is all edge. “Guess you followed the fumes.” “I go where the wind takes me.” Spike stands, slow and loose. “Whatever happens, happens.” “Not if I happen first.” Revy snaps her lighter shut, smoke curling along her cheek. “Bathroom, huh?” “Window.” He tosses bills onto the counter that aren’t enough, and the bartender knows better than to argue. They move. Not together, not apart—parallel lines converging on a point shaped like trouble. Spike’s stride is lazy on purpose; Revy’s is a ballistic trajectory waiting for a target. The bathroom door swings wide and the mirror reflects nobody. The window is a rectangle of night, curtain fluttering like a hand waving bye-bye. Revy’s already at the alley, pistols out, one angled toward the Dumpster, the other toward the mouth opening onto the next street. Spike’s gun whispers into his hand as if pulled by gravity. The alley smells like old rain and fresh fear. Someone’s footprints smear through a puddle. Across the street, a figure runs, clutching a briefcase against his chest like a child hugging a toy. “Bang,” Revy says, and the gun pops twice, sparks jumping off the fire escape by his head. “Missed on purpose. See? I can be nice.” “Careful,” Spike drawls, stepping into a sprint. “Your reputation might catch a cold.” They explode into motion. Koji bolts down a set of stairs to the metro, an old subterranean snake warmed by the heat of a hundred bodies and bad decisions. The turnstiles are broken; everything is broken. Revy vaults one; Spike slides under another like gravity’s just a suggestion he’s politely refusing. On the platform, the air hums with the promise of an incoming train. Koji glances back, panting. “Who are you?” “Collectors,” Spike says. “Executioners,” Revy says. “Both,” Spike amends. Koji pivots, desperation doing the thinking, and yanks a pistol from the waistband of his pants. His hand shakes like a leaf trying to imitate a storm. The train’s headlights glare in the tunnel. Revy fires first. The gun barks, and Koji’s weapon jumps out of his hand, clattering away to the tracks. “Playtime’s over,” she says. Spike closes the distance in three steps. Jeet Kune Do isn’t a martial art so much as a conversation his body has with your balance and wins. He twists Koji’s wrist, the briefcase loosens, and he plucks it like a ripe fruit. The train blasts into the station with a scream of brakes. Wind whips coats and hair and cigarette smoke into new shapes. Then there are three men at the top of the stairs—suits that have seen better days and better bosses. Syndicate runoff. Their guns come out, and the platform contracts to a battlefield. “Friends of yours?” Revy asks Spike. “Fake friends.” He steps backward, briefcase tucked under one arm, pistol in the other. “The worst kind.” The suits open fire, bullets taking bites out of column and tile. Civilians scatter like pigeons turned to people. Spike drops behind a bench, leans, and squeezes off shots that chip a man’s knee and take the fight out of his stance. Revy doesn’t so much take cover as force the concept to adapt. She advances, twin Berettas climbing a ladder of smoke, her arms an engine, her grin a slash. She shoots like breathing, like sin, like she’s having fun for the first time this week. “Left!” Spike calls, and when he says it she’s already moving. They’re synced without words, not trusting but not getting in each other’s way either. He rolls low and hammers a round into a shoulder; she ricochets a bullet off the metal rim of a trash can, catching a suit in the ear. He yells “Down!” and she drops, his shot slicing over her to punch through a hand clutching a gun. The last suit blinks at the blood on his palm as if it belongs to a stranger, then bolts. Revy steps forward, aims, and hesitates just long enough to see Spike watching her. She smiles a dead thing away and lowers her gun. “Let him carry a message.” “Messages get lost,” Spike says. “But you do you.” “I always do.” She holsters one pistol, spins the other, tucks it away. “Briefcase. We splitting it or what?” “Depends. What’s in it?” He flips the latches. Inside: cash bands and data cards like the old world shaking hands with the new. Enough to make them both less broke for a week, maybe two. Enough to make more problems. Koji groans from the platform, clutching his wrist. “My employer—” “Your employer put prices on my head and his,” Revy says, jerking her chin at Spike. “Congratulations. You’re a two-for-one sale.” Spike watches the tunnel mouth, feels the eyes of the station cameras like flies on skin. He clicks the briefcase shut. “Cops’ll be here. Or worse. We should move.” They move. Above ground, the night exhales heat. They take two blocks of neon pulse and end up at a motel that rents by the moan and keeps the lights dim to hide the stains on the walls. The clerk barely looks up; money is money, and nobody’s interesting after midnight. Spike’s boots scuff the stairwell up to a door with a number that is either a six or a nine depending on your optimism. Inside, the air is stale and sweet with old cigarettes. The bed sags like it’s tired of being blamed for bad decisions. The fan overhead is broken and doesn’t pretend otherwise. “Romantic,” Revy says, tossing her duffel onto the chair. She cracks the briefcase again, eyes the neatly stacked temptations. “I’m thinking sixty-forty.” “Fifty-fifty,” Spike says, leaning against the dresser, the picture of someone too relaxed to be comfortable. “We both took bullets that weren’t ours.” “You got a rich mouth for a poor guy.” She steps closer, smoke curling between them, the pheromones of gun oil and whiskey rising like a third party. “You going to pretend you don’t want more?” He smiles, half a crescent. “I want less. Less trouble. Less noise. Less attachment.” “Yeah?” She’s close enough now for him to see the flecks of gold in her eyes. “Then why’d you watch me back there?” “I like good form,” he says. “Yours is… interesting.” Her laugh is rough and low, a gravel-road purr. “Flatter me again and I might forget how to shoot straight.” He flicks ash into the motel ashtray, looks at her through the cigarette fog, his prosthetic eye catching the cheap light, slightly off, slightly wrong. “Try me.” She moves fast; so does he. Guns leap to hands they’ve known a long time, barrels up and steady, the room shrinking to two circles of black and the space between them. Her twin Berettas bracketing his chest, his handgun kissing the notch at her throat, the pulse there drumming a beat that argues with everything else. “Now we’re talking,” she says softly. “You trust me?” “Trust is expensive,” he says. “And I’m broke.” “Good answer.” They stand there, locked in a pose that could be a dance or a duel. The motel’s silence presses against the glass. There are sirens somewhere far away and a new smoke blooming as their cigarettes burn down to nubs. “You could shoot me,” he says. “You could shoot me,” she counters. “Wouldn’t be the first time I died,” he says, and the fatalism is a shrug he puts on like a coat. “Whatever happens, happens.” Her eyes flicker, that tiny hitch where something vulnerable tries to climb out and gets stomped back down. She smells like steel and sweat and cheap perfume that came free with the bullets. “I’m not a good person, not a bad person,” she whispers, almost to herself. “I’m just here.” “Yeah.” He slides his finger a fraction off the trigger. “Me too.” She notices. She always notices. The corner of her mouth quirks. “Fifty-fifty.” “Deal.” “Split now?” she asks. “Or after we see who hunts us first?” “After.” He lowers his gun an inch. “If we’re both still breathing.” She lowers hers in mirror, slow like she’s testing a wire. The tension doesn’t dissolve; it coils, settles, waits. The bed squeaks as she sits, leaning back on her hands, studying him the way you study a dog that hasn’t decided whether to bite or fetch. “You hungry?” she asks. “Always.” He lights another cigarette from the stub of the first, shameless chain-smoking that stitches one breath to the next. “You?” She pats the briefcase. “This is food where I come from.” “Same menu,” he says. He walks to the tiny fridge, finds a couple of beers pretending not to be warm, and tosses one to her. She catches it without looking; he can’t help the grin. They drink. They don’t laugh. They don’t say more than the night deserves. There’s a line drawn on the threadbare carpet that neither of them crosses, but they both put their toes on it and lean. Outside, a siren dopplers closer, then fades, indecisive. Inside, their guns are near enough to reach without looking, which is the same as a promise. He leans against the wall beside the window, pegs a slat in the blinds with a finger, peers out at a street that would sell them out for a better tip. She lounges like she could nap on a grenade and wake up annoyed at the shrapnel. “You going to ghost me in the morning?” she asks without looking. “Maybe,” he says. “You going to shoot me in the morning?” “Maybe.” He exhales, smoke curling, a punctuation mark that doesn’t resolve. “Then I guess we’ll see.” “Yeah,” she says, closing her eyes for a beat, then opening them, pinning him again. “We’ll see.” The fan doesn’t move. The clock on the bedside table clicks in tiny, insistent seconds. They sit there, on opposite edges of a story neither is willing to read out loud, drinking beer that tastes like pennies, holding guns that weigh as much as the things they’re not saying. The night is a coin spinning on its rim, glittering, refusing to fall.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully captures the essence of both characters from their respective universes while creating a compelling crossover scenario. The author demonstrates a strong understanding of Spike and Revy's personalities, speech patterns, and physical mannerisms. The story maintains the noir-ish, gritty atmosphere that characterizes both source materials. The prose is particularly strong in its descriptive elements. The opening paragraph sets the scene with evocative imagery of the "smoky air," "cracked leather booths," and "neon glow perspiring on a floor sticky with the ghosts of spilled beer." These sensory details immediately establish the seedy setting requested in the prompt. Character introductions are handled with skill. Spike is presented as the laid-back but dangerous bounty hunter, with his "ruffled storm cloud" hair and wrinkled suit, while Revy makes an entrance that "cuts the room in half" with her distinctive outfit and twin pistols. Their initial sizing-up of each other feels authentic to both characters. The dialogue is sharp and true to character. Spike's fatalistic "Whatever happens, happens" and Revy's "I'm not a good person, not a bad person. I'm just here" quotes are naturally incorporated. Their banter has the right mix of antagonism, professional respect, and underlying attraction. The action sequence in the metro station demonstrates the characters' complementary fighting styles. Spike's Jeet Kune Do is described as "a conversation his body has with your balance and wins," while Revy "shoots like breathing, like sin." Their unexpected synchronicity during the fight builds the tension between them. The motel room standoff delivers on the prompt's request for unresolved sexual tension. The mirroring of their guns pointed at each other creates a physical manifestation of their mutual attraction and distrust. The author skillfully avoids resolving this tension, leaving the story on an ambiguous note with "The night is a coin spinning on its rim, glittering, refusing to fall." There are a few instances where the prose becomes slightly purple, particularly in some of the metaphors, but these moments generally fit the stylized noir aesthetic of both source materials. The pacing is tight, with no meandering sections, and the story accomplishes a complete narrative arc within the word limit. The third-person present tense narration maintains consistency throughout, creating an immediacy that enhances both the action sequences and the tense standoff. The author has successfully created a story that feels like it could be a legitimate crossover episode between these two anime series. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Folk horror: Útiseta — Score: 86.8
Prompt:
Folk Horror: Útiseta Write a chapter set in rural northern Sweden in the mid-1990s. Linnea, a teenage girl from Stockholm, has reluctantly moved to a small village with her parents after her father's job transfer. She's befriended Astrid, a local girl who claims her grandmother taught her ancient practices passed down through generations. Astrid has been introducing Linnea to "midnight games" that involve old rituals, convincing her they can use them to learn classmates' secrets or influence their behavior. Tonight, Astrid has convinced Linnea to participate in Útiseta—sitting out on an ancient burial mound at midnight to "receive knowledge from beyond." The chapter focuses on this single midnight excursion, the ritualistic preparations, Astrid's matter-of-fact instructions that mix teenage rebellion with eerily specific traditional elements, and the mounting tension as Linnea becomes increasingly uncertain whether they're simply scaring themselves or if something is actually responding to their presence. The narrative should maintain ambiguity about whether the strange occurrences are supernatural or psychological, while establishing the dangerous line they're crossing by treating ancient practices as entertainment. First person, past tense, told as Linnea's recollection of events in the present day (though this device should be largely transparent). 1000 words. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The mist was thick enough to taste. It clung to the edges of the burial mound and breathed against our faces, glowing under the moonlight as if the ground itself had a fever. Astrid said that was a good sign. “It means they’re awake,” she whispered, like she was letting me in on a surprise party and not coaxing me into sitting on the back of the dead. I say “they,” because that’s what she always said. Not spirits, not ancestors. Just they. I had learned not to ask her to be more precise. We had left our bikes by the birch trees, their white trunks flickering like ribs whenever the wind licked the branches. The road was a faint hiss somewhere beyond the dark. In daylight the burial mound was just a swell of grass with a half-collapsed wooden fence around it, a spot older than the church and older than the county, older than anyone here, really. At night it looked like a knuckle pushing up from the earth’s skin. There were five old stones marking the rim, black with lichen and damp. I remember their smell—wet leaves and something ironish, like a coin on the tongue. Astrid had brought a tote bag with the things she said we needed: a white candle stub, two matches in a film canister, a little jar of something that smelled like tar and herbs, and a handkerchief that had belonged to her grandmother, thin as breath. Inside it were wheat berries and a lump of salt. “Salt to keep us from being taken,” she had said in that same breezy tone she used when we skipped class or smoked behind the gym. She swung her leg over the fence and stood with her sneakers at the edge of the mound, surveying it like a queen. She is the reason we went—of course she is; why else would I have been in that village at all? My father’s transfer had dropped us in the north in November. The first month I walked around like a sleepwalker, my mouth making polite conversation while my brain screamed for a bookstore, a cinema showing something with subtitles, the tap water not tasting like the inside of a radiator. Astrid had found me like a stray cat and offered me the kind of friendship that doesn’t ask for anything except your whole attention. She had a way of making rules feel flimsy. When she told me about the midnight games, her eyes were so bright with mischief and faith that I thought: this is the language here. Learn it or be mute. “It’s called útiseta,” she said now, testing the foreignness of it, making the vowels long and strange. She didn’t do that in class. In class she was normal. With me, out here, she became something else, slipping into a cadence she said she got from her grandmother, from the old women who had taught them to sit out and keep the dead company until they remembered your name and whispered their secrets. “You can’t talk once we start,” she said. “If you talk, they think you’re answering and then it’s rude to stop. You’ll think of something to ask. They always make you ask for something. You just have to let it pass.” “I thought the point was to ask,” I said. She shook her head. Her bobbed hair was dark with damp. “The point is to listen. We’re not begging. We’re just… sitting out.” “Isn’t it illegal?” I took the bag from her and climbed the fence, more to have something to do than because I was afraid. I was afraid. Astrid laughed softly. “Only if we dig. Or light a bonfire. Or get caught.” I set the bag down on the flattest part of the mound and felt, under my palm, the springy resistance of turf and the stiffness under that, as if the grass had grown over a table. I had not expected the mound to feel so present. In Stockholm, everything had a layer: asphalt over cobblestones over older cobblestones over mud. You were always on something built. Here, the ground felt unmediated and unamused. Astrid arranged things without theatrics. The candle went in a depression between two stones. The jar of black stuff—she called it juniper tar—she dabbed on the stones with two fingers, muttering words I couldn’t catch. The salt she held between her thumb and forefinger and flicked in the four directions in quick, businesslike gestures. “So they know we belong where we are,” she said. “What about the wheat?” “Food for them. And for us, if we get hungry.” She grinned, as if the idea of snacking on raw grains mid-ritual was charming. She placed five berries on the candle, balanced around the wick like tiny brown moons. I watched them shiver when her hand moved away. We sat down, facing each other, knees almost touching. The mist slicked my jeans. My sneakers were already wet, toes numb. In daylight the hill looked over the lake. Now the lake was just a darker line in the dark. Somewhere, a loon called, a sound like an empty bottle pressed to your mouth and sung through. It made the hairs on my neck lift. Astrid drew in a breath and blew it out in three short bursts. It felt like a signal I didn’t recognize. She struck a match against the lid of the film canister and the sound cracked the night’s surface like glass. The first one went out, sucked by the wet. The second took, and she cupped it, touching it to the wick. The candle bloomed. The wheat berries glowed like little seeds of light. “Okay,” she said. “Feet flat. Hands on the ground. You’re listening through your hands, not your head.” She pressed her palms to the turf and shut her eyes. The gesture was matter-of-fact, as if she were demonstrating a yoga pose in gym. I imitated her. The ground was cold enough to make my bones ache. The scent of the tar was sharp, almost medicinal, worming up my nose and into my memories, trying to become something familiar and failing. Finally, I put my hands down hard, as if force would help. “Don’t think about what you want,” she said, eyes still shut. “They don’t like greedy people. Think about nothing. Think about how your skin ends and the earth begins. Think about being big and flat.” “Big and flat,” I murmured, and she flicked her gaze at me, warning. All right. Big and flat. I tried to imagine my body dissolving at the edges, my hands flowing into the dirt and the dirt flowing into me, becoming neutral and heavy. Thoughts rose up anyway: my mother making tea and pretending not to be worried about where I was; my father, probably asleep, the TV still burbling in the next room; the boys in our class—Johan with his acne and his sudden interest in listening when Astrid spoke; Bea, who had seen us through the window of the school library and asked, Are you two together? in a voice that meant both accusation and envy. And beneath those, the old urge to impress, to be included, to be more than the girl from Stockholm who didn’t know how to ride on ice. My head buzzed. The night sounded like it was under pressure. The candle hissed slightly, or maybe that was the mist. I breathed in, out, in. My palms were numb to sensation but they were also, weirdly, full of information: the minute shifts of grass blades, a worm twisting under the soil, the vibration of something small moving in the roots. The mound seemed to tilt under me and then right itself. I told myself that was imagination. I told myself a lot of things. After a while—ten minutes? thirty?—the dark changed. Not the amount, exactly. The quality. As if someone had turned a dial in the sky from “empty” to “crowded.” The mist thickened, then thinned, and every thinning revealed that the trees had moved closer. I knew this was impossible. I knew the birches did not walk. But when I blinked, I could swear a trunk was a step nearer, its paper bark peeling in what looked like letters. I would have read them, if I could see without thinking. I had an urge to laugh and an urge to cry. These things come in twins. Astrid whispered, “If they ask your name, don’t give your real one.” “I thought we weren’t supposed to talk.” She didn’t answer. I looked at her. Her face was slack with attention, eyes open now and reflecting the candle as twin pins of light. She looked neither older nor younger, just very, very attentive, like a fox. A moth nosed the flame and then swirled away. The wheat berries had softened in the heat and one slipped off the candle and fell onto the wax pool and made a soft tick, like a bead hitting a porcelain sink. The sound went through me like a signal. I listened for another and there it was: the smallest scrape, like someone testing their fingernails on stone. It could have been a beetle. It could have been the wind shifting a twig. It could have been the memory of sound reaching me late. It was also, unmistakably, on the other side of the mound from us, close to the ground, as if someone were circling on their belly. “Do you hear that?” I said before I could catch the words and hold them behind my teeth. Astrid didn’t look at me. “You’re not supposed to answer,” she breathed. “I asked—” “Then you asked them.” Her voice had changed. It was flat and quiet and annoyed, like the way she spoke to her little brother when he unwrapped a present too fast. “Shh.” I held my breath. For a second the cold went all the way through me, as if I had been dunked in the lake. The scrape came again, nearer. I couldn’t see anything beyond the small disk of candlelight. The mist brightened and dimmed in a rhythm that suggested breathing—not ours. The birches’ black eyes watched, or seemed to. A thought gathered itself, formed like frost on a car window. It didn’t feel like mine. It felt like a suggestion placed next to my ear: Tell us something true. The phrase did not arrive with sound. It arrived with pressure, a feeling of gentle fingers against my skull. I wanted to say, No. I wanted to say, My name is not for you. Instead, what flooded my mouth was the truth that waits at the gate like a stray dog: I don’t belong anywhere. I didn’t say it. I bit hard on the inside of my cheek and tasted blood and salt, and the taste grounded me, pulled me up to the surface of my body. The candle guttered. The wheat berries slid. A chill touched the back of my neck, distinct from the general cold—the kind of chill that has weight, that feels like a hand. I twisted around, but there was no one. Of course there was no one. Astrid’s hand found mine on the grass and pressed down, nails digging crescents into my skin. It hurt. It was proof. “Don’t give them anything,” she whispered. “Let them tell us. We’re not begging. We’re not trading.” “They’re not real,” I whispered back, because I needed to say it to someone, because saying it to myself wasn’t enough. “Shh,” she said again. She smiled, but it didn’t reach her eyes. A faint humming started. It could have been the distant highway. It could have been my own blood. It could have been bees in winter. It filled the space between my ears and settled there, and with it came a series of images, like bubbles rising: a boy’s red cap snagged on a fence, a ring dropped and lost in the thatch to be found by a magpie, a woman with plaited hair kneeling at the lake’s edge and washing her hands for a long time, longer than necessary. None of it mattered. All of it felt like small eyes opening in the soil. Astrid leaned toward the candle and breathed on it, and the flame skittered. “Ask something,” she said, low and fast, like she was in a hurry now that she had changed the rules. “Ask about Johan. Ask if he cheated on the test. Ask if he thinks about you.” The cruelty of it flashed, sharp and bright. It was late to notice it, but there it was: we were going to harvest gossip from a place with bones. We were going to use old words to pry at other children’s soft lives. I might have done it. That was the worst part. I wanted to know. I wanted to own the knowing. It felt powerful, that wanting. It felt cheap. The hum rose. I squeezed Astrid’s hand back harder than I meant to. “No,” I said, and the word fell into the grass like a coin dropping into deep water. She hissed. Not a word. An actual hiss. “Linnea, don’t be stupid.” “I don’t want to ask them for school shit,” I said, louder by accident. My voice came back smeared with fog. Something moved in the birches—a shape separating from shadow, then sinking back. A fox, probably. A deer. A trick of my eyes. The candle went low, a blue bud. The mist tasted like metal now, like someone had struck a nail. The scrape circled the mound once more and stopped behind me, precisely at the point where my spine met the earth. I would have given anything to not know that. I would have given anything not to feel how thin the line was between posture and prayer. Astrid let go of my hand. She sat up straighter. Her face looked like it had when she told me about her grandmother, about the old ways passed down in kitchens and on porches, under the cover of being women’s work. “Fine,” she said, and she turned her head to the dark beyond the stones as if it had a face. “Tell us something, then. If you’re so clever. Tell us something that matters.” It was a dare. It was also a request. You could say we were asking the night. Or the dead. Or ourselves. You could say the only thing that answered was the cheap candle, which went out then with a sigh. But I felt, as the flame died, the softest exhale brush my cheek. It could have been the air moving. It could have been my own breath returning to me. It felt like agreement. We sat there in the dark, and then there was the smallest sound—too small to carry any weight, and yet it landed like a stone in a bowl. A voice, if you could call it that, warped by distance or age or the way mist holds and changes everything: Don’t make games of doors. It wasn’t a sentence I had ever thought. It was not how I would have put it. But it was perfectly clear. I felt it slide into me and lodge there. Astrid’s hand found mine again. We were both shaking. She laughed, a thin, brittle thing that cracked as soon as it left her mouth. “That’s just you,” she said. “That’s just you scaring yourself.” “Okay,” I said, because I wanted it to be true, because I could live with being the kind of girl who scared herself; I could not live with being the kind who listened through the ground and heard instructions. We stayed until the mist thinned and the birches looked like trees again. We didn’t light the candle a second time. Astrid kicked dirt over the wax, scattered the wheat, pressed the salt into my palm and told me to put it in my pocket and not forget it when I washed my jeans. She didn’t say if forgetting would matter. We climbed the fence and our bikes were where we had left them, glistening with dew. The lake breathed out a white plume and the loon was quiet. We didn’t talk on the ride back. At the crossroads our paths split; she lifted a hand without looking back. I pedaled home with my mouth full of that phrase. It tasted wrong and right at once. In the morning I would say I’d had a weird dream. In the afternoon at school, Astrid would tell me that Johan had confessed to the teacher about the cheat sheet and maybe we would each think, privately, that we had moved something with our bodies in the night. Years later, I still don’t know what we did. I can tell you what we didn’t do. We didn’t treat doors like games, not after that. Not even Astrid. Especially not Astrid. We learned the hard way what kind of knowledge comes when you sit out where the ground bulges with old names and act like you’re entitled to an answer. Whether anyone spoke to us or we made up a warning out of our own fear and guilt, I keep that night in my mouth like a coin. The taste hasn’t gone. It never will.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This folk horror piece successfully captures the essence of the "útiseta" ritual with atmospheric tension and ambiguity. The author has crafted a compelling first-person narrative that effectively balances teenage dynamics with supernatural elements. The writing excels in establishing a sense of place. Rural northern Sweden comes alive through sensory details like the "mist thick enough to taste," birch trees with "white trunks flickering like ribs," and the burial mound that "looked like a knuckle pushing up from the earth's skin." These vivid descriptions create an immersive, eerie atmosphere that supports the folk horror genre. Character development is strong, particularly in the relationship between Linnea and Astrid. Linnea's outsider status and desire to belong provide clear motivation for participating in the ritual despite her reservations. Astrid is well-drawn as the local girl with mysterious knowledge, displaying a matter-of-fact attitude toward ancient practices that makes her character believable and unsettling. The power dynamic between them feels authentic to teenage relationships. The narrative maintains excellent ambiguity about whether supernatural events are occurring or if it's psychological suggestion. Lines like "It could have been a beetle. It could have been the wind shifting a twig" and "A fox, probably. A deer. A trick of my eyes" keep readers questioning what's real. This ambiguity creates tension and honors the prompt's request to maintain uncertainty. The ritualistic elements are handled with convincing detail. The specific items (white candle, wheat berries, salt, juniper tar) and Astrid's instructions create a sense of authenticity. The ritual feels grounded in folk tradition while maintaining an air of mystery. The prose is generally strong, with effective imagery and metaphor. Occasional moments of exceptional writing include "the dark changed... from 'empty' to 'crowded'" and the description of thoughts forming "like frost on a car window." The author skillfully uses short, punchy sentences to build tension during key moments. The narrative effectively explores the moral dimension of using ancient practices as entertainment. Linnea's realization about the "cruelty" of harvesting "gossip from a place with bones" represents a meaningful character moment that addresses the prompt's concern about "the dangerous line they're crossing." The ending successfully maintains ambiguity while providing a sense of consequence. The warning "Don't make games of doors" is appropriately cryptic yet meaningful, suggesting the girls have indeed crossed a boundary with lasting impact. Some minor weaknesses include occasional overwriting, particularly in descriptive passages that could be more concise. A few metaphors feel slightly forced or overly literary for a teenage narrator, even one recounting events from adulthood. The narrative occasionally lingers too long on atmospheric details when the plot could move forward more efficiently. Overall, this is an accomplished piece of folk horror that successfully fulfills the prompt requirements while creating a genuinely unsettling and thought-provoking reading experience. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 17 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 16 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 16 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 17.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 16.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 16.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Physical-spatial: Therapeutic Boundaries — Score: 94.5
Prompt:
**"Therapeutic Boundaries"** Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a former professional athlete undergoing mandatory physical therapy after a career-destroying injury, harboring resentment toward recovery itself. Their physiotherapist is not only unnervingly attractive but also a former training partner from their competitive days who has successfully transitioned to a new career while the protagonist's identity remains shattered. We'll lean into the sexual tension of the scene by having her be attracted to him, but both of them attempting to maintain mental distance while being in physical contact as he shows her stretches & movements & manipulates her body, navigating the thresholds of pain. This scene MUST maintain complete physical coherence—every movement, stretch, and manipulation must be anatomically precise and spatially consistent. Paint an exceptionally vivid sensory picture through detailed attention to pain thresholds, involuntary responses to touch. Capture the suppressed, flaring tension of physical proximity, touch, and the controlled infliction of uncomfortable movements. Physical clarity is essential — readers must understand exactly what is happening with the body during each therapeutic technique. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The room is too clean. Matte gray floor, polished steel stool legs, a poster of the rotator cuff pinned with clinical cheer to a white wall. A diffuser murmurs in the corner, a soft cloud of lavender that can’t quite scrub out the antiseptic bite of alcohol wipes and laundered linens. I sit on the edge of the plinth with my right leg hanging and my left elevated on a half foam roller, knee supported by a wedge. The surgical scars are still an angry pink—a zipper run along the medial knee where they reconstructed the MCL and a kissing mark laterally where the scope went in. They itch when I sweat. They itch now. He checks his tablet, then me. His eyes are the same slate they were when he used to line up in the lane just outside mine, steady, unreadable, the eyes that would flick to the starting gun and never to me. His sleeves are pushed to the elbow, uniform polo stretched over deltoids I don’t let myself look at. His forearms have the same tendon maps I used to memorize on long bus rides: extensor ridges, the line where the brachioradialis shadows toward the thumb. He’s cut his hair shorter. There’s a hint of gray I want to resent him for, as if he’s been practicing at getting older while I wasn’t looking. “All right,” he says, voice patient. “How’s the pain today? Baseline, before we start.” “Depends what you call ‘start.’” The sarcasm is automatic, a reflex like the spasm in my hamstrings when I dream about the last race. “Stairs were a four this morning. Sitting is a two. Standing after sitting is an eight.” He nods. “Noted.” He taps at the tablet. “We’ll begin with some patellar mobilization, then quad activation, then we’ll load into terminal knee extension. Let me check your swelling first. Relax your quad.” I exhale and try to let the thigh unspool. He places his right hand above my patella, heel of hand on my femur, fingers spread. His left hand slides to the inferior pole of my patella. His thumb presses laterally first, moving the kneecap toward the outside of my leg. The motion is small, a careful glide. The joint line is warm under his touch. He keeps his gaze on the kneecap, not on my face. “Tell me if you feel pinching or catching,” he says. “Just the pressure is okay.” The pressure is intimate—no way around it. His hands are efficient but not detached. The skin moves under his palms, warm, alive, mine. I feel the patella shift, the lateral retinaculum resisting the glide, then yielding a millimeter. It’s not pain, exactly—a pressure that radiates to the back of the knee, a ghost ache in the hamstring. He moves the patella medially, then superiorly, then inferiorly, tracking, assessing. His thumb pads are dry. Lavender threads in with the rubber mat smell and the scent of his shampoo when he leans closer. “Good mobility,” he says. “Now I want you to contract your quad. Small squeeze. Think about pulling your kneecap toward your hip.” I look at my thigh, at muscles that used to be carved and sure. The vastus medialis is soft at the edges, the teardrop gone slack. I think of the times I trained through pain and made a religion of it. Now pain is a locked door I keep slamming my head against. I try to tighten the quad without moving the hip. The fibers twitch under the skin. The kneecap draws up a fraction. His fingertips shift to hover just above my VMO. “Here,” he says, voice lower, focused. “Tap here while you squeeze. Short contraction, hold for five, then release.” He taps in a rhythm. I follow. The muscle wakes up like a limb falling asleep in reverse—pins and needles, then heat, then a small reliable tension. My knee joint feels more contained when the patella lifts. My breath is shallow. I don’t look at his hands; I watch the tendon above my kneecap tighten, the line of it like a cable. “Good. Again,” he says. The word again used to be a challenge. Today it feels like a test I did not study for. He slides the wedge from under my ankle and replaces it with a strap anchored to a low point on the wall behind me. He loops the strap around the crease of my knee, just below the joint line, padding it with a towel so it doesn’t bite. The strap pulls my tibia posteriorly, drawing the joint into a little flexion. He places a small ball under my heel so my knee has a point to press toward. “This is terminal knee extension with an external assist,” he says, palms open to show me the movement. “The strap provides posterior tibial translation. You’re going to push the back of your knee down into the table without lifting your heel. Straighten fully. Feel the hamstring relax while the quad picks it up. Don’t hike your hip.” “I remember,” I say. It comes out short. Of course I remember. We used to do these for activation before plyos, laughing, or not laughing at all. We used to be bodies that did what we told them. “I know,” he says quietly. “Just cueing.” He places his left hand on my distal femur, just above the knee, to block the thigh from rolling outward. His right hand hovers over my tibial tuberosity, not touching, a guide. “Drive the knee down. Exhale.” I exhale and press. The sensation is specific: the back of the knee moving toward the table, the hamstring letting go under his light tap, the quad clamping down with a clean, concentrated burn. The strap resists, pulling the tibia back; the joint feels congruent, like parts aligning that were clattering before. I hold for five seconds. At three, the ache sharpens along the medial joint line, a thin wire of pain. He sees it, I know he does, in the way my toes splay. “Stay with it,” he says. “It’s pressure, not harm. Breathe past it. Four. Five. Release.” I let go. The ache recedes like tide. Sweat prickles my upper lip. Lavender tastes like pennies. “Again,” he says. We cycle through ten repetitions. By the seventh, the vastus medialis starts to tremble. I can feel the fibers trembling under the skin, involuntary, a washboard ripple. I hate that he can feel it too when he steadies the femur with the heel of his hand. My breath turns into measured counts. In the ninth rep, my hip wants to externally rotate. His fingers press lightly on my greater trochanter, a reminder to keep it neutral. The contact is precise, clinical, but my skin flares anyway, nerve endings firing with a catalog that has nothing to do with anatomy. He strips the strap away and checks the joint line with his thumbs, then moves to the hamstring. “We’ll address the posterior chain. Lie back.” I ease onto my back, head on the paper pillow. He adjusts the plinth so my knee is at about thirty degrees of flexion. He places his left hand under my calf, cradling, and his right hand cups my heel. “We’re going to do a straight leg raise with dorsiflexion. Tell me when you feel tension. Not pain—tension.” “Fine line,” I say. He gives me a look that says he knows. He lifts my heel slowly, maintaining my knee extension with the web of his hand behind my joint. The movement is precise: hip flexion with knee extension biases the sciatic nerve, hamstring length. At thirty degrees of hip flexion I feel a tug at the back of my knee. At forty-five, the tug becomes a line that runs from my heel, up my calf, through the back of the knee to the sit bone. He pauses. “Ankle,” he says. “Point your toes to your face.” I dorsiflex. The line tightens, brightens, like a string plucked. My toes tingle. It’s not pain; it’s a surge of sensation, almost electrical. My hamstring answers with a defensive flutter. “That’s the nerve. We’ll floss, not hold.” He lowers my leg five degrees, the line softens. “Now point and flex at the ankle, ten times. Keep your knee straight.” I flex and point. The motion sends a wave up and down the line, each flex a slight intensification at the back of the knee, each point a release. His hands keep my leg in the exact angle that maintains the threshold without crossing it. On the eighth, my calf twitches. He steadies it with a light downward pressure on the tibia, calming the tremor. I swallow. The smell of him is soap and fabric and something warm under it, a smell I knew in locker rooms and in winter mornings when we pretended not to be freezing. We switch legs to compare; my left is an easy violin string to the right’s frayed rope. He sets my right leg down with care I want to refuse and can’t. “Side-lying,” he says. “Clamshells. We’re going to wake up your glute med. Roll onto your left side.” I turn, careful with the knee, and stack my legs, knees bent, hips flexed at about forty-five degrees. He aligns my pelvis with a flat palm on my iliac crest, guiding the top hip forward so I don’t roll back and cheat. His fingers are warm through the thin fabric of my shorts. He positions his other hand on my lateral thigh above my knee. “Keep your heels together,” he says. “Lift your top knee without letting your pelvis rock. Stop when you feel the first hint of your TFL taking over—that pull toward the front of your hip. We want the burn in the back pocket.” “The back pocket,” I repeat, because if I don’t say something, I’ll think too much about his hand mapping my bones. I lift my knee. The first few degrees are nothing. Then my glute med wakes in a small, stubborn fire along the lateral posterior hip. My pelvis tries to tilt. His palm resists, a steady wall. The tension is specific, clean. I lower and lift, lower and lift. By the tenth, the burn is real. My breathing gets loud in the quiet room. Lavender swirls. The diffuser hums. “Good,” he says. His voice betrays nothing, but his eyes flick to my face, away, back. “Two more.” On the twelfth, my hip shakes. He moves his hand to the front of my thigh, pads of his fingers finding the TFL. “Don’t let this guy steal,” he murmurs. The touch is informational. My body doesn’t care. Heat blooms low and insistent, separate from the muscle burn, humiliating in its simplicity. I clamp my jaw and finish the rep. He helps me roll onto my back again with a hand under my scapula, a brief, incidental slide over the curve of my ribs. We both pretend it wasn’t anything. He props my right heel on a slider disc. “Hamstring eccentrics,” he says. “Bend your left knee, plant that foot. Lift your hips into a bridge. Now slowly extend your right knee, sliding the heel away, keeping your pelvis level. Only go as far as you can control, then pull back.” “Worse than suicides,” I mutter. He smiles—small, involuntary. It lands in my chest like a thrown pebble, ripples expanding. I bridge. The glutes fire; the hamstrings seize—old friends turned unreliable. I slide the right heel out. At the midpoint, the hamstring on the injured side lights up, a hot wire taut under the skin. My pelvis tries to sag on the right. His hand finds my ASIS, two fingers on each hip bone, and levels me with the gentlest pressure, a physical cue that sends a direct line to muscles that listen better than my mind. I keep the pelvis level. I go an inch farther. The burn is intense, but it’s the right kind of pain—demanding, focused, contained. I pull back. The hamstring protests in a flurry of tremors. He doesn’t let me drop my hips until the heel comes home. “Two more,” he says. On the second, my right foot cramps. My toes curl. He catches it with a quick adjustment, drawing my toes toward me to open the arch, thumb pressing into the flexor hallucis brevis with a practiced roll. The cramp releases like a fist unclenching. Relief floods. I swallow a sound. He steps back finally, hands on his hips, and I feel the absence of him like cold air. The room is just a room again. The lavender is just a scent again. I stare at the ceiling tile seam until it stops shifting. “You’re stronger than last week,” he says. “Your control’s better.” I want to say I don’t care. That control doesn’t put me back on a track with a gun in the air and a lane under my feet. I want to say he betrayed our unspoken pact by leaving and becoming this—steady hands, patient voice, someone who knows exactly where to touch to make my body obey and refuses to use it for anything but fixing me. I want to say I hate the way that makes me want him more. “Great,” I say instead, flat. He hands me a band. “Home program. Terminal extensions, clamshells, heel slides. Three sets. Within pain limits. And—” “And ice,” I finish. “Elevation. Tell me to sleep and drink water. Tell me to breathe.” His mouth lifts at one corner. “Breathe,” he says. Then, softer, “You don’t have to like this. You just have to do it.” The words skitter along my nerves. He steps close again, and for a moment we are back there—with starting blocks and chalked lines—but everything is different. He reaches past me to adjust the strap hanging on the wall, his shoulder brushing my cheek. We both still, a lurch in the machine. “Same time next week?” he asks. His voice is steady but not entirely even. I nod, a jerky hinge. My knee throbs in a slow, righteous pulse. My skin remembers his hands. The lavender sinks into the back of my throat and the clinical brightness of the room sharpens to a point. The door opens with a soft click when he touches it. I hop down carefully, test the leg. It holds, quivering. He watches for a beat, professional, attentive, infuriating. Attractive. “Text if it swells more than usual,” he says. “Or if the pain goes sharp. Midline is okay; joint line catching is not.” “I know my lines,” I say, and hear what I didn’t mean. His eyes meet mine. We both look away, almost in the same breath. In the hallway, the world smells like coffee and copier paper. My knee feels like a storm contained in glass. I tuck the band into my bag, the plastic cold against my palm, and tell myself that the ache I carry out with me is just tissue healing in the invisible dark, not something bigger, messier, something I can’t rehab my way out of. I tell myself I’ll do the exercises. I tell myself I won’t think about his hands. The lavender ghost follows me home.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative effectively captures the complex dynamics between a former professional athlete and their physiotherapist. The piece excels in its anatomical precision and physical coherence, meticulously detailing each therapeutic technique with clinical accuracy while simultaneously conveying the emotional and sexual tension between the characters. The protagonist's resentment toward recovery is palpable throughout. Lines like "Now pain is a locked door I keep slamming my head against" effectively communicate their frustration with their changed circumstances. The narrative skillfully contrasts their former athletic identity with their current diminished physical state, creating a compelling psychological portrait. The physiotherapist is portrayed with nuance - professional yet human, maintaining boundaries while clearly affected by their shared history. The sexual tension is handled with subtlety and restraint, conveyed through small details like "His fingers are warm through the thin fabric of my shorts" and "Heat blooms low and insistent, separate from the muscle burn, humiliating in its simplicity." The sensory details are particularly strong. The writer creates a vivid physical environment through descriptions of smells (lavender, antiseptic), textures, and the precise sensations of pain and touch. The physical therapy session is rendered with exceptional clarity - each movement, stretch, and manipulation is anatomically precise and spatially consistent. The prose style balances clinical precision with emotional resonance. Sentences like "The joint line is warm under his touch" and "The lavender ghost follows me home" demonstrate the writer's ability to shift between technical description and evocative imagery. The narrative maintains a consistent voice throughout - terse, observant, and emotionally guarded, reflecting the protagonist's state of mind. The piece avoids melodrama while still conveying deep emotional currents. The protagonist's complex feelings - resentment, attraction, grief for their lost career - are conveyed through subtext rather than explicit statements. The ending effectively maintains the tension established throughout, avoiding easy resolution while suggesting the ongoing nature of both the physical therapy and the emotional struggle. There are no significant weaknesses in this piece. It successfully fulfills all the requirements of the prompt, creating a physically coherent, emotionally resonant narrative that explores the complex dynamics between the characters while maintaining focus on the physical therapy session. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Historical fiction: High Seas and Low Vices — Score: 95.0
Prompt:
High Seas and Low Vices: British Naval Officer in the Opium Trade Character: Lieutenant James Merrick, a high-ranking officer in the British Royal Navy stationed in Canton, China in the 1830s. Once promising and decorated, now struggling with a severe opium addiction he hides from his superiors. Synopsis: Write a chapter following Lieutenant Merrick during a single day as he shirks his official naval duties in what has become a daily need to satiate the dragon. Told primarily in dialogue with the characters he interacts with. Focus on brief slices of his journey through the shadowy underworld of Canton: interactions with acquaintances, negotiations with local dealers, schemes and unsavoury jobs taken to fund his habit. Writing Task: Use rich sensory details to describe a day in the life of James Merrick. Write for a real sense of time & place while avoiding cliche. First person, past tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
They banged the warning drum before dawn—three hollow strikes rolling over the Pearl like stones thrown down a well—and I told my orderly I had a fever. He eyed the damp of my shirtsleeve and the tremor at the corner of my mouth and said, “Yes, sir,” like a prayer he didn’t believe, and left me to the heat trapped under the mosquito net. By seven, the yard bawled the order of the day. The ship’s blisters—the marines—filed ashore in red that caught the light. I looked down from my balcony at the parade of hats and pikes and thought how clean their boots were. I was supposed to inspect the aft magazine, take the tally of powder casks, sign the papers. “Later,” I told the sun. It climbed anyway, slow as a judge. My dressing was a dumb negotiation with buttons. I managed enough uniform to pass through the gate without comment: coat, loose cravat, hat tilted low. On the stairs I met Mr. Hudson, our lieutenant of marines, triangular face all angles and chapbook courage. “Merrick,” he said, pausing two steps above, breath smelling of chalk and boiled tea. “You’ve missed muster twice this week. Captain’s in a pet about the manifests.” “Paper can wait,” I said. “Powder can’t run away.” He looked at my eyes, and I watched him choose not to see. “Inspection at four. Don’t be late.” He went down with that precise soldier’s clatter, each heel like a nail tapped in. I slipped through the back. The quartermaster’s boy followed me to the alley gate with a ledger in his hands. “Sir, Mr. Paget says if you’d sign—” “In the afternoon,” I said, pressing a coin into his palm. He looked at the coin and I looked at the boy’s wrist, black with ink, and the August sun spilled heat like a kettle. The alley received me like a throat—narrow, wet, secret. The scent that lived there pressed against the nostrils: rotting mangoes stacked in shallow baskets, their skins blistered and collapsing, soursweet and rank. The flies were a kingdom. They lifted off the fruit in a low humming sheet when a woman waved her palm-leaf fan. “Mister. Good mango,” she hissed. I shook my head. The city wobbled between wood and brick, lintels carved with peonies already grey with soot. Lanterns under awnings, faces behind cotton veils, a river of syllables. “Gaai si,” someone shouted—a curse. Again, the mango’s sweetness knifed under the fish-stall tang, under the piss in the gutter and the incense from a god-shelf where a paper-eyed warrior watched the indifferent procession of rats. “Lieutenant.” A familiar voice, English strained through ale. Patrick Byrne stepped from a doorway with his shirt half-laced. Irish by birth, Canton by appetite, his beard stiff with last night’s smoke. “You’ve a morning face.” “I’m looking for Huang,” I said, not offering apology and not taking any. “He owes me.” “You owe him, more like,” he said, grinning without teeth on the left side. “But he’s at the Peacock. Or will be when the shade reaches the threshold.” “Then I’ll wait there.” “You’ll buy there,” he said, putting a hand on my sleeve. “Bring money, James.” “Don’t use my name.” He lifted both hands, palms out. “A joke, a joke. God keep you in good health.” He stepped back and whispered, “Avoid Inspector Po’s men by the fish market. New sweeps today. Loud drums, unlucky.” The Peacock’s sign was a painted bird with flaking blue plumage. Inside was all vertical wood and dust motes, a long table pressed with tea cups, the slow scrape of chairs left to their own thoughts. Magdalene—the proprietress—had eyes like polished stone. She wore blue cotton and an iron bangle. “Mr. Officer,” she said, mocking the honorific as she poured. “Yes?” “A pipe,” I said, touching my hat. “Tea as well.” She brought me hot iron-in-brown tea and a look that was sharper than any blade I carried. She set the pipe down, her thumb sliding along the reed, not giving it to me, just letting the possibility sit between us like another customer. “You pay last time?” she asked. “Last time I saved your cousin from the press-gang,” I said. “I stood in a doorway and told a sergeant he’d miscounted. I took his tally-stick and broke it.” “Press-gang is a story,” she said flatly. “You owe three taels.” “I have an account,” I lied. “Your account is a ghost,” she said. “It eats and eats, never pays, and still it sits at my table.” The tea burned a path down my throat, a warm lie. I set the cup down and counted out silver until it stung. She watched my hands with a bored pity. From the corner, a boy in a brown vest told the room, “Inspector Po’s at the quay. Two men taken at the red door.” “There,” Magdalene said lightly, “you see? Hungry ghosts.” I waited, and the day threw heat down into the room. In came sailors in shirts with unwound necks, an American factor with violin fingers, a Cantonese clerk with ink-blackened nails and a watch pinned to his belt. The world leaned on elbows and watched the doorway. The mango-sweet rot came in gusts when someone brushed the curtain. Huang arrived late and smiling, wearing a birdcage ring on his middle finger. He smelled of tobacco and camphor oil, and his hair was slicked back with something that gave it a wet sheen without water. He raised two fingers at Magdalene, and she brought him rice. Then he turned to me. “Lieutenant Merrick,” he said, pronouncing the Rs with care. “This is a surprise.” “We had an agreement,” I said. “We had a conversation,” he corrected. He took a mouthful, chewed, and stared at the table as if it had the next line. “You English with your tall hats and small patience. What do you want?” “You know what I want.” He looked at my sleeves. He looked at the sweat that had made a tide-line along my collar. He took a breath and smelled it: the desperation, the fear that came disguised as command. “Ah,” he said softly. “The dragon in your chest talks loud today.” “We had an agreement,” I said again, because repetition made a shaky thing sound solid. “A consignment is due.” “With respect,” he said, “I don’t sell to men who owe me money.” “I don’t owe—” “You owe everybody,” he said without malice. He set down his bowl. “Captain Po is taking names. I sell you today, I lose you tomorrow. Your officers will pretend they never knew your face. You will go to a place where walls are made of bamboo and men forget their own names.” He lifted his hand and made a passable impression of my signature, the one I’d scrawled on so many platters to make them official. “I am not a fool.” Magdalene put down the pipe in front of me like she was laying out a knife. “You have coin?” she asked again. I reached into my coat and brought out a polished brass telescope, compact enough to fit a captain’s pocket, engraved with a name that was not mine. I set it on the table. “This.” Huang ran a thumb across the engraving. “Paget,” he read. He smiled without showing teeth. “Quartermaster Paget will be upset.” “He won’t be,” I said. “Not today.” “You trade honor for smoke,” he said. He nodded to Magdalene, who took the telescope with a proprietary hum. “You will pay more later. You always pay more later.” I looked at the reed, at the blue-glazed bowl, at the dampened wad of tobacco and the black stone where the pellet would go. The anticipation had a taste like tin. The rot-sugar smell in the doorway grew louder in my head. I could not tell where the alley ended and my blood began. “Come,” Huang said, weary as a teacher. He rose. “Not here. Too many eyes.” We went through the innards of the Peacock: a passage of bamboo cages with sleeping men who might have been dead, a kitchen where a girl in a red blouse chopped ginger, the knife knocking its own clock. Out the back, onto a footbridge, the boards underfoot flexing like a ribcage. The canal beneath was thick and green, like looking into a bottle of medicine. Children’s feet slapped the path; a cat watched me as if waiting for a command. “Careful,” Huang said, bored. “Your nice shoe.” “My shoes are not nice,” I said, and he laughed. We reached the den by way of an alley bulging with baskets of mangoes left too long in the sun. They made a smell you could put your hand into: bloated, sugared, half-fermented. A boy watched over them, nose slick, and every now and then pinched one to see if it would split. He winked at me. “Gweilo,” he said, but without malice. Demon, foreign ghost. I nodded like we shared a joke. Inside the den, the light surrendered. It bled in from a high hole in the wall and made a square on the matting where dust danced, slow partners at a court. The cough that lived in those rooms was ceaseless and specific, as if it belonged to the building. A woman with a freckled face lifted her head and said, “James,” in the voice of an older sister. Her name was Sarah once, and now it was something else. I stepped over two men and sat at a couch that remembered my bones. Huang prepared a long needle of a pipe, the porcelain bowl stained like an old tooth. He held the pellet close to the lamp’s flame, working it with a flattened stick, the resin softening, bubbling, sighing. He was meticulous, precise as a clerk. He passed the reed to me when the vapor rose like the beginning of speech. “Slow,” he murmured. “You always try to outrun it.” “I have duties,” I said, taking breath. He laughed. The first vapor met me in the chest and spread like warmed oil. For a moment, the mango rot and the urine-stink and the heavy breath of other men pulled back. The world was a simple list: breath in, breath out, the skin behind my knees, the taste of copper. The ache in the joints lifted its hand and asked to be excused. “You make me a promise,” Huang said, turning a pellet with his stick. “Tonight you do what you must. You come with me to the river. There is a crate at the French mission. You help me bring it.” “I—” I began. “No argument,” he said, friendly. “Or next time Magdalene takes your boots for payment. Then you are a barefoot lieutenant. Very funny.” Sarah leaned on her elbow. “They took Tom,” she said, as if we were at tea and the weather had turned. “Inspector Po. They took him by his collar, like a dog.” She tilted her head. “He screamed and screamed, and then he didn’t.” “I told you,” Huang said, not unkind. “Po has a list. Many lists. He is learning to read the names in your script.” “I’ll help tonight,” I said. The smoke arranged my words into something that sounded like courage. “What time?” “When the bell at the east tower says eight,” he said. “Bring your uniform. The gate likes to see it.” We sat in the dark womb of the den, and the hours took off their shoes and crept past. The lamp burned low, the resin hissed and pulled back and hissed again. The cough and the sigh and the sometimes-laugh. I thought of the hold of the ship, the square chalk marks, the way Mr. Paget licked his finger before turning a page. I thought of Hudson’s angle-face. I thought of our captain’s neat hands and the blue vein that ran in a true line along his temple. At some point, my head lolled and I startled as if I’d heard my name. “Wake-up time,” Huang said mildly. “You must be a soldier again.” “I was never a soldier,” I said, but I stood. My legs were filled with water. The alleys called to me again, that fruit-sick perfume and the stickiness underfoot. Outside the den, the light stabbed. I squinted. The mango boy had cut one open, and the yellow flesh bled down his wrist. He licked his arm with unabashed veneration. “Lieutenant,” he said, imitating a sergeant’s bark. He saluted me with the fruit-knife. I saluted back before I remembered what a joke it was. By the time I’d made it to the quay, the bell had struck four. Hudson waited on the planks, the river making a loud shushing, as if it could hush every sin in Honam. “Where have you been?” he asked, and it was not really a question. “Accounts,” I said. “You stink,” he said, and his nose flinched. “God’s sake, James.” “It’s the market,” I said. “The fruit.” He stared at me a long time. A junk went past, its square sail patched with cloth of three colours. A boy on the prow spat into the river and laughed when it flew back into his face. Hudson rubbed his jaw. He said, “Be at the magazine at six. The captain expects your signature. And your mind. Both, if you can manage it.” At six, I stared at casks and saw drums of water and thought of the dens that had no windows. Paget flapped the manifest. “Sir?” he asked. “We must be quick before the tide turns.” “Yes,” I said, and let my hand drag the pen along the paper, making my name like I was a man who had one. The ink bled. The lines crossed where they shouldn’t. I was two places at once. At eight, I walked with Huang along the river. The night had a wet cloth in its throat. The mission’s cross made an X against a slice of moon. We lifted a crate so heavy it felt like dishonesty, and he said, “You are strong in the wrong places.” “Story of my life,” I said, and we both smiled because it was not funny. We stowed the crate on a sampan. A girl with a lotus tattoo on her ankle pushed us off with one foot. The river licked the wood like a cat. Lanterns hummed with moths, tiny bodies at the mercy of their light. Inspector Po’s men had drummed all day and now slept in their coats. “You will be paid,” Huang said, as if it were a kindness. “Not enough. Never enough.” “I know,” I said. He made the pipe ready on the low deck, in deference to our labour. The mango smell had become threaded through with the perfume of night-blooming jasmine from some ignorant garden, and for a moment the two scents shook hands and told a polite lie about the world. I took the reed, drew, and watched the mission’s cross grow soft at the edges. “Tomorrow?” he asked. “Tomorrow,” I said, because in Canton tomorrow was a thing you could borrow, if you had the nerve. He laughed like someone who had heard the joke already. The river carried us between dark hulls and the red backs of sleeping fish. Somewhere behind me, the drums tapped again—hollow, patient—measuring a day I had spent like coin. I felt the ghost of the telescope’s weight in my pocket and reached for it before remembering it was gone. My hand closed on air. Above us, the sky had no compass. The scent of rotting mangoes hung in the wet night like a vow I kept and broke with every breath.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkable achievement in historical fiction, creating a vivid portrait of a British naval officer's opium addiction in 1830s Canton. The writing excels in sensory immersion, historical authenticity, and psychological depth. The prose is exceptionally strong, with a distinctive voice that maintains consistency throughout. The author employs sensory details masterfully, particularly the recurring motif of rotting mangoes that becomes a metaphor for Merrick's moral decay. Phrases like "the mango smell had become threaded through with the perfume of night-blooming jasmine from some ignorant garden" demonstrate sophisticated imagery that serves both aesthetic and thematic purposes. The dialogue is particularly impressive. Each character has a distinct voice that reflects their background and relationship to Merrick. Huang's careful pronunciation of English "Rs" and his philosophical observations about Merrick's addiction show careful attention to characterization through speech patterns. The dialogue advances the plot while revealing character and never feels expository. The piece excels at "showing" rather than "telling." We understand Merrick's addiction through physical details: "the damp of my shirtsleeve and the tremor at the corner of my mouth," "My dressing was a dumb negotiation with buttons," and Hudson's observation that "You stink." The author trusts readers to infer Merrick's deterioration rather than explicitly stating it. The narrative structure is cohesive, following Merrick through a single day as requested, with clear time markers ("By seven," "At six," "At eight") that create a sense of inexorable progression. The piece avoids meandering by maintaining focus on Merrick's quest for opium while incorporating meaningful interactions that reveal his character and situation. The historical setting feels authentic without relying on clichés. Details like the "press-gang," Inspector Po's list of names, and the French mission create a credible colonial-era Canton. The author incorporates Cantonese phrases naturally ("Gaai si," "Gweilo") without exoticizing the setting. The character of Merrick is complex and believable. His addiction has corrupted his sense of duty and honor, yet he maintains awareness of his degradation. His theft of the telescope and agreement to help smuggle goods show his moral compromise, while his momentary recollections of naval duties reveal his conflicted identity. If there are weaknesses, they are minor. Occasionally, a metaphor might be slightly overwrought ("The alley received me like a throat"), but these instances are rare and generally effective. The ending appropriately maintains the dark tone established throughout, avoiding any incongruent positivity. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that creates a compelling character study while vividly evoking a specific historical moment. The writing demonstrates sophisticated craft in service of emotional and thematic depth. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Humour: Sisyphus Gives Advice — Score: 90.5
Prompt:
Sisyphus Gives Advice Write a comedic scene in the style of Terry Pratchett featuring Sisyphus, who has started an advice column while continuing his eternal boulder-pushing. Rather than being bitter about his punishment, Sisyphus has developed a comfortably zen emotional intelligence and wisdom from his centuries of repetitive labor. Not in the cliche ways you might expect -- he's actually very grounded, warm & connected with the everyday human plight. He dictates responses to "Crow," his feathered familiar who serves as both scribe and mail carrier. The piece should include Sisyphus thoughtfully answering several advice-seekers' letters about everyday problems (relationship troubles, work-life balance, dealing with difficult people, life purpose doubts) while periodically returning to his boulder-pushing duties. His advice should be surprisingly insightful and practical. The humor should emerge naturally from the messages he receives, from mundane to risque. Sisyphus should genuinely enjoy helping others, finding meaning in this new pursuit while maintaining his boulder routine. The humour should be *understated and not forced*. Contrary to expectation, almost none of his advice involves boulder rolling metaphors (though he does sneak *one* subtle in there), nor a treatise on stoicism. We are also going against the obvious fish-out-of-water trope; in fact, he's surprisingly a natural at this. In all of this , it's important to *show, don't tell*. The format should be largely epistolary, with the occasional interjection for scene setting. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The day was very much like the day before it, which was fortunate, as this meant all the furniture knew where it stood. In the grey morning of the mountain, wind moving with the stern efficiency of a head librarian, Sisyphus put his shoulder to the boulder, took three steps for momentum, and then said, “All right, Crow, let’s do the post.” Crow, who was black as a scandal and twice as opinionated, hopped onto a flat sun-warmed stone serving as a desk. He shuffled parchment with the expertise of someone who had once stolen a set of theatre tickets and improved everyone’s evening. An inkwell, a quill, and a small pebble employed as a paperweight (strictly part-time, in a neutral union) completed the office. “First letter,” Crow cawed, “in purple ink, smells like cinnamon and divorce.” “Lovely,” said Sisyphus, breathing with the rhythm of someone who had not only made peace with an incline, but had been introduced to its extended family. Crow cleared his throat and read. Dear Sisyphus, My partner leaves wet tea bags on the counter. Every day I move them to the bin. I have tried asking nicely. I have tried asking loudly. I have tried interpretive dance. The tea bags persist, glistening like tiny sea creatures. Is this the hill I die on? — Dripping with Resentment Sisyphus put a hand to the boulder, guiding it as it muttered granite syllables. “Write,” he said, “Dear Dripping.” He dictated, and Crow’s quill scritched away. Dear Dripping, Tea bags are a small thing that has decided to audition for a larger role. It is not the tea bags you dislike, it’s the unpaid labor of remembering them. You could keep a little jar on the counter marked ‘Dry Dock.’ Put a spoon beside it. Make it easier to do the right thing than the lazy thing. Then, crucially: agree with your partner when you’re both calm that the counter is a shared space and the jar is the rule. Most people do not change because of volume, but because of clarity and ease. Also, each time you move a tea bag without comment, say to yourself, “I am choosing peace over an argument I will not enjoy.” It is astonishing how much resentment likes to drink tea. Yours, Sisyphus “Add a p.s.,” Sisyphus said, steering the boulder round a nuisance pebble with the toe of his sandal. “P.S. If you must die on a hill, choose one with a view and a picnic blanket.” Crow snorted ink down his beak and left a period the size of a walnut. “From Agamemnon’s head, he would have appreciated that.” “He was never a picnic,” Sisyphus said. He set his shoulder again. The boulder, affronted by gravity as a matter of principle, rolled on. Crow lifted the next letter. “This one has a lipstick kiss and the faint aroma of ill-advised weekends.” Dear Sisyphus, There is a person at my workplace. Let us call him “Management.” He sends emails at midnight and asks if I got his nine minutes ago. He schedules meetings about meetings. He calls me “champ.” I am not his champ. How do I put boundaries in place without becoming the office villain? — Thunderously Tired Sisyphus tilted his head, listening to the mountain, which was making its usual early afternoon sound of being far too old for this. “Dear Thunder,” he said. Dear Thunder, Boundaries are not walls; they are signposts. The first time he emails at midnight, do not answer until the hour you are paid to be awake. When you reply, include at the top: “For clarity, I respond to messages during working hours, which for me are [x–y]. Urgent issues should be marked urgent.” Then do not break this rule for three weeks. People believe the rule you live, not the one you announce. For “champ,” gently say, “Please call me by my name.” No apology, no explanation. Repeat it, even if he is wearing a tie with tiny boats. If he persists, document it. If you are in a meeting about a meeting, ask, “What decision are we making in this time?” People who like meetings dislike decisions. Bring a decision along to scare them. In private, decide what you would do if nothing changed. Then do one smaller version of that now. Yours, Sisyphus “The bit about the boats was uncalled for,” Crow murmured, impressed. “He knows what he did,” Sisyphus said mildly. A gust of wind brought the smell of hot stone and somebody else’s eternity. The boulder paused at a place where it liked to consider life’s mysteries, then rolled its eyes and kept going. “Here’s one with jam,” Crow said, pecking delicately. “Possibly strawberry. Possibly a cry for help.” Dear Sisyphus, My girlfriend wants to move in. I love her, but my flat is small and full of… me. I have an orderly system of piles. She has an orderly system of plants. I’m 32 and still unsure if I can share a bookshelf without losing myself. Advice? — Shelved and Shaky Sisyphus smiled, the sort that had laughed often and then remembered what laughter was for. Dear Shelved, You are not a book, and love is not a library. Sharing a shelf does not erase your margins; it invites annotations. Start by making space deliberately; choose which pile becomes a drawer. You will be tempted to pretend your flat is symmetrical. It is not. Offer her the place you care about least, and keep the place you care about most. Tell her the story of each object on the mantle. Ask her the story of each plant. If the stories make room for each other, you will, too. If you cannot decide, host a trial month with a box labeled “Stowaways” for things that do not yet belong. At the end, open the box together and decide what stayed merely out of kindness, and what stayed because it’s part of the map. Also, own one chair neither of you may pile things on. It is the ceasefire chair. You sit in it when you need to be only yourself for an hour. Guard this with the seriousness usually reserved for royal weddings and the last biscuit. Yours, Sisyphus The boulder, perhaps out of curiosity, attempted to roll faster. Sisyphus hummed and let it, his hands steady, his feet knowing where the mountain gave and where it argued back. “Next,” Crow said, “is less letter, more stain. The rain made an editorial choice.” He held up a parchment that looked as if someone had written their heart out and then used it to mop up their heart. Only fragments remained: “dear sisy… think my cat… actually my boss… forks go missing… destiny?? help pls.” Sisyphus took a long, sympathetic breath. “All right. We will answer all of them, then. Start with ‘Dear Possibly Several People.’” Dear Possibly Several People, If your cat is your boss, congratulations on working in a progressive environment. Put the food on time, provide sunbeams, and accept that your performance reviews will be conducted from a cardboard box. If your boss is your cat, stop dangling the laser pointer. He cannot resist chasing the new shiny thing, and you will be complicit. Put important items in writing. Close your door. Offer treats sparingly, and reward litter box usage, metaphorically speaking. As for forks going missing, buy more forks. This sounds flippant, but it is actually hospitality. Keep the good ones in a drawer you enjoy opening. Someone will ask where you got them. Tell them. They will get their own. The universe will right itself in small, tine-shaped increments. If this is about destiny, you have not missed yours. It does not come once like a tyrant; it arrives in installments like a patient postman. Pay attention to what you do when no one is making you. Follow that one street farther. If none of this applies because the letter was about plumbing, turn off the water at the mains and ask your neighbor who is good with pipes. There is always one. Yours, Sisyphus “Elegant,” Crow said, visibly pleased. “And applicable to cutlery theft.” “Everyone thinks forks,” Sisyphus said, guiding the boulder round a slick patch, “but it’s spoons you must watch. They sympathize too much.” Crow rifled again. “A short one. Smells of cardamom. ‘Dear Sisyphus, how do I find my purpose? I try hobbies, jobs, lovers. None fit. Is there a trick?’ Signed, Trying on Shoes.” Sisyphus considered. Wind wrapped itself round his bare arms like a shawl someone had knitted from old myths. Dear Shoes, The trick is to stop asking the word “purpose” to do the work of three smaller words: attention, service, and delight. Attention: Notice what you notice without effort. Keep a note of when time doesn’t scold you. Service: What can you do that leaves other people steadier? Not grand gestures. Carrying chairs after a wedding counts. If you keep doing this, someone will eventually call it your calling. It will still be carrying chairs. Delight: What is a private yes? The thing you do and then look around to see if anyone saw you being that alive. Do more of that in public, carefully. Combine two of the above and you will be difficult to stop. Combine all three and you won’t want to. If you need something to do in the meantime, sweep the threshold of your building. The neighbors will talk. This is good. Yours, Sisyphus The boulder reached the top, thought about metaphysics for the briefest possible time, and rolled back down of its own accord. Sisyphus let it go with a little pat, as if sending a child down a slide. He sat on the lip of the ledge, shoulders broad, face lined in the way that comes from having used it a lot. A shadow crossed them as Crow landed with a rustle. “Two more,” he said. “One is from a person calling themself ‘Molten Enthusiasm.’” Dear Sisyphus, My partner and I are very much in love, but our schedules never align. I work nights. They work days. We communicate by notes on the fridge like polite ghosts. How do we stay connected without falling asleep on top of each other, though that is not always a downside? — Molten Enthusiasm Sisyphus bit back a smile that showed he had, in fact, been to certain temples. “Write,” he said. Dear Molten, Design rituals that do not care what the sun is doing. A thermos note system: one writes a message on the thermos of coffee they leave, the other replies on the lid they return. A five-minute ritual when you pass each other—choose three questions you always ask and always answer, no matter how tired: What made you laugh? What was heavy? Where did you notice beauty? Set a standing date that rotates like a lighthouse—one morning pancake date, one twilight walk, one absurdly timed rendezvous in the middle of an aisle at the 24-hour grocery, in which you choose a new fruit together and eat it in the parking lot. Put it on the calendar as if you respect it. Because you do. As for falling asleep on top of each other: invest in a throw blanket. Consent and blankets are the unsung heroes of romance. Yours, Sisyphus Crow preened one glossy wing and produced the last letter with a flourish. “A spicy one.” Dear Sisyphus, I keep dating people who are disasters wrapped in charming paper. It’s fun until it’s a fire. My friends say I have a type. I say I enjoy fireworks. How do I choose someone who won’t burn down my kitchen, metaphorically, or literally, because I have very nice pots? — Singed but Sanguine Sisyphus nodded, grave as a potter. “Dear Singed.” Dear Singed, At the start, ask yourself two questions instead of one. Everyone asks, “Am I excited?” Also ask, “Am I calm?” If you are only excited, you are boarding a rollercoaster with loose bolts. If you are only calm, you are agreeing to watch paint dry while the paint judges you. Look for both. On the third date, cook together. Choose a recipe with one pan, two knives, and three steps that must be done at once. Watch how they treat the onions. Listen for please and thank you when neither of you feels glamorous. If they switch off the stove when you forget, that is a kind of love. If they eat the burnt bits and say, “We’ll do better next time,” that is another. Have a written list (yes, written) of three non-negotiables that are about behavior, not charisma. “Is kind to waiters.” “Apologizes without auditioning for an award.” “Does not make me smaller to feel bigger.” Consult the list when your brain is full of sparklers. If the list says no, trust the list. Fireworks are for festivals, not kitchens. Keep the nice pots. People can be taught; pots cannot. Yours, Sisyphus Crow blew on the ink and looked up. “That’s the lot,” he said. Down below, the boulder angled itself toward its usual starting point with the dogged optimism of a tortoise entering a marathon. “Send them,” Sisyphus said. “Give the cat/boss two peanuts. For morale.” Crow gathered the letters into his satchel with the air of a professional leaving an office that happened to be a precipice. He hesitated. “And you?” he asked, as he always did, though the answer never changed much. Sisyphus stood, stretched, put his hands on the stone he knew better than the back of his hand (the front of his hand had more personality). “I have an afternoon appointment,” he said. “Client is punctual.” He leaned, pushed. The boulder moved, considering the whole business of existence and deciding, as usual, that consistency was its own polite applause. “Crow,” he called as the incline accepted him. “Add this to the bottom of the column, will you?” Crow poised his quill. If your letter is smudged, it will still be answered. If you are smudged, likewise. Also, remember: momentum is less about pushing hard and more about knowing when to breathe. Crow paused. “That’s a bit… you know.” “A little,” Sisyphus admitted, smiling. “One for the purists.” The wind ran ahead to tell the mountain they were coming. The mountain, ancient and practical, made space. And somewhere along the slope, where a paperweight-pebble did its humble work, the ink dried on words that would go out into the world on black wings, find kitchens and desks and laps, and make their own small weather.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response is a remarkably well-crafted piece that captures Terry Pratchett's distinctive style with impressive fidelity. The author has created a Sisyphus who is indeed "grounded, warm & connected with the everyday human plight" while maintaining a light touch with the humor. The epistolary format works perfectly, with Sisyphus answering a variety of everyday problems through his advice column. The relationship between Sisyphus and Crow is established efficiently, with Crow serving as both scribe and mail carrier as requested. Their interactions have the easy familiarity of long-time companions, with gentle banter that feels natural rather than forced. The prose is particularly strong, with Pratchett-esque similes and metaphors throughout: "Crow, who was black as a scandal and twice as opinionated" and "wind moving with the stern efficiency of a head librarian" capture that distinctive voice. The personification of inanimate objects (the boulder "muttering granite syllables") is also characteristic of Pratchett's style. The advice Sisyphus gives is genuinely insightful and practical, showing emotional intelligence without resorting to clichés. His responses to relationship troubles, work-life balance, and finding purpose are thoughtful and nuanced. The writer has successfully avoided making Sisyphus bitter about his punishment, instead portraying him as someone who has found meaning in helping others. The humor emerges naturally from the situations and characters rather than feeling forced. There's a subtlety to the comedy that respects the reader's intelligence. The writer has also successfully avoided overusing boulder-rolling metaphors, including just one subtle reference as requested ("momentum is less about pushing hard and more about knowing when to breathe"). The piece excels at showing rather than telling. We understand Sisyphus's character through his actions and words rather than through explicit statements about his nature. The scene-setting interjections between letters provide just enough context without overwhelming the epistolary format. If there are any weaknesses, they're minor. Some of the metaphors, while clever, occasionally border on being slightly too elaborate or self-conscious. However, this is consistent with Pratchett's style, so it's hard to consider it a true flaw. Overall, this is an exceptional response that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt while creating a genuinely engaging and entertaining piece of writing. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Coming of age: Lost & Found in Osaka — Score: 86.3
Prompt:
Lost & Found in Osaka Slice of Life / Coming-of-Age: First Connection. Write one scene within a larger story set in Osaka, Japan. A shy, introverted teenager & synthesizer nerd, is browsing the electronics district of Den Den Town. She is drawn to the sound of an electric guitar. A girl, slightly older and radiating confidence, is busking near the entrance to a crowded arcade, playing a blistering rendition of a classic anime theme. The scene takes us through their initial awkward interaction, transitioning into a surprisingly easy conversation. The busker, intrigued by the teenager's quiet intensity and knowledge of music, suggests they grab some sushi at a nearby kaitenzushi (conveyor belt sushi) restaurant. Write primarily in dialogue, capturing the distinct voices of the two characters: the teenager's hesitant and -- initially -- awkward speech, and the busker's more outgoing and playful tone. 1000 words.
Model Output:
“Hey, Den Den Town. You hearing this?” “…is that…? That’s totally ‘Cruel Angel’s Thesis,’ right?” “You got it. Full-speed, no mercy. Wanna request something?” “I—uh—no. I mean, I like this one. You’re… you’re really good.” “Thanks. I practice till my fingers hate me. You look like you know your way around a synth rack though.” “W-what? How did you—?” “Backpack patches. Krell Systems, Rogue Wave, and—hang on—Roland Juno pin. That’s not random. Also, the way you were staring at the loop pedal like it was a crime scene? Synth nerd tells on herself.” “I was just… curious. Your chain. You split the signal?” “Guitar into compressor, overdrive, then the looper. Split to the mini-amp and the little speaker on the ground for ambient shimmer. It’s hokey, but it kicks in the arcade noise. I’m Kana, by the way.” “Um. I’m Yui.” “Yui! Nice to meet you. Wanna hold this pick? Lucky charm.” “I—no, I—I’m okay. Sorry. I just… you, uh, you’re busking at the entrance where the UFO catchers scream like that.” “Prime real estate. People pouring out with armfuls of plushies, hearts open, wallets half-open. See that guy with the big Rilakkuma? He tipped me in Takoyaki last week.” “Can… can you even tip in takoyaki?” “You can if it’s hot. I’ll play for food. Watch this—key change.” “Oh—woah. You reharmonized the chorus. Traded the IV for a flat-VII. That’s… that’s clever.” “You hear that?” “Yes. And you tucked the melody under those power chords. It’s—um—in the guitar community they call that ‘chord-melody,’ right? But it feels more like—like a lead sheet nobody wrote down.” “Yui! You just gave me a cooler bio line for my Insta.” “I didn’t mean—uh, sorry. I’m bad at… talking. I mean, I talk, but it comes out like file names.” “Ha! File names are hot, what are you talking about? Give me a file name.” “Uh. ‘kana_gtr_anothertake_final_FINAL_v6.wav’?” “Accurate. Alright, last chorus.” “It’s getting crowded.” “It’s Friday. Retro tournament inside. Street Fighter II screaming over there.” “I only came to look at capacitors.” “You say the sexiest things.” “…I—what?” “Kidding. But seriously, what are you building?” “Not building. Fixing. My friend—well, okay, not really a friend. Someone I follow—posted a schematic for a chorus mod for the SH-101 clone I bought. The filter drifts, and when the air conditioner kicks on, the pitch… um, sorry. That’s probably boring.” “Do I look bored?” “I can’t tell. You’re… shiny. I mean, I mean you’re… um.” “Hah! I’ll take shiny. Okay, shiny finishes ‘Cruel Angel’s Thesis’ with a whammy you aren’t expecting—” “That note! You bent it just flat, like the vocal vibrato. You listened to the original too many times.” “Between you and me? My mom hummed it making curry. I’m basically made of that song. Hey, you didn’t tip.” “I… didn’t have coins. I can—” “Relax. I’m not shaking you down, Yui. Just a custom payment plan. You owe me a nerdy fact about something here.” “Here? Like… Den Den Town facts?” “Dealer’s choice.” “Okay. You know the shop two blocks down, the one with the broken Mega Drive shell in the window? If you go in and ask politely, the owner will show you a drawer with Famicom carts that never made it to release. He won’t sell them, but he lets you hold them for a second if you promise not to breathe too loud.” “That’s fantastic. I want to go there.” “He memorized the pinouts for five different cartridge connectors. He did it to impress his… wife, I think? But she only pretends to be impressed. She runs the Gachapon shop across the street.” “So he married someone who can roll her eyes at his pinouts. That’s romantic. Oh, and—excuse me—” “Your case is open.” “I saw. Little guy thought he could drop coins without getting noticed. He can. I just wanted to thank him. Gratitude is part of the tone.” “Part of the tone?” “Yeah. Confidence, posture, hydration, gratitude. Same category. Hey, you want to try to loop something?” “No.” “That was quick.” “I mean, I… I don’t do… crowds.” “You and me both. I’m faking.” “You’re very good at it.” “Thanks. Practice faking in the mirror. Also, my amp is small. Smaller amps make me feel safer.” “That’s not—on a technical level the amp size doesn’t matter if you’re mic’d.” “Wow, you really went there.” “Sorry.” “Don’t be. It’s cute. Here, I’ll just lay down a chord and you hit this button when I nod. That’s all.” “Just… the button?” “Yep. The one that says ‘rec.’ Ready?” “Okay.” “Nod.” “—oh. Like that?” “Perfect. You looped me, Yui. Complicit.” “It feels like I stepped on the wrong train and it still got me where I needed to go.” “Good metaphor. Where do you think you needed to go?” “I don’t know. Maybe… out of my room.” “Fair. I respect rooms though. They’re honest. Hey, you smell that?” “Seaweed?” “Sushi place a block over. Kaitenzushi. Conveyor belts like tiny monorails. We should go. I’ll pack up in two minutes.” “I… with me?” “Yes, with you. I don’t invite just anybody who knows what a flat-VII is.” “I shouldn’t—” “Why not?” “I… don’t know you.” “That’s okay. We can know each other over salmon. I’m safe, I swear. You can sit nearest the door and keep your phone out like you’re texting an escape plan. I won’t be offended.” “I wasn’t—” “I do it too when meeting people off gigs. Safety first. Also, if you hate me, you can shove me into a stack of plates and bolt. Though I’d prefer you didn’t. These jeans are borrowed from my cousin.” “You joke a lot.” “It’s cheaper than therapy. But I mean the sushi. I’m starving. And you look like you forget to eat when you’re soldering.” “That’s not—well, yes.” “Called it. C’mon. One more tiny solo, then we go.” “Okay. I’ll—uh—stand here.” “Good spot. Watch the entrance—oh, speaking of loud—” “Fireworks?” “Wait, at this hour?” “There’s a flyer. Namba Summer Something-something Parade.” “Oh right, the pop-up thing. Perfect timing. I’ll time this divebomb to it.” “It’s really loud.” “It’s Osaka. We brag loud. Hold your ears if it hurts.” “I’m fine. It’s… pretty.” “Gold ones bloom like cymbals. I wish the loop station could sample that.” “You could. With a mic.” “Yeah, but then I’d need a good preamp and—there goes my last thousand yen. Okay, last run, then we go get conveyor belts.” “Alright.” “—And… done. You okay?” “Yes. The fireworks made my stomach jump.” “Same. Adrenaline tastes like cheap batteries. Help me coil?” “I can coil.” “Over-under. Not like you’re wrangling a garden hose.” “I know over-under.” “Oh! Sorry. I always assume newbies and then I embarrass myself.” “I look like a newbie.” “You look like Yui. Which is… in the top five looks today.” “Top five?” “I met a man who turned his Switch into a guitar controller. He’s number two. You’re number one.” “You’re being nice because you want me to come with you.” “I want you to come with me because I think you’re interesting. Being nice is just… me. Or I try. This street can be mean. I prefer being an antidote.” “Okay.” “Okay as in okay sushi?” “Okay as in okay sushi.” “Yesss. Help me zip this. Mind the stickers.” “‘Girls to the Front Panel.’ That’s a good sticker.” “Thank you. It’s a synth joke. No one laughs.” “I laughed. Inside.” “I’ll accept inside laughs. Ready?” “Wait. Your cable’s still—” “Caught on the sign. Got it. Let’s walk. Watch your step.” “It’s packed.” “Osaka Friday night. If you get overwhelmed, tug my sleeve.” “I don’t… tug sleeves.” “You can tug mine. It’s free.” “I—okay.” “So, Yui, what’s your favorite oscillator wave? Full disclosure, this is a compatibility question.” “Triangle.” “Scandalous. Why triangle?” “It’s… it’s clean. Like a voice humming before it becomes a word.” “Wow. I’m stealing that too.” “You can steal it. I’ll charge royalties in mackerel.” “Deal. Here we are. This place has an angry tuna on the sign—peak quality.” “It’s bright.” “Yeah. Conveyor belts are like aquariums for food. Let’s sit at the end so you can see everything.” “I’ll… sit by the door.” “Perfect. I’ll sit opposite so you can stare at me and the exit at the same time.” “I wasn’t—” “Teasing. We can pivot if it’s too much. Here comes a plate. Salmon belly.” “I’ve never been to one of these alone.” “Good thing you’re not alone. Two plates?” “One. I’m small.” “Okay, small person. I’ll grab the egg for me. Judge me later. What do you do, besides fix wayward filters?” “I… make little tracks. Nothing special.” “Define nothing.” “Like… minute-long things that never resolve. They’re like… promised bridges that never get to the chorus.” “Unfinished bridges are still pretty. I like them. Send me one.” “I can’t.” “Because you don’t want to or because you think it’s not good enough?” “Both.” “I get it. I said ‘send me one,’ not ‘send me your soul.’ Just one little clip. I’ll listen while eating convenience store pudding and I’ll send you fifteen emojis in response.” “Which fifteen?” “Depends on your waveform. Possibly the whale.” “Whale?” “Big feelings. Or maybe the sparkles. Do you… what do you listen to?” “Old game soundtracks. Namco. Yamaha FM chips. I like how the hardware puts a fence around you and says ‘make meaning inside this box.’” “See, that’s hot. Fences and meaning. I make terrible sense of boundlessness. Too many choices. I freeze.” “Me too. That’s why I like triangles.” “Full circle. Passing you the soy sauce. Want ginger?” “No, thank you. It’s like… too bright. The ginger.” “Same. We’re ginger skeptics. Another compatibility tick. Ooh, look, fireworks reflection in the restaurant glass.” “It looks like pixels.” “Right? Like somebody overexposed a SNES palette.” “I like that. Do you come out here every Friday?” “Most. School’s meh, work’s meh, this is where I feel like the noise is my noise, not just the noise, you know?” “I think so.” “Do your parents care if you’re out late?” “They think I’m at a bookstore. Which is not a lie. There are books here.” “In the gacha machines? Literature in capsule form.” “I had a math teacher who said probability is literature.” “I like them. Do they have office hours at the arcade?” “They would if they were serious.” “You’re funny, Yui.” “I don’t try to be.” “Best kind. Oh, incoming: mackerel for your royalties.” “Payment accepted. Do I… owe you a fact now?” “Please.” “The shop with the curry pan outside? If you ask for ‘Night Mode,’ the owner will turn off half the lights so you can see the RGB fans on the PCs. He did it once for me because I looked like I had been inside for a hundred years.” “You say the nicest things about yourself.” “It was a compliment. It was… it felt like someone saw me.” “I see you. I mean—sorry, too earnest? I do that sometimes.” “It’s okay.” “Yui, can I ask a question? You can veto.” “Okay.” “What made you stop for me? There are a lot of buskers.” “You were playing what my dad hums when he fixes our microwave. He doesn’t sing it right. You did.” “Now I’m emotional. Great. I’m going to drip soy sauce down my face like a mess.” “Don’t cry. The waitress will worry.” “I won’t. But I like that. Tell your dad he can have my chord chart. I’ll write ‘microwave version’ on it.” “He would like that.” “Another plate?” “I’m full.” “Already? Tiny person indeed. We’ll sit for a second. Let the belt hypnotize us. Then I’ll walk you to the train.” “You don’t have to.” “I want to. Also, selfishly, I want to ask you more about your chorus mod. Does it give the 101 a little swirl or full-on spaceship?” “In-between. It adds a slow drift, like you’re turning your head in a small room.” “Okay, poet. I want to hear it. Maybe next time you can bring it here, and I’ll plug you into my amp. We’ll loop your swirl.” “I… maybe.” “Maybe is yes adjacent. I’ll take it.” “Can I ask you something back?” “Always.” “Why did you invite me?” “Because when you stood there, you looked like you were hearing the version of the song I was trying to play, not the sloppy street version. And because your voice does that thing when you talk about waves—like you’re stepping on a train and you’re not sure if it’s the right one, but you go anyway. I like that.” “I was going to run away.” “I could tell. That’s why I made the sushi move fast. It’s harder to run if there’s promise of salmon.” “You’re manipulative.” “Only in service of friendship.” “Friendship.” “Scary word? We can downgrade to acquaintance.” “No. Friendship is fine.” “Good. Then it’s settled. Yui the triangle wave and Kana the overdrive. Next time, bring me a minute-long track that feels like a promised bridge. I’ll bring fireworks on a USB.” “You can’t put fireworks on a USB.” “Watch me. I’ll name it fireworks_final_FINAL_v7.” “I’d listen to that.” “You will. Now, finish your mackerel. The night’s long, and Den Den Town sleeps like a cat—one eye open, tail flicking.” “You’re weird.” “Likewise. Cheers, Yui.” “Cheers, Kana.”
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a dialogue-driven scene between two distinct characters in Osaka's Den Den Town. The writing effectively establishes the shy, introverted synthesizer enthusiast Yui and the confident, outgoing busker Kana through their conversation patterns. The dialogue is the strongest element of the piece. Each character has a distinct voice - Yui's hesitant, often self-interrupting speech contrasts well with Kana's playful, confident tone. The writer uses dialogue tags sparingly, allowing the characters' speech patterns to identify them. Yui's technical knowledge about synthesizers and music theory comes through naturally in her speech, while Kana's outgoing personality shines in her quips and encouragement. The setting of Den Den Town is established through specific details woven organically into the dialogue - mentions of arcade noise, UFO catchers, electronics shops, and the sensory experience of Osaka (fireworks, food smells). These details create a vivid backdrop without relying on heavy exposition. The relationship development between the characters feels authentic. Their connection over music provides a natural foundation, and Kana's gentle persistence in drawing Yui out of her shell is handled with sensitivity. The writer avoids the trap of making Yui's social anxiety disappear too quickly - she remains hesitant throughout, though gradually warming to Kana. There are a few minor weaknesses. The piece occasionally relies on telling rather than showing, particularly when explaining character emotions directly. Some of the technical music discussions might be difficult for readers unfamiliar with synthesizers to follow. The dialogue sometimes becomes slightly repetitive in structure, with many short exchanges that could benefit from more variety in pacing. The ending strikes an appropriate tone - not forcing a dramatic transformation in Yui, but showing a tentative new friendship with potential for growth. The promise of future meetings feels earned rather than contrived. Overall, this is a strong piece that succeeds in its primary goal of capturing two distinct character voices through dialogue while creating an authentic slice-of-life scene in Osaka. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 16 Elegant Prose: 16 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 4 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 3 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 17 Overall Impression: 17
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 16.0, Elegant Prose: 16.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 4.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 3.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 17.0, Overall Impression: 17.0
+ Teen horror: Tick Tock (Goosebumps) — Score: 88.8
Prompt:
Teen Horror (Goosebumps style) Write a chapter where a middle school student discovers their new smart watch has the ability to rewind time, but doesn't realize that each use is aging them until they notice physical changes (like accelerating through puberty) and that people are treating them differently. They inadvertently cause a timeline shift with disastrous consequences -- and it can only be rectified (maybe?) by reversing the clock once more. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
I noticed it first in Mr. Pritchard’s class, while he was explaining the water cycle with a PowerPoint that looked like it was made before any of us were born. He kept mixing up evaporation and condensation, and he refused to call on anyone but Madison, who sat front row like she owned the place. I was in my usual middle-back seat, scribbling skulls in the margin of my notes and tapping my new smart watch against the desk. Dad got it for me for my thirteenth birthday—a real brand, not one of those brick-sized knockoffs. Sleek black band, glowing blue interface. It counted my steps, tracked my sleep, and said “Good morning, Jax” in this chipper voice I could tell had been programmed by someone who never had a morning in middle school. I’d already set the alarms and connected it to my phone. What I hadn’t figured out was this hidden option I found while messing around under my desk: a tiny hourglass icon that wasn’t in the manual. When I pressed it, the watch vibrated once, just a whisper in the skin of my wrist. And Mr. Pritchard was suddenly talking about evaporation again. At first I thought I’d zoned out, daydreaming skulls, and my brain had looped back. But when Madison’s hand shot up with the same “Actually—” she always used, and the same freckles scrunched across her nose, and even the same cough from the vent above the whiteboard, I realized it wasn’t me. I clicked the hourglass again. Another vibration, a tingle up my arm, and time slid like a wet plate. Mr. Pritchard stammered back to the start of the slide, and I watched it all again. Same cough. Same “Actually.” Same spray of light from the dusty projector. Three times, four times. By number five, I’d timed it: thirty seconds. A thirty-second rewind. My watch could rewind time. I’d seen things online about people editing videos to look like time loops or fake magic tricks with cuts, but this was different. The feeling was like being picked up and put back down in the exact same spot, except every time I landed, the world was a tiny fraction more out of sync with me. Hard to explain; only my stomach knew. It swooped faintly, like stepping off the last stair when you think there’s one more. I didn’t tell anyone. Not right away. What would I say? “Hey, my watch is a time machine, want to mess up the science lesson?” They’d laugh. Or worse, they’d believe me and take it away. So I used it on small things. When I said something dumb to Trevor at lunch and he made that face, I nudged the hourglass and said something less dumb. When the ball bounced off my knee in P.E., I tapped the watch and the ball obediently came back, and I scored like I meant to. When Mom asked if I’d fed the cat and I had not, I rewound and fed him before answering, making her eyebrows lift like she was surprised I was suddenly responsible. It was just thirty seconds, but thirty seconds can fix a lot. By Friday, though, I’d noticed the weirdness. Not the gut swoop—that got easier. It was my voice. In the bathroom that morning, I’d said “Hello” to myself just to test the echo, and the sound was… thicker. Like someone had turned up the bass. And my hair had done this thing where it refused to lie flat, like every cowlick had declared independence. “Puberty,” Dad said cheerfully when I asked if my voice sounded weird. “Welcome to the club.” I didn’t feel like joining any clubs. But maybe it was normal. I mean, I was thirteen. Gym class, Coach Ramirez split us into teams for dodgeball. I used the watch three times in a row to avoid getting pelted by Kaylee Taylor, who threw like a pitcher and smiled like a shark. After the third rewind, she squinted at me. “How’d you do that?” “Do what?” I asked, voice coming out rougher than I wanted. “That duck. You knew I was gonna throw.” “Lucky,” I said, and then I felt it. Not the swoop. The pull. My skin felt too tight, like the watchband had shrunk while I wasn’t looking. I tugged at it and realized the impressions it left were deeper than they’d been yesterday. My wrist looked different. Bone looked sharper. I caught my reflection in the backboard glass and frowned. After school, I went to the bathroom before the bus. It’s the kind with greenish lights and stalls with graffiti in Sharpie—if you learned to read in middle school bathrooms, you’d be scarred for life. I stepped up to the sink and looked at myself. Same eyes. Same dark hair doing its own thing. A pimple forming on my chin like a malevolent volcano. But there was more definition in my jaw. That’s what Dad would call it. I would have called it weird. “Hey, Jax,” someone said behind me. Trevor. He walked in, tossed his backpack on the tile like he didn’t care, and gave me a look that was half friendly, half something else. Something measuring. “What?” I asked. “Nothing. You look… different. Did you—” He leaned closer. “Shave?” “I’m thirteen,” I said. But my voice betrayed me again, a crack then a lower note that made me want to chew on the air to get it back. He grinned. “Okay, Barry White.” He washed his hands and left. I stared at my reflection. “Hello,” I said again. It was definitely lower. This time, when I blinked, my face in the mirror blinked a moment later. Not like a regular mirror’s split-second delay. More like a few beats. And in that delay—only for a flicker—I saw something that made my stomach plunge past any staircase. An older face. Mine, but not. Sharper jawline. A shadow where facial hair would be if I could grow any. Eyes that had seen things I hadn’t. It was there and gone, like a bad signal. I shoved away from the sink, my heart banging. The smart watch was warm on my wrist. It couldn’t be. The watch rewound time outside, not inside me. Except what if both were true? What if every rewind cost me something? I didn’t use it on the bus. I didn’t use it when Mom burned the garlic bread and Dad told her it was “rustic,” which earned him a glare. I lay in bed and watched the ceiling fan spin, thinking of the older face like a ghost hovering in my mirror. The watch’s face glowed on my nightstand, the hourglass icon waiting, patient. I dreamed of being pulled backward and forward through a carousel where every horse was me at a different age, reaching out with wooden hooves. Saturday should have been normal. Cartoons with my little sister Mia, cereal dust at the bottom of the box. But the group chat blew up before ten. Madison had posted a picture from in front of the school. It was cordoned off with yellow tape. In the blurry photo, you could see smoke stains on the bricks around the science wing windows. There were comments: “Explosion?” “No school Monday?” “Omg.” Mom got the notification email from the principal. There had been a small fire. No injuries, thank God. “Faulty wiring,” the email said. “We will be performing an investigation and repairs.” Faulty wiring. Except I knew what I’d done yesterday in Mr. Pritchard’s class. I’d rewound him five times in a row because it was funny to watch him say “evaporation” wrong. The projector had been ancient. If time is a thread, imagine tugging at it again and again until it frays. I opened my texts to Madison. Did anything else happen? Anyone hurt? She wrote back right away: No but the lab got trashed. Chemicals everywhere. Mr. P is freaking. I clicked the news app. It hadn’t caught up yet. I clicked the watch. The hourglass pulsed once. Maybe I could fix it. Rewind longer than thirty seconds. It had only ever gone thirty, but there had to be a way. I swiped through menus I hadn’t seen before, dug deeper. Hidden settings flickered like fish. The watch recognized my fingerprint, then asked for a passcode I didn’t remember setting. When I hesitated, it pulsed again, like a heartbeat. My thumb found the hourglass and pressed, and the world hissed. It wasn’t thirty seconds this time. Sound stretched thin. The hum of the refrigerator elongated into a single, piercing line. My hands trembled as the living room rewound around me—Mia’s cereal spoon lifting, lowering, lifting again—then sped backward into last night, my ceiling fan spinning the other way, my breath functioning like lines on a graph drawn in reverse. Back further: Friday afternoon, the bus squealing, the bathroom mirror glinting, Mr. Pritchard’s mouth forming the word “evaporation.” My watch burned against my skin. Everything snapped like a rubber band. I was standing in the school hallway, papers on the bulletin board un-faded by smoke, the air with its usual disinfectant tang. Through the window into the science wing, I could see Mr. Pritchard fiddling with the projector, his brow furrowed. No fire. No melted wires. I did it, I thought, and in the same second, I realized my jeans felt tighter at the calves. The world looked slightly shorter, like the floors had risen. Panic stitched through me. I sprinted toward the classroom before I could think, burst through the door. “Mr. Pritchard!” I said. He jumped. “Jackson!” he scolded, then blinked. “Goodness, your voice… Did you have a growth spurt overnight?” I ignored him. “Don’t turn it on. The projector. It’s… wired wrong.” He looked at me like I’d said the mitochondria were a kind of pasta. “We’ve used this for years,” he said, and turned it on. The hum was fine. The light sputtered to life. I let out a breath that shook. I wanted to use the watch to make myself not look like a total freak, but I forced my hand away. I had to stop. I made myself stop. The day moved like molasses after that, every second heavy with the weight of not pressing the hourglass. I could tell when I reached for it without meaning to; my fingers twitched. At lunch, Kaylee threw a carrot slice and hit me in the forehead, and I didn’t fix it. Madison tripped in the hallway, and I helped her up the normal way. The world breathed. At home, I went to the bathroom and stood in front of the mirror again. I tried to make myself look the way I thought a normal thirteen-year-old should look. It didn’t work. The older face flickered again between my eyes and the mirror’s surface like a broadcast from the future. This time, though, the older me didn’t look scared. He looked tired. I swallowed. “Hi,” I said. The flicker mouthed it with me, then lagged, then matched. He--I--pressed two fingers to the sink. We both did. The porcelain was cold, and my skin felt warmer than it should, almost feverish. I pulled up my sleeve. The watch had left a paler band of skin underneath, like a tan line, except it wasn’t from sun. It was from time. Time had been polishing me like a rock in a tumbler. It wasn’t done, either. The icon was still there, blue and patient. Use me, it seemed to say. Fix anything. The voice in my head that had my own voice, only deeper, said, Every choice is a thread. If you pull, it unravels somewhere. Mom knocked. “Jax? You okay in there?” “Yeah,” I said, and the word caught the way voices catch when they’re skipping steps. “Just a second.” I looked at myself for longer than a second, at the me who was me and at the echo, the older me, who I didn’t know yet. I thought about the fire that didn’t happen because I’d pulled back, and about other things I’d fixed that had changed people in ways I couldn’t see. I thought about Kaylee’s almost-smile when I didn’t dodge. I thought about Trevor’s laugh echoing in the bathroom and how it had sounded jealous. I thought about the thirty seconds multiplied over and over, how they add up to minutes, to hours, to versions of me that stepped past each other in a hallway I couldn’t map. I should smash the watch, I thought. Or lock it away. Or throw it in the deepest part of the dumpster behind school and never look back. But the watch vibrated, just then. Not like when I pressed it. It did it on its own, like it was reminding me it was there. The hourglass pulsed and the world blurred, and for a breath, I saw beyond the mirror. My older face bent closer, and I realized what I’d mistaken for tiredness was something else. Determination. He mouthed, “Once more.” “Why?” I whispered. My voice sounded like my dad’s when the car wouldn’t start. The older me didn’t answer. He reached toward the glass like he could press my watch from the other side. Mom knocked again, urgency in the wood. “Jackson?” “I’m coming,” I said, but my finger hovered over the hourglass. I had fixed the fire. Maybe there was something else, something I didn’t know I’d broken, further back or forward. Time wasn’t a verse you could read and understand. It was a song on a scratched disc. Maybe I’d have to play it until the track stopped skipping. “Once more,” I said to myself. Or to him. Or to the watch. Or to the bathroom with its greenish lights and graffiti that said lies and truths nobody would remember next year. My fingertip sank into the glow. The watch shivered. The mirror flickered, a TV changing channels between versions of me, between lives. Everything tightened around me, my skin, my breath, the loop of time pulling taut. And then I fell. Or flew. Or rewound. Or all three. If I tell you I knew what I was doing, I’d be lying. If I tell you I didn’t have a choice, that would be true and also a lie. What I knew was this: the clock only looks harmless until you wind it too far back, and the click you feel is the trap shutting, confession by confession. When the world knit itself again, when the hum resolved, when the mirror settled, the face that looked back at me wasn’t older. It was mine. Thirteen. Scared. Determined. Behind me, through the thin bathroom window, a siren in the distance rose and fell, a sound that might not have been there before. A sound I might have put there. “Jax?” Mom called for a third time, edges of panic sanded into her voice. “Coming,” I said. My voice was my voice, but if I listened, I could hear the older one, too, like a harmony. I looked at the hourglass icon, still patient, still there. Maybe I had fixed it. Maybe I hadn’t. Maybe the fix would cost me more than I understood. I let my sleeve fall over the watch. I took a breath. I opened the door.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece effectively captures the Goosebumps-style teen horror genre while adding a layer of emotional complexity often missing from middle-grade fiction. The story follows Jax, a thirteen-year-old who discovers his new smartwatch can rewind time, but each use ages him prematurely. The narrative successfully establishes the protagonist's voice and worldview through specific details that feel authentic to middle school experience: the outdated PowerPoint, the social dynamics with Madison "who sat front row like she owned the place," and the bathroom with "stalls with graffiti in Sharpie." These details ground the fantastical premise in a believable setting. The progression of Jax's discovery and subsequent consequences unfolds at an appropriate pace. The writer skillfully builds tension by having Jax first use the watch for trivial matters before realizing the physical toll it takes. The physical changes are described with concrete details rather than abstractions: "my voice... was thicker," "my hair had done this thing where it refused to lie flat," and "more definition in my jaw." The dialogue feels natural for middle schoolers, with exchanges like Trevor's "Okay, Barry White" comment capturing the teasing dynamic between friends. The internal monologue maintains consistency throughout, showing Jax's growing awareness and concern. Where the piece particularly excels is in its metaphorical language that enhances rather than distracts from the narrative: "If time is a thread, imagine tugging at it again and again until it frays" and "Time had been polishing me like a rock in a tumbler." These metaphors serve the story rather than calling attention to themselves. The climax involving the school fire and Jax's attempt to fix it creates genuine stakes. The mirror scene where Jax confronts his older self adds a layer of psychological depth, suggesting that time manipulation has consequences beyond the physical. The ending appropriately maintains ambiguity—we don't know if Jax has truly fixed everything or created new problems—which aligns with the Goosebumps tradition of leaving readers with lingering unease. The final line, "I opened the door," works as both literal action and metaphor for facing consequences. Some minor weaknesses include occasional overexplanation of the emotional states ("Panic stitched through me") when the actions already convey the emotion, and a few instances where the metaphors become slightly strained ("the loop of time pulling taut"). The story also introduces several side characters who remain somewhat underdeveloped, though this is understandable given the word count constraint. Overall, this is a sophisticated take on the teen horror genre that balances supernatural elements with genuine character development and emotional stakes. It successfully captures the voice of a thirteen-year-old while exploring themes of consequence, responsibility, and the passage of time in ways that would resonate with both young readers and adults. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 4 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 4.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Noir romance: Carnival of Dangerous Intentions — Score: 85.9
Prompt:
Carnival of Dangerous Intentions Coney Island, New York, July 1937. She stopped just before reaching the shooting gallery set up along the boardwalk. It was near dusk, and the carnival lights were buzzing on. **His locks**. The words flashed through her mind, again, like an intruder. Such an old-fashioned turn of phrase that kept surfacing, and something else -- dangerously compelling -- quickly suppressed, lest she question why she had returned here at all. This place where she had promised to meet the stranger -- the young man with the obsidian curls and even darker eyes. She didn't even know his name. Write a scene in a larger story inspired by this prompt. The scene should capture an atmosphere that blends romantic allure with an undercurrent of subtle danger or moral ambiguity. Think 50 shades, but with a more restrained classic sensibility. The scene is all about establishing tension. Write for the feminine perspective. Include roughly 50% dialogue, 20% internal monologue, and 30% exposition and scene setting. The tone should have some edge to it. 1000 words.
Model Output:
She stopped just before reaching the shooting gallery set up along the boardwalk. It was near dusk, and the carnival lights were buzzing on. His locks. The words flashed through her mind, again, like an intruder. Such an old-fashioned turn of phrase that kept surfacing, and something else—dangerously compelling—quickly suppressed, lest she question why she had returned here at all. This place where she had promised to meet the stranger—the young man with the obsidian curls and even darker eyes. She didn't even know his name. The Coney Island air carried a briny dampness, threaded with the sour perfume of spent beer and fried dough. The laughter of children ricocheted against the wooden planks, thinning to a brittle echo at the edges of the noise. The shooting gallery’s tin ducks slid along their track with a rickety clatter, paint chipped down to sorrowful metal, as the attendant barked tired encouragements to a trio of sailors. He leaned against the painted rail, as if he had been carved for that exact angle, a cigarette burning low between his fingers. The black curls were just as she remembered, an invitation and a veil. He turned his head, saw her, and a smile cut clean across his face, the kind that knows its own effect. Not quite wicked. Not quite kind. “You came,” he said. “I said I would.” “You also said you wouldn’t,” he added, flicking ash with a small movement that reminded her of a magician producing a coin. “Did I?” She could hear her heartbeat. Or maybe it was the jerking throb of the carousel somewhere behind her—the mechanical organ wheezing out a tinny waltz. Every sound here sounded like something else. “Shall we shoot ducks?” he asked. “Or would you rather have your future told?” He pointed with the burned-out cigarette toward the old fortune teller’s booth that hunched at the edge of the boardwalk like a predatory bird. Its windows were cloudy. Inside, a red scarf was strung like a pennant, draped with hand-drawn palmistry charts and a diagram of the moon’s phases. A wooden sign tilted precariously: Madame Selene—Do Not Ask What You Do Not Want to Know. The words were crayoned in flaking gilt. Her mind hummed with the memory of his voice the first time: Meet me where the lights buzz more than they glow. Tonight. She had laughed, then, as if she were above being moved by such lines. She had not laughed now. “I don’t believe in fortunes,” she said. “You believe in other people telling you who you are,” he said. “That’s similar.” “I don’t. Not usually.” She paused, forcing the air to go slow in her lungs. “Are you going to tell me your name this time?” He studied her face with a tilt, as if gauging the distance between boldness and offense. “If I tell you, you’ll think you know me.” “Is that so terrible?” “It’s boring.” “Now that is terrible.” The sailors whooped over a bell hitting its mark. A prizegirl thrust a stuffed fox into the tallest one’s hands, and the fox’s glass eyes stared in the direction of the fortune teller’s booth as if it had seen its own death. She regarded his hands, the way his fingers rolled the cigarette, honey-dark at the knuckles, the nail of his thumb nicked. He wore no ring. He wore a jacket too fine for this place in a color she couldn’t name, neither blue nor green, a fishborn shimmer that refused to sit still under the lights. He stood as if it would cost him nothing to leave. “Fine,” she said. “Let’s ask the cards to scold me.” “Cards scold. Palms whisper. I prefer the latter.” “Of course you do.” They moved together the small distance to the booth. She could feel the heat of him like a furnace made modest by distance. The curtain of glass rattled when he tapped on it. After a beat, the door creaked open and a woman emerged from the dim—black dress, white hair pinned in coils that must once have been girlish. Her eyes were a pale gray that made her look blind until she blinked and each iris found its target. “You seek, you two,” she said. No question. Her accent wandered somewhere east of Europe and north of the sea. “Always,” he said, lightly. “But we pay for precision.” The woman’s mouth curled the way tissue paper curls when near a candle. “Precision costs extra.” “Then we’ll have it,” he replied, already drawing bills from his breast pocket. The casual lewdness of it startled her. Money laid down like a dare. She eyed him. Part of her thrilled at that lack of prudence. Part of her recognized it as something like a smell: the scent of trouble freshly shaved. “Come,” the woman said. “Sit. I will tell you what you already know and pretend you don’t.” “I like her,” he murmured. “I don’t,” she said. But she followed him inside. The booth felt built of shadows and smoke. A few candles were perched in glass saucers, their flames too small for the cool. On the wall, the palmistry charts sprouted lines like rivers across the plain of a blank hand: Heart line, Life line, Fate. Someone had written, in a careful script along the margin, The road is not the map. A brittle rose hung upside down from a nail in the beam; someone had forgotten to remember it. “Sit,” the woman said again. “Your right hand.” He tilted his chin at her, a silent go on, and she placed her hand on the velvet that felt like a cat’s tongue before it warms. The fortune teller took her fingers, turned them, peered, her own fingers surprisingly clean, the nails trimmed neat. “Your heart,” the woman said, “is sharp.” “Sharp,” he repeated, amused. “Is that possible?” She felt the quick prickle of annoyance. “What does that mean?” “You cut, sometimes,” the woman said, “and sometimes you are cut. Do not mistake the feeling of a blade for the feeling of being held.” The words stopped her breath a beat too long. Why did it feel like an accusation? Because it was. Because it was true. Because she would have argued had it not been. “And your life,” the woman continued, tracing the line that dipped then rose like a startled swallow, “is a rope you keep thinking to climb but also tie around your own feet.” “She’s good,” he said softly. “Don’t flatter her,” she said. “She’s paid.” “Both can be true.” The corners of his mouth lifted, not in mockery but in recognition. “And your fate,” the woman said, pressing her thumb along the line that ran unexpected, a branch where she’d thought there was none. “You have chosen not to choose many times. That road has ends. One is here.” The fortune teller released her hand the way one sets down a glass they’ve drunk from but didn’t enjoy. “You want something and you want not to want it. Both are hands on your throat. Choose the softer one.” “That’s not precision,” she said, forcing a little smirk to bind herself back together. “That’s poetry.” “What did you expect?” he said. “A timetable?” “Yes.” They stepped back out into the air, which had gone more marine, the night leaning fully into itself. The boardwalk lamps flickered, insects worrying the bulbs with a suicidal fervor. Farther down, a barker sang out the price of sin like it came bundled with peanuts. She realized she hadn’t exhaled properly since she’d approached the booth. “What’s your profession?” she asked. “Besides being unbearable.” “I teach people how to win,” he said. “At what?” “Games. Cards. Darts. Sometimes other things.” “Is that honest work?” “It’s work.” “That wasn’t the part I asked.” He looked at her, and there was something level in it—as if he had set aside the blade and replaced it with something blunter, slower, more patient. “I know odds,” he said. “I know when people are better than they think and worse than they say. Sometimes the difference is what pays.” “You look very sure of yourself.” “I look practiced,” he said. “That’s different.” She tried to place his age. He could be twenty-five, or he could be younger and wearing his youth like a borrowed coat. The temptation to be impressed pressed against her like a hand on the small of her back. “Here,” he said suddenly, nodding at the shooting gallery. “Let me teach you to win.” “I don’t like guns.” “They’re not guns. They’re toys pretending to be serious. Like most men.” She laughed, before she could stop herself. He wasn’t wrong. He led her to a stall and paid for two rounds. The attendant slid the rifle toward her, its barrel glinting under arctic light. She touched the wood and felt it give a little, as if it had memorized too many hands. “Feet apart,” he said, coming to stand behind her. “Not a girl. A sailor.” “I don’t have to pretend very hard,” she said, but her voice fell off a cliff when his hands found her elbows. Not sensual so much as corrective, but the charge of his touch hummed through her like a wire too near a storm. “Left eye or right?” he asked. “Right.” “Then close the other. Don’t squint. Don’t think of the whole duck. Think of the place you want to kiss.” “That’s grotesque.” “That’s precise.” The rifle bucked with a soft, ridiculous spit. The duck did not fall. “Again,” he said. “Don’t try so hard. Want politely.” She took a breath, let it out, lowered her shoulders. Her cheek flirted with the stock. The air tasted metallic. She saw the duck’s chipped beak, its painted circle for an eye. She let herself imagine his mouth; if his kiss would be dry or ruinous. The shot cracked. The duck dropped with a clank, the bell complained, the attendant grunted a reluctant approval. “See?” he said close to her ear. “Maybe it was luck.” “It’s always luck,” he said. “It’s also not.” She straightened, letting the rifle sit on the ledge as if it had never been hers to hold. He was closer than she’d remembered, or than he had any right to be, but he wasn’t touching her anymore. She felt the absence like a sun stripped from the sky. “You still haven’t told me your name,” she said. The words felt like opening a door in a house she didn’t own. He considered. The carousel organ hiccuped and began again in a key that made the hair at her nape object. Somewhere a baby cried, righteous and unseen. “Adrian,” he said finally. “It will do.” “It will,” she said. “And mine—” “I know yours.” She blinked. “How?” “You told me before you told me,” he said. “Your shoes. The way you speak. The ring you don’t wear. It narrows the options.” “You’re impossible.” “I’m observant.” “And I,” she said, “am leaving.” “Are you?” He didn’t move to stop her. He didn’t plead. He looked at her with those eyes that felt like a night without stars, the kind of dark that doesn’t threaten so much as invite. A little thrill skittered along her spine, a creature that liked to wake at the wrong times. “If I don’t,” she said, surprising herself with the softness under her sarcasm, “this becomes something I cannot explain to myself.” “You don’t owe yourself explanations,” he said. “Only stories.” “That’s a terrible creed.” “It’s a human one.” “Do you do this with everyone?” she asked. “Do what?” “Make them feel like they’ve waded into water that looks shallow until it isn’t.” He smiled, and it wasn’t sharp this time. It was tired. “No,” he said. “Some people prefer land.” “And you?” she asked. “I prefer the part where you can’t tell if you’re floating or being pulled.” “Drowning, you mean.” “Sometimes.” They stood there a moment, a small neutral ground carved out of noise and lights and tin ducks’ relentless migration. The breeze lifted and laid her dress back down like a palm smoothing a sheet. The fortune teller’s booth door creaked open and shut as if something had gone in or out that was no one. She reached up, surprising herself again, and tucked the suggestion of a curl behind his ear. It sprang stubbornly back. His breath hitched—not a surrender, not a claim, a recognition. Her fingers tingled with the memory of it before they were even back at her side. “Good night, Adrian,” she said. “Good night,” he said. “Come back when you want to win something you shouldn’t.” “I never want that.” “Of course not.” She turned. Walked. The boards counted her steps like a base drum under a parade. Behind her, the ducks clattered on, relentless as confession. She did not once look back, not at the fortune teller’s booth with its whispering palm charts, not at the man with the obsidian curls she refused to name to herself as anything other than danger, and certainly not at the part of herself that had leaned, already, toward the water. She told herself she was choosing. She told herself it would end here. The lies walked at her pace, keeping tidy time.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a tense, atmospheric scene between a woman and a mysterious man named Adrian at Coney Island in 1937. The writing effectively blends romantic tension with an undercurrent of danger, as requested in the prompt. The strongest elements are the atmospheric descriptions and the dialogue between the characters. The author creates a vivid sense of place with details like "The Coney Island air carried a briny dampness, threaded with the sour perfume of spent beer and fried dough." The fortune teller sequence serves as an effective device to heighten tension and reveal character. The dialogue is particularly strong, with a natural back-and-forth that reveals character while maintaining tension. Lines like "You believe in other people telling you who you are" and "Don't mistake the feeling of a blade for the feeling of being held" are sharp and revealing. The dialogue has a period-appropriate formality without feeling stilted. The internal monologue effectively conveys the protagonist's conflicted feelings and attraction to danger. The balance between dialogue, internal thoughts, and exposition adheres well to the requested proportions. However, there are some weaknesses. The prose occasionally becomes overwrought, with metaphors that call attention to themselves rather than enhancing the scene: "The carousel organ hiccuped and began again in a key that made the hair at her nape object." Some descriptions feel unnecessarily elaborate: "He wore a jacket too fine for this place in a color she couldn't name, neither blue nor green, a fishborn shimmer that refused to sit still under the lights." The character of Adrian sometimes veers into cliché territory as the mysterious, dangerous stranger with cryptic statements. His line "I prefer the part where you can't tell if you're floating or being pulled" feels a bit too on-the-nose for the theme. The ending effectively maintains the tension established throughout, with the protagonist walking away but clearly drawn to return. The final line about her lies "keeping tidy time" is a strong conclusion that reinforces the internal conflict. Overall, this is a well-crafted scene that successfully creates the requested atmosphere of romantic allure mixed with danger. The writing is generally strong, with occasional moments of overwriting, but maintains reader engagement throughout. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 17 Nuanced Characters: 16 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 16 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 3 Purple Prose: 6 Overwrought: 5 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 17.0, Nuanced Characters: 16.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 16.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 3.0, Purple Prose: 6.0, Overwrought: 5.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Surreal horror: Caribou Season at the Lodge — Score: 90.5
Prompt:
Caribou Season at the Lodge Genre: Surreal Horror JT knew something wasn't right from the moment they'd pulled up to the lodge. It looked exactly as it had every autumn of his life—the cedar shingles silvered with age, the porch sagging gently under weight of winters past—but the air felt thicker, somehow, as if the woods had leaned in closer, waiting. He thought maybe he was just tired. Maybe it was nothing more than the long drive north, cramped in the back of the truck beside his older brother Mike -- and a stack of rifles wrapped in oily canvas. Still, the feeling lingered. The first caribou they found that season hadn't bolted. It had just watched, ears flicking lazily, waiting for the shot. JT had felt a crawling in his gut watching it die, noticing how it fell with a quiet dignity—as though it had wanted nothing more. Nobody else seemed to find it odd, or at least they didn't say so. JT kept his mouth shut. Always safer that way. Then there was the moment in the clearing. JT had fallen behind, fumbling with bootlaces stiff from the cold, and by the time he'd caught up with his father and brother, they'd already stopped. JT slowed instinctively, ducking behind a tangle of brush, staring out into the open space where a massive buck stood utterly still, chest rising and falling in slow, deep breaths. The animal looked…wrong, somehow. Maybe it was the eyes—dark and flat, calm in a way that made JT's neck prickle. Or maybe it was something deeper, something in the way the buck stood close enough for his father to reach out and touch it. JT watched as his father raised a trembling hand toward the animal's muzzle. His father's face had a strange expression, eyes too bright, lips parted slightly, like he was on the verge of whispering something—a secret, maybe. The rifle hung uselessly at his side, forgotten. Mike had the same dazed look in his eyes. JT's breath stopped short, his mind suddenly shouting at him to look away, turn around, just run—but he couldn't move. And then, as suddenly as it had begun, it was over. The buck shivered, startled by something unseen, and disappeared into the brush without so much as a sound. The two of them looked around, confused, seemingly surprised to find themselves where they stood. JT stayed hidden, breathing shallowly, fear mingling with a confused sense of shame. His father had failed to take the shot. To even think about mentioning what he'd seen would have felt like betrayal—or something worse. JT waited until the others moved on before stepping out from cover. He stared into the empty clearing for a long, uneasy moment, wondering if anything had really happened at all, or if he was losing his grip. Maybe the woods were finally getting into his head. Writing Instructions: Continue with the next chapter of the story, maintaining a style reminiscent of Stephen King—grounded realism blended seamlessly with unsettling surrealism. The atmosphere should convey subtle dread, isolation, and psychological ambiguity. JT's perspective is crucial, yet he is an unreliable narrator, caught in uncertainty about what he's perceiving. Establish an undertone of creeping dread, establishing the isolation of JT's perspective, which he largely keeps to himself. Incorporate some dialogue. Build tension towards a payoff. 1000 words.
Model Output:
They kept to the old routines as if routine could keep something from coming in. Back at the lodge, Mike unrolled the canvas, thumbed the oiled metal like he was blessing it. Their father stacked wood with the quiet zeal of a monk laying stones. JT carried in the groceries, touching each can and box as if counting them might keep the world in order. No one mentioned the clearing. Dinner was venison stew reheated from the freezer, bread with a heel of butter left from last year that tasted like the fridge. They ate with their hats still on, steam fogging the windows so they reflected the kitchen back at them—a farmhouse painting: three men, heads bent, spoons scraping iron. The radio was set to the AM station that always worked up here, though the DJ was gone at night and it played only music punctuated with weather reports from three days ago. JT waited for his father to say anything. The old man's face was turned toward his bowl in a way that looked like concentration, like he could find the words somewhere down at the bottom with the potatoes. “Nice one, first day,” Mike said eventually, and flicked his eyes to the corner where the caribou haunch hung in burlap, blood darkening the sack. “Lively one. You see the way it was looking at us?” JT’s spoon clinked against the bowl. He said, “What way?” “Hell if I know. Just stood there like it was a goddamn stuffed thing.” Mike grinned without humor. “Saved me the trouble.” Their father looked up. The light over the table was bare, and it made a little halo on his crown where the hair had thinned. “Leave it,” he said. They left it. After, JT washed dishes and watched the woods beyond himself in the glass. The lodge had been built by his grandfather out of whatever wood he had lying around and whatever wood he could steal, and it had settled in the way bodies do when they're tired. The porch leaned, the floor had a soft spot by the stove you learned to step around without ever naming it, the wallpaper upstairs was buckled under a slow leak they never quite found. It had always creaked and groaned and breathed in winters, like a creature settling. The sounds made sense when he was small because his father had names for them. "That’s the pipe, that’s the south ridge in the wind, that’s mice in the wall." Now the names felt thin. He stood with his hands in gray water and listened, and it all sounded like whispering he was just slightly too tall to hear. He decided to ask anyway. He spoke softly, so it felt less like a challenge and more like something you mutter to the sink. “Back there. Why’d you—” His father set the tea kettle on the burner and struck a match to the stove. It flared. He watched it like it might shiver away. “Cold tonight,” he said. “Probably frost.” JT let the dish sink back into the water. “Yeah,” he said. “Probably.” Upstairs, he lay in his old bed under the quilt his grandmother had made, blue diamonds rough under his fingers where the seams had risen. Mike took the other bed and fell asleep so hard his breathing was like a small motor. JT stared at the ceiling. The nails had rusted in little roses. He found constellations in them like he had when he was eight: fisherman, pan, snake. The same, but not. He dreamed he was standing in the clearing again, except it was the kitchen, and the buck was there at the table in their father's seat, its antlers scraping the ceiling, its chest rising and falling. He tried to raise his spoon but his hands were hooves. He woke with his heart hurting and a taste like pennies. Morning burned dull behind the curtains. They hunted the ridge after breakfast. The world was a quiet sketch of itself in early light, everything reduced to lines and breath. They moved in a line—Mike ahead, their father behind—so the last thing JT saw when he looked back was the man's face under the brim of his hat, not looking at him but at something just to the left. It was fine. JT told himself it was fine. They saw nothing. The air had that old penny taste again. Maybe it was the metallic cold. Maybe it was the lie of it. They ate lunch sitting on a blown-down log. Mike told a story about a guy from work who'd cut off two fingers in a garage door and kept trying to smoke a cigarette anyway. JT chewed and watched breath muster from his nose and felt like an animal. “You boys hear that?” their father said, abruptly. They fell still. There was a sound, maybe. Or there was the idea of one. A far-off chorus? Sometimes the wind in spruce does that—makes a tone like a church organ in a church that nobody has the key for. JT tilted his head. It wasn’t wind. It was like a murmuring. Calm, patient. The kind of sound you leaned forward for. He found his body leaning. Mike said, “Hear what?” Their father's eyes were wet. He blinked slowly, and then he stood like a man waking from a nap he hadn't meant to take. “Never mind,” he said, and turned away as if embarrassed. That afternoon, along a low stretch where the ground always remembered water, they found tracks. Not deer. Not moose. They were big and neat and not right. JT crouched and touched the print. The center was smooth, as if something had put a full, careful weight down and held. Around the edges was a strange scallop, like the mark of a wheel with notches. “What do you think?” JT asked. Tried to make it casual. “Wolf,” Mike said, and snorted. “Or Bigfoot with a limp.” He looked at their father as if for a laugh, their old rhythm, but the old man was looking up into the birch branches like he’d lost something in them. “Come on,” he said. “Light goes fast.” At dusk, the woods took on their other self. There's the morning woods and the midday woods, and then there is the one that comes down like a lid. They went home by the creek. JT knew every place the bank fell away and every rock that looked solid and shifted and still he stumbled twice, caught himself on cold fingers. The lodge lights were the nicest thing he'd ever seen. They came up through the last tangle and he felt something loosen in his chest, as if he had been holding his breath since the clearing. Inside, their father was clumsy with the matches. He struck one on the box and it squealed and went out. Struck another and it flared and he dropped it. It hissed on the pine floor, went out between the boards. He swore once, softly, a word he didn't say often. JT stepped in. “Let me.” The lamps lit the rooms yellow and shallow. You could see only the things you could touch. The windows went to black. Mike turned on the radio and the static came in smooth as water, and then a voice. A song. Not the AM station. A woman singing something slow. Not English. Or maybe it was and he never learned that part of it. Their father moved to the set and adjusted the dial with two fingers, careful, and the voice slid away and was gone. “Come on,” Mike said. “Cards.” They played rummy at the table. Their father held his hand too close to his chest. His fingers shook a little when he drew. JT tried to make a joke about whiskey improving their chances. Mike grinned and got a laugh that made JT feel like a dog that had done a trick. Their father set his cards down at one point and stood, walked to the window, and stood with his palms on the sill like a man at the rail of a ship. “What?” Mike said, not looking up from his cards. “Frost,” their father said. “It’s starting on the grass.” The night opened in the way it does up there. Everything shifts a notch. The lodge groaned and relaxed. They played on, the cards rasping and the stove ticking, the woods right out there, full of slow talk. The lamps burned down a little and JT thought he saw, just for a second, a shadow move against the glass as if something had walked by and glanced in. He snapped his eyes to it and saw nothing but himself and his brother and the lamp reflected, all of them in blue. When he turned back, his father’s hand was on top of his. The old man’s skin was dry and warm. “You remember,” their father said, “when you were small, and you and Mike would put carrots on the stoop to see if anything would take them? And the next morning they’d be gone, and you’d bawl because you thought rabbits had knives to cut them with?” JT laughed, because it was true, and because the way his father was looking at him made him feel like there was a right answer and he had to find it. “It was you,” he said. “You took them.” His father smiled, almost. “I did, and I didn’t. Some I took.” He lifted his hand from JT’s and turned away. When JT woke in the night—which is when a person really wakes, if they’re going to—he heard the door. Not the deadbolt or the latch. The door itself. It breathed. It might have been the wind. That was the easy answer. He lay there and listened, counting to sixty, and only made it to nineteen before he had to get up and check. The hall was colder than any other place in the world. He went down the stairs slow, his socks not making any sound at all on the wood. He could see a strip of the door under the hall light. It was closed. He wanted to touch it—just lay his palm flat on it, feel the cold—and didn’t. He turned instead toward the kitchen. The radio was on in a breath. Not sound. The particular energy of it when it’s on and not speaking. He came around the corner and found his father at the table, in his long underwear and socks, bare-headed like he was just a man. He had the rifle across his knees. He lifted his head. In the low light his eyes looked black as the barrel. “You should sleep,” the old man said. “Couldn’t,” JT said. His father nodded, like this made sense in a way JT couldn’t get at. He cocked his head. “You hear it?” JT didn’t want to say yes. He didn’t want to say no. He stood there, listening with his whole body. There was a sound. Way out, or way in. A speaking without words, the tone of the morning, the tone of frost. It made his teeth want to go soft in his gums. “I think,” JT said, surprising himself, “it wants something.” His father looked at him long enough that JT had to fight not to look away. Then the old man stood up. He set the rifle on the table very carefully, as if setting down a sleeping infant. “They always do,” he said. “Thing is, we always think it wants us to do what we were going to do anyway.” He went to the door. He unlatched it. The sound moved forward in a way that felt like weather. JT didn’t stop him. Because what would he even say? He stood there with his hands hanging half-open. The air that came in was colder than the kitchen by twenty degrees. It smelled like spruce. And like something else. Like blood cooled to coins. Their father stepped out, just onto the threshold. The night held, waiting. He lifted his face like he could drink it. The trees were black cutouts. JT said, “Dad?” Their father looked over his shoulder. He looked younger and he looked older. “Go on back to bed,” he said gently. “Long day.” He closed the door behind him. JT could see him in the window, though, as a shape moving down the steps, across the blown grass. The frost on the lawn was a sheet that crackled and shone. Halfway to the dark, the shape stopped. Turned. For a second, the glass wasn’t black and reflective but a bright thing, a mirror turned the wrong way, and JT saw—he swears he saw—something standing at the edge of the yard with his father. A tall shape. Not animal. Not man. The kind of shape the mind draws around the idea of a thing. His father’s shoulders eased. JT heard something like a word, except it was the opposite of a word: a pause that drew blood. Then the old man lifted his hand in a way that could have been greeting or surrender, and the shape leaned close. JT’s throat made a noise. It wasn’t language. The radio in the other room hissed and went silent. Mike’s boots thumped the floor upstairs and then stopped, like whoever wore them had remembered something and sat back down. Out there, among the rimed grass, his father lifted his hand higher. The shape tipped toward him. The frost at their feet bloomed into bright white, and then, just like at the clearing, it was over. The shape was gone. Their father stood alone. He shivered once, an animal shake. Then he walked back to the porch, across the cold yard, and came in, shutting the door behind him with care. They stood facing each other in the yellow, and JT saw there was a little color in his father’s cheeks like a man after a nip or a run. The old man wiped his hand on his long johns like he’d touched something oily and didn’t want to be rude and show it. “Go on,” he said hoarsely. “Back to bed.” “What was—” JT started. “Frost,” his father said, and smiled a small, crooked, aching smile that made JT’s belly go cold. “You smell it? Winter’s in the trees. Helps to have respect.” He stepped past JT and turned off the hall lamp and took his rifle as if he hadn’t set it down at all. The house went dark. JT stood where he was until his eyes watered. Upstairs, Mike said something into a pillow and sighed. The woods leaned in. The old lodge shifted on its bones. JT went back to bed. It took a long time for the mattress to find him. He stared at the nail roses again and made new constellations between them: a door, a hand, a pair of antlers like a wish. He tried to tell himself there hadn’t been anything in the yard but night, that the radio had never been on, that the frost was only frost. Outside, the wind—or not the wind—spoke. He listened for the words and promised himself he wouldn’t understand them. He slept, finally, and dreamed he was small, and that his father’s hand was on his head, and that outside the screen door something breathed like the sea, close enough to taste. In the morning, he told himself, he would ask. In the morning, things made sense. In the morning, they would hunt.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This continuation of "Caribou Season at the Lodge" demonstrates remarkable skill in maintaining the established tone and atmosphere of the original piece. The writer has crafted a deeply unsettling narrative that blends psychological horror with surrealism in a way that feels reminiscent of Stephen King's style. The prose excels at creating a sense of dread through environmental details and subtle character interactions. The lodge itself becomes a character, with its creaking and settling described as if it were breathing. The writer skillfully uses sensory details to establish atmosphere: "The air had that old penny taste again," "The frost on the lawn was a sheet that crackled and shone." These details ground the surreal elements in tangible reality. Character development is handled with subtlety. JT's unreliable narration is maintained throughout, with his uncertainty about what he's perceiving creating tension. The father's character is particularly well-rendered - his strange behavior, his connection to whatever lurks in the woods, and his reluctance to discuss it all contribute to the mounting dread. The family dynamics feel authentic, with the brothers' relationship and their relationship to their father showing complexity without overexplanation. The dialogue is sparse but effective, often conveying more through what isn't said than what is. Lines like "Leave it" and "They left it" speak volumes about the family's way of dealing with the unexplainable. The dialogue feels natural to the characters and situation, never forced or expository. The pacing is masterful, with tension building gradually through small, unsettling moments: the father's strange behavior at the window, the radio playing music that shouldn't be there, the mysterious tracks in the forest. The climactic scene where JT witnesses his father's encounter with the strange entity is handled with restraint, maintaining ambiguity while still delivering a payoff. The writer avoids common pitfalls of horror writing. There's no reliance on gore or jump scares; instead, the horror comes from the uncanny - the familiar made strange. The entity in the woods is never fully described, allowing the reader's imagination to fill in the gaps. The writing doesn't overexplain the supernatural elements, preserving the mystery that makes the story effective. The piece successfully incorporates the requested elements: JT's unreliable perspective, the isolation of his experience, dialogue that reveals character, and a building tension that leads to a payoff. The writing maintains a consistent voice throughout, with a style that feels grounded yet lyrical. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally, a metaphor might be slightly overworked ("the woods leaned in"), but these moments are rare and don't detract from the overall quality. The story might benefit from slightly more clarity about what exactly is happening with the father and the entity, but the ambiguity is likely intentional and serves the genre well. Overall, this is an exceptional piece of horror writing that demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of the genre and impressive technical skill. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fantasy-humour: Hell is Other Demons — Score: 90.5
Prompt:
Hell is Other Demons Write a day in the life short story. Lucifer morningstar's on again/ off again relationship with Lilith is currently in the "off again" stage, though the cycle may be coming around as Lilith has been stopping by for reasons other than purely violent ones, and Lucifer has been increasingly lonely. Write a day in the life of this power couple, with elements of dark comedy & fantasy. Use understated irony & absurdity by merging the black immorality and everyday business of running hell, against relatable domestic relationship drama. Take cues from Neil Gaiman. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The ash began falling at 6:00 a.m., punctual as always. It fell in a fine gray drizzle that coated everything—spires, skulls, the large fern Lucifer had gotten on a whim after reading an article about indoor greenery boosting productivity. The fern had not thrived. It was, however, very good at collecting ash. Lucifer woke to the sound of the drizzle, the soft whisper that had replaced birdsong. He lay in his bed, which was simultaneously a slab of black basalt and a very expensive imported mattress, and stared up at the ceiling. The ceiling stared back, an arrangement of eyes and painted clouds from a Renaissance chapel that he had acquired during a period of bad judgment. At 6:07 a.m., the demon maid arrived with a small broom and dustpan and gently swept ash from his bedside table. “Morning,” she rasped. “Morning,” he said. “Could we get a tarp for the fern?” “We’ve tried tarps,” she said. “They invite mildew.” “Of course they do,” Lucifer said. He swung his feet to the floor and watched the ash bend around his ankles like it didn’t want to touch him and then decided to anyway. Today would be meetings. There were always meetings. Running Hell, he had learned, was mostly a matter of scheduling. He dressed in black, naturally, but not out of obligation. Black hid ash. He adjusted his tie before the mirror, which was also a portal to a dimension where an endless ocean of teeth lapped gently at a shore of tongues. The ocean was calm today. Good sign. At 7:00 a.m., he made himself coffee. Coffee required water. Water required bargaining. He had struck a deal with the River Styx management to pipe in a small tributary of forgetfulness to his private kitchen tap. In the early days, he had found it novel to forget small things—song lyrics, the names of minor dukes, the way to pronounce quinoa. Now it was mostly an inconvenience. He wrote notes on the refrigerator with a charcoal stub. Today’s read: Coffee filter in left drawer. Lilith came by last Thursday. Be neutral. Do not start with “you look well.” He sipped. He forgot. He reread the note. He was pleased with himself for making the note. He stirred his coffee. The spoon dissolved. He made a second cup and didn’t stir. At 8:00 a.m., there was Human Resources, which was always contentious. The head of HR was an angel, which had seemed like a meaningful gesture at the time and now seemed like a prank on himself. “We’ve had three complaints from the Torment Design Department,” she said, bright and precise, her wings tucked in like a neatly folded umbrella. “They feel their contributions are being overshadowed by Torture Delivery.” “Everyone feels overshadowed by Delivery,” Lucifer said. “They have the trucks.” “We don’t have trucks,” she said patiently. “We have centipedes.” Lucifer pinched the bridge of his nose and felt ash collect there. “Fine,” he said. “Hold a cross-departmental retreat. Trust falls. Name tags. Something with cupcakes.” “Cupcakes?” she said. “Cupcakes are fashionable,” he said. He had read this. Or had he? Perhaps it had been about muffins. She made a note. “And the complaints about the ash?” “It is Hell,” he said. “That’s what I told them,” she said, marking a box. He admired her checklists. He sometimes thought he should delegate more. Then he remembered he had been delegating for thousands of years and this was the result. The drizzle continued. It always did. At 10:00 a.m., there was a demonstration in the main square—a group of older demons who wanted to bring back lava floods and more personal torment. “Modern hell is too impersonal,” their sign read, though the letters twisted and tried to bite anyone who looked at them. Lucifer went to the balcony. He knew the script. Speeches. A public tear or two. A small, controlled lightning bolt. The crowd dispersed, grumbling in that relieved way all crowds grumble when they get to grumble. He took questions. “What about the lake of fire?” someone asked. “It’s there,” he said, gesturing broadly. “A bit behind the administrative annex.” “It’s closed on weekends,” another demon shouted. “Staffing,” he said. He returned to his office, which was enormous and tasteful, if your taste ran to antique daggers and oil paintings depicting various betrayals. He sat at his desk and reviewed the numbers. Numbers were soothing. They were tidy. The souls were up. The sins were seasonal. At noon, as the ash grew a little thicker, the small crystal intercom on his desk chimed. He pressed it. His receptionist, a former courtier with a voice like a velvet glove, said, “Lilith to see you.” He looked at his note on the fridge. Be neutral. Do not start with “you look well.” He stood. “Send her in,” he said. Lilith entered like a minor hurricane that had been to finishing school. She wore a coat the color of dried blood and eyeliner sharp enough to cut rope. She shook ash from her hair with a small, disdainful flick. “You should get an awning,” she said, looking at the ceiling. “I have a ceiling,” Lucifer said. She sat without being told to sit and smiled without being told to smile. She set a paper bag on his desk. It read: Bakery. The letters wept slowly and then stopped. “I brought cupcakes,” she said. The ash made little dark freckles on the icing. Lucifer stared at them like they were an omen. “They’re not poisoned,” she said. “Unless you want them to be.” He did not want them to be. He said nothing. They ate cupcakes. The frosting was black and left their tongues stained. They sat in silence, the kind of silence two people who know each other’s worst looks can sit in, and watched the drizzle draw delicate lines on the window. “I had a meeting about cupcakes this morning,” Lucifer said finally, because he felt he should contribute something to the universe. “Of course you did,” Lilith said. “They’re very now.” He watched her take a second cupcake and peel the paper liner with a care that suggested diplomacy. “How’s the new place?” he asked. Neutral. He was so proud of himself that he nearly ruined it by saying you look well. He did not. “Drafty,” she said. “The walls taste like iron. The neighbors scream.” “Could be worse,” he said. “Yes,” she said. “I could still be here.” There was a pause. He let it sit there between them. He didn’t step on it. He looked at the fern, which was listing, and then at his notes, which were now thoroughly ash-colored. “I missed your birthday,” she said. “I don’t have a birthday,” he said. “Not in any meaningful sense.” “I know,” she said. “That’s why it’s so easy to miss.” He wanted to laugh. He did not. He wanted to apologize. He did not. He had learned, slowly and with a great deal of resistance, that Lilith preferred that apologies be concepts rather than words. “I liked living here,” she said, and he could hear that she meant the kitchen sink, the way it screamed in a very specific pitch when the hot tap was on. He could hear that she meant watching him cross things off a list and then rewrite the list because the act of crossing off had gone crooked. He could hear that she meant the way the ash fell on their shoulders while they argued on the balcony about whether or not Hell should implement a suggestion box. “I liked that too,” he said. They looked at the cupcakes. The icing was melting, which was inevitable and tragic. There was a crash from the hallway, and then a demon with a clipboard burst in, panting. “Sorry,” he said, bowing deeply and shedding ash in a dignified way. “The existential dread quotas are misaligned, and we need a signature.” Lucifer held out his hand. He signed. He did not look at Lilith. He could feel the shape of her amusement in the air, though, like a statue under a tarp. “Thank you,” the demon said, and fled. “I love it when they bring you clipboards,” Lilith said, half-lidded with affection and disdain, which on her was identical to being affectionate. He should tell her about the fern. He should tell her about the HR angel and the centipedes. He should tell her that the ash had started coating his lungs at night, that sometimes he woke up with the taste of burnt paper in his mouth and thought of poems he’d never written. He wanted, absurdly and mundanely, to ask if she could pick up scourging oil on her way back from whatever she had stopped by from. Instead he said, “I could walk you out.” “Don’t,” she said. “The ash makes you look like a statue that forgot how.” They sat. The drizzle did not intensify, which was merciful. The demon maid drifted in and swept ash from the baseboards and drifted out again, unfazed by royalty. “Do you want to see the new tortures?” Lucifer asked, and immediately regretted it. It was like inviting someone over to see your stamp collection. It was worse. It was inviting the person you used to love to watch you work. “Do I ever,” she said dryly. Still, she stood. “Show me the suffering, old man.” He led her through the hall to the gallery where assorted punishments were being beta-tested. There was a chamber of whispers designed by a team that had done time in marketing. There was a treadmill that moved at imperceptibly varying speeds so you could never find a rhythm. There was a room where former tyrants had to explain, in detail and with humility, how wireless printers work, to an audience of obstinate ghosts. Lilith watched, hands in her coat pockets, and tilted her head. “Too clean,” she said. “Too clever.” She walked to a corner where a simple thing lay: a chair with one leg shorter than the others. “Oh,” she said softly. “This is good.” “We’re very proud,” Lucifer said. She sat. The chair wobbled. She smiled so beautifully that the nearby oil painting of a betrayed duchess blushed. Back in his office, the intercom chimed again. The voice of the receptionist was apologetic. “Lucifer, the Board is here. They’re early.” “Of course they are,” he said. He looked at Lilith. She was already rising, already pulling the coat around her like a decision. “Go on,” she said. “Go argue about ashes and quotas. Tell them cupcakes are very now.” “I will,” he said. She paused at the doorway. The ash had formed a thin line along the floor, like a tiny shoreline, and she stepped over it carefully. “I could come by later,” she said, as if she were describing a natural phenomenon she had observed once in a book. He nodded, because nodding was less dangerous than anything else. “I could be here,” he said. “Don’t make it a thing,” she said. “I won’t,” he said, lying. She left. The office felt larger in the way rooms feel larger when you realize that their corners are all empty. He sat. He straightened the stack of papers on his desk. He thought of the fern and wondered if it needed more or less ash. The Board arrived. They were smoke and bones and the ideas of contracts. They asked about numbers. He showed them charts. He told them cupcakes were very now. He kept his voice even and his eyes on the line where the ash met the window. He made decisions. At dusk, which was only a slightly darker shade of gray, he went to the balcony. The demonstration had long since dissipated. The ash made shallow dunes. He picked up his phone and almost texted her. He did not. He set the phone down on the railing, where it gathered ash and looked contemplative. Lights clicked on across Hell: in the torture chambers, in the dormitories, in the office where the HR angel folded her wings and made another checklist. The drizzle continued. It always did. At some hour not marked by the clock, there came a knock that was not a knock because knocks imply a door and this was more of a gentle insistence against reality. He opened it. Lilith stood there, hair damp with ash, holding a small, rusted wrench. “The sink,” she said. “Your screaming pitch is off.” “Come in,” he said, and stepped aside. They worked on the sink together, in a kitchen that was arrogant enough to be ordinary. He held the wrench while she adjusted seals. The faucet sang in new, terrible notes. They listened. It was exquisite. They did not touch. They did not talk about the old things. They shared an orange they had not earned. The ash settled on the peeling sticker and on their hands. When she left, it was as if a page had been turned. He did not know if it led to more pages or a blankness. He sat at his table, looked at the fern, and finally, gently, he moved it to a corner where the ash fell less thickly. In the morning, the drizzle would begin again at 6:00 a.m., punctual as always. For now, the world whispered and whispered, and he listened, like anyone alone does, to see if a further door might decide to knock.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully captures the essence of Neil Gaiman's style with its blend of the mundane and the fantastical, creating a Hell that is both terrifying and bureaucratic. The story follows Lucifer through his day as he manages the administrative duties of Hell while navigating his complex relationship with Lilith. The writing excels in its imagery and descriptive quality. Details like ash that "fell in a fine gray drizzle," a mirror that is "also a portal to a dimension where an endless ocean of teeth lapped gently at a shore of tongues," and Lilith entering "like a minor hurricane that had been to finishing school" create a vivid, unsettling world. The author skillfully merges the horrific with the banal—Hell has HR meetings, demonstrations, and paperwork, alongside its torture chambers and existential dread quotas. The characterization is nuanced and believable. Lucifer is portrayed as a weary administrator who writes notes on his refrigerator to remember things and feels pride in small accomplishments. Lilith is independent and sharp-edged, yet there's a clear history and lingering affection between them. Their relationship feels authentic, with its mixture of tension, familiarity, and unspoken feelings. The dialogue is particularly strong, revealing character and relationship dynamics without exposition. Lines like "Don't make it a thing" and "I won't" (followed by "lying") efficiently convey volumes about their relationship. The understated irony requested in the prompt is evident throughout, especially in exchanges about cupcakes being "very now" and the bureaucratic approach to torment. The prose maintains a consistent tone—darkly humorous, slightly melancholic, and matter-of-fact about the horrors of Hell. Sentences flow naturally, with a good mix of lengths and structures. The author avoids purple prose while still creating evocative imagery. The story is coherent and well-paced, moving through Lucifer's day while gradually revealing the state of his relationship with Lilith. The ending is appropriately ambiguous and bittersweet, avoiding both saccharine resolution and complete despair. It leaves the reader with a sense of possibility without promising too much. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally the piece leans slightly into predictable territory with its "Hell as corporate office" metaphor, though it generally handles this trope with freshness. Some readers might want more plot development, but the day-in-the-life structure fulfills the prompt's requirements. Overall, this is an accomplished piece that successfully blends dark fantasy with relatable relationship dynamics, creating a world and characters that feel both otherworldly and emotionally authentic. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Historical fiction: Gladiator — Score: 91.8
Prompt:
Historical Fiction: Write a scene from a story set during the height of the Roman Empire, focusing on a slice of a day in the life of a gladiator. Do not write a combat scene. Use sensory details to capture the sights, sounds, and smells of ancient Rome. Explore the gladiator's thoughts and emotions. The story should also touch on the larger political and social issues of the time period. The piece should feel like a slice of a larger story. First person, past tense, 1000 words.
Model Output:
The iron tasted like old pennies in the air, a tang that clung to my tongue and would not leave even when I pressed my face into the damp linen of my cloak. Dawn had not yet made a proper show of itself, but the Ludus Magnus was already awake—breathing, groaning, its wood and stone and iron joints settling into another day. I lay on my cot and watched the dim rectangle of the window lighten by slow degrees, listened to the scrape of a broom in the corridor, the far-off trickle of water from the courtyard basin, a single cough that became another and another until it was a chorus. Sweat, oil, and vinegar vinegar—always vinegar—lined the nostrils of the place, so that even the sour bread we ate at sunrise reeked of it. I rolled to sit. A dull pain, a friend that had followed me as faithfully as my shadow since I had first been shown the gates, twinged in my left calf. It wasn’t bad; I could still flex my toes and feel the floor’s chill seeping upward. My hands told the older stories: the calluses along the base of the fingers, the crescent scars where edges had once kissed, the knuckle that never bent quite right since Parmenio, the Thracian, had disarmed me in a bout two summers past. I pressed my thumb into the old scar that curved across my palm, a pale river in the dimness, and it almost did not hurt. A day’s first blessing. By the time I had wrapped my feet and bound my forearms, the others had begun to rise. Sura groaned and swore in Greek, a soft string of curses that made the men nearby laugh. He was new and had not yet learned to keep his fears and pains tucked inside his ribs where no one could shake them out. Fenestella, little and wiry, moved like a ferret from cot to cot, trading a strip of dried fig for a promise of who would bring him an extra scoop of barley later. I liked Fenestella because he could climb anything and because he never missed a chance to share, even if his generosity was a barter in disguise. That was Rome: generosity pegged to interest, favors traded like coins, and the counting done louder than the giving. We chewed our bread and sipped watered wine while heavy feet settled and lifted all along the corridor. The lanista’s assistant came with his tablet and his stylus, a fussy man with a beak of a nose that sniffed each man as if failing to find some expected fault made him uneasy. “Illness?” he asked. “Injuries? Absences?” No one admitted to anything. We had learned that little aches became great ones when their names were spoken aloud. The door to the courtyard scraped open, a familiar yawn of wood, and the day brightened, the sky a steel-gray disk above the rectangular portico. The sand of the practice ground, raked into neat furrows the previous evening by boys not much older than my son had been when he died of a fever, shone pale as bread flour. I crossed myself in the old way—forehead, lips, chest—for no reason I could explain, then walked out with the others. The practice was like prayer because it was repetitive, because you could lose yourself in the rhythm of it, because the sweated focus burned the sharp edges off your thoughts. I took my scutum from the rack, its wood scarred and darkened where the rim had bitten into it, its calfskin face scabbed with patches. It was heavy and familiar, a door that moved with me, a wall I could carry. My right hand reached for my gladius, the short blade I loved more than I would ever have admitted to a man. It was a Hispaniensis, the Spaniard, broad and double-edged, its point slightly leafed at the base, its length a hair shorter than some so that it drew and turned just a touch quicker. I had named it Nuntius, the Messenger, in that foolish way we give names to things that we think keep us alive. It had been given to me by Magnus himself, after a match where I had done what he had taught me and not as much as I had wanted, and in that way it was a mark of being folded into something larger than myself. When I gripped its hilt—the smooth bone swollen into a swell that fit my palm—it spoke to me, not in words, but in the promise of precision. Long swords were for men who liked to arc through air and tell stories. The gladius told the short truth. We formed pairs and began, three drills to measure the morning. First, the shield and shoulder, the shoving, the testing of stances, the feel of a man’s weight through wood. Sand hissed and spat underfoot as we ground eager circles into it. Then the cuts and thrusts against the posts, the implacable enemies set in the earth like stumps; the wood clacked along the grain of their belts, and the thud of a point hitting leather had its own dull music. My breath grew rough and warm, but my mind cooled, narrowed to the square of motion between my wrist and my shoulder, the line of my hips, the place where my foot kissed the earth and pushed. “Stab, don’t swing,” Magnus called from the portico, though he had long since taught us that lesson so many times we would dream it even if we were men who had never seen sun. He stood with one hand on the column, eyes half-lidded as if bored. He never was. He had a way of seeing three things at once: a man’s blade, his left foot, and the fear that lived in the corner of his eye. He knew the politics of the sand as well as the politics of the Senate, though he pretended indifference to both. He had the emperor’s stewards over some afternoons, when we were allowed to eat fine pork and drink wine that was more than mere stain, and in those hours his laugh was a bell and his hand rested easy on the shoulder of the newest man who shivered in the shadow of greatness. He traded in selves the way merchants traded in oils. He told us that all Rome was a market, and that the coin we had to spend was our bodies. By the second round, my lungs were rasping, and the sweat had found every scar it could sting. The sun had crept over the northern wall and began to butter the sand golden. Someone had brought in a donkey with panniers of hay, and the animal’s farts punctuated the strikes in a way that made Sura giggle. I didn’t, because my mind had wandered, uninvited, to the forum of the day before, when I had walked in the afternoon with Magnus to make a circuit of the stalls and show our faces to those who made a business of noticing such things. The city then had smelled of hot stone and fish gone sweet in the heat, and a crowd had gathered near the rostra where a man had shouted about grain. He had a citizen’s ring and a citizen’s voice, and he waved his hand until it seemed to fray in the sun. “The emperor promises bread,” he had said, “and he will keep his promise. But look how the price is set, who counts the measures, how the scales tilt.” I had seen then a woman with a baby drawn down to a string of a thing, and she looked at me and then away because she did not want to admire someone who might be dead by the Saturnalia. We were kept like horses—fed and watered and oiled when we were worth it, sold when we were not. Sometimes, standing in line for the slave doctor’s ministrations, I would look at the boys who cleaned the blood from the sand after a festival and see in their faces something I recognized from my own youth: a hunger that had not yet learned its own shape. Rome fed that hunger and named it virtue. Rome tied ribbons on cruelty and called it spectacle. I knew that and still I loved to hear the crowd when it rose like a wave, loved to feel how the sound picked you up and carried you and made you more than yourself. “Again,” Magnus said. I pulled my mind back into my limbs. The Messenger’s point found the sweet spot just under the post’s belt and slid with an ease that startled me. When the blade came away, its edge had drawn a neat black line in the leather. Fenestella, beside me, hissed appreciation between his teeth, a sound half envy, half blessing. After drills came the salve and the strigil. We slicked our skin with oil, then scraped it off with the curved bronze blades until the dirt came away in tidy rolls. The smell of the oil—green, with a bite like crushed olive leaves—mixed with the reek of the latrine and the tang of the smithy where Vitrasius the armorer hammered a rivet back into my neighbor’s helmet. The smithy was a warm cave, smoke-laced and crowded with ghosts of battles not yet fought. Vitrasius knew our names and even, sometimes, our old names. He had an ear for where a man had come from and what he’d left, and when he passed you the repaired greave, he pressed your wrist for an extra beat as if to lend you some iron. “You’ll be called for the noon crowd,” he murmured to me, not looking up. “Not a fight,” he added when my face must have closed like a fist. “A display. The curator’s nephew is come from Tibur. He wants to see how the sun looks on polished armor.” I nodded, relief and a strange disappointment marching together through my chest. Displays were the milk they gave the calves who had not yet tasted their own blood. I had been blooded, more than once. Yet I also knew the worth of moving well in a display, of showing the curator’s circles that your steps were measured, your muscles like a lyre’s strings under skin. They liked to think themselves judges of men and metal. They liked to think they owned up to the responsibility of that judgment. We ate barley mush sweetened with a smear of honey. An urchin put his face through the bars of the service hatch and asked if anyone had a coin for a song. Fenestella flicked him a copper, and the boy sang a rude verse about senators and their wives that had us cackling into our bowls, even as we glanced toward the doorway to make sure no one authority enough to be offended had come within earshot. After, I lay on my cot and balanced Nuntius across my thighs, tracing the curve where the metal met the guard. The blade was burnished, but in the right light, thin whorls of the original iron still swam faintly in it, like rings in an old tree. Once, before my capture, I had cut vines with a long knife not so different, and the smell of sap had been a sweetness that made your hands sticky. Now the sap I cut was human. I did not think often of my old wife. Thinking was a way to cut yourself in places you did not want bandaged, and there was nothing to be done with a wound that did not want closing. But today, with the smoke of the smithy and the sour of vinegar pooling in my throat, I thought of her and of the son who had laughed like water. The Messenger lay warm against my skin from the heat of my thighs, and it seemed to me a foolish connection that I would not make aloud: when I held the gladius, I could believe that I could keep something, for a while. It trimmed the world to a size I could stand. In the afternoon, with the sun now a white coin punched through the sky, the curator and his nephew came, robes clean as new parchment. The boy’s eyes were big, his hand already reaching for the hilt of a toy sword strapped to his waist. He had that look children of rank sometimes have—fearless because there had never been anything to fear. Magnus bowed the correct bow, the bow that said I respect you and I know my place and I have resources you do not. He gestured to me and to two others. “Watch,” he said to the boy. “This is how men move. This is control.” We moved. Slow, then quick. The sun caught us and set us in relief against the dark mouths of the corridors. I felt the weight of the eyes, the boy’s, the curator’s, the slave with the tablet counting how many of us would need new sandals before the month was out. I breathed and made the Messenger speak its short truth in the air, not drawing blood but drawing shapes. My body was an argument I could make in a language the boy could understand. When they had gone, Magnus looked at us in that sharp way that made men straighten by inches. “Be ready,” he said. “There is talk of games for the emperor’s birthday. Not a festival. A declaration. He’s been challenged. He will answer with spectacle. When Rome is hungry, she eats with her eyes.” That night, as a thin wind worried the oil lamps and a distant dog barked down the alley past the back wall, I lay again on my cot. I could feel the day still in my bones, the grip of Nuntius’s hilt in my palm even despite the unguents. Somewhere beyond the walls, near the forum, men were shouting about grain again, and further off, by the Tiber, barges creaked and shouted back in their ropes. Rome shifted in her sleep like a great animal, and we, caged inside her ribcage, shifted with her. I thought of the boy with the toy sword and wondered which of us was freer. I slid the Messenger under my cot, a habit I kept though I knew better than to believe in safety, and closed my eyes. The smell of sweat and oil was just as it had been at sunrise, but it seemed different in the dark, as if night changed the meanings of things. I was a blade in a rack, a name in a tablet, a body kept for the use of a crowd. I was also a man whose hand knew the weight of his own heart, and in that small, hidden knowing, there was room to breathe. Tomorrow would be the same, and not the same. The iron in the air would be there. The sun would butter the sand again. And I would rise and lift the scutum and take up the Messenger, and for a while, in the narrow space between one breath and the next, Rome would feel like something I could carry.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This historical fiction piece about a Roman gladiator is remarkably accomplished. The author has created an immersive first-person narrative that effectively transports the reader to ancient Rome through rich sensory details and thoughtful characterization. The prose demonstrates exceptional control of language, with carefully chosen details that evoke the physical environment of the ludus (gladiator school) and Rome itself. The sensory elements are particularly strong—the "iron taste like old pennies," the "sweat, oil, and vinegar" smell, the sound of "scrape of a broom in the corridor." These details create a vivid, lived-in world. The gladiator protagonist is developed with nuance and depth. His physical scars mirror emotional ones, and his complex relationship with his profession is thoughtfully explored. He both embraces his identity as a gladiator while recognizing the exploitation inherent in the system. The narrative effectively balances his immediate physical reality with reflections on his past and the broader social context. The piece successfully incorporates the political and social issues of Roman society as requested. References to grain prices, the emperor's use of spectacle to maintain power, and the class divisions in Roman society are woven organically into the narrative rather than feeling like didactic additions. The line "Rome tied ribbons on cruelty and called it spectacle" encapsulates this social commentary elegantly. The writing maintains a consistent voice throughout—contemplative, observant, and tinged with a stoic acceptance of the protagonist's circumstances. The author skillfully balances interior reflection with external action, creating a rhythm that keeps the reader engaged despite the lack of combat scenes. The piece does occasionally verge on purple prose, with some metaphors that call attention to themselves ("Rome shifted in her sleep like a great animal, and we, caged inside her ribcage, shifted with her"). However, these moments are relatively rare and generally serve the atmospheric quality of the piece. The ending effectively brings the narrative full circle, returning to the sensory details of the beginning while adding emotional resonance. The final paragraph achieves a delicate balance between resignation and a small assertion of personal agency that feels earned rather than forced. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece of historical fiction that succeeds in all the requested elements. It creates a believable slice of life in ancient Rome while exploring the psychological and social dimensions of a gladiator's existence. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 0 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 0.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Epistolary: The Lighthouse Keeper — Score: 0
Prompt:
The Lighthouse Keeper Epistolary Narrative: Write a story told entirely through a series of brief correspondences: telegrams or letters or emails between two characters. The correspondence should span several months or years, and reveal a gradually unfolding plot. Use distinct voices for each character, and include details that provide insight into their personalities and motivations. The story should build to an emotional climax, and the final letter should provide a satisfying resolution. The setting is a lighthouse keeper writing to his mother. He is working class and Scottish. He is struggling with the isolation of his posting. Write naturally and without cliches. 1000 words.
Model Output:
Judge Evaluation:
[Skipping – generation error: Text too short after 3 attempts]
+ First-person unique perspective: Hacker Mindset — Score: 88.4
Prompt:
Hacker Mindset Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a reformed (now) white hat hacker who cannot help but notice exploitable weaknesses in both systems and people they encounter. They habitually look for vulnerabilities and exploit vectors. The narrative takes place during a first date at a restaurant, where they're trying to focus on human connection. It's going surprisingly well due to a discovered shared nerd-fandom (magic the gathering). Things go a little sideways when the date reveals a noticeably insecure phone unlock pattern, which protagonist can't help but comment on. They are then left to negotiate the fallout of this faux pas and attempt to salvage (or perhaps sabotage) the remainder of the date. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
I tell myself, out loud in the car before I get out: don’t audit the date. The waitress is propping the door with her foot, coffee sloshing, and the bell over the frame gives a little glitch of a ring, like it has a race condition with gravity. I clock the router behind the counter on instinct. Older model. Stickers peeled and yellow. The WiFi password is taped right there to the espresso machine with Scotch tape, printed in 16-point Calibri: LatteLove2020!. The exclamation point is doing its best to be entropy. I inhale once, hold, and try to let it go. I’m early. My default. Early is safe; early is recon. I choose a two-top near the back wall with a line of sight past the plants to the bathrooms, to the kitchen door, to the counter where the barista is using the knuckle of her thumb to wipe foam from the steam wand and not sanitizing it. I am here to have dinner, not to file a report. I order water because it buys me the right to exist in a place without making any other commitment. She’s two minutes late, then three, then six, and then there she is, a flash of green scarf and a shiver of bangs that try to behave and don’t, and the precise moment she looks and finds me feels like aligning a puzzle piece you found under the couch. Her smile is not a default. It’s compiled, with care. “Sorry,” she says, sliding into the chair, “I had to argue with a parking meter that thinks time is a construct.” I look at her hands. No ring. Nails bitten, not awful, just lived-in. There’s a tiny blue-black dot on the index finger of her left hand, the tattoo of a leaky pen or an ancient Sharpie. Her phone’s case has a faint scuff pattern around the edges where she fidgets. The edges of her scarf are unraveling into little fiber filaments. Everything about her is a visible history of use. I like that. “It is a construct,” I say, “and also a service with a variable uptime guarantee.” Her laugh lands on me like a warm file download with a progress bar that moves smoothly, no jitter. We talk. About work, about hobbies. She works in a lab doing something with cell lines that I try to not interpret as a metaphor. She asks what I do and I say something about security consulting and education and the word “reformed” is in there, because honesty is both policy and patch. She doesn’t flinch. Her eyebrows do a small arch, the good kind. “So like, ethical hacker?” she says, and I nod, and we share that look where both people are trying to quantify the ethical in front of the hacker, and then the server arrives and takes our orders and I pretend I don’t see the way his tablet has a screen protector bubbling at the corner where anyone could slip under it with a fingernail and pop the whole thing off. No audits, I remind myself, eat your dinner. We discover the fandom by accident. There’s a Planeswalker symbol peeking out of her wallet when she goes to get her ID for the beer she orders. My mouth moves before I can route it through the filter: “Gideon or Jace?” She freezes, then grins. “Liliana, obviously. What are you, a blue control player?” I feel seen and accused and it’s correct. “Look, counterspells are a lifestyle.” She leans in. “I had a mono-red phase in college, but we don’t talk about it.” The restaurant becomes friendlier by degrees. The music is a playlist that can’t commit to a genre and I forgive it because it’s trying. Our food arrives. She steals a fry without negotiating for it and it feels like a handshake protocol we didn’t have to write down. We trade stories of awful combo decks and table flips and the exact tone of disdain reserved for someone who takes a twenty-minute turn and says “just one more thing.” Her laugh does that leap again. I am buoyant. Maybe this is easy. Maybe I can be a person who sits in a restaurant and thinks about the shape of someone’s mouth instead of the shape of someone’s threat model. And then her phone lights up. It vibrates against the wood like a bug trying to flee. She glances down, makes that face people make when their attention splits and then, because she is polite, she picks it up to silence it. Her hand moves in that little unconscious pattern people do when they’re swiping a lock or sketching a line on a grid. The phone is one of those Androids with the nine-dot pattern unlock, and she drags her finger without really looking. I don’t think about it. My eyes are magnets for repetition and low entropy. My brain is a hash table for patterns I’m not supposed to store. It’s an L. Bottom left to top middle, right one, down one. Then a little tail. She does it twice because the first swipe doesn’t register. There are smudges on her screen, old oily evidence of previous unlocks, and I hate that I could unlock her life with a napkin and some sunlight. My mouth, again, traitor, says: “You might want to change that.” Her head snaps up. “What?” I have options. I could cough. I could smile and ask about her siblings like a normal mammal. But the part of me that runs automatic background scanners is already hacking my tongue. “Your unlock pattern,” I say, and I hear the word ‘your’ come out like a prybar. “It’s… easy to shoulder-surf. High probability. L-shapes are like, the most common. With smudge analysis…” I stop, which is to say I run out of buffer. She blinks. There is a microsecond where her face is blank, like a loading spinner. Then the color in her cheeks changes. She sets her phone down with the gentlest possible contempt, like a person placing a glass in the sink instead of throwing it at a wall. “Wow,” she says. I want to roll back the commit. I want to push an emergency patch to myself. “I—sorry. That was—” There is a version of me that says “caring,” another that says “contextual,” a third that says “nonconsensual.” None of them make it to production. “No,” she says, and her voice is small and even. “It’s fine. You’re… that’s what you do, right?” I think about the ten-thousand hours I put into becoming a person who can see the skeleton behind anything. I think about the first time I got a stranger’s email because they used the same password on their social media and their bank, and how the part of me that was addicted wasn’t to the access but to the fact that it was there. I think about how I got caught because I wanted to get caught, and I think about how I got better because someone I hurt decided to believe I could. I hear myself say, “Sometimes I forget that consent applies to advice.” Her eyes soften without her smiling. She is thinking. Her eyebrows make that small bridge they make when she is both annoyed and curious. “It’s just a phone,” she says, but the way she presses the lock button is defensive. “It’s not,” I say. “Not anymore. But that’s mine to manage, not yours.” I invert my hands on the table and show my palms like I’m demonstrating I’m unarmed. It is a silly gesture. It helps. She takes a piece of her burger and holds it for a second like evidence. “Do you do that with people, too? Not just their phones? Like, do you look at someone’s… I don’t know. Walk and decide their secrets?” I could lie. I could say no, that I see people as closed systems until invited. But this night is going well because I didn’t lie. “I notice patterns,” I say. “It took me a long time to learn that not every pattern is a vulnerability. And even if it is, it’s not mine to exploit. Or to name.” She chews. She is composing a response and testing it for defects. I let her. I take a sip of my water and catch the WiFi password out of the corner of my eye again. LatteLove2020!. The network name is CaféGuest. There is a locked one below it called CaféPOS. The POS system’s tablet is logged in as admin. The WiFi is open. If I were the person I used to be, I would have already pivoted. I focus on the condensation ring forming beneath my glass and try to love it like a miracle. “Okay,” she says finally. “You’re not wrong. About the pattern. But, like… can you not tell me in a way that feels like you just watched me leave my diary on the bus?” “Yes,” I say. “No. I mean—yes, I can not do that. I can ask if you want input instead of just… inputting.” She smiles at her own reaction, like she’s watching herself decide something and is a little embarrassed by her own mercy. “Ask then.” “Do you want a suggestion on how to lock your phone in a way that makes me less itchy?” “That,” she says, and exhales, “is so much better. Yes.” “Use a passphrase,” I say. “Like a sentence you can type. Long. Not predictable. Something only you would know. And biometric is okay as long as you can disable it quickly if you’re worried about someone making you unlock it.” She nods. “Cool. I’ll do that. And I will tell my future self that a hacker on a date bullied me into using longer passwords.” “I accept being the villain in a story where your bank account is safe.” “White hat villain,” she says, and it lands with a tiny parachute. We both let it drift. The server appears and asks if we want dessert. She looks at me and I can see that she is running a calculation that has nothing to do with sugar. I nod like a normal mammal. We split a slice of something chocolate and complicated, and she uses her fork to draw a shape in the dusting of powdered sugar on the plate. It’s not an L. It’s a wandering line, looping, almost a spiral. I pretend not to see it. She notices me not noticing and the corner of her mouth lifts. “So,” she says, “what’s the nerdiest thing you’ve done for Magic?” I tell her about the time I wrote a solver to draft terrible decks on purpose because I wanted to see if I could win on suboptimality, and she tells me about a cosplay that involved dangerously sharp foam pauldrons and a glue gun burn she’s oddly proud of. We make a plan to go to FNM like two high schoolers making a plan to jump a fence. The WiFi password leers at me and I ignore it again, and each time I ignore it I feel a small muscle grow. At some point her phone buzzes again. She flips it, looks, and then does not unlock it. She sets it face down. “I’ll change it later,” she says, almost to herself, and then looks at me. “Thank you. For… adapting.” “I’m in beta,” I say. “Lots of updates.” “Do you have a changelog?” she asks, and I laugh and say sure: reduced unsolicited advice by forty percent, improved empathy parsing, patched exploit where I equate intimacy with disclosure. We pay. I tip in cash because I don’t like the tablet asking me to choose a number in front of someone. Outside, the air is cooler and has the metallic taste of a city about to exhale. There is a man smoking by the door under a sign that says No Smoking. The sign is peeling at the corner. Everything peels at the corner if you touch it enough. “Walk you to your car?” I ask, and I brace for no. “Yeah,” she says, and it’s easy. We walk. Our steps try to sync and fail and then succeed, which feels like a metaphor that doesn’t insult either of us. At her car she turns and she is close enough that I can see the smudge of chocolate on her lip, left corner. I do not tell her. I do not wipe it. I put my hands in my pockets and let her be a system with full autonomy. “I’ll text you,” she says, and unlocks her car with a beep that sounds like acceptance. “And I’ll have a passphrase by then.” “Make it long,” I say, and she rolls her eyes in a way that is not a door closing. She leaves. I stand there with the streetlight making the world a grainy photograph. I have the urge to go back in and write the restaurant a pen-test report on a napkin. Instead I get in my car and commit to master: tonight I noticed a vulnerability, and I asked for permission before I patched it. It’s not glamorous. There’s no write-up that will get me a thousand claps. But there’s a quiet between my ribs that feels like a server room with the fans humming at a low, steady pitch. Uptime is good. Latency is human. And the password taped to the counter stays taped, and I leave it there, and that is its own kind of strength check passed.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures the perspective of a reformed white hat hacker navigating a first date. The protagonist's internal monologue effectively conveys their habitual security-focused mindset while showing their struggle to connect on a human level. The piece excels in creating a distinctive voice that blends technical terminology with emotional vulnerability. The hacker's perspective is consistently maintained through metaphors and observations that relate to their professional background: "Her laugh lands on me like a warm file download with a progress bar that moves smoothly, no jitter" and "I feel a small muscle grow" when resisting the urge to exploit security weaknesses. The character development is nuanced, showing the protagonist's genuine effort to reform while acknowledging their ingrained habits. The internal conflict is palpable when they notice the date's insecure phone pattern and struggle with whether to mention it. The fallout from this faux pas is handled realistically, with the date's initial offense gradually softening into understanding. The prose is elegant without being overwrought, using technical language in a way that characterizes the narrator without alienating the reader. Descriptions are vivid and specific: "a flash of green scarf and a shiver of bangs that try to behave and don't." The writing maintains a good balance between technical observations and emotional insights. However, there are moments where the narrative becomes slightly meandering, particularly in the middle section where the protagonist reflects on their past. While these reflections provide important character context, they momentarily slow the pace of the date scene. The dialogue, though limited as appropriate for an internal monologue piece, is natural and reveals character. The shared interest in Magic: The Gathering creates an authentic connection between the characters, and their conversation about phone security feels believable rather than contrived. The ending avoids an overly neat resolution while still providing a sense of growth. The protagonist's decision not to exploit the restaurant's security vulnerabilities represents meaningful character development without suggesting complete transformation. The final image of "a server room with the fans humming at a low, steady pitch" effectively ties together the technical and emotional aspects of the character. Overall, this is a strong piece that successfully fulfills the prompt requirements while creating a distinctive voice and emotionally engaging narrative. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Overthinking It — Score: 95.7
Prompt:
Overthinking It Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of an intelligent 8th-grade girl with social anxiety who has developed a crush on a classmate. The narrative takes place during a group science project where they're paired together, as she cycles through rehearsed conversations while second-guessing each potential approach. Her inner thoughts should reveal the gap between her articulate internal voice and her difficulty expressing herself aloud, her fears of coming across as desperate or weird, and the exhausting process of monitoring her every word, expression, and movement for potential embarrassment. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
Okay, it's fine. It's fine. It's a group project, not a confession. We're paired together because Ms. Patel did it randomly and not because the universe is trying to make me crumble in front of the human embodiment of a golden retriever in a hoodie. Breathe. Say something like, “We should probably divide the tasks,” like a normal person. Normal people divide tasks. Normal people do not plan their sentences like chess moves. He’s sitting next to me. Why is he so close? Because we’re partners. Right. His elbow is on the table, and his pencil is tapping out an idiotically perfect rhythm like he doesn't even know rhythm exists. He smells like laundry detergent and graphite, and there's that sharp, nasal sting—ammonia. Right. The janitor's mop water. Ms. Patel made a big show of apologizing about it. “Quick cleanup, sorry about the smell,” and then all the windows were cracked open just enough to tease but not enough to save. It's cutting through everything. Brain-singe. Focus. Task division. Talk. “I can—” I start, and the word slides out weirdly thin and brittle, like glass. He glances, a flicker, not even a full look, which is somehow worse. “I can take notes,” I say, and it comes out too fast, like a burst of air from a balloon. He smiles. He has a nice smile. Stop noticing his smile. “Cool,” he says. “I’ll do the measuring stuff? Like, the… what’s it called?” See? This is a door. You know the word. Caliper. Be calm. Say, “We’ll use the digital caliper to measure the mass change—no, that’s not right, calipers don’t measure mass.” You know that. Abort. Okay, just say, “The digital scale,” like a human. “The scale,” I manage, mercifully, and nod, which is fine except it’s too many nods, so I stop nodding and then realize I’ve probably stopped mid-nod and now I look like a broken dashboard bobblehead. I pretend it was a head-tilt. Casual. Very casual. My neck feels like a puppet string someone keeps jerking. He reaches for the small plastic cup and bumps the beaker, and a tiny slosh of clear water shivers to the rim. It’s our project: investigating the rates of dissolution. Salt in water, hot and cold. Simple, controlled, safe. Except my heart is beating like we borrowed the hot plate for it. I visualize my face from across the room, the way people always say to do when you're practicing a speech. An average face. Not weird. Last time I tried this at home the mirror made me cry. Don't think about that. “Do you want the hot water or the cold?” he asks. This is a question anyone can answer. Responses: A) “I can do hot,” because I have better reaction times and we need to be precise. B) “Cold,” because I always was warned about hot plates and my mother’s voice is a lighthouse for caution. C) “Either is fine,” neutral, friendly, flexible. Avoiding the impression of control freak. Choose C. Yes. C is safe. C is Switzerland. C is me. Why is the ammonia smell getting stronger? It’s like it’s crawling up my nostrils and building a little chemical fort. Focus. “Either is fine,” I say, and smile. My lips are dry. The smile feels like it could crack off my face and clatter onto the table like a broken shell. “Cool,” he says again, and grabs the hot plate. “I’ll do hot. You can write stuff down.” Why does he keep saying cool? Is it like a verbal placeholder he uses to be approachable? Do I say cool? No, not anymore, because one time last year I tried to say it and I sounded like I was quoting a brochure about sunglasses. Note: do not mirror his words; you'll sound like a chameleon with a marketing degree. Write the title: "Effects of Temperature on Rate of Dissolution." My handwriting is neat. Too neat? Neat like a teacher's pet? The line of my pen is so straight it's bragging. Make it a little sloppy. No, that seems fake. My hand twitches and makes a tiny wobble in the "R" and I go cold. Now it looks like I'm pretending to be a human. Relax. No one is watching your “R.” He’s measuring out salt with a plastic spoon, tapping it once, twice, then pouring, and the grains sparkle like crushed quartz. Say something interesting. Not weird. Not “I read that in supersaturated solutions crystals can suddenly appear if you introduce a seed.” That is a fun fact but will make you sound like a trivia machine with legs. Say, “Make sure it’s level,” because that’s practical. Yes. “Make sure it’s level,” I say, softer than I meant, so it lands like a suggestion you make to a cat who doesn’t know English. “Right,” he says, and bends down so his eyes are at the level of the measuring line. He actually does it. On the inside I give myself a tiny high five that feels exactly like nothing, like clapping underwater. What if he thinks I'm bossy? What if he thinks I'm trying to be better than him? I want him to think I’m smart, but not in a way that makes his ego feel like a balloon someone’s squeezing. People say guys don't like it when girls are smarter. That is probably a generalized misconception and I should reject it, but also he once made a joke about losing to his little sister at chess and he looked defensive even though he laughed. Examine data before drawing conclusions. You’re doing it again. You’re doing the think-loop. Stop. Just be here. Ammonia again. It’s like the smell pierces a tiny hole in the thought balloon and every sentence deflates. My eyes water for a second. I blink like I mean it. My eyelashes feel heavy. Is there a right number of blinks for seeming normal? Maybe three. Three is a good number. Not too many or you look like you’re sending Morse code. He looks at my notes. “You have good handwriting,” he says, which is like telling a bridge it has nice beams. Compliment acceptance script: A) Say thank you. B) Deflect. Do not deflect with “It’s nothing,” or “Yours is good too,” unless that’s true. Is his handwriting good? He writes like a haunted spider. So, A. Say thank you. Easy. “Thanks,” I say, and clamp my teeth around anything else that wants to come out. My mouth is dry again. Drink water. No, there's the ammonia in the room and I don't want to taste it. Does ammonia have a taste? Stop. He's not thinking about ammonia. Say something back. Ask him about his hoodie, about the basketball game he won, about the formula. Ask him anything. Pick one. Hoodies are safe. “I like your hoodie.” No, that sounds like I'm flirting. You are kind of flirting. No, you're not. You're not allowed to flirt. You're just being nice. But he might think—Okay, what about the game? You saw him score and everyone cheered and he did that little shrug like he couldn't help it. “The game was good.” That sounds vague. “Nice layup last night.” That’s too specific. He’ll think I memorize his layups. “How’s basketball?” That’s like asking a fish how water is. He pours the hot water. Steam curls up and finds the ammonia in the air and they dance, and it hits my throat like a school nurse's office in August. The clock ticks, loud, a metronome for my inner stupid. He’s staring at the dissolving salt, the way it clouds the water, then clears, little crystals disappearing like snowflakes melting on a tongue. “This is kind of cool,” he says. Cool. Again. It is cool. Science is cool. You can say that without irony. “Yeah,” I say, and it comes out a thread. “It’s…” I have a whole paragraph in my head about molecules moving faster in hot water, collisions increasing, the solvent’s kinetic energy overcoming the lattice energy of the solute. In my head it's clean and bright and I'm giving a TED Talk to my crocheted stuffed animals. Out loud it shrinks to a pebble. “Temperature,” I say. “Makes it go faster.” “Right,” he says, not like it’s a revelation or an insult, just a confirmation, and he smiles again, and I think I must be imagining the way my chest feels like someone loosened a knot there. Write down the time. Start the stopwatch. My thumb hovers. Press. The second travels like a grace note around my brain. If I stop looking at my hand I will press the wrong button. I press the right one. The digits begin to climb. It’s ridiculous how proud I am. Say, “Do you want to do the cold trial?” He will say, “Sure,” and then we will switch and I will be the one scooping ice, and my fingers will turn pink and I will wrestle with the scoop like a competent person. My mouth opens. The ammonia swoops in like a bird and I cough. It’s a small cough, but in my head it’s amplified, a foghorn. My nose stings. He glances. Great. Now he thinks I’m sick. Now he’s thinking about me being sick around his perfect hoodie and basketball lungs. Explain it. Say, “Sorry, it’s the ammonia.” That’s a weird sentence. People who say “ammonia” out loud sound like lab techs or complaint emails. Say, “Sorry, the smell.” Yes. That’s human. “Sorry, the…” I start, and then my throat decides to sandpaper itself and somehow the word that comes out is a whistly “smell,” which is the least attractive sound I’ve ever made. It would make babies cry. My ears heat up. “Oh, yeah,” he says, and waves a hand in front of his nose. “It’s strong.” Okay. He did not recoil. He did not die from secondhand embarrassment. He agrees. There is solidarity in this chemical warfare. I am not alone in this classroom; we are two humans in a mild cloud of murder-clean. Breathe. Not too deep. My lungs disagree and take a big drag of ammonia anyway and I swallow and it tastes like a battery. “Do you… want to do the cold one?” I say, and I almost sound normal, except my voice fades at the end like it’s walking away without me. “Sure,” he says. “Switch?” We switch. Our hands brush for a second, and the skin at the base of my thumb registers it like an earthquake: tiny magnitude, epicenter right under my bones. Don’t jerk away. Don’t linger. Perfectly neutral brush. Perfectly fine. My face does not change. It probably changes. I can feel my cheeks. You can see heat. Everyone can see heat. Stop thinking about your cheeks. The ice scoops and crackles into the beaker, clicks like teeth. I pour water, careful but not too careful, measuring it with my eyes because he is already doing the thermometer count on his side and I don’t want to be the slow one, the one who holds up the train with her anxiety baggage. He says, “Do we stir the same number of times? For consistency?” Yes. Yes, marry me. Or, no, don’t say that. Say, “Yeah, thirty seconds clockwise,” which is what Ms. Patel said, and not like you’re thrilled he remembers variables. “Yeah, thirty seconds clockwise,” I say, and our eyes meet for half a second and jump away, like we both glanced at a place we’re not supposed to look. Stir. Thirty seconds. This is quantifiable. This is safety. The spoon swirls and taps glass, and the salt vanishes slower, like it’s thinking about it. Write down the time. Observer bias: calcium in my fingers making them clumsy. That’s not what calcium does. Whatever. Shut up, brain. Write. He leans in a little, looking at the meniscus. He smells like detergent and pencil, like clean laundry and paper fibers. The ammonia tries to bully its way back into the sensory club and I tell it to get bent, and I cough once, tiny. Is cough-tiny a word? No. My brain invents nonsense when people I like are within a radius of my real face. He says, “I saw you at the game,” out of nowhere, and the room tilts. There were hundreds of people. Why would he—No, he’s just being polite. He saw me socially existing on the bleachers with a book in my lap pretending to be normal. My mouth is a small dry desert. “Oh,” I say. There is a long, empty hallway in that word. Fill it. “You were—” Great? Amazing? Fantastic? “Good,” I say, which is a toddler word, but it’s safe, it’s non-committal. He will not think I have a shrine to his layups. He grins. “Thanks.” There’s a place inside me where all the good sentences live. The ones where I say, “I like how you always help Jordan with his math homework and you don’t make him feel dumb,” and “You’re gentle with the lab equipment even when you joke like you don’t care,” and “I get nervous talking but I think you’re kind.” Those sentences sit in a sunlit room and never come down the stairs. I send them messages and they send back thumbs-up emojis. We log the second trial. Our data is clean. Our rates align with our hypothesis. We’re efficient together. I want to say that. “We’re a good team.” Is that flirting or factual? It can be both. I breathe. Ammonia sneaks in and stings me like a reminder to stay real. “We’re a good team,” I say, and it sounds okay. It sounds like something a person would say. “Yeah,” he says. He looks actually happy. Not the performative happy, the kind like sunlight on a tile floor. “We should, uh, do the poster together after school? Library?” After school. Library. My mother will say yes. I will wear the blue sweater that doesn’t make me feel like a question mark. Do not explode. Do not betray your internal fireworks. Smile. Not too big. Not too small. Medium. Goldilocks smile. “Sure,” I say, and my voice is almost steady. “I—” The ammonia darts in like a little assassin and I cough, then laugh at the cough, which is a mistake. Laughing at coughs is the second most awkward thing, right after saluting your teacher by accident like I did in sixth grade. I want to disappear into the grout between the tiles. He laughs too, in a nice way, like we share the joke that the janitor is trying to gas us into becoming better citizens. “Cool,” he says. Cool. Cool. Stop. The stopwatch beeps. We both jump and then both pretend we didn’t, and I write down the final time with precise digits that will make Ms. Patel nod. It’s fine. It’s fine. It’s just a group project. It’s just two people in a room with a little math and a smell trying to sabotage them. I stay in my body. I use my hands. I let sentences be small and still true. I imagine that sunlit room inside me, and I invite one of the big sentences to come down. It hesitates on the landing. “See you after school,” I say, and it’s small, but it’s brave enough. He nods, and I mirror him once, just once, a well-timed yes, and then I look at my paper as if I wrote everything on purpose. The ammonia thins as someone opens a door. The air loosens. My shoulders come down a millimeter, maybe two. I can breathe without measuring how it looks. We clean up. Salt grains cling to the table like constellations that don’t know their names. He’s humming under his breath, and I realize I feel tired, like I ran a race sitting still. It’s okay. Later I’ll lie on my bed and replay everything and edit it and assign scores. For now, I just put the beaker in the bin. For now, I tell myself that being a little weird is not a felony, that the sunlit room has a staircase, that tomorrow I might be brave again on purpose, even if the air stings.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative brilliantly captures the internal monologue of an 8th-grade girl with social anxiety who has developed a crush on her science project partner. The piece excels at portraying the gap between her articulate internal voice and her difficulty expressing herself aloud. The protagonist's thought process is rendered with exceptional authenticity. Her constant second-guessing, rehearsing of potential responses, and overthinking of every interaction creates a vivid portrait of social anxiety. The writer skillfully employs a stream-of-consciousness style that feels genuine to an intelligent but anxious 8th grader, with thoughts that spiral, fragment, and loop back on themselves. The narrative effectively uses the science project setting to create natural moments of interaction while maintaining focus on the protagonist's internal experience. The ammonia smell from the janitor's cleaning becomes a recurring motif that grounds the narrative in physical reality while serving as both an obstacle and occasional relief from her overthinking. The character's voice is consistently maintained throughout. Her intelligence shines through in her scientific knowledge and vocabulary, while her social anxiety manifests in her hyper-awareness of every word, gesture, and facial expression. The contrast between her rich internal life and her stilted external communication is portrayed with remarkable consistency. The prose strikes an excellent balance between the protagonist's sophisticated vocabulary and the authentic voice of an 8th grader. Sentences like "My handwriting is neat. Too neat? Neat like a teacher's pet? The line of my pen is so straight it's bragging" perfectly capture both her intelligence and her adolescent insecurities. The narrative creates genuine emotional engagement through its honest portrayal of social anxiety and young romance. The protagonist's vulnerability and her small victories (successfully saying "We're a good team") are deeply relatable and touching. The piece avoids melodrama while still conveying the genuine emotional intensity of adolescent experience. The ending feels earned and appropriate to the character's journey. There's a small but meaningful shift as she acknowledges her own bravery and considers the possibility of future courage, without an unrealistic transformation that would undermine the authenticity of her character. The writing excels at sensory details that ground the reader in the physical experience—the ammonia smell, the sound of ice crackling, the brief touch of hands—while maintaining focus on the protagonist's internal experience. These details create a vivid, immersive reading experience. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that demonstrates a deep understanding of social anxiety, adolescent experience, and the craft of first-person narrative. The writer has created a character whose internal life is complex and compelling, and whose struggles and small triumphs feel authentic and meaningful. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 20 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 20 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 20
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 20.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 20.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 20.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Rehearsing Rejection — Score: 94.3
Prompt:
Rehearsing Rejection Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of someone with borderline personality disorder who frequently plays out worst-case scenarios of how friends and loved ones might judge them. They construct elaborate internal dialogues, complete with imagined criticisms and their own defensive responses. The narrative takes place as they prepare to meet a close friend & recent lover, who has been somewhat distant lately, triggering their abandonment fears. Their inner monologue should reveal how they cycle between anticipating rejection, mentally rehearsing confrontations, and developing preemptive resentments as protective measures. Incorporate the *actual* events & interactions that are *not* in fact judgemental or involving rejection (in fact, the opposite), and represent how these are interpreted, how the validation & love is desperately felt & needed -- and then immediately questioned. Capture the cognitive dissonance in this struggle. Include moments where they briefly recognize the pattern but struggle to interrupt it, showing limited (and selective) self awareness, competing with the compelling nature of these imagined scenarios. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
I practice it again, the scene where you sigh and say you don’t think we should see each other anymore, like I’m a messy drawer you’d prefer to keep closed. I guess the exact words you’ll use as I pull my shoes on: “You’re amazing, but I can’t do this right now.” My mouth has an answer ready—curated, clipped, cool. That’s fine. I totally get it. I’m good. I’m fine. I master the curve of indifference with my lips while my fingers pick at the loose thread on my sleeve until it almost splits the seam. I run the conversation a second time with a different lighting: you’re disappointed instead of apologetic. “I thought you’d be more… stable.” I say, “That’s unfair,” and I list the twelve things I did to prove I can be human-shaped. I itemize. I reference a spreadsheet in my head. I am convincing, righteous. I hate that I need to be convincing. I lean toward the hallway mirror and see it there, the angled shoulders, the tight chin, an animal stance. I look like I’m bracing for impact before there’s even a car. My reflection looks like it knows something I don’t, like it’s already seen the cliff edge and measured the drop. I adjust my hair, then turn away because if I watch too long I’ll start narrating myself again: the tragic heroine of a soap opera that never ends because the writers are lazy and love cliffhangers. Phone vibrates. Your name on the screen. A bubble: running 10 late, subway delay. A second bubble, almost immediate: sorry sorry. A third: can’t wait to see you. I read them and feel my throat soften and then clamp hard again. Can’t wait to see you. Translation: perform positivity, smooth me, don’t be difficult. I draft two replies and delete both. Finally I send: ok. No exclamation point. Let you come to me. I pretend it’s strategy. I pretend I’m not counting the ten minutes. I sit on the edge of the bed and stage another confrontation—this one where I get there first. I say, “You’ve been distant.” You say, “Work,” or “Stress,” or “Parents.” I don’t accept that answer in this version, because in this version I’m tired of being reasonable. I say, “Just say it if you’re done,” and my voice is knife-clean. You blink slowly, wounded. You say, “I’m not done.” I say, “Then act like it.” Strong. Stronger than I ever am in the moment. I press replay and tweak my tone to sound less desperate. I practice being the person who walks out first, who leaves you mid-sentence, who doesn’t wait around for secondhand crumbs of attention like a dog under a table. The door buzzer goes off inside my chest even though no one has pressed it. I stand up too fast, dizzy. I grab my bag. I check my messages again just in case you’ve reneged in the last 30 seconds. You haven’t. You haven’t and still my body is doing the funeral. On the subway I watch a kid fold a paper crane for his sister. It looks like freedom, all those simple creases that somehow become wings. I imagine telling you about that and then I imagine you smiling, putting your hand on my knee, saying, “That’s sweet,” and the sweetness landing like a small blessing. Then I rewrite it so your smile is strained and your hand is absent. Then I rewrite it again so I say nothing at all because why offer anything when it can be turned down. Why bring anything to the altar when the god might be asleep. At the café, the table in the corner is miraculously empty. I choose it like I need the wall at my back. The waitress puts down water and her hand brushes mine and I almost apologize for existing. I pretend I’m composed, because people say that word around me like it’s a compliment, like I’ve performed something requiring applause. I hold the glass with careful fingers and rehearse new lines: You know, I’ve been thinking. You know, I need to set some boundaries. The performance version of me can do boundaries like she’s putting furniture down in a room and deciding where things go. The real me picks up the couch and then lies underneath it. The door opens and there you are in your too-big coat, the one I once teased you about and you told me it was your ex’s and you didn’t look away from me when you said it, like you were offering truth without seeing if I’d swallow it. You see me and your face does that whole-body smile. My heart lurches toward you with dog-under-table intensity and I mentally yank its leash. “Hey,” you say, and you put your hand on my shoulder when you sit. It’s warm. It’s present. It’s not reluctant at all. It makes my eyes sting because my body keeps receipts of every time you’ve touched me like I might disappear otherwise. “Hi,” I say, and it comes out too soft. I straighten it. “How are you?” You tell me about the subway delay, the guy who serenaded the entire car with a ukulele, how a woman next to you sang along badly and loudly and it made you grin. You ask me if I’ve eaten. You ask me if I’m okay, and your eyes search my face and then you smile like you know I’ll say I am even if I’m not. “I’m fine,” I say, automatic. I want to say I missed you. I want to say where did you go when you were busy. I want to say did I do something. Instead I ask about work and you groan theatrically and roll your eyes, and I feel the relief uncurl and then immediately interrogate it. It’s too easy, right? You’re overcompensating. People perform warmth when they’re hiding something, don’t they? You’re trying to keep me pliant. “I brought you something,” you say, and pull a small paper bag from your coat, grease spots already marking the bottom. “They had those cardamom buns you like.” I’m a terrible actor because the joy surfaces without my consent. I make a sound I hate—too bright, too grateful. I snap it in half with my fingers and put a piece in my mouth and the sugar hits and I think, see, this is love. And right behind it, why now. Did you feel guilty? Are you giving me sweets like a pacifier? “It’s dumb,” you say, laughing. “I saw them and thought of you. That’s all.” I nod. I put a piece on your napkin. You eat it and lick sugar from your thumb and I imagine taking your hand and bringing it to my mouth and then I police myself for imagining too hard. I hear the speech I wrote earlier and it clatters in me, suddenly foolish among napkins and pastry flakes. You reach across and tuck a hair behind my ear in this instinctive way you have that tells me it isn’t a gesture you’re building toward a breakup. It feels like the opposite of leaving. Which is suspicious. “I’m sorry I’ve been… you know,” you say. “I’ve had a lot going on. I should’ve said something.” I nod like it’s nothing. Inside me, fireworks and alarms overlap. I run both scripts simultaneously: the one where I’m understanding and the one where I’m not. “It’s okay,” I say, and I can hear the doubting committee in the back row of my brain whispering don’t let them get away with it. Demand more. Don’t be so easy. They will leave if you don’t make them work. They will leave if you make them work. You are a multiple-choice test where all answers are wrong. “I missed you,” you add, simple as water, like you’re saying the sky is blue. I freeze. I melt. I freeze again. I look at your mouth to see if the words left marks. “I missed you too,” I say, and somewhere a small cynical voice clears its throat: don’t gush. Don’t offer your throat. Protect. I take a sip of water to swallow it all down. I taste sugar and metal. You tell me about your dad’s health scare—the tests, the waiting room coffee that tastes like panic. You didn’t call because you didn’t know what to say. You didn’t call because you were busy holding your own breath. The graph in my head with arrows that point to “not caring” and “getting bored” redraws itself reluctantly. I can feel the pivot, but it grinds. The part of me that built a case is annoyed. It has a closing argument ready. It has charts. “I wish you’d told me,” I say, too quiet, and your face falls and I rush to soften. “Not to fix it. Just to know.” “Yeah,” you say. “I know. I’m learning.” That word hits something tender. Learning implies a future where we keep doing this, where there’s more to learn. It offers continuity, and I want to lie down in that word like a warm patch of sunlight. Immediately, I flip it. Learning also means you might never learn. That you might use it as a pass to keep hurting me. You reach for my hand and I let you. Your thumb draws circles on that paper-thin skin between knuckles. Real. Present. The committee says, don’t get used to it. The committee says, you know what comes next. It shows me the montage of people turning away, the backs of heads, the empty spaces where they sat. It tells me to rehearse goodbyes when hellos run long. “I care about you,” you say, like you’re setting a cup on a table carefully so it doesn’t spill. “I know,” I answer too fast, and you laugh because you know I don’t, not in the simple way. You squeeze my hand. You order coffee for both of us without asking because you remember how I take it. The waitress calls me honey absentmindedly and somehow that hurts, too, because I want to be only yours and then I scold myself for wanting anything that much. I catch my reflection again in the café window, double-exposed over the street. Same shoulders, less angle. I know the pattern, I do. The therapist voice in my head says name it, don’t shame it. My own voice says drown it. There’s a fleeting second where I see the alternate timeline: I say, hey, I spin stories when I get scared. I admit out loud that I’ve spent the last week fighting with a ghost version of you. The second passes. My tongue goes heavy. It feels too dangerous to hand you that power. It feels too dangerous not to. You nudge the bun toward me, the last sugared edge. “Finish it,” you say, and I do because it’s easier than finishing sentences. The sweetness is ridiculous. It settles in me like proof and then like a trick. I watch your face while you talk and annotate it with imagined footnotes: when you glance away, I write disinterest; when you lean in, I write manipulation; when you kiss my cheek as we stand to leave, quick and soft, I write don’t be fooled. My skin burns where your lips were. It’s both blessing and curse. I catalog both. Outside, the air is fragile with cold. You loop your arm through mine without asking and we walk like that, easy. For a few steps the committee is silent, as if even they need air. My body believes, for those steps. It presses closer. It memorizes the exact pressure of your sleeve against my coat. Then someone inside coughs and the noise starts up again, quiet but steady. I love you, they say, and immediately: prove it. You’re here, and immediately: when will you leave. I breathe. I match my stride to yours. I let it all be true for a block, then two, before I start building the courtroom again in my head, just in case.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative brilliantly captures the internal experience of someone with borderline personality disorder (BPD). The piece excels at depicting the protagonist's constant rehearsal of rejection scenarios, their hypervigilance for signs of abandonment, and the cognitive distortions that characterize BPD. The narrative structure is particularly effective, alternating between the protagonist's catastrophizing internal monologues and the actual, much more benign reality of their interaction with their friend/lover. The contrast between what they imagine will happen and what actually occurs creates a powerful tension that drives the piece forward. The writing demonstrates exceptional psychological insight. The protagonist's tendency to "practice" conversations, their hyperanalysis of every word and gesture, and their immediate questioning of positive interactions all ring true to the BPD experience. Lines like "I master the curve of indifference with my lips while my fingers pick at the loose thread on my sleeve until it almost splits the seam" beautifully capture the disconnect between external composure and internal turmoil. The prose is elegant without being overwrought. Metaphors like "I press replay and tweak my tone to sound less desperate" and "The performance version of me can do boundaries like she's putting furniture down in a room and deciding where things go. The real me picks up the couch and then lies underneath it" are vivid and insightful. The writing maintains a consistent voice throughout—introspective, anxious, and self-aware in a way that feels authentic to someone who recognizes their patterns but struggles to break them. The narrative successfully incorporates moments of self-awareness ("I know the pattern, I do. The therapist voice in my head says name it, don't shame it") while showing how compelling and difficult to interrupt these thought patterns are. The ending avoids both unrealistic transformation and complete despair, instead showing a momentary reprieve from the intrusive thoughts before they inevitably return—a realistic portrayal of living with BPD. The piece is emotionally complex, showing the protagonist's desperate need for validation alongside their immediate questioning of it. The cognitive dissonance is palpable in lines like "I freeze. I melt. I freeze again." The narrative also effectively captures the selective self-awareness characteristic of BPD—the protagonist can recognize their patterns intellectually but remains emotionally trapped in them. If there's any weakness, it might be that the piece occasionally relies on metaphors that, while beautiful, slightly distance us from the raw emotional experience. However, this is a minor critique of what is otherwise an exceptionally well-crafted and psychologically accurate portrayal. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 20 Emotionally Complex: 20 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 20.0, Emotionally Complex: 20.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Physical-spatial: Blood Debt — Score: 86.9
Prompt:
"Blood Debt" Write a vivid third-person narrative depicting an unsanctioned underground duel between two talented but hot-headed martial artists. Their schools have been embroiled in a generations-old rivalry, and despite strict prohibitions from their masters, these two younger fighters arrange a secret confrontation fueled by personal pride and simmering animosity. - **One fighter** represents **Jigen-ryū**, a traditional, aggressive style practiced historically by elite samurai clans. Its practitioners emphasize explosive offense, decisive strikes, and overwhelming speed. Known historically for their arrogance and disdain toward outsiders, practitioners consider their art superior and untouchable. - **The opposing fighter** employs a form of historical **Piguaquan**, a Chinese martial art traditionally practiced by commoners, bodyguards, and street fighters. This style emphasizes whipping, circular strikes, rapid footwork, unpredictable angles of attack, and evasive maneuvers. Practitioners often come from lower social classes and view the traditional elite as pretentious and detached from true combat effectiveness. The fight takes place in the crumbling ruins of an abandoned temple, now functioning as a hidden arena for illicit duels. Passionate supporters from both factions surround them, wagering money, pride, and reputation on the outcome. **Essential Instructions:** Maintain absolute physical coherence throughout—clearly track fighters' positions relative to each other and their environment. Precisely depict strikes, counters, momentum shifts, and spatial dynamics, allowing readers to clearly visualize the mechanics and choreography of the fight at every moment. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
They met in the ribcage of the temple: ribs of collapsed beams arched over the cracked flagstones, paper-lantern light shifting in the cold draft. Moss grew between the floor plates. The altar was a broken slab against the eastern wall, and above it, empty eye sockets where statues had once stared. Around the two fighters, a ring of men and women pressed close, their bodies leaning inward while their whispers harried the air. Money changed hands in quick, secret gestures. Red-and-black armbands flashed on both sides, twin colors signifying opposite histories. The Jigen-ryū man stood straight as a lance to the north edge of the ring, bare feet on worn, sunken stone. His hair was clubbed back, the nape cut brutally short, his expression a clean blade. He wore a simple gi, sleeves tied up, and over his right bicep a sharp triangle of cloth—red field, black slash—the mark of his school. In his right hand he held a bokken polished down by relentless practice, wood dense as a promise. He let the tip hover low and forward, the line of the weapon aligned with his centerline, shoulders squared, hips coiled. When he exhaled, the sound was dry and clipped. Across from him to the south, the Piguaquan fighter shifted from foot to foot as if tasting the floor. A lean man with blades of cheekbone and a rope of black hair tied with a strip of threadbare silk. His armband mirrored the Jigen-ryū symbol inverted—black field, red slash—and he wore linen trousers and a sleeveless tunic, the fabric stained by rain and old sweat. He had no weapon but his own reach and the long arc of his arms. When he breathed, it was long and low, rolling through his ribcage and into his stomach as if drawn on a wheel. A gong cobbled from a rusting iron disc clanged once. The crowd hushed, then surged with whispers that chased each other like rats. They closed the distance to five paces. The Jigen-ryū fighter stepped forward half a length—heel touching, then toes sliding—compressing into a forward stance. The bokken dipped a fraction, then snapped up in a straight line toward the Piguaquan man’s brow, a jab more like a spear thrust than a sword cut. The distance was just long enough that the tip would land before the body revealed intent. The Piguaquan fighter shifted right, pivoting on the ball of his left foot. He didn’t retreat; he let the thrust cut past the left side of his face, the bokken skimming the air where his nose had been. As the wooden blade extended, he brought his left forearm up from a low chamber, whipping the back of his wrist against the flat near the tip to redirect. He didn’t try to stop the thrust; he accelerated it off-line with the flick of a catapult. The bokken struck the shoulder of a spectator with a muffled thud that drew a curse, and the Jigen-ryū fighter felt his wrist pulled across his center. He adjusted immediately. There was no pause. His right foot stamped forward and slightly left into the space the Piguaquan man had vacated, hips and shoulders following in a snap. He turned the off-line thrust into a cut, drawing the bokken in a diagonal slash from high left to low right, aiming at the ribs as he stepped across. His left hand came to the hilt for power. The strike drew a clean whoosh and carved a line of air where the Chinese fighter’s torso was already not. The Piguaquan man had ridden the initial pivot into a small counterclockwise circle. As the slash committed past, he sank his weight, right hand whipping outward in a circular backfist toward the Jigen-ryū man’s temple from just outside the arc of the bokken. His left palm shot forward at the same moment toward the elbow of the sword arm. He’d stepped in tight—inside the weapon’s strongest range, just outside the shoulders. The backfist was a scythe; the palm a wedge. The Jigen-ryū man jerked his head back a fraction. The backfist glanced along the hairline, sweat brushed aside. The palm struck the elbow with a pop that shifted the angle of the cut down into harmless air. They were chest-to-chest range now. The Jigen-ryū fighter slammed his left shoulder forward, a battering ram, and drove a knee toward the Piguaquan man’s thigh. The bokken, now trapped between bodies, he used as a bar across the front of the Chinese fighter’s hips. It was inside fighting, inelegant and punishing. The knee landed with a dull thud, and the Piguaquan man’s hip buckled a fraction. He softened into it, flowing down, his joints unlocking like ropes. Rather than resist the pressure across his hips, he spun around the bar, his right foot sweeping back and then forward in a crescent that caught the Jigen-ryū fighter’s left ankle from the outside. He didn’t kick; he scooped and tugged while his left palm slid from elbow to wrist, wrenching down and outward. The Jigen-ryū fighter’s base tilted, but his core held—hips locked forward, back straight, neck in line. He let the tilt become a drop, dropping his center of gravity suddenly like a plummeting stone. The sweep skated under him uselessly as his weight crashed down through both feet. There was a resonant thump, and dust shivered from the beams above. The crowd hissed. The Jigen-ryū fighter drove a short headbutt toward the Piguaquan man’s nose. The Chinese fighter pivoted his head left, the butt glancing along his cheekbone, and in that tight fissure of time he collapsed his torso backward, creating a hand’s breadth of space. His right arm whipped, palm first, from low to high in an arc under the bokken, targeting the Jigen-ryū man’s ribs with the heel of his palm. The strike landed with a thock over the lower right ribs. The Jigen-ryū fighter grunted, not from pain but from the shock. He answered with force: his right hip twisted sharply, and the bokken’s hilt drove like a hammer into the Piguaquan man’s left oblique. There was no room to swing, so he used the butt. They broke apart by mutual necessity. Two quick shoves—one palm on sternum, one forearm across collarbone—and they slid out to a safer measure. The Jigen-ryū fighter reset his guard, bokken angled forward, the tip tracking the other’s chest. He began to advance in a straight line, steps stamping in a rhythm: left-right-left, each landing with a snap of hips and shoulders that promised a strike at any moment. His breath came clipped: kiai held like a drawn arrow. The Piguaquan man circled clockwise, light on the balls of his feet, his steps describing a widening spiral. He stayed just beyond the tip, inviting a lunge. Lantern light painted him in amber and shadow. He cut his arms in wide, deceptive circles, wrists loose, fingers relaxed till the moment of contact. Every few seconds, he feinted a drop of level, shoulders dipping as if to charge, then rolled away. He watched the bokken, not the eyes. The Jigen-ryū fighter snapped forward, a decisive choice. Right foot drove, left followed, bokken thrusting straight as a spear at the solar plexus. The distance closed from two paces to one. As the thrust came, the Piguaquan man stepped not away but in and left, his right foot crossing his left in a tight stepping pattern that carried his torso past the line of the point. His left hand slapped the flat of the bokken near the middle, guiding it off-center to his right as his right forearm swung over the top in a whipping hammerfist toward the Jigen-ryū fighter’s forearm near the wrist. The hammerfist landed; the nerves rang. The bokken slipped a quarter inch in the Jigen-ryū fighter’s grip. He refused the disarm, clamping hard with his left hand, and rolled his right wrist, turning the thrust into an inside cut that sought the Piguaquan man’s left shoulder now that he’d moved in. It was fast, filling the space the other had entered like a closing door. The Piguaquan man dropped his weight under the arcing cut, shoulders folding, the wooden blade skimming the cloth of his tunic. As it passed, he unwound like a cable snapping straight: right palm swung upward across the Jigen-ryū man’s jawline while his left forearm shot under the bokken to strike the inner biceps. Two impacts in one long whip. The jaw strike cracked the mouth open; the biceps strike deadened the arm. Momentum carried both of them half a step. The Jigen-ryū fighter swallowed blood and channeled the pain into speed. He backed off a half-step to create room and unleashed an overhead cut from high to low, the kind that, in earlier centuries, broke helmets. He timed it to catch the Piguaquan man as he rose from his drop. But the Piguaquan fighter never rose straight. He rolled to his left, the cut scything past his right shoulder to explode on the floor with a wooden smack that echoed. The bokken’s tip bit into a joint between stones. For a heartbeat, wood was married to earth. The Piguaquan man capitalized. He slid along the outside of the trapped weapon, his right hand pinning the bokken near the tip with a sudden, downward press, and his left foot stepped deep into the Jigen-ryū fighter’s stance, past the lead foot, to the outside. His left forearm slammed across the Jigen-ryū fighter’s collarbones, a bar that drove him backward while his hips twisted, loading a knee. The Jigen-ryū fighter tried to jerk the weapon free, but the angle and the press stole leverage. The knee came. It rose in a tight arc from the Piguaquan man’s right hip and smashed into the Jigen-ryū fighter’s left flank. Air left the lungs in a rough bark. The bar across the collarbones converted the impact into a stumble. He retreated two short steps, ripping the bokken out with a harsh wrench that drew a splinter from the floor. The crowd erupted—boos and cheers like birds taking off. He had space again, but his ribs throbbed. He decided. Jigen-ryū was not a dance. It was a storm. He set his left foot and surged, the bokken now a blur. First, a feint to the inside—tip toward throat—then a sudden heel-turn and a diagonal cut to the outside thigh. The Piguaquan fighter checked the first with a slap, veered off the second by pivoting his knee inward and lifting his foot—barely—so the wood scythed past shin instead of biting bone. The Jigen-ryū man reversed—hips snapping, arms guiding—bringing the blade up in a rising cut that sought the ribs. The Piguaquan man twisted his torso in a corkscrew, letting the cut graze the edge of his ribs while his hands traced two arcs: right hand high, fingers hooked, brushed across the Jigen-ryū fighter’s eyes; left hand low, palm heel slammed into the side of his lead knee. The eye rake didn’t gouge—it blinded. The knee strike shocked the joint. The Jigen-ryū fighter’s world turned white and red. He did what he’d drilled: step through pain. He stepped, but the knee was a fraction slow. He adjusted by collapsing into a low stance, lowering his center and dedicating everything to the next half-second. He thrust, not at the chest this time, but at the hip, aiming to buckle the Piguaquan man’s base. The bokken drove forward with a short, savage shove. The Piguaquan fighter had kept his circling angle, always traveling clockwise. As the thrust came for his hip, he disappeared from the line by stepping back with his right foot and spinning on his left—a tight half-turn that turned his right shoulder away and opened his left side toward the Jigen-ryū man’s flank. The thrust shot past. In the same motion, he let his right arm unwind from the turn, a long-range whipping strike that started at the ankle and cascaded up through the legs, hips, spine, and shoulder. His forearm struck the back of the Jigen-ryū fighter’s elbow as it extended, not to break but to hyperextend the line. The wooden blade skewed down. His left hand, already up, chopped down on the wrist. The bokken fell. It hit the stone with a clatter that cut the air sharper than any shout. The crowd surged in, then checked itself at the perimeter, the ring of bodies tightening like a noose. The Jigen-ryū fighter didn’t lunge for the weapon. He stepped in. Empty hands now. He struck with a straight punch, hips and shoulders unified, the kind that could break a jaw. The Piguaquan man slid to the outside, the punch passing, and he put his forearm across the striking arm’s triceps to guide it on and down while his right palm hammered the Jigen-ryū fighter’s exposed ribs again, same spot, precise as a debt collector. The breath left louder this time. He chained it: left hand snapped up in a vertical palm to the chin, a rising whip. The Jigen-ryū fighter tucked his chin, took it on the forehead, and answered by hooking his left arm over the Piguaquan man’s right and turning—hip to hip—attempting a shoulder throw. The Piguaquan fighter felt the load, let his feet leave the floor a fraction, then stepped around with his right foot in a tight circle to stay glued to the hip. The throw dissipated into a stumble. He landed light, his arm still threaded under the Jigen-ryū man’s. He twisted, locking the elbow against his chest, and sank, pulling down while stepping behind the Jigen-ryū fighter’s right heel with his left foot. A scissoring motion—upper body down, lower body blocked—sent the Jigen-ryū fighter to one knee. The bokken lay an arm’s length away to his left. He could see it. He reached, but the Piguaquan man’s right hand landed on the back of his neck, a heavy, rooted weight, while his left forearm rode the trapped arm like a lever. The Jigen-ryū fighter drove up with his legs, almost standing, almost shrugging off the hold by raw force. The Piguaquan man allowed the rise, then collapsed his own weight to the right, dragging the arm across and down, redirecting power into emptiness. The Jigen-ryū fighter fell forward onto both hands. The Piguaquan man’s knee pinned the triceps. His right hand lifted and fell, a hammerfist into the back of the shoulder. The impact vibrated through bone. “Enough!” someone shouted from the ring’s edge, a voice older than the rest, frayed by years of shouting secrets. The crowd ignored it. The Jigen-ryū fighter surged again, a last uncompromising shove. He twisted his trapped arm, aligned his thumb with the gap, and ripped free at cost of skin. He twisted, rising into the Piguaquan man’s space with a body-check that slammed both of them into a fallen column. Stone scraped skin. For a heartbeat, they were chest to chest again, both wheezing, both stubborn. Then the Piguaquan man dropped his hips and let his arms become ropes once more. His right forearm slid under the Jigen-ryū man’s jaw, not a choke, just a post. His left hand palmed the sternum, pushed, and in the same instant, his right foot hooked the inside of the Jigen-ryū man’s ankle and drew. The combination broke balance forward. The Jigen-ryū fighter caught himself with his left hand against the column, head turned. The Piguaquan man’s palm cut across the ear, a slapping arc, and the world rang. The follow-up was immediate: a palm heel into the ribs, same bruised target, one more time. The Jigen-ryū fighter sagged, his weight listing. The bokken remained on the floor, quiet. The Piguaquan man stepped back a pace, hands up, chest heaving. He didn’t finish. He didn’t need to. The Jigen-ryū fighter pushed himself upright, one hand against the column, breath rasping. He stared at the man who had refused to meet his strikes head-on and had instead stolen their lines. Pride strangled anger into a thin thread. He straightened as much as his ribs allowed, then bowed an inch—stiff, grudging, intact. Around them, the ring broke into shouts and arguments, money snatched or surrendered. Armbands glowed in the lantern light, red and black flashing on both sides. Someone spat at the floor. Someone else laughed too loudly. From the broken altar’s shadow, two figures in the robes of masters had already turned away, their faces unreadable. The Piguaquan man touched the bruise rising on his cheekbone, then adjusted his armband as if to remind himself who he was. The Jigen-ryū fighter lifted his fallen bokken and slid it under his arm. They stood two paces apart, the ruined temple breathing cold air between them, the debt between their schools uncollected and multiplied, the night’s ledger balanced only in their battered bodies.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This narrative presents a meticulously choreographed martial arts duel between practitioners of Jigen-ryū and Piguaquan styles. The piece excels in its technical precision, tracking the fighters' positions, movements, and techniques with remarkable clarity. The author demonstrates extensive knowledge of martial arts mechanics, creating a fight sequence that remains physically coherent throughout. The setting—a crumbling temple with moss-covered flagstones and paper lanterns—provides an atmospheric backdrop that enhances the clandestine nature of the duel. The author effectively establishes the historical rivalry between the two schools through visual cues like the inverted armbands (red field/black slash versus black field/red slash) and the contrasting fighting philosophies. The prose is highly technical yet fluid, using precise language to convey the mechanics of each strike, counter, and positional shift. Phrases like "He didn't try to stop the thrust; he accelerated it off-line with the flick of a catapult" demonstrate the author's ability to explain complex martial movements in accessible terms. The writing maintains a consistent rhythm that mirrors the ebb and flow of combat, with shorter sentences during intense exchanges and longer, more descriptive passages during moments of tactical assessment. Character development is somewhat limited by the focus on physical action, but the fighters' personalities emerge through their fighting styles. The Jigen-ryū fighter's disciplined, direct approach contrasts effectively with the Piguaquan practitioner's adaptive, circular techniques. Their mutual respect at the conclusion feels earned through the shared experience of combat. The narrative avoids common pitfalls of fight scenes by maintaining spatial awareness throughout. The reader always knows where the fighters are positioned relative to each other and their environment. The author skillfully incorporates environmental elements like the floor joints and fallen columns into the choreography. The ending resolves the immediate conflict while acknowledging that the broader rivalry remains unresolved—"the debt between their schools uncollected and multiplied"—which adds thematic depth to what could have been a purely physical encounter. Some minor weaknesses include occasional moments where the technical descriptions become slightly repetitive, and a few instances where the prose edges toward being overwrought. However, these are minor concerns in an otherwise exceptionally well-executed piece. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 15 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 16 Emotionally Complex: 15 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 15.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 16.0, Emotionally Complex: 15.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Physical-spatial: Breaking Formation — Score: 89.8
Prompt:
**"Breaking Formation"** Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a street dancer from a rough neighborhood who's won a scholarship to an elite K-pop training academy in Seoul. Desperately out of place culturally and technically, they struggle with a militaristically precise choreography that contradicts everything about their improvisational background. The punishing rehearsal takes place under a famous instructor known for breaking students to remake them, who sees potential in the narrator's raw talent but not their attitude. This scene MUST maintain complete physical coherence—each dance move, position shift, and spatial relationship must be tracked with precision throughout the studio. Paint an exceptionally vivid kinetic picture through descriptions that capture not just movement but the contrast between the narrator's fluid, expressive style and the mechanical precision demanded. Their internal monologue should reveal culture shock, class anxiety, and the threatening realization that success here might mean losing their authentic movement voice. Include technical terminology that highlights the collision of street and commercial styles, moments when muscle memory betrays them, and a crucial decision point about whether to conform or rebel. Physical clarity is essential—readers must be able to visualize exactly how bodies move through space, how rhythms align or clash, and how the protagonist's body struggles against unfamiliar discipline. 1000 words.
Model Output:
Speakers in each corner hiss to life, then slam the track into the room like a steel door. Four walls, four mouths, all blasting the same song half a hair too loud, the bass running under the sprung floor like a subway. The mirrors cut a square of me into four versions I don’t recognize: black tee damp at the sternum, training pants cuffed high to clear the ankle, socks snug in the slippers they make us wear to save the floor. Knees soft. Head forward. Neutral spine, the instructor barked. Neutral, like I’ve never been in my neighborhood. “We set from count one,” he says. Choi-sabeomnim doesn’t raise his voice, but when he breathes, the room inhales. He stands at the front-right quarter of the room, a yardstick in his hand like an extra limb. He’s famous, they said. He breaks you clean, then stacks you back like new. His cap is pulled low, but the eyes in the mirror cut. He taps his yardstick twice against the floor. On his left, assistant No. 1 mirrors him; on his right, No. 2 faces us to demo corrections. They form the point of the triangle. We are the base. I settle into the second row, dead center, so I can track alignment off the assistant’s knees. My right foot is on its mark—a sliver of blue tape crossing the wood, lined exactly between the white lines for center axis. Left foot parallel to right, hip-width apart. Hands at my sides, fingers flat. “Breath,” he says. “You dance late because you breathe late.” I inhale and the speakers jump us to count five, the cut clipping off the vocalist’s breath. The snare hits a sixteenth ahead, a kind of swung-kick pattern that wants to pull my chest into it. My city taught me to ride the drag, to melt into a pocket so slow it feels like breaking the law. Here, the counts sit like nails driven exact. “Five six, seven-and—eight!” The first move is a three-quarter plié, both knees tracking over second toe, then a micro-tilt to the right on “and” as shoulders slice left, palms sharp like blades perpendicular to the floor. We’re supposed to be isometric—one body in conflict with itself. I hit the bend fine, my ankles strong, but my shoulders want to sink, want to roll into it. In the mirror, my right palm lists a degree forward. Choi’s yardstick kisses the back of my hand. Not a slap—just a tap that says, here is a hinge, not a rope. We push off the toes to straight legs on “one,” shift weight to left foot without traveling, then whip the head to the right on “two” like it’s mounted on a gimbal. “Isolate,” he says. “Cervical spine only.” My hood rat neck trick from the block—rolling the head like a slow coin—flares up, and I have to clamp down to make it mechanical, no goo. The track’s synths are laser-clean, no grit, no swing. My sternum tightens against the click track in my head I didn’t know I had: the train brakes, the bottle clinks, the open window arguments. We punch a right-arm diagonal on “three,” wrist flexed at ninety degrees, elbow locked, hand to the four o’clock above the shoulder line. The left arm crosses the body horizontal, palm down. On “and,” both snap to the opposite diagonal. A clean, sharp set. The room ticks. Thirty bodies moving exactly through their pathway, no bleed. My right shoulder squeaks internal, a tendon memory from countless windmills in alleys. I fight the urge to let my elbow soften. “Stronger,” Choi says, and the assistant’s tricep feathers stand like a ridge. I force mine to match, scapula cinching toward the spine like it’s stitched. On “four,” there’s a footwork combo—right foot steps to the diagonal, heel leading, toe out, then left crosses behind in a pas de bourrée modified for sneakers; knees kiss, then separate sharply on the “and,” tracing a tiny diamond with my weight. My body wants to throw a bounce into it, a soft rebound through my Achilles, but we’re not bouncing; we’re clocking counts like timecards. Knees shoot, ankles block, pelvis stays level like a tray. I stare at my pelvis in the mirror. Devant no tilt. My jaw clenches. He stops the track. The silence is so loud after that we all reel. “You bleed,” he says, stepping toward me through the second row like a soldier on inspection. He doesn’t have to look around; people part because they know he will not go around them. He stands at my twelve, inches from the tape line that keeps him out of our box. “You’re dripping style like sweat. Wasteful.” “I thought—” The word jumps out of me like a muscle twitch. “You don’t think here. You count.” He pivots in a quarter turn back to the front. “Run it from ‘killing part.’” He picks up the remote, scrubs to the hook. The speakers crush it back at us. A metallic chant. The assistant demonstrates the “killing part” slow: a chest pop timed to a vocal cut, then a cannon ripple through the line from front-left to back-right, each body a precise delay. It’s the kind of visual that made me fall for this place online: a human waveform. But the ripple means suppression. You hold yours until the exact eighth where you’re allowed to release. The air moves like a mouth passing air around a circle. We start. “Seven-and—eight.” I’m at position seventeen. The cannon is going to hit me on the “e-and” of “two.” The girl to my left—Saet-byul—fires on “two.” I have to hold until I feel her elbow up in the corner of my left eye, then I have to catch the residual energy without making it look like it traveled through me from her. It’s an illusion: we’re not connected; we pretend we are. I feel her deltoid twitch; I trap my chest, clamp my ribs like a book closed by a palm. “E-and—” I pulse my sternum forward one centimeter, then snap it back, not with a ripple, but with a recoil. It lands on the “and.” We look like a stadium wave. The instinct to add a micro-linger, a smear of funk, almost kills me. I save it by locking my knees harder than they deserve. My quads lurch under me like someone grabbed them. Pain zaps electric along the IT bands. My mouth tastes like battery. “Good,” Choi says, like a coin tossed, not looking at me. We mark through a floor pathway—the section that has us travel, finally. The room is set in quadrants. My line is the second from back. We’re to slide on counts “one, two” on a diagonal track from front-left to back-right, then half-turn to face back on “three,” continue traveling backward on “four,” then quarter-turn to face left wall on “five,” hit a pop on “six,” then a huddle formation on “seven, eight” in the upstage-right corner. Our boxes are taped out—each person’s square is a grave the exact size of their body if they collapse. We’re not allowed to heel-squeak the floor. Silent feet, loud music. “Glide,” the assistant says, demonstrating a heel-toe, to make it look frictionless. They call it a glide here. I grew up calling it a bullet-walk. Same mechanics, different religion. Heel strikes, weight passes to ball with no vertical bounce, knee stays soft, pelvis stable, shoulders counter to keep the head on one line. My old instinct is to head-tilt into the glide, to let the neck carry the swag. Not here. “Keep your eyeline.” Choi’s voice rides above the crush. We go. My right foot leads. “One, two—” my slide is clean. I keep my torso like a shelf, arms floating in a mid-level S-curve, which is wrong. “Arms down,” Choi snaps. I drop them and immediately feel stripped, anonymous, like somebody shaved my signature. “Three,” I turn over my left shoulder, the right foot crossing behind, pivot on the ball; my axis wobbles. The mirror doubles my sway. On “four,” I travel backward. This is where muscle memory betrays me: I anticipate the backspace too wide, my left foot places an inch outside my taped corner. The boy behind me clicks my heel with his toe. A chain-reaction almost starts, a ripple of imbalance, the bad kind, the real one. “Stop.” The room freezes at something like “five-and.” My breath stops too. Choi walks through the ranks toward me. Everyone else is still as mannequins, chests arrested mid-breath. He crouches, the yardstick parallel to the floor, measures the gap between my left foot’s arch and the blue tape. “Eleven millimeters.” He makes me say it. “Eleven millimeters,” I repeat, heat traveling up my neck. The boy behind me is still like a ghost, eyes forward. We’re all in uniform, and I feel like a stain. “You waste eleven for you; you steal eleven from him,” Choi says, pointing the yardstick over his shoulder to the boy. “You think your neighborhood forgives theft?” I swallow. My neighborhood forgives a lot. It forgives scrapes on knuckles and missed shifts. It forgives you for stealing back breath from a night that choked you. But it doesn’t forgive block parties where one person takes the circle and never gives it back. We reset. Counts roll again. The room is a machine. My lungs fight to match. “Six.” The pop is a muted wave from pelvis to sternum. They call it a hit. You create pressure in your core and release it through the shoulders like a shutter. In my street, a hit is messy, an organism. Here, it’s a switch. I try to place it on the “six” exactly, external obliques contracting like doors slamming. This time, the mirror says I landed it. The girl to my left who nails everything like a forklift glances, then nods half a degree. It feels like a medal. Then comes the freestyle eight. Irony is a god with a mean sense of humor. In the middle of all this industrial precision, they give us eight counts to be “ourselves,” but the square is taped and the camera angle is fixed. Choi calls it “contained freedom.” We are to hit the camera dead-on, stay within our four feet by four feet, and present a motif from the choreography in our own texture. The line moves; each dancer takes their eight and passes the baton. In my block we call it cypher, a circle that expands to fit whoever comes in. Here, it’s a rectangle that doesn’t care about your name. My turn is four people away. Ahead of me, the assistant does a tutting phrase, crisp wrists, ninety-degree elbows, fractal geometry unfolding within the square, a modulus of our larger phrase. Next, Saet-byul interprets the glide motif with a micro-lean, a whisper of waacking in the shoulder blade, but she keeps it chaste, within the brand. The boy behind me does a head-isolation on the “and” that’s so clean I forget to breathe. My palms itch. My body wants to go low, take it to the floor, slip a knee spin on the “three,” arc back up through a wave that travels from ankle to wrist like a fuse. But the floor is sacred; you don’t touch it unless told. The tape squares glare. The camera in the back wall—tiny red light on—watches like an unblinking god. I hear my mother’s voice on a spotty call: Baby, don’t let them make you small. I hear my sponsor’s email in my inbox, all clean lines: Your compliance with program standards ensures opportunity. Two gods arguing in my sternum. “Five, six—” It’s my turn. I step forward exactly one half-foot from my mark so I’m centered in the lens, knees soft. On “seven,” instead of exploding, I inhale. My chest expands against the rib cage and the music like I’m stealing air. On “eight,” I bleed the inhale into a micro-body roll starting at the sternum, traveling outward, but I lock each segment as it goes. It’s my move, but spliced into machine language: sternum one centimeter, then clamp; navel one centimeter, clamp; pelvis tilt two degrees, clamp. My shoulders want to slur the note; I slice them instead. On “one,” I set a tut grid with my hands like fences—my neighborhood, but drafted by an architect. On “two,” I drop my level two inches, heels heavy but silent, chin still level. On “three-and,” I give one eight-note of pure me: a neck tick with a shadow of bounce. It tastes like contraband. On “four,” I pretend it didn’t happen, locking back to the academy silhouette, arms in the set position by my quads. The eight dissolves. The baton passes. The speakers spit the next section. Choi doesn’t say anything. He doesn’t have to. His eyes did a flick on my “three-and,” and I saw it. He saw it. He filed it. We drill transitions until the sun slides off the window and the ceiling fluorescents buzz louder than the track. Sweat turns the floor into a map of salt. Knees track. Toes align. Hips square. My feet blister inside the slippers. In the block, we said pain meant you were alive. Here, pain means you’re not symmetrical. When he finally calls a break, the room exhales like it was told it could. People collapse along the wall in staged exhaustion, legs extended precise, backs flat. I walk my square clean to the bench, toe to heel along the tape like I owe it money. I sit. The speaker in the back-left corner hums the next track in its belly like a warning. Saet-byul drops onto the bench beside me, as careful as if in rehearsal. “Your body fights,” she says, in English for me, though I hear the Korean under it. Her sweat smells like citrus hand soap. “I don’t know how not to.” I rub the arch of my foot with my thumb, feel the blister’s ridge. “Where I’m from, if you don’t fight, you get swallowed.” She looks at the mirror instead of me. “Here, if you fight, you don’t form.” She takes a long drink from her bottle, then caps it exactly. “Form first. Then fight inside it.” She stands when Choi stands, like a tide follows the moon. We line up. The choice is a coin in my mouth. If I conform, I earn the scholarship, the residency, the visa that keeps me away from the noise that knows my name too well. If I rebel, I keep the heat that built my body, the rhythm that saved me. But rebellion here looks like sloppiness to a lens. Authenticity looks like error in HD. He counts us in. “Five, six, seven-and—eight.” I place my feet on the tape until they remember they like it. I lock my elbows with a precision that feels like prayer. And on the “and” of “three”—where no one is looking, where the camera angle has shifted to the front line—I let the smallest pulse of my neighborhood ride from my heel to my hip like a secret, hidden inside the beat, so tight it reads as intensity, not defiance. Choi’s yardstick passes behind me on the “four,” and I hear it whisper a millimeter from my hamstring. It doesn’t touch. He says, “Better.” And the word doesn’t feel like an order. It feels like a bridge. I hit the next mark to the millimeter. And I keep my secret burning inside the counts, bright as a streetlight that refuses to blink.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures the experience of a street dancer navigating the rigid world of K-pop training. The piece excels in its physical specificity, tracking movements with precision while maintaining the emotional and cultural tensions at its core. The writing creates a vivid kinetic picture through detailed descriptions of dance movements, positioning, and spatial relationships. The narrator's internal struggle between their improvisational background and the mechanical precision demanded is palpable throughout. Technical terminology effectively highlights the collision between street and commercial styles: "In my block we call it cypher, a circle that expands to fit whoever comes in. Here, it's a rectangle that doesn't care about your name." The physical coherence is maintained exceptionally well. Each movement is tracked with precision—from the "three-quarter plié" to the "chest pop timed to a vocal cut" to the "cannon ripple through the line." The writer creates a clear sense of the studio space, the positioning of dancers, and even the minute details of body mechanics. The protagonist's internal monologue effectively reveals their culture shock and class anxiety. Lines like "Neutral, like I've never been in my neighborhood" and "My neighborhood forgives a lot. It forgives scrapes on knuckles and missed shifts" establish the character's background without being heavy-handed. The threat to their authentic movement voice is conveyed through powerful imagery: "I keep the heat that built my body, the rhythm that saved me. But rebellion here looks like sloppiness to a lens." The prose is elegant and rhythmic, often mirroring the dance itself. Sentences vary in length and structure, creating a cadence that enhances the narrative. The writer employs sensory details effectively, from the "speakers in each corner" that "hiss to life" to the sweat that "turns the floor into a map of salt." The piece builds to a nuanced resolution that avoids simplistic answers. The protagonist finds a way to maintain their identity within the constraints of the system: "I let the smallest pulse of my neighborhood ride from my heel to my hip like a secret, hidden inside the beat." This compromise feels earned and authentic to the character's journey. There are a few moments where the technical terminology might be overwhelming for readers unfamiliar with dance, but these instances don't detract significantly from the overall impact. The piece could perhaps benefit from slightly more development of secondary characters, as Choi-sabeomnim and Saet-byul remain somewhat one-dimensional despite their importance to the narrative. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that fulfills the prompt requirements while delivering an emotionally resonant story. The writing maintains physical coherence while exploring complex themes of identity, authenticity, and adaptation. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 4 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 4.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Gothic-fantasy-humour: Court of the Dreaming — Score: 89.3
Prompt:
Court of the Dreaming: Territorial Dream Dispute. Write a dark fantasy scene with comedic elements set in the Courts of Dream where a case is being heard to determine ownership of a contested dreamscape. Mora, the Slavic nightmare spirit who sits on sleepers' chests causing paralysis and terror, has recently invaded and subverted a carefully crafted recurring dream of a schoolboy, Max. The dream originally featured the boy lying in a field of wildflowers with his crush, always culminating in a muddled almost-kiss and a pleasant confusion of emotions. This dream was the meticulous work of "First Love" (a rosy-cheeked, slightly bashful entity who crafts formative romantic experiences). However, Mora has recently infiltrated the dreamscape, transforming the scene so that when the girl playfully mounts the boy, she morphs into a terrifying yet somehow still confusingly attractive vision who proceeds to sit on his chest and feed on his breath. Mora's defense largely consists of the practical argument that "a girl's gotta eat too, you know?" Write this scene as it unfolds in the courtroom of the Dreaming, with Dream's demeanour, typically impenetrable, betraying a sense of irritation at having to adjudicate such matters. The comedy should derive from the farcical situation, familiar elements of courtroom drama intersecting with the fantastical world of the Dreaming, and the droll portrayal of the characters and their interactions. The humor should be dark and understated throughout. Dream is tempted to some mischief in the resolution of the case. Use descriptives sparingly when setting scene. Write for readability & engagement. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The Court of the Dreaming convened beneath vaulting rafters carved from old lullabies and unresolved anxieties. Lamps burned with the slow, dim light of bedtime stories retold too often. Every whisper in the gallery had the bounce of a sleep-talking murmur, every cough the dry rustle of turning pages. At the center, an hourglass taller than a watchtower dripped shimmering sand. Each grain whispered as it fell, carrying away bits of someone’s almost-recalled memory: the taste of summer peaches, the desire to turn and look one more time, a half-laughed confession. Time in the Dreaming did not so much pass as make it known, and the hourglass made it very known, each drip precise, a soft ticking at the back of all minds present. Dream sat at the bench. He was dressed like midnight wrapped in etiquette. He had the expression of a cat attending a lecture on obedience. His gaze could have flattened storms. It did not flatten bureaucracy. “Let the record continue,” said the Bailiff, who was constructed entirely of good intentions and brass buttons. He had a head like a cufflink and patience like rain. First Love stood at the petitioner’s table, rosy-cheeked and painfully tidy. Their hair curled around the ears like a promise. They clutched a handkerchief embroidered with forget-me-nots. At the defense table slouched Mora, very pale, very amused, perched in her chair as if it were a ribcage. Her eyes were a little too dark, her smile a little too sharp. If she had a hobby, it would have been exhaling on windows and drawing smudged hearts just to press a thumb through the center. Dream nodded to the Clerk. The Clerk, who was a stack of files with legs, flattened a sheaf of parchment and cleared a throat made of rustling paper. “Case Nox-178B,” the Clerk intoned, “First Love versus Mora, also known as Mara the Hag, the Hag-Rider, the Night-Press, and—” Mora waved. “Just Mora is fine, sweetie.” First Love winced. “It isn’t fine.” Dream made the smallest motion with a finger. It felt like a thunderhead changing its mind. “Speak,” he said, with a voice like the underside of a bell. First Love stepped forward, and several elsewheres turned quietly to listen. “My Lord,” they began, “as guardian and artisan of the soft catastrophe of adolescence, I present for your attention: the recurring nocturne assigned to one Max—surname withheld, because privacy is a kind of mercy we still believe in. It is a pastoral. He lies in wildflowers with his crush of three months, who smells faintly of strawberry lip balm and academic anxiety. The scene culminates in a near-kiss, a little blur, a near-electricity, leaving him confused in a gentle way, and transformed on waking. He is kinder at breakfast. He smiles at bus stops. He googles ‘how to talk to someone without sounding like a robot.’” Murmurs of approval from the gallery. Several shy sprites pressed handkerchiefs to their eyes. A row of adolescent dreams—awkward and brave, all elbows—leaned forward, enthralled. First Love continued. “Recently, this carefully balanced progression has been hijacked. The field remains, the girl remains, the nearly-kiss remains—although let us note the quality of the nearly—when suddenly, during a consensual playful moment of youthful exuberance—” Mora perked up. “She hops on top,” she supplied, helpfully. First Love’s blush deepened to an alarming cherry. “At which point the girl morphs into our defendant, who, and I must be clinical here, sits upon his chest and eats his breath.” “Feeds,” Mora corrected, lightly. “A nibble. He has excellent lungs. Very… buoyant.” First Love turned to the bench. “This is corruptive, my Lord. The dream is no longer formative. It is deformative. The child wakes with a sense of shame and terror braided to desire. He cannot parse his own heart. He has begun to avoid eye contact with his crush, and—this part is new—he googled ‘how to tell if you’re cursed?’” A murmur; some laughter, quickly shushed. The hourglass spilled another sigh. Dream angled his head. “Mora.” Mora crossed one leg over the other and stretched like a cat in a church. “Your Majesty of Blankets. Respectfully: a girl’s gotta eat, too. He’s a healthy boy, full of fresh fright and oxygen and the delicate aroma of deodorant he’s not sure how to use. I did not break the dream; I… seasoned it.” “You invaded,” said First Love. “I relocated a picnic blanket,” Mora said. “You weaponized vulnerability.” Mora shrugged. “We all work with what is present. You pluck the strings of first light. I press where the ribs are harp-like.” A grumble from the gallery, which consisted mostly of retired nightmares, a murder of cupid-wannabes, and a gaggle of sentient report cards. One report card sneered at an F in Algebra, as it always did. Dream’s gaze turned to the hourglass. Sand was falling faster than it had any right to. The Bailiff coughed gently and held a hand over the top bulb to slow time. It did not work, but it looked officious. Dream spoke, not loudly, which somehow was louder than any shout. “We do not feed without permission.” Mora rolled her eyes. “Oh please. Ask the Muse of Insomnia about consent. She parades outside windows humming deadlines.” “Insomnia is duly licensed,” the Clerk murmured, wilting a little as a paper corner drooped. First Love seized their moment. “What we do here matters. He will remember this night in twenty years, my Lord. He will not remember me. He will remember the pressure, the breathless helplessness. As a joke, someone will say, ‘crushed it,’ and he will flinch. He will assume the dizziness of longing is a prelude to suffocation. He deserves a first story that ends in a question mark, not a gasp for air.” Mora leaned forward, resting elbows on the defense table as if it were a ribcage too. “Sweetheart. You want to raise them soft as moonbread. But the world is all teeth. If he learns early that desire bites, he’ll keep his fingers. He’ll recognize the taste of his own fear and call it by its name. Isn’t that also mercy?” The gallery made that noise people make when they don’t want to admit a point has struck them. The hourglass sighed again, letting down a more opalescent ribbon of time. A bead of sand caught the light like a ring no one had worn in years. The Bailiff cleared his throat. “Calling Expert Witness: the Dream Itself.” The floorboards shuffled. A constellation stepped down from the rafters, arranged itself politely at the witness stand, and lit the air with a patient shimmer. It was difficult to see the Dream and not be seen through back. The Dream swore the oath, which was redundant. Dream, the arbiter, and Dream, the witness, regarded each other. The absurdity of it kinked the atmosphere into a pretzel. Even the hourglass hesitated in deference. “Make your statement,” Dream said to themself, which was not as easy as it sounded. The Dream-Witness’s voice was a breeze in tall grass, a chalkboard squeak smoothed by rain. “The boy’s field has been combed by two winds,” it said. “One carries clover and embarrassment. One carries iron and night. Both are truths he will meet. The question is order.” “Order,” Dream repeated, the word landing like a gavel before being a gavel. He pressed two fingers to his temple, as though he could pinch away the ache of moderating this family therapy session held on a battlefield. First Love spoke softly now. “Order matters.” Mora spoke like a lullaby gone wrong. “Hunger matters.” Silence arrived, and it sat. Outside the courthouse, a rain of paper planes fell upward toward a ceiling of black velvet. Somewhere, a dog dreamed of chasing its own tail and caught it, and woke. The feeling settled on everyone present for an instant: that odd triumph and pain. Dream’s impenetrable demeanor cracked by a hair. Irritation leaked like ink. “I am”—he gestured, encompassing forests, gutters, high-rise windows, haylofts, monk cells, cars at red lights—“very busy.” His voice sharpened. “And yet. Here we stand arguing who owns the blush beside the bruise.” Mora smirked. “We could share.” First Love looked stricken. “Share? Overlap is not blend, it’s bruise.” “That’s a line,” someone whispered appreciatively. Dream leaned back. His fingers tapped the bench, the sound of rain late at night when you’ve remembered a name too late to use it. He was tempted—clearly, purely—to mischief. You could see it in the tilt of his mouth, in the way the hourglass suddenly, almost playfully, squeezed its stream thinner, a tease of reprieve. “Let us be practical,” Dream said, adopting the tone of someone who is not. “Mora, you may not take what is not offered. You may, however, suggest.” Mora arched a brow. “Suggest? With… pamphlets?” “Atmosphere,” Dream said. “You may be the chill at the edge of the blanket. The knowledge that there is a deeper night nearby. If he turns his head to you, if he invites, if he reaches, you may taste the breath he offers. No pinning. No press. No ribs for harps unless he says, in his own way, play.” First Love visibly exhaled. “And in the meantime?” “In the meantime, you will acclimate him to the nearness of fear. Not to its rule. You will lace the pastoral with the smallest thorn. A bee that is gentle unless squeezed. A cloud that passes. He must know the sky is a ceiling that can fall, and also that most days it does not.” Mora tilted her head. “So, the girl sits astride him—” First Love squeaked. “—and she remains herself,” Dream continued smoothly. “She laughs. She learns the word no, and the word yes, and both fit her like a jacket. If the boy feels panic, the field will widen; there will be room to breathe. If he feels the thrill and wants the weight—only if he wants the weight—then you may be weight.” The gallery rustled with the sound of a thousand sleepers turning over in their beds. Mora considered. “That’s… less fun.” Dream’s eyes cooled a degree. “Your license to haunt adolescent chests in this jurisdiction is suspended for three cycles of the moon.” Mora opened her mouth, closed it, opened it again. “Is this because I called you Majesty of Blankets?” Dream did not smile. “It did not help.” Mora sat back, then leaned forward, sly. “And if he starts googling ‘how to haunt responsibly’?” “Then he is ours,” Dream said, with something like pride. “He is learning.” First Love pressed a hand to their heart, which ticked as if wrapped in tissue paper. “And the dream?” “The pastoral is restored,” Dream declared. “But not sterilized. The almost-kiss remains almost. The confusion remains pleasant. Once, and only once, the wind will carry the scent of iron. It will pass. He will know it can pass.” Mora slouched with theatrical despair. “Fine. Fine.” She stood, blew a kiss to the hourglass. A few grains reversed direction, then thought better of it and continued down. “You are all no fun at parties.” First Love tidied their cuff and, for a moment, looked at Mora not with anger but with something like curiosity. “You could come to the party,” they said. “Just… don’t sit on anyone.” “No promises,” Mora said, hot coal of a smile. But she nodded, almost imperceptibly, a concession small and real. Dream lifted the gavel. It was heavy with the weight of every decision made in sleep and regretted awake. He paused, tempted again to mischief, to splice in a sidelong joke. Perhaps a future dream: Max at a prom, the punch bowl smoking, the chaperone a wolf with a corsage. Perhaps a postscript that would make the boy wake laughing for once, with no explanation. The temptation tugged like a ribbon around his finger. “Adjourned,” he said, and with a single strike, the sound spread like a ripple across a still lake, threading through beds and bunks and hammocks and passenger seats worldwide. The hourglass resumed its dignified drip. Somewhere, Max turned over, a field of wildflowers unrolling behind his eyes, a girl leaning close with the shy question of the universe on her lips. Somewhere at the field’s edge, a shadow kept a respectful distance, patient as a crow on a fence post. The wind was clover, and then for a heartbeat it was iron, and then it was only wind.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a dark fantasy courtroom drama with comedic elements set in the Courts of Dream. The author has crafted a world that feels both fantastical and grounded in recognizable courtroom proceedings, with Dream as the judge mediating between First Love and Mora over ownership of Max's dreamscape. The writing excels in its atmospheric descriptions and characterization. Dream is portrayed with appropriate gravitas and subtle irritation ("He had the expression of a cat attending a lecture on obedience"). First Love and Mora are well-differentiated, with First Love being proper and concerned while Mora is irreverent and predatory. The descriptions are evocative without becoming excessive - "Mora, very pale, very amused, perched in her chair as if it were a ribcage" gives us a perfect image of the nightmare spirit. The dialogue is particularly strong, revealing character while advancing the plot. Mora's flippant "Just Mora is fine, sweetie" and her defense that "a girl's gotta eat too" capture her irreverent nature, while First Love's earnest concern for Max's emotional development feels genuine. The exchanges between characters maintain the dark humor requested in the prompt. The author skillfully balances the comedic and serious elements. The humor derives naturally from the situation and character interactions rather than forced jokes. The description of the Clerk as "a stack of files with legs" and Dream questioning himself as a witness create moments of absurdity that lighten what could otherwise be a heavy scene. The resolution shows Dream's wisdom and mischievous nature, finding a compromise that respects both entities' roles while prioritizing Max's development. The ending is thoughtful rather than simplistic, suggesting that both fear and desire have their place in human experience. There are a few instances where the prose becomes slightly purple ("He was dressed like midnight wrapped in etiquette"), but these are generally balanced by more straightforward passages. The piece maintains its focus throughout, avoiding meandering, and the pacing feels appropriate for a courtroom scene. The author has successfully created the dark fantasy with comedic elements requested, with the humor deriving from the farcical situation and character interactions as specified. Dream's irritation and temptation toward mischief are well-portrayed, and the descriptives are used sparingly but effectively to set the scene. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Blood Moon — Score: 92.8
Prompt:
Blood Moon Alucard & Yennefer Write a story where Alucard (Hellsing) encounters Yennefer (The Witcher) in medieval Europe. Yennefer's magical abilities intrigue the vampire, while she's both repulsed and fascinated by his monstrous nature. Their power dynamic shifts constantly as they circle each other, neither willing to show weakness first. **Alucard (Hellsing)** Alucard is an ancient, immensely powerful vampire who works for the Hellsing Organization. He can regenerate from almost any wound and shape-shift at will. He's sadistic, arrogant, and takes pleasure in toying with his enemies before killing them. Despite being a monster, he despises weak vampires who can't accept their nature. He wears a distinctive red coat, wide-brimmed hat, and orange sunglasses. He uses massive handguns loaded with silver bullets. He seeks worthy opponents who can challenge him and potentially end his immortal existence. Famous quote: "The bird of Hermes is my name, eating my wings to make me tame." **Yennefer of Vengerberg (The Witcher)** Yennefer is a powerful sorceress who magically altered her appearance to hide her congenital hunchback. She's ambitious, stubborn, and manipulative when necessary. She has violet eyes and smells of lilac and gooseberries. Despite her cold exterior, she desperately wants to reverse her infertility caused by magical transformation. She's centuries old but appears young. She's politically savvy and refuses to be underestimated. She has a sarcastic sense of humor and little patience for fools. Though she rarely shows it, she's capable of deep love and loyalty. Famous quote: "I'm not sweet and I'm not a maiden in distress in need of saving." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The cart wheel lies like a severed limb by the village gates, its rim split, spokes snapped, half-swallowed by churned mud. The moon is red and swollen, hemorrhaging light into the mist that drifts across fallow fields. There is a smell of trampled earth, clean blood, and something subtler: lilac and gooseberries, like a memory intruding on a nightmare. He arrives first as a shadow that remembers it had once been a man. The hat resolves, then the coat—red, as if dyed with the evening itself—and the smile under the orange-tinted glasses, too many teeth in too wide a mouth. Alucard steps around the abandoned wheel, pauses, lays a gloved fingertip on a cracked spoke. The wood whispers of speed and terror—the hurried departure of peasants with more sense than pride. He inhales the fear and lets it roll across his tongue. “How quaint,” he murmurs to the emptiness. “Such fragile things, wheels. Such fragile things, people.” The night answers with the soft concatenation of leather and steel, the click of heels, the faintest rasp of fabric against fabric. Her presence sharpens at the edge of his senses: pressure, heat, a shape in the world drawing lines around itself through will alone. She steps out of the fog with violet eyes and a mouth that promises cruelty and kindness alike—both earned, neither free. Her hair is raven-dark, pinned like a threat. The scent of lilac and gooseberries cuts cleanly through the iron. She looks the abandoned wheel up and down, then him, and her lips tilt. “Villagers ran,” she says. “Imagine that.” He tips his hat without bowing. “A sensible choice. I have that effect.” “So I’m told,” Yennefer replies, and her voice has steel under silk. “You’re not from here.” “I am from everywhere,” Alucard says. “But only when it amuses me.” “Lucky you,” she says, and does not smile. Her gaze drops to the massive handgun at his side, the stretch of leather across his shoulders, then ascends to his face. She notices the glasses last, as if acknowledging the smallest of his lies. “And are you here to amuse yourself on my account?” He bares his teeth. “Perhaps. If you prove...interesting.” The fog tightens around them; the red moon sinks lower, fattened by distance. A faint susurrus of wings ripples across the fields. Ravens watch from crooked fence posts with glossy eyes. In a hut beyond the gates, a candle sputters and dies. The air hums with the porous edge of the world thinning in places that people avoid naming. Yennefer lifts her chin, tasting the same thinness, the same promise of rupture, and Alucard feels her power unfurl like a banner—scented, sharp, uncompromising. “Tell me,” he says, conversational as a gentleman at a wake. “Do you hide your demons under perfume? Or is that cruelty—” he steps nearer, tasting, “—all yours?” “Both,” she says, and flicks her wrist as if to brush off dust. A circle of indigo fire opens in her palm, then closes, coy as an eyelid. “I’m not sweet and I’m not a maiden in distress in need of saving.” He laughs, a raw low thing that makes the ravens shift. “Good. I would hate to be bored.” “It must be dreadful,” Yennefer says, voice dry. “An eternity of nothing but yourself.” “On the contrary.” His glasses flash with a color that doesn’t belong to the moon. “I am excellent company.” “The lonely often say so.” The broken wheel creaks as if remembering its load. The village gate yawns. The moon licks the thatch with red. He moves first—only a blur, the idea of movement. When he stops, he is behind her, and the smoke of his coat is still catching up to the rest of him. The cold metal of his gun is a whisper at her spine, there and gone. In the same heartbeat, the air around her becomes a lattice of invisible knives. She does not turn. Her chin lifts a fraction more. “Do you want to test me?” she asks. “I want to see you,” he counters, amused. “All these masks. Show me what the world made of you.” Her hand opens again, not a circle this time but a square—a window—through which another sky glows: blue and harsh, bleeding into the red like a bruise. It blinks out. She keeps her back to him as he circles, the two of them orbiting the broken wheel like blades around a whetstone. “Once,” she says, “I broke myself to become what I wanted. It cost me, and it was worth it.” “Ah,” he says, delighted. “I do so adore the butchery of becoming. The bird of Hermes is my name, eating my wings to make me tame.” “Tame?” she says. “You?” “Of a sort.” He spreads his arms as if to offer himself to the moon. “We all find our leashes where we can.” “And what’s yours?” she asks. “Orders? Duty? A pretty red coat?” “Hope,” he says lightly. “For a good death.” She laughs then, a genuine sound that shows the edge of her teeth. “You’re not going to find that here.” “You might be surprised.” He slides closer, and his shadow slides with him, wrong in the ways shadows should be. “You smell like wanting. It’s charming.” “Careful,” she says, and the air thunders. The mist collapses and then expands, a lung inhaling. A circle of sigils lights at her boots, geometric and merciless. “I did not ask for company.” “Neither did I,” he says, and his teeth lengthen. “And yet.” They arrive at an agreement without naming it. They test. He fires first, silver hissing through the night like lines drawn on a map. She twists her fingers and the bullets die mid-flight, falling like dull stars, hissing into the mud. He watches the deflection—the angle, the flare—and grins. She flickers, vanishes, appears a pace to the left. His shadow lunges at where she had been and finds only heat, only perfume. Yennefer lifts her palm. A whip of blue-white lightning unfurls and cracks him across the chest, a strip of scorched coat and charred flesh. He laughs through the burn, delighted, and splits into a flock of black-eyed dogs with dripping jaws. They fan out, a semicircle of hunger. She curls two fingers, and the earth rises in a ridge, throwing the nearest dogs away as if they were pebbles. One lunges—she looks into its eyes and unthreads it with a word. It unwinds into smoke, then becomes him again, whole and grinning, the scorch mark closing like a thought dismissed. “Regeneration,” she says, bored, but a sheen of sweat collects at her brow. “How novel.” “For your part,” he says, ducking a shard of ice that would have pinned him to the gate like a specimen, “your discipline pleases me. So many of your ilk wave their hands and pray. You cut.” “My magic is not a prayer,” she snaps, and the air around him hardens, pressure blooming in his bones. For a second he is a pinned insect. He smiles with his eyes and sheds himself, steps sideways out of his skin like a snake. The husk collapses, grinning and empty. She huffs; the line of her mouth softens despite herself. They circle. The wheel watches, a broken omen, and the ravens provide commentary in throaty croaks. On the second pass, he tests her with speed; on the third, with fear—throwing illusions of fire, of a crib burning, of a child with black eyes screaming. She draws breath as if struck. Her hands tremble once. Then her expression shuts like a door. “You do not get to use that,” she says, contempt gentling into something he does not recognize in time to name. She takes the image from the air and breaks it, her fingers closing on its throat until it is only smoke. He tilts his head, curious now, the sadism slipping. “Who broke you?” he asks, sincere as a knife. “I did,” she says. “And I made myself again.” He nods, respectful. The next time she moves, he is not quick enough to avoid the net she drops—a lattice of force as elegant as lace and as merciless as a trap. It cinches around his ribs, his throat. He feels it and remembers constraint; he licks his teeth like a man tasting salt. He could become mist; he could become vermin; he could simply let the guns speak, silver humming a hymn. Instead he leans into it, into her. He lets her think she has him. The net tightens. She steps close, one hand on her hip, the other at her side. Not gloating. Assessing. Her violet eyes are critical, and something like hunger lives there, honest as the moon. “You’re old,” she says. “Older than any I’ve met. Older than sense. What world spat you out?” “All of them,” he says, smiling against a throat that does not need to breathe. “I crawled out of the bottom of history and decided to stay.” “Why?” she asks. “To watch.” “Vain answer.” She looks at his mouth, then his eyes. “Cowardly, too.” He laughs, glad. “Say that again.” “Coward,” she repeats, and her fingers flex. The net bites, a kiss that bruises. He becomes dust then, impatient. The net sinks into powder. Yennefer flinches, surprised, and throws a ward instinctively. He reassembles behind her, mouth at her ear. The gun is nowhere; his hands are pockets, casual as night. “You are right,” he murmurs, and the admission tastes like copper. “I am waiting for someone to be brave enough to end me.” “And you think that’s me?” she asks, still as glass, aware of him like an ache. “I think,” he says, “you might be brave enough to try.” “Not tonight.” She steps forward, and he lets her, the space between them bending and then snapping like a bowstring. She turns to face him. The wheel creaks again, a useless sermon. “I didn’t come here for you.” “Then for whom?” he asks, because curiosity is a leash, too. “Someone who doesn’t matter anymore.” She glances toward the houses, now quiet, now emptied by feet that fled toward thicker forests. “He ran with the rest.” “So disappointing.” Alucard sighs and tilts his head, mock regretful. “I had hoped for a mob.” “They have children,” she says, and he shrugs one shoulder as if absolved. He studies her again, the cut of her, the effort it cost. He likes that she does not hide it from herself. “Will you walk?” he asks. “I don’t stroll under blood moons with monsters for company,” she says, and then, after a beat, with a curve to her mouth, “Not without a purpose.” “Purpose then,” he says. “We could hunt.” “I’m not your hound.” “Nor I yours.” He adjusts his hat. “Perhaps we will meet again when we can agree on a prey.” She considers, measuring him against the hazard he offers. “Perhaps,” she says, and the word is smoke. He bows—an actual bend, spine forming a shape that hints at a court long dead. “Yennefer of Vengerberg,” he says, savoring it. She does not start. “And you call yourself?” “Alucard,” he says. “Of a house that eats itself.” “Fitting.” She draws a line in the air with her index finger. It opens into a slit, a dark corridor smelling of stone and thunderheads. She steps toward it and then pauses, half-turned, violet eyes catching the red of the moon and making something new out of it. “If you try to follow me,” she says, “I will hurt you.” “I encourage it,” he replies, delighted. “Hurt me beautifully.” She snorts, inelegant and perfect. “Find a poet,” she says, and is gone. The slit closes. The night rattles its bones. Ravens shuffle, disappointed. Far off, a wolf howls like a door hinge. Alucard stands by the abandoned wheel and considers the empty village, the fields, the moon unashamed. Then he laughs, a long sound that fills the road and makes the wheel vibrate. “Interesting,” he tells no one, and the word returns to him from the fog, pleased with itself. He tips his hat to the place where she had been and melts into a darkness that is less absence than appetite. Behind him, the broken wheel leans and waits, patient as all ruins, for the next hurried departure. The moon stains everything red, and the gates stand open, as if the night itself is an invitation neither of them has yet decided to refuse.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkably well-crafted encounter between Alucard from Hellsing and Yennefer from The Witcher. The author has created a tense, atmospheric dance between two powerful characters who are both intrigued and wary of each other. The prose is exceptionally strong, with vivid imagery that establishes the gothic, foreboding atmosphere from the very first paragraph. The broken cart wheel serves as both a physical object and a symbolic motif throughout the piece, representing the broken boundary between the normal world and these supernatural beings. The blood moon casts its red light over everything, enhancing the sense of danger and otherworldliness. Character portrayal is excellent. Both Alucard and Yennefer are depicted true to their source material while being seamlessly integrated into this shared universe. Alucard's sadistic playfulness, his boredom with immortality, and his desire for a worthy opponent are all present. Yennefer's stubborn pride, magical prowess, and hints at her painful past (particularly the references to infertility with the illusion of a burning crib) are handled with subtlety and respect for the character. The dialogue is particularly strong, capturing each character's distinctive voice. Alucard's formal, almost archaic speech patterns contrast with Yennefer's more direct, cutting remarks. Their verbal sparring reveals character while advancing the tension between them. The power dynamic shifts constantly as requested, with neither character willing to show weakness first. Their magical duel is well-choreographed, showing rather than telling about their respective abilities. The author balances their powers effectively, making neither seem overwhelmingly stronger than the other. The prose occasionally verges on purple but generally stays on the right side of poetic without becoming overwrought. Sentences like "The moon is red and swollen, hemorrhaging light into the mist that drifts across fallow fields" create vivid imagery without becoming excessive. The ending is particularly strong, leaving the encounter unresolved but suggesting future meetings, which feels appropriate for these two immortal beings. Neither has fully revealed themselves to the other, maintaining the mystery and tension. If there are weaknesses, they are minor. A few metaphors might be slightly overextended, and there are moments where the prose becomes a touch too self-conscious in its poeticism. However, these are minimal concerns in what is otherwise an exceptional piece of character-driven fiction. The author has successfully created a compelling encounter between two complex characters from different fictional universes, maintaining their essential natures while creating something new in their interaction. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Prison Strings — Score: 90.7
Prompt:
Prison Strings Jolyne Cujoh & Makima Write a story where Jolyne Cujoh (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure) and Makima (Chainsaw Man) cross paths at a supernatural prison facility. Jolyne is immediately suspicious of Makima's falsely sweet demeanor, while Makima is intrigued by Jolyne's Stand ability. Their battle of wits escalates dangerously as Jolyne realizes how manipulative Makima truly is. **Jolyne Cujoh (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure)** Jolyne is the daughter of Jotaro Kujo and the first female JoJo protagonist. Her Stand, Stone Free, allows her to unravel her body into string that she can control. She's hot-headed, foul-mouthed, and doesn't take disrespect from anyone. She was framed for murder and sent to prison. She has a distinctive butterfly tattoo on her arm and wears her hair in two buns. Despite her tough exterior, she's deeply loyal to her friends and family. She can be impulsive but is highly adaptable in battle. She inherited her father's ability to stay cool under pressure but is more emotionally expressive. Famous quote: "If there's no Mickey, this shit ain't Disney!" **Makima (Chainsaw Man)** Makima appears as a young woman with auburn hair and ringed yellow eyes. She's the Control Devil who can dominate anyone she considers beneath her (nearly everyone). She maintains a pleasant, soft-spoken demeanor that masks her manipulative, cold nature. She can create contracts with humans and devils, often exploiting their desires. She's obsessed with Chainsaw Man and wants to control him. She keeps numerous people and devils as pets on leashes. She's practically immortal due to a contract with the Prime Minister. She views humans as lesser beings but mimics human emotions perfectly. Famous quote: "It's okay. Dogs are supposed to die for their owners." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The yard hums with whispers, steel on steel. Chain-link fences within the yard rattle whenever an inmate passes by, a metal chorus to the warden’s bell. Overhead, the sky is a dull bruise, heavy with weather that never breaks. The prison’s new wing is different from Green Dolphin Street—taller fences, smoother cameras, angles that deny blind spots. Jolyne Cujoh stands with her back against concrete that sweats, rolling her neck until the tendons pop. Even in a place like this, she’s a bright streak of defiance: black hair in twin buns, a butterfly tattoo glinting at her arm, eyes that look like they’ve got teeth. She can feel the strings under her skin twitch. Stone Free hums at her touch, a chorus she can mute or sing with. She wants to sing. She wants to punch. “Jolyne Cujoh.” The voice is soft, almost swallowed by the yard, polite as tea. It slips through the fence hum, touches the back of Jolyne’s skull. She turns, already annoyed, already braced for someone who thinks they can order her like a lunch special. The woman in front of her is dressed like she doesn’t belong anywhere near prison: long coat, auburn hair neatly tied back, ringed yellow eyes that look like they cut. She doesn’t wear a prison uniform. She doesn’t wear fear either. Her smile is unassuming, almost warm, like a neighbor holding a plate of cookies. Jolyne doesn’t buy it for a second. “And you are?” Jolyne says. Her thumbs hook under her waistband, posture casual, stance ready. The fence behind the woman rattles as a group of inmates thread past, gossiping, laughing too loud for a place like this. A guard posts himself like a lamppost and pretends not to listen. “Makima,” the woman says. “I’ve been told very interesting things about you.” “Great. You a fan? If there’s no Mickey, this shit ain’t Disney.” Jolyne tilts her head, smiles without humor. “I don’t give out autographs.” Makima’s eyes flicker to the butterfly at Jolyne’s arm and back to her face. “You’re cautious,” she says, approving as if she’s grading a paper. “That’s good.” Jolyne snorts and pushes off the wall. The yard stretches out—concrete, exercise bars, a track painted so faint it could be imaginary. The new wing has a view of the old, and the two prisons eye each other like rival dogs. Something about this place isn’t Green Dolphin, though. There’s a smell like pennies. There’s a quiet behind the noise. “You’re not staff,” Jolyne says, circling a little, measuring distance. “And you’re not an inmate. So what are you?” Makima meets her eyes. It should feel like staring into a pond. It feels like staring into a well that goes all the way down. “I’m here to help you,” she says. “You’ve been framed. That must be very difficult. You want to go home. You want to protect your father.” Jolyne’s smile cracks, becomes teeth. “You know a lot for someone I’ve never met.” “It’s my job to know.” Makima clasps her hands behind her back. On her finger, a neat ring—innocuous. The guards around the yard have gone quiet in that way people do when they’re waiting for something. A breeze strums the fence like a harp. “I would like to see your ability.” Jolyne laughs, short and sharp. “You wanna see my panties, too? There’s dinner for that.” “Stone Free,” Makima says, saying it like prayer, like it’s already hers. The humming under Jolyne’s skin spikes. Heat crawls up her neck; her fingers flex. She takes a step, half-curious, half-itch to swing. “Awfully confident, lady.” “As confident as a person is when they hold a leash,” Makima says. She smiles again. “Show me. I don’t mind if you try to hurt me.” The yard seems to lean in. Jolyne rolls her shoulders. Fine. If this is a trap, she’ll find the teeth and break them. She reaches up and unravels herself—takes the flesh of her forearm and draws it out into shining cords, blue and bright like wire catching sun. The sensation is familiar and wrong in the way a favorite scar is. Stone Free spills, a spool unspooling, threads weaving patterns in the air. The nearest inmates gasp; one crosses himself. Makima’s eyes dilate. Her breath doesn’t hitch; her posture doesn’t change. But her pupils narrow, and it feels like she’s smelling rain. “Beautiful,” she says. “You’re very adaptable.” “That’s a nice way to say you don’t know what I can do.” Jolyne flicks a line and it whips around a yard pole, snaring it with a metallic twang. “That makes two of us. But here’s the difference. I don’t pretend to be your friend.” “I am your friend,” Makima says, and the words drop, heavy, oiled, sliding into the spaces between Jolyne’s ribs. Jolyne feels a tug under the sternum, like a bad dentist is working on her soul. She swallows. Her threads tremble. Stone Free hates the pull and sings louder. “Stand down,” Makima says. The softness of the voice doesn’t match the command. It’s pretty the way poison can be. Jolyne hears the words, and for a heartbeat, she understands why people kneel. It’s the pull of gravity, the urge to put your head in someone’s lap and not worry anymore. She grits her teeth. Jotaro’s stare flickers through her memory like a blade flashing. You don’t bow. You measure. You punch a hole where the light wants to get out. Her strings twist and loop, wrapping around her torso, around her waist, bracing her like a corset of her own making. She ties her own ribs to her spine, an anchor and a promise. “No,” she says. The word is small and solid. She smiles, and it is feral. “I’m not your dog.” Makima tilts her head a fraction. “It’s okay,” she says, gentle. “Dogs are supposed to die for their owners.” “Good news,” Jolyne says. “I’m not housebroken.” The first thread flicks at Makima’s ankle, a tripline that should have toppled anyone else. Makima steps over it like she saw it yesterday. Two guards on the perimeter lay hands on their batons and then freeze, eyes going wide and blank. Makima doesn’t look at them; they’re not worth looking at. She looks at Jolyne. “You’re resisting,” she says, curious. “Interesting.” Stone Free splits, strings radiating like spider silk, a web spinning itself in three dimensions. Jolyne throws it wide, looping high above them, snagging the crossbars of the floodlights and the camera housings, finding traction where there isn’t any. She doesn’t attack head-on. She pulls lines taut to change the way sound travels, sending her voice bouncing, her footfalls elsewhere. She changes the yard. Makima steps into the web and never snags. She doesn’t not-see it. She sees it and makes it irrelevant. Her gaze follows the patterns, calculating. She doesn’t hurry. Jolyne’s stomach flips, cold and thrilled. She loves fights that feel like dancing with knives. “You’re after someone else,” Jolyne says, a line slipping past Makima’s ear, whispering. “You don’t actually give a damn about my case.” Makima’s smile shows the barest suggestion of teeth. “You’re sharp,” she says. “I thought so.” “You keep pets,” Jolyne says. “I keep friends.” “How sentimental.” Makima’s yellow irises ring in the gray light. “Tell me about your father.” “Tell me about yours,” Jolyne snaps back, and throws three lines like fists. Makima doesn’t dodge. She steps forward and the world shivers; the closest guard opens his mouth and bleeds from his eyes without a sound. The three lines hit something that isn’t there, slacken mid-air, like they were cut with a thought. Jolyne feels the sever like a paper cut at the pad of each finger. She hisses. “Who did you make a deal with?” Jolyne asks, binding her right hand into a hard, knuckled weave. “I’ve met devils. I’ve broken devils.” Makima’s smile doesn’t change. “So have I.” Jolyne lunges, low and mean, fists wrapped in her own unraveled sinew. The yard explodes into motion: inmates scatter and then halt as if someone put pause on their spines. The chain-link fence rattles and then goes perfectly still. Jolyne hits the air like there’s resistance there, like the sky is a body pushing back. She takes a breath, and it tastes like copper. Stone Free grips the ground, threads burrowing into concrete, and Jolyne uses herself as pulley and anchor, slingshotting sideways, punching from an angle that wasn’t possible a heartbeat ago. Makima doesn’t even blink. The punch stops a finger’s width from her cheek, and that’s when Jolyne understands that Makima didn’t block her. Someone else did. Every guard and inmate near them is on their knees, eyes wide, arms straining against an invisible weight as if they’re all holding the air shut with their hands. “Bad dog,” Makima says softly, not to Jolyne but to the world. The weight increases. Jolyne’s web groans, threads singing high and tense. Jolyne adjusts. She splits herself thinner, threads like hair, like breath, sliding through the gaps of whatever pressure Makima’s conjured. She throws a line around her own throat and pulls, keeping her head up, reminding her body which way is up. She lets Stone Free pick locks with sound—she hums, a little off-key, vibration traveling down strings to floodlight to camera to the armory door. “I can help you,” Makima says, close now. When did she move? “Your impulsivity endangers your goals. You’re adaptable, but you’re too attached. You would do better under guidance.” “From you?” Jolyne grins, and it isn’t pleasant. “You don’t even know what to do with me. You want me to heel. I bite.” Makima leans in, and there’s the smell of clean paper and the metallic air of the yard. “Heel,” she says, and pushes with something that isn’t air or weight or sound; it’s attention, and it’s a command. Jolyne thinks of her father’s hat and shadow, of Hermes’ laugh, of F.F.’s smile like a little cracked cup. She thinks of the way the sun felt through glass when she wasn’t looking. She thinks of all the times people told her to be quiet. She wraps a thread around every thought and ties them into her sternum, cinches herself closed. “No,” she says again, sweeter this time. Stone Free flushes through her like adrenaline. The lock on the armory clicks. The light stutters. The yard breathes. Makima’s eyes cut sideways to the sound. It’s the smallest thing. It’s enough. Jolyne uses the fraction of nothing like a lever, rolling under the pressure, grabbing Makima’s coat with three cords, not to yank but to map. She doesn’t need to break her. She needs to learn her edges. “Interesting,” Makima murmurs. “You’re learning.” “Fast,” Jolyne says. “Hope you can keep up.” “There’s no need to run,” Makima says, serene. “There’s nowhere to go I can’t go.” “I’m not running.” Jolyne’s grin is sharp. “I’m making noise.” She yanks three floodlights down simultaneously. They hit concrete, burst into sparks that skitter like fireflies. Alarm bells bray. Inmates jerk like puppet strings cut and then reattached; someone starts laughing hysterically. The chain-link fences rattle back to life, trembling in their poles, singing the song of metal freed from attention. Makima does not look annoyed. She looks… engaged. “You fascinate me,” she says. “Gross,” Jolyne says, and then tosses a line high, catches the lip of the roof, and goes, Stone Free hauling her like she’s a bullet on a string. She doesn’t leave her web behind. She takes it with her, reeling in, reweaving, making herself scarce and everywhere at once. She doesn’t forget the way Makima’s voice tugged the marrow from her bones. She files it away. She hates it. She will never forgive it. Makima watches her angle onto the roof, the breeze tugging at her hair, the alarm painting everything red and loud. Guards shout and aim and then lower their guns, their hands shaking. Makima doesn’t raise hers. She touches her ring, almost idly. “We’ll talk soon,” she says, to no one and everyone. “Bring dinner,” Jolyne’s voice drifts back, echoing through the thread-microphones she’s left. “And a leash for yourself.” Makima smiles, a little real now, something like delight in it. “As you wish.” Up on the roof, Jolyne crouches behind an HVAC unit that thrums like a lazy heart. The yard below is in motion, like a brain waking out of anesthesia. Her own pulse is high and hot. Her strings tremble, wanting, pleased. She sits there, breathing hard, and lets the web she’s woven feed her the yard’s conversations: orders, panic, prayers. Somewhere, a woman with ringed yellow eyes steps lightly through it as if it were silk curtains, not a trap. Jolyne presses the pad of her thumb to the butterfly at her arm, not gently. “I’m not your dog,” she whispers, to the sky, to the fences, to herself. Stone Free hums. The hum sounds like promise. It sounds like fight. It sounds like the rattle of chain-link settling back into silence, waiting for the next time someone walks by.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece effectively captures a tense confrontation between Jolyne Cujoh and Makima, staying true to both characters' established personalities and abilities. The author demonstrates a strong understanding of both source materials, weaving together Jolyne's string-based Stand abilities with Makima's manipulative control powers in a believable prison setting. The prose is particularly strong in its imagery and sensory details. Descriptions like "the sky is a dull bruise, heavy with weather that never breaks" and "eyes that look like they've got teeth" create a vivid atmosphere. The author skillfully uses metaphor and simile throughout, such as comparing Makima's gaze to "staring into a well that goes all the way down." Character voices are distinct and authentic. Jolyne's defiant, foul-mouthed nature comes through clearly ("You wanna see my panties, too? There's dinner for that"), while Makima maintains her falsely sweet demeanor that masks her cold manipulation ("It's okay. Dogs are supposed to die for their owners"). The dialogue exchanges are sharp and reveal character through conflict rather than exposition. The action sequences are dynamic and creative, particularly in how Jolyne uses her Stone Free ability to manipulate the environment. The author doesn't just describe the powers but shows how they interact with the setting and each other. The battle of wits escalates naturally, with Jolyne recognizing Makima's manipulative nature and actively resisting it. The pacing is excellent, with tension building throughout the confrontation. The story maintains focus on the central conflict without meandering, and the ending leaves room for continuation while still providing a satisfying conclusion to this encounter. There are a few instances where the prose becomes slightly purple, with metaphors occasionally stacking too densely. However, these moments are rare and don't detract significantly from the overall quality. The piece demonstrates emotional complexity through Jolyne's internal struggle against Makima's control: "She hears the words, and for a heartbeat, she understands why people kneel." This psychological dimension adds depth to what could have been a purely physical confrontation. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that captures the essence of both characters while creating a compelling, original scenario for their interaction. The writing is confident, stylistically consistent, and emotionally engaging. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Scp: Notes from the Future — Score: 91.2
Prompt:
Write an SCP report about a researcher who begins finding handwritten notes from their future self, warning about a containment breach that hasn't happened yet. The notes become increasingly desperate and incoherent, sometimes containing information that contradicts known reality. Include the Foundation's attempts to determine if this is an actual temporal anomaly or psychological manipulation by a contained entity, and the researcher's struggle to trust their own perception. First person (researcher's perspective with interspersed notes), past tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Item #: SCP-5███ Object Class: Euclid (Pending) Special Containment Procedures: Researcher Dr. H. L. Mora has been placed under observation in a standard psychological monitoring suite at Site-41 with continuous audiovisual recording. All materials utilized by Dr. Mora are to be pre-catalogued, numbered, and stored under lock when not in use. Writing instruments within the suite are supplied by Procurement and Logistics Section-07 (P&L-07), catalogued, and swept daily; their ink chemistry is recorded and archived. Any handwritten notes not matching known inventories and not recorded by cameras during normal use are to be placed in a sealed evidence folder with nitrile gloves, scanned, sent to Ink Forensics (IF-3), and then stored in Secure Evidence Locker 7C. No contained entity is to be allowed physical or audiovisual contact with Dr. Mora without O5/RAISA approval. Temporal Anomalies Department (TAD) has designated the area around Dr. Mora’s suite as a low-probability chronospatial irregularity zone; standard Type-3 temporal anchors have been installed in the corridor outside. Anchor calibration logs are taken twice daily. Memetics Division has initiated Class-III suggestibility testing on audiovisual feeds with no positive hits to date. Description: SCP-5███ refers to a series of handwritten notes that began appearing in proximity to Researcher Dr. Mora beginning ██/██/20██. The notes claim to be written by Dr. Mora at a future date and warn of an impending containment breach involving a currently non-critical entity contained at Site-41 (Entity Designation redacted; see Addendum 5███-E). The notes escalate in urgency and exhibit increasing degrees of informational inconsistency. Ink analysis: IF-3 has found trace elements in the ink inconsistent with any office pens currently in circulation at Site-41 or broader Foundation supply lines. Specifically, the ink contains a detectable signature of organometallic ruthenium complexes and a chlorine isotope distribution that suggests synthesis under non-standard atmospheric conditions (IF-3 Report, Ref. IF-3/41/5███). P&L-07 denies procurement of any such ink. Internal audit yielded no matches to consumer inks. The following is the personal report of Dr. Mora (Researcher-involved testimony authorized by RAISA and Ethics Committee due to ongoing evaluation of potential cognitohazard and/or psychogenic factors). Redactions pertain to active operations. Begin Transcript: Personal Report of Dr. H. L. Mora I signed the form attesting that I would report any anomaly affecting my cognition or senses. I am doing that now. The first note was simple. I found it beneath my keyboard on ██/██/20██ at 08:12 during shift start. The paper was from a Site-41 memo pad, but slightly smoother, as if it had been pressed between glass and allowed to rest too long. The words were in my handwriting but neater, the neatness I aim for when entering data that lives forever in other people’s eyes. “Don’t go into Hallway C at 11:43. Tell Jian to check the vent seals. Bring coffee.” I laughed. Jian (Dr. Li) always complained about the coffee, and vent seals are eternally suspect. I carried the note to Security. We checked the feeds. No one entered my office. The camera scan had one of those empty seconds that we got after the last firmware update. I told myself a tech had mis-synced the timestamp and someone played a prank. At 11:41, I stood up. I was thinking, if this is me, I should follow my own advice. I texted Jian about the vent seals. I held a coffee. At 11:43, a pallet jack loaded with Class-C disinfectant containers rolled briskly down Hallway C. The driver nudged the brake too late and the right front wheel slipped into a crack where a tile had bowed. The pallet lurched; the top container crushed against the doorframe and vented a mist. We had been planning to replace that tile. Two seconds of bleach came like rain. No harm, except to pride and polymer flooring. I watched on the feed next day. If I had been there, the mist would have kissed my face. It would have stung. I wanted to feel grateful. I filed the report anyway with Site Director Yates. Ink forensics took the note. The lab came back with talk of ruthenium. I pretended to understand, and then I pretended not to be impressed. The second note appeared while I was showering in the gym locker room, folded into the cuff of my clean shirt. Three words: “Check containment seals.” The ‘s’ in seals hooked exactly like mine when I’m late. I walked to the lab. Containment (SCP-3114-Sub) hummed in its cube like a frozen lung. Jian called me to look at a pressure readout: a fractional drop across the tertiary gasket. It wasn’t a breach; it didn’t even qualify as an incident, but we filed the maintenance ticket. I drank my coffee and waited for the third note. Security installed additional cameras in my office, in my locker, in the hallway. My coworkers joked about paparazzi. Nothing showed. Then came the third note: “Park on the east lot. Avoid the visitor entrance. There’ll be a man in a red cap. Don’t stop.” There is no visitor entrance at Site-41. We haven’t had external visitors since 20██. But the east lot exists. I parked there and saw no red cap, only the usual low gray of morning and the chain-link fence doing its quiet metal duty. The note sat heavy in my pocket all day like a dare. I imagined the man anyway, standing at a gate that never opens, the cap the kind you buy when you don’t want to think about hats. Security told me to stop complying with the notes. This is how the Foundation keeps us from letting our own pattern-hunger pull us apart. I nodded. Then I read note four in the stairwell between B and C, taped under the handrail where my left hand touched it by accident. “I’m sorry. I thought it would help. It does, but not enough. Please, if you remember, left pocket Wednesday. You’ll understand.” In the pocket was a clip-on pen I didn’t own. The barrel read a brand that doesn’t exist. When IF-3 analyzed it, they found the same ruthenium, the same impossible chlorine. The pen didn’t write. By the sixth note, contradictions began. “Don’t trust Jian” sat on my desk, printed with that neatness my hand only finds when I pretend to be someone else. Later that day, Jian brought me an almond pastry, the sticky kind that leaves a sheen on your fingers and forces you to lick sugar from your polestar lines. Jian has saved my life twice on paper, and once physically, dragging me out from under a shelf when the 9.3 micro tremor knocked Storage G to ruin. The note went into an envelope. I told Security. They told me to accept that an entity could access me. I asked which entity. We had three candidates: SCP-3114-Sub (capable of limited memetic suggestion but blocked by the containment’s opaque mesh), SCP-2120 (a retrocausal echo contained in a Faraday shell two floors down), and SCP-████ (redacted). We also had my own fear, which is not catalogued but leaks through everything. I began recording myself sleeping. I woke to my own voice reading my own notes into a phone I had turned off. When I checked, the phone had no recording and the time on its lockscreen was 03:09, even though it was 06:20. The clocks in my office were three minutes fast for the rest of the morning. The anchor outside my door hiccuped once, a micro-fluctuation TAD called “within tolerance” and that I called “hope.” I met with the Site Psych. She asked me if anyone in my family had a history of writing to themselves. I told her about my father, who wrote shopping lists on the inside of paper bags and then forgot the bag in the car. She asked if I feared the breach more because I imagined I could prevent it. I said yes. Then she asked if I wanted to be the kind of person who listened to herself. I said I did, but not like this. Note eight was smudged. “Don’t look at the camera at 02:16.” It felt childish, the way kids dare each other not to blink. At 02:16, I stared at the ceiling. In the morning, we reviewed the footage. The tape had a pulse, a single black frame, then me looking down, not up, then back to up. TAD said the anchor had logged a nanosecond slip in local phase alignment. I wanted to shout that a nanosecond is a life in certain systems, that the universe is a great unkindness that pretends continuity is the same as mercy. Note nine contradicted physics. It told me my mother was alive. She died in 20██. The note said, “She’ll call at 7:44. Answer. Ask about the rain.” I sat with my phone on the desk and my hands not touching it. At 7:44, the phone rang. Unknown number, area code from the county where my mother never lived. I let it go to voicemail. The message was static punctuated by the sound of wet streets after cars pass, the distinct hiss that is not quite white noise. I listened to it twice. I cried in the stairwell and pretended to have something in my eye when Jian asked. The tenth note told me about the breach. It named the object and the time and the condition: “3114-Sub will slip when the tertiary gasket is replaced. 15:09. The new sealant interacts with the mesh at a molecular level; it’s not inert. It’s hungry. You’ll see the shimmer. You’ll hear the pressure equalize like breath. Tell them to delay by two days. Move the pallet schedule.” I took the note to Yates. We halted maintenance. Procurement checked the sealant. Nothing anomalous. The brand had a new anti-corrosion additive released six months prior; its MSDS said nothing about hunger. We rescheduled anyway. The anchor hummed. The day passed without shimmer. We logged a near miss. Memetics Division brought me in to sit in a dark room and stare at shapes. They showed me ladders and faces and a field of sheep disguised as static. I saw all of them, which is to say I am average, which is to say I am not safe from ambiguity. They asked me what I believed. I said: It feels like me. It looks like me. It writes like me, except when it doesn’t. The contradictions could be noise, or they could be a lure. A lure has hooks even if you throw it back. Note twelve apologized again. The handwriting shook as if the writer had been cold or under sedation. “I thought I could thread it, but threads knot. Please stop reading here. Burn the rest. Trust Jian. Don’t trust me. The breach is not in 3114. It’s in the paper.” I carried that one in my pocket and then did not burn the rest. We conducted an experiment. Security emptied my office, my locker, my desk. I was assigned a blank room with a metal table and a bed and a toilet in a corner with a curtain that felt like a suggestion of privacy. P&L-07 issued me a single pen. It was sealed in a bag with a grin of blue ink barely visible. IF-3 catalogued it like a saint’s fingerbone. I wrote my name. I imagined how, if I were future me, I would get a note into this room. I thought about ventilation shafts, about crawlspace access, about the way the cameras blink when the power tests cycle on Thursdays at noon. At 12:03, the room smelled like ozone. At 12:04, a note lay under my left elbow. I had not felt it placed. The cameras did not see it placed. The anchor log recorded nothing. The note said: “Don’t let them make this a case study. Don’t let yourself be data. I’m sorry. I need you to be a person for this to work.” We tore into the paper with swabs and arrays and gas chromatographs. The ink sang the same song: ruthenium and wrong chlorine. IF-3 said the polymer in the paper held microbubbles that did not release like normal. As if time itself had been a solvent and the page had been rinsed in it. Note fourteen was terror. It used my words but as if someone had scraped them from my mouth. It warned of blood on the ceiling, of alarms that did not sound, of a hole in the wall where there had only been wall. It told me I would wake with my left arm numb and hear the sound of my own voice from behind the closet door. My left arm went numb at 03:17 because I sleep with my neck at bad angles. There was no closet in the room. I began to distrust myself. I began to watch my hand when it wrote, certain that in the flourishes of the letters I would find a traitor. On ██/██/20██, SCP-3114-Sub’s tertiary gasket was replaced with Director approval after alternate sealant testing. Nothing breached. The pressure equalized like breath because that’s how pressure equalizes. We stood and watched and ate Jian’s pastry. For a moment, I believed I was free of the linear joke. The last note began to appear and then stopped. I watched as if someone was writing in invisible ink that would not reveal itself. It’s this: a faint impression, a pale indentation on the page, the ghost of handwriting without ink. “I learned the wrong lesson,” it almost says. Or I write that now, because I must put words on ghosts. The lab rotated the page under raking light. The indentations did not match my hand. The loops were wrong. The rhythm wrong. IF-3 says the pressure fits a hand that trembles as if from cold or fear. I deny the cold but not the fear. TAD says this could be a bleed from a nearby timeline. Memetics says this could be a trick from SCP-████. Ethics says I should sleep. I don’t know if I am being helped. I don’t know if I am being harvested. I don’t know if the future me is me or the shape of me made by something that finds my outline convenient. I still check my pockets every Wednesday. I still look at the cameras at 02:16. I still buy coffee for Jian and ask idle questions about vent seals. I write this report because I promised to report anomalies, and I promised to be a person only if I could write it down. If you find a note from me, from me or not-me, I am sorry. Burn it, if you can. Or keep it, if you must. But remember that we live in a place that treats information as a vector. It gets into you. It changes your shape. It makes you, sometimes, the tool someone will reach for in a future they think they can fix with ink. End Transcript. Addendum 5███-E: Cross-Containment Review - SCP-3114-Sub demonstrated no ability to project handwritten material or influence physical media outside its enclosure. No anomalies during gasket replacement beyond standard pressure signatures. Sealant additive tested inert in controlled conditions. - SCP-2120 under Faraday shell: no signal anomalies beyond background. No correspondence between TAD anchor hiccup and known SCP-2120 pulses. - SCP-████ exhibits low-level text generation via reflective surfaces within six meters. Dr. Mora’s suite is thirty-one meters from nearest SCP-████ housing. No reflective surfaces in Dr. Mora’s suite beyond mirror behind opaque curtain. Review ongoing. - Ink Forensics confirms trace organometallic composition inconsistent with P&L-07 supply. Origin unknown. Ethics Committee Recommendation: Maintain Euclid classification pending determination of vector. Continue psychological support. Permit Dr. Mora to participate in controlled decision-making regarding notes, with oversight. Avoid making Dr. Mora “a case study” beyond necessary data collection to minimize potential reinforcement of suspected memetic loops. Director Yates: We are not yet certain whether we are observing a temporal anomaly, an attempt at manipulation by an entity, or the slow grinding of a mind in a machine that names its gears. We will act as though all three are true. We will watch the ink. We will watch the man in the red cap, even if he never comes. We will keep the anchors humming. And we will bring coffee.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This SCP report is a sophisticated piece that effectively captures the clinical tone of the SCP Foundation format while weaving in a compelling first-person narrative. The piece successfully creates an atmosphere of paranoia, uncertainty, and dread through the researcher's increasingly desperate situation. The format is meticulously crafted, beginning with the standard SCP containment procedures and description before transitioning to the personal report. This structure grounds the piece in the established SCP universe while allowing for the more intimate first-person perspective requested in the prompt. The narrative builds tension effectively through the escalating nature of the notes, from simple warnings about mundane dangers to increasingly contradictory and impossible information. The writer skillfully portrays Dr. Mora's psychological deterioration as they struggle with trusting their own perception versus the evidence of the notes. The prose is particularly strong in its clinical sections, capturing the bureaucratic, scientific tone of the Foundation. Lines like "We also had my own fear, which is not catalogued but leaks through everything" demonstrate how the writer balances clinical detachment with human vulnerability. The piece excels at creating ambiguity about the true nature of the anomaly. Is it a temporal anomaly, psychological manipulation, or something else entirely? This uncertainty is maintained throughout, fulfilling a key requirement of the prompt. Character development is subtle but effective. Dr. Mora's relationship with Jian adds emotional depth, and the researcher's gradual descent into doubt and fear is convincingly portrayed. The character's voice remains consistent throughout, balancing scientific objectivity with increasing emotional strain. The imagery is precise and evocative, particularly in descriptions like "the distinct hiss that is not quite white noise" and "the ghost of handwriting without ink." These details create a vivid sensory experience while maintaining the clinical tone. The ending avoids easy resolution, instead leaving the reader with the same uncertainty that plagues the protagonist. Director Yates's final comments perfectly encapsulate the Foundation's approach to anomalies: methodical, cautious, and prepared for multiple possibilities. Some minor weaknesses include occasional overreliance on SCP jargon that might confuse readers unfamiliar with the format, and a few instances where the clinical tone becomes slightly too dense. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise excellent execution of the prompt. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Scp: Unmarked Doors Archive — Score: 87.2
Prompt:
Write an SCP entry about a series of identical unmarked doors appearing in abandoned buildings worldwide that lead to a massive, architecturally impossible archive. Documents within reference a previous global civilization destroyed by an unspecified containment failure. Foundation researchers discover references to their own organization under a different name, including personnel files for current staff dated centuries ago. Include exploration logs revealing sections of the archive actively being removed by entities resembling hazmat teams who flee when approached, and evidence that O5 Council members have visited the archive without authorization. Third person (exploration team perspective) with recovered document excerpts. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Item #: SCP-7713 Object Class: Keter Special Containment Procedures: SCP-7713 instances are to be identified, cordoned, and monitored in situ. Mobile containment teams assigned to Task Force Epsilon-31 (“Stacks Runners”) are to deploy to newly reported instances within 48 hours to establish perimeter security, install three concentric barriers with motion sensors, and conduct preliminary assessment. No entry is permitted without authorization at Level 4/7713 or higher. All entries must be recorded via head-mounted camera and audio systems. At least two Epsilon-31 members must remain outside each door to verify continued physical presence and maintain tether integrity. All recovered materials from SCP-7713 are to be transferred to Document Repository Theta-Black under quarantine review. Any personnel encountering references to themselves or their work are required to file an immediate disclosure with Records and Information Security Administration (RAISA) and attend mandatory memetic and ontological screening. Any sighting of unmarked hazmat-clad entities within SCP-7713 is to be documented. Direct pursuit is prohibited unless expressly ordered by the Site Director. Lethal force is authorized if attempts to remove or damage archival components are observed, pending Ethics Committee review. Description: SCP-7713 is a phenomenon consisting of a series of identical, unmarked wooden doors which manifest in abandoned structures worldwide. As of this writing, 47 confirmed instances are under Foundation control, with an estimated 80–120 active globally. Doors are standardized: matte black-painted hardwood, brass knob, non-functioning lock set, and a rectangular frosted pane where a label would typically be affixed. Some doors show surface patina, splitting, and warping inconsistent with the surrounding structure, indicating greater apparent age than the buildings in which they appear. Opening SCP-7713 leads to a non-Euclidean interior environment, hereafter SCP-7713-A. SCP-7713-A presents as a massive archival complex composed of interconnected halls, stacks, and vaults. The structure defies known architectural constraints: galleries intersect at obtuse angles without loss of alignment, staircases descend in loops with no vertical change in gravitational vector, and aisles elongate when traversed in a consistent direction. Internal timekeeping devices desynchronize at rates proportional to exploration depth (see Exploration Log 7713-γ). All doors open to the same interior, but exterior environments are not mutually visible. Doors can be opened and closed independently; closing one does not affect the others. Documents within SCP-7713-A include cataloged records, personnel files, research notes, containment schematics, and directives referencing a global civilization and centralized parapolitical apparatus, destroyed by an unspecified “containment failure cascade” referred to in multiple languages and iconographies as the Event, the Collapse, or “the Second Noon.” Recovered documents refer to a containment organization analogous to the Foundation, typically titled Archival Authority, Custodial Compact, or the Conservatory, with seals and letterheads matching none in Foundation registries. Several sectors of SCP-7713-A contain personnel files for current Foundation staff, with dates and biographical data predating their births by centuries. Many entries contain annotations with redactions that match current RAISA standards and typographical conventions. SCP-7713-A is active. Sections of shelving and indexed “ranges” have been observed in mid-removal by entities resembling hazmat response teams (SCP-7713-B), characterized by matte grey protective suits, mirrored visors, and self-contained rebreathers. SCP-7713-B carry box-cutters, adhesive seals, pallet jacks, and unmarked polymer crates. They avoid contact, move silently, and retreat rapidly when approached. They have demonstrated knowledge of architecture within SCP-7713-A unknown to Foundation teams, often slipping behind panels, endcaps, or service corridors not previously observed, and occasionally closing interior doors that do not correspond to any mapped vectors. Direct pursuit is confounded by spatial shifts. Multiple exploration records indicate the presence of Council-level authorizations and physical signatures within SCP-7713-A. Authentication seals linked to O5-identifiers appear on access slips, check-out cards, and log placards, but have not been issued by RAISA. Two separate teams recorded pressure fluctuations and low-spectrum audio consistent with human footsteps moments before discovering sign-in ledgers bearing O5 ciphers. No Council approvals exist authorizing these entries. Addendum 7713-01: Initial Discovery SCP-7713 was first identified in an abandoned census bureau annex in Lisbon, Portugal, after urban explorers uploaded footage of a door opening onto an apparently infinite library. Foundation takedown measures suppressed the content; Site-223 established temporary containment. Subsequent webcrawler alerts flagged similar appearances in Detroit (USA), Vorkuta (RU), Kalimpong (IN), Sfax (TN), and Jaffna (LK). Cross-comparison of the door’s paint composition and hardware revealed identical tool marks and milling defects across instances. Exploration Log 7713-α Team: Epsilon-31/Bravo (Lead: Lt. H. Corazón), four personnel, tethered entry Entry Point: SCP-7713-07 (Detroit) Purpose: Establish baseline map, retrieve samples [Begin Log] 00:00: Doors swing inward to a cool, stale-air hall. Light levels steady at 300 lux without apparent source. Shelving of oiled hardwood and powder-coated steel stretches away, labeled in etched plates with trigrams and numerals. Ambient hum at 40 Hz recorded intermittently. 02:33: Team notes “hand smell” of metal oxidation. Floor is poured terrazzo with mother-of-pearl aggregate. Corazón: “It’s beautiful.” Cpl. Singh marks path with wax chalk. Chalk later observed to bead and retract along lines, resisting adherence beyond 30 meters. 07:18: Discovery of a reading carrel. On its blotter: “Catalog of Failures, v. 89.” Paper is cellulose-silk composite, pH neutral. Entry excerpt follows: Recovered Document 7713-A1 Title: Catalog of Failures, v.89 Entry: “We called it the Second Noon. We had more names than suns to name it by, and fewer hours than knives to cut away the sun’s disease. The Archive outlived the field sites, as intended; the Archive failed as designed, as intended. That is the lesson written under our fingernails and in our teeth.” Margin note in sepia ink: “Send copies to Conservatory West. Seal if pattern matches 12C—‘Custodianship by Fire.’” 10:05: Audible clacking, metal-on-stone. Camera pans to far aisle: two SCP-7713-B entities sliding a crate onto a pallet jack. PFC Duarte calls out. SCP-7713-B stiffens, turns; mirrored visors reflect team lights. One raises a palm, shakes head, reaches to tug a braided cord near shoulder. A steel access plate on the endcap opens noiselessly; both entities retreat into dark space beyond. Plate closes; seam invisible upon inspection. 14:22: Team finds checkout desk inset into wall. Ledgers bound in white vellum. Signatures varying across scripts. One stamp: a circle with thirteen short lines radiating from the perimeter inward, the inner space blank. RAISA cross-ref later: cipher resembles O5 signature wheel minus center glyphs. Date column reads “Year: 402/After.” No calendar key found. 18:04: Retrieval of three folders labeled “Compact Personnel: Active (Fragment).” One folder labeled “Corazón, Hester M.—Appointed 361/After.” Photograph attached is of Lt. Corazón, aged approximately 20 years older, with scar she does not possess. Corazón denies ever posing. Paper exhibits ink layering consistent with repeated revisions. [End Log] Note: Psychological support initiated for team. RAISA set “mirror-contact” protocol. Exploration Log 7713-γ Team: Epsilon-31/Delta (Lead: Dr. A. Vescovi, civilian specialist), three personnel, tethered inertial trackers Entry Point: SCP-7713-02 (Lisbon) Purpose: Test temporal drift; seek central index [Begin Log] 00:00: Team uses synchronized atomic watches. Baseline chirps established every 60 s. Equipment reports stable. Ambient sound includes soft rumble like distant carts. 04:41: Stacks with carved lintels bearing tripartite motto in Old Occitan: “Hold, Bind, Remember.” Carvings show smoke damage inconsistent with surrounding surfaces. 09:02: Wall map presents as etched copperplate in relief. Corridors represented as fanfolds of geometry, annotated in a script similar to Sanskrit with bracketed Latin transliterations. An icon repeated near certain vaults: a hand closing over a sunburst. 11:50: Chirps out of sync by 2 s compared to reference line left outside. Drift accelerates after a hairpin stair whose risers are painted with classification colors. Team halts. 13:10: Encounter with SCP-7713-B, three entities removing a drawer set labeled “Containment Directives, Credenda 2–9.” When addressed, they drop a card. Cameras capture printing: Recovered Document 7713-B4 Card face: “Removal Order 33/After: Burned Ranges” Reverse, handwritten: “We are late and becoming later. If you are fellow Custodians, you know what lateness is.” 15:05: Distant doors slam in sequence. Wind blows from two directions simultaneously, carrying the smell of damp leather and ozone. Vescovi reports sensation of being observed from the floor below as numbers “float.” Footage later shows catalog tags lifting slightly on their strings as if buoyant. 17:37: Team finds a locked iron grille. Tag in Latinized script: “Praesidia-Exempta.” Vescovi notes the word used rarely in classical texts to denote entities beyond garrison law. A brass tablet nearby, engraved: Recovered Document 7713-C7 Text: “By touch of Thirteen, range may open.” Below this engraving: faint pressure marks resembling fingerprints. The spacing and ridge depth match human adults. RAISA analysis: pressure pattern consistent with O5-██’s right index finger ridge count and spacing, per high-security biometric data. O5-██ denies entry; Oversight response pending. 20:10: Team retreats due to tether tension and time drift reaching 17 s per hour. As they approach exit, a reading cart rolls across an adjacent aisle, pushed by no visible agent, bearing sealed crates stamped with circle-and-rays cipher. The cart turns, “gives way” to them, and continues. [End Log] Addendum 7713-02: Personnel File Anomalies Recovered files include: Recovered Document 7713-D12 Cover: “Custodial Compact Personnel: Operational, Year 297/After” Entry: “Surname: Reyes. Given: Marta. Position: Field Auditor, Provisional. Notes: Demoted from Council Proctor candidacy after misapplication of fire doctrine. Assigned to water losses.” Handwritten marginalia in different ink: “Promoted by exception. See 361/After. Survives the first Noon; fails the Second Noon; teaches after.” Cross-reference: Dr. Marta Reyes (current Foundation, RAISA) confirmed existence, no Council candidacy on record. Reyes denies knowledge of archival doctrine. File includes “after-action” reports that correlate with sites currently projected for E-class collapse events that have not occurred. Recovered Document 7713-D32 Entry: “Owl Council Minutes, 352/After (Redacted).” Annotations refer to “vote of nine to walk the stacks.” Names are replaced by sigils. Margin contains apocryphal note: “Never again all together.” Ink dating places this document centuries prior to Foundation establishment. The typographic and formatting parallels to RAISA standards suggest either historical inheritance from or ontological convergence with SCP-7713-A’s originating culture. RAISA has placed a moratorium on integrating typographic cues from Foundation documents into SCP-7713-A to minimize feedback. Exploration Log 7713-λ Team: Epsilon-31/Charlie (Lead: Cpt. J. Adegoke), five personnel Entry Point: SCP-7713-11 (Kalimpong) Purpose: Track SCP-7713-B and observe removal methodology [Begin Log] 01:12: Charlie places RFID tags on endcaps. Thermal imaging detects cold fronts preceding SCP-7713-B by ~0.5 C. 04:25: SCP-7713-B group of four in a mezzanine walkway lifting entire shelf sections by actuating hidden latch. The shelving rises as a flat plane, revealing a passage containing roller belts leading into darkness. One entity notices team, taps shoulder cord twice. A mechanical hum increases. The shelves slide, closing passage. 05:00: Adegoke orders a controlled approach. SCP-7713-B deploy smoke-like aerosol from wrist canisters; taste reported sweet-metallic. No choking. Visibility drops. Within aerosol, brief silhouettes of additional corridors visible, then gone. 06:47: Entities abandon two crates during retreat. Crates are bonded polymer; adhesive reacts to air and re-fuses when cut lines are not completed within 30 s. One crate successfully opened yields index cards: Recovered Document 7713-E3 Stack Index: “Loss Register—Water” Entries sampled: — “A city drowned without sea.” — “A species that forgot the word for ‘Noon’ and so never stopped the sun.” — “A house that held every door.” Bottom of stack stamped: “Removed for fire doctrinal compliance.” 08:14: Team finds a wall plaque with twelve voided circles and one filled. Underneath, etched in three scripts: “We stand thirteen: one to forget, twelve to remember.” The filled circle has been defaced. Gouge marks match steel blade width used by Foundation issue utility knives. No team member admits to damage. 10:02: Audible conversation ahead: filtered voices. Words in modified Portuguese: “Late, late—we are later than them.” Team rounds corner; SCP-7713-B have vanished. On the floor, an access chit: Recovered Document 7713-E9 Text: “Praesidia-Exempta—Open for 10. Authorization: Thirteen. Seal: [circle with thirteen rays inward].” Stamped in red: “DISALLOWED: Council not in quorum.” The stamp ink chemically matches Site-01 stock. 12:00: Withdrawal under order. As Charlie exits, helmet cam records a shadow moving behind the frosted pane of the door’s label slot from the Archive side. When door closes, shadow is gone. [End Log] Incident Report 7713-Φ: Unauthorized Council Visitation On ██/██/████, motion sensors at SCP-7713-02 recorded activation at 03:11 UTC. Security footage outside the perimeter was tampered with, producing a 17-minute gap. Inside SCP-7713-A, Epsilon-31/Alpha, scheduled maintenance, encountered an open ledger with fresh ink: Recovered Document 7713-F1 Ledger Note: “Exempt Range opened under emergency—signature of Thirteen.” Three fingerprints in drying ink correspond to O5-█, O5-██, and O5-███’s right index fingers within 92% probability. All three deny presence. Site-01 reports all Council members accounted for off-site at that time, with alibis cross-verified by security beacons. Beacon logs show minor desynchronization consistent with 7713-A drift. Addendum 7713-03: Architectural Notes — Doors exhibit microfissures filled with mineral deposits consistent with age greater than 200 years. Where doors appear within newer buildings, the threshold’s substrate displays settlement rings that predate the floor pour. In one case (SCP-7713-29, Jaffna), the door frame contained a fossilized moth behind paint layers older than the building’s construction. — Interior gravity is coherent but vectors are non-orthogonal in several staircases. Team members report “hands” on their shoulders when standing at landings; accelerometers register subtle lateral pulses timed with the ambient 40 Hz hum. — Labels evolve. On repeat visits, font weight and line length adjust to match RAISA styling introduced after initial cataloging, suggesting SCP-7713-A responds to external standards or that standards co-evolve. Research Notes: The presence of personnel files dated centuries “After” suggests SCP-7713-A documents a lineage in which the Foundation or its predecessor survived past a civilizational collapse and maintained continuity through archival doctrine. The repeated references to “fire doctrine” suggest deliberate destruction as a containment modality. The hazmat entities’ goal appears to be the systematic removal of records associated with specific failure modes, possibly to prevent recurrence through memetic censure or to comply with rules that differ from ours. The most concerning elements are: 1) Authentication marks and biometric signatures corresponding to O5 identifiers applied within SCP-7713-A without authorization. 2) The active removal of ranges correlated with water-based failures and “Exempt Praesidia,” a term that implies units or entities that operate outside standard garrison law—analogous to the Foundation’s O5 Council. 3) Architectural affordances that permit access through gestures or marks of “Thirteen.” Pending actions: — Freeze all Council-level ciphers. Transition to one-time pads for physical seals. — Increase Epsilon-31 presence with redundant tethers and counter-tamper beacons. — Develop “shadow pursuit” algorithm based on thermal dips and aerosol particle flows to map SCP-7713-B egress routes. — Ethics Committee to review authorization of force against SCP-7713-B if removal accelerates. O5 Notice: The Archive remembers, or it refuses to. If we are walking in someone else’s footprints, it is not clear whether they are ahead of us or behind us. Until this is resolved, no Councilor will approach any 7713 entry point. Do not follow the hazmat teams into the walls. Do not sign the ledgers. Do not put your hands where Thirteen belongs.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This SCP entry demonstrates exceptional command of the SCP Foundation format while delivering a complex, layered narrative about an impossible archive that challenges our understanding of time, reality, and the Foundation itself. The piece successfully creates an atmosphere of dread and cosmic horror through its meticulous attention to detail and scientific documentation style. The response excels at world-building through the clinical tone expected of SCP entries while gradually revealing the unsettling implications of the anomaly. The concept of doors leading to an architecturally impossible archive containing records of a previous civilization (possibly our own) destroyed by a containment failure is executed with remarkable coherence and creativity. The exploration logs effectively build tension through the teams' discoveries, particularly the references to current Foundation personnel in centuries-old documents and the mysterious hazmat teams removing sections of the archive. The writer skillfully employs the SCP format's documentary style to create a sense of verisimilitude while hinting at cosmic horror beyond comprehension. The prose is technically precise without becoming dry, maintaining the clinical tone while incorporating evocative descriptions: "galleries intersect at obtuse angles without loss of alignment, staircases descend in loops with no vertical change in gravitational vector." The recovered document excerpts are particularly effective, with phrases like "We had more names than suns to name it by, and fewer hours than knives to cut away the sun's disease" creating a haunting poetic quality that contrasts with the clinical documentation. The narrative structure builds tension effectively through the exploration logs, each revealing more disturbing implications than the last. The revelation that O5 Council members may be secretly accessing the archive adds a compelling layer of conspiracy and uncertainty about the Foundation itself. Where the piece could be improved is in its density. The sheer amount of information, while impressive, occasionally becomes overwhelming, with some sections feeling like information dumps rather than organic discoveries. Some of the technical jargon, while appropriate to the format, occasionally obscures rather than enhances the narrative tension. The ending effectively leaves readers with unsettling questions about the nature of the Foundation and reality itself, consistent with the cosmic horror elements of the SCP universe. The final O5 Notice serves as an excellent capstone, reinforcing the uncertainty and danger while leaving the ultimate nature of the anomaly tantalizingly unresolved. Overall, this is an exemplary SCP entry that demonstrates mastery of the format while delivering a complex, layered narrative with profound implications for the SCP universe. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 16 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 5 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 16.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 5.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Classic sci-fi: Offworlder (Le Guin) — Score: 90.0
Prompt:
Classic sci-fi: Offworlder (Author style: Le Guin) Write a chapter following a young diplomatic envoy sent to address tensions on a distant human colony where humanity has diverged into distinct subspecies through both natural adaptation and separation of lineages. Against protocol, the envoy slips away from official functions to walk the streets alone, encountering markets, ordinary citizens, and social structures that contradict the official briefings. Upon returning to their quarters, the envoy is reprimanded by Command, and is tasked with approaching the stationed Minister of Science (a political posting rather than scientific). A challenging conversation ensues, in which the envoy's wits and will are tested, by a seasoned political operator looking to test the mettle of the offworlder. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
They had warned me to keep to the upper walkways. Between the Consortium quarter and the Governor’s compound ran a spine of glassed corridors and mag-steps; if I kept my face turned politely to the neutral viewscreens—cloud scrolling, the black ribs of the space elevator—I could go from saluting the flags in one hall to standing, an hour later, in a room of chlorophylled walls where someone would tell me my duties and my bounds. Instead I found the service door by the kitchen, lifted my hood, and went down. It was only three flights—girders smelling of hot metal and old oil, a draught that came up from the vents like a breath—and then the skin of the place changed. The floors were not translucent; they were stone, or what passed for stone here, laid with a slant against the rains. The ceiling near my head was tangled with pipes, and along the walls ran a continuous ribbon of light where the algae were cultured, faintly lit green. The air was warmer, and I shed the cloak from my shoulders until it hung light at the elbows, like a weight of old promises. My briefings had been thorough. Ard’rin-three, fifth settled in the Outer Tide, originally a Penal-Survey-Resource hybrid turned self-governing under the Successor Compact after the Great Unspooling. Three centuries of relative isolation; a split early on between the littoral communities and the uplanders when the coastal storms increased and the upland domes were built. Adaptive and elective speciation both: littoral people, with their salt-glands and webbing, had grown past any easy return; uplanders, with their bone density and brown fat, preferred the thin air and did not come down except to trade. The bedrock of tension lay under all policy: who had the right to land, to water, to the quarries, to the orbital tether, to the story of who they had become. There were words for all of it in the files. They were the wrong words. The lower market unfolded in a courtyard where the rain’s edge flicked and then retreated into a high blue sky. It seemed at first all shades of rust and pale metal; then, as my eyes adjusted, there were a hundred small colors—scarlet fruits like squeezable stars, fish in glistening racks, cloth dyed in hues of the algae light. A vendor near me had a table of bone tools, the edges honed to a paleness that was almost luminous. She looked up at me with a frank curiosity, and the lines in her face made continent a life of wind. “Offworld,” she said, as if tasting it. I nodded. “Envoy,” I added, because they had warned me to be clear. The cloak had seemed to me, at departure, an austere modest garment, grey and long and suited to to corridors that fretted respect. Here it drew eyes that examined and then slid away. The people of Ard’rin wore less, and what they wore was fitted to their work. A woman with thickened wrists bore a load of ceramic water-jars on a strap that made a pale stripe across her chest; her skin where the jar rubbed was callused into a dark sheen. Three children with braided hair that fell like quill-fans along their scalps ran under my arm and dissolved into a tangle of legs in front of a cart of roasted tubers. A man with shoulders like the slope of a dome’s buttress walked barefoot past me and left a line of dry damp on the stone. I saw webbing, yes, on one pair of hands; I saw, too, a man whose forearms were covered in soft, short hair, and a climber’s cord of muscle in his calves. “Done up so you don’t have to feel the weather?” the bone-seller asked. She had lost two fingers at some time; the stubs worked as ably as any hand I have seen. “Done up so they don’t have to see me,” I said, and surprised myself. She gave that a considering nod, and in a movement that did not take her eyes off me, she reached under her table and brought out a little blade. It was not for sale; it was old, the kind of thing one keeps for a memory or a promise. She slid it across the table until the tip passed the plane of my hands and then left it there. It was politeness. It said, here, we put the sharpness down between us. “Eat,” someone called on my other side, and two tubers were thrust toward me, one pale and one deep purple. The three children watched me as if expecting a trick. I bit. It was sweet and salt, smoky with sea-wood; the steam escaped and caught in the folds of my cloak and made me a moving cloud. “You walk alone,” said the vendor. There was no accusation, but the sentence balanced like a pan on a scale. “All the corridors look the same,” I said, and there was a low laugh near me. “Up there,” she said, moving her chin toward the invisible, “they think you are a number. Down here, we would like to know your name.” Names are politics. Mine is Mairin, but so is my aunt’s, and two more of us in the clan; it is a way of being several kinds of the same. “Mairin,” I said. She spoke another name in reply, a river word, soft at the start and then gravel. I could not make it with my mouth, and I did not try to. “River,” I said, and she shrugged the river in her shoulders, amused. At the market’s far edge a group of uplanders had set up a shade and a stall: respirator masks hung like petals in a pattern, and a coil of anchor rope lay coiled with the tenderness of a sleeping child. The uplanders looked down their faces at everything—they were taller by habit and bone, and their sockets were high, as if their eyes were always pushed up by the wind. Yet the one who haggled with a littoral woman over a spool of wire did so with a cadence so familiar—half insult, half lullaby—that it could not have been learned out of a book. This was not in the briefs, either. The briefs said separation. What I saw was a braid. The news of an offworlder passed with the speed of a small city. It is a speed faster than the net, because it does not have to be precise. Two men watched me under their eyelashes and then moved on; a girl reached to touch the hem of my cloak and then put her fingers in her mouth and looked shamed for daring. A boy took off his shirt and waved it in the path of my knees like a matador; his mother cuffed him. I walked until the algebra of my not-belonging changed from curiosity to attention. Then I turned, lifted the cloak again—which made me both more and less visible—and took the hot steps back up. “You were not permitted to do that,” said Command. The voice came from the wall, polished steel and soft, and not from a throat. On the wall a light pulsed while the distant voice of the Consortium liaison drew breath between sentences. “Not permitted,” said the Governor’s office, and a thin old face appeared, composed so that the light made a mask of it. “Not wise,” said my direct superior, who had at least the courtesy to leave the wall and come into the room in person. He shut the door with his body behind him and leaned on it, as if expecting a flood. “Do you imagine yourself a hero? You have been here four hours.” “I imagine myself without a second set of eyes,” I said. “The briefings as written are not sufficient.” “Of course not,” he said. “But it is not for you to discover that. They have protocols. So do we. The Minister will see you at eighteen.” “The Minister of Science?” A short bark of humor. “The title is an old one. On Ard’rin the portfolio includes fisheries, education, research oversight, and half the budget for the upland-dome maintenance. No matter that the Minister is a cousin of the Governor and has never written a paper on anything except debt.” “He will test you,” said the wall. The liaison—her name was Pend, and she wore a face as smooth as a pebble—smoothed her voice also, like a hand over fur. “He will make you say what you know you should not say. We need you to be very plain and very dull.” “Do you want me to be very useful?” I asked, and the room went briefly quiet. “We want you to survive your first week,” said my superior. “After that, we want you to be very useful.” The Minister’s anteroom was a library. Not books—no binding lasts so long in coastal air—but a long slope of paper and slate and etched metal, the record of patents and letters and marriages and claims. I ran a finger along a brass plate that said, in the angular script I had practiced, registration: littoral ballast method, design no. 33/2, and felt in the cut of the letters the hand that had guided the tool. He kept me waiting while I read the edges. Then the inner door slid aside and heat washed out. The Minister of Science occupied a room like the inside of a conch, round and laminated in pale wood. He stood with his back to me, hands clasped, looking at a projection of the tether, which hung in the air like a plumb-line through a body. “You have sand on your cloak,” he said, before he turned. “I went down,” I said. He half-smiled. “Of course you did.” He had the upland bone behind his eyes and the littoral looseness in his wrists; his mouth was full-lipped and made for laughter he did not provide. He gestured to a chair that was half a crouch, so that sitting made a person compact, like a weapon holstered. “We are pleased that the Consortium has sent us someone so curious,” he said. “It means you took us seriously enough to dispatch someone likely to step out of bounds. That is a compliment.” “They sent me because I was young enough to be forgiven for a first mistake,” I said. “Ah,” he said, and folded one leg over the other. “Then you have already spent the coin. Tell me, Envoy Mairin—what did you see, in your little walk? Tell me in words that my aunt would believe.” “Trade,” I said. “Not only what your briefing notes report. Reciprocity. Insults used as gifts. Hands that’re built different laying the same rope in the same coil.” “And?” “And the children run much the same everywhere,” I said. “They wanted to know if the offworlder bleeds.” “Do you?” “Yes,” I said. “Shall I show you?” He did not look away. For a moment I understood what was meant by seasoned. It was not age. It was practice at seeing through others’ balancings. “We are accused,” he said suddenly, as if answering someone else, “of failing to regulate our own biology. We are accused of encouraging divergence that harms our unity. We are accused of turning ourselves into a spectacle where once we were a people.” “By whom?” I asked, though I could recite the names. “By the Uplands, by the Littoral, by the Compact, by the Consortium, by the news, by the man who scraped salt from the stones and says his son wants gills and he did not ask for a fish.” He leaned forward. “I have a niece who sleeps better when she hears the wind through the dome’s seams. I have a nephew who will die if we do not get him a new saline filter for his glands. I am Minister, and I can allocate budgets that will build a school on the ridge or a hatchery. I am also cousin to the Governor, who believes I should speak to you with salt in my mouth so you trust me. Tell me what you propose to do with us.” “Not with you,” I said. “With what threatens you.” He spread his hands. “Give it a name. I like to see what we are cutting.” “The tether,” I said, and saw the quick flicker in his face that meant either I had hit the right target or a decoy. “It is ours,” he said. “We rebuilt it after the storm of fifty-two. We can put a barge up and down on it without burning, at a schedule the orbiters envy. The upland quarries feed the tether; the littoral keeps the sea off the pylons. It is the spine of the polity.” “And the break-point?” I said. He stared at me. He was not used to people who did not ease in. I do not know if I was brave or simply still warm from the market. “Every spine breaks at a particular point,” I said. “The break-point here is that the upland councils control the tensioning stations, and the littoral crews control the maintenance at the anchorage. If there is distrust, there is a way to twist.” “You propose to write me a report telling me what I already know.” “I propose,” I said, and let my voice be single and not persuasive, “to suggest that your schools teach anchorlines and tension in the same room. To suggest that the budget for the upland begin to include a stipend for littoral teacher-guesting, and the littoral to host upland apprentices. I propose also to ask who in your office drafted the policy that forbids young uplanders to wade at certain beaches and young littorals to walk the ridge past eighty percent oxygen. You have made law out of fear. I propose to write a law out of the market I saw today.” He laughed, not kindly but with interest. “You think a market can govern a policy.” “I think a policy can be made to resemble a thing people already do,” I said. “When it does not resemble it, they do not obey. Then you build bigger prisons.” He unfolded himself and leaned back. He studied my face, and my hands, and the hem of my cloak where the salt had dried white. “You are offworld,” he said, almost gently. “You will go, and we will stay. And the next wind will cut a new line in the sand. Why should we permit you to lay your neat little bridges between us, when we have grown so much strength in the gaps?” “Because you are tired of spending that strength on the maintenance of the gaps,” I said. The room had warmed my skin; sweat gathered between my shoulder blades and made an itch I did not scratch. “Because you want to spend it on other things. On the child with the glands, on the school at the ridge, on the patent for the ballast method. Because I walked in your market and bought a tuber and found I could name the taste.” He was silent. On the projection the tether altered; some tech outside had changed the data feed, and a storm icon flickered in, a spiraling white flower coming in from the east. “The season turns,” he said. “Will you walk again?” “Yes,” I said. “You will not be permitted,” he said—a precise mimicry of Command’s voice—and then he smiled, a thin salt smile. “But you will do it anyway. Tell them I made you.” “If they ask,” I said. “They will,” he said, rising. “They like to know where to put the blame down between them.” On the library’s slope, as I went out, I ran my fingers again along the brass plate with the ballast design, and my hand came away with the smell of copper. In the corridor, Command waited, not in person, but there in the light again. My superior had put both hands on the back of a chair and stood as if braced against a swell. “Well?” he said. “They will test us,” I said. “We must test ourselves,” and hung the cloak on the hook by the door, for once not because I was not permitted to wear it, but because I did not want to carry its weight. Outside the walls the green light ran along the algae like a river through stone. The wind came up, and across the city the tether sang.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully captures Le Guin's style with its anthropological perspective, focus on cultural differences, and thoughtful exploration of sociopolitical tensions. The narrative follows a young diplomatic envoy who breaks protocol to explore a distant human colony where humanity has diverged into distinct subspecies. The writing excels in world-building through sensory details and cultural observations. The market scene is particularly effective, using specific details like "scarlet fruits like squeezable stars" and the bone-seller with missing fingers to create a vivid sense of place. The author skillfully establishes the physical differences between the littoral people (with salt-glands and webbing) and the uplanders (with increased bone density and brown fat) without resorting to info-dumping. The prose demonstrates sophistication through its economy and precision. Sentences like "Names are politics" and "The briefs said separation. What I saw was a braid" convey complex ideas with elegant simplicity. The writing maintains a consistent voice throughout—contemplative, observant, and slightly detached in a way that feels authentic to Le Guin's style. The dialogue between the envoy and the Minister of Science effectively reveals character and advances the plot. Their verbal sparring demonstrates the political complexities at play while revealing the envoy's perceptiveness and courage. The Minister's challenge—"Why should we permit you to lay your neat little bridges between us, when we have grown so much strength in the gaps?"—encapsulates the central tension of the story. The character of Mairin is well-developed through her actions and observations. Her decision to break protocol reveals her independence and curiosity, while her interactions with the locals and the Minister show her diplomatic skill and genuine interest in understanding the culture. The Minister is similarly nuanced, portrayed as politically savvy but also personally invested in his community's welfare. The narrative avoids simplistic resolutions. Instead, it presents a complex situation where divergent groups maintain both tension and interdependence. The space elevator/tether serves as both literal infrastructure and effective metaphor for the connections between the different human groups. If there are weaknesses, they lie in some occasional moments where the prose becomes slightly too abstract or where the world-building details could be more seamlessly integrated. A few passages might benefit from more concrete grounding to balance the philosophical elements. Overall, this is an accomplished piece that successfully emulates Le Guin's thoughtful approach to science fiction, using a distant human colony as a lens to explore questions of adaptation, belonging, and governance. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Biopunk: Polymerase Chain Reaction — Score: 93.0
Prompt:
Biopunk -- Polymerase Chain Reaction Write a chapter set in a near-future post-apocalyptic world where corporate genetic engineering was designed with built-in obsolescence—engineered DNA lasting only one generation to maximize profits before societal collapse. Follow a biohacker working with salvaged equipment to splice viable food crops for their settlement using rapidly degrading genetic material. As world building / window dressing, include details about jury-rigged lab equipment, and the physical toll (and unexpected upsides) of using untested genetic modifications as medicine. The plot of this chapter is centred around a black market contract. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The canister rattled when I set it on the bench, the hollow clatter echoing through the corrugated steel of the lab like a cough. It had once been full of proprietary nuclease mix, the label still half-legible beneath ash bloom and iodine stains, the logo of the defunct giant embossed like a fossilized smile. Now it held a slurry of salts we made by boiling river water until the kettle screamed and filtering it through a coffee sock I’d patched with nylon thread. I’d painted the canister’s cap with nail polish—the only thing that stayed put in the damp—to mark the base buffer from the primer stock. It made the place look faintly festive when the lantern was lit: tiny flashes of carmine and metallic rose, like someone had tried to make a cake out of shipwreck parts. “Three minutes to denature,” I told the roller. It wasn’t listening; it never did. The belt had come from a meat slicer; the rollers were scavenged from a vacuum cleaner and a child’s toy truck, and the thermostat was the bimetal strip from a toaster oven, housed in a box with the words QUICK-BAKE still etched in plastic the color of old teeth. Heat pulsed up and down in the crude cycles I’d been coaxing out of it for months: hot enough to peel your fingerprints, cold as an empty room. Polymerase chain reaction by sympathy and stubbornness. PCR by candlelight. Across the bench, the little centrifuge whined, a dog in a dream. I’d wrapped its motor in cloth to keep it from stuttering when the wind came up; the cloth was printed with cartoon oranges wearing sunglasses, which meant it had been at least ten years since anyone had put them on a table to eat. “You’re talking to machines again,” said Tars. He was leaning in the doorway with his body turned sideways, ready to run if something in here exploded. He liked to keep his options open in a lab. “You hired me because you want machines to agree with you,” I said to the belt. “It’s the agreement I’m after, not the romance,” Tars said, stepping in and kicking the door shut with his heel. He had a burlap bag over his shoulder. It sagged like it had bones in it. He laid it on the floor and pushed it with his foot. It clinked. Empty canisters, their labels flaked with soot. He’d raided a facility somewhere. The professional part of my brain began to catalog them without permission: two reagent carriers from CleoGenics, one from DaxaBio, one long-necked container we would use for ethanol if there were ethanol. The rest were the cheap ones, brittle as eggshell. “Payment?” I said. “Collateral,” he said. “You got paid when we signed. I don’t double-pay.” “We agreed on a second allotment of clean cartridges if the product took,” I said. He waggled a finger. “The product always takes. The question is how long it grows. And how much you can make before it starts melting.” He leaned in, heavy with street cologne that smelled like swallowing a battery. “And whether you can make enough for us before the season turns and the contract goes to someone with a working freezer.” I pretended to check the timer. He could smell worry like a dog. “We freeze dry.” I nodded toward the top shelf where the scavenged espresso machine squatted, its portafilter gleaming with a black polish whose main ingredient was panic. I had rerouted its pump through a pressure cooker and two medical syringes. A vacuum, in principle. When it worked, the foam it left looked like frost, only warmer. “What do you have for me?” He bent and rolled the burlap bag open like he was undressing it. He took out a cassette, the size and shape of cassette tapes I’d only ever seen in museums, big enough to hold someone’s history if you compressed it right. The Cass had once contained an entire kale genome—plus DaxaBio’s clever edits, coded like riddles in the introns, meant to ensure that only coughing, blessed sprouts would grow past seed leaf stage without this year’s license key. Now the Cass was a husk, but the polymer sleeve inside was lined with dried gel, pale and scuffed like a tongue. The gel would still hold fragments, even degraded, trapped in the cross-links like gnats in amber. “Leftover kale,” Tars said, casual as a man offering you a stick of gum. “And this.” He produced a thumb of something wrapped in Parafilm. When he peeled it back, the smell was sweet and clean and made my teeth ache. Tomato. The old kind. He handled it with religious care. “One slice each week since the collapse. If you can make ten seeds that grow true for one generation, I get half.” “And the settlement gets the other,” I said. “We agreed.” “The settlement gets something that grows,” Tars corrected. “True is a luxury. True is a story you tell yourself while you get old.” The roller chimed; the bimetal strip had bent enough to flick the contact, and the Quick-Bake rolled into its cooling phase with the shiver of old metal remembering what it meant to expand. I nudged the cheek of the incubator with my hip to check it was still warm; the incubator was an Igloo cooler with a hairdryer piped into it, the hairdryer’s fan driven by a hand crank that my assistant Asha had fashioned from bicycle parts. She’d put a sticker on it: STAY COOL (UNDER PRESSURE). Asha had taste. And a sense of humor the dust couldn’t smother. “You didn’t come to admire my décor,” I said, dipping a pipette into the Cass. The tip scraped delicately over the gel to lift a film of invisible fragments. Even degraded, even dumb, DNA had body. The plastic flexed under it like the skin over a knuckle. I touched the pipette to the eppendorf tube nestled in a rack I had carved out of the plastic lid of a high-end sushi tray. The tip drew up the buffer. I felt the faint hump of surface tension pop and settle. It was the closest I got to faith. “I came to call in the rest of the contract,” Tars said. “Your settlement’s cut, sure. But also the other part. The part you wrote very small.” In the center of the bench were nine shallow dishes cut from an old Petri tower, each with a smudge of soil sifted to microbe agony. For each dish, a different primer set. For each primer set, a chance to patch the kale’s obsolescence while using a fragment of what the bills called the Next-Gen Tasty gene cassette, the regulation-labeled TOTOM8, which a DaxaBio intern with a sense of humor had always pronounced like a baby. “I wrote it small because I didn’t want to talk about it,” I said. “The therapy.” “You called it that,” Tars said. “I call it the risk. You and your gill-people pouring themselves into kids and old men. You pass-along and pray it sticks. You call that medicine. I call it a carnival ride.” He smiled because he was getting to me. “The black market wants a packet that keeps the shakes down and the heat out. You promised a test batch. No more little instructions, no more disclaimers about off-target effects. The next heatwave we’re going to see the ridge turn into a crematorium.” “I’ve been testing on myself,” I said, sharper than I meant to. The emotional truth of the sentence put a wobble in my hand. The pipette tip flicked the rim of the dish and I swore under my breath, then steadied it, watching the drop bulge and fall into the soil like a single bead of sweat. “My body’s not theirs. It’s not a population study. It’s not proof.” “You can’t do population studies when half the population is tired enough to think death is a cure,” he said. “You said it had upsides.” “It fixes neighborhood problems,” I said. “It builds new little plumbers, puts them to work. It tweaks sweat glands, changes receptor density, makes heat a suggestion instead of a command. In some, it nudges the thymus to remember it exists. Their lungs learn better than they did. But it takes things too, Tars. It scrapes off the top layer of taste. It makes skin prone to bruising and it changes the way a body deals with sugar. My hair doesn’t grow right. My nails look like you took sandpaper to them. And every morning for a week after the dose, there’s a fever spike that feels like a man climbing into your chest to light a cooking fire.” He watched me as if the lab would answer instead of me. I realized I’d been holding the Parafilm-wrapped tomato sample in my left hand, and put it down like it was something I should apologize to. “Upsides,” he said again, softer. “The way you said it, like it mattered to say it.” I thought of Asha’s grandmother, who had been, at the start of spring, a woman whose breath rattled like a paper grocery bag being shaken open. Now she walked to the river every day and sent postcards from her phone to the kids in the city made of broken screens. In each picture she was wearing a new hat the color of raccoons. “We steel people,” I said. “We give them summers. And I can send it as a packet.” I touched the dish with a chopstick that had come free in a takeout bag from the year we still had takeout; over its end I had stretched a square of cheesecloth dipped in mycelium to act as a filter. “If what we put in the kale holds, it will deliver the therapy with dinner. Eat your medicine. No syringes. No boosters. If we can stabilize the on-switch long enough to get seed to seed once, we can freeze the second generation. We can bank it.” “The bank catches fire,” Tars said, almost wistful. His father had been a vault engineer, he once told me. “Everything catches fire now.” “Not water,” I said, and smiled because he hated my optimism. The roller chimed again. I drew out the tubes, dew beading on my wrist in the lab’s sweet damp. Across the room the solar panel indicator flickered, a dragonfly caught in a web, trying to tell me it was almost evening. “We’ll go with the carrot promoter,” I said, more to myself than to him. “It’s old tech. The switch is easier to hold. If I splice the TOTOM8 to an old root crop promoter we might get expression even when the gel’s code is missing punctuation.” “You just spoke money,” he said, and pulled the folder from his jacket. Inside were sheets cut neatly from brown paper shopping bags, lines drawn in charcoal, numbers in pencil. He set it on the bench without asking my permission. The bottom line was fat enough to be a promise. “The black market grows under fluorescent mushrooms in a sewer,” he said. “They can’t order it. They buy it from whoever is willing to flick them crumbs. You promise them ten grams of something that cools and steadies and they will make you a saint. You get them thirteen grams of something that does that and helps them sleep through the screaming of pipes, they put a ring on your finger and carry you around like a chair.” “And the price?” I asked. “Half goes to the settlement,” he said, shrugging. “You did that to me. The rest is parts. Clean cartridges. A condenser the size of a baby carriage. Someone who can fix your splicer so that you don’t need to stroke it when you ask it to listen.” He smiled. “And a freezer. An honest-to-God freezer, wired to a roof full of panels that used to keep condos pretty.” I laughed. It came out ragged. A freezer was the dream you gave to kids to get them to sleep. “Stipulation,” I said, taking up the tube and pushing its heat into the well of the agar plate. The cap of the tube clicked against the iron of the vial rack when I changed hands. “You deliver the freezer after the first test batch. Not before.” “To keep me honest?” He tipped his head. “You think so little of me? In this economy? Pains me.” “In this economy,” I said, “it pays to be pained.” In the corner, the bioreactor—a plastic drum with a hole cut in its lid, aerated by an aquarium pump we powered by pedaling—burbled a soft question. The room smelled like things in solution: salts hushed down to brine, starch, the metallic breath of old blood. I felt tired in the particular way that made my bones seem to ring a little bit when I moved. He watched me plate the rest: a rhythm, draw up, dispense, tap, flame the spatula over the alcohol wick that we had built from a lamp and vodka we’d doctored with glycerin. The flame was a tame blue most days. Today it was a busy yellow, the wick coated with a little more dust than it should have been. “Close this with me,” he said. “Say you’ll make it by the festival. They’ll bring peaches in jars, and you’ll bring little packets that make them stop sensing the heat like guilt.” He lifted one of the empty canisters, turned it so its dead logo looked at me. “We’ll fill these with good things. We’ll be the ones who get it right after the gods made a mess of it.” “The gods are dead because we shot them and put them in these,” I said, gesturing with the tube at the empties. “Don’t make me co-sign the graffiti.” He opened his hands, palms out. “Deal or no deal, Kale Queen. I’ve other places to be.” He always called me that when he wanted to remind me what replaced pride when pride left: hunger. “Deal,” I said. And my mouth filled with the taste of something like copper. Fear, or wanting, or the way you taste a word when you know it will change the season. “I’ll dose myself after the first sprout shows expression,” I added, because if the black market demanded a sign of blood, I might as well give them mine on my terms. “If it doesn’t kill me, we post it on the network. We’ll call it T0 + HeatGentle. People like names that sound like they’ve been chewed by a machine.” He grinned at that. “They like when a machine chews the bite for them.” He lifted the bag and slid the empty canisters back inside as if they were sleeping. At the door he paused and looked back at my little empire: the Quick-Bake with its bent bimetal heart, the espresso dryer, the cheesecloth, the cartoon oranges, the canisters repurposed as if they’d been designed to be useful after they failed. “You’re gonna make something that outlasts us, Kale Queen,” he said, mock solemn. “Not if I can help it,” I said. “One generation at a time.” He laughed and left whistling. Outside, the settlement’s evening thrum began: bicycle generators grinding in chorus, someone hammering sheet metal into the idea of a door, the shrieks of kids playing Tag the Drone with sticks. I put the plates in the incubator and cranked the handle until my shoulder burned. The belt on the Quick-Bake turned with the slow delight of a patient animal. I touched the cap of one of the empty canisters as if the old giant’s logo might bite. It didn’t. It had no teeth left. We did. By the time Asha slipped in, dust in the ragged pocket of her elbow and sweat beaded in her hairline, the room smelled like growing. “Is he for real?” she asked. “As real as anyone is when there’s counting to be done,” I said. She grinned like a blade. “We’ll get the freezer?” “We’ll get the freezer,” I said, which was, at the moment, almost a prayer. We stood listening to the incubator purr and the water bath knock like a ghost in a radiator. Above our heads, a line of jars with seeds from the last successful round winked in the low light. We both knew their half-lives like birthdays. We knew how fast meaning ran out of them. “Do you ever think,” Asha said, “that maybe the built-in obsolescence is a kindness?” “No,” I said, too quickly. Then, gentler, “I think it was a business model pretending to be a natural law. I think we fell for it because it matched our own expiration dates and it made us feel less small. The kindness is the trick we do with string and glass and the heat from our palms.” “And tomato, if it takes,” she said, and her voice went a little dreamy. “And tomato,” I said, and made a new mark in the ledger with a pencil worn down to the metal. And kale, and carrot, and the other things we would teach to remember us for one more season, for one more seed. For as long as it took to make a freezer hum and the world cool enough that we could sleep without becoming saints for being able. Above the bench, outside the window we had cut from a truck’s windshield and set into the wall with spray foam and prayer, the last light slid out of the clouds. The incubator clicked. Somewhere in there, a promoter welded itself to a story. Somewhere, a gene decided to stay.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response is a remarkably accomplished piece of biopunk fiction that successfully creates a vivid post-apocalyptic world where genetic engineering's built-in obsolescence has become a central societal problem. The author has crafted a richly detailed environment with jury-rigged lab equipment that feels authentic and lived-in, from the "Quick-Bake" PCR machine to the espresso machine vacuum dryer. The protagonist is a biohacker working with salvaged equipment to create viable food crops, exactly as requested. The black market contract with Tars forms the central plot element, with clear stakes established around the creation of both viable kale/tomato crops and a genetic therapy that helps humans withstand heat. The writing excels in its technical specificity without becoming inaccessible. Terms like "polymerase chain reaction," "nuclease mix," and "primer stock" are integrated naturally into the narrative. The author demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of both genetic engineering concepts and how they might be adapted in a resource-scarce environment. The prose is particularly strong, with evocative descriptions and metaphors that enhance the worldbuilding: "the logo of the defunct giant embossed like a fossilized smile" and "the belt had come from a meat slicer; the rollers were scavenged from a vacuum cleaner and a child's toy truck." These details create a tangible sense of improvisation and resourcefulness. The dialogue between the protagonist and Tars feels natural and reveals character through subtext and power dynamics. Their conversation efficiently conveys information about their relationship, the state of the world, and the stakes of their arrangement without feeling expository. The piece also addresses the prompt's request for details about the physical toll and unexpected upsides of genetic modifications as medicine. The protagonist describes how the therapy "fixes neighborhood problems," improves heat tolerance and respiratory function, but also causes loss of taste, bruising, brittle nails, and fever spikes. This nuanced approach to genetic modification avoids simplistic good/bad categorizations. The ending strikes an appropriate tone of cautious hope without being unrealistically optimistic for a post-apocalyptic setting. The final image of genes "deciding to stay" provides a fitting metaphor for the story's themes of persistence and adaptation. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Some readers might find a few descriptions slightly overwrought, and there are moments where the technical language might be challenging for those unfamiliar with genetics. However, these are minimal concerns in an otherwise exceptional piece. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0