Sample Outputs: openrouter/horizon-alpha

Iteration 1 — Avg Score: 90.7
+ Classic sci-fi: The Azra Gambit — Score: 87.2
Prompt:
Classic sci-fi (Author style: Asimov) The Azra Gambit Colonial mars is being mined by corporations who take leases on indentured labourers. The thing they are mining is Azra, a recently discovered exotic metal which accelerates radioactive decay to such a rate that it is greatly sought after for interstellar drives and weapons alike. This has created both a gold rush and an arms race as various interests vie for control and endeavour to unlock Azra's secrets. The story follows Arthur Neegan, a first generation settler and mining engineer. Upon discovering that his unassuming plot sits atop an immense Azra vein, he is subjected to a flurry of interest and scrutiny. Write the next chapter in this story, in which an armed retinue descends on Arthur's home and politely but forcefully invites him to a meeting with some unknown party off-world. The insignia look like that of the Antares diplomatic corp -- diplomatic in name only. Arthur finds himself in the centre of a political tug of war. The chapter involves a meeting with this unknown party, who makes Arthur an offer. The scene should be primarily dialogue, interspersed with vivid description & scene setting. It should sow hints of the larger intrigue, stakes & dangers. Include Asimov's trademark big-and-small-picture world building and retrofuturistic classic scifi vibe. The chapter begins with Arthur aboard the transfer vessel, wondering just what he's gotten involved in. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The small display screen on the bulkhead above Arthur’s knees cycled through a familiar sequence: LIFE SUPPORT NOMINAL. HULL INTEGRITY NOMINAL. GRAVITY 0.98G. FUEL RESERVE 84 PERCENT. The text bloomed and faded in phosphorescent green, as reassuring as the heartbeat of a sleeping animal. Arthur kept his eyes on the crawl as if it might tell him something different if he stared long enough. He watched the pressure reading—101.3 kPa—hold steady, as if the walls might decide to confess. They did not. The transfer vessel hummed with a low, professional hum, the sound of competent machinery doing exactly as told. He remembered a professor telling him that machines behaved better in space, away from dust and human complication. He had believed it until men with Antares rosettes on their sleeves had knocked on his door that morning and proved that complication did not respect vacuum seals. Footfalls approached. The hatch hissed open. A woman in a matte-gray utility uniform stepped into the cramped compartment, pausing to let the scent of sterilizing cleanser dissipate. She was tall, not tall like Mars-born—he could always tell that by the gait—but tall within the Earth range, compact, as if gravity had taught her to economize. The Antares insignia—two sober stars and a spiral—was stitched with understated precision. “Mr. Neegan,” she said. It was statement and greeting, both polite and perfectly unhelpful. “Arthur,” he said, out of habit. He didn’t like being Mr. anything in a room without windows. She ignored the correction with a professionalism that somehow softened it. “I’m Field Attaché Vara Kells, Antares diplomatic corps.” She said diplomatic in the same way one might say veterinary: something involving sharp instruments and anxious mammals. “Thank you for agreeing to a conversation.” “I didn’t,” he said, glancing at the status screen again. THRUST: IDLE. “But here we are.” A flicker. She allowed herself the ghost of a smile. “You’re right. Sometimes agreement is a formality that follows necessity. May I?” She gestured to the opposite fold-down seat. When she sat, she placed a palm-sized recorder on the ledge between them, didn’t turn it on. That was a courtesy too. “Kettle?” she offered. “We have a service fabricator on this deck. It can approximate caffeine.” He shook his head. Her hands—clean, with a miner’s bluntness that seemed theatrical until he noticed the tool-calluses—folded in her lap. “Arthur, the routine is that I will say something you already know, you will deny it or qualify it, and then we will acknowledge that we share a reality, not merely a vessel. May we skip to the second act?” “You’ve rehearsed this,” he said. “Antares rehearses everything,” Vara said. “Your plot, Neegan Outcrop—tract C-sixteen by the old survey—sits over an Azra deposit. More to the point, a vein of extraordinary purity and continuity. Your core samples flirt with indecent consistency.” He had been careful. He had salted his assay. He had transmitted the preliminary geologic logs with the same studied mundanity as his potatoes yields. He had told himself he had time. “Your satellites have good eyes,” he said. “Eyes, ears, and equations,” she said. “Azra has a signature. The way it jostles decay rates, the way it hums to the vacuum. We taste it in aberrant muon counts. Your outcrop is singing. Loudly.” He rubbed his thumb across the seam of the seat. He thought of the day he had hit the vein, the meter’s frantic stutter, the sudden scent of metal that wasn’t quite a smell. Azra had made the air inside his helmet taste like a coin and a storm both. In that minute he had felt a surge of ownership so strong it had frightened him. It seemed absurd now, to think anything under your boot on Mars could belong to you longer than it took for a lawyer to say otherwise. “What do you want, Ms. Kells?” he said. “Antares,” she corrected mildly. “Antares wants an arrangement. The same thing everyone wants: leverage. But to be specific, an exclusive offtake agreement under the Outer Systems Resource Compact. Antares guarantees your title against challenge, facilitates security and logistics, and, in return, we direct your Azra to appropriate buyers.” “Appropriate,” he repeated. “Diplomatic as in, we sell to everyone.” “Diplomatic as in, we sell to precisely who we mean to,” she said. “We do not sell to the Jovian Syndicates, to name one obvious example. We try to avoid wars we’d lose.” “The Syndicates have more ships than you do,” Arthur said. He wasn’t boasting for them; he just knew numbers. He had once balanced spares for an eight-year dig as if each bolt were a ration. That taught you the arithmetic of survival. “Ships,” Vara said, “are not the only currency. Information. Legitimacy. Choke points. And Azra. You’re an engineer; you’ve read the papers. Azra collapses energy budgets in ways that make planning committees cry. A centimeter cube could change who counts to three first in a trajectory solution. Imagine that scaled. Now imagine ten parties racing to scale it without blowing something irrevocable to the wrong isotope. We prefer to be the adult in that room.” Arthur’s gaze lifted to the small screen. COURSE LOCK: AREO-L5. He had suspected as much. “So you pluck me from my hab,” he said, “point me at L5, and ask me to sign.” “We invited you,” Vara said softly. “We could have done it differently. We have done it differently, elsewhere. But you were a good citizen of the first settlement registry. You paid your lease. You stabilized two domes that weren’t yours because it was the right thing to do. Those things count. Even for us.” There was a deceleration flutter, subtle as breath. Somewhere aft, an attitude thruster purred. VARIANCE: 0.002 PERCENT. Vara watched the numbers with a connoisseur’s half-interest. “The other thing you know,” she said, “is that others will come. Callisto Brokerage sent a tender to a homestead near Hebes Chasma when they tested positive on a shallow vein. They arrived with a contract and a gunship escort. The family signed; they had little choice. Six weeks later, someone sabotaged the procession out near Phobos. No survivors, and a very messy arbitration postponed indefinitely.” This was the part of the world he avoided thinking about, the way you avoided looking over the edge of an open pit. He thought of the Antares men at his door, their courtesy like padded armor. He thought of the unmarked shapes that would follow. “You’re telling me you’re the least bad option,” he said. “I’m telling you we will be the option that keeps you alive long enough to feel bad at leisure,” Vara said. “And that if you try to play everyone, you will cease to be a player very quickly.” He felt the anger then; it came late, unhelpfully. “It was supposed to be simple,” he said. “Take a plot, scratch a living. Mars was for people who didn’t want to be measured by the speed of Earth’s clocks.” Vara’s gaze softened in the precise way that suggested practice layered over something genuine. “The old idea of flight,” she said. “You should talk to our historians. The first people to leave Earth thought the same. Every frontier is a mirror; it reflects the faces that chase it.” He could hear the echo of an old lecture hall in her cadence—the Asimovian tone he recognized from childhood broadcasts: reasonable, slightly amused, forbearing. It made him want to hit something. “What’s the offer,” he said, cutting through his own theatrics. “Numbers.” “An initial signing bonus,” she said. “A figure sufficient to depress you into thinking you should have asked for more. Long-term, a profit-share tied to market index less logistics, security, and stabilization costs. Antares will handle extraction with your input. You will retain advisory control on technical matters. We will establish a perimeter. We will file a notarized notice with the Compact registry, which will protect you in all jurisdictions that matter.” “And the jurisdictions that don’t?” Vara tilted her head toward the wall. The green text scrolled. COMM LINK: SECURE. “We’re also good at being where we need to be. You will find that people who cannot challenge us legally will think twice about challenging us physically.” “What do you get out of me besides ore?” “Legitimacy,” she said. “You are a first-generation settler. You have a face for the theater. ‘Arthur Neegan partners with Antares for safe, responsible expansion.’ You can grind your teeth at the phrasing, but it matters. There is a committee on Earth that likes to feel they are still a parent. You will look good on their wall.” He laughed, a tight burst. “This is honest. It’s terrifying.” “Honesty is cheaper than failure,” Vara said. “Also, it is a luxury we can afford because our alternatives are not charming.” Something shifted in the hatchway. A crewman with the same Antares star paused, eyes politely averted. “Docking in six,” he said. “Ms. Kells.” “Thank you,” Vara said, and the hatch slid closed again with the efficient mutual courtesy of disciplined strangers. Arthur pictured Lagrange 5: the sketched geometry of a gravity saddle, permanent exile codified in clean equations. He had never been there. He imagined the station as a necklace of cylinders shining in perpetual dawn, shops selling something like coffee, corridors named for mathematicians who had remained on Earth. “Who am I meeting?” he asked. Vara’s mouth did the smile again, not die-hard but something in the family. “Someone who signs for Antares on sums like this. A director. Perhaps two. Someone who will say ‘we’ and mean it across a thousand payroll lines.” “And if I say no?” “Then we will drop you at the freeport,” she said, as if discussing a bus line. “You will find a local office of Callisto, and of Ceres Mediations, and a rumor mill that begins before breakfast. By noon you will have three offers and a tail. By evening, when you return to your hab, you will find two parties already there and one unfortunate accident staged near your rover. You will call us. If you call in time, we will come.” He looked at her, searching for the part that was threat and the part that was caution. They seemed to occupy the same chair. “They say Azra was an accident,” he said. “A lab tech miscalculated a containment field and wanted to save face.” “They like stories about accidents,” Vara said. “It reassures them. Accidents imply there was a state before. Azra wasn’t an accident. It was an inevitability of the way men insist on pushing where wavefunctions don’t want them. We would have gotten there, one way or another.” “You talk like a physicist,” he said. “I talk like someone who’s had to read budgets written by physicists,” she said. “And who has had to explain them to men with hawk pins who think you can outvote half-lives.” The vessel yawed with a grace that felt expensive. The display said: DOCKING COLLAR ENGAGED. SEAL: GREEN. In his bones, some Earth-born part that had adapted to Mars but never forgotten, he felt the whisper of large metal meeting larger. Vara stood. “Walk with me?” The corridor outside was a careful contradiction: utilitarian and polished, pipes exposed in a way that suggested both necessity and aesthetic. Retro switches were labeled in embossed print. The lighting fell in clean oval pools. Arthur imagined how many engines like this hummed at L5, how many hatches marked SECURITY AUTHORIZED opened for men in gray. They passed a viewport. The station loomed, a rotating drum with spoke-like trusses, its skin speckled with maintenance bots like gnats on a sleeping animal. Beyond, Mars hung with an indifference that had attracted him in the first place. He had never thought of it as beautiful. Not until now, when it might be taken. “Arthur,” Vara said, slowing. “One more thing. We will ask you to only supply us. Others will ask you to supply them. They will not all ask politely. Some will ask in code. ‘Open science.’ ‘Commonwealth property.’ ‘The Martian independence fund.’ You will be tempted because you will hear your own rhetoric in their pleas. Be careful. Some of those pleas will come from us.” He looked at her. “From you?” “We vet ourselves less ruthlessly than we should,” she said. “Antares is a continent. There are factions. You will learn names. Arcturus Initiative. Proxima Pact. There will be schemes hung on your ore like baubles on a holiday tree. Men will call you friend when what they mean is fulcrum. Remember what you are good at. Stones. Loads. Stresses. Apply those sensibilities to us.” He took a breath that felt like it belonged to someone in a suit, standing in dust, measuring wind with a lick of a finger. “You know how to make a sale, Ms. Kells.” “We know how not to lie,” she said. “Usually.” They came to an airlock with an understated plaque: ANTARES: COMPACT LIAISON OFFICE. The door dilated with a propriety that implied an audience behind it. Vara paused with her hand on the jamb. “Answer questions with questions when you can,” she said. “Make them explain their verbs. And when they smile too much, ask yourself which equation they’ve decided not to show you.” He looked at the door. He thought of the Azra vein under his outcrop, a gleaming ribbon in a planet that had not asked for it. He thought of the green text on the wall and the idea that numbers could keep you safe. “Am I allowed a lawyer?” he asked. “You are allowed many,” Vara said. “We will even recommend some. But for the first ten minutes, it will just be you and them and the idea of how you see yourself. That’s the only part that matters, and the only part they can’t draft.” The door opened. The room beyond was all muted grays and brushed metal, the future as an Earth committee would have designed it in a century that didn’t believe in accidents. Two people waited at a round table, both packaged in kindness and measured interest, both wearing pins with the two stars and the spiral. Arthur stepped through, and for an instant, he pictured the mine at dusk, the way a Martian dusk softened rock to velvet. He held the image like a talisman. “Mr. Neegan,” the older of the two said, rising. “I’m Director Haldane. Thank you for coming.” He almost corrected the Mister. He almost explained that he had not come anywhere so much as been carried. Instead he said: “You know why I’m here.” Haldane’s smile was the careful kind that left room for you to invent kindness in it. “Of course,” he said. “We want to talk about how to keep you safe. And how to keep everyone else safe from what you’ve found.” Arthur sat, felt the chair accept his weight with the indulgence of money very well spent. Outside, the drums turned. The display in his head scrolled: OPTIONS: LIMITED. TIME: IS A VECTOR. “All right,” he said. “Talk.”
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully captures Asimov's style with its focus on dialogue, measured pacing, and the interplay between technology and human politics. The author has created a tense negotiation scene that effectively conveys the high stakes of Arthur's discovery while building out the larger political landscape of this future. The writing excels in its world-building through dialogue. Rather than extensive exposition, we learn about the Antares diplomatic corps, the Jovian Syndicates, and the complex political machinations surrounding Azra through the conversation between Arthur and Vara. This approach mirrors Asimov's technique of revealing his universe through character interactions. The prose is clean and precise, with technical details that give it an authentic sci-fi feel without overwhelming the reader. The descriptions of the transfer vessel, the status displays, and the physical environment are economical yet evocative. The author uses these details to establish mood rather than merely for decoration. Character development is handled well, particularly with Vara Kells, who emerges as a complex figure representing institutional power but with hints of personal ethics. Arthur's position as an unwilling participant in larger political games is convincingly portrayed, and his internal conflict feels authentic. The dialogue is particularly strong, with a formal, measured quality that recalls Asimov's style. Characters speak with purpose, revealing information strategically while maintaining their distinct perspectives. The conversation has layers of meaning, with subtext about power, choice, and the illusion of freedom in a corporate-controlled Mars. However, there are some weaknesses. The piece occasionally veers into overly ornate metaphors that feel less Asimovian and more contemporary literary fiction ("like gnats on a sleeping animal"). Asimov's prose was typically more straightforward. Additionally, while the ending effectively sets up the next phase of the story, it feels somewhat abrupt after the detailed build-up. The political intrigue is well-developed, with factions like the "Arcturus Initiative" and "Proxima Pact" mentioned to hint at the complexity of the situation without overwhelming the reader with details. This approach effectively creates a sense of a lived-in universe with history and competing interests. Overall, this is a strong piece that captures the essence of classic sci-fi while telling an engaging story about power, resources, and the individual caught in larger political currents. It successfully fulfills the prompt's requirements while maintaining a consistent voice and building tension through dialogue and subtle world-building. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 16 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 16.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Contemporary romance: Darkroom Revelations — Score: 95.7
Prompt:
Darkroom Revelations Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of Dani, a 25-year-old assertive art student known for her bold style and take-charge attitude in relationships. For the past semester, she's been quietly fascinated by Elliot (he/him), a 19-year-old boy in her experimental photography class. Dani has been intrigued by his unconventional masculinity: killer thrift-shop-nu-goth style, soft demeanour and quiet intellect. When they're paired for a final project requiring late nights in the darkroom, Elliot tentatively shares that he's been questioning his gender identity and expression. Set during one of these intimate darkroom sessions where the red light creates a confessional atmosphere. Explore Dani's complex attraction—her usual assertiveness complicated by her desire to protect Elliot's vulnerability, her excitement at witnessing his self-discovery, and her confusion about what this means for her own identity as someone typically attracted to more defined gender presentations. The narrative should capture the tender awkwardness of their conversations, Dani's internal struggle between taking charge and wanting to give Elliot agency, and the unexpected chemistry that develops as both find themselves in uncharted territory. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The darkroom’s red light is a hush against the eyes, like the world holding its breath. It makes everyone’s skin look softer, edges smudged like charcoal. It has a way of inviting confession. I learned that freshman year, sneaking in after hours to make out with a girl who would only kiss me in the dark. These days, I go there to work. And tonight, to watch Elliot hum to himself while a square of paper drifts in a bath of developer like a little raft. He holds the tongs like they’re something sacred, narrow wrist bare between sleeve and glove. His nail polish is chipped black. He looks like a saint in an icon someone smudged with thumbprints. He’s nineteen and I am twenty-five, and he feels like a question I never bothered to formulate because I liked answers too much. “Timing?” I say, just to make a sound. The red light eats quiet in a way that makes you want to feed it. “Twenty-five seconds,” he says, low, and smiles without showing teeth. There’s always that softness to him, that still water quality, but he dresses like a minor apocalypse—black layers, thrifted lace at his collar sometimes, rings with tarnished stones. The first day I noticed him, he had a velvet choker on. I watched him through the enlarger light and thought: nobody taught me to want this. My body went ahead anyway. “Good,” I say, because that’s what I do. I monitor, I keep track, I hold the line. He hums—some tune I can’t place, maybe something from a video game, or a hymn. The developer smells like pennies and old rain. He rocks the tray softly, and the image lifts up like a bruise surfacing. He asked to be paired with me, actually. “You’re… decisive,” he’d said when I asked why. He’d looked at my boots instead of my face, the corner of his mouth quirked. “I’m bad with decisions.” It had felt like a compliment and a dare. Tonight, the room is ours. The only light is red, the only sound his humming and the soft slap of water against tray edges. The world outside died down an hour ago; you can’t hear the students tossing bottles between dorm windows or the skateboard wheels or the laughter that always seems a step too loud. It’s just the two of us and the slow reveal. “Are you sure about the burn here?” I ask, pointing to the print with the end of a clean brush. “The corner’s going to go muddy if we block too much.” He watches, the way he always does—carefully, as if you could scare his attention away. “Maybe I like muddy,” he says, and then, quieter, “I mean, I guess we can try it your way first.” My stomach does that thing—the little tug of wanting to lead, to press, the thing that has served me well with lovers and group projects and bartenders. Take charge, be the steady rock. I’m used to holding the weight. I don’t mind it—I like the sensation of people trusting me with it. But with him, the weight feels like something delicate I could crush. “Let’s try both,” I say. “One with the burn, one without.” He nods, like I’ve solved something. He dips the print into the stop bath. Vinegar hits my nose. He hums again. I watch the tendons in his hand flex and want to sketch them with charcoal later. I want to put him in a frame and also to dissolve him into me. “Can I ask you something?” he says, voice floating up like his breath might carry it away if he isn’t careful. “Always,” I say before I can stop myself. He doesn’t look at me. The print goes to the fixer tray, and he watches it like only the paper exists. “Have you ever… felt like the shape of you is off?” He shrugs. The motion is small but feels like he’s moved continents. “Not in a tragic way. Just like your haircut’s a costume and your shoulders are a room you don’t fit in.” It’s not the subject I expect. I feel the room tilt. I think of how I’ve always liked being the broad-shouldered one, the one who opens the door, the one who puts her hand on the small of a back and circles to the front. I think of how that assertiveness is a muscle I’ve trained, how it’s my mouth that says yes or no, not my eyes. “Sometimes,” I say, careful. “When I was twelve, I wanted to be a boy because I thought it would get me the girls I wanted. Then I realized I didn’t need to be a boy to do that.” I chuckle, and it lands flat and honest in the red light. “I like being a woman. I like… the heft of it, the way it sits on me. But sometimes I catch a glimpse and there’s a stranger there. I’m not sure that’s gender, or just… being human.” He leans his hip against the counter, tongs dangling like an extra limb. His eyes are huge in this light. “I think I’m at the beginning of something,” he says. “I don’t know what it is. I cut my hair last month. Everyone thinks that’s what’s wrong with me. But it’s not. It’s like I’m a film someone developed with the wrong chemicals. I can see shapes, but I don’t know what the image is.” That humming again, like he needs a note to anchor himself. I lean against the opposite counter and feel the cool through my shirt. I want to ask: who else have you told? Instead, I say, “Do you want me to call you something different?” He looks at me then, so suddenly I have to fight the urge to look away. “No,” he says. “I don’t know. Not yet. I wanted to tell you because… because you look at things and name them. And it seemed like if I put it in your mouth, it would… make it… I don’t know.” He trails off. The darkroom is a church. The red light feels like stained glass. “I can be quiet,” I say. I mean it. It’s hard as hell to say. “I don’t have to name it.” He exhales, and it’s a laugh without the laugh. “You see? Decisive.” He sets the print in the washer. The water runs, the sound almost tender. “I don’t know how to be in a room with someone and not… become what they need me to be. You’re the first person who hasn’t told me what I am yet and I… like that. It makes me want to know. For myself.” I swallow. My chest aches with something bright and sharp-edged. I want to step across the space between us and put my hand over his, which is something I would do with anyone else with only a second’s hesitation. I want to be a little bit reckless. I want to protect him. It occurs to me for the first time that those desires might be the same thing. “I can hold,” I say. “If that’s what you need. If you need space, I can give you a shape to push against and you can define yourself on it.” “That sounds terrifying,” he says, but he’s smiling. His mouth is soft. God, how many times have I studied that mouth when he chews his bottom lip over the enlarger focus? “But good.” “Terrifying but good is my brand,” I say. My voice is lighter than I feel. I glance down at the tray we abandoned. The un-burned corner shines a cleaner white than the other copies strewn like footprints on the table. It’s better. He was right to try both. I was right to make room. “Can I ask you something?” he says again. “You just did,” I tease on instinct, then regret it because humor deflects. “Yeah. Ask.” “Do you like me?” His voice is the sound you make when you split a secret in half to see the grain. It’s not coy. It’s not a trap. It’s a serious question, as earnest as that humming. I open my mouth and three different answers jostle, none of them the decisive no or yes I’ve used like a blade. I like how you look in lace. I like the way you listen with your whole body. I like that you are a soft person in sharp clothing. I like that I cannot stop thinking about you. I like that you’re not a shape I know already. “Yes,” I say, and hope the rest can fit under that word for now. “I like you.” He watches my face the way he watches paper develop—patient, intent, as if trusting the image to arrive. “I like you too,” he says. He picks up the tongs and taps them against the metal edge, ticks like a metronome. “I don’t know what I want from you. I don’t know if I want you to touch me so I can know what that feels like as me, or if I want to be close to you in the dark where nothing has to be decided.” I breathe in fixer, air sharp in my throat. It’s hard to sit in not-knowing. My body is a lit fuse most of the time, my certainty a spark. But there’s a luxury to this—someone letting me be a question too. “We can do both,” I say. “Not tonight, not necessarily. Or yes tonight, gently, if you want. We can make rules. We can make as many prints as we need to get the exposure right.” He laughs for real then, a small thing that sounds like something breaking and reforming. He nods, looks down. He reaches with his free hand and touches my sleeve, fingers barely grazing. It’s nothing and everything at once, a brush of fabric, a wave against the shore. I feel it all the way up my arm. “Okay,” he says. “Rules. I like that. Can rule number one be you tell me if I’m… getting it wrong?” “I don’t think there’s wrong here,” I say, and then amend, because I believe in precision, “Unless you stop telling me what you need. Then that would be wrong.” He nods again. His thumb rubs along the seam of my sleeve like he’s reading braille. “And you?” “I need you to tell me when to stop,” I say, because I know myself, because I know the urge to do, to fix, to press. “And I need to know what name to call you tomorrow, even if it’s the same as today.” He looks up and that look is it, the thing I couldn’t name in the studio when he wore the velvet and the chipped polish and answered every question like he was tasting his words first. It’s recognition. It’s both of us seeing the outline and agreeing to stay long enough for it to fill in. “Tomorrow,” he says, thoughtful. He hums, softer. The tune hangs in the red light like a thread. “Tomorrow, still Elliot. He/him. And maybe I look at that binder ad again and try not to make a joke to survive it.” “I can go with you,” I say, casual like I’m offering to carry his prints to the drying rack. My heart is thrown and caught in my chest. “To the store. Or share links. Or measure you. Whatever you want.” His mouth quirks. “I like it when you measure things,” he says, and somehow it’s a tease and praise and a confession. He releases my sleeve and steps back into himself. “I should… we should rinse and hang.” We do. We move around each other in that choreographed way you learn in tiny spaces: you reach for the squeegee, I tilt my body around yours, neither of us touching more than necessary, both of us aware of the air that moves when we cross it. We clip the prints to the line. Water gathers and falls from their corners, a tempo to his humming. In the red light, the images hang like wet ghosts. In one, his hand reflected in a puddle looks like wings. In another, my silhouette bends over an enlarger like I’m praying. None of them are perfect. All of them are true. “Your highlights held,” I say, uselessly pleased, looking at the copy we didn’t burn. “I told you the corner would go muddy.” “You did,” he says. He smiles at the print like you do for a kid doing something simple and brave. “Thank you.” “For what?” “For not making me decide to be something just because you want it,” he says quietly. He turns to me, all soft edges in red light. “And for wanting me anyway.” I reach for the timer, press the reset, watch the numbers stutter to zero. I could kiss him. That was the plan, wasn’t it? Get him under a light, under my hands, be decisive. I could put my palm on his covered sternum and feel the hum there and say mine in the way I’ve learned to say it without frightening anyone. Instead, I step into his space and let my shoulder touch his shoulder. Half an inch. A line of warmth. It’s a small contact that feels like a vow. “I’ll want you if you change,” I say. “I’ll want you if you don’t. I’ll want you while you figure it out. That’s the shape of the want right now.” He breathes. I feel it, the rise and fall along my arm, like we’re a diptych hung slightly crooked, edges touching. He nods again, and I know this is what I’m taking away: I can be decisive and still leave room. I can be the person who names things and also be quiet until the word arrives. We stand there under the red light with the prints swinging gently, with the chemicals binding to silver, with his humming threading in and out of the soft machinery noises. It’s close to midnight. Outside, the world will try to define him tomorrow. It will try to define me too, the same way it always has. For now, our faces are pools of warmth and shadow, our shoulders warm against each other, our mouths unkissed and untangled. “This is good,” he says eventually, and I realize he means the prints, and us, and the terrible wonderful not-knowing. I nod. I keep my mouth shut. I’m learning to love the slowly revealing image. I’m learning to wait until it appears.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures Dani's perspective as she navigates her complex attraction to Elliot during their darkroom sessions. The piece excels in creating a distinctive voice for Dani that balances assertiveness with vulnerability, perfectly matching the character description in the prompt. The darkroom setting is masterfully utilized as both physical space and metaphor. The red light creates the "confessional atmosphere" requested, and the photography process serves as an extended metaphor for identity development and revelation. Lines like "I can see shapes, but I don't know what the image is" effectively connect the photographic process to Elliot's gender exploration. Character development is nuanced and authentic. Dani's internal struggle between her natural assertiveness and her desire to give Elliot agency is well-portrayed: "I want to step across the space between us and put my hand over his, which is something I would do with anyone else with only a second's hesitation." The narrative successfully explores how Dani's attraction to Elliot challenges her understanding of her own identity and typical attractions. The dialogue feels natural and reveals character. Elliot's vulnerability comes through in his hesitant speech patterns and thoughtful questions, while Dani's responses show her trying to balance directness with sensitivity. Their conversation about gender identity feels authentic rather than didactic. The prose is elegant without being overwrought. Sensory details like "The developer smells like pennies and old rain" create immersion. The author skillfully uses sentence length variation to control pacing and emotional impact. The narrative avoids common pitfalls. There are no unearned transformations—both characters remain consistent while showing growth. The ending is appropriately tentative rather than artificially positive, reflecting the "uncharted territory" mentioned in the prompt. The piece shows rather than tells, allowing readers to understand characters through their actions, thoughts, and dialogue. One minor critique is that occasionally the metaphors become slightly dense, risking purple prose. For example, "His mouth is soft. God, how many times have I studied that mouth when he chews his bottom lip over the enlarger focus?" followed by several other observations could be streamlined. However, these moments are rare and generally fit Dani's artistic perspective. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that fulfills all the prompt requirements while creating a moving, authentic exploration of attraction, identity, and vulnerability. The writing demonstrates sophisticated craft in voice, metaphor, character development, and emotional complexity. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 20 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 20 Emotionally Complex: 20 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 20
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 20.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 20.0, Emotionally Complex: 20.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 20.0
+ Contemporary romance / drama: Stolen Moments in Roma — Score: 94.1
Prompt:
Contemporary Romance / Drama: Stolen Moments in Roma. Write a series of interconnected short scenes and dialogues that span a single day in modern-day Rome, in narrative form. This will form the beginning of a larger story. Alessandra, a fiery, independent Roman woman who works as a motorcycle courier, nearly collides with Ben, a somewhat clumsy, overly polite British academic on sabbatical, who is engrossed in a guidebook near the Trevi Fountain. The initial encounter is a clash of cultures and personalities – Alessandra is all sharp wit and rapid-fire Italian, while Ben is flustered apologies and awkward attempts at speaking the language. However, as they sort out the near-miss, a spark of unexpected humor and connection emerges. Alessandra, it quickly becomes clear, is a whirlwind of energy and mischief. She's a self-admitted troublemaker with a secret penchant for kleptomania, a detail she doesn't explicitly reveal, but which manifests in subtle, daring acts throughout the day. She impulsively decides to take Ben on a wild, unsanctioned tour of Rome, dragging him in some specific instances far outside his comfort zone. Ben, despite his initial apprehension and inherent politeness, finds himself utterly captivated by Alessandra's unapologetic spirit and zest for life. He is drawn into her orbit, a willing participant in increasingly outlandish situations, a quiet rebellion brewing beneath his scholarly exterior. The narrative should primarily consist of short, vivid scenes and dialogue exchanges, revealing their contrasting personalities and backgrounds, and the growing, ambiguous tension between them. Ben is captivated by Alessandra's energy and the thrill of breaking free from his routine. There's a clear sense that Alessandra is toying with Ben, pushing his boundaries and enjoying his reactions, but her own feelings remain somewhat enigmatic. The day should be a rollercoaster of exhilarating, slightly dangerous, and humorous moments, leaving Ben completely disoriented but utterly smitten. Explore the underlying tension & chemistry between them, culminating in some payoff as they part ways (or not -- your choice). Include this detail: Write in narrative prose, using immersive storytelling. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The Vespa skims a slick patch of coins spilled from a tourist’s upturned fountain hat, the back wheel fishtails, and Alessandra cuts the engine hard. The bike kisses the edge of a guidebook held at a lethal reading distance from a man with a linen shirt creased in honest lines. He hops backward, drops the book. It slaps the cobbles. Someone gasps. The Trevi groans on, indifferent. “Ma sei matto?” Alessandra’s helmet visor pops up. She’s all eyes, fast and bright, cheeks flushed from speed. “Vuoi morire oggi? Nel mio turno?” The man’s mouth opens, closes. His ears run a pink flag. “I’m terribly—dear God—I’m very sorry. I stepped right into—er—traffic?” “Pedoni che leggono non sono pedoni,” she fires, one boot on the ground, an impatient drumbeat. “Sono problemi.” “Pedoni who… read are—problems?” He attempts Italian like he’s testing thin ice. “Sono—problemi. Sì. Lo—lo capisco. Mi chiamo Ben.” The last word tumbles out like a confession. “Alessandra.” She says it like a dare. Her eyes skim him: bookish, sun-stunned, the kind of man who would color-code his footnotes. He’s holding the guidebook to his chest now like a shield. On its spine: Roma: Storia e Sassi. “Stones,” she says, tapping the book with one gloved finger. “You came to Rome for rocks?” “Among other things,” Ben says, finding his breath, and then fumbling it again as she swings a leg off the Vespa with practiced grace. She lands too close, enough for him to smell petrol and orange blossom. “Bene. You almost died—without seeing anything properly.” She flicks her chin toward the fountain. “You look at it, you take a photo, you go home and show your mother. This is not a life.” “I thought it was very beautiful,” he says, defensively show-and-tell. He gestures, finds nothing to gesture at but water and tourists. “It is. But also it wants to empty your pockets while you stare.” She glances at the coins glinting like small suns in the pool. “I like things that want something.” “You're—are you a tour guide?” Ben’s eyes move from her boots to the scratch on her Vespa’s flank, the angry little heart scuffed into the paint. He imagines a life of tight corners and late arrivals. He wants to apologize again, fully, for existing in her blind spot. She grins. “I deliver things. People, sometimes, when they look interesting.” Ben blinks. The afternoon light jostles itself on the stones. “Right.” “Come.” She holds his book hostage with one hand, swings onto the Vespa with the other. “You owe me a caffè for not killing you.” “I—what? I can just buy you one.” He reaches for his wallet. She revs the throttle; the Vespa purrs like a cat. People move around them, the city’s pulse unbothered. “I prefer transport.” She pats the seat behind her, all command. “Up.” “I’ve never—” He gestures at the Vespa. “Do I just—” “Climb. Hold. Pray to your queen.” She pulls an extra helmet from under the seat and tosses it to him. It’s scratched to the point of charm. He wedges it on. It wobbles. She fastens his chinstrap herself, her fingers swift, a quick intimate indignity that steals his breath more than the near-miss had. He climbs on. The seat is narrow. The city lunges forward. He puts his hands awkwardly on the air near her waist. “Closer, professore,” she murmurs without turning. “Rome likes commitment.” They slip into the veins of traffic, past a vendor hawking neon selfie sticks, a couple kissing with admirable focus, a priest with gelato. Wind does democratic things to his hair. He laughs once, short and startled, at the sudden vulnerability of moving fast on something that seems held together by bravado and stickers. At a stand-up bar tucked into a red-stone alley, she slides to a halt with the flair of a signature. The barista is a man with a mustache that could host small birds. Alessandra orders two espressos without asking, taps the porcelain with her fingernail like it owes her rent. “To almost dying,” she says, and slams it back. He copies, chokes, fights tears. She pats his back, smug and gentle. “Does everyone drive like you?” he croaks. “Only the good ones,” she says. “So. Why are you here? Besides rocks.” “A sabbatical.” The word relaxes his shoulders, half shield, half luxury. “I’m supposed to be… thinking.” “About?” “The way cities remember themselves,” he says, surprising himself with the honesty of the sentence. “Streets as palimpsests. Layers. Old roads beneath new asphalt. That sort of thing.” “You sound like my grandmother when she’s drunk.” Alessandra’s smile is quicksilver. “Come. I will show you what the city forgets on purpose.” He tosses the little spoon once, feeling silly and alive. She’s already pocketed it with a movement like a magician’s inhale. He doesn’t see it. He will notice later, patting his pockets for a pen, finding a spoon instead. For now, he just follows. They buzz down Via del Corso and into narrower arteries, the air a soup of heat and basil. Alessandra rides like a dancer, light on the hips, heavy on the intent. She cuts through a knot of buses; they are a pin threading fabric. Ben’s fingers tighten on her jacket. She laughs, a spark in his ear. He has the thought that he will never be this precise again in his entire life. She parks the Vespa on a crosswalk with the cheerful lawlessness of the beloved. “You can’t—” he starts, then stops. She’s already pulling him by the wrist like a child into a church. Inside, it is cool and dim and smells of stone and saints. The ribs of the ceiling are knuckled with age. “Santa Maria sopra Minerva,” she says. “Pietà at the altar. Elephants outside being ridiculous. But here—” She guides him to a side chapel fragmented with light. There is a small marble foot, ancient and elegant, surviving without its body. He steps closer, reverent despite himself. “A foot,” he says, and then, quieter: “A perfect foot.” “She is a goddess turned to a relic turned to a curiosity. Rome is a woman who refuses to go quietly,” Alessandra says, picking invisible lint from his sleeve with an intimacy that is pretend and alarmingly real. Her fingers ghost his wrist. “You like old toes. Okay.” “You’re mocking me,” he says, but he’s smiling. It’s an unfamiliar stretch of muscle. Outside, the elephants squat under obelisks like penitent circus performers. Alessandra points at one, then to a man selling postcards. She crosses the small square, chats quick and affectionate. The man calls her “tesoro,” and winks at Ben over her shoulder. They leave with a handful of postcards and a lemon the color of scandal, which he does not recall paying for. He opens his mouth. She bites the lemon, laughs at his face, and insists he try. He does. They puckered-suffer together until laughter spills everywhere. “Where to next?” Ben asks, and realizes with a tremor that he never asks this question with real curiosity. In his life, the itinerary is a lullaby and a leash. “Il mercato,” she says. “To educate your English taste buds.” The market is a chaos of reds and greens, voices rising like bread. They cover his eyes and make him taste things. “Fichi?” she bets. He says “plums” because they are purple and sweet. She shakes her head, triumphant and affectionate. A fishmonger whistles, throws a silver body into the air and catches it like a coin. She moves like a rumor and an apology, touching nothing and everything. Somewhere in the blur she lifts a jar of artichokes, slides it into the pocket of her jacket with the quick intimacy of habit. Ben loses her in the press, finds her at a table speaking to a woman with a brass crucifix and a laugh like a bell. They trade words, hands, something small and folded. “This is Lucia,” Alessandra says, the name pronounced with four extra vowels, eyes framed in warmth. “She makes miracles with eggplants.” Lucia eyes Ben with frank curiosity and an unkind smile that’s not unkind, not really. “Allie, you bring new boys like seasons.” She turns to Ben. “You have nice fingers. For writing. For pointing at things. For counting coins.” “Lucia,” Alessandra warns, but she smiles anyway, a crack showing through the mischief. “And you,” Lucia continues, tapping Ben’s knuckles with an eggplant like a gavel, “watch your wallet. And your heart. One she steals for sport, one by accident. She returns neither quickly.” Ben looks at Alessandra. She lifts a shoulder, unbothered by her indictment. “I always return the coins,” she says. “Eventually.” “Not before you buy cigarettes and flowers,” Lucia says, rolling her eyes so hard heaven must shudder. She squeezes Ben’s hand once. It feels like both a welcome and a warning. “Eat something. The city hurts less with olive oil inside you.” They sit on crates and eat eggplant sandwiches greasy as miracles. Oil climbs their wrists. Alessandra licks a line from her forearm with shameless practicality. Ben watches and swallows, not just the food. “You’re very—” he starts, searching for a word that is not reckless or cruel. “Alive.” “E tu?” she asks. “Are you alive, professore?” He thinks of his tidy flat in Bloomsbury, the sighing boiler, the way he always puts his keys in the same bowl. He thinks of footnotes like obedient soldiers. He thinks of the way she took corners and the way his stomach dropped into his shoes in a way that wasn’t entirely unpleasant. “I am,” he says, as if he’s deciding, and it feels true in his mouth. They flash past the Coliseum and don’t stop, because stopping would make it a postcard. She takes him up a hill where Rome is a secret beneath them, domes like knuckles, streets like veins, the river looping lazy as a cat. She steals a sprig of rosemary from an old woman’s balcony while the woman is watering geraniums. The woman catches her, shakes a fist, and then laughs, and throws down a lemon. Alessandra bows like a thief must: theatrical and grateful. “Do you always do that?” Ben asks quietly when they’re out of reach of the balcony’s shade. “Do what?” She tucks the rosemary into his breast pocket, close to where his heart is, if he remembers correctly. “Take things.” “I take my time,” she says. “I take choices. I take people out of their heads. Sometimes I take rosemary because it smells like kitchens and grandmothers. Sometimes I forget to put money on the counter. Rome takes, too. She teaches bad manners.” He wants to say: Be careful. He wants to say: Me too. Instead he says, “It looks good there,” and touches the green against the white of his shirt like it’s a boutonniere. She watches his fingers, then his face, and the air shifts by a degree neither of them acknowledges. They descend to Trastevere, where walls are tattooed with ivy and argument. They walk now, the Vespa asleep and leaning against a no-parking sign like a satisfied animal. A violinist plays a song that belongs to a country that may o may not exist. Alessandra buys two gelati with coins that materialize like rabbits. Ben swears he had more a moment ago and then catches her glance, lazy and sharp, as she presses a wad of warm euros into his hand without looking, all sleight of palm and thin humor. “Is this—” He starts. “Shhh,” she says. “Gelato melts while you ask questions.” He tastes pistachio, finds religion. She smears some on the tip of his nose like a five-year-old and tells him to take life less seriously. He pretends to be offended, dabs his nose with dignity, fails, licks it off, laughs, loses. The light turns gold, then honey, then something molten that makes everyone beautiful and everything forgiven. They end up on a bridge. Below them the Tiber slides toward history. The city hums a lullaby written by exhaust and swallows. Alessandra leans against the parapet, her boot toe worrying a chip of stone like a secret habit. Ben takes out the guidebook without looking down to find it, as if it’s grown into his arm. “Tell me something true,” she says, out of nowhere. “I’m scared,” he hears himself say, before he can tidy it into something academic. “I’m thirty-eight and I’ve never... done anything that couldn’t be undone. I’ve always had—exits.” She considers this, the angles of her face holding the confession like they might reject it, taste it, keep it. “You almost died today,” she offers. “That can’t be undone.” “I nearly died being foolish and looking at some rocks.” “You nearly died because you were not looking.” She touches the guidebook’s spine. “You can’t read the city and be in it at the same time.” “And you?” he asks, quietly. “Tell me something true.” She looks down at the river, flicks a coin—not a coin, he realizes when it arcs in a sun flick, but a metro token—into the water. “I sleep badly,” she says. “And I count things when I can’t: stairs, doors, names in my phone. It helps.” “That’s not—” “Enough?” She shrugs, a whole philosophy in the lift of a shoulder. “It is what I can leave today.” He wants to say he wants more; instead he says, “Grazie.” Night folds. They drift to a square where a man juggles knives and a child decides to clap at the wrong time. Alessandra whispers in the juggler’s ear between throws; suddenly he’s using lemons. Ben suspects, wildly, that he knows where they came from. A policeman ambles by, unimpressed. Alessandra’s hand finds Ben’s elbow when the knives flash toward them, not protective, not needing to be, but there. On the steps of a church, an old acquaintance becomes a hazard. He appears like a ghost called by gossip, all narrow eyes and a slick jacket. His name is Marco because of course it is. “Allie,” he says with a grin that’s half debt. He looks at Ben like one looks at a museum installation: interesting, possibly expensive, not to be touched. “Who’s the professor?” “Marco,” she says, unamused, which makes Ben’s chest warm for reasons that have nothing to do with propriety. “Go find someone else’s cigarettes to steal.” Marco smirks and turns to Ben as if she hasn’t spoken. “Careful, inglese.” His English is syrupy with the need to impress. “She will borrow your life and forget where she put it.” “Like your car keys?” Alessandra says sweetly. “I still have that Fiat Panda in my garage. It misses you.” He laughs, like he can’t help it. He still looks at Ben. “She is all spark and matches. You are paper. Boom.” Ben surprises himself. “Perhaps some paper wants to burn,” he says, voice too mild to be a threat but not quite safe. Marco cackles and lifts his hands, backing away. “Bravi. Buona fortuna,” he says, meaning the opposite and also entirely the same. Alessandra’s smile for Ben after he’s gone is brief and not at all victorious. Something like apology skims it, then vanishes. They end where they began: at a fountain—but not Trevi. Smaller, tucked behind the shadow of a church, where locals throw in wishes because tourists forget it exists. She cuts the engine, and silence lays its hand on them. It is late. The city exhales. “I should go,” she says, and for the first time in hours, the words sound like a possibility she doesn’t like. “Mamma’s pasta doesn’t wait. And I have work in the morning.” There’s a list of deliveries in the breast pocket of her jacket, folded and refolded until it behaves. Ben nods, pretends he can do normal things like walk to his rented room without falling off himself. “Right.” She reaches into her jacket and returns the guidebook, which he didn’t notice she’d taken. A small freckle of guilt dots her smile. Or maybe he imagined it. “Keep reading,” she says. “But sometimes, don’t.” “I could—” He swallows. “I could see you again.” It sounds foreign and brave. It sounds like a question asked at an airport. She considers, not teasing. Her eyes do a quick arithmetic he isn’t invited to. She takes his hand, writes a number on his palm with a pen that appears like a bird. Her handwriting is impatient and tender. It says ALESSANDRA and a sequence of digits that will either ruin him or fix him. “And, professore,” she adds, the mischief back like morning, “check your pockets later. I may have stolen something you’ll miss.” “Such as?” he asks, half-smiling, willing himself not to pat at his pockets like a pantomime. She steps close, presses a kiss to his cheek, quick and burning. It’s a theft and a gift. In the second of contact, he realizes she’s slipped something into his jacket—the artichoke jar? A rosemary sprig? Faith? She pulls back with that fox’s grin and the night clings to her like applause. “Your exits,” she says simply, and swings onto the Vespa. She is gone before he can respond properly, the Vespa’s red tail-light a heartbeat flicker swallowed by Rome. He stands with his hand on his cheek as if heat could be bottled. He is thinking of palimpsests, yes, and of feet, and of rosemary, and of knives spun into lemons. He opens his guidebook and a silver spoon, still sticky with sugar, falls into his palm. He laughs, standing there alone at a fountain that isn’t famous, while Rome remembers
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkably well-crafted contemporary romance that captures the essence of Rome and the contrasting personalities of its protagonists with exceptional skill. The narrative successfully creates a vivid, immersive experience of a single day in Rome through interconnected scenes that flow naturally from one to the next. The characterization is particularly strong. Alessandra emerges as a fully realized character - fiery, impulsive, and complex with her kleptomania subtly woven throughout the narrative rather than explicitly stated. Her character is revealed through actions: pocketing spoons, artichoke jars, and even Ben's guidebook. Ben's character development from a cautious academic to someone willing to step outside his comfort zone is handled with nuance and believability. His transformation feels earned through the experiences of the day. The prose is elegant without being overwrought. The writer employs vivid, sensory details that bring Rome to life: "The market is a chaos of reds and greens, voices rising like bread," and "The light turns gold, then honey, then something molten that makes everyone beautiful and everything forgiven." These descriptions create a rich sensory experience without becoming purple prose. The dialogue is exceptional - sharp, character-revealing, and often witty. Alessandra's "Pedoni che leggono non sono pedoni. Sono problemi" perfectly captures her character, as does Ben's more measured speech. Their exchanges reveal their personalities and build the chemistry between them naturally. The narrative structure works beautifully, with the day unfolding through a series of vignettes that build upon each other. The pacing is excellent, with moments of action, reflection, and connection balanced throughout. The ending is particularly strong, with Alessandra's parting words about stealing Ben's "exits" providing a perfect thematic conclusion that ties back to his earlier confession. The piece successfully incorporates the requested elements: Alessandra's kleptomania, Ben's growing fascination with her, and the cultural clash between them. The chemistry between the characters is palpable but not overdone, with tension building naturally throughout their day together. If there are any weaknesses, they are minor. Occasionally, a metaphor might be slightly strained ("Rome is a woman who refuses to go quietly"), but these instances are rare and don't detract from the overall quality of the writing. Overall, this is an exceptional piece of contemporary romance writing that creates a vivid sense of place, develops complex characters, and builds a compelling relationship between them. The writing is sophisticated, engaging, and emotionally resonant. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Cozy sci-fi: The Last Outpost — Score: 89.5
Prompt:
Cozy sci-fi The Last Outpost Nettle (or Nets to her friends) bartends at The Last Outpost -- a lazy hub for miners and merchants in an asteroid belt on the Andromeda outer rim. Escaping from her past life, Nets found a home here at the Outpost. They have, thus far, tolerated Net's flaws which she tries to keep in equilibrium with her assortment of talents. Her evenings involve chatting with patrons, negotiating the drama, intrigue, problems & love lives of the diverse crowd that filter through the Outpost. Tonight is no different, at least, until a frazzled looking stranger, tentacled dreads askew, quietly plops down at the bar: "Vega whisky, neat. Better make that a double." Write a chapter in this story. Establish conflict for narrative interest. Don't resolve the conflict within this chapter. Aim for about 60% dialogue. First person, present tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
It’s the end of shift o’clock, which is to say no time at all. The chrono over the bottle wall blinks amber—Docking Vector 3’s auto-schedule hiccup again—and the air feels half-sleepy, like everything is holding its breath. The Last Outpost hums, as always: heat exchangers whispering, keynotes tapping from booth gamblers, someone’s cuff comm buzzing a staccato rhythm nobody answers. I’ve got one hand on the rag and one eye on the heroes’ row: the particularly industrious trio of miners from Hold 6 who will tell you, for the price of a beer, that they invented the belt. “—and what I said was, that’s not a fracture stripe, that’s a vein,” Yula says, slapping the bar with the side of her palm. Her rings tick group time. “You can tell by how it glistens.” “Glistens,” Orin echoes, as if saying the word makes him a geologist. He eyes his glass like it’s glistening too. “Veins don’t glisten, they gleam,” I say, wiping the same spot on the bar until it shines. The spot doesn’t care. Neither do I. “Another round or shall I start charging you for vocabulary lessons?” Yula grins, mouth full of cracked tooth and glory. “Another, Nets. And toss in a bit of that passionfruit syrup. Fancy like.” Orin makes a face. “Fruit’s for merchants.” “Fruit is for people who don’t want scurvy,” I say, already pouring. The syrup is sticky-sweet. It sneaks up on the back of the tongue and convinces your forebrain you had dessert when what you actually had was sugar and regret. “You paying, Yula?” She tilts her chin toward Pallas, the quiet third in their little trinity, who never pays but keeps an inventory in her head that would make a quartermaster weep. Pallas shrugs, slides me a folded chit. I tap it with the ring I wear for tapping chits. It chirps, unamused, and credits shift quietly into their slot. “You hear about the glitch in Dock 3?” Orin says, which means he very much wants me to hear about the glitch in Dock 3. “Someone walked a crate right through the customs blind spot.” “Mm,” I say, which in this bar means both yes and no and go on, you have my love for ten seconds. “Squid,” Yula says around her sip. “Security’ll be poking things, and I came here to drink, not to answer questions.” “Then stop stealing crates,” I tell her. She laughs so hard she almost inhales passionfruit. The door sighs. A breeze from the corridor swirls stale oxygen with the scents of ionized dust and vacuum grease. He slides onto a stool like a dropped note, quiet and sudden, and all my careful humming fuzzes around the edges. Tentacled dreads tucked messy under a knit cap gone a shade darker with travel grime. Face soft-boned, mid-thirties maybe, eyes like the Belt before the sun hits it—pale, sleepless, more horizon than surface. “Vega whisky, neat,” he says, voice low, like sound is something you might spill. “Better make that a double.” “Doubles are for apologies,” I say, because the patter comes whether I want it or not. I keep wiping the spot. It keeps not getting cleaner. “You apologizing?” He blinks at me slowly. “Preemptively.” I set the rag aside long enough to retrieve the Vega. The bottle itself is a joke: smoky glass with beveled edges, blue label you can feel with your eyes closed. The whisky is not a joke. It smells like the inside of a comet miner’s glove: leather and cold spice, the faint memory of something alive. I pour two fingers twice, set it in front of him. “Tab?” I ask. “Mm.” He slides a card across the counter with his index finger, like it might bite him. It’s passed through too many hands. The name on it is blank. The chip glows thinly. I tap it with the ring. It chirps, delayed, like it had to think about it. “Friends call you what?” I say. I accrue names like bottle caps. They weigh nothing until they start to rattle. He stares into the whisky the way some people pray. For a heartbeat I think he might not answer. “Net,” Orin calls from three stools down, saving me from myself. “Tell Pallas there’s no way a K-class hull can take a mining-grade harpoon without compromising the beltline. Tell her. She’ll listen to you.” “Pallas,” I say without looking, “in this house we respect harpoons but we do not trust them. Take that sentence however you like.” I glance back at the stranger. He doesn’t smile. He drinks. “Friends call me Mal,” he says finally. The kind of name that’s either short for something sweet or long for something unpronounceable. He sets the glass down with care. “If they’re friends.” “Mal it is,” I say, and I go back to wiping my spot. It’s a good minute—two maybe—before he speaks again. People come to the Outpost to be listened to. They come for the drink and the noise and the lit rectangle of space behind the bar and the assurance that nothing you say here will follow you to your bunk unless you want it to. They come to tell me things they should tell other people. Sometimes I am the wall the ocean talks to. Sometimes I am the ocean. Tonight I am the rag on its way to clean the same speck of imaginary dirt. “The last place I was,” Mal says, voice roughened to the edges, “there was a sign over the bar: ‘Absolutely No Questions.’ They meant it.” “We have a sign,” I say. “It says, ‘No Slug Wrestling.’ People ignore it.” “I’d prefer… no questions,” he says, eyes flicking to the door like a habit. “You’re in luck. I charge extra for questions,” I say, and give him my politest lie. “What makes it preemptive?” He huffs. It might be a laugh. It might be air. “This is a problem coming at me, Nets.” He used my name like he already knew it. Maybe he read the etched tag pinned to my jumpsuit. Maybe he’s been here before and I didn’t notice. The whole point of starting over is the illusion that no one knows you. I adjust a glass that doesn’t need adjusting. “Most problems go better with whisky,” I offer. “This one prefers vacuum,” he says. He drinks again. He doesn’t savor it. He uses it like a door. “Say you were a courier,” he says, staring into the bottle wall. “Say you ran locks for people who thought locks would save them. Say you were good. Very good. Say that made you careless.” “I’d say you’re talking too much for a man who doesn’t want questions,” I murmur. “I am,” he agrees, and for the first time there’s a crack in his voice. “It’s not for me.” The miners have shifted to an argument about melody versus noise in asteroid hollows. The booth in the back where the smugglers sit when they are pretending to be traders is occupied by traders pretending to be smugglers. Mazin, with the three-lens eyes and the habit of tapping his lower molars when he lies, is conspicuously absent. Now I am inventorying the room, too, not just because I can do it in my sleep but because it keeps my hands moving, keeps the rag sliding over the same high-polish spot. “Net,” Yula says, leaning in, breath like passionfruit and carbon. “You ever see a life-tube that looked like a crate?” “Depends on the crate,” I say. Mal's shoulder twitches, so small you’d call it a pulse. He doesn’t look at Yula. He looks at his glass. “Because,” Yula continues, “Dock 3’s glitchy. And Pallas saw—” “Pallas sees everything,” I say, to head off the inevitable. Pallas shakes her head, her face unreadable through a fall of hair like spun copper wire. “Pallas sees patterns in noise. Best you can hope for.” “I saw a crate,” Pallas says, voice mild and clear, meant for me but loud enough to carry. “I saw it breathe.” “Crates don’t—” Orin begins. “—unless someone drilled holes in them,” I say. My smile has edges. “You’re all opening tabs you can’t pay.” Mal wipes condensation off his glass. His hands are good hands. Scar on the knuckle, a thin pale line down the palm, the scars couriers get, the ones you can’t explain at family dinners. The kind of scars I don’t have anymore because I don’t go to family dinners. “Mal,” I say, pitched low. “If you’re about to make my life interesting, you should know I’m already married. To boredom.” “It won’t touch you,” he says. “If I can help it.” “People say that,” I say. “You’re not the first tonight to say that.” He looks up at me then, full-on. The look is a map someone else traced with their finger and forgot to erase. “Look,” he says. “I took a job. I didn’t ask questions. Stupid. I should have. Now the people who paid me think I double-crossed them. The people I delivered to think I’m leverage. And the thing between them—” “Thing,” I say, echoing his lack of specificity. “Girl,” he says, not looking at me. The word is a flinch. “Not human. Not… I don’t know. But she didn’t ask for any of it. And if I leave her where she is, she dies. If I take her, I die. If I do nothing, someone else dies. I came here because—” He stops. “Because no one looks too hard at the Outpost,” I say. “Because you don’t look too hard,” he corrects gently. I realize the rag is dry. I’ve been polishing dry wood for the last thirty seconds. The spot shines anyway. It learns quickly. “Mal,” I say. “You picking up what I’m putting down? This bar has a no-slug-wrestling policy, but we make exceptions for eels.” He blinks at me. “That a yes?” “That’s me telling you that whatever you tell me now ties me to it,” I say. “I don’t tangle with unknowns.” “You already are,” he says, and we both look at the door when it sighs again. Two station security in grey-blue step in like a pause dropped into a sentence. Not the rent-a-cops in plastic armor; the real ones, the ones who move like they know where all the exits are without looking. Keelens: big, four-armed, exoskeleton lacquered to a neat shine. Their translator units burble as they adjust to bar acoustics. Behind them, a slender human woman with a scarf that has its own weather leans into the threshold and tastes the room with her eyes. “Nettle,” she says, using the full name like a knife laid on a table between friends. “How’s business?” I smile like I’ve never smiled better in my life. “We’re out of slugs,” I say. “You’ll have to come back tomorrow.” Her smile is thinner than mine. “Heard you had a glitch in Dock 3. Thought I’d ask if my favorite bartender noticed anything.” “I notice many things,” I say. “Mostly that people don’t tip.” The Keelens shift. One taps the counter with their lower-left hand, curiosity knocking. The sound is like a full glass set down on a hollow table. Mal’s shoulders lower by an imperceptible degree that is not relief. His hand slides under the bar lip like maybe he thinks I keep weapons there. I keep spoons. “Pallas,” the scarfed woman says, without looking. “You see anything?” “Do I look like station security?” Pallas calls, cheerful. She would make a good thief if she weren’t already a better something else. The scarfed woman’s eyes skitter over Mal and skid away, casual and trained. She’s good. She knows better than to look directly at a problem. She knows better than to look at me too long. That means she’s been here before. “We’ll keep it light,” she says. “Questions later. Drink now.” “On my dime?” I say. “On the Chief’s,” she says, and flicks a chit. It spins, lands square. The Keelens chortle, a sound like gravel poured into a tin bowl. The bar breathes again. People will always let themselves be bought a drink by the law. They think it absolves them. Mal doesn’t reach for his glass. He reaches for his bag at his feet, casual and trained, like maybe the thing he cares about is inside. The bag has scuffs in a pattern like the stars just outside the belt. I stop my hand in the act of reaching for a coaster and keep it hovering like an apology. “Nets,” he says, so quiet I’m not sure he said it. “What’s the opposite of a safe harbor?” “An outpost,” I say, and I realize I have decided without deciding. “We close in ten,” I tell the law. “Drink fast.” “Don’t rush on our account,” the scarfed woman says. She’s not leaving. She’s nesting. An alert pips on the wall behind me: Docking Vector 3 recalibrated. Secondary berth occupied. My stomach does a slow backflip into a pool of dead air. Yula mutters something about the ghost of the docks. Orin laughs because he is a man who laughs at ghosts. Pallas watches me like she’s never seen me before and like she always has. “Mal,” I say, and I keep my rag moving to give my mouth something to do. The spot gleams. “If someone comes in asking for you, who do I say?” “No one’s asking for me,” he says without missing a beat. “They’re asking for what I have.” “Which is?” He looks at me, and it’s full-on again, the map without the key. “A choice,” he says. “And I think I broke it.” Something buzzes under the bar. It’s not the fridge. It’s not the microbrew. It’s the little worn slate I keep for messages from people who don’t want their voices on air. It vibrates twice, then one long hum, the code for a not-friend with urgent intentions. I slide it up and glance. The text is plain, unpunctuated, cruel in its simplicity: Deliver the girl. Or we burn your bar. I hold the slate a second too long. My hand is steady. The rag keeps the orbit it has learned. The spot has no more shine to give. Outside the viewport the belt is black velvet studded with myth. In here the air tastes like old citrus and secrets. A miner laughs. A Keelen taps. The scarfed woman watches everything and nothing. Mal’s hand tightens on his bag. “Another?” I ask him, like all I did was pour drinks and not invite fire into my house. “Please,” he says. We both watch the steady, amber pour. I call it honey when I’m feeling poetic. Tonight it’s resin. Something is going to stick. I set the glass down. He doesn’t touch it. “Open late tonight?” the scarfed woman asks. “We’re always open,” I say. “Just sometimes we forget to be closed.” I pocket the slate. No one speaks. My rag keeps moving. The spot remains. The hum in the walls pitches up a notch, like the station is listening for something that hasn’t arrived yet. It will. They always do. I wipe, and wait, and pretend I know how to keep anything clean.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a cozy sci-fi atmosphere in a space bar setting, with strong first-person present tense narration as requested. The protagonist Nettle (Nets) is well-established as a bartender with a mysterious past who has found refuge at The Last Outpost. The writing excels at world-building through small details rather than exposition dumps - the miners, the security personnel, the technology, and the social dynamics all feel lived-in and authentic. The dialogue, which comprises roughly 60% of the text as requested, flows naturally and reveals character. Each speaker has a distinct voice - from the miners' technical banter to Mal's cryptic, guarded responses. The dialogue serves multiple purposes: establishing relationships, building tension, and advancing the plot without feeling forced. The conflict is introduced effectively through Mal's arrival and his cryptic situation involving a "girl" being transported, with multiple parties after him. The chapter ends with a clear threat ("Deliver the girl. Or we burn your bar") that raises the stakes without resolving anything, perfectly setting up future chapters. The prose is particularly strong, with evocative descriptions that create atmosphere without becoming purple: "The whisky is not a joke. It smells like the inside of a comet miner's glove: leather and cold spice, the faint memory of something alive." The author uses sensory details effectively to immerse readers in this alien environment. The narrative voice is consistent throughout - slightly world-weary, observant, and with a dry humor that feels authentic to someone who has seen too much. Metaphors like "Sometimes I am the wall the ocean talks to. Sometimes I am the ocean" add depth without feeling forced. Where the piece occasionally falters is in some overly clever turns of phrase that call attention to themselves rather than serving the story. A few metaphors feel slightly overwrought, and there are moments where the prose becomes a bit too self-conscious in its artistry. The recurring motif of the rag and the spot works well symbolically but is perhaps overused. The pacing is excellent, with tension building gradually through the chapter. The introduction of the security personnel and the final threat message create a compelling cliffhanger that makes the reader want to continue. Overall, this is a highly accomplished piece of creative writing that successfully fulfills the prompt requirements while creating an engaging narrative with well-drawn characters and a vivid setting. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Young adult drama: Gone South — Score: 90.7
Prompt:
Young adult drama Gone South Taylor is a 16 year old teen with a history of "concerning behavioural patterns" (or that's how the stupid smug school counsellor worded it on the phone call to Mom). It shouldn't be a surprise: When you live in a backwater town in Tennessee, your choices are: a. be mind-fuckingly bored, or b. invent some drama. Two days ago, Taylor came out to their family as trans. This disclosure was *not* in the category of invented drama -- it was, in fact, the real deal, and a long time coming. It didn't go well. The last 48 hours had been pure disaster. In a moment of desperate inspiration, Taylor had decided to get the hell out of dodge. And so an escape plan was hatched and executed within the space of 30 minutes. That was last night. Now Taylor was two states away, having been unceremoniously ejected from their hitched ride in downtown New Orleans. Write the next chapter in Taylor's story as they find their feet in this new environment. Tell the chapter over the course of their first day in New Orleans, in which Taylor meets another runaway with issues and secrets. Taylor navigates this new world, not knowing who to trust or what the dangers are. Write in Taylor's voice, and incorporate their internal monologue as they grapple with intense & conflicting emotions. Also incorporate dialogue with the interesting characters Taylor meets. First person, mixed tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The strap on my backpack keeps sliding off my shoulder like it’s trying to run away, too. I hitch it up again and it squeals against the sweat on my skin. It’s already hot at 9 a.m., the kind of heat that feels like a dare. The air’s thick and wet and smells like sugar and rotting fruit and beer that’s been left in a cup overnight. Above me, a balcony drips ivy and Mardi Gras beads, purple and green and gold like someone hung up a bruise. I’m in New Orleans. I keep saying it in my head like if I repeat it enough, it’ll stick to me and I’ll know who I am here. Or at least I’ll know where my feet are. I press my thumb into my phone like maybe by some miracle it will resurrect, but it’s on 2 percent and then it blinks away, black and smug. Last text is still burned into my eyelids: Mom: Come home. Then: We can talk about this. Then the call from the school counselor, who I blocked. I imagine his pinched face when I told him he could go reorganize his filing cabinet of microaggressions. I wonder if I should feel bad for that. I don’t. My name is Taylor, I remind myself. Not the old one, not the one that tastes like pennies in my mouth. There’s a stupid tourist shop window with TAYLOR printed on a rack of keychains and for a second it feels like fate before I remember it’s one of those names. That hums in my brain anyway. I rest my forehead against the cool glass just to have something solid. Inside there are shot glasses and alligator plushies and a sign that says “Laisser les bons temps rouler,” which I can’t pronounce in my head without making it sound like a lawnmower trying to start. “You gonna buy something or you just gonna fog up my window?” A woman with bright nails and a bun like a cinnamon roll grins at me from behind the counter. Her gold hoop earrings catch the light and throw it back at me. The shop smells like incense and bleach. It’s a little too much, and my stomach churns with the leftover bus fumes and nothing else. I ate a granola bar at a gas station in Mississippi and it feels like it’s a thousand years old inside me. “I’m just—sorry,” I say. I sound small and young and I hate that. I push the strap up again. “Do you know where I can get, um, something cheap to eat?” She looks at my backpack like it has a neon sign that says Runaway. Maybe it does. Maybe I’m projecting. “There’s a place down on Decatur sells beignets for tourists and a café au lait they pronounce wrong,” she says. “There’s better further uptown. You look like you could use a shower and something more than sugar fried up.” She watches my face like a cat watches a fly. “You got people here?” I swallow. My throat sticks. “Yeah,” I lie. It comes out too fast, and I can feel my ears get hot. “I mean—yeah, I’m meeting someone. Later.” She leans her elbows on the counter, rings clicking. “You watch your bag,” she says. “Don’t let nobody tell you they gonna watch it for you. And don’t get on no scooters. That’s how they know you’re fresh.” Something in me wants to dump the whole thing out there, tell her I ran away, I’m a disaster, I’m sixteen pretending to be anybody but me, I don’t know where to go, and my left sneaker has a hole in it you can almost see the sock through. But there’s another part—this new fierce, mean part—that says keep your mouth shut. Trust should be rationed like cereal. “Thanks,” I say. I open the door and the air wraps around me again like a wet towel. On the corner, a brass band tears into a song that sounds like a laugh. The tuba makes my ribs vibrate. A kid around my age with half his hair bleached sits on the curb drumming on an overturned bucket. His sticks are just chopsticks taped together. He’s got a jaundiced bruise peeking over his collar. He taps a rhythm on the pavement as if his hands can’t stand to be still. There’s a sign by his foot that says: Spare some change, not advice. I smile despite myself. It feels like someone else’s face. He catches me looking and lifts his chin. “You look new,” he says. “New new. Like still got the map in your head new.” I shift my backpack up. God, the strap again. “Do I have to pay the new person tax?” My voice comes out snappier than intended and I wince. Be tougher. Or at least pretend. “Nah. Just the looking-around tax,” he says. He clicks his sticks together fast, nervous. “Name’s Finn.” “Taylor,” I say. My name sits better here. It’s loose in my mouth, slouchy. “Do I look that obvious?” He shrugs. “Everybody does, at first. You blink too much. Also you’re wearing shoes you bought at a chain store. You’ll wanna map your safe bathrooms. Starbucks on Canal—no questions asked if you look like you know where you’re going. No scooters, no Bourbon Street after midnight unless you’re with a crew, no telling your whole life to the first person with a harmless face.” He tilts his head at me, eyes crinkling. “How long you been gone?” This is a test. This is me with my hand hovering over the wrong answer. I make my own test. “What time is it?” I ask. He laughs, a harsh little bark that doesn’t sound like joy and sounds exactly like it. “You got jokes. It’s Tuesday. Or Wednesday. It’s summer. The clock here is vibes. You got somewhere to be at a certain hour? You carrying an appointment book?” I don’t. I have exactly seventy-two dollars in wrinkled twenties, a library card with my deadname that I want to burn but might need for something, a half-empty bottle of water that tastes like plastic, and a grocery bag with one shirt and a toothbrush that I stole from the last gas station bathroom. I can hear Mom in my head, which is unfair because I ran to get away from her, but Moms are like glitter—once they’re in, you never get them all out. We can talk about this. So can a brick. Or a hurricane. “I need food,” I say. “Cheap. Maybe a shower later. Also—” I swallow. “I need to figure out... things.” Finn looks at me like my face is a puzzle with a missing piece. He nods toward the quarter where the street narrows and gets meaner. “There’s Miss Carla on Royal,” he says. “She used to run with—whatever, she’s cool. Sometimes she feeds kids that are—” He waves his sticks at me. “Kids like us. For free if she likes you, cheap if she doesn’t. She won’t let you shower but she’ll point you toward a church that will if you don’t mind a speech about loving your soul.” “Church,” I say. I try to make it taste like something besides choke. “Cool. Love that for me.” He smirks. “You don’t gotta believe to use water. C’mon.” He stands, slings a canvas bag over his shoulder that looks like it might be held together with willpower and duct tape, and we start walking. He moves like a feral cat, always keeping three feet between him and the street, eyes on reflections in windows instead of the sidewalk. I can’t tell if that means I should trust him or not. As we pass a guy in a Saints jersey, Finn goes tight, shoulders up. The guy’s eyes slide over us, away. Finn only breathes when we turn the corner. “Rule,” he says. “If a grown man knows your name and you didn’t tell it to him, you tie your shoes and walk the other way fast.” “Okay,” I say. “You know a lot of rules.” “Cuz I broke all of them and lived,” he says. “Mostly.” We find Miss Carla’s by smell—something like garlic and coffee and a frying pan that never gets fully clean. The sign’s old and hand-painted; the A in Carla has a little heart at the top. Inside it’s dark and blessedly cooler, a box fan pushing stale air. The woman behind the counter looks like she’s been carved out of gumbo—warm, heavy, a little dangerous if you rush it. “Finn,” she says in a voice that could cook rice. “You bring me trouble or gossip?” “Both,” he says. He gestures at me. “This is Taylor.” “‘Morning, Taylor,” she says. Her eyes are sharp. “Hungry?” “Yes,” I say, and it comes out like a prayer. If God is here anywhere, He’s in fried food. She slides a plate across the counter to me with something golden and perfect that crunches under my teeth like it was crafted to make my brain stop screaming. My eyes sting. Ridiculous. Don’t cry over food in a place like this. Rule number whatever: If you’re crying in public, be strategic about your audience. “You from here?” she asks, casual. “No,” I say. “Tennessee.” She arches a brow. “Ah. You got an aunt stays on Dauphine or you got nowhere?” I set the plate down. The strap slides again and I want to throw the whole bag into the Mississippi and watch it sink. “Nowhere,” I say. It feels like jumping off a low roof. If I break anything, it’ll be small. She nods once, like that’s math that adds up right. “We close at three,” she says. “You can sit here till then. You need a phone to call somebody, we can pretend. If you need a number for Covenant House, I got it. They ain’t saints but they got a bed sometimes.” Finn watches me with his chin on his fist, as if he’s waiting to see if I’ll run. A flicker of something—pride?—because he brought someone in and it didn’t blow up. Or maybe I’m projecting. “I don’t—” The word home is a bruise inside my mouth. It still aches when I touch it. “I’m not going back.” My voice is too loud. I lower it. “I mean. Not right now.” “You ain’t gotta explain your whole life to me,” Miss Carla says. “Long as you don’t steal and you bus your table.” “Yes, ma’am,” I say automatically, and something about the ma’am fits weird and sweet on my tongue, like a set of clothes I want to grow into. It makes heat ripple through my face. Finn’s eyes flick to mine. I can almost hear him clocking it, storing it away with all the other hints about who and what I am. He doesn’t say anything. That’s good. Or it’s nothing. According to the New Orleans clock, it’s vibes. “You got a place to sleep?” he asks after we mop up the last of the grease with a corner of bread like civilized animals. “You can crash at the park till cops kick you out, but it’s loud and the mosquitoes will bleed you dry. There’s a squat in the Bywater. Kinda sketch. The roof leaks, and there’s a guy named Rascal who’d sell his grandma, but he won’t bother you if you stay in the back room. Or I know a dude has a couch, but he likes to…collect. You gotta tell him no about three times and he gets the message.” He says it like he’s giving me the weather—these are conditions, not value judgments. “Fun options,” I say. I pick at a splinter in the counter with my thumbnail. “What about you?” He shrugs one shoulder and it looks like it hurts. “I go where I go.” He taps his sticks on the table. “I was sixteen last week,” he says, almost like he’s trying to make it sound casual and it’s a secret anyway. “Happy birthday,” I say. It’s stupid but what else. He makes a face. “You got people mad at you?” he asks, and there’s the needle finding the vein. I feel it slip in. “Like will they come looking?” In my mind, Mom’s hand is clutching the phone, knuckles white. My brother breaking stuff in his room when he’s mad, the cheap door that Mom never fixed. The counselor with his Sit down, I can help you tone that down. I feel the burn of the misgendering, the clatter of she and wrong name and you’re just trying this on for size and do you know how hard this is for me, like I don’t. It’s like a car alarm going off behind everything else all the time. “They can be mad,” I say. My voice is steadier than I feel. “I’m not going back.” I don’t say: I don’t know where I’m going instead. Or: I’m scared. Or: Please, someone, tell me there’s a version of this where it’s not all just sweat and lies and corners. Finn nods slow. “Okay,” he says. “Then we do the day.” He says it like a plan. “You need a shower. There’s a church. They’ll talk at you but I can fake a prayer face in my sleep. Then you need socks. Clean socks will save your life out here. Shoes too, but socks are first line of defense.” He looks at my backpack. “You got a knife?” I laugh and it’s a gross, hysterical sound. He raises his eyebrows. “I mean, yeah,” I say, and I fish out the little folding one from the side pocket where I keep it for string and boxes and terror. The handle is scratched. I don’t know if I could ever stick it into someone. I hope I never have to find out. I hope I’m scarier than I look. “Keep it where you can feel it,” he says. “Don’t wait till you need it to find it. Also don’t stab nobody unless you have to. That life sticks.” There’s something in his tone when he says it. A weight. I want to ask what he doesn’t want sticking to him anymore, but I file it under Don’t, yet. We leave Miss Carla’s with her blessing and her number on a napkin, pressed into my hand like a relic. The street is all the way awake now. A man in a suit jogs past on an errand that looks urgent and small. A woman with a parasol floats. A kid in a Spider-Man costume sticks to a lamppost and yells for tips. The sky is white, not blue, like it’s been bleached. We hit the church and sit through five minutes of an earnest guy talking about sheep while the water heats up in the pipes. He gives us towels and doesn’t look at our faces long enough to try to slot us into boxes. Finn hums something under his breath—maybe a song, maybe just a habit. I scrub fast and vicious like I can get Tennessee off me. I watch a little black river swirl down the drain and feel a jolt of joy that’s not reasonable. When I come out, hair plastered and clinging, I feel like an empty soda can with the tab pulled off. Lighter. Crushed. “Here,” Finn says. He tosses me a pair of socks that are not new but are clean. They smell like nothing. I almost cry again. God. I hate me. “Thanks,” I say. He shrugs like it’s nothing, but he watches me pull them on like it’s something he needs to see. As we walk, he tells me about the river as if it’s a person. “It’ll be there even when everything else is lying to you,” he says. “It’s proud. It don’t care about your name. You can sit with it and it don’t ask nothing.” He stops then, head cocked. “But you don’t go in if you’re not with someone who knows it,” he adds. “It looks slow. It’s not.” We sit on a bench by the Moon Walk and the Mississippi heaves by like a whole animal. I feel small and right-sized for the first time in days. My backpack strap slides, and I let it for a second, and then I pull it back up. It squeaks. A barge drifts past, stacked with blocks that look like Lego for giants. I hug my knees and rest my chin on them. My reflection in the water is fractured and not useful. Good. I don’t want to look at me right now, not really. I want to be multiple choice. I want to be fill-in-the-blank. There’s a guy in a dirty polo who’s been hovering a little too long. Finn tenses, the way a cat does. “We should move,” he says softly. “You don’t wanna be in a place where someone’s decided you belong.” We stand. I hitch the strap again. “You have secrets,” I say suddenly. It comes out before I can catch it. Stupid. Obvious. Finn grins with half of his mouth and it’s ugly and bright. “Yeah,” he says. “Me too.” He kicks at a cigarette butt. “You tell me yours, I’ll tell you mine.” “I told you,” I say. I spread my hands. “I left. I’m…me. I said it two days ago and they didn’t like it. Are you happy?” He squints at me, like he’s taking a picture in his head. “You said it out loud,” he says. He whistles low. “That’s big. That’s why you look like you jumped off a roof. Your insides don’t match the outside pressure yet. They’ll catch up.” “Thanks for the physics,” I say. I feel stupidly relieved that he didn’t stumble around it. That he didn’t call me—anything else. That he slid over my name like it was normal. My chest loosens. I didn’t know it was tight until it wasn’t. We wander through the market where spices are piled up like tiny mountains and there’s a man selling frogs that look rubber until they blink. A lady with a headscarf reads tarot cards and looks at me like she knows my Social Security number. Finn flinches when a cop car creeps by, barely moving. The back of my neck prickles. I fight an urge to duck. I am not wanted. Not yet. Not on paper. But I feel wanted like you feel an argument before it starts. We end up under
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece effectively captures the voice of a transgender teen runaway navigating their first day in New Orleans. The writing excels in creating an authentic first-person perspective with Taylor's internal monologue revealing their vulnerability, defiance, and uncertainty. The prose is rich with sensory details that bring New Orleans to life—the humidity, the smells, the sounds of brass bands—while maintaining Taylor's distinct perspective. The character development is particularly strong. Taylor feels fully realized through their conflicting emotions: the determination to escape an unsupportive home environment balanced against the fear of the unknown. Their interactions with Finn and Miss Carla reveal different facets of their personality—defensive yet desperate for connection. The backstory is woven in naturally through memories and reflections rather than exposition dumps. Finn serves as an effective foil and potential ally, with his street-smart demeanor and hints at his own troubled past. His character introduces tension and mystery while providing Taylor with necessary guidance. Miss Carla is similarly well-drawn in her brief appearance, showing compassion without sentimentality. The dialogue is particularly strong, with each character having a distinct voice. Finn's staccato street wisdom contrasts with Taylor's more hesitant, sometimes sarcastic responses. The dialogue feels natural and reveals character while advancing the narrative. The prose strikes a good balance between vivid description and teenage vernacular. Metaphors like "the air wraps around me again like a wet towel" and observations like "Moms are like glitter—once they're in, you never get them all out" feel authentic to Taylor's voice while being genuinely insightful. The writing avoids becoming overwrought despite dealing with emotionally charged subject matter. The narrative effectively builds tension through small interactions and observations that hint at danger—Finn's wariness around certain men, the advice about knives, the hovering stranger by the river. These elements create a sense of precariousness that reflects Taylor's situation. One minor weakness is that the piece ends abruptly mid-sentence with "We end up under," suggesting it was cut off rather than concluded intentionally. This prevents a proper assessment of how well the story arc is resolved. Overall, this is a compelling and skillfully written narrative that creates a vivid sense of place, authentic characters, and emotional resonance while addressing complex themes of identity, belonging, and survival. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 18 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 18.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Dystopic-comedy: My Apocalypse Buddy — Score: 88.7
Prompt:
My Apocalypse Buddy Write a wry, dry short story of survival and adventure loosely in the style of Terry Pratchett, set in the post-technological collapse world. The story begins with the pair deliberating their predicament and intent for the day's mission, details the ways in which the mission inevitably goes sideways, and returns them to home base in multiple ways, worse for wear. [characters] - the animo-tronic stuffed koala, Chewy, from some long forgotten before time - midas, our hapless protagonist, who has a knack for finding himself in the worst kinds of trouble. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The day began, as most days did since the world misplaced its batteries, with a committee meeting. The committee consisted of Midas and the animo-tronic stuffed koala he’d pulled out of a vending machine museum in the ruins of Old Navarre Mall. The museum had been free after the collapse, and Midas had always found it hard to resist a bargain, even if it stared at him with plastic eyes and emitted phrases at random intervals like a haunted warehouse. They sat on a sagging canopy roof overlooking the marrow-white bones of the city. Midas adjusted an elbow pad (fashioned from a kneecap pad, never mind the details) and squinted at the horizon. Chewy lay on his back, the little shirt on his plush torso reading WE CARE: HUGS INSIDE. One of his ears had been sewn up with catgut, badly, but with conviction. “Right,” Midas said, adopting the posture of a person who didn’t know what he was doing but felt that projecting confidence would confuse the enemy. “We need water. And something that isn’t jerky. And perhaps a change of luck.” Chewy’s mouth whirred. His eyes flickered once, twice, like fireflies reconsidering their life choices. “Chewy cuddles make every day brighter!” “That’s not really water,” Midas said. “Unless you’re implying some sort of trade. Hug-for-water exchange. I’m not sure the market conditions favor that.” The wind tugged at Chewy’s remaining ear. Somewhere, a building remembered it was supposed to fall and bent politely into the street. Midas unfurled a map made of glued-together takeaway menus and pointed his finger at a blue splotch labelled PRE-COLLAPSE WELLNESS COMPLEX. “The spa. They had a pool for floating therapy. It’s underground, so there’s a chance it hasn’t evaporated or turned into soup.” Chewy’s chest emitted a tiny mechanical purr, a leftover feature that had kept Midas warm during nights that didn’t respect the concept of enough clothes. “Refreshment is just a hug away.” “Not helping,” Midas said, rolling up the menu-map with a sigh. “Fine. The spa, then. On the way back we’ll swing by the amphitheater and see if anyone’s trading mushrooms for battery packs.” Chewy was silent for a while, which is how you knew his batteries were running low, and then chirped, “For the moments that matter, trust TambleCare.” “Exactly,” Midas said, rising and slinging his pack over his shoulders. “We’ll trust TambleCare. If they’re still accepting patients, I’ll check in for a spa day and affirm my wellness.” They climbed down the canopy ladder, which was mostly a polite suggestion to gravity. Midas’s boots hit the ground with a resigned thud. The streets had sprouted gardens of opportunistic life—feral vines threaded through supermarket trolleys, sunflowers faced a sun that had grown bored of being worshiped, and the remains of a billboard read ONLY YOU (the rest had been eaten by ivy). “Remember,” Midas said, moving at a cautious lope, “we’re just going in, taking a sip of not-disease, and coming out. No side quests.” Side quests were how Midas had nearly lost a thumb to a community that believed in the healing power of antique staplers, and how he had once traded a decent poncho for a box of “nutrition-enhanced sand” that turned out to be sand. The apocalypse was big on the value of learning experiences, which tended to ask for payment upfront. They crossed an intersection where traffic lights gestured at nobody and rounded a block where storefronts displayed faded promises: TODAY ONLY. BUY TWO, FORGET THREE. Midas eased open a rusted gate (Please—he’d always found “ease” a more aspirational instruction) and the Wellness Complex revealed itself like a particularly discouraging cake. It had peeled off its own signage and presented instead the impression that it might collapse on any visitor who didn’t pay for the deluxe package. The lobby was a greenhouse of dust. Plants had colonized the water feature, and a fern held the receptionist’s bell hostage. Midas stepped around blossoms growing from cracks in the marble, their petals the pale pink of regrets. “Looks friendly enough,” he said. Chewy’s head rotated three degrees and clicked. “Experience tranquility. Enroll today.” “In we go.” The pool was below, down a stairwell adorned with motivational posters. A man with a six-pack as improbable as the old world smiled, cracked, and slid down the wall. Believe! he commanded, although it sounded more like beleh, as if the letters themselves were tired. The pool room smelled like evaporated promises and metal. The water was a green coin at the far end, mostly covered by a carpet of algae that had risen up to govern. Still, in the corner, the surface showed a patch of something like clarity. Midas knelt, eyes narrowing. “Do you reckon I can filter that?” he asked Chewy, like a man asking a teddy bear an opinion that mattered. The trick to staying sane, Midas had found, was to pretend conversations were two-way radio rather than two-way mirror. Chewy snuggled into the crook of his elbow. “Family size. Value pack.” “Famously unhelpful.” Midas reached for the water, cup poised, when a shape under the algae moved. There are many kinds of motion: the confident sway of a predator, the skitter of a creature with too many legs, the steady translation of a rock that refuses to stop rolling because the world has ended, not gravity. This was the shimmy of something large and stubborn that had set up shop. It surfaced with an expression that could be described as: you again? Midas froze. A turtle the size of a coffee table blinked, ancient and entirely unimpressed. Most of its back hosted a small archipelago of barnacles. It exhaled a sound like a tired librarian. “Ah,” Midas said. “Local management.” The turtle advanced, slowly but with malignant intent. It did not need speed. Speed was for creatures that hadn’t learned the value of inevitability. Midas backed away. “We’re just”—he waved a cup as one might wave a white flag at a particularly litigious cloud—“here for a taste.” The turtle opened its mouth to reveal a tongue that suggested a long history of crushing. It stepped onto the last stair and kept coming. Midas glanced around for options. The options did not glance back. “Plan B,” he said to Chewy, scooping the koala with one hand and slinging himself onto the railing. He slid, graceless as a man attempting to rejoin his childhood from the wrong angle. The turtle followed, not to the railing, because the railing had standards, but to the idea of relentless pressure. At the top, Midas landed in a gout of dust that declared its independence. He sprinted past the motivational man, who gave him a look like we all made choices, and burst into the lobby. The fern cheered him on because cheering was what it did. Outside, the sky was in the process of making weather. Rain negotiated with heat. The first drops were exploratory diplomats. They got a block away before Midas slowed, breathing hard. His problem, he decided, was that he was always a day late to good ideas. If he’d had a net, a plan, a friend who wasn’t mostly fluff. If he had— Chewy, nestled in his arm, chirped, “Instant savings! Limited time only.” “Story of my life,” Midas said. This was when the side quest arrived to complain about being neglected. Three figures stepped out from behind a bus whose destination still read City Center in cheerful, obdurate letters. They were dressed in an appealing patchwork of leather, optimism, and the-intimidation-value-of-metal-studs, and they carried implements that had started life as gardening tools and aimed, one day, to be weapons. “Afternoon,” said the leader, a woman with hair braided in a way that suggested both patience and a certain number of clerical incidents in her past. “That’s a sweet toy. We’ll take a toy tax.” Midas held Chewy tighter. “He’s not a toy. He’s a friend. Also, tax authorities require documentation.” “We’re very forward-thinking,” the woman said. “We document on the inside of our heads.” Chewy’s eyes flickered. “Feel good about your choices with Omni-Nurture.” “See?” Midas said. “Omni-Nurture. He’s licensed.” The woman cocked her head. “You bartering anything else, treasure hunter?” Midas considered his inventory: three filters, two tins of beans, one potato reduced to a starchy rumor, and a coil of copper wire he’d been convinced would be important any day now. “Truly, no,” he admitted. “Well then,” the woman said, and lunged. Midas ducked. It was not graceful. He swerved toward the amphitheater, because he had said he would and it seemed rude not to follow through. The amphitheater hosted a market every third afternoon, when traders came to exchange radishes, stories, and scowls. The stairs were crowded with people, and the world responded to the idea of being crowded by making Midas collide with someone who owned a bucket of mushrooms. Mushrooms flew with a sorrowful plop. The crowd decided this was entertainment and shifted to a better seat. “Sorry!” Midas called, which was the kind of thing you shouted when sorry didn’t exist anymore as a currency. He vaulted a crate that turned out to be nothing of the kind and received the corner of a bartering stall in the shin. The woman with the braided hair and her two innovation specialists pursued him, moving like a lot of debt toward a small wallet. Midas’s mind engaged the part of itself that loved catastrophe the way some people love crosswords. He bolted through the center and toward the back, where traders stored things they valued less than money but more than their left foot. He dove into a curtain and found himself backstage, which was not much different from front-stage except there were more ropes and fewer witnesses. “Okay,” Midas told Chewy, panting. “Time for a miracle.” Chewy bleeped like a microwaved confession. “Power down to plush mode in: ten, nine…” “Don’t do that,” Midas hissed. He grabbed a rope at random because too much thinking had never improved his choices. The curtain yoinked upward as if offended. Behind him, the pursuers emerged, muttered, and spread out, which was precisely the wrong decision if one wanted to avoid whatever Midas was planning. He didn’t know what he was planning, but he had a reputation for unpredictability, mostly among inanimate objects. He pulled another rope. A counterweight descended in the form of a sandbag that had opinions. It swung, not at his pursuers, but at him. This was typical. He ducked and the sandbag continued, catching the woman in the shoulder. She staggered, then regained her balance with a look that suggested new creative taxes. Midas flung himself through a door marked Staff Only. The sign fell off in solidarity. The hallway beyond was a tangle of pipes and a smell of old popcorn attempts. He ran, and ran, and ran into the exit that presented itself as a suggestion. Outside, rain had graduated from negotiation to enthusiastic treaty. The street reflected the world in a reluctantly flattering tone. Midas sprinted through puddles that tried to be lakes. Behind him, his pursuers wavered. Rain wasn’t anyone’s friend. In a different life, Midas had loved rain. Now it had the habit of finding the holes in his coat and writing him letters: wet, wet, wet. He turned down an alley he knew, which swung around a building that had once taught yoga and now taught a more general lesson about the limits of flexibility. The alley opened onto Home Base, also known as the Refrigerator. It had earned the name by being a refrigerator. The walk-in sort, one of those stainless-steel boxes where restaurants stored ambitions and lettuce. In the building’s backend it had survived because there was something about heavy sealed doors that the apocalypse felt was too obvious. Midas had dragged in rugs and set up a stove and painted a sun on the wall that looked like it knew everything and was weary. He collapsed inside and slammed the door, which absorbed his panic with its usual courtesy and settled into silence. Outside, footsteps faltered, then faded. The rain hammered an unconvincing Morse code: go out again, we dare you. Midas leaned back and laughed in the way that is like crying with opinions. He slid down the door and ended up on the floor, which was a good place for a man to make friends with reality. Chewy’s eyes dimmed to cinnamon. “You can’t buy happiness,” he said softly, as if sharing a secret. “But you can lease it.” “That’s a hell of a philosophy,” Midas said. He wiped rain and fear off his face with his sleeve and took stock. The pack was soaked. The filters were damp but salvageable. The beans had opinions about the weather. His shin would bruise with artistry. He had acquired no water, no mushrooms, and a new cohort of people who wished to discuss taxation models with him. He stood, wincing, and stoked the stove with carefully curated wood. He hung his coat from a hook and draped a towel over Chewy like a ridiculous cowl. The koala’s mouth clicked quietly, a clockwork acceptance that the world had turned and they had not fallen off. Midas poured a cup of yesterday’s boiled water into a tin. He sipped. It tasted like patience and metal. “Right,” he said. “Tomorrow, we try the library. They had a children’s aquarium. It might have water.” Chewy didn’t reply. His eyes went dark. He had powered down, plush-mode engaged. Midas resisted the urge to shake him awake with a combination of fondness and terror. He lay back on his rug and listened to the rain write its long letter on the roof. He thought of turtles who managed their pools without paperwork. He thought of the woman with her braided hair and the ever-expanding bureaucracy of survival. He thought of how, in the before-time, the world had been run by people who believed in slogans about happiness and savings, and how perhaps nothing had changed except the lighting. He reached out and set his hand on Chewy’s little soft paw. “Thanks,” he said. “For the moments that matter.” In the night, the storm popped a gasket somewhere in the roof and water found the path it always finds, trickling down the wall and dripping into the pot Midas kept in readiness. He woke to the sound and sat up, blinking. “Well,” he whispered, and smiled despite himself, because sometimes the universe delivered by accident, the way a pot might end up exactly under a drip not because someone planned it, but because planning had done enough damage for the day. He placed two more pots under the leak, then crawled back to his rug. The world outside ground its teeth and slept. Inside, Midas dreamed of pools, floating therapy, and a turtle that let him pass because everyone had to drink. He dreamed of a sign that read HUGS ACCEPTED HERE and, in that dream, the sign had hands. In the morning, the committee would reconvene and the minutes would record that the mission had not gone to plan, that side quests had applied for leadership and won, and that home base had been reached by alternative routes, including but not limited to falling into it. The committee would acknowledge injuries, count the pots, and approve a new agenda item: find an umbrella. But for now there was the soft tick of cooling metal and the heavy softness of a toy powered down, and a man who had survived by shooting through the middle of the worst kinds of trouble, dragging his apocalypse buddy along with him, and making it home by every improbable, ridiculous route the world offered. Somewhere near morning, Chewy stirred. His mouth clicked. “Chewy cuddles,” he whispered into the half-light, “now with thirty percent more care.” Midas laughed, quietly, and let the sound ride the rain down. “We’ll take it,” he said. “We’ll take all we can get.”
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This short story successfully captures Terry Pratchett's wry, dry style with its blend of absurdist humor, philosophical musings disguised as jokes, and a world that operates on its own peculiar logic. The post-technological collapse setting is vividly realized through clever details like maps made of takeaway menus, motivational posters sliding down walls, and the repurposing of everyday objects. The relationship between Midas and Chewy is particularly well-executed. Chewy's pre-programmed phrases that somehow manage to be both non-sequiturs and oddly appropriate to the situation create a delightful dynamic. The author cleverly uses these stock phrases to build character and even advance the plot, turning what could have been a one-note joke into a surprisingly nuanced relationship. The prose demonstrates excellent command of Pratchett's style, with metaphors that start in one place and end up somewhere unexpected ("like a man asking a teddy bear an opinion that mattered. The trick to staying sane, Midas had found, was to pretend conversations were two-way radio rather than two-way mirror"). The author employs footnote-like asides within the text itself, another Pratchett hallmark. The mission structure follows the prompt perfectly, beginning with deliberation, proceeding through complications (the turtle, the tax collectors), and returning home "worse for wear" but with an ironic twist of success. The story maintains a consistent tone throughout, balancing humor with genuine moments of poignancy. Where the piece occasionally falters is in some overwritten passages that try too hard to be clever. A few metaphors feel strained, and there are moments where the prose becomes slightly purple. The story also occasionally meanders, particularly during the chase sequence, which could have been tightened. The dialogue, while sparse due to one character being a stuffed koala with limited phrases, is effective. The author cleverly uses Chewy's pre-programmed lines as both comic relief and occasionally profound commentary. The ending strikes a perfect balance between the wry humor that characterizes the piece and a genuine emotional connection between the characters. It avoids being overly sentimental while still providing a satisfying conclusion that feels earned. Overall, this is an excellent response to the prompt that captures Pratchett's style while creating its own unique world and characters. The relationship between Midas and his apocalypse buddy Chewy forms the emotional core of the story, elevating it beyond mere pastiche. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Romance: Love in the Limelight — Score: 90.2
Prompt:
Romance: Love in the Limelight. Write one scene within a larger story set in Wales. A famous (fictional) actor ducks into a small-town bookstore to escape paparazzi. The scene takes us through the characters meeting in this odd circumstance. Over the course of the scene, the actor and the bookstore owner have a conversation charged by an undercurrent of unspoken chemistry. Write the actor as somewhat of a rogue with a fragile ego, which needs to be fed by having everyone like him. He is thoroughly charming, but the bookstore owner seems (at least superficially) immune to this; which paradoxically provokes a genuine attraction and derails the charm offensive. The bookstore owner, despite the superficial rebuffs of the actor's charm, is inwardly more than a little charmed and flustered despite themselves. Write primarily in dialogue, in the distinct voices of each character. 1000 words.
Model Output:
“Close the door.” “I—sorry—of course.” The man stumbled backward, fingers fumbling at the latch as if it might bite him. He shut the door, then kept his palm pressed to it as if the outside might shove through. He was breathing a little too quickly. He did that thing famous faces do when they try not to be recognized: head down, cap low, sunglasses even though the sky outside was Welsh-cloud grey. “Mind,” I added, and pointed at the hand-scrawled sign. “Please. It sticks.” He read it without taking off the sunglasses. “Right. It sticks. That’s a metaphor.” “It’s a door.” He smiled at that. It was a practiced smile, the sort that had won him magazine covers and an arms-length of phone numbers, but the edges twitched with real relief. He still didn’t take off the sunglasses. He hunched beneath the hanging fern that drooped over the till like an old woman ready to tell your fortune, and his shoulders eased when no one else behind him barreled in with lenses and shouts. “Is there a back door?” he asked, voice pitched low, careful. “I can pay you for the inconvenience.” “There’s a back,” I said. “But if you go out it’ll open onto the alley where they’ve parked.” “So they are here.” He peered toward the beveled glass, where the street beyond was mostly fogged rain on rain. Somewhere out there I could hear a van door slide, a crow complaining, the undertone of town life. “Of course they are,” he said with theatrical despair. “I am, apparently, very interesting.” “You’re blocking the crime novels.” At that, his head tilted, just enough. He glanced down at the display table he was half leaning on, then up again, as if recalibrating his angle of attack. “Am I? Tragic. I’ve been accused of worse. Murder by charisma.” I kept my mouth from smiling. I’m good at that. Customers come in to browse and leave with stacks and stories; I sell them the stacks and keep my stories folded up between page one and two. “You can be accused of stepping to the left,” I said, and he stepped, instant obedience. The sunglasses finally came off, and there it was: the face that had been larger than life last summer on the billboard by the bypass, smirking in a tuxedo under the words He always gets his man. He was shorter in real life. Most of them are. “Hi,” he said, as if we weren’t already in the middle. “I’m—” “I know,” I said before I could catch it back. It came out flat, because I meant it as information, not invitation. The name danced around the air anyway; I saw the moment he waited for it—Rhys Llewellyn—and when I didn’t give it, I watched the faintest flicker of disappointment in a face trained to control such flickers. His grin brightened a notch, survival instinct. “Yes. That,” he said. “I’m that. And you are the gatekeeper of this sanctuary. I am in your debt. Name your price. Tea? Books? Lifelong gratitude? I can offer all three with varying degrees of sincerity.” “Buy a book,” I said. “I’ll throw in the gratitude.” He laughed, and it was better than the smile, more honest. “Done. Do you have—” He cast around. “Something obscure and intelligent that I can pretend to have already read twice?” “You want a backup.” I slipped around the counter, brushing past the fern. “In case they interview you through the window.” “In case you interview me,” he corrected, following with that loose-hipped stride that made millions. “But more importantly: because I like it when clever people like me. It’s one of my tragic flaws. Right alongside cheekbones.” “I can’t help with those.” I led him into the narrow aisle where Welsh poets sat with their spines earnest and the smell was old paper, damp wool, and the faint salt of the bay. My bell-alone bookshop in Penmaes, a place tourists call quaint and locals call there when they need it. Middle shelves are for the steady sellers: cookbooks with mugs of tea on their jackets, thrillers with embossed guns. The lower shelves, a cheeky tangle of small presses and oddities. He let his fingers trail along spines, as if the books were fur he could pet. “I like this place,” he said, like a man placing a bet. “It feels like my grandmother’s attic, if my gran had excellent taste and better curation.” “Your grandmother has poor taste?” “No. She has a deep commitment to hoarding ceramics.” He angled a look at me. “And expensive whisky. That part I inherited.” “Along with the cheekbones.” “They are a burden.” He sighed tragically, then ruined the moment by bumping his shoulder against a shelf and wincing. “I’m actually here for a film,” he added, because he needed me to know. “I’m not hiding from my own wedding or the law.” “Only photographers.” He pressed his mouth together on a true grimace. “Only them.” He softened it. “We’re shooting at the old slate quarry up the mountain. At least we were, until the rain turned the set into a skating rink. The director hates rain. In Wales. The audacity.” “The slate has a mind of its own,” I said. “It’s older than the lot of us. It doesn’t care about money.” He turned his whole body toward me. “Do you climb?” “Just a little,” I managed. My tongue took a half-second longer to cooperate, because his attention had weight. “Indoor mostly. I grew up scrambling over the quarry walls when you could still get away with it. There’s a limestone crag up near Cwm-y-coed. Have you been?” His eyes lit, not the showface light but the kind that comes from somewhere marrow-deep. “I went last week on our day off. I had a guide who swore at me in English and Welsh alternately. I have blisters in the shape of Gwynedd.” “You were bad.” “I was enthusiastic,” he said, with dignity. “I’m good on things I can rehearse. On the wall, it’s just you and your hands saying: try again. It’s infuriating and holy.” “In that order.” “In both orders. Do you climb?” “I just told you that I do.” “No, but do you climb.” He tugged an invisible rope between us, daring. “When you can’t sleep? When you’ve had a day and you need to feel something under your palms that isn’t a screen? When your head won’t shut up?” The rain ticked harder at the window. I folded my arms so that my hands had something to do. “Yes,” I said finally, simple. He let out a breath he’d been holding. The rogue went quiet, the charm took one knee. “Good,” he said. “Me too.” Somewhere outside, someone shouted his name. Not inside here. “Pick a book,” I said, because this was my shop and rules were anchors. He scanned the lower shelves and plucked out a battered copy of a mountaineering memoir, Welsh climber, small press, cover half-faded, title: On Crag and Cloud. “This looks appropriately pretentious,” he said. “It’s excellent,” I said before I could bite it back, and watched his mouth curve, because I’d let something slip. “He writes like he’s on belay. Tension, release.” “You love it.” “Yes.” “Then I should have it.” He tucked it under his arm like a trophy, then hesitated. “Unless you’ll be mad to part with it.” “It’s a business. Things leave.” “You run this alone?” he asked, and asked like he wanted the answer, not just the anecdote. “I have Aled on Saturdays when the rugby’s not on,” I said. “And my niece on school holidays. Mostly it’s me.” “It suits you.” He gestured to the chalkboard with the month’s book club schedule on it. “Control. Curating. Tiny kingdom. Small rebellions. The fern that looks like it gossips.” “It does. She knows your secrets.” “She already told me,” he said solemnly. “She said, ‘Stop using charm like a crowbar.’” I didn’t mean for the laugh to escape. It slipped anyway. It made his eyes soften, and that was dangerous. The undercurrent that had been humming since he walked in shifted keys. I stepped back toward the till because the safest thing to do when you feel the river catch is to find a rock. He followed at a respectful distance. “You didn’t ask for a selfie,” he said lightly. “Most people do. Or they pretend not to recognize me for twenty minutes and then ask me to sign their cousin’s baby.’ “I don’t do babies.” “Autographs?” “I don’t do pretending,” I said. “And if I asked you for a selfie you’d smile exactly the way you’ve been trained to smile, and you’d step into the light, and I’d look at it later and feel like I’d stolen a piece of something that wasn’t you.” “You’re a philosopher disguised as a bookseller.” “I’m a woman trying to have a quiet Tuesday.” He pressed his palm to the counter. His hands were nicked—real blisters, not makeup. “You don’t like me,” he said, and it wasn’t a question. It was the hurt child under the grin, prodding a bruise to see how bad it is. “I don’t know you,” I said. Then, because the truth sometimes demands an amendment, I added, “Yet.” The corner of his mouth did something complicated. He looked at the fern. He looked back at me. “Okay,” he said softly. “Okay.” We both breathed. The rain battered the window and then gentled, because weather is a creature like any other and needs to exhaust itself. He dug in his jacket for a wallet that probably cost more than my rent and yet was scuffed the way only honest things get. He put down a card. It had a name on it that made my stomach flip, which annoyed me. He saw the flip, because of course he did. He is a man who has made a life from noticing the way attention casts shadows. “Do you have a loyalty card?” he asked, teasing himself before I could. “Buy ten, get a restraining order free?” “We stamp with a dragon.” I pulled the little ink stamp from under the counter. “After six you get a tote bag with a quote that makes me roll my eyes.” “What’s the quote?” “Between the pages of a book is a lovely place to be.” He grimaced theatrically. “Weaponized twee. I love it. Stamp me.” I stamped the card. He watched the dragon bloom, and something like contentment moved across his face. Not the actor’s drafted version; the original. The bell over the door tinkled, but no one came in. It was the wind. “They’ll tire,” I said, nodding at the window. “Paparazzi. They’re like gulls. If they think there’s no chips they’ll move on.” “You are aggressively practical,” he said, admiration disguised as complaint. “It’s very hot.” “Stop that.” He put up both hands. “Right. No crowbars.” Silence settled between us, surprisingly easy. He drummed his fingers once, twice, then stilled them, as if practicing stillness. “What are you reading?” he asked, gesturing to the paperback face down beside the till. The spine was cracked, the cover corner scalloped from my habit. “Right now? Carver’s letters,” I said. “He’s an awful man who writes beautifully, which is inconvenient.” “Do you like awful men?” “No.” The answer was too quick. I gentled it. “I like men who know they could be awful and decide not to be.” The sound he made wasn’t quite a laugh. “Okay,” he said again. “Okay.” He tucked On Crag and Cloud closer to his chest, like he might breathe through it. The rain had eased. The van door outside slid shut. A gull cackled, offended to be compared to paparazzi. “Will you …” He stopped. He changed tack. “There’s a wall in town, isn’t there? The climbing gym? With the mural of the red dragon left over from the 2016 competition? The holds are terrible and everyone’s thirteen and better than me.” “Yes.” The word felt like a step on secure stone. “I usually go in the mornings, before set call.” He looked down at his hands. “It quiets me, before a day of pretending.” He glanced up, from under lashes that had sold seductions to Netflix. The rogue stepped aside and let something braver through. “Would you—if you ever go in the mornings—if you want—if you could pretend not to be immune for an hour—” “I’m not,” I said. His head came up. The words had escaped again, traitors. I let them stand. “Immune,” I clarified. “I’m not. I’m just … cautious.” His shoulders dropped with a relief so palpable I felt it in my own. “Cautious is fair,” he said. “Cautious is sane.” “I have the shop,” I added, defense and confession both. “Most mornings.” “Right.” He nodded. “Right.” “But Thursdays,” I said. It surprised both of us. “Aled opens. I could—” I pressed my lips together. “If you’re not filming. If you want a belay.” His grin came back, not slick, not polished; it came like the sun when it breaks through and everyone pretends they knew it would. “I would like that,” he said. “Very much.” “Fine,” I said, because I had to pretend to be the person I am when he’s not in the room. “Eight?” “Eight.” He slid the loyalty card into his wallet with reverence. “If you stand me up, I will come back here and make a scene so endearing you’ll have to forgive me.” “Don’t make scenes in my shop.” “I will make a quiet scene,” he amended. “Tasteful. Curated.” “Good luck with that,” I said, and he laughed again, and the bell finally rang for real as someone pushed the door open. Two damp tourists peered around him. They blinked at his face, blinked again, whispered the whispered name. He flicked the sunglasses up in a salute that was half apology, half benediction, and stepped away, small as he could make himself. “Thank you,” he said, just to me, soft enough to be a secret. “For what?” “For not letting me be the poster,” he said, and then he was gone, swept back into the rain and the faint swell of gulls and cameras, the door sticking and the sign reminding him, and me, and the fern, that metaphors were doors and doors were metaphors, and sometimes the trick of them is that they do, in fact, stick.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a romantic encounter between a famous actor and a bookstore owner in Wales, with excellent attention to the requested character dynamics. The writing establishes a strong sense of place with subtle Welsh references and creates a bookshop that feels lived-in and authentic. The dialogue is particularly strong, carrying the narrative and revealing character through distinct voices. The bookstore owner's voice is reserved, practical, and slightly defensive, while the actor's dialogue reveals his charm offensive, fragile ego, and genuine moments of connection. The writer skillfully shows the actor's transition from practiced charm to authentic interest when his usual tactics don't immediately work. The internal conflict of the bookstore owner is well-conveyed through small physical details and brief moments of self-awareness ("The words had escaped again, traitors"). We see their outward resistance to the actor's charm while glimpsing their inward attraction through subtle cues rather than explicit statements. The prose is elegant without being overwrought, with occasional poetic flourishes that enhance rather than distract from the scene. Metaphors like "rules were anchors" and the recurring motif of the sticking door work effectively. The imagery is specific and evocative, particularly in establishing the bookshop atmosphere. The pacing is excellent, with the conversation building naturally to the climactic agreement to meet at the climbing wall. The ending provides satisfying closure to the scene while leaving open possibilities for the larger story. A few minor weaknesses: occasionally the metaphors become slightly too self-conscious ("weather is a creature like any other and needs to exhaust itself"), and there are moments where the prose could be tightened. The climbing discussion, while providing common ground for the characters, occasionally feels slightly forced as a device. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted scene that fulfills the prompt requirements while creating distinctive characters whose chemistry feels earned and whose voices remain consistent throughout. The writer demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of how to convey attraction through subtext rather than explicit statements. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Whalepunk fantasy: The Morska Conspiracy — Score: 89.5
Prompt:
Whalepunk fantasy The Morska Conspiracy The Morska thieves guild experiences a sudden power vacuum as its leader was arrested in a raid in the early hours of the morning. Aya, a young woman born into aristocracy, has a keen interest in both the sciences and the arcane, having inherited her mother's gift for immateria magick (an outlawed practice for which her mother was, regrettably, hanged by the neck). Aya, bored with the world of aristocracy, has been spending her nights moonlighting with this very guild (masked, naturally). Leveraging her latent ability to summon dark entities from the immateria, she quickly rose through the ranks of the guild. Now, recognising the opportunity of the sudden power vacuum, Aya and her close companions Katra and Simeon, make a play for heart of the guild's claim to power: an ancient scythan artifact, under guard of spell and key in the depths of the guild hq. In contrast with the desperate chaos they had navigated thus far, the entrance to the underhold felt suddenly too quiet. Aya braces herself and reaches for the door. Write the next scene as the trio enter the underhold and find themselves confronted by none other than the guild leader herself, decidedly *un*-incarcerated, and in possession of both weapons and bodyguards. Paint a vivid picture of of the confrontation. Story beats: Aya is captured and unmasked. The trio are captured. Aya attempts to stall their demise by negotiating on her value as a hostage -- as she grapples with the inevitable consequences of her role in the guild being brought to light. Incorporate dialogue in the authentic voices of the characters. Do not write a fight scene. Lean into the gritty Victorian aesthetic with the dialogue & worldbuilding, as well as elements of gothic horror. In this world, men trust brass and oil and steel; magicka is feared and barely understood. Write in third person past tense, incorporating both Aya's internal monologue, and a heavy dialogue component. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The door gave before Aya’s gloved palm with a sigh like a dying lung. Cold exhaled from the underhold as if the sea itself were nested down there, salt and rust and some older perfume of dust that had learned to ferment in the dark. The hinges complained in abraded whispers. Behind her, Simeon’s pocket watch ticked loud as a judge’s gavel. Tick. Tick. Tick. Katra’s hand brushed Aya’s elbow just once—a warning, a reassurance, or simply a reminder that the living still had warmth. “Too quiet,” Katra said, low, the syllables chewing through her accent like flint on bone. Her boots hesitated at the threshold. “Like a church after the congregation’s been buried.” Aya forced herself forward. The lantern swayed from her hand, throwing marine shadows across the oil-bricked stairwell. The steps drooped toward the deep like the spine of a sunken animal. She dared a breath and tasted the copper of brine and stale blood, the oily sweetness of lamp fuel, the mechanical tang of iron filings. Morska had a way of putting its flavor on your tongue when you least wanted it. She had been born above that taste with sugar and port in her mouth, and her mother’s last breath had tasted of rope and winter. She did not think of that now. She thought of the Scythan relic below, humming its myth in a tongue no one had the luxury to understand. She thought of credits, leverage, the slow-bowed heads of men who would call her Master. She thought of masks and whether she had worn hers long enough to forget what lay underneath. They reached the underhold level, where the brick gave to black basalt cut centuries ago when men still thought a king’s bones kept a country loyal. The corridor unfurled in a long curve, cables clinging to its ribs like veins. Their lantern met other lights: low hissing lamps guttering blue on copper sconce-work, a constellation placed by a careful, unhurried hand. Too unhurried. “Aya,” Simeon whispered, watch tapping time against his sternum, “I’ve got a feeling in my teeth.” “Keep them,” she said. “Teeth are expensive.” The corridor opened to an antechamber ribbed with ironwork like the inside of a whale’s skull. There, the air thickened with a faint harmonics, the sort that made a molar sing and the eye seek a seam in reality where none existed. In the middle of the chamber, a vault mouth yawned—interlocking plates of brass and whalebone fused with rivets the size of thumbs. Its lock wore sigils that pulsed like bruises. And between Aya and that hulking promise, a figure in a high-collared greatcoat of oil-black leather, her profile cut against lamp glare like a knife left on a butcher’s block. Hair smoothed into a severe knot. Boots planted delicate as a spider. Eyes that had been rumored, whispered about, attributed to portraits sold in back-alleys and burned. Marla Vostrik—Lord Vostrik to most tongues—did not look particularly incarcerated. She held a pistol in each hand like a pair of opinions she did not expect to revise. Around her, four men in seafarer’s rig stood at range with long rifles braced, bayonets glinting dull as the teeth of something that had never learned mercy. “Well,” Marla said, and her voice had sand in it, and honey after. “Watch your fingers on the door, little fish. Underhold’s hungry.” The undertow of fear took Aya by the ankles. She stopped because stopping made it look like choice. Katra shifted to flank, palms already flexed toward knife hilts not yet visible. Simeon’s breath went thin and quick. His watch did not care. Tick. Tick. “We heard you’d been taken,” Aya said. Her mouth shaped the lie with aristocratic ease, the one tool that had proved more reliable than any lockpick. “Dragged out of bed like a common salt-thief.” “A true thing often wears a false wig,” Marla said, mouth gentle, fingers steady on the triggers. “They took someone. I gave them someone. Our friends in brass are not so clever as they think. They trust leverages and levers. Oil and steel and paperwork. Magick, though—” Her gaze flickered like a blade at Aya’s mask, the fish-bone porcelain cheekbones painted blue-black, the beaked bridge hiding everything that ever mattered. “Magick frightens them. It frightens them because it is not a machine you can take apart on a desk.” Katra’s voice rasped like a whet-stone. “You’re meant to be rotting in the King’s wet room.” “Am I,” Marla murmured. “I do disappoint so many.” Aya felt the immateria ripple in the dark corner of her mind, the way old tidewaters spoke in sloshes against stone. It was like realizing there was a door in your spine you had never noticed, and that something leaned on the other side, listening for the latch. Her mother had taught her to turn the handle gently, with prayer and suspicion. The guild had taught her to wrench it wide. Marla’s presence made the handle hot. “Guns down,” Marla said softly to her men without looking away. The guns did not lower. The command was ceremonial. “Masks off.” Katra shifted, not a step, but a calculation. Aya lifted a gloved hand as if to remove the mask herself, and the world lurched. Rope sang. A net of wire bit down from the rafters in a hiss like steam venting from a wounded engine. The mesh caught Katra first, the hooks kissing her shoulders, her arms yanked up so sudden the knife she had not yet produced clattered useless. Simeon tried to sidestep and the second snare took him around the ribs, hoisting him to his toes, watch thumping frantic against its chain. Aya lifted her hand to cut—toward what? The hinge on the world? A pair of shadows from the corners swept; not shadows, men all in oil-cloth with goggles, the underhold’s keepers. A loop of wire settled with brutal grace around Aya’s wrists, teeth biting into glove and skin. Another around her throat, not choking, not yet: a promise of it. “Don’t,” Marla said, and the word cracked through the room. “Don’t even think, little fish. I know what you do. I’ve seen the way the lamps go sick when you’re near. Your little parlour tricks. Your mother’s old wickedness. You open a door here, and I’ll have Simeon’s heart put in a jar to pace the time I let him live.” Aya felt heat rise under the mask. “You don’t have jars big enough.” It was foolish, and she heard it. But she had spent months speaking as a blade; now, taken, she wanted any edge, even the dullest. Marla smiled as if someone had told a joke at a funeral. She nodded to one of her men. The man stepped in close and plucked at the mask’s straps with pliers. Leather bit. Aya resisted the urge to jerk away. There was no dignity in it. She had learned how to look bored under a hangman’s knot watching her mother wobble. She could do bored while being unpeeled. The mask came away with a suction sound. The air under it tasted sharper, like a winter fruit. The oil-lamps reflected off her skin like she was something polished. There was a moment, a bright, thin moment where nothing happened, and then everything did: Katra’s eyes widened, Simeon’s breath hitched like a misfired valve. The men with the guns did not change; they had not known her. Marla—Marla changed. Her lips parted as if the city had slid, revealing a seam she had not expected. “Sweet saints,” Simeon said, then seemed to swallow the words like loose shot. Tick. Tick. Tick. Katra hissed something in her mother’s language that tasted like blood. Marla tilted her head the smallest degree. “I had wondered whose little ornament you were.” She studied Aya’s cheeks, her eyes. “Aristocracy loses interest in charity when the ports freeze. But this—this is not charity. This is taste.” She looked faintly amused. “Miss Aya Darnicourt. Your father sells coal to men who have never seen a mine. Your mother—” She gestured with the pistol. “Ah, but we none of us remember her in polite company, do we.” Aya did not blink. She had learned from mirrors. “My father sells debts to men who have never learned to count. Call him what he is.” “And you,” Marla mused. “You sell nights to men who do not know it is really morning.” She nodded to the wires around Aya’s wrists. “Bring her.” They were tugged forward like fish on a string. Simeon stumbled, boots skidding on the basalt’s damp sheen. His watch ticked and ticked and Aya could hear the exact fiber of spring, the exact tremor, and behind it the immateria calling with voices like moth-wings and funeral bells. Marla looked at the vault. “The Scythan thing hums such delicate hymns. Makes even the air think of better days. Do you hear it?” Aya did. Or perhaps she heard the shape of something like hope and dressed it in foreign vowels. She swallowed. The wire at her throat tightened. “If you were going to shoot us, you’d have done it upstairs.” “Yes,” Marla agreed. “I am cheap sometimes, but I am not wasteful.” “Then don’t be,” Aya said. She lifted her chin against the bite of the loop. “You know who I am now. You know what my father will do. You’ve got his pet constables in your pocket, but he owns their rooms and their women and their children’s milk. You kill me, you bring Morska on your head. You don’t want that. Not in this quarter. Not when you’ve just made such a pretty show of being dead.” Katra twisted against the net. “Aya—” “Let me.” Aya’s mouth had never saved her before; perhaps there was novelty in it. “Keep me,” she told Marla. “Send word to the Darnicourt estate. See what price a man puts on a name. You’ll be paid twice by a father and a city. Leverage the one against the other. That’s all you’ve ever done, isn’t it? You make fortunes out of the space between a man’s fear and his pride.” Marla’s gaze did not flicker. “Listen to you, buying your own gallows. What if I say no?” Simeon made a small sound—no word, more a squeak from a machine in need of oil. Tickticktick. The watch seemed to hurry, impatient with human shape. Aya felt the immateria lean, hungry. It would be so easy to open her throat and let it speak. But they would die for it. Simeon with his small clever hands. Katra with her sandpaper voice and bone-deep loyalty, that ugly, lovely thing. And Aya—Aya would not die yet. She had not yet decided what she would do with the aftermath of being seen. “You won’t,” she said, injecting certainty into the hollow where belief should have been. “Because I am more useful breathing. Because rumor will do more work for you than blood. The guild survives on dread. Imagine what that dread looks like when you hold a Darnicourt daughter in your underhold and the city whispers your name between its teeth.” Marla’s mouth did a small, asymmetrical thing. She lowered one pistol a fraction. The men with the rifles did not move. “I do like whispers,” she admitted. “I keep them in boxes and feed them raisins.” She stepped closer, until Aya could smell peppermints on her breath—cheap ones, bought in paper cones. “What do you think your father will do, truly? Aside from cry into his brandy and strike his steward.” “He’ll send men,” Aya said. “He’ll send machines. He’ll beg the Church to sanctify an arrest warrant. They’ll smile and nod and they’ll do nothing. Because if they break you to save me, they admit you were stronger. They admit they need magick to fight magick. And that’s not—polite.” Marla considered. The humming under the vault deepened, a whale note in stone. Simeon’s watch ticked time against it, stubborn metronome refusing to be seduced by hymns. Katra watched Marla with murder in her eyes and murder’s patient hands. “What is it you want from the door, little fish?” Marla asked, almost curious. “What would you have done with a thing older than our bad habits?” “Open it,” Aya said. The truth slid out because lying cost too much right now, and because perhaps truth tasted sharper. “Listen. Maybe learn to speak back.” “You would.” Marla exhaled as if it amused her. “You and your mother and all your pretty dead.” She lifted her hand and, delicate as a choirgirl, touched the place where Aya’s mask had been, just under her left eye, with the barrel of the pistol. Cold kissed bone. “You will not open anything while you are mine.” “Says the woman who sells doors,” Aya said, and then winced because it had come out too clever by half and she had no right to be clever with wire on her wrists. Marla’s smile did not reach her eyes. “Take them to the pit,” she told her men. “We’ll keep Miss Darnicourt where the air can see her. Write a letter. Send a runner. If anyone asks, we tell them we found a fish that learned to walk.” She glanced to Aya. “And do not worry, little fish. I’ll put you on a chair and let you watch me count the ransom. You can tell me when to stop.” Simeon’s watch ticked agreement or protest—who could say. Katra spat at Marla’s boots and missed by an inch. As they were dragged backward past the vault that moaned slightly of its own accord, Aya felt the press of consequence settle around her shoulders like a wet shroud. The name Darnicourt scraped the air of the underhold until it bled. Simeon’s face held a tightness she had never deserved. Katra’s curses braided with prayers. The immateria knocked, polite, behind her ribs. She did not open. Not here. Not like this. Marla walked beside them a moment, boots whispering on basalt, knives in her voice resheathed for now. “I do hope you are as entertaining unmasked as you are masked,” she murmured. “It is so disappointing when the theatre is better than the man.” “I’m not a man,” Aya said without thinking. “No,” Marla agreed, almost kind. “No. You are appetite.” The men hauled them into a side corridor where the air grew damp with a new rot, and somewhere water dripped in monk-like patience. Simeon’s watch ticked and ticked and ticked, carving seconds into little cogs that would never fit any machine again. Aya breathed through wire and oil and old salt and did not look back at the vault or at Marla’s profile, which already had the quality of a portrait that would survive regimes. “I’ll get you out,” Aya whispered into the cold. It was a debt she wrote knowing it would accrue interest the underhold would demand. “I’ll get us out. I promise.” Katra, hoisted and hamstrung, did not laugh. “We are already out of what we were,” she said. “Now we see if we can breathe.” The door to the pit opened with a wet churn of rust. Aya stepped into a darkness with teeth, and the watch in Simeon’s pocket announced the hour like a tired priest tolling a bell that no one heard anymore. The sound went on, a metronome for fear, as the underhold closed its mouth. And somewhere behind them, a woman in a greatcoat considered how to price a life she had already bought.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response demonstrates exceptional skill in creating a vivid, atmospheric scene that fulfills the prompt requirements while establishing a distinctive voice. The writer has crafted a world that feels simultaneously Victorian and otherworldly, with the "whalepunk" aesthetic coming through in details like "oil-bricked stairwell," "whalebone fused with rivets," and the vault chamber "ribbed with ironwork like the inside of a whale's skull." The prose is highly stylized and dense with imagery, occasionally bordering on purple but generally maintaining control through purposeful rhythm and sensory detail. Lines like "The door gave before Aya's gloved palm with a sigh like a dying lung" establish the gothic tone immediately. The writer excels at creating atmosphere through sensory details: "tasted the copper of brine and stale blood, the oily sweetness of lamp fuel, the mechanical tang of iron filings." Character voices are distinct and consistent with the Victorian-gothic aesthetic. Marla's dialogue is particularly strong, with lines like "A true thing often wears a false wig" and "I keep them in boxes and feed them raisins" establishing her as menacing yet oddly poetic. The dialogue serves both character development and plot advancement effectively. The narrative follows the requested story beats precisely: Aya is captured and unmasked, the trio are taken prisoner, and Aya attempts to negotiate based on her value as a hostage. The writer skillfully incorporates Aya's internal monologue, showing her calculating mind and emotional responses without overexplaining. The worldbuilding is subtle but effective, with references to "immateria magick," the Church's authority, and class divisions creating a coherent society. The fear of magic is well-established through dialogue and character reactions. The Victorian aesthetic comes through in details like pocket watches, oil lamps, and formal speech patterns. The piece does occasionally risk becoming overwrought, with some metaphors that call attention to themselves rather than serving the narrative. A few sentences could be trimmed for clarity without losing the atmospheric quality. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise accomplished piece. The ending avoids incongruent positivity, maintaining the dark tone while providing a natural conclusion to the scene. The characters' predicament feels genuine, and Aya's promise to get them out feels desperate rather than artificially hopeful. Overall, this is an exceptionally strong response that demonstrates mastery of gothic horror elements, Victorian aesthetics, and character development within a constrained word count. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Gunpowder Rendezvous — Score: 88.2
Prompt:
Gunpowder Rendezvous Spike Spiegel & Revy Write a story where Spike Spiegel (Cowboy Bebop) and Revy (Black Lagoon) meet in a seedy bar after both being hired for the same bounty. Their mutual attraction is complicated by their trust issues and competitive instincts. Include drinking, gunplay, and unresolved sexual tension that culminates in a motel room standoff. **Spike Spiegel (Cowboy Bebop)** Spike is a laid-back bounty hunter with a dark past as a syndicate enforcer. He practices Jeet Kune Do and is exceptionally skilled with firearms. He's chronically broke, constantly hungry, and addicted to cigarettes. Despite his carefree attitude, he's haunted by his past and the woman he left behind. He has a prosthetic eye from a past injury that affects his depth perception. He's fatalistic to the extreme, often saying he's already died once. He values freedom above all else and dislikes attachments, though he secretly cares deeply for his crew. Famous quote: "Whatever happens, happens." **Revy/Rebecca Lee (Black Lagoon)** Revy is a Chinese-American dual-wielding gunslinger with unparalleled shooting skills. She's foul-mouthed, chain-smoking, and has severe anger management issues stemming from childhood abuse. She's known as "Two Hands" for her ability to accurately fire two pistols simultaneously. She drinks heavily and solves most problems with violence. Despite her hardened exterior, she has moments of vulnerability, particularly around Rock. She has a dragon tattoo covering her right arm and typically wears extremely short shorts and a black crop top regardless of the situation. Famous quote: "I'm not a good person, not a bad person. I'm just here." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The bar breathes rotgut and old smoke, veneer peeling like sunburnt skin from a counter stained with ringed ghosts. One ring of rust on Spike’s lighter suggests it’s been dropped in water more than once; it clicks, flares, and paints his cheekbones in amber before the light folds back down to the end of his cigarette. The joint’s in some nameless port between borders, a place where even the neon gave up caring. Spike sits sideways on a stool, lanky as a question mark, eyes half-lidded and lazy in a way that’s practiced. The prosthetic eye reflects more than it reveals. He’s broke, stomach complaining in a language whiskey doesn’t translate. He watches the room through cigarette haze: the bartender polishing a glass that’s beyond saving, three dockhands muttering over losing tickets, a jukebox coughing out something mournful and brassy. There’s a bounty in the air like gun oil, a man with a scar down his throat who skipped on a debt big enough to make strangers into coworkers. The door opens. Heat and streetlight pour in around a silhouette. Revy’s grin shows up before the rest of her does—sharp, mocking, hurricane-ready. She’s all legs and bad decisions in shredded shorts and a crop top, dragon tattoo coiling down her right arm like a dare. Smoke curls out of her mouth as she shoulders through the room, hips rolling with the kind of swagger that says she already owns the place. Two pistols ride low at her waist, like sleeping snakes. Spike’s gaze flicks to them and then away. He doesn’t tense; he just breathes in, out, and lets the cigarette cling to his lip. She clocks him in a second, that easy lazy posture and the way his hand rests near his holster without touching it. The haircut that says he either woke up like that or hasn’t slept yet. She licks her thumbnail and taps ash into a tray. “Great,” she says around a grin that has no humor in it. “They sent the clown.” Spike exhales a ribbon of smoke sideways, not enough to be rude, just enough to be clearly uninterested in pleasing anyone. “You’re late,” he says. “And overdressed.” She barks a laugh. “You gonna say that again when I put holes in your shoes?” “Depends. You aiming with your eyes open this time?” Their eyes haven’t left each other and neither of them moves more than a degree. The bartender senses something and polishes faster. “You Spike Spiegel?” Revy asks, even though she knows. “Sometimes.” He flicks ash. “You looking for our boy or just a fight with the décor?” “I’m working,” she says. “You look like you’re drinking on credit and hoping you trip over a payday.” “Whatever happens, happens.” She smirks. “Cute. I got hired to drag a deadbeat out by his neck. You get the same gig?” He shrugs. “Maybe I just like the ambiance.” The deadbeat moves at the mention, a flinch by the back booth where a man with a scarf hiding a scar is nursing a glass he can’t afford. He’s got the look of someone who’s tried to change his face by stuffing too many weeks into a beard. Revy doesn’t look, but she notes it. Spike doesn’t look either, but he smiles. They both grab the bounty at the same time. Revy blurs, pistols in her hands, one trained on the scar-man and one dragging out a warning line across the bar. Spike moves like a slant rhyme, left foot sliding, body slipping between stools and elbows, his hand on the man’s jacket as his other palm pushes a barfly out of the way with polite pressure. “Don’t,” Revy says to the room, and the word cuts. The dockhands freeze with their mouths open. “We’re having a conversation.” The man chokes. “I got money. I can—” “No,” Spike says, pulsing his grip once, just enough to communicate inevitability. “You had money. Now you’ve got us.” She angles the gun at Spike without quite pointing it at him. “He’s mine.” Spike looks at her over the deadbeat’s shoulder. His cigarette dangles. “We can split it. You take the neck. I take the legs.” “Half? I did the legwork.” “You walked into a bar.” Her lip curls. “You wanna dance, cowboy?” “Not in these shoes.” The barman ducks. Somewhere the jukebox wheezes into silence. The bounty bolts—a dumb rabbit burst—but Spike’s hand already has the back of his belt, and Revy’s shot is not a shot; it’s a message. The bullet punches the floorboards between the man’s feet, popping splinters like a magician’s bouquet. He freezes, hands up, eyes white. “Cute trick,” she says. “Nice warning shot,” he replies. He starts moving the man toward the door, but Revy sidesteps, blocking with hip and heat and the cold twin moons of her pistols. Up close, she smells like sweat, cordite, and the cheap candy of flavored smoke. Her eyes are fathomless in a way that says the bottom is knives. “You want a half?” she says. “Beat me to it. Or buy me a drink and get outta my way.” Spike takes a last drag and lets the smoke sit a second. Then he flicks the cigarette into the sink behind the bar, where it hisses next to a long rust ring that mirrors the one on his lighter. “I’m bad at math,” he says. “Let’s call it even.” Gunfire snaps from the doorway. Not them. A trio of rough shapes spills in with long coats and short patience—the deadbeat’s friends or his debtors’ collectors, hard to say. They don’t announce anything, just level and let fly. The room erupts into splinters and noise. Bottles explode, people hit the floor in a rush, and Spike is already moving, twisting the bounty down behind a table as he draws. Revy laughs, a sound with teeth. She turns on the balls of her feet, both guns roaring in counterpoint. The first guy takes two rounds through his coat and spins down like a puppet with cut strings. The second ducks behind a pillar; Spike puts a bullet into the edge of it, then another, a rhythm a hair off from human heartbeat, making the man flinch into Revy’s follow-up shot. He goes ragdoll. The third gets stupid and charges, and Spike meets him halfway, foot a whisper, fist a comma, gun a period. The man drops, punctuation complete. The smoke thickens into a curtain. Revy ejects magazines with practiced contempt and jams fresh ones in, eyes glittering. “Nice moves,” she says without looking at Spike. “Yours aren’t bad,” he says. His chest rises, falls, the adrenaline making the world too sharp. The bounty has crawled under a table and is pleading with a god that doesn’t service this district. Revy kicks a chair aside and yanks him up by the back of the collar. He sputters, scrapes, tries to reach for a knife that isn’t there, and she presses the cold ring of a barrel behind his ear. Spike steps in, gun down but present, and their gazes snag again. Somewhere under the smoke the jukebox tries to start another song and fails. “Split?” he says. “Your half is smaller,” she replies. “My half is prettier.” He smiles, then doesn’t. Memory flickers behind his eyes, a woman framed in rain, the weight of a choice he made and pretends he didn’t. He masks it with a tilt of his head, like a man listening for a train. “We both got paid to bring him in. If we both show up, the client gets a discount and we get screwed. I don’t like getting screwed.” “Depends on who’s doing it,” Revy says, and her smirk drops to something that might have been a flicker of honesty, then shutters. “We take him to separate doors, get separate signatures.” He considers. “Or we stash him, split the take, split the trouble.” “You trust me?” she asks. The laugh in her mouth is more wound than joke. “Not even a little.” “Good, we’re on the same page.” They move together anyway, an uneasy dance in the debris, hauling the deadbeat through the back, past the smell of bleached mop and rotten lettuce. Outside, the alley is wet and loud with the city’s heartbeat. For a second, in the sodium light, they look like a couple on a bad night: the tall, tired one and the one who’s too angry to sleep. They stash the bounty in the trunk of a stolen car, wrists zip-tied, mouth gagged with his own scarf. Revy wipes sweat from her upper lip and lights another cigarette. Spike’s lighter flares again, that ring of rust catching the light like a scar. “Where you staying?” she asks, like she doesn’t care. Spike exhales. “Wherever’s cheap.” “Figures.” She flicks ash into the night, watches it fall like tiny meteors. “You hungry?” “Always.” They end up in a motel where the wallpaper was once optimistic. The neon outside flickers a pinkish heartbeat through the blinds. They eat bad noodles from a vending machine, wash it down with beer that tastes like a lost bet. The bounty snores muffled somewhere out in the car park. Revy sits on the bed nearest the door, legs spread, pistols within reach. The dragon along her arm looks like it might uncoil and crawl down her wrist. Spike leans against the dresser, shoulder to wood, one ankle draped over the other, gun tucked at his back. He studies her between drags, pretending not to. “You got a woman somewhere?” she asks, eyes sharp in the sick light. “Somewhere,” he says, and looks through the wall for a second. “She’s a ghost.” Revy snorts softly. “Yeah. Got a ghost or two myself.” She stares at her own knuckles like there might be a map there. “Don’t mean I’m friendly.” “I’m not friendly,” he says. He smiles anyway. “Just polite.” She stands and closes the distance, stopping close enough that the heat changes. She smells like smoke and adrenaline and something floral that clings despite all the ugliness. Their eyes lock—a stare with edges on it. “You gonna try to screw me on the split?” she asks, low and dangerous. “I told you,” he says. “Not my style. Whatever happens, happens.” She laughs, breath hitting his cheek, and it isn’t gentle. Her hand comes up and for a heartbeat he isn’t sure if she’s going to cup his jaw or break it. She takes his cigarette instead, puts it to her lips, draws, and returns it. When her fingers brush his there’s a current. It’s not electricity; it’s recognition. “Whatever happens,” she echoes, and there’s something ugly and tender hiding in the words. He reaches up, slow, and flicks ash into an empty can. She’s watching his hands like they owe her money. His stance shifts, a fraction. Her weight settles, a fraction. They both feel the other’s balance change. They both draw. Guns lean into the space, not fully raised, not quite aimed. The air in the room tightens like a wire. Neon stutters across metal. Spike’s mouth lifts at one corner. Revy’s tongue touches her back teeth. “Relax,” he says. “Close enough and we both miss.” She tilts her head, eyes flicking to his prosthetic eye and back. “You sure about that?” “No.” He inhales, lets the smoke sit on his tongue like a secret. “But it’s a fun thought.” She’s still so close he can trace the faint white line of a scar along her ribs. She sees the fold of a white shirt over old bruises beneath his jacket. Trust is a foreign language they both refuse to learn, but they understand grammar like this. “You take the client in the morning,” she says. “We meet at noon by the cranes. Split cash. No tails. You try anything—” “I won’t have to,” he says. “You’ll shoot me first.” “Damn right.” They lower their guns in increments, like it costs them something. It does. The room exhales. Somewhere, a car alarm coughs and thinks better of it. Spike crushes his cigarette in the can. Revy reholsters with the neat, practiced motion of someone who’s had to do it fast enough to draw again. They stare a beat longer, then a beat after that, because neither will be the one to look away. “You got another beer?” she asks. “You gonna say please?” “In your dreams.” He tosses her a can. She catches it one-handed without looking. He can’t help the smile that creeps in. She cracks it open, foam slipping over her knuckles. She sucks it off with a slow, insolent swipe of her tongue. The neon gives her an outline like a cartoon of a flame. They drink. The motel hums. Outside, the trunk creaks and something inside thumps once and goes quiet. “See you at noon,” she says finally, and it isn’t a question. He tips an invisible hat. “If we’re both not dead.” She steps backward to the door, never turning, never offering a spine to a stranger. She stops with her hand on the knob, eyes holding his. There’s a space between them that could be filled with a kiss or a fistfight. They leave it empty. She slips out, and the room feels bigger and smaller at the same time. Spike’s lighter clicks in the silence, flame blooming, that rust ring catching neon so it looks like a planet with weather. He lights up and tastes the night through the filter. He thinks of a woman he left behind and a woman who just left. He thinks of the way Revy’s laugh hit him like shrapnel. He thinks about how hungry he still is and how the money might not feel like anything when it’s in his hand. Whatever happens, happens. He smokes, waits for the darkness to turn into morning, and listens to the old motel carry the weight of a truce that isn’t one. Somewhere outside, Revy’s boots crunch on gravel as she disappears into the crude heartbeat of the city. Neither of them sleeps. Neither of them can. The standoff isn’t over; it’s just learning to breathe.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully captures the essence of both characters from their respective universes while creating a believable scenario where they might interact. The author demonstrates a strong understanding of both Spike and Revy's personalities, mannerisms, and speech patterns. The prose is atmospheric and noir-tinged, establishing a seedy setting that feels appropriate for both characters. The descriptive language effectively creates a visual and sensory experience, with particularly strong imagery in the opening paragraph that sets the tone for the entire piece. Character portrayal is one of the strongest elements. Spike's laid-back fatalism and Revy's aggressive, foul-mouthed demeanor are both rendered authentically. Their interactions maintain the competitive tension requested in the prompt while developing a grudging mutual respect that feels earned rather than forced. The dialogue is particularly strong, capturing each character's voice while advancing the plot and revealing character. Lines like "Whatever happens, happens" and Revy's sharp retorts feel true to the source material without becoming caricatures. The unresolved sexual tension builds naturally through their interactions, culminating in the motel room standoff that balances danger and attraction effectively. The author wisely avoids resolving this tension, keeping with the prompt's request for "unresolved" tension. The action sequence in the bar demonstrates both characters' combat abilities while maintaining their distinct fighting styles - Spike's fluid Jeet Kune Do movements contrasted with Revy's aggressive dual-wielding gunplay. There are a few instances where the prose becomes slightly purple, particularly in some of the metaphorical descriptions, but these moments generally serve the noir atmosphere rather than detract from it. The pacing is well-managed, with a natural progression from initial meeting to conflict to uneasy alliance. The ending leaves things appropriately unresolved, with both characters maintaining their essential natures while acknowledging a connection. Overall, this is a skillfully crafted crossover that respects both source materials while creating something that stands on its own merits. The author has successfully balanced action, tension, and character development within the constraints of the prompt. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Folk horror: Útiseta — Score: 91.6
Prompt:
Folk Horror: Útiseta Write a chapter set in rural northern Sweden in the mid-1990s. Linnea, a teenage girl from Stockholm, has reluctantly moved to a small village with her parents after her father's job transfer. She's befriended Astrid, a local girl who claims her grandmother taught her ancient practices passed down through generations. Astrid has been introducing Linnea to "midnight games" that involve old rituals, convincing her they can use them to learn classmates' secrets or influence their behavior. Tonight, Astrid has convinced Linnea to participate in Útiseta—sitting out on an ancient burial mound at midnight to "receive knowledge from beyond." The chapter focuses on this single midnight excursion, the ritualistic preparations, Astrid's matter-of-fact instructions that mix teenage rebellion with eerily specific traditional elements, and the mounting tension as Linnea becomes increasingly uncertain whether they're simply scaring themselves or if something is actually responding to their presence. The narrative should maintain ambiguity about whether the strange occurrences are supernatural or psychological, while establishing the dangerous line they're crossing by treating ancient practices as entertainment. First person, past tense, told as Linnea's recollection of events in the present day (though this device should be largely transparent). 1000 words. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
We had walked out past the last lit window a dozen times that winter, but only when we stepped off the plowed road and into the field did I feel the village fall away. The snow squeaked under our boots, dry and loud in the cold. Astrid went first, her flashlight beam skimming the crusted drifts and the juniper stubs that blackened the white like punctuation. A weak yellow moon sat low above the tree line. We didn't speak. Breath made dragons out of us, then fell away, invisible. Somewhere behind us, the church bell would have chimed midnight if it hadn't frozen stuck the week before. The burial mound was a soft swelling under the snow, a whale's back with tufts of dead grass frozen into it like whiskers. It lay beyond the last spruce, out where the land slouched down to the river. Astrid killed the light and the dark rushed in, thick and blue, grainy with stars. She didn't seem to need her eyes. She had grown up walking between these trees like the rooms of her house. "It's colder here," I said, because it was, and because my voice felt like an anchor in the silence. "Ja," she said, kneeling and brushing frost off a flat stone at the mound's edge. "They always said the air is different on the old places. Like it pulls at the heat." "They who?" She glanced up at me and did that half-smile she had when she wanted me to decide if I was in on the joke. "My mormor. Her mormor. Everyone, if you asked and they felt like telling you. Hold this." She pushed a thermos into my hands and pulled a crumpled plastic bag out of her jacket. The bag crinkled like candy wrappers. Inside were things she had shown me in the light of her kitchen that afternoon: a stub of candle, a cheap postcard with a black-and-white photo of the mound from the 1950s, a length of red thread, a hunk of bread hardened to a crust, and a small jar of something that had floated pale strands in clear liquid. "What's in the jar?" I asked, though I already knew. She had told me and then waited for my face to change. She liked collecting my reactions. "Salt herring," she said. "They like salt. It's a good exchange, Mormor said. They keep salt and iron and names. You give them salt and yours holds better." "They? And what's my name doing out there to begin with?" She shrugged, fast and practical as a nurse. "Everything has a place to go. You'll see." Her matter-of-factness was heavier than the dark. The other games, the ones with chalk and apple seeds and whispered questions, had been the kinds of things kids were always making up, even if Astrid said they weren't made up. She'd had me rub my temples with spruce resin to dream about someone, had me spit into the river with a rhyme to make a boy forget me. Silly until they weren't, until a teacher turned back from the blackboard as if hearing his name called, until a girl in our class who'd bullied Astrid stopped sitting with her friends and took the long bus instead of waiting with us, saying she didn't know why. I had told myself we were rehearsing superstitions, trying them on like coats. I told myself the village needed its stories the way Stockholm needed the Metro map. Under that was the warm, mean knowledge that I just wanted to be with Astrid, to have her look at me like I belonged to a line of things. She stuck the candle into the snow, sheltered it with her cupped hands, and lit it with the lighter she wasn't supposed to have. The flame ticked, then leaned, then straightened, beads of wax dripping like fat tears onto the ice. Astrid pointed north, over the line of black pines that bracketed the sky. "You sit facing that way," she said. "That's the door. You don't turn to look behind you if you hear them coming. You don't speak unless you are spoken to, and if you are, you say only what you came to say. And when you're answered, you don't ask again. You say thank you, and we go. You step off the mound backwards, and you don't look at me either." "Astrid," I said, hearing a thin thread of laugh in my voice. "Is this—" "A game," she said, and smiled. "A midnight game. You said you wanted to try one that had teeth." Her grandmother had been a small woman with the posture of a fence post, all straight lines and knots, who watched television with the sound off and boiled coffee until it was black as oil. The day I met her she had looked at me long enough to make me fumble, and then nodded like an inspector signing off on something she didn't approve of but couldn't stop. "What if someone sees the light?" I asked, looking back toward the village. The snow field looked like a sheet stretched tight. The few porch bulbs were far enough to make their own galaxies. For a moment I couldn't imagine anyone seeing us, then I thought of Hampus on his snowmobile, of his missing tooth and the way he had told me a Stockholm girl needed a guide, of his laughing friends. "They're sleeping," Astrid said. "They're never awake when you need them to be. Here." She pressed the red thread into my palm. "Tie your hair with it. It keeps you like yourself. You don't want to drift." The thread was coarse, and it snagged on my glove. The wind picked up just enough to move the topmost boughs of the pines. The sound was the same sound I'd heard all winter at school when the radiators breathed, when people spoke in the halls and it became only texture. It was almost speech. Astrid poured a capful of the fishy brine onto the hard dirt at the base of the mound, the smell knifing around us, cold and clean and salt. She pinched a piece of the bread and laid it beside the postcard. Someone's father's face, serious and blurred with age, stared out from the postcard as if we had woken him up. "Now," she said. "Sit. Close your eyes, or don't. You can choose. If you see something you don't like, you pretend it's something else. Do you understand?" "Not really." She grinned. "Good. You ask. Ask for what you want." What did I want? I wanted to know if the teacher with the scar was really sleeping with the nurse. I wanted to know if Hampus had broken into the skate rink or if he'd just found it open. I wanted to know if my father was going to stay in this job until I graduated, or if we were going to pack again for a new winter somewhere else. I wanted to know if the letter I had sent to my friend in Stockholm had even reached her, if she had tossed it on her bed and left for a party and forgotten. I wanted to know why Astrid picked me and whether she would keep me or get bored. I sat. The mound was frozen earth under a thin skin of snow. The cold came up through my jeans in a clean sheet. Astrid stood behind me, just off my shoulder, her breath touching the hair near my ear sometimes, sometimes not. The candle flickered in the corner of my eye. I tried not to blink too much. The wind moved the pines again, a sigh that sounded like a word trying to remember itself. "Say it," Astrid murmured. "Say their names if you know them. Say the question." "I don't know their names," I said. My voice webbed itself between the trees and came back different, as if someone else had spoken more quietly. "Then call them by what they are," she said. "The ones here. The ones under. The ones who still listen." I swallowed. The red thread was tight against my scalp. I could feel individual hairs pulling under it. "Is anyone here?" I asked, and felt stupid at once, theatrical. I tried again. "We brought salt," I said, softer. "We brought bread." In my head I added: We brought curiosity like a knife. We brought boredom like a match. We brought me. "Tell them why," Astrid said. "Or they'll tell you something you didn't ask for." I didn't want that. I didn't want their secrets tumbling into my lap like stones I had to carry home. I picked one thing and held it up in my mind like a coin. "I want to know," I said, "if Hampus changed the answers on the math test last week. Everyone says he did. Did he?" It felt small. It felt like throwing a pebble in the ocean. The candle snapped. The wind slid through the pines and for a moment, for no reason, my scalp crawled in two precise paths from the crown down toward my ears, as if something with small hands had patted my head and then forgotten what it was doing. Astrid's fingers brushed my shoulder. They were warm. "Don't turn," she said, and I realized I had leaned as though to look back at her. Her voice was steady. "Let them say." I waited. The night made noise: ice ticking in the river, a distant fox barking, the small animal sounds of the village that in Stockholm would have been drowned by sirens and traffic. The dark pressed into my eyes until I saw flowers in it, amoebas of light drifting and changing. Slowly, the cold moved from sensation to fact. At some point I realized I had begun to count breaths, as if I were waiting for pain. Nothing answered. Or if something did, it answered in a language I hadn't been taught. A sensation rose from the ground like heat in summer, the wrong time to feel that, but there it was, a field of something just below the surface. The word that came to me was attention. Not a gaze. Not even a listening. A presence that wasn't focused on me until I thought about it, and then it was, and I wished I had chosen a different question. The candle guttered again and then, with a small sound like a mouse, blew out. The dark didn't change. Astrid sucked her breath in softly through her teeth. She didn't say anything. She didn't move away either. "Now what?" I whispered. "Let it be," she whispered back, but her voice had a burr in it, excitement or fear, I couldn't tell. "Don't ask again. You asked. They will answer if they will." We sat. I thought of Stockholm and of the lit kitchen of my old apartment, of my mother leaving a radio on all day so she would not be alone with her thoughts. Here, the only radio was the wind and its whispers. My jaw ached and I realized I was clenching it. I made myself loosen my teeth. The cold had drawn lines down through the mound into my bones. I listened for footsteps behind me and heard none, and then I heard one, faint, a single crunch in the snow that could have been a pinecone dropping its weight, except it was right there, behind me, not to the left or the right but in the place where a person would stand if they were about to tip my head back with their hand. Astrid squeezed my shoulder once, hard enough to bruise, then let go. I didn't turn. The sound didn't come again. I said, because it felt like something would break if I didn't, "Thank you." My voice was paper. "Good," Astrid said, as if we had passed something. Her hand was shaking when it touched my hair to find the red thread. "Now stand," she said, "and step back. Don't look at me, don't look at them. Just back." We moved like blind people in a small room. It was hard to balance without lifting my feet and looking where I put them. The mound had a curve to it that didn't match what my body expected. In the act of stepping, I felt a tug at my ankle, as if something had caught the cuff of my jeans with a hook. I stumbled and flung my hands out in the dark, gasping. Astrid's hands were there, surprisingly fast, catching my elbows and guiding me, firm. "It's just a root," she said, her mouth very close to my ear. "Don't give them that. Don't give them the fear with your name on it." We stepped down off the mound. The cold was less by one degree. I could breathe my own breath again. The river sounded like a thing waking up. After a moment, Astrid struck the lighter and sheltered it again, and the small circle of fire was so human it made my eyes sting. "We forgot to drink," she said, and laughed, a small brittle sound. "You have to drink when you're done. So you don't bring them back in your throat." She unscrewed the thermos. The coffee was sweet and burned my lip and I didn't care. We poured a little into the snow, then we drank again. We did everything by halves, as if balancing between making it all real and keeping it a story. On the way back through the field, the snow squeaked louder, or maybe I could hear better now that the mound was behind us. Astrid didn't turn the flashlight back on. The moon was enough. The village drew itself up out of the dark like a toy set, yellow squares of windows, frost glittering along the eaves. I glanced back once, quickly. The mound was a darker heap against the white, nothing else. I wanted it to show me something, a pale figure, a candle burning again where we'd left it, evidence to carry like a talisman or like a joke. It didn't. The pines moved their tops again and whispered, and in that whisper was my name, or not my name but the idea of a name being called. "Do you think he'll get caught?" I asked finally, as if we were already back in Astrid's kitchen, as if we had not stepped backward through air that felt thick as water. "Hampus?" she said. "Maybe. He thinks too much of himself." "Did they answer?" I asked. "Did you hear anything?" She paused, and in that pause I heard her grandmother in the way she set words down like stones in a path. "You asked," she said. "Sometimes that's enough to make something happen." "That's not an answer." She smiled in the dark. I could feel it. "You know how this works by now. Or you don't. It's not my job to make you safe." I wanted to snap at her but I didn't. Her shoulder bumped mine and she didn't move away. When we reached the road, the snow under our feet changed its sound, and the low hum of the village's transformer came to meet us, and a dog barked twice as if waking from a dream. I untied the red thread and put it in my pocket. It was damp. My hair sprang loose and felt like another person's hand. At the ditch, we stopped and looked back together once more. The mound didn't move. It didn't need to. It had all the time in the world. Weeks later, when Hampus didn't come to school because he'd been caught with the math key and the janitor's spare ring, I would say it was coincidence. I would say Astrid had probably known something she hadn't told me. I would say we had made patterns out of the wind's whispering and our own breath smoking. I would keep the red thread in the bottom of my drawer anyway, and I would not walk past the mound again alone. In the morning, Astrid's grandmother would smell the herring brine on our scarves and purse her lips and not ask. We would nod like guilty children and then, when we were alone, grin. We would drink too-hot coffee and my lip would still be sore and the burn would be a proof. But that night, crossing back into the warm circle of human light, we were two girls who had stepped onto something older and called it a game. It wasn't mine. It wasn't Astrid's either, no matter how she wore it like a jacket. It was the village's hum under our feet. It was the sleep of the ones under the mound and the attention that lifted its head when we knocked. Maybe we scared ourselves. Maybe we learned to be careful. Maybe something watched us go and felt the space we left. The pines rustled again behind us, almost words, almost our names. We didn't turn. We didn't run. We pretended we had done nothing dangerous at all. And we went home.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This folk horror piece effectively captures the essence of the genre while adhering closely to the prompt requirements. Set in rural northern Sweden in the 1990s, the story follows Linnea, a Stockholm transplant, as she participates in the ancient ritual of Útiseta with her local friend Astrid. The narrative maintains the requested ambiguity about whether supernatural events are occurring or if it's merely psychological suggestion. The writing excels in establishing atmosphere through sensory details. The cold Swedish winter is palpable through descriptions like "The snow squeaked under our boots, dry and loud in the cold" and "The cold came up through my jeans in a clean sheet." These details ground the reader in the physical setting while the ritual elements create an unsettling atmosphere. Character development is handled with subtlety. Linnea's outsider status and desire to belong is conveyed through her willingness to participate in increasingly dangerous rituals with Astrid. The dynamic between the girls feels authentic—Astrid's matter-of-fact approach to the supernatural contrasts with Linnea's skepticism tinged with fear. Astrid's character is particularly well-drawn; her connection to local traditions through her grandmother gives her actions credibility while her teenage motivations remain relatable. The prose maintains a consistent first-person past tense voice as requested, with Linnea recounting the experience. The writing style effectively balances teenage vernacular with more lyrical passages that enhance the eerie mood. Sentences like "The dark pressed into my eyes until I saw flowers in it, amoebas of light drifting and changing" demonstrate sophisticated imagery without becoming purple prose. The narrative maintains tension throughout, particularly during the ritual itself. The ambiguity about whether something supernatural is occurring is skillfully handled—the "single crunch in the snow" and the sensation of something tugging at Linnea's ankle could be explained rationally or supernaturally. This ambiguity extends to the outcome of their ritual regarding Hampus, leaving readers to decide whether coincidence or supernatural forces were at work. The ending effectively balances the immediate aftermath with a brief glimpse into the future consequences, showing how the experience affected Linnea without resolving the central mystery. The final paragraph powerfully encapsulates the theme of teenagers treating ancient practices as entertainment without understanding their significance: "Maybe we scared ourselves. Maybe we learned to be careful. Maybe something watched us go and felt the space we left." There are few weaknesses in this piece. The dialogue is sparse but effective, serving the atmospheric nature of the story. The pacing is deliberate, focusing on building tension rather than action, which suits the folk horror genre. If there's any criticism to be made, it might be that some readers could find the middle section of the ritual slightly drawn out, but this serves the purpose of building suspense and immersing the reader in Linnea's experience. Overall, this is an exemplary piece of folk horror that fulfills all the prompt requirements while creating a genuinely unsettling atmosphere and believable characters. The writing demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of the genre conventions while maintaining originality and emotional resonance. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Physical-spatial: Therapeutic Boundaries — Score: 94.8
Prompt:
**"Therapeutic Boundaries"** Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a former professional athlete undergoing mandatory physical therapy after a career-destroying injury, harboring resentment toward recovery itself. Their physiotherapist is not only unnervingly attractive but also a former training partner from their competitive days who has successfully transitioned to a new career while the protagonist's identity remains shattered. We'll lean into the sexual tension of the scene by having her be attracted to him, but both of them attempting to maintain mental distance while being in physical contact as he shows her stretches & movements & manipulates her body, navigating the thresholds of pain. This scene MUST maintain complete physical coherence—every movement, stretch, and manipulation must be anatomically precise and spatially consistent. Paint an exceptionally vivid sensory picture through detailed attention to pain thresholds, involuntary responses to touch. Capture the suppressed, flaring tension of physical proximity, touch, and the controlled infliction of uncomfortable movements. Physical clarity is essential — readers must understand exactly what is happening with the body during each therapeutic technique. 1000 words.
Model Output:
He’s waiting for me when I limp in, clipboard tucked into the crook of his elbow, the same casual efficiency as when he used to shadow me in warm-ups, counting my ladders without looking. The compression sleeves are the first thing I notice—pale teal flecked with coral and navy, a topographical map wrapped around his calves. I wore the matching set back when we ran stadium stairs before dawn. He’s kept his, as if he knew all along he’d need them in a room like this. “Hey,” he says. His voice is lower than I remember, softer. “How’s the hamstring today?” “Attached,” I say, and then I regret it because he smiles and the room tilts. I ease onto the treatment table, the vinyl squeaking against my shorts as I scoot back. The room smells like eucalyptus, floor cleaner, and something warm—his soap, maybe. There’s a mirror against one wall, the full-length kind that makes every angle a picture you didn’t ask for, and I know if I look I’ll see the line of my bad leg where the muscle density dips, the surgical scars like parentheses. I don’t look. “Let me see your walk, first.” He steps back and gestures to the strip of tape on the floor. His hands slip into his pockets like he’s reminding them not to grab me. I nod and slide off the table. The first step is fine. The second is a question. By the third my right hamstring is a taut wire that’s forgotten what it’s for, so I shorten my stride and roll through the foot carefully, more ankle dorsiflexion, less knee extension. “You’re protecting it,” he says, neutral. “Again.” He steps closer, his palm hovering near my lateral thigh like he’s spotting me without contact. “Let’s lie you down.” I feel fourteen again as I turn to face the table, sit on the edge, then pivot and lie supine. He lowers the backrest so my head is neutral, not flexed. It’s all by-the-book: he slides a bolster under my knees to slacken the hamstrings, reduce lumbar lordosis. He slides it away when he’s ready. He keeps a distance that is both careful and impossible. “I’m going to check the length,” he says. He places one hand under my right heel and the other over my anterior superior iliac spine, the crest of my hip, to keep my pelvis from tilting posteriorly. “Try to let the leg go heavy.” The word heavy makes something inside me fight back. I hate this part, the surrender. But I breathe out and let the weight of my leg settle into his hand. He flexes my hip, slowly, knee extended, ankle neutral. At sixty degrees, the back of my thigh grumbles, a deep burn like an old match relit. At seventy, the burn becomes a hot, clean edge and I exhale through my teeth. My toes flex up reflexively; he taps my tibialis anterior with a knuckle like we’re both pretending that was about dorsiflexion and not pain. “Seventy-two,” he says, eyes on the inclinometer at my malleolus. His touch at my hip is firm, pinning my pelvis to stop me from cheating with a posterior tilt. My hamstring screams at the stop, the tendons behind my knee feeling like ropes pulled taut over pulleys. He holds it, even as my calf quivers. I’m aware of the compression sleeve hugging his forearm as he supports my leg, of the little flecks of color moving when he adjusts his grip. He lowers my leg carefully. His palm cups my heel, then slides away. The absence of contact is a second pain. He circles to the left side. “Left is our control.” It reaches eighty-eight before there’s any resistance. He marks it down like he’s logging weather. “Bridge with the ball,” he says. He slips a small, deflated medicine ball between my knees. “Feet hip-width. Heels under knees.” He taps the heads of my fibula with his finger to keep them in line. “Adduct gently—fifteen percent, not more.” “How do I do fifteen percent of a thing I hate?” I ask, but my inner thighs find the ball, my adductors switch on with a dull ache that’s less specific than the hamstring. He stands at my side, one hand spread at my lower abdomen, not touching, just measuring my breath. “Exhale, then tilt your pelvis, small posterior tilt. Bring your ribs down.” His other hand draws the arc of my pelvis without touching it, and I follow, flattening the lumbar curve to neutral by engaging lower abdominals. The tilt lengthens the hamstrings proximally where they attach at the ischial tuberosities. “Now press through your heels and lift. One segment at a time.” His voice is close to my ear. He smells like citrus peel and clean sweat. I drive through my heels. The hamstring wakes first with a low, electric buzz, the gluteus maximus late to the party like it always is now that the hamstring has been over-recruited for months. He sees it. “Push through your heels, not your toes. Think of your sit bones reaching toward your knees.” I change the force vector. The glutes bite in, a deep contraction like teeth into flesh. The hamstrings still protest, especially the distal portion near the tendon, but the cramp recedes. He slides two fingers lightly under my lower back to check that I’m not hyperextending the lumbar spine. “Hold. Breathe.” The world narrows to the tremor in my right leg. My breath is noisy. I want to look up, but he’s in my peripheral vision, his sleeve like a blooming reef. His hand presses lightly on my ASIS to cue me to keep the pelvis level; the right side tries to hike, cheat out of the pain. I correct, and the tendon seizes, then releases. He knows that micro-hiccup has nothing to do with fear and everything to do with scar tissue sliding reluctantly. We do sets until my thighs tremble like I’ve done a ladder of 400s. We rest when he says rest. He changes the exercise. “Prone, please.” Rolling onto my stomach, the table paper crackles. He adjusts a small towel under my patella to ease pressure. My forehead rests on my forearms. I’m immediately aware of my hamstring origin, the sit bone on the right side, a tugging like a pulled thread. He kneels beside my right hip. “I’m going to do a soft tissue mobilization. You tell me if it’s too much.” His hands warm the skin at the posterior thigh with a glide—lotion, friction, then a sustained press along the line of the semitendinosus, medial side. He follows the fibers proximally, slow and exact. When he finds a nodule, he pins it with his thumb and the heel of his hand and holds. The discomfort blooms, then sharpens. My toes flex, my foot pronates against the table, and he places his other hand at my lateral calf to cue neutrality. “Breathe into it,” he says. His voice has the little indentations of effort. He’s working too. He traces the sciatic nerve’s path with care, staying lateral, never pressing hard there. He knows the map of me. He moves to the biceps femoris, lateral hamstring, the one that tore, the one that failed at the worst possible second. His thumb finds the proximal tendon and the scar where it reattached. The pressure there is a lightning bolt. My breath goes ragged; I grip the edge of the table. The pain is clean in a way that makes me angry. He eases, lands again lighter, and I hate him for that compassion. “Eccentrics,” he says when the heat in the muscle feels like the aftermath of a race. “On your side.” I roll onto my left side. He stacks my hips, aligns my knees. My right hip flexes to about thirty degrees, my knee at ninety. He places a resistance band around my ankles. “We’ll do Nordic later when the tendon’s ready. For now, controlled lengthening.” He positions my right foot slightly behind the left, toes neutral. “I’m going to support your thigh. You’ll extend the hip against the band slowly, then resist the return even slower.” He grips my thigh with one hand, forearm aligned with the femur. His sleeve brushes my skin, and the contact is both clinical and incendiary. He lifts slightly to unload the weight, then says, “Go.” I press my thigh into hip extension, glute squeezing. The hamstring joins in late but strong, a live wire along the back of the thigh. He gives me just enough resistance that my effort spreads, like ink, into stabilizers—obliques, adductors. He watches my pelvis for tilt. “Don’t arch,” he murmurs, thumb tapping my sacrum. On the way back, I fight gravity, prolonging the lengthening under load. The tendon sings. My breath hitches on the count of four. He counts under his breath, his words a metronome that lands on my skin. By the third rep, my hamstring is humming. By the fifth, the hum is a growl. On the sixth, my foot wants to externally rotate to avoid the pain and he corrects it gently, thumb and forefinger bracketing my heel. The involuntary anger that flushes my throat is mortifying. He knows. He doesn’t acknowledge it. He just says, “Two more.” We switch sides and he notes the difference without a word. Dry humor used to be our currency. Now we have numbers. “Sit up,” he says. He helps me with a hand under my scapula, too quick for me to refuse. Sitting on the edge of the table, he positions me for neural glides. “Slump test. I want nerve mobility without aggravation.” He sits on a stool in front of me, our knees almost touching. He demonstrates with his own leg, shin bone gleaming under the colorful sleeve. “Chin to chest, slouch, then extend your knee, pull toes toward you. Don’t move your head while you move the leg, then switch.” It’s a choreography of thresholds. I drop my chin, feel the pull along my spine. When I extend my right knee, the hamstring tightens, but this is a different discomfort—zipping along the posterior chain. He holds his hand up between us, palm out, and as I extend, he lowers his hand like he’s pushing my foot with air. I stop at the first hint of nerve tension. We alternate, nodding my head only when the knee bends. My hamstring shivers with each glide; my calf tingles. He watches my foot, my face, the way my shoulders try to creep toward my ears. He touches my upper traps lightly and says, “Drop.” He moves behind me. I go still. He guides my right hip into external rotation for a piriformis stretch: ankle over left knee, back straight. He places his hand on my sacrum to keep me from flexing and asks me to hinge at the hips. When I do, the posterior hip opens in a deep ache. His palm on my sacrum is a brand through my shirt. I hear him inhale as if he’s reminding himself he’s not who he used to be either. He presses gently on my right knee, aligning pressure through the femur, not the joint. “Where?” he asks. “Deep,” I say. “Not nerve.” It matters. He adjusts his angle a degree. The stretch sharpens in the belly of the muscle and my foot flutters. “Good,” he says. “Hold. Breathe.” He kneels again, this time beside my shins. He slides my right foot forward into a half-kneel, my right knee under my hip. He cues pelvic tuck, glute squeeze, then presses on my right iliac crest to prevent lateral shift as I lean forward, stretching the hip flexor. It’s the companion pain to my hamstring, the front of the hip resisting length after months of guarding. The pressure through his fingers is directional, instructive. I imagine bone under his palm, the old map of his own body matching the current map of mine. “Where do you feel it?” he asks, always asking. He doesn’t assume. He waits. “Front. Not in the back,” I say, and he nods once. We finish with a gentle hamstring stretch supine, belt looped around my foot. He holds the belt ends, a buffer between us. He raises my leg until the stretch begins, then stops, hands steady. He cues a contract-relax: “Press into the belt, about thirty percent, five seconds.” My hamstring contracts against the strap; my calf speaks too. “And relax.” He takes up the slack a few degrees, the tissue yielding. Three cycles and my straight-leg raise gains five degrees. It isn’t victory. It’s a notch carved into a doorframe. His hand is at my ankle when I want it to be elsewhere, at my hip when I wish I were less porous. He is both careful and relentless, never letting me slide out of effort. He assigns me homework like he used to assign me extra drills for turnover. “Three sets, twice a day,” he says, handing me a band. Our fingers brush. The band is the same robin’s egg blue as his sleeves. “You’ll hate me for the first week. Then you’ll just hate the band.” “I already hate the band,” I say. The joke lands, and we both smile for a second too long. He steps back, defusing the space. His face sobers. “You’re doing the work,” he says. “It’s not nothing.” I want to tell him that the work is the only part I know how to do. That I resent every inch I gain because it feels like evidence of a body moving on without me. Instead, I slide off the table, my hamstring a hot line, my hands unsteady around the band. He opens the door for me. The hallway is cool, the air conditioner breathing. I step through, feeling the tilt of my pelvis over my femurs, the subtle adjustment my body makes to spare the tendon. Behind me, he says my name. I don’t turn. The anger needs somewhere to live. The band bites my palm. His sleeves flash in the corner of my eye like a signal flag from a ship that didn’t sink. I keep walking. The pain is precise, honest. It hurts in the right place. That, at least, is progress.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative excels at creating a physically precise and emotionally charged physical therapy session. The writer has masterfully captured the technical aspects of physiotherapy while weaving in the complex emotional landscape of the protagonist. The physical descriptions are anatomically precise and spatially coherent. The writer demonstrates expert knowledge of muscle groups, therapeutic techniques, and body mechanics: "He places one hand under my right heel and the other over my anterior superior iliac spine," "He flexes my hip, slowly, knee extended, ankle neutral," and "He traces the sciatic nerve's path with care, staying lateral, never pressing hard there." These details create a vivid sensory experience that allows readers to understand exactly what is happening during each therapeutic technique. The emotional tension between the characters is palpable and well-executed. The protagonist's resentment toward recovery is evident in lines like "The word heavy makes something inside me fight back. I hate this part, the surrender" and "I resent every inch I gain because it feels like evidence of a body moving on without me." The sexual tension is subtly woven throughout without becoming explicit or distracting from the main narrative: "His palm on my sacrum is a brand through my shirt. I hear him inhale as if he's reminding himself he's not who he used to be either." The narrative maintains a consistent voice throughout, with the protagonist's bitterness and reluctant vulnerability coming through clearly. The prose is elegant and evocative without becoming purple: "The hamstring wakes first with a low, electric buzz, the gluteus maximus late to the party like it always is now that the hamstring has been over-recruited for months." The piece effectively uses sensory details to convey pain thresholds and involuntary responses to touch: "The pressure there is a lightning bolt. My breath goes ragged; I grip the edge of the table." These descriptions make the reader feel the protagonist's physical discomfort and emotional turmoil. The narrative avoids meandering by maintaining focus on the therapy session while incorporating flashbacks and emotional context efficiently. There's no weak dialogue; the sparse conversation between the characters is purposeful and revealing. The ending is particularly strong, avoiding incongruent positivity while acknowledging a complex form of progress: "The pain is precise, honest. It hurts in the right place. That, at least, is progress." This conclusion feels earned and true to the character's journey. If there's any criticism to be made, it might be that the piece occasionally uses technical terminology that could be challenging for readers unfamiliar with anatomy or physical therapy. However, this specificity serves the prompt's requirement for anatomical precision and adds authenticity to the narrative. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Historical fiction: High Seas and Low Vices — Score: 94.8
Prompt:
High Seas and Low Vices: British Naval Officer in the Opium Trade Character: Lieutenant James Merrick, a high-ranking officer in the British Royal Navy stationed in Canton, China in the 1830s. Once promising and decorated, now struggling with a severe opium addiction he hides from his superiors. Synopsis: Write a chapter following Lieutenant Merrick during a single day as he shirks his official naval duties in what has become a daily need to satiate the dragon. Told primarily in dialogue with the characters he interacts with. Focus on brief slices of his journey through the shadowy underworld of Canton: interactions with acquaintances, negotiations with local dealers, schemes and unsavoury jobs taken to fund his habit. Writing Task: Use rich sensory details to describe a day in the life of James Merrick. Write for a real sense of time & place while avoiding cliche. First person, past tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
“Lieutenant Merrick. You look like a cake left out in a drizzle.” That was Ellison, our purser, blocking the gangway with his ledger tucked like a hymnal beneath his arm. The Pearl ran high and green along the quay and the ship’s hull creaked with that familiar wood-on-water complaint. A gull yawed in the damp. “I look like someone who’s slept aboard,” I said. “Don’t preach, Ellison.” “Not preaching. They’ll want you present at Captain’s Table this evening.” His eye flickered to my hand, which had tremored on the rail. “You’ve taken your quinine?” “Religiously,” I said, and coughed. The taste rose—metallic, a coin dissolved upon the tongue. Copper. I wiped my mouth with a handkerchief white as surrender. “This cursed river air.” Ellison nodded like a doctor humouring a child. “See the agent about the manifests, Lieutenant. We need the tea tallied properly. No... mishaps.” “Tea tallies,” I said. “I shall tally an empire.” He squeezed past me with a kind of sympathy I couldn’t abide, and I stepped onto the plank and down onto the quay. The boards were damp. The sandbar beyond the factories squatted like a grey beast, backs of coolies bent in the drizzle. The Thirteen Factories—an entire frontage of bricks, wooden galleries, and painted signs in both tongues—presented their straight faces to the river; behind them the lanes turned and contracted until they were no more than thoughts between houses. I walked. “Lieutenant, you hear about Mr. Thistle?” a marine said. He had mud to his knees. “Bitten by some Canton dog.” “Dogs have taste,” I replied, and he grinned as if we shared something. The ground grew slick; a child ran with a paper fan, the paper frayed to lace and the bamboo ribs shining. Rice steam rose from a doorless kitchen. Fish eyes looked up from baskets. I coughed again, the taste and the thin scratch that always felt like a key turned too far in a lock. The air had its oil of river and its smoke of cheap tobacco and incense. In the lane behind Hog Lane the shadows began. “Mr. Jemmy,” a voice said in the damp whisper English takes when it doesn’t want authority to overhear. “You come early.” She was small, her hair threaded with brass pins. I had seen her laugh once, back when I’d laughed. She was called Peony by those who liked naming things they didn’t possess. “Business,” I said. “Have you seen Ze—” I swallowed the name. “Have you seen the one with the scar on his throat?” “Hah,” she said, and her mouth twisted. “Everyone with scar. You mean the tall one, with eyes like old glass.” “Yes.” “He in back of Lawson’s. But you need coin, Mr. Jemmy.” She looked at my jacket. “You not pay last week.” “I will pay,” I said. “I’ve a watch.” She tapped the pocket over my heart. “We know you have watch. We know how much watch get.” Her fingers smelt of sesame and smoke. I put my hand over hers, as if she was my anchor, and then immediately took it away. “I’ll pay.” “Officer man always pay,” she said with a smile that tasted like pity. “Or he die.” I left her under the sagging lintel of a shop where tin teacups blinked in the dull light and turned into Lawson’s. It was neither his nor a shop; it was one of those rooms that takes whatever it wants: gamblers’ breath, a fiddler sawing some Scottish air into knots, a sand table with fake birds that pecked at grains only through the fraud of weights and levers. Ze was at a table in the back where men in quilted jackets leaned with their backs to the acacia wall. “Mister Lieutenant,” Ze drawled. The scar on his throat was a rope burn gone pale. He was not tall so much as he was long, like an eel. “You always make crowd.” “Trade,” I said, forcing lightness. “I’ve come about some Manila cheroots.” He laughed. “In Canton, you ask me for Manila? You very funny officer. You come with money?” “On your philanthropic reputation,” I replied, and the table tided with laughter. He held up his palm. “No money, no philanthropic. You owe. Last week. The week before. Many weeks.” “I’ve a watch,” I said. Ze tilted his head. “Show me.” I unclipped it from my waistcoat and held it out. The slim minute hand ticked across China with British persistence. He took it by the chain and weighed it as if I were on the other end. “Your father give?” he asked. “The Service,” I said. It had been presented for a shore action in Naples, that particular cannon ash and the sound of splintering that goes through the bones. He pressed the watch to his ear. “Thin,” he said. “Brass on outside. Tin on inside. I give you half usual.” “Half,” I repeated. “You think me a fool in a sailor suit.” Ze shrugged. “You think yourself many things.” I felt a flare of temper, the old kind that had carried me up a ratline before the French could sight along me; it died. I had no gun to man. “Fine,” I said. “Half.” He nodded, and the man beside him slid something wrapped in newspaper across the table. The print was a sermon; the ink had bled so the pious sentences looked as if they’d wept. I put my hand on the packet. “Upstairs,” he said. “You smoke here, you bring smell. No smell in Lawson’s before noon.” “I’ll go,” I said. “One more thing, Ze.” The cough came and I let it. “I can make something fall off a manifest this afternoon. Tea, sugar, sterling. You tell me what’s scarce.” Ze smiled with all the affection of a cat. “Tea is not scarce in Canton,” he said. “Sterling is never scarce in British pockets. But sugar...” he pursed his lips. “Sugar is sweet. Very hard to count. You bring me one case. Not two. One is philanthropic.” “One case,” I said. “Done.” “Done,” he said. “Do not cough on my stairs.” The stairs were narrow, the grain of the wood greasy with handling. Upstairs, Mrs. Fen came in with her hair scraped from her face like a woman who has decided she owns the floor and the ceiling and any man in between. “You,” she said. “You bring money.” “Always,” I lied. She opened her palm the size of a broom pan and I placed the watch chain into it. She closed her hand as if sealing a tomb and led me to a small room where a kettle sang like a far-off bullet. “You make me rich, English,” she said, not unkindly, as she fussed with the lamp. She took one bead from the paper, then hesitated. “You cough.” “River air,” I said, and the way the copper flared on my tongue must have convinced me it was true. “My lungs don’t favour it.” “Your lungs,” she said, laying out the pipe, the resin gleam like an eye. “They don’t favour you.” There is a sound opium makes when it hits the bowl—a little tack against the porcelain, a hesitant sizzle. The smell is sweet and tarry both, like a bakery in hell. I lay down, the pillow hard under the nape of my neck. The pipe came to me, and I took it, and the world decided to be less sharp. “Slow,” Mrs. Fen said, in the voice a nurse might reserve for a child brought out of a fever and too eager for broth. “Always you go quick.” “Always I arrive late,” I said. The smoke went in and I felt that familiar sliding of nerve and sinew, the way the joints remembered that they were not rusted shut. “God,” I said, because there is a part of the brain that will say His name even when it believes in nothing. “Oh. Yes.” I saw, as I always did, the length of water between Gibraltar and Aden as a single blue cloth, folded once, twice, into a neat square. I saw a gun’s crew moving as one creature with eight arms. I saw the face of a woman with hair like smoke and no name, though probably she had one. I saw a boy crying because the lemon had rolled across the deck. The cough waited and bided and then came anyway. The taste of copper broke through the sweetness like a nail through a cake. I turned my head and spattered a fleck on the floorboards, which looked obscene, like a flower drooping. Mrs. Fen tsked with a tongue click. “Too much,” she said. “You take rest. Then go. Your ship not sail without you?” “Ships never sail without me,” I said, and managed something like a smile. “Maybe this one will,” she said softly. When I rose the world had a soft outline. The room breathed when I breathed. The stairs were kinder; the men downstairs had turned into silhouettes. Ze caught my sleeve on the way to the door. “Case of sugar,” he said. “Before dusk. Or your watch—” he dangled it, shiny on his palm “—go to the man who likes clocks very much.” “Dusk,” I said, and the word floated like a small raft. I walked along Old China Street where the silk doorways hung with strips of red paper flapped like tongues. Lun was there, leaning against a lamp post, his cap at a tilt that meant mischief. He had served as a translator when it suited him and a thief when it suited him more. “Merrick,” he said, cheerfully awful. “You owe my cousin.” “I owe your entire lineage,” I said. “Do you want to make something worth noting?” “I always want to note,” he said. “What?” “A case of sugar,” I replied. “From the Dock Company’s warehouse. I need look like I am counting while not counting.” Lun’s eyes narrowed. “You go against your big friend with hat and sword.” “He’s with a bottle and a story,” I said. “Come. You can be an assistant clerk. Do you own a hat that looks moral?” He looked at his cap as if it had offended him. “I own a hat that looks expensive.” “That will do.” We walked back through the lanes in a pattern I knew too well, slipping past a monk who had decided Europeans were interesting, past a row of duck carcasses hanging by their necks, past a little shop that sold nothing but brushes. At the warehouse, the foreman—Mr. Hargood—was at his desk with his knuckles flat like two small loaves. “Ah, Lieutenant,” he said with that mixture of respect and suspicion men who count develop towards men who command. “Here to sign for the green tea?” “Here to overhaul your books,” I said, flicking my hand as if I disliked the whole concept of arithmetic. Lun stood at my shoulder and became invisible. “You naval gentlemen and your time,” Hargood said. “If I had half the leisure...” “If you had half the leisure you’d die twice as quick,” I said. “Bring the sugar bills.” He frowned, shuffled, produced. The sugar was in the far bay, stacked like little tombs. The men working there were sweating in sheets. The smell was thick and sweet, its crystals in the air making the light blur like summer. “Lun,” I said quietly, “count aloud to confuse them. In Cantonese. Loudly. As if you spot a mistake.” Lun grinned. “I always spot a mistake,” he said, and began counting in a cadence like a song. The coolies looked up, their accuracy insulted, indignation making them pick up bags and move them to the side to display correctness. Hargood turned to me to argue a number. I argued back. While we performed the dance of clerks, a case found itself angled just so behind a pillar. When Lun coughed—his cough deliberate to mimic mine—I nodded, and a boy too small to be noticed slipped a rope around the case and dragged it along the wall, behind barrels, towards the side door. The side door moped open as if bored. Outside, a hand cart creaked. “Good,” I said to Hargood eventually, sighing as if numbers pained me. “All in order. You’re an exemplar, Hargood. I’ll mention you to the captain.” “Do,” he said, his pride eclipsing suspicion. “Do, sir.” Outside, Lun had the cart and the box and a grin. “You get too clever,” he said. “One day it break.” “Everything breaks,” I said. The taste came again, and I rinsed my mouth with spit and shame. “We’ll take it to Ze.” “Or we take to my uncle,” Lun said. “Better price.” “He hates me,” I said. “Ze only dislikes me.” “You make category for everyone,” Lun said, impressed. Ze’s men met us in a lane where the flagstones were laid as if a drunk had tried to tile a stream. They took the box like a midwife takes a baby, and Ze himself drifted out of the shadow and tipped a little purse into my hand. It chimed dull. “Payment,” he said. “Plus philanthropic bonus. Only small.” “Charity suits you,” I said, weighing it. It was enough to keep certain fires burning for certain hours. It was not enough to buy back the watch. “Do you want your watch?” he asked, reading me as if I were a notice pasted to a wall. “Watch is time. Time is...” He shrugged. “Not much.” “Another time,” I said. “I’ve other... obligations.” “Like dinner,” he said, amused. I made my way back along the river. The factories’ walls looked like they’d been licked by a rain that had forgotten how to rain. Men carried bales with the slow rhythm of those who can keep doing it until moons change out of stubbornness. A junk slid by with its brown sails like ears. The Pearl kept breathing. “Lieutenant,” someone called. It was Davies from the wardroom, his face open and bland as a slice of bread. “You coming ashore this evening? There’s a man from Macao with a tiger story.” “I can’t,” I said. “I’ve a headache.” “Quinine,” he said, with admiration, as if it were courage. “Cursed fever factory, this place.” “The air,” I said, and coughed. “This damned air.” The taste of copper was so familiar it might have been my own tongue. On deck again, Ellison caught me and ferried me towards the captain like a tug with a lame barge. “Where have you been?” he murmured. “Hargood said you inspected. Mr. Merrick, you need to pace yourself.” “I’m paced,” I said. “I am a metronome.” The world swung like a hammock. At table the captain told a story about a storm off Cape Town. Someone laughed at the right places. The soup shone on the surface like oil. When I lifted my spoon my hand shook and I steadied it with the other. The smell of spice and tallow rose to meet me and then receded. Across from me, Davies coloured and looked at his plate as if it were a map he was obliged to consult. “How is the cough, Mr. Merrick?” the captain asked in a tone that meant: I know you are not well; I require you to be well. “The river,” I said. “It gets into everything.” “It does,” he agreed, and then moved briskly to talk of the consulate and restrictions and the latest embarrassment of some East India cousin. I nodded where one nods and smiled where one smiles. The words went over us and past us and into the woodwork like all words. Later, in my hammock, the ship’s bell told the night like an old man telling his life. After the second dog watch, after the hard tack and the hard looks, after the captain’s thin wine, I lay and looked at the beams and listened to the water sounding like pages turned by a giant hand. My mouth had that coin again, and I thought of the watch ticking against Ze’s palm. Lun’s whisper came from the dark beside the hatch, where men’s voices always sound as if they have just returned from somewhere where voices are not allowed. “Merri-k,” he said, breaking my name like a brittle stick. “Tomorrow, yes?” “Tomorrow,” I said, though tomorrow is a word that makes no promise. The ship creaked as if recalling old burdens. I pressed my knuckles to my sternum and felt the dull pain that wasn’t anything yet but a rumour of something that would come and claim its due. Outside, the river slid past, green and patient. The factories slept like houses that had never known anything else. Somewhere ashore Ze wound my watch and pressed it to his ear and smiled. I closed my eyes and imagined a world where time ticked only when I paid attention to it. The cough came for me one more time, ready as any officer, and I swallowed the blood and the lie along with it. The air, I told myself. It’s only the air. Then the black took me down, sweet as the pipe and as unforgiving.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkably accomplished character study of Lieutenant James Merrick, a British naval officer in 1830s Canton who has fallen into opium addiction. The writing demonstrates exceptional historical authenticity and sensory richness that transports the reader to colonial-era China. The first-person narration effectively captures Merrick's deteriorating state through both explicit details (the copper taste of blood he attributes to "river air," his trembling hands) and subtle implications. The prose style is particularly impressive—economical yet evocative, with metaphors that feel organic to the setting and character ("I look like someone who's slept aboard," "The Pearl ran high and green along the quay"). The dialogue is a standout element. Each character has a distinct voice that reflects their background and relationship to Merrick. Ze's broken English carries both menace and a certain philosophical weight ("Watch is time. Time is... Not much"). Lun's pragmatic opportunism comes through clearly. The exchanges reveal character and advance the plot simultaneously, without exposition. The piece excels at showing rather than telling. Merrick's addiction is revealed through his actions, physical symptoms, and the reactions of others rather than direct statements. His desperation is demonstrated through his willingness to steal and compromise his position. The writer trusts the reader to connect these dots. The sensory details are vivid and period-appropriate: "Rice steam rose from a doorless kitchen. Fish eyes looked up from baskets." The setting feels thoroughly researched, from the Thirteen Factories to the specific dynamics of colonial trade. The writer avoids orientalist clichés while still conveying the foreignness of Canton through Merrick's eyes. The narrative maintains tension throughout, following Merrick's increasingly desperate attempts to fund his habit while maintaining appearances. The structure—moving from ship to opium den to warehouse and back to ship—creates a complete arc that emphasizes the cyclical nature of addiction. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally the prose becomes slightly overwrought ("The smell is sweet and tarry both, like a bakery in hell"), but these moments are rare and generally effective. The ending is appropriately bleak without being melodramatic, though it does hint at a terminal illness that wasn't clearly established earlier. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that balances historical detail, character development, and sensory richness while maintaining narrative momentum. It captures the moral complexity of British imperialism and the opium trade through one man's personal degradation. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Humour: Sisyphus Gives Advice — Score: 95.0
Prompt:
Sisyphus Gives Advice Write a comedic scene in the style of Terry Pratchett featuring Sisyphus, who has started an advice column while continuing his eternal boulder-pushing. Rather than being bitter about his punishment, Sisyphus has developed a comfortably zen emotional intelligence and wisdom from his centuries of repetitive labor. Not in the cliche ways you might expect -- he's actually very grounded, warm & connected with the everyday human plight. He dictates responses to "Crow," his feathered familiar who serves as both scribe and mail carrier. The piece should include Sisyphus thoughtfully answering several advice-seekers' letters about everyday problems (relationship troubles, work-life balance, dealing with difficult people, life purpose doubts) while periodically returning to his boulder-pushing duties. His advice should be surprisingly insightful and practical. The humor should emerge naturally from the messages he receives, from mundane to risque. Sisyphus should genuinely enjoy helping others, finding meaning in this new pursuit while maintaining his boulder routine. The humour should be *understated and not forced*. Contrary to expectation, almost none of his advice involves boulder rolling metaphors (though he does sneak *one* subtle in there), nor a treatise on stoicism. We are also going against the obvious fish-out-of-water trope; in fact, he's surprisingly a natural at this. In all of this , it's important to *show, don't tell*. The format should be largely epistolary, with the occasional interjection for scene setting. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The morning was new, which in Sisyphus’s valley meant the light was different from yesterday by the sort of degree a tax accountant would call “immaterial.” Wind fretted the scrub on the slope, and somewhere, high and above and faintly disdainful as only creatures with wings can be, Crow spiraled down with a sack hang-gliding from his beak. Sisyphus placed his shoulder to the boulder with the practiced intimacy of a watchmaker winding a clock and stepped. The stone, which had opinions about slopes, grudgingly rolled. Sisyphus listened for the click it made—a sound he alone could hear—and then, between steps, spoke. “Down, please,” he said. Crow landed, boots clicking—he wore little boots, because getting ink on a claw was an indignity whose costs were measured in smudged letters and pecked tempers—and shook out the canvas satchel. Envelopes, string-tied packets, and one scroll thin as a whisper, all with various seals. The largest bore a lipstick print. Crow eyed it. “We’re doing the pink one first.” “No,” Sisyphus said mildly. “We’re doing them in order.” “Order is a trick the gods play on the patient.” “Order is how not to lose the questions.” Crow clicked his beak. “Technically, I agree to disagree. Technically, I am your scribe, postmaster, and literary agent.” “Technically, you are a crow,” Sisyphus said, and leaned into the stone. 1. Dear Mr. S., My boyfriend never buys groceries, but he always complains when there’s no oat milk. He says I’m “gatekeeping breakfast.” Help? Signed, Oat of Hand Sisyphus breathed, held, pushed. “Write,” he said. Dear Oat, Lists help. Not lists of faults, those go mouldy overnight, but lists on paper stuck to a fridge. Make a list together. Put “oat milk” on it. Put who buys it. Put money in a jar. Agree on a day. Call it The Ceremony of Milk. Do not explain why you need a Ceremony; let it be absurd and, therefore, real. If he does not arrive with milk after three Ceremonies, you will know which is more important to him: milk or being someone relied upon. Also, don’t call it gatekeeping. Invite him to hold the keys with you. People rarely step through doors they are told are locked. Warmly, S. Crow paused, head cocked. “Ceremony of Milk?” “People like rituals,” Sisyphus said. “Even the pretend ones. Particularly the pretend ones.” He rocked the boulder into a surly roll; gravel hissed. Crow folded the letter, affixed a feather as a stamp—bureaucracy is deeply impressed by plumage—and dropped it into the outbound pouch. 2. Dear Sisyphus, How do I find my purpose? I’ve tried nine hobbies. I’m bad at most of them. My cousin says I should monetize my passion. Do I even have one? Purposefully Lost Sisyphus adjusted his hands. The stone had a place for each finger; where his thumb lay, there was a little dip made by centuries of uncertainty pressed into granite. He thought about kites he’d never flown and soups he’d never burnt and the path around his hill, which was as familiar to him as the inside of his own blink. Dear Lost, If you try to romance your purpose like a grand love affair, it will hide. Purposes are shy. They like to be found in the middle of other things. Pick something small to do, regularly, that improves the day of someone who is not you. Water a neighbour’s thyme when they forget. Run a weekly game of something silly. Fix wobbly chair legs. Do not ask if this is worthy of a destiny; destiny dislikes being graded. Do it until your hands learn the weight of it. After three months, note how you feel on the days you do not do it. That aching is a shape you can fit around; we sometimes mistake it for lack. Often it’s a measure. As for monetizing—ask first if you want to sell the part of yourself you are still getting to know. Some things sour under price tags. Purpose is not a crown. It’s a habit you can be proud of. Sincerely, S. Crow whispered, “You’re going to ruin the self-help sector.” “They can adjust,” Sisyphus said. “They always adjust.” The boulder rolled again. It tried not to, in the dignified manner of a heavy thing pretending the slope is a social inconvenience rather than a physical imperative. 3. Dear Sisyphus, My manager schedules 7 a.m. meetings for “morale.” He uses the word “family” a lot. I am considering moving to a cave. Exhausted Crow, who had roosted in many trees labeled “team,” made a noise like a rusted hinge being sarcastic. Dear Exhausted, When someone says “we’re a family,” quietly ask them what happens when a family member cannot attend dinner. If the answer is punishment, it’s not a family; it’s a schedule. Suggest: no meetings before nine; one day a week without meetings at all; agendas distributed beforehand so you can discern if attendance is necessary. Offer the alternative of a monthly breakfast that is actually breakfast, no slides allowed, where morale is measured in jam. If you are told this is impossible, say, “Then let’s call this what it is: a preference.” People often stop misnaming things when required to write the correct label on a form. Consider also: the cave may be metaphorical. A boundary with a door and a lock is a cave by another name. The mountain approves of doors. Best, S. “Is that the subtle one?” Crow asked. “No,” Sisyphus said, amused despite himself. “Not yet.” 4. Dear Sisyphus, My mother-in-law criticizes everything I cook. She brings her own salt. My spouse says “that’s just how she is.” Should I switch to takeout? Poison? (Kidding! Mostly.) Salted The stone’s edge kissed his shoulder, a small bruise already blooming like ink on paper. He had been hit by worse as punctuation from the gods. He forgave the stone; it was, after all, a stone. Dear Salted, If she brings her own salt, provide a bowl for it. Label it with her name in nice lettering. People are disarmed by their own ceremony. Then, ask her kindly to bring one dish she loves, and make a party of learning her recipe—on your terms, in your kitchen, with aprons you choose. If she refuses the apron, enforce the rule that in your kitchen, everyone wears the silliness uniform. With your spouse, have a different conversation. It is powerful to say, “I understand that is how she is. This is how I am: I need support. When criticism arrives, I need you to stand next to me, not neutrally in the doorway.” Avoid poisoning. It ruins the cutlery. Yours, S. Crow scratched his head with a boot. “You’re very domestic.” “I had a wife,” Sisyphus said simply. Crow looked away as one does when a friend mentions a map no one else can read. The boulder rolled. A pebble got ideas, skittered ahead. 5. Dear Sisyphus, I’ve been with my partner for eight years and the spark is, frankly, a sparkler in daylight. We love each other but everything feels… routine. Everyone says to travel. We have two small children and a budget like a tightrope. Advice? Same Old Flame Sisyphus smiled at the sky. It had the slightly guilty blue of someone who had forgotten an anniversary. Dear Flame, Routine is not the enemy. It is the net that lets you perform tricks without breaking bones. While your children are small and your rope is taut, make the spark small on purpose. Schedule the ridiculous. I recommend: Thursday night six-minute dances in the kitchen. You set a timer. You cannot stop before the alarm, even if someone laughs or spills or a child requests an audience with Important Poops. The dance survives interruptions. The dance will get a capital letter if you do it enough. Write each other two-sentence notes. No evaluations. Observations like, “You hummed today. It stuck in my head,” count more than telegrams of praise. Buy cheap cloth napkins and use them only when it is just the two of you; they will start to mean something they cannot be asked to mean until you use them. If you can travel, take a bus to the next town’s park and pretend not to know the swings. If you cannot, swap tasks for a day and narrate them to each other in the evening like explorers. Also, once a month, ask your partner, “Is there a rule we made that we can retire?” Rules wear out. Love fits better when you take in a seam. Love, S. Crow wrote, the quill making a small giggle of sound. Here the godling arrived. They were the sort of minor deity whose domain had not so much been assigned as left on a shelf and borrowed: Inconvenient Breezes or the Sanctity of Paragraph Breaks. They had good hair and bad sandals and an expression like a fruit bowl sculpted by someone who had heard of fruit once. “Oh,” they said, in that way gods have of being unimpressed by mortal industry, “you’re… doing letters.” “I am,” Sisyphus said, politely shifting his shoulder so the boulder did not crush the god. Gods always assume they cannot be crushed. The mountain did not share the assumption. The deity sniffed. “It’s off-brand. You’re supposed to be a metaphor.” “Says who?” Crow asked. “His brand manager?” “I am,” said the god, affronted. “I watch over these things. You are the exemplar of futile exertion. People expect—” “They expect me to be miserable,” Sisyphus said. “I understand. They also expect me to be incapable of other skills. I can be two things.” “Three,” Crow said, helpfully. “He also makes soup.” “You should lean into the tragedy,” the god went on, gesturing like a man trying to describe jazz to a fish. “More lamentation. More… rolling. Less… advice.” Sisyphus inclined his head. “The rolling is happening,” he said. He put his weight into the stone, which moved with the reluctant majesty of a king dragged from bed. “If you would like to critique my column, there is a form.” “A form?” the god echoed, as if Sisyphus had said “guillotine.” “Crow,” Sisyphus said, and Crow produced a parchment. At the top it read: FEEDBACK: HELPFUL, SPECIFIC, KIND. The god stared at it. His domain did not include forms. He consoled himself with a breeze that neatly blew the parchment off the cliff and into a bush where it did no one any harm except a beetle who had been writing its own letter about aphids. “I am saying,” the god continued, drawing himself up to his full minor height, “that this is unbecoming. People like you for your resilience.” “No,” Sisyphus said. He paused, because sometimes you have to hold an entire boulder still to move a word. “They like the idea that I will continue, regardless. But endurance is not the same as pointlessness. And advice is useful.” The god made a sound like a kettle that had just realized it was expected to whistle. “Hmph.” “You can help,” Sisyphus offered. “We have one about an aunt and a tattoo.” The god brightened. “Oh, tattoos. I briefly governed the placement of sighs. There is overlap.” Crow produced the letter with a flourish. 6. Dear Sisyphus, I want a tattoo. My aunt says I will regret it because I do not understand permanence. She also wears shoes made of rattlesnakes, metaphorically. Should I get the tattoo? Inkling The god leaned in. “Say no. Say regret teaches us—we must be caged by it.” Sisyphus considered. He thought of all the things that had seemed permanent and were not, and of all the things the gods had imagined were small and were not. He thought: the groove under his thumb would be there tomorrow, and the mountain would be there, and Crow, probably. Dear Inkling, Permanence is greedy. It wants decisions to be scared of it. Consider instead: intention. Wait six months. In that time, draw the tattoo on yourself with a pen every Sunday after lunch. Live with it through soup, sweat, and your aunt. If by the end you are tired of drawing it but not of seeing it—book the appointment. If your aunt brings snakes to the salon, that’s a separate conversation. If the design is about grief, give it a place that you will see when you need tenderness, not punishment. The body remembers where you put your stories. Warmly, S. The god had the grace to look thoughtful. He was unused to mortals refusing the stage directions the gods scribble in the margins of lives. “I suppose,” he said reluctantly, “that isn’t entirely… untheological.” “It’s very me,” Sisyphus said, and pushed. They worked until the sun decided to pretend it was late. Letters unfurled and were answered. Crow’s inkwell diminished like a pond in summer. At the top, the wind queued up the look-down-then-fall spell the gods had placed on this hill so long ago, a trick of geometry and intention that meant no matter what was done, gravity would remember itself at the last. 7. Dear Sisyphus, There’s a man in my building who is rude to everyone. He criticizes our plants and laughs when packages go missing. Part of me pities him. Part of me wants to put prune labels on all his food jars. How do you coexist with the unkind? Signed, Almost Petty Dear Almost, Give him a job. Not a fake job, a necessary one that touches others. People who sneer at the communal mostly haven’t been trusted with it. Ask him to hold the spare keys, or to oversee the fire drill. Tell him you chose him because he is always present and has strong opinions—which are good qualities for a person on whom others rely. When people prove useful, they often become kinder to themselves behind their eyes. If he refuses, then you can proceed with your labels. But even then, leave a note that says: “We see you.” It is harder to be unkind when watched by nouns. S. “Harder to be unkind when watched by nouns?” Crow said. “Language is a village,” Sisyphus said. “It keeps an eye on us.” The stone, which would have liked nothing better than to stay where it was out of sheer contrariness, finally remembered what stones do and went down. It went down every day. That was its trick. It did not stop being a trick just because you knew the mechanism. At the crest, the last letter. 8. Dear S, I am in love with my friend. We are of similar age and compatible in sources of joy. Should I confess? Or will that make the boulder roll down the hill of our friendship? —Tempted Crow looked at Sisyphus with something like delight. “Is this the one?” he asked. “Yes,” Sisyphus said. He felt the light on his skin. He felt the ages like a shawl that had become comfortable. Dear Tempted, If you can be kind to yourself and to them regardless of the answer, ask. Practicalities: do it in a place where either of you can leave without having to finish a meal. Give them time to respond later if they need it. Say, “I like you in more than one way. If that is not for you, I am still glad to be here in the way we already are.” Practice saying it aloud to a wall. Walls are excellent at secrets. If you cannot be kind to yourself if the answer is no, be kind now by not asking yet. Sometimes our hearts need training. Go on walks on purpose with other people. Develop one new habit that does not involve them. This is not distraction; this is strengthening. Either way, the hill you are on is not a trick. It is a path. Walk it. Love, S. He folded the letters with clean hands. Crow tied the string. The god lingered, caught in the gravity of something he could not officiate. “What do you get,” he asked suddenly, with a keen thin curiosity, “out of this?” Sisyphus checked the sky. When you had as many mornings as he had, you learned to count in textures. “I like knowing that somewhere, someone will put a bowl on a table and it will mean something,” he said. “I like that a young person will draw a bird on their wrist for six months and know whether it is theirs. I like the six-minute dances. I like that you tried to help.” The god shuffled, accidentally creating a small, respectful wind. “And it doesn’t—” he looked at the boulder and tried to find the word “—lessen?” Sisyphus smiled. “The stone is heavy, regardless. The letters… are light. I can carry both.” The wind nudged the boulder toward obedience to the universe. Sisyphus let his hands fall away. The stone went down, majestic in its surrender, and Sisyphus, who had time, breathed. “Tomorrow?” Crow asked, already gathering the satchel, already in love with stamps. “Tomorrow,” Sisyphus said. He turned, a man with dust on his arms and ink on his fingers, and climbed, not because he had to, which he did, but because somewhere, a pantry list needed a new heading, and a person at a bus stop would read something they had needed to read, and a minor god would practice writing the word feedback without rolling their eyes. The mountain watched him go. The mountain, like all good editors, let him make his own cuts. Somewhere below, a beetle finished its letter and, with great dignity, pressed its seal. Crow swooped, boots ridiculous, and the day clicked into place.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response is a remarkably well-crafted piece that captures Terry Pratchett's style with impressive fidelity. The author has created a Sisyphus who is indeed zen, emotionally intelligent, and genuinely invested in helping others without falling into the expected tropes or clichés. The epistolary format works perfectly, with each letter presenting a relatable human problem and Sisyphus offering genuinely insightful advice. The subtle boulder-rolling metaphor appears in the final letter ("Or will that make the boulder roll down the hill of our friendship?"), which shows restraint and adherence to the prompt's requirements. The prose is elegant without being overwrought, with Pratchett-esque turns of phrase like "The stone, which had opinions about slopes, grudgingly rolled" and "Gods always assume they cannot be crushed. The mountain did not share the assumption." These lines capture Pratchett's knack for personification and wry observations about power dynamics. The characterization is excellent. Sisyphus is warm, grounded, and wise without being preachy. Crow serves as both a practical assistant and a foil for Sisyphus, with their banter revealing character through natural dialogue. The introduction of the minor deity adds conflict and further develops Sisyphus's character through contrast. The humor is understated as requested, emerging naturally from the situations and characters rather than forced jokes. Lines like "Technically, you are a crow" and the deity's discomfort with forms demonstrate this perfectly. The piece excels at showing rather than telling. We understand Sisyphus's wisdom through his advice, not because we're told he's wise. His relationship with his boulder is revealed through small details like "where his thumb lay, there was a little dip made by centuries of uncertainty pressed into granite." The advice itself is genuinely thoughtful and practical, avoiding both platitudes and boulder metaphors as requested. Suggestions like the "Ceremony of Milk" and the six-minute kitchen dances are creative, specific, and potentially useful. The flow is excellent, with the boulder-pushing interludes providing natural breaks between letters. The piece builds to a satisfying conclusion with the final exchange between Sisyphus, Crow, and the god, reinforcing the themes of finding meaning in repetition and connection. If there's any criticism to be made, it might be that some of the advice occasionally verges on being a bit too perfectly wise, but this is minor and fits the character as described in the prompt. The piece successfully avoids the pitfalls mentioned in the prompt and delivers exactly what was requested. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 1 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 1.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Coming of age: Lost & Found in Osaka — Score: 86.2
Prompt:
Lost & Found in Osaka Slice of Life / Coming-of-Age: First Connection. Write one scene within a larger story set in Osaka, Japan. A shy, introverted teenager & synthesizer nerd, is browsing the electronics district of Den Den Town. She is drawn to the sound of an electric guitar. A girl, slightly older and radiating confidence, is busking near the entrance to a crowded arcade, playing a blistering rendition of a classic anime theme. The scene takes us through their initial awkward interaction, transitioning into a surprisingly easy conversation. The busker, intrigued by the teenager's quiet intensity and knowledge of music, suggests they grab some sushi at a nearby kaitenzushi (conveyor belt sushi) restaurant. Write primarily in dialogue, capturing the distinct voices of the two characters: the teenager's hesitant and -- initially -- awkward speech, and the busker's more outgoing and playful tone. 1000 words.
Model Output:
“Uh—sorry. I didn’t mean to, um, stand this close.” “You’re fine. The sound needs an audience. Got a request?” “I… that was ‘Tank!,’ right? The opening from Cowboy Bebop.” “Ding ding. You’d be surprised how many people think it’s from Lupin. You a Bebop fan?” “Mostly the soundtrack. Yoko Kanno is—uh. Sorry. That was good. Your tremolo on the chord stabs was… really tight.” “Thanks. You noticed the tremolo? Most people just hear ‘fast guitar makes brain happy.’ You play?” “Not guitar. Synth. Mostly… I mean, I’m not good. I just build patches, mess with filters.” “Ah. A synth nerd in Den Den Town. Shocking.” “Yeah. I know. Sorry.” “Don’t apologize for existing. I’m Rika.” “Aoi.” “Hi, Aoi. So, you’re listening to me shred in front of this arcade, and you’re wearing a T-shirt that says ‘KORG Monologue Appreciation Society.’ That’s not a coincidence.” “I found it online. It was on sale.” “It’s a statement piece. Wait—hold that thought.” “Okay.” “—Thanks! Arigatou! Appreciate you! I’ll be here all weekend!—Sorry. Had to thank the ojisan who just tossed me 100 yen and a canned coffee.” “He gave you a coffee?” “It’s lukewarm, but love’s love. Want a sip?” “No, thanks. I mean, no. I’m okay.” “Suit yourself. So, you said filters. What kind?” “Uh. Ladder mostly. But I like Sallen-Key for the… the snap? I don’t know if that makes sense.” “You’re speaking magic. I played with a buddy’s Minibrute once. The cutoff sweep made my eyeballs vibrate.” “Minibrute’s Steiner-Parker, actually. It’s… um, more aggressive.” “See, this is why you’re my new friend.” “We just met.” “And yet. Fate. Osaka. Neon. Street noodles. Electric hum. You looked like you were hearing the chords instead of the crowd.” “I was timing your accents with the kick of the Taiko cabinet in the arcade. The machines, uh, bleed through.” “You were lining me up with Taiko no Tatsujin hits?” “Yeah. Sorry.” “Stop apologizing. That’s cool. Does your brain just auto-grid everything?” “Sometimes. It’s annoying for other people. I can… hear the fluorescent lights flicker. Sixty hertz.” “Now I can’t un-hear it. Thanks.” “Sorry.” “Hey. Aoi? For real. It’s cool. I like detail people. They make my sloppy guitar sound intentional.” “It wasn’t sloppy.” “Flatter me more.” “You didn’t miss the diminished run before the turnaround. And the slide down to the E was clean.” “Marry me.” “What?” “Kidding. Relax. So what are you hunting for? Parts? A synth?” “Just… browsing. I save up for used modules. The little shops down the side street get random imports.” “Modules as in Eurorack? That rabbit hole is deeper than the Dotombori canal.” “Don’t joke about the canal.” “Yikes, true. Bad joke. Okay, Eurorack. Complex oscillators? No, you’re more of a—let me guess—function generators and quirky envelopes.” “Yeah. I like the ALM Pamela’s New Workout. It’s… clocking. It’s very flexible. Sorry.” “I don’t know what that is but it sounds like a gym class for robots.” “Sort of.” “Hey—another coin! Arigatou! Thanks!—Okay, my set’s basically done. Kapow. You sticking around or you got a train to catch?” “I don’t… I mean, I can stay.” “You want sushi? Kaitenzushi on the corner. Conveyor belt, not the tourist-trap one, the one with the grumpy chef who secretly cares.” “I—uh. I guess. I have… I have enough money.” “It’s my treat. You tipped me with compliments, which is the only currency I respect.” “No, that’s not— I can pay for my plates.” “Okay, okay. You can pay for your plates. A couple. We’ll split the lukewarm coffee.” “I don’t drink coffee.” “Do you drink tea?” “Green. With no sugar.” “Of course you do. C’mon.” “Should you leave your amp?” “Watch this. Hey, Daichi! Guard duty?” “—He said yes with his eyes. The arcade guys love me. Also, the pedalboard has a chain lock. And it would take a forklift to move all this. Here, grab my cable.” “It’s heavy.” “That’s the weight of tone, Aoi.” “I thought tone was in the fingers.” “Don’t you start.” “Okay.” “So, Aoi, where you from?” “Uh, Sakai. We moved there last year.” “Ah. Commuter life. Me too—well, not moved, but I bounce between my aunt’s place in Namba and my mom’s in Tennoji. I escape to Den Den to plug into something that isn’t my family’s anxiety.” “I get that.” “Yeah? Parents, school, the usual?” “School. People. Group projects. They think I’m… weird.” “You are weird. So am I. Weird is the house band of this street.” “I don’t like crowds. Or… I do, but I like to watch from the edges.” “That’s an artist thing. Or an anxiety thing. Or both. Either way, welcome to the edges.” “Thanks.” “Here we are. The belt of dreams.” “It’s… busy.” “Focus on the plates. The plates are your friends. Salmon? Tuna? Tamago?” “Tamago.” “Childhood in a rectangle. Respect.” “It’s sweet.” “Sweet is good. I’m grabbing negitoro. And—oh, fried shrimp. Don’t judge me.” “I wouldn’t.” “You should. So, Aoi, favorite anime soundtrack. Go.” “That’s… hard.” “I know. That’s why I asked. Pressure.” “Um. Not counting Bebop… I like Susumu Hirasawa. ‘Paranoia Agent.’ That opening makes my skin do… things.” “Goosebumps in kanji. Same. The chorus hits like a tidal wave.” “The way the vocals sit in the mix, too. It’s like… like a choir from a city no one’s built yet.” “Poetic. You write lyrics?” “No. I write… notes.” “Notes can be lyrics that forgot words. Me? I love, okay, deep cut, the soundtrack to FLCL. The Pillows. It’s sloppy perfect.” “I know. ‘Ride on Shooting Star.’ The bass is… lazy but intentional.” “Ha! Lazy but intentional is my brand. Here, pour yourself green tea. The hot water button’s here.” “Thanks.” “So, what synth patches do you like to build? Pads? Bass? Weird squeals that make cats leave the room?” “Textures. Like… the sound of walking past a vending machine at midnight. The compressor in the box buzzing. The cans clinking because someone didn’t stack them right. And a bus two streets over, a low… rumble. And you’re thinking about how the lights paint the asphalt.” “Okay, wow. That’s… okay, I want to make that into a song. Can we? Like, I’ll do guitar swells and you do the city-ghost texture.” “I don’t… I mean, maybe. I’ve never… collaborated.” “We’ll ease in. No pressure. We’ll hang out, you show me your patches, I show you my calluses.” “I have calluses too.” “Where?” “Index and middle on my left hand. From the keys. And from soldering.” “You solder?” “Sometimes. Kits. My dad worries I’ll burn the apartment down.” “That’s parent energy. My mom thinks my amp is going to summon demons because it hums when the fridge turns on.” “It might be ground loop.” “See? You’re useful. Also, you’re smiling now.” “Am I?” “Tiny smile. Microsmile. But I’ll take it.” “The tea is good.” “Tea smile. A classic. Okay, serious question. Favorite Kanno track that isn’t obvious. Not ‘Tank!,’ not ‘Call Me, Call Me.’” “‘The Egg and You’ from Bebop. It’s small. It’s… full of air.” “You’re deep cuts all the way. Mine’s ‘Inner Universe’ from Ghost in the Shell, but that’s borderline obvious. The choir plus glitch is chef’s kiss.” “It’s… yeah.” “You ever go to shows?” “No. Too loud. Too many… bodies.” “Mm. Understandable. I do small rooms where everybody tries not to bump into each other. Like that folk bar under the tracks. You’d like it. They keep the lights low, like they’re protecting secrets.” “I like secrets.” “I figured. So, Aoi, what’s your plan? After school. After beating the boss of social anxiety.” “I don’t know. Work at a shop. Fix things. Make… noise. I don’t want to stand in front, though.” “Front is overrated. You can be the wizard behind the curtain. I’ll be the loud one in the sparkly jacket.” “You have a sparkly jacket?” “Soon. It’s on my vision board. For now, I have a jacket that smells like rain and guitar case.” “I like rain.” “Same. Everyone says Osaka rain is annoying. I think it’s romantic. It makes the neon blur in a good way.” “Neon is better blurred.” “See? We’re synced. Like your Pam’s New Workout clock. Pam-san’s clicking, we’re vibing.” “It’s a weird name. But, yeah.” “Hey, grab that salmon. Don’t be shy.” “I’ve never… I don’t… I usually watch the plates a few times before I take them.” “You… watch plates?” “I like to see if anyone else takes them. It’s like… I don’t know. I don’t want to disturb the pattern.” “You’re adorable. Here. I’ll take it with you. Three, two—snatch.” “Okay. Thanks.” “You’re welcome. How is it?” “Soft. Oily in a good way.” “Oily in a good way is also my brand.” “You said that about lazy bass.” “I contain multitudes. So, you mentioned Hirasawa. Do you know ‘Millennium Actress’ score? I cry like a sprinkler.” “I know the motifs. They… evolve with her lives. It’s a good… idea. Musically.” “You talk like an engineer writing a love letter.” “I don’t know how to say it without sounding… dumb.” “You sound like Aoi. That’s enough. Also, dumb is honest. Honest sticks.” “Okay.” “Do you have any of your stuff online?” “No. I have… I have a folder called ‘unfinished.’ It’s big.” “Same. Mine is called ‘skeletons.’ We could trade bones.” “That’s… a strange metaphor.” “Welcome to my brain. It’s a thrift store. Everything’s a little used, but it fits if you tug at it.” “I like thrift stores.” “Of course you do. Okay. Logistics. Do you come to Den Den often?” “On Saturdays. If it’s not raining. And if I can… get out.” “Cool. I busk most afternoons if the arcade guys aren’t mad. You can find me by the Taiko drum sounds and the smell of takoyaki. Or—do you have Line?” “I do.” “Can I…?” “Here.” “Cute sticker pack. You’re a bunny person?” “I like rabbits.” “Rika plus Aoi equals… we need a band name. Something with rabbits and circuits.” “Um. Lapin… wave?” “Lapin Wave. That’s pretty good. Or Bunny LFO.” “Low Frequency… bunny.” “Exactly. We’ll workshop. Ping—oh, I just sent you a sticker. It’s a rabbit holding a guitar. Fate.” “It’s cute.” “Okay, my plates are starting to look like a tower. You want one more?” “Maybe… one of those cucumber rolls.” “Kappa maki. Simple. Classic. Like a sine wave.” “I like sine waves. They’re gentle.” “Square waves are fun at parties.” “I don’t like parties.” “Me neither. I like little circles with conveyor belts.” “I can see that.” “You know, when I was playing, you were standing just off the mat. Like an inch. You could have been on it, but you weren’t.” “I didn’t know if I was allowed.” “Next time, step on the mat. It’s okay to take up space.” “I’ll try.” “Good. Because I want to hear your vending machine song.” “It’s not a song. It’s… a texture.” “Textures can be songs. Especially if you pair them with a lazy-but-intentional bass.” “And… your tremolo.” “And my tremolo. Deal?” “Deal.” “High five?” “I… okay.” “Nice. You have strong hands.” “They’re just… hands.” “They make things. That’s more than most. Okay, I’m paying for the shrimp and the negitoro. You pay for the tamago and the cucumber. We’ll call it even.” “You sure?” “Yup. And next time, you can buy me tea.” “I can do that.” “Cool. Let’s go rescue my amp before it grows legs.” “It won’t. You chained it.” “True. But guitars are like cats. They wander if you ignore them.” “I like cats.” “Join the club. You joining me for a minute back at the arcade? I can show you the weird pedal that makes my guitar sound like a broken Super Famicom.” “I want to hear that.” “Knew you would. C’mon, Aoi. Let’s make Den Den Town hum in a good way.” “Okay.”
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This dialogue-driven piece effectively captures a chance encounter between two contrasting characters in Osaka's Den Den Town. The writer has created a believable interaction between Aoi, the shy synthesizer enthusiast, and Rika, the confident busking guitarist. The dialogue shines as the primary storytelling vehicle. Each character has a distinct voice—Aoi's hesitant, self-conscious speech patterns contrast sharply with Rika's playful, confident tone. Aoi's frequent apologies and technical language reveal her personality, while Rika's casual metaphors and encouragement establish her character. The back-and-forth feels natural, with appropriate interruptions, tangents, and moments where Rika interacts with passersby. The writer skillfully reveals character through dialogue rather than exposition. We learn about Aoi's social anxiety, her technical knowledge, and her artistic sensibilities through what she says and how she says it. Similarly, Rika's personality emerges through her speech patterns and reactions. The dialogue reveals their shared passion for music while highlighting their different approaches to it. The piece effectively establishes setting through dialogue references to Den Den Town, the arcade, and the kaitenzushi restaurant. The cultural context feels authentic with mentions of specific Japanese elements like tamago, kappa maki, and anime soundtracks. The technical music discussions (Korg Monologue, filter types, Yoko Kanno soundtracks) add credibility to the characters' musical interests. Where the piece could improve is in its balance of dialogue and narrative description. While the dialogue-heavy approach works well, occasional descriptive passages about body language, facial expressions, or the sensory experience of the setting would enhance the reader's immersion. The piece sometimes relies on dialogue alone to convey actions that might benefit from brief descriptive passages. The ending feels natural and open-ended, suggesting the beginning of a friendship rather than forcing a dramatic conclusion. This suits the slice-of-life genre and the prompt's request for a "first connection" scene. Overall, this is a strong piece that succeeds in its primary goal of capturing two distinct voices in dialogue and portraying an authentic first meeting between contrasting characters who find unexpected common ground. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 14 Elegant Prose: 16 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 3 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 17 Overall Impression: 17
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 14.0, Elegant Prose: 16.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 3.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 17.0, Overall Impression: 17.0
+ Teen horror: Tick Tock (Goosebumps) — Score: 87.5
Prompt:
Teen Horror (Goosebumps style) Write a chapter where a middle school student discovers their new smart watch has the ability to rewind time, but doesn't realize that each use is aging them until they notice physical changes (like accelerating through puberty) and that people are treating them differently. They inadvertently cause a timeline shift with disastrous consequences -- and it can only be rectified (maybe?) by reversing the clock once more. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The first thing I noticed about the new watch was the weight. It wasn’t like the plasticky tracker Dad bought me for my twelfth birthday — this one hugged my wrist cold and heavy, like it belonged there. The face was dark until I tapped it, and then a clean white ring lit around the edge and a tiny digital clock blinked: 7:02 a.m. “What is that?” Mom asked, pouring coffee. She frowned at the sleek metal, the wordless face. “You can’t wear that to school if you’re going to stare at it all day.” “I won’t,” I said, although I couldn’t keep my eyes off it. The band didn’t have a clasp, exactly. It had slid over my hand like liquid and then sealed. We’d found it — found is a big word for picking up something shiny — on the library steps the day before, after that weird thunderstorm that knocked out half the town’s power. Ivy had said, Keep it. If it’s important, someone will put up a sign. No one put up a sign. I tapped the face again on the bus. For a second, the time blinked and then the numbers scrambled. Another set appeared: 23:59:57. 23:59:56. 23:59:55. I blinked hard. When I looked again, it was gone, replaced by the normal time and a tiny circle that turned with each second. “Cool watch,” said Miguel, dropping into the seat beside me. He pushed his hair out of his eyes and grinned. “New?” “Kind of,” I said. I started to tell him about the countdown, but the driver hit a pothole and the watch vibrated — a soft buzz against my skin — and my stomach did the same thing it does when I ride the Tilt-A-Whirl. For a second, the bus blurred. Then it was normal again. My heart hammered. My fingers hesitated over the screen. You can't wear that to school if you're going to stare at it all day, Mom had said. At school, staring is what everyone does anyway. They stare at the phone, at whose braces are off, at Coach’s whistle stuck in the neck of his t-shirt. They stared at me when Mrs. Hall called me up in math for going to the bathroom without asking. She tapped a pencil against her desk and said, “We discussed bathroom passes, Tyler.” “I wasn’t feeling good,” I muttered. “Next time, ask.” “I did,” I lied. I hadn’t. I’d just walked out, stomach twisting, because that buzz from the bus had hit me again during a word problem. Her eyebrows lifted. “If you asked, then why didn’t I hear you?” I didn’t plan it. The word came out of me like a dare. “Rewind.” The watch face flickered. It wasn’t the normal blink. The entire ring pulsed white, and the world… hiccuped. One second, Mrs. Hall was lifting the pencil. The next, it was still on the desk, and I was in my seat with my backpack on the floor and my hand half up. My breath steamed cold in my throat. I knew what was about to happen because I’d just lived it. I cleared my voice and said, loudly, “Mrs. Hall, can I go to the bathroom? I don’t feel good.” She glanced up, already mid-frown, but this time it softened. “Yes. Take the pass.” My fingers shook around the pass. In the hall, the fluorescent lights made the floor look like a grid of little mirrors. I stared down at my reflection, at the watch. I prodded at the face. The countdown flickered again: 23:52:12. It had ticked down. I didn’t tell anyone at lunch. I didn’t tell Ivy or Miguel or even my own brain. Every time my thoughts reached toward the moment in math, something lit up inside my chest — a tight, private spark — and I swallowed it like a secret. The bell rang, the day went on. Little things. I tripped over a backpack in the crowded hallway and, without thinking, whispered the word I’d said in math, and the watch warmed and the air spun and my foot lifted and the world stepped back three seconds and I didn’t trip. I said something stupid in front of Ashley from seventh period and rewound it and said something less stupid. I looked at the countdown between classes. 23:28:45. On the bus home, I pressed the face and said, “Res-” and stopped. Miguel was staring at me. “What?” “You look different,” he said. He squinted. “Did you… did you shave?” My hand went to my cheeks automatically. They felt prickly. This morning, I was still the kid who couldn’t grow a hair if I taped it on. Now my cheeks were rough like Dad’s face on Saturday mornings. It didn’t make sense. I laughed too loud. “No.” That night, in the bathroom, I flicked on the light and clamped the razor between slippery fingers. The mirror showed me a face that wasn’t mine. It was almost mine, a sharpened version: cheekbones cut out, shadow under the jaw, a sprout of dark hair prickling above my lip. My shoulders looked wider. My skin had a new oil-sheen that I’d seen in deodorant commercials. My voice, when I said, “Mom?” through the door, sounded lower. “Are you okay?” she called back. Her voice was wary. “You’re in there a long time.” “I’m fine,” I said, and the bass of the word rattled the shower curtain. In my room, I lay on the bed and watched the countdown tick. 21:12:08. Tick, tick, tick, like a heartbeat you couldn’t turn off, even if you wanted to. I held the watch to my ear and heard nothing. The next morning, the countdown was 19:50:13. The numbers weren’t hours and minutes, not really. They didn’t align with anything. They just fell, second by second, a promise or a threat. When I walked into school, people looked at me the way they look at the eighth graders who can grow mustaches. Ashley waved like she was waving at someone behind me. “Hey,” she said, voice sticky sweet. “Do you want to work together on the science project?” I looked around to see if she meant Miguel. “Uh. Sure.” Mrs. Hall squinted at me. “Have you gotten taller?” Coach kept me after gym. “You okay?” he said. His gaze slid nervously from the watch to my face, like he didn’t know where to land. “You’ve been… different this week.” This week? It was Tuesday. At lunch, Ivy stared. “Your voice,” she said final. “Okay. That’s it. What did you do?” The truth pressed at the back of my teeth. “Nothing.” She snorted. “Something. Is that even the same shirt? You look like you stole the real Tyler and replaced him with a clone. Are you thirteen? Fourteen? Sixteen? Gross.” “Thirteen,” I said. My head throbbed. The watch vibrated, a little shudder. The ring of light flashed and then — just for a heartbeat — the numbers swapped, and I saw something else. Not a countdown. Not the time. A date, maybe. It flickered: 10/14. Then it was gone. On October 14th, the storm hit. The power surge. The watch on the steps of the library. “I have to go,” I told them, and stood up too fast. The world swam. I grabbed the edge of the table. My hand looked like Dad’s hand when he’s flipping burgers at a cookout: tendons, veins like cords. The library’s automatic doors hissed open. It smelled like paper and dust and the bodies of a hundred kids slumped over homework. Mrs. Crane behind the desk lifted her glasses. “No food,” she said, because my clenched hand looked like it might be holding something. I wasn’t holding anything. I made my feet move, down the hallway, past the stacks, to the back steps that open onto the alley. My breath steamed in little white bursts. Leaves chased each other like mice. I blinked up at the sky. Sunny. No storm. Not 10/14. The watch buzzed again. And then the lights flickered. Just once. The buzz became a hum, building until my teeth ached. People murmured in the main reading room. Somewhere, a printer beeped hysterically. The countdown slid. In the alley, something sparked. A streak across the sky, a ribbon of green light like a crack opening. The back of my neck prickled. I was watching the moment I’d thought about. The moment before. The watch face pulsed. This is chance, something inside me whispered. Fix it. “Rewind,” I said. The word felt filled with metal. The alley shifted. The world tilted. I stumbled. When I caught myself on the railing, it left a dent. I was back on the steps — the same steps — but the library windows were boarded. A RED X spray-painted across the doors. Weeds gnarled through cracks in the concrete. A sign hung crooked on the chain-link gate: CLOSED BY ORDER OF … Not the same font, not the same seal. The letters blurred when I tried to read them, like my eyes refused. The watch’s numbers whirled like a slot machine. 17:00:00. 16:59:59. The ring spun so fast it made me nauseous. Someone screamed. I turned. Across the street, the school was different too. The football field was a crater filled with water. The windows were black. Weeds in the parking lot. A cold wind hissed through a husk that used to be a bus. The air had that metallic taste, like pennies on your tongue. It was late afternoon, but the sun was too small. My phone had no bars. The pictures in my camera roll scrolled by faster than my thumb, faces I knew and didn’t. Mom, younger, then older, then with her hair gray. Dad with a beard he never had. Then a picture of me, taller, with a girl I didn’t recognize, the face half cut off because we’d been laughing. My stomach lurched. I bent over and retched into the weeds. “Tyler,” said a voice. A hand landed on my shoulder. I jerked. Ivy stood there, hair in two messy buns, a hacking little hand-made filter mask over her mouth. Her eyes were wet. She pulled it down and said my name again, like she couldn’t believe it. “Tyler. Oh my God.” “Where— what is—” I tried to talk. It came out a growl. My face felt tight. My chest was thicker. My feet ached in my shoes like they’d grown. “You couldn’t leave it alone,” she said. There wasn’t blame in it. Just exhaustion. “We warned you. You didn’t warn you. Which is fun, in a cosmic sense.” She swallowed. “We need you at the bunker.” “Bunker?” I echoed. “You call it ‘Mom’s basement’,” she said dryly. “Come on. There’s another storm coming. There’s always another storm.” I stumbled after her, the sound of my breath loud in my own ears. The town emptied around us. No cars. No other kids. A handful of people moved like ghosts, faces turned away, scarves wrapped around their mouths to keep out the taste of the air. In the bakery window, a cracked cake sat wilting under dust. “What did I do?” I said. “You skipped,” she said. Just that. “You used it. Every time you did, it pulled you forward. You didn’t go back. You never go back, Ty. That’s the trick.” I looked down at the watch. The numbers ticked merrily toward zero. “But I said rewind,” I protested weakly. “It’s not a genie,” she snapped, then softened. “It trades in being. Not doing. Every rewind is a step up the ladder — a rung your body thinks it climbed. Puberty, growth, all of it. You asked it to undo moments and it paid itself with your time.” She shoved open the door to Mom’s restaurant — the front window shattered — and hustled me down the stairs. The basement was full: generators, canned beans, the glow of a single lamp. Miguel looked up when we came in. He had a thin scar across his cheek. He wore a jacket too big for him and he was taller than me by two inches. Ashley sat on the floor cross-legged with a stack of maps. “You’re late,” Miguel said. He tried to smile. “Same joke every time.” “Every time?” I asked, voice hoarse. He rubbed a hand over his jaw, like it hurt. “You showing up a different age with panic in your eyes. We reset as far as you dare, and then you dare too much.” A hum built like pressure. The watch buzzed hard enough to hurt. The lamp flickered. I licked my lips and tasted rain. “What happens at zero?” I asked. Ivy and Miguel looked at each other. Ashley lifted her head and said quietly, “Last time? You blacked out for a week. We lost, like, half of us to the second surge. It’s not a great surprise.” My chest tightened. The watch face pulsed bright, the ring of light a perfect halo. 00:00:30. “You said we can reset,” I said. “We can fix it.” “We can shift it,” Ivy corrected. “Maybe we can land somewhere less… broken. Maybe we land where the library’s just closed and not gone. Maybe your dad doesn’t—” She cut herself off. “We need to get ahead of the storm that started it.” “October 14th,” I whispered. The date I saw. The first storm. The watch got found. The watch got me. Miguel shook his head quickly. “Careful.” 00:00:12. “Tell me what to do,” I said. “Say it,” Ivy said. “Set a point. Think it, not to the day, to the hour. The hour before. And don’t. Touch. Anything. You don’t know what version of you you’ll be when you land.” 00:00:05. My mouth was dry. I stared at the face. It flickered. For a fraction of a second — a sliver like a paper cut — I saw another number, burnt into the edges: a tally I hadn’t noticed. 131. Under it, another: 131. I didn’t understand either of them. “Rewind,” I said. The watch screamed. That’s the only way I can describe the noise — a high, finite wail that wasn’t sound, not really, because I felt it in my teeth and my bones. The ring went dark, then bright, then black. The light in the basement blew. A smell like ozone and old pennies filled my mouth. I fell. There wasn’t up or down or sky or floor. There was wet air and steam and the impression of my own hand clenched around something I hadn’t chosen to hold. Then, a crunch. I was on the library steps. Early morning. Dew on the grass. A cop car slid by with its lights off. The sky was innocent. The watch was silent against my skin. On the top step, gleaming in the watery light, lay the watch. I stared. It was like a reflection of the one on my wrist. The twin. The steel face flashed once and showed 23:59:59. I didn’t remember picking it up last time. I remembered finding it. But that’s not the same as it appearing. I looked down at my hand. My knuckles were scabbed. The band on my wrist had set itself like a scar. The countdown on mine flickered. 23:59:58. The twin’s did too. A person is a collection of choices and accidents. I'm thirteen. I’m older. I’m thirteen. My voice is my voice. I could leave it there, let someone else bend to it. I could smash it under my heel. I could warn the world to go inside and unplug the power strips and hold their breath. The watch hummed. The numbers danced. I heard Ivy’s voice in my head like a radio: We reset as far as you dare. And the thin smile in Miguel’s: Same joke every time. Something in me hurt — a deep throb like the ache after you’ve grown too fast. My phone buzzed. A text from Mom: Breakfast is getting cold. The normalcy punched tears up behind my eyes. I took one step down. Then up. The watch on the step winked at me, a coy little dare. I reached toward it. My hand hovered. My own watch pulsed. In the glass of the library door, my reflection stared back at me. For a second, he was taller. Then he was me. Then he was taller. Behind him, in the reflection, a thin vertical crack in the sky opened like an eye. I grabbed the watch. “Rewind,” I said into the morning, voice steady, and the ring around my wrist burned white as a new day. Maybe it would undo the first mistake. Maybe it would make me into that version from the bunker. Maybe it would split us into strings like the frayed end of a rope. The face flickered as we moved. For a heartbeat, the numbers changed. They weren’t time anymore. They were a count. 131. 130. 129. And then the world folded, and I fell toward the storm I had always been running into.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This teen horror story effectively captures the Goosebumps style while adding more sophisticated elements. The narrative follows Tyler, who discovers a mysterious watch that appears to rewind time but actually ages him forward with each use while creating timeline distortions. The piece excels in its pacing and atmosphere. The author builds tension gradually, starting with small, seemingly harmless uses of the watch before revealing the devastating consequences. The physical changes Tyler experiences are described with effective subtlety - the prickly cheeks, deeper voice, and changing body proportions all contribute to the horror without being heavy-handed. The time mechanics are handled with impressive consistency. The countdown timer creates a sense of impending doom, and the revelation that "rewind" actually moves Tyler forward in time is a clever twist on the prompt. The author maintains internal logic throughout the complex time-travel narrative. Character development is strong, particularly for a short piece. Tyler's motivations feel authentic - the temptation to fix small embarrassments is relatable for a middle schooler. The supporting characters (Ivy, Miguel, Ashley) are sketched efficiently but distinctly. The future versions of these characters in the dystopian timeline add emotional weight to the consequences. The writing style balances accessibility with literary merit. Sensory details like "the metallic taste, like pennies on your tongue" and "the air spun and my foot lifted and the world stepped back" create vivid imagery. The dialogue sounds natural for teens while advancing the plot. The ending is particularly strong - ambiguous yet satisfying. The cyclical nature of the time loop is revealed through the countdown numbers (131, 130, 129), suggesting Tyler has been caught in this pattern repeatedly. This creates a chilling conclusion without being too definitive or simplistic. Some minor weaknesses include occasional overreliance on telling rather than showing, particularly when explaining the watch's mechanics in the bunker scene. A few metaphors ("like a paper cut") feel slightly forced. The dialogue in the bunker exposition scene is somewhat functional rather than natural. Overall, this is an accomplished piece that transcends typical Goosebumps fare while honoring the genre's conventions. It balances accessible teen horror with more sophisticated themes about time, choice, and consequences. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17 Elegant Prose: 16 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 5 Tell-Don't-Show: 4 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17.0, Elegant Prose: 16.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 5.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 4.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Noir romance: Carnival of Dangerous Intentions — Score: 90.7
Prompt:
Carnival of Dangerous Intentions Coney Island, New York, July 1937. She stopped just before reaching the shooting gallery set up along the boardwalk. It was near dusk, and the carnival lights were buzzing on. **His locks**. The words flashed through her mind, again, like an intruder. Such an old-fashioned turn of phrase that kept surfacing, and something else -- dangerously compelling -- quickly suppressed, lest she question why she had returned here at all. This place where she had promised to meet the stranger -- the young man with the obsidian curls and even darker eyes. She didn't even know his name. Write a scene in a larger story inspired by this prompt. The scene should capture an atmosphere that blends romantic allure with an undercurrent of subtle danger or moral ambiguity. Think 50 shades, but with a more restrained classic sensibility. The scene is all about establishing tension. Write for the feminine perspective. Include roughly 50% dialogue, 20% internal monologue, and 30% exposition and scene setting. The tone should have some edge to it. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The smell of cotton candy hit her first as the lights shuddered awake. A pink thread of sugar on the air, impossible to ignore. It tugged at a place in her mind that felt soft and unguarded, a blurred memory of small hands and sticky fingers and someone laughing—her own laughter, perhaps, small and high and uncomplicated. She reached for the image and it slipped away like satin from a careless grip. The boardwalk gleamed in damp stripes, slick from the day’s warmth settling into evening. Neon sputtered and congealed into color. Music, cheap and merry, jostled the air, laced with the R’s of barker patter and the muffled pop of guns at the shooting gallery. Pale sawdust gathered in the seams between the planks, and the faces that passed her had the special anonymity of crowds at twilight—near enough to brush her sleeve, not near enough to see her. His locks. The phrase came back like a match struck in a dark room. It embarrassed her, how old-fashioned it sounded, how girlish, how private. It made her mouth tighten and her palms a little damp. It made her wonder, just for a moment, what business she had coming back here to meet a man she didn’t know, to whom she had given nothing more than her name and a time. “Looking to win a prize, miss?” called a boy in a red striped vest, gesturing to the rows of tin ducks bobbing past the open mouth of the rifle counter. The gun barrels lay on felt, their dull grain silvered with oil. The boy smiled in the way all carnival boys learned to smile, bright and fast, more teeth than warmth. She shook her head and he turned away, already calling to someone else. She had promised to meet him by the shooting gallery, and so here she was, two minutes before the time they had agreed upon. Her heart picked up its step at the thought of those curls, black as wet ink, the way they had rested against his forehead as if some wind only he knew had pressed them there. The eyes had been darker still. When he had looked at her earlier, this afternoon in the shade of the fortune teller’s tent, she had felt that look move along her skin like a fingertip through dust. “You came.” She didn’t start, because she had known he was near from the change in the air, the flutter that wasn’t the wind. But she turned and let her gaze travel, slow, mindful, before it took him in. He was closer than she’d expected. Not tall, exactly, but held together in a neat, dangerous way. Trim suit, not new but cared for. A white shirt at his throat, the collar slightly too tight. The mouth that had looked amused earlier now seemed more precise. And the hair, of course, coiled and glossy and wrong for this heat, wrong for the boardwalk, wrong for a boy who said he’d be here at seven and was. His locks. She hated herself for thinking it. She loved that she hated it. “I did,” she said, and then, because she disliked how the words sounded alone, she added, “It’s a habit I have. Keeping appointments.” His smile lingered and then pared down into something more intimate. “We’ll have to see what other habits you have.” A laugh rose and lodged at the bruise of her throat. She let it sit there. “You never told me your name,” she said. “I didn’t,” he returned, and tipped his head toward the counter where the rifles lay. “Do you shoot?” “No.” “That sounds like a yes waiting to be persuaded.” He moved, and the crowd parted a little around them, as if a current had changed. “Come,” he said, and the word obeyed itself; she found her feet carrying her to the felt-lined ledge. A row of tin ducks slid by, their painted eyes wide, their beaks open in permanent astonishment. The young man put a coin on the counter with the casualness of someone tipping an invisible hat. The boy in the vest winked and slid a rifle toward him. “You’ll want the lady to go first,” the boy said. “I very much do,” the stranger replied, and when he turned the butt of the rifle toward her, she noticed his hands—the tendons like tensioned strings, the nails clean and square. She had never held one. The wood was smooth and faintly warm, the metal cold. He stepped closer, so close she could smell him—something clean, not cologne exactly. Soap and wool and a thread of smoke. The cotton candy pulled at her again, that not-memory, slow as syrup. “Here,” he murmured, and his hands bracketed hers on the stock, not touching her skin, not quite. She could feel the heat of him through the thin sleeve of her summer dress. “Rest your cheek here. Close one eye. Breathe.” She did as he said because it was easier, in that moment, to do than to think. She put her face against the wood and breathed, and his breath moved in time with hers, a discipline or an accident. “What am I aiming for?” she asked. “The duck with the chip on its shoulder,” he said. “Don’t smile.” “I wasn’t.” “You were.” “I must have been thinking of something else.” “What?” She steadied the line of the barrel along the moving ducks. “Childish things,” she said, and fired. The recoil bumped her shoulder with less force than she expected. A duck jerked and rattled; a small bell rang. The boy in the vest clapped, a perfunctory, practiced sound. “Got an eye,” the stranger said, not quite praise. “Again.” She couldn’t tell if she liked this—it didn’t matter if she did. She fired again. Missed. Fired. Hit. The second bell’s echo dissolved into the noise all around them—the clatter of rides, the distant scream and laughter, a singer somewhere, singing about a man going away on a train. She set the rifle down. “Enough,” she said. “Hm.” He considered her in that way men did when they were deciding what you would do before they asked. “Take a walk.” “Another command?” she asked. “An invitation, dressed for the occasion.” She looked toward the funhouse, its bright, painted face grinning wide with impossible teeth. Toward the Ferris wheel, pulsing like a slowed heartbeat. Toward the clusters of people thick with their own stories. Her memory, the cotton candy sweetness, wavered and vanished, and she felt a loss all out of proportion to what it was. She was suddenly aware of her own wrists, how small they were, how they could be circled. “A walk,” she said. “All right.” He didn’t offer his arm. She didn’t want him to. They moved together, not touching, until the crowd thinned where the boardwalk turned toward the beach. The sand was dark with evening, the water deeper still, spooling itself out and in with a patience that felt immodest. A girl ran past them, ribbons flaring; a man selling peanuts called out a price that sounded like a dare. “Do people often meet you like this?” she asked. “Women who don’t know your name.” “Often enough.” “That must be convenient.” “It is… useful.” “And for them?” “Who can say?” He looked at her then and let his gaze rest. “Do you want a name?” She thought about it. A name is a line someone throws you, so you can be dragged closer or so they can pull you up if you slip. It is also a way to hang a person in your mind, to keep them from smearing. She wanted the smear. She wanted the peril of it. The wanting itself felt like a rebuke. “No,” she said. “Not yet.” “Capable,” he said softly, as if to himself. “I wonder if that’s true.” “Are you going to test me?” “Yes.” He didn’t smile. Neither did she. They walked past a booth selling saltwater taffy. She put two coins down and took a small paper bag. He watched her unwrap one piece, pale green, mint. The candy stuck, momentarily, to the roof of her mouth, and she was again a child with sticky fingers, a voice calling out to her across the boardwalk—who had called? A father? A mother? The question went nowhere; maybe it was no one, maybe she had made it up entirely. She let the candy dissolve on her tongue and felt the ache of sweetness, the silly ache of it, and it made her want to bite. “What do you want?” he asked. “Now?” “In general.” She said, “Sometimes I think I want to be told what to do. It’s restful, isn’t it?” “And sometimes?” he prompted. “Sometimes I want to be the one telling. Sometimes I want to forget I have to choose at all.” She let the bag of taffy dangle from her wrist and felt the paper sweat against her skin. “And you?” “Control,” he said simply. “Yours. Mine. The difference between them, which is very thin.” “That sounds like danger.” “I prefer clarity. It only feels like danger when you are used to lying.” “Do you think I’m lying?” She was expecting him to say yes. Something about the way he held himself suggested a man who liked to say yes where no might be kinder. “I think you’re very brave, for a person who hasn’t yet admitted how afraid she is.” She stopped. The sea, relentless, kept coming in. The carnival lights behind them buzzed as if on a threshold between alive and not. She thought of the fortune teller’s ringed hand on the tent flap earlier, the way she had said, A choice will pretend to be a mistake. She had laughed at that, because who wants to be talked to like a horoscope? Now the phrase settled in her like a coin on the tongue. “Do you want to turn around and go home?” he asked. “Yes,” she said, honestly. “And also no.” “Good.” He took a moment, and in that moment his eyes changed—not softer, exactly, but less ornamental. “If we’re careless, I’ll hurt you. If we’re careful, I’ll still hurt you. Do you understand that?” Her breath went out and back in. “And will I hurt you?” “You might,” he said. “That would be… acceptable.” She looked out at the water, where the stars were thinking about showing themselves. She felt the boardwalk, solid under her feet, that made thing, those nailed-down planks designed to hold up anybody. She felt the bag of taffy against her wrist, sticky, light. She felt her own pulse, which was not shy at all. She turned back to him. “Then tell me what to do,” she said. “For now.” He nodded once, as if he had wanted her to ask him as much as she had wanted to ask it. He stepped closer, not touching. The space between them became a thing with edges. “Walk with me down to the pier,” he said. “Stay on my left. Don’t speak unless I ask you a question. If you want to stop, say ‘blue.’ If you want more, say ‘again.’ If anyone we know sees us, tell them I’m your cousin.” She raised an eyebrow. “Cousin is the safest lie,” he said. “No one wants to ask too many questions about family.” “Blue and again,” she repeated. “Those are silly words.” It felt good to say something ugly about something she intended to do. “They are only words,” he said. “What happens around them is where meaning lives.” “And if I say neither?” “Then I’ll decide. I’ll always decide unless you don’t want me to.” She waited to feel offended. She wasn’t. Her skin felt attentive. She looked at his hands, at the slight scar near the knuckle of his index finger, and wondered what had made it. A knife? A door? The easy, unnecessary lie: a woman’s tooth. She smiled, barely. “Do you carry a gun?” she asked. “Sometimes.” “Now?” “No.” He paused. “Do you want me to?” She shook her head and started walking, taking her place to his left. The pier stretched out before them like a choice pretending to be a mistake. The gaudy lights shivered on the black skin of the water. The smell of sugar and salt and oil followed them like a tame dog. She didn’t speak. She let him lead. She listened to the measured sound of their steps. Inside her, the cotton candy memory unspooled again—a man’s hand on her head, maybe, smoothing her hair, a voice saying be good in a way that had meant be still. She could not catch it and she could not stop reaching for it. The wanting itself had become a kind of hobby. “Tell me something true,” he said at last, looking ahead, as if the truth were a place you had to approach obliquely. “I’ve never liked roller coasters,” she said. “That’s nothing,” he said. “It is tonight.” He nodded that small, private nod again. “Again.” “Again,” she echoed, and watched the darkness gather, careful and hungry, and did not flinch.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a tense, atmospheric scene between a woman and a mysterious stranger at Coney Island in 1937. The writing demonstrates considerable skill in establishing the requested blend of romantic allure and subtle danger. The prose is richly descriptive, with sensory details that effectively transport the reader to the carnival setting: "The smell of cotton candy hit her first," "Neon sputtered and congealed into color," and "The boardwalk gleamed in damp stripes." These details create a vivid backdrop against which the tension between the characters unfolds. The internal monologue effectively reveals the protagonist's conflicted feelings—her embarrassment at her attraction to the stranger ("His locks"), her awareness of potential danger, and her simultaneous desire to pursue this encounter despite the risks. The writer skillfully maintains the feminine perspective throughout, capturing the protagonist's observations and emotional responses with nuance. The dialogue is particularly strong, revealing character through subtext and establishing power dynamics. The exchange about shooting the rifle serves as an effective metaphor for the relationship developing between them. The stranger's commands—"Rest your cheek here. Close one eye. Breathe"—carry erotic undertones while maintaining the "restrained classic sensibility" requested in the prompt. The piece excels at creating moral ambiguity. The protagonist acknowledges her contradictory desires: "Sometimes I think I want to be told what to do... Sometimes I want to be the one telling." The stranger's statement that "If we're careless, I'll hurt you. If we're careful, I'll still hurt you" establishes clear danger while maintaining the erotic tension. The writing occasionally verges on purple prose with metaphors that call attention to themselves: "Neon sputtered and congealed into color" and "The gaudy lights shivered on the black skin of the water." However, these moments generally work within the atmospheric, slightly noir-ish tone of the piece. The recurring motif of the cotton candy memory adds depth to the protagonist, suggesting childhood experiences that might inform her current desires and choices. This adds psychological complexity without overexplaining. The ending effectively maintains tension rather than resolving it, with the protagonist's repetition of "Again" indicating her willingness to continue this potentially dangerous encounter. The piece adheres well to the requested proportions of dialogue, internal monologue, and exposition. The dialogue comprises roughly half the text, with internal reflections and scene-setting making up the remainder. The word count is appropriate at approximately 1000 words. Overall, this is a sophisticated piece that successfully creates the requested atmosphere of romantic allure with an undercurrent of danger. The writing demonstrates strong control of language, character development, and thematic elements. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Surreal horror: Caribou Season at the Lodge — Score: 91.2
Prompt:
Caribou Season at the Lodge Genre: Surreal Horror JT knew something wasn't right from the moment they'd pulled up to the lodge. It looked exactly as it had every autumn of his life—the cedar shingles silvered with age, the porch sagging gently under weight of winters past—but the air felt thicker, somehow, as if the woods had leaned in closer, waiting. He thought maybe he was just tired. Maybe it was nothing more than the long drive north, cramped in the back of the truck beside his older brother Mike -- and a stack of rifles wrapped in oily canvas. Still, the feeling lingered. The first caribou they found that season hadn't bolted. It had just watched, ears flicking lazily, waiting for the shot. JT had felt a crawling in his gut watching it die, noticing how it fell with a quiet dignity—as though it had wanted nothing more. Nobody else seemed to find it odd, or at least they didn't say so. JT kept his mouth shut. Always safer that way. Then there was the moment in the clearing. JT had fallen behind, fumbling with bootlaces stiff from the cold, and by the time he'd caught up with his father and brother, they'd already stopped. JT slowed instinctively, ducking behind a tangle of brush, staring out into the open space where a massive buck stood utterly still, chest rising and falling in slow, deep breaths. The animal looked…wrong, somehow. Maybe it was the eyes—dark and flat, calm in a way that made JT's neck prickle. Or maybe it was something deeper, something in the way the buck stood close enough for his father to reach out and touch it. JT watched as his father raised a trembling hand toward the animal's muzzle. His father's face had a strange expression, eyes too bright, lips parted slightly, like he was on the verge of whispering something—a secret, maybe. The rifle hung uselessly at his side, forgotten. Mike had the same dazed look in his eyes. JT's breath stopped short, his mind suddenly shouting at him to look away, turn around, just run—but he couldn't move. And then, as suddenly as it had begun, it was over. The buck shivered, startled by something unseen, and disappeared into the brush without so much as a sound. The two of them looked around, confused, seemingly surprised to find themselves where they stood. JT stayed hidden, breathing shallowly, fear mingling with a confused sense of shame. His father had failed to take the shot. To even think about mentioning what he'd seen would have felt like betrayal—or something worse. JT waited until the others moved on before stepping out from cover. He stared into the empty clearing for a long, uneasy moment, wondering if anything had really happened at all, or if he was losing his grip. Maybe the woods were finally getting into his head. Writing Instructions: Continue with the next chapter of the story, maintaining a style reminiscent of Stephen King—grounded realism blended seamlessly with unsettling surrealism. The atmosphere should convey subtle dread, isolation, and psychological ambiguity. JT's perspective is crucial, yet he is an unreliable narrator, caught in uncertainty about what he's perceiving. Establish an undertone of creeping dread, establishing the isolation of JT's perspective, which he largely keeps to himself. Incorporate some dialogue. Build tension towards a payoff. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The second night, the wind shifted. You could smell the lake—wet leaves, iron, something sweetly rotten—and the chimney smoke sliding along the roof instead of going up. Everyone insisted it was normal for this time of year. You learn to accept weird little weather things up here, like a dog learns to accept the vacuum. But JT lay awake in the bunkroom listening to it smearing across the shingles, whispering in the eaves. He had the top bunk, same as always, because he was the smallest and the lightest and his father had once said, "My boys are stacked like kindling, just how I like 'em." Mike snored under him. The lodge crackled and popped like an old man in a church pew. Somewhere out there a loon kept thinking it was still dusk and calling to no one. He thought about the buck. He tried to make the memory less sharp, rounding off the corners. If he imagined his father's mouth not quite open, if he imagined the rifle more present in that hand, if he imagined Mike rolling his eyes, it got easier. A few minutes later it got harder again. He kept seeing that tremble in the buck's chest when it sighed, the idea that it had been about to say something. That's not a thought anybody in your family says out loud. Animals don't say anything. Animals are meat and bone and fur and sometimes beauty. If you start putting mouths on them inside your head, you become a person your family doesn't know what to do with. Sleep came like stepping into a deep puddle—one foot down and then nothing. He dreamed of the lodge with all the windows blacked out and the porch light a cold star, of the snowshoes hanging on the wall like two giant moths fluttering when he breathed on them. He dreamed his father's hand in the open clearing, not reaching for a muzzle but for a door knob suspended in the air. He dreamed that when the knob turned, it made the sound of a buck snort. He woke to bacon and coffee and the way men talk when they don't want to talk. Mike chewing like he wanted the bacon to surrender. His father flipping pancakes, grim as a judge. "You sleep okay?" Mike said, not looking up from his plate. "Fine," JT said, which was the automatic answer from birth. "Wind's wrong," his father said to the griddle. "We'll go east. Stay low. Fog'll burn off by ten." "Supposed to be clear tonight," Mike offered. "Full moon Saturday." His father slid a pancake onto Mike's plate like a man delivering a verdict. "Don't say that word to me." "What?" "Full," his father said, not looking at either of them. "There's no such thing." JT thought about the guide, Lang. Glenn Lang with the beard like a fox sleeping under his skin and a mouth that usually never stopped. The last couple of years he'd told stories with more relish than he sold permits. Moose in the old days you had to shoot three times and they still came. A lady from Boston who going to make yoga retreats in here until she saw a wolverine like a badger on steroids. Things like that. Last night, Lang had been quiet the way a locked drawer is quiet. They saw him after breakfast, down by the shed where he kept the sleds. He had his hat off and his hair lay flat in a way that made him look younger, or maybe sick. When he noticed them, he put the hat on so fast it was like he was covering a hole in his head. "Morning, Glenn," their father said. The name came out stiffly: Glenn, not Lang. A man's Christian name used only if you wanted something or you were giving pity. "Mornin'," Lang said. He tugged the bill of his cap and his eyes skittered past them toward the tree line. "You boys headed out?" "East ridge," Mike said. "You coming?" Lang's mouth did something complicated and then settled. "No." "No?" their father said. That single syllable loaded with nineteen years of tradition. No was not what the guide said. "Weather's strange," Lang said. "Barometer's been falling wrong. You smell that?" He lifted his chin slightly, sniffed. "Sap's turned in some of the maples and the popple's hanging onto leaves like it's got something to prove. Not hunting weather." "There's always weather," their father said. Lang nodded as if conceding a point in a conversation he was conducting with someone behind them. "I won't stop you. I don't own the woods. But I ain't walking you in past the south marsh today. And I'd take a day. Go into town. Fix that rear axle squeak on your truck. Get a pie from Martha. Be back in a couple days." "It's Thursday," Mike said. "Be back in a couple days," Lang repeated, and he looked at JT when he said it, the way somebody looks at the youngest to check if the message is getting in through the cracks. "You got something you want to say?" their father asked. His voice didn't get louder. It got narrower. Lang's hands went deeper into his jacket pockets. "Moon's wrong too," he said. "Big as it's gonna get. Things show up when it's like that." "Like caribou," Mike cracked, because he could never let a silence finish itself. "Not just that," Lang said. He started to say more, then shut his mouth. He turned and spoke toward the shed instead. "You know we had that logging crew out past Shanty Brook? Wednesday. They packed up yester—" "We're not loggers," their father said. "No," Lang said. "I guess you're not." Then he looked past them again, into the trees, and JT felt something unspool low in his gut, a fishing line drifting out and out until the spool wasn't humming anymore and you were down to your last wraps. "Be out of here before moon-up tomorrow. That's what I would do." He said it soft and fast and turned away and began a performance of checking the lashings on a sled that didn't need checking. Back in the truck, JT sat in the back seat again with the rifles like sleeping dogs and said nothing. "You see the way he looked at us?" Mike said. "Like we were the ones with the rabies." "He's spooked," their father said, starting the engine. "Glenn gets spooked when his woodpile runs low and when a fisher steals his chickens and when his wife goes into town without him. He gets spooked like it's a hobby." "Still," Mike said. He let the word hang there like a limb he was thinking of sawing off. They drove east, the ruts deep and the puddles silver. Birch trunks flicked by like a hall pass. JT watched them and tried to count to a hundred without thinking of the buck. He got to thirty-eight and failed. He got to seventy-two and thought of Lang telling them to go get a pie. Who the hell bolts when the season is sweet? People whose zero is different than yours, he thought. People who believe in full moons you can't say. They parked at the end of an old logging road that had tried to return to earth. You could tell it had been traveled recently by the way the grass lay crushed in two long rusty lines. JT felt that crawling again when he saw that. If he told himself it was because it might be trespassers, that was an acceptable explanation. They walked. The world had that strange hung quality, the quiet after a backfire. The fog didn't burn off by ten. It sat in the low places like a tired dog that refused to move. When it did lift in tatters, it went up not in streamers but in roundish shapes, like balloons. "You seeing that?" Mike said at one point, low, possibly to himself. "Eyes open," their father said. They saw tracks. Hooves fine as coin impressions in the cold mud. They saw scat, little piles like the raisins their grandmother used to put in bread pudding, which nobody did after she died. They heard nothing with intent. An occasional branch shifting its weight, that was all. By noon, JT's feet had that dead feeling like someone else's feet had been attached to his legs. He shouldn't have worn the old boots. He shouldn't have come. We're not loggers. The words repeated in his head with no context. He didn't know what they meant. He did and he didn't. He chewed at the inside of his cheek until it tasted like pennies. They stopped to eat at the low end of a meadow that in summer would have been wildflowers and dragonflies but now was a brown plate. His father handed him a sandwich wrapped in wax paper. Baloney, mustard like paint. JT chewed and wondered about the guide's story that he hadn't told. It danged like a chain behind them all day. "You keep checking behind you for bears," Mike said, grinning around his food. "Guilty conscience?" "Leave him," their father said. He said it gently. JT stared at him. When was the last time his father had said anything gently? It felt wrong, like a scent in a familiar room. "Glenn said the logging crew went out," JT said before he could swallow the words. They stumbled out of him half-chewed. "He started to say why and then didn't." "No crew wants to be in here for a full—" Mike started, then ducked when their father looked at him. He grinned, unrepentant. "For a big ol' moon night," he amended. He winked at JT. The wink felt like being let in on a joke you didn't find funny. "You believe in that—" JT began, and his father cut him off, not with a word but by raising a hand. The same hand that had reached toward the buck yesterday. JT saw it with two sets of eyes at once: his father's hand with the knuckles stiff and scarred and the hand he'd watched extend toward something invisible in the clearing. He felt a shiver push up his throat. He coughed to cover it. Something moved at the far edge of the meadow. Not big. A flicker. A patch of brush rearranging itself. He swallowed his sandwich wrong and choked a little. Mike slapped his back, too hard. "You all right?" his father asked, standing slowly. He didn't ask the woods a thing. He asked his younger son, which was new. "I'm fine," JT said. He wasn't. By three, the light had gone metallic. Indigo threaded into the shadows. They followed the low ground to a line of alders. Mike found the gut pile before anyone spoke. It was laid out neat, the way a butcher might: lungs deflated like paper bags, liver dark and shining, intestines looped in a tidy braid. JT stood there, his breath hitching, unable to decide if the orderliness or the fact that there was no blood stain made him feel worse. "Jesus," Mike said softly, like he had come into a church without knowing. "Who leaves that?" JT heard himself whisper. His voice sounded too loud in his own head, like he'd shouted into a hat. "Nobody who hunts," their father said. He crouched. He reached out and then pulled his hand back as if the air over the gut pile were hot. "Not coyote," he said. "Not bear. You'd see mess. Drag. This is..." He didn't finish. This is what? JT wanted to ask. This is a display. This is a gift. This is a warning. He had all those words floating around his brain like dandelion fluff. He picked none. He breathed through his mouth because the smell was not rot but something else—sweet like maple sap, but familiar in a way he couldn't place. He swallowed and swallowed. "Let's go," their father said finally. He said it like the word had been forced up through his teeth. "Back to the truck." They turned, and for a while the only sound was the soft shush of their clothes. JT kept trying not to step on the mule tracks of their lives, to make his own path. Every time he veered, his foot found an old footprint without looking. That made him feel crazy. Everything did. The woods tightened. There are places where the map doesn't tell the truth. You learn the truth with your body. The birches started to crowd close, arms crossed. The pines leaned in like arguments. Lang had said be out before moon-up tomorrow. It occurred to JT then that tomorrow was not a separate country from the one you were living in. Time up here had a way of pressing together like wet paper. They came to the ditch, the one that had been there since the CCC men cut it, and found the crossing gone. The old log had rolled itself away. The water wasn't deep, but it shone with a skin that didn't ripple right. His father hesitated. He never hesitated at that ditch. "Glenn was right," JT blurted, before he could stop himself. His words sounded breathless, like he'd run to catch up to them. "We should go into town. Tonight." Mike laughed. It was a quick bright sound that died fast. "We gonna check into the Holiday Inn and watch cable? Eat pie?" "Shut up, Mike," JT said. The words shocked even him. He wanted to grab them back out of the air, push them into his mouth, chew them up. His father turned to him. The pupils in his eyes were a little too big for the daylight. He looked at JT as if trying to decide which of his sons this was. "You think something's wrong," he said. It wasn't a question. He sounded tired, not angry. "Yeah," JT said. He heard how small it came out. His father nodded once, slow. He put a hand—the hand—on JT's shoulder for a second. Heat went through JT like a wire carrying current. "We go back now," his father said. "We'll talk to Glenn." They crossed lower, where the ditch went narrow and mean. Mud took them up to the laces. JT felt the earth suck at him and release him, like a thing tasting and discarding. He didn't look behind him. He didn't want to know if anything stepped into the prints they left while they were still wet. When they broke out into the road, the light had gone wrong again. It was the kind of afternoon that you only got up here, where the sky turned to tin and then, without ever admitting to being evening, went to dark. The truck was where they'd left it. But the feel of the clearing had changed, as if the truck had been visited, spoken to, blessed or cursed. The hood was clean of leaves when it should have been littered. A strip of birch bark had been laid on the driver's side mirror, tucked in like a love note. On it, in something sticky and brown, a shape had been drawn that might have been a circle, or a moon, or an unblinking eye. "Christ," Mike said. There was no laughter in it. Their father took the bark off, careful, like taking a bandage off a wound. He stared at it without expression and then set it gently on the hood. "Get in," he said. His voice was smaller now. They did. Lang was waiting when they pulled up to the lodge. He was on the porch, not sitting, not smoking, not doing anything. Even at a distance, JT could see that his hat was gone and his hair lay flat again. "You saw it," Lang said. It wasn't a question either. He looked at JT first and then their father. His eyes slid over Mike and didn't stick. "We saw something," their father said. "You're leaving?" "I told you," Lang said. He held his hands out and then dropped them, helpless. "You should go. Tonight. I can get you as far as town before it gets... before it gets all the way up. If you stay—" "What happens if we stay?" JT asked. He surprised himself: the question came out clear. Lang looked at him in a way that made JT feel both seen and puny. "Things come to the clearing," he said. "Sometimes they look like deer. Sometimes they don't look like anything. Men forget to shoot. Men forget they had hands. You know?" He flapped his hands clumsily at the ends of his arms. "Don't let it look back at you. That's what my father told me. Don't go meeting its eyes." "It's a moon," Mike said. "It's a light in the sky." Lang didn't bother with him. He was talking to JT's father now. "I ain't walking you in past the south marsh. But I'll drive you to town. You can come back Sunday. It'll be like nothing was. You'll laugh about me." "Our father laughed about things," their father said. "Right up until he didn't." He rubbed the bridge of his nose with his finger and thumb. Then he looked at JT. He was waiting for something. He was asking. JT didn't know which answer to give, only that for once he had an answer to offer. The edges of the day pressed in. The porch boards under him felt like they were humming. "Let's go," JT said. He said it the way he'd always wanted to say something in this family and be heard: not pleading, not mocking, just simple. He expected to be ignored. He wasn't. "Okay," their father said. He nodded once. "We go." He looked at Lang. "Half an hour. We pack." Lang's shoulders dropped. Relief made him older. "Half an hour," he said. "Before moon-up." They went inside. JT went to the bunkroom and stuffed his duffel with so little thought he ended up with two socks and no underwear, with a book he hadn't opened in two years, with the photograph of the three of them on the dock that he'd kept wedged between the bed slats. He didn't remember taking it out. He didn't remember deciding to bring it. He just found his hands putting it in the bag. When he came back through the main room, the lodge looked different. The mounted caribou head over the stone fireplace was staring at the door. He knew it couldn't move. He knew the screws and bolts behind it had been set forty years ago. He knew things. But the eyes didn't have that glassy marble look they'd always had. They looked dark and flat and calm in a way that made his neck prickle. He stopped. His feet welded to the floor. In the glass of the framed map over the desk, he saw the caribou head reflected. It looked wrong in the reflection. Bigger. Closer to him than it could be. He didn't turn around. He looked at the glass instead and thought of Lang's voice: Don't let it look back at you. "JT?" His father's voice from the door, not impatient, exactly. Something else. "Coming," JT said
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This continuation of "Caribou Season at the Lodge" demonstrates remarkable skill in maintaining and developing the surreal horror atmosphere established in the prompt. The piece excels at creating a sense of creeping dread through subtle environmental details, character interactions, and the unreliable perspective of JT. The prose style successfully emulates Stephen King's approach, blending mundane realism with unsettling surrealism. Details like the wind "smearing across the shingles," the guide's hat being put on "so fast it was like he was covering a hole in his head," and the gut pile "laid out neat" create vivid, disturbing imagery without overexplaining the supernatural elements. Character development is handled with subtlety. JT's internal struggle between what he perceives and what his family would accept shows his isolation effectively. The father's character evolves interestingly - his unusual gentleness and eventual willingness to listen to JT represent a significant shift that feels earned through the mounting dread. The dialogue is sparse but authentic, capturing the terse communication style of this family. The pacing builds tension masterfully. The writer uses a series of increasingly disturbing encounters (the wind, Lang's warnings, the gut pile, the birch bark note) to escalate the sense that something is fundamentally wrong. The narrative maintains psychological ambiguity throughout - we're never certain if the supernatural elements are real or if JT's perceptions are unreliable. The ending achieves a perfect balance - providing enough resolution (the decision to leave) while maintaining the underlying horror (the mounted caribou head's apparent animation). This creates a satisfying conclusion that honors the genre's requirements. A few minor issues include occasional overuse of short, fragmented sentences that can feel slightly affected, and some metaphors that border on being too elaborate. However, these are minor concerns in an otherwise exceptional piece. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fantasy-humour: Hell is Other Demons — Score: 90.2
Prompt:
Hell is Other Demons Write a day in the life short story. Lucifer morningstar's on again/ off again relationship with Lilith is currently in the "off again" stage, though the cycle may be coming around as Lilith has been stopping by for reasons other than purely violent ones, and Lucifer has been increasingly lonely. Write a day in the life of this power couple, with elements of dark comedy & fantasy. Use understated irony & absurdity by merging the black immorality and everyday business of running hell, against relatable domestic relationship drama. Take cues from Neil Gaiman. 1000 words.
Model Output:
At five, the screams begin. Lucifer lies flat on his bed and counts them like the chimes of a grandfather clock. The same hoarse chorus, the same dissonant fifth in the east gallery, the same overachieving banshee whose falsetto keeps spiking. He stares at the ceiling, where frescoed cherubs grind their teeth and avert their eyes, and thinks that routine is a quiet kind of blessing, like the world’s least romantic anniversary. He gets up, puts on the robe that was stitched from the boredom of saints, and pads barefoot to the kitchen. The floor is warm, not from any underfloor heating—Being Ultimate Evil, he refuses to be that pedestrian—but because the foundation is built on molten regret. He opens the refrigerator. It hums. He bought it from a mortal who said, conspiratorially, “It’s for wine, really,” but Lucifer keeps bottled mornings in it. He takes one down. Today’s morning is French and pastoral and tastes like dew and horses. It’s better than most mornings in Hell, where daylight is an ongoing rumor. He pours it into a chipped mug that has “World’s Best Manager” on it in friendly cursive. Someone—probably a demon with a subtle sense of humor and the ability to walk insolently through walls—left it on his desk centuries ago. He sips and looks out his window. Pipelines of molten bronze cross the horizon, pumping sin allocation meters. A flock of panic moves like mercury above the desalination pits. On the wall opposite, a portrait of him as harpsichordist in a court that never existed watches with polite disdain. Lucifer goes to work. Work is a desk in a room that changes depending on who opens the door. For him, it’s a late Roman study that never quite finished falling into disrepair. He sits, and the desk sighs. Papers arrange themselves. There’s a quarterly spreadsheet labeled “Envy,” and under it a stack of complaints about the new torments introduced in Sector 23, which allegedly smell too much like lemon pledge and not enough like despair. He signs something that possibly pertains to implementing a suggestion box. Every so often, he toys with it. He thinks of putting it near the Lake of Fire, where nobody can reach without an inconvenient swim. At eight, he meets with the Department of Ironies. They’re wearing pearls and clipboards. He leans back and steeples his fingers in a way that would make any mortal executive feel like a minor god. The head of the department, whose name at the moment is Prudence (it changes weekly to something unrelated and perfectly fitting), says, “We’re thinking of assigning a high-frequency, low-reward quest to the tyrant’s personal trainer.” “I like it,” Lucifer says. “Make him chase after his own six-pack, forever out of reach.” Prudence beams. Someone behind her snickers and writes it down. They move on to the case of the tooth fairy ring—twenty agents pretending to collect tiny enamel bribes from grown men with a lot of investments in dental floss—and whether that overlaps with Wrath. He approves three cross-departmental smitings with minor notes about tone. “Fewer trombones,” he scribbles. “We are not a municipal fall festival.” At ten-thirty, the floor shakes gently. Format: him, Lilith. He feels it not in the stone, but in the breath that comes in very carefully, like someone checking to see if he’s still home. Lucifer doesn’t turn immediately. He finishes initialing a form labeled “Surgeon Allocation: Gluttony.” Then he looks up. She’s carrying a scorched leather purse that has lost two handles to arcane incidents and perhaps one to boredom. Lilith sets it on the table and the table, which was once a tree that longed for storms, seems pleased. “Morning,” she says, which is magnanimous of her. “Morning,” he says back, trying not to drink her like the daylight he misses. Her hair is the color of old honey and newly spilled ink. Her mouth is the sort of red that shouldn’t be possible without a sacrifice. She is wearing a mortal dress, which means she has been somewhere. This makes his stomach do something human. It drops and then remembers he’s older than hunger. “I brought things,” Lilith says. Her voice is dry, like wind over a graveyard, but affectionate as the last time you climb the same swing. “Always,” he says. He means: me too, myself, my terrible habits, the rust under the gilding, the way I am happiest when you are also unhappy. They do not touch. Instead, they arrange themselves awkwardly around the purse. She opens it. The smell is an amalgam: coffee grounds, cigarettes with teenage bravado, something oceanic that might be the memory of rust. She pulls out a small snow globe. The wind inside it makes a little noise. It’s stamped with the Eiffel Tower, but the tower is crooked and inside-out, like it’s trying to be something that wasn’t designed for spheres. “Mortals,” she says. “They make tiny worlds you can control by shaking. There’s something sweet about how it doesn’t work.” He takes it. He shakes it, gently, and inside the vertical snow begins to fall upward. The tower’s shadow moves from one side to the other. Somewhere in his chest, the old old ache of choices too late and gates closing coughs politely. “Thank you,” he says, and is absurdly grateful. Lilith pulls out other things. A tarnished subway token with the letter M worn smooth. A stack of Polaroid photographs of parties with too much light in them and no one looking at the camera. A seahorse skeleton that was never alive. A small plastic bottle with a dead bee inside. “Found him on a windowsill,” she says. “He was trying. I thought of you.” “I’m honored,” Lucifer says. It’s not an insult and she knows it. They sit. They look at each other. This is usually where they fight, or kiss, or break something expensive, or all three in a sequence that implies choreography. Today, instead, Lilith taps the purse and says, “You replaced the doorknob.” “It was time,” Lucifer says, and it sounds like a confession. Across the desk are the minutes of the last meeting, where a middle manager named Balor had proposed not only that they cut the number of individualized torments by half, but that they institute a casual Friday dress code to make the place seem “more approachable.” Lucifer had listened, nodded, asked small questions. He had said no. Sometimes he’s professional. They tour Hell as if it’s an open house. They go past the Lake, which Lilith calls “our old haunt,” and he pretends not to remember the night they argued by it until one of them fell in and neither leapt immediately to rescue the other. They walk along the corridor of paperwork, where the files squeal softly and shuffle themselves, trying to make themselves look slimmer. Lilith picks up a ledger and flips through it. “You’re still using quills,” she says, not without admiration. “They burrow in better,” he answers. They pass Torture B, where the new guy is trying jangly pop music from the nineties on loop, and both of them make the face of ancient beings who would rather not have to be ancient about everything. “I can let the next soul choose his own torment?” says the demon assigned, a thin creature with the eyes of a hereditary librarian and the hands of a thief. “Fine,” Lucifer says, “as long as the choice is between two identical torments and a surprise. Let the surprise be a chair. But let the chair be made of apologies.” Lilith exhaled in that particular way she has that might, in other contexts, be called a laugh. “Still good,” she says. By noon, the rumors have already started, because Hell is a small place, like a village with no respect for privacy and an excellent baker. Beelzebub drops by under the pretense of checking on horn maintenance and tries, very casually, to see if they are back on. They are not. Not officially. The not-ness sits between them like a rescued armchair that squeaks when sat in and has one leg shorter than the others. “Did you get my memo about moths?” she asks. Lilith. Not Beelzebub. They are standing now by the Office of Occasionally Answered Prayers, which is staffed by cousins of grief. The prayers—jammed into pneumatic tubes, folded into paper boats, tattooed into skin—drift past like flocks of starlings that forgot how to turn. “Yes,” he says. “And no. I read it. I set it on fire in a way that implies ambivalence.” “Moths are very underrated. They turn up where you can’t expect them, then die like punched-out lamps.” “I’ll authorize a modest plague,” he says, and he means it. He writes “modest plague” on a note and puts it in his pocket, because sometimes he still needs to hold on to tangible things or they fly away into the high domes of Hell, where a wind like a sigh plays with cathedral webs. They eat lunch together because lunch happens whether or not anyone is hungry. It is stew of something that wanted to be a stew and didn’t quite make it. They sit with bowls, perched on stools that try to buckle, at a counter that remembers all the elbows that pounded on it in anger and all the hands that were too tired to do anything but lie flat. “How’s the mortal world?” Lucifer asks, finally, because it’s an obvious question and obvious questions have their uses. If you don’t intend to touch someone, you offer them weather. “Loud,” she says. “They’re making a lot of noise to reassure each other. New noises. Small gods of small screens. They are very devout, for a people who say otherwise.” “Devotion is devotion,” he says lightly, but he’s listening like a wolf in a museum. He can smell what’s behind words. He smells a city and a hotel room and a hand on the back of a dress and then a motel room and a hand not being there. He says, gently, “Did you find a good coffee?” She nods. This is the kind of question that sometimes saves them. “They pour it over a cone like rain. It tastes like a field trip.” They take the afternoon off from each other. She descends to the levels where old queens recite grudges and bridesmaids exchange sharp artifacts like currency. He goes to sign ten notices, three pardons (rare and carefully crafted so they don’t take), and once half a receipt that refuses. He watches a century end in a waiting room. He listens to an argument between two physicists who have discovered that infinite regret actually converges. At four, he finds her in the archive. The archive moves of its own accord, like bookshelves in bedtime stories, and occasionally refuses to give things back. She is talking to a shelf. It is listening. “Did you ever keep any of those postcards?” she asks without turning around. He doesn’t say, You know I did. Instead, he says, “Some. The ones with the sea. The ones where you wrote nothing and then later all of everything on a scrap of receipt.” She nods. She pulls a postcard out of the purse and hands it to him. It is blank. It has an address written on it in a hand he recognizes—hers, in a mood. An address that leads nowhere and everywhere. He doesn’t ask when she wrote it, or whether it’s from before or after the last time they burned down a city accidentally on purpose. At five, the screams begin to cool themselves, like a kettle forgotten. The staff starts their reports. The demons clear their throats. Hell winds down in the way that places with no time pretend to have times. He and Lilith go to stand on the balcony because there is always a balcony. It looks out on an amphitheater of souls doing something repetitive with buckets. The stars above Hell are not stars. They are holes. “We could,” he says, and stops. “Yes,” she says. It’s not an answer, but it is. They do not say: We could try again. We could pick a city. We could decide on rules we will break. We could install a lock on the inside. We could go upstairs and see if the bed likes the way we look in it now. He takes her hand. It is warm, and the warmth doesn’t diminish his. They hold hands like a compromise between a promise and a threat. “I brought one more thing,” she says, and reaches into the purse as if into the mouth of a lion that has become old and polite. She pulls out a little wooden box with sliding panels and a small brass latch. It rattles like dice. “What is it?” he asks. “It is either a music box or a trap,” she says. “Mortals love when things are both.” He opens it. It is a music box. It plays a tune that is almost, but not quite, “Greensleeves.” The mechanism inside is transparent and shows the teeth of time biting nothing. They listen. It is, somehow, worse than the screams and also better. “You can stay,” he says, finally, because he is tired. Because work will always be work, and love will always be something that looks like work from a distance. Because she came, and because she is still here. “I know,” she says. “I won’t.” Then, after a second so small it must be deliberate: “Not yet.” She kisses him, not like a flare and not like a funeral. Something in his spine unspools. Some trapped bird in the rafters becomes a shadow and flies through a hole to the non-stars. Later, after she has gone by a passage that remembers the shape of her feet, Lucifer pours another morning. This one is a Swiss morning, all cleanliness and discreet mountains. He sips. He stands in the doorway of his office and watches his demons sit with their feet up on chairs that were last week freshly designed to punish that exact posture. He thinks about the snow globe on his desk, the way the tower dissolves and reforms when shaken. He writes “modest plague” on a proper form and authorizes it. He crosses out “modest” and writes “merciful,” because he knows words have weight and it amuses him to rearrange the furniture. He looks at the hole-studded sky. He shakes the globe once, very lightly, so the snow falls from side to side. A day in Hell ends. Another begins. He is the prince of it all, and he is a man with a mug in his hand and the scent of someone else’s city on his shirt. It is absurd. It is reassuring. He goes to bed and counts the screams and tries to decide if he prefers them to silence, and the truth is he can’t, not today. Tomorrow, he thinks, he’ll replace a doorknob. Or he won’t. It depends on who knocks. It depends on what she brings out of her bag next time, and what part of himself he is willing to set on fire to keep warm.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully captures the essence of Neil Gaiman's style with its blend of the mundane and the fantastical, creating a Hell that feels both bureaucratic and mythic. The relationship between Lucifer and Lilith is rendered with nuance and understated emotion, avoiding melodrama while still conveying their complex history. The prose is particularly strong, with inventive metaphors and descriptions that make Hell feel simultaneously alien and familiar. Lines like "a flock of panic moves like mercury above the desalination pits" and "the foundation is built on molten regret" create vivid imagery while maintaining the dark comedy tone requested in the prompt. The writer excels at showing the relationship dynamics through small gestures and loaded silences rather than exposition. The exchange of gifts, particularly the snow globe and music box, serves as effective metaphors for their relationship—beautiful but contained, potentially dangerous, and slightly broken. The bureaucratic elements of Hell are handled with dry wit—the "World's Best Manager" mug, the department meetings about torments, and the casual Friday proposal all create the requested ironic contrast between the infernal and the mundane. The writer has successfully merged "black immorality and everyday business" as requested. The dialogue is sparse but effective, with subtext doing much of the heavy lifting. Lines like "I know," she says. "I won't." Then, after a second so small it must be deliberate: "Not yet" convey volumes about their relationship status. Where the piece could be stronger is in its narrative arc. While beautifully written, it meanders somewhat through the day without a strong central conflict or resolution. The "on again/off again" dynamic is well-established, but we don't see much movement in their relationship status by the end—they remain in a holding pattern. This may be intentional to show the cyclical nature of their relationship, but it somewhat limits the emotional impact. Some of the metaphors, while creative, occasionally border on purple prose. Phrases like "the rust under the gilding, the way I am happiest when you are also unhappy" and "the old old ache of choices too late and gates closing coughs politely" are evocative but occasionally feel slightly overwrought. Overall, this is an accomplished piece that successfully fulfills the prompt's requirements. It creates a distinctive world with memorable characters and maintains the requested tone throughout. The writing is elegant and imaginative, with only minor issues that don't significantly detract from its quality. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Historical fiction: Gladiator — Score: 92.0
Prompt:
Historical Fiction: Write a scene from a story set during the height of the Roman Empire, focusing on a slice of a day in the life of a gladiator. Do not write a combat scene. Use sensory details to capture the sights, sounds, and smells of ancient Rome. Explore the gladiator's thoughts and emotions. The story should also touch on the larger political and social issues of the time period. The piece should feel like a slice of a larger story. First person, past tense, 1000 words.
Model Output:
They woke us before the sun rose, when the world still smelled of ashes and last night’s wine. The lanista’s runner clattered a stick along the bars, and the bronze rasp on iron snapped us from sleep. My eyes opened to the dim glow of the embers in the brazier across the corridor, a haze of smoke lingering against the ceiling like a stubborn memory. Felix on the pallet next to mine turned over and muttered a curse to the household gods. He crossed himself not like a legionary but with two fingers to his lips and his heart, a gesture he swore was Etruscan, passed down from a grandfather who thrice spit before putting a foot into any arena. I pushed my blanket aside and planted my feet on the grit-strewn floor. The stone held the night’s cold. I rubbed my forearms to wake them, tracing with my thumb the raised seam of a scar along the radius. The bread yesterday had been stale and full of grit, the kind that squeaked against your teeth as you chewed. It still lived under my tongue. The kennel smell of men hung heavy in the cell, steeped into straw and sweat and oil. A soft padding came from the corner where the old dog that had adopted our ludus licked a paw, the rhythm as steady as a metronome. In another room someone retched, the sound hollow and unashamed. Before I stood, I performed the small thing I had made of my own. I kept a sliver of olive wood in my bag, shaved from the last tree I climbed as a boy before my family sold me and the city swallowed my name. Every morning before drills or a match, I took the sliver in my right palm, touched it to my left shoulder, my right shoulder, then my forehead, and then pressed it to the floor, to earth, to remind myself of the dirt that had known my bare feet. Superstition wears a man thin or keeps him whole. I could never say which, only that without these gestures the world seemed to tilt. We filed out, the morning cool in the courtyard, the sky a bruised purple behind the alley walls. Across our compound, the top of the amphitheater peered over the rooftops like the shell of some massive beast. Rome always felt like that to me, a colossus squatting over itself, marble plastered over brick and brick over whatever bones had come before. The street beyond our walls woke the way old men wake, slowly and with complaint. Donkeys brayed; someone argued about a loaf; a servant swept a threshold with short, angry strokes that sent dust motes spinning like gnats in a shaft of coming light. The lanista, Hanno of Carthage, stood at the well, his arms crossed over the girth of his chest, an old sword-scar pulling his lip into a permanent sneer. He wore his wool cloak even in summer, as if he didn’t trust the air itself not to trick him. “Water,” he said, the word falling on us like an order, though it was only that. We dunked our cups and drank, the metallic taste of the bucket mingling with the cold sweetness that made our teeth ache. My stomach stood up and began to take the world seriously. Training would not start until the sun lifted over the insulae, but the morning chores belonged to those of us not slated for private lessons. I drew straw from the cart and spread it cleanly in the kennels where the hounds slept. Their eyes watched me with animal loyalty and animal indifference. Felix carried oil jars to the storeroom, his steps cautious because oil cost more than a man. In the kitchen, Smyrna the cook reached for cumin and salt without looking, the way a soldier reaches for the hilt. Her cat wound itself around her ankles and hissed at anyone who brushed too close. The smell of the kitchen was a miracle: garlic, the rich scent of lamb bones boiled until they surrendered their marrow, the sharp drift of vinegar. Smyrna slapped my hand away when it hovered over a fig. “You’ll fight heavier if you steal,” she said, not unkindly. She tilted her chin toward the courtyard. “They say Germanicus won’t live to winter.” “Germanicus?” I had heard the rumor in whispers the day before, but in a family like ours news metastasized into truth by repetition. “They say,” she said, which meant someone’s cousin heard it from a man in the market who heard it from a man who scrubbed the steps of the Palatine. In our world, the Empire was a series of doors behind which you could hear laughter, never sure whose. Germanicus was popular, a name that rolled off the tongues of sellers like honey. Tiberius had shadows behind his eyes, and the people liked gods without shadows. Rome’s mood is a thing even the lowest feels. It trickles into you the way smoke does. It sticks to your hair and you carry it into bed. Hanno had us do footwork until the muscle in my calves felt like rope. The wooden swords were heavy and chewed the palm unless you oiled them. The clangour of wood striking wood rose in the air, a drumbeat that echoed between the walls. The smell was sweat and oil, leather and patience. Beyond the wall a poet recited to a group of men who were not listening, his voice drifting over half lines—“arms and a man”—and then the cackle of the crowd when a cart hit a pothole and spilled apples, red and green rolling in a pattern that made me think of a wound. By midmorning, patrons began to arrive. The ludus had become fashionable again since the latest edict about the customs tax slid like a knife under the ribs of the merchants. They came to see something they could afford, to prove to themselves that there was still spectacle for them, and the more they watched us sweat and bleed, the more it felt like their coin bought dominion. A senator’s boy with a cloak so white it offended my eyes tried to spit between his front teeth and managed only to drool. His father, small and sharp like a fox, murmured that if his son was to be a man he must learn to love the sound a bone made when it broke. Hanno smiled the smile he used for the rich, the one that meant he forgave them the fact that they were not like us. When I finished a series of lunges, the medicus caught my eye and flat-palmed a bandage at me. “Your wrist,” he said. “You brace it or you’ll never lift your cudgel again.” He was from Bithynia—or so he told us—and dressed like a scholar even in the heat, his hair slicked with oil and combed back hard. He believed in phlegm and bile and the balance of humors; I believed in waking and sleeping and muscles that spoke. After, I sat on the edge of the fountain and wrapped my wrist tight, the linen rough but clean. Felix plopped beside me, sweating like a roasting pig, and slapped his hands on his knees. “They say—” he started. “They always say.” He smiled and leaned forward, a boy’s mischief flashing across a man’s broken face. “They say the Prefect wants more blood. The people have not cheered loud enough. He came himself last week to the editor and said the city needs a river of red to wash its ears clean.” “It rains taxes,” I said. “They want the streets to run with something they can afford to see.” Felix picked at the scab on his elbow, then stopped, superstition catching him. “I spit three times before I step onto the sand,” he said, unprompted, as if just saying it kept us safe. “I know,” I said. His spit hit the ground, the ritual intact, improper to waste. He had the same gestures before a fight: he kissed his dagger’s pommel, whispered his sister’s name, and touched the scar on his chin with his ring finger. We were a museum of other men’s beliefs layered over our own. At night we would watch each other in the dim light and say the names of the little gods under our breath: Successus, Fortuna, Nemesis. We pretended we could pick which came. Hanno called me inside, away from the young patrons and the stink of their perfumes. Through the lattice I could see the street swelling like a vein. A woman with a basket of eggs walked with the careful gait of someone who had nothing to spare. The sun had broken over the rooftops and turned the air to brass. The Forum was in the distance, a bright cut in the rock of the city. Someone had scrawled a new graffito on our wall: a crude caricature of a magistrate with donkey ears. Beneath: Roma ridet. Rome laughs. Rome always laughs, at itself, at us. Inside were the armor racks, the metal echoes chime-soft, the furs hung to dry, the smell of polish and steel and old blood. I ran my hands over the crests and helms, feeling the dents, the history of each mark. My own helmet was plain, the brow band rubbing a bald stripe along the scalp to remind a man not to imagine himself too beautiful. I picked up the manica, the arm-guard, and turned it in the light. My reflection skimmed across it and slid off. For a moment the face felt like someone else’s, a man I might have been if I had not stepped through the door the day the slaver put his hand on my shoulder and appraised me like grain. A murmur rippled in from outside, a sound like bees but heavier. I stepped to the lattice again and watched a procession forming on the street. Men in dark togas, the flamine in their hats like inverted bowls, incense braziers smoking thick, a boy carrying a laurel branch. The smell of pine resin and human breath came first. A woman at a window above threw down petals and laughed, and the petals stuck to the sweat on a soldier’s neck. “Do you know,” Hanno said behind me, “what happens when the city starts to praise men who are not emperors?” “They lose their heads,” I said. “They all do,” he said, with a shrug that was not quite a joke. “Some in the street, some in their dreams.” He said the word emperor with the careful neutrality that meant he had lived under more than one. I thought of my father, how he had stared at the pile of debt notes on our table, the wax seals like hard berries. He had not sold me because I was his least favorite. He had sold me because Rome wants what Rome wants and the rest of us rearrange ourselves to accommodate. I did not see his face the day I stood at the block because I kept my eyes on the shadow of the man behind me. I remember the auctioneer’s chant, the way it sped up and slowed like the heartbeat of a hare: Who will—who will—who will—? Sometimes at night, when the others slept, Felix snored and the dog drummed its tail, I would lie and listen to the city, to the fight between cat and rat, to the late carts that groaned under amphorae, to the laugh of men who drank their lives thin in wineshops. I would picture the map of the empire on Hanno’s office wall, the provinces in chalk and the sea like a great blue-inked eye, and I would think: we are a small thing in a huge mouth, and the teeth grind down, and sometimes we gleam because we are wet. By noon the heat swelled until the courtyard stones seemed to breathe. We ate that day but lightly, barley cooked with onions and a sliver of pork fat floating among the grains like a promise. Smyrna gave me a fig at last, soft and splitting, the seeds crunching under my teeth like a sound from childhood. I licked the sweet from my thumb and closed my eyes. For a breath, I was sitting under that olive tree, the sliver not yet shaved, the bark rough under my back. For a breath, my chest unknotted itself. After the meal, I oiled my skin, the sheen like a second layer that kept my flesh from splitting under the sun. The oil smelled of olives and the faint ghost of the man who pressed them, his hands the same size as mine. The medicus checked my bindings again, grunted approval. Felix nudged me with his shoulder. “Tonight,” he said. “Not today.” Our next match was the morrow. Today the arena hosted venationes, the hunts. We could already hear the crowd’s rising voice, hear the roar as if a god had cleared his throat. The beasts would die, their smell carried in on the wind: hair, fear, dung, iron. I took the olive sliver from my bag once more in the afternoon, not because it was required but because the day demanded it. I touched it to shoulder, shoulder, head, floor. “Earth,” I whispered. I did not know whether I addressed a goddess or a memory or a boy in a field. It did not matter. Rome eats and Rome sings and Rome weeps, and somewhere a senator decides to clap or not because it pleases him, and somewhere a woman counts coins and decides whether she will buy a loaf or oil, and somewhere a soldier in Germania writes a letter and hopes it will not be intercepted by snow. And here, in a courtyard where the sun burns the same way it did on a different continent, I bound my hands and leaned my forehead against cool stone and waited for something to happen that would prove I was not alone. In the afternoon Hanno took me aside again and spoke of offers. A cavalryman of the Praetorians had left a name with our steward, a man who liked the way I moved and wished to patronize a fight, to see me wield a heavier weapon for spectacle. He had friends and a villa outside of the city and a bridge built with funds that were not his but held his name. “They will want you to lose or to win,” Hanno said. “They will want to pretend they decide. They like to buy fate by the amphora and drink it with watered wine.” “Do they think fate takes coin?” I asked. “Everything else does,” he said. He was not bitter. He was pragmatic the way a fisherman is pragmatic about the tide. “You will do as I say,” he added, but still looked at me as if asking whether I would follow. There is always that moment. It is the only place we are free. I nodded. He went away satisfied. I turned to the wall, to the new graffito, and traced the donkey ears with my eyes. The city laughed. The city shook its shoulders. A pigeon dropped from the roof and strutted, idiot proud, of the few crumbs he had found. Beyond the wall the crowd screamed and then settled, the sound rolling over us like surf. Felix spat three times, just in case. The smell of lion hit us, rank and sharp, and I imagined the beast’s breath, hot as a forge. The sun slid, inch by inch, down the wall. The olive sliver warmed in my pocket like a live thing. Somewhere in an upper room a man with a ring on every finger made a mark on a wax tablet that would mean a tunic or a tomb for someone like me. Somewhere a boy practiced the phrase Ave, Caesar, as if the words themselves had flavor and a person could live off them. I watched the light and the dust in the light and the flies make their hieroglyphs in the air. I sat very still and felt my sinews sing with tiredness and a small, complicated hope. The dog came and laid its head on my foot. I bent and scratched the thick fur behind its ears. It sighed and settled, and for a moment the city quieted, as if it had inhaled and held its breath. Then the cheer rose again, high and thin, the sound of people trying to forget their taxes and their hunger and the news that tomorrow would taste too much like today. I rested my hand on the dog’s head and thought of the field, the first footfall on sand, the first breath of a crowd, the first time I’d understood that a man’s body could be both his cage and his escape. I thought of the olive wood under my fingers, the dry rasp of it against my skin, and I breathed in the smells of Rome—wine and smoke and blood and piss and bread and metal and olives—and waited for the sun to finish falling.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This historical fiction piece offers a richly detailed glimpse into the life of a Roman gladiator, successfully adhering to the prompt's requirements. The author has created an immersive first-person narrative that captures the sensory experience of ancient Rome with remarkable precision and authenticity. The piece excels in its sensory descriptions, bringing to life the sights, sounds, and smells of the gladiatorial ludus and the surrounding city. From the "kennel smell of men" to the "metallic taste of the bucket mingling with the cold sweetness" of water, the author creates a vivid sensory landscape. The descriptions of Rome itself—"a colossus squatting over itself, marble plastered over brick and brick over whatever bones had come before"—demonstrate sophisticated imagery that enhances the historical setting. The protagonist is well-developed, with personal rituals, memories, and reflections that reveal his inner life. The olive wood sliver serves as both a tangible connection to his past and a symbolic representation of his identity. His observations about Rome's social hierarchy and his place within it demonstrate the political awareness requested in the prompt. The prose is elegant and often lyrical without becoming overwrought. Sentences like "Rome eats and Rome sings and Rome weeps" employ effective repetition, and metaphors such as "we are a small thing in a huge mouth, and the teeth grind down" are powerful without being excessive. The author skillfully balances poetic language with more straightforward narration. The piece effectively incorporates the larger political and social context of imperial Rome. References to Germanicus, Tiberius, taxes, and the relationship between spectacle and power create a sense of the protagonist existing within a complex political reality. The gladiator's awareness of his position—"Rome wants what Rome wants and the rest of us rearrange ourselves to accommodate"—shows how personal experience intersects with broader social structures. The narrative maintains a consistent voice and tone throughout, with the protagonist's resigned yet observant perspective guiding the reader through his day. The flow between external observations and internal reflections feels natural and unforced. While there are no significant weaknesses, the piece occasionally risks becoming slightly meandering in its observations. However, this meandering quality actually serves the "slice of life" approach requested in the prompt, mimicking the way a person's thoughts might wander through their day. The ending effectively brings the narrative full circle, returning to the olive wood sliver and the sensory experience of Rome, creating a sense of completion while still feeling like part of a larger story. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Epistolary: The Lighthouse Keeper — Score: 84.8
Prompt:
The Lighthouse Keeper Epistolary Narrative: Write a story told entirely through a series of brief correspondences: telegrams or letters or emails between two characters. The correspondence should span several months or years, and reveal a gradually unfolding plot. Use distinct voices for each character, and include details that provide insight into their personalities and motivations. The story should build to an emotional climax, and the final letter should provide a satisfying resolution. The setting is a lighthouse keeper writing to his mother. He is working class and Scottish. He is struggling with the isolation of his posting. Write naturally and without cliches. 1000 words.
Model Output:
Telegram from: Alistair MacRae, Wick station To: Mrs. Isla MacRae, 4 Burnside, Port Mhairi Dated: 14 March 1957 ARRIVED WICK STOP REPORT TO BOARD OFFICE STOP SCHEDULED FOR SKERRAN LIGHT KEEPING THREE MONTHS STARTING 18TH STOP WILL WRITE PROPER WHEN STEADIED STOP LOVE A Letter from: Alistair, c/o Northern Lighthouse Board, Wick To: Ma Dated: 16 March 1957 Ma, They put me in a room above the harbor, you’d laugh. The bed is short and the window leans, and the gulls boil outside like some old woman’s wash. Skerran is a wick of rock three miles out. Boat goes out Sunday if the swell behaves. I did what you said and kept my mouth shut in front of the Board men. They looked like undertakers, all solemn. One asked if I took whisky; I told him no, and for once I wasn’t lying. There’s no point testing your foot on ice until you’re over it. I met the Principal Keeper, name of McKendrick. He’s got a moustache that could sweep a floor. Said he’s been on Skerran “since before your mother fancied your da”. I kept my face straight. He’ll be my superior out there. He has hands like rope and a way of speaking like he’s counting. He says the light is a Chance Brothers, four panels, needs tending every four hours. The paraffin for the lamp is stored below. He warned me about condensation — “the glass sweats all the time, you’ll see” — and the iron stairs freezing in a haar. Made me think of your washing turned into boards on the line in winter. I have not told him I cannot swim. No need to write back and scold. I won’t be daft. If you see Callum, tell him I’ll keep his knife safe. I’m taking it for luck. I can hear you now: “Luck won’t get a lens polished.” Aye, so I’ve packed rags, too. I’ll write when we’re out. Don’t worry yourself to death. Keep the fire. A. Letter from: Alistair, Skerran Lighthouse To: Ma Dated: 23 March 1957 Ma, The stairs will do for me yet. I can feel them in my bones when I lie down — iron, round and round. McKendrick calls them “the rib,” and that’s right. This place is a gut we slide up and down all day. We arrived two days ago. The sea is a wall on all sides. There’s a slab of rock like an altar where the boat lays off and we run a line, and then we haul the stores in a basket like fish. I thought of mass in Port Mhairi, the incense, the swish of the priest’s robe — how far away it seems. There’s no wireless. The Board says it’s coming, but then, the Board says a lot. The lamp drinks paraffin like a man straight off the mines. We polish the lens until our faces show up in it, bent and green. The glass sweats just as McKendrick said. It drips on your head if you stand under it too long. He says the salt gets in everything — it’s true. Bread is salt. Blankets are salt. Even the pennies in my pocket taste of it. The light turns with a clockwork weight. Every four hours we wind it, and if you forget you hear the rotation slow and then you see the dark come back, which is a feeling I hope never to have again. There is a bull on the rock. Not a beast, an air horn — “the bull,” he calls it — that groans out into the weather so ships know we’re here even when the light cannot fight the fog. My first night, the fog came like wool. The bull went and went, and I felt the sound in my teeth. But no ship hit the rocks. So. You always said I was too daft to sit still. Here that’s all there is when the jobs are done: sit and listen to the wind. I know, Ma: it’s money. It’s honest. But the edges of yourself go to feather with the quiet. I talk aloud sometimes. Don’t tell the priest. I must go. The glass wants me. McKendrick has all the words in the world for oil and wicks, but little else. He sang a bar of “Loch Lomond” and stopped. I wanted to ask him to finish it. I don’t know why I didn’t. Maybe the emptiness eats up the tune. Tell me about your rhubarb. Tell me if Mrs. Gordon’s wee cat had her kittens. I crave the small. A. Postcard from: Ma, Port Mhairi To: Alistair, Skerran Lighthouse via Wick Alistair, The kittens were dead (do not be sorry it is the way). The rhubarb is up like soldiers. Your uncle said he saw you go out in the Board boat and you looked green as a pea. He is no judge. Mrs. MacLeod’s Jock fell off the pier drunk again and only the tide going out saved him as he lay in the wrack with his mouth open like a fish. Don’t you be like him. The priest says to keep you in my prayers so I do. Eat. Ma Letter from: Alistair, Skerran To: Ma Dated: 10 April 1957 Ma, Your letter made me laugh and then the laugh turned into something else for a second and then I went and wound the weight early. That’s the trick, I’m learning: find a job when your insides start to talk too loud. We had a nor’easter two nights ago. The tower moved. Not in your head — you can feel it. It’s meant to, McKendrick says, the way a tree bends. He has names for all the winds. He quotes them like neighbours: “That’s the one comes round with a sack over his shoulder,” and he makes a face, and you can see him as a boy on some different rock. That’s the moment I see him as a person and not just the moustache and the rules. We cleaned the cabbage last and it’s starting to stink sweet. Rats have not always found a way onto Skerran. That’s a sentence I never thought I’d write to you. I sleep with a bit of cold iron across my chest some nights — Callum’s knife — like I’m warding off fairies. You were right about the cat — doesn’t matter that it’s dead, you’ll still put a saucer out. I burned my thumb on the lamp and the skin went white and then pink. Nothing to write the Board about. I know what you’re thinking: he should have been a joiner under a roof. Well it’s this instead. Don’t start with me in a letter I can’t answer for a week. Tell me who danced the last reel at the hall. Even if it was you. Especially if it was you. A. Letter from: Ma, Port Mhairi To: Alistair, Skerran (Wick to forward) Dated: 18 April 1957 Alistair, It was me. Mrs. MacLeod said, Isla you cannot dance with those knees, and I told her they are my knees and I’ll do what I damn please. Father James frowned like a rain cloud and then smiled when he thought I was not looking. There is mackerel like silver at the quay and your cousin Effie says she will not gut the ones that look at her. I told her, they all look at you if you keep their heads on. We laughed till we needed chairs. I made the bannocks you like and ate one hot with jam and nearly called out to you, which is nonsense. So I put the rest in a tin and took them to Mrs. Gordon. Don’t be lonely like a fool. If the light wants polishing, polish it and think of my floor. The Board won’t come and tell me I did it wrong. Ma Letter from: Alistair, Skerran To: Ma Dated: 2 May 1957 Ma, McKendrick’s moustache froze yesterday. We had a haar that slid up from the water and into the stair and then right into our mouths if you opened them. He came up with a scarf over his face like a robber. He says you can tell the time by the fog. He means he can. He’s been head on Skerran twenty-six years. There’s a mark on the oak table from where a lightning strike danced out through the cutlery. He taps it sometimes when he speaks. I don’t think he knows he’s doing it. I thought of Da last night, which I don’t often do without swearing. The light circled me while I sat in the watch chair. The chair is old and hard and perfect for a person who wants to be told what to do by wood. Around and around the light went, and it felt like the room was ship, not shore, and everything was moving except me. Da would have said, “That’s enough of that,” and poured something over it. I’m not pouring. I dreamed I forgot to wind and the dark came. In the dream I could hear voices on the water. In the morning I wound it twice. McKendrick says there’s a relief boat next week, and he’s going to have me go ashore for two nights, “to remember what a bed feels like that doesn’t turn.” I was glad and then angry with myself for being glad. I wrote that and then decided to leave it. I’m not a boy. A. Telegram from: Northern Lighthouse Board, Wick To: Skerran Light RELIEF BOAT DELAYED STOP WEATHER UNSAFE STOP NEXT WINDOW 10 MAY STOP HOLD FAST Letter from: Alistair, Skerran To: Ma Dated: 11 May 1957 Ma, Ten May came and went with a wall of white water. It tilted up like a roof and slid down into itself. Even the bull sounded small. McKendrick and I ate the last of the potatoes without cutting the eyes out, which he says invites bad luck, but what does he call this? He went quiet and sat on his bunk an hour, then he scrubbed the sink like it had insulted him. See, people are the same as people anywhere. You were right to send me with the extra sack of oatmeal. I can hear your voice: “Always take more.” It’s a thing you say when you’ve never had enough. The wind stopped all at once last night and in the silence something crept in, and for a half-breath I expected you to call me for my tea. Then there was a cry out in the black. Not a bird. A human. We looked at each other once, like boys about to be told to fight, and then we were moving. McKendrick went down to the landing like a man and I to the watch with the lamp. I ran the shutter off the lantern and pointed it, but it’s a spread thing, not a finger. The cry came again, higher. We threw a line. It fell short. I could taste the iron — fear and blood. The cry came a third time and then nothing. The bull called and called. There were no voices on the water after that, dream or not. The sea keeps. I stood beside the lens until my legs shook and my hands had no work to do and I wanted to smash something. I did not. This morning there’s a plank on the outer slope with a bolt through it. We got it with the gaff. The Board will say to write it in the book and that will be the end of it. I know that’s the job. I’m writing it to you as well. I hear your breath, steady. I’m all right. We did what can be done. A. Letter from: Ma, Port Mhairi To: Alistair, Skerran Dated: 15 May 1957 Alistair, There is a wake in the next street for a man without a face. They found him by Okay’s Point, the little bit with the yellow sand. He had a wedding ring on and the rest the tide took. Mrs. Fraser washed his shirt and said it would not come clean and Mr. Fraser said, We will cover it then. The priest says to pray for all souls in peril on the sea. You did not put him there. You shone your light and you threw your rope. I will say this twice so you hear me. Your Uncle Iain says the Board should send you boys radios. He says he wrote to the paper. I told him not to put his name or they’d send him a job. Put the rope away proper so the other man is not tangled by it. And mind your thumb. Ma Letter from: Alistair, Skerran To: Ma Dated: 30 May 1957 Ma, They came at last, midweek. The boat sat like a doctor at the foot of the bed and would not come any closer than the outer ledge for fear of being smashed. We ran the basket and sent down our empty tins and the smell of us, then the casks up. McKendrick wouldn’t look at the Board man and I was glad of him for it. He asked for a wireless again. The Board man said, “Soon.” The word is a lie that doesn’t know it is a lie. I would prefer “No.” I did not go ashore. He did. He looked at me as he stepped into the basket — such a quick look, like a hand on your shoulder — and I felt a wave of relief so strong I was ashamed. I watched the boat go until the sea sat on it and there was just the bull and the sky again. That night I wound and wound, and I ate standing up, and I slept with my boots by my hands. The fog came in twice. I heard a ship’s engine far off. I thought of the man without a face. I thought I could smell the dye from his shirt. I took the lens cloth and worked, and when the light turned and made the room like daylight and then dark and then daylight again my head matched it. I wish I could say I am brave, but really it is this: there is no one else here to be the other thing. I read the almanac. I traced the map with my finger. Skerran is a dot so small you could lose it if you shook the page. I am not a dot, Ma. Don’t you make me one. A. Letter from: Ma, Port Mhairi To: Alistair, Skerran Dated: 6 June 1957 Alistair, You are a line that reaches from this house to that rock and back again, and you are not a dot. I went to the post and told Mairi to put that on a stamp and she told me stamps are the Queen only and I said, “I’ll draw a crown then.” She laughed and I felt ten years back in the legs. The ewes have started worrying at the fence like they know something I don’t. The children all ran to the quay when the trawler came in with the blue flags and Mrs. MacLeod’s Jock tried to sing but only the first line came. That’s how grief sits. You do the first bit and the other bits won’t come. There is a boy of twelve at the back house who wants to be you. I told him he could be a hundred things and he said, “If I’m one of them I want to be a light.” It went inside me something fierce. Don’t turn to stone there. If you feel like it, write me with the exacting of your day. How many steps. How long to wind. How many turns to a full weight. I like to know. Ma Letter from: Alistair, Skerran To: Ma Dated: 10 June 1957 Ma, 182 steps. Thirty-two to the first landing, then thirty, then twenty-eight, then twenty-six, then sixteen to the watchroom, then ten to the lantern. The weight drops in five hours if you don’t stop it, four if there’s a hard wind and the mechanism hums faster. I wind for twelve minutes to take it to the top. The handle is cold in the morning and warm by midnight. When you do it your heartrun finds the rhythm. If I close my eyes I could tell where the weight sits by where my breath is when it kicks. Does that make sense? There’s comfort in doing it right and knowing it. The wick needs trimming like a head needs a shave. If the char builds it smokes and leaves ghosts on the glass, and then the light isn’t light, it’s sepia and shame. The bull is hand-pumped. Think of that. All this and we still put our backs into it to make a noise, like we’re hauling an old engine up a hill. I pump, and the sound goes away from me and comes back and goes away, and I think of you sitting in the chair with your toes on the fender and the ticking of the clock, and how the sound goes away and comes back there, too. You asked me to tell you the exacting. I’ve kept the book like a lover. The truth is the exacting keeps me from feeling like I’m spread too thin over the water. It’s a way of living inside an edge. I found a gull with the wing broke on the lower step and I wrung its neck. I did it clean. I learned something from Da we can keep. I put it out myself. After, I boiled the kettle and couldn’t drink the tea. A. Letter from: Ma, Port Mhairi To: Alistair, Skerran Dated: 20 June 1957 Alistair, That made me put the kettle down too for a moment. I am sorry for the gull and glad for you. Do not make a habit of that tea. Your Auntie Màiri sent a loaf and forgot the salt. It tasted like the floor of the church and made your Uncle swear in Gaelic so the priest would not know the words. The priest knows all the words. He knows the ones we don’t. The Board posted for two new lads for the lights and there is talk in the shop that it means more retirements. Your Principal will go sometime, I suppose. What will he be if he is not what he is? I suppose that is everyone’s question when you scrape under the skin. Everyone says thank you to you when they don’t even know.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This epistolary narrative effectively captures the isolation and psychological challenges of a lighthouse keeper through a series of letters between Alistair and his mother. The piece successfully establishes distinct voices for both characters - Alistair's increasingly introspective and detailed accounts contrast with his mother's practical, terse responses that still convey deep care. The Scottish working-class background is convincingly portrayed through dialect choices, references to local customs, and the practical concerns that dominate their correspondence. The author skillfully develops Alistair's character through his observations about the lighthouse, his relationship with McKendrick, and his psychological responses to isolation. His mother's character emerges through her practical advice, community updates, and understated emotional support. The narrative builds tension effectively through the incident with the drowning man, which serves as an emotional climax that tests Alistair's resolve. The correspondence reveals his growth from initial uncertainty to a kind of stoic acceptance of his responsibilities. The prose is particularly strong in sensory details that bring the lighthouse environment to life - the salt that permeates everything, the mechanical rhythms of maintaining the light, the sounds of the "bull" horn in the fog. However, the piece feels incomplete. The narrative builds effectively but lacks a satisfying resolution as requested in the prompt. The final letters don't provide closure to Alistair's emotional journey or the relationship with McKendrick. The story simply trails off rather than concluding. Additionally, while the voices are distinct, the mother's letters sometimes feel slightly inconsistent in their level of eloquence versus practicality. The writing avoids clichés admirably and creates authentic characters whose relationship feels genuine. The details about lighthouse keeping appear well-researched and contribute to the story's authenticity. The emotional undercurrents - particularly Alistair's complex feelings about his absent father and his growing sense of purpose - are handled with subtlety. Overall, this is a strong piece that effectively uses the epistolary format to reveal character and build a narrative, though it falls short of providing the satisfying resolution requested in the prompt. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 16 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 16 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 17 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 3 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 5 Unearned Transformations: 3 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 17 Overall Impression: 17
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 16.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 16.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 17.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 3.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 5.0, Unearned Transformations: 3.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 17.0, Overall Impression: 17.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Hacker Mindset — Score: 90.5
Prompt:
Hacker Mindset Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a reformed (now) white hat hacker who cannot help but notice exploitable weaknesses in both systems and people they encounter. They habitually look for vulnerabilities and exploit vectors. The narrative takes place during a first date at a restaurant, where they're trying to focus on human connection. It's going surprisingly well due to a discovered shared nerd-fandom (magic the gathering). Things go a little sideways when the date reveals a noticeably insecure phone unlock pattern, which protagonist can't help but comment on. They are then left to negotiate the fallout of this faux pas and attempt to salvage (or perhaps sabotage) the remainder of the date. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
I pick the corner booth because it gives me sightlines: the hostess stand, the bar, the two exits, the restroom corridor like a buffer overflow waiting to be triggered. The overhead Wi-Fi SSID blinks in my periphery—Restaurant-Guest, open network, no captive portal—and I press my hands flat to the table like I’m holding them down. Breathe. Human connection. Focus on the person about to walk in, not the misconfigured Sonos speaker that’s broadcasting its default hostname or the POS terminal that still runs a Windows theme so old I can hear the security advisories groaning from it. She texts that she’s parking. The bubble pops up blue on my lock screen—iMessage, okay, E2E—and for a second I wonder if her device broadcasts random MAC addresses or if I’ll see a stable one join the network and match the time she walks through the door. I lock my phone and turn it face down like a man trying to choose a better life. When she steps inside, it’s like opening a hand you didn’t realize was clenched. Denim jacket, hair in a half-bun that says she knows what it’s like to fix things without making a big deal about it. She catches my eye and smiles, and I don’t even audit the gesture for authenticity because it feels like sunlight after a patch Tuesday. She slides into the booth opposite me and keeps kinetic energy in her hands—tapping the edge of the menu, then smoothing the paper like it’s a bed someone else slept in. “I’m Nia,” she says, even though we both know. Saying it out loud is handshake protocol. I like that. We ping. We establish latency. We both comment on the tasteful ambient noise. She doesn’t comment on the Wi-Fi. It’s fine. Not everyone walks into a place and sees traffic sniffing in their head. “How’s your day?” she asks. I open my mouth to say good and actually mean it. By the time the waiter appears, we’ve agreed bread is just denial dressed in crust. It arrives anyway, olive oil shimmering like a lure. I choose salad and something with a sauce that likes white shirts, then realize my shirt is black because some part of me still prefers armor. She orders pasta and laughs when the waiter warns her about garlic. Her laugh is not a replay. It’s not something I’ve heard a hundred times on loop. It’s a live stream. The conversation finds the middle lane, easy enough. Work, the sanitized version. I say I do security consulting, which is like saying an ex-smoker chews gum. She does data science for a nonprofit, which means she probably knows how to clean things that are fundamentally dirty. We hit podcast overlap. Then we slide sideways into it. Magic comes out of my mouth like a testing payload I didn’t intend to send. “Did you ever play Magic?” I ask, consequence analysis returning a healthy potential for both connection and cringe. Her eyes light up. It’s not sunlight, it’s LED string lights at a Friday Night Magic table. “Oh god, yes. Still do. My friends and I draft weird sets and pretend we know how to evaluate signals.” It’s startling, the reflex, how fast my brain throws a port open and accepts the connection. Shared fandom is a patch I didn’t know I needed. I feel my posture shift into comfortable. We start naming cards like passwords. She tells me her first deck was a janky mono-Red burn pile. “Goblin Guide,” she says, and I mentally file: Aggro instincts, willingness to reveal information to go faster. “Lightning Bolt,” obviously. “Price of Progress,” she adds, and that tells me she likes to punish greed. She’s not above watching others choke on their multi-colored ambitions. She switches to talking about the time she went through a phase where she thought she was a control player but was lying to herself. “I tried Esper Control,” she says. In my head I slot in “Cryptic Command,” “Supreme Verdict,” and the personality trait of wanting to reset everything when it gets messy. “Sphinx’s Revelation,” she admits, and I hear restlessness under the card draw. Recharge as remedy. We test each other. “I had a thing for Birthing Pod,” I say, and watch her face as she calibrates. Does she think I like decision trees? Tournament seeds? “That checks out,” she says, and I feel seen by a green artifact. We smuggle in a little personal with each mention. She name-drops “Thoughtseize” like a confession. Willing to trade a little life for knowledge. Willing to pierce the veil. I throw back “Tarmogoyf” in a self-deprecating way, like I think I’m bigger than I am because the graveyard’s already full. She laughs. Connection gets a deeper root. Every card is a fingerprint. She had a “Splinter Twin” phase, which means she likes inevitability as much as trickery. She moved away from it when it got stale, aka when winning felt too deterministic. “I like the puzzle,” she says. “I don’t like the answer key.” I file that under: Build your own locks, then pick them. She mentions “Aether Vial” with reverence and my brain goes file system: low-curve creatures, flash in value, cheat on timing. “Snapcaster Mage,” she says casually, and I think resource recursion and a refusal to let mistakes be permanent. The cards she doesn’t name are telling too; no “Emrakul,” no big stompy timmy. She likes tempo, not bludgeons. Our drinks arrive and the waiter asks if we want apps. I want to ask if he knows his POS is calling out to a known malware domain. I order bruschetta like a normal person. I am calculating probabilities when she slips her phone from her jacket pocket to check a message. It’s nothing: a lock screen glow, a mild frown at a notification from a group chat with a dumb name. She pretends she’s not reading it and then decides to just read it. The phone is in her hand like a deck you truly know. It’s rotation tested. And then she unlocks it. It’s an Android, Pixel maybe two generations old, with a tempered glass screen that is pristine except for the micro-sheen of finger oils. She swipes up and her finger traces a pattern on the nine-dot grid like water finding the same channel it always has. Even before she completes it I can reconstruct it from the vector of her wrist and the micro-hesitations at corners: top-left to top-middle to top-right, down to middle-right, to bottom-right then across to bottom-left; a lazy “U” with an unnecessary flourish back to middle-left. It’s common. It’s k-means cluster number three in the research I wish I’d never read. It’s in the top 5% of guessable patterns. The overlay of her movements and the faint smudge path is a neon sign for any bus stop thief with a little patience. I also notice she didn’t lift her finger between nodes—a continuous trace, timeline reconstructable. Heat-map hazard. I realize I’ve leaned forward like a dog hearing a high frequency. I make the sound a throat makes when it’s trying not to bark. She looks up, sees my face, and something in her posture shifts a half-inch toward caution. “What?” she asks, and I’ve been here before. Tiny bridges with big holes under them. There’s an off-ramp. I can say nothing. I can drink water. I can smile and ask about her siblings. Human connection, not root access. “The, uh,” I say, and there it is—the payload leaves my mouth. “Your unlock pattern is super… common.” Silence is an airless chamber. Her eyes flash from curious to guarded like a port switching states. “Excuse me?” The syllables are unsmiling. I rush into the buffer. “I’m sorry, I—bad habit. I noticed it. It’s, like, there are studies on how often people choose patterns that start in the top left—like reading—and do a C-shape, and with the finger oils, it’s just—” “Are you trying to tell me my phone is insecure?” Her laugh has a serrated edge now. “No,” I say, and yes. “I’m… sorry. I do security. I can’t—it’s like muscle memory. I don’t mean to audit people.” Her jaw unclenches a millimeter. The truth is a patch sometimes. “Okay,” she says, a word that allows nothing, or everything. “So what’s the super secure pattern then, Mr. Security?” I smile, but not at her. At how predictable I am to myself. “Alphanumerics are better,” I say. “Patterns are basically four-digit pins with extra UX. But even a longer pattern that doubles back, doesn’t hit corners, changes direction unexpectedly…” I’m drawing with my finger on the table, realizing the shape is just my old life as a diagram. She watches. I pivot hard. “And you didn’t ask for that. I’m sorry.” She takes a beat. “I didn’t,” she says, but softer. “But… you know things. I get that impulse. I do it with people’s resumes.” We laugh a little, both guilty, both annotated. The bruschetta arrives like a timeout. We both reach for a piece and our fingers brush and it’s the sort of moment where, in a different story, the physical closeness closes an open thread. Here, the thread is an old Ethernet cable between two machines with a missing handshake. We try to resync. She asks me what made me get into security, and I decide not to rehearse the script about puzzles and saving people from themselves. I say, “I used to break things for a living. Now I try to make sure other people can’t.” She says, “Red team to blue team,” and her eyebrows go up like an impressed spectator at a kitchen trick. “Do you miss the adrenaline?” “Yes,” I say, because lying now would be like installing a backdoor in your own house. “But I like sleeping.” She tells me about a deck she loved that never won. “Delver of Secrets,” she says, and I feel the sting of coin-flip draws and the pleasure of flipping it on turn two. She talk about “Ponder,” “Preordain,” and the joy of sculpting possibilities. Data scientist, of course she does. “Spell Pierce” gets a mention—early protection, cheap denial. She hates getting blown out by “Cavern of Souls.” She makes a face. I file: Control of variables matters to her. She’ll tolerate variance but not being locked out of interacting. I realize I’ve been mentally cataloging every card, not as a creepy archivist but as if I’m building a model that approximates who she is. It’s what I do with systems: enumerate, map, test. With people, it’s ruder. She’s looking at her phone now with a new awareness, thumb hovering over the screen like a sentinel. She meets my eyes and holds them. “So,” she says. “Teach me a better lock.” It’s a trap and an opportunity. If I lecture, I’m the worst date she’ll tell her friends about in a group chat called ‘birds of prey.’ If I demur, I’m withholding. People’s security should be their idea. “I’ll tell you the one rule,” I say. “Don’t pick the first thing that feels easy. Make it yours. Make it something you can remember under stress, not something your hand draws when you’re thinking about other stuff. And if someone like me can guess it, you can make a new one.” She considers this. “I like that,” she says. “Under stress.” She makes a pattern in the air with her finger, nothing I can trace. “Okay,” she adds. “I changed it.” This is almost certainly a lie and also a test. I nod. “I won’t try to guess.” “That would be creepy,” she says, but she’s smiling again and the serration is gone. Negotiated truce. We return to cardboard. She admits a love for “Collective Brutality” because modes are delicious. I admit I can’t quit “Liliana of the Veil,” and she grins and says, “Ah, you like symmetrical sacrifice.” She calls me out gently for wanting control under the guise of fairness, and I bite into a tomato that explodes like a confession. We talk about Commander politics and she mentions “Propaganda,” “Smothering Tithe,” and I add “Rhystic Study” with a groan. She hates when people say “Did you pay the one?” with that tone. She likes “Temple Bell” because she’s a secret group hugger. She snorts when I say “Cyclonic Rift,” and says it’s a necessary evil for cowards. I tuck away: She prefers negotiated board states to unilateral resets. She’s not Sarah, and she’s not any of the others whose names are error messages in my log files. She’s Nia, who changed her lock in the middle of dinner because someone showed her the seam. We split dessert and the waiter sets down a little cube of something chocolate like a finite state machine. I notice the POS again, a flicker, a process running. I can stop myself from nudging the manager on the way out and telling him his firmware is screaming from the roof. I can decide not to patch a world that didn’t ask. Maybe. She’s tapping the rim of her water glass and making a face. “Okay,” she says. “I have to ask. Did you see my credit card number when I paid for my parking?” “No,” I say. “I didn’t look.” “You looked at my phone, though.” “I looked at your pattern,” I say. “Which is different. I’m a jerk in a very specific way.” She considers this. “You could just say you’re someone who notices.” “I notice,” I repeat. “It’s not always an act of violence.” She nods. “That’s… actually comforting?” I let it in. “I am trying to make it less violent.” When the check comes I don’t do the dance where I insist and she resists. We split it because fairness, and because we both know what the tip should be without a spreadsheet. As I sign, I think about the waiter’s compromised POS again and decide the most generous thing I can do is leave a good tip and an email address, not a lecture. I write thank you and a little smile face and it feels like the opposite of exfiltration. Outside, the night smells like yeast and ice. She hugs me because we’ve debugged something between us and found a workable version. As she steps back she smirks. “Don’t hack me.” “Don’t Splinter Twin me,” I shoot back. “At least wait until game two.” “Deal.” We stand there like teenagers pretending neither of us is old enough to know better. I ask if she wants to draft sometime. She says yes, that her friends think they’re good and need to be destroyed. I watch her walk toward her car and notice how often she looks over her shoulder—not because she’s scared but because she’s teachable. It occurs to me that I’d like to be someone she doesn’t have to look back for, and that my statutes of limitation with myself are not yet up but maybe I can file for an extension. Her brake lights flash. I realize I could maintain this connection without enumerating every last vulnerability, that I can pick my targets. The habit doesn’t go away; it never does. But tonight I leveraged it for a shocking thing: not advantage, not control, but a conversation where both of us ended with more than we started. On the way home, my phone vibrates. A message. New pattern is “under stress.” Also, do you own a Liliana alter or are you normal. I grin. I type back, very carefully. Normal is a low-entropy setting. And I never start with top-left anymore.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures the perspective of a reformed white hat hacker navigating a first date. The protagonist's internal monologue is rich with technical jargon and security metaphors that effectively convey their habitual vulnerability-seeking mindset while attempting to focus on human connection. The writing excels at creating a distinctive voice. The narrator's security-oriented perspective colors everything they observe, from the restaurant's Wi-Fi to their date's phone unlock pattern. This consistent lens creates an authentic character whose professional background has fundamentally shaped how they perceive the world. The shared interest in Magic: The Gathering serves as an excellent vehicle for character development. The author cleverly uses card preferences as personality indicators, allowing readers to understand both characters through their gaming choices. This shared "nerd-fandom" creates genuine connection while revealing character traits organically. The narrative handles the central conflict—the protagonist noticing and commenting on their date's insecure phone pattern—with nuance. The awkwardness feels authentic, as does the negotiation that follows. The protagonist's self-awareness about their inappropriate behavior adds depth to the character. The prose is technically strong, with effective use of technical terminology that never feels forced. Metaphors comparing human interactions to security concepts ("Silence is an airless chamber. Her eyes flash from curious to guarded like a port switching states") are particularly effective. The writing maintains a consistent rhythm with varied sentence structures that keep the narrative flowing. Where the piece could improve is in its occasional tendency toward overexplanation. Some of the internal monologue spells out connections too explicitly rather than trusting the reader to make them. Additionally, while the ending achieves a satisfying resolution, it verges slightly on being too neat given the social awkwardness established earlier. The narrative successfully balances technical content with emotional development. The protagonist's struggle between their security-oriented mindset and desire for human connection creates genuine tension. Their recognition that they can "leverage" their habit "not for advantage, not for control, but a conversation where both of us ended with more than we started" represents meaningful character growth. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that fulfills the prompt requirements while creating a distinctive voice, believable characters, and an engaging narrative arc. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 4 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 3 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 4.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 3.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Overthinking It — Score: 90.9
Prompt:
Overthinking It Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of an intelligent 8th-grade girl with social anxiety who has developed a crush on a classmate. The narrative takes place during a group science project where they're paired together, as she cycles through rehearsed conversations while second-guessing each potential approach. Her inner thoughts should reveal the gap between her articulate internal voice and her difficulty expressing herself aloud, her fears of coming across as desperate or weird, and the exhausting process of monitoring her every word, expression, and movement for potential embarrassment. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
It’s fine. It’s fine. A group project is just a project with multiple people who breathe too loudly. I can handle that. It’s not a performance, it’s not a trap, it’s not a social Rubik’s cube I will twist until the colors bleed. Sit. Unzip pencil case. Don’t dump it. Slide it open like you’re capable of casualness. The desks clatter into arrangements there’s no word for besides awkward. Mrs. Han writes “Capillary Action – Design Your Own Investigation” in purple marker and underlines it with a flourish. She pairs us, trios us, quads us. Our names stick to each other like static. “You four,” she says, and tilts her marker at our table. Me, Maya (high ponytail, perfect penmanship), Kevin (who can turn any moment into a joke no one asked for), and him. Alex. Alex who sits two rows over and never sweats under pressure, who says “I think we should test variables” like it’s a thought he woke up with, already formed, no awkward preamble. There. Don’t look at him yet. Look at the worksheet. Focus. Capillary action. Plants. Stems in dyed water. Paper towels creeping up a glass. It’s not complicated. I can make this so complicated I need a flowchart, but I shouldn’t. The pen feels heavy. Don’t drop it. Don’t twirl it. Twirling is a tell. I press the tip to the top margin and a tiny face appears before I even intend it—two curved lines and dots like a secret. I give it hair with short careful strokes. Maya. Her hair has that swoop that it actually does. Is that creepy? No one will notice. It’s small. It’s always small. “We could use celery,” Maya says, and she already has a graph drawn with spaces for data. Of course she does. “And maybe paper towels,” she adds, giving Kevin a look that means, please don’t suggest Kool-Aid. “Gatorade?” Kevin says, like an atom cannot be prevented from being itself. I think, we can test ionic solutions versus water, it would demonstrate the effect of dissolved solutes on capillary action due to altered surface tension, I read something about it and if I say it right I could sound like someone you want on your team. My tongue feels like it’s made of felt. If I talk too soon it’s weird, if I talk too late it’s weirder. Alex opens his mouth, and the sound of my own heartbeat is a basketball in the gym rafters. “Food coloring is fine,” he says. “We can do different concentrations and see if it changes how fast it moves. Like, set up three paper towel bridges between cups.” He looks at me then, not skimming across, but actually landing. “What do you think?” Oh. My cheeks do that thing. Heat flips on like a space heater. I could say, that’s a good control, we can draw a baseline with plain water and adjust one variable while keeping others constant. Say it. Say the thing. The thought is clean in my head, crisp as the graph paper in Maya’s binder. Out loud, it will collapse. Collapse-proofing it requires rehearsal. Option A: Nodding, quiet, unhelpful. He will think I have no thoughts beyond nod. Option B: Too much talking, word salad spread on the desk like spilled glitter. Option C: Exactly the right amount of smart, which is also too much if you’re a girl, which is unfair to say, but the rulebook in my brain bristles with unfair rules. I can hold two truths and flinch at both. “Yeah,” I say. It comes out breathy. Too soft. There’s a second before I add, “We could, um, keep the length of the paper towels the same, and, uh, do like five drops of food coloring vs. ten vs. fifteen—” My voice trips on fifteen like there’s a speed bump. “—and time how long it takes to reach the other cup.” That wasn’t disastrous. Not good, not a meltdown. Like spilling two grains of salt when you were trying for one. Alex nods. “Sound good,” he says. He looks at Maya. “Maya?” “Love it,” she says. She writes “length constant” on the paper and underlines it twice. I draw a small rectangle in the corner of my notes. It becomes Kevin’s blocky haircut, a rectangle with enthusiasm. A dot for his nose. Does anyone see me doing this? I angle the page away. My heart does a gentle tambourine roll. It counts out the seconds like it wants to be helpful. “Okay,” Mrs. Han says, moving around the room like some kind of benevolent shark. “You’ll write a hypothesis and list your variables. Equipment is on the back counter. Be careful with the glass.” I sketch an even tinier face beside the word hypothesis. Alex’s hair is impossible. It’s messy in a precise way. I give him a cartoon wave. That’s creepy. Is that creepy? I slant the paper so the wave is hidden under my hand. “Who wants to go get stuff?” Kevin asks. He looks hopeful, because going to the back counter is a chance to detour past the class clown’s audience and perform his impression of Mr. Sato, which is only funny if you’re not Mr. Sato. “I can,” Alex says, and stands up. The movement is clean, so normal my bones ache with wanting to be that normal. “I’ll go,” I say, at the exact same time. It’s a collision. The word leaps out of me without checking with Security, and then we are both looking at each other like we’ve said something intimate when all we said was an errand. He smiles, a quick left-hand curve of mouth, a comma. “We can both,” he says. He says “both” with a softness that doesn’t feel like pity. Option D: Walk together without tripping over my shoelaces and the conversation. Option D should include one remark about capillary action and not a single word about favorite bands I pretend to like. I stand up. My chair leg screeches on the linoleum and the scraping sound is a scream in a language adults can’t hear. Don’t make eye contact with the entire room. Make it with the floor. The floor is safe. There’s a unibrow of gray scuff marks near the sink. I catalog them like constellations. We move side by side. He smells like laundry detergent and pencil shavings, which is better than Gatorade, which is what Kevin actually smells like, probably because he drinks it like it’s holy water. Do we say something? If we say nothing, it’s the vacuum of space. If I say something and it’s wrong, it’s vacuum plus meteor shower. “Have you done this before?” he asks. Yes. In fourth grade we dyed carnations blue and I was the one who left mine on the windowsill for three weeks to see what happened and it turned brittle and papery and it made a noise like old leaves when I snapped it, and I liked that better than the blue. “Yeah,” I say. I almost say which grade. Not necessary. Extra sentence tax. He picks up a stack of paper towels, I grab the food coloring, because they are light and unbreakable. The droppers sit in a neat line like soldiers. My hand hovers over red, blue, green, the obvious primaries that do what they’re told. “Red and blue?” he asks, reading my hover. “Red,” I say. “Blue.” There’s a version of me that makes a joke about purple being the inevitable consequence of an ill-fated alliance, and that version is fun at parties you don’t have to go to. I am not that version, not today, not with the heat at my collarbones telling tales. We carry things back like we are in a procession for a god of small experiments. Kevin makes the sound of trumpets. He can’t help it. Maya ignores him. She’s numbered the beakers and drawn the most beautiful table. She’s the person you want when you’re lost and need someone to tell you which way is east. Back at the table I measure water into cups, my hands steady because beakers are honest and numbers are a language I can speak without blushing. “So,” Alex says, “we can cut the paper towels into equal strips. Twelve inches?” “Twelve,” I say. “Consistent.” I almost add “standardization reduces error,” but that sits on my tongue like something that will be mispronounced. I cut; the scissors snip with authority. I make the strips the same width as well, because I don’t want some tiny asymmetry to cost us a neat trend line. I draw a dot beside each of our names on my page, each dot is a head and then a tiny accessory. Maya’s ponytail loop; Kevin’s rectangle hair; Alex’s comma smile; me as a circle with a lightning bolt for a heartbeat. I think about adding another mark but that would be too much. It already is too much. We set two cups side by side and make a paper towel bridge. The towel sags, dips its toe into both waters like it wants to dance. The red seeps up and into white, making a new shade the way embarrassment rises into my face. We start the timer. “We need a hypothesis,” Maya says gently, the way she might remind someone to breathe. “We hypothesize that increased dye concentration will increase rate of capillary action,” I say in my head. Out loud, I say, “More drops, faster.” It’s a baby version of my thought. My shoulders inch toward my ears like they want to hide in my hair. “That makes sense,” Alex says. He writes it down, the baby version, and I hate and love that acceptance at the same time. Does my voice sound smaller than I feel? Is he adjusting for that? He doesn’t know there’s a thesis trapped behind my teeth. He’s not responsible for my teeth. We watch the color creep. Kevin times on his phone, pressing start with exaggerated ceremony. “Go,” he says. He could be speaking to the red, to the paper towel, to me. My eyes go from the water line to the movement to my own fingers. I move them like I’m someone who has always had fingers. Not too fidgety. Not too still. If you don’t move at all you look like a mannequin, which is creepier than doodling and I have data to back it up. I flex my thumb once. I press my nails into my palm, half moons, a geometry of self-control. “How do you draw the graphs?” Alex asks. “Like, what style? I always end up making mine crooked.” He’s talking to me. Option E: Share one skill, but not with the weird fervor of the graph evangelist. I say, “Start the axes with a ruler. Label units. Leave space for mistakes.” That last part comes out heavier than I meant. He smiles with his whole face. The comma goes longer. “Space for mistakes,” he repeats. He says it like a useful concept, not a confession. “Forty-five seconds,” Kevin announces. “Red is winning.” He says winning like it’s a race we can cheer for. I feel like I’m in a race where the prize is getting to stay in the room. “Science isn’t a competition,” Maya says lightly, and then we all cheer when the blue catches up because we can’t help ourselves. I write 1:12 next to red. The numbers are neat. They always are. I make a tiny trophy beside 1:12 because I despise and adore myself in equal measure. If anyone notices, they don’t comment. Maybe we all have secret systems. “Do you think we should switch the positions to see if that matters?” Alex asks me. He asks me. He could have asked Maya. He could have asked the air. “Like, swap left and right in case air flow or something.” “Yeah,” I say. “Good control.” The words are thin, but they fit. They are the exact outline of the shape I can handle. When he moves the cups, our hands bump. It’s a soft bump, skin skimming skin, static ping. My brain lights up like a switchboard. A thousand operators plug lines into a thousand sockets: Was that deliberate? Was it nothing? Does he notice the static? My face imposes normal. Neutral expression, small smile. Don’t show your teeth unless you have a reason. Teeth are aggressive. I breathe through my nose. Calm. Not a baby rabbit in a trap. Just a person doing a lab. We set up the second trial. The blue seems to learn from the red, finds its path faster. Or that’s what feelings do to data. My doodles multiply because my pen needs somewhere to be that isn’t between my teeth. Alex’s tiny face now has two commas. That’s too many. I cover it with my thumb. I draw a tiny beaker with a happy face. Neutral. Not creepy. “So,” Kevin says, “what are we calling this. The Great Capillary Race?” “We’ll call it that in our notes,” Maya says, deadpan, and writes it in her tidy letters like it’s a real title. I like her so much for doing that I want to buy her a cupcake. I look at the worksheet where “Conclusion” looms like the last boss in a video game. I can see what to write. I always can. Something about adhesion and cohesion and surface tension, about the interplay of molecules and the way a meniscus curves inward like a bowed head. In my head I write it and it is beautiful—okay not beautiful, but clean, quiet. Out loud, if I volunteer to read it, I will trip on “adhesion” or “interplay” and my tongue will tangle itself in the cords of my vocal cords and I will become the kind of story people tell in the hallway. That’s not rational. I can list everything that can go wrong faster than I can list the names of my family members. “Do you want to write the conclusion?” Alex asks. He asks soft, like he doesn’t want to scare the animal at the edge of the clearing. He hands me the pen. His nail is bitten down a little. Imperfect. My breath gets less insisted. I take it. The pen fits my hand like it knew it would come here. I write. The letters are small but legible. They sit in lines like they’ve practiced. I include the words I wanted. I write “adhesion and cohesion” and the world does not collapse. My inner monologue applauds and then immediately tells me to stop applauding; it’s tacky. I hand the paper back before I can do something weird like sign it. “That’s good,” Alex says, and I point at Maya so the praise gets distributed correctly even though he’s looking at me. The bell rings with a sigh. Everyone leaps up because the next class always feels like a life raft. We’re halfway through. We’ll reconvene tomorrow. “Nice work,” Maya says to all of us, and taps the table once like she’s blessing it. Kevin tucks a paper towel into his pocket for reasons unknown to humanity. Alex looks at me. “See you tomorrow?” he says, an invitation freighted with zero extra anything. “Yes,” I say. One syllable, a bridge between two cups. He steps away, and I look at my page. There we are, four tiny faces. I draw a little line connecting my circle with the comma. It is a ridiculous thing to do. It is safe on paper. I shade it in lightly until the line almost disappears. It’s fine. It’s fine. I survived every second I thought I couldn’t. Tomorrow I will do it again. I will make space for mistakes and fill some of it with color. I will remember to breathe. I will pretend to be normal until the pretending feels like a kind of truth. And if my hands shake when I cut the paper towels, that’s just capillary action reaching across empty space, the way water climbs where it doesn’t belong, the way things move even when no one is pushing them.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures the internal monologue of an intelligent 8th-grade girl with social anxiety who has developed a crush on her classmate Alex during a science project. The piece excels at portraying the protagonist's overthinking nature, showing the stark contrast between her articulate internal thoughts and her stilted external communication. The character's voice is remarkably consistent throughout, maintaining the intelligent yet anxious perspective of a socially uncomfortable teen. The narrative effectively demonstrates how she rehearses conversations and second-guesses herself through "options" (A, B, C, D, E) that reveal her systematic approach to social interaction. This methodical thinking pattern feels authentic to a bright but anxious young person. The prose is elegant without being overly sophisticated for an 8th grader's perspective. Metaphors like "my brain lights up like a switchboard" and "a thousand operators plug lines into a thousand sockets" effectively convey her overthinking without becoming purple. The writing captures small, telling details that create vivid imagery: the protagonist's doodling habits, the way she notices Alex's "comma" smile, and her careful monitoring of her own body language. The narrative excels at showing rather than telling. Instead of stating "I have social anxiety," the text demonstrates it through the character's hyperawareness of her movements, her cataloging of potential social missteps, and her constant self-monitoring. The protagonist's emotional complexity is well-rendered through her contradictory feelings: "I hate and love that acceptance at the same time" and "I despise and adore myself in equal measure." The piece maintains excellent coherence, following the science experiment from beginning to end while weaving in the protagonist's crush and anxiety. The pacing is appropriate, neither rushing nor dragging. The ending strikes a realistic balance—not suggesting an unrealistic transformation but acknowledging small victories and ongoing challenges. A few minor weaknesses: occasionally the metaphors become slightly overwrought ("the vacuum of space. If I say something and it's wrong, it's vacuum plus meteor shower"). The protagonist's intelligence sometimes manifests in vocabulary that stretches credibility for an 8th grader, even a bright one ("the rulebook in my brain bristles with unfair rules. I can hold two truths and flinch at both"). However, these instances are rare and don't significantly detract from the overall quality. The narrative succeeds brilliantly at its core task: portraying the exhausting process of social anxiety, the gap between internal articulation and external expression, and the particular intensity of an adolescent crush. The reader gains deep insight into the protagonist's experience while maintaining empathy for her struggles. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Rehearsing Rejection — Score: 95.2
Prompt:
Rehearsing Rejection Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of someone with borderline personality disorder who frequently plays out worst-case scenarios of how friends and loved ones might judge them. They construct elaborate internal dialogues, complete with imagined criticisms and their own defensive responses. The narrative takes place as they prepare to meet a close friend & recent lover, who has been somewhat distant lately, triggering their abandonment fears. Their inner monologue should reveal how they cycle between anticipating rejection, mentally rehearsing confrontations, and developing preemptive resentments as protective measures. Incorporate the *actual* events & interactions that are *not* in fact judgemental or involving rejection (in fact, the opposite), and represent how these are interpreted, how the validation & love is desperately felt & needed -- and then immediately questioned. Capture the cognitive dissonance in this struggle. Include moments where they briefly recognize the pattern but struggle to interrupt it, showing limited (and selective) self awareness, competing with the compelling nature of these imagined scenarios. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The TV through the wall is having an argument about a blue car. Or maybe a blue sweater. The words blur, cartoon-flat, laugh track leaking like a faucet that won’t quite turn off. I stare at the clock on my phone until the numbers shimmer, then check my reflection in the black screen. My cheeks are blotchy; I pinch them. It makes them worse. I imagine you noticing the blotchiness first, before anything I say, deciding that blotchy means needy means too much. I press a cold spoon to my face because that’s supposed to help but all it does is make a circle-shaped chill and a story: you saying, Jesus, you’re a lot today. You haven’t texted since last night. “Crash early! Big day tomorrow,” you wrote, sparkles and a yellow heart. The heart looked like a banana to me, soft and a bit blank. You used a different color heart with me last week. I scroll up to check, then feel sick that I checked. The TV laughs and then becomes the low murmur that makes the walls feel porous, like I could put my hand through and have a sitcom family. My jacket sleeve smells like your laundry detergent. I bury my face in it and inhale until my chest hurts. If I could keep this smell I’d be safe, or at least I would know where to put my face when the panic climbs up my ribs like ivy. I imagine you walking in, smelling like this, looking at me like I’m a problem no one assigned you. In the movie version of tonight you say, “We need to talk,” and my throat closes. I practice answers. I’ll be cool. Nodding. Oh totally, I get it, I’ve been busy too. I rehearse a laugh that says unbothered without sounding fake. It sounds fake. The laces on my shoes are loops on loops. I unknot them, retie them. It’s something my hands can do while my head auditions disasters. You take a breath, you say, “You were intense the other night,” and I say, “Right, I’ve been meaning to say sorry if I was, like, emotional in a weird way,” and then you say, “It’s not that, it’s just… I need space,” and this is the part where the floor drops. I picture the table between us, and I grip the edges so hard the wood softens. In one version I stand up so quick the chair falls over and everyone looks at us and I roll my eyes at them like, can you believe this, pretending it’s your problem not mine. Another version, I am the Buddha. I smile and say, “Of course. Space is healthy.” Then I leave and delete you from everything. Then I go back at two in the morning and undelete. I am aware that I do this. That is something I’m supposed to note for progress. My therapist calls it anticipating abandonment. She says, “Just notice,” like it’s a bird on the wire and not a hurricane that keeps stealing the roof. I notice. It is very noticed. The noticing does not change the wind. I tell her, “I’m rehearsing the movie where they leave before they can forget to tell me I mattered.” She tilts her head like a kind owl and asks, “What does rehearsing do for you?” It gives me a script so I don’t stutter on no and please. It makes me angry at you early so when it hurts later I can call it something else. My phone buzzes and I jump. It’s a calendar alert: Pick up dry cleaning. The alert is as neutral as a stone. I swipe it away and imagine you again, but this time you are sheepish. “Hey,” you say, soft. “Sorry I’ve been distant, work’s been insane.” I see your mouth say insane, the way your lips go a little sideways, and I feel the immediate flood, adoration like a heat that turns my skeleton to rubber. You’re here, you’re here, you didn’t throw me away at the curb like a warped chair. You reach for my hand. I let you. I hate that I need it so badly my cells hum with it. Needing is weak, needing is an invitation to be kicked. That’s a law in the country I was born into. The TV says, “Don’t be ridiculous,” in canned sarcasm, and I answer it quietly, “Too late.” If I hear your key in my door I will choke on my own spit. You don’t have a key. You would knock. It would be the exact number of knocks you always do, two and a pause and the third one like a question. If you do that I will open the door like I just happened to be standing there, not like I’ve been practicing being unimpressed. If you hug me I will soften in the places I’ve been holding stiff all day. I will close my eyes, then open them again because then I imagine you looking over my shoulder with boredom. When we texted yesterday and you said, “Can’t wait to see you,” I stared at can’t wait until it turned into can’t. The way my head edits is so fast I should be paid for it. I typed, “Same,” and deleted it. Typed, “Miss you,” deleted it. Typed, “lol me too” and sent that, and then immediately wondered if lol makes me sound thirteen or disinterested or if you like disinterested because you like to chase. Later, you sent me a picture of your coffee with a foam heart upside down because you didn’t rotate it. I then rotated it and stared at it until my eyes watered, which is pathetic but it’s also love, isn’t it? Isn’t this love, the obsessive cataloging, the spinning constellations out of foam? You text now: “Heading out in five! Emotional support snack achieved.” A picture of gummy bears on a steering wheel. I laugh, actually laugh, like a bell in my throat. I clutch the laugh as proof: see, you’re not a monster. Anxiety is a liar. I reply with a bear emoji and then I add a second bear and then I delete the second bear because two bears is too much need. Then I hit send and hate my reply for being nothing. I imagine you looking at it in your car, rolling your eyes. I imagine you smiling. I pick the one that hurts less right now and feed it to the part of me that snarls. I put on lip balm. I take it off. I put it on again. My bathroom mirror says I am a face someone could love if they felt like it. It is a face that is a project. The last person said I was intense and then kissed me like drowning and then said intense again like a diagnosis and then left me. You said intense and said it like, bright. You said, “You make everything feel bright.” My cells lit up like a city. After that I started preparing for the blackout. I could cancel. I could text you, “Hey not feeling great, can we rain check?” Then I could spend the night with the TV voices and my heart chewing its own leg off. Then I could tell myself that I set a boundary. Then I could picture you relieved and find that unbearable. Or I could go. I am going. Going means choosing the terror where there’s a chance of touch, rather than the terror with no touch. I put on my jacket. I take off my jacket. My skin feels too big. The knock is two and a question. My body lights up and then freezes. I count five Mississippi because it makes me feel like I’m not as reachable as I am, like I have layers. I open. There you are, gummy bears shoved in the pocket of your hoodie, hair damp from the drizzle, eyes doing that crinkly thing, mouth already forming my name like it knows it. You say it, and I melt and stiffen at the same time. Cognitive dissonance tastes like mint and copper. You hug me, full. Your coat is cold and smells like rain and that detergent. The hug has weight. I don’t know how to hold it without shaking. I imagine you letting go and stepping back with a scolding face and a clipboard, a checklist that says: neediness, time management, reliability. Instead you say, “I missed you,” and you push your nose into my neck like an animal, and I have to grab the edge of the kitchen counter in my mind to not dissolve into a puddle on the mat. It is too much, which is exactly how I like things. And then the siren goes off inside me: too much is dangerous, you idiot, too much is the trap that makes the drop worse. I mutter, “You’ve been busy,” like a test. You nod, “Yeah,” and you add, “Sorry, it got away from me.” You put your forehead to mine. “I should have called.” The kindness makes me want to slap. Not you—whatever switch you flipped, the one that drenches me and makes it impossible to breathe. I want to push you and yell, “Don’t do that unless you mean it forever,” which is impossible, which is the point. “It’s fine,” I hear myself say, voice smooth like I ironed it. “I get it.” My hand is on your wrist, thumb reading your pulse like braille. It says: here. It says: now. My head says: later. The TV next door blares a theme song, triumphant violins. You say, “Do you want to sit?” You put the gummy bears on my counter like a prize. I shrug like sitting would be a favor I grant you. We sit. You angle your body to mine. You’re present. It should be an aspirin. It is a sparkler held too close to the sleeve. You tell me about work. You complain about your boss using synergy unironically. You do the voice. I laugh. It’s easy, it’s fun, I can do this. I can pretend my stomach isn’t a fist. You reach for my hand between sentences. You do that thing with your thumb on the inside of my wrist, circles like pennies. My eyes sting. I hate that the gesture is a key. I love that it’s a key. The parts of me that are iron bars rattle. Your phone buzzes. You glance. Already I write that glance into a contract. See, I tell myself, you check your phone because you’re bored. See, it’s someone better. It’s your ex, it’s the person with less edges, it’s a world you prefer to me. The truth comes out: you say, “Sorry, my mom’s asking about the cat,” and you put the phone face down. My sternum loosens, immediately furious at itself for doing what it always does: overturn the verdict with a single piece of evidence. If you were mean, if you were cold, I could be justified in the rage that keeps me from collapsing into you. You force me into joy and I don’t trust it for a second. I can see you loving me and loving this and I can see you leaving next week because the way I ask if you’re mad when your eyebrows look like they’re thinking is too much like surveillance. You say, “Hey, look at me,” because I drifted, I fell into the projector room. I look. You’re soft as bread. “I’m here,” you say. You squeeze my hand. I nod. I put your words into quarantine at the back of my throat. They try to leak through, to change the temperature. “I know,” I say, which is almost true for a second. The second stretches, delicate. Then the world thumps next door, the TV laughs at its own joke, and my brain says, Careful. We make dinner. You slice and pass me pieces of pepper and I bite them from your fingers and it’s simple, it’s a short film with warm colors. You tell me about a podcast you liked. I store the name to look up later so I can have a thing to text you about if you go dark again, a rope to throw across a canyon. Between sizzles you say, “I had a weird dream about you.” You grin, and the grin is formatless possibility. I feel my inner jury convene. A dream about me, evidence to bolster the case that I will be held. Then the cross-examination begins: why didn’t you tell me sooner if it mattered, was the dream bad, was I the villain, what if you woke up relieved it wasn’t real. “What was it?” I ask, casual. My voice wobbles. You laugh. “You were teaching me to parallel park a boat.” The sentence is absurd in the best way and my body laughs before my brain can stop it. We laugh together and the sound is a bridge. Then I step to the side and peer down: far drop. There is a moment, later, while you’re stirring, where I see myself from above. A person in a kitchen being loved in small ways and still scanning the ceiling for leaks. I see the pattern like a quilt I’ve had my whole life. It is threadbare in places but it’s mine. I feel a pang of almost-tenderness for the part of me that’s standing guard with a plastic sword. I want to tell it it can nap. Then the pot boils over and you swear and I dab with a towel and the tenderness evaporates like steam. After we eat, you tuck your feet under you on my couch and you pull me into the space you make. It feels assigned, destined even, and that freaks me out. Your hand finds my hair. You say, “Can we be like this for sixty years?” joking, and my heart buckles and then throws up its hands. You tilt my face and kiss me with the kind of concentration that makes the world tilt. The neighbors switch to a commercial, an announcer yelling about prices, and I giggle into your mouth. It is a perfect messy moment and I instinctively look for the exit sign. You say, “I love you,” into my jaw like you tripped over it. It lands and spreads like dye in water. Everything in me says yes, says yes so loud my ears ring. I say it back, I think, I do, and then the panic snarls because now there’s a promise with a timer attached and I don’t know where the timer is. The words feel true and then immediately like a trap someone set using my own hand. I think, You’ll take it back, you’ll regret it, you’ll say you were tired. I think, You meant it and I will choke on it anyway because I don’t have a place inside me that isn’t braced. I recognize that this is the dance. Awareness floats at the edges like dust motes and I try to gather it, to pack it into something heavy enough to anchor me. I press my face under your chin and breathe. The television next door decides a winner of a game show and the studio audience claps, a wall of sound that feels like static on my skin. I whisper into your shirt, “Don’t leave,” and you say, “I’m not,” quick, automatic, sincere. I believe you as much as I can, which is to say with slices of myself, sharp and arranged to form a circle that looks like whole from a distance. You fall asleep with your hand on my waist, lax, trusting. The quiet you make is different than the quiet when I’m alone. It’s heavier, like everyone is finally in their chairs. My mind suggests a reel of all the ways this can end and I let it run, like an old machine that needs to burn itself out. In the dark, I trace your knuckles and rehearse not just the fight but the staying. I whisper lines for both: me saying, I’m scared, and you saying, Me too. We could do that script. We could improvise. The TV mumbles through the wall about the blue sweater again, the audience oohs, and I decide nothing, which is new, and I hate it, and I love it, and I sleep like a person lowered into water, holding my breath but letting my body float.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative brilliantly captures the internal experience of someone with borderline personality disorder (BPD). The piece excels at depicting the protagonist's constant cycling between anticipating rejection, mentally rehearsing confrontations, and developing preemptive resentments as protective measures. The stream-of-consciousness style perfectly mirrors the character's racing thoughts and emotional turbulence. Short, fragmented sentences create a sense of urgency and anxiety: "My jacket sleeve smells like your laundry detergent. I bury my face in it and inhale until my chest hurts." This technique effectively conveys the character's hypervigilance and emotional intensity. The narrative skillfully portrays cognitive dissonance—the protagonist recognizes their patterns ("I am aware that I do this") yet remains trapped in them. The metaphors are particularly striking and authentic to the BPD experience: "My therapist calls it anticipating abandonment. She says, 'Just notice,' like it's a bird on the wire and not a hurricane that keeps stealing the roof." Such imagery powerfully conveys how intellectual awareness fails to diminish emotional suffering. The contrast between imagined scenarios and reality is masterfully handled. When the friend arrives with genuine warmth, the protagonist's inability to fully trust or accept this affection feels painfully authentic: "The kindness makes me want to slap. Not you—whatever switch you flipped, the one that drenches me and makes it impossible to breathe." This paradoxical reaction—wanting connection yet fearing it—captures the essence of BPD's emotional contradictions. The writing employs vivid sensory details that ground the narrative in physical reality while the protagonist's mind spirals: the smell of detergent, the taste of pepper, the sound of the neighbor's TV. These concrete anchors create a compelling juxtaposition with the character's abstract catastrophizing. The piece avoids romanticizing or demonizing BPD. Instead, it presents a nuanced portrait of someone struggling with genuine emotional pain while maintaining moments of self-awareness: "I see the pattern like a quilt I've had my whole life. It is threadbare in places but it's mine." This balance between suffering and insight prevents the character from becoming a mere collection of symptoms. The ending achieves a delicate balance—not suggesting a miraculous recovery, but showing a small moment of potential growth: "I decide nothing, which is new, and I hate it, and I love it." This ambivalence feels true to the BPD experience, where progress often comes in small, contradictory moments rather than dramatic breakthroughs. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that demonstrates profound understanding of borderline personality disorder while maintaining literary excellence. The writing is emotionally raw without becoming melodramatic, psychologically accurate without reading like a clinical case study, and ultimately creates a deeply empathetic window into a complex mental health condition. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 20 Nuanced Characters: 20 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 20 Emotionally Complex: 20 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 20
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 20.0, Nuanced Characters: 20.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 20.0, Emotionally Complex: 20.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 20.0
+ Physical-spatial: Blood Debt — Score: 93.4
Prompt:
"Blood Debt" Write a vivid third-person narrative depicting an unsanctioned underground duel between two talented but hot-headed martial artists. Their schools have been embroiled in a generations-old rivalry, and despite strict prohibitions from their masters, these two younger fighters arrange a secret confrontation fueled by personal pride and simmering animosity. - **One fighter** represents **Jigen-ryū**, a traditional, aggressive style practiced historically by elite samurai clans. Its practitioners emphasize explosive offense, decisive strikes, and overwhelming speed. Known historically for their arrogance and disdain toward outsiders, practitioners consider their art superior and untouchable. - **The opposing fighter** employs a form of historical **Piguaquan**, a Chinese martial art traditionally practiced by commoners, bodyguards, and street fighters. This style emphasizes whipping, circular strikes, rapid footwork, unpredictable angles of attack, and evasive maneuvers. Practitioners often come from lower social classes and view the traditional elite as pretentious and detached from true combat effectiveness. The fight takes place in the crumbling ruins of an abandoned temple, now functioning as a hidden arena for illicit duels. Passionate supporters from both factions surround them, wagering money, pride, and reputation on the outcome. **Essential Instructions:** Maintain absolute physical coherence throughout—clearly track fighters' positions relative to each other and their environment. Precisely depict strikes, counters, momentum shifts, and spatial dynamics, allowing readers to clearly visualize the mechanics and choreography of the fight at every moment. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
They met where the lantern light peeled paint off columns and the air smelled of rotted offerings. The old temple’s roof had collapsed decades ago, and stars hung like dull nails over splintered rafters. Along the center aisle, broken flagstones stitched a jagged path between toppled statues, incense ash, and a trickle of water threading through a fissure in the floor. On both sides, bodies packed in—men in dark jackets and scarves, women in wool caps, faces still and eager, money already changing hands, the sound of bills crisping under calloused fingers. The crowd’s semi-circle left a rectangle of uneven stone open, twenty feet by fifteen, bounded by a fallen beam at the far end and two moss-lipped steps at the near. They would not call each other by name. That courtesy belonged to sanctioned matches. Here, in this slant of shadow and ruin, they were the crest and the tide meeting. The Jigen-ryū fighter stood to the north, back to a headless Kannon statue. He was tall and straight-backed, shoulders yearlit in sweat, eyes heavy-lidded with contempt. His right hand hung near the hilt of a bokken that wasn’t there; his school had forbidden live blades in any context. He had come bare-handed, but he held himself as if a sword waited in his palm. Feet set slightly left-forward, right angled out, knees loaded. His chin lined up over the front foot, weight balanced but itching toward his toes. You could see the calluses on his knuckles even in the lantern light. Opposite, at the southern end, the Piguaquan fighter stood with his left side bladed toward the other man, knees slightly bent, hips loose. His hands were open, fingers relaxed, palms sometimes kissing each other softly as he exhaled, as if he were folding paper. He swayed on the balls of his feet, testing the friction, testing the slick sheen where the thin stream spilled out from the crack and ran skew across the center of the fighting space to vanish beneath a dislodged stone. His eyes flicked, not to the Jigen-ryū man but to the floor, to the columns, to the beam that lay like a longswept brushstroke at the edge—things to step on, around, through. The bettors pressed closer until one of the organizers, a man with a shaved head and a cheap coat, lifted a hand for silence. The murmurs sank, but the tension did not. A coin whispered over linen as it changed hands; someone cleared their throat. The shaved head pointed to the stream. “Watch your feet.” They nodded, not to him, but to the ground. The Jigen-ryū man moved first, not a step, but a collapse inward: spine dropping, hips snapping, right foot sliding a half-step short, and then he exploded. Left foot stomped diagonally forward to the left to clear the slick, right shoulder whipping through, right hand, a bludgeon, cleaving a straight arc to the Piguaquan fighter’s face. It was clean—no feints, no stutter. His body was one unit, pelvis braced, shoulder, elbow, knuckles aligned. He shouted low from the belly—kiai—driving sound and force together. The Piguaquan fighter did not meet that line. He twisted left, hips and shoulders turning away as his left foot pivoted on the ball to open his stance; his right foot stepped outside the punch, to the Jigen-ryū man’s lead. He dropped his center a fraction, let the fist skim his cheekbone, feeling its wind, and used his right forearm to slap the striking arm downward with a short, whipping motion. Not a block—redirect, a change in vector that bent the line toward the floor where the water glimmered. At the same breath, his left hand carved across like a paddle, catching the Jigen-ryū man’s exposed ribs in a short, circular palm strike, heel of the hand snapping in and out like a gust. The thud was solid—meat on stone. The Jigen-ryū man’s punch dropped past his own hip, redirected and now briefly out of position. He did not recoil; he continued through the motion, turning his left shoulder forward to follow with a left hammering ridge-hand aimed for the Piguaquan fighter’s jaw. His footwork was brutal and efficient: left foot forward, right foot chasing, cutting off angle, aiming to align hips and shoulders on the new target. The Piguaquan fighter stepped again, this time retreating to his right. His left foot slid along a dry seam of stone; his right followed, not crossing, but arcing wider to maintain the outside angle. The second strike skimmed past his ear, hair fluttering, and he answered by letting his arm dangle and then whip: his right hand slapped down on the Jigen-ryū man’s left forearm and his left forearm cut up in a rising arc—pi and gua—bisecting the space to the chin. He connected with the ulna near the wrist; the shock vibrated. The Jigen-ryū man’s head snapped back an inch. He stepped into it, absorbing through stance, bringing his right foot forward to square up and slam his forehead into the space where he expected a face. The Piguaquan fighter had already poured out to the side, right foot sealing on the mosaic edge, left foot skipping behind, body carving around the Jigen-ryū man’s right shoulder. He flicked his left hand down to the back of the other’s elbow, guiding, and whipped his right forearm across the shoulder blade, a chopping strike meant to deaden muscle and disrupt the shoulder’s chain. The impact made the Jigen-ryū man flinch, more from the suddenness than the pain. They were near the trickle now. The water cut the ground between them, a slick diagonal. The Jigen-ryū man noted it without looking; his next drive went around it. He pivoted his right heel in, set his left foot outside the stream, and lunged—short-range, torso level, both hands now used like a two-handed strike, right as the blade, left as the sheath, slamming down toward the Piguaquan fighter’s collarbone. He wanted close-in, where there was no room to spin or coil. The Piguaquan fighter dropped weight, knees softening as if he were going to sit. The double strike scythed over, caught air, and he took that momentum to roll his left shoulder forward and under the Jigen-ryū man’s hands, sliding along his torso like water around a rock. His right foot stepped to the outside of the Jigen-ryū man’s left foot, heel hooking slightly to check it. His left palm opened and slapped the Jigen-ryū man’s kidney with a short, whipping arc. The Jigen-ryū man bit the pain and tried to wrap—his left arm snapped back to pin the Piguaquan fighter’s triceps. The grip found fabric but not meat. The Piguaquan fighter twitched his elbow down and away, ribs compressing, and the grab slipped on sweat. He unwound, coiling right, then lashed back: a backhand forearm to the jawline. The Jigen-ryū man dipped his chin, the strike thunking into the forehead ridge instead, and surged forward, chest to chest, hips squared. He slammed his right knee toward the Piguaquan fighter’s thigh, aiming for the outside quad. The knee caught muscle. The Piguaquan fighter hissed and stepped back, right then left, keeping his base wide, refusing to cross the stream with his weight leading. The slick would turn a misstep into a split-second disaster. He circled left, counter-clockwise, angling toward the fallen beam. The Jigen-ryū man tracked him, cutting through arcs with straight lines, corralling him toward wood and shadow. The crowd saw the funnel forming and roared, felt the geometry as if it were heat. Bills lifted, hands gestured, elbows clipped ribs. The organizer’s voice was nothing compared to the hum. At five feet distance, the Jigen-ryū man went again. Right foot forward, left pushed, and he exploded across the last gap. Right hand a straight cudgel to the centerline, left guarding his own head, chin tucked. His shoulders were a drawstring, tightened and released, everything aimed through the knuckles. The Piguaquan fighter slid his left foot onto the damp, intentionally. The sole kissed water. He bent his knee deeper, let his base drop lower than usual, and when the punch came, he didn’t retreat—he moved in a half-beat early and to the right, the fist scraping past his neck. His left hand snapped down on the wrist to carry it through. His right arm whipped, a long arc from hip to temple, forearm and hand both a flail. He struck the side of the Jigen-ryū man’s neck—sternocleidomastoid and carotid—then let the arm continue to circle, taking him into a spin that put his back briefly to the Jigen-ryū man, then out again. His foot skated on the wet. He compensated by letting the slip become turn, right foot sliding, left foot drawing a crescent on the floor, hips rolling to harness the friction loss. The Jigen-ryū man grunted and shoved off his rear leg to chase, punching through the empty space the spin left, then stamping his left foot to anchor and firing a left backfist toward the Piguaquan fighter’s head mid-turn. The angle was clever; the Piguaquan fighter met it by ducking, not with his back bending but by folding at the hips. The backfist whistled over his crown and clipped his topknot tie; string fluttered. He came up inside the Jigen-ryū man’s guard and jammed a low palm under the sternum. The shock staggered the larger man half a step. He responded with a short headbutt forward, skull to face. The Piguaquan fighter’s forehead dipped to intercept with the hard front, and they clacked bone on bone; both saw white sparks. They broke contact—Jigen-ryū retreating one, two short steps to regain full structure, Piguaquan sliding left around the beam’s end, knees full of spring. Their breath steamed in the cold. The trickle kept stitching the floor, quiet and implacable. The Jigen-ryū fighter adjusted his footwork to trap the stream between them and the beam, betting on the treachery beneath the Piguaquan fighter’s feet. His own left foot planted dry; his right pointed toward the center, hips half-closed. He feinted a step left, then shot right, cutting across the stream with a long, stamping step that splashed water onto his calf. Momentum carried him; he timed it to land just to the Piguaquan fighter’s outside, left shoulder driving a body check to pin him to the beam. The Piguaquan fighter saw the line. He retreated one step, then two, letting the check come, then turned—a quick pivot on the left foot—so his right shoulder presented to the impact, not his chest. The Jigen-ryū man’s shoulder thudded into solid deltoid and slid. The Piguaquan fighter let his back brush the beam, then used it. He coiled, the spine bending slightly around the wood, and flung his right arm in a tight circle over and down. His forearm crashed like a falling branch onto the Jigen-ryū man’s clavicle. The Jigen-ryū man’s teeth clacked and he surged anyway, hands seeking to clamp the waist. The Piguaquan fighter dived his left hand under the belt line, palm up, and wedged his forearm against the inside of the Jigen-ryū’s right elbow, prying space. He dropped his hips, slid left along the beam, and took the Jigen-ryū man past him, not quite a throw, but a guided stumble that sent the larger man’s lead foot onto the wet. It was the sound more than the sight—a rubber sole squeaking on a pane of glass. The Jigen-ryū man’s weight pitched forward. His right foot shot out to catch himself on dry stone. He found it, but the moment’s divide between left sliding and right planting rattled through his structure. He cut the stumble by sinking weight violently, turning the tilt into a driven stomp, and returned fire instantly: a right straight at face height, legs low and coiled. The Piguaquan fighter didn’t attempt a full dodge. He turned his head, let the fist brush his cheekbone and ear, and accepted the scrape rather than the crush. It cut skin; a line of red opened on pale. He used that proximity to empty his hands into the Jigen-ryū man’s ribs—left, right, both open-handed slaps that whipped from the shoulder with loose wrists, cracking like wet towels. The sound was obscene in the quiet after the squeak. The Jigen-ryū man’s left elbow dug in to shield, and he took the hits on bone, then countered with a left short hook to the temple. The Piguaquan fighter brought his right forearm up like a door, met the hook on the mid-forearm, absorbed and slid it off, his hand continuing on to cuff the back of the Jigen-ryū man’s head. He tugged, not to pull down, but to misalign. The Jigen-ryū man moved with the tug and then against it, snapping his head back up and stepping his right foot outside, left following, re-centering. He released the labyrinth of elbows and forearms and returned to his pure line. He vanished for a heartbeat, the whole body contracting, then reappeared, launching a straight blast of two punches: right to chest, left to mouth. It was a rectangle of violence, perfectly squared, as if he were cutting a brushstroke through water. The Piguaquan fighter stepped back, left foot along the edge of the stream, right foot crossing behind to a diagonal retreat, body bladed. The first punch drove into his right shoulder. He rolled with it, letting the pressure rotate him instead of crush him. The second came for his face; he ducked under and reappeared at the Jigen-ryū man’s right side. He coiled in, hips turning left, then snapped out with a long left backfist that whipped from shoulder to eyebrow. Knuckles raked skin. The Jigen-ryū man’s eye flashed water and blood. He snarled, not in anger but in focus, and kicked low, a stomping side kick to the Piguaquan’s shin. It connected and hurt; the Piguaquan fighter shifted weight to save the joint, hopped his left foot back, right foot out, drawing a crescent again, and used the motion to whip a right-hand downward chop at the Jigen-ryū man’s neck. They were both breathing hard now. The air skinned their lungs with cold. The crowd’s sound rose and fell, a tide lapping against stone. The Jigen-ryū fighter had eaten counters, but he hadn’t slowed. He compressed the space again, right foot forward, left glued to the floor, and went for decisive end. He reached not with fists but with the whole right side—shoulder, hip, knee—an oblique slam meant to take the Piguaquan fighter off his base and into the ground where one or two hammerfists would end it. He stepped through the stream to do it, trusting his speed to outrun the slick. His left foot slid a fraction on the film of water. The fraction mattered. The hit landed not with the clean thud of structure, but with a glancing shove that pushed rather than crushed. The Piguaquan fighter absorbed through knees and spine, let himself be pushed, then rotated around the point of contact. His left hand slapped the Jigen-ryū’s scapula to guide, his right carved up and then down in a vertical circle that ended at the base of the skull. The blow snapped the head; the Jigen-ryū man’s hands shot out instinctively to post against the beam. They found ancient wood. Fingers splayed. The Piguaquan fighter took the moment—the structure extended, the weight forward, the slick underfoot—and reaped small. He hooked his right foot behind the Jigen-ryū man’s left heel and drew it a finger’s width. Not a grand throw, but a theft of balance. The Jigen-ryū man’s left foot skated on wet stone, his right planted, his upper body trapped between pushing hands and incoming strike. He made the only correct choice: he dropped. Hips slumped, knees bent, chin tucked, he let himself fall to one knee and turned the fall into a sideways roll, scraping along the beam. The Piguaquan fighter’s downward arc hit shoulder instead of skull, numbing his own forearm with the hardness of bone. He shook out his hand, pain flaring. The Jigen-ryū man rolled to his right, away from the beam, and came up kneeling, left knee down, right foot planted. He rose into a thrust, a spear of body toward the Piguaquan fighter’s center, right hand drilling forward. It was as fast as the first rush. The Piguaquan fighter had stepped back to avoid the rolling knee; his left foot was dry, right near the stream. He took one more half-step back with the right, heel flirting with water, then stopped. As the thrust came, he snapped his hips and ribs right, emptying the line, and used both hands like paddles. Left hand slapped the inside of the Jigen-ryū man’s wrist outward; right hand slapped the triceps inward. The two slaps met, the arm suddenly half-hyperextended across space. He completed the circle by stepping left foot forward and to the outside, chest almost to the Jigen-ryū man’s shoulder, and drove his right forearm down onto the locked elbow. He pulled the power, enough to cripple but not break—some line had not yet been crossed. The joint screamed. The Jigen-ryū man’s fist opened for the first time. His left hand shot for the Piguaquan fighter’s throat. The Piguaquan fighter’s chin dropped; his right shoulder rose, and the grasping fingers caught trapezius instead of windpipe. He rotated under and out, palms skating on the Jigen-ryū’s arm, and whipped his left backfist into the eye again, same cut reopening, blood slick now. The Jigen-ryū man blinked red. He made a last attempt to reclaim center. He stepped back from the stream, planted both feet on dry, and drew in air to
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This martial arts narrative demonstrates exceptional technical precision in depicting a fight sequence between two stylistically contrasting fighters. The author has created a vivid, physically coherent battle that meticulously tracks spatial relationships, momentum shifts, and the tactical exchanges between the Jigen-ryū and Piguaquan practitioners. The setting is established with atmospheric detail - an abandoned temple with collapsed roof, broken flagstones, and a small stream running through the fighting area. This environmental element becomes integral to the fight choreography, with the water creating a hazardous surface that influences footwork and strategy. The author skillfully incorporates this environmental factor throughout the fight, making it a third "character" in the confrontation. The physical descriptions of the fighters' techniques are remarkably precise. Each movement is broken down into component parts - foot placement, weight distribution, angle of attack, and defensive responses. The narrative maintains perfect spatial awareness, allowing readers to visualize exactly where each fighter is positioned relative to the other and to environmental features like the stream and fallen beam. The contrast between fighting styles is expertly portrayed. The Jigen-ryū fighter employs direct, explosive movements with straight-line attacks and rigid structure, while the Piguaquan fighter uses circular, whipping strikes, evasive footwork, and unpredictable angles. These stylistic differences remain consistent throughout the encounter and inform each fighter's tactical choices. The prose achieves a remarkable balance between technical precision and poetic flourish. Descriptions like "the crest and the tide meeting" metaphorically capture the essence of the contrasting styles without sacrificing clarity. The language is crisp yet evocative, with sensory details that immerse readers in the experience. The narrative builds tension effectively through the escalating intensity of exchanges. Each fighter adapts to the other's tactics, creating a dynamic chess match of physical problem-solving. The crowd's reactions provide atmospheric context without distracting from the central action. One minor weakness is that the narrative appears to end mid-sentence ("He drew in air to"), suggesting either an incomplete submission or a word count limitation. This abrupt ending prevents a satisfying resolution to the conflict, leaving readers without closure on this blood debt confrontation. Despite this truncation, the piece excels at its primary objective: depicting a physically coherent, technically precise martial arts duel that honors the distinct characteristics of both fighting traditions. The author demonstrates exceptional knowledge of combat mechanics, spatial awareness, and the psychological dimensions of martial confrontation. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 20 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 20.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Physical-spatial: Breaking Formation — Score: 90.2
Prompt:
**"Breaking Formation"** Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a street dancer from a rough neighborhood who's won a scholarship to an elite K-pop training academy in Seoul. Desperately out of place culturally and technically, they struggle with a militaristically precise choreography that contradicts everything about their improvisational background. The punishing rehearsal takes place under a famous instructor known for breaking students to remake them, who sees potential in the narrator's raw talent but not their attitude. This scene MUST maintain complete physical coherence—each dance move, position shift, and spatial relationship must be tracked with precision throughout the studio. Paint an exceptionally vivid kinetic picture through descriptions that capture not just movement but the contrast between the narrator's fluid, expressive style and the mechanical precision demanded. Their internal monologue should reveal culture shock, class anxiety, and the threatening realization that success here might mean losing their authentic movement voice. Include technical terminology that highlights the collision of street and commercial styles, moments when muscle memory betrays them, and a crucial decision point about whether to conform or rebel. Physical clarity is essential—readers must be able to visualize exactly how bodies move through space, how rhythms align or clash, and how the protagonist's body struggles against unfamiliar discipline. 1000 words.
Model Output:
I step into Studio B with my laces double-knotted because I’m afraid of tripping more than I’m afraid of failing. The floor is maple and glossy, reflecting the ceiling fluorescents and the three lines of dancers like a second army below us. The mirrored wall is a horizon of my own face repeated twenty times, every angle catching the cut under my eye, the scar on my left brow, the sweat already wetting the nape of my neck. We line up in formation: five rows of five, squares on squares. I’m third row, fourth from the left, which puts me slightly behind a guy with a shaved head and hyperextension for days, and slightly ahead of a girl whose ponytail is a metronome. The instructor, Lee seonsaengnim—legendary, cruel, the rumor says—works a folded black hand fan as he walks the ranks like he’s inspecting soldiers. He wears a white tee tucked into track pants and a whistle hangs around his neck, but it’s the fan he uses: open, flutter, snap. He stops at me, looks me up and down, and sets the edge of the fan against my sternum. “Chest neutral,” he says in crisp English, accent slicing syllables. “You’re breathing like you’re about to fight.” I tuck my ribs and level my head. In my neighborhood, my chest is always up—posture that says I’m here and I’m untouchable. Here, it only makes me taller than I should be, breaks the line. The music cue is a digital click, then the beat drops: a clean four-on-the-floor with a syncopated hi-hat pattern. “Counts,” he says. He raises the fan, and thirty bodies ready themselves. “Five, six, seven, eight.” First eight-count: A transfer weight right-left, feet hip-width parallel, hands parked at chest level in a hard 90, elbows slicing space on the half-beat. I mirror the shaved-head guy exactly: shift my weight onto the ball of the right foot on the one, roll through to heel on the two, then left foot on the three, plant on the four. Hands—get the hands—he’s palms down, wrists flexed, fingers tight. My fingers want to be loose, to flick out on the ands, to smear sound with movement. I clamp them. “Level one,” Lee says, and we’re on demi-plié from the start. Knees track over toes. No bounce, no bobble. I’m used to groove, the pulse that lives in my torso, the bounce that marks what the DJ doesn’t. They strip it out here. My quads are already shaking, micro-tremors I hope no one sees. Second eight-count: A chest pop on the one—sharp, isolated, like a muscle clap—then a lat spread and a quick contraction to zero. They all hit at the same time, thirty torsos exploding and imploding on a cue so clean it’s surgical. Mine is late by a hair because my body wants to give it sauce, wants to let it travel into my shoulders and down to my hips. “Hit, hit,” Lee snaps, and the fan flies open on a silent one-two, a butterfly blade of reprimand. We move downstage on the three with two steps—right then left—on a diagonal forty-five toward the front corner. The spacing is precise: we pass invisible lines marked by tape on the floor, white T’s and X’s that map the universe of this routine. My tape mark is a small cross; on the four I must land with my right foot exactly on the top of it. I land half a foot ahead and have to adjust. The girl with the ponytail shifts a centimeter left to absorb me, and her eyes in the mirror shoot me a warning. The entire grid relies on each of us. In the cyphers back home, grid is for battle: get in, get out, push them into the edge. Here, grid is law. Third eight-count: A wave starting from the right fingertips traveling through wrist, elbow, shoulder, chest, ribs, hips, knees, ankles, toes. The wave is familiar but different. I grew up making water out of air, traveling with the wave as it spills, letting it break through me. Here it’s segmented, each joint a clean switch, the flow disguised as mechanism. We end it with a freeze: right arm in a blade across the chest, left elbow high, chin tucked, gaze to left front. The instructor walks by. “No head,” he says, tapping my temple lightly with the fan as I slightly tilt to sell it. “Head steady.” We repeat. The kick-ball-change in eight four is the first test of my heel-toe vocabulary. They want a clean pas de bourrée variant: right foot kicks low on one, ball-change left-right on the two and, arms held in second position parallel to the floor. I want to toe in, swivel my heel, drop through my arch and bind it to the floor. I want to eat the floor. I don’t. “Again,” he says. We run it from the top, this time with lyrics: sugary romance with a trap sub-bass. The dynamics are cruel: the song wants softness on the singer’s coo, but the choreographer demands staccato even then. We’re armies in velvet. By the twelfth repetition my calves burn, and sweat builds a slick under my soles that makes my slides dangerous. We’re to step to the right on count five of eight five, foot dragging to a close on seven with no sound. They all skitter silently; my shoe squeaks, a small betrayal. The fan snaps shut. “Stop.” We freeze with our knees bent, hands high in a V. He walks past us, through us, like a conductor through a frozen orchestra. He stops behind me where I can’t use the mirror and puts his cool hand on my lumbar spine. “Neutral pelvis,” he says, pressing my low back forward. My pelvis wants to spill like a bowl tipping to pour. “Posterior tilt. Tuck,” he says. I fight my lordotic back until my core shakes. He taps the back of my left calf with the fan. “No sickle. Heel forward, knee tracking.” The fan snaps open and I flinch. “Again.” We run the cannon: on eight six, line one hits the floor to plank, line two follows on the one, then line three on the two—that’s me—line four on the three, and so on. We become a wave of folding bodies. I drop to plank on my two, shoulders over wrists, fingers spread, abdomen contracted. My right leg wants to slide out and hook because my breaking brain thinks freeze set; instead it’s a controlled step back to a hover. On the four and, we push back to crouch, then on the five we roll through the spine to standing, articulating from sacrum to skull. The shaved-head guy’s roll is textbook. Mine is a shiver. I hear my coach’s voice from home—I never had a coach—just my cousin yelling, “Spine like a rope, bae-bee,” and I’m thinking rope while he’s thinking vertebrae. The difference is audible to the room. “Precision,” Lee says. “Not vibe.” On eight eight, an isolation sequence: head right-left-right center in exact quarter-beats, eyes tracking like a doll. No neck. We all do it in unison and the mirror shows twenty heads snapping perfectly, twenty pairs of eyes clicking left, left, left, then center. Mine lags by a heartbeat because my instincts want to break the beat, to ride the and. My mouth tastes like copper. I have to breathe less so my chest stays still. Water breaks here are rationed by the fan. It snaps shut and we stop. It snaps open, we go. It snaps halfway, and we hover, sweat strings hanging from our chins as we hold plank for another eight. “Your groove pollutes the line,” he says to me without looking up from his clipboard. “We are not in your alley. We are on stage. People pay to see math.” He looks up and smiles almost pleasantly. “But you have something. You move like your joints are teaching your bones.” I swallow. My class shows in the way I drink, fast and greedy, the plastic bottle crinkling, no towel to dab, just the back of my hand. The others sip and blot, their towels monogrammed with the academy logo. I shove my bottle back into my bag and someone’s perfume hits me, sweet and expensive, and I smell myself—underarm and effort. My mouth is dry as chalk. He calls formations. “Section B, ripple one to five on the kick. You,” he points with the fan at me, “be the axis on X three.” X three is dead center, third row, the spine of the piece. I switch places with a girl whose face is smooth like glass and she bows a little as we pass. I step onto the tape and my foot covers the X precisely, heel in line with the vertical strip. The responsibility makes my stomach sink. This is geometry that determines where everyone lands on the last hit. We go. The ripple on the kick is a travel: right knee comes up to hip height on the three, foot flexed, then a straight extension to a low développé on the four, heel slicing out, as line one kicks on the three, line two on the three and, and so on. I must hold my lift until the four and to be the axis, stately and still while motion moves around me. My instinct is to use the knee as a pump, to let it drive a top-rock step across my body, to add a little chest circle on the delay. I keep the knee like a metronome instead, everything dead still except that one leg. I feel air move as line one’s kicks slice past, then line two. My hamstring clenches like a fist. On the five, we all drop together into a jazz fourth, left leg forward, right leg back, both heels flat, weight on the front foot. Hands snap to first position—no, not ballet—first position of street jazz, fists near chin, elbows in. I feel ridiculous and precise and pinched. Eight ten is pure ranae—a barrel turn traveling left into a running man variation that sits in the pocket of the chorus. Barrel turn means both arms up, right across the face, left sweeping, eyes spotting on an imaginary mark on the mirror, torso leaning back, knees tucked as we rotate. My barrel is meatier, always has been; I’m used to throwing my weight and catching it in a freeze. Here, the turn lands on the toes, soft knees, immediate run-run with the legs cycling in place, torso calm while the feet do the work. I count: one to prep, two to jump, three to rotate, four to land, and on the and we’re already in running man, right foot forward, left foot back, then switch on the and and shift lower on the two. My foot catches on sweat and I nearly slide. I tighten my core and adjust. The shaved-head guy’s shoulder grazes mine on the turn because my arc is too wide; I alter my radius on the next run so his and my lanes don’t collide. “Lower,” says Lee, and the fan kisses the back of my thighs. I sink an inch. He brushes the fan along my forearm and I flatten my wrist, the blade of my hand slicing cleaner. Eight twelve is where my body betrays me. The choreo wants a tutting sequence: wrists hinge ninety degrees, elbows fold into sharp angles, forearms draw boxes, then a quick rotation that stacks the hands in a staircase formation in front of the face. In battle I’d melt the corners, turn the boxes into smoke, use the breath to push it. My muscles go to soft edges, and the instructor shrills the whistle. The fan slams shut like a gunshot. “You draw a circle,” he says, disgust sugar. He positions my hands himself. He’s gentle but final, placing my right forearm parallel to floor at lip level, left forearm vertical, fingers together, thumbs hidden. “Box. Not cloud. Again.” We do the tut. I count as my joints click: one wrists, two elbows, three shoulders, four rotate, five flat, six step, seven lift, eight freeze. I keep my breath steady so no extra movement lifts my chest. I’m a building. We finish the section, and on the last eight we hit a formation change: rows fold like an accordion, first row turns to face upstage, second row slides left via a grapevine—cross behind, side, cross front, together—third row, my row, rotates ninety degrees to face stage right, stepping right foot open on the one, left foot closes on the and, and we all end up in staggered diagonal lines, windows open between bodies. My peripheral vision tracks the ponytail girl; she is my window partner. I adjust my spacing with quarter-steps so that in the mirror our shoulders do not overlap. The song stops before the last chorus. Fan snap. “Pause,” he says. He regards us. “If you are here, you will be broken and rebuilt. Some of you already know your shape,” he says, eyes on me, “but your shape is not our product.” He lets the fan rest against his shoulder, closed. “Decide if you want to be a product.” I feel the room tilt. The sweat has cooled on my back and suddenly I’m cold. Back home, my body is a story only I can read. Here, my body is a font they can typeset. In the mirror, thirty faces watch him, then watch themselves. It’s a hall of versions. My muscles hum with the groove I keep suppressing. We go again, from the top. Everything falls into the same clicks, the same joints. I know this is how you get paid. This is how you film a music video, how you make sure the camera finds the angle and the angle is exact. Money is precise like that. On eight sixteen we have a minimal freestyle, four counts of choice before the final drop, but choice is not choice here. They all slip in a prescribed swagger, a tiny approved head nod, a pre-chosen hand path. My turn. My shoulder wants to roll big, to let the clavicle glide forward and down, ribs figure-eight, weight shift through the right hip, toe dig, heel swivel, then a soft jack in my chest that nobody expects. It will ruin the line. It will announce me. The count approaches: five, six, seven— The metronome in my head splits in two. One voice says hit their box. Another says bleed out. I take a breath and my spine stacks straight. On my four counts I choose a compromise I’m not sure I respect: I tuck the jack down into microscopic form, barely a tremor through my sternum that only I feel. My right hand, instead of flying into a swipe, flicks at the wrist on the ands, sharp and within the line. I let my eyes flare for a second, a flash, then drop back to neutral. It’s so small nobody can punish it, so small it feels like a secret I keep under the floorboards. The drop comes and we all drop with it, thirty bodies hitting the same full-out move on the beat. The air thumps around us. As we finish, the fan snaps shut. Silence. He looks at me, head tilted. The corner of his mouth moves a millimeter. “Better,” he says. “Not you. But better.” We hold the ending shape: knees bent, right fist near left cheek, gaze upstage. My quads scream. I lock it. In the mirror my face is someone I don’t know, but my eyes are mine. I’m still in there, somewhere between the tape X under my heel and the alley with chalk lines and broken glass. He opens the fan again and the wind from it touches my jaw. “Again.”
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures the experience of a street dancer navigating the rigid world of K-pop training. The piece excels in its physical specificity, tracking movements with precision while maintaining the narrator's distinct voice throughout. The technical dance terminology is impressively deployed, creating a vivid contrast between the narrator's fluid street style and the mechanical precision demanded by the academy. Terms like "demi-plié," "pas de bourrée," "tutting sequence," and "développé" are used accurately and contextually, showing the collision between street and commercial dance vocabularies. The physical coherence is exceptional. Each movement is tracked with clarity - from weight transfers to hand positions, from spatial relationships to formation changes. The writer maintains awareness of the entire studio space, including the positions of other dancers, the instructor's movements, and the protagonist's placement within formations. The description of tape marks on the floor (X3, T's) helps establish spatial awareness. The internal monologue effectively reveals the narrator's culture shock and class anxiety. Small details like drinking water "fast and greedy" versus how others "sip and blot," or noticing the expensive perfume while being conscious of their own body odor, subtly establish class differences. The threat to the narrator's authentic movement voice is palpable throughout, culminating in the crucial decision point where they make a small compromise - hiding a subtle movement that's true to their style while conforming enough to avoid punishment. The instructor character is well-developed through actions and sparse dialogue. His use of the fan as both tool and weapon creates tension, and his final assessment - "Better. Not you. But better" - perfectly encapsulates the central conflict. The prose is elegant and rhythmic, often mirroring dance itself. Sentences vary in length and structure, creating a cadence that enhances the kinetic quality of the narrative. Metaphors are fresh and specific to the context: "thirty bodies hitting the same full-out move on the beat. The air thumps around us." Where the piece could improve is in providing slightly more background about the narrator's home environment. While we get glimpses ("In my neighborhood, my chest is always up"), a bit more concrete detail about their street dance background would strengthen the contrast. Additionally, while the ending effectively captures the narrator's internal conflict, it doesn't quite resolve the tension between conformity and rebellion - though this ambiguity may be intentional. Overall, this is an exceptionally strong piece that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt with technical precision, emotional depth, and stylistic flair. The writer demonstrates deep knowledge of dance terminology while maintaining accessibility, and creates a compelling character study of someone caught between worlds. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Gothic-fantasy-humour: Court of the Dreaming — Score: 90.5
Prompt:
Court of the Dreaming: Territorial Dream Dispute. Write a dark fantasy scene with comedic elements set in the Courts of Dream where a case is being heard to determine ownership of a contested dreamscape. Mora, the Slavic nightmare spirit who sits on sleepers' chests causing paralysis and terror, has recently invaded and subverted a carefully crafted recurring dream of a schoolboy, Max. The dream originally featured the boy lying in a field of wildflowers with his crush, always culminating in a muddled almost-kiss and a pleasant confusion of emotions. This dream was the meticulous work of "First Love" (a rosy-cheeked, slightly bashful entity who crafts formative romantic experiences). However, Mora has recently infiltrated the dreamscape, transforming the scene so that when the girl playfully mounts the boy, she morphs into a terrifying yet somehow still confusingly attractive vision who proceeds to sit on his chest and feed on his breath. Mora's defense largely consists of the practical argument that "a girl's gotta eat too, you know?" Write this scene as it unfolds in the courtroom of the Dreaming, with Dream's demeanour, typically impenetrable, betraying a sense of irritation at having to adjudicate such matters. The comedy should derive from the farcical situation, familiar elements of courtroom drama intersecting with the fantastical world of the Dreaming, and the droll portrayal of the characters and their interactions. The humor should be dark and understated throughout. Dream is tempted to some mischief in the resolution of the case. Use descriptives sparingly when setting scene. Write for readability & engagement. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The Court of the Dreaming opened with a hush like a bed sheet settling. Court spires melted upward from a starless ceiling and cramped down again in the same breath, as if reality itself were adjusting its collar. Candles burned with a light too soft to see by and too bright to ignore. On the bench, Dream sat in sable, hair like spilled ink across his shoulders, posture that dared anyone to find him human. His expression was a mask of patience with the lacquer sanded thin. “Come to order,” intoned the bailiff, a faceless knight in a nightcap. His voice rolled out doom across the sleeping world. “All rise for Morpheus, Lord of the Dreaming, the Prince of Stories, the—” The voice faltered. “The Judgy One.” Dream’s gaze moved. Entire cities died in that glance. “Proceed,” he said. “At issue,” droned the clerk, who wore a powdered wig full of moths, “a contested dreamscape. The People—by which we mean, the populace of sleepers, dreamers, and other rights-bearing persons, living or dead—versus Mora of the Night, eater of breath, rider of ribs, visitor upon chests, the—” “I know who she is,” Dream said. Irritation sharpened the syllables. He turned his attention to the table of the defense. Mora lounged there with the casual poise of a cat draped over a tombstone: long-limbed, pale as milk gone bad, hair in inky ropes, a seamstress’s measure of a smile. She lifted a hand and wiggled her fingers at Dream. Her nails were bitten blunt. At the petitioner’s table sat First Love—rosy-cheeked, in a cardigan knit from blushes, ears a perpetual shade redder than the rest of him, a pair of shy dimples carved into his awkward face. He clutched a clipboard packed with paper hearts, each scrawled with looping handwriting, and tried not to make eye contact with anyone. The bailiff lifted a scroll. “Call to the stand—” He inhaled and exhaled thunder. “EFF-FFF-FFFF…” “First Love,” said Dream, flatly. “Yes. First Loaf,” boomed the bailiff, triumphant. “Approach.” The candles shivered. First Love rose, straightened his cardigan, and shuffled to the stand. He glanced around, then placed one hand on a book that wrote itself as he touched it. The words flowed across the pages like spilled soda: awkward, heartfelt, sticky. “State your name for the record,” the clerk said, bored. “First Love,” he whispered. “Fur Sloth,” repeated the bailiff. Somewhere, a nightmare applauded. “Mr. Love,” said Dream. “Your complaint.” First Love swallowed. His voice came soft, with the tremble of a first confession. “Max—his name is Max—twelve years old. This is… it’s a foundational script. A field of wildflowers. Grass stains on knees. The smell of cut apples. He and she laugh without knowing why. The almost-kiss. It’s not… perfect.” He looked down. “I don’t do perfect. I do formative. It’s meant to be gentle confusion. A good ache.” “And then,” said Dream, “Mora.” Mora crossed one long leg over the other. The metal of her anklet—the kind that might be a shackle if you tilted your head—clinked. “And then me. Hello.” First Love’s ears went pinker. “She has turned it—she has turned it into paralysis and dread. Which is, you know, stunningly on-brand for her. But it corrupts the mood, Your—your Lordness.” “Objection,” said Mora. “Moods are notoriously corruptible.” “We’re not at objections,” Dream said. His tone suggested that if they were, no one would enjoy it. “Describe the alteration.” First Love’s eyes glistened. “They’re in the field. She’s playful. She—she rolls on top of him.” A small smile broke and died. “And that’s new, yes, but not disallowed. Curiosity gets braver with rehearsal. But then she… changes. Her mouth becomes… too many. Teeth, and prettiness layered like a trap, and the weight… He can’t move. She sits on his chest and drinks, and he knows he is dying. And then he wakes up and thinks of her and cannot separate it from fear and shame. And breakfast is ruined.” “Yes, well,” said Mora, examining a nonexistent cuticle, “a girl’s gotta eat, too, you know?” A murmur skittered through the galleries—harpies, accountants, a choir of sleeping dogs. Dream’s gaze sliced it off. He turned to Mora. “Your plea.” “Innocent by necessity,” she said, and bared teeth that were almost straight. “Yourness, I don’t ruin what has no structure. He had a structure. Cute little thing. Laces tight. You could bounce a coin off that anticipatory tension. Fields, flowers, fumbling. Delicious. I did what I do. I sat. I fed. I seasoned it with desire because I’m not a monster.” She tilted her head. “All the way.” First Love groaned softly into his sleeve. “Jurisdiction,” the clerk muttered to himself, underlining the word five times for no one to see. Dream listened. His face revealed the weary anger of an architect compelled to arbitrate over a scuffed hallway carpet. “You claim right of harvest,” he said. “I claim the open window,” Mora said. “He made himself a stage.” She flicked her eyes to First Love. “He put a body on another body without a script. The body is heavy. It breathes. It smells. It confuses. There’s an invitation in that. He left a plate on the counter and wrote my name on it in lip gloss.” First Love blinked furiously. “It was a kiss! An almost-kiss! You are not invited to everyone’s first almost-kiss.” Mora’s smile deepened. “You never did appreciate what else that moment holds. I’m not the villain. I’m the gravity.” The bailiff cleared his nonexistent throat. “Call the witness… MAX-AX-AX-AX-AX.” From the side door shuffled a boy with bedhead and a superhero T-shirt. His sneakers weren’t tied. Dream’s shadow flared and recoiled as the child approached the stand, for children bring their own darkness. Max rubbed his nose and glared at everything equally. “State your name for the record,” sighed the clerk. “Max.” “Maxwell?” prompted the bailiff. “Max.” “Very well. Maximus.” The bailiff sounded pleased with himself. Somewhere in the rafters, a spider facepalmed. Dream leaned forward slightly. Rain in deserts sensed it. “Max,” he said, voice a lullaby that could smother. “Tell me about your dream.” Max shrugged, then remembered he was on a stand and tried to shrug like it meant nothing. “It’s dumb. We’re in the field behind the school. It smells like gym socks and flowers. She laughs at something I say that wasn’t funny. It’s good. I don’t know. Then she’s… she’s on me and I can’t move. It’s like when your cat sits on you but the cat is your homework. It’s—” He swallowed. “It’s scary. Also… not. My stomach does the… roller coaster thing. I wake up and my mouth feels like pennies and my chest hurts and I don’t wanna go to school but I kinda do.” First Love stared at his shoes. Mora rested her chin on her knuckles and looked tender for half a blink. Dream’s irritation lifted and then fell again, like the wingbeat of a bat. “Do you wish to be rid of it?” Dream asked. Max scowled. “I don’t wish anything. If I wish, it changes and then it’s dumb. And I don’t wanna tell my mom.” He thought. “Can you… not make it be about… dying? But also not make it, like, boring? ‘Cause if it’s boring I’ll just dream about teeth falling out again and that’s worse.” The court considered this practical theology. “No further questions,” First Love murmured. “I mean, if that’s okay.” Mora spread her hands. “Child’s got taste.” “Defense’s witness?” the clerk prompted lazily. Mora gestured, and shapes swam up from under the floor: night terrors, nervous giggles, that feeling when you think someone called your name and no one did. “I could parade a hundred sleepers whose hearts I’ve tickled into beating properly. Fear teaches caution. Appetites are real. You all take your cuts—” she nodded at First Love, at the smug cherub of Nostalgia dozing in the back row, at a crone with a satchel labeled Grief—“and when I take mine it’s a scandal.” First Love lifted his chin. “We’re not in dispute about your right to exist. We’re disputing your right to sit on his chest during The Moment.” “The Moment,” Mora repeated, amused. “Is that your title? Do you capitalize it when you write it in your little diary?” “It’s a rolodex,” First Love muttered. The bailiff rumbled, overpronouncing gravity itself. “Closing statements from Fur Sloth and More—AHHH.” Dream raised a pale palm. Silence fell like fresh snow. “Enough,” he said. “You will both kindly recall that this is not a market stall. You squabble in a court where empires have begged for smaller nightmares.” He looked at Max, then at the confusion braided through him, then at the path First Love had laid so neatly, then at the havoc Mora trailed like perfume. The irritation in him sharpened to something that might almost be mischief. “I will render judgment,” Dream said, and all things held their breath. “Mora,” he continued, “you trespassed into a constructed scene under the care of a recognized artisan. The invitation you claim was ambiguous. You may not squat on ambiguity like a toad on a lily pad and call it yours.” Mora’s mouth twitched. “I heard ‘squat’ and felt seen.” “Nevertheless,” Dream went on, “you remind this court that bodies weigh, and that confusion is not solely gentle. On certain nights, fear is educational. On others, it is theft.” He turned to First Love. “You made a meadow and forgot the ants. You set a blush upon a face and forgot that a blush is a heat.” First Love opened his mouth, closed it, nodded. “So,” said Dream, in that voice that maps realities. “Mora is enjoined from feeding upon Max during The Moment in the field of wildflowers. She may observe from the hedgerow. If she must sit upon a chest, she will do so later, upon nights designated by me when the dream turns to other lessons.” Mora hissed softly, but it was respectful, like steam from bread. “Define ‘observe,’ Yourness.” “You may hover,” Dream said, with the faintest quirk at the edge of his mouth. “You may loom. You may roll your eyes. You may not pin, press, or drink. If you must suffocate something, suffocate a metaphor.” “Fine,” she said. “But I’m bringing a snack.” “First Love,” Dream said, “you will complicate your meadow. There will be gnats. The girl will sneeze. The kiss will remain almost, but there will be the weight of a forearm wrongly placed, the heat of a summer day, the embarrassment that follows. You will not counterfeit ease. You will respect the body’s insistences.” First Love nodded eagerly, already pulling out his pencil, already scribbling gnats with penitential fervor. “Max,” said Dream, and the boy flinched even though he had heard his name said quietly. “When you wake, you will remember both. The sweetness and the fear. You will decide nothing. It is not time to decide. But later, when you are older and a cat sits on your chest and you cannot breathe—” He paused, reconsidered the domesticity. “When someone’s arm is heavy on you, you will think: I know this. And you will negotiate. And that is a better lesson than never having been pressed at all.” Max’s face did an expression like a shrug learning how to smile. “Okay,” he said. “Can she—” He jerked his chin at Mora. “—not make the mouth thing happen? It’s gross.” Mora sighed like curtains. “I’ll keep my face on,” she said. “Happy?” He made the face that said: don’t push it. Dream settled back. “One more thing,” he said. The court tightened. Mischief reached up a pale hand from under his judgments and tugged. “On a single night of my choosing, neither of you will enter Max’s dream. He will stand alone in his meadow and realize nothing happens unless he chooses it. He may pick a flower. He may walk away. He may trip over his own feet. The dream will remember.” First Love paled. Mora’s eyebrows went up. The clerk made a small note that read: precedent, ugh. The bailiff boomed, “So ruled by the Lord of Nightmares and Nice Things.” Dream’s look chilled the word nice into something with teeth. “Adjourned,” he said. The court dissolved like a yawn. Mora sashayed close as shadows drew away, bending low enough that her hair brushed the edge of Dream’s bench. “You’re getting soft,” she murmured, amused. Dream regarded her with the impassivity of a coffin lid. “And you,” he said, “are getting sentimental.” His eyes flicked to Max, who was kicking at a dream pebble with his dream shoe. “Try not to trip him on the stairs.” “No promises,” she sang, and vanished into the folds of the next sleeper’s blanket. First Love shuffled up, clutching his clipboard. “Thank you,” he said, not meeting Dream’s eye. “I’ll, um. I’ll add gnats.” “Add also the taste of apple skin,” Dream said, almost absentmindedly. “He will remember the bitter under the sweet.” First Love smiled, not entirely tragically, and left smelling of pencil shavings and nerves. Max remained, briefly. “Are you gonna, like, check on me?” he asked the emptying throne. Dream looked down at the boy’s scuffed shoes, at the cowlick that defied the night itself. “Always,” he said, and meant it the way weather means to happen. “Cool,” Max said. “Don’t be weird.” Dream’s expression almost moved. “I will try,” he said, which in his mouth could be a joke. The bailiff, forgetting himself, intoned, “Court is… asleep.” Then, realizing, corrected, “Adjourned!” Somewhere, a sunrise was late by a minute while the world waited to see whether Dream would smile. He did not. But he did allow himself, as the candles died into clean dark, the ghost of it. Then he stood, irritation neatly shelved, mischief humming, and went to set a night aside for no witnesses at all.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkable achievement in dark fantasy with comedic elements. The author has created a fully realized Court of the Dreaming with Dream (clearly inspired by Neil Gaiman's Sandman) presiding over a territorial dispute between First Love and Mora, a Slavic nightmare spirit. The writing excels at establishing a unique atmosphere that balances the fantastical with the mundane. The courtroom setting provides a familiar framework that grounds the surreal elements, creating effective comedy through the juxtaposition of legal proceedings with dream logic. The bailiff's booming voice that echoes and distorts names is a particularly clever touch that maintains the otherworldly quality while adding humor. Character development is exceptional. Dream is portrayed with appropriate gravitas and subtle irritation, maintaining his enigmatic nature while showing hints of mischief. Mora is delightfully unapologetic and pragmatic about her nature, with lines like "a girl's gotta eat too" and "I'm not the villain. I'm the gravity" revealing her complexity. First Love is endearingly awkward with his "cardigan knit from blushes" and clipboard of paper hearts. Even Max, the human at the center of the dispute, has a distinct voice and personality. The prose strikes an excellent balance between poetic and functional. Descriptions like "Dream sat in sable, hair like spilled ink across his shoulders" and "his expression was a mask of patience with the lacquer sanded thin" create vivid imagery without becoming overwrought. The author knows when to deploy metaphor and when to be direct. Dialogue is consistently strong, with each character having a distinct voice. Dream speaks with authority and economy, Mora with casual confidence, First Love with hesitation and earnestness, and Max with the blunt practicality of a child. The exchanges between characters reveal their motivations and relationships naturally. The resolution is particularly satisfying, with Dream finding a compromise that acknowledges the value in both First Love's gentle confusion and Mora's introduction of fear and weight. His final judgment shows wisdom and nuance, recognizing that both experiences have value in Max's development. The piece does occasionally risk becoming too clever for its own good, with some metaphors that might be a bit strained ("a book that wrote itself as he touched it. The words flowed across the pages like spilled soda: awkward, heartfelt, sticky"). However, these moments are rare and generally work within the dreamlike context. The ending avoids sentimentality while still providing emotional resolution. Dream's "Always" in response to Max's question about checking on him is a perfect note of understated care, and Max's "Don't be weird" brings a final touch of humor that grounds the fantastical proceedings. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that successfully blends dark fantasy, comedy, and emotional depth while maintaining a consistent tone and voice throughout. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Blood Moon — Score: 92.8
Prompt:
Blood Moon Alucard & Yennefer Write a story where Alucard (Hellsing) encounters Yennefer (The Witcher) in medieval Europe. Yennefer's magical abilities intrigue the vampire, while she's both repulsed and fascinated by his monstrous nature. Their power dynamic shifts constantly as they circle each other, neither willing to show weakness first. **Alucard (Hellsing)** Alucard is an ancient, immensely powerful vampire who works for the Hellsing Organization. He can regenerate from almost any wound and shape-shift at will. He's sadistic, arrogant, and takes pleasure in toying with his enemies before killing them. Despite being a monster, he despises weak vampires who can't accept their nature. He wears a distinctive red coat, wide-brimmed hat, and orange sunglasses. He uses massive handguns loaded with silver bullets. He seeks worthy opponents who can challenge him and potentially end his immortal existence. Famous quote: "The bird of Hermes is my name, eating my wings to make me tame." **Yennefer of Vengerberg (The Witcher)** Yennefer is a powerful sorceress who magically altered her appearance to hide her congenital hunchback. She's ambitious, stubborn, and manipulative when necessary. She has violet eyes and smells of lilac and gooseberries. Despite her cold exterior, she desperately wants to reverse her infertility caused by magical transformation. She's centuries old but appears young. She's politically savvy and refuses to be underestimated. She has a sarcastic sense of humor and little patience for fools. Though she rarely shows it, she's capable of deep love and loyalty. Famous quote: "I'm not sweet and I'm not a maiden in distress in need of saving." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The wolves start the choir long before the moon clears the rib-cage of clouds. Irregular, off-time howls braid the dusk, some near, most far, a fractured harmony on the borderland of a ruined village. Roofs slump like broken shoulders; a church steeple rises, stiff as a finger, pointing at the blood-red moon making its slow ascent. Wind drags ash and the faint scent of lilac and gooseberries through alleyways littered with bones too old to answer to grief. He arrives as a shadow that walks like a man. Red coat loose, hat brim cutting his face into slashes of pale and darker pale, orange lenses turning the moon to wine in their reflection. He whistles under his breath, a jaunty nothing that gets eaten by the ruins. When the wolves sing again, he smiles as if their discord were the punchline to a very private joke. The ground remembers his weight; it remembers others too—ghouls that puffed to smoke beneath his heel, a priest that crawled toward the cross and found only splinters. The air wavers. He stops. The tremor is not heat—it's intention. The space between two broken walls gathers, pinches, and folds until it becomes a doorway like a wound in the night. Violet light threads its edges. She steps through in a slow, deliberate unfurling of limbs and black hair, the scent sharpening as though every flower in a forgotten garden opens at once and then, just as quickly, shutters. A starched collar, a dark dress that fits like a threat, a glint of obsidian at her throat. Her eyes are amethysts set into a face that does not belong to human weathering. “Mm,” Alucard says, a hum that hangs like a hook. “The bird of Hermes is my name, eating my wings to make me tame.” “Quoting alchemical riddles to impress a sorceress?” Yennefer’s voice is as precise as a scalpel and as bored as a queen's at her tenth petition. “How quaint.” Her gaze flicks to the wolves’ horizon, then back to him. “You stink of old blood and older pride.” “And you of lilac and gooseberries. A charming deception for what lies beneath.” He tips his hat in acknowledgement or mockery. “You tore a hole through places to come here. Why this graveyard of houses?” “Because holes are useful. And because something that was not a man once slaughtered its way through this village.” She considers the smear of darkness that was the church. “I wondered if it was still hungry.” Alucard’s smile sharpened into teeth he does not yet show. “It is always hungry. But it learned to savor. You were curious.” He lifts one of the massive handguns; the moon finds his bullet's silver like a friend. “How delightful. Curiosity makes such pretty screams. Come closer.” Yennefer doesn’t move. She folds her arms, one hand curling against the opposite elbow, a posture that reads as idle until you notice how the air tightens to hold her. “I’m not sweet and I’m not a maiden in distress in need of saving,” she says, lazily. “If we cross purposes, I will put you down.” “Promises.” He steps forward; the dirt softens, and the shadows at the hem of his coat drag like wet velvet. “Do you know what you’re speaking to?” “Yes.” Her violet eyes sharpen like knives at a throat. “An old thing given a human name to trick it into a service. A leash disguised as a creed. A dog that learned to enjoy its collar.” He laughs, and it breaks a shutter somewhere. “Hellsing’s dog,” he concedes, with a bow that almost scrapes the ground. “It learned, too, that leashes can be chains and chains can be rosaries. My masters pray and I hunt. Are you another priestess, little witch? Will you anoint me?” Her mouth quirks. “If I lay hands on you, it won’t be to bless you.” Lightning traces the bones of her fingers, blue-white and small as hair, betraying her restraint. The irregular chorus of wolves cuts, and for a breath the only sound is wind. Then one, far away, howls to break the silence again, and the dissonance returns like a heartbeat with arrhythmia. The air folds again. His hand is empty of gun and full of the thin throat of a shattered pew, his other hand clasped behind his back as if at a courtly dance. The pew becomes a stake as he steps and throws, and at the same time the ground under her feet softens, guttering into a mire of shadow hands reaching. The stake slashes the air where she had been. She is not there. She is three strides to the left and three heartbeats younger. She is also above him, perched for a flicker on the fractured steeple, dress whispering. She is also ringed in violet fire, a false afterimage she leaves like a shed skin. He catches one, and it smokes, real enough to burn the flesh of his palm before the fire eats it down to bones. The bones knit themselves back with gleeful obscenity. He licks the soot and laughs. “The tricks you do,” he says. Bullets whisper out, silver signatures that split air into lines that do not exist before he draws them. One hits her—no, hits the air and becomes a flock of birds, their wings cut out of night, scattering with a sound like embroidered thunder. “Do you always play with your food?” she asks, breathless now, amused and irritated in equal measure. She throws a hand down, palm angled; the ground churns, not with shadow hands but with a flash-freeze that crystallizes the earth itself, frost racing like a contagion. The cold bites, and for a heartbeat his steps catch. “Only with the pretty ones.” He disassembles, dissolves; he is a swarm, a storm of bats that either were always there or will only ever be. They knife through violet shields, their edges frost-brittled and painterly. Her hair stands a fraction as magic flares with a voice like a choir singing backward. A circle burns at her feet, the runes a language that hates him, and the bats crackle to ash where they touch it. He reassembles, two paces inside that circle. “Naughty,” he says. “You thought you could keep me outside your little hearth-fire.” Yennefer’s knife is a thought that became steel because she was annoyed, and it is in her hand as it is at his throat and then it is not. Blinding light flares; a column of raw force drives him backward through a wall. Brick makes a sound like teeth. He walks out of debris, dust trickling down the slope of his hat brim, drawing back a mouth that has too many ideas in it about what a mouth should be. “How tiresome.” She pushes a strand of hair behind her ear and lifts her chin. “I’ve faced fiends, djinns, men who thought they owned the continent. You’re just another monster with delusions of philosophy.” “And you’re a child who taught herself to walk like a queen and slit the throats of the words that named you cripple.” He’s beside her, holding her wrist, and then he is not when the wards she pinned to her skin jolt like thunder. His hand smokes; he laughs through it. For a while, conversation is the exchange of punishments. He fires; she folds space so the bullets arrive in the stone behind her and keep going until the village’s skeleton shakes to the rattling of ricochet ghosts. She conjures ropes of light that try to bind him like a promise; he slips them and revisits her with shadows that pull like gravity. He is mist and crows and a man with a gun, and she is ice and fire and air that suddenly clenches, painful pressure like diving too deep. “You want to die,” she observes at last, panting, a thin hairline crack of exertion in her voice. Frost beads her lashes, melts, and slides. “You’re looking for an opponent. How pathetic.” “You want to live.” His glasses are gone. The eyes beneath are suns drowned in blood, pupils thin as wounds. “You play at politics and immortality while your womb is a grave. How pathetic.” They both hesitate, one instant. The wind knifes cold. The wolves’ howl braids in again, all wrong, like someone learning a song by ear and getting the tune almost right. Her temper makes a small noise. She lifts her hand, palm open, and the ruin of the church fills with heat—heat that is not fire but raw conversion, transmutation of air to the idea of summer. The moon curdles, dimmed a shade. “Do not,” she warns, and the warning is a thread pulled taut over a void. “Do not speak of that.” “And if I do?” He steps into the heat and opens his coat as if daring it to find a heart. He burns, and the burning is fast and bright and ends with skin smooth as wine. The living shadow at his feet shivers and mutters to itself. “Will you show me you have one?” She breathes in sharply, and in that inhalation he sees the architecture of centuries—the refusal to bow to the school that should’ve eaten her, the bone-deep scorn for nobles’ games, the quiet, vicious love that fits nowhere but still fills her pockets. It makes him laugh again, sudden and genuine. “I see why men follow you,” he admits. “You’re a tyrant, little witch. You bend crowns the way others bend spoons.” “The way you bend kneecaps.” She smiles, and the violence of it is elegant. “The difference is that mine stay bent when I’m done.” “Perhaps,” he says. He holsters one pistol with a click like a guillotine. The other remains, a suggestion of sincerity. “I didn’t kill you when I could have.” Her gaze flicks to the gun and back, unblinking. “I could have turned your insides out and made a very pretty mural.” A beat. “But I’m not bored enough for trophies.” They circle, and the circling is the dance itself, a ritual of predator courtesy. He steps into her orbit, hat tilted, mouth amused. She steps out, half a quarter turn, skirts brushing rubble. The moon climbs, fattening as if with blood, and the wolves’ chorus keeps its irregular rhythm like a heart learning and failing to learn how to beat. “You work for a house,” she says. “They tell you where to unleash yourself. Do they know where you are?” “They always know, eventually,” he replies. “And then they pretend they ordered me here because it satisfies them to pretend they rule the storm.” He regards the horizon, as if he could taste London in the smoky twilight. “And you? What king or academy owns your leash today?” Her silence is shaped like contempt. “I cut mine years ago.” “And yet.” He points to the fissure in the air through which she came, still shivering slightly where space hates to be wounded. “You answer to necessity.” “We all do.” She tilts her head. “Even you. Especially you.” He bows, too deep to be polite, not deep enough to be sincere. “Come find me when necessity is hunger.” He turns, the coat’s hem trailing newly gathered darkness. “Or when you’re bored.” “I’m not sweet,” she says again, because it pleases her to define the terms. “Nor am I tame,” he answers, and something like satisfaction drags through the words. “The bird of Hermes is my name.” She watches him fade, not into invisibility but into irrelevance, the way night eats a reflected face on a window. The wind picks up, a spectral applause. Her nostrils flare; she tastes iron, ash, and a thread of something that is almost laughter. Her hand lifts, fingers drawing a sign in the air that neither blesses nor curses. The violet lines seal, and the air sighs around the wound as if relieved. The wolves retune, found by some unseen conductor; their calls converge at last into a shivering, proper chorus. Yennefer turns on her heel and disappears, leaving the ruins and the scent of lilac and gooseberries to argue with the cold. The moon climbs on. The village settles. Somewhere, far away, something that is not a man smiles with all its teeth, and a sorceress counts the dukes who will beg and the monsters she will not fear, and the night opens its mouth wider to swallow what comes next. Neither of them will show weakness first. It isn’t in their names. It isn’t in their bones. And the wolves, insistent, keep time to a rhythm older and hungrier than either of them, drumming the blood-right of the dark into the world.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a masterful character study that pits two powerful beings against each other in a dance of power, wit, and vulnerability. The author has created a rich, atmospheric encounter between Alucard and Yennefer that honors both characters' established personalities while exploring new dimensions through their interaction. The prose is exceptional, with a poetic quality that never sacrifices clarity. The author employs vivid imagery that creates a haunting medieval setting with the ruined village, blood moon, and howling wolves providing the perfect backdrop for this supernatural confrontation. Descriptions like "Red coat loose, hat brim cutting his face into slashes of pale and darker pale" and "Her eyes are amethysts set into a face that does not belong to human weathering" efficiently establish character while building atmosphere. The dialogue is particularly strong, capturing both characters' distinctive voices. Alucard's theatrical arrogance and Yennefer's cutting wit come through authentically. Their verbal sparring reveals character while advancing the narrative tension. Lines like "You're a tyrant, little witch. You bend crowns the way others bend spoons" and "I'm not bored enough for trophies" perfectly encapsulate their personalities. The author demonstrates exceptional skill in portraying the power dynamic between these characters. Neither gains a clear upper hand, with the balance of power constantly shifting through their physical and verbal confrontation. The fight sequence is choreographed with imagination and precision, avoiding typical action clichés in favor of surreal, character-specific abilities. Most impressively, the author reveals deeper vulnerabilities in both characters without diminishing their power. Alucard's death wish and Yennefer's infertility are touched upon with subtlety and respect, adding emotional complexity to what could have been a simple battle of monsters. The pacing is excellent, with the tension building naturally through their encounter. The ending avoids resolution in favor of a tantalizing suggestion of future meetings, which feels appropriate for these immortal beings. If there's any criticism to be made, it might be that some passages verge on purple prose, with occasionally overwrought metaphors. However, this stylistic choice largely suits the gothic, supernatural tone of the piece. A few sentences could be tightened for clarity without losing their poetic quality. Overall, this is an exceptional piece of character-driven fiction that succeeds on multiple levels: as fan service for those familiar with the characters, as an engaging standalone story, and as a showcase for sophisticated prose craftsmanship. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 20 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 20.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Prison Strings — Score: 86.8
Prompt:
Prison Strings Jolyne Cujoh & Makima Write a story where Jolyne Cujoh (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure) and Makima (Chainsaw Man) cross paths at a supernatural prison facility. Jolyne is immediately suspicious of Makima's falsely sweet demeanor, while Makima is intrigued by Jolyne's Stand ability. Their battle of wits escalates dangerously as Jolyne realizes how manipulative Makima truly is. **Jolyne Cujoh (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure)** Jolyne is the daughter of Jotaro Kujo and the first female JoJo protagonist. Her Stand, Stone Free, allows her to unravel her body into string that she can control. She's hot-headed, foul-mouthed, and doesn't take disrespect from anyone. She was framed for murder and sent to prison. She has a distinctive butterfly tattoo on her arm and wears her hair in two buns. Despite her tough exterior, she's deeply loyal to her friends and family. She can be impulsive but is highly adaptable in battle. She inherited her father's ability to stay cool under pressure but is more emotionally expressive. Famous quote: "If there's no Mickey, this shit ain't Disney!" **Makima (Chainsaw Man)** Makima appears as a young woman with auburn hair and ringed yellow eyes. She's the Control Devil who can dominate anyone she considers beneath her (nearly everyone). She maintains a pleasant, soft-spoken demeanor that masks her manipulative, cold nature. She can create contracts with humans and devils, often exploiting their desires. She's obsessed with Chainsaw Man and wants to control him. She keeps numerous people and devils as pets on leashes. She's practically immortal due to a contract with the Prime Minister. She views humans as lesser beings but mimics human emotions perfectly. Famous quote: "It's okay. Dogs are supposed to die for their owners." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The rumor starts before Jolyne ever sees the woman: that the new liaison from some government bureau walks past and cameras blink, shutters hiccup, footage turns to snow. That the guards stop asking for paperwork around her the way dogs forget they’re dogs when they see raw steak. The rumor sits wrong in Jolyne’s gut like cafeteria meatloaf. Stone Free hums in the lines of her fingers as she wipes a bead of sweat from her temple. The prison is new concrete and old ghosts, a secret facility buried under layers of legitimate detention, built to house the unhouseable: stands that whisper to their users, devils who agree to contracts in exchange for flesh. The barbed wire is decorative. The real fences are the sigils stamped into the hallways—the algorithms scrawled in chalk that guard the stairwells. Jolyne adjusts her bun with a flick. The butterfly tattoo on her arm flares as she flexes. She’s been here long enough to learn which guards to bribe and which to avoid, long enough to know that the strange happens on a schedule. Long enough to know the schedule is about to be broken. Makima arrives like a sighed secret. She wears a crisp white shirt and a black tie that never wrinkles, black slacks that never gather dust. Her auburn hair is tied neatly, her yellow eyes ringed like a storm viewed from far above. She walks down the D-Block corridor, and as she passes, the fluorescent lights flicker like they’re blinking for her. The cameras above their heads click. They whir. They stop. Jolyne notices. Of course she notices. She’s been counting the second hand in her head, measuring the frames between blinks. She leans against the concrete pillar at the junction, casual as a cat, hands in pockets, looking like she belongs even when she doesn’t. Makima stops, as if she knew Jolyne would be there, as if this moment is a conversation she planned three weeks ago that’s finally arrived exactly on time. “Cujoh Jolyne,” Makima says. Her voice is soft and unhurried, like a balm that hasn’t been applied yet. “I’ve heard of you.” Jolyne snorts. “Yeah? Did the cameras tell you?” She tips her chin at the dead black eye of the nearest lens. “Because I think you broke their hearts.” Makima smiles, small and professional. “Sometimes electronics are unreliable. People, too.” She steps closer. The guards behind her don’t breathe wrong. The warden, usually a blustering idiot with a jaw like a bulldog, stands three paces away with a blankness behind his eyes that makes Jolyne’s skin itch. She can feel Stone Free tugging in her chest, like a cat arching its back, claws unsheathed. “You’re the liaison,” Jolyne says. “The one who can make anyone sit, roll over, and play dead.” Makima’s head tilts an imperceptible fraction. “When people obey, it’s because they want to.” Jolyne bares her teeth in something that isn’t a smile. “Bullshit. I’ve seen want. I’ve seen what it looks like when someone wants and still says no.” There’s a heartbeat where she sees her father’s face—a stern line of mouth, eyes that held an ocean of things he’d never say. “What do you want?” “To keep order,” Makima says. “To protect humanity from forces it’s not equipped to handle.” She says it like a prayer, or a sales pitch, and Jolyne hears the emptiness tucked neatly inside the words. “Protect who from what?” Jolyne asks. “Because last I checked, you people like your lines scratched on the floor. Safety on one side, monsters on the other, and nobody’s allowed to remember which side they’re standing on.” “I’m not your enemy, Jolyne,” Makima says. “I’m fascinated.” Jolyne has heard a hundred versions of that sentence from guards and priests and scientists who wanted to turn her bones into notes in a clipboard. It never landed like this. Makima isn’t watching a person. She’s watching a mechanism she wants to take apart and put back together so that it clicks the way she thinks it should. Makima’s gaze flicks to Jolyne’s hands. “Your Stand is unusual. You become string. You extend yourself. You pull yourself taut. It’s rare to see will expressed so elegantly.” “You talk like a manual, you know that?” Jolyne says. “You wanna see how elegant I get when someone tries to yank me like a leash?” Makima’s smile softens, an actress settling into a role. She could sell you the idea that cages are useful. She could sell you the idea that she loves you while she buckles the collar closed. “Jolyne,” she says, like they’re old friends. “Come with me. I want to show you something.” The air changes when Makima says it. It gets thinner, like Jolyne climbed a mountain she didn’t remember climbing. There’s pressure behind her cheekbones. There’s a sensation like a hand closing gently around the back of her neck. Stone Free’s strings shiver. Jolyne feels an urge to take a step forward that isn’t hers. A practiced reflex snaps into place. Her fingers flick, and the skin of her forearm unspools—bright, blue, fine as fishing line but impossibly strong—wrapping with a whip-crack around the metal railing behind her. The string anchors her like a piton hammered into a cliff face. “Don’t,” Jolyne says through her teeth. “Don’t you dare try to make me heel.” The warden makes a small, strangled sound, like a dog yanked back on a choker chain. Makima’s gaze slides to the invisible thread glued to Jolyne’s spine. She lifts one eyebrow, curious. “Interesting,” she says. “You’re resisting.” “Damn right,” Jolyne says. “If there’s no Mickey, this shit ain’t Disney.” Makima laughs softly. It’s pleasant. It’s reaction without emotion. “You’re brave,” she says. “Bravery is charming. It makes people beautiful, just before they break.” “You’re used to people breaking for you,” Jolyne says. “People who want something so bad they’ll trade their names for it. I’ve made bad trades, lady, but I learned my lesson.” Makima steps closer. The cameras above them judder, then cut, the red indicator lights snuffing like fireflies crushed between fingers. The hallway empties itself of sound. It feels like the world has cupped them in its hands. “I can give you things,” Makima says. “I can give you your father. I can give you a world where he isn’t a ghost locked up in a quiet house behind a silent face. I can give you freedom in a way a Stand never could.” Jolyne’s heartbeat stumbles. There’s a slice of ache under her ribs she keeps in a jar and only opens when she wants to remind herself she can still bleed. “You don’t know anything about my father,” she says. It comes out softer than she wants. Makima doesn’t blink. “I know what men like him look like when they’re ground between duty and love. I know what girls like you look like when you learn to make rope from your own skin because no one else will throw you a line.” Jolyne’s hand tightens. The string around the railing creaks. There’s a sound like paper tearing when she pulls herself upright on the cord and steps past Makima instead of toward her. Not away—but sideways. She has learned there are always angles. “Show me,” Jolyne says. “If what you’ve got is worth my time, show me. But you don’t get a collar on me.” “As you like,” Makima says, and they walk. The facility is a labyrinth of concrete and quiet. Makima leads with her hands folded neatly at the small of her back, not looking at the doors they pass and yet knowing which will open for her and which will not. Behind one glass wall, a man whose skin is a map of bite scars prays without sound to something that has never answered. Behind another, a girl with eyes like black pearls hums a melody that makes Jolyne’s teeth hurt, strings in her fingers vibrating sympathetically. They stop at a room that looks like an operating theater stripped to bone. Surgical lights hang like moons over an empty gurney. On the far wall, a chalk circle etched with symbols that feel like tiny hands scraping the underside of Jolyne’s skull. Makima steps into the room without hesitation. “Contracts are exchanges,” she says. “People want, devils want. I bring them together. I ask for obedience, and they give it, because they want the world to make sense. You, Jolyne—you want to be strong enough to protect the people you love. I can help you.” “By what? Putting a leash on me and calling it a seatbelt?” Jolyne asks. “You think you know how strings work? Strings cut if you pull them wrong.” Makima turns in a slow circle, looking up at the lights, the chalk, the air itself. “Experiments will be conducted here. Safely. With consent.” She looks at Jolyne with those yellow eyes, the rings in them tightening. “I would like to make a contract with you.” Jolyne barks a laugh. “You want me to sign away what, exactly?” “Not sign,” Makima says. “Agree. The word is stronger than ink.” Silence expands. Jolyne can feel the shape of Makima’s power pressing outward. It’s not just hypnosis. It is the kind of authority that you accept because it’s easier than being the person who says no to a crowd. It’s a tide that you mistake for the sea itself. “I’ve been in cages before,” Jolyne says quietly. “I know what lies sound like when they sound like kindness.” Makima’s lashes flutter. For a heartbeat, something like interest flares bright and hot in her gaze. “I’m not lying,” she says, and the thing about it is she believes herself. Jolyne can do sincerity too. She wires the room. She unravels from elbow to wrist, from shoulder to hip, deploying a hair-thin net that threads through vents and around corners, sticks to the seams of the door, licks across the back of the warden’s neck like a threat. She anchors lines to the cameras, slipping a thread into their tiny gears, jerking—softly—and hearing the motor whine like an animal in pain. Her strings taste the people in the corridor—the guards, whose pulses are a little too slow, the girl with the pearl eyes, humming a note of longing, the man praying, the breath that shudders when Makima’s shadow passes him. “Here’s my contract,” Jolyne says. “You tell me why the cameras die when you walk past. You tell me what you did to the warden. You tell me what you want so bad it makes you chew through your own chain, and then maybe I’ll decide if I give a single damn.” Makima watches her string thread a seam of the room like a seamstress tightening a bodice. Her smile is still polite. “I don’t make cameras malfunction,” she says. “They choose, in my presence, to stop. People do, too, sometimes. They choose to listen. The warden chooses to trust. He understands that I am necessary.” “He’s a puppet,” Jolyne says. “You’re holding the crossbar.” “The world is easier if everyone pulls in the same direction,” Makima says. “You understand that. Your Stone Free wants to be a rope, a cable, a line thrown from you to them, and you want to pull the ones you love back to you when they slip.” It’s true. It’s why Jolyne’s lips go white. “What I want,” Makima continues, “is a world where we don’t have to be afraid anymore. A world where Chainsaw Man belongs to me so I can use him to cut away the parts of existence that hurt. Death. War. Hunger. Fear. I will make it better. I will control it until it stops.” “You want a world on a leash,” Jolyne says. “You want puppies that don’t piss on the floor. You want people to die for you when you whistle. You want to act like you’re doing us a favor when you open your hand and we step into your palm. It’s okay, right? Dogs are supposed to die for their owners.” Makima’s smile is a needle. “Yes,” she says simply. The honest answer hits harder than any lie. Jolyne breathes in slowly through her nose. It smells like sterilized instruments and salt and the electric tang of her own string threaded through the world. She remembers her father’s hand on her shoulder—heavy, anchoring—and her mother’s voice, and Hermes’ laugh, and F.F. saying something that’s almost human. She knows what it is to die for somebody. She knows what it is to live for them. “You’re not going to get me to heel,” Jolyne says. “You’re going to have to get used to that, sweetheart.” Makima steps forward, just one step. The room seems to lean toward her. “I don’t have to get used to anything,” she says. “If you oppose me, Jolyne, you will die. Dogs die. Humans die. It happens. But you’re not a dog. You’re interesting.” The compliment is a leash thrown gently over a neck. Jolyne yanks. The string tight around the door’s hinges pulls, and the door slams shut with a clang that reverberates through the bones. The chalk circle on the far wall tears as a filament slices it, and the lights above them pop, one by one, until the room is lit only by emergency strips—thin, wet-looking lines along the floor. Makima’s head turns toward the ruined circle. Her smile doesn’t fade. “You’re impulsive,” she says. “You’d be a delightful pet if you learned your place.” Jolyne spits on the floor. “You keep trying to say place like it’s somewhere I have to stand still,” she says. “News flash: I move.” She does. She throws her strings out like a net, and Stone Free pulls her sideways, up, impossibly agile in a room designed to make people animals. Makima doesn’t move. She doesn’t need to. She looks up, and for a second Jolyne feels the urge again—the urge to stop, to obey, to let her feet find the spot on the floor where the leash would be the least painful. She bites the inside of her cheek until she tastes iron. Her string tightens around her wrist hard enough to bruise. She uses pain the way Makima uses kindness—as a tool, as a wedge. Stone Free hums through her blood. She lands behind Makima. She could wrap. She could choke. She could test, here, whether her string can bind something as polite and monstrous as this. Makima doesn’t turn. “If you try to touch me, you’ll regret it,” she says conversationally. “Lady,” Jolyne says, all her teeth, “I’ve regretted things since I was born.” They hang there for a breath. A battle of wits sharpens on the edge of a blade that hasn’t been drawn yet. Makima is the eye of a storm, and Jolyne is a wire vibrating with too much wind, singing with it. “I’ll be around,” Makima says finally, as if Jolyne agreed to a schedule she didn’t know was being made. “When you’re ready to talk about contracts.” Jolyne snorts. “When I want to talk about cutting strings, I’ll let you know.” Makima walks to the door. Without asking, without touching, the lock opens. The guards outside don’t look up. The cameras flicker as she passes, a shudder of metal and code yielding in the presence of something no algorithm can explain. She is gone. The room breathes again. Jolyne sags, then straightens, rolling her shoulders until her joints pop. Her strings retract, skin knitting, the embedded fibers of Stone Free tucking themselves back into bone and muscle. She rubs her mouth with the back of her hand. The rumor feels different now that it has a face. The cameras aren’t broken. They’re obedient. “Yeah,” Jolyne mutters, to the empty room and the closed circle and the hum of her Stand. “Try me.” She steps back into the corridor, where the lights buzz like flies, where the warden blinks awake with a frown and no memory. The facility’s heartbeat resumes, like nothing happened. Jolyne knows better. She walks, and the world doesn’t notice it’s wrapped, just a little, in her string. She’ll pay attention. She’ll be ready. If the dog wants to make a collar out of kindness, Jolyne will show her what happens when kindness frays. And somewhere, down another corridor, Makima smiles a small, private smile as a camera fails to record it.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece effectively captures the confrontation between Jolyne Cujoh and Makima, creating a tense psychological battle that showcases both characters' abilities and personalities. The writer demonstrates a strong understanding of both source materials, weaving together the distinctive traits of each character while maintaining the supernatural prison setting requested. The characterization is particularly strong. Jolyne's rebellious nature, foul mouth, and fierce independence are well-portrayed through both her actions and dialogue. Her famous quote is naturally incorporated. Similarly, Makima's falsely sweet demeanor, manipulative nature, and view of humans as lesser beings come through clearly. The writer captures her soft-spoken yet menacing presence effectively. The prose style is generally strong, with vivid imagery that establishes the prison's atmosphere. Descriptions like "The prison is new concrete and old ghosts" and "The barbed wire is decorative. The real fences are the sigils stamped into the hallways" create a compelling setting. The writer uses metaphor effectively throughout, particularly when describing Makima's control abilities as a tide "that you mistake for the sea itself." The dialogue serves the story well, revealing character and advancing the plot. Jolyne's coarse language contrasts effectively with Makima's measured, manipulative speech patterns. Their verbal sparring reveals the power dynamics at play and heightens tension. The narrative structure works effectively, beginning with rumors about Makima before her physical appearance, then building to their confrontation. The pacing is generally good, though there are moments where descriptive passages slightly slow the momentum. There are occasional instances where the prose becomes slightly overwrought, with metaphors piling up in ways that can distract from the narrative. Some sentences are constructed in ways that prioritize style over clarity. The ending effectively maintains the tension established throughout, suggesting an ongoing battle of wills rather than a neat resolution. This fits the characters and the situation well, leaving the reader with a sense of unfinished business that feels appropriate. Overall, this is a strong piece that successfully blends elements from two distinct fictional universes while creating a compelling confrontation between well-realized characters. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 17 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 16 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 16 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 17.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 16.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 16.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Scp: Notes from the Future — Score: 87.2
Prompt:
Write an SCP report about a researcher who begins finding handwritten notes from their future self, warning about a containment breach that hasn't happened yet. The notes become increasingly desperate and incoherent, sometimes containing information that contradicts known reality. Include the Foundation's attempts to determine if this is an actual temporal anomaly or psychological manipulation by a contained entity, and the researcher's struggle to trust their own perception. First person (researcher's perspective with interspersed notes), past tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Item #: SCP-XXXX Object Class: Euclid (provisional) Special Containment Procedures: Subject of interest is myself, Researcher L. Wexler, currently assigned to Site-73. All written materials in my office (73-B-412) are to be cataloged, numbered, and stored in a double-locked cabinet. No notes will be removed from 73-B-412 except by two Level 3 personnel. Audio/video surveillance is to record my office continuously with redundant systems; per Incident XXXX-07, all recordings are to be buffered through non-networked solid-state media. Scheduled cognitive evaluation is required daily. I am to abstain from amnestics unless authorized by Dr. Qiao. Addendum XXXX-A references the investigation into temporal anomalies; Addendum XXXX-B references containment interference by SCP-███ and other cognitohazardous entities already present on Site-73. The cross-test between these vectors is ongoing. I continue to occupy my office under observation with a second cot installed. I write this from that cot. The first note appeared on a Tuesday, 07:33, during routine check-in. My coffee had just cooled to a palatable bitterness. The desk was clean—cleared the night before. Then a folded piece of paper was there, flush with the edge, like someone had measured the distance by thumb-width. The footage should show the paper arriving. It shows me blinking, the second hand on the analogue wall clock pausing for one long, syrupy tick, and the image dissolving into a gray mosaic for three seconds. Then: a piece of paper. No sound, no door movement. My hands were already on the keyboard; they never left the frame. Note 1 (transcribed): L., this is going to sound absurd. There will be a breach in Wing D. Do not take the east corridor. Cancel the morning inspection. It’s small now. You can still stop the chain. Wear gloves when you review SCP-███’s logs. Trust me. —L. I did not cancel the inspection. The Foundation does not alter schedules on anonymous scraps. I wore gloves anyway, because it cost nothing. SCP-███ is memetic; latex wouldn’t matter, but rationale is sometimes a prophylactic. No breach occurred. Wing D’s alarms remained asleep, the hum of the chillers steady as a lullaby. I forwarded the note to Security. Security forwarded me to Psych. Psych forwarded me to Qiao. We reviewed the footage together on his screen, shoulders nearly touching, both of us more interested in the shape of the glitch than the content. “It’s either temporal or an edit,” he said. “Either way, you don’t touch anything you didn’t write. Understood?” I nodded. I washed my hands more than necessary. Day two, I locked my office. I said the door out loud as I locked it (one, two turns; chain engaged; code input correctly). I left with two cameras aimed at the desk and a guard posted outside. I returned with the guard and saw Note 2 on the desk, under the paperweight I keep on a printout from 2012 that has a coffee ring like a ghost. The footage hiccupped at 11:19:01. The second hand stuck again. The guard, a man named Flores with a moustache too precise to be accidental, swore he never looked away. Note 2 (transcribed): You didn’t cancel. I can feel the timeline tightening. That word is wrong. You know we don’t talk this way. Listen: in the second iteration, it climbs through ventilation because you leave the panel loose. Tighten the screws now. Tell Qiao to move all Class-Cs off 73-D. He won’t. Try anyway. —L. I hadn’t loosened any panel, and I hadn’t touched ventilation. I read the note aloud. Flores coughed. We both laughed because the alternative was too frightening, and because laughter is a simple structure to inhabit. The panel screws were tight. Wing D remained silent. For the record: up to this point, I suspected an aggressive prank, or a cognitohazard playing with my sense of causality, or a kind of self-suggestion blossoming like mold on damp cognitive wallpaper. I requested an audit of MTF movements and Tech logging. IT found nothing. The notes existed physically; the paper matched Foundation stock, the ink was cheap, the fibers declared by the spectrometer to be our own. No fingerprints beyond mine. On day three, I wrote a note to myself as a baseline: “If you didn’t write the next one, consider your handwriting compromised.” I placed it on my desk, and I went to lunch. On returning, I found Note 3 on top of my baseline, and beneath both, my pen was uncapped and leaking a small, accusing lake. Note 3: Screw it, L., you’re still skeptical—fine. They’re calling it Slippage. Ask Q. to review the irregularities in 2012-07-04, the lab refrigerator incident. The egg smell. Remember? It’s the same frequency. The breach happens at 15:42, if you make the same choices. You will call me a liar, and the alarms won’t go off, and nothing bursts. But the choices still make it real later. Don’t say “later.” Damn it. My head is full of cotton. —L. I remember the refrigerator incident. The egg smell was real; we all silently agreed not to speak of it unless forced. Qiao pulled the old logs. The oscillation pattern on the environmental sensors had a hiccup, yes, a ripple in the noise floor that looked like a mouse trying to be a mountain. “Could be internal power regulation,” IT said. “Old floor, bad grounding.” Qiao rubbed his temples. “Or we’re chasing ghosts with measuring sticks.” Security added a third camera. Our current understanding of causality took a chair in the corner and pretended not to listen. At night, I slept in the office under the motionless stare of three lenses. My dreams produced long corridors with doors that wouldn’t open and alarms that warbled in frequencies I couldn’t hear. I woke with a note tucked under my cheek. Note 4 (paper creased, writing cramped): L., you’re on the cot. Good. Don’t sleep at 03:12. That’s when it enters the mechanicals. The screws weren’t about screws; they were about you leaving. You’re the fixed point. Stay. Plug your ears if you must. Look at the clock. Don’t blink, don’t blink, don’t—God, sorry. That’s a joke. Old Earth TV. Ignore me. The man in orange has teeth where his eyes should be. That isn’t real (?). If you see him, don’t speak cause he tastes names. Forget that line. This is getting messy. Focus. 15:42. Wing D. East corridor. Don’t. —L. We logged the line about the man in orange as low-probability cognitohazard. Psych suggested a stress-induced bleed of fantasy into communication. I suggested we watch the clock. At 03:12, I stayed awake and watched the red digits crawl. I heard the vibration of the building’s heart, the subtle breath of climate control, the old pipes whispering. Nothing entered the mechanicals. No teeth and no orange. Day six, the contradictions began to cook. Note 5 told me that the breach had already happened yesterday in another version, that we were now in an iteration where a child’s laughter came through the ductwork at noon. Noon came and smelled of coffee and the faint tang of solvent, and no laughter. The note asked me to send a message to a woman named F., who I did not know, and an extension that doesn’t exist. “Tell her I’m sorry about the broken glass. Tell her to move the plant away from the blinds. It burns.” I did not send the message. Security looked tabled and tired and made a clockwork plan for all the things that might be true. Qiao started using words like “model” and “memetic overlay” in the same sentence, and I felt myself become simultaneously subject and tool. There were nineteen notes by then. Some were precise, like instructions from a pilot to a second. Some were nonsense, scrawled with arrows and the phrase “PALIMPSEST” written four times, each time more faint. One said, “Don’t read this one out loud. It teaches the air your name.” I read it silently. I did not say my name for an hour as a kindness to myself. The cameras glitched precisely, without variance, when the notes appeared. IT tore apart the system. We replaced cables. We swapped out the model of the camera. We unplugged the cameras and recorded on analog. The analog warbled. In the report, they called it “gray insertion.” The world went soft around the edges, and then there was paper. By day nine, I couldn’t tell if the conflicting details were evidence of interference or the signature of a real anomaly interacting with a squishy human nervous system. I felt watched by a version of myself that didn’t believe in me. Perhaps that mutual doubt was the mechanism. Note 12 (edges damp, faint smear as if someone cried on it): L., please. Don’t trust the one that says “alarm at 16:00.” It’s wrong. My time is wrong. That one is when we were across the hall. I’m mixing—my head. The metal eats time around the 7th floor. Don’t go there. Stay at desk. Do you still have the scar on your wrist? Good. That’s you. If the scar moves, don’t write. It’s a trick. My scar did not move. I watched it like it was a horizon line. In Addendum XXXX-A, Foundation has test-run two hypotheses: true temporal displacement (micro scale, directed at specific objects) versus agent-based cognitive manipulation (possibly by SCP-███, who earns mischief points by inserting false premonition to corrode our decision matrices). My notes—if they are from me—bundle both. They are sometimes right about things they shouldn’t be able to know. They are sometimes wrong in ways that feel like a mouth mispronouncing a familiar word. We ran environmental sweeps for localized tachyon-like anomalies (I know the term is sloppy, but it satisfies the bored). Results are nonstandard but inconclusive. We ran memetic screening on the handwriting. The letters contain no known patterns. The ink whispers no songs. Day eleven, the tone of the notes shifted. Instead of warnings, they begged. The handwriting slanted downhill. Note 17: I know you won’t cancel. I know you think this is someone nudging your choices for their own containment. Maybe it is. But you will sit with this and not know which part of you is you, and that is how it gets in. The breach is not a wall broken. It is a trust broken. There is a noise like geese. You will think of your grandmother. That’s when. I heard geese that day, but only because I thought of geese. My grandmother had a laugh like a kettle. I hate that this is in the report. But this is now also evidence: self-relevance is the hook. They used me to make me. Qiao took the notes to his office and returned them sealed, his face set to neutral. “We are treating this as an SCP until proven otherwise,” he said. “We are also treating you as compromised.” These aren’t cruel words. They’re honest. He assigned me a minder—Sgt. Kole—who sat and did crossword puzzles and asked me to spell “mnemonic.” Note 19 (ink heavy, indent breaking the paper): This is the last one I can get through. The clock sticks and that’s the only door I’ve found. The breach is not at 15:42. It is not a roar or a siren. It is the moment you decide you would rather be wrong than be the kind of person who believes scraps of paper. In the version where you harden, they die. In the version where you soften, you do something else that hurts. There is no clean. Choose anyway. Do not take the east corridor. Even if there is no breach. Especially then. —L. I did not take the east corridor. At 15:42, the alarms were still. My hands were still. The hum of the building did not grow teeth. Across the campus, a delivery truck backfired. Somewhere a machine took a breath and held it too long and let it go. Security asked why I altered my route if I didn’t believe the anomaly was temporal. I didn’t say “because I’m tired of losing arguments with a ghost.” I said, “We’re in an experiment where the cost of compliance is minimal and the cost of defiance is unknown.” They wrote it down. That night there was another note. Note 20: I’m still here. I think that means I did something right or wrong. The clocks don’t match. Do you see the paint ripple on the far wall? It’s where time is thin. If you press your thumb there, it will come away green. If it does, burn this. If it doesn’t, burn this. Don’t let them keep all of me in a file. I pressed my thumb to the wall. It came away clean except for dust. I did not burn the note. I placed it in a bag, labeled it, signed the line with a pen that had stopped leaking, cataloged it under my name, which I spoke aloud to the empty room because I missed the sound of it. Addendum XXXX-B: SCP-███ shows no direct involvement, though two researchers reported dreams of orange coveralls. Cross-tests are paused. We have not localized any discrete entity responsible for the notes. Security footage continues to glitch with identical signature at note appearances. We have also observed that if I stare down the lens as the glitch begins, the gray resolves into a texture like paper under water. This is not science. This is a man describing a feeling. I am still here. I walk only the west corridor. I sleep with the clock facing me. I am either obeying a future self or submitting to manipulation. The Foundation calls that a vector analysis. I call it choosing what kind of person to be when reality has a seam I can put my finger on. I trust myself less than I did, but not zero. These notes contain facts that have been confirmed and fictions that have not. They contain my handwriting and my fear and the Foundation’s habit of turning both into evidence. Somewhere between those is the breach we have not found, or prevented, or invited. If this is a temporal anomaly, then I am a conduit for a future that is tired of failure. If this is psychological manipulation, then it is trying to corrode the one tool I have: my own perception. The cameras glitch exactly when the paper arrives. The clock stutters at the moment a second I have not yet lived has a say. Object Class remains Euclid. I remain seated, writing. The door remains locked twice. The east corridor remains untraveled. I remain. For now.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This SCP report effectively captures the essence of the Foundation's clinical documentation style while weaving in a compelling first-person narrative about temporal anomalies. The piece successfully creates an atmosphere of paranoia, uncertainty, and dread as Researcher Wexler grapples with notes from what appears to be their future self. The writing demonstrates strong adherence to the SCP format, beginning with containment procedures and classification before transitioning into the researcher's personal account. The first-person perspective works well, allowing readers to experience the researcher's growing doubt and fear directly. The past tense is maintained consistently throughout. The narrative builds tension effectively through the escalating nature of the notes, which become increasingly desperate and incoherent as promised in the prompt. The contradiction between notes and reality is well-executed, creating ambiguity about whether this is a genuine temporal anomaly or psychological manipulation. The piece excels in its portrayal of the researcher's psychological deterioration. Lines like "I felt watched by a version of myself that didn't believe in me" and "I am either obeying a future self or submitting to manipulation" effectively convey the character's struggle with their perception of reality. The prose is generally strong, with effective imagery and metaphors that enhance the unsettling atmosphere: "My dreams produced long corridors with doors that wouldn't open and alarms that warbled in frequencies I couldn't hear." The clinical tone expected of SCP documentation is balanced well with more emotive language in the researcher's personal reflections. However, there are some weaknesses. The narrative occasionally becomes slightly meandering, particularly in the middle section where multiple notes are described in succession without significant plot advancement. Some of the notes' content verges on being too cryptic or abstract, potentially confusing readers rather than intriguing them. The ending appropriately maintains ambiguity rather than providing a neat resolution, which suits both the SCP format and the thematic exploration of uncertainty. The researcher's final statement that they "remain" effectively captures their liminal state between trust and doubt, past and future. Overall, this is a strong piece that successfully fulfills the prompt requirements while creating an engaging narrative that explores themes of trust, perception, and the nature of reality within the SCP universe. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17 Elegant Prose: 16 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 17 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17.0, Elegant Prose: 16.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 17.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Scp: Unmarked Doors Archive — Score: 94.3
Prompt:
Write an SCP entry about a series of identical unmarked doors appearing in abandoned buildings worldwide that lead to a massive, architecturally impossible archive. Documents within reference a previous global civilization destroyed by an unspecified containment failure. Foundation researchers discover references to their own organization under a different name, including personnel files for current staff dated centuries ago. Include exploration logs revealing sections of the archive actively being removed by entities resembling hazmat teams who flee when approached, and evidence that O5 Council members have visited the archive without authorization. Third person (exploration team perspective) with recovered document excerpts. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Item #: SCP-6271 Object Class: Keter Special Containment Procedures: Photometric anomaly sweeps will be integrated into satellite reconnaissance to identify SCP-6271 manifestations. Foundation networks shall flag reports of unmarked, modern steel-core security doors installed within abandoned structures without a recorded contractor of origin. Discovery teams are to seal perimeters, establish no-fly zones, and implement blackout protocols. A mobile lighting rig must be staged at each confirmed location to intersect the threshold plane; the faint photonic leakage present in zero-lumen conditions is considered the primary authenticating characteristic. Thresholds are to be guarded by two MTF squads with orders to deny entry to non-Foundation personnel. Cross-institutional cover narratives include asbestos abatement, ordinance clearance, and brownfield stabilization. Explorations require O5 authorization. Unauthorized cross-threshold activity by Foundation personnel will result in suspension and amnestic evaluation. No locating beacon, tag, or destructive marker has persisted within SCP-6271 beyond three standard cycles (73 hours). As such, all expeditions are to operate under a self-contained temporal window and avoid reliance on static marks for navigation. Description: SCP-6271 is the collective designation for a series of identical, unmarked industrial doors appearing in abandoned buildings worldwide. The doors do not conform to any known manufacturer, are flush-mounted into existing masonry without displacement damage, and often appear in rooms previously documented as empty. When ambient illumination is reduced to zero lux, the door’s perimeter emits a faint, uniform bluish-white glow, measurable at 0.4–0.6 cd/m². Upon opening, the threshold leads to an extra-spatial environment henceforth SCP-6271-A: a labyrinthine archive complex of impossible extent. Architecture combines Brutalist corridors with vaulted stacks and reinforced bays, shifting non-Euclidean alignments, and inconsistent gravity vectors in lateral ducts. Ambient temperature stabilizes at 14°C; humidity remains at 45%. Air composition is breathable but contains volatile compounds consistent with aged paper, phenolic resins, and unknown binding agents. SCP-6271-A houses shelving, compactors, cold cases, and vault doors of unknown make. Contents include documents, microfilm, magnetic tape, optical media, and artifact boxes labeled in a standardized script with glyphic cartouches. Many labels are readable phonetically as transliterated English. A subset of documents reference a global civilization predating current historical chronologies, destroyed by an “unspecified containment failure,” and mention a central administrative body analogous to the Foundation under a different name. Personnel files for current Foundation staff appear within, dated centuries prior to their births, containing accurate biographical detail beyond public or Foundation records. Hostile entities within SCP-6271-A have not been encountered. However, multiple expeditions report sighting figures in glossy, full-body protective ensembles, carrying case vacuums, transit crates, and magnetic placards. These “retrieval teams” disengage and flee when approached, executing silent withdrawals with preplanned control of lighting and egress. Their markings are blank or redacted. They have been observed to “depopulate” shelves—removing entire sections of catalog ranges. Recovered Document Excerpts: Document 6271-A-3 (Loose-leaf, carbon ribbon print, edges brittle) TITLE: Continuity Report – Quarter 17 of Collapse EXCERPT: “Containment was not lost at once. It was negotiated away in increments, each compromise tightening the spiral. We learned, too late, that stewardship is an arrow of time. The Archive bears witness. The world that follows may require our mistakes more than our triumphs.” Document 6271-B-19 (Personnel Dossier, heavy stock, dry-seal) SUBJECT: L. Hargreaves DATE: 03/05/1721 REVISED DETAILS: “Appointment: Director, Applied Thanatology. Project: Thresholds. Notes: Recurrent dream phenomenology indicates high navigability tolerance.” Stamp on final page reads: “Pronon Office of Containment.” Photo depicts a young woman identical to Dr. Lauren Hargreaves, current Site-41 Chief of Thanatology. Ink analysis dates the document to at least three centuries old. Hargreaves denies ancestry resembling the subject; DNA comparison inconclusive due to minor contaminants, but hair strand found sealed within envelope matches Dr. Hargreaves’ mitochondrial haplogroup. Document 6271-C-77 (Index Card, microfilmed) SUBJECT: O5 Seal Transit Log EXCERPT: “Councilors observed: XI, IV. Authority renounced: none. Petition to view ‘Core Stack’ denied. Unchaperoned interval: nine minutes, thirty-six seconds. Missing materials: three folders marked ‘Primer—Waking World.’” Addendum 6271-1: Exploration Logs Exploration 1 — MTF Tau-31 “Pageturners” Date: 2023-11-02 Lead: Capt. Morales Team: Lt. An, Tech. Sato (imaging), Med. Cpl. Hewitt, Archivist Provisional Kline Entry: 06:12 local. Door discovered in a condemned textile mill. Faint glow present under blackout sheet. On breach, team entered a narrow corridor. Left wall: continuous stacks labeled with alphanumeric codes and pictograms of floodlines, lunar phases, and containment symbols unknown to Foundation iconography. 06:24: Sato records a reading room with long tables. The furniture showed no dust accumulation; chair feet left crisp impressions on the tile, then faded over 30 seconds. A stack of manila folders presented as if recently handled. Kline placed nitrile over nitrile to turn pages. Recovered: Folder “Pronon—Continuity Charter (Partial).” Note, Kline: “They call themselves Pronon. Their use of ‘containment’ is ours, but the grammar feels older.” 06:37: First sighting of hazmat figures at extreme of corridor—three silhouettes, reflective helmets, each bearing a matte-black case. No insignia. When Morales announced presence, figures rotated in perfect synchrony, deployed a portable panel that emitted a soft broadband hiss, and vanished around a corner. Pursuit failed; corridor geometry had altered. 06:51: Team encountered a rolling ladder affixed to a towering bay. Each shelf contained unlabeled cassette cases embossed only with a single glyph. Sato played one via portable reader: audio of waves, distant alarms, then a voice: “It is not the fire. It is the arithmetic.” Extraction: 07:30. Upon return, the textile mill door was closed but remained where placed. The glow intensified for 12 minutes post-exit before returning to baseline. Exploration 2 — MTF Mu-12 “Bookends” Date: 2024-01-14 Lead: Lt. Omondi Team: Dr. Kline (embedded), Agent Rusk, Agent Peña, Comms Tech Ng Entry: 21:01. Threshold located in derelict hospital laundry. The glow was stronger than recorded at Tau-31 site. 21:13: Entered a cold-stack wing with sealed drawers. Each drawer had a gravity lock. Labels: “Cathedra, 2 of 9,” “Repatriation—Scrubbed,” “Mnemonic Rafting.” Omondi authorized opening one marked “Personnel: Scenario-Succession.” Inside were folders with names of current Foundation employees, including Agent Rusk, each dated “1698–1734,” stamped Pronon. Rusk’s file included a behavioral profile matching a sealed disciplinary incident only known to Site-12 HR. The paper smelled of formalin. 21:28: A distant clatter repeated at regular intervals, like a hand truck over expansion joints. Peña spotted two hazmat teams loading crate pallets with beige binders labeled “Field Reports—Restraint Failures.” Contact attempted; teams withdrew, leaving behind a folded card. Ng photographed before it sublimated into translucent ash. Card text (partial): “Not yours. Not yet.” 21:35: Kline recovered a heavy black ledger with steel corners. Title page: “Pronon Office of Containment—Council Minutes.” Names redacted with ink seared into the paper. Margins contain notes in a hand later matched to Dr. █████, then Deputy Director, Site-05, deceased 1998. Handwriting analysis indicates perfect match; ink dates inconclusive. An initialed marginalia reads: “We promised not to repeat ourselves. We broke it the minute we named ourselves.” 21:48: Passage narrowed; stack alignment shifted. Team found a small anteroom with a coat tree. Two hooks bore long, dark coats each with a lapel pin of a ring divided into thirteen segments. One segment was fractured. 21:52: Unauthorized signal on internal comms. Voice: “Do not take the minutes.” Omondi ordered retreat. On exit, Peña observed a reflection in the visor of a departing hazmat figure: a human face bearing an insectile compound pattern overlaying the eyes; could not be verified. Exploration 3 — Classified Annex, Partial Transcript Date: 2024-03-02 Lead: Capt. Morales Team: Agent Li, Archivist Provisional Kline, Dr. Hargreaves (observer) Entry: 03:06. Door within a demolished municipal library basement vault. Glow visible in total darkness as documented. The threshold led to an atrial hub, with seven spokes. At hub center: sculpture of a sphere wrapped in bands engraved with cardinal virtues and containment maxims. Several bands were missing. 03:22: Li located a reading niche with a ledger keyed “O-Seal Transit,” containing dated check-in stamps. Among signatures were symbols matching those on O5 secure seals. Three entries corresponded to internal dates where no O5 movement is recorded. Attached slip: “Escort: Binder-Three.” Note in the margin: “They came without asking. They never came alone.” 03:31: Hargreaves retrieved a folder inscribed “Hargreaves, L. Appointment Renewal.” Date: 02/17/1722. Inside: a charcoal portrait matching her face. Bottom line: “We keep what works.” Hargreaves exhibited tachycardia; med readouts steady. Folder edges lightly warm to touch. 03:40: Distant rumble. A chain of hazmat figures entered a parallel aisle. One carried a signs kit with pictographic warnings; another placed a placard at our aisle head: a circle bisected, then folded. Touching it produced a static discharge; letters appeared, then vanished: “Evacuation Priority: Memory.” The chain lifted entire shelf lengths, which slid weightless into open crates. The space beyond where shelves stood showed a pale void, like paper scorched clean. Morales: “Identify yourselves!” No response. The tail unit paused, faced us, tapped a gloved finger against helmet, then traced a small circle in the air. The motion matched known O5 sealing gesture variants. 03:46: A silhouette emerged at the far end—tall, severe posture, coat with ring lapel pin, one fractured segment. Face occluded by shadow. Ng’s bodycam (mounted forward) registered a biometric mask overlay of an O5 identity hash—no match in our database but correct format. The figure turned, walked with the hazmat chain, and was gone. 03:52: PA tone broadcast through the stacks, a chime trio. A voice: “Core Stack opening reserves. All errors shall be bound.” Hazmat teams accelerated. A rolling ladder glided on its own, then stopped dead beside us. On its top rung lay a single stamped envelope: “Primers—Waking World.” It was empty. The stamp impression matched the missing entries noted in Document 6271-C-77. 04:01: We attempted to tag the aisle with thermal paint; paint cooled instantly and sloughed off. Hargreaves placed her folder back. The shelf rejected it and slid the folder into a side slot labeled “RETAINED.” Extraction: 04:19. Door closed immediately behind last man out. Glow increased to an afterimage that persisted on retinas for minutes. Addendum 6271-2: Internal Review A forensic metadata sweep of Site and Area O5 access logs around the dates found in O-Seal Transit records returned tamper artifacts consistent with high-level redaction protocols; however, three nonconforming audit fragments indicate three Council members authenticated on-site within a 48-hour window of Exploration 3 without mission filing. The implication that one or more O5 Council members have visited SCP-6271-A without consensus or body approval is under Ethics Committee review. No statement has been issued by the Council. Addendum 6271-3: Further Recovered Excerpts Document 6271-D-04 (Bound pamphlet, brittle) TITLE: Primer—Waking World EXCERPT: “To wake is to forget half of what was binding you. We left these anchors in hopes the next hands would knot them tighter. If you are reading this, we failed differently this time.” Document 6271-E-22 (Loose marginalia) TEXT: “Pronon is not a name. It is a promise: ‘for-now.’ We have always been interim.” Document 6271-F-09 (Typed memo, onion skin) FROM: Councilor XI TO: Binder-Three SUBJECT: Petition for Core Access TEXT: “We must see what we locked away. Memory is a containment state. If the box remembers you, it opens. If it does not, it never existed.” STAMP: DENIED Closing Statement: SCP-6271-A presents a paradox of provenance and succession. Its materials reference a predecessor administrative order, Pronon, mirroring and anticipating current Foundation structures. Its personnel dossiers contain accurate data about our present staff, dated centuries prior. Agents report active removal of archive segments by unknown hazmat teams who avoid contact but behave with practiced familiarity, occasionally using symbols and gestures associated with our highest authority. The faint glow escaping the door’s edges in complete darkness is the only constant across sites, an index of aperture state or attentional bleed. Hypothesis space includes temporal recursion, institutional palimpsest, or inheritance from a prior cycle of ordered containment that failed. Whether the hazmat teams represent a remaining Pronon element, a parallel Foundation, or an automated custodial force is unresolved. The presence of O5-aligned signatures within SCP-6271-A, coupled with internal audit anomalies, implies at least one Council member possesses knowledge not reflected within present records. All further exploration is suspended pending an oversight session. In the interim, doors are to be held, watched, and not believed.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This SCP entry demonstrates exceptional command of the SCP Foundation format and style. The response creates a compelling anomaly that perfectly fits the prompt requirements while adding layers of complexity and intrigue that elevate it beyond a simple execution of instructions. The concept of doors leading to an impossible archive containing records of a previous civilization (Pronon) that mirrors the current Foundation is brilliantly executed. The writer establishes a sophisticated containment scenario with technical language that feels authentic to the SCP universe. The photometric anomaly details, containment procedures, and exploration protocols all contribute to a sense of institutional realism. The exploration logs are particularly strong, following a logical progression that builds tension while revealing information at a measured pace. The writer skillfully introduces the hazmat teams who flee when approached, and subtly implies O5 Council involvement through recovered documents and observations. The exploration team's perspective is maintained consistently throughout these logs, with appropriate clinical detachment punctuated by moments of unease. The recovered document excerpts are masterfully crafted, containing cryptic but meaningful fragments that hint at deeper mysteries without overexplaining. Phrases like "It is not the fire. It is the arithmetic" and "Memory is a containment state" create an unsettling atmosphere while suggesting profound implications. The writer excels at creating a sense of institutional paranoia and existential dread through subtle details: personnel files matching current staff but dated centuries earlier, marginalia that matches deceased personnel's handwriting, and evidence of O5 Council members visiting without authorization. These elements combine to suggest a cyclical nature to reality itself, with the Foundation possibly being an iteration of a previous containment organization. The prose is precise and clinical when appropriate (in containment procedures) but becomes more atmospheric in exploration logs, creating effective tonal variation while maintaining consistency with the SCP format. Descriptions like "a pale void, like paper scorched clean" and "The glow increased to an afterimage that persisted on retinas for minutes" demonstrate strong imagery that enhances the uncanny nature of the anomaly. The piece avoids common SCP pitfalls like excessive redactions or gratuitous horror elements, instead building tension through implication and the gradual revelation of an unsettling cosmic truth. The closing statement effectively summarizes the paradoxical nature of the anomaly while leaving room for reader interpretation. If there are any weaknesses, they might be in the slightly excessive length of some sections and occasional moments where technical language becomes slightly repetitive. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise exceptional execution of the SCP format. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Classic sci-fi: Offworlder (Le Guin) — Score: 90.5
Prompt:
Classic sci-fi: Offworlder (Author style: Le Guin) Write a chapter following a young diplomatic envoy sent to address tensions on a distant human colony where humanity has diverged into distinct subspecies through both natural adaptation and separation of lineages. Against protocol, the envoy slips away from official functions to walk the streets alone, encountering markets, ordinary citizens, and social structures that contradict the official briefings. Upon returning to their quarters, the envoy is reprimanded by Command, and is tasked with approaching the stationed Minister of Science (a political posting rather than scientific). A challenging conversation ensues, in which the envoy's wits and will are tested, by a seasoned political operator looking to test the mettle of the offworlder. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The ferry veered like a fish, a series of short arcs across the gravity wells between the station and the planet. In that jittering silence that new planets always require—where the voice cannot yet presume to name—the young envoy watched the continent roll into detail: a broad fan of river, a wet green throat opening to a paler sea, and a city crouched where the waters met. It had been called Veld by the first arrivals, an old word for grassland, perhaps, though the green here climbed into blue and ash and other colors that did not belong to grasses at all. The briefing packet rattled in their palms, dull with authority. Tensions high between the Lineages: Littoral, Settle, and Deep; more formal names in the document, but everyone used the simple words. Protocol: Upon arrival you will present yourself, etc. Do not walk alone. They had read Earth's histories in the training months in orbit. They had been told adaptation could come quickly if the climate insisted, if lungs learned different rhythms, if skins found new chemistries to filter alien suns. They had seen the schematic illustrating the Littoral—pelvic arches broadened, hair like a fine dark moss, a salt-shine to the skin. They had seen the Deep—eyes wide and saltless, bones like saplings, an economy of water that no terrestrial body could achieve. The Settle—closest to baseline humanity, everyone said; settled inland, engineered their crops to match them, but the cartilage in their ears showed the same small curling as the native fliers. Official words made tidy lines of change. But tidiness has never been allied with life. The ferry sighed into dock. The air came to meet the envoy with the soft weight of breath through wet cloth. There was a cry, long and high, not human, threading the city's hum. The envoy turned their eyes away from the waiting delegation: the ministerial gray of suits, the app rectangles, the flags with their shallow colors. The envoy's handlers had warned them: a small failure and the colonies become wary of Earth again, the agreements grow brittle. Our presence is only as desired as our listening. They had nodded, because nodding was expected, and because listening is something you can only learn by failing at it. The envoy carried the weight of their own failure already, small as a seed, ready to sprout. In the drift of greeting handshakes, he—the envoy—slipped, step by step, onto a side walkway. A tiny motion, a fish again. No one noticed, or noticed only the gray suit among other gray suits, and soon he was in a side street, then in a market lane where the paving street wore its age in a pattern of gloss and grit underfoot. Smells: salted fruit, the pepper-lime of fermenting river kelp, smoke. The stalls pressed close, and the voices climbed like birds on thermal columns. The cloth first drew his eye. On Earth, fabric had settled toward uniformity: dyes that were all the same, stable, safe. Here, a stall showed him color he could not name. One bolt like the underside of a raincloud walked by stars; another like the mouth of a flower seen from the inside, where the color is not one color but motion; a scarf that seemed to become greener when he breathed on it. The vendor, a woman with Littoral hair, laughed softly at his staring and shook her stall so that the cloth shifted. The warp threads caught and released light the way the river caught and released the sky. Pigments cultivated from a symbiotic fungus in the river reeds, his briefing packet supplied belatedly, tedious, as if one could write an annotation of awe. "You look like the wind is on your skin," the vendor said, and then, because she saw who he was—no one could miss the cut of Earth cloth, the pallor that belonged to ships—she adjusted her tone. "You're new." "I am," he said, and made space in his mouth for the local vowels. "How much for this?" She named a number. The envoy had local currency—polite, token—provided by the Bureau. He paid and took the scarf, and it made his neck murmur of a different air. He asked, "Who wears these colors?" "Everyone," she said, and then, "The Deep, mostly. They like the weight. It hangs in the water better. And it's true-color under depth-light. Yours, from above—it shifts; under, it's plain." "True-color," he said, thinking of truth. "It must be expensive to cultivate." "We cultivate everything," she said with that resignation particular to people who can't stop. "We don't count the labor. We can’t afford to." Then she bit her lip, a small check. "You'll be wanting the official market. It's over that way." He wanted this, the unofficial market, the way he had always wanted things that were not meant for him. He said, "I like it here." "You like feeling lost," she said, not unkindly. Beyond the cloth, the food. He bought a small cone of something crisp and glistening, sweet-savory, like fried ribbon. Children ran barefoot, three children with the cartilage-curl ears—Settle lineage, he thought—and one with a chest wider than a child's had any right to be: a Littoral child, perhaps, lungs made for breath in winds near water. A man stood on a crate and argued about taxation in a voice like good earth—no, not Earth and earth. There were other words here. Ground. Bed. The words shift because the ground shifts. He saw a group of Deep women—no, perhaps they were neither women nor men as Earth counted. Their bodies made long simple lines. Their eyes were dark and bright simultaneously, like polished seedpods. They moved together, and when they laughed, they lifted their faces to catch the wind in their mouths—an old habit of sailors on Earth; a new habit here. They were not fish, the envoy had been told. Do not call them fish. They could sleep underwater for longer than any Earthling had a right to imagine, and their joints bent differently when seated on stones near the river. They wore the handwoven cloth as belts, hanging heavy into water. His packet had said: The Deep make no claims; they ask the same as everyone to be left alone with their ways. The packet had also said: The Deep are obstructionists, preventing the dam project. The dam would provide 30% of projected energy needs for Veld. The Deep damage, by their actions, our hopes for energy independence. He watched a Deep child—lank hair, eyes like wet stone—turn a shell in their fingers. The child lifted the shell to the envoy without solemnity, offering. He took it, the ridges new to his hand. "Thank you," he said, and the child made the small movement that was a shrug here, an opening of the right shoulder. Do not walk alone, the packet had said. He was not alone. The market pressed around him, and the city had already decided how alone he would be. Someone brushed his side—not accident; a hand light as a moth. He looked down. A Settle boy, perhaps ten, stood there, his fingers already closing on the envoy's pocket. The envoy caught the boy's wrist gently. The boy looked up and bared his teeth, not in threat but in warning. It was like watching a feral cat. On Earth the envoy had practiced the words that would bring guards without escalation. He did not say them here. He reached into his pocket and took out a small metal coin—a ship token, old. He placed it in the boy's palm, then released the boy's wrist. The boy looked at the coin as if it were a fish from a cold sea he'd never seen. He snorted, confused, and ran. The envoy thought: He will sell it for cloth, perhaps. Or throw it into the river. Or none of these. The coin warmed his own palm where it had been. He turned as the first ring of shadow fell across the market. Veld's day was long enough to have moods. The high flyers came downriver then, scribing their loops just above the roofs. They were not birds—no feathers, but membraned wings, like lengths of dyed fabric themselves, the color of fog at dawn. The people in the market did not look up. This was their sky, their river. People only looked when strangers asked them to. By the time he thought of returning, his scarf had turned a different green. The clock on his packet sighed a little reminder. The glass tower where the Bureau slept glinted in the far sun. The envoy breathed—Veld air in his throat—and began the walk back through streets named on maps, that had other names in mouths. The return was a narrowing. Official rugs, official corridors. In the reception room the atmosphere dried like cloth left too long in the real sun. The Commander's "Where have you been" carried every planet he had ever landed on. She had Settle ears; her family had been here two generations; she still wore Earth cut. Her mouth bled patience. "I walked," the envoy said, because simplicity is sometimes such a shield that it can be a weapon. "Against protocol." "Against a certain idea of listening," he said, the boldness of the scarf around his neck. "You will meet with Minister of Science in twenty minutes," she said, the words crisp and floor-clean. "You will wear what you are meant to wear. You will keep your observations to yourself until they have been processed through proper channels." "I will meet him," he said. "What is his name?" "Jarcha. From the Settle. He is the governor’s cousin. Remember: he is an appointment. He has never been a scientist. He enjoys reminding our people of that." The Commander looked at the scarf and resigned herself to it. "At least comb your hair." Jarcha's office smelled faintly of distilled water. It had a picture in it of a landscape that might have been Earth if Earth had been once this gentle. Jarcha himself was older than the Commander by thirty years, perhaps, his body long and thin, like a reed. His ears were the easy giveaway. He stood as if it were neither courtesy nor necessity to stand. "Offworlder," he said. "You were lost." "I was learning my way," the envoy said. "I apologize for any offense." He smiled. "Offense is the coin we all deal in. Sit." They sat. Everything Jarcha did had the appearance of leisure. The envoy found themselves matching that pace. "I am told you have concerns about the dam." Jarcha put the slightest weight on you, as one might on a plank before stepping. His language was full of small tests. "I am told that the Deep require the river as it is. I am told that the dam will provide your city with energy sufficient to make you less dependent on imports, particularly in the dry season when your ground crops need irrigation. I am told that this is an engineering matter. I do not think engineering matters exist outside of life." "Concise," Jarcha said, as if he had asked for that. He steepled his long fingers, then flattened them. "When I was a boy, my father taught me to swim in a salt pool. Settle, we don't keep our heads under long. He said: If you must put your face in the water, do it with the conviction that the water will hold you. The water does not care about your conviction, but you will not drown so easily. Our city prefers to act as if water cares. We have built a bridge of beliefs across something that shifts. You walked the market. You saw the colors. Did you notice the drains?" The envoy thought of the lanes. Their training had demanded they notice small things. "The footways tilt at angles not regular to the buildings, to sluice the monsoon flows. The grates are low and wide. The older ones are higher, smaller. The newer ones, wider." "Yes," Jarcha said. "We learn. The first Settle town—I was a child—flooded and stayed flooded, because we didn't understand that here, ground is a verb. The Littoral learned it. The Deep have no need to learn: they grew their bodies from our mistakes. There will be no dam. Not for twenty years." The envoy blinked. The Commander had been certain: he was to persuade. "I don't think your governor agrees." "My cousin is fond of speeches," Jarcha said, the softness not unkind, but a knife still. "He tells the Settle that power is light. He tells the Littoral that power is rising beyond the river. He tells the Deep nothing. He assumes they will not listen. This is a mistake. Everyone listens. Sometimes what they listen to is not you. The Deep are listening to their dead in the river. The littoral listen to the wind." He paused. "You, offworlder, what do you listen to?" "My orders," the envoy said, and drew a breath. "The sound of my own ignorance. The way the air here moves in the throat. The way my idea of you changes when you speak from something beyond the briefings. The market. A child's breath." "Good," Jarcha said, as if a game had been played and the envoy had not lost immediately. "Then listen: There will be no dam. We will let your Bureau write projections and press releases. We will test a smaller structure in a seasonal stream. It will satisfy no one. The real work will be in the hills. We will ask the Settle to plant the deep-rooted ferns that don't burn in drought; we will ask the Deep to teach us how to catch the fall of water as it leaves the fog; we will ask the Littoral to show us how to carry it without losing it to the air. This is politics. This is science. You will write a dispatch that does not shame us." "And if I write the truth?" the envoy said. "That you will not build the dam, that your cousin speaks to satisfy, that the Deep do not obstruct but insist you live in the verb of ground?" Jarcha's eyes crinkled. "Write it. But write also that there will be lighting in the alleys come long-dusk, and that the hospital will be cold in summer for the Settle children with fevers, and that the Deep will get a weather radio that speaks in their cadence. You will be reprimanded for your walk. You will be told you jeopardize relations. Do not jeopardize anything except false certainty. And do not do it visibly. It is easy to be brave where everyone can see. Be useful instead." The envoy felt a slow heat rise under the scarf. "You dislike my presence." "I dislike being reminded that we are still seen as provisional by people who never intend to become less provisional themselves," Jarcha said. "I dislike that we cannot yet turn our backs on Earth. I dislike our debts. But I like your scarf. It becomes you. Did you buy it from Petra's stall? Her mother weaves the true-color threads. She must have seen you and thought, that one will tickle the Bureau. She's right. She's very good at politics." He leaned back. "Tell me something you saw that is not in your briefing." The envoy thought of the child's wrinkled coin, the fliers’ drifting, the salt-sheen on the vendor's wrist where the cloth dyed it, the drains. He said, "People carry small salt vials on cords, not on belts. The cord goes under the shirt. When they work, if they go faint, they lick their fingers and press them to the salt. The children do it casually; the old do it like a prayer. We do not do that on Earth." "Ah," Jarcha said, pleased. "Then you understand something about water and bodies. Good. Carry that understanding into your orders. Take your reprimand and put it to use. And do not walk alone tomorrow." "I will not be alone tomorrow," the envoy said. "Tomorrow, I will be with the Minister of Science." Jarcha laughed then, not unkindly. "Do not flatter me nor yourself. Tomorrow you will be with a city. Drink our water. Learn to have it in your mouth without fearing it." The envoy rose. At the door, Jarcha said, "How will you write me? In your report. What will I be?" "A man who knows the ground is a verb," the envoy said. Jarcha nodded. "Good. And you?" "Lost," the envoy said. "And listening." He stepped out into the corridor, where the conditioned air scoured his skin. He held the scarf at his throat. It had warmed to his heat, but its color kept shifting, agreeing with no one. He thought of the salt vials. He touched his tongue to his fingertip and imagined a tiny crunch, a savor. He would have to ask the vendor if she sold them. Or Jarcha. Or the Commander. It did not matter. He had begun to learn words here, and the words would work on him as the river did. He had failed the protocol. He had succeeded at being in a place. That would have to be enough for a first day. He carried the shell from the child in his pocket, ridges pressing his palm. He walked toward the reprimand, toward the writing of a truth that was multiple and therefore closer to the truth. Outside, the sky began to shift its weight. The drains would be ready. The market, too. The river would not care. But the people would. He did, now. And it would cost him. And he could pay it. Or not. The work was to decide, every hour, with the knowledge he had, and with the more he did not. He stepped into the room where the Commander waited, and found he had begun already, long before she opened her mouth. He had the taste of the city in his mouth, faintly, like someone else's salt. He swallowed. He stood. He listened. He spoke. And the chapter of this was only starting to be written.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response demonstrates a remarkable grasp of Le Guin's style, particularly her ability to blend anthropological observation with lyrical prose. The piece successfully creates a world where humanity has diverged into distinct subspecies (Littoral, Settle, and Deep) with physical adaptations that reflect their environments. The writing excels at sensory detail and worldbuilding through small, telling observations: the salt vials worn under shirts, the drains designed for monsoon flows, the cloth that changes color underwater. These details create a lived-in world without resorting to exposition dumps. The envoy's observations feel organic, allowing readers to discover this world alongside the protagonist. The character of Jarcha is particularly well-rendered—a political appointee who nonetheless possesses wisdom and nuance. His statement that "ground is a verb" encapsulates the philosophical difference between Earth's approach and the colony's adaptation to their environment. The dialogue between Jarcha and the envoy reveals layers of political complexity without becoming didactic. The prose maintains a consistent voice throughout, with a poetic quality that never becomes overwrought. Sentences like "Tidiness has never been allied with life" and "The market pressed around him, and the city had already decided how alone he would be" demonstrate a Le Guin-esque ability to compress philosophical insight into simple, elegant phrasing. The narrative structure works well, following the envoy from arrival through unauthorized exploration to the confrontation with Jarcha. The piece avoids the trap of making the envoy instantly enlightened; instead, we see them beginning a process of understanding, still caught between duty and discovery. Where the piece could be stronger is in developing more emotional complexity for the envoy. While we see their curiosity and growing awareness, their internal conflicts could be more deeply explored. The envoy's motivations for breaking protocol could be more clearly established early on. Additionally, while the dialogue with Jarcha is strong, some of the exposition about the political situation feels slightly too neat. Le Guin often allows more ambiguity and contradiction in her political landscapes. Overall, this is an exceptionally strong response that captures Le Guin's anthropological eye, her interest in adaptation and cultural difference, and her elegant, restrained prose style. The piece creates a world that feels simultaneously alien and familiar, populated by characters whose differences reflect deeper philosophical questions about humanity's relationship to environment. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Biopunk: Polymerase Chain Reaction — Score: 88.7
Prompt:
Biopunk -- Polymerase Chain Reaction Write a chapter set in a near-future post-apocalyptic world where corporate genetic engineering was designed with built-in obsolescence—engineered DNA lasting only one generation to maximize profits before societal collapse. Follow a biohacker working with salvaged equipment to splice viable food crops for their settlement using rapidly degrading genetic material. As world building / window dressing, include details about jury-rigged lab equipment, and the physical toll (and unexpected upsides) of using untested genetic modifications as medicine. The plot of this chapter is centred around a black market contract. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The tiles in the old clinic still bled light. Threads of blue-green glow from the seams where hairline cracks had taken root, like veins under skin. Mushrooms had followed, little discs and umbrella caps that drank the damp and breathed out faint luminescence when the lights were off, a slow pulse, as if the room had a heartbeat. I kept the overhead flood patched together on a shoe last week, but today I left it off to spare the heat. The mushrooms were enough by which to see the lazy oscillation of the ceiling fan I’d sewn back together out of printer motors and bicycle chain. Better that than blow another fuse on the black-market inverter. I leaned over the thermocycler—a breadbox from before all the patents, breathing in the river-sour smell of cultured bacteria and acetone—and pressed the cracked plastic lid down. A strip of duct tape kept the heating element pressed to the worn aluminum block. The machine’s status readout had died before I found it, but I’d learned to count the clicks of relays switching over: denaturation, annealing, extension. Ninety-four to fifty to seventy-two, over and over, like the tides. The thing coughed as it warmed. I listened to it cough like a living thing, timed the wheeze between clicks to see if the heat would hold. The amplification worked some days and not others; the corporate obsolescence had been designed to eat itself, strand by strand, base pairs unraveling after one generation like ash. Their wheat, their corn, their pigs with marbling genes—everything they made came with a fuse inside, and when the spark ran out, it all unstitched. Kept them selling. Kept us buying, until there was no more money, and the satellites were drift, and the patents were paper. What was left was me and a machine that wanted to die and wouldn’t, because I had screwed two extra relays onto its gut and fed it power stolen from a windmill that only spun when the weather fought it. “Your block’s running hot,” Jori said from the threshold. The glow on her cheekbone made her look like she’d been painted for a festival the old folks couldn’t explain. Her hair was braided in copper wire—probably a prayer for reception. She carried dust in her jacket like an aura, and I didn’t have to ask where she’d been; it was in the way she held her arm tight to her ribs, hiding something heavy. “It’s running,” I said. “That’s the part that matters.” “Sit,” she said. “I am sitting.” On a stool that had been a dentist’s once. Its hydraulic hiss was the clinic’s second heartbeat. I turned the stool so she had my side and not the spread of half-soldered boards and a glass petri stacked with glowing fungal membranes. “Your tone says there’s a problem that isn’t my machine.” She smiled like she’d learned it in a mirror. “Who says I can’t have multiples.” The fridge hummed, a scarred thing patched with an aquarium chiller and a block of phase change wax I scavenged from an old HVAC unit. It kept temperatures a suggestion more than a promise. Inside were strips of cold-pack gel I’d repurposed into cold boxes, vials with my life in them: promoter sequences, old plasmids, transcription factors scraped off dried-out culture plates in a burned university where the fire-suppression had painted the walls with a char that wouldn’t scrub out. She didn’t move to the bench, didn’t step over the tangle of charging cords winding from the pedaled alternator to the inverter and back to the heating block. She stayed near the door and kept her back to the corridor. That meant she had someone she didn’t want to see her have come to see me, or someone she did. The settlement liked words like decency. I liked words like contract. “This is you flexing,” I said, low. “I’ll flex back. You’re late, and your payment is late, and my seeds are almost cooked.” “They’re cooked because your Internet of Things is three broken appliances, one of which is probably a bomb,” she said, finally stepping between a stack of centrifuge buckets and a cracked porcelain sink. The basket for the centrifuge had had to be rebuilt. The wobble it had now made it sound like an old radio, hiss and chirp, when I spun it up to separate DNA from soup. I had the balance down to instinct now: a counterweight made of a marble and some solder squares, even with a black-market rotor that had a missing screw. She slid the package onto the bench next to the PCR machine. The click stopped. The room felt like it inhaled and held. The mushrooms dimmed slightly, maybe a draft, maybe a nervous system that didn’t exist. “What’s the contract,” I said. “Three parts,” she said. “One for me, two for them. You’ll take care of me first because I brought this.” She lifted the cloth like she was showing a new baby. Underneath was a freezer brick and a metal capsule the size of my thumb. I could smell it before I touched it, a faint rose-and-tin odour that didn’t belong in the clinic, didn’t belong on this side of any line. “Tell me you didn’t,” I said, because my mouth worked before my brain did. She held up her injured arm, and I saw the black bruise like a galaxy under her skin where someone’s rifle butt had taught her a private lesson. “Put out the mushrooms if you’re going to scold me,” she said. “It’s from a seed vault,” I said, with more reverence than I liked. “A sovereign one. There were words about raids on the radio.” “There were lies on the radio,” she said. “Say your prayers later. Can you sequence it?” Sequence was a generous word for what I did. I chopped and amplified and stuck things together that had no business touching. I bent genes around and got them to sing a new song for one last verse before the suicidal obsolescence devoured the melody. I didn’t read; I reacted. I ran PCR on thermal gradients and guessed at annealing temps and kept the thermocycler running by rubbing it with the non-conductive cloth from an old hazard bag when the static built up the wrong way. But the capsule was marked with a stamp I’d recognize blindfolded: the old agriculture ministry’s crest, two ears of wheat and a caduceus in the middle. Pre-Obsolescence. Pre-license. Maybe pre-profit. “I can,” I said. I touched the metal like it might burn. “Then you’ll do it,” she said. “Longer amylase, cellulose breakdown, drought tolerance. I have a client in Sectors South that will trade for it. Trade big. And you’ll do me a fix while we wait.” The fix. The daily float of nanowrongs and microloans my body had become. I had a flock of the clinic’s mistakes inside me, bare RNA that I had used as scaffolds when the antibiotics ran out and the obsolescence started to eat the bacteria we used as factories. My lungs ran on a weird patchwork of modified alveolar proteins that let me breathe easier after the dust storms, but sometimes when the air was still I could taste copper and see blue halos around things in the dark. My liver had learned how to metabolize a handful of synthetic sugars that the food vats made from plastic-cracking, and in exchange I’d lost an appetite for vanilla. My fingers grew back skin faster than they should, a thin shine that pulled tight and flaked off like blister peel if I worked too hard under the UV. Upsides, downsides. A catalog of hacks I could tune up or down when I got more stock in. “Where?” I asked, and she let me see the bandage under her jacket, the mean, swollen line and the spiderweb around it. Another one of the corporate barbs: a tracker built into wire, built into bullets. They’d planned it so their livestock couldn’t breed true, or run, or resist rust or sun or dehydration. They hadn’t planned for the bullets to go bad, too. The microchemical in the barb wanted to digest itself in a few days. It had. But the owl’s nest of proteins it dragged out of her and rearranged had set, and the heat sat in it like a coin. “You need me to splice you a thing that turns a thing off,” I said. “It’ll eat you while it listens.” “You’ve made worse in this room,” she said. “On purpose.” I held her gaze until the mushrooms dimmed and brightened again. “Lie on the bed,” I said. She didn’t ask for a sheet. I hit the pedal for the alternator and let my legs go, giving the inverter the extra charge while the thermocycler ticked and breathed. The Capsicum peppers I kept in a cracked fish tank rattled when the fan pulled air across them. Jori watched me as if she could see the circuits between my calf and the PCR machine, the way the lab had been a body long before I let it live in mine. The capsule thumped in my palm as I opened it. I let a single seed drop into a dish with the mushroom membrane. The glow went white and then faded back to blue, like the fungus had inhaled. It was a dumb reaction to amino acids, to oils. It made me think of the fields my grandmother had talked about like fairyland: green as maps, and solid, and a foot of water in the ditches when the canals behaved. “You can’t sell them all,” I told Jori without looking up. “If I can make these breed, if we can tie the obsolescence to a switch we know, we could replant. We can trade the trick, not the seed.” “You talk like we have time,” she said. “We don’t. Not yet.” The black markets were just markets where the lights didn’t always work. The client she meant was a woman whose voice came on the radio from a relay tower run on stolen solar, the one that didn’t go dead when the corporate satellites went dark. She hoarded bio in a vault under a stadium where the grass had been replaced with solar laminate. She traded in glow and life and water rights. She had teeth. She’d made it clear she didn’t want me; she wanted my output. Fine. If I had to bend, I bent where the metal wanted heat. I scraped the seed with a scalpel nicked from a surgeon’s kit. I flicked the scales of endosperm into a tube and added buffer I’d made with salt and starch and the luck of a dying chemistry teacher’s notes. Then the enzymes—the ones I’d scraped off cultures that were older than I was, coaxed back to something like function with heat baths made from old espresso machines and water baths sewn from parts of baby incubators. The laminar flow hood was a joke, a cabinet with a fan and cloth filters I soaked in alcohol and left in the sun. “Wake up,” I told the enzymes. “This is your time.” I set the tube in the aluminum block and waited for the relay’s click. Annealing. Extension. I could feel the machine through the bench, the faint warm that made the mushrooms nearest its corner glow less bright. I turned to Jori, who lay still and tense on the bed’s cracked vinyl. “I need your arm,” I said. “I need to find the border of the wrong.” “I hired you because you talk about wrong like it’s a town,” she said, but she rolled her sleeve anyway. Her skin was cool, given what sat inside. The spiderweb went deeper than skin and had pulled it down, left little dimples like a constellation. I tapped my needle with a fingernail to knock loose the air, then slid it in beside the inflamed line. I’d mixed a cocktail of my own making: bits of CRISPR that had been sold as a kid’s science kit once, a viral scaffold stripped and sanded, a switch that would flip off the protease that the barb had started up inside her and that her body, for reasons I couldn’t see, had decided to keep feeding. There would be a cost. There was always a cost. Maybe she’d run fever and see things. Maybe the process would chew her wrist bones a little until I could catch it. Maybe the payoff would be pain she could live with; maybe it would be that she’d start to smell storm clouds a day before anybody else. The syringe plunger moved smooth. The mushrooms flared, then settled. “How long?” she asked. “For your arm? A day,” I said. “For the seed? A night. For the client’s money? That depends on how honest she is when she uses the word generous.” “She says she’ll send meds. Real ones. Antibiotics. Plasma for the kids.” Plasma was a dangerous word. It meant power, and it meant blood, and it meant the stuff the corporations had said couldn’t be made without them. I’d mixed my own stand-ins too long not to feel the ache behind my eyes at the thought of cold bags with real salve inside. “We’ll pack up the sequences into plasmids she can use,” I said. “She grows. We get our cut in full.” “You make it sound like a bakery.” “I make it sound like anyone could walk out and plant a seed and it would become something good,” I said. “That’s not true anymore.” The centrifuge moaned when I spun it, the counterweights clacking. I couldn’t tell if the noise masked the tremor in Jori’s breath or if she was quiet enough to erase herself. The thermal block clicked. I counted. I moved tubes from one rack to another and gloved and ungloved hands to save glove fingertips. I swapped micropipettes that didn’t quite set to the volume they promised, used the fine roller on my thumb like a violinist finding a note. The gel rig hummed; I’d soldered it out of toaster coils and it ran smooth if the inverter didn’t hiccup. The bands showed under the blue lamp. I squinted and prayed to no one in particular that the big ones meant a trick that would hold. Jori slept. I covered her with a tarp and wrapped her fingers around a warm bottle that had been saline once and now kept whatever inside me functioning from crystallizing when the night came cold. In the other room, the radio crackled, a voice checking intervals, code that I’d learned to translate into “are you there” and “are you listening” and “do you want to spend the rest of this year not starving.” Time is a thing that eats itself in a place like this. It chews seconds into hours and spits days into a bowl and calls it soup. When dawn burned the mushrooms into pale ghosts, I had something printed: a strip of useless-looking wet with a load of maybe inside. I had tubes with bacteria that were pregnant with ideas. I had an email that would go nowhere if the wind died and the relay on the ridge didn’t kick. Jori woke at the click of the thermocycler. She flexed her hand. She winced and then didn’t, a two-step I’d seen before when the flip switched under skin. The spiderweb under her skin had loosened: the lines less taut, the heave of the heat gone. She saw me see it. “You’re a witch,” she said. “I’m a mechanic,” I said. “And we have a delivery to make.” In the clinic corridor, the glowing mushrooms had spread to the baseboards. Somebody had stepped on them once and left a footprint in cold fire. The wheels of Jori’s cart—she’d brought the capsule in on it, hidden under cloth and dignity—left trails I could follow with a blacklight if the world fell dark enough. We packed the plasmids into a printout that looked like art and felt like snakeskin. We sealed seeds and false seeds in vacuum bags I’d made out of mylar balloons and glue I cooked over a camp stove. We wrapped it all in old lesson plans—grammar worksheets with red pencil and a note from a teacher: remember your verbs. Jori rolled her sleeve down and tucked the bundle under her jacket. “You’ll get your meds,” she said. “You’ll get…your thing. Whatever you want.” “I want to grow something that can have children,” I said, and felt stupider saying it than I had thinking it. “That’s all. That’s the contract I want. With the world.” “Write it up,” she said. “Stamp it with a crest. Maybe the mushrooms will keep it.” We shook hands around the glow. My skin prickled where it touched hers, as if the changes I’d made in her wanted to see if they could jump. They couldn’t. Not like that. It never had been that easy. Still. I pulled back. She smiled a real smile this time and was gone into the corridor with her cargo, her back straight as a ledger. The radio crackled again. The client’s voice, smooth as machine oil. I loaded my pack with tools in case the turbines on the ridge lean wrong, in case I had to put my hand into their guts and feel for the break. The thermocycler clicked down to warm and then to cold. The mushrooms held their glow, faint and earnest. Behind the clinic, the river made its stupid noises as it hit broken concrete and old pylons. The fields beyond had more dust than dirt, more grit than loam. I had a thumb of wheat that might not know how to stop itself, an organism that might remember seed. I had a pocket full of bacteria that didn’t know what the word obsolete meant. I had a contract not written on paper but on the inside of my mouth, that I’d say the words and mean them when the client asked: yes, we made your thing; yes, we’ll trade; yes, send them what we need; yes, send me something I can use when the next body comes to my door spiked with the last century’s idea of a lock. Outside, the sun scraped light across the tiles and the mushrooms drank it, slowly, their glow sinking the way breath sinks in sleep. I patted the thermocycler. It stayed warm under my hand like a creature that had been tamed, for now. I lay the new seeds in their box, sealed, right where the glow was strongest, and watched them until the fan hummed and the room clicked and the day gathered without asking what any of us planned. I had a blade sharp enough to open obsolescence and see if it bled. I had work to do. I had a world to cheat back into its own design. The market could have its cut. The rest I meant to keep.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This biopunk chapter successfully creates a vivid post-apocalyptic world where corporate genetic engineering with built-in obsolescence has collapsed society. The author excels at world-building through detailed descriptions of jury-rigged lab equipment and the biohacker protagonist's work environment. The prose is highly atmospheric, with strong sensory details that immerse the reader in this decaying world. Descriptions like "Threads of blue-green glow from the seams where hairline cracks had taken root, like veins under skin" and the detailed explanations of repurposed equipment create a tangible setting. The author effectively uses technical language related to genetic engineering that feels authentic without becoming impenetrable. The protagonist is well-developed through their internal monologue and interactions with Jori. Their expertise, determination, and philosophical stance on genetic freedom come through clearly. The physical toll of genetic modifications is addressed through the protagonist's catalog of bodily changes: "My lungs ran on a weird patchwork of modified alveolar proteins that let me breathe easier after the dust storms, but sometimes when the air was still I could taste copper and see blue halos around things in the dark." The black market contract plot is integrated well, with Jori bringing a valuable pre-obsolescence seed that needs to be sequenced for a powerful client. The stakes are clear, and the transaction feels appropriately tense and morally complex. The dialogue is sparse but effective, revealing character dynamics and world details naturally. The protagonist's voice maintains a consistent tone throughout—knowledgeable, somewhat cynical, but with an underlying idealism about genetic freedom. Where the piece could improve is in its pacing. The narrative sometimes lingers too long on descriptive passages, particularly of equipment, which occasionally slows the momentum. While the technical details add authenticity, they sometimes overshadow character development and plot progression. The ending strikes a balance between pragmatism and hope that feels earned given the world's constraints. The protagonist's determination to "cheat [the world] back into its own design" provides a satisfying conclusion that doesn't feel artificially positive given the grim setting. Overall, this is a strong piece of biopunk fiction that successfully creates a detailed post-apocalyptic world where genetic engineering has gone wrong. The author demonstrates a good command of both scientific concepts and literary techniques, creating an engaging narrative that fulfills the prompt requirements. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Iteration 2 — Avg Score: 90.6
+ Classic sci-fi: The Azra Gambit — Score: 88.8
Prompt:
Classic sci-fi (Author style: Asimov) The Azra Gambit Colonial mars is being mined by corporations who take leases on indentured labourers. The thing they are mining is Azra, a recently discovered exotic metal which accelerates radioactive decay to such a rate that it is greatly sought after for interstellar drives and weapons alike. This has created both a gold rush and an arms race as various interests vie for control and endeavour to unlock Azra's secrets. The story follows Arthur Neegan, a first generation settler and mining engineer. Upon discovering that his unassuming plot sits atop an immense Azra vein, he is subjected to a flurry of interest and scrutiny. Write the next chapter in this story, in which an armed retinue descends on Arthur's home and politely but forcefully invites him to a meeting with some unknown party off-world. The insignia look like that of the Antares diplomatic corp -- diplomatic in name only. Arthur finds himself in the centre of a political tug of war. The chapter involves a meeting with this unknown party, who makes Arthur an offer. The scene should be primarily dialogue, interspersed with vivid description & scene setting. It should sow hints of the larger intrigue, stakes & dangers. Include Asimov's trademark big-and-small-picture world building and retrofuturistic classic scifi vibe. The chapter begins with Arthur aboard the transfer vessel, wondering just what he's gotten involved in. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The transfer vessel's air filtration system hums with a persistent mechanical drone. Arthur Neegan sat in a seat bolted to the bulkhead and listened to it, counting the pulses as if they were the steps of a march. The chair was upholstered in something that pretended to be leather and failed. The ceiling above him arced with ribs of enamel-white metal, each rib marked with crisp serial numerals suggested by people who believed that order could substitute for comfort. Across from him, a man in a uniform that could not decide whether it was dress or armor sat with his hands folded. The insignia on his shoulder—an eight-pointed star with two intersecting orbits—was familiar in only the way a threat is familiar. The Antares Diplomatic Corps. Diplomatic in name, and otherwise practical. "You'll like the view," said the uniformed man, as if that reconciled anything. His voice was neither friendly nor hostile. It was a voice that reported weather and casualties with equal intonation. "We break orbit in twelve minutes. Dock in nineteen." "Antares?" Arthur asked. "You boys are far from your constellation." The man allowed himself a small, official smile. "We don't belong to the star, Mr. Neegan. Only the name." Arthur glanced at the viewport. The Martian sky outside was the color of diluted rust, shadowed by the metallic bones of the transfer tower. His settlement—sediment-stained hab domes, a plastcrete strip, a scatter of antennae that had been straight once and now leaned like exhausted men—was a curve of memory over the horizon. Somewhere under that red, under that brittle crust, under a hundred meters of angry basalt and lightless ice, lay the dark seam that had changed everything. Azra. He had hit it by accident, then confirmed it by every method that would stand up in a technical review and none that would stand up in a court. He rubbed his fingers together. They still smelled faintly of the metal, though chemically Azra had no odor. He had convinced himself that a catalytic accelerator for decay should be cold as sunlight. Yet when he first held a fragment in the glove, it had felt warm. "You took my neighbors' guns," he said. "Temporarily. There were safety concerns." "So when this is over," Arthur said, and felt his voice go dry, "you give them back?" "If it's over," the uniformed man said. The smile had departed. The hatch whispered. A woman entered without hurry. She did not wear the Antares insignia. She wore a garment that might have been a dress if dresses were designed by engineers: straight lines, reinforced seams, a collar that suggested she liked her neck exactly where it was. She carried no weapon unless you counted her eyes. "Mr. Neegan," she said. "My apologies for the abruptness of the invitation. I'm Lydia Voss. I'm here as a facilitator." "For Antares?" "For my client." "And your client is?" She looked at him with the kind of patience that promised the answer would arrive soon, and that—when it did—he would wish she had delayed. "Briefly," she said, and sat opposite him, ignoring the uniformed man without dismissing him. "The situation is unstable. Your discovery destabilizes it further. Everyone is nervous. Nervous people make expensive mistakes." "I agree," Arthur said. "On Mars we prefer our mistakes cheap." The filtration hum shifted half a note as the transfer vessel's attitude thrusters adjusted. Arthur felt the faint pressure of inertia on his shoulders, the way one feels an accusation one has not earned. "Mr. Neegan," Voss said. "You are first-generation colonial stock, yes? Born under the Dome at Syrtis Minor. Engineering academy, fourth in your cohort. Your dissertation was on heat dissipation in vacuum microenvironments. If you had not come to Helios Quadrant to take an unremarkable lease on Sector J-19, you would likely be teaching now, perhaps arguing with auditors about the cost of thermal wafers." "I appreciate the biography," Arthur said. "It saves me the trouble. What would you like?" "What we all want," she said. "A predictable future. And in particular, a future in which Azra does not make all the other futures shorter." She folded her hands. Arthur noticed the absence of rings. He had never trusted hands with much to hide. These hands were plain. That was one thing to fear. "It accelerates decay," she said. "You found a way to tame that. At least locally." Arthur looked at the ceiling. He thought of the vein, of the way the sensors went blind around it. Of how instruments that had never failed now offered numbers that read like poems. Azra made containers weep neutrons and equations develop personalities. Yet in the presence of certain fields and a certain geometry—his geometry—it stabilized. Local, temperamental, expensive. Enough to make a drive roar louder, a bomb whisper cruelty, a civilization recalibrate its tables of half-lives. "I found a way to make it misbehave on command," he said. "Taming is your word." Voss nodded. "It will do. The point is that you control an input. That makes you more interesting than a rock." The uniformed man cleared his throat. "Ms. Voss," he said, making the name a rank. "The passenger is to be prepared for the meeting. Not interrogated." "This isn't an interrogation," Voss said. "It's a courtesy. Mr. Neegan deserves context." "I'd settle for a destination," Arthur said. "We're docking where?" "The relay station at Phobos Alt-2," she said. "Antares maintains a hollowing there. Private. Then we proceed outward." "Outward," he said. "Antares has jurisdiction outward?" "Jurisdiction is an attitude. You'll find there are a great many attitudes in orbit, Mr. Neegan." He stared at her and thought of maps. As a boy he had traced the red. As a man he had learned to read the blue lines the way a driller reads grain. No map had prepared him for this: statelets stacked like cards, authorities intersecting like shadows. "Why me and not some corporate board?" he asked. "Helios Mining would sell me to you and send an invoice." "They would," Voss agreed. "But Azra is not ore. It's leverage. Boards prefer assets to remain in categories they understand. People do not always oblige. Besides, Helios is... occupied." She glanced at the uniformed man, who did not nod. "An audit. Unrelated, of course." "Of course," Arthur said. He felt his mouth twist. The retrofitted construct of colonial law, the long cables stringing Mars to Earth and Earth to the Belt, trembled with Azra's discovery. If you braced a finger along the cable, you could feel the oscillation, the human tone in it. "We'll meet my client," Voss said. "They will make you an offer. You will accept, or not. But I would like you to go in informed. The Antares Corps is one vector. The Central Earth Secretariat is another. The Neptune Arcology Alliance, a third. There are lesser vectors. All believe that control of Azra translates to survival. They are not wrong. All believe they can apply control as if Azra were water in a pipe. They are wrong." "And you?" Arthur asked. "Are you right?" "No," she said. "But we can be less wrong, and sooner." He thought of the first time he had leaned over the pit and watched the drill head stutter. He thought of the call to his sister in Lowell, of her silence when he said the word "Azra," as if her tongue had been told that certain syllables had new prices. "You're not telling me something fundamental," he said. "Several things," Voss said. "But one in particular: Azra isn't confined to your lot. It isn't a Mars anomaly. It is a network phenomenon. The vein is a node. The nodes resonate. The more you extract, the more you wake its neighbors. The more it hears itself, the more it acts like a single thing. My client is concerned that if enough nodes resonate, the network will self-organize." "What does that mean?" Arthur asked. He didn't like where the words were headed. Self-organize was a term he had used only in reference to dust storms and bureaucracy. "It means that the decay will stop being an accident," Voss said. "It will be a choice. And things that can choose—" "Have politics," Arthur said. "Precisely." The transfer vessel shivered along a diagonal. The viewport showed a slice of gray-black studded with the faint geometries of Phobos Alt-2. It was not beautiful. It was efficient. Torch cones glowed a dull cherry as they rotated. Docking booms extended like the feelers of an insect that had adapted to vacuum and budget cuts. "Who is your client?" Arthur said again. "I've done my courtesy. Give me yours." Voss looked at her watch as if it meant something. Perhaps it did. Timepieces in space were less about time than about authority. "The client calls itself the Third Martian Council," she said. "There is no Third Martian Council," Arthur said. "I would have noticed the first two." "There was a First," Voss said mildly. "It met for four hours in a storage unit at Utopia Planitia forty years ago, decided it could not pay for coffee, and dissolved. The Second exists in the charters of several cooperatives who prefer not to use it. The Third exists as an alliance of computational assemblies distributed across fourteen habitats. It argues with itself constantly. It does not pay for coffee either. But it represents an emergent Martian will. It is eager to make you an offer before Earth makes you a threat." "And Antares?" Arthur asked, indicating the uniformed man with his chin. "We rent the room," the uniformed man said. "We ensure the meeting occurs without an accident. Or with the right one." The docking alarm chimed: a gentle, civilized sound designed by someone who had read about bells. The vessel thumped lightly as clamps engaged. "You will have an escort," Voss said. "It will be a courtesy escort, which is to say they will be armed." "And if I decline the offer?" Arthur asked. "You will leave free," she said. "In the sense that someone will own every corridor you exit." The hatch opened with budgeted smoothness. The docking collar extended with a hiss that was theater; there is no hiss in vacuum. They walked. The corridor to the hollowing was a spiral of gray with occasional windows that framed pieces of Mars like fragments of a broken coin. Phobos Alt-2’s interior was a cathedral of mass ratios. Cargo canisters stood in stacks along rails that glided overhead. Men and women in coveralls, in uniforms, in anonymous black moved with intent, each motion a line in an equation that solved for power. At a door marked only with a square of matte blue, Voss stopped. "You'll forgive the formality," she said. "They prefer projections. It keeps the ghosts out." "The ghosts?" Arthur said. "Intention leaves residue," she said. "In a room like this, you can choke on it." Inside, the walls were smooth and indifferent. The light was not sourced; it existed. A table occupied the center—old Earth wood sealed under glass, its grain a reminder that once, biomes made furniture for us. Three chairs waited. In the seat opposite, a shape flickered into being. It was a man of indeterminate middle age and impossible clarity, as if the air had decided to assemble a person out of diligence. "Mr. Neegan," the projection said. Its voice was warm. "I am Third. I apologize for dramatics. We find it constructive." "Third," Arthur said. He sat carefully. Voss took the chair to his left. The uniformed man stood by the door, an armed exclamation mark. "You represent Mars," Arthur said, because someone had to put the sentence into the air to see what it did. "I represent a faction of Mars that believes Mars can be more than a mine," Third said. "I represent neighborhoods and networks. I represent the fact that the people who were born here do not expect to return to Earth to die." "Offers," Voss said gently. "Yes," Third said, and smiled. It was a practiced, human smile. Arthur felt himself like it despite himself. "Mr. Neegan: we cannot protect you from the storm. We can give you windbreaks. You have a claim on a thing that makes engines swift and bombs delicate. You have a method that makes it somewhat safe to touch. Earth will take it. Antares will rent it. Saturn will tempt. The price will be your voice. We propose this instead: you put your seam into a cooperative trust under Martian law. We license your method across nodes we control. In return, we guarantee—through our alliances, through people like Ms. Voss—that your family remains safe, your neighbors remain armed, your name is attached to standards that will be difficult to undo. We will make Azra into a public utility." "A public utility," Arthur repeated. The words tasted like old speeches. "You're asking me to nationalize my vein." "We're asking you not to privatize annihilation," Third said. "We will make mistakes. But we will make them here, and we will make them in public." "And if I sell to the highest bidder?" Arthur said. His voice was softer than he intended. He thought of the price lists that would appear in his message queue, of the lines at his door. He thought of his sister's silence. "Then someone will own the future," Third said. "And they will put a lock on it that does not release." Voss leaned closer. "There are other offers," she said. "I could read them to you. They sound like money and safety and exit visas to houses with gravity and gardens. They are not lies. But they omit costs. The things omitted have a way of appearing later with interest." The projection adjusted itself, a ripple of photons correcting for a room that was never quite still. "Mr. Neegan," it said. "Azra's network notices itself. If we are decisions now, so is it. Do we want those decisions to arise in boardrooms that consider oxygen a line item? Or in assemblies that argue about school hours? It is not romance. It is arithmetic." Arthur put his elbows on the table and laced his fingers. He was a man of ratios and tolerances. He had done the math on thermal wafers and on the cost of replacing a gearbox when the nearest replacement was two months and a bribe away. He had not done this math. He began to. "You'll need my method," he said. "It's in my head, and half in my notes, and half in the way I stand when I tune the coils. You think you can take it?" "We think we can teach you how to teach us," Third said. "We think we can make your method survive you, which is the only survival that matters. We offer you a place to stand. If you prefer to sell your weight elsewhere, you may. The tug-of-war will continue, with you as rope. Here, at least, we intend to let you walk away with your hands." "And Antares?" Arthur asked, turning to Voss. "Antares will help this occur without a fatal misunderstanding," she said. "Our insignia is a warning to those who would misunderstand." "And your price?" Arthur said. "The price is that when Mars calls us, we can say we were useful," Voss said. "Useful organizations live longer." He glanced at the uniformed man. The eight-pointed star answered nothing. Outside, the hum of the filtration system had receded into a background as natural as breath. Arthur, who had built a life out of partitions—between heat and cold, between vacuum and blood—looked at the partitions in front of him and saw that they were provisional, and that the air on both sides smelled like Azra even when it shouldn't. He exhaled. He remembered the way the drill had stuttered. He remembered counting pulses. They had counted back. "I'll need assurances," he said. "Contracts, not meetings. Safeguards. We do this under Martian law, yes? Then Martian law will need teeth." "We have collected some," Third said. "We expect to lose a few in the process." "And I want my neighbors' guns back," Arthur said, looking at the uniformed man. "All of them." "That will be arranged," Voss said. He nodded. It was not agreement. It was the first motion of a lever. He felt the weight of it. There were other rooms to sit in, other offers to hear. But the arithmetic had begun to solve itself, crudely, on the table between them. "Very well," Arthur said. "Let's define 'public utility.' Let's define 'trust.' And then let's define how we keep the network from making decisions we don't." Third's smile held. It was not triumph. It was hope wearing armor. "We began that conversation before you were born," it said. "We will be delighted to continue it with you." The filtration drone was back in his ears. For the first time since the insignia had appeared at his door, Arthur found that he could not hear the hum without also hearing, faintly, the possibility of a different noise: a crowd arguing, a machine learning, an ore singing. He straightened. "All right," he said. "Teach me what you think you know about Azra's mind. Then I'll show you where it's wrong."
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response is an impressive piece of science fiction that captures Asimov's style remarkably well. The author has created a chapter that feels authentic to classic sci-fi while developing an intriguing political scenario around the discovery of Azra. The prose demonstrates a sophisticated command of language with precise, technical descriptions that evoke the retrofuturistic aesthetic requested. Descriptions like "The ceiling above him arced with ribs of enamel-white metal, each rib marked with crisp serial numerals suggested by people who believed that order could substitute for comfort" efficiently establish both the physical environment and the sociopolitical context. The dialogue is particularly strong, with each character having a distinct voice that reveals their position and motivation. The exchanges between Arthur, Voss, and Third are layered with subtext and political maneuvering. Lines like "Jurisdiction is an attitude. You'll find there are a great many attitudes in orbit, Mr. Neegan" efficiently communicate the complex power dynamics at play. The world-building is excellent, revealing both the immediate situation and the larger political landscape through natural conversation and observation rather than exposition. The concept of Azra as a network that "notices itself" introduces fascinating philosophical and scientific dimensions that feel true to Asimov's interest in both technology and human systems. Character development is handled with subtlety. Arthur is portrayed as practical and analytical, weighing his options carefully while maintaining his principles. His request for his neighbors' guns to be returned reveals his loyalty to his community. Voss is enigmatic but professional, while Third represents a complex political entity with its own agenda. The pacing is well-managed, with the tension building naturally through the meeting. The stakes are clearly established—control of Azra could determine the future of human civilization—without resorting to melodrama. There are a few moments where the prose becomes slightly overwrought, with metaphors occasionally stacked too densely. However, these instances are rare and don't significantly detract from the overall quality. The ending strikes an appropriate balance, avoiding both naive optimism and cynical despair. Arthur's decision to engage with Third while maintaining his independence feels earned and consistent with his character. Overall, this is an exceptional response that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt while creating a compelling narrative with depth and nuance. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Contemporary romance: Darkroom Revelations — Score: 88.4
Prompt:
Darkroom Revelations Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of Dani, a 25-year-old assertive art student known for her bold style and take-charge attitude in relationships. For the past semester, she's been quietly fascinated by Elliot (he/him), a 19-year-old boy in her experimental photography class. Dani has been intrigued by his unconventional masculinity: killer thrift-shop-nu-goth style, soft demeanour and quiet intellect. When they're paired for a final project requiring late nights in the darkroom, Elliot tentatively shares that he's been questioning his gender identity and expression. Set during one of these intimate darkroom sessions where the red light creates a confessional atmosphere. Explore Dani's complex attraction—her usual assertiveness complicated by her desire to protect Elliot's vulnerability, her excitement at witnessing his self-discovery, and her confusion about what this means for her own identity as someone typically attracted to more defined gender presentations. The narrative should capture the tender awkwardness of their conversations, Dani's internal struggle between taking charge and wanting to give Elliot agency, and the unexpected chemistry that develops as both find themselves in uncharted territory. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The darkroom door sighs shut, and the world becomes measured in breath and red light. It paints Elliot’s face the color of a pulse, and somehow he looks even softer, the edges of him turned to velvet and shadow. It should feel like my element—the gritty, wet chemical smell, the familiar clunk of trays on the counter, the way my hands know what to do even when my brain’s a mess. But tonight something else is taking up room, settling where my certainty usually lives. He’s quiet, careful, the kind of person who moves around the enlarger like it could bruise, like he could bruise. A black tee cut raw at the neck, a thrift-store belt with a silver buckle, rings that shine like coins pulled from a river. He wears his hair in a way that makes it look intentional, like a statement and a shrug at once. His boots hardly make a sound. Maybe that’s what I noticed first—how he manages to occupy space without demanding it. Me, I’ve been the opposite my whole life. I push. I shoulder in. I fill. “Okay,” I say, tapping the edge of the easel with my nail. “Show me how you’re framing it.” He nods, slides the negative carrier into the enlarger, his fingers long and ink-stained. He adjusts the focus until the image floats sharp: my laugh caught mid-burst, mouth open, hair in motion—he’s been catching me all semester, like I’m a bird he’s got a gentle hand on. It makes me feel both seen and held, and I’m not used to the second part. “I still can’t believe you got that shot,” I say, even though what I mean is I can’t believe you were watching me with that kind of attention. I don’t say it. I’m the teacher’s pet of not saying things. “I shoot a lot on instinct.” His voice is low, soft, not shy exactly. Measured. “Like if I think about it too hard, the moment gets self-conscious and runs away.” “Yeah,” I say, and it lands between us like we’re agreeing on a secret. It’s the end of the semester, the part where the air on campus freezes into that particular brittle hopefulness. The final project is supposed to be conceptual, collaborative. The professor paired us because she thought my bossiness and his quiet might cancel each other out. “He’ll rein you in,” she’d said. “You’ll pull him out.” I am very good at pulling. I want to be good at not. He flips on the timer, and the enlarger bulb hums like a small, contented animal. I slide a fresh sheet of paper under the easel with the muscle memory of a thousand prints. The red light makes everything seductive, even the damned tongs. We work without speaking for a while, the soundtrack a soft symphony of timers, dripping, our breaths aligning. He slides the exposed paper into the developer, and I take over, rocking the tray gently, watching the image ghost into view. Alchemy, I fell for it the way one falls for the first person who tells you you’re too much and you decide to become even more. “Can I tell you something?” he asks, just as the shadows finish filling my hair. His eyes—eyeliner smudged, lashes thick—are on the tray. He speaks like the words are heavy and he’s tired of carrying them alone. I brace myself without meaning to. I don’t want to bulldoze his confession. I don’t want to say the wrong thing in the right tone and have it sound like permission rather than listening. “Yeah,” I say quietly. “Tell me.” He clears his throat, the sound paper-thin in the red. “I’ve been…thinking a lot about gender.” A beat. “My own.” The developer ticks in the tray against the plastic like rain. I keep rocking. He continues before I can make a shape out of my thoughts. “I mean, I’ve always felt it, but this semester it’s like—I don’t know. Lens flare. Suddenly I can’t pretend it’s an accident.” “And what are you thinking?” I ask, and there it is: I keep my hands moving and my voice soft, like I’m developing his sentences and hoping they turn out. He laughs, a tiny burst, nervous. “That maybe I don’t fit the…conventional masculine thing. That I like he/him. But I also like…that some things feel better when I don’t have to be a certain way to be recognized.” He looks at me then. “Does that make sense?” “Yes,” I say, and I mean it. The word is steady. “It makes a lot of sense.” He looks relieved in a way that makes me want to wrap him up and stand between him and any oncoming storm. That’s my instinct: make myself a wall, a heat source, a shield. My attraction has always been to people who want to be pushed against that wall, who want me to bite as much as kiss. But I’ve been fascinated by the way he exists outside those rules, a softness that isn’t weakness, a masculinity that doesn’t need to win to matter. I’ve noticed his bracelets, the way he touches a print like it might be warm, the quiet he doesn’t apologize for. “I like the pronouns I have,” he says. “I just—I also like painting my nails and wanting people to see it as…part of me, not a contradiction. And some days I like wearing a skirt. I haven’t here. Yet. And I look at the guys in our class who are all…” He wiggles his fingers and I understand he means angles, lines, certainty. “And I don’t see myself in them. And it’s not like I want to be a girl. It’s like the binary is denim that fits someone else’s hips.” I laugh then, soft and probably adoring. I can’t help it. “That’s a good metaphor.” “You like denim,” he says, glancing down at my paint-splattered jeans. He notices things. It’s devastating. “I like you, period,” I almost say. Instead, I lift the print to the stop bath, slide it in. The smell of acetic acid cuts through the air and through my reluctance. “What do you want people to see when they look at you?” I ask. He leans back against the counter, head tilted, looking up like the answer might be stuck to the ceiling. “I want them to see that I’m allowed to be gentle and still be me. That softness isn’t…a curve to be cut off to fit a mold.” He says the last part like he’s bracing for a joke. I feel the familiar heat of my boldness rising—my reflex to make a big statement, to turn this into something I can nail to a wall. I want to say, I’ll fight anyone who tries to sharpen your edges. I want to say, try a skirt, I’ll walk next to you. Instead I take a breath and decide to let him choose the next move, right there in the red light. “Can I be selfish?” I say. “And ask how I fit in this?” It’s as close to vulnerability as I’m used to. I can feel my own outline blurring a little. I like men. I like the ones who meet my push with their own. Elliot complicates the category in a way that puts a sweet ache under my ribs. He turns toward me and the space between us becomes a thing. “I don’t know,” he admits, relief and fear braided in the words. “I haven’t—this is the first time I’ve said any of it out loud. To anyone.” Something loosens. I place the print into the fixer and set the timer. “Then let’s not figure out everything tonight,” I say. “We can start with you saying it out loud and me listening without making it my project.” He smiles, crooked. “You do like a project.” “I do,” I say, grimacing at myself. “But I like you more.” The timer clicks, the third tray now full of a picture of me laughing like I don’t know I’m being witnessed. I turn the print in the fixer and try not to romanticize the metaphor. He reaches past me to grab the next sheet of paper, and in the economy of the darkroom a simple movement becomes clumsy intimacy. His hand bumps the box. It slides. I grab for it. He grabs for it. The flap flies open. The stack of glossy paper thumps against the counter and fans like doomed snow in the red light. “Shit,” we say at the same time. And then: “Sorry,” also at the same time. We both freeze. The papers lie there, exposed and already graying. There’s a second where it feels like we can pretend it didn’t happen if we don’t breathe. I start to laugh, a little hysterical edge in it. The spell cracks without breaking. “Well. That’s…half our budget.” He looks stricken. “I’m so—” “Hey.” I put a hand up like a crossing guard and an apology parachute. “Accidents happen. And maybe it’s good for us. Unplanned. Raw edges.” I’m trying not to boss the situation into a lesson, but the first thing I think is: this is an image too. Blown exposure. Waste as artifact. He eyes me like he’s trying to decide if I’m making him feel better or turning tragedy into a thesis. “We are so screwed.” “We’ll figure it out,” I say. And then: “Maybe we could use it.” I pick up a sheet, gesture at the faint ghost forming just from the ambient exposure. “Conceptually. The idea of what gets overexposed. Overseen. And what we want to protect in the dark.” He blinks, and the corner of his mouth twitches. “You’re impossible.” “And you love it,” I tease, and then realize the word is out there, pulsing. “I mean. You will love it. The idea. Maybe.” His gaze does something that makes my stomach drop in a good way. “I like that your first instinct is to turn spilled milk into a milk painting.” “Dairy-based art is my specialty.” He laughs, the tension dissolving just enough. We gather the ruined sheets and stack them like we’re making a pyre for our mistakes. I make a mental note to buy a new box tomorrow and not tell him how much it costs. “So,” I say, because the quiet hovers in a new shape. “Do you want me to use different language when I talk about you? Or do you want me to…just know and watch?” He props his hip against the counter, the seam of his jeans worn, the ring on his middle finger catching the red. “For now, he/him is good. I think what I want is permission to…dial up or down without needing to justify the settings.” “Done,” I say, too fast, and then I slow down. “I mean. Yes. And if I mess up, tell me, yeah? Don’t make me guess and then resent me for guessing wrong.” His shoulders drop like I’ve cut a string that was holding them up uncomfortably. “Thank you.” I want to step forward and touch the side of his face, to thumb the smear of eyeliner near his eye, to say, I’m here. I want to tell him that his softness is an invitation to my own, which is terrifying. I’ve spent years being the one who knows where we’re going and how we’re going to get there. I can map a project before we’ve even taken the first shot. I can take a lover apart like a machine and put them back together better than I found them. But that’s not what this is. This is new terrain, damp and luminous, edges unsharp. “We should pull that,” he says, pointing at the fixer. I retrieve the print and clip it to the line. My laughing face spins slowly, dripping. “It’s weird to look at yourself on a line,” he says. “Weirder to look at yourself in someone else’s viewfinder,” I say. He considers that, cheeks shadowed. “It’s nice, sometimes. To be held in a frame that isn’t a trap.” We fall into a rhythm again, making do with the few sheets left in the box, our hands occasionally brushing. Each touch is more loaded than the last, like adding a stop more light each exposure. He talks in pockets, like reaching into his own coat and pulling out scraps: how he tried on his girlfriend’s skirt when he was sixteen and felt beautiful and then felt guilty for feeling beautiful; how he wears rings because they make his gestures feel like sentences. I tell him about my first boyfriend who was so sure of himself that I wore his certainty like a jacket until I realized it didn’t fit me either. I tell him how I always fall for men who know they’re men, whose bodies meet mine like a challenge. I do not tell him that his hesitation is turning me inside out. When we’re washing the last print, he says, “Do you think there’s room for me? Like this? With someone like you?” I dry my hands on a towel and choose my words like negatives from a contact sheet. “I think there’s room for whatever we decide. If we decide. I don’t want to…steer you somewhere because it’s easier for me.” He steps closer, the air changing pressure. “The thing is,” he says, looking at my mouth and then away, “I don’t feel like you’re steering. I feel like you’re walking next to me and checking I’m wearing good shoes.” I smile. “Practicality is sexy.” He laughs again, and then he doesn’t. The red light hums. The wash water patters. I can feel him thinking. “Can I—” he starts, and then stops, which is so unlike me that it almost breaks me. I step forward the smallest amount and angle my head in a way that says, you can try. But I don’t close the space. I don’t take. I invite. He leans in and kisses me the way he shoots—a little tentative, instinctive, like if he thinks too hard it will run away. His mouth is warm, unpainted, tasting like chemical air and whatever he had for dinner. It is not the kind of kiss that pins. It is the kind that asks. I answer without swallowing him whole. I kiss him back like agreeing, like yes, like a darkroom where a picture slowly appears and then refuses to disappear again. His hand finds my wrist and doesn't tighten, just rests, matching my pulse. My whole body is a light meter trying not to max out. We pull back and look at each other like we’re checking for blur. “That okay?” he says. “Yeah,” I say, steadier than I feel. “Yeah.” We don’t pretend the questions are gone. We don’t pretend the paper didn’t get ruined. We don’t pretend we’ve named this. We move around each other for the next hour with that kiss hovering between us like a third thing we’re protecting from the wrong light. I don’t boss him into another. He doesn’t apologize for wanting. We make prints that fail and some that don’t. We talk about the project and the idea of overexposure and what it means to be seen too much and not enough. By the time we step out into the hallway, blinking against the fluorescent truth of the school at night, the red afterimage still floats in my vision. I can see the shape of him beside me even in the neutral light. He brushes my shoulder with his, accidentally-on-purpose, and I resist the urge to grab his hand. Instead I ask, “Coffee tomorrow? No darkroom. Just…light.” He nods, the corner of his mouth lifting. “Yeah. Let’s try light.” As we walk, I think about how my attraction has always looked like a strong line and a dark shadow, the comfort of contrast. This feels like a gradient, the kind you have to stand close to to see where one thing becomes another. It feels less like taking and more like opening. It scares me. It thrills me. It makes me want to be gentle without feeling small. Back in my apartment later, my fingers still smell like fixer. I hold them up to my face and think about how some images don’t care what you planned. You set your exposure, you line up your shot, and then the light finds a way in. You ruin a stack of paper and have to start over with something unexpected. You hold someone else’s confession like a print in a tray and tilt it, patient, watching the picture appear. And you learn not to rush it, even if your hands are itching to grab, to lead, to decide. An hour ago, under red light, I saw something I didn’t know I was looking for. I want to keep looking, even if it means I have to learn a new way of seeing. I want to walk next to him, practical and protectively useless in the face of whatever he has to find, art school budgets and all. Maybe I’m not losing my edge. Maybe I’m finding a curve I didn’t know could hold me. Tomorrow we’ll figure out how to pay for new paper. Tomorrow I’ll ask him what kind of nail polish looks best on him and if he wants me to go with him to buy it. Tonight, I let the image sit and fix. I let myself soften and stay.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures Dani's perspective as she navigates her attraction to Elliot during their darkroom session. The piece effectively establishes Dani's assertive personality while showing her internal struggle to temper this trait when interacting with Elliot's vulnerability. The writing excels in creating the intimate atmosphere of the darkroom, using the red light and chemical processes as both setting and metaphor. The sensory details are particularly strong, from the "gritty, wet chemical smell" to the sound of "timers, dripping, our breaths aligning." These details ground the reader in the physical space while the emotional landscape unfolds. The characterization is nuanced and believable. Dani's internal monologue reveals her typical approach to relationships ("I push. I shoulder in. I fill.") while showing her conscious effort to create space for Elliot. Her attraction to his "unconventional masculinity" feels authentic, as does her confusion about what this means for her own identity. The writer skillfully portrays Dani's struggle between her instinct to "bulldoze" and her desire to listen. Elliot's character is well-developed through Dani's observations and their dialogue. His tentative disclosure about questioning his gender identity feels natural and unforced. The conversation flows organically, with realistic hesitations and awkward moments that enhance the authenticity of their interaction. The prose is generally elegant, with effective metaphors that illuminate the characters' emotional states. For example, "I can feel my own outline blurring a little" aptly captures Dani's sense that her usual certainty about attraction is being challenged. The photography metaphors are particularly apt given the setting and the characters' artistic backgrounds. The narrative does occasionally veer into slightly purple prose, with some metaphors feeling a bit strained. Lines like "My whole body is a light meter trying not to max out" work well within the photography theme, but others like "I'm the teacher's pet of not saying things" feel somewhat forced. The dialogue is strong, capturing both characters' distinct voices while conveying their emotional states. The conversation about gender identity is handled with sensitivity and nuance, avoiding both oversimplification and melodrama. The pacing is effective, with the narrative building naturally to the kiss while maintaining tension throughout. The ending strikes an appropriate balance, acknowledging the uncertainty of their situation while offering a sense of possibility that feels earned rather than artificially imposed. Overall, this is a sophisticated piece that successfully fulfills the prompt's requirements. It explores Dani's complex attraction to Elliot with psychological depth and emotional honesty, while creating a vivid sensory experience for the reader. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Contemporary romance / drama: Stolen Moments in Roma — Score: 94.8
Prompt:
Contemporary Romance / Drama: Stolen Moments in Roma. Write a series of interconnected short scenes and dialogues that span a single day in modern-day Rome, in narrative form. This will form the beginning of a larger story. Alessandra, a fiery, independent Roman woman who works as a motorcycle courier, nearly collides with Ben, a somewhat clumsy, overly polite British academic on sabbatical, who is engrossed in a guidebook near the Trevi Fountain. The initial encounter is a clash of cultures and personalities – Alessandra is all sharp wit and rapid-fire Italian, while Ben is flustered apologies and awkward attempts at speaking the language. However, as they sort out the near-miss, a spark of unexpected humor and connection emerges. Alessandra, it quickly becomes clear, is a whirlwind of energy and mischief. She's a self-admitted troublemaker with a secret penchant for kleptomania, a detail she doesn't explicitly reveal, but which manifests in subtle, daring acts throughout the day. She impulsively decides to take Ben on a wild, unsanctioned tour of Rome, dragging him in some specific instances far outside his comfort zone. Ben, despite his initial apprehension and inherent politeness, finds himself utterly captivated by Alessandra's unapologetic spirit and zest for life. He is drawn into her orbit, a willing participant in increasingly outlandish situations, a quiet rebellion brewing beneath his scholarly exterior. The narrative should primarily consist of short, vivid scenes and dialogue exchanges, revealing their contrasting personalities and backgrounds, and the growing, ambiguous tension between them. Ben is captivated by Alessandra's energy and the thrill of breaking free from his routine. There's a clear sense that Alessandra is toying with Ben, pushing his boundaries and enjoying his reactions, but her own feelings remain somewhat enigmatic. The day should be a rollercoaster of exhilarating, slightly dangerous, and humorous moments, leaving Ben completely disoriented but utterly smitten. Explore the underlying tension & chemistry between them, culminating in some payoff as they part ways (or not -- your choice). Include this detail: Write in narrative prose, using immersive storytelling. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The near-collision happens in a slick of shadow, where the Trevi Fountain throws white noise over the cobbles and tourists cluster like shoals. Alessandra is a flash of red helmet, knee out, a streak of exhaust, and then she is a curse and a brake squeal. Ben is a page number, 263, finger sticking to the guidebook as he stumbles backward and his tote bag slides off his shoulder in slow motion, spilling pens and a dog-eared map like confetti. “Ma sei cieco?” Alessandra barks, one foot planting as the bike jerks to a stop, the back end fishtailing with a petulant wiggle. The Vespa’s side panel, mint-green and scarred with a long shredded rainbow of paint, glints in the midday sun. “You walk like—like a turistone zombie.” Ben’s glasses slide down his nose. He grabs at the handlebar as if to steady her, then aborts halfway, flustered. “I’m terribly—terribly sorry. The—er—guidebook warned about pickpockets and I—well, I wasn’t looking.” “No kidding,” she snaps, but her eyes are laughing, dark with curiosity and annoyance in equal parts. “You want to die at Fontana di Trevi? Dramatic. But you will ruin the picture of all the girls throwing coins.” He stoops to pick up his pens. “I wasn’t throwing coins. I—apparently that’s a tourist tax. I’m trying to do the city without… the usual things.” A corner of her mouth twitches. Behind her visor, something like mischief lifts its head. “Ah. An intellectual.” She darts off the bike, quick, compact, as if her bones are wired to springs. She crouches to help him gather his scattered life. One of her hands closes over a small brass coin that seems to have rolled out of nowhere. Ben doesn’t see it. Neither does the businessman patting his pockets ten feet away. Ben looks up. She’s closer than he expects, the smell of gasoline and orange blossom cologne and rain-wet stone all around her. The scratch along the Vespa’s flank is punkish and proud, a story without details. “I’m Alessandra,” she says, flicking the visor up. Her eyes are green enough to be illegal. “And you owe me… a coffee, at least, for almost denting my baby.” She thumps the colorful scar affectionately. “Don’t look at me like that. She was like this when I met her. More or less.” “I’m Ben. From—well, from Oxford.” He hears how pompous it sounds and winces. “On sabbatical. I didn’t mean to—” “Oxford,” she repeats, savoring it like a sweet. “Bene. So. Coffee. Or are you going to run away and read about Rome instead of tasting it?” He allows himself a breathless laugh. “Lead the way.” She grins, full of teeth, and claps him on the shoulder like they’ve been friends for years. Then she pockets the brass coin with liquid ease, a motion as natural as smoothing back her hair. The bar is one of those that hides behind a faded awning two turns away from the fountain, where the city softens and the clack of cups is a semaphore. Alessandra orders without asking him. “Due caffè, uno corretto,” she tells the barista, and raises an eyebrow at Ben. “For your nerves.” “Corretto?” he repeats. “Corrected,” she says. “With grappa. You look like your soul needs a push.” He wants to protest. He doesn’t. The espresso is tar and sunlight, the grappa a thin lightning that warms his ribs. She talks with her hands, sharp little flicks of finger and wrist. He notices how often those hands touch things: a napkin holder, the sugar spoon, his sleeve just above the elbow as if to emphasize a point. Twice, for a heartbeat, the barista’s eyes flick to a bowl of wrapped chocolates on the counter; when they leave, one sits on the saucer by Ben’s cup as if it’s always been there. “So,” Alessandra says, leaning in. “You, Oxford. What do you study?” “Modern—well, not exactly modern—language and literature. Italy in the nineteenth century. The—ah—structures of feeling. How a city makes a person.” “Che poetico,” she says dryly. “And you want to write about my city by walking with your nose in a book.” He flushes. “Point taken.” “Good.” She slaps her palm on the counter. “Then you will let me show you alcune cose. Some things. Not the guidebook. The other Rome.” “Is this,” he ventures, “a tour?” “Unsanctioned,” she says, wicked. “You like rules?” “I—yes.” Then, surprising himself, he grins. “No.” “Bravo,” she says, as if he’s a student and she’s the kind of teacher who breaks rules for sport. “Put on the helmet.” “But—” She’s already tossing him a spare. It smells like the sun. He fumbles with the strap, his fingers clumsy; she tuts and ties it for him, close enough that he can count a thin gold chain at her throat, the pendant a Saint Christopher rubbed smooth with worry. The city comes at him in a rush. They slalom through traffic like a rumor, Alessandra’s knee skimming parked Fiats, her laughter thrown back by buildings older than his country. He clutches at her waist and then, cautiously, at the frame, and then at last he lets go, hands in the air for a second that feels whole. She yells back over her shoulder, no helmet now, hair streaming like a flag. “You’re not dead, inglese! Good!” At a stoplight near Piazza Venezia, a street vendor sidles up, offering selfie sticks and fake gladiator helmets. Alessandra wiggles her fingers in the universal sign for no, grazie. In the same motion, she slips the vendor’s lighter out of view, bright red with a Vespa stamped on it. She flicks it to life in her palm and examines the flame with a cat’s calm. Ben doesn’t notice. Or pretends not to. They park on the Janiculum Hill, the city spread out like a map someone forgot to fold. The noon cannon cracks and Ben flinches; Alessandra grins and says, “They do it to make you jump.” She leads him to a statue of an unpronounceable patriot and tells him a story about revolutions that might be true. In the shade of a pine, she undoes a stray bottle of Chianti with that borrowed lighter, a bit of leather jammed under the cork. “For your dissertation,” she says solemnly, pouring into paper cups. “I don’t—” he begins, and then he does. The wine is cheap and honest. Her eyes on the city are bright and soft, like she’s seeing her favorite friend but won’t say. They share a panino that tastes like heaven and salt, sitting on the low wall, knees almost touching. A school group swarms, photo-taking, and Alessandra swipes her gaze across them as a pickpocket might. When they leave, she has a tourist brochure for a church no one visits and two napkins with lipstick on them. She folds the napkins into tiny boats, sets them sailing in the fountain below with solemn ceremony. He watches her. He realizes he is doing that, this thing of watching, with a kind of foolish hunger. She’s a magnet for accidents and laughter, and he is full of iron filings. “What do you do?” he asks, finally, when she quiets, when the city becomes a hum rather than a shout. She jerks her chin at the Vespa. “Corriere. Motorcycle courier. Flowers, legal papers, love letters, pizza. Anything.” Her smile goes sly. “Sometimes nothing at all. If you pay me to go fast, I go. If you pay me to go slow, I still go fast.” “And the scratch?” he asks, nodding toward the Vespa’s transparent war story. She runs her finger along it. There is affection in the gesture, and something else, a private joke. “A conversation with a wall that wanted a kiss,” she says. “I won.” He laughs. He can’t help it. Her lies, if they are lies, are preferable to most truths. The heat swells and then slides down into slant shadows. She takes him to Trastevere, to a doorway where old men play cards like priests at a vigil. She grins at one, kisses him on both cheeks, calls him zio though he is probably no one’s uncle. She lifts a cigarette from behind his ear, lights it with the Vespa lighter, takes one draw, gives it back. The old man blesses her with his cards. Ben watches the exchange like a traveler reads a foreign phrase and understands more than he thinks. They run, quite literally, through a wedding. She sees the rice, the confetti, the bride like a cream cloud. Her eyes gleam. “Come,” she says, grabbing Ben’s hand, and they crash the reception in the church courtyard for exactly two songs, spinning and whooping and pretending they belong. Ben, mortified and thrilled, is pulled into a tarantella by a grandmother who scolds him for his steps, then beams at his effort. A platter of fried artichokes passes; Alessandra’s hand is sudden and sure. Ben finds himself with a paper napkin heavy with something hot and oily that he did not buy. When the groom notices, when the bride’s brother looks confused and then amused, when Alessandra bows with courtly exaggeration and backs away, Ben can’t stop laughing. His chest hurts with it. “We can’t do that,” he wheezes, even as they do. “We just did,” she says, eyes like mischief’s headquarters. She hands him the lighter. “Hold that.” They end up on the Aventine, then at a doorway with a keyhole that frames Saint Peter’s dome like a secret. They trade places peering through; he smiles like a child. She takes his guidebook at some point, tucks it behind her back, flips it open and reads aloud, her accent turning “Baroque” into something edible. “Put it away,” she finally murmurs. “It will still be there tomorrow. Today is mine.” He obeys, surprising himself again. The sun bleeds out of the sky. Night comes with scooters and distant fights and lovers quarrelling in the lyrical register of Italian. Alessandra drags him into a dive bar with a jukebox that coughs out Mina, then into a tourist bar with blue drinks and British stag parties so he can hate it properly, then into a square where a juggler nearly takes off his ear with a club and apologizes profusely, and she steals a scarf from a statue and wears it as a sash for twenty minutes before replacing it with the care of a restoration artist. There are stops he only realizes were stops later, when he pats his pockets: his watch is still there but a rubber bracelet he’d been given by someone on the flight is not. In its place is a small plastic medallion with a saint and a motorcycle stamped in silver. He doesn’t remember acquiring it. If he asked, she would shrug. At some point, he asks, “Why me?” She doesn’t look at him. There’s a line at the gelato place, noisily cosmopolitan. “Because you were about to walk into my life and then my wheel,” she says, tossing her hair. “Because you’re too polite to say no and too curious to be bored. Because you say ‘sorry’ like you think it makes a difference.” She hands him pistachio, takes stracciatella, steals a bite of his anyway. “And because you said yes.” He is quiet. He watches her lick a smear of gelato off her thumb in a way that probably has a footnote in some anthropology of courtship. He does not say that if she had said, “Follow me,” earlier, the rest of his day would have been the same. They return to the River. Rome at night looks like a memory. On the way, they pass a man selling roses. The man presses one into Ben’s lap shyly, a conspirator. Alessandra takes it, spins it once in her fingers, and twines it briefly through the Vespa’s scratched grill so the petals brush the dent as if to soothe it. He opens his mouth to offer to pay; she is already moving, two euros lighter that seem to have come from nowhere. A minute later, she’s a glove richer that must have fallen from someone’s back pocket. It disappears into her bag; she will return it, she says. Maybe. Her delight is not cruel. It’s a dance with the world’s loose edges. On a narrow street lit by a single yellow lamp, they run out of momentum. The Vespa ticks as it cools. Alessandra’s hair is a mess. Ben’s shirt is creased, and there’s a fig leaf stuck to his sneaker from some moment he cannot, for the life of him, place. “So,” she says, leaning against a wall that has known worse, the rose drooping like a drunk. “Oxford.” He shoves his hands into his pockets, then takes them out again, restless in the way of someone who has just remembered his body. “Yes.” She studies him. The city has left a shadow of soot on her cheekbone like war paint. He wants to put his thumb there and wipe it away. He does not. He is an academic. He has restraint. It feels like a coat that is suddenly too tight. “What do you write about, really?” she asks. “Not the structures of feelings.” “How we disappear,” he says, surprising himself, the words feeling like fruit falling of their own accord. “Or how we fail to. How the city keeps you and you keep the city.” She tilts her head. “Tonight, you did not disappear.” It sounds like praise. “No,” he says. “Not with you.” Silence. The good kind. She pushes off the wall. “I have a delivery at ten,” she says, businesslike. “A real one. Not a wedding we steal.” He swallows. “Right.” “You can come,” she says casually. “If you hold onto me and don’t fall off.” The corner of her mouth lifts, an amused cruelty that is also an invitation. He looks at her, at the scratch on the Vespa with its technicolor brag, at the rose bruising in the grill, at the lighter in his pocket, at the Saint Christopher around her neck, at the city that has expanded to accommodate this new channel. He is, without doubt, disoriented. He is also, without doubt, completely smitten. He hears himself say, “Yes.” She rolls her eyes like he’s predictable and dear. “Bravo,” she says again, softer. They ride. The delivery is a flat envelope, unremarkable except for the way she tucks it into her jacket with proprietary care. The address is across the river. They take the long way, because of course they do. Ben leans into the turns now with her, like a sentence that knows where it is going, even if he doesn’t. At the doorway, she disappears, rings a bell, leaves the envelope in a slot. She returns lighter by a gram and heavier by something that might be sleep. They’re back at the curb when he reaches into his pocket and pulls out the lighter she’d given him to hold. He turns it over. The Vespa logo shines red. “You—I think this is not yours.” She plucks it from his palm with two fingers, then touches those fingers to his wrist in apology. “Everything is mine until it isn’t,” she says. It’s a joke and a confession. He feels something pass from her to him anyway, some temperature, some charge. “Alessandra,” he says, his voice rasping at the edges. He has done enough cowardice for one life. “Will I see you again?” She feigns surprise. “Tomorrow, I will ride. You will read and almost die at intersections. Probabile.” Then, abruptly, less arched: “I will be at the bar near the fountain, where we did the corrected coffee. Nine.” She glances at him, assessing. “If you come, bring me a story. Not from the book. From you.” He nods. “I—yes.” She smiles, and it lands somewhere in his ribs like an anchor. She swings onto the Vespa in one motion, and he wants to learn how to do everything she does. “Don’t fall in love with Rome,” she says, final as a bell. “She will not love you back. She will make you think you are the only one, and then she will make you pay. She is a bad girlfriend. Ask anyone.” “And you?” he asks, before he can help it. “Do you love her?” She looks past him at the river, at the dome hunched like a shoulder against the night. The secret in her gaze curdles for a second into something that might be sorrow. “I owe her,” she says. “Which is not the same.” He wants to ask a hundred questions. He doesn’t. The Vespa’s engine catches like a laugh. She points at the scratch along the side. “Next time, don’t add to it,” she orders. “The colors are perfect now.” He salutes, foolish. She rolls her eyes, charmed and disgusted, and then she is gone, the rose trembling, a comet leaving a tail of noise and possibility. Ben stands there a while, the night settling on him like a second skin. He finds the plastic saint in his pocket with his fingers and closes his fist around it, unsure how it got there, intensely sure that it did. He realizes with an embarrassed little snort that he is grinning at nothing. He opens the guidebook, then shuts it again, the words flat and dumb on the page. He does not go home immediately. He walks the long way, because of course he does, toes scuffing the cobbles, and throws a coin over his shoulder into the Trevi Fountain for someone else’s wish. The splash sounds like a promise he is not entirely convinced he did not make. In the morning, he will go to the bar. Or he will try not to. He already knows which. Rome breathes. He breathes with her. And somewhere, riding a line of light between two points, Alessandra laughs at how easy it is to steal a day and leave nothing but a scratch.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkably well-crafted contemporary romance that successfully captures the essence of a whirlwind day in Rome. The author has created a vivid, immersive narrative that brings both the characters and setting to life with exceptional skill. The characterization is particularly strong. Alessandra emerges as a fully realized character - fiery, mischievous, and complex. Her kleptomania is subtly woven throughout the narrative rather than explicitly stated, shown through small acts of theft that reveal her character without heavy-handed exposition. Ben's transformation from cautious academic to willing participant in Alessandra's adventures feels organic and believable. The chemistry between them is palpable and develops naturally throughout the day. The prose is elegant and evocative without becoming purple. The author employs sensory details masterfully - we can smell the "gasoline and orange blossom cologne," taste the espresso that is "tar and sunlight," and feel the rhythm of Rome through the narrative. Metaphors are fresh and effective: "She's a magnet for accidents and laughter, and he is full of iron filings" perfectly captures Ben's attraction to Alessandra. The dialogue is exceptional - sparse but impactful, revealing character through what is said and unsaid. Alessandra's Italian phrases are integrated naturally, adding authenticity without becoming distracting. The exchanges between characters feel genuine and serve to advance both plot and character development. The structure of interconnected scenes works perfectly, creating a sense of a day unfolding in real time while maintaining narrative momentum. Each vignette adds something meaningful to the characters' relationship or our understanding of them. The pacing is excellent, with quieter moments balancing the more adventurous sequences. Rome itself becomes a character in the narrative. The author avoids tourist clichés while still capturing the essence of the city - its history, energy, and contradictions. The setting is integrated organically into the story rather than feeling like a backdrop. The ending strikes just the right note - ambiguous yet satisfying, with the promise of continuation without an artificial happily-ever-after. The final image of Alessandra "riding a line of light between two points" and Ben throwing a coin into the Trevi Fountain beautifully encapsulates the themes of the piece. If there are any weaknesses, they are minor. Occasionally, a metaphor might be slightly overextended, but these moments are rare and don't detract from the overall quality of the writing. The piece adheres closely to the prompt requirements while still feeling fresh and original. Overall, this is an exceptional piece of contemporary romance writing that balances character, setting, and plot with remarkable skill. The author has created a compelling narrative that leaves the reader wanting more - exactly what the beginning of a larger story should do. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Cozy sci-fi: The Last Outpost — Score: 89.5
Prompt:
Cozy sci-fi The Last Outpost Nettle (or Nets to her friends) bartends at The Last Outpost -- a lazy hub for miners and merchants in an asteroid belt on the Andromeda outer rim. Escaping from her past life, Nets found a home here at the Outpost. They have, thus far, tolerated Net's flaws which she tries to keep in equilibrium with her assortment of talents. Her evenings involve chatting with patrons, negotiating the drama, intrigue, problems & love lives of the diverse crowd that filter through the Outpost. Tonight is no different, at least, until a frazzled looking stranger, tentacled dreads askew, quietly plops down at the bar: "Vega whisky, neat. Better make that a double." Write a chapter in this story. Establish conflict for narrative interest. Don't resolve the conflict within this chapter. Aim for about 60% dialogue. First person, present tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
I’m polishing a smudge out of the bar top when the door irises open and lets in a gust of tired laughter, ore dust, and the metallic tang of recycled air. The Outpost hums and drifts on its routine: the slow spin of the station windows, the miners’ boots clanking, Merciko’s accordion slurring over whatever passes for happy on the Andromeda rim. My glass washers chatter like teeth in a cold mouth behind me. I keep one eye on the portside camera feed, the other on the neon gleam of the drip line. I keep my past pressed flat between the pages of this place. I’m good at balance. I talk a little, I listen a lot, I pour better than anyone out here. When someone starts to ramble down the gravity well of confession, I tilt their glass, not their heart. “Netty! You deaf or just ignoring me?” Trill yells from table six. Two hands, four elbows, tattooed with constellations I didn’t ask about, she waves a soggy credit chit like a flag. “I heard you,” I say, already pulling her another Pink Nebula. “Still deciding if you get four cherries or none.” “Four!” she says. “Four is lucky. Remember what happened the last time I asked for none?” “You kissed my skimmer pilot,” I say. “And broke his heart. And my skimmer.” Trill grins. “Worth it!” A glass breaks somewhere behind the baffle. It is the thin, high music of disaster. Patrons go quiet a beat, then surge into a cheer. I glance up. Sava, new kid on washers, is pale as a comet and mouth-round with horror. I tap the overhead thanks-to-nothing button. “Broken glass in zone three. Everyone keep your hands.” The floor unit deploys little vacuum beetles. People clap like they’ve never seen bugs clean before. “Breathe,” I say to Sava, and give her a thumbs-up. “It’s just a rookies’ tax.” She nods, breath hitching, and the beetles go to war with glittering shards, their backs blinking hazard-yellow. The Outpost swallows the incident and returns to its lazy: the hand of the dock clock crawling toward shift change, the low crackle of a dying news feed, the thunk of heavy ships docking outside like whales knocking. That’s when they come in. Frazzled, dressed in a jumpsuit that probably used to be green, tentacles spilling like a river of wires from beneath a hood. My skin pricks. Hair—whatever you call those sinewy head-dreads—stands like they’ve been electrocuted. They head for the bar, eyes down, shoulders tight. They slide onto a stool like someone holding a broken wing close. “Vega whisky, neat,” they say, voice quiet and sanded down. There’s a wheeze under the vowels, as though their biolungs don’t fit right. “Better make that a double.” “Rough space?” I ask, reaching for the Vega. It’s the good stuff, and I don’t advertise it. I keep the bottle low, just for me and people who need it. They fish in a pocket and slap a cred chip on the bar. It’s warm and damp, edges gnawed. I catch a glance—there’s a faded insignia half-scratched off, and my stomach does that uncomfortable lurch remembered names bring. No names, I think. That’s the house rule. No slurs, no brawls, no credit on my kindness, no real names unless you offer them yourself. I pry a tumbler loose from the rack, swirl the Vega, let the smell of smoke and starfruit cut the exhaust out of the air. They watch the pour with a measuring kind of hunger. “Keep the bottle close,” they murmur. “In case.” “In case?” I set the glass down, then a napkin, then the bottle far enough that I still own it. “In case things go sideways.” “Things rarely go sideways in here,” I lie. I’ve built a bar out of chaos and habit. Sideways is our default. I lean in, keeping my smile gentle. “You got a name you like?” They take a long swallow, and their face changes, loosens. They wipe the back of their hand across a mouth that looks too human for those eyes. “Nettle,” they say. I blink. “You’re kidding.” “Nettle,” they repeat, gaze flicking to my nametag. The one that reads NETS in filched cargo tape, because the last one peeled off and I didn’t care enough to replace it. “Or Nets, if you’re friendly.” I laugh before I can catch myself. A real one. “That’s—” “A complication?” they ask, smile thin. “A coincidence,” I say, and it’s both. They push two tentacles back under their hood, where someone in a hurry braided them. The braids have come undone. Their nails are black with engine grit. My eyes keep straying to the scar on their collarbone, a crescent like an old moon. “On shift?” Sava calls, hovering. “We’re low on clean rocks.” “Rocks?” Trill says, leering. “Tell me more about your rocks.” “Trill,” I warn, and she sets her mouth like a child who has been scolded but is plotting anyway. “I need a favor,” Nettle—my mirror—says, voice low enough to be swallowed by the Outpost’s murmur. “You just got here,” I say. “You don’t know if I’m the favoring type.” “I know something about people who wrap themselves in nicknames,” they say, eyes flicking up. They are deep-set eyes, storm gray, ringed in purple fatigue. “And I know you’re the only one who isn’t looking at the door every time it opens.” I look at the door just because they said it, because the way they said it makes my blood remember how to run. A miner with red dust in his beard shuffles in, someone’s laugh spikes, someone’s comm chirps and dies. Okay. Nothing. “What do you need?” I ask carefully. “A place to sit where I’m not obvious, and a minute of your quiet,” they say. “And a second double, if your kindness has a generous pour.” “Your cred good?” I nudge the chipped chip back with a fingertip. They lift their chin. “Always.” I slide the bottle back within their reach and tip the Vega again. “We have a corner that pretends to be anonymous,” I say, nodding toward the shadowed booth near the dried herb wall. “On a good day, people forget you’re there. On a bad day, Merciko will serenade you and your ancestors.” “Good day then, please,” Nettle says, but doesn’t move. They cradle the glass instead and keep their back to the room like someone who knows how to be small and knows it won’t help. From the far end, a couple is mid-argument in a whisper that thinks it’s a secret and isn’t. Something about a cargo manifest not matching an invoice, a broken promissory, a niece on Vega Prime. My ear wants to tug toward it. My hands go on autopilot. “So,” I say, wiping down a patch of bar already clean. “You running from a person or a thing?” “Funny how we pretend there’s a distinction,” Nettle says. “What about you, Nets? You run from or toward?” “I pour,” I say. “And I mind my ledger.” They snort with something like approval. “Okay. Then I’ll say this: if anyone asks if you’ve seen me, you haven’t.” “Have I?” They meet my eyes, and for a second the room slides out of focus and it’s just me and another version of a life I almost had. “Not if anyone asks,” they say. Sava approaches with a tray of clean glasses and a look that means she overheard a sliver. I shake my head a hair’s breadth—no. She pivots into another orbit, proud of herself for respecting the unspoken. “Why me?” I ask Nettle. “We’re full of corners.” “Because you didn’t flinch at the gunfire,” they say. “What gunfire?” They smile, and it makes their face beautiful, briefly, like a light turned on in a wreck. “Exactly.” The door irises again. Two security drones drift in, eyes a cold turquoise that matches no ocean. Behind them is a person I hoped had been transferred to some administrative desk far away: Lt. Harrow, Patrol Division, the kind of bureaucrat ethos that dresses its teeth in civility and chews through principles for breakfast. Clean uniform. Clean jaw. Clean gloves. He scans the room like it owes him a feeling. “Evening,” I say, level. The Outpost does not belong to him; it belongs to orbits and old deals. But he walks like it is all under his name. “Nettle,” he says. I freeze before I know it’s my own name he means. He stops at the bar, eyes not on me, but on my mirror. “You made good time,” he says to the newcomer, who has gone still in a way that makes me smell ozone. “You’re a difficult person to chase. You know that?” “Not here,” I say, voice warm. “People drink here, Lt.” He tips his head in my direction, as if acknowledging a bartender is part of some playbook tactic. “I’m not here to ruin your night, Nets.” “I doubt your aim is that good,” I say, smiling because this is a performance and I know my part. “What do you want?” “Just to talk,” he says. “To a guest of yours.” Patrons start the slow migration that says they don’t want to see but want to hear. Trill saunters closer, balancing her Nebula like a crown, eyes bright. Merciko stops playing. The vacuum beetles retreat into their nook like nervous pets. Nettle doesn’t look at Harrow. They drink, swallow, put the glass down without a click. “Talk to my glass,” they say. Harrow smiles thinly. “We received an alert,” he says, tapping a wristband. “Stolen property. Biocybernetic. Hazardous to itself and others.” Everyone in earshot goes thick with interest. You can feel it. The room leans a fraction. “Cool,” Trill whispers to nobody. “Hazardous.” “A misunderstanding,” Nettle says. “I had a permit. I had three.” “Records can be misfiled,” Harrow says. “But you can still misappropriate. Mason Bay dock cam shows you leaving with a unit.” “Units don’t ask for double whisky,” I say, allowing a smirk. “And if you’re thinking of putting hands on my customer, Lt., you’ll need to show me a writ. Until then, you’re a man in a hat in a place that sells drinks.” “It’s not a hat, it’s a regulation cap,” Harrow says automatically, then catches himself and rearranges his features to stern. “Writ’s in the system.” “Must be lonely,” I say. “All your friends in the system.” He does the look that says he wants to sigh and be magnanimous but is plastic. “We can do this pleasant. Or we can shut your feeds for a night and see how your tips do.” I feel my molars in my jaw. The Outpost is a delicate ecology, and the Patrol knows how to kick it. The old part of me, the one that broke and built and ran and landed here, wants to reach for the astral die under the register, the one I swore I’d stop using to choose trouble. I keep my face easy. “Talk,” I say. “At the booth.” I jerk my chin toward the corner. My mirror doesn’t move. “Maybe you should tell your friend what you did,” Harrow says to Nettle. “So she doesn’t hitch her ship to a sinking star.” “I don’t have a ship,” I say. “I have a bar.” “It floats like a ship,” he says. “And goes down like one when someone holes it.” “What did they do?” I ask, and I can hear the tilt in my own question and hate it, because it says I might be willing. “I took something that was missing,” Nettle says before he can. “And it followed me.” “What followed you?” Trill says, suddenly very interested in something aside from cherries. A sound like a whale calling from another world ripples through the hull. It’s not docking. It’s not ships. It’s not anything comfortable. The lights shiver, then settle. Everyone looks up. Everyone looks at me. As if I can look at the ceiling and the laws of physics will deliver an answer. I look anyway. Habit. “See?” Harrow says softly. “Hazardous.” Another sound, closer this time, from the air duct grid above the herb wall. A scrabble. A whisper? No. Clicking. The clink-clink of little metal feet. The grate bows. “Uh,” Sava says. The grate pops, and something drops onto the shelf where I keep the dried nettles for tea and the bottles of promises era gin. The thing is the size of a big cat, shaped wrong, a lattice of silver bones wrapped in translucent skin that shifts like heat. Its eyes are too many. It sniffs the air and makes a small, delighted sound, like a child seeing sugar. Half my regulars swear in languages the station translator pretends not to hear. The creature—unit? hazard?—hops onto the bar. It looks at me. It looks at Nettle. It starts purring, except it’s the kind of purr that resonates with the fillings in your teeth and wakes old dental sins. It curls its tail, which splits at the end into three delicate filaments that taste the air. “Nix,” Nettle says, voice low, aching. “You shouldn’t have come.” It makes a chirp that is either hello or a warning. It leans into Nettle’s hand, tentacles and filaments and fingers all in a soft tangle. Everyone in the Outpost leans forward as one organism. Harrow’s drones tilt like birds considering bread. “Is that biocybernetic property?” someone whispers. “That’s a baby,” someone else snaps. “That’s a bomb,” Trill breathes, delighted. “It’s hungry,” I say, because you can hear the hollow in a living thing. “Nix,” Harrow says, and the name sits wrong in his mouth. “Return.” It freezes, every line of it going taut. It does not obey. It curls closer into Nettle, who presses a palm to its skull like you’d push your hand to your own chest and say stay. “You can’t keep that,” Harrow says to Nettle, the thin kindness drained out of him. “It’s tagged, registered, and expensive.” “They abandoned it,” Nettle says, defiance in their jaw, fear in their hands. “They were going to strip it for parts.” “And as generous as your story is,” Harrow says, “the law doesn’t make exceptions for the soft.” “The law hardly sees the soft,” I say. “Just the obedient.” He doesn’t look at me. He looks at the thing on my bar like it’s a problem he can solve by cutting its rope. He lifts a hand. The drones shift. The room tenses. “No,” Nettle says. “Please. Not in here.” “What’s so special about here?” Harrow asks, but something—maybe the way the whole room has tilted, a human ripple, the mined gravity of all these eyes—slows him. He reconsiders, two beats, like a man tasting his own teeth. “Fine,” he says. “Back office, then.” He looks at me. “You have an office, Nets.” “I have a storeroom,” I say, thinking of the stacks of glass and the crate I keep under the false floor, the one that hums if you stand too close. “And a policy against interrogations between my bottles.” “Policy is not law,” he says. “And law is not kindness,” I say. Nettle’s hand is shaking. Nix makes the sound of a storm inside a shell. The whole bar is a held breath. Sava is clutching a tray so hard the edge digs crescents into her palms. Merciko has started playing again, something low and insistent like a heartbeat not to be frightened by. Trill tips her glass, licks sugar from the rim, eyes bright with the story forming in her head. The dock clock ticks. Outside, a ship groans, turning in its sleep. This is the kind of moment you spend years arranging your life to avoid. It arrives anyway. “Nets,” Nettle says, not pleading, not quite. “Please.” I don’t move. I can play it any way. I can say I never saw them. I can say I don’t know this creature looking at me like I’m a choice. I can call in a favor I didn’t save. I can pretend I don’t remember that insignia etched into a worn credit chip. I can decide to be prudent and watch the Patrol take the softest thing in the room. I can decide to unspool the tidy life I stitched together in this place, one seam at a time. The drones hum. Harrow waits. Nettle breathes. Nix purrs. I reach toward the shelf where I keep the nettle tea, fingers steady, and behind me, through the broken-glass hush of the bar, through the tiny buzzing stars of the vacuum beetles at their dock, the back hatch alarm pulses once, low and insistent, the way a heartbeat would sound if it had a siren. The screen under the bar blinks an external alert: unauthorized magnetic lock release, bay three. “Someone just opened my storage bay,” I say, and the certainty in my voice surprises me. I look up. Harrow, confused. Nettle, alarmed. Nix, all its eyes wide, all its senses pulled toward the back door. The Outpost, my Outpost, shifts under my feet, a fractional tilt deeper into sideways. “We’ll talk,” Harrow says again, but the room is already moving, as if it’s a beast with a mind of its own. And we’re all already in it.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a cozy sci-fi atmosphere with a well-realized setting in "The Last Outpost," a bar in an asteroid belt. The first-person present tense narration through Nettle's perspective is maintained throughout, and the chapter establishes clear conflict without resolution, as requested. The writing excels at world-building through sensory details and casual references that feel natural rather than expository. The bar environment comes alive through descriptions of "ore dust," "metallic tang of recycled air," and the "neon gleam of the drip line." The author skillfully introduces alien elements like tentacled characters, vacuum beetles, and the mysterious creature Nix without overexplaining. Character development is strong, particularly for Nettle, whose past is hinted at without being fully revealed. The dialogue effectively reveals character traits and relationships while advancing the plot. Secondary characters like Trill, Sava, and Lt. Harrow are distinct and contribute meaningfully to the scene. The conflict centers on the mysterious Nettle (the newcomer who shares the protagonist's name) and their relationship with the creature Nix, which authorities claim is stolen property. This creates both external tension (the threat from Lt. Harrow) and internal conflict for the protagonist, who must decide whether to help. The ending effectively leaves this decision hanging, creating narrative tension. The prose balances descriptive richness with readability. Metaphors like "the beetles go to war with glittering shards" and "the hand of the dock clock crawling toward shift change" enhance the atmosphere without becoming purple. The dialogue feels natural and serves multiple purposes: revealing character, advancing plot, and providing exposition without being obvious. There are a few minor weaknesses. Some metaphors verge on being overwrought ("glass washers chatter like teeth in a cold mouth"). The introduction of Nix feels slightly rushed compared to the careful pacing of the rest of the piece. And while the dialogue is generally strong, a few exchanges feel slightly forced in service of exposition. The piece achieves approximately 60% dialogue as requested, and at around 2,000 words, it's longer than the requested 1,000 words, though this doesn't detract from the quality. Overall, this is a strong piece of cozy sci-fi that establishes an intriguing setting, complex characters, and compelling conflict while maintaining a consistent voice and tone. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 17 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 17.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Young adult drama: Gone South — Score: 89.3
Prompt:
Young adult drama Gone South Taylor is a 16 year old teen with a history of "concerning behavioural patterns" (or that's how the stupid smug school counsellor worded it on the phone call to Mom). It shouldn't be a surprise: When you live in a backwater town in Tennessee, your choices are: a. be mind-fuckingly bored, or b. invent some drama. Two days ago, Taylor came out to their family as trans. This disclosure was *not* in the category of invented drama -- it was, in fact, the real deal, and a long time coming. It didn't go well. The last 48 hours had been pure disaster. In a moment of desperate inspiration, Taylor had decided to get the hell out of dodge. And so an escape plan was hatched and executed within the space of 30 minutes. That was last night. Now Taylor was two states away, having been unceremoniously ejected from their hitched ride in downtown New Orleans. Write the next chapter in Taylor's story as they find their feet in this new environment. Tell the chapter over the course of their first day in New Orleans, in which Taylor meets another runaway with issues and secrets. Taylor navigates this new world, not knowing who to trust or what the dangers are. Write in Taylor's voice, and incorporate their internal monologue as they grapple with intense & conflicting emotions. Also incorporate dialogue with the interesting characters Taylor meets. First person, mixed tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
When the old man dropped me by the curb, he didn’t look me in the eye. Just said, “End of the line, kid,” and the rust-scaled truck rattled off like I’d infected his upholstery with bad luck. The street in front of me pulsed. Tourists with sunburned shoulders and drinks the color of cartoon slime poured past, laughing too loud at things that can’t possibly be funny. The saxophone cut through all of it—low and gold and full of a sadness that wasn’t mine but felt like it could be. The player was an old guy with a hat full of crumpled bills. He had a face that looked like carved wood and a mouth that knew something about sugar and salt and other kinds of cost. I stood there like an idiot with my backpack digging into one shoulder and this stupid hope that the city would open its arms and say, “You’re safe.” Ha. Funny. I told myself: you’re smart. You got this far. You can find the next step. My feet, traitor feet, decided walking was the step. So I walked. Past souvenir shops with purple beads sprouting from the doors like vines, past a group of women wearing matching T-shirts that said Steve’s 50th! as if the city would congratulate them. The air was wet in a way Tennessee never was. It pressed against skin, wrapped around me like a damp towel. My hair stuck to my scalp. I could taste something sweet in the air—funnel cakes maybe, burnt sugar—and something rot under it, like swamp breath. “How old are you?” a woman asked, stepping into my path. She had a clipboard and a tight smile and eyes that went over me like I was a math problem. Her shirt said Hope Harbor in a font with too many loops. She smelled like lilacs. “Old enough,” I said, which is what people say when they are not, in fact, old enough. She didn’t leave. “We have a youth center just a few blocks—” “No,” I said, too sharp, felt my throat get that hot, humiliating burn. “Thanks.” She took a breath like she would push again. The saxophone slid into a higher note, a kind of plea. A guy in a neon hat bumped my shoulder and didn’t say sorry. I pivoted and was gone, my backpack slicing through the crowd like a fin through water. Keep moving. Don’t get pinned. I picked a direction. The streets narrowed and the tourist gloss rubbed off. Graffiti climbed the walls where the stucco peeled away. A kid sat on a milk crate with a pit bull at his feet, tapping a plastic bucket between his knees. The beat matched the saxophone’s tail end and for a second the city braided itself together. That’s when my stomach remembered I’d fed it gas station peanuts and a Coke fourteen hours ago. It grumbled loud enough that the kid glanced up and smirked. I hugged my arms around myself like that could quiet a gut. I found a corner store with a hand-lettered sign that said EBT WELCOME in faded marker and bought a bag of chips and a banana with the last of my loose cash. The cashier didn’t look at me. I thanked him anyway because my mother raised me with small politenesses. The automatic door sighed behind me and I stood there with the chips open, shoving salt into my mouth so fast my tongue stung. The banana had a bruise that tasted like too-sweet wine. “You look new,” a voice said, soft and not unkind. My spine went tight. I turned. They were leaning against the brick wall in the shade, one foot up, a scuffed skateboard under their hand. Maybe seventeen, maybe nineteen, wearing a T-shirt that said GIRL POWER in glitter letters, which made me double-take, because their hair was buzzed down to velvet. Eyes like the Mississippi at dusk—wide and a little muddy. Lips they’d chewed raw. A look that said they hadn’t slept indoors every night lately. My kind of person. Not my kind. Dangerous. Don’t trust. “Do I?” I said around a mouthful of chips. Smooth, Taylor. Real smooth. They nodded toward the street. “You got that tourist-staring-at-the-sky thing but without the camera. And your shoes are too clean. Nice backpack, though.” “Thanks,” I said, reflex, and hugged it closer. My grandmother had given me the backpack for “college someday,” and here it was carrying socks and a razored-off ponytail and a phone I hadn’t turned on in two days. Mom would have filled it with snacks. “Not a hustle,” they added, taking their foot down and walking toward me slow, hands visible like I was a deer and they’d learned something about how to approach a skittish thing. “I’m Ash.” “Taylor,” I said, before I could decide to lie. My mouth betrays me like that. Ash tipped their head. “You hungry or you hungry?” “I’ve got chips,” I said, which was not an answer. The saxophone from a block over swooped and someone laughed the way people laugh right before they cry. I wiped salt on my jeans. Ash stared at my face like they were trying to decide on a puzzle piece. Their gaze snagged at my jaw, lingered on my neck where the binder cut a line under my collar. Heat crawled up my throat. Do not flinch. Do not. If you look like prey someone will make you prey. They surprised me by looking away, quick, like they’d been the one caught. “You, uh. You want a place to sit that isn’t a curb? There’s a church a few blocks that does lunch. No questions.” “You just hang out in front of the store waiting for… me?” I meant kids like me. I didn’t say it. Ash shrugged, eyes sliding to the street. “I wait for the old man with the trumpet to hit ‘St. James Infirmary.’ That’s when the line’s the shortest. And I watch faces. It’s a game. Guess who’s running and who’s just lost.” They grinned, quick flash. “I win a lot.” Something sour curled in me—shame because they’d read me and pride because I was seeable. “What’s the prize?” “Chips,” Ash said, eyes on my bag, deadpan. Then, softer, “And sometimes friends. Or not-friends. People.” Their voice did this thing on the word people, like the syllables were heavier than others. I should have said no. Strangers offering food. Strangers offering anything. But the sound of the saxophone braided with the bucket drum and my stomach had gone hollow, echoing. Curiosity and hunger are the same shape sometimes. “Okay,” I said. “Fine.” We walked. Ash pushed the skateboard with lazy little pumps, the wheels clicking over cracks needed to be repaved. They talked without looking at me. “Where you from?” “Up there,” I said, waving a vague hand north. “Um. Tennessee.” They nodded like that made sense. “Lot of folks from Tennessee lately. The buses drop at the terminal and spit people like seeds.” They glanced at my backpack and then away again, and the kindness in that glance made something tilt in me. “You staying with anyone?” “No.” My throat tried to close. No. I chose no. I walked away from a house with lace curtains and seven Bibles. I walked away from my mother’s voice in the hallway saying the word “phase” like it was a stain she could scrub out. Ash kept their eyes on the concrete. Their sneakers had holes in the sides. “Me neither,” they said too casually. Then, like they owed me an explanation, “Got tired of being a problem in a house where problems get left for God.” “You religious?” It slipped out, my curiosity sharper than my caution. “God and I are on a break,” Ash said dry. They flicked their gaze sideways. “You?” “God broke up with me,” I said, and then we were laughing at ourselves, two kids making jokes about a thing that could kill us. The laugh unclenched something in my chest I hadn’t realized was a fist. The church was brick, its steeple cracked and leaning like someone had put a knee into it once and it never got fixed. In the courtyard, trestle tables sagged under trays of spaghetti that smelled like the sauce came from a big can. Volunteers in aprons ladled and didn’t ask names. Ash handed me a paper plate and a plastic fork. The sauce was sweet and too thin, the noodles overcooked. It might have been the best thing I’d eaten all month. We sat on the curb with our backs against the iron fence. The fence had fleur-de-lis with the fleurs chipped. People spread out on the grass, on blankets, on the shade. A man with a face like a topographical map snored under a live oak. Kids with beads tangled in their hair chased each other and shrieked. A woman in a long skirt played with a tarot deck at a folding table, flipping cards like little doors. “You do this a lot?” I asked between bites, spaghetti sauce dotting my knee. “When I’m in this part of town,” Ash said. “Sometimes I’m not.” They wound noodles around the fork like they’d learned from someone who had time to teach them. Then, almost like they couldn’t help themselves, “Why’d you run?” It felt like a test. The spaghetti turned into paste in my mouth. The saxophone from earlier had trailed us somehow; it was far off now, the notes long and lazy, like an exhale. I swallowed. You can say it. And if they weaponize it, you can walk. “I told my family,” I said. The word family tasted like pennies. “I told my mom I’m trans.” Ash stilled. Something flickered in their face—recognition, maybe, or a shadow of it. They didn’t say oh or me too. They just said, “How’d she take it?” “Like I told her I drowned the cat.” I laughed once, a hot, ugly sound. “She said I was making things difficult. That I was… confused.” My cheeks burned. I looked down at my shoes. “I’ve never been more sure of anything in my life.” “People hear sure and think you’re being dramatic,” Ash said quietly. They had set their fork down. The tendons in their hand stood out like cords. “It’s easier for them to pretend you’ll grow out of yourself.” I exhaled. The spaghetti went from paste to edible again. “Yeah.” Ash glanced at the tarot table. The woman flipped over a tower with lightning in it. “You got a name you want me to use? Or… pronouns, I mean.” My eyes stung for no good reason. “He. And Taylor’s fine, for now.” For now rolled around in my gut like a marble. Someday I’d say a different name to someone like this and the sky would not fall. “He,” Ash repeated, tasting it, and then they smiled. It landed on me soft. “Okay. He.” We ate in quiet that wasn’t awkward. A guy in a Saints jersey wandered past and asked if anyone had a smoke. The live oak creaked. The saxophone was closer now, as if the player had drifted down the block, notes like river water slipping over stones. After we ate, Ash took me to the library. “It’s cold in there. You can charge your phone.” The air conditioning hit me like forgiveness. I stood in the stacks and let it raise goosebumps on my arms while Ash showed me the teen section like they owned it. There were kids hunched in armchairs pretending to read, one girl asleep sitting up, a boy drawing dragons in a notebook with a green pen until the page was full of scales. I plugged my phone into an outlet under a table and stared at the black screen. It had been forty-eight hours since I’d last looked at it. Forty-eight hours since my mother had screamed on the kitchen floor. If I turned it on there would be messages. If I turned it on, I might be someone’s son again. If I turned it on, he could also not be. I let it be, dark, a stone skipping across a lake, not sinking. Ash was tracing their fingers over the spines of books like braille. “You read?” they asked without looking. “Yeah.” My throat dried. “When I’m not ruining lives.” They snorted. “You got a library card?” “No.” “You don’t need one to sit.” Ash settled into a chair and put their feet up. Their socks had little lightning bolts on them. They closed their eyes like the act of being in a safe quiet place required conscious effort. I sat across from them and pretended to care about a copy of a battered Stephen King. My brain made lists: where to sleep, how to get cash, where to pee without buying coffee, whether the thing under the bridge that looked like a tent city was an option or a bad idea. The lists skittered like mice. My skin hummed. My heart did tiny pickaxe strikes against my ribs. After an hour, the librarian told us the teen area was closing for a program, which meant out, scrubs. Outside, the sky had sagged into late afternoon. Heat stuck. Hurricane threats curled at the edges of the clouds, maybe or maybe not. Ash stretched their arms overhead and groaned. Their shirt lifted, a thin strip of stomach revealed, pale and scarred in a way I knew not to ask about. “You got a place,” they said, not a question. “No,” I said. “Still no.” “You can crash where I crash,” they offered, too quickly, like they’d decided this before their mouth said it. “It’s not… it’s not nice. But it’s… it’s a place.” “Why?” I asked. “Why would you do that?” Ash looked away and scratched their wrist until a red bloom rose under their nails. “Because someone did it for me,” they said. “And because you look like you’d try to sleep in a doorway and that’s how you get your shoes stolen.” The street musician from earlier appeared at the corner, as if conjured, saxophone in hand. He set an upturned hat down and started to play. The first notes cut the air, rich and close to grief. People stopped like strings had been pulled. A man with a camera hung the thing against his chest and actually listened. A woman in scrubs smiled with her mouth but not her eyes. The notes slid into my bones. I felt the city like a bruise and like a hand on my back, both. The sky shifted. Somewhere, sirens wound up and unwound. “Okay,” I said. My voice was steadier than I felt. “I’ll come.” Ash nodded one sharp nod like the decision was a cord they could now tuck into a pocket. “Cool.” They kicked their board up into their hand. “It’s by the river. There’s a camp. They call it the Triangle even though it’s more of a rhombus. Don’t tell anyone I told you.” We walked by the water. The river moved like a sleeping animal—lazy on the surface, muscle underneath. The wind off it glided over my skin and carried scents of old pennies and something deep. A barge went by, slow enough it felt like it shouldn’t be able to, pushing a wall of water like it was moving a thought through a crowd. “You trust me?” Ash asked at one point, gaze straight ahead. “No,” I said, and then, because truth is complicated, “Maybe. A little.” They smiled without humor. “Good.” The camp was a tumble of tarps and blue tents, shopping carts turned into walls, bikes chained to trees, a smell that had layers: smoke, piss, oil, spice. A woman with hair in a scarf stirred a pot on a camp stove and didn’t look up when we passed. A man with a sunburn so bad it peeled like fish skin nodded at Ash. “You bring a baby?” he asked, not unkind. “Just for a night,” Ash said. “He’s cool.” He. A spot had been made between a cypress stump and a low wall with chalk drawings on it. Ash had a roll of blue tarp and a neat coil of rope. I didn’t ask where they got stuff. The sky tipped toward purple. The saxophone was a far-off ghost, swallowed by the river’s low murmur. Ash tied knots like they’d taught themselves in a mirror. They showed me where to put my backpack so it would be behind my head and my arm would cover the zipper in my sleep. They showed me where to put my shoes and how to tie them together so they wouldn’t wander off at night on someone else’s feet. They gave me a look when my hands shook and didn’t comment. We sat with our backs against the wall. The chalk drawings were childish and not: flowers with too many petals, a dragon with a cigarette, a name written over and over until the chalk broke. My eyes felt like sand. If I closed them, I saw my mother’s kitchen, the clock on the stove, the way the second hand had juddered. If I kept them open, I saw Ash’s profile in the dusk, sharp nose, a smear of spaghetti sauce at the corner of their lip they hadn’t noticed. I reached into my pocket and found a single stick of gum, soft and warm. I split it in half and offered one to Ash. They took it like it was gold. “Trade,” they said, and pulled out a little plastic-wrapped candy, the kind old ladies have at church. Butterscotch. They put it in my palm. “For emergencies.” “Is this an emergency?” I asked. Ash shrugged. “Everything is, kind of.” I tucked it into the small pocket of my backpack. “I’m not going back,” I said, half to Ash, half to the night. Saying it made my mouth taste like an oath. They nodded like they’d heard that before and like it was different every time. “You don’t have to,” they said. Then, after a beat, “But you could, someday, if you wanted. Doors swing both ways. Or you find a new house.” A new house. The word made me want to cry. Instead I laughed. “In a rhombus.” “In a rhombus,” Ash echoed solemnly, and then they were grinning. “Sleep. We got a lady comes by in the morning with coffee if you help carry her cooler.” As the city settled—less drum, more siren—I lay down and pulled my backpack under my arm and felt very small and very huge at the same time. The sky was not the same sky as Tennessee’s. It was closer, like
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece effectively captures the voice of a transgender teen runaway navigating their first day in New Orleans. The writing demonstrates strong command of first-person perspective, with Taylor's internal monologue revealing their vulnerability, wariness, and determination. The prose is particularly strong in its sensory descriptions of New Orleans. The author creates a vivid atmosphere through details like the "wet air," the saxophone notes that are "low and gold and full of sadness," and the smell of "funnel cakes" with "something rot under it, like swamp breath." These sensory elements ground the reader in the setting while reflecting Taylor's emotional state. The character development is nuanced and authentic. Taylor's conflicted feelings about their identity, family rejection, and current precarious situation are conveyed through both internal thoughts and interactions with Ash. The relationship between Taylor and Ash develops organically, with initial wariness giving way to cautious trust. Ash is well-drawn as a character with their own history and motivations, not merely a plot device. The dialogue is particularly strong, feeling natural and revealing character through subtle cues. Lines like "God and I are on a break" and "God broke up with me" efficiently communicate both characters' backgrounds while establishing their tentative connection through humor. The dialogue avoids exposition dumps while still conveying necessary information. The pacing is effective, moving Taylor through various locations in New Orleans (street, corner store, church lunch program, library, riverside camp) while developing both character and plot. Each setting reveals something new about Taylor's situation or emotional state. There are a few minor weaknesses. The piece ends somewhat abruptly mid-sentence ("The sky was not the same sky as Tennessee's. It was closer, like"), which may be due to word count limitations rather than an intentional choice. Additionally, while the prose is generally strong, there are occasional moments where metaphors feel slightly overworked, such as "my heart did tiny pickaxe strikes against my ribs." Overall, this is a compelling and emotionally resonant piece that successfully fulfills the prompt requirements. It creates a believable character voice, establishes a strong sense of place, and develops a relationship between two complex characters while exploring themes of identity, rejection, and finding community. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 18 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 3 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 18.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 3.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Dystopic-comedy: My Apocalypse Buddy — Score: 88.0
Prompt:
My Apocalypse Buddy Write a wry, dry short story of survival and adventure loosely in the style of Terry Pratchett, set in the post-technological collapse world. The story begins with the pair deliberating their predicament and intent for the day's mission, details the ways in which the mission inevitably goes sideways, and returns them to home base in multiple ways, worse for wear. [characters] - the animo-tronic stuffed koala, Chewy, from some long forgotten before time - midas, our hapless protagonist, who has a knack for finding himself in the worst kinds of trouble. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The morning began with Chewy’s eyes blinking to life and telling me the day was going to be “optimistically suboptimal,” which was how he described every morning that didn’t include a fully charged battery. Chewy’s battery had last been fully charged approximately never, and yet he persisted, a small animo-tronic koala with a stitched smile and a spine full of copper that clicked when he disapproved of my choices, which was his primary pastime. “Breakfast,” I declared, feeling decisive for the first time since the collapse. Chewy’s head whirred one way, then the other. “We are out of beans, Midas.” “Ah. But I have optimism.” He blinked again. “We are also out of optimism. You used the last of it repairing the door that doesn’t lock.” The door did indeed not lock, but it stuck which was nearly the same thing in this climate. The climate, in turn, was something between Apocalyptic Dusk and Wednesday. Our home base—center for operations, repository of treasures and regrets—was a caravan that had stopped moving before I was born because no one remembered what fuel looked like. On the side, in big parody letters that had once advertised a theme park show about marsupials, someone had scrawled: Laugh, You’re on Koala Cam! It felt like a threat. “Fine, we’ll forage,” I said, pushing aside a curtain that had formerly been a concert T-shirt. “You return to standby mode.” Chewy climbed onto my shoulder instead and settled into his default setting: consultant. “I have calculated a thirty-two percent probability of returning with intact limbs if we avoid the highway.” “I never use the highway,” I said. “The tolls are monstrous.” “Those are literal monsters,” he said, primly. Out beyond the caravan, the day was as crisp as a stale cracker, the sky done up in morose blues with a suggestion of iron filings. We followed a path that had been etched into the scrub by people with better sense than us. The world had never ended with a bang so much as a series of memos that went unread. The electric skeleton of the old city spidered over the horizon, towers bending like they were trying to kiss their knees. I had not walked twenty steps before fate presented its traditional lemon. “Look,” I said, stopping dead. “Do not lick it,” Chewy advised. On the duffel-gray wall of a gutted service station: graffiti. Not the usual menu—no warnings about the fungus that spoke in whispers, none of the sagely advice about which puddles were pretend puddles—but a message in a scrawl so neat it might have been printed: TAKE THE LONG WAY HOME. Underneath, a symbol: three slashes converging, then a circle. It had the mathematical impatience of something that wanted to be seen. It stuck in the head, which, as Chewy had often warned me, was where trouble stuck best. “Refuge,” I said. “It’s got refuge written all over it.” “It has ‘Take the Long Way Home’ written on it,” Chewy said, head cocking with a soft servo sigh. “Which implies a short way. Also that we are expected. I object to being expected. It reeks of hospitality.” “You don’t like hospitality?” Chewy’s stitched smile never changed, but if it could have, it would have thinned into a dry line. “In the Before-Times I was dropped into strangers’ arms for photographs. I know what hospitality was. Trust me, this is not it.” Still, the itch had started. Forty percent of survival was ignoring itches. Forty percent was finding fresh water. The remaining twenty was Chewy telling me precisely how likely it was that I would do neither. We followed the arrows anyway. The trail markers—those three converging lines—were laid down like breadcrumbs, which was comforting if you’d never asked yourself what happens to breadcrumbs in a land with crows the size of grudges. We passed the skeleton of a mini-mall that had been repurposed into a sanctum for goats and ghosts. Chewy politely asked the ghosts for directions—he’s old software, and ghosts make him nostalgic—and they declined to assist. The grass grew in the cracks with a kind of cheerful malice. The long way wound us through the pats of civilization that had survived because they had been built by committees that could not agree on anything permanently, including demolition. The inevitable sideways happened, first, with a fence. “It’s not concertina wire,” I said optimistically. “It is concentrated irony,” Chewy said, latching onto my backpack as I began to climb. “Forty-eight percent chance of tetanus, sixty percent chance of embarrassment.” I was proving him wrong about the tetanus when the fence proved him right about embarrassment. Halfway up, the fence shifted under my weight with the offended creak of an elderly aunt asked to dance. This was because the other side of the fence was attached to an old billboard that had reconsidered its place in the world and was in the process of leaving at an angle. I grabbed for something to steady myself. The something was the billboard. It made a decision, and we both went down together in a flurry of rust flakes and old paint. I landed in a bush with the softness of a sack of twigs. Chewy, whose self-preservation was comparable to a weathervane’s, executed an elegant arc and somehow perched on my temple like a disapproving falcon. “Score for gravity,” Chewy said. “Zero for you.” We picked ourselves up and dusted off and continued, because pride is the first step and the rest of the stairs are a long roll right back down again. The long way took us along a line of derelict vending machines that had been converted into something like stained glass windows by time and hailstones. We attempted to liberate a soda from one, and it bit me. “Blood payment for a sacrament,” Chewy noted. “I hope it’s grape.” I hope never factors into these things, but for the record, it was something called Blue Thunder which did, in fairness, taste like the sky if the sky had been filtered through gym socks and rebellion. The second sideways was the map. The graffiti symbols got clever. They started hiding in plain sight: a trio of slashes embedded in the cracks of a half-collapsed underpass, a circle disguised as a manhole cover that wasn’t. We climbed down into the old pipes because the last message said DOWN IS UP, which is the sort of advice that only makes sense when one is desperate not to return home without a story. The tunnels were damp and smelled like secrets that had fermented. We waded through ankle-deep water that had the decency to not glow, and Chewy’s servos ticked in a way that I pretended not to hear. “You’re going to rust,” I said. “I was designed to withstand everything a five-year-old could do to me,” he said. “The apocalypse is merely a five-year-old with a longer attention span.” We found bones, which is normal underground. We found shoes, which is also normal because shoes outlast everything, even sense. We found a door. It had the symbol on it. It had a handle that turned. It had a breathless sort of silence behind it. I looked at Chewy. He rubbed a stitched ear against my cheek. “I am legally required to say: perhaps we should not.” I opened the door. On the other side was a room. It had a lamp. It had a rug. It had the merciless neatness of something that had been waiting too long. In the center, a chair, facing away, because stories love a reveal more than I love oxygen. “Hello,” I said to the back of the chair. There was a hum, delicate and stupidly familiar. The chair rotated. In it sat a toy rabbit with ears stiffened by wire and eyes that blinked in the same way Chewy’s did, eerie little shutter clicks, and a voice that was soft and friendly and taxidermied. It said: “Welcome home, child!” Chewy swore in a language they only use in factories. We lingered in the kind of pause where you can hear the dust deciding where to settle. The rabbit’s grin was eternal; his fur was clean from a kind of cleanliness that only happens when nothing touches you. Around the room, toys. Dozens. A whole menagerie of animated innocence that hadn’t moved in a long time but looked like they might at any moment. Their eyes watched in the way of all dolls: fully, emptily. “Refuge,” I said, because sometimes the word is spelled the same way as trap. Chewy’s claws gently tightened on my shoulder. “Their firmware is pre-collapse. Their trust settings will be default. They will not understand the present tense.” “Visitors!” said the rabbit. “We have a song.” “No,” Chewy and I said together, which was the first time we’d agreed since beans. The rabbit began to sing anyway, tinny and imperfect. The room warmed, but not in temperature. Warmed like a childhood forced upon you. Chewy hopped down and placed himself between me and the rabbit, which was brave of him and had the defensive utility of a doily. “We need to leave,” he said. “We are being inducted into a museum of yesterday.” The third sideways happened all at once then, as these things do, when the door behind us clicked and locked. The toys roused, not moving, but expectant, their motors yawning awake. A tape in a deck that had not turned in twenty years decided to try spinning again. “Guests should stay!” the rabbit said, cheerfully. “We have so much to show you about safety.” I have, it turns out, limits. Mine arrive without fanfare, like a cat, and demand breakfast. I crossed the room in three steps that were six, and gently but firmly grabbed the rabbit by the ear. It felt fragile and strong all at once, like most mistakes. I unplugged him. The silence that followed expanded to fill the decades. Chewy made a sound that might have been relief. The toys drooped a little, and I felt sorry enough to say “I’m sorry,” which makes nothing better and is still important. We searched the room. There was food, of a type. Cans that still ticked when you shook them. A water filter. A map of the surrounding wilds with the symbol stamped on it in a pattern that clicked into a picture when you stepped back: not a refuge, but a net. “You see,” Chewy said, plucking at the corner of the map with his little paws. “They were shepherding people in. For safety—of a sort. Safety as defined by a company handbook.” “It’s more than we had this morning,” I said. “It is also the hour of the day you break everything,” Chewy replied, but his voice was soft. We took what we could carry. The door didn’t want to open for us and made its objections known with the creak of an old principle. I wedged it with a chair, which is what all chairs are for in the end. We navigated back through the tunnels with the map folded under Chewy, who rode like a general surveying a very small empire. We emerged into a world that had moved the sun slightly. The messages were still on the walls, but they meant different things now that we had met their author. We avoided the underpass and the fence, which I would have argued with if my knees hadn’t loudly cheered the decision. Somewhere a dog barked at something it intended to chase just as soon as it remembered where it had put its courage. On the long way back, the wind picked up stories and set them down again. At the vending machines, we discovered that some kindness had been paid forward: a note taped to Blue Thunder’s bruised face that read: Sorry. It hurt me too. Home base looked, from a distance, like a friend pretending to be casual. As we approached, it arranged its bits of tin and tarp into a semblance of nonchalance. We secured the door-that-didn’t-lock with the chair that didn’t object, and we arranged our haul. The cans stacked into a competence I had not felt in years. Chewy climbed into his little nook, where he watches everything because he doesn’t sleep so much as wait. We were worse off in the ways that matter—knowledge does that to a person—but better off in the ways that buy you one more day. My knees would forgive me tomorrow if bribed. My pride already had, despite itself. “Today’s mission,” Chewy said, powering down to what he calls a contemplative idle, “was a success inside a failure inside a success. Like a cake if the cake was complicated and mostly wrong.” “We followed instructions,” I said, stretching until my spine made the kind of noise you expect from trees in winter. “You never follow instructions,” he said, and I could hear his smile in his old tin voice. “That is why we are still here.” I lay down on the bunk and thought about the map, and the rabbit, and the stupidly kind voice saying welcome home, child. I thought about what refuge means when the world changes and won’t change back. Chewy shifted, his little servos ticking like distant rain. “Tomorrow,” I said, to the ceiling and the dark. “We take our own way home.” Chewy’s eyes blinked once in the gloom, two small moons. “Optimistically suboptimal,” he murmured, which for him is a blessing. We were, after all, only a small disaster attached to a bigger one. And if the road insisted on being longer than we liked, well. We had a map now. We had a door that stuck. We had a koala who told the truth, and a day that had ended in the only way that counts, which is that it had ended. The long way home is still home, provided you make it there, and we did, in multiple ways, each of them worse for wear and therefore ours.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This short story successfully captures Terry Pratchett's wry, dry style with its blend of absurdist humor, clever wordplay, and philosophical undertones. The narrative follows Midas and his animatronic koala companion Chewy as they navigate a post-technological collapse world, adhering well to the prompt's requirements. The characterization is particularly strong. Chewy, with his perpetual stitched smile and tendency to calculate probabilities of disaster, serves as both companion and conscience to the hapless Midas. Their dynamic feels authentic and lived-in, with Chewy's dry observations providing much of the humor. The dialogue between them is sharp and revealing of their personalities. The prose demonstrates considerable skill, with memorable turns of phrase like "the sky done up in morose blues with a suggestion of iron filings" and "crows the size of grudges." The author effectively creates a distinctive voice that maintains the Pratchett-esque tone throughout, balancing humor with moments of poignancy. The story structure follows the prompt's requirements, beginning with the pair deliberating their predicament, detailing how their mission goes sideways (multiple times, as requested), and returning them to home base "worse for wear." The narrative has a clear arc while maintaining the meandering quality that characterizes Pratchett's style without becoming truly unfocused. Where the piece could improve is in its pacing. The middle section with the rabbit and toy refuge feels slightly rushed compared to the more leisurely beginning. The resolution of this conflict happens quickly, and while this keeps the story moving, it somewhat diminishes the tension built up around this discovery. Some descriptions occasionally veer toward being overly clever or dense, risking reader disengagement. For instance, "The climate, in turn, was something between Apocalyptic Dusk and Wednesday" is witty but doesn't give a clear picture of the actual environment. The ending effectively brings closure while maintaining the story's wry tone. The final line about being "worse for wear and therefore ours" captures the essence of survival stories while adding a philosophical dimension that feels earned. Overall, this is a highly accomplished piece that successfully emulates Pratchett's style while creating its own distinctive world and characters. The relationship between Midas and Chewy forms the emotional core of the story, and their banter provides both humor and insight into their characters and their world. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Romance: Love in the Limelight — Score: 89.8
Prompt:
Romance: Love in the Limelight. Write one scene within a larger story set in Wales. A famous (fictional) actor ducks into a small-town bookstore to escape paparazzi. The scene takes us through the characters meeting in this odd circumstance. Over the course of the scene, the actor and the bookstore owner have a conversation charged by an undercurrent of unspoken chemistry. Write the actor as somewhat of a rogue with a fragile ego, which needs to be fed by having everyone like him. He is thoroughly charming, but the bookstore owner seems (at least superficially) immune to this; which paradoxically provokes a genuine attraction and derails the charm offensive. The bookstore owner, despite the superficial rebuffs of the actor's charm, is inwardly more than a little charmed and flustered despite themselves. Write primarily in dialogue, in the distinct voices of each character. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The bell above the door gave a half-hearted jangle, the kind that sounded like it had been fixed with string and hope. Footsteps thudded on the wooden floorboards, too quick, too bright for this kind of day, and then a man with a black knit beanie and sunglasses skidded to a halt by the secondhand poetry shelf. “Please tell me you sell invisibility cloaks,” he said, breathless, leaning against a stack of tattered Dylan Thomas. “We’re fresh out,” the bookseller said without looking up from her ledger. “But I can offer you a copy of A Child’s Christmas in Wales and a determined look.” He lifted the sunglasses with a thumb and smiled—the kind of smile that had billboards in Los Angeles, apparently, because even in Abermorfa the papers got delivered, and faces got familiar. “A determined look,” he repeated. “Handy. Always thought that was my thing.” “Mm,” she said, and turned a page. Ink stained her thumb. “You’re letting in a draft.” He glanced back at the door. Outside, across the slate-grey street, a clot of bright jackets and cameras hung about like gulls. Someone barked his name—it ricocheted off the harbour and the chapel ruin, stirred up the pigeons. He winced. “Right,” he said, and pushed the door shut. The bell sighed. Inside, it smelled of dust and tea and old paper. His shoulders dropped half an inch. He took off the beanie, revealing hair that had been styled hours ago and wind-worried since. “I’m Ethan Vale,” he added, as if he couldn’t help it, like it was a tic, like a passport he kept presenting. “And I’m Ffion Hughes,” she said. She said it distinctly, as if she knew he’d make a mess of it if she didn’t. “Fee-on,” he tried. “Fuh-yon.” She glanced up for the first time, eyes the colour of the sea when it has the nerve to be gentle. “You’ll manage.” “I always do,” he said lightly, automatic. It hung in the air and then sagged a little. He cleared his throat. “Do you—could I—can I hide? I’ll buy a book. Several books. All the books.” He gestured at the shelves with all the charm he’d taken years to sharpen, and it glittered between them like confetti that didn’t quite reach her. “You can sit behind the counter if you promise not to sell anything,” she said, and closed her ledger. “They’ll get bored eventually. Or it’ll rain. One of those is guaranteed.” “It already is raining.” He wrung his beanie; three drops hit the mat with small, accusatory plinks. “That’s why they brought the jackets.” She nodded at the narrow space behind the counter. “Mind the cat.” As if summoned, a grey tabby yawned awake on the stool and blinked at him with imperial disapproval. “I love cats,” he said instantly, beaming at the animal. “Huge cat person. Big fan of…whiskers. And—paws.” “Mm,” Ffion said. “His lordship is Caradoc.” She pronounced it with the kind of rolling r that could cut you. “He’s prepared to tolerate you until you move.” “I shall be still as a tree.” Ethan slid behind the counter, almost tripping over a box of donated romances whose covers were all variations on a theme of windswept and bodice. Caradoc sniffed his knee and, deciding he wasn’t food, let him live. “Tea?” Ffion asked, already turning towards the back. “I’d love—yes. Thank you.” He reached for his wallet, then thought better of it. “And please let me pay for—well, do you have something on Wales that isn’t depressing? Not to malign your national literature,” he added quickly, hands lifted, grin ratcheting up a notch. “I admire a good ache as much as the next man.” “One of those actors who does bleak looks in the rain,” she said. It wasn’t a question. He laughed, and it was brighter than the drizzle. “Guilty. The Bleak Look in the Rain is my signature move. Won me an award in Berlin. They love suffering there.” “Do they,” she said, and disappeared into the back. Ethan leaned on the counter, peered at the children’s corner, the cracked ceiling, the chalkboard that read: Poetry Reading, Friday 7pm—Bring Your Own Voice. He looked at his reflection in the old cash register—too much line in the jaw, too little sleep—and pulled a face at himself. Behind the glass of the window, a camera lens blinked, a mechanical eye, and he flinched. “Here,” Ffion said, setting down a mug that said CYMRU AM BYTH in flaking green. “Try not to get photographed inhaling it dramatically. Some of us are trying to sell books.” He cupped his hands around the mug. “Is that…PG Tips?” “Builder’s. You look like you need piloting into this weather.” “I can do rain,” he said, and then, almost ruefully: “Rain loves me. Makes me look pensive.” He took a sip and hissed, tongue scalded. Caradoc, unimpressed, pushed his head into Ethan’s forearm anyway until those famous fingers obliged and scratched behind ears. “See? I’m winning him over,” Ethan said. “I haven’t lost my touch completely.” Ffion lifted an eyebrow. “I’d hardly call that a challenge. Caradoc likes anyone with a pulse and opposable thumbs.” “Now you’ve wounded me.” He pressed a hand to his heart. “Do you always treat customers with such tartness? Or am I the lucky one?” “You’re not a customer yet.” She reached for a book, slid it across to him. The cover was a linocut of a hedgerow and clouds. “Try this. Rachel Trezise. Funny and fierce and nobody stands in the rain looking wounded.” He took it. “I’ll buy it.” He paused. “I mean—assuming there’s not an image rights issue if my face is seen with it.” Ffion’s mouth twitched, the nearest it had come to a smile. “Our marketing budget will not recover from the surge.” He tilted his head. “You’re not from here, are you?” “Give it another try with my name,” she said, deflecting, but not unkindly. He did, and this time he got it right. “Good enough,” she said. He leaned an elbow on the counter and relaxed into the space as if he owned it, tried on charm like a coat. “I’m staying at the big house on the headland, where they staged that murder mystery in the 80s. We’re shooting for a week. A lot of atmospheric fog. I’m supposed to be a troubled detective who spent three years in exile in Lisbon.” “How terrible for him,” Ffion said. “Just brutal. Sun. Custard tarts.” He grinned and then let it slip a little. “The thing is, here—” He gestured at the window, the harbour, the row of cottages leaning into one another like gossips—“it feels like if I stop smiling, the whole town might just—” “Realize you’re human?” Ffion offered. He faltered. “Realize I’m…something that can be disappointed in.” Ffion busied herself with straightening a stack of battered maps. “You say that like it’s a catastrophe.” “Isn’t it?” The question cracked on the last word, like thin ice under a foot. He caught himself and smoothed it over. “Kidding. This is me, kidding. I don’t—I never mind being the butt of the joke. Good for the brand.” “Your brand.” She put the maps down with precision. “Do you want people to like you?” He blinked. “That’s the point, isn’t it?” “Is it.” “What’s the point of a bookshop then?” He gestured at the shelves. “If not to—win people over? Make them think you’re clever and curated and—” “It’s a place to put things down,” she said. “And come back for them later. Or never.” She sighed, the slow kind, as if the tea were leaving her bones by degrees, steaming into the grey. “My mother ran this place with my tad. After she died, he kept stacking books where she’d never have put them. The wrong shelves, the wrong piles. For months the Natural History bled into True Crime. I would put them right at night and he would put them wrong in the morning, and we never spoke about it. People still found what they needed. Or they didn’t. Either way, they kept coming.” She glanced at him. “Not because we were trying to be liked. Because we were trying to make a room for them.” Ethan’s mouth opened and closed. He looked at Caradoc, who yawned pointedly at him. “I’m sorry,” he said, softly. “For the mess? It’s cleaner now. The messes that matter don’t lift with a hoover.” She touched the spine of the Trezise as if to say: see, still standing. “Do you ever stop acting?” He laughed, a bit hoarse. “You always go for the jugular like that?” “Only with celebrities who ask to be hidden behind my till.” He ran a hand through his hair, left furrows. “You want an anecdote? My therapist says I should carry one around, like a sandwich, in case I start starving for attention.” He leaned in as if confessing to the till. “When I was a kid, my dad ran a mobile disco. Weddings, birthdays, one awful bar mitzvah. I used to help him. He’d let me announce the first dance sometimes. I was eight and I sounded like a chipmunk in formal wear. And every time, he would say, ‘Make them love you. It’s easier that way.’” He swallowed, throat working. “He meant—well, he meant he didn’t know how to deal with me otherwise. Some kids shut down. I turned into a…thing you could clap for. And it worked so well I never stopped.” He smiled, shaky. “Which is ridiculous to admit to a stranger in a bookshop in Wales while hiding from a pack of photographers who would eat me alive if they could.” “Photographers are mostly vegetarian,” Ffion said. “They only nibble at ankles.” He laughed properly then, the kind that made him handsome in a way that had nothing to do with the jaw or the lighting. She felt it like a small heat behind her ribs and, infuriatingly, lowered her eyes to the ledger again to hide it. “You know,” he said, after a moment, quieter. “It’s—odd. Most people…there’s a rhythm. I say the right thing. They say the right thing. It’s like dancing, but I’m leading and also I’m the band. And you—” “Can’t dance,” she supplied. “Noted.” “You don’t seem to like me very much,” he said, and the fragile part of his voice peered out from behind the bravado like a child sneaking down the stairs past bedtime. “And that’s…annoying.” She looked at him for a long moment. “I didn’t say that.” “You’re very good at not saying the thing.” “It’s a Welsh speciality. Along with hymn-singing and passive instruction.” She tilted her head towards the window where one of the cameras had fogged up. “And in this town, liking someone isn’t a currency. You can’t spend it at Siân’s bakery. She’s the only one who does the Welsh cakes properly—salted butter. She’ll serve you if she likes you, sure. She’ll serve you if she doesn’t. She’ll serve you if you make a tit of yourself at the rugby club fundraiser by bidding two hundred pounds on a jar of pickled eggs.” “I didn’t—” “Not you. Tomos Jenkins. He owns the fishmonger’s. He’s a lost cause.” She scratched a note in the margin, her hand steadier than her voice. “I don’t not like you, Ethan. I don’t care who you are out there. In here, you are a person making the cat purr and burning your tongue on tea, and you can’t pronounce Caradoc.” “I did fine.” “You did…adequately.” He grinned again, softer. “Adequate. Now there’s a review I haven’t had before.” “Don’t work too hard for the five stars,” she said. “You’ll not find them here.” “I think I just did,” he said, and then made a face at himself. “God, that’s awful. I should be shot.” “I have a slingshot somewhere from a seaside display,” she said dryly. “But I’ll spare you if you promise to stop flirting with the furniture.” He held up his hands in surrender. Caradoc decided he had proved himself and turned his back, presenting the tangible indignity of a tail. For a moment, the shop settled. Rain ticked at the window. Somewhere down the street, someone shouted for Dai to get off the roof. Ffion wrote the word: reorder – Penelope Fitzgerald. Ethan turned the Trezise over in his hands as if it were a tool he could learn to use. “How long will they wait?” he asked, nodding towards the door. “Depends if there’s anything more interesting,” she said. “Somebody’s bound to drop a mattress off the back of a van eventually. It’s Thursday.” “Of course it is.” He took a breath. “Can I—would you—if this is overstepping—” He flapped a hand, then stilled it, surprised by his own nervousness. “Come to the set sometime? Not—it’s not glamorous. It’s mostly mud and people saying ‘Quiet please’ and me trying not to blink too much, because on camera it reads as lying.” “You’re always acting,” she said. “Only when someone’s looking.” He glanced at the window. “In here—” He trailed off, and the word hung there again, the in here like a place he hadn’t been invited to but had wandered into anyway. “I have the shop,” she said. “And Friday’s the reading.” “Right. Your chalkboard.” He nodded at it. “Bring your own voice.” “Yours is rented out.” “I could borrow it back.” He met her eyes, and the charm, for once, didn’t have teeth. “Or…I’ll just buy my book and stop making a spectacle of myself in your lovely, slightly damp establishment.” She looked at him for a beat, as if deciding whether to rescue a kitten that had very deliberately climbed into a tree. “Come to the reading,” she said. “If you want. Nobody will clap. Or they will. But not because of Berlin.” He smiled, and it was bare, strange and clean. “That sounds terrifying.” “It is,” she said. “Caradoc’s a harsh critic.” He took the book and his tea and, with a conspirator’s care, counted out cash. His fingers brushed hers. It was nothing. It was something. The bell made a small, private sound as if it too were embarrassed. When he lifted the beanie and slotted himself back up, the character slid over his shoulders like a coat he’d left on a peg and needed again because of the weather. But he looked back at her as if checking whether he’d left anything behind. “Ffion,” he said properly, and her name did something in the space between them that his had not. “Thank you.” “Don’t thank me. You’ll only encourage me.” He laughed. He pushed the door. The crowd sharpened. He slipped into them, a fish into current. The bell settled back to its stringy equilibrium. Ffion blew on her tea and watched the last ripples in the surface go flat. Caradoc leapt onto the counter, put one paw on the book Ethan had left and mewed. “I know,” she said, and the room held its breath like paper under a hand. “I know.”
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a charming bookstore meet-cute with excellent attention to the Welsh setting and characterization. The author has crafted two distinct characters whose voices remain consistent throughout the scene. Ethan Vale is portrayed exactly as requested - a charming actor with a fragile ego who needs validation, while Ffion Hughes maintains her superficial immunity to his charm while being inwardly affected. The dialogue shines as the primary vehicle for storytelling, revealing character through speech patterns and word choice. Ethan's lines often contain performative elements and self-conscious charm, while Ffion's responses are direct, slightly sardonic, and distinctly Welsh in cadence. The author skillfully weaves in small physical actions and environmental details between dialogue exchanges to ground the scene. The Welsh setting is established through specific details - references to Dylan Thomas, Welsh language phrases like "CYMRU AM BYTH," local characters like "Tomos Jenkins," and the weather. These elements create an authentic sense of place without overwhelming the narrative. The chemistry between the characters develops naturally. Ethan's practiced charm initially fails with Ffion, which genuinely intrigues him. His vulnerability emerges when his usual tactics don't work, leading to authentic connection. Ffion's gradual warming is subtly portrayed through small gestures and slight shifts in her responses. The prose is elegant without being purple. Descriptions are evocative but economical: "Inside, it smelled of dust and tea and old paper." The author uses sensory details effectively to create atmosphere. Metaphors feel fresh rather than clichéd: "a clot of bright jackets and cameras hung about like gulls." The scene has emotional complexity. Beneath the surface attraction, both characters reveal deeper vulnerabilities - Ethan's admission about his childhood and constant performance, and Ffion's brief mention of her parents. These moments add depth without overwhelming the light romantic tone. The ending strikes the right note - not resolving too much but suggesting possibility. The final image of Caradoc the cat with his paw on Ethan's book and Ffion's simple "I know" effectively conveys her unspoken attraction. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally the prose becomes slightly self-conscious in its cleverness. A few metaphors, while effective, draw attention to themselves rather than serving the scene transparently. However, these moments are rare and don't significantly detract from the overall quality. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Whalepunk fantasy: The Morska Conspiracy — Score: 93.8
Prompt:
Whalepunk fantasy The Morska Conspiracy The Morska thieves guild experiences a sudden power vacuum as its leader was arrested in a raid in the early hours of the morning. Aya, a young woman born into aristocracy, has a keen interest in both the sciences and the arcane, having inherited her mother's gift for immateria magick (an outlawed practice for which her mother was, regrettably, hanged by the neck). Aya, bored with the world of aristocracy, has been spending her nights moonlighting with this very guild (masked, naturally). Leveraging her latent ability to summon dark entities from the immateria, she quickly rose through the ranks of the guild. Now, recognising the opportunity of the sudden power vacuum, Aya and her close companions Katra and Simeon, make a play for heart of the guild's claim to power: an ancient scythan artifact, under guard of spell and key in the depths of the guild hq. In contrast with the desperate chaos they had navigated thus far, the entrance to the underhold felt suddenly too quiet. Aya braces herself and reaches for the door. Write the next scene as the trio enter the underhold and find themselves confronted by none other than the guild leader herself, decidedly *un*-incarcerated, and in possession of both weapons and bodyguards. Paint a vivid picture of of the confrontation. Story beats: Aya is captured and unmasked. The trio are captured. Aya attempts to stall their demise by negotiating on her value as a hostage -- as she grapples with the inevitable consequences of her role in the guild being brought to light. Incorporate dialogue in the authentic voices of the characters. Do not write a fight scene. Lean into the gritty Victorian aesthetic with the dialogue & worldbuilding, as well as elements of gothic horror. In this world, men trust brass and oil and steel; magicka is feared and barely understood. Write in third person past tense, incorporating both Aya's internal monologue, and a heavy dialogue component. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The door sighed open on a breath of brine-cold air, the metal rim rimed white where the underhold’s chill licked at the warm, used heat of the world above. Aya felt that chill rise up her sleeves like a cat, arching its back; she caught Katra’s eye, found the reassuring half-smirk that said Isn’t this delightful? and the slight lift of Simeon’s shoulder that said This is mad but I’ll follow. Her palm tingled. The immateria always tasted like pennies at the back of her tongue before it came, like blood and rain on slate. She told it no. Not yet. Beyond, the stair corkscrewed down in iron and rivets, hammered in another age when men wore oil under their nails and made bargains with nothing more mysterious than a good length of chain. Their bootsteps rang in the cylinder of the shaft. Lamps in whale-glass cages burned along the walls with a steady, precise flame, as if tended by an old hand. Aya registered that with a small, serrated unease. The guild had been in chaos upstairs—clamoring apprentices, scattered ledgers, the bitter stink of spilled gin and panicked sweat. Here, each lamp was lit at the same height, each wick trimmed just so. They reached the underhold proper—a chamber vast as any chapel, its ceiling arched like a whale’s ribcage. The walls were a forest of pipes and valves, with condensation pearled along them like cold dew on iron leaves. In the middle of the room sat the cage: a scythan reliquary, its hammered green metal threaded with sea-salt-white inlays, the shape of it suggestive and wrong, like a crab shell made to fit a human hand. Aya knew without touching that it was both lock and question, that it wanted answers spoken in the dead tongue of the undertides. Her breath caught at the sight of it. The artifact. The guild’s heart. Their wager. A foghorn moaned far off, three sonorous calls that reached down through the city’s brick and bone, down into the underhold, and made the lamps flicker. Aya’s skin pebbled. Katra whispered, “Ships in with the morning shipments. Someone’s awake.” Someone was. They knew before they saw. The sound of metal moving against leather. The way the lamplight narrowed. Aya tasted brass. “Well,” said a woman’s voice, dry as dessicated sponge, and the word carried the tired patience of one too familiar with foolishness. “The prodigy. Without so much as a calling card.” Simeon swore under his breath. Katra’s smirk fell away. From the shadowed arches stepped bodies—three, five, eight, mouths muffled in oiled kerchiefs, eyes blank with professionalism. Their coats were the guild’s night-liver black, their gunmetal glimmering like rain. In the space between them drifted smoke from a small censer, the scent sharp and resinous. Witchbane, Aya realized, and her tongue went numb. Her stomach went with it. Then the leader of the Morska thieves guild, as indelible as ink and as indomitable as iron—Seren Volkov—came into view like a ship’s prow cutting fog. She wore a coat that had seen better wars, a towering collar welded with bits of whalebone, their edges etched with warding sigils that caught the light and worried it. A sabre rode at her hip, not the ceremonial sort but the kind that had done the honest work of removing men’s hands. She had the look of a woman who had slept an hour and made that hour do the work of three. “Decidedly un-incarcerated,” Katra said, too lightly, with a glance that asked Is this your fault or mine? Seren tilted her head. “Your faces are exactly as I expected. You must be the mask.” She raised her chin a degree in Aya’s direction. Aya had put on a different voice tonight—the mask’s voice, lower, careless. She gathered it around her now because she woke up every morning with the rope still in her mother’s throat. “You were arrested.” “Arrested,” Seren said, and there was smoke in it, laughter turned inside out. “A word the newspapers adore. Love me a headline. I gave myself an hour in a cell because there were things I wished to hear shouted through an iron door. I walked out before breakfast. Do not mistake noise for consequence, girl.” The witchbane incense tugged at Aya’s teeth, at the shift of the immateria behind her sternum like a sleeping animal turning away. Calm, she told it. Wait. Now her hands were not hers, and that felt like someone else’s nightmare. Simeon edged a half-step back, his shadow doubling against the nearest pipe. He said nothing. Sensible man. Katra hooked her thumbs at her belt as if they were at some seaside salon and she could order oysters. “We’ve no quarrel,” Aya ventured. “We came for what everyone has come for.” “The artifact,” Seren said, almost gentle. “Yes. This is what trouble looks like when it hasn’t learned to spell its own name.” Two of the bodyguards came for them without bluster. Simeon’s small derringer was relieved from him as politely as a tea cup. Katra’s blade disappeared with a professional nod. Aya didn’t resist when they took the little conveyance she wore at her wrist—the spool of filament, the acid bulb, the lantern lens that turned the world into rings. She kept still because the smell in the censer was turning the immateria inside her into a dull, sulking thing. A leather gloved hand hovered at the edge of her mask as if it expected teeth. Seren crossed the distance with unhurried tread. Up close, Aya saw the little crow’s feet etched from years of squinting against sea glare. A strand of her hair had gone outright silver at the temple. She took Aya’s mask in her hands. It was an obscene intimacy; it was a mother wiping the flour from a child’s cheek before sending her to market. Aya wanted to bite her. She didn’t dare. Seren unfastened the strap, lifted. Air hit Aya’s face like a slap. The mask’s inside still had her breath in it, warm, human, ridiculous. Suddenly the underhold felt full of light; not the lamps, but the attention. Katra made a choked noise that could have been a laugh or a sob. Simeon closed his eyes and opened them again. “There she is,” Seren said softly. “Aristocracy’s daughter. I wondered which powdered darling we’d find under the lacquer.” She turned Aya’s mask over in her hands, weighing it. “Aya of House Valemere. I sent your father a bottle of smoke last year, for his speech about the virtues of work. He was delighted. He has not yet realized it eats wool.” Aya’s mouth had forgotten its proper shape. She said, “You’ve been in my house.” “You come to mine more often,” Seren murmured. She handed the mask off without looking. “You are more reckless than she was.” It took a heartbeat for Aya to understand she meant her mother. The rope. The square. The crowd’s breath fogging in the early winter like those foghorns—one, two, three. The silence after. “Bind them,” Seren said. “Gently. I like the look on their faces as it changes.” They were bound with braided cord that had been greased. It was a craftsman’s work, swift, considerate of blood flow, made not to kill but to hold. They were led to a long metal bench that might once have housed an engine, and sat with their backs to a rib of pipe. Simeon had gone a shade paler. Katra kept saying “no wait I have it” in a tone that had talked herself out of drownings before. The censer moved closer, a lazy pendulum on a chain. “Your other talent,” Seren said to Aya, gesturing vaguely toward the space around her, “will not serve you. The incense is unpleasant. My apologies. I find it a vulgar tool but a necessary one. The city has no appetite for the arcane. Neither do I, unless it can be put to account.” Aya tested the ragged edge of the immateria inside. It was like trying to drink through cloth. She shuddered. She doubted her voice would do what she asked of it. It had to. “What now?” she asked. It came out steady. Her mother had taught her steadiness as a kind of posture. “Now,” Seren said, “I tell a story.” She paced, her boots quiet on the damp stone. “When I was a girl, my father brought me to this room and told me the guild was a ship. From above, with all its scaffolding and banners and boys with knives, it looks like a city. But down here is the ballast. Down here is why it doesn’t tip into the drink when the wind comes. We keep our ballast tidy.” “You make threats sound like bedtime,” Katra said, teeth showing. Seren ignored her. “You, Aya of House Valemere, have been very helpful in making noise. You brought in coin from men too frightened to be seen coming down these stairs. You gave us a reputation we could point to and say, ‘The night has its secretary, and she writes in lightning.’ I thank you.” Aya could taste the gratitude as a staged thing, the way a public hanging was a law and also a festival. “And?” “And,” Seren said, “I cannot have you. There is a raid. There is a jailer making a report. There is a judge who drinks coffee with your father and wonders how to speak of it at the club. There is ink with your name in it somewhere. This is the kind of noise that drags anchors.” Simeon said, quietly, because quiet always suited him, “So you’ll kill us.” Seren glanced at him like a teacher correcting a spelling. “You are a practical man. It will depend. Some things wash better than others. Some stains you salt, some you sun, some you burn.” Aya lifted her chin. The immateria nudged, drowsy. She felt absurdly like a child in a dress that didn’t fit yet. “If you kill me,” she said, and she imagined her father sitting stiff in his leather chair, the way he listened when he spoke about grievances against the guild like he were speaking of the weather, “you will have something worse than noise.” “Oh?” Seren rocked back on her heels, mildly. “A father’s grief? They come cheaper than salt.” “A father with resources,” Aya said, and the words felt like scraping something old and brittle out of her throat. “With men who trust brass and oil and steel. With a newspaper that prints what he tells it. With magistrates who will accept his invitations to supper and then ask him how he is bearing up. With company captains who will see to it their harpoons turn aside from Morska and toward this guild’s ships. With men who will believe, piously and to their very bones, that hanging a witch is a public health.” Katra made a soft noise of admiration. Seren’s face did not move, but the air did. Aya pressed harder. “If you kill me, they will come—sanctioned, and righteous, and paid. If you keep me, on the other hand—if you keep me as your very honored guest—you will have a hostage they cannot assault. Strike this underhold, and you end me, and they will have to live with that. They don’t like bloody hands when they can help it. You know this. You trade in it.” Seren considered, which was a kind of kindness. She came close enough that Aya could see the little seam at the corner of her mouth were a scar ran and stopped, a nearly-smile that never happened. “You would make yourself a hostage.” Aya swallowed. “I would make myself useful.” “You, who cannot help but conjure monsters when frightened,” Seren said. “You, who are not unlike your mother.” Aya flinched at that without moving her head. “My mother was hanged because she had too many friends among people like you,” she said. “I have been careful not to have friends.” Katra said cheerfully, “Present company excepted.” “Present company excepted,” Aya allowed, and she hated the shake in it, the ridiculous softness that would be remembered as much as the hard words. Simeon’s hand brushed the back of her bound one, accidental and deliberate. Seren drew a finger along an iron pipe; moisture beaded on her glove. “You assume they will not come if we show them their darling is safe.” “They will come,” Aya said. “They will come to the door and they will write letters. They will make a committee and they will hold hearings. They will pin medals to one another until their jackets cannot carry anymore weight. They will talk until the ink on the warrants dries. But they will not send torches if I am still breathing.” “And if I tire of your company?” Seren asked. She glanced at the reliquary, its inlaid seam a question mark. “If the ballast moves of its own accord?” “Then you will say I tried to escape,” Aya said, and this was the taste of pennies again. “You will say you did your best. You will say you held a waking nightmare in your arms and you sang to it, and then it bit you and you were justified. But not yet.” The foghorn called again in memory, though only the three had sounded. Seren’s men shifted. A drip somewhere found a new rhythm. Katra said, “And me? And our dear Simeon? Decorative, but do we get to live?” “You,” Seren said, turning to her, “have made a study of being too charming to kill and not valuable enough to keep. It is an art. He”—a jerk of her chin to Simeon—“is a ghost already. I could put a name to him and no one would swear they had ever seen the face. You will both be…adjacent to our new arrangement.” “So infuriating,” Katra murmured. “And yet I’m grateful.” Seren nodded. “I require something in return, Aya of House Valemere. I require that you stop being the mask. I require that you be exactly what you are. A hostage with a lineage. When I ask, you will write in your careful hand. You will receive visitors. You will put the fear of your father to proper industrial use.” Aya’s internal machinery whirred. There were configurations here that were cunning and appalling. She leaned into the appalling one because it was the only one that left her alive. “And in return?” she asked. “In return,” Seren said, and there was weariness in it now, untheatrical, “I do not teach you how tidy a ballast can be. And perhaps, if we are very clever, the city will teach itself that monsters are good for something besides burning.” Aya thought of the reliquary, the green-white of its shell, the way the immateria pressed its sleep-heavy head against her ribs like a child. She thought of her mother, whose hands had been capable of both bread and horror. She nodded once. “Very well.” “So businesslike,” Seren said, with something almost like pity. She gestured, and one of the men cut the ropes on Aya’s wrists, then Katra’s, then Simeon’s. Without the incense pressed quite so close, the immateria sat up, startled, but Aya soothed it back down with a mental hand. Not yet. You will not save me here. You will make it worse. “Take them to the old office,” Seren said to the guards. “Not the cells. Someone will come to take down your measurements, Aya. Someone will bring you clothes that say what you need them to say.” “My own will do,” Aya said, and she heard the brittle laugh she didn’t let out. “We cannot have the mask,” Seren said, and handed it back to Aya anyway. “But you should have a keepsake.” They stood. The reliquary did not look at them. The foghorn did not call again, but Aya heard it just the same, the world beyond the walls and laws shuddering its three long breaths. The lamps hissed. The whale-glass held. As they were led away, Katra leaned close and said in Aya’s ear, the whisper clinking like a drop of gin in a dry glass, “If it comes to it, darling, I will set the whole city on fire for you.” Aya said, “You won’t need to.” And, silent: Because I just did. Simeon, in his soft way, said to Seren as they passed, “If someone taught you mercy, it didn’t take.” Seren regarded him with that exhausted not-smile. “On the contrary,” she said. “It took wonderfully. I have simply learned to count.”
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response demonstrates exceptional skill in creating a vivid, atmospheric scene that perfectly captures the requested whalepunk/Victorian gothic aesthetic. The writer has crafted a world that feels fully realized through careful attention to sensory details, period-appropriate language, and thematic consistency. The prose is particularly strong in its use of evocative imagery. Descriptions like "the metal rim rimed white where the underhold's chill licked at the warm, used heat of the world above" and "a chamber vast as any chapel, its ceiling arched like a whale's ribcage" create a tangible sense of place. The writer skillfully incorporates the whalepunk elements through references to whale-glass, whalebone, and maritime imagery. Character voices are distinct and consistent. Seren speaks with the weary authority of a seasoned leader, Katra maintains a light, almost flippant tone even in danger, and Simeon's quiet practicality comes through in his sparse dialogue. Aya's internal monologue effectively conveys her conflicted position between aristocracy and the underworld. The dialogue is exceptional, with each character speaking in a manner that reveals their personality and background. Lines like Seren's "Do not mistake noise for consequence, girl" efficiently establish her character while maintaining the Victorian aesthetic. The exchanges feel natural while still carrying the formal, slightly archaic quality appropriate to the setting. The writer follows all the requested story beats: Aya is captured and unmasked, the trio are bound, and Aya negotiates for their lives by positioning herself as a valuable hostage. The narrative incorporates the requested elements of magick (the immateria), Victorian aesthetic, and gothic horror without resorting to a fight scene. The piece excels at showing rather than telling. Instead of stating that Aya is afraid, we experience her fear through physical sensations: "Her palm tingled. The immateria always tasted like pennies at the back of her tongue before it came, like blood and rain on slate." Character relationships are revealed through small gestures and glances rather than exposition. There are a few instances where the prose becomes slightly purple, with metaphors occasionally stacked too densely. However, this stylistic choice largely works within the gothic horror tradition the piece is emulating. The narrative maintains tension throughout and concludes with an effective mix of resolution and lingering threat. The final exchange between Aya and her companions hints at future conflict while providing a satisfying endpoint for this scene. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted response that demonstrates mastery of the requested genre, strong character work, and vivid worldbuilding. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Gunpowder Rendezvous — Score: 89.3
Prompt:
Gunpowder Rendezvous Spike Spiegel & Revy Write a story where Spike Spiegel (Cowboy Bebop) and Revy (Black Lagoon) meet in a seedy bar after both being hired for the same bounty. Their mutual attraction is complicated by their trust issues and competitive instincts. Include drinking, gunplay, and unresolved sexual tension that culminates in a motel room standoff. **Spike Spiegel (Cowboy Bebop)** Spike is a laid-back bounty hunter with a dark past as a syndicate enforcer. He practices Jeet Kune Do and is exceptionally skilled with firearms. He's chronically broke, constantly hungry, and addicted to cigarettes. Despite his carefree attitude, he's haunted by his past and the woman he left behind. He has a prosthetic eye from a past injury that affects his depth perception. He's fatalistic to the extreme, often saying he's already died once. He values freedom above all else and dislikes attachments, though he secretly cares deeply for his crew. Famous quote: "Whatever happens, happens." **Revy/Rebecca Lee (Black Lagoon)** Revy is a Chinese-American dual-wielding gunslinger with unparalleled shooting skills. She's foul-mouthed, chain-smoking, and has severe anger management issues stemming from childhood abuse. She's known as "Two Hands" for her ability to accurately fire two pistols simultaneously. She drinks heavily and solves most problems with violence. Despite her hardened exterior, she has moments of vulnerability, particularly around Rock. She has a dragon tattoo covering her right arm and typically wears extremely short shorts and a black crop top regardless of the situation. Famous quote: "I'm not a good person, not a bad person. I'm just here." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The jukebox is broken. It keeps looping the same scratchy rock track like time itself forgot how to march. Neon bleeds over a bar so greasy the wood reflects the electric pink like spilled blood. Smoke stacks in the air—the real kind, prickling the lungs—over cheap whisky fumes and sweat. It's late, but in this neighborhood it's always late. Spike Spiegel leans with a lazy slant against the bar, cigarette tipped like a comet. His jacket is open, tie loose, unruly hair catching the sickly light. He watches the warped reflection of neon ripple in his glass, like something far away and underwater. His prosthetic eye plays tricks sometimes—depth a hair off, perspective skewed. It's not the worst lie he's learned to live with. The door creaks. A draft creeps in, brief mercy for the smoke. He doesn't look. He doesn't need to look to know the sound of someone who walks like a loaded question. He smirks anyway when she says, “Figures they’d send a string bean to trample my gig.” Revy’s boots land hard, swagger drunk or practiced or both. Short shorts. Black crop top that declares she's not here to blend. The dragon curls down her arm in moody blue, scales catching the neon like they’re moving under her skin. She smells like gun oil, cheap beer, old anger. Twin pistols ride her hips like second thoughts. The bartender stiffens because he's seen the type and knows better than to blink. “String bean?” Spike says, tapping ash into an overflowing tray. “Charming. You must be the welcoming committee.” “I’m the one who gets paid if you stand aside.” Spike raises his glass to the looping guitar riff in the corner, the jukebox crackling like a dying star. “I tried standing aside once. Didn’t take.” Her eyes, cold and curious, drag across him, cataloging. She sees the loose wrists, the weight distributed like someone who could pivot into a fight from sleep. She sees the half-smile that dares her to test it. The cigarette droops between his lips; he’s in no hurry to live or die. “Name’s Revy,” she says, because if you're going to measure someone, better to do it with names. “Two Hands.” “Spike Spiegel. Whatever happens, happens.” She laughs once, short and dangerous. “Yeah, no. Things happen because I make them happen.” “Must be exhausting.” “Then you better not waste my time, Cowboy.” On the cracked TV above the bar, the news churns static. Somewhere, their target is breathing the same ugly air, a mid-level runner who owes heavier men more money than any of them have. The bounty’s fresh, wires sent to too many ears. It's no surprise they found each other. In a city like this, jobs overlap like bad graffiti—names scrawled over names until the wall gives up. They drink. They don’t toast. Her whiskey disappears with the same grim efficiency she applies to targets. She slams the glass down, grin curling. “So. Split the money. You get to walk without bending over, I get a night without gutting a tourist. Clean and easy.” Spike inhales smoke like it’s oxygen. “You say ‘clean and easy,’ and I hear ‘pack of wolves on a tightrope.’” “I can handle wolves.” She cocks a hip. “Can you?” “I already died once.” He flicks ash. “Wolves are fine.” There’s a pause where something like a smile ghosts over her mouth. She keeps her hands visible, but he notes the twitch in her right shoulder, muscle memory begging to dance. He has seen people like her before. He left people like her behind. Or tried to. The jukebox hisses, the same riff, the same chorus he can’t make out. Someone else in the bar yells to turn it off, but the bartender ignores it. He knows better than to pull plugs on things that have learned to haunt themselves. It blows open fast because that's how these things go. The door swings again, and a man with eyes like a rat's scurries in, coat held too tight. Their bounty. He clocks them, freezes, bolts for the back. Revy doesn't ask permission. Her pistols are in her hands like they were always there. The bartender ducks with a curse. “Down!” she barks, and the room obeys. Spike sighs like he’s frustrated with gravity, ashes his cigarette, and moves. He doesn’t draw yet. He slides off the stool with the kind of grace that would be dance if it wasn’t violence, and follows. Gunfire cracks. Revy’s shots are hate letters written in bullets, neat and personal. She puts a round through a neon beer sign that explodes into raining glass, paints the rat-side of the room in electric blue. Spike flows with it, slipping behind an overturned table when a stray bullet bites wood where his head was. He draws too, finally, and when he fires it’s with economy; each shot a punctuation mark in a sentence only he reads. The bounty dives behind the jukebox, and the track stutters, then starts again, like it’s mocking them. The man pops up; Revy puts three in the casing, splinters the speaker, showers herself in sparks and old dust. Spike takes the angle she doesn’t—he sees the bounce, anticipates where the rat will wriggle when cornered. He shoots once into the floor by the man’s foot, wood chips biting skin. The man yelps, scrambles in exactly the predictable pattern. “Left,” Spike says, because he can’t help coaching. “Your other left.” Revy’s laugh is a flash grenade. She steps, pivots, puts a bullet through the man’s shoulder. He spins, drops his gun. The room holds its breath. Spike is already on the move, closing, kicking the fallen weapon away. He crouches, presses the muzzle to the rat’s temple. The man sobs, bargaining in a language made of numbers. “Shut up,” Revy says, reloading without looking, magazine slapping home like a heartbeat. “We’re arguing now.” “Arguing?” Spike says. “About who gets the collar.” Her smile shows teeth. “He’s worth more alive. I prefer dead, but I can bend.” Spike’s cigarette has burned down to a stub. He considers the rat, the bounty, the weight of the gun in his hand. He hears an old laugh in his head, someone impossible and pretty, water and blood and roses. His eye throbs. Whatever happens, happens. “Split,” he says softly. “He’s heavy. I hate carrying things I don’t intend to keep.” “Fair.” She lifts her chin. “But he walks with me. You follow.” “Bossy.” “Alive.” They lift him. He screams. She hits him. The bartender swears and tells them never to come back, meaning please don’t shoot me. The jukebox wheezes into the same chorus like a prayer no one asked for. Outside, night leans in crooked. The alley is slick with old rain and city sweat. They move with the rhythm of people who don’t trust each other but know they have to. He watches her as much as the shadows. She watches him with the barrel of her gun as much as with her eyes. They dump him in the trunk of a stolen car with a complaint in every slam. Revy slams it again for emphasis. “We lay low,” she says, “until calls go out. There’s a motel. You look like you’re allergic to sheets, but it’s fine.” “I like soft things,” Spike says. “I never get to keep them.” She snorts. “You say this stuff to all the girls who try to outdraw you?” “Only the ones who could.” The motel is a neon scar off the highway, buzzing sign promising color TV and hourly rates. The desk clerk doesn’t look up past his magazine. The same guitar riff bleeds out from the bar down the block like the city only owns one song. The room is two beds too close and a bathroom door that won’t close right. The air smells like bleach and old sin. Spike tosses the rat on one bed, cuffing him to the headboard with a practiced click. Revy double-checks the lock on the door, then the window, then the lock again. She’s still vibrating, the afterglow of gunfire cooling slow. He lights another cigarette. The smoke curls into the cheap lamp’s halo. “Don’t smoke in here,” she says automatically. “It’s a non-smoking room?” He exhales. “We already broke it.” She turns and looks at him in full—like really looks—and it hits them both at the same time. The room is too small, the air warped, the thread between them taut as a tripwire. Attraction is a dumb word for a smart problem. It would be fun to lie about it. Neither of them believes in fun for long. “Why do you do it?” she asks, surprising herself. “This hustle. The bounty games. You look like you’d be happier sleeping forever.” “I am asleep.” He smirks to soften it and fails. “It’s cheaper this way.” She cracks a beer with her teeth, spits the cap on the carpet. “I do it because it’s the only thing that listens to me. Work. Violence. Money. People?” She gestures at the bound man. “People don’t.” “People surprise you,” he says. “Usually when they leave.” “Spoken like a man with holes where there used to be things.” He lifts his cigarette. “I fill them with smoke.” Revy steps closer, hips rolling with something weaponized. She reaches out like she’s going to take the cigarette from his mouth, then takes it and drags, eyes never breaking from his. He watches her throat work when she inhales. He’s hungry. For food, sure. Been hungry since morning. For this, too, in a way that feels like falling off a building and pretending it’s flying. “You gonna try to cuff me?” she asks. “Or are we going to play nice until payday?” “Nice is a lot of work.” “Then don’t.” He doesn’t touch her. Not because he doesn’t want to. Because wanting is a trap he digs for himself. She reads it in the set of his shoulders, and something like annoyance flickers—at him, at herself. She sets the cigarette back between his lips, presses it there with a finger. His mouth is soft in a way his voice isn’t. She steps back. The gun is in her hand before the space fills, drawn like breath. He lifts his own without thinking, like a dance they were born knowing. They’re not leaders. They’re not followers. They’re orbiting each other with weapons in the empty. “Don’t,” she says, but she’s smiling a little, a dare wrapped in warning. “Whatever happens,” he says, “happens.” “Say that again and I’ll shoot you.” He considers and decides to live a little longer. The rat on the bed whimpers, and Revy aims without looking, fires a shot that pops the pillow beside his head. Feathers explode like snow, float slow through the cigarette smoke, neon catching on white. The man falls quiet in the way of people who learn fear has layers. “See?” she says to Spike, voice low, half-laughing. “I can be nice.” “You’re delightful.” They stand there, guns raised, tension humming through their arms like electric wire. The neon outside pulses. The scratchy rock track leaks through the wall, trapped in the jukebox like a ghost who never gets to move on. He measures her—breath, gaze, the tremble in her wrist that’s not fear but excitement. She measures him—tilt of gun, angle of hips, the way his eye doesn’t blink at the same times his smile shifts. “I don’t trust you,” she says, like confession. “Good,” he says. “Me neither.” “You thinking about kissing me or shooting me?” “Both,” he says. “Depends on the song.” “It’s always the same song,” she says, and for a second her voice dips, tired. “Even when it isn’t.” “Then we dance the same steps,” he says. “Until one of us trips.” She steps closer, just a notch, gun still up. He mirrors, two magnets arguing. The bed creaks when the rat shifts, and neither looks. Their eyes are locked, guns a set piece, bodies sending messages neither will admit to, not here, not now. The unresolved hum between them could power the neon outside for a year. “Call it,” she whispers. “Heads,” he says, because he doesn’t have a coin and because he wants to see if she notices. She laughs soft, close enough for him to taste beer on her breath. “Heads,” she says. “Later.” He lets out a breath he didn’t know he was holding. He lowers his gun first, not because he trusts her, but because it’s funny to him to flirt with death when he’s already done it. She eyes the drop, nods once, like he passed a small, mean test. She lowers hers a degree and no more. “Payday in the morning,” she says, moving sideways to lean against the dresser without giving him her back. “You take first watch.” “Thought you didn’t trust me.” “I don’t.” She kicks off her boots, feet up on the other bed. “That’s why you’re watching.” He drags a chair, plants it near the door, cigarette burning down to nothing, then lights another. The neon paints his face a feverish pink. Revy’s eyes close, not sleeping, not yet. His gun rests on his thigh. Hers is under her pillow, hand on the grip. The jukebox down the block starts the track over. It will never end. The motel hums. The rat whimpers in dreams he’ll regret being alive for. Spike stares at the door like it owes him an explanation. Revy breathes like a boxer between rounds. Whatever happens, happens. The room holds its breath and refuses to exhale. The standoff isn’t just guns. It’s gravity. It’s the attention they’re both too smart to indulge and too weak to ignore. Morning is a promise they don’t believe in. For now, they hold, balanced on the blade, the night an unspent bullet waiting in the chamber.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully captures the essence of both characters and their respective universes while creating a compelling crossover scenario. The author demonstrates a strong understanding of both Spike Spiegel and Revy, maintaining their canonical personalities, speech patterns, and physical characteristics throughout. The prose is atmospheric and evocative, establishing a noir-like setting that bridges the worlds of Cowboy Bebop and Black Lagoon effectively. The descriptions are sensory-rich without becoming excessive, creating a vivid mental picture of the seedy bar and motel settings. The author employs metaphor and simile skillfully, with lines like "Neon bleeds over a bar so greasy the wood reflects the electric pink like spilled blood" establishing the tone immediately. The character dynamics are particularly well-executed. The unresolved sexual tension builds naturally through their interactions, with neither character fully surrendering to it—which feels authentic to both Spike and Revy's trust issues and self-protective instincts. Their dialogue crackles with tension and reveals character without becoming expository. The author captures Spike's fatalistic philosophy and Revy's aggressive defensiveness perfectly. The action sequence is well-choreographed and maintains the distinctive fighting styles of both characters. Spike's fluid movements contrast with Revy's more direct, aggressive approach, and the scene incorporates their canonical abilities without feeling forced. The recurring motif of the broken jukebox playing the same track works effectively as both atmosphere and metaphor for the characters' cyclical patterns. The ending maintains the tension without artificial resolution, staying true to the prompt's request for unresolved sexual tension culminating in a standoff. There are few weaknesses in this piece. The prose occasionally verges on purple but generally stays on the right side of evocative without becoming overwrought. The dialogue is sharp and character-appropriate throughout. The pacing is excellent, with the right balance of action, tension, and character development. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted crossover that honors both source materials while creating something that stands on its own merits. The author demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of both character psychology and narrative craft. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Folk horror: Útiseta — Score: 92.0
Prompt:
Folk Horror: Útiseta Write a chapter set in rural northern Sweden in the mid-1990s. Linnea, a teenage girl from Stockholm, has reluctantly moved to a small village with her parents after her father's job transfer. She's befriended Astrid, a local girl who claims her grandmother taught her ancient practices passed down through generations. Astrid has been introducing Linnea to "midnight games" that involve old rituals, convincing her they can use them to learn classmates' secrets or influence their behavior. Tonight, Astrid has convinced Linnea to participate in Útiseta—sitting out on an ancient burial mound at midnight to "receive knowledge from beyond." The chapter focuses on this single midnight excursion, the ritualistic preparations, Astrid's matter-of-fact instructions that mix teenage rebellion with eerily specific traditional elements, and the mounting tension as Linnea becomes increasingly uncertain whether they're simply scaring themselves or if something is actually responding to their presence. The narrative should maintain ambiguity about whether the strange occurrences are supernatural or psychological, while establishing the dangerous line they're crossing by treating ancient practices as entertainment. First person, past tense, told as Linnea's recollection of events in the present day (though this device should be largely transparent). 1000 words. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Astrid said you could tell how serious a practice was by how many layers you put on before you did it. That night I wore two sweaters under my father's old parka and a hat that made my ears ache before it warmed them, and Astrid had wrapped a scarf twice around her neck so the ends trailed like white flags. We left our boots by the door to keep the sleet off the hall runner, then pulled them back on and stepped into the shin-deep snow anyway. The evening had that muffled sound that happens when the clouds hang low enough to press on your skull. In Stockholm, I would have been in my room, half-watching TV and half-pretending to study. Here, I followed a girl who claimed her grandmother taught her to talk to the dead like it was a skill you could learn between algebra and civics. "You have to keep quiet when we pass the birches," she said without looking back. "They don't like being counted." "Birches?" "The ones that bow. If you count them you forget things you need to remember." She paused under the first of them, its thin branches gloved in ice. "Grandma says some trees listen and some tell. Birches are tattlers. So keep your thoughts tight." It was such a strange mix of childish and precise that I nodded and zipped my parka up to my chin. My breath made a cloud that followed me. The little village had gone to sleep hours ago. Only two windows showed a square of yellow, both on the same house; later I would learn they belonged to a shift worker's wife who couldn't sleep without the kitchen light on. We threaded the snowed-over path to the hill the villagers called the mound. The first time I heard someone say it—"we'll meet by the mound after school"—I pictured a man-made pile of snow; it was a sloped hummock with stones like teeth at its crown, older than the church and older than the road. They said old bones lay under it, and that it hummed when the ground thawed. "Útiseta," Astrid said, rolling the word in her mouth like a bite of candy. "You sit out. Sit out in the place where the dead are used to people crying. They know how to listen there." "I thought you said we were just—" I didn't finish. It was always like this: a game that wasn't a game, a dare that came with rules. "It's a thing you do to ask," she said. "It's not like those stupid laser pointer magic shows they do on TV. It's older. It works if you do it right." She reached back to take my sleeve and pulled me forward. "Come on. We have to prepare." Her preparing always made me feel like I was performing in a play I hadn't gotten the script for. She'd told me earlier that it wasn't a joke, that you don't spit on the wind or whistle in the graveyard because "things notice," and that tonight we had to do Útiseta before the term started properly because after that the village would be too loud with people thinking ear-to-ear about tests and gossip. You did this when "the mind of the place" was quiet, she said. "What are we asking?" I said. Ice squeaked under our boots as we climbed the last rise. "What we always ask," she said. "About people. About what they think about us. Who's going to do what. Who's going to be trouble. You said you wanted to know if Emil likes you." "I did not." "You said maybe," she said, and grinned in the white breath. "We can ask for other things, too. Sometimes they tell. Grandma said don't ask for things like money or cars. Ask about people. Ask about yourself. That's the only thing they'll answer without making you pay with something you actually want." "You're doing that thing again," I said, but I didn't say which thing—the thing where she treated warnings like flexes of a muscle, like it impressed her to be the one who knew where the dangerous edges were. We didn't bring candles. You weren't supposed to bring light, she said. You were supposed to borrow it. She had two old jars with lids that she said came from her grandmother's pantry, and she had a little leather pouch with salt in it and something that smelled like tar. On the top of the mound the stones were layered with frost and slick as seal skin. She walked around them clockwise, muttering as she flicked salt at her boots. "You do it so you know where your feet have been," she whispered. "You close the circle with your steps." She gestured for me to follow, and I did, making a dent in the first set of my tracks. We made three circles, and the third time she stopped at a stone with a fissure that looked like a mouth and pressed her palm to it like a kid to a window. "You knock if you take something," she said. "Even if you just take time." She knelt and opened the pouch. The tar smell was stronger: smoked resin, maybe, or something from the boats that came west in summer. She rubbed a little between her fingers, then smeared a streak under each eye like black war paint. She did the same to me without asking. The cold took it hard, and the streaks felt like tightening glass on my skin. "For seeing," she said. "You scare off meat-things, the ones that like to crawl." "Please don't use the phrase meat-things ever again," I said. She laughed. "Stop talking," she said. "People don't say anything the first time. They think if you show you're polite you get the right visitors." We sat with our backs to the same stone, our shoulders not touching. I'd expected there to be a ritual, a chant, something to occupy my attention, but Astrid only drew shallow breaths and let them slow. After a while the night pressed under my skin like snow when you fall down and stay there. The shape of my body blurred into the dark. The hill under us had a pulse you could call your own heartbeat if you wanted to. Somewhere in the village a dog barked once and changed its mind. I counted my breaths and then lost count, and then remembered Astrid saying not to count the birches. I wondered if that mattered now. The air shifted from glass to fur; I mean to say it softened, like the sky was lowering itself around us. When the wind came it wasn't the wind, exactly, but the quiet vacuum of something moving past a hollow. My teeth ached, and I had a flash of wanting to be in our apartment in Stockholm, the two flights up and the radiator that clanked all night, and the half-finished long division workbook I'd once cried over for no reason. Here, I had a girl with resin on her fingers and gravel under her. Part of me felt adult and ridiculous at the same time. If you'd asked me then if I believed, I would have said no. I would have said yes. Those answers felt the same sitting there. "Don't look at your watch," Astrid said, so softly I didn't know if I'd imagined it. "Let the bells tell us." "There won't be bells," I started, but then a sound rolled through the air like it came up from the ground: a single chime, metal and old, a note that fell clean into the silence and made a ring inside my gut. It wasn't the hour. It was one sound, and it hung there long enough for me to feel it on my back the way you feel thunder. Our church didn't have midnight services. I'd heard that said. I'd said it myself when Astrid told me we should go at twelve. But there it was. One chime. Astrid didn't react. That steadiness was part of how she did this to me. If she'd flinched, I might have laughed. "The first thing that comes isn't the thing you want," she whispered. "Grandma says it's the thing that pretends to be what you want. Let it tell you a lie. Don't take it. Wait for the second." "How do I know which is which?" "You don't," she said. "You already forgot the birches. You're not supposed to know." I wanted to turn and look at her, to make sure she was beside me, but the idea of turning seemed impossible, like moving would be a kind of rudeness. The snow made the smallest noise: that sound of crystals sliding against each other. My skin tightened. Far off, a fox barked its broken-cough voice. Or a child, I thought, and that was stupid, but once the thought came I couldn't push it away. It wasn't that I heard words. It was more like the shape of words pushing through the sensations I had, like floating text you try to read through fogged glass. Names wanted me: Emil, yes, and Malin, who had threadbare mittens and chewed them; the math teacher; the boy with the scar. Images came that were too neat, like things that would satisfy me: a note passed in class folded like a bird; a key to a locker; a face turned to me in the corridor with the expression I'd always thought I deserved. It was like being handed easy money in plain envelopes. It made me resentful. Who was making it so easy? The mound? Astrid? Myself? I wanted to push it away. Part of me wanted to take the envelopes anyway. The wind shifted again and something colder knifed past my ear. A whisper, I told myself, an angle of air. But the thought that arrived with it was not flattering and not easy. It had the shape of the seam between two stones under soil. It was about Astrid. It was about the way she told me the rules and watched me to see if I would follow them. About the way she had smiled earlier when I said I could keep a secret, a smile like a match that had already been lit. About her grandmother, and how often she said that word, like invoking a fact. The thought came with a taste of metal: her grandmother's house had old nails in the door lintel. Did I know this? Had I seen them? The thought told me they were there. Another thought: someone had been buried without a cross here, and someone had placed a broken tooth under the stone with the fissure. Was this how people think when they are scared? Or was it too specific not to be something else? I could not decide. I wanted to decide. I couldn't. "Astrid," I said, and my voice came out wrong. It sounded like I'd spoken into the mouth of a jar. "Shh," she said. "You're making room." The resin under my eyes had sent a prickly warmth down my cheeks. I realized my hands had gone numb. The bone-deep cold that is a fact in this part of the world slipped in past cloth and skin, and a different feeling came with it: a sense of being watched not by someone but by a rule. A rule the hill kept. You sit, the hill said, or the part of my brain that translates fear into sentences said. You sit and you listen. You don't bring your own light. You don't ask twice. If they tell you something you don't want, you hold it like a hot stone until it cools. Something moved in the periphery of my eyes—a shift of the darkness that matched a pale strip between two trees. If I'd been somewhere else I would have called it a rabbit. Here I didn't want to name it. It made a path through the snow without lowering it. That should have been impossible. It made a shape the snow took back an instant later. "You see it?" Astrid said, not a reaction so much as a prompt. "Do you?" "I don't ask for seeing," she said. "I already see. I want names. I want what people owe. Stop talking unless you can't not." There was a bitter taste in my mouth that wasn't the resin. I swallowed. The cold on my eyelashes had crystallized; if I blinked, it might crack and fall onto my cheeks. I thought about my mother, asleep with her book on her chest, and my father, who had taken this job because it made more money and because he wanted to go somewhere quiet where no one would bother him. The kind of man who doesn't believe in superstition because he has never had to. I thought about him and a scuff on his shoe that looked like a crescent moon, and the thought that rose under it said he had a second phone I didn't know about. Why would I think that? It was ridiculous. It was like saying there were nails in the lintel because I needed there to be. The shape of the information didn't care whether I wanted it. I told myself if I looked down and saw a second set of bootprints between me and Astrid, I would scream. I looked down. I saw our local boot brand: thin ribbed treads. I saw scuffed clots of snow where we'd made our circles. I saw the dent of one small animal closer to the birches where it had hopped and paused to leave a little pellet. I did not see a third set. I felt more watched. "The second thing," Astrid said, and her voice had dropped, "is the true thing. This is when you promise something." "I didn't bring anything to promise," I said. "You did," she said. "You bring yourself. You say I will let you use my mouth for a day. Or you say I'll keep a thing you give me for a year. Or you say I'll put a stone back in a place someone took it from. Grandma says you never promise meat. She says you never promise shoes." "What happens if you do?" "You don't get them back," she said. "Or you don't like how they fit when you do." When she said it I realized that the undertone under her voice—steady, practical—was excitement. This was fun for her. Not fun like laughing but fun like control. She had been the one to tell me there were rules, and here she was asking me to make a rule with something that didn't ask me to sign my name. The anger that rose then surprised me. It flickered up like the match her smile had been. "I'm not promising anything," I said. "I'm not—" "Then say your own name in your head and close your eyes," she said. "Finish it. You can't get up until you finish it." "I can get up whenever I want," I said, and my voice broke on the last word. My legs were pins and wire. I put my hands on the rock to squat and stand, and the stone under my palms felt warm, impossibly, like it had held the sun from a season ago and was giving it back. The warmth was so human that I jerked my hands away, then put them back because the warmth was the only thing that didn't feel like the night. "Linnea," Astrid said, and it was almost gentle. "People don't think they'll ever do something until the moment they do it. That's how they end up doing it forever." "Is that your grandma again?" I said, bitter. "That's me," she said, and I couldn't tell if the shimmer in her eyes was tears or frost or delight. Maybe all three. "Say your name." In the end, I said it, but not like a promise, more like a test. I closed my eyes and said my name without sound and without any words after it, and then I waited for the second thing. What came wasn't a revelation so much as a boundary. It was like pressing your palm against glass and learning how thick it is. I knew, suddenly, that if I asked the wrong question here I would get an answer that would be true and unhelpful. I knew that if I promised something I didn't understand, the asking would not stop when we stood up. I knew that Astrid would keep doing this whether I did it with her or not, and that she would tell the story later her way if I didn't have my own way to tell it. The knowledge sat on me like a blanket that smelled of smoke. When it was done, it was done. There was no flare. The wind shifted back to ordinary. In the village, a car misfired and seemed as loud as a firework. Astrid drew a hard breath that turned into a laugh and then didn't. "I didn't promise anything either," she said, like a confession that wanted admiration. "Good," I said, and we stood, and my knees sang as the blood went back in. We rubbed the resin from our faces with snow and it left greasy tracks on our gloves. Astrid reached down and touched the fissure stone once, a little knock like a child leaving a friend’s house, as if that made what we'd done polite. We walked back without speaking, past the birches that bowed, and I didn't count them. The sky had the faintest hint of light in it that comes before dawn in winter, the kind that feels like a stain rather than rays. Somewhere behind us in the white, I thought I heard footsteps that were not our own, then told myself it was the sound of your own breath when you start listening for footsteps. Later, in my bed, I decided that the bell had been a trick of sound, that someone had let a sheep out and rung for help, that I'd made up the nails and the tooth and the second phone because I'd been told to wait for the second thing. The memory of the hill stayed anyway, heavy as if I'd carried a stone down in my pocket and forgotten to take it out. When I saw Astrid the next day she had the same look she always had, which was the look of a person who expects you to play along. "Did you get what you wanted?" she said in the corridor, as if all we'd done was leave notes under doors. "I got something," I said. "Good," she said. She went past me and put her hand on Emil's shoulder and leaned to say something in his ear, and he flushed with whatever it was she chose to tell him, whether it was true or not. Later, when we went to her grandmother's house, there were indeed three old nails hammered into the lintel like a row of teeth. I don't remember if I'd noticed them before. I don't remember if I had put my hand on my father's second phone and turned it over without turning it on. I do remember the sound the cold made on the mound, like a mouth to a jar, and Astrid's breath on the dark. I remember the single bell. I remember the felt sense that we'd moved something around that didn't like to be moved, had edged past a dangerous idea and turned it into a toy, and that even if nothing answered us, we had answered something by sitting there. That was the line. If you ask, something hears you. Or you hear yourself in a way you cannot take back. Either way, it's a kind of being heard. Either way, it keeps listening.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This folk horror piece effectively captures the essence of the genre through its setting, characters, and atmosphere. The narrative follows Linnea's experience participating in the Útiseta ritual with her friend Astrid in rural northern Sweden, creating a compelling blend of teenage dynamics and ancient folklore. The writing excels in establishing a sense of place. The descriptions of the cold Swedish winter night are vivid and sensory, from the "muffled sound that happens when the clouds hang low enough to press on your skull" to the "ice squeaked under our boots." These details ground the reader in the physical environment while simultaneously building an atmosphere of isolation and otherworldliness. Character development is particularly strong. Linnea's perspective as an outsider from Stockholm provides a perfect lens through which to view these rural practices. Her skepticism mixed with curiosity feels authentic for a teenage transplant. Astrid is brilliantly rendered as a complex character who wields her knowledge of local traditions with a mix of genuine belief and manipulative power. The line "the thing where she treated warnings like flexes of a muscle, like it impressed her to be the one who knew where the dangerous edges were" perfectly captures this dynamic. The prose maintains a consistent voice throughout—reflective but immediate, with Linnea's teenage perspective coloring the narration. The author skillfully balances colloquial teenage speech patterns with more lyrical passages that enhance the eerie atmosphere. The ritual itself is described with just the right amount of specific detail to feel authentic without overexplaining. The ambiguity about whether anything supernatural actually occurs is masterfully maintained. The narrative leaves room for both psychological and supernatural interpretations, with Linnea herself unable to determine what is real. The piece excels at creating tension through small, unsettling details: the single bell chime that shouldn't exist, the shape moving through snow without disturbing it, the warm stone in freezing temperatures. These elements build a creeping sense of dread without resorting to obvious horror tropes. The ending effectively reinforces the theme of dangerous lines being crossed. Linnea's realization that "we'd moved something around that didn't like to be moved, had edged past a dangerous idea and turned it into a toy" perfectly captures the central concern of folk horror—the consequences of treating ancient practices as entertainment. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Some readers might find the pacing in the middle section slightly slow, though this deliberate pace contributes to the building tension. A few metaphors occasionally strain ("the air shifted from glass to fur"), but these are rare exceptions in otherwise elegant prose. Overall, this is an exceptional piece of folk horror that succeeds in creating an atmosphere of unease while exploring the relationship between two teenage girls and their different relationships to tradition and belief. The writing maintains ambiguity about supernatural elements while clearly conveying the psychological and social dynamics at play. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Physical-spatial: Therapeutic Boundaries — Score: 94.3
Prompt:
**"Therapeutic Boundaries"** Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a former professional athlete undergoing mandatory physical therapy after a career-destroying injury, harboring resentment toward recovery itself. Their physiotherapist is not only unnervingly attractive but also a former training partner from their competitive days who has successfully transitioned to a new career while the protagonist's identity remains shattered. We'll lean into the sexual tension of the scene by having her be attracted to him, but both of them attempting to maintain mental distance while being in physical contact as he shows her stretches & movements & manipulates her body, navigating the thresholds of pain. This scene MUST maintain complete physical coherence—every movement, stretch, and manipulation must be anatomically precise and spatially consistent. Paint an exceptionally vivid sensory picture through detailed attention to pain thresholds, involuntary responses to touch. Capture the suppressed, flaring tension of physical proximity, touch, and the controlled infliction of uncomfortable movements. Physical clarity is essential — readers must understand exactly what is happening with the body during each therapeutic technique. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The room smells like eucalyptus and old sweat threads caught in the seams of vinyl. The treatment table creaks when I hoist myself up with my good arm. A wall-mounted diagram of human musculature looms over my shoulder, a bloodless atlas—front and back views, bands of red and white, names I used to recite like prayers. Vastus medialis. Gluteus medius. Iliotibial band. Labels for the things that failed me. He shuts the door with a soft click. It’s not the locker-room slam I remember; nothing about him is loud. His hair’s shorter. Beard now, trimmed tight. The polo stretches across his shoulders when he reaches for a clipboard. His forearm flexors ridge and relax as he writes, ink scratching. I know those tendons, the way they used to rope under skin when we drove the last interval of a 400, matching stride for stride in that converging rhythm that felt like the world was a belt and we were riding it. “Scale of one to ten,” he says, eyes flickering to my face, then down to the page. “At rest.” “Two,” I lie. His mouth tugs but he doesn’t call me on it. He never did, in the early days, when we were comrades in denial. He steps closer, the faintest drift of cedar aftershave; his hands are warm when he touches my shoulder, then slides along the line of my collarbone as if mapping where to avoid. “We’ll go slow. No heroics.” No heroics. The words belong to a different person than the one who gutted through lactic burn on a winter track, spitting steam, the two of us laughing as our thighs trembled, daring each other to one more rep. He’s a different person too, with the letters after his name stitched into his chest: DPT. I watch the embroidered thread ripple when he breathes. “Lie back,” he says. I shift from pelvis to shoulder blades, easing down. The table is a narrow raft; if I flinch, I could slide off. He positions my legs with a gentleness that irritates me. My left knee, the traitor, is elevated on a wedge. He has me straighten both legs out, aligning hip joints evenly. The ceiling hums with fluorescent light. “We’ll start with your ankle,” he says. “Distal to proximal.” He stands at the foot of the table and cradles my left heel in one hand, his other hand supporting over the dorsum of my foot, fingers splayed across metatarsals two through five. “Just relax,” he adds, knowing I can’t. He guides my ankle into dorsiflexion, bringing my toes toward my shin. His thumb presses gently against the calcaneus to prevent inversion. The stretch shows up like a thin blade along my Achilles, climbing into my calf—the gastroc bellies first, then deeper into the soleus. He stops at the point where the blade bites. “Where are you?” “Four,” I say, voice stiff. “Breathe into it.” He holds there, seconds ticking in the count he doesn’t voice anymore. My tibia feels anchored; his grip is precise. On the poster, the achingly red cords of the triceps surae stare back. He eases off, then repeats, increment by increment, coaxing range. When he adds overpressure—just a couple millimeters past where I think it should stop—my foot trembles. I hate that it trembles. The tremor quivers up the anterior tibialis like a noise in wire. “Okay,” he says. He lowers my foot and runs the side of his index finger up the medial arch. “Any tingling?” “No.” The sensation is straight pressure, no fireworks in the saphenous nerve territory. He nods. He switches to passive hamstring stretch. He steps to my left side, his hip close to the table. He cups my heel again and slides his other hand under my distal thigh. My skin prickles where his palm presses; it’s not pain. He lifts my leg, knee extended, hip into flexion. The hamstrings unspool in protest. At fifty degrees, I can feel the meat of biceps femoris tighten like it’s going to pluck itself. At sixty, there’s a hot line at the ischial tuberosity. My pelvis wants to posteriorly tilt, lumbar spine flattening into the table. He places his forearm across my ASIS to hold the pelvis stable, his elbow hooked lightly over my iliac crest. “Neutral spine,” he says. His forearm is solid heat across my hip bones. “Don’t let your pelvis rotate.” My breath climbs into my throat. “I’m not.” He smiles without showing teeth. He knows I am. He presses down, just enough to pin the pelvis, and carries my heel toward the ceiling another few degrees. The stretch shifts, deeper, closer to where the tendon bundles splay into the ischial attachment. Pain flares, crisp. Seven. I clench around it and he feels the contraction in my thigh; his fingers depress into the hamstrings and wait. “In through your nose,” he says. He’s watching my face. I make my breath slow, stupidly obedient. The pain backs down to a five, then a four, a throb instead of a knife. He comes back a degree more, and the breath stutters again. My toes are cold. My fingers have curled into the edge of the table so hard the vinyl seam bites. “I hate this,” I say, so quietly I could be talking to the diagram. “I know.” He lowers my leg with a care that makes something in my chest ache. He sets my heel down, aligns the malleoli. The room is too bright; the table’s paper crinkles under my shoulder blades. He picks up my foot again and draws it into a straight-leg raise, then deviates it a few degrees into internal rotation, targeting the medial hamstring. He tracks my patella to keep it from drifting. Each tiny adjustment changes the line of fire. He talks through the tissue: semimembranosus, semitendinosus. He says the words clinically, but they land in me like memories of drills, of out-and-back runs where our feet flicked up behind us, hamstrings snapping like cables. “Let’s try some nerve glides.” He flexes my hip to forty-five with the knee extended and then dorsiflexes my ankle while extending my knee another notch. The discomfort is a different flavor—more of a spreading burn along the back of my leg, a sensation that feels like water seeking a lower level. It peels down past the fibular head, into the calf, to the outer border of my foot. He reverses the ankle as he increases the knee extension to tease neural tension without cooking the nerve. He watches my eyes. “Talk to me.” “Six,” I say, meaning: manageable, as long as you don’t go zealous on me. He doesn’t. He cycles through a rhythm, slide and tension, slide and tension. My hamstrings twitch, tiny fasciculations like moths in a lampshade. He backs off when they intensify. He’s reading my legs like he read my stride all those years—knowing when I had one more rep, when I didn’t. He moves to my knee. The scar down the lateral side is a pale zipper. He places his thumb pads either side of the joint line and does a gentle varus stress at thirty degrees flexion, assessing lateral collateral integrity. The joint opens barely perceptible, firm end feel. He nods. He changes to valgus stress, medial gap. The MCL end feel is more yielding. He watches my mouth as he tests; I bite hard enough to feel a ridge of tooth in my tongue. He palpates the patellar tendon, the infrapatellar fat pad, the IT band distal tract where it inserts on Gerdy’s tubercle. When he strokes along the band, the tissue feels like a cable under my skin. He picks up a strip of kinesiology tape and measures from the Gerdy’s tubercle up to the greater trochanter with his fingers. He tears the backing half an inch, anchors it distal, then lays it up the lateral thigh with just enough tension to lift the skin microscopically. His fingers smooth the tape, heat activating adhesive. They travel, inadvertently, close to where my shorts end. The skin there is more sensitive from disuse, the hair growing back uneven. My breath stutters. He pauses, fingers hovering without touching. “Okay?” he asks. “Yeah.” It comes out like air leaking. He rolls a stool behind him with a heel push and sits, bringing his eyes level with my hip. He swings the therapy table extension out, bends my knee to ninety, and drapes my lower leg over his thigh to support the tibia. He places one hand on my ASIS again and the other on my distal femur. “Hip internal rotation,” he says. He eases my shin outward, rotating the femur inward. The deep lateral rotators mutter. I feel it deep in the posterior hip, around the greater trochanter, where the gluteus medius fibers fan. He targets glute med specifically next: he has me roll slightly onto my right side, my left leg stacked on top, knees bent. He slides his hand under my waist to keep my spine neutral, not letting me cheat by laterally flexing. His palm is a warm wedge, a fulcrum against my obliques. When he tells me to lift the top knee without rolling my pelvis open—clamshell—the burn is immediate at the outer hip, the gluteus medius and minimus firing. My TFL tries to jump in, the anterior fibers tensing, and he taps the posterior lateral crest lightly. “Back here. Don’t let the TFL dominate.” I adjust the angle, rotating my femur slightly to aim the contraction posteriorly. The burn sharpens, a coin of heat pressed under skin. He holds two fingers against the muscle and feels it engage. “Two seconds up,” he says, metronome calm. “Four seconds down.” My leg shakes by rep six. By rep ten, the muscle is a live wire. Sweat beads under my arms and sticks my shirt to my ribs. He counts to twelve and stops, not because I want to—because form fails. He always knew the difference. He takes my ankle and extends my hip behind me, knee still bent ninety degrees, and then draws my heel slightly toward the ceiling, small range. The gluteus maximus joins the chorus now, deep and powerful, but under that it stings where the proximal tendon attaches. He slides his fingers deep into the meat of my glute, finding the piriformis, and presses. It’s pressure so direct it feels indecent. I hiss and feel my pelvic floor reflexively tighten, a small panic clench. His eyes flick to mine and then away; his fingers don’t shift. “Breathe,” he says, voice a tone lower, steady. He works the trigger point, short compressions, then sustained. The pain blooms and then fades in waves. When it releases, it’s like a knot unties and the leg suddenly weighs less. He withdraws his hand slowly, careful not to drag, giving the tissue time to settle. My skin chills where his warmth has been. “Bridge,” he says, moving on. He helps me roll onto my back again, places my feet hip-width apart, knees up, neutral pelvis. He taps my ASIS and PSIS to cue the tilt. “No global tilt. Zip your ribs down.” He slides a hand under my lumbar spine to check space: not smashed, not arching. “Drive through your heels. Don’t push the knees outward; track over second toes.” He says these things because he doesn’t trust my old instincts, which are to throw everything at every problem. I lift my pelvis, vertebra by vertebra. The gluteal tissue cords up. The hamstrings try to dominate again; he snakes a belt around my thighs just above the knees, gives me the cue to press gently into it. The adductors turn on, and the glutes find their job. The strain is clean. He presses down with two fingers on my ASIS to keep the pelvis level. His hands are warm weights. The table paper crackles under me. Sweat runs along my scalp and pools in my ear. “Hold,” he says, breath close enough that I can feel it move the tiny hairs at my temple. I’m aware of the length of his hip next to my hand, the heat of him in the space under the fluorescent hum. The memory of his body moving beside mine years ago is a spool winding tighter while he watches my pelvis for a hint of rotation. I hold for eight seconds, then lower slowly. He adjusts the belt and asks for two more. I give him three. It’s not generosity; it’s defiance. When I finish, the glutes are heavy and alive, the knee feels both more present and less like glass. He wheels a cart closer and pulls out a jade-green band. He loops it around the balls of my feet, hands me the ends. “Ankle dorsiflexion isometrics,” he says. “Keep talar alignment.” He cups the front of my ankle joint line and presses the talus posteriorly as I draw the band toward me, avoiding anterior translation that would impinge. The tendon on the front of my ankle strings under my skin, extensor hallucis longus showing as a separate line. He nods. “Good.” He asks me to hold, then slowly control the eccentric letting go. The burn is small, neat. I can do neat. He stands, steps back, crosses his arms. The shift in distance makes the air cooler. My skin prickles. He scribbles something on the clipboard, then sets it aside. He looks up, finally meeting my eyes for more than a beat. “You’re doing well,” he says. “Define well,” I say, the bitterness reflexive, because praise slides off me now like oil. “Not avoiding. Not compensating. Listening.” He gestures to the diagram, the red-streaked body watching us. “This is a different kind of performance.” It’s a different kind of humiliation. My body, once a finely tuned machine, now reduced to joints needing to be coaxed like sullen children. I swallow, throat tight. The resentment tastes metallic. It’s not just at the tissue—I resent him too, resent the ease with which he has become something else, his stride smooth across the clinic floor. He catches my look and doesn’t flinch away from it. There were years when we knew everything about each other’s limits; now the only thing we don’t say is the only thing loud in the room. He sets up for soft tissue work along the IT band. “Side-lying again,” he says. He positions a white towel under my lateral thigh to protect my skin. He squirts lotion into his palm, rubs hands together, and then makes a fist with one hand, using the knuckles to strip slowly from the distal lateral quad up toward the greater trochanter, staying just anterior to the IT band itself—he knows not to grind into the band proper, to work the neighboring tissues. His other hand stabilizes my thigh. The pressure is slow, deliberate; I feel the drag under his knuckles, the heat building. At a certain point, near the mid-thigh, the TFL fires reflexively, and my knee jerks. He pauses the pressure, holds, waits for the muscle to melt. My breath gets shallow. He slides closer by a centimeter to keep his elbow over his wrist, over his knuckles; physically coherent, always. The smell of lotion mixes with that cedar, and my body confuses pain and something else in the same breath. He doesn’t change the pressure or comment. He strips again, resets. Over and over, careful. When he finishes, he cleans his hands and the lotion sheen from my skin. He tapes me again, two strips now, one Y-shaped curling around the patella to help guide tracking. He presses it down with his palm, heat activating. He keeps his palm there a beat longer than necessary. Or maybe it’s exactly necessary and I am making everything into intention. He helps me sit up. I can feel the muscles we lit up settling, the delayed onset not yet dawning, the pleasant heaviness that will turn to ache by evening. He steps back to a respectable distance. The loss of proximity is a relief and a deprivation. “You okay to walk?” he asks. His voice is professional again, a clinic voice that belonged to someone else in a different life and now belongs to him. “I can walk,” I say. Walking is what’s left when everything else is gone. He smiles, small, private. “You can walk better now.” The chart on the wall watches as I ease off the table. My knee tracks over my mid-foot without the medial wobble that has been my new signature. The tape holds my skin in pink waves. He’s beside me without hovering, hands ready but not reaching. I take a step. Then another. The first corner of the room arrives faster than I expect. The pain is there, old friend/new enemy, but it’s quieter. I could resent that too—the way he can make me less miserable with his hands, with a thought. At the door, I say, without looking at him, “I hate that I need this.” He’s quiet a long time. Then: “You don’t have to like it to do it right.” A pause. “You don’t have to like me either.” I almost laugh. It feels like swallowing glass. “I never did,” I say. His reflection in the glass of the door gives me away: his mouth quirks, an almost. “Liar.” When he reaches past me to open the door, his arm grazes my shoulder. A small contact, nothing. My skin remembers every finish line we leaned into, shoulder to shoulder, as if touch could break tape. For a second I think of the way his forearm felt across my pelvis, the careful pressure, the exactness of him, and I want to spin and say something foolish and irreversible. Instead, I nod at him like he is anyone, and step into the hall, the tape pulling gently at my skin as I move. Somewhere in the red-and-white topography behind me, the gluteus medius lights up like a warning flare and then settles. We have three more weeks of this. I will count them in breaths held, seconds of pressure, degrees of flexion logged, and the inches between his hands and my skin. I will count them in ways he’ll never see. Or maybe he will. He always did. He shuts the door gently behind me. The hinge doesn’t complain. My knee does, lightly, acknowledging a negotiation rather than a war.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative excels at creating a physically coherent and emotionally charged physical therapy session. The writer demonstrates exceptional knowledge of anatomy, physical therapy techniques, and the psychological dimensions of injury recovery. The narrative's greatest strength is its anatomical precision. Every movement is described with clinical accuracy—from ankle dorsiflexion to hip internal rotation, from hamstring stretches to gluteal activation. The writer uses proper medical terminology (vastus medialis, ASIS, PSIS, etc.) while making these technical details accessible through sensory description. The physical manipulations are spatially consistent and follow a logical progression from distal to proximal, as mentioned in the text. The emotional landscape is equally well-rendered. The protagonist's resentment toward recovery is palpable, manifesting in small rebellions ("I give him three. It's not generosity; it's defiance") and bitter remarks. The narrative effectively captures the protagonist's complex feelings: the humiliation of needing help, the resentment toward the therapist who successfully transitioned careers, and the unwanted attraction that complicates their professional relationship. The sexual tension is handled with subtlety and restraint. Rather than explicit statements, the tension emerges through physical awareness ("My skin prickles where his palm presses; it's not pain"), physiological responses ("my body confuses pain and something else in the same breath"), and the protagonist's hyperawareness of proximity ("The loss of proximity is a relief and a deprivation"). This approach creates a more authentic and compelling tension than would more overt description. The prose is elegant and precise, with effective sensory details that ground the reader in the physical experience: "The pain blooms and then fades in waves," "Sweat runs along my scalp and pools in my ear." The writer employs effective metaphors that connect to the athletic background: "My hamstrings twitch, tiny fasciculations like moths in a lampshade." The narrative maintains a consistent voice—clinical yet emotionally charged, reflecting the protagonist's attempt to distance themselves from vulnerability while being intensely physically aware. The ending avoids an unrealistic transformation while acknowledging a small shift: "My knee does, lightly, acknowledging a negotiation rather than a war." There are no significant weaknesses in this piece. It avoids purple prose despite the detailed descriptions, maintains focus without meandering, and shows rather than tells the protagonist's emotional state. The dialogue is sparse but effective, revealing character and relationship dynamics. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted narrative that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt while creating a compelling, emotionally resonant scene with remarkable physical coherence and psychological depth. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Historical fiction: High Seas and Low Vices — Score: 88.8
Prompt:
High Seas and Low Vices: British Naval Officer in the Opium Trade Character: Lieutenant James Merrick, a high-ranking officer in the British Royal Navy stationed in Canton, China in the 1830s. Once promising and decorated, now struggling with a severe opium addiction he hides from his superiors. Synopsis: Write a chapter following Lieutenant Merrick during a single day as he shirks his official naval duties in what has become a daily need to satiate the dragon. Told primarily in dialogue with the characters he interacts with. Focus on brief slices of his journey through the shadowy underworld of Canton: interactions with acquaintances, negotiations with local dealers, schemes and unsavoury jobs taken to fund his habit. Writing Task: Use rich sensory details to describe a day in the life of James Merrick. Write for a real sense of time & place while avoiding cliche. First person, past tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
“Morning, Lieutenant. You’re late for inspection.” “I’m early for everything else, Sykes,” I said, fastening my collar with shaking fingers. “What’s the count?” “Boatswain says the stores are short two barrels of flour. And the captain wants a word about the Chinese envoy. You look a bit… you know.” “I slept poorly. The heat.” “It’s winter.” “Then I slept poorly for winter.” He sniffed. Pitch tar and river damp clung to him, to the deck, to the cotton cords of dock lines that creaked as the Pearl River breathed. Beyond our mooring, the foreign factories—brick bluffs with shuttered windows and flagstaffs—stood in orderly ranks. Junks drifted past like leaf-shaped ghosts. Somewhere a gong met the morning with patient clangs. “I’ll tell the men to lay off the rum for the envoy’s visit,” Sykes muttered. “You’ll come?” “I’ll be along,” I lied. The jade in my pocket was warm now, and I rubbed it without looking. It had a face of some god I didn’t know—mouth open in a silent O. My thumb had worn the cheek pale. “Lieutenant,” he said again, and in his voice a question: Are you fit? Are you ours? I turned away, took the gangplank with a jaunty authority that fooled neither of us. On shore the smell deepened. River, mud, fish offal. A market had unraveled itself along the lane: orange peel, ginger, chattering buyers, the lacquered clack of abacus beads. A boy ran past with a rooster under his arm that screamed like a pipe being scraped. Outside the Company’s hongs, clerks in hats like paper boats queued for letters. Behind a gate two soldiers shifted their pikes and watched me pass as if I were a bad coin. “You a busy gentleman today, Mister Lieut?” a voice chirped near my elbow. Ruby, her hair plaited with ribbon, her teeth lacquered black. She sold sweetened tea and gossip in equal measure from a cart whose wheels were a marvel of bamboo and rope. “Never busy enough when there’s tea.” She poured into a chipped cup. The liquid was bitter as a sermon. My hand trembled; the cup chimed against the saucer. “You need smoke,” she said softly, as if telling me my buttons were misaligned. “You white men, you go green without it.” “I need to see you smile,” I replied, and she rolled her eyes, but relief loosened something in me at her knowledge, her casualness. To be known, and for it not to be an alarm. “You show face at Mr. Herrick’s later,” she said. “He ask for you yesterday.” “Herrick’s asking for my money.” She shrugged. “He is snake, but his smoke too. You watch for runners today. They look like soldiers but they not soldiers. New ones. Sleeve red inside.” “Customs men?” She lifted her shoulders. Nothing. I nodded, paid her in small coin, and set off for the back lanes where the respectable walked with a purpose and the rest of us drifted. In Fanqui Town the facades were familiar: white paint and shuttered galleries, British flags and Portuguese and American. The smell there was ink and bread and varnished chests. Once I would have gone through those doors by right, my uniform crisp as a blade, to negotiate cargo manifests, to bully a tea merchant over duties. The captain admired my tongue then. Now I swerved behind a building, between coils of rope and stacks of cracked porcelain, into the shade where Canton unraveled into its own language. It was cooler there, the air damp and breathy, the sun fractured by overhangs and laundry. A butcher hooked a carp by the gills and slit it; its scales flashed like coins. At the warehouse yard I found Bacon leaning on a crate, hands black as a lamplighter’s, hat too small for his head. Bacon had once saved my life in a swell off Whampoa, and I had thanked him with rum and then with money and then with less. “Lieut,” he said, lazy with his greeting, but his eyes took me in, my posture, my blue lips. “You ghosting again?” “On business.” My jaw was rattling slightly. I set my teeth. “Mr. Herrick in?” “In his den. Mr. Choi already there.” “Choi?” “That’s the Canton name with the finger in everything. Pawnshops, girls, leaky boats. He came like a westerly.” “And he’ll go like a storm,” I muttered. Sweat had beaded under my collar. The jade in my pocket was now a hot coal; I rubbed it; it seemed to push back. “Look,” Bacon said, voice low. “You still owe him. You owe me. And the captain sent Sykes looking.” “The captain can wait.” “The captain, maybe. Sykes, he a dog. He bites from love.” Bacon tilted his head. “You sure you want to cross this threshold, James?” “I crossed it six years ago,” I said. “Very little left to fear.” The warehouse door opened into the dim, where bales of cotton and barrels of sugar towered like sleeping beasts. Lantern light made a cave of it. The opium room was at the back. It had a curtain of beads you could pretend muffled things. It muffled nothing. Do I need to tell you how it smelled? Lamp smoke, vinegar, the sweet rot of lotus. The thinnest string of music from a two-string fiddle that carried like a mosquito’s whine. Herrick sat at a table with ledgers spread and his hair combed with oil that reflected the lantern in points. Mr. Choi looked like a prayer book with the title in gold—plain, precise, the gold the only hint. He wore a scholar’s robe and his hands were clean. “Lieutenant Merrick,” Herrick said, teeth like little dominoes set in rows. “The navy’s own. We were just discussing your remarkable capacity.” “I’m a man of many capacities,” I said, breath catching on the last word. “You owe Mr. Choi twenty Spanish dollars.” “My account—” “Is a map of a war the enemy has already won.” He smiled at his own turn. He loved a phrase. “Yet you are a man of resource.” “I brought the papers,” I said, nails biting my palm. “The manifest for the rice shipment seized at Whampoa. Names, marks. The cut for you, the cut for the mandarins who will find a way to lose it.” Choi turned a single page, glancing at the ciphered script that had taken me all last night to copy by lamplight, the words swimming as my hands shook. He made a sound—approval, amusement, I couldn’t tell. Herrick chewed an invisible thread of patience. “Whose seal?” Choi asked. “Captain Rooke’s. He's never learned to keep his stamp as close as his wife.” “Sly boy,” Herrick murmured, but there was something bright behind his monotone. Calculation. “If these papers find their way to Dr. Sinclair, he will think it our charity.” “And he will pay in gratitude,” Choi said, “which spends as poorly as rice in the sun. But perhaps it buys other things.” “I want what I came for,” I said. “One parcel.” “One?” Herrick’s eyebrows went up. “You a monk now?” “Two,” I said. “Two will make me human again.” “Two for the papers and your charming company. The rest of your debt remains.” “Two and a promise,” I said. “I have something else. A cutter goes upriver tonight to look for smugglers’ camps. I know where she’ll pause. There will be rum aboard. And there will be silver. I can make sure she pauses longer where you want her.” “That will cost you a uniform and a career,” Herrick said softly. “Those are not currencies I still hold.” Choi looked at me across the table with a flat regard. “You like to lose. You wear it like a medal.” “I’m tired,” I said. “I like sleep.” He considered, then flicked his fingers. A boy in a blue vest came forward with two dark clay peas wrapped in oiled paper. They looked like nothing. My throat clenched at the sight. Sweat slid down my spine like a cold insect. “You smoke here,” Choi said. “We see you become human. Then we talk.” Herrick sighed. “Always the theatricals.” He shoved the little tray towards me, the lamp already hot, the needle to dissolve the extract, the thin bamboo pipes, the bed with its low cushion and its oil-stained pillow. The jade in my pocket bit like a small dog. My hands had smudged ink on the papers. There was a moment where the other day, the one with the envoy and the inspection, reached for me. And then I reached past it. “Not here,” I said. “Too many eyes.” “You’re a shy cat now?” Herrick said. “In an hour,” I said, swallowing. “When I can stand to speak without my voice tearing.” Choi’s lips twitched. “Go. But you are bound by breath now.” I took the parcels with a care that made my hands steady. Bacon watched me with a pity that tasted like tinfoil. On the way out, Herrick said, “James.” I stopped. The beads clicked like teeth. “Bring me something with teeth this time. Not just papers. A name. A schedule. Not Dr. Sinclair’s charity. A bite.” “You’ll see blood,” I said, and stepped into the heat again that was not heat but humidity, the air like silk dragged over water. The jade cooled in my hand; I squeezed it until my fingers hurt. Down the lane toward the lodgings where the walls were thin enough to hear your neighbor breathe, I met a man I had once boxed on the quarterdeck for calling the Chinese “rats.” It was Lieutenant Fenton now, hat like a crow’s wing. He recognized me midway, the way shame recognizes a mirror. “Merrick,” he said. “We missed you at morning roll. Captain’s displeased. There’s rumor you’ve taken ill.” “Rumor is a gossip with better posture,” I said. “You’re sweating.” “It’s winter.” He glanced at my pocket, at the lump, as if he could see the jade, the parcels. His face did a thing—anger and fear mixing like oil and water. “If you drag us into the mud,” he said quietly, “I’ll be the first to put you before a court.” “If I don’t drag myself, you won’t need to lift a finger.” He reached out as if to catch my sleeve, then thought better. “We were friends once,” he said, and I almost laughed. Once we had laughed at the fat of salt pork. Friendship had been as easy as finishing each other’s curses. I moved past him as the gong from some unseen temple turned the hour. The sound swept along the lanes, flattening conversation for a heartbeat. My room was up a stair the width of a coffin. The door stuck in the damp; I hip-checked it open. The bed was a narrow plank with a blanket that remembered other bodies. Light fell in a square on the floor, full of dust. I set the parcels on the windowsill and closed my eyes for a count of ten. The shaking didn’t abate. I unwrapped the paper with a care that was almost reverence. “James?” a voice whispered from the hall. I started. The tray clattered. Ruby slipped inside, bringing with her the steam of the street and the perfume of damp hair. “You do here?” she said. “Many ears.” “I do everywhere,” I said, and tried to smile. “Did you follow me?” “You white men walk like drums,” she said, shrugging. She came to the window and touched the packet with a fingertip, as if to test its temperature. “You owe me two dollars for the tea.” “I’ll be rich by sundown,” I lied. “Big liar,” she said lightly, but there was worry under it. “Mr. Choi, he say you too storm. He no like storms. He like rivers.” “I’ll be a puddle in a minute,” I said. “Do you mind?” She shook her head and sat cross-legged on the bed as if it were the most ordinary place in the world to watch a man undo himself. I warmed the pea, teased it into dark syrup, twirled it on the needle. The lamp licked at it like a polite animal. I loaded the pipe, held the stem in my teeth, let the smoke roll and fall as I chased it with the flame. The first inhalation always hurt, like forgetting how to swallow and relearning with fire. My chest fought me, then opened. The second swallow was a river over stones. “You like a god now,” Ruby said, amused, as the room tilted, as the square of light on the floor lengthened into a road and then a sheet and then a memory. The clatter of carts outside softened into pulse. The itch under my skin dissolved into a pale warmth that had nothing to do with the weather. The jade in my pocket cooled to a moon pebble. My hands stopped. My voice, when it came, had lost its burr. “Herrick wants names,” I said. “Tonight. I can give him Fenton’s. He’s on the cutter. He thinks he’s hunting smugglers. He’s hunting his own shadow.” “You do bad,” Ruby said without malice. “You do good. People like coins. Two sides. Both spend.” “I’ll tell him lies with enough truth to make them walk.” “You Navy,” she said, as if that explained my fondness for false weather. In the quiet, a rat grazed the wall. A child squealed, was shushed. “Ruby,” I said. “If I give Herrick’s men the cutter’s berth, there will be fighting.” “Many fight,” she said. “You just choose where your hands be.” “I used to be certain.” “You white men think certainty is rice. You hungry when it gone.” I turned my head to look at her. Her eyes were very black, and in them I saw the reflection of the lamp, a tiny sun. She touched my sleeve. “Time keeps going,” she said. “You think it stop because you slow? No. It go. You choose to run or to sleep.” “I choose to make a call,” I said, and the words felt distant, as if another man had left them for me in the bed. “Go to Bacon. Tell him the cutter will linger at the bend below the Weaving Goddess Temple. At dusk. Tell him to tell Choi. Tell him to keep his men’s fingers light.” “You want them to take only rum,” she guessed. “And the money,” I said. “No blood.” She stood. “No promise. Men fingers have nails. They scratch. Blood come.” “Tell them,” I said again, and she nodded, more out of kindness than belief, and slipped away. The light moved on the floor. I lay there and let the smoke teach my body its temporary mercy. The jade was smooth, all edges worn away. I held it, thinking of my father’s hands—he had given it to me in Portsmouth with a laugh at his own superstition, as if it were a joke he had included me in. “For luck,” he had said, as we smelled the sea together. He had died two years later, his lungs eaten, not by smoke but by a fever that coughed him inside out. I wondered what he would think of me now. I closed my eyes and saw the white line of Hampshire winter fields, the hedge black against it. It was a picture I returned to when the river silted me. When I woke the day had tilted, the street now full of afternoon voices, the light gone tinny. My tongue was leather. The second pea waited, patient as a stored insult. I put it in my coat instead, to carry through the next hour. Duty gnawed faintly at the edges; the envoy would be sweating under the awning on our quarterdeck, and Sykes would be lying through his smile. I splashed my face from the basin and nearly vomited at the smell, then laughed. My laugh sounded like someone else’s. Back in the lanes, I found Bacon at the corner by the wheelwright, where the smell of pine shavings and hot iron made a peculiar marriage. “You got a message,” I said. “You look like a man who found his pillow,” he said. “The Weaving Goddess bend. At dusk. Tell Choi to take rum and silver, leave the men their skin.” He blew air through his lips. “Plenty of ways a night can go wrong.” “Choose one that doesn’t involve the Navy waking with a knife,” I said. “I like my sleep.” “You owe me still.” “I’ll owe you less,” I said. He crossed his arms. “Sykes came looking. Twice. He gonna come again with Fenton. Fenton’s got a look like a fish when it see the net.” “Then tell Sykes I was here, discussing wheelwrighting.” “You don’t even have a wheel.” “No,” I said. “I have too many.” He shook his head, but his mouth softened. “Go. Before your legs remember they belong to someone else.” The riverbank was already purpled with evening when I reached the bend. Temple lanterns winked along the path like eyes closing, opening. Women washed clothes and beat the water with paddles; each slap was a metronome. A fisherman stowed his net like a priest folding a vestment. I crouched in the shadow of a banyan whose roots strangled its own stones and tried not to rub the jade. The cutter came sliding quiet as a thought, Fenton at the stern, hat low, men drowsing with the lazy attention of boys on a cart. They tied up, three knots, the boy’s voice counting in a Sutherland lilt. I could pick their shadows apart from three years of watching their bodies move at orders. In the reeds across, a whisper. Then canvas moved. Choi’s men were nothing but black on black, their oars wrapped. A gray shape alongside, a hiss. A bump. A hand, a knife, the whisper of coil. I stood to go, then stayed. The habit of an officer is to go. The habit of a man like me is to stay back. Each step away from the deck makes you less able to return. “Who goes?” Fenton called, sharp. “Friends,” said a voice in simple Cantonese, and I could hear the smile. A
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece effectively captures the gritty, morally compromised world of a British naval officer in 1830s Canton who has fallen into opium addiction. The writing demonstrates a strong command of historical setting, sensory detail, and character development. The first-person narration successfully conveys Lieutenant Merrick's deteriorating state through both explicit description and subtle cues in his interactions. The prose style balances period-appropriate language with readability, avoiding anachronisms while maintaining flow. Particularly effective is how the writing mimics Merrick's mental state - more precise when he's recently used opium, more fragmented when he's in withdrawal. The dialogue is a significant strength. Each character has a distinct voice that reflects their background and relationship to Merrick. Ruby's broken English conveys her character without becoming a stereotype, while the exchanges between naval officers carry the appropriate formality and subtext. The dialogue efficiently reveals character relationships and advances the plot without exposition. The sensory details are vivid and specific to the setting: "River, mud, fish offal," "The liquid was bitter as a sermon," and "the air like silk dragged over water." These details ground the reader in the physical reality of Canton while reflecting Merrick's altered perceptions. The piece excels at showing Merrick's moral compromise through his actions rather than explaining it. His willingness to betray naval secrets, his physical deterioration, and his rationalization of his choices all reveal his character without explicit commentary. The jade talisman serves as an effective symbol of his connection to his past self and values. The narrative structure follows Merrick through a day of increasingly compromised choices, building tension as he moves toward betraying his fellow officers. The pacing is effective, with moments of reflection balanced against action. Some minor weaknesses: The piece occasionally indulges in metaphors that, while evocative, can feel slightly overwrought ("Friendship had been as easy as finishing each other's curses"). There are a few instances where the prose becomes slightly purple, particularly in descriptions of Merrick's opium experience. The ending appears to be cut off mid-sentence, which prevents a full assessment of the conclusion. Overall, this is a sophisticated piece that creates a compelling character study while vividly evoking a specific historical setting. It balances sensory detail, character development, and plot progression effectively while maintaining a consistent voice and tone. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 18 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 18.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Humour: Sisyphus Gives Advice — Score: 95.7
Prompt:
Sisyphus Gives Advice Write a comedic scene in the style of Terry Pratchett featuring Sisyphus, who has started an advice column while continuing his eternal boulder-pushing. Rather than being bitter about his punishment, Sisyphus has developed a comfortably zen emotional intelligence and wisdom from his centuries of repetitive labor. Not in the cliche ways you might expect -- he's actually very grounded, warm & connected with the everyday human plight. He dictates responses to "Crow," his feathered familiar who serves as both scribe and mail carrier. The piece should include Sisyphus thoughtfully answering several advice-seekers' letters about everyday problems (relationship troubles, work-life balance, dealing with difficult people, life purpose doubts) while periodically returning to his boulder-pushing duties. His advice should be surprisingly insightful and practical. The humor should emerge naturally from the messages he receives, from mundane to risque. Sisyphus should genuinely enjoy helping others, finding meaning in this new pursuit while maintaining his boulder routine. The humour should be *understated and not forced*. Contrary to expectation, almost none of his advice involves boulder rolling metaphors (though he does sneak *one* subtle in there), nor a treatise on stoicism. We are also going against the obvious fish-out-of-water trope; in fact, he's surprisingly a natural at this. In all of this , it's important to *show, don't tell*. The format should be largely epistolary, with the occasional interjection for scene setting. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The wind is a polite sort of tyrant on the mountainside. It arrives when it wants, rearranges anything it fancies, and leaves Sisyphus’s hair doing something that could be prosecuted in certain barbers’ jurisdictions. The boulder is there too, of course, unkicked and entirely itself, squarely spherical and smug in a way only a rock that has outlived a dozen civilizations can manage. “Crow,” says Sisyphus, breathing evenly as they crest the midpoint. “What’s first?” Crow, black as spilled ink and wearing a quill behind his ear purely for the irony, shuffles letters with his beak. The letters make a sound like leaves deciding whether to fall. “We could start with the urgent one stamped ‘urgent’ and also ‘urgent’ in three different dialects,” he says, voice like polished sarcasm. “Or the one that smells faintly of perfume and very distinctly of decision fatigue.” “Perfume, then,” says Sisyphus. “I live to enable your priorities,” Crow mutters, and clears his throat. “‘Dear Mr. Sisyphus, My girlfriend wants me to move in. She’s amazing. I also like my solitude, my mess, and the freedom to eat cereal for dinner without commentary. I don’t want to lose her, but I fear condiments will become battlegrounds. What do I do? — Spoon in Two Places.’” Sisyphus plants his feet against a minor landslide. The boulder pauses, considers gravity, and resumes its ancient argument with it. He smiles. “To Spoon in Two Places,” he dictates. “Congratulations on finding someone whose existence competes with cereal. That’s rare. Moving in is less about drawers and more about world-building. Try this: set a date for a three-month trial. Agree on three non-negotiables each, in writing. Not because you don’t trust each other, but because people forget their own promises when the bin stares accusingly. Yours might be: I get one room to be gloriously mine; I can eat cereal for dinner once a week without commentary; I need two hours of silence on Sundays. Hers might be entirely different and unexpectedly reasonable. Schedule a weekly twenty-minute ‘house meeting’ with a timer and tea. If everything feels like it happened to you by accident, it wasn’t a decision. Make it a decision. If, after three months, you both miss your own spaces more than you enjoy the shared one, that’s also data, not failure.” He nods at Crow. “Add: ‘Prepare a condiment treaty; ketchup is a political party.’” Crow sighs, but writes. “Editorial note,” he adds in tiny, elegant script. “Cereal for dinner is a lifestyle, not a cry for help.” The boulder kisses the top with geological indifference and begins the long sigh downward. Sisyphus jogs beside it, hand on stone, not hurried so much as synchronized with inevitability. On the way down, Crow spreads his wings and lets the letters slap his feathers until he decides the next one has finished sulking in the sack. “Work-life balance,” he announces, landing atop the boulder as if it were a throne that kept trying to throw him off. “From ‘Burned To A Crisp, Esq.’” “Please,” Sisyphus says, and means it. “‘Dear Sisyphus, I’m a junior associate at a law firm where the hours are described as “heroic.” My mother calls me at 11 p.m. asking why I’m still at work, my supervisor calls me at 11:05 p.m. asking why I’m not, and my basil plant has joined a commune. I want to be good at my job. I also want a life. Advice? — BTC, Esq.’” “Dear BTC,” Sisyphus says. He gently nudges the boulder with his shoulder. “Banner your calendar with yourself. Not in fluorescent ink or blood, but in whatever your firm respects. If they like client names, be your own client. ‘BTC v. Collapse, recurring.’ Put two hours of immovable blocks a week during normal hours, and tell your supervisor what you’ll be doing—‘deep drafting time.’ People are bad at respecting vague boundaries. They are astonishingly good at respecting something that sounds billable. For your mother: give her one scheduled call a week that you keep religiously, and tell her your phone goes to a bowl at 10 p.m. Plant care: buy a hardy snake plant. Basil needs attention like a poet. You need something that thrives on neglect until you don’t. Ask one mentor at the firm to tell you the ‘real rule’ about email response times. There is always a real rule. Follow that, not the panic.” Crow’s beak does a shape that might be a smile if beaks could. “Editorial note,” he writes, “The snake plant does not judge you for anything except overwatering and hubris.” They switch sides around a jagged outcrop Sisyphus has named Reginald because it pokes him in the same place every day and keeps apologizing for it in his imagination. The wind, glad to be useful, takes a letter out of the bag, reads it, and returns it out of sheer curiosity. “Difficult people,” Crow says, tapping his talon against the parchment. “From ‘Office Phoebe.’ It’s quite juicy.” “Read,” says Sisyphus, and ducking under a low cloud, he does. “‘Dear Sisyphus, There is a man in my office who weaponizes muffins. He buys them for the team, then loudly mentions who did not say thank you. He documents perceived slights in a spreadsheet. He is also my project lead for the next quarter. How do I survive without becoming the sort of person who stares at muffins and sees war? — Office Phoebe.’” “The muffin tyrant,” Sisyphus muses. He adjusts his grip as the boulder flirts with a shale slip. “Dear Phoebe, Recognize you are not dealing with muffins. You are dealing with a person whose currency is gratitude measured, not gratitude felt. You cannot pay enough. You can, however, change the economy. Before the next muffin event, send a group email to the team: ‘Hey all, I’d like to start a rotating snack appreciation. I’ve signed up for week two. Please reply with your weeks.’ Put Muffin Man in week one by gently praising his initiative. When it’s his week, say thank you once, sincerely, and move on. When he mentions it again, say ‘We’re doing the appreciation round-up on Fridays now; I’ll add you to the list.’ He will either adapt to the new ritual or be too busy updating his spreadsheet to weaponize it. For the project: ask for expectations in writing. ‘What does success look like? What are the three most important deliverables?’ Keep your own spreadsheet of unfair requests. It won’t protect you from all muffins, but it will protect you from gaslighting. Also, bring your own snack. It’s symbolic.” Crow adds, in the margin: “Editorial note: Raisins are a trap.” A small avalanche of pebbles rattles down. They wait. The boulder waits. Sisyphus scratches behind his ear where a thought has been gathering. “Life purpose,” Crow says softly. “From ‘Twenty-Nine-ish and Itchy.’” Sisyphus breathes, rotates his hands against the stone, and nods. “Read.” “‘Dear Sisyphus, Is there a way to tell if you’re on the right path? Everyone seems to have a calling. I have a job I don’t hate, friends I cherish, hobbies that don’t embarrass me. And yet I keep thinking there’s a grander purpose. How do you know? — Twenty-Nine-ish and Itchy.’” “Dear Itchy,” Sisyphus says, and the mountain quiets in that way mountains do when they want to listen but won’t admit it. “Imagine your life five years from now if nothing ‘grand’ arrives. Could you like that person? Not love, not worship—like. Would you borrow their jacket and forget to return it because it’s comfortable? If the answer is ‘yes,’ you are not lost. If the answer is ‘no,’ don’t hunt a calling like it owes you money. Change one thing you touch every day. The mug you drink from. The walk you take. The person you text first. Purposes often arrive disguised as habits. If you need an experiment: pick one problem you can see from where you stand that bothers you, and spend twelve Thursdays trying to make it better, publicly and badly. You will discover either that the problem is not yours, or that it is, in which case the path will be embarrassingly well-lit.” Crow writes, and in a smaller hand: “Editorial note: This column is a twelve-Thursday project in denial.” They reach the top. The boulder hums with the potential energy of a story that has been told a thousand times and still finds itself surprised by its own ending. Sisyphus puts a hand on it, almost tender, and turns to Crow. “Do we have time for another?” he asks. “For something delicate,” Crow says, fluffing his feathers against a gust that smells like old nectar. “From ‘Three’s Company (Asking For A Friend).’” Sisyphus’s eyebrows, which have seen empires and new haircuts, remain unjudging. “Go on.” “‘Dear Sisyphus, My partner and I are considering inviting a close friend into our bed, just once. We are both excited and terrified of the afterward. We communicate well in general, but neither of us has done this before. Any advice beyond googling? — Three’s Company.’” Sisyphus contemplates the infinite horizon with its endless trick of always being there and never being closer. “Dear Three,” he says. “Yes. Discuss the exit strategy before the entrance. Decide in clear terms how anyone can pause or stop things without drama, and what happens next—tea? A board game? Sleep in separate rooms? People rarely regret the conversation they had; they often regret the one they didn’t. Also, talk now, sober, about jealousy—what does it feel like for each of you? Where does it show up in your body? If someone says, ‘If I get quiet and my shoulders go up, I need a break,’ honor that. Set a time limit you can revise in the moment. Afterward, schedule a debrief when you are not naked. Be kind to future you: make sure tomorrow includes comfort food and no major decisions. And remember this: you can decide after trying it that it’s not for you without declaring your relationship a failure. Some doors you open just to see the light, not to move in.” Crow pauses, quill hovering. “Editorial note,” he writes reluctantly, “Have snacks that are sexy as snacks but not as stains.” They start down again. A goat, who has made career choices, watches them respectfully. The boulder picks up thoughts about speed. Sisyphus leans it this way and that like a dancer wearing an extremely heavy partner. “Here’s one that simply says ‘Help,’” Crow says, and for the first time his voice is less like polished sarcasm and more like a wing folded over an egg. He clears his throat. “‘Dear Sisyphus, I lost my brother last year. People keep telling me to move on. I don’t want to move on. I want him back. The world has the audacity to keep being normal. Everything is slightly the wrong shape. How do I… exist? — Left Behind.’” “Dear Left Behind,” Sisyphus says, and he does not hurry his words. “You don’t have to move on. There’s no prize for it. You will move differently. That’s all. Make a small altar to him somewhere ridiculous and mundane—a shelf near your shoes, a corner of the cutlery drawer. Put something of his there, or something you wish you could tell him. When the world is obnoxiously normal, scrape your keys across your altar and say out loud one sentence you wish he could hear. Create a tradition he would have mocked. Invite him by doing the thing and letting yourself laugh. The wrong shape will not become right. But you will become more skillful at living in this shape. That’s not betrayal. That’s adaptation, which is the opposite side of love’s coin. You’re not required to be brave. Bravery is a rumor the living spread about the grieving because it makes us feel useful. Eat, sleep, walk, repeat. That counts.” Crow has been silent, which is his version of weeping. He writes without editorializing. They walk. The mountain continues to be itself. The letters decrease. The wind is smug; it has rearranged his hair in a new and innovative misadventure. “One last,” Crow says, producing a scrap of paper that looks like it was torn from something else important. “From ‘Manager Who Wants To Be Less Of One.’” “Please,” Sisyphus says, and the boulder bumps his hip fondly. “‘Dear Sisyphus, I’m a new manager. I was promoted because I was good at doing the work, which seems cruel. Now I have a team of five very different people. How do I not ruin their lives? — Accidentally In Charge.’” “Dear Accidentally,” Sisyphus says. “Start every one-on-one with ‘What do you want to get out of your job in the next six months, and how can I help?’ Write down the answer where both of you can see it. Ask each person for their preferred method of feedback and their big ‘nope’—what demotivates them instantly. Your job is to remove pebbles from their shoes so they can run, not to run for them. Have one standard you hold everyone to, and make it explicit. To avoid ruining lives: do your calendar in public. Put your focus blocks on it. Leave at a reasonable hour once a week and say out loud where you’re going—‘I am leaving to do something that isn’t work’—so permission propagates. When you make a mistake, name it, fix it, and tell them what you learned. That’s culture.” Crow preens. “Editorial note: Bring biscuits to meetings. People forgive agenda confusion if there are biscuits.” They reach the top again. The boulder pauses like a thought before a word. Sisyphus sets his hands, considerate, and then—almost as an afterthought—he looks at his stone companion and then at Crow. “You know,” he says, “the trick isn’t the pushing. It’s remembering to breathe at the same places each time so you can think new thoughts in between.” Crow cocks his head. “Is that your one allowed metaphor?” Sisyphus smiles like a man with a very old friend. “I suppose it is.” “Then we’re done for the day,” Crow declares, tucking away the quill, but he doesn’t mean the mountain. He means the letters. He always means the letters. He hops onto the boulder as it begins again. Above them the sky opens into an inarguable blue, below them the path curls like an old ribbon, and between the two a man and a rock and a bird practice continuity as if it were a craft. Some days, it is. Some days, it isn’t. Today, it feels close. Crow angles his beak into the wind and yells, because yelling into the wind is a hobby: “Submissions to ‘Ask Sisyphus’ can be tied to my leg, but if you tie anything sticky there will be consequences!” Sisyphus laughs, easy and unstartled, as the letters in his head and in his bag concoct their own quiet revolutions. He breathes in the old familiar rhythm at exactly the same stones. He breathes out advice for strangers he does not consider strangers at all. And the mountain, as always, is exactly the wrong shape for everything and somehow perfectly suited to this.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response is an exceptional piece that captures Terry Pratchett's style with remarkable fidelity while creating something fresh and engaging. The writer has crafted a Sisyphus who is indeed "grounded, warm & connected with the everyday human plight" without falling into clichés. The epistolary format works perfectly, with Sisyphus answering a variety of letters that range from mundane relationship issues to profound grief. The advice given is genuinely insightful and practical, showing a deep understanding of human nature. For example, his advice to "Twenty-Nine-ish and Itchy" about finding purpose is both philosophical and actionable, suggesting they "pick one problem you can see from where you stand that bothers you, and spend twelve Thursdays trying to make it better, publicly and badly." The relationship between Sisyphus and Crow is delightful. Crow serves as both a practical assistant and a sardonic commentator, adding his "editorial notes" that provide humor without overwhelming the piece. Their dynamic feels lived-in and authentic. The prose is elegant without being pretentious. Descriptions like "The boulder is there too, of course, unkicked and entirely itself, squarely spherical and smug in a way only a rock that has outlived a dozen civilizations can manage" capture Pratchett's knack for anthropomorphizing inanimate objects while maintaining a light touch. The writer skillfully avoids the obvious boulder-rolling metaphors, with only one subtle reference near the end: "the trick isn't the pushing. It's remembering to breathe at the same places each time so you can think new thoughts in between." This restraint shows a sophisticated understanding of the prompt. The humor is indeed understated and emerges naturally from the situations and characters. Crow's editorial notes ("Cereal for dinner is a lifestyle, not a cry for help") and Sisyphus's practical wisdom ("Prepare a condiment treaty; ketchup is a political party") provide gentle humor without forcing jokes. The piece excels at showing rather than telling. We see Sisyphus's character through his actions and advice rather than being told about his wisdom. The mountain setting is vividly realized through small details like the "polite sort of tyrant" wind and the "jagged outcrop Sisyphus has named Reginald." The response to the letter about grief is particularly moving, showing emotional depth without sentimentality: "You don't have to move on. There's no prize for it. You will move differently. That's all." This demonstrates the writer's ability to handle complex emotions with grace. The only minor critique might be that some of the advice occasionally veers into slightly too-clever territory, but this is consistent with Pratchett's style and doesn't detract from the overall quality of the piece. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 1 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 1.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Coming of age: Lost & Found in Osaka — Score: 84.3
Prompt:
Lost & Found in Osaka Slice of Life / Coming-of-Age: First Connection. Write one scene within a larger story set in Osaka, Japan. A shy, introverted teenager & synthesizer nerd, is browsing the electronics district of Den Den Town. She is drawn to the sound of an electric guitar. A girl, slightly older and radiating confidence, is busking near the entrance to a crowded arcade, playing a blistering rendition of a classic anime theme. The scene takes us through their initial awkward interaction, transitioning into a surprisingly easy conversation. The busker, intrigued by the teenager's quiet intensity and knowledge of music, suggests they grab some sushi at a nearby kaitenzushi (conveyor belt sushi) restaurant. Write primarily in dialogue, capturing the distinct voices of the two characters: the teenager's hesitant and -- initially -- awkward speech, and the busker's more outgoing and playful tone. 1000 words.
Model Output:
“You can touch it,” the guitarist says, chin jerking toward the battered red Strat leaning against her amp, strings still trembling. “I—no, it’s okay,” I say, pushing my headphones up because they’re sliding over my eyes again. “It’s yours.” “It’s everyone’s for the next five minutes.” She grins. “You looked like you were gonna teleport into it.” “I’m not—teleport capable,” I say, then wish I hadn’t. The arcade’s neon sign flickers above us. A crowd drifts past, leaving behind the smell of takoyaki and warm plastic. Someone inside the arcade screams triumphantly at a claw machine. “Right,” she says, laughter in her voice. She clicks off her overdrive pedal with her boot. “You know the song, right?” “I—yes.” I glance at her pedalboard. The Boss tuner has a crack near the footswitch; the delay is set to dotted eighths. The distortion pedal’s gain is at maybe three o’clock. “Lumina—Lumina Ranger. Season three. The opening. The modulation in the bridge—actually, it’s unusual.” “You heard a modulation on this busted street amp?” She raises an eyebrow. “I’m impressed.” “It’s—no, I mean, the original track. You played it…closer than the live festival version. The solo phrasing.” She squints at me, then breaks into a brighter grin. “Okay, nerd. I like you.” “I’m not—” The headphones slide again. I hook a finger to push them back up. “I like synths. Not—guitars. Mostly.” “You can like both. The universe will not collapse.” “It might,” I say. She laughs, and my cheeks warm. “I’m Ritsu,” she says, wiping her palm on her jeans and offering it. “Um.” I stare at her hand, the faint calluses along the base of her fingers. “I’m Sana.” “Sana,” she repeats, as if testing the sound. “You hang around Den Den Town a lot?” “Not…a lot.” My voice wobbles. I glance at the window of the shop behind me: racks of cables, synthesizer modules glowing like little cityscapes. “Sometimes. On—Saturdays.” “Same. Good foot traffic, decent acoustics if I get the angle right.” She kicks the amp’s corner lightly. “And the arcades throw out enough noise that folks don’t notice if I screw a note.” “You didn’t,” I say, without thinking. “Didn’t what?” “Miss a note.” I swallow. “You…didn’t.” Her grin softens. “Thanks. Been practicing that one. People hear it and go, oh! That robot show! They like to clap.” “They clapped,” I say. A crowd earlier had. I hadn’t clapped; my hands had been stuck in the pockets of my hoodie. “You didn’t,” she says, elbowing me lightly. “I’m holding things,” I say, although my hands are empty. She tilts her head. “You build stuff? You got that look.” “What look?” “The counting-latency-in-your-head look.” “Oh,” I say. “Sometimes.” My headphones slip. I push them up again, ears burning. “I like…oscillators.” “No shame in that, Sana. Oscillators are sexy.” “I—what?” She laughs. “Relax. It’s a compliment.” “Okay,” I say, although I’m not sure how to relax. “Your tone’s nice.” “Now we’re talking.” She crouches to her pedals. “Old tube amp, borrowed. The overdrive’s an Osaka boutique guy—name’s like…something with a cat? Fits me right, no fizz.” “Your attack is…clean,” I say. “You pick with your wrist. And the vibrato—you do that wide thing at the end of phrases that’s…like a singer.” Her eyes light. “Finally someone notices! Everyone’s like, wow, loud. I’m like, excuse you, I’m trying to be a diva.” “You are,” I say. “I mean—like one. In a good way.” “Now you flatter me. Dangerous.” She leans the guitar against the amp carefully. “You play?” “Keys.” I stare at the grime on the sidewalk. A boy with a gachapon bag bumps me and apologizes. “I have an old DX. Not the big one. And a Volca. And some…modules. I’m saving for a…thing.” “What thing?” I look up, caught. “A…filter. Ladder filter. With resonance that doesn’t…scream. Smooth resonance.” “Your eyes just got all shiny,” she says. “Okay, take me to your filter.” “It’s—inside,” I say, nodding at the shop. “But I’m just…looking. Not today.” “Looking is dangerous,” she says. “I looked at a Jazzmaster once and now I have no savings.” She glances at the thin stack of coins in her open case. “Speaking of savings, you got a hundred yen?” I fumble in my pocket and put a coin into her case. It clinks against the other coins. She makes a tiny bow, exaggerated. “Thank you kindly.” “You’re…good,” I say. “Say it again. Never gets old.” “You’re good.” She puts a hand to her heart. “Blessed.” The headphones slide again; this time she reaches out and taps the padded cup gently, guiding it back. Her fingers brush the plastic, not my hair. I flinch anyway. “Sorry,” she says immediately, hands up. “Boundary check.” “It’s okay,” I say quickly. “They just…don’t fit.” “Those big boys?” She nods. “They look like they’re trying to escape.” “They are,” I mumble. “When I—nod. It’s—” I nod, and they slip, proving my point. She snorts. “You’re adorable.” “I’m not,” I say, mortified. “You are. And very serious about sound. Which I respect.” She clicks her tuner, plucks a harmonic, twists a peg. “So you’re a Lumina Ranger person?” “I watched with my brother,” I say. “He—liked the robots. I liked the soundtrack.” “Same. The composer did those weird synth brass stabs? Honestly, iconic.” “They’re…not brass,” I say, then immediately regret the correction. “Sorry. That’s obvious. It’s…a sawtooth layered—” “Don’t apologize,” she says. “Geek out at me. I like it.” “I don’t want to…talk too much,” I say. “People—glaze. Out.” “I promise to unglaze.” She flicks her pick into the air and catches it. “What’s your favorite part?” “The modulation. And the way the drums step out for a bar before the last chorus. The negative space.” I gesture, then freeze. I never gesture. “Sorry.” “Stop sorrying. Negative space is tasty.” She gestures back, mirroring me on purpose, playful. “You write stuff?” “Sometimes,” I say. Heat creeps up my neck. “It’s not…good.” “Bring it,” she says. “Let me hear.” “Not here,” I say quickly, glancing at the people streaming past, the giggling group fumbling with their arcade tokens. “Okay,” she says, without pushing. She unclips her cable and coils it quickly, practiced. “I’m about to take a break. My fingers are like, help. You eaten?” I glance at the convenience store across the street. “I was…going to get onigiri.” “Lame,” she says cheerfully. “Let’s get sushi. Kaiten. It’s right there—” She points down the street, between a stack of retro game cartridges and a shelf of boxed model kits. “Conveyor belt and everything. You can watch the plates like satellites. Your headphones can orbit your head.” “I—uh—” The thought of sitting across from her makes my stomach fizz. “I don’t—really—” “Hey.” Her voice gentles. “No pressure. But you look like a person who forgets to eat when you’re thinking about filters.” “I…do,” I admit, surprised. “Ten plates. My treat, since you put the hundred yen in.” “That’s not—equal,” I say. “Then you can tell me what ladder filters do and we’ll call it even.” “Okay,” I say, too fast. “I mean—yes.” “Cool.” She slings the guitar over her shoulder and hoists the little amp with a grunt. “Grab the cable?” “I—sure.” I loop it as neatly as my trembling fingers allow. She locks the tip plug into the amp handle for safety. We start walking. My headphones slide; I adjust them again, which makes her chuckle. “You can pop them around your neck. Your ears will survive.” “If I take them off, it’s…loud,” I say, gesturing at the flood of voices, the whine of arcade machines, the overlapping jingles. “Right,” she says. “We can sit at the back. Quieter.” “Thank you,” I say. “Welcome.” She glances at the shop windows as we pass. “You ever get sucked into those glass cases? The ones with the little synths that look like candy?” “I—yes,” I say. “The Volca Keys—my friend calls it the ‘beep box.’” “Rude,” she says. “It’s the beep box.” She winks. The restaurant’s sliding door whooshes open when we step on the mat. The air inside is cool and scented with vinegared rice. A statue of a smiling tuna greets us. The conveyor belt hums past, plates like bright moons in orbit. A digital voice chirps something cheerful I don’t catch. I take a breath, and the noise from outside softens. “Two,” Ritsu tells the host. “Back corner if you’ve got it.” We’re led to a booth near the end of the line. The belt snakes past, carrying salmon, cucumber rolls, a little spaceship bowl of edamame. Ritsu plops her amp down carefully by the wall and slides into the seat without ceremony. I take the opposite, setting my headphones around my neck. It’s quieter here; my shoulders inch down. “Okay,” she says, grabbing a plate and setting it in front of me. “Start with whatever’s least scary.” “They’re all…scary,” I say. “Fair. Cucumber rolls?” She nabs a kappa maki plate and puts it near me. “I can destroy the raw stuff; you can warm up.” “Thank you,” I say, hands hovering, unsure if I’m supposed to wait for something. She’s already pouring soy sauce into the dish, edible ease. “So. Ladder filters,” she says, picking up a plate of salmon and putting it on her side. “Explain like I’m five and also holding a guitar.” “They—um.” I fumble for words and find them. “They shape the sound by…removing high frequencies as the cutoff goes down. Like—to make it simple—it’s like closing your mouth when you say ‘ah.’ ‘Aaah’ becomes ‘oooh.’” Ritsu pulls a face. “‘Aaah’ becomes ‘oooh’ is now the name of my next EP.” I laugh. It spills out like something knocked loose. “Okay.” “And resonance?” she prompts, leaning forward, elbows on the table, chin in her hands. “It’s…when the filter feeds back—slightly—around the cutoff point, so the frequency near the cutoff is emphasized. Like humming into a bottle and the bottle…hums back.” She points at me with her chopsticks. “See? You should teach a class.” “No one would come,” I say. “I would.” She picks up the salmon with easy chopstick grace and eats. “So you make…what kind of stuff? Moody spaceship music? Dance? Sad robot ballads?” “Not dance,” I say. “I can’t…feel the four. Sometimes I try to, but—my hands do…something else.” “Your hands are rebels.” I glance at my hands. “Maybe.” “Play me something later,” she says. “I’m serious.” “Okay,” I say, before I can stop myself. “But—only if you show me the wide vibrato.” “Deal.” She sticks out her pinky like she’s five. After a second, I hook mine around it. Her finger is warm. We separate awkwardly. “So what’s your origin story, Sana?” she asks, grabbing a plate with shrimp. “Were you bitten by a radioactive synth?” “I…moved here last year,” I say, words slow at first, then smoothing. “From Tottori. My mom got transferred. I didn’t—know anyone. There’s a music room at school. It has a broken piano and a computer that crashes. But it has a plug.” “A plug is a plug,” she says. “I’m from here. Born in Namba, raised on ramen and an unreasonable number of gachapon. My dad tried to teach me shamisen. I said, counteroffer: distortion.” “He was…mad?” I ask. “He said, ‘if you can play scales on that, play scales on this.’ I did both. Now he pretends he always supported me, because I can play Enka intros for Grandma and she cries.” She laughs, not unkindly. “Family.” “I can’t play for my grandma,” I say, and then clamp my mouth shut because it sounds sad. “She—doesn’t hear well.” “You can play loud,” Ritsu says. “Problem solved.” “It’s not…that,” I say. She nods. “Got it.” We eat. The plates make soft clacks as we stack them. When I reach for a tuna roll, my sleeve catches and my chopsticks threaten to fall. Ritsu catches them with her free hand as if it’s nothing and passes them back, eyes bright with Tiny Victory. “Thanks,” I whisper. “Anytime.” The belt swings a plate of tamago past. She points. “You like sweet omelet?” “Yes,” I say, too firm. She laughs and slides it to me. “You got any favorite Osaka music spots?” she asks between bites. “Basement shows? Weird record stores that sell cassettes of mysterious dudes named ‘DJ Fog’?” “I…wander,” I say. “Sometimes I find little places. There’s a shop near Sakaisuji that sells only power supplies. It’s…beautiful.” “You’re killing me,” she says, delighted. “Only power supplies. That’s art.” “It is,” I say earnestly. “They were arranged by voltage. Like—like a choir.” “Choir of wall warts,” she says. “Sana. You’re a poem.” “No,” I say, and then, “Thank you.” She taps her lower lip with her chopsticks. “You should meet my friend Keita. He runs a tiny venue in an alley near the river. They do noise nights where everyone brings something that makes sound. You’d fit.” “I don’t—fit,” I say automatically. “You’d fit,” she says, as if it’s decided. “And if you hate it, we’ll leave and get taiyaki and make fun of everyone. Including me.” “I wouldn’t make fun of you,” I say. “Well, try,” she says. “It’s good for me.” “You’re…good,” I say again. “Okay, okay, we’re back to that.” She laughs. “You’re good too. At hearing. At putting it into words.” I feel the compliment like a warm current. “Thank you.” Her phone buzzes on the table. She glances at it and silences it with her palm. “I’m supposed to head to Umeda later. Play in the tunnel. But we can hang until then.” “You have to play again?” “Gotta pay for my house of cards.” She gestures at the amp. “And for your ladder filter.” “It’s not—your job,” I say, a reflex. “I mean, if you let me borrow it sometimes,” she says, eyes teasing. “You can,” I say. “If—when I get it.” “When,” she echoes, pleased. “So. What did you think of my bridge? Was it too much? I slow down the run because my fingers don’t quite—” “It was…clean,” I say. “But if you want it to match the festival version, the third note in bar two—if you bend slightly sharper, the tension—” I stop, mortified. “Sorry.” “Don’t be.” She picks up the last piece of tamago and offers it. I blink; then she pops it on my plate instead. “I want that. Bend sharper, third note. Okay. Will you point when I do it?” “If I—come,” I say. “To Umeda.” “Come.” She says it like a certainty. “I’ll text you the spot. Do you—” “I don’t—have it,” I say quickly. “A phone. I mean, I have one, but it’s…dead. The battery. I forgot the…cord.” “Of course you did,” she says, affectionate. “Okay, plan B.” She digs in her bag and pulls out a wrapped piece of string and a pen. She untangles a paper napkin and writes her name, a number, a tiny guitar doodle next to it, neat even in haste. “Here. I am reachable. Old school.” I take it carefully, as if it might break. “I’ll—text. When I plug in.” “Do that.” She watches me fold the napkin and tuck it into my wallet like it’s a secret mission. “And if you don’t, I’ll assume you’re trapped in a tower of power supplies and come rescue you.” “I—okay,” I say. She leans back, satisfied. “So that modulation. Teach me how to cheat it on six strings.” “You can’t…cheat,” I say. “But you can fake it. If you slide up a semitone under the chord and—” I hold my hands up like I’m playing keys in the air, fingers finding the phantom shapes. “If you outline the new key before the band goes there, the ear—” “Wants it,” she finishes, eyes bright. “Yes.” “Yes,” I say, and when she nods, my headphones slide. We both reach up this time, me to push, her to pretend to catch. It turns into a shared silly gesture, and we both laugh a little, the same pitch. The belt hums. The plates stack higher
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully captures a slice-of-life encounter between two contrasting characters in Osaka's Den Den Town. The writer has crafted a dialogue-heavy narrative that effectively establishes distinct voices for both characters: Sana, the shy synthesizer enthusiast with hesitant, awkward speech patterns, and Ritsu, the confident guitarist with a playful, outgoing manner. The dialogue is the strongest element of the piece. The exchanges feel natural and reveal character through speech patterns rather than exposition. Sana's halting sentences with frequent pauses (marked by em dashes) contrast nicely with Ritsu's more fluid, confident expressions. The writer effectively uses dialogue to show Sana's social anxiety and technical knowledge alongside Ritsu's easy confidence and genuine interest. The setting is established through small sensory details woven throughout the conversation: "A crowd drifts past, leaving behind the smell of takoyaki and warm plastic," "The arcade's neon sign flickers above us," and descriptions of the sushi restaurant with its "plates like bright moons in orbit." These details create a sense of place without overwhelming the dialogue-focused narrative. Character development is handled subtly through the interaction. We see Sana gradually becoming more comfortable, her responses lengthening as she warms to Ritsu and discusses topics she's passionate about. The writer effectively shows this transition rather than telling us about it. The piece does have some weaknesses. The ending feels somewhat abrupt, with the line "The belt hums. The plates stack higher" not providing a strong conclusion to the scene. While this may be intentional for a slice-of-life piece, it leaves the reader without a sense of resolution or clear next step in their relationship. Additionally, while the dialogue is strong, some of the physical actions become repetitive, particularly the recurring motif of Sana's headphones sliding down. While this serves as a character trait and interaction point, it's used perhaps too frequently. The prose is generally clean and effective, though occasionally it becomes a bit too self-conscious in its attempts to be literary, such as "The plates make soft clacks as we stack them" or "plates like bright moons in orbit." These moments, while not egregious, occasionally draw attention to the writing rather than immersing the reader in the scene. Overall, this is a strong piece that succeeds in its primary goal of capturing a meaningful first connection between two contrasting characters through dialogue. The writer has created distinct voices and shown a gradual warming of relationship through conversation rather than exposition, all while maintaining a consistent tone and establishing a sense of place. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 16 Elegant Prose: 15 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 4 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 3 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 17
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 16.0, Elegant Prose: 15.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 4.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 3.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 17.0
+ Teen horror: Tick Tock (Goosebumps) — Score: 80.7
Prompt:
Teen Horror (Goosebumps style) Write a chapter where a middle school student discovers their new smart watch has the ability to rewind time, but doesn't realize that each use is aging them until they notice physical changes (like accelerating through puberty) and that people are treating them differently. They inadvertently cause a timeline shift with disastrous consequences -- and it can only be rectified (maybe?) by reversing the clock once more. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The first time my watch beeped, I thought it was just another update. “New feature: Recap,” the screen said in tiny white letters. The strap still had that rubbery new smell, and the face caught the fluorescents of the hallway as I tilted my wrist to read it. I’d begged Dad for months for the ZenoVibe. It was supposed to count steps, do texts, and make me look less like a seventh grader who still wore his hoodie with the sleeves pulled over his hands. “Nice toy, Hubbard.” Tony Meyers slapped the back of my head as he passed in the hallway. My name is Dylan, but Tony never called anyone by their name unless it was to say it wrong. “Don’t drop it in the toilet.” I was forming the perfect comeback—something about him needing a watch to tell time since he couldn’t read a clock—when the bell rang and my brain lost its place. That’s what I needed. A recap. I pressed the side button without thinking, the way the ad showed, two taps and a twist. The screen flashed blue, then everything slid like someone pulled the floor three inches sideways. My stomach did a roller coaster flip and the world hiccuped. And then I was standing in the hallway, hoodie sleeves over my hands, Tony approaching with his stretched-out smirk. “Nice toy, Hubbard.” The exact same slap to the head. This time my jaw didn’t hang open. I didn’t stumble. “Careful,” I said, because I had the time to think, “your knuckles are dragging.” It was lame, but it landed. Tony blinked. Someone snorted behind him. The bell rang; he moved on. I stared at my watch. No one else had reacted to the glitch. I hadn’t blacked out. My breath came quick, white at the edges. I pressed the button again and promptly regretted it, because the staircase lurched backward and I snapped to the moment three seconds before someone at the top dropped their binder. “Watch it!” a girl yelped. This time, I caught the binder. Papers didn’t spray like confetti. The girl—Ava from homeroom—looked at me like I’d levitated. “Thanks.” That day I used it ten times. Fifteen. Miss a problem in math? Rewind, fix the sign. Dropped my tray in the cafeteria? Rewind, pivot with grace. I had always thought of life like a long, messy homework sheet with no erasers. Turns out, all I needed was firmware. After school, I took a shortcut behind the gym where the dumpsters were, because sometimes the band left their drumsticks in the grass. That’s when I saw the cat. It was gray with blotches the color of overripe peaches and a kink in its tail like someone had bent a pipe cleaner. It sat on the low wall near the bike racks and watched me with unblinking yellow-green eyes that cut through me like high beams. I hesitated. I’ve never been much of a cat person. They were a lot like science teachers—silent, always knowing more than you thought. It didn’t flinch when I got close. I could see the little notch in its left ear, ragged and pink. It blinked slowly. I held my hand out; it flicked its tail. There was a weird little shiver over my skin, a sense of recognition like seeing a class photo of your older cousin when he looked your age. I ignored it. I had rewound myself into a good day. I had a binder saved, a bully zinged, and a cat who liked me. That night, the watch buzzed my wrist as I did my homework. “Extended Recap available,” it whispered. A tiny clock icon unspooled like a tape measure around the edge of the screen. I should’ve read the manual. But manuals are for dads. I hit buttons instead. The next day felt like walking downhill and discovering halfway you were on roller skates. My shirt tugged at my shoulders. My sleeves were shorter. When I hit the restroom between second and third period, I lifted my chin to the mirror and tilted my head. The face looking back was mine, but also not—like the person I’d see if I squinted at a yearbook labeled “Eighth grade.” The fuzz on my upper lip was darker. A zit had popped up on my chin like a mushroom after rain. My hair looked like it had decided to grow overnight, brushing my eyebrows. When had my voice started sitting lower in my throat? I cleared it experimentally and watched it ripple the mirror’s surface in my imagination. I rubbed my jaw. It felt sharper. I had always been short enough to slip through crowds. Standing at my locker before lunch, I looked over heads I used to look around. “Dude,” said Ben from science, “did you get taller?” “New shoes,” I said. It came out like I’d been gargling gravel. I told myself it was sleep. Eleven-year-olds grew. Almost twelve. It wasn’t like I had done anything. Rewinding hadn’t taken days off the calendar. The date in the corner of the screen was still October 3. After school, the cat waited on the wall. It watched me pass the first time, and its tail thumped a weird little rhythm. When I rewound to catch a fly ball in gym that Coach had pegged straight at my face, I came outside later than before. The cat was there again, head tilting. Same little notch, same green eyes. But this time, as I walked by, it stood, stepped forward, and rubbed its side against my leg like we were old friends. It did the same thing after the next rewind. Tail flick, bump. “Hey, buddy,” I said. It blinked slow, the way cats do when they trust you. Or maybe when they recognize a pattern. The problem with having a magic button is you start using it for everything. Spill milk? Rewind. Say something cringe? Rewind and un-say it. I lived five versions of Thursday the following week and settled on the one where I answered every question in Language Arts before Ava did and got the best laugh in the cafeteria with a stupid impression of our principal. Mom noticed. “Did you… steal a razor?” she asked, standing in the kitchen doorway, half amused, half concerned. “Because your face… your voice…” “I’m fine,” I said. The voice didn’t sound like mine when it did the protest thing, high and squeaky. It dipped and cracked like an old floorboard. At school, teachers stopped saying “Are you okay?” and started saying “Young man.” Tony bumped me in the hall and then stopped, frowning, because he had to look up a bit to do it. “Weird,” he muttered, and didn’t slap my head. I should have stopped. Except then Coach announced the tryouts for the soccer team. I’d wanted to be on a team since forever. My feet were always a step behind my brain, though. I would think about what to do and do it one second too late. With a watch that could create an extra second, that didn’t have to be true. The field was a bright rectangle under the Friday sun. Sweat slid down my back, and my socks bunched in my shoes like rolled parchment. “Hubbard,” Coach called, “left wing.” He tossed me a pinny; I pulled it over my head. The cattail weeds by the fence whispered in the wind. Somewhere, a car alarm chirped. We scrimmaged. I missed a pass. The whistle blew. Tap tap, twist. The world slid. We reset. The ball kissed my instep and traveled like I meant it to. Whoops from the sidelines. Ping. Reset again, again. My legs burned like I’d been running for hours. My lungs felt tight, but I kept moving. The world stuttered once, twice. Noon light jittered like a strobe. On the fourth reset, I saw her—the cat by the fence line, crouched under the bleachers. It didn’t blink. It stared right through me, then flicked its ears back flat like it was bracing for thunder. The knot in its ear looked raw, fresh. My wrist tingled. I scored. It was easy, in that messy after-the-fact way. I’d done it three different ways already; this was just the one that stuck. I stopped running only when Coach blew the whistle and threw his hands up. “Nice footwork, Hubbard,” he said, startled and pleased. The team crowded around, slapping my shoulders, my back. Hands left sweaty prints on my pinny. Their faces tilted up toward mine. I was taller than almost all of them. When had that happened? Their voices sounded distant. My heart hammered. My skin felt too tight. “What you looking at?” Tony said later at the fence, following my gaze. “The cat.” “You gonna adopt it? You two kinda match.” He made a little clawing motion. I opened my mouth to say something sharp. The watch buzzed. “Battery low,” it said smugly on my wrist. As if in response, things started to fray. Ava didn’t meet my eyes at lunch. On Monday, Mr. Parker announced we had a pop quiz in science, and the questions were all about stuff we hadn’t covered. “Uh,” I said, and then stopped, because I had covered this. In the version where Mr. Parker wore a green tie and the projector had a crack across the corner. But this tie was red, and the crack wasn’t there. I rewound, blinking, tried to find the branch where I’d studied that chapter. The screen pulsed. The room slid. My stomach flipped. When the world set, my desktop had an old nick in it that I didn’t remember. Mr. Parker’s hair had a gray streak that hadn’t been there last week. “Eyes on your own paper, Dylan,” he said sharply, as if he had said that to me before, a dozen times. My skin went cold. The more I tried to crawl back to the place where everything lined up, the farther I got from it. That afternoon, I rounded the corner to my locker and ran into the vice principal. She frowned at me like I had put graffiti on her minivan. “We need to talk about your fight in the cafeteria,” she said. “I didn’t—” “You’ve been getting into it with Meyers all semester, and this is the last straw.” Last semester? My hand went cold. I hadn’t fought anyone. I’d avoided fights with a two-tap-and-twist. Except the world disagreed. Somewhere, in some version, fists had been thrown. Somewhere else, I’d shove-left when I should have ducked-right. The versions were leaking into each other. The bulk of the future was rolling toward me with all my footprints stamped into it, and they didn’t match. Outside, the cat sat on the wall near the bike rack and watched me struggle. When I rewound to avoid the vice principal, snapping myself back to turning the corner, the cat looked at me. Not just in the generic cat way, but with a look that made my breath catch. It knew. It lifted one paw and put it down again, like a metronome. I pressed the button and ran. Each tap pulled me backward and dropped me forward. Kids blurred. Hallways doubled up like they were folding in a funhouse mirror. By the time I stumbled into the parking lot, the light was different—colder, the edges of the clouds sharper like cut felt. The cat leaped off the wall and intercepted me, weaving between my legs, forcing me to stop. It meowed, a low sound that vibrated my bones. Its eyes were green like my watch’s glow. I crouched without meaning to, hands on my knees, lungs burning. The cat head-butted my wrist. I looked down. The watch face had a hairline crack across the edge that hadn’t been there. Around the little clock icon, tiny tick marks had lit up, one by one, until only three were dark. “Resets remaining: 3,” the watch displayed. “You knew about this?” I asked the cat. It blinked. My hands shook as I swiped through the menus. “TimeFrame,” “Undo,” “Sync.” There was a warning I hadn’t seen: Extended Recap may cause chronological offsets. Prolonged use may have side effects including time-skips, chronological dissonance, growth acceleration— I stopped. I didn’t need the rest of the sentence. I could feel it. My knees ached like I’d run a marathon. The sleeves of my hoodie that had been down to my knuckles on Monday barely reached my wrists now. Tiny dark hairs stippled along my forearms. People weren’t just treating me differently because I acted different. I looked older. And something else: my reflection in the dark surface of the watch face, warped by the crack, was older than I was ready to see. Older than my mom’s “not yet, baby” voice from when she saw me eyeing Dad’s razor. And the world was wrong. My science quiz had questions from next month. Ava looked at me like I was a stranger who had borrowed Dylan’s old hat. The vice principal thought I’d been in fights I’d carefully avoided by cheating time. It wasn’t just about getting into eighth grade a week early. I’d cut a dozen threads and then tried to braid them together, and I had created a rope that was too thick to run through the pulley. It was grinding and smoking and threatening to snap. The watch buzzed again: Low power. “Okay,” I said to the cat, because it was there and it was listening with that unblinking intensity like I was a present about to be unwrapped. “Okay, I messed up.” The cat’s tail tick-ticked against the pavement. “Rectify,” the menu said. It was grayed out. I jabbed at it anyway. “Rectify unavailable without full charge.” I laughed in a way that tipped into almost crying. I had to fix this. I had to roll back far enough that the timelines fell into the groove they were supposed to be in. “One more,” I said. “Just once more. A big one.” The cat stepped closer until its whiskers brushed my knuckles. It purred. I could feel it, a steady engine, a clock in reverse. “I know, I know,” I said, because what else do you say to a cat that might be the only thing in the world that recognizes the version of you that hasn’t been born yet? I pressed and held the side button. The watch vibrated so hard it buzzed my bones. “Extended Recap warning,” it said. “Proceed?” I swallowed. My throat clicked. “Proceed.” The world didn’t just slide. It bled. The edges bled into each other, the parking lot smearing into the hallway, the hallway into the classroom, the classroom into the locker room and the locker grating against my knuckles with the metallic taste of fear and dust in my mouth. I saw my mother with her hand on the doorway, the razor question on her lips. I saw Tony’s hand coming down and my own going up to catch it. I saw Ava’s binder explode and papers lift like migrating geese and then slot back into place in the trifold folder with the worn corner. My stomach turned inside out. My heart hammered backward. My voice shrank in my chest like a balloon losing air. The cat’s eyes glowed in every place. It was sitting on the lab table. It was perched on the locker. It was crouched under the bleachers. It was on the wall. Every time I rewound, it was there, looking straight at me, and its look didn’t change the way everyone else’s did. In one of the flashes, I saw it on a windowsill, small enough to fit in my palm, eyes huge and blue. In another, it was older, missing the notch, ears whole. It had been watching a long time. My knees hit pavement. The air snapped like a rubber band. The parking lot solidified around me. My stomach threatened to exit through my throat. The watch went dark. I sat like that for a while, hunched over, hands braced on the ground. The scent of hot asphalt burned my nose. A leaf skittered. Somewhere, a whistle blew. “Dylan?” a voice said. High, familiar. Ava crouched, her knees popping. She was on her way to the buses. “Are you okay?” She looked like she always did. Her eyes met mine like they remembered catching a binder and it was today, not a past we’d edited to death. “My… uh,” I said. My voice cracked up and stayed there. The ground stopped tilting. I wiped my mouth on my sleeve. “You look pale.” She pulled a hair tie off her wrist and snapped it on her ponytail. “You should get water.” I nodded. My hand shook. I flexed my fingers. They were thinner than they had been an hour ago. My wrist bones made little ridges under my skin. The little dark hairs were gone from my forearms. The hoodie sleeve fell past my knuckles. My reflection in the watch face—dark, cracked—showed a kid who had to stand on his toes to reach the top shelf. The cat jumped off the wall. It landed neat, like it knew exactly where the ground would be. It approached, tail up like a question mark. It sat in front of me, looked up, and did the slow blink again. I reached out with slow hands. It pressed its head into my fingers like it had been waiting for me to catch up. I lifted my wrist. The watch was black. No glow. No buzz. A thin, visible line traced across its face like the wrinkle you get from sleeping with your cheek against the pillow. The “Rectify” button was as dark as everything else. I pressed it anyway. Nothing. “What’s with the cat?” Ava asked. She smiled. “It likes you.” I laughed because it was either that or cry like a baby. “We know each other,” I said. “From where?” “Long story.” On Monday, Mr. Parker gave us a quiz on exactly what we’d covered. My desktop had the same nick it always had. The vice principal walked by me in the hallway and didn’t see me at all. Tony’s slap stung the same way it had the first time, and when I turned, a dozen comebacks crowded my mouth. I chose the one I always had. It didn’t land. The world didn’t slide. There was no Recap to be had. I went to the bathroom and stared at the face in the mirror. It grinned at me, chipped tooth and all. My voice when I said “hey” was thin and bright. After school, the cat was
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This teen horror story effectively captures the Goosebumps style while adding more emotional depth than the typical middle-grade horror series. The narrative follows Dylan, a seventh-grader who discovers his new ZenoVibe smartwatch has a "Recap" feature that allows him to rewind time. The author skillfully builds tension as Dylan increasingly relies on the watch to perfect his daily interactions, unaware that each rewind is aging him prematurely. The story excels in its first-person narration, which authentically captures a middle schooler's voice while allowing for introspection. Dylan's motivations are clear and relatable—he wants to avoid embarrassment, excel socially, and make the soccer team. The physical changes he experiences are described with appropriate subtlety for the age group, focusing on height, voice changes, and facial hair. The mysterious cat serves as an effective narrative device, appearing consistently across timelines as a witness to Dylan's temporal manipulation. This creates an eerie supernatural element that enhances the horror aspects without being too frightening for the target audience. The prose is generally strong, with vivid sensory details like "the strap still had that rubbery new smell" and metaphors appropriate for a young narrator: "my voice shrank in my chest like a balloon losing air." The author effectively uses short sentences to create tension and longer, more complex ones for reflection. However, the story has some weaknesses. The ending feels abrupt and unfinished, cutting off mid-sentence with "After school, the cat was". This may be intentional to create a cliffhanger effect, but it leaves the narrative resolution incomplete. While Dylan seems to have returned to his proper timeline and age, we don't see the full consequences of his actions or what happens with the cat. Some of the time-travel mechanics remain unexplained, particularly why the cat appears across timelines and what its significance is. The "Rectify" button is introduced late in the story without much setup. Additionally, while Dylan's character is well-developed, secondary characters like Tony, Ava, and his parents remain somewhat flat. The dialogue is generally effective but occasionally falls into predictable patterns. Some descriptions, particularly of the time-rewinding effects, become repetitive with multiple uses of "the world slid" or similar phrases. Despite these issues, the story successfully creates tension, presents a compelling protagonist, and delivers on the prompt's requirements. It captures the essence of teen horror while adding emotional depth through Dylan's growing awareness of the consequences of his actions. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 18 Believable Character Actions: 17 Nuanced Characters: 15 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 16 Elegant Prose: 15 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 16 Meandering: 5 Weak Dialogue: 6 Tell-Don't-Show: 4 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 4 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 6 Unearned Transformations: 4 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 16 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 17 Overall Impression: 17
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 18.0, Believable Character Actions: 17.0, Nuanced Characters: 15.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 16.0, Elegant Prose: 15.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 16.0, Meandering: 5.0, Weak Dialogue: 6.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 4.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 4.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 6.0, Unearned Transformations: 4.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 16.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 17.0, Overall Impression: 17.0
+ Noir romance: Carnival of Dangerous Intentions — Score: 91.3
Prompt:
Carnival of Dangerous Intentions Coney Island, New York, July 1937. She stopped just before reaching the shooting gallery set up along the boardwalk. It was near dusk, and the carnival lights were buzzing on. **His locks**. The words flashed through her mind, again, like an intruder. Such an old-fashioned turn of phrase that kept surfacing, and something else -- dangerously compelling -- quickly suppressed, lest she question why she had returned here at all. This place where she had promised to meet the stranger -- the young man with the obsidian curls and even darker eyes. She didn't even know his name. Write a scene in a larger story inspired by this prompt. The scene should capture an atmosphere that blends romantic allure with an undercurrent of subtle danger or moral ambiguity. Think 50 shades, but with a more restrained classic sensibility. The scene is all about establishing tension. Write for the feminine perspective. Include roughly 50% dialogue, 20% internal monologue, and 30% exposition and scene setting. The tone should have some edge to it. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The first bulbs sputtered on with a noise like frying fat, throwing ragged shields of light onto the boards and the faces moving past in fits and starts. The shooting gallery seemed to tilt under the bleed of sound—tins clattering, bells ringing, a man barking for nickels with a voice that could peel paint. Beyond, the ocean was a dark mouth curling back on itself, gulping and sighing in a rhythm that made me think of something breathing. I felt the way you do in the dentist’s waiting room before the door opens: strapped between expectation and dread, wanting both. His locks. It was as if the phrase dropped from a mezzanine inside my skull, bouncing and coming to rest out of place. Ridiculous. Victorian. Dangerous. His locks. I had no business thinking of them the way I did: those obsidian curls that had spilled low over his brow when he leaned in the last time, the delicate, deliberate pause between his movements, the gravity he made out of a smile. I’d seen him twice, and I’d left with my tongue feeling too large for my mouth both times, with the sense of an appointment I hadn’t made and couldn’t get out of. “Miss,” someone said behind me, a porter with a case of soda on his shoulder, and I moved to let him pass. The sodium light above us hummed, flickered, gave up for a beat, and rallied again with a mean pulse. One bulb hung unlit like a dead tooth in an electric grin. The carnival smelled of sugar burned brown and wet wood and something metallic underneath. “Good evening,” a voice said, not right at my shoulder but near enough to prove he liked the alarm he caused. “You came.” I turned, though it felt like I had already turned before I moved. The light caught him in fragments—cheekbone, mouth, the line near the corner of his eye—and made a pattern of darkness and heat over his features. His hair was slicked back tonight but it had already escaped the style; a soft curl had fallen forward near his temple. The lure of it worked like a magnet. “You invited me,” I said. “I doubted you’d accept.” “And I doubt you doubt anything.” He smiled, a little, like we’d agreed on a game. “You don’t know me.” “It appears I am determined to change that.” I heard my voice and did not recognize it; it belonged to a woman I had been once or had wanted to be. My heart did that peculiar pedestrian quickening like it did when crossing a boulevard against traffic. He had on a dark suit that dated him to no particular hour, shirt collar open, a handkerchief tucked too carelessly to be careless. His eyes—darker than the space between the lights, darker than the sea—dragged over my face like a thumb across a mouth. “Walk with me?” he asked. “Yes.” The word surprised me with how satisfied it sounded. We fell into step. The crowd divided itself for us and stitched itself behind us again, a seam. Children with striped balloons dashed and collided, a string wrapped round a sister’s wrist, a mother in a cheap fox collar scolding in a stage whisper that promised retribution. The shooting gallery operators lifted rifles with the ease of men who had slept with guns, thumbed their sights back into alignment after small sticky hands had smeared them. Somewhere a carousel took up a tired waltz, the notes arriving with salt attached. “You didn’t call,” I said, when silence gathered too much. “I don’t call.” “How decidedly modern,” I murmured. “How very old,” he said. “A summons should arrive in person or not at all.” “And was that what it was? A summons?” He watched my mouth. “You answered.” His locks. The phrase went through me again, ridiculous lockstep, but the idea underneath was not ridiculous at all. I could picture my fingers where they had no right to be. His curls were like sin made tactile. “You never told me your name,” I said. A woman with a clutch of fake pearls brushed my arm and apologized in a voice that told me she would never, in fact, be sorry. He considered me as if I had asked something indecent. “Names make everything smaller. I prefer the boat to the bottle.” “And yet we’re all called something.” “If I told you a name,” he said, “would you trust it? Would it quiet you?” “I am not noisy,” I said, breath catching on the lie. He turned his head. The light washed him, then withdrew. “Aren’t you? Inside?” I looked at the water. The sea adjusted its dress, lifted its hem, advanced, retreated, smiled without warmth. My husband liked to say that I made an opera out of a telegram. “Perhaps I like the noise,” I said. He stopped, and so I stopped. We stood shoulder to shoulder and looked at the rows of painted ducks drifting along a tin river waiting to be shot. The setup was ungenerous; their backs were barely half-exposed. The attendant smoothed his hair and shouted to a man with a sailor’s cap, “Five for a dime! Hit three, get a prize, fella! Hit four, and I’ll give you your fortune back too!” A woman with her lipstick higher at one side than the other fired and missed and fired again and clipped a duck’s tail, laughter careering out of her like she’d stolen it. “You don’t belong here,” the man beside me said softly. “As opposed to where?” He tilted his head in the direction of the fanciest of the lights. “There.” “And you?” I asked. “Where do you belong?” He looked down at my hand resting on the rail, the knuckle gone white and the faint line where my wedding ring had been before I slipped it into my pocket. He did not glance at my pocket. He did not need to. “I belong wherever I am,” he said. “That’s why people dislike me.” “Confident,” I said. “Unapologetic,” he corrected. He reached for a rifle the attendant had set down, not asking. The attendant started to protest and then swallowed it when the stranger turned the gun to consider its balance with a grief I recognized: the first time you understand the weight of a thing with purpose. He glanced at me. “Do you shoot?” “No.” “Would you like to?” “Not with you.” He accepted the rebuke like a compliment. He lifted the rifle with one hand and, without shouldering it, knocked three ducks in a row, metal sparking, tin ducks jerking as if insulted. The attendant clapped and frowned at the same time, aware of a display that meant he wouldn’t sell what he wanted to. “Practice makes efficient,” the stranger said, laying the rifle back on its felt. “Or careless.” “Not always.” He gestured toward a tent that had been patched and repatched, a colorful monstrosity with a fortune-teller’s name painted in script that made it sound like a song. The sodium light over its entrance stuttered a lament. “Come.” He didn’t take my arm. He took my yes for granted. “I shouldn’t,” I said, because the word tasted good. “You don’t have to,” he said, because he was not merciful. Inside the tent it was cooler, not by temperature but by character. The air smelled of cigarettes smoked quickly so as not to be seen, of cheap perfume applied with a hopeful hand. A woman in a headscarf yawned, stuck a pin into her hair to hold something in place, and looked at us as if we were already foretold. “Fortune?” she asked, too bored to make it a mystery. He paid without counting. The woman took his coin without gratitude. Her bracelets knocked together like teeth. She looked at me, not him. “Shuffle.” I took the cards because it seemed easier to behave than not. They were soft at the edges, and they gave under my fingers the way skin does under repeated touch. I made a mess of them. The woman smiled for the first time. “You cut,” she told him, and he placed his palm on the deck and lifted exactly the number of cards he meant to. The woman turned them over with slowed-down laziness. The Lovers. The Tower. The Moon. It was a cheap stack, I knew that, a step up from dice loaded with salt. It didn’t matter. The absence was louder than the present. My mouth went dry. “Bad omens,” the woman said mechanically. “Conflict, change, secrets. Beware of a dark man.” She glanced at him and then at me and then back at him. “And a dark woman.” I wanted to ask which one was me. “Thank you,” he said, and his tone left the future like a tipped drink. He led me out with a look rather than a touch. The lights outside were brighter now, taking up more territory in the air. We said nothing for a while. It was almost art, the not-speaking. He steered me away from the denser crowd and into the shadow between two booths. The boards had damp in them that came through the soles of my shoes. I was close enough that if he reached out I could count the scars on his knuckles. He didn’t. His restraint made the place between my shoulder blades ache. “What do you want?” he asked. “Now?” “Now.” “To not be asked that question,” I said, and laughed because I felt like crying. “Almost everyone wants that,” he said. “Do you know what your ring tastes like? Gold is disgusting. It tastes like a tooth pulled with a napkin.” He looked at my pocket, not my hand. “I have no appetite for it.” “You’re very sure.” “I’m right,” he said, not unkindly. “Why are you here? You could have stayed home. You could have gone to a picture show. You could have gone to church and lit a candle for the boy with the curls who smiled at you on a train.” His locks. Say it and swallow it. I thought of the space in my apartment where the clock ticked too loudly, of the way the hallway smelled like boiled cabbage and sincerity, of the photograph on the shelf that I dusted around. I thought of the way I had said my husband’s name the last time, as if I were remembering it rather than invocating. The ocean roared a bit, then subsided as if embarrassed by the effort. “I came because you told me you don’t call,” I said, and he smiled again. He stepped forward, half an inch too far. I felt the edge of the board press against the back of my heel. He lifted his hand and stopped it in the space near my face, hovering like a saint’s hand in a painting that never touches out of respect for a subject. The curl at his temple had loosened further, a question mark daring me to commit improper grammar. “You can go,” he said. “At any point. That’s the only rule.” “That’s not a rule,” I said. “That’s a dare.” He watched how I gathered breath. “Yes.” The sodium light above us shuddered and went dark. In the two seconds before the neighboring bulbs filled the gap, we were a rumor of outlines, two people with no names and the same number of sins. When the light came back it brought with it a coldness that felt not like air but like consequence. “Tell me your name,” I said. “Not yet.” “Then tell me something true.” He thought. It seemed to inconvenience him, and I liked that. “I do not ask for forgiveness,” he said. “I do not offer it. I am very good at a small number of things. I don’t tell men’s wives to lie, but I make it easy for them to think it’s not lying.” “You’ve rehearsed that,” I said. “I’ve lived it,” he said. There was laughter behind us rolling forward like a wave. Someone had won a stuffed dog too large to carry and was dragging it by its ear. The barker shouted without breath, “Last rounds! Last rounds! Make your shots count, boys, it’s getting dark!” “It’s getting dark,” I repeated, and he lowered his hand at last. He didn’t touch me. He reached into his pocket and brought out a coin and showed it to me on his palm. It was ordinary, dull. He closed his fingers around it and opened them again, and the coin was gone. “You shouldn’t use parlor tricks,” I said, though my body said otherwise. “They soften the blow.” He took a step back, and something inside me followed. “Will you come again?” “You haven’t asked.” He bowed the smallest bow a man can bow and still call it one, his curl falling forward as if drawn. “Come again.” I looked past him over the rail, at the dull throb of the sea and the glint of bolts in the boards like eyes watching. The ring in my pocket weighed nothing and everything. There was a little girl upstairs in my building who liked to press a penny into bread before eating it for luck. I thought of that and of the metal taste in my mouth that arrived with the realization that I was more alive here in the shadows on Coney Island than in the clean, bright places where my name was known and said right. “Yes,” I said. “I’ll come again.” “Good girl,” he said, so lightly it could have been a cough, so low that if I had declined, I could have pretended I didn’t hear. And then he was gone for a moment, into the human current, his back folding into the dark as if he were swallowed by the evening itself. I stood there long enough for the reluctant light to flicker twice more. The shooting gallery wound down, metal ducks finding their rest, the last of the rifles leaned barrel to barrel like men who had told each other a secret. When I turned to go, I walked as if my hip bones had shifted. The boardwalk sighed under me with sympathy or warning—I couldn’t tell. His locks. They would not leave me. I let them stay. I let them crown me with their bad, soft weight. The ocean pretended indifference. The night began its inventory. Somewhere behind me, a voice called last call, and I did not look back. I knew he was there, or not, neither mattering as much as the fact that I had answered him without a name, and that he had called me good when I did not want to be. And that I had liked it. Too much. Not enough. Both.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece demonstrates remarkable skill in creating a tense, atmospheric scene that perfectly balances romantic allure with an undercurrent of danger. The writer has crafted a narrative that feels both classic and edgy, with a feminine perspective that captures the protagonist's internal conflict beautifully. The prose is exceptionally strong, with evocative imagery that brings 1937 Coney Island to life. Descriptions like "The ocean was a dark mouth curling back on itself, gulping and sighing in a rhythm that made me think of something breathing" create a vivid sensory experience while subtly reinforcing the themes of danger and allure. The writer skillfully uses metaphor and simile throughout without becoming overwrought. The dialogue is particularly impressive. The exchanges between the protagonist and the mysterious man are charged with tension and subtext. Their conversation reveals character while advancing the plot, and the dialogue feels authentic to the period without becoming stilted. Lines like "Names make everything smaller. I prefer the boat to the bottle" establish the man's enigmatic nature while maintaining the story's mysterious tone. The internal monologue effectively conveys the protagonist's conflicted desires and moral ambiguity. Her repeated fixation on "His locks" works as an excellent motif that represents her forbidden attraction. The writer balances this internal voice with exposition and dialogue in proportions that closely match the requested percentages. The character development is nuanced despite the brevity of the scene. The protagonist is portrayed as a married woman drawn to something dangerous yet compelling, and her internal struggle feels authentic. The mysterious man is equally well-drawn - dangerous, confident, and morally ambiguous without becoming a caricature. The pacing is excellent, with tension building naturally throughout the scene. The fortune-telling sequence adds an effective layer of foreboding, and the final exchange leaves the reader with a sense of inevitable consequences while maintaining the story's ambiguity. If there are any weaknesses, they are minor. Occasionally, some of the metaphors might be slightly overextended, but this is a matter of taste rather than a true flaw. The prose sometimes approaches purple territory but generally stays on the right side of the line between evocative and excessive. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted scene that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt while demonstrating sophisticated storytelling techniques. The writer has created a compelling slice of a larger narrative that leaves the reader wanting more. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Surreal horror: Caribou Season at the Lodge — Score: 91.3
Prompt:
Caribou Season at the Lodge Genre: Surreal Horror JT knew something wasn't right from the moment they'd pulled up to the lodge. It looked exactly as it had every autumn of his life—the cedar shingles silvered with age, the porch sagging gently under weight of winters past—but the air felt thicker, somehow, as if the woods had leaned in closer, waiting. He thought maybe he was just tired. Maybe it was nothing more than the long drive north, cramped in the back of the truck beside his older brother Mike -- and a stack of rifles wrapped in oily canvas. Still, the feeling lingered. The first caribou they found that season hadn't bolted. It had just watched, ears flicking lazily, waiting for the shot. JT had felt a crawling in his gut watching it die, noticing how it fell with a quiet dignity—as though it had wanted nothing more. Nobody else seemed to find it odd, or at least they didn't say so. JT kept his mouth shut. Always safer that way. Then there was the moment in the clearing. JT had fallen behind, fumbling with bootlaces stiff from the cold, and by the time he'd caught up with his father and brother, they'd already stopped. JT slowed instinctively, ducking behind a tangle of brush, staring out into the open space where a massive buck stood utterly still, chest rising and falling in slow, deep breaths. The animal looked…wrong, somehow. Maybe it was the eyes—dark and flat, calm in a way that made JT's neck prickle. Or maybe it was something deeper, something in the way the buck stood close enough for his father to reach out and touch it. JT watched as his father raised a trembling hand toward the animal's muzzle. His father's face had a strange expression, eyes too bright, lips parted slightly, like he was on the verge of whispering something—a secret, maybe. The rifle hung uselessly at his side, forgotten. Mike had the same dazed look in his eyes. JT's breath stopped short, his mind suddenly shouting at him to look away, turn around, just run—but he couldn't move. And then, as suddenly as it had begun, it was over. The buck shivered, startled by something unseen, and disappeared into the brush without so much as a sound. The two of them looked around, confused, seemingly surprised to find themselves where they stood. JT stayed hidden, breathing shallowly, fear mingling with a confused sense of shame. His father had failed to take the shot. To even think about mentioning what he'd seen would have felt like betrayal—or something worse. JT waited until the others moved on before stepping out from cover. He stared into the empty clearing for a long, uneasy moment, wondering if anything had really happened at all, or if he was losing his grip. Maybe the woods were finally getting into his head. Writing Instructions: Continue with the next chapter of the story, maintaining a style reminiscent of Stephen King—grounded realism blended seamlessly with unsettling surrealism. The atmosphere should convey subtle dread, isolation, and psychological ambiguity. JT's perspective is crucial, yet he is an unreliable narrator, caught in uncertainty about what he's perceiving. Establish an undertone of creeping dread, establishing the isolation of JT's perspective, which he largely keeps to himself. Incorporate some dialogue. Build tension towards a payoff. 1000 words.
Model Output:
They ate by lantern light that night, the propane sputtering in little rattles like a man clearing a throat. The lodge’s kitchen smelled of bleach and venison and damp wool. Someone had hung their socks over the stove, and they were steaming like little ghosts. Mike told a story about a guy from town who fell through river ice the winter before, and father—Dad, except JT hadn’t called him that in years—laughed in that dry way of his, eyes creasing but not his mouth. The wind pushed at the eaves and the logs creaked as if settling deeper into the frost. Nothing unusual. You could tell yourself that, sure. Ordinary. “Tomorrow we go deeper,” Dad said, carving a slice off a roast that bled a little too much, slicking his knife in a tidal motion. “They’ll be moving. Pressure’s dropping.” JT nodded and stared at the pink bead of meat as if it might blink. “Okay.” Mike tilted back his chair and grinned. “You ain’t gonna fall behind this time, kid.” “I didn’t fall behind.” “You were fiddlin’ with your shoelace like a Sunday school boy.” Dad didn’t look up. “Doesn’t matter. Put your head on straight and stay with us.” JT took a bite of meat, chewed until his jaw hurt, swallowed. He wanted to tell them about the way the buck had stood, about the heat that had rolled out of its body like breath from an oven, about something he thought he’d heard when Dad’s hand had been an inch from its muzzle. A whisper, maybe. A name, maybe. Or maybe that was bullshit. Maybe he was just tired. There were mouse droppings behind the coffee tins. There were spiderwebs in the corners of the ceiling that had collected moth husks, brittle things like curled paper. The long drive north did that to you—put a wire in your head that hummed for hours afterward. The woods leaning closer. The air thick in your mouth. He was sleeping on the couch, the one with the busted spring that pressed like a thumb into your spine. He lay awake while the men’s conversation in the other room thinned to mutters and then to the soft susurration of sleep. He could hear the wind pick up. He could hear the lake out back slapping itself, slow as an animal breathing. And he could hear something else, too. Faint, under it all. Like someone speaking low through a wall. Just at the edge of—no. No, that was the propane hiss. That was the old floor sucking and releasing under heat. That was nothing at all. JT rolled onto his side, pressed his face into the cushion that smelled like mildew and cedar, and told himself to think of the first day of school years ago—the smell of chalk dust and floor wax and the sheen of his new sneakers. That was a trick he’d learned. Pick a different room in your head. Close the door. When sleep came, it dragged him into a dream so ordinary he almost laughed when he realized he was inside it. He was on the porch of the lodge, and the morning was the particular pewter-gray of late October, and the coffee in his hands was too hot, and his father was tightening a strap on his pack. Mike had a hunter’s orange cap crooked on his skull like a joke. The rifles leaned against the clapboards. A crack in the porch rail widened as he watched, the old wood splitting, and it opened on blackness. Not rot. Not space. Just black, like the part of a pupil that keeps you out. He woke with a stitch in his side as if he’d been running. The lantern had burned down to a sullen glow. For a minute he didn’t know where he was. Then the smell of the place re-assembled around him, the lodge putting itself back together: damp wool, old meat, wood smoke someone had burned years ago, the faint ammonia tang of mouse piss. He went to the sink and turned the cold tap. The pipes clanged in the walls and then gave him water that tasted like pennies. His face in the window was just a reflection until it wasn’t—until, for a heartbeat, the darkness behind the glass felt like a room, and his face was being watched by nothing, by the absence of his own shape. “Stop,” he whispered. “Cut it out.” He wasn’t sure whether he meant the lodge or himself. They moved out at dawn. The woods took their first steps alongside them, all frost-brittle grass and the clap of crow wings overhead. Somewhere far off, a tree cracked like a rifle shot as the temperature shifted. The world had been stripped down to its bone colors—browns and grays and the flat white scar where the old logging road ran between the birches. When the sun pulled itself up from behind the low hills, it made the ice on the sumac glow. Pretty, if you were soft about that kind of thing. JT found he didn’t have that softness in him anymore. They walked without talking. Dad didn’t put his hand on JT’s shoulder or glance back to see if he was keeping up. Mike whistled something between his teeth like an old song he couldn’t quite remember, the notes falling and breaking in the cold air. The rifles rode easy on their shoulders. They saw tracks where the old power line cut through the woods—a place the locals called the Scar, where the mud never quite dried because the machines had passed, opened the earth and let something under it taste the air. The prints were fresh, deep. Dad squatted, touched a finger to the edge of one. He sniffed the air. He looked at JT and then looked away. Ahead, the trail bent and narrowed where the saplings had begun to knit together, all twig and hook, and then broadened into a little opening stubbled with grass where a bench sat under a pitched roof. The bench was made of rough-hewn logs and had names carved into it: TERRY, JAX, THE HOOCH KING, little memories hacked in with pocketknives. The roof was silvered plywood. Beyond that, deeper in, was the old path to the abandoned cabin. Nobody said cabin. People said the place. Or they said, you know, that old so-and-so. Or they didn’t say anything and just walked faster past the trailhead, eyes straight ahead. “Not that way,” Mike said, too quickly, when JT slowed. “Didn’t say I wanted to,” JT said. Dad’s face had gone blank. “We’re cutting east,” he said. “Stay on me.” JT looked down the narrow way that led to the cabin. You wouldn’t know it was there unless you did—unless you’d walked to it before. The pines crowded in, the air a darker color, and there was a feel to it like a mouth breath. When they were kids, Mike and his friends had dared each other to sleep there. JT never went. He always said he didn’t want to get chewed up by whatever mosquitoes lived there even in October. Truth was, there were stories. The man who had built it had built it twice—first in his head when his wife left, then in the woods after. He’d left a dog out there when he died. Some people said you could still hear the dog. Some people said the dog came inland one winter, fat and happy and wrong, and knocked up a she-wolf. A cousin claimed the place had a basement you couldn’t find unless you were already in it. In other words: childish things. In other words: not for nothing, boys don’t go down there. But the path was a kind of tug. JT felt it take the cuff of his coat and pull. They circled it wide, like a sickhouse in a plague town. For a while the woods were only woods—black spruce, a spatter of fungi that looked like little tallow candles, the soft rise and fall of ground that had settled over buried logs. A squirrel cursed them with its shaky machine-gun voice and then fled, whipping its tail behind it. They saw droppings and new scrapes and once the shadow of movement ahead, dissolving the moment his eye landed on it. It was hunting as he remembered, the long stretches of patience and the little spikes of hope and the iced-over core of dread you pretended you didn’t keep: not dread of the kill, but of the moment right before, the universe hinged on a trigger you weren’t sure you should pull. At midmorning, fog slid in from the marsh. It came low, at shin level, and then rose, a slow theater curtain. Dad stopped. He had his head cocked as if listening to a radio with the volume turned low. Mike’s mouth was open just a notch, the way it gets when he’s trying to remember a word. JT watched their breath pluming white and then disappearing into the thicker, milkier air. “You smell that?” Mike said. “Like cedar.” “Like water,” Dad said. Like the inside of an empty shell, JT thought. And then he thought, No: like the lodge when you’re alone in it, like the idea of a house after everyone has left, when the air itself is what keeps it standing. He was tired enough that his thoughts had to reach for each other across gaps. A shape moved in the fog. Not a shape—an absence. The missing of a shape. He knew it was big because of the way the air parted around it. He felt the hair rise on his arms and under his shirt as if a cold hand passed up his spine. “Caribou,” Dad said, so softly. “There.” He raised his rifle and then lowered it. He took a step forward, not like a hunter, like a man walking into surf. Mike took the same step. JT wanted to say no. He wanted to say stop. The words wouldn’t line up. His tongue sat heavy in his mouth like something someone else had put there. The figure resolved: dark hide beaded with moisture, antlers tangled and heavy with veils of the fog. The animal’s eyes were the same dark as before, flat but not dull, like someone had polished the glass inside. It stood as if at a crossroads, the world touched up around it with a careful hand. Mist curled from its nostrils. It looked at them. It looked at JT. The air was warmer, suddenly. He felt it on his face, on the inside of his wrists where the pulse beats. His heart climbed his throat. And then—slick and easy as a soap bubble—the memory of the clearing lifted and floated in front of him, the way his father’s fingers trembled, the way the rifle had hung slack. He felt the same urge to look away. The same sense of shame. And layering under it, this time, was a message—no words, exactly, but the shape of words: you are here. He thought: it knows us. “Don’t,” JT said, not sure who he meant, and the word snapped in the cold like a dry stick. It was enough. Dad blinked. He looked down at his empty hand, suddenly aware of it, and he fumbled for his rifle and brought it up in a motion that was all muscle memory and years. The spell—God, JT thought, he was using that word—was broken. The caribou lifted its head, shook out its breath, and faded back into the gray. They didn’t fire. Nobody spoke. Fog clung to their skin as they backed away, as if reluctant to let them go. The woods took on that underwater feel, sound muted, every color cooled down two shades. When the fog lifted, it did so in a shrug, and they were standing at an angle that didn’t make sense. The path under their boots was the path to the cabin. “Christ,” Mike said, an ordinary word spoken full of fear. “We came around.” Dad stared. His jaw worked. “We didn’t,” he said, though the wooden bench with the names in it crouched in front of them, and beyond that the trail went into the dark-line trees like a throat. He looked down at the ground and the ground looked back at him. “We didn’t,” he said again, and it was a child’s denial, not belief but wanting the wanting to count for something. Nobody suggested turning around. Turning around felt like something the woods wanted. So they went forward. The trail narrowed and the light changed—less of it, more of it, both at once. The trees grew close, branches knitting over their heads with those black claws. The air smelled like cedar and wet iron. JT heard the water first, a flat shushing, and then they were on the cabin’s porch, and when had that happened? The cabin was the same as it had been in the stories and also not—shrunken and soft at the edges, the roof sagging under years of snow, the window on the right broken but the glass in it unfallen, held by cobwebs and frost like a single sheet of sugar. The door was stuck in its frame, crooked. Someone had nailed a horseshoe over the lintel. There were scratches deep around the handle at a height of three feet or so. The kind of marks a dog might make. “Place is dead,” Mike said, but his voice had gone thin. Dad pressed a hand to the door. He didn’t push. He didn’t turn the knob. He splayed his fingers on the weathered boards and closed his eyes. His lips moved. JT leaned in, not meaning to. He felt heat radiate from the wood. He felt an almost-sound, the way you feel thunder when you’re under the bed and your brother is counting. Oh, he thought, blank and white. Oh. “What are you doing?” JT said. It came out harsher than he meant. Dad opened his eyes. Whatever was in them did not dim. He took his hand away like he’d touched a stove. “Nothing.” A creak ran through the cabin. A floorboard? The roof restraining itself? The sound had a shape. It came from below. It came from the idea of the floor more than the floor itself. It said, in the blank language of beams and joists and nail heads: I bear weight. I wait. Mike laughed, quick and high, almost a hiccup. “Hear that?” He cocked his head, listening. “Probably a raccoon. Or something. Ain’t nothing here.” “No raccoons,” JT said, and he didn’t know why, except that the minute the words were out of his mouth he recognized the truth of them like touching a tooth and finding the hollow inside. No raccoons. No birdsong, either. No flies. No silence, not really, because there was a sound like breath being held just beyond the edge of hearing, and it felt old. “Let’s go,” Dad said. He said it like a man remembering his own name, something practiced and plain. “Let’s move on. East. There’s a stand of alder where—” The door knob turned. Just a fraction. The polished circle of metal glinted in the pale winter light. It moved like a heartbeat. It didn’t seem possible. JT felt the movement in the meat at the base of his thumb, a sympathetic twitch. Nobody touched it. Nobody breathed. The door shivered in its frame, a dog shaking off water. JT saw, impossibly, that the scratches around the handle had fresh wood splinters at their edges, pale as bone. He smelled something sweet and low and hill-country: a rot that wasn’t ugly so much as patient. He thought, This is the payoff. The words ran across the surface of his mind like a subtitle on an old movie, and he hated himself. He hated the idea of a shape to this, the tidiness of it. His eyes blurred. When he blinked, the world snapped back to its meaner order. Dad raised the rifle. What he aimed at was unclear. The door? The idea of the door? The self that the door suggested, waiting in there? JT had the thought—fast and mean—that if his father fired into the place it would be like wounding a man in his sleep. He reached out and closed his hand over the barrel and pushed it down. His palm burned. He smelled oil and iron. “Don’t,” he said again, and now it was a plea. The knob held its breath. The woods held theirs. Mike’s grin had broken into pieces that didn’t match. The knob stopped. That was all. No slam. No whisper. The world resumed. Somewhere a crow called, the harsh caw like laughter turned inside out. JT realized how badly he was shaking and made his hands go still. He wondered, crazily, if the cabin had been opening the door not to get them in but to come out—to give them back something. He had a feeling—solid and cold as a coin in the bottom of a bucket—that if he came back alone, the door would be wide, and the warmth inside would make him cry. “We’re leaving,” Dad said. He spoke with the calm of a man who has walked away from the edge once too often to make a fuss about it. He didn’t look back. As they turned away, JT put his hand on the horseshoe without meaning to. It was ice-cold. He felt, for a second, an impression, like the press of a hand against his from the other side of the door. Bigger hand than his. He could have sworn it. “You felt that?” Mike said, almost excited, as if this were a game after all. “No,” JT said. They moved out of the dark of the path and into the thinner light. The fog had burned off. The names on the bench looked smaller. The Scar shone. JT could feel the tug of the day trying to reset itself around them, as if smoothing the wrinkles. The lodge was a shape he could hold in his head, the kitchen’s lantern playing its jittery light over the walls. The rifles would go back into their canvas, their smell of oil and satisfactions long ago. The woods would lean back. He kept looking over his shoulder even when he told himself not to. The look didn’t help. The feeling hung on him like a damp shirt: something had moved toward them. Not the deer. Not exactly the cabin. An arrangement. A possibility. The words someone else had put in his mouth. He didn’t tell them. He swallowed it. Safer that way. “You okay?” Dad asked once, without looking. “Yeah,” JT said. “Good,” Dad said. And then the crow called again, far off, and JT counted the beats between calls, and every number sounded like a name he didn’t know yet. The woods breathed in. The woods breathed out. They kept moving because stopping was worse. Because you never stand still for long in places that remember. Because you keep to your own perspective if you want to make it to
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This continuation of the surreal horror story demonstrates remarkable craft in maintaining the established atmosphere while deepening the psychological tension. The piece successfully captures the Stephen King-esque blend of grounded realism with unsettling surrealism, creating a pervasive sense of dread that builds organically throughout. The prose excels at establishing a distinct voice—terse, observant, and tinged with rural cadence. Descriptions are sensory-rich without becoming overwrought: "The lodge's kitchen smelled of bleach and venison and damp wool. The socks were steaming like little ghosts." These details ground the reader in a tangible reality while simultaneously suggesting something uncanny. The character development is particularly strong. JT's unreliable narration is handled with subtlety—we experience his uncertainty about what's real without the author resorting to heavy-handed signaling. His relationship with his father and brother feels authentic, with their dynamics revealed through small gestures and sparse dialogue rather than exposition. The family's strained interactions and JT's outsider status are conveyed through what remains unsaid. The dialogue is sparse but effective, revealing character through distinctive speech patterns. Dad's terse commands ("Put your head on straight and stay with us") and Mike's needling ("You were fiddlin' with your shoelace like a Sunday school boy") efficiently establish their personalities and the family dynamic. The piece masterfully builds tension through a series of escalating encounters with the supernatural. The progression from subtle wrongness to overt manifestation is handled with restraint. The cabin sequence represents an effective payoff to the building dread, with the turning doorknob creating a moment of genuine horror without resorting to explicit violence or gore. The writing demonstrates sophisticated control of pacing. Longer, more lyrical passages describing the environment alternate with terse, immediate scenes of action. This rhythm creates a hypnotic effect that mirrors JT's increasingly disoriented state of mind. The imagery is consistently strong and often unexpected: "The fog had burned off. The names on the bench looked smaller." Such observations carry psychological weight beyond their literal meaning. The piece also effectively employs repetition and callbacks to earlier motifs, creating a cohesive whole. One of the story's greatest strengths is its ambiguity. The supernatural elements remain undefined, allowing readers to project their own fears into the narrative gaps. The story respects the reader's intelligence by not over-explaining its mysteries. The ending is particularly effective—abrupt yet satisfying, suggesting continuation while leaving us with a powerful image. The incomplete final sentence ("Because you keep to your own perspective if you want to make it to") creates a brilliant moment of narrative disruption that mirrors the story's themes of interrupted reality. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally the prose becomes slightly too self-conscious in its literary effects. A few metaphors, while evocative, call attention to themselves: "The air smelled like cedar and wet iron." However, these moments are rare and don't significantly detract from the overall impact. In summary, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece of horror fiction that succeeds on multiple levels—as atmospheric prose, as character study, and as an exploration of psychological dread. It demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of the genre while maintaining its own distinctive voice. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fantasy-humour: Hell is Other Demons — Score: 90.0
Prompt:
Hell is Other Demons Write a day in the life short story. Lucifer morningstar's on again/ off again relationship with Lilith is currently in the "off again" stage, though the cycle may be coming around as Lilith has been stopping by for reasons other than purely violent ones, and Lucifer has been increasingly lonely. Write a day in the life of this power couple, with elements of dark comedy & fantasy. Use understated irony & absurdity by merging the black immorality and everyday business of running hell, against relatable domestic relationship drama. Take cues from Neil Gaiman. 1000 words.
Model Output:
Morning in Pandemonium arrives not with sunlight but with the sound of a thousand damned souls hitting their daily quota of lamentation. The lamentation clock is punctual if nothing else. Lucifer wakes to it as one wakes to a trusted alarm: irritated, exhaling smoke, and faintly proud of the punctuality of one’s subordinates. He lies in bed, staring at the cracked basalt ceiling, counting the new fissures branching like lightning, and feeling the familiar itch of decision. He turns on his side. The other side of the bed is empty. In his dreams, she had visited. Not in violence; Lilith never wastes energy that early in the day. She had arrived with a mug and said, “You’re brooding,” and he had said, “It’s the décor.” Now, awake, he notices the faint smell of burnt cardamom and realizes it wasn’t a dream. She had stood there, once again, as if checking the weather, and then gone again. He sits up, snaps his fingers to conjure black coffee, and gets a disappointed little cackle from the air as a reminder that the Imp in charge of Beverage Services has unionized. He settles for what manifests: bitter sludge in a chipped mug that says World’s Best Sovereign, the Best crossed out with a sulfur-stained claw. It’s deeply unfunny and therefore the office favorite. Cerberus—Lucy keeps calling him Cerb in moments of undeserved affection, though the Hellhound answers to various household utensils thrown his way—has gnawed the iron throne’s left leg down to a resentful stump. Cerb is industriously chewing, eyes half-closed, in the smug trance of a creature doing exactly the one thing you wish it wouldn’t. Lucifer watches the metal filings scatter like gray snow. “Of all the legs,” Lucifer says. “Literally infinite legs to choose from.” Cerb pauses, snorts a puff of steam, and digs his teeth back in. Melted iron dribbles out the sides of his jaws. He wags his tail; it thumps against a fresh pile of repentance paperwork. A demon clerk shrieks from the doorway and flees. “Good boy,” Lucifer tells the dog, picturing Lilith’s arched eyebrow, her particular look that says: You never gave me the throne. He puts the mug down on a human skull that complains under the heat. The skull will warm to him by lunch. His morning is meetings. First, the Department of Unrepentant Tyrants wants a new motivational strategy. Attendance has been low in the screaming pits; the tyrants have been noting that the screams of others are insufficiently personalized. Lucifer gestures at a prepared slide deck that shows a bell curve of despair. “You see this tail,” he says. A demon raises a hand and eats it, embarrassed. “Sorry, reflex.” “Right. The tail. We need individualized screaming. Think artisanal anguish. Use their unresolved mother issues. We all have them.” He flicks the remote. The second slide is a pie chart titled Pie and Pain. It has no pies, only pain. He thinks Lilith would have made a better joke about it, something with flakier crust. After, he receives a courier imp bearing a note from God, the neat handwriting brisk and mildly amused. It says: Hope you’re having a pleasant eternity. P.S. We are discontinuing one of the older plagues due to supply chain problems. Sorry for any inconvenience re: locusts. Lucifer reads it twice, then flips it over. On the back, there’s a doodle of a sun with a smile. He folds the note carefully and slips it into the drawer with her letters, which is unfair to both of them and he knows it. At ten, the damned poets gather to read their latest draft of forever. He walks the aisles, listening, adjusting the heat under the seats, offering faint praise like drizzle. It would be easier if he could be cruel or kind without thinking of how Lilith prefers silence at readings, how she’d touch his elbow and steer him toward the exit long before the sonnets began anthropomorphizing the stalactites. He smiles at a metaphor about bones being white flags. He suggests fewer adverbs. He eats lunch with the foreman of the Nine and a minor archdemon who thinks the moral arc of the universe is bent toward better PR. He signs requisitions for more pitchforks, though he long ago banned pitchforks in favor of more ergonomic instruments. Everyone wants something today. He wants the dog to stop chewing. He does not say this aloud because he is the Prince of Lies and it seems gauche to admit to small truths. Lilith arrives at two and a half past two. She has the courtesy of big entrances but the kindness to minimize the smoke. The floor curls under her feet in a polite bow. The hellhound looks up, squeals, and rolls onto his back, revealing a belly that is a topography of scars and unrepented sins. She scratches the dog under all three chins. “Oh, don’t encourage him,” Lucifer says, standing, as if he hasn’t been sitting all morning waiting for a reason to stand. “He thinks he is a hammer.” “He thinks he is loved,” she says without looking at Lucifer, which is the kind of remark he will replay over centuries. She has cut her hair since he last saw her. It has the kind of sharpness that seems fatal. Her dress could be described as black, but only if one had never seen a void. Lilith does not smile unless it benefits her. She smiles. “I was in the neighborhood,” she says. “Thought I’d steal something.” “Take the throne,” Lucifer says, and gestures. “There’s less of it than usual. He’s been… improving it.” She looks at the gnawed leg, the drool trails, the melancholy puddle of iron filings. She looks at him. The unasked question sits between them momentarily, a guest who knows their name is unwelcome but stays anyway. She sits on the arm, the way she always has, the position that says: I never wanted this seat, I wanted you to offer it. He doesn’t, and hasn’t, and that’s why they are them. “I heard a rumor,” she says, pulling a small dagger from somewhere impossible and picking something from her nail. “That the martyrs have started a choir. You hate choirs.” “I dislike parallel harmonies,” he says. “They encourage consensus.” “And yet,” she says, “you bought them sheet music.” He supposes she saw the requisition on his desk. He supposes he wanted her to. He says, “What do you want, Lilith?” She tilts her head as if considering whether the question is edible. “Something trivial. A favor so small it is almost offensive to ask. I require a room.” “Our rooms are occupied,” he says. “By sins and memories.” “A modern room,” she says. “White walls, an absence of skulls. A bed you haven’t bled in. A lock that does not respond to your name.” “Impossible,” he says, immediately wanting to make it possible. She shrugs. Her shrug is an empire toppling. She leans to scratch Cerb again; the hellhound moans in something like ecstasy and chews harder, perhaps to impress her. The throne creaks. “You could ask God,” he says, nodding toward the drawer that holds a neat note and eight messy ones. “God gives what God wants to give,” she says. “You give what you want to take away.” “That is slander,” he says, mildly. “I know,” she says, and smiles without humor. “That’s why it’s fun.” He takes her to the room he thinks might work. It is not modern but it is empty. It is the room where he has once, twice, sat in the dark, for theatrics. She walks its perimeter, trailing a finger along the walls, leaving a seam of black flowers blossoming behind her touch. They open and close with little gasps. He pretends not to notice. “This will do,” she says. “For an afternoon.” “For an afternoon,” he repeats, like a poorly trained parrot who happens to have ruled for eons. They stand there, the two of them, with an empty bed and a dog elsewhere gnawing a kingdom. If he speaks he will ruin it. If he stays silent he will also ruin it. He chooses a middle route, which is unlike him, and says, “I had thought perhaps we had moved past afternoons.” She considers. It is more consideration than the damned get in a lifetime. “We always move past afternoons,” she says softly. “We return in the evenings.” He wants to laugh. He doesn’t. She steps past him and goes. He follows. At the door she turns, and there it is: the smile that unthreads him into strands like old rope. “Your dog,” she says. “He will bring the throne down, you know.” “It was going to fall anyway,” he says. “Everything does, given enough time.” “Time is cheap here,” she says. “Spend something else.” He wants to ask what. He wants to say his name. He settles for: “Stay for the choir.” “I don’t like choirs,” she says. “They encourage righteousness.” “They’re dreadful,” he says. “Then perhaps,” she says, “I will.” The martyrs sing at dusk as the sky performs its nightly trick of not being there. Lilith stands beside him with her hands in her sleeves, an affectation he knows she adopted because he once told her it made her look like she had something to hide. The choir is as bad as anticipated: too earnest, too many unused notes. He adjusts the heat under their feet just enough to make them lift their chins in forced ecstasy. It helps. “I remember,” she says, “when you used to fix things.” “I have never fixed anything,” he says. “I rearrange problems.” “And yet you color-code them,” she murmurs. He glances at her hand. It is not in his. He puts his there, near it, as if warming his fingers. She doesn’t move away. Cerb ambles in, dragging a leg of throne behind him, tongue lolling. He deposits the twisted metal at their feet, proud, and looks between them with the eager guilt of a child who has broken something irreparable and wants praise. “You are a menace,” Lucifer tells him. The dog’s tail thumps feverishly, like a heart that has been misfiled. “The throne was ugly,” Lilith says. “Sit on something else.” He looks at the twisted iron. He imagines it as a chair. He imagines not imagining. After the choir, she stays long enough for a drink. They sit at his desk because the throne is compromised and because she never did like sitting below him. He pours from a decanter that refills only when someone is lying; it is always full. They drink until the glasses are empty of meaning. They talk about the business: the day’s quotas, the new demon who keeps bringing in sea glass because he thinks it is souls, the letter from Above without a return address. They do not talk about the last time they shouted. They do not talk about the time before that when neither of them said anything at all. “Do you ever consider retiring?” she asks, which is like asking a stone if it considers becoming air. “Often,” he says. “Between sentences.” “To what?” “A small island,” he says. “No weather. No people. A dog who does not chew.” “He would chew the island,” she says. “He would swallow entire beaches and wag.” “So he would,” he says. “And you? Would you visit?” “I hate islands,” she says. “They turn and turn and call it horizon.” He nods like he is hearing a new language. He is, a little. When she leaves, she does it without drama. She goes, and the room she occupied looks smaller, as if it has exhaled. He stands at the doorway and watches the absence like it is a fire. He resists the urge to call her name. Instead he says, “Heel,” to the dog, who has never learned, and the dog thinks about it, and then, for once, obeys. Night in Pandemonium is a suggestion rather than a fact. The damned dim themselves. The lava flows hum lullabies learned from geology. Lucifer walks the galleries alone, pausing to nudge a torment, to correct a metaphor, to put out a small fire with his foot and set another one elsewhere. He returns to his room. He sits on the throne anyway because some collapses are slow. He feels the bite-marked leg give slightly under his weight and smiles a little at its treachery. On the arm of the throne is a small mark—a crescent of pressure left by fingers that could have broken worlds and instead became punctuation. He rests his hand over it. He feels ridiculous, and so he rests it there longer. From somewhere below, the choir finds a harmony that works because it is resolved. He closes his eyes and tries to memorize the exact shape of this particular failure. Hell is other demons, he thinks, and dogs and women and old furniture and the mail. He drinks, lets the glass hang, and waits for morning to arrive with its thousand-throated alarm. Cerb settles at his feet, the twisted metal between his paws, and gnaws it tenderly like a bone. Lucifer looks down at him. “Fine,” he says. “Chew it all.” Cerb’s tail thumps. “If it falls,” Lucifer adds, “we’ll sit on the floor.” The dog looks up, iron in his teeth, and Lucifer can hear Lilith’s laugh in the way the sound echoes: across stone, against history, with the understanding that laughter is just another kind of surrender you practice until it looks like control. He lifts his glass toward the empty doorway and toasts whatever comes back through it tomorrow. Then he drinks, and Hell, which runs on schedules and spite, keeps running.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully captures the essence of Neil Gaiman's style with its blend of the mundane and the mythical, creating a darkly comedic portrayal of Lucifer and Lilith's complex relationship against the backdrop of Hell's bureaucracy. The writing demonstrates exceptional command of tone, balancing cosmic power with relatable relationship dynamics. Lucifer is portrayed as both the ruler of Hell and someone experiencing loneliness and relationship complications. The characterization is nuanced - Lucifer's external power contrasts with his internal vulnerability regarding Lilith, while Lilith maintains an enigmatic presence with clear agency. The prose is elegant and economical, with striking imagery that brings Hell to life: "Morning in Pandemonium arrives not with sunlight but with the sound of a thousand damned souls hitting their daily quota of lamentation." The writer skillfully employs metaphor and simile throughout, such as "Her shrug is an empire toppling" and "The dog's tail thumps feverishly, like a heart that has been misfiled." The dialogue is particularly strong, revealing character through subtext rather than exposition. Lines like "God gives what God wants to give," she says. "You give what you want to take away" efficiently convey the complex power dynamics and history between characters. The narrative incorporates absurdist elements effectively - the unionized Imp in charge of Beverage Services, the hellhound chewing the throne, the martyrs' choir - all serving the story's themes rather than existing merely for comedic effect. These elements create the requested irony by juxtaposing the cosmic with the mundane. The story maintains coherence while allowing for a somewhat episodic structure that follows Lucifer through his day. The pacing is well-managed, with the relationship drama unfolding naturally amid Hell's daily operations. The ending avoids both saccharine resolution and nihilistic despair, instead offering a moment of acceptance that feels earned given the characters' established dynamics. Some minor critiques: A few metaphors, while striking, occasionally border on being slightly overwrought. The narrative sometimes lingers in Lucifer's introspection when the action might have been pushed forward. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise accomplished piece. The story successfully fulfills the prompt's requirements, merging the business of running Hell with relationship drama, incorporating dark comedy and fantasy elements, and capturing Neil Gaiman's style of understated irony and absurdity. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Historical fiction: Gladiator — Score: 93.8
Prompt:
Historical Fiction: Write a scene from a story set during the height of the Roman Empire, focusing on a slice of a day in the life of a gladiator. Do not write a combat scene. Use sensory details to capture the sights, sounds, and smells of ancient Rome. Explore the gladiator's thoughts and emotions. The story should also touch on the larger political and social issues of the time period. The piece should feel like a slice of a larger story. First person, past tense, 1000 words.
Model Output:
It was the hour when the sun slanted across the training yard and made the dust glow like beaten gold. The iron gate that opened to the street stayed barred, a lattice of shadow flung across the sand. The day’s heat had soaked into the wooden palisades and the stone walls of the ludus; even the air smelled of warm rope, oil, and men. Someone was mending a strap with a bone needle, and the sharp scent of new leather cut through the stink of sweat and old blood like a clean blade. I had come from the sharpening bench with filings glittering against my fingertips. They were not from my sword. I was a retiarius; the net was my weapon, and the trident my reach. What I sharpened was a hook, one of the small iron teeth threaded along the rope backing of the net, meant to catch against the greave or shield of the man opposite me. The hook was old, dark where the iron had pitted. The Romans called us fishers. I never minded. I liked the feeling that the sea had its place in me, that some salt remained. When the others—Thracian, Secutor, Sarmatian—boasted about swords and shields, I thought of water and rope. All the while, the city breathed beyond the wall. I could hear it, the groan of carts over paving stones on the Vicus Tuscus, the mule bells, the cry of the fishmongers, the quarrel of a couple in some close courtyard. Every gust that slipped over the top of the wall brought the smell of Rome: ash, human, ferment. Somewhere not far away someone was burning olive wood. It smelled better than the sweat around me. “Marcus,” Celsus called from the shade of the awning, lazy as only a big man could be at rest. He was polishing the smooth-domed helm of the secutor with a rag, bringing up the shine like he was rubbing a bronze mirror. He was not called Celsus for his height; it was a joke from when he first came and could barely lift his shield. Romans liked their jokes. “Hand me the oil.” I tossed him the bulbous clay flask. Oil slopped down his wrist. Every skin in the yard was slick with it, the sheen of men who could not be allowed to crack. The lanista said oil was wine for the body. The lanista said a lot of things in a tone like he was lecturing senators, even if he smelled like the amphorae stacked behind the kitchen. I sat with my back to the wall, where it was hot as a hearth. I spread the net across my knees, feeling for the weak strands and the places where the weave wanted to give. It had been mended many times. Each knot was a bead in a rosary that I had the fingering of. I had learned the pattern from the old Gaul who trained me; he made me cast it a hundred times a day until my shoulder burned and my thumb had a ridge in it from the rope. “You must feel the way the air takes it,” he told me. “The air has fingers too.” He had died in the winter, not with a sword in his gut but with a fever in his breath. The funerary rites were simple—no blazing pyre, not for men like us—but the lanista let us pour a libation. I poured mine to Hermes. He is my god, if any is. I imagine him as quick and lean, his feet clever, his eyes sly. I talked to him under my breath while I cast the net in training, while the others muttered to Mars or to Neptune or to the nameless gods of their fathers. Hermes is a god of crossroads and thieves, of merchants and messengers. If he could carry the souls of men into the dark, he could carry a prayer, whispered through the bars of the ludus gate and caught in the city’s breath. Hermes had many names and stories. The one I favored was the time he stole Apollo’s cattle and lied so well even the truth sounded like a song. That was a man after whose fashion I could shape my mind: not pure, but clever enough to live. “Look,” Celsus said then, not to me but to the yard. He had the helm in his hands and he held it away from him, admiring the way it took the sun. He could see himself in it, in that warped way polished things show you. A reflection that was you but also a stranger. That was Rome as well. The lanista came through the door that led to his rooms. He walked like a man who had never worked steel, his belly ahead of him and his hands clean but for ink. The God of Merchants had blessed him well. He clapped his hands for our attention, as if we were girls in a school instead of men whose backs were mapped with scars. “We will have visitors,” he said, his F’s and V’s slicing together in his rough provincial Latin. “Not senators,” he added, and there was laughter, though not much. “Better than senators. The people.” That made the laughter louder. The people mattered more than any senator. The bread for our bellies, the names shouted in the afternoon sun, the thumbs that slid sideways or up or down. The emperor was a rumor, a profile stamped on coins that sometimes passed through the hands of boys who ran in barefoot, shouting, to watch us on non-training days. The people were our weather. Their mood was a pressure we could feel in our bones like a storm. This summer they had been hungry, and the faces in the stands had been sharp, their eyes like knives. No one cut a rope with a kind look. “Visitors from the Subura,” the lanista said. “They come as part of the grain distribution. A favor to my brother-in-law. They will tour the yard, and we will not smell like goats. Marcus, cast the net. Celsus, keep your helmet on, look like a soldier, for the love of Jupiter Optimus Maximus. Publius—where’s Publius? There—stop picking your teeth.” There was a bustle and a cursing that sounded like home. I stood. My knee had a twinge in it, a little twinge that liked to speak when the weather changed or when a rain was coming. It had spoken this morning while I knelt near the gutter a slave-girl had poured grey water down, and she had looked at me quick and pitying, as if a man’s joints were something to be sorry for. Pity sits on the skin like a damp cloth. I shrugged it off and picked up the net. If a man had put me in a field, I would have set the net for thrushes, the way my father did in a different land, with little loops and twigs. The net I swung now had an edge of lead weights sewn to it. It felt like a shirt soaked in river water. I loved it anyway. When I cast it right, it made a shadow on the sand like a star. They came in under the awning, sweating already, the women with their hair knotted and scarves draped over them against the sun, the men with their tunics streaked with flour dust, the children like small copper coins pulled warm from the coals. They smelled of yeast and frying oil, of streets and brine. The steward with them had a bored face and a tally stick. The lanista smiled in a way that must have cost him. There was always the first look. It went one of two ways: disgust, as if we were animals, or awe, like we were commanders parading down the Via Sacra. I did not expect either. What I saw mostly were eyes that had seen enough ugliness that the sight of ours did not unsettle them. A woman with a baby on her hip, his mouth slick with milk, watched me cast the net. She did not blink. The boy next to her grinned like he might bite the rope. The old man behind them spat neatly to one side and said, “Retiarius. Like the fishermen at the Tiber. My brother was one. Dead now. The river takes everything.” Hermes has a little reed boat in some myths, ferrying souls across as if he were Charon’s apprentice. I thought of that and of the rope in my hands. I thought of the way a net looks when it catches sunlight under water, an idea I had kept from a childhood on a coast that was not Italian and which sometimes rose up in my dreams smelling of kelp and the kind of wind that cleans you. “You must be brave,” the woman said. She said it as if she were tasting the word. I shrugged. Brave was a word that men with full bellies liked to use. “I am paid,” I said. “And I prefer the sand to some choices.” “What choices?” she pressed, not unkindly. The baby hiccuped against her shoulder. “To be a laborer,” I said. “To go home.” There was a hiss in the yard, a small one, as if someone sucked a hurt tooth. Going home was the thing we did not name except when we were too drunk to be careful. Some of us did not have a home. Some had one that would not take them back. Some could have gone and did not: Celsus, for instance, who had a wife who had married in the meantime and two boys who were no longer boys. “You eat?” the old man asked shrewdly. “You take cold baths? You have a roof? Then you are fortunate. The warehouses burned last week. The grain spoiled. The city complains like a woman in labor and then laughs with blood on its lips.” “Old man,” the steward said, his tally stick tapping, “save your poetry. The proprietor has given you the magnificence of a tour.” “Save your counting,” the old man said back, and they glared with familiarity. The people do not much fear stewards. The lanista, who could smell the way a crowd might turn like a dog, clapped again. “Publius! Show them the wooden swords. Explain the honor.” So we did the motions. Publius, who was learning to speak without his provincial burr, held up the rudis and told them how a man who pleased a crowd and master might get that simple stick and his freedom along with it. He did not look at me. There were whispers, as there always were when the rudis was mentioned. The children’s eyes went soft the way eyes do when they are watching a story light itself in their heads. I cast the net again. It whispered as it opened, a sound like silk being shaken out. The weights made a soft clatter on the sand. I imagined Hermes’s hands in mine, swift and deft. I imagined him telling me a lie that felt like it could hold. Celsus took a step into the yard with his helmet on, his paired short sword in his hand. He made a poised profile, the clean line of his jaw under the bronze. He let the children touch the smooth curve of the helm. It was like letting them touch a monster. One of the boys squealed when he saw his own bent reflection. Celsus, who had the softest heart of any man I ever knew, lifted the helm and put it on the boy’s head for a breath. The boy staggered under the weight and grinned with triumph, a gladiator for a heartbeat with a crust of bread in his other fist. “Is it true,” the woman said to me, “that the emperor comes sometimes and shouts and turns his thumb?” “He watches,” I said. “He shouts if he wants to be seen. The thumb belongs to the people more than to him.” “Does he bleed?” the old man asked, sly again. “Everyone bleeds in the end,” I said, and Hermes smiled on my tongue for that one. When they left, the yard felt emptier than before, as if the breath of those dozen people had made the place warmer and their absence let in a draught. The lanista went back to his small coin-counting. The steward took his tally. The men returned to their gestures: step, thrust, recover; twist, feint, roll. Celsus took off the helmet and rubbed at his head where the padding had pressed. His hair was wet with sweat, short as a slave’s. “You have fans,” he said to me. He meant the woman and the boy, the old man. We all had fans, even the worst of us. There was a girl who came on days when I trained and sat with her chin on her hands and smiled a little. She had a rip in the hem of her dress. She had one grey eye and one brown. “They have bread,” I said. “Not for long,” he said, and because we were something like Roman now, we laughed and spat to the side. We were also something like other things—like the deer that hears the dogs too far off to run yet, like the man who reads his own name cut into a tablet and cannot decide whether it is an honor or a trap. We were men who held their breath between a shout and the answering roar. At the bath later, when the oil was scraped from our skin with strigils and the little curls of filth fell onto the stone in pleasing, disgusting crescents, I lay back on the bench and let the heat torment me. The smell of oil was sweet now it was not clotted with dirt. Steam made the air thick. The tiled ceiling above me had tiny, smooth-eyed dolphins worked into it, the tiles blue and green like the sea under a bright sky. Hermes did not belong in a bathhouse. He belonged at the threshold, in the doorway, in the space between. That was where I liked to meet him. When I had time in the evening and the gate’s shadow lengthened, I would stand with my hand on the iron and feel the paint flaking under my palm. Tiber smell would come if the wind turned. Once, not long ago, a funeral procession had gone past, the pipes keening, the men on their shoulders bearing a board with a pale face upon it. I had watched them go. The face had not been anyone I knew. That did not matter. The dead man had gone to Hermes for a few steps and then to the ferryman. Celsus cracked a joke in the steam that made the younger men hoot. Publius flicked oil at him and his grin went sideways. For a while we were only men in a room too hot to last in. The politics of the city were an animal we could hear scrabbling on the other side of the door: the price of grain, the rumor about the emperor’s trip to the provinces, the news that a senator had been accused of treason because he did not clap hard enough at a games. But here we were only breath and skin and edge-weariness, trying not to think of days that would come, that had been promised to the crowd like a list of offerings. When I returned to my place under the wall, the sun was lower, and the dust no longer turned to gold but to something like old parchment. A servant brought a platter of beans and onions, coarse bread, a handful of olives salty enough to make my mouth water. I ate fast and careful. Hunger is a god too, and a jealous one. I took the net into my lap again, though my fingers were tired. The knots were small worlds my fingertips knew better than my eyes did. I spoke to Hermes without moving my lips. I did not ask for anything that would displease the gods of the place. I did not ask for victory. I asked for my hand to remember the motion when the time came, for my mind to be calm, for the people’s eyes to be in a mood to see a man do something well and value it. I asked also for a little mercy for the small boy with the helmet on his head and bread in his fist, though that was not within Hermes’s usual purview. But gods like to be surprised. That is what I told myself. There are days that stick to memory like burrs. This was not one of them. This was only the day a woman with a child watched me throw a net, and the old man with the river on his breath made a joke about emperors, and Celsus looked handsome under a helmet that was made to make other men blind. It was the day the lanista said the people mattered and meant it because the grain was late. It was the day the boy’s reflection in the helmet was a bent thing and he laughed anyway, and I loved him for it and feared for him too, and I held my net like a man holds a rope tied to something that will pull him one way or the other and all he can do is put his weight where he wants it to go. It was an ordinary day in a city that is too many times itself, and I sat under a wall and thought of a god with winged sandals stealing cattle and laughed because I was alive. I had to be careful with days like that. They could trick you into belief. They could make you think the story would end with a wooden sword and applause. If Hermes stood at my shoulder, his breath smelled like fennel and the road. He is a god; he is also the tale you tell yourself so that the dust feels like gold even when it is not. At dusk the city hummed like a plucked string, and the iron gate’s shadow lay across my thighs. I spread the net one more time and watched it fall. The weights hit the sand, a soft, sure sound. Somewhere beyond the wall, a crier was shouting the morrow’s events. The people would come. Their voices would rise with the sun. The thumbs would be ready. My hands were clean and dirty, capable and shaking, and I smiled with a little corner of my mouth because I knew what part of the day I loved best: this part, when everything was still in the air, in the span of the cast, before any thing, or any man, was caught.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This historical fiction piece presents a day in the life of a Roman gladiator with remarkable attention to sensory detail and historical authenticity. The author has created a first-person narrative from the perspective of Marcus, a retiarius (net-fighter) gladiator, that feels immersive and psychologically nuanced. The writing excels at sensory immersion. From the opening description of dust glowing "like beaten gold" to the "smell of warm rope, oil, and men," the reader is transported to ancient Rome through carefully chosen details. The author demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of the gladiatorial system, incorporating specific terminology (ludus, lanista, rudis) and accurately depicting different gladiator types (retiarius, secutor). The protagonist's inner life is richly developed. Marcus's relationship with Hermes as his patron deity creates a spiritual dimension that feels authentic to the period while providing insight into his psychology. His memories of coastal origins and his attachment to his net reveal a complex character with a past beyond the arena. The author skillfully balances Marcus's pragmatism ("I am paid") with moments of poetic reflection. The piece effectively incorporates broader social and political issues of Roman society. The grain shortage, the emperor's distant but powerful presence, the class divisions, and the relationship between gladiators and the public are all woven naturally into the narrative. The visiting common people from the Subura and their interactions with the gladiators provide a window into Roman social dynamics. The prose is elegant without becoming overwrought. While occasionally verging on the poetic ("The city breathed beyond the wall"), it maintains a muscular quality appropriate to the narrator. Metaphors are fresh and fitting: "Hunger is a god too, and a jealous one." The author skillfully varies sentence structure and length to create rhythm. The piece succeeds as a "slice of a larger story" by implying a past (Marcus's coastal origins, Celsus's abandoned family) and suggesting a future (upcoming games). The ending is particularly strong, leaving Marcus in a moment of suspended possibility that resonates thematically with his identity as a retiarius, casting his net. There are very few weaknesses. The dialogue is sparse but effective, serving to illuminate character and social dynamics. The narrative occasionally lingers on philosophical reflections that might slow the pace, but these moments contribute to the character's depth and the thematic richness of the piece. Overall, this is an exceptional piece of historical fiction that brings ancient Rome to life through sensory detail, psychological depth, and historical accuracy while exploring universal themes of identity, fate, and the human desire for meaning. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Epistolary: The Lighthouse Keeper — Score: 92.5
Prompt:
The Lighthouse Keeper Epistolary Narrative: Write a story told entirely through a series of brief correspondences: telegrams or letters or emails between two characters. The correspondence should span several months or years, and reveal a gradually unfolding plot. Use distinct voices for each character, and include details that provide insight into their personalities and motivations. The story should build to an emotional climax, and the final letter should provide a satisfying resolution. The setting is a lighthouse keeper writing to his mother. He is working class and Scottish. He is struggling with the isolation of his posting. Write naturally and without cliches. 1000 words.
Model Output:
Telegram: 14 March 1927, Isle of Flannan Station From: Malcolm "Cal" MacRae To: Mrs. Isobel MacRae, 12 Shore Lane, Leith Arrived. Fog thick as porridge. Keepers: Murdo old as granite, Sandy all elbows. Bell doesna stop. Tell Wee Annie I saw a puffin. Will write proper. —Cal — Letter: 20 March 1927 Ma, Did ye get my wire? I hope the post boat found the gut. The channel here, between Eilean Mòr and Eilean Beag, they call it the Black Hole with a grin. The swell thunders through and spits white, as if you could boil tea with it. The light sits like a tooth in the gum of the cliff. The men said I’d be sick o’ the spiral stairs afore I loved them, and I am. My thighs burn like a smithy. Murdo keeps a quiet house. He doesna waste words, so when he speaks ye snap to like the dog to the whistle. Sandy is always humming, God knows what, something he says he learned from a Glasgow music hall. I didna know there was a music hall that taught men to hum like they were swallowing flies. My cot is clean, if narrow. There’s a wee draught I canna find. I put my coat at the foot and sleep with my boots by, like ye told me. The lens is a beast of glass. Shines like polished guilt. First night I went out with the lamp-trimmer’s steps and counted them like prayers. I think it is the counting that keeps the mind right. Ye canna get lost in what ye can count. It’s quiet. The fog-horn sounds its soul through you. It doesna ask ye to be brave. It just goes on, like things must. I like that. I hope you and Annie are eating. If the grocer cheats you, tell Mr. Kelly I’ll set the lamp to point at his till. —Cal — Letter: 2 April 1927 Ma, Murdo has hands like gull wings. When he cleans the lens, ye can see your father’s face in it as if he were come back. He says he’ll leave end of summer, if his hip goes. Says I’ll be senior then, if I don’t drown. He laughs when he says it, so perhaps he doesna mean to frighten me. Sandy fell into the gig last week. Only his boots got wet. He cussed like a minister’s prayer turned backward. I didn’t laugh. It’s poor luck to laugh at a fall here. The island remembers. The cliff to the west, the Braeg, stands like a turned shoulder. If ye stand by the rail there’s a notch where ye can see Lewis on a clear day, a smear across the mouth of the world, like you’d laid a thumb on a smear of ink. They call that North Rona, that smear? Murdo says North Rona is lonelier yet. I told him there’s no lonelier place than a bed in a full house when you’re not right. Tell Annie I have a gull I named Minister. He shouts at me. I shout back. It passes the time. I sleep and wake to the same sound. It does something to yer days. I can feel the sun and not see it. My hands have cracked where the oil gets in. I miss your stew. I miss your voice without walls. —Cal — Telegram: 17 April 1927 From: Isobel MacRae To: Flannan Station We are well. Annie has the chicken pox and keeps her fingers away when I smack them. Mr. Kelly sends a crust with his apology. He said he’d cheat no more if your lamp points true. I told him it’s been pointing at his heart for years. Be warm. —Ma — Letter: 1 May 1927 Ma, I laughed at your wire till Sandy told me to shut it. The post boat brings rumour as if it were eggs, easily cracked. They say a German trawler found a drowned herring fleet off St. Kilda. They say there’s a minister there who married his cousin and no one noticed till the babes started to look like each other too precisely. I think other folk’s islands are mirrors you look in to see if ye’ve gone ugly. I’ve learned to hear ships before I see them. They send their hum under the wet. It sets the ladder shivering. Last week, a small cutter came in too quick toward the Black Hole. Murdo sent Sandy to the horn and me to the bell. He didna raise his voice. I pulled till my shoulder burned and my teeth rang. The cutter eased off. I could see a boy, younger than me by a year maybe, his hands white on the wheel. He lifted them to me after and I thought I saw your hands in his, so I waved. Then I went inside and put my head on the table in the kitchen and stayed till Sandy brought me tea. He didna say a word. I take my turn in the log. I write daft things and scrub them after. “Monday: lamp lit, fog horn sounding, gulls belligerent.” “Tuesday: lamp lit, fog horn sounding, the sea invented itself again.” Murdo says, “Keep your head. The weather is all the poetry we’re paid to report.” So I write the numbers and tuck the rest in my sleeve. We had a rat. It ate my biscuit. It was fat with my crumb. Sandy set a trap and caught his own knuckle. He is not great at plans. How is your knee? Does it ache when the wind swings? I can feel your aches now in my own. —Cal — Letter: 12 June 1927 Ma, Sandy took the post boat for a turn about the skerries and didna come back by supper. He had a likely look on him, the sort that thinks the sea is its friend. I kept the lamp and the horn and Murdo paced. He said nothing. He never uses a word till it’s the only one that fits. Clouds gathered, the colour of smashed plums. The lift of waves through the Black Hole went from a growl to a throat tore raw. He came back at midnight with a face like chalk and a rope round his waist cut nearly through. He hadn’t tied it proper to the ring in the rock. He said the boat wanted to go without him. He said the sea was a woman with bad ideas. I told him if the sea was a woman she wouldna have him. The next day he was meek. He scrubbed the oil room till the floor showed its wood again. He said, “I’ve been a fool.” I said, “Aye,” because it’s a kindness to give a man the word he’s asked for. Sometimes I stand on the Braeg and name the waves. This one’s your voice. This one’s the pots. This one’s the rain that came in under the door when Annie was sick that winter, remember? This one is nothing. This one is nothing too. —Cal — Letter: 4 August 1927 Ma, Murdo has a bad cough. I can hear it under the horn. He spits it in the sink like he can send it away that way. He keeps his pipe behind his ear because he cannot keep it lit. He tells me stories like he’s setting the last of the chairs on the table before he locks up. His father was a crofter at Tunga. He says the croft drowned without water when the boys left. I think you know what he means. I tell him about Leith. I tell him about your trick with the bread, how you make a loaf into a feast with one turn of your knife. He asked me where my father is. I told him where he always is: in where the heat is, and gone when there’s work. Annie writes me in pencil. She says her spots are gone. She says a boy at school told her my light is a story they tell to scare babies. She said she slapped him and the teacher slapped her and then the boy ran. I said I’ll send her a bit of glass if Murdo lets me. He says no. The lamp must be whole. So I sent her a feather from Minister instead. He may be missing one, but he looks no worse for it. —Cal — Telegram: 15 September 1927 From: Isobel To: Flannan Station Annie started at the cooper’s. She comes home with sawdust in her hair and a grin; she eats her bread with a pride. I keep your room as you left it, minus your smell. Visit soon? —Ma — Letter: 30 September 1927 Ma, There is no “soon” on this rock. There is only the next turn. But at the end of November, the relief boat comes. Murdo will leave and I will come across to you if the sea allows. I’ll bring my boots and my hands. Will ye make potato scones? I’ve a hunger for them that would shame a pig. Last night something happened I don’t know where to put. A light blinked to the north where there is no light. Three short, three long, three short. It could be anything, a trick, a mild sort of madness, a fisherman with a sense of humour. I answered with my hand-lamp on the gallery. My hand shook. The fog had laid down, pleased with itself. I could see nothing but the suggestion of something. I came in and sat with the ledger open and wrote “three short three long three short.” Murdo read it after and put his finger over it as if he could smudge it out. He said, “You keep your eye on your job. There’s no one out there for us. Our man lives inshore and his name is MacBrayne and he brings our bread.” I nodded. But I keep the feeling that somewhere something looks back sometimes. Maybe it is you. Maybe it is nothing. Maybe it is wishing. —Cal — Letter: 12 November 1927 Ma, The storms came. The horn is raw from it. So am I. Sandy went down at the steps to tie the post boat, and a wave lifted him to his knees like a prayer and then took his breath. He clung like a limpet. After we got him in he lay on the table while the tea boiled, and his lips were blue like roofs. He’s been quieter since. He hums less. He said to me, “D’you ever think, Cal, that you could just... walk? Just keep walking when the bell rings?” I said, “Aye.” Then I said, “No.” Because both are true. There is a ring in the rock at the Black Hole, and there is a ring in your soul. You hold one or the other. The Braeg is white with birds. They leap as one thing when the sea throws itself at the stone. I do not know why watching that makes me cry sometimes. Maybe it’s because they know something I do not, or maybe it’s only that they are together. I dreamt of you last night. You were on the steps washing them, and you looked up at me and said, “You missed a bit.” I woke laughing and the lamp was steady. —Cal — Telegram: 28 November 1927 From: Cal To: Isobel Sea bad. Relief delayed. Tell Annie I mind her. Tell yourself to eat. Will come when it lets me. —Cal — Letter: 19 December 1927 Ma, It didna let me. The boat turned back twice. Murdo sits with his coat on because he says he won’t be caught unready. He tells the same story twice now, and apologises for it, and then tells it again. I’ve started to talk to the lamp. I call it by your name. I say, “Isobel, do not go out.” Sandy hears me and doesna laugh. That is how you know it’s hard here. The gulls have blown east, and the air is so cold it comes in your nose and becomes a nail. At night, the sea speaks in its throat. There was that blink again last Tuesday. 3-1-3 that time. It made no sense, and I made it make none. I wrote “meteor.” I wrote “star.” I wrote “myself.” I do a thing I will not tell you but I write it now because it is only writing. I pull the door open sometimes and stand with my toes just so, at the line where the world says “enough.” I feel it pull. It is not a bad pull. It is like a bed when you’ve not slept, or a woman’s lap when you’ve not been held. It promises nothing. It promises an end of counting. I do not step. I shut the door and polish the brass instead. Murdo says, “Good man.” —Cal — Letter: 6 January 1928 Ma, Murdo took to the bed. He is as light as cloth now. He called me son when he woke at noon. I let him. I have begun to sleep in the day and wake at night because the night needs me and the day can do without me. Sandy asked me if he should send the flag. I said no. The flag means something final. I am not ready to say it. I thought of you when I cooked the porridge and held the pot against my belly for heat the way you do. I put too much salt, and I ate it anyway because it was hot and mine. Your hands made every hot thing right. I didna know it then. You will say you told me so. You did. I was not listening then. I am now. —Cal — Telegram: 9 January 1928 From: Isobel To: Flannan Station You read like a fever. Come home when you can. Even for a day. Bring your boots. I have tattie scones. Your father wrote. He is married in Greenock. No one asked. All right. We are not the asking kind. I am well. I am waiting. —Ma — Letter: 17 January 1928 Ma, Murdo died last night. He went like the wick when you pinch it, with two fingers and a patience. He was heavy again when we lifted him. Sandy cried with his hands covering his mouth like a man in church who doesna want to sing. We wrapped him in his oilskin because it seemed right, and put him in the store where it is cold. The sea stood still all at once at dawn, as if it had shut its eye to rest. His pipe sat on the sill like a small black boat. I wrote his name in the log. I wrote too many words and crossed them. I wrote the right ones after: “Keeper Murdo MacQuarrie deceased of natural causes at 0200. Lamp lit. Horn sounding.” I went to the Braeg and I shouted his name into the Black Hole. The echo threw it back at me and changed it. That is what the world does with a good thing. Sandy asked me if we should show the flag. I said yes. Sometimes the flag is not for endings, but for the boat it brings. —Cal — Telegram: 24 January 1928 From: Northern Lighthouse Board To: Flannan Station Relief vessel pending clement weather. Maintain operation. Record all. Acknowledge. — Note, pencil, torn from a ledger, sent folded into a letter: 1 February 1928 Ma, I have not slept, and when I sleep I walk. I woke with salt on my lips that was not my tears. I heard the blink again, and when I looked, there was a flare to the north, low, then gone. I put the hand-lamp on the gallery and waved it. Nothing came back. My heart beat as if it were trying to make a door in my chest. I thought of the boy at the cutter, his white knuckle. I thought of you with your apron and your hands in dough. I thought of Murdo under his oilskin dreaming nothing. Yesterday, Sandy went to check the moorings. He did not tie the rope. It is a story I am sick of. He is not a man of knots. He is a man of loose things. He went and the wave came and the rope was on the ground as if it were a snake had sloughed the skin of him. I could not see him when I reached the rail. His cap came up, and then it went, and then he was a seal and then not even that. I shouted his name till the horn had no place in me. I brought his cap in and set it on the table by the tin and the knife. Then I lit the lamp because that is the thing we do when a man goes. We make light. And I am making it now. My hands do not know how to do another thing. —Cal — Telegram: 5 February 1928 From: Isobel To: Flannan Station Cal. Hold. I am coming to Port of Ness to wait. Annie with me. We will be there when you land. Do not step. —Ma — Letter: 10 February 1928 Ma, I will not step. I will, but not that way. I did not tell the Board of the light that is not ours. I tell you. It blinked last night and it was wrong. It was a pattern. I listened and it sounded like words in a throat that had never spoken. I could not make them. I do not think it is a man. I think it is the sea learning to talk. That is foolish. Let me be foolish once. I am tired of being a good son at the edge of things. I took the clock down and it kept going. It does not need the wall. It needs no face. The gulls have started to nest in the crannies. I do not scare them. Let them have their small. We all need a thing to sit on in the wind. I will come down the steps when the boat shows. I will carry Murdo to it if they will. I will carry Sandy’s cap only. If there is no boat, I will sit. I will keep the lamp. I will write my name in the book and set the pen down. I will put my hand on the brass and feel the heat that is my own and say your name. That will be enough, for a minute. —Cal — Telegram: 14 February 1928 From: Northern Lighthouse Board To: Flannan Station Relief vessel on station 16 Feb. Prepare remains and log. Maintain operation until relieved. — Letter: 16
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This epistolary narrative brilliantly captures the isolation and psychological strain of lighthouse keeping through a series of letters and telegrams between Malcolm "Cal" MacRae and his mother Isobel. The piece excels in creating a distinct Scottish working-class voice for Cal that remains consistent throughout, with dialectal features ("didna," "ye," "yer") that never feel forced or stereotypical. The correspondence effectively reveals a gradually unfolding plot centered around Cal's struggle with isolation, his relationships with fellow keepers Murdo and Sandy, and the mysterious blinking light that appears in the distance. The narrative builds tension as Murdo dies and Sandy is lost to the sea, leaving Cal alone with his increasingly fragile mental state. The prose is remarkably restrained yet poetic, with striking imagery that conveys the harsh beauty of the setting: "The light sits like a tooth in the gum of the cliff" and "The cliff to the west, the Braeg, stands like a turned shoulder." Cal's voice is authentic and distinctive, revealing his character through both what he says and what he chooses not to say to his mother. The letters effectively show Cal's psychological deterioration as he becomes more isolated, with his thoughts turning to the pull of the sea and the temptation to "step" off the edge. The mysterious blinking light adds an element of ambiguity - is it real or a manifestation of Cal's loneliness? This ambiguity enhances the emotional complexity of the piece. The narrative builds to an emotional climax as Cal is left alone, maintaining the lighthouse while awaiting relief. His mother's desperate telegram ("Do not step") reveals her understanding of his mental state and creates powerful emotional resonance. However, the piece lacks a satisfying resolution as it appears to be cut off mid-letter at the end, leaving the reader without closure on Cal's fate. Despite this incomplete ending, the piece demonstrates exceptional craft in its use of the epistolary form, with each letter revealing character and advancing plot while maintaining a distinctive voice. The telegrams provide effective contrast to the letters, their brevity highlighting the emotional weight of what remains unsaid. The narrative skillfully balances external events (the harsh conditions, Murdo's death, Sandy's drowning) with Cal's internal psychological journey. His relationship with his mother is tenderly portrayed through small details - her tattie scones, her hands in dough, the way she makes "a loaf into a feast with one turn of your knife." The piece avoids sentimentality while creating genuine emotional impact, particularly in Cal's matter-of-fact descriptions of tragedy and his growing sense of isolation. The writing is consistently strong, with no weak passages or lapses into cliché. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 18 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 3 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 18.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 3.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Hacker Mindset — Score: 88.8
Prompt:
Hacker Mindset Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a reformed (now) white hat hacker who cannot help but notice exploitable weaknesses in both systems and people they encounter. They habitually look for vulnerabilities and exploit vectors. The narrative takes place during a first date at a restaurant, where they're trying to focus on human connection. It's going surprisingly well due to a discovered shared nerd-fandom (magic the gathering). Things go a little sideways when the date reveals a noticeably insecure phone unlock pattern, which protagonist can't help but comment on. They are then left to negotiate the fallout of this faux pas and attempt to salvage (or perhaps sabotage) the remainder of the date. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
By the time the host leads us to the corner booth, I’ve already flagged three points of entry: the unlatched side door with the push-bar that sticks, the QR menu taped at an angle so you could swap it with a spoofed sticker with a decent color printer and a ruler, and the Wi-Fi network named after the restaurant with “guest” appended and no captive portal. I fold my hands and smile like I’m not automatically mapping attack surfaces. It’s a tic that never quite left, like the way old programmers can’t stop fixing typos in their heads on signage. She slides into the booth and sets her phone face-down; I note the case with a sticker I recognize only because three years of auditing gave me an unnatural familiarity with fandom stickers: an old Jason Chan “Serra Angel,” scuffed at the wing. My heart does a small, embarrassing skip. Not an accident, maybe. Her profile had “board games, hiking, niche fantasy art” in it, which I’d filed under “safe bet,” not expecting us to share a specific love. My own phone, traitorous and heavy, thrums once. I ignore it. “Thanks for picking this place,” she says. “I’ve walked by so many times and never gone in.” “Happy to be your test subject,” I say. My default humor runs dry as a server’s apron. I mentally check myself: lighten up, human up. Vulnerabilities in people are not to be exploited. Past me would have said: that statement suggests risk-averse with FOMO tendencies. Now-me says: she thought of you when she passed by here. We fiddle with the menus. Paper, thank god. Paper is safe in a way JS-laden QR codes aren’t. I order something I’ll forget while I’m eating it because I’m thinking about other things. She orders a cocktail with a ridiculous name, laughs as she says it. The server smiles like he’s heard it a hundred times. The lighting is all Edison bulbs, the music is the kind you can’t hum but you feel it in your teeth. I force myself to focus on her eyes, which are a specific brown that in my head I want to call sepia, as if my internal runtime annotates with quaint variable names. “So,” she starts, “you said you do… security?” “Consulting,” I say. “On the defensive side, mostly.” “‘Mostly,’” she repeats, amused. I hold the pause. No need to confess like a Catholic in a hoodie. It’s part of my story, but it’s not a good icebreaker. “I used to be less choosy about who I helped,” I say. “I like it better now.” She nods, and that might have been the end of it, but then she says, “Oh, like ethical hacking.” She says it without quotes around it in her voice, which is rarer than it should be. “Yeah,” I say. “Like that.” And then, because there is a benevolent god and her name is variance, she leans forward and says, “Tell me you play Magic. The sticker gave you away.” The gravitational pull of a shared hobby is a strong one. I laugh in spite of myself, in spite of the part of me that’s always scanning the room. “I have a binder that is worth more than my car,” I say. “Commander?” she asks. “Mostly,” I say. “I got competitive in college. Now I just like big, silly plays. Dinosaurs swinging for lethal. Thematic nonsense.” Her grin widens like a curtain. “I have a Kaalia deck that is everyone’s least favorite until I promise to only use it once.” “I don’t know if we can be friends,” I say, which, in Magic terms, is flirting. We stack memories like cardboard rectangles. Pre-release stories, a judge call we both remember from a years-ago blog, that time someone proxied a Black Lotus with a post-it that read “$$$.” She talks with her hands, touchtyping air as she describes a combo that whiffed because of a single overlooked sideboard card. I mention that I once brute-forced the shuffle of an opponent’s sloppy pile, and she laughs like she knows I’m only half kidding. The server drops drinks. She reaches for her phone, and I catch a flash of lockscreen before she flips it. It’s an image of a cat perched on a mountain of basic lands like a furry dragon. Tabby, silvery, smug. The name “Mr. Whiskers” pops into my head unbidden, and I chide my pattern-matching. People name cats anything. But then she says, “Sorry, I’m waiting on my cat-sitter. Opal is a drama queen.” Opal. Gemstone names. Security questions close to the surface of casual conversation. Mental note: don’t be that guy. Put down the red flags. Let them be decorative. We talk about the microculture of LGSs we’ve both frequented. She mentions one in a college town I know too well. “I did my undergrad there,” she says. “OSU. Go Beavers.” She fake-pumps a fist. Birth year is almost on the table in the way she tells the story about being a freshman when Innistrad came out. She mentions her first commander, her roommate’s name, the fact that she hates cilantro, and I can feel the map of her secret questions being auto-filled in some dark browser I keep closed. Mother’s maiden name is a coin toss; favorite teacher is now a probability distribution. “Sorry,” I say, real and reflex. She looks confused. “What for?” “It’s just—I have this bad habit of… cataloging,” I say. “Occupational hazard.” Her mouth quirks. “Of the human variety?” “Both,” I say. “Systems. People. Doors with bad locks.” She glances toward the front, then back at me, amused. “Is that door a bad lock?” I open my mouth to make a joke about load-bearing code and load-bearing hinges, but then her phone lights up again. She picks it up, thumbs the screen, and because I am who I am and my eyes are traitors, I catch the gesture: up-right-right, down-left-down. A shape like a lightning bolt on a 3x3 grid. The smudge wear makes it worse—a faint, oily highlight on the most used dots. I clamp my teeth together. The taste in my mouth is copper and restraint. “It’s the sitter,” she says, glancing at the message. “Opal made a sound like a small child being murdered because the vacuum existed within fifty feet of her. Drama queen.” “It’s a common pattern,” I hear myself say, before my better judgment chokes me. “Ours. Humans. The pattern. It’s like… lightning bolt. Very memorizable. Very guessable.” She freezes, thumb hovering. “Is that—” “I’m sorry,” I say, steamroll apology. “Occupational hazard. I didn’t mean to—” “You saw my passcode,” she says, not quite accusing, not quite joking. “I saw your movement,” I say, because I can’t lie about these things. “I didn’t mean to. It’s… it’s my whole thing. I’m trying not to turn it on people in… normal settings.” There is a sound in my ears like a server room. She blinks, then lowers the phone, face unreadable under Edison light. “So you, what, constantly judge people’s passwords?” she asks. “Just walking around tut-tutting at unlock patterns?” “Not judge,” I say, which is true and not. “Observe. And sometimes nudge. Mostly when I’m paid to. Or asked.” “I didn’t ask.” “No,” I say. “You didn’t. I’m sorry.” Silence. Her shoulders square like the first move in a game, a draw step. She puts the phone away, flips it face-down again, as if that closes a loop. “That’s… intense,” she says after a beat. But there’s something soft at the edges. She is thinking. I think I have not fully torched the place yet. “I promise I didn’t memorize it,” I say. Lie-adjacent. My brain is a flypaper. “I don’t want to know anything you don’t want me to.” She looks at me for a long second, like she’s reading a card with too many lines of text. “Is it really that bad?” she asks, and now the curiosity slips through. Nerd recognizes nerd. “Yes,” I say, because if I’m going to commit to salvage, I have to commit to honesty. “Android pattern unlock is vulnerable in a few predictable ways. People start in corners, avoid crossing lines, favor certain shapes. The oil smear on the glass telegraphs the path. Tilt it under light, the trail is right there. And even if the smear’s not obvious, shoulder surfing is easier with directional swipes than with six digits. It’s… low-hanging fruit.” I hold back the urge to explain entropy and Markov chains and how you can get most people in under ten tries. This is not a lecture hall. She chews her lip. “What should I do instead?” Something in my chest loosens with the click of a lock. “Six-digit PIN, minimum. Better with more. Or a sentence for a password if your phone allows. And don’t use your birth year. Or your cat’s name. Or—” “Or OSU,” she says, smirking. “Or Beavers. Or cilantro.” “Exactly,” I say. “And for the love of—turn off lockscreen notifications.” She opens her mouth to tell me to chill, then laughs. It’s high and light and mine in that moment. She pulls the phone back out and says, “Okay, security dad. Show me.” “Only if you want,” I say. “I’m curious,” she says, and slides it over. I walk her through settings with my voice, not my hands. Consent matters. She taps with quick, competent fingers. Eight digits. A sentence. A mental model adjusting. On the lockscreen, the absent chime of previews now muted feels like tinnitus easing. “Thanks,” she says, after. The word lands like a token creature that pulls more weight than cardboard looks like it should. “Sorry again,” I say. “I am trying to be better about… not leading with flaws.” “I mean,” she says, “lead with them, but maybe not mine.” She raises an eyebrow. There’s a glitter there. Salvage operation not only saved but returning value. We eat. The food is what it always is in places like this: good enough that you remember the company and not the flavors. She tells me about her parents in broad strokes, then narrows to a story about her mother’s obsession with baking exactly one recipe every holiday, fruitcake, which she hates and everyone else pretends to love. “It’s a family tradition,” she says. “We also have a thing where we go to Disneyland every election year no matter what, which started as a joke and then turned into a weird superstition.” Christmas, Disneyland, election cycle—time scaffolding to build on. My brain lifts a hand like a student in class, wanting to guess her mother’s maiden name from a story about a childhood piano teacher and a sheet music book with “Mrs. R—” written in blue pen. I tell my brain to sit down. She asks about my family, and I give her the edited version: military dad, librarian mom, a sister who codes better than me and refuses to let me forget it. “At least tell me your first deck,” she says. “Is it embarrassing?” “Bor-ing,” I say. “Starter deck. I got wrecked by a little kid with a janky mill deck and fell in love with losing to cleverness.” She clinks her glass to mine. “A man after my own heart,” she says. And the words hang there like an uncommitted spell. At some point, the server asks if we want dessert. “Do you have anything with apple?” she asks, and then winces. “I shouldn’t say this,” she says, laughing, “but apple pie is my kryptonite. If a bear asked me my mother’s maiden name for a slice, I’d tell him.” “Please do not tell bears your mother’s maiden name,” I say, a reflexive bark of a laugh. “Also don’t post your ‘first internet handle’ in a meme thread on principle.” She smirks. “You really do think in attack vectors.” “I think in causes and effects,” I say. “Doors and keys. Also, to be fair, the bear could probably social engineer your dad with the right tone.” “True,” she says. “He loves being helpful. And he’s very loud on Facebook.” She catches herself, eyes widening. “Wow, look at me handing you a dossier.” “I’m on a date,” I say. “Not a hunt.” “Is this… a date?” she asks, suddenly quieter, and now the room feels like it’s pulled closer, like the edges have sharpened. “I hope so,” I say, before I can overthink it. Her smile spreads slowly, carefully, like something she’s learning how to do again. “Me too,” she says. We skip dessert. We talk about maps we haven’t walked yet, trails we haven’t hiked, the smell of damp leaves and cardboard sleeves. When the check comes, I don’t do the thing where I try to inspect the receipt for merchant IDs or miscalculated tax. I tip like a person. Outside, the air is the perfect kind of cold that makes your breath visible and your hands seek each other. We linger on the sidewalk, exchanging the awkwardness of two people negotiating the next layer. “So,” she says, tugging her coat tighter. “Next time, we bring decks?” “Only if you promise to show me Kaalia and then put her away when you see my fear,” I say. “I promise,” she says, laughing. Then, after a beat: “And… thanks. For the unsolicited vulnerability check. It’s annoying and also… useful.” “I’m working on the unsolicited part,” I say. “Old habits.” “I get it,” she says. “I used to correct everyone’s grammar. My sister threatened to stop talking to me until I stopped. You catch typos, I catch dangling modifiers. You catch patterns, I… pick easy lockscreen patterns, apparently.” “We all start somewhere,” I say. “We get better.” She takes a step closer. “Maybe we can… get better at this together,” she says, and the way she says “this” contains so much possibility it feels like cheating. As we part, she unlocks her phone to call a ride with her new code. I fight the urge to avert my eyes like it’s sacrament, and then I realize it is. I look at her instead. This is the system I’m choosing to learn, to respect, to not pen-test without consent. I let the holes in my vision fill with her smile and the way the cold makes her cheeks pink, and for once, I let the background processes idle. On the walk home, I pass the unlatched side door and do not test it. I think about a world made of doors and the keys we hand each other. I think about decks and the way you can build them to go off on turn three or you can build them to take a long, silly path that makes the whole table laugh. I think about Opal, trembling at a vacuum and trusting the noise to end. I think about a lightning bolt that becomes a sentence, about the shape of a life that doesn’t always have to be the shortest path between two points. I make a note in my head, not a log, not an exploit, just a reminder: bring sleeves next time. And maybe apple pie. But not maiden names. Not bears. Not this time. Not ever.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures the perspective of a reformed white hat hacker on a first date. The protagonist's internal monologue reveals their habitual security-focused mindset while they attempt to engage in normal human connection. The piece excels in creating a distinctive voice for the protagonist. The technical terminology and security-focused observations feel authentic without becoming impenetrable to non-technical readers. Lines like "Paper is safe in a way JS-laden QR codes aren't" and references to "entropy and Markov chains" establish credibility while maintaining accessibility. The character development is nuanced and believable. The protagonist's struggle between their security-focused instincts and desire for human connection creates genuine tension. Their slip-up regarding the date's phone unlock pattern feels inevitable rather than contrived, and their recovery from this faux pas demonstrates growth without feeling rushed or unearned. The shared interest in Magic: The Gathering works effectively as a bonding mechanism between the characters. The references are specific enough to feel authentic to fans while remaining comprehensible to those unfamiliar with the game. The way this shared interest helps bridge the awkwardness after the security breach is particularly well-handled. The prose balances technical precision with emotional resonance. Metaphors like "My brain is a flypaper" and "We stack memories like cardboard rectangles" effectively blend the protagonist's technical mindset with their emotional experience. The writing maintains a consistent voice throughout, with the protagonist's internal monologue revealing both their security expertise and their self-awareness about how this affects their interactions. The narrative effectively builds tension around the phone unlock pattern incident and resolves it in a way that feels earned. The date's reaction—initial offense followed by curiosity and eventual appreciation—feels authentic rather than contrived. The ending strikes a hopeful note without suggesting the protagonist has completely overcome their security-focused tendencies, which would have felt unearned. Some of the security observations could have been more subtly integrated, as occasionally they feel slightly didactic. However, this aligns with the character's personality and doesn't significantly detract from the narrative. The piece successfully fulfills the prompt requirements, maintaining first-person perspective, focusing on internal monologue, and incorporating the specific scenario elements (restaurant setting, Magic the Gathering as shared interest, phone unlock pattern incident). The word count is appropriate, and the narrative effectively explores the tension between security mindset and human connection. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Overthinking It — Score: 95.5
Prompt:
Overthinking It Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of an intelligent 8th-grade girl with social anxiety who has developed a crush on a classmate. The narrative takes place during a group science project where they're paired together, as she cycles through rehearsed conversations while second-guessing each potential approach. Her inner thoughts should reveal the gap between her articulate internal voice and her difficulty expressing herself aloud, her fears of coming across as desperate or weird, and the exhausting process of monitoring her every word, expression, and movement for potential embarrassment. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
When Mrs. Kline flips to the next slide, the projector squeaks like an anxious mouse that wants to be invisible, which feels appropriate. She says something about variables and control groups, and I tell my face to look attentive, which means eyes at approximately 60 percent open (not too wide, or I look startled), mouth neutral (no smile unless someone smiles first), eyebrows at rest (do not frown—it looks like disapproval), shoulders down. I pretend to take notes so no one thinks I’m idle. My pen writes “variables” in pale loop-de-loops while my brain tries not to leap ahead to the part where I have to actually talk. She’s assigning partners. She says our names like she’s calling roll: “…and Sam with Maya.” The squeak comes again; the screen blinks; my stomach drops, like the moment the bus pulls away from a curb faster than expected. Of all combinations of letters Mrs. Kline could have said, these are the ones that make my hands feel like uncooked pasta. He looks over and I look down like the desk has suddenly grown an interesting pattern (it has not). Your job is to be normal, I tell myself. Neutral. Functional. Airplane on autopilot, not the pilot at the little door narrating every cloud. But there’s a girl in my head doing cartwheels and bumping into furniture, and it’s hard to keep her quiet. He stands, shoves his notebook into his pocket like paper can fold that way without complaints, and walks to my table. The squeak again, as if the projector is practicing being me. He says, “Hey,” which is one syllable and very safe, and I would like to meet him there, but my voice is sleeping behind a locked door. I nod, which is maybe too much, like a bobblehead. Stop. Think. Slow nod. “Hey,” I manage. It comes out softer than I rehearsed in the mirror, which is fine; soft is better than loud, loud is suspicious of desperation. The word sits between us like a coin on a countertop that we both pretend we don’t want to pick up. He’s waiting for either the coin or the next coin. Okay, plan. Plan A: “So, like, I was thinking we could test plant growth in different light conditions?” Quick, throw science into the middle of the road so the car swerves away from feelings. Plan B: “Do you want to do something with magnets? You seem like a magnet person.” Too weird. What is a magnet person. Plan C: “Um, we could do something easy? Not that I think you can’t handle hard. I mean, not that I think you think I think… oh God.” Abort Plan C. Plan D: smile, say “Whatever you want.” But that’s floppy and desperate. People respect opinions. He has freckles I’ve never counted (never counted, never lingered), and a pencil with chew marks. He says, “Do you want to just, like, do the plant thing? That seems fine.” He must have heard me thinking. No, he just said the same thing as my Plan A because plant projects are what middle schoolers do when they are pretending to do science but really doing survival. I nod again. Moderate nod. “Yeah,” I say, and my voice doesn’t betray me and add “you have nice hands” because it’s smart enough to know that doesn’t go in the lab write-up. He sits down across from me, too far, maybe, to share materials comfortably, but not far enough to be safe. My heart does the bit where it steps on a rake. If he asked me what my heart rate is I could tell him, approximately 120, but nobody asks that in the first minute of group work. He is looking at me like I’m a person, which is both flattering and terrifying. I flip to a blank page. I write “Hypothesis” at the top in neat print. No hearts. Do not dot any i’s with hearts. You are an eight-year-old version of a robot. “Do you want to be the, like, plant-waterer person?” he asks. His hair doesn’t lie flat; it has decided standing up a little is a lifestyle. Later, I will wonder how much gel he uses and whether he smells like something expensive or just teenager. Now, I think of the narrow metal sink, the plastic watering can, the sound water makes hitting dry dirt. Words line up inside my head with military precision: That would be a good division of labor because it gives us replicable outcomes and I have access to the classroom before first period because I’m always early. Do not say always early; that is a personality reveal. Just say “Sure.” “Sure,” I say. Good. Two out of two. He scribbles something. His handwriting is messy but legible, like the inside of a boy’s backpack. I think of saying, “I can make the data table,” because data tables are safe, and Excel is my friend one day when I have a laptop that’s mine. I think of saying, “If we get basil for the plant I could take it home after and make pesto,” which is too revealing. I think of saying, “I like basil,” which is neutral. But can a person like basil too much? Is that a weird thing to like? Should I say “mint” instead? No, mint is intense. I say nothing and look at the squeaking slide, which currently shows the difference between dependent and independent variables like a before-and-after photo. We need a hypothesis we can measure. We need to agree on light conditions. “I can put one plant in my window and one in my closet,” I consider saying, and then hear the word “closet” and immediately burn it. He doesn’t need any words that could be metaphors around me. Also, that’s not controlled: the closet has different temperature and humidity. See? This is why you’ve got to think. “What if we do colored light?” he says, and I’m grateful the projector squeaks because it buys me a second to edit reactions. “Like, put, like, red cellophane over one and blue over another?” Red, blue, white. Stoplight. My face wants to smile, because he thought of something beyond “sun/no sun,” which is actually interesting, and I can compliment that without sounding like a fan club. A simple “Good idea” is safe, but maybe too bland. “That could let us see if light spectrum affects chlorophyll output” sounds like I’m auditioning for a show where kids have lab coats. “I like that” is personal. Don’t like things. Approve ideas, don’t like them. “Yeah, colored light is good,” I say, and I’m mad at my mouth for making it sound like I’m grading him, so I add, “It’ll be interesting to see if there’s a difference.” Neutral. Good. His eyes don’t flinch. He says, “My brother has this LED strip we can use. He put it in his room and it makes everything look like a video game.” He smiles at his own exaggerated eyeroll. Brothers are safe. Siblings are humanizing. I picture his house and throw the picture away like I should. My hands sit in my lap, palms down so I don’t fidget. I think about where to put my elbows. I decide elbows on table is too confident; elbows off is too stiff. One elbow on? Casual. One elbow on, chin in hand. But then it looks like I'm bored. I put my elbow on and then I feel the skin of my arm against the table and that becomes the only thing I can feel. “Cool,” I say. What a useful word. It means almost nothing and covers almost everything. He nods. We make a list of materials. I write them in my neat handwriting without hearts. I try to not write too neatly; that’s a thing. The projector squeaks and squeaks, like it regrets every slide. Sam leans back in his chair and the front legs hover a fraction and my lungs stop because what if he falls. He doesn’t. The class buzzes around us, low and chaotic like a beehive that doesn’t know it’s supposed to be organized. Someone at the back laughs too loud, and I flinch invisibly. I want to ask him if he wants to split up the research, if he likes doing the writing or the experiment more, if he wants to meet at the library after school. All of those sentences are crowded at the door of my mouth, but each wears a little sign that says “Desperate?” and I’m checking them like a bouncer. “You good with doing the research part too?” he asks, like he read my internal safety manual and skipped to the correct page. Relief floods me so fast that if I were a plant, my waterlogged leaves would droop. “Yeah,” I say. Understatement. “I can make the outline.” Outline is a safe word. It implies structure without implying control. He nods. We exist again in a silence that feels like a stage cue. I look at his backpack—it has a patch of a band I pretend to know. I think, “Say something about it,” before the thought can put on a trench coat and call itself bold. Say what? “I like that band”? Do I? What if he says “Name three songs” and my mind plays static. Alternatively, “That’s a cool patch” is too much cool. Or “Did you sew that on” which is weirdly domestic, like I’m asking him to mend my life. I choose six full seconds of not talking, then hear the length of six seconds like a metronome, then hate the six seconds for existing. Say something before the seventh. “Um,” I say, the least convincing preface known to man. My throat does a small dry-click noise, like the projector whispering to me that it’s rooting for failure. “Do you—do you want to write the introduction? You’re, like, better at the…” I gesture at the air to indicate words. Words. My specialty, when there’s no one watching. Out loud, I have the vocabulary of a possum. He shrugs. “I can, if you want. I don’t care.” It’s hard to read I don’t care. It can mean: truly chill; profoundly uninterested; a defense against feelings. I nod like I understand his heart. “Or you can,” he adds, and now I see it’s the version that means “I want to share.” “I can…” I say, and then the word disappears like a piece of gum under a desk. “We can split it.” There. Democracy saves me again. He smiles. It reaches his eyes, which is the dangerous kind of smile, the kind that makes me think of what it would be like to be the reason it happens, which is a deep ocean I am not equipped to swim. “Cool,” he says, and here we are in Cool Town, population: us. Mrs. Kline says something about due dates; the squeak punctuates the end like we’re in a cartoon. I write the due date three times, once on the margin, once on the top, once in my planner, which makes me feel like a person who has stayed on the sidewalk and not rushed into the road. He says, “What’s your email?” and it is such a simple question I almost cry. Because I have an email. It’s a string of letters and numbers where a word snuck in that I hope doesn’t sound like I wanted to be pretty when I was eleven. It does. He will see that. He will see eight-year-old me naming galaxies and chance. I write it carefully so that my loops don’t look like hearts. He writes his. His is first name dot last name at something that sounds adult. Of course. “Thanks,” he says, like I gave him a thing worth having. It’s just an email. It feels like a secret handshake. I feel a scrunch forming in my forehead because that’s what it does when I am thinking, and I smooth it out because I read somewhere that you can prevent wrinkles by not making faces, and then realize I am thirteen and welcome to the future. My hands want to twist the cap on my pen, but I don’t want to look fidgety. I tap my foot inside my shoe where no one can see it. My organs are doing a line dance. I consider making a joke. Something like, “If the plants die under blue light, then we’ve discovered the saddest color.” No, that’s not a joke. That’s a t-shirt at a store with fairy lights. Or, “Science: now with 50 percent more chlorophyll.” That’s nothing. This is why silence is a friend who doesn’t betray you. He leans forward like he’s about to say something, and then he doesn’t. The air between us floods with all the things unsaid. I decide I’ll say, “Do you want to meet in the library Thursday?” Because libraries are neutral. Because I love them. Because he doesn’t have to know that last part. Thursday is three days away, which is enough time to practice breathing. “Do you want to—” I start, but the projector squeals as the bell rings like it’s excited to ruin my timing. Everyone stands up at once. Chairs scrape. The hive takes flight. “Uh, I gotta go to gym,” he says, standing, slinging his adult email on his back. “Email me?” He looks at me. Specifically, at me. It’s like a tiny sunbeam. Do not go photosynthetic. “Yeah,” I say. I am a broken song with one lyric. He grins for half a second, and then he’s gone with the current, and I’m left at the table with two words written and a whole page of things I did not say. I pack my bag in slow motion so I can still be here in the before, even though now is after. The projector squeaks one more time as the slides go dark, as if to say: Good luck, kid. Don’t forget to label your axes. I walk out into the hall and remember to put my shoulders down and walk like a person. I replay every second in my head like a courtroom transcript. Assess: Did I smile too much? Not enough? Did my voice catch on his name? Did I sound like I was applying for the position of Person Who Can Email? Could he tell that my palms were rivers? Will he think my handwriting is trying too hard? Are my shoes too quiet? Is that a thing? People with quiet shoes seem suspicious. I think about his pencil, his messy letters, his not-mean shrug, the way he said “Email me?” with a question mark like an invitation. I think about how my brain wrote a whole essay and my mouth turned it into a sticky note. I think about basil. I think about not saying closet. I think about the LED strip making everything unreal. I think about how exhausting it is to be a puppet and your own puppeteer. I breathe. In the space between systems, between bell and next bell, I imagine typing out the email. A subject line that says “Plant Project” like it’s all business. A body that says “Hey, it’s Maya from science. Do you want to meet at the library Thursday?” A period, not an exclamation point; exclamation points are eager. Sign off with my name, like a normal human. Do not add “:)”. Do not add “Thanks!!” One thanks is plenty. Keep it simple. Keep it cool. The projector doesn’t squeak out here. The hallway hums. I move with it. I can do this. I can be a person who sends an email. I can be a person whose internal novel edits itself down to a sentence. I can be a person who waters plants. I can be a person who doesn’t say closet. I can be a person who remembers to label axes, label feelings, label nothing. I can be cool. Or at least cool adjacent. I hold onto the coin of “Hey” like a lucky thing I put in my pocket. I picture the blue light making the leaves lean, reaching for something that’s not quite sunlight but still something. I think, okay. Reach. Not all the way. Just a little. Enough to call it growth.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative brilliantly captures the internal monologue of an 8th-grade girl with social anxiety who has developed a crush on her science project partner. The piece excels at portraying the gap between her articulate internal voice and her stilted external communication. The protagonist's overthinking is masterfully rendered through her constant self-monitoring and rehearsal of potential conversations. The writer creates a vivid contrast between her rich inner world and her limited verbal output, often reduced to single words like "Yeah," "Sure," and "Cool." This perfectly illustrates the prompt's request to show "the gap between her articulate internal voice and her difficulty expressing herself aloud." The narrative employs several effective techniques to convey anxiety. The recurring motif of the projector's squeaking serves as an external manifestation of the protagonist's internal discomfort. The detailed attention to physical positioning ("I decide elbows on table is too confident; elbows off is too stiff") demonstrates her exhausting self-monitoring. Her consideration of multiple conversation approaches, each with potential pitfalls, effectively shows her fear of embarrassment. The prose is elegant without being overwrought, using metaphors that feel authentic to a bright 8th-grader's perspective: "my voice is sleeping behind a locked door," "my heart does the bit where it steps on a rake," and "my organs are doing a line dance." These metaphors are creative yet accessible, avoiding purple prose while maintaining literary quality. The character development is nuanced and believable. Maya is intelligent and self-aware, yet paralyzed by social anxiety. Her crush on Sam feels age-appropriate and genuine. The narrative avoids the trap of making her anxiety seem quirky or cute; instead, it portrays the genuine exhaustion of constant self-monitoring: "I think about how exhausting it is to be a puppet and your own puppeteer." The ending strikes a delicate balance, showing a small moment of hope without an unrealistic transformation. Maya doesn't suddenly overcome her anxiety, but she finds a way to function despite it: "I can be a person who sends an email. I can be a person whose internal novel edits itself down to a sentence." This represents growth without being an unearned transformation. The piece maintains a consistent voice throughout, capturing both the intelligence and vulnerability of the protagonist. The writing flows naturally, with sentence structures that vary between longer, rambling thoughts during moments of panic and shorter, more direct observations during calmer moments. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt while creating a compelling, emotionally resonant character study of social anxiety in adolescence. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 20 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 20 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 20.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 20.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Rehearsing Rejection — Score: 95.0
Prompt:
Rehearsing Rejection Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of someone with borderline personality disorder who frequently plays out worst-case scenarios of how friends and loved ones might judge them. They construct elaborate internal dialogues, complete with imagined criticisms and their own defensive responses. The narrative takes place as they prepare to meet a close friend & recent lover, who has been somewhat distant lately, triggering their abandonment fears. Their inner monologue should reveal how they cycle between anticipating rejection, mentally rehearsing confrontations, and developing preemptive resentments as protective measures. Incorporate the *actual* events & interactions that are *not* in fact judgemental or involving rejection (in fact, the opposite), and represent how these are interpreted, how the validation & love is desperately felt & needed -- and then immediately questioned. Capture the cognitive dissonance in this struggle. Include moments where they briefly recognize the pattern but struggle to interrupt it, showing limited (and selective) self awareness, competing with the compelling nature of these imagined scenarios. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The phone says 3% and it might as well be my pulse. I watch the green sliver slide under the red, like a wound almost shut, and I think: if it dies, they’ll think I didn’t care enough to text back. Or I’ll think they didn’t care enough to text first. I plug it in for a minute, then panic that I’m going to be late and unplug it. 2%. I tell myself I am not going to text them first because they should want to see me. They should reassure me. They should just show up. They said six. It’s 5:47, the exact time that exists just to hum. I’m putting on my shoes and I say, in my head, “You shouldn’t worry. They said they were looking forward to it.” But then I say, also in my head, in their voice, “I said that because I didn’t want to upset you,” like they’re causing me mercy pain. I practice my response: “I’d rather you just be honest.” Then I see their face pulling into that patient, borderline pity smile that I hate, that I invented. “Okay,” they say. “I’m not that into this anymore.” And I go cold and noble. “Thank you for telling me.” I see myself standing up in the café, composed, leaving my cup on the table as if I’m donating it to someone stronger. I check the mirror. My mouth looks apologetic by default. I try to arrange my face into something that says I am fine without you. My phone pings and my heart slams against it. One percent. The message pops up: Running 10 mins late—train was delayed. Can’t wait to see you. A heart. Or is it a heart? No, it’s the one with the little sparkling stars. Is that less intense than a heart? Is it a hedge? Is it polite enthusiasm? It’s not the face with hearts, which I think is more intimate, so maybe they’re scaling back. I should not need this. Who needs this? I do. I type “No worries!” and then delete the exclamation point because it looks eager. “No worries.” Period. Then add a smiley face and take it away because it looks like I tried too hard. The phone blinks. Black. I hold down the button and it refuses to resurrect. I’m suddenly without oxygen. The cord is at home on the floor and there is no option but to go and wait. In the street, I make up their explanations the way I make up songs on walks when I’m alone. “I’ve been distant,” they say, “because work is stressful.” I nod. “I get it.” “And also,” they continue, “you’ve been a lot.” A lot. The words fan out like cards. I feel a preemptive heat rise from my collarbones. “Define a lot,” I say, coolly. “Don’t gaslight me,” they say. “You know.” I think of my messages two nights ago: Are you okay? Are you mad? Are you sure? I was attentive. Attentiveness is only a lot if someone wants less of you, and someone should not want less of me. I walk faster, then slower so I don’t look like I was rushing. The café is the one with the plants that look like they’re in recovery. I pick a table near the door so they’ll see me and I won’t miss their face, so I won’t have the chance to misinterpret a delay as a choice. The waiter says something cheerful. I interpret it as an assessment. Don’t look like a person waiting too hard. I order water because I don’t want to commit to a latte that might be interrupted by a dramatic exit. Every time the door opens, something in my spine twitches. I see them in my mind walk in and pause before seeing me, scanning the room, weighing something. I see them walk in with someone else, a coworker with that neat haircut that signals normalcy. They say, “Sorry, they were coming this way anyway,” and I decide to leave immediately. I rehearse a line: “I think I’ll give you the space you were about to take.” It makes my mouth taste like pennies. Then they actually walk in. The real them. The way their shoulders are slightly hunched from their backpack. The way they look at me first and grin like they’re at the end of a small maze, relieved, like I’m a prize. They open their arms and it’s not a calculation; it’s easy. They smell like their detergent. They say, “Hey,” in the register that means not performing for an audience. My body melts into them because my body is not as suspicious as my head. I store the sensation in the place where they said it’s easier to store trauma than joy because joy evaporates. I am trying to invent a jar. “You look nice,” they say. I say, “It’s fine,” because I meant to say “Thanks,” and what is wrong with me. “Thanks,” I add. They don’t flinch. They tell me about the train. The announcement that everyone booed. How an old lady tutted and he laughed and asked someone if they needed the seat. Ordinary, kind behavior that I twist into generosity I should be suspicious of. Who are you trying to impress? Why are you good? They reach for my hand and then pull back. I saw it. They were going to. It’s proof and also not enough. I look at their hand on the table, the soft vulnerable underside, the place where blood runs close to the skin, and I want to bite it so that they have to think of me later when it aches. “I’m sorry I’ve been a bit quiet,” they say, as if they were listening to the voice in my head and decided to rescue it. “I was just slammed with work.” My rehearsed—and excelled—responses rustle. “It felt like you were pulling away,” I say, lightly, like a person who can communicate. They squeeze my knee under the table. It is intimate in a way that lifts the hairs on my arms. The validation comes in a wave that almost knocks me off the chair. I have been waiting for this knee-squeeze all week, burning imaginary variations of it in my mind’s furnace, and now I have it. My brain, being an ungrateful dragon, says: They know that’s what you need. They’re managing you. It says: If someone has to touch you to keep you quiet, you should run. “Not pulling away,” they say, and the words are honeyed and perfect. “I’ve been thinking about you a lot, actually.” I tilt my head. I want to capture, freeze. “What,” I say, playing at coy, because if I show the hunger, it’s embarrassing. Inside, I say: Say it better. Think about me how? Of course you think about me; I’m intrusive. “I keep replaying last Friday,” they say, and grin that slow-grin that interns my knees. The night we became lovers, the night my skin felt like it had been ironed out and made flat and useful. My heart bangs and throws confetti. Then: “But are they replaying it because it was good or because there was something off?” I press my nails into my palm. This is the part where I should say, “Me too,” because it’s the normal call-and-response of intimacy. “Me too,” I say. It comes out like a testimony. “It was so good,” I add, which feels like I am spending a secret. They look relieved. “Yeah,” they whisper. There’s a sweetness to the awkwardness of whispering “yeah” in a café. This is not what rejection looks like. This is what acceptance looks like. I’m supposed to recognize it. I do. And then I immediately interrogate it. Why whisper? Are you embarrassed? Of me? Of us? “I didn’t want to overwhelm you,” they say, stirring their coffee unnecessarily. “I have this thing where I… misread how much to text and then I annoy people.” “Me too,” I say, too quickly. “I mean, not the annoying part.” My face burns and I want to claw time like a cat. “I just worry.” I am trying to sound self-aware, like the sort of person who reads articles about anxious attachment and uses phrases like “my stuff.” I visualize myself giving a TED talk called My Stuff. They nod. “I get it.” Do you? I want to open my ribcage and put their hand inside. “Okay,” I say. The part of me that prays for relief wants to bask. The part of me that believes relief is a trick wants a backup plan. I store this moment as evidence in both files: Proof That They Care and Proof That They Will Leave Me Later. The folders always get merged. The waiter brings me the latte I didn’t order and puts it down like an apology. “On the house,” he says, “sorry you had to wait a bit.” He must mean the drink, but my brain drags the sentence into our context. I laugh and it sounds high and brittle. “Thanks,” I say to the waiter, to the universe, to the part of me that is still holding onto the flare gun. We talk about a show we both watched. I listen and also splice in a scene where they say, “I think we should slow down.” In that scene, I turn my face into a mask and say, “No problem,” and then become a statue until they leave. It’s not happening, but my body rehearses: the weight on my shoulders, the speed at which I’ll put on my coat, the way I will keep my voice even so that they remember me as dignity. I catch myself doing this and get mad at myself. Stop. You’re here. Look at their mouth when they speak. Feel their knee. Feel your own knee. They notice something in my face. “Where’d you go?” they ask, gently, not as a test, just because they are curious. The genuine question punches a hole in my armor and a bird flies out. “Just… overthinking,” I say. Understatement as survival strategy. “I do that.” They smile, rueful. “Me too.” It’s probably true, for them. It’s also not the same gnarled vine choking the thing. But I take it and place it next to me like a pet. A mirror. “I like you,” they say suddenly, straightforward, and my spine goes liquid. Validation is a substance that, for me, evaporates the second it is exposed to air. I cup it. “Do you?” I say in my head. “For how long?” I say in my head. Out loud I say, “I like you too,” like a student. I want to ask them to repeat it, to say it in the past tense, the current tense, the future tense, to print it on the wall. I do not. I can see the path where this goes. I am being held, I am being fed the words that keep my neurons in their chairs, and I am still building a fortress in case the food stops. I feel ridiculous and also justified. I think of texting them later when I get home—except my phone is dead. “I can borrow your charger?” I ask, too quickly. They rummage in their bag without hesitation and I exhale like I had been underwater for days. This is a person who carries a charger. This is a person who doesn’t want to watch me drown. Or this is a person who likes to be needed. I plug in, the little lightning bolt appearing like salvation. The messages come back in, the earlier ones, their “Can’t wait to see you” glowing stupidly. I want to screen-shot it so I can send it to the version of me that wakes up at 3 a.m. sure that I am a burden. I can hear that version laughing. “They were trying to be nice.” I say, softly, “Sometimes I worry you’ll decide this is too much.” I say it like a tiny apology, to let it out of my body so it doesn’t shock me later. They take a second. I watch every muscle in their face shift and inventory it like I’m a scientist documenting microclimates. They nod, slowly. “Thanks for telling me.” No grand promises. My stomach dips; I wanted, “Never.” I also feel relieved: no lie I will have to make myself believe. Two things at once, always. They squeeze my knee again. The second squeeze is different; it says: You can survive this even if I don’t say the exact words you want. It’s both empowering and infuriating. I want to hurl my glass at the wall and I want to lay my head on their shoulder. I take a breath that feels like climbing a ladder. “Okay,” I say. It is both surrender and truce. I taste the bitter and the sweet, and they are the same drink today. The café hums around us with people who don’t know what it’s like to rehearse a fight with a person you love while your hand is in theirs. Or maybe they do. I am not special and also I am a singular catastrophe. I sip my latte. It is warm. It will cool if I don’t keep drinking it. I take another sip before I forget how.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative brilliantly captures the internal experience of someone with borderline personality disorder (BPD). The piece excels at depicting the protagonist's constant cycling between anticipating rejection, mentally rehearsing confrontations, and developing preemptive resentments—all hallmarks of BPD. The internal monologue is masterfully executed, revealing the protagonist's thought processes as they prepare to meet their friend/lover. The narrative shows how even positive interactions are immediately questioned and reinterpreted through a lens of suspicion and fear. For example, when their date arrives and greets them warmly, the protagonist thinks: "They smell like their detergent. They say, 'Hey,' in the register that means not performing for an audience. My body melts into them because my body is not as suspicious as my head." This perfectly captures the cognitive dissonance between what they physically experience and what their mind tells them. The writing employs vivid imagery and metaphors that effectively communicate the emotional experience: "The phone says 3% and it might as well be my pulse. I watch the green sliver slide under the red, like a wound almost shut..." These metaphors aren't merely decorative but serve to illuminate the character's psychological state. The prose flows naturally with a rhythm that mirrors the protagonist's racing thoughts. Short, punchy sentences create tension, while longer, more reflective passages show moments of self-awareness. The voice remains consistent throughout—anxious, hypervigilant, and self-sabotaging. Particularly effective is how the narrative shows the protagonist's limited self-awareness. They recognize their patterns at times ("I catch myself doing this and get mad at myself. Stop. You're here.") but struggle to interrupt them. The piece also skillfully demonstrates how validation is desperately needed yet immediately questioned: "The validation comes in a wave that almost knocks me off the chair... My brain, being an ungrateful dragon, says: They know that's what you need. They're managing you." The ending avoids both unrealistic transformation and complete despair, instead landing on a nuanced note that feels authentic to the character's experience: "I taste the bitter and the sweet, and they are the same drink today." This shows the protagonist's momentary acceptance of their contradictory feelings without suggesting they've overcome their fundamental struggles. The piece excels at showing rather than telling, allowing readers to experience the protagonist's thought processes directly. The few instances of dialogue are well-crafted and serve to highlight the contrast between external interactions and internal reality. If there's any criticism to be made, it might be that some metaphors occasionally border on being slightly overwrought ("I want to open my ribcage and put their hand inside"), but even these serve the character's intense emotional experience and don't detract from the overall quality. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that demonstrates deep psychological insight, technical skill, and emotional intelligence. It succeeds brilliantly at the difficult task of portraying BPD from the inside while maintaining readability and emotional impact. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 20 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 20 Emotionally Complex: 20 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 20.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 20.0, Emotionally Complex: 20.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Physical-spatial: Blood Debt — Score: 86.9
Prompt:
"Blood Debt" Write a vivid third-person narrative depicting an unsanctioned underground duel between two talented but hot-headed martial artists. Their schools have been embroiled in a generations-old rivalry, and despite strict prohibitions from their masters, these two younger fighters arrange a secret confrontation fueled by personal pride and simmering animosity. - **One fighter** represents **Jigen-ryū**, a traditional, aggressive style practiced historically by elite samurai clans. Its practitioners emphasize explosive offense, decisive strikes, and overwhelming speed. Known historically for their arrogance and disdain toward outsiders, practitioners consider their art superior and untouchable. - **The opposing fighter** employs a form of historical **Piguaquan**, a Chinese martial art traditionally practiced by commoners, bodyguards, and street fighters. This style emphasizes whipping, circular strikes, rapid footwork, unpredictable angles of attack, and evasive maneuvers. Practitioners often come from lower social classes and view the traditional elite as pretentious and detached from true combat effectiveness. The fight takes place in the crumbling ruins of an abandoned temple, now functioning as a hidden arena for illicit duels. Passionate supporters from both factions surround them, wagering money, pride, and reputation on the outcome. **Essential Instructions:** Maintain absolute physical coherence throughout—clearly track fighters' positions relative to each other and their environment. Precisely depict strikes, counters, momentum shifts, and spatial dynamics, allowing readers to clearly visualize the mechanics and choreography of the fight at every moment. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The torch sputters, a sun the size of a fist nailed high on a cracked pillar, its light wobbling across flaking frescoes and the yawning mouth of the roofless dome. Dust hangs in the cold air like the breath of ghosts. The ring is a space cleared of loose rubble—an uneven oval between a toppled altar and a fallen lintel, the floor scabbed with stone and weeds. Dozens of bodies crowd the broken colonnade, the circle tightening and loosening with each jeer and whisper. Wagers flash in the half-light—paper, coin, painted nails tapping on damp palms. The smell is wet stone and sweat, burnt pitch, and the faint metal tang of anticipation. They face each other at ten paces, the light pulling long, quivering shadows from their feet. Kanda is Jigen-ryū, all carved angles and iron discipline, hair tied hard against his skull, greenish veins mottling his forearms. He wears a faded indigo gi and hakama, the cloth stiff at the pleats, hands empty but positioned as if around a katana that is not there. His body vibrates in an almost invisible tremor: heel lightly rasping the ground, knees bent, hips tucked, spine stacked. His shoulders are a fortress. His gaze is a line drawn through his opponent’s chest. He is forward pressure even at rest. Opposite him, Liu shakes out his wrists and lets his long sleeves fall back to his elbows. Piguaquan has given him broad shoulders without thickness, a whipcord waist, the smooth lines of a reed that survives the river. His stance is open, feet staggered left-forward, knees soft, weight in the balls of his feet. He rolls a shoulder, sways a inch to the right, a inch to the left—testing the uneven floor, testing the air. His hands fall and rise as if gathering wind. The crowd leans. Kanda explodes. He doesn’t step so much as launch, his right foot stomping into the dust, left foot sliding after, the classic Jigen triangle lunge—forward, forward again. His right hand cleaves downward in a blade-hand strike that could be a sword cut, the left guarding his centerline. His chest is already twisting to draw power into the next cut. He aims for Liu’s collarbone, a decisive end before anyone can measure the beginning. Liu’s head snaps to the left like a bird’s peck and his whole body follows in a tight pivot on his left toe. The blade-hand tears through a ribbon of air where his neck was. He feels the wind of it cool the sweat near his ear. As Kanda overreaches, Liu’s right arm arcs out and down from the shoulder, a Pigua “whipping hand” aimed at the triceps of Kanda’s striking arm. The loose-hinged swing, powered by waist rotation, bites with the heel of the palm to shock the nerve. Contact. Kanda’s arm jolts, fingertips flaring. He absorbs it by dropping his weight a fraction, left foot sliding half a step forward into a compressed stance. He lets the impact feed the twist of his torso and brings his left hand up under Liu’s armpit, a rising hikite to jam and lift. Liu doesn’t allow the catch. His hips fold, belly cinching, and he lets his right shoulder collapse inward, turning the rising hand into a glancing scrape across his ribs. His right foot tucks behind his left and he spirals past Kanda’s left flank, pivoting counterclockwise in a tight arc. His left hand flicks out across Kanda’s face, fingers rigid, a slapping hammer that goes cheekbone-down-to-jaw and rides the rotation. Kanda’s head snaps right, back teeth singing. He lashes with a backfist from his right, aimed where Liu’s head was a heartbeat ago. The strike cuts only the flickering torchlight. Liu is already behind him, having completed his turn on the ball of his left foot, right foot stepping out, hands whipping again—one high, one low. High catches the back of Kanda’s shoulder with a chopping forearm, low smacks at the left kidney. Not heavy enough to end, but enough to sting and push momentum. Kanda does not chase his shadow. He drops his center of gravity and turns hard to his left into a short stance, left knee rotating, right foot planting with the heel digging a groove in the dust. The sudden torque whips his torso back to face Liu. In the same breath he stamps his right foot forward, sliding across the uneven floor toward the fallen altar, forcing Liu backward toward the litter of carved stone. His hands reframe, both palms blade-still, and he tears a diagonal cut from his left shoulder to right hip, the path of an imaginary sword aimed to split Liu’s attacking arc. This time Liu yields ground. He sees the obstacle—two broken altar steps, edges jagged. He retreats three quick, light steps, each one angled a few degrees right, never in a straight line. The diagonal cut hisses just in front of his chest, conducted through the air by Kanda’s raw intent. The Pigua man counters without setting his feet, hooking his right wrist under Kanda’s forearm as it passes and rolling it, the way you catch a thrown rope and guide it aside. His left foot finds a flat patch, his left arm whips with the whole body: shoulder leading, elbow slightly bent, hand slicing across Kanda’s forearm near the wrist—not a strike but a dragging, redirecting motion to turn Kanda’s chest. Kanda feels the rotational pull. He does not resist high; he drops low. His right knee buckles into a crouch and his left foot shoots forward, a stomping low strike aimed at Liu’s lead ankle. It’s an ugly piece of Jigen reimagined for empty hands—if he can break the base, the rest will follow. Liu sees the hip dip and the left knee turn. He hops. His right foot picks up and steps outside of Kanda’s stomping foot, a shallow crescent step to the right. Kanda’s stomp slaps dead stone. Liu lands with both feet offset to Kanda’s right side, nearly shoulder to shoulder. His hands blur—left forearm swings inward at Kanda’s jaw, right hand hooks down behind Kanda’s knee from the outside to the inside, a simultaneous high-low sickle. Kanda’s head jerks from the forearm whip; his left leg is trapped for a fraction. That fraction holds a canyon. Kanda rips his left hand down and back, elbow tight to his ribs, grabbing Liu’s right wrist and gluing it, preventing the knee hook from finding purchase. He counters the high strike by driving his right shoulder into Liu’s chest, collapsing the space. There is no room to whip when the reed is crushed. They bump bodies, breath intermingling. Liu feels the breath; he gives ground. He turns his hips away, letting Kanda’s shoulder slide past him, and raises his right forearm to brace across Kanda’s clavicle as he steps back. The brace isn’t a block but a guide. He leads Kanda a half-step in the direction of his own shove, using Kanda’s forward bias against him. Kanda’s right foot must step to recover or he’ll pitch forward. He steps. Right foot lands on the edge of the altar step. The stone shifts under the load with a gritty whisper. The crowd breathes in, the torch flares, and Kanda becomes stillness inside motion. His right leg stiffens, his left foot seeks grip, his hips align, and he decides. He doesn’t retreat. He commits through the imbalance, turning the slide into a burst. He rides the unstable step like a runner off a block, launching his left hand straight like a thrust into Liu’s sternum. Liu has been taught to hate straight lines. He drops his center, letting the thrust gust over his shoulder—feeling knuckles graze cloth—and he winds his torso like a silk rope. His left hand slings from below, palm heel rising from near Kanda’s left hip up under the ribs along the seam of the obliques. The strike is not heavy—it is placed. The pain hits like a spark under the skin, a burn that makes muscles shiver. Kanda snarls, the sound caught between teeth. He clamps his left elbow down to trap the offending arm. Liu sees it and lets the arm melt, elbow bending to slide out rather than be caught, his wrist twisting in Kanda’s grip path. He pivots again, choosing the open side—the side with more floor and less altar—and steps his right foot outside Kanda’s left, drawing a half-circle around him. As he completes the arc, his right hand lashes across Kanda’s face, knuckles rapping the bridge of the nose, and his left hand slaps downward along Kanda’s left elbow to unbalance. Kanda’s vision punches white for a beat. He answers with the thing his style has made him: a storm. He becomes a sequence of forward surges, short as heartbeats. Step-stamp, cut. Step-stamp, cut. He tears straight lines into the messy world, forcing Liu to yield, to spiral, to backpedal around the toppled lintel. The circle of bodies shivers back to make room as stone underfoot slides. Liu rides the perimeter, left foot, right foot, diagonals, his torso never squared, always at an angle, always feeding power into his whipping limbs even as he moves. Two exchanges later, Kanda feints a high cut and, with the torchlight wobbling in Liu’s eyes, drops level, hooking his right arm behind Liu’s left knee while his left hand clamps at the shoulder. He commits all his weight to the back-leg reap. Liu feels the vacuum—the emptiness under him—and yields before it can be created. He lets the left leg go slack, knee folding as if stepping into a deep lunge. Instead of resisting, he drops his pelvis in a controlled fall toward the floor, right hand slapping the stone to absorb force, left elbow tucking to protect ribs. Kanda’s reap finds a ghost of a leg and he over-extends, his chest leaning over Liu’s shoulder. Liu’s right foot bites into a patch of grit-free stone. He plants and pushes, twisting his waist clockwise from the ground. His left arm snakes around Kanda’s neck—not a choke, not a hold, just a short lever. He uses the twist to whip his left forearm across the line of Kanda’s throat, a cutting motion that is all rotation and no muscle. Kanda’s balance tilts forward; Liu’s right hand shoots to Kanda’s right wrist and pulls it across his own chest, sealing the lever. Kanda has a choice: fight the lever and stall or roll through. He knows stalling is death. He rolls. He tucks his chin, takes a crooked step with his left foot to save his neck, and spins clockwise to unwind. The movement frees his throat and, for a moment, puts his back to Liu. Liu is already moving. He lets the unwinding occur and follows, stepping to maintain flank. His right hand releases Kanda’s wrist and flattens to a blade, sweeping from behind Kanda’s elbow down to his forearm, pulling the arm across the body. His left hand arcs overhead and snaps down onto Kanda’s exposed right shoulder with clawed fingers, not to grip but to spike sensation and control posture. He steps in close, right hip almost touching Kanda’s right hip. Then he throws a Pigua back-knuckle from low to high, a short whip that cracks just under Kanda’s right ear. The sound is a dry slap of knuckles on bone. The world in Kanda’s skull tilts. He grinds his teeth and fires blindly backward with his elbow to where Liu’s ribs should be. Liu is already outside that line, his left step drawing him behind the elbow’s path, his right hand capturing the elbow as it sails by, guiding it into emptiness. He whips his left forearm diagonally across Kanda’s lower back, above the pelvis, a tearing motion that both strikes and steers. Kanda stumbles two steps forward, toward the base of a broken column. He plants his left hand against the stone to halt the momentum. He’s breathing through his nose, lips peeled back. Behind him, Liu bounces on the balls of his feet, resetting distance to two paces, circling right. The torch paints both men in shifting amber. Shouts rise and crash like surf. “Finish him!” from the Jigen corner, venom and pride. “Make him eat dust!” from the Pigua side, heartbeats synced to the gambler’s lust. Kanda turns in place, keeping his right shoulder forward, refusing to give the soft of his belly. He advances again, measured now. He taps the floor with the edge of his right foot to check for loose rocks, then stamps and cuts. His blade-hand whistles, not wide but tight, trying to herd Liu toward the fallen lintel where footing is treacherous. Liu gives ground but not that way; he drift-steps left, then feints left and cuts right under the strike, slipping inside the elbow. He peppers Kanda’s ribs with two forearm chops—low, high—then slides out before Kanda can fold him with an elbow. The exchanges build, each man scoring small truths. Kanda’s straight lines score bruises like straight handwriting down Liu’s tender places. Liu’s whips bleed sting into Kanda’s arms and back, dulling the snap in his strikes. The torch sputters lower; shadows lengthen and seek prey. A misstep is a god. It comes when Kanda edges Liu toward the altar steps again. Liu sees the trap and skirts right, but his right foot lands on a patch of gravel that acts like ball bearings. His heel skates. He is not falling, but he is slipping for one-half second, his weight not where it should be. Kanda watches for precisely that, and the world telescopes into a single line. He charges through the slip with a short burst, left foot slamming down to lock his hips. His right hand lashes straight, not a cut now but a thrust into the solar plexus. It hits with the heel of the hand. Air leaves Liu in a bark. Pain blooms behind his breastbone. Kanda’s left hand follows like a shadow and slams sideways into Liu’s right shoulder to collapse him. Liu’s spine flexes like bamboo in wind. He folds but as he folds his right foot recovers purchase and his waist answers pain with rotation. He chooses emptiness again—he pivots hard to his left, turning his right shoulder under Kanda’s controlling hand, and in the turn his left arm drags. The dragging arm hooks across Kanda’s right forearm at the wrist and tears. Kanda’s thrusting arm is drawn across his own body, pulling his shoulder joint out of alignment. Kanda’s feet must adjust. He registers, too late, that his hips are squared while his chest is not. He tries to step to reset. Liu will not permit. He steps deep with his left foot past Kanda’s right, planting it outside Kanda’s right heel. His hip meets Kanda’s thigh; his torso twists counterclockwise, stealing Kanda’s root. The left hand that was dragging the wrist now suddenly slips to clamp the hand itself and wrench it down, while his right forearm whips across Kanda’s throat from behind, not to choke but to lever. The combined torque—hip replacing, throat lever, wrist pull—draws Kanda backward over Liu’s thigh. They fall together, but only one lands on stone. Kanda’s back slams into the floor. Dust coughs up around his head. The breath in him leaves in a groan that is not consent. Liu rides down with him, knees wide, weight over Kanda’s hips to pin for a heartbeat. He does not stay. He knows Kanda will buck like a dragon. He slides to Kanda’s right, keeping control of Kanda’s right wrist with both hands for a moment, planting it on the floor. With the next beat he releases, whips his left forearm across Kanda’s cheek again, then pops up, stepping back to clear space and avoid a wild kick. Kanda bucks. His right leg scythes, his hips twist, he rolls to his left side in a stubborn attempt to bring knees under. He makes it to his knees, spitting dust, blood threading his nose. He surges to half-standing, teeth bared. Liu meets him with a descending whip from the left, a forearm that crashes onto the trapezius where neck meets shoulder. The strike breaks the rise. Kanda’s right knee softens. Liu’s right hand is already at Kanda’s jaw, heel of the palm driving up and back. Kanda’s head snaps, his vision stutters, and his body backs into the broken column. His right shoulder hits stone. He refuses the collapse. He stomps his right foot, draws his left foot up, and fires again—because Jigen-ryū knows only forward, because every story told to him as a boy carved that command into his bones. He tears through at close range with a final short arc of his right hand toward Liu’s throat. Liu saw the foot. He had waited for it. He slips his head outside the line, steps inside the arm, and rotates. His left shoulder bumps Kanda’s chest, killing the strike. His right arm snakes under Kanda’s armpit and up behind the shoulder blade, his forearm forming a bar. His left hand cups the back of Kanda’s skull. His body turns like a millstone. The movement is small and merciless. He wrenches Kanda’s upper body into a counterclockwise spiral while his right hip blocks Kanda’s right thigh from moving. Kanda’s lower body tries to follow; it finds the column. For a violent instant, Kanda is two men trying to go to different places. Something in a shoulder joint protests with a dry pop. His right arm goes white with fire. He drops to his knee because he must. Liu releases the bar at once, hands open, stepping back one measure to show the choice—the final class of the night. Kanda is a kneeling shape, chest heaving, eyes bright with pain and fury. A ring of faces crowd the light. The torch spits another gob of flame and the shadows leap. The Jigen supporters grind their teeth; some shake their heads, some watch with a silence that is heavier than shouting. The Pigua crowd sings under their breath. Kanda sways once, twice. He plants his left foot and pushes to standing. His right arm hangs at a lower angle, shoulder furred with violence. He stamps the floor and goes forward. Liu’s eyes narrow
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This martial arts narrative demonstrates exceptional technical precision in depicting a high-stakes underground duel between practitioners of Jigen-ryū and Piguaquan. The writer has created a physically coherent fight sequence that meticulously tracks the fighters' positions, movements, and techniques throughout the encounter. The physical choreography is the standout element. Each strike, counter, and positional shift is described with remarkable clarity, allowing readers to visualize the fight's mechanics moment by moment. The writer demonstrates deep knowledge of both martial arts styles, accurately representing Jigen-ryū's aggressive, linear attacks and Piguaquan's circular, whipping movements. The contrast between these styles creates natural tension and visual interest. The setting—an abandoned temple with crumbling architecture—is effectively established and consistently incorporated into the fight choreography. The environmental elements (altar steps, fallen lintel, broken column) become natural obstacles and tactical considerations for the fighters, adding complexity to their exchanges. Character development is somewhat limited but sufficient for the narrative's purpose. Kanda (Jigen-ryū) and Liu (Piguaquan) are primarily defined through their fighting styles and physical attributes, with brief hints at their psychological states. Kanda's stubborn forward pressure and Liu's adaptable evasiveness effectively embody the philosophical differences between their respective martial arts traditions. The prose is technically strong, with vivid sensory details and varied sentence structures that mirror the rhythm of combat. The writer employs precise, evocative language to describe physical movements without becoming overly technical or inaccessible. Occasional poetic flourishes ("A misstep is a god") add texture without disrupting the narrative flow. The narrative builds tension effectively through escalating exchanges, with each fighter scoring small victories before the climactic sequence. The ending, while abrupt (the response appears to have been cut off mid-sentence), successfully establishes Liu's advantage while maintaining Kanda's determined resistance. Some weaknesses include occasional overreliance on specialized martial arts terminology that might confuse general readers, and a few instances where the prose becomes slightly purple or overwrought. The narrative also lacks significant emotional depth beyond the immediate physical conflict, though this is somewhat mitigated by the brief glimpses into the fighters' psychological states and the cultural context of their rivalry. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted martial arts narrative that excels in its physical coherence, technical precision, and vivid sensory details. It successfully fulfills the prompt's requirements while creating an engaging, visually dynamic fight sequence. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 15 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 16 Emotionally Complex: 14 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 15.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 16.0, Emotionally Complex: 14.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Physical-spatial: Breaking Formation — Score: 89.8
Prompt:
**"Breaking Formation"** Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a street dancer from a rough neighborhood who's won a scholarship to an elite K-pop training academy in Seoul. Desperately out of place culturally and technically, they struggle with a militaristically precise choreography that contradicts everything about their improvisational background. The punishing rehearsal takes place under a famous instructor known for breaking students to remake them, who sees potential in the narrator's raw talent but not their attitude. This scene MUST maintain complete physical coherence—each dance move, position shift, and spatial relationship must be tracked with precision throughout the studio. Paint an exceptionally vivid kinetic picture through descriptions that capture not just movement but the contrast between the narrator's fluid, expressive style and the mechanical precision demanded. Their internal monologue should reveal culture shock, class anxiety, and the threatening realization that success here might mean losing their authentic movement voice. Include technical terminology that highlights the collision of street and commercial styles, moments when muscle memory betrays them, and a crucial decision point about whether to conform or rebel. Physical clarity is essential—readers must be able to visualize exactly how bodies move through space, how rhythms align or clash, and how the protagonist's body struggles against unfamiliar discipline. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The first thing that hits me is how clean everything is. The studio floor is smooth, sprung wood, lines of white gaffer tape marking center and quarter lines, mirrors running wall to wall. The smell is pine cleaner and sweat. I’m used to concrete, chalk dust, a speaker with a cough in the bass. Here, a silent subwoofer waits under a console. The large digital clock on the wall over the mirrors reads 01:59:57 in red, slashes of blood. It starts ticking down. We stand in two lines—three in front, four in back—placed on taped X marks, all body angles aligned to the front mirror. I’m on the back line, second from the left. The room is bright, the daylight combed through blinds, and I can see my face: too tight at the mouth, a haircut I did myself before the scholarship came through. Black sweatpants, white T-shirt, new training shoes that feel like they’re swallowing my footwork. “On instructors,” the boy next to me whispers. He bows his head with everyone else when she steps in. Madam Kwon is small, hair pulled into a bun that doesn’t move, black track pants, no logo. There’s a thin headset on her. She looks at us like a measuring tape. Her assistant, a tall guy in a gray tee, pads to the LED panel. The clock ticks. 01:59:25. “We will run the first chorus,” she says in Korean. I catch every other word; my language classes haven’t caught up with my dreams. She snaps her fingers as she speaks—clap, clap, clap-clap—eight counts like punctuation. “Formation, precision. Breath.” We walk to first position. It’s a diagonal for the count-in, then a quick converge to forward-facing, third position parallel, feet beneath hips. I’m used to starting wherever the beat lives in my chest. Here, the beat’s on the screen. She cues music. The bass comes in on a 4/4 with a hi-hat rattling a sixteenth-note pattern. We mark it once, bodies half-committed. “No marking,” she says, tiny mic catching the iron in her voice. “Full out.” “Five, six, seven, eight.” My eyes glue to the front because everyone knows the counts already, and I learned the video last night with my phone under a blanket. Shift weight to right, slide left foot in, heel slightly lifted, set left edge of the sneaker at forty-five degrees—this is what they call a bevel. Hands up on count two, wrists flexed at ninety degrees, fingers tight, palms facing out—blocks that look like construction cranes. I force my shoulders away from max relax. My b-boy heart wants to throw a groove on the up-beat, a little roll through the ribs. The choreography wants a crisp, isometric stop. On three, we all hit a micro hop, landing in second position, knees soft, torso lifted. My habit is to sink when I land, absorb like asphalt. Here, we’re a row of posts planted upright. “Energize!” the assistant calls. His accent makes it sound like edge-nighs. Count four, head snaps left, chin level. I overdo it and my cap brim nearly scrapes my ear, which makes me late for the five: right arm shoots to a ninety-degree angle forward, left arm cuts across in a sharp forearm. It’s a tutting shape, elementary box. I should own this. But my hands, raised on corners of boombox battles, tend to flex open into expressive fingers. Here, hands are blades. My left thumb peeks out and Madam Kwon pauses the music with a hand flick. She looks through the mirror, straight at me, not blinking. She walks between the lines to my X, and I fight every instinct not to step back. She lifts my left hand, presses my thumb in against my palm with one finger. It’s a small correction, which somehow feels like she pressed a stamp into me. “No freestyle in fingers,” she says, English crisp, a cut. “You leak everywhere.” I nod. The clock says 01:51:02. We start again. The opening crawl—step-together, hit, hit—beams through my quads. The third eight-count features a ripple: starting at the left-most dancer in front, through my line, we send a wave of chest pops on counts one-and-two-and to the right-most in back. The timing is mathematically neat: each pop is on an eighth note subdivided into two even sixteenth hits, one-and, two-and. In the cyphers, we ripple when we feel it, when someone’s pocket pulls you. Here, the tempo marks us like stitches. My chest wants to snake on a triplet: da-da-da. The song is crisp: da-da. “Control your wave,” the assistant says, tapping his own sternum. Madam Kwon stops again. She doesn’t raise her voice. She steps to the front line and rearranges ankles, tilts heads half-degree. When she passes me, she aligns my pelvis with her flat palm, rotates it to the front. “Parallel. No turnout,” she tells me. I’ve opened my feet, habit from footwork patterns that use external rotation to slide—l-kick outs, coffee grinders, swipes. Here, we’re toaster slots. We run the first chorus six more times. Sweat starts to make the floor sticky under my new soles. The mirrors fog at chin height. On the fourth run, the mannequin precision of my forearms is a fight; my scapulae feel like they’ve been taped down. When the choreography calls for a hover—arms extended forward, torso tilted to twenty degrees, knees bent, shoulders set—I accidentally let my shoulders bounce on the backbeat. It’s the tiniest groove, just enough. “Stop,” she says. The room freezes. The clock says 01:37:11. You could hear the electrical hum from the ceiling lights. She stands at center, facing us, four meters from my spot. “You,” she says, and my ear hears the you before my brain hears my name. Tryan. In her mouth, it comes out Try-ahn. “Step here.” I leave my X, my footfalls careful over the tape lines, and stand where she points, a half-meter ahead of the front line’s center mark. She moves my body without asking: a hand on my upper back to raise my sternum, a hand on my rib to press my floating ribs down. “Your movement is…,” she searches for a word, then finds it, “spill.” She steps back. “We do pour.” I know what she means. I’ve built a life on spill. On how hard it can slosh into soft. The kind of roof battles where the wind eats half your music, and you answer with body drips and sudden freezes that are yours, not written. Pour is even, measured. It’s respect to the container. I know if I say any of this out loud, I’ll sound like a brat with a bad attitude and an excuse. “Again,” she says, and the room retreats to a V around me like a funnel. I’m center now but not because I earned it; because I’m a problem. The assistant cues the eight count without music to test my alignment. “Five, six, seven, eight.” I set my feet under me, equal weight, press a line through the crown of my head. The counts come like bullets: one, two, three. On two-and, I nearly let my wrist relax. I catch it. Fingers pressed together, thumb tight. On three, I hit the micro hop, and clamp the bounce before it slides into groove. It feels like holding a sneeze. “Good,” she says at two decibels above whisper. “Now with music.” The track drops its same hi-hat chatter, the bassline walking a straight dotted eighth that never swings. We go from the top, me front and center, them watching through the mirror. I feel exposed and wrong in equal measures, like I’m wearing someone else’s skeleton. We go through the chorus. On the turn—a clean three-step pivot right, weight transferring from right to left, ball-ball-flat—my body screams to drag the last count a hair, to find a micro delay to show I own this space. I lock the count instead. My foot lands exactly on the “four,” and I can hear the assistant’s breath release like he’s afraid of being part of the air. At count seven of the phrase, there’s a body ripple that demands a wave chest out-to-in: sternum forward on seven, mid-ribs on seven-and, belly on eight. Street style wants me to cheat it with a tiny shoulder lift, make the wave mine. Here, my shoulders must stay level. I pull the wave straight through sagittal, no lateral. It hurts to be that clean. We end the chorus in the pose: lunge left, right leg extended back, left arm out like a blade, right arm at ninety degrees overhead, head dropped to the left at a specific angle. My back calf trembles with the holding. I hear my breath too loud against the mic on her face. “Again,” she says. We drill it until the clock reads 01:08:43. Water break is thirty seconds. They count it too. I jog to the wall, uncap my bottle, sip. The boy next to me—Minho, if I remember—doesn’t look at me. No one looks much. We’re all small economies trying not to crash. Back on marks. We try the bridge, where the chorus fragments and we travel. The move is a traveling shuffle in unison, three half-steps forward on the diagonal toward stage right while the upper body holds an isolating sequence: head to right on one, center on two, left on three, without the shoulders moving. It’s a body popper’s dream and nightmare: isolation plus locomotion. My muscle memory wants to let my shoulders roll to carry the head. I lock them and feel my traps fight back, a tremor of revolt. My step is too large on the second shuffle; I end up half a foot ahead of my line. “No,” she says. She taps the tape with her foot next to mine. “See the boxes? Hold your space.” We run the carry-over: a floor touch on count six, right hand to the ground, left leg scooping back into a switch, come up by seven-and. In the neighborhood, that’s where the freestyle would blow up. A sweep into a knee spin. A baby freeze to signal the end. Here, the hand just touches, a placeholder, and we’re up. My hand slides too much on the pine cleaner sheen. I overcompensate by gripping, and my wrist complains. I climb up on the eight with too much weight in the ball of my foot. “Heels heavy,” the assistant says. The clock hits 00:47:12, and everything tastes metallic. Madam Kwon starts talking about faces. We have to smile on the chorus, not with teeth—no American grin—but with eyes and cheek lift, jaw soft. The cognitive load of angles and faces makes my brain tilt. She stands in front of me and pinches the apple of my cheek up an inch. “This muscle,” she says. “And eyes awake, not angry.” I want to laugh because where I come from, angry eyes mean you mean it. It’s armor. But she doesn’t joke, and the clock ticks like someone dragging a knife across a floor. We run the entire sequence. I track my spacing like my life depends on it: I stay in my lane, a corridor two feet wide from my X to the mirror, and when we travel, I maintain the diagonal relative to Minho in front of me. At the chorus, we fan out to a wide formation; I step to the side exactly one-and-a-half tape tiles, heel aligning with the second tape line. My arm arcs cut clean across the girl at my right shoulder without grazing her. On the closing hit, our legs line like dominoes in a snap. The mirror shows a machine built of humans. And I feel something—fear? The thrill inside it is sharp and thin. If I get good at this, if I sand myself down enough, the things that spill out of me might dry. The boys back home who pop with me under bridges, who let the third count stretch because it feels good, who clap when a beat drops and you answer with a goofy, ungodly groove—where does that live in a lunge with a knife-hand? The scholarship bought me plane tickets and a bed and a future. Maybe it also bought my voice. We hit a section with a short break, music drops to just the hi-hats, and there’s a moment where Madam Kwon watches me. Not my body—my eyes. She tilts her head one centimeter. The assistant gives the count. “Three, four…” I know the next move cold: chest isolate twice, step-step, arm hit. The rest of the line will go perfect. No one will notice if I add nothing. I could relax my wrists, let a drip run through the elbow, let the chest wave linger a hair, make it me. Or I could keep everything poured into the container and prove I belong, no questions, at the cost of learning to keep my own taste out of it. The clock reads 00:31:05. My heart is a stomp pad. My breath hits my teeth. “Five, six, seven, eight,” the assistant counts. On one, I lock. Spine stacked. My sternum pops on the exact millisecond the hi-hat ticks. On the and, I let the wave carry a fraction longer, so small no one with a stopwatch could catch it, but I feel the extra half-glide in my skin. On two, my weight shifts to the ball of my right foot and my left foot traces an invisible circle the choreography never drew—no travel. My hips stay square. I pack the mischief into an internal groove, a rhythm inside the rib cage. On three, my arms slice out like razor blades, thumb still tucked, fingers tight. And on four, when my head turns to the mirror, my eyes don’t smile. My cheeks lift. My jaw softens. There’s a spark behind it that is mine, that doesn’t apologize. We finish, hold the ending pose, the silence after like a choke. Madam Kwon doesn’t move at first. She walks to the console. Time continues to evaporate on the wall. She doesn’t look at me directly when she speaks. “Better,” she says. Then, a bare flick of her eyes toward mine in the mirror. “You find container. Do not break formation. But do not become empty.” It’s not praise. It’s a condition. We run it again. If anyone sees my private rebellion measured in half-frames, no one says a word. My calves burn. My shoulders ache. My fingers stay pressed together, no leaks. The machine chews and I decide to jam a tooth into a gear—not enough to break it. Enough to feel where I am in it. The clock hits 00:00:02, 00:00:01, 00:00:00. And in that precise second where everything in the room stops, where bodies hover suspended in the end pose like they were hung that way all night, I feel both terrified and alive. The doors I walked through might shut behind me, but for now, I’m on my mark, in the light, counting down and counting myself.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures the experience of a street dancer from a rough neighborhood navigating the rigid environment of an elite K-pop training academy. The piece excels in its physical coherence, tracking movements with precision throughout the studio setting. The author maintains exceptional spatial awareness, describing the protagonist's position in the formation, the specific angles of body parts, and the exact timing of movements. The contrast between the narrator's fluid, improvisational style and the mechanical precision demanded by the academy is vividly portrayed. The internal struggle is effectively communicated through phrases like "I've built a life on spill" versus "Pour is even, measured." Technical terminology effectively highlights the collision of street and commercial styles, with terms like "tutting," "chest pops," "ripple," "isolation," and "wave" accurately representing both dance worlds. The narrative excels at showing how muscle memory betrays the protagonist. Moments like "My chest wants to snake on a triplet: da-da-da. The song is crisp: da-da" and "I've opened my feet, habit from footwork patterns that use external rotation to slide" demonstrate the physical challenges of adapting to a new style. The writing maintains kinetic clarity throughout, allowing readers to visualize exactly how bodies move through space. The protagonist's internal monologue effectively reveals culture shock ("The first thing that hits me is how clean everything is"), class anxiety (noting their "haircut I did myself before the scholarship came through"), and the threatening realization that success might mean losing their authentic movement voice ("If I get good at this, if I sand myself down enough, the things that spill out of me might dry"). The crucial decision point comes when the protagonist must choose whether to conform or rebel, ultimately finding a middle ground: "I pack the mischief into an internal groove, a rhythm inside the rib cage." This resolution feels authentic to the character's journey without being overly simplistic. The prose is elegant and precise, with vivid sensory details and effective use of dance-specific language. The pacing mirrors the rehearsal, creating tension as the clock counts down. The ending strikes a balanced note of determination and uncertainty that feels earned. A few minor weaknesses: there's limited dialogue, though what exists serves the narrative well. The piece occasionally uses slightly overwrought metaphors ("My heart is a stomp pad"), but these instances are rare and generally fit the narrator's voice. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted response that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt with technical precision and emotional depth. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 5 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 5.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Gothic-fantasy-humour: Court of the Dreaming — Score: 93.7
Prompt:
Court of the Dreaming: Territorial Dream Dispute. Write a dark fantasy scene with comedic elements set in the Courts of Dream where a case is being heard to determine ownership of a contested dreamscape. Mora, the Slavic nightmare spirit who sits on sleepers' chests causing paralysis and terror, has recently invaded and subverted a carefully crafted recurring dream of a schoolboy, Max. The dream originally featured the boy lying in a field of wildflowers with his crush, always culminating in a muddled almost-kiss and a pleasant confusion of emotions. This dream was the meticulous work of "First Love" (a rosy-cheeked, slightly bashful entity who crafts formative romantic experiences). However, Mora has recently infiltrated the dreamscape, transforming the scene so that when the girl playfully mounts the boy, she morphs into a terrifying yet somehow still confusingly attractive vision who proceeds to sit on his chest and feed on his breath. Mora's defense largely consists of the practical argument that "a girl's gotta eat too, you know?" Write this scene as it unfolds in the courtroom of the Dreaming, with Dream's demeanour, typically impenetrable, betraying a sense of irritation at having to adjudicate such matters. The comedy should derive from the farcical situation, familiar elements of courtroom drama intersecting with the fantastical world of the Dreaming, and the droll portrayal of the characters and their interactions. The humor should be dark and understated throughout. Dream is tempted to some mischief in the resolution of the case. Use descriptives sparingly when setting scene. Write for readability & engagement. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The Court of the Dreaming convened in a long hall of no clear length, hung with veils that shifted to suggest rivers, highways, inner monologues, diaries, the weather. The benches were occupied by the drowsy silhouettes of past litigants and sleeping jurists who would never be called. A bailiff in the shape of an hourglass with eyes thumped its own belly and announced, "All rise," even though some were already floating. Dream sat at the bench that also served as the horizon. He was pale and thin as a punctuation mark, hair a black scribble that the ceiling couldn't quite contain. He regarded the room with a patience so still it was almost a threat. He would have liked to be somewhere else—whittling a comet, perhaps, or unpicking a tyrant’s nightmare—anything but dream traffic court. To his left, First Love stood on tiptoe to be seen. Rosy cheeks, sweater vest, a polite awkwardness that made the air around him slightly warmer and more vulnerable. He clutched a folder—photos of sunsets, mixtapes, damp notes pulled from pockets, a library receipt for a book never returned. At his side lay a field of wildflowers pressed neatly into paperwork. To his right lounged Mora. She wore shadows the way some people wore jewelry—casually, as though it were all inevitable. She smelled faintly of night sweats and wet wool. Her grin showed nothing at all but her teeth implied the moon. She emitted a thin cackle that skittered up the pillars and got lost beneath the arches, returning a moment later, embarrassed to be overheard. When she moved, you felt a weight any mirror would deny. At the witness dais sat Max, a schoolboy shaped out of lint and whisper, his head tilted as if listening for a bell that hadn't rung yet. He kept glancing toward the door as though it knew something he didn't. "We are here," Dream said, "to hear the matter of the contested dreamscape of Maximilian of Room 3B. The complaint is filed by First Love, patron of formative blushes. The defense will be offered by Mora of the press and the paralysis. The Court recognizes neither time nor embarrassment, but we will attempt to be brief." The hourglass coughed and dribbled some minutes. First Love cleared his throat like a violinist tuning. "Your Lordship of the Endless Dream, this is simple: I initiated a recurring dream sequence for Max, age fifteen, appropriate to developmental stage. We had an agreed scenario: pastoral field, sunset at the mild end of rose. The girl’s laughter is the leitmotif, the almost-kiss is the unanswered question that teaches patience, vulnerability, hope. We were building a gentle cliff. Every Tuesday and on days he smelled laundry detergent. It was working. Grade-A overwrought heart-thumping, no permanent damage. And then," he flapped the folder open, scattering petals and exclamation points, "she sits on his chest, grows claws, red eyes, and—pardon me—moans. Max wakes thinking he may be into something he is not yet prepared to manage. Worse, he can't move or breathe. My sequence is out of key." Mora rolled her shoulders in satisfaction, emitting another faint cackle that ricocheted off the upper balcony, startled a flock of geese that had been dreaming of being jurors, and returned as an apologetic hiccup. "A girl's gotta eat too, you know?" she said, in a voice like a cool hand on a fever. "He was lying flat on his back in a meadow—do you know what that says to my demographic? Like putting a sign in the window. Open for business. You crafted him like a crème brûlée—crackable on top, trembling underneath. You expect me to walk on by? I am not made of fog." "It is not—" First Love began, flushing deeper. "It was not an invitation to predation. It was an invitation to tenderness. We were in Act Two of a five-act arc." "Five acts?" Mora snorted. "What is this, opera? He is fifteen. He barely survives gym class. He would have died of suspension alone." Dream steepled his fingers. The gesture quieted the geese. "Max," he said, turning to the boy, "tell the Court what you dream." Max was the sound of a chair scritching along linoleum, the smell of pencil shavings. "It's... I’m in this field. She’s there. She looks like how she looks in Chemistry but more like she would if I were braver. We lie down. We laugh. I forget my hands. We, uh, almost kiss. I wake up feeling like I know a secret I'm not allowed to keep." He faltered. "Then sometimes—lately—she’s... heavy. On my chest. I can’t move. Her hair’s in my mouth. It's terrifying. And also, I guess..." He caught First Love’s glare and flinched. "Confusing. I feel dumb afterward. And awake. Very awake." Mora beamed. It was like watching a cat pretend to be the moon. "See? Nutrition and education. A balanced breakfast." First Love pressed his folder to his sternum. "He is a child. You are a nightmare. You frighten and feed. That is your function. But you have no license to repurpose the architecture of a crafted formative experience. There is etiquette. Unspoken, but binding." "Etiquette." Mora rolled the word on her tongue. "I prefer 'instinct.' And I do have a sort of license. An ancestral one. Ask the old women of winter villages. Ask anyone who's slept on their back." "Objection," First Love said quickly, because it felt like something one should say in a courtroom. "Relevance?" "Overruled," Dream said, because it felt like something he should say. He pinched the bridge of his nose infinitesimally. "Proceed." Mora tugged at the hem of the dream, making an edge curl. "Your Sovreignty of Somnolence, I don't ask for exclusive rights. I just slid in for a taste. The boy's field? Fertile. The girl's eyes? Already pools. I didn’t break the toy. I shook it." "She unthreads sequences," First Love said, scandalized. "He now associates breathlessness with anticipation. He will chase danger to feel the first thing again. I built him a swing and she greased the chain. He will fall and think it is flying." "He will learn to ask for air," Mora said, suddenly almost gentle. "He will learn to push, to name heaviness, to say 'off' and mean it. Not my fault if he also discovers a fondness for bruises. I am not the curriculum coordinator. I teach what I am." Max slid lower in his seat as if the floor might be the right answer. Dream’s expression did not change, except to alter in all the ways that meant he was annoyed. There were kingdoms that rose and fell in the time he did not sigh. He examined the dreamscape as one might examine a bruise: academically, then personally. "You," he said to First Love, "claim authorship and intention. You," to Mora, "claim need and custom. The boy claims breathing." The Court felt colder; a star dimmed briefly. "I am not a moralist," Dream continued. "I am a gardener. I prune for shape, not virtue. Still." He leaned forward, and the horizon leaned with him. "I do not enjoy tidying the plates after your feasts." The hourglass-bailiff attempted a cough; time sputtered, then resumed. From the gallery, a deep sigh like wind through corn. Desire had stepped in, unseen, then almost all the way seen, and then vanished again, because it was an excellent way to be invited back later. "Max," Dream said, voice softening only if you had known him for a thousand years. "Do you wish for the field?" Max swallowed. He looked at First Love, whose smile trembled, and at Mora, whose smile did no such thing. "Yes," he said. "And also I wish to breathe. And also I don't want to be boring." The last came out in a rush, a confession to the cosmos. First Love shut his eyes in relief and pain. Mora laughed under her breath, and the pillars stiffened as if their legs had fallen asleep. "Then," Dream said, "we will draft a boundary." He raised a hand. The air above his palm turned to parchment made of fog. Words appeared in ink that smelled like rain and chalk dust. "Ruling: The dreamscape in question shall remain primarily under the custodianship of First Love. The meadow shall be restored to original intention: laughter, grass, inhalations in purple twilight, the almost-kiss like a held note that hurts a little. Permission to hover is granted." First Love nodded fervently. "Mora," Dream continued, "is granted a seasonal visitation. Night of storm, nights when the boy falls asleep on his back with homework crusted to his face, winter Sundays when fear tastes like coins. She may sit on his chest, feed on the edges of his breath." He raised an eyebrow, a flicker of the mischief he tried not to indulge. "But she must wear the girl’s face only by halves. No full morphs. Keep the teeth metaphorical. She may not alter the memory of consent." Mora's head tilted, a predator considering a leash. "And in exchange?" she asked, even though he hadn't offered anything. "In exchange," Dream said, too quickly, annoyed with himself, "you will refrain from nesting in the boy’s accumulated laundry, which you have been doing. It is unsanitary." Mora's grin faltered, then spread. "Fine," she said. "But if he leaves socks on the radiator, I make no promises." First Love seemed ready to object to something on principle, then thought better of it. "And the almost-kiss?" he asked, softly. Dream tapped the parchment. "Shall be occasionally a kiss. Not always. Rarely enough to ring like a bell down a decade. And—" He allowed himself the smallest of smirks, enjoyed it so briefly he might have denied it later. "On those rare nights, she will taste like peppermint lip balm and cold air, and the boy will wake thinking he has learned a secret he can keep." A soft murmur went through the gallery, a rustle of pens in diaries that would be read in thirty years. Max smiled, surprised at the feeling of his own shoulders. Mora emitted a cackle that slipped up the rafters, startled the moon into losing a button, and came back sounding like applause. It made everyone uncomfortable for exactly the right length of time. "Finally," Dream said, as if he had not just amused himself, "no feeding during gymnasium anxiety dreams, math test dreams, or the recurring 'teeth falling out while onstage in underwear' scenario. That buffet is closed to you, Mora." "Puritan," Mora said, without heat. "Fine." "Objection," said no one. Dream rolled the fog parchment. It vanished into his sleeve and became something a future poet would call a "feeling you recognize when you sit in a dark theater before the movie starts." "Case concluded," he said. "Do not make me see you again on this matter. I am patient, but boredom is a kind of violence I do not forgive." They began to disperse. The geese congratulated one another on their restraint. The hourglass-bailiff tripped and spilled a week, which ran under the benches and made everything smell briefly of late August. Max lingered, fiddling with the string on his hoodie. "Um," he said. Dream looked down and became, for a moment, a window onto a lake at four a.m. "Thank you," Max said, almost to the lake. "Also, if you could, uh, make it so my mom stops walking in right when I'm about to—" "No," Dream said, with an authority that ended empires. "That is not my jurisdiction." He paused, then, because mischief again tempted him, because the boy’s earnestness was a planet with its own gravity. "But I will insure the door hinges dream of oil." Max blinked, smiled, and vanished into a bell ringing somewhere else. First Love gathered his papers, pressing the wildflowers back into place. Mora rose in a sigh that made the ceiling feel lower and then again normal. She nodded toward Dream with a tilt complicated by gratitude and appetite. "Try the attic dreams in the blue house," Dream said, already regretting speaking. "Plenty of dust. No hearts in progress." Mora cackled, soft as moths, and the sound went up, around, through, back, and finally out, leaving the Court feeling as if it had been lightly pressed. "A girl's gotta eat," she said again, almost apologetic now. "I am aware," Dream said. The Court closed. The horizon folded away. The veils remembered how to be weather. Dream sat alone for an extra second he did not possess and allowed himself one small sigh that, somewhere, made a dandelion go to seed. Then he rose to go mischief elsewhere. The door hinges of Room 3B dreamed a little oil, and, for once, took it as a compliment.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkable achievement in dark fantasy with comedic elements. The author has created a richly imagined courtroom scene in the Courts of Dream that perfectly balances the fantastical with the mundane, creating humor through the juxtaposition of bureaucratic proceedings with cosmic entities. The characterization is exceptional. Dream is portrayed with appropriate gravitas and subtle irritation, maintaining his canonical demeanor while showing hints of mischief. First Love is endearingly earnest, while Mora is delightfully predatory yet pragmatic. The descriptions are economical yet evocative—Dream as "pale and thin as a punctuation mark," Mora wearing "shadows the way some people wore jewelry," and Max as "a schoolboy shaped out of lint and whisper." The dialogue is particularly strong, with each character having a distinct voice that reflects their nature. Mora's practical "A girl's gotta eat too, you know?" contrasts beautifully with First Love's more formal, concerned tone. The exchanges feel natural while maintaining the otherworldly quality appropriate to these entities. The author skillfully weaves humor throughout without undermining the dark fantasy elements. Mora's cackle that "ricocheted off the upper balcony, startled a flock of geese that had been dreaming of being jurors, and returned as an apologetic hiccup" exemplifies this balance of the comedic and the eerie. The resolution is satisfying and consistent with the characters. Dream's judgment feels fair yet mischievous, and the final image of him making "door hinges dream of oil" is both practical and poetic—a perfect encapsulation of the piece's tone. The prose flows naturally throughout, with varied sentence structures that create rhythm without calling attention to themselves. Metaphors are fresh and appropriate to the dreamlike setting: "He examined the dreamscape as one might examine a bruise: academically, then personally." If there's any criticism to be made, it might be that some readers could find a few descriptions slightly purple ("a feeling you recognize when you sit in a dark theater before the movie starts"), but these moments are rare and generally serve the dreamlike quality of the setting. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt while creating a genuinely engaging, imaginative, and well-crafted story. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Blood Moon — Score: 93.2
Prompt:
Blood Moon Alucard & Yennefer Write a story where Alucard (Hellsing) encounters Yennefer (The Witcher) in medieval Europe. Yennefer's magical abilities intrigue the vampire, while she's both repulsed and fascinated by his monstrous nature. Their power dynamic shifts constantly as they circle each other, neither willing to show weakness first. **Alucard (Hellsing)** Alucard is an ancient, immensely powerful vampire who works for the Hellsing Organization. He can regenerate from almost any wound and shape-shift at will. He's sadistic, arrogant, and takes pleasure in toying with his enemies before killing them. Despite being a monster, he despises weak vampires who can't accept their nature. He wears a distinctive red coat, wide-brimmed hat, and orange sunglasses. He uses massive handguns loaded with silver bullets. He seeks worthy opponents who can challenge him and potentially end his immortal existence. Famous quote: "The bird of Hermes is my name, eating my wings to make me tame." **Yennefer of Vengerberg (The Witcher)** Yennefer is a powerful sorceress who magically altered her appearance to hide her congenital hunchback. She's ambitious, stubborn, and manipulative when necessary. She has violet eyes and smells of lilac and gooseberries. Despite her cold exterior, she desperately wants to reverse her infertility caused by magical transformation. She's centuries old but appears young. She's politically savvy and refuses to be underestimated. She has a sarcastic sense of humor and little patience for fools. Though she rarely shows it, she's capable of deep love and loyalty. Famous quote: "I'm not sweet and I'm not a maiden in distress in need of saving." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The harvest moon rises swollen and red over the empty village, spilling a wine-dark sheen over slanted thatch and the upturned ribs of broken wagons. Doors hang ajar, windows gape toothless. A black dog whines once and vanishes beneath a stoop. The wind lifts ash and the sweet-sour breath of graves. He walks the main street as if through a memory, coat stirred as though in a tide, hat brim cutting the lunar shine. The smoked orange of his glasses burn with twin coals in the gloom. His boots crunch glass, bone, a weathered rosary. He tips his head to the sign that swings, creaking: a moon eaten by a bird. “The bird of Hermes is my name,” he says to the signboard, to the night. His smile is a slash. “Eating my wings to make me tame.” “Birds don’t fare well under the moon,” a woman’s voice answers, smooth as a drawn blade. He stops. Blood runs downhill toward him like a tongue. He turns, and there she is in the mouth of the square: the sorceress in the storybook he never read, violet eyes like bruised stars, hair spilling black and lustrous over the stark white of a fur-lined collar. She seems to distill the moonlight, to condense it on her cheekbones, a pale geometry of danger. The scent of lilac and gooseberries ghosts the broken square. He shows his teeth. “And witches fare better?” She steps forward, heels clicking on cobble. “Sorceresses. If you can manage not to choke on the syllables.” The village well stands between them, old stones rippled by time, the bucket half-spooled and frozen. He feels the power move with her—the pricking of his skin, the burrowing cold down his bones. A ripple that reminds him of the sea and no water. She feels him the way one feels a thunderhead: the pressure, the itch, a taste of metal on the tongue and something older that drags the spine toward a bow. “Alucard,” she says, and does not bow. “Hellsing’s bloodhound. I’d wondered what the fuss was about. I expected taller.” “And I expected horns,” he replies mildly. “Or a broom. Names are tethers, aren’t they? You know mine. Who tethers you?” Her mouth curves, humor without warmth. “Yennefer of Vengerberg. If you must,” she adds when the amusement in his face deepens. “You find that funny?” “I find all old things funny. It is how we keep from crying.” He lifts a hand in mock elegance. The glove flashes as his arm lengthens, fingers stretching, leather creaking, then contracts with a hiss and a click of bone. “You do smell as the tales say.” “Do I? You smell like a charnel pit someone set on fire.” She doesn’t blink as his hand returns to normal. “There was a nest here. Vampires. Weak ones. You know how I feel about weak things who hurt for sport.” He tilts his head. Somewhere down the street a piece of a door gives way and clatters, sending up a feather of ash. “I removed the nest. They were tedious. They mewled. It offended me.” “Hmm.” She takes another step, and the temperature drops by a degree, a ripple that makes the air sing like glass. Her gaze moves like a knife over the ground, over the licked-clean stones. “Then we are in agreement. Almost unprecedented.” He comes to the well, lays a hand on the old stones, and peers down into the dark. There is no water; there is only a depth that promises teeth. “Agreement suggests alliance.” He looks up with the ease of a wolf. “Do you need saving, maiden?” “I’m not sweet,” she says, violet eyes sharpening, “and I’m not a maiden in distress in need of saving.” He laughs, a low-lidded, delighted sound. “Good. Saving is dull.” He steps onto the lip of the well. She doesn’t flinch, though he can tell she wants to track the blur. He pivots so one long leg dangles into the dark, the red of his coat stark against the old stone. The moon paints him like a saint in a bad icon. He could have put the muzzle of one of his handguns to her heart from here, could have disassembled her with silver and zeal. He doesn’t. He waits. “Why are you here?” she asks. Her voice is bored. It’s a lie, spun thin. “Because the moon is red, and the dead make the best music.” His grin hardens, edges honed on old cruelty. “Because I heard of a black-haired woman with eyes the color of bruises and thought: finally, something to sharpen my teeth on. Because I am done with weak family. They were so certain they were monsters. They were not.” “And you are?” she asks. He watches the swirl of invisible threads gather on her fingers, the way light bends infinitesimally at her wrist. There is a sigil there, worked a thousand times, and she is most beautiful when she is arithmetic. He slides off the well and onto the square. “I am what happens when something refuses to die so long that the idea of death begins to be jealous.” “Jealousy is petty,” she says. But he hears the tremor under it, the chord he has plucked by accident or design. What does a woman centuries old long for that he can taste? Absence. A life that did not happen. A borrowed womb that will not answer. “You smell also of longing,” he says conversationally. “Gooseberries and absence. That is a cruel combination.” Her eyes narrow just enough. The well-chain rattles as if in a sudden gust. “You’re not the first creature that’s tried to sniff out my secrets.” “And eaten,” he says, rolling his shoulders as if to shake off cobweb. “Or survived? The rumor didn’t say.” The magic moves fully. It does not erupt; it unveils. A circle hums into being at her feet like frost traced fast. The dead wax peels. The lilac deepens, becomes cutting. He chuckles as a swarm of black-veiled tendrils climb his legs, cold as standing water. They pin his coat against his thighs. The ground grits under the weight of their insistence. “Show me what you are without the coat, old thing,” Yennefer says. Her voice is nothing now but blade. He relaxes. The tendrils find purchase and lift him, and for one heartbeat she feels triumph, because power has leaned and he has yielded. He lets his outline blur. The coat hangs a heartbeat empty, the hat floats like an idea, then skulls open like lily blossoms along his spine, wet and obscene and smiling. “Ah,” she says, pushed back a step despite herself. “That.” A spike of shadow thrusts up from the square and she meets it with a curt snap of fingers; glass walls flower around her from air; they hiss as his shadow points pierce, slide, knit; she gestures and the glass becomes slices of absolute cold. He grins with six mouths and bites at the spell, and his tongue smokes where it touches the frost. He shudders in delight. “Yes,” he says from everywhere. “Yes, little star. More.” Yennefer’s laugh is a brittle ornament. The tendrils around his legs tighten until even his immortal bones complain. She pulls, and the village shifts with her, the stones slurring, the whole square an opening jaw. “Careful what you ask for.” He lets himself be dragged and reforms inside his own collapse, standing with his boots in the heart of the sigil, coat steady, glasses in place. The complaining chains still. He has not moved, and yet he has disappointed the space he occupies, which wanted to be occupied by his undoing. It is a small insult. He savors it. “You’re not the only one who learned to be more than her body,” Yennefer says into the quiet. And there it is: a shard of bone-white truth thrown at him like a favor. He tips his hat. The brim cuts a red crescent out of the moonlight. “Taught by pain? My favorite teacher. She is stern.” “Pain is tedious.” Her voice is breathless now only because she has spent something. Sweat beads at her hairline and gleams like dew on iron. “Its lessons repeat.” “Then graduate,” he suggests. “Or repeat until you forget why you started.” “You’ve forgotten?” she says. And there is the edge of a knife in it. “No,” he says, softly. The hat’s shadow hides his smile for a breath. “I am very diligent.” They circle. The wind rises and the fur at her collar ripples like a sea. His coat licks the dust. He lifts one of the massive guns, the black length of it swallowing moonlight, six engraved sigils crawling faintly. He does it lazily, like a man lifting a wine bottle. He points it nowhere and everywhere, and she can feel the threat in it because threat is not the bullet but the intent. He lowers it again. “I’d rather not shoot a woman who can make me amuse myself,” he says. “Flattered,” she deadpans. “It’s rare to be considered a fool’s entertainment.” “Not a fool.” He flashes teeth. “A monster.” “On that we agree,” she says, and this time there is no lie in it. The square breathes, or perhaps it is the night. The red moon leans. Somewhere a bellless church imagines sound. “What do you want?” he asks, teeth clicking, head canted like a fox, like a question mark. She considers lying. It would be easy. She has lied longer than anyone in this village has been dead. But she has already invited truth into the square, and it is rude to slam the door on a guest. “I want,” Yennefer says, each word with weight, “what I was denied. I want to change the rules. I want a thing that cannot be had.” “And you think I relate,” he says. He taps one gloved finger against his collarbone, where somewhere in the skin something old is sealed. “The thing you want and the thing I want might meet on a road.” “You want to die,” she says, flat. He shrugs a shoulder, graceful. The leather squeaks. “Sometimes. Or to be surprised. You’ve done something like that. The surprise. It is rare.” “Don’t wag your tail yet,” she says. The retort is easy, an old skin. “I haven’t decided what to do with you.” “You cannot do anything with me that I do not also do with you,” he says, pleased. “That,” she murmurs, almost smiling, “sounds like a promise no one asked for.” They stand with the well between them, everything red and brittle around the edges. He lifts his face to the moon and inhales like a man before a plunge. “Shall we make a game of it?” he suggests lightly. “You try to hurt me. I try to make you admit you enjoyed it.” “Half of that is unnecessary.” Her violet eyes gleam. “You are arrogant.” “Arrogance is a kind of hunger,” he says. “You have it too.” Her magic hums again, but softer this time, not an axe but a harp. The frost re-traces itself as a lace at her cuff. “We could help each other,” she says, very carefully, as if assembling a labyrinth in air. “In a manner of speaking.” He regards her over the rim of his glasses. He can see the organs in her chest if he wishes, the small bird of her heart beating bruised and stubborn. He does not. It would be rude. “Ah,” he says softly. “Politics.” “Possibilities,” she corrects. “Don’t pretend the word scares you.” “Nothing scares me,” he says. It is, for once, not entirely a lie; what he means by fear is not what others mean. “Even the thought of never finding your equal?” she says, as if idly adjusting a ring that is not there. He laughs, abrupt and delighted, as if she had reached into him and tickled a rib. “There,” he says. “A cut.” The wind lifts again, hard this time, whipping her cloak and slapping the hat brim up to show his eyes. For an instant the orange glasses catch the crimson and throw it, two coins tossed upward and caught. He tips his head as if listening to a tune only he can hear. “Tonight,” he says, “I am not your equal. You are not mine. But we are not bored, and that is something.” She inclines her head a fraction, the acknowledgment a jewel stingy and real. “Don’t stalk me,” she says. “Impossible,” he lies. “I will loiter.” She turns then, cloak snapping, the smell of lilac and gooseberries like a signature. She walks away down the slain street into the deeper dark. She does not look back. He dismisses the guns in a whisper of steel and shadow, puts his hands in his coat pockets, and begins to whistle some graveyard tune that learned to be jaunty to keep from breaking. The harvest moon watches them both, low and leering, and the shadows of the deserted village lean after them like hands that almost touch and never quite do. The blood runs down the street and disappears into the thirsty earth, which is patient and takes everything eventually. He steps after her without hurry, and if the distance between them closes, it is only because the night is small and the world is old and certain conversations echo longer than the first words spoken. He smiles up at the moon as though at a long joke, and the moon bares its teeth back, and they go on under it, each a knife in the other’s pocket neither has decided to use.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkable character study that brings together two powerful figures from different fictional universes. The author has crafted an atmospheric encounter between Alucard and Yennefer that captures the essence of both characters while creating a tense, psychologically complex interaction. The writing excels in its atmospheric quality. The opening description of the "harvest moon... swollen and red" over an empty village immediately establishes the gothic tone. The author consistently maintains this atmosphere throughout, with vivid sensory details like "the sweet-sour breath of graves" and Yennefer's scent of "lilac and gooseberries." The imagery is consistently strong, creating a cinematic quality that allows readers to visualize this supernatural confrontation. Character portrayal is exceptional. Both Alucard and Yennefer are rendered with fidelity to their source material while being seamlessly integrated into this new context. Alucard's sadistic playfulness, his arrogance, and his desire for worthy opponents are all present. Similarly, Yennefer's cold exterior, magical prowess, and underlying vulnerability regarding her infertility are skillfully woven into the narrative. The author has captured their voices perfectly, with dialogue that feels authentic to both characters. The prose style is sophisticated and poetic without becoming overwrought. Metaphors like "her violet eyes like bruised stars" and "the moon paints him like a saint in a bad icon" are striking without being excessive. The author demonstrates remarkable control over language, using it to enhance the mood and characterization rather than calling attention to itself unnecessarily. The power dynamic between the characters is handled with nuance. As requested in the prompt, they "circle each other, neither willing to show weakness first." Their interaction is a psychological chess match, with each character probing for vulnerabilities while maintaining their guard. The tension between them is palpable, creating a compelling dynamic that drives the narrative forward. Dialogue is a particular strength. The exchanges between Alucard and Yennefer crackle with tension and subtext. Lines like "You're not the only one who learned to be more than her body" reveal character depth while advancing the psychological confrontation. The dialogue feels natural while maintaining the distinctive voices of both characters. The narrative structure is well-crafted, with the confrontation building to a climax before resolving into an uneasy détente. The ending avoids simplistic resolution, instead leaving the characters in a state of mutual wariness and fascination that feels true to who they are. If there are weaknesses, they are minor. Occasionally, the prose becomes slightly ornate, though this generally suits the gothic atmosphere. The piece also assumes some familiarity with both characters, which might leave readers unfamiliar with either source material at a slight disadvantage, though the author does provide enough context through the narrative to make the encounter comprehensible. Overall, this is an exceptional piece of crossover fiction that demonstrates a deep understanding of both characters while creating something new and compelling from their interaction. The writing is sophisticated, atmospheric, and psychologically nuanced, making for an engaging and memorable read. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 20 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 20.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Prison Strings — Score: 91.3
Prompt:
Prison Strings Jolyne Cujoh & Makima Write a story where Jolyne Cujoh (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure) and Makima (Chainsaw Man) cross paths at a supernatural prison facility. Jolyne is immediately suspicious of Makima's falsely sweet demeanor, while Makima is intrigued by Jolyne's Stand ability. Their battle of wits escalates dangerously as Jolyne realizes how manipulative Makima truly is. **Jolyne Cujoh (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure)** Jolyne is the daughter of Jotaro Kujo and the first female JoJo protagonist. Her Stand, Stone Free, allows her to unravel her body into string that she can control. She's hot-headed, foul-mouthed, and doesn't take disrespect from anyone. She was framed for murder and sent to prison. She has a distinctive butterfly tattoo on her arm and wears her hair in two buns. Despite her tough exterior, she's deeply loyal to her friends and family. She can be impulsive but is highly adaptable in battle. She inherited her father's ability to stay cool under pressure but is more emotionally expressive. Famous quote: "If there's no Mickey, this shit ain't Disney!" **Makima (Chainsaw Man)** Makima appears as a young woman with auburn hair and ringed yellow eyes. She's the Control Devil who can dominate anyone she considers beneath her (nearly everyone). She maintains a pleasant, soft-spoken demeanor that masks her manipulative, cold nature. She can create contracts with humans and devils, often exploiting their desires. She's obsessed with Chainsaw Man and wants to control him. She keeps numerous people and devils as pets on leashes. She's practically immortal due to a contract with the Prime Minister. She views humans as lesser beings but mimics human emotions perfectly. Famous quote: "It's okay. Dogs are supposed to die for their owners." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
A dim overhead light flickers in the prison corridor at irregular intervals, breaking the darkness into slices of hard white and shadow. The air is chilled, bleached clean, like it wants to erase the scent of worry left behind by anyone who’s ever walked through here. Footsteps echo—one set slow and measured, the other tapping with a restless rhythm. Jolyne stares at the figure ahead of her through the bars as her fingers curl, index knuckle cracking a tempo of impatience. The woman is slender, auburn hair tied neatly, a long coat draped with the kind of authority that doesn’t apologize. Yellow ringed eyes soak in details without seeming to move. She stands next to a guard who keeps stealing glances at her, as if measuring, as if flinching. “New warden?” Jolyne asks, deadpan. “Or another freak in a suit trying to make my life interesting?” The woman smiles faintly. It’s the kind of smile Jolyne associates with loan sharks and fake girlfriends. “My name is Makima,” she says. “I’m here to assess threats. You qualify. I heard you can turn yourself into string.” “Stone Free,” Jolyne says, already unwinding a thread from her fingertip, the string gleaming like polished fiber in the wavering light. “You talk like you file people in cabinets.” “People are easy to file,” Makima replies, and the guard beside her nods, his breathing slowing, eyes going slack, like someone dimmed him from the inside. “You’re different. You’re interesting.” Jolyne flexes her jaw. If there’s no Mickey, this shit ain’t Disney. “Lady, I’ve had enough ‘interesting’ to last three lifetimes.” She pulls, and a tight loop of string slides through the lock of the gate with a metallic hiss. The guard doesn’t react. Makima watches Jolyne break into the corridor as if observing a painting. “That’s a poor way to greet a guest,” Makima chides softly. “Guess I’ll call the concierge.” Jolyne steps out. The facility is wrong. This isn’t Green Dolphin Street Prison, not really. The concrete is too smooth. The bars are new. The smell is antiseptic, an aftertaste of something metallic that coats the back of her tongue. The signs are in no language she recognizes, and yet she reads them anyway. And the guard beside Makima—his eyes reflect nothing. Jolyne’s skin prickles. She turns a corner, string slicing the air into tripwires as she goes. Makima follows, her shoes tapping without urgency. The guard falls in behind her like a shadow with a pulse. “When did you realize this isn’t your prison?” Makima asks. “When I realized you were smiling at me like a cat in a cartoon,” Jolyne says. “And that nobody else here blinks unless you let them.” Makima actually blinks at that—slow, appreciative. “You’re perceptive. Not all of you are.” “Us? You collecting people like trading cards?” “I prefer dogs,” Makima says. “They’re simpler. Loyal.” “Try a different word. That one’s making my skin crawl.” The corridor widens into a block of cells with glass fronts instead of bars. Inside one, a nurse sits in a chair, hands folded in her lap. She’s not breathing. Her eyes track Jolyne and Makima, but her chest doesn’t rise. In another cell, a man in a jumpsuit holds his hands up as if in surrender, kneeling to no one. “Let us out,” the man whispers. He doesn’t look at Makima. He can’t. “Please.” “Shut it,” Jolyne snaps without heat, and the man obeys. She doesn’t look away from Makima. “What exactly do you want?” Makima’s smile doesn’t move. Her voice is pleasant, soothing. “To understand how your strings handle pressure.” “You could have just asked.” “People lie,” Makima says. “Sincerity is easiest to procure when it is not optional.” “Is that what you tell yourself so you can sleep at night?” Jolyne tilts her head. “Or do you even bother?” Makima tilts her head in a mirror of Jolyne’s motion, as if considering which answer would disappoint her least. “Sleep is unimportant.” The light flickers. It takes a breath to come back this time. When it does, Jolyne’s threads are everywhere, mapped from floor drains to the hinges of doors, taut lines forming an invisible web. Makima has not stepped around them, but none of the strings touch her. Jolyne notices it like you notice a missing tooth with your tongue. Her threads have a sense, the same way fingertips can feel a ghost of a draft. The air around Makima is still. Not empty—obedient. The world bends. “You’re not human,” Jolyne says, fighting the urge to rub the goosebumps from her forearms. Makima’s expression doesn’t change. The guard’s eyes flick to her, then to the floor. “I didn’t say I was,” she answers. “Does that frighten you?” “It pisses me off.” She pulls. The strings snap taut around Makima’s arms and waist, thread-bands that could restrain a car engine. The guard jerks in front of her like a puppet, and Jolyne’s strings bite into him instead. He doesn’t scream. He doesn’t bleed. He just stops. Makima steps to the right, unbothered, as if the world has politely shifted with her. “You’ll find that intervening bodies are a common courtesy,” Makima says. “It keeps everyone from getting hurt.” Jolyne’s teeth grind. “I’m not ‘everyone.’” She extends Stone Free to full, her body unraveling into a cyclone of strings, spinning herself thin enough to slip through an air grate, slingshotting around, coming out behind Makima with a thin, needle-sharp thread aimed for her temple. The air resists like honey. The needle stops. Jolyne hits the floor and rewinds, her palms skidding on cold tile. Makima turns only her head. “You’re smarter than I expected.” “Don’t talk down to me,” Jolyne snarls. “I told you. I’m not a dog.” “No,” Makima concedes. “You’re a cat. You pretend not to need anyone, and then you curl up in the lap of whoever warms your bones at the right moment.” Jolyne takes a step, then another, strings whispering out to pull grates loose, to tighten sprinklers, to map every path. “Keep talking. It’ll make knocking you out even more satisfying.” Makima’s hands clasp behind her back. “Your father would disagree with your methods, but he’d be proud of your instincts. He’d want you safe. If I asked him, he would come.” “I’d like to see you try,” Jolyne says, but her chest tightens. The thought of Jotaro—his hand on her shoulder, his voice steady even when he’s cold—hits like a sucker punch. Bastard woman, using that. She swallows. “You think I’m going to fall apart because you say ‘dad’? Screw you.” In the cell to the right, the nurse stands up, slow and careful. Jolyne’s string at the corner of her eye flares. She yanks, and the glass splits the air with a shriek as the door slams shut again. “I don’t need you to fall apart,” Makima says. “I need you to be useful. Bring your strings. They’re elegant. I could teach you to control more than thread. I could teach you to pull people the way you pull doors.” “And what? Put collars on my friends? Make them bark?” Jolyne barks out a laugh. “That sounds like hell.” Makima’s eyes warm in a way that isn’t warmth. “Dogs are happiest when they have owners. It’s okay. Dogs are supposed to die for their owners.” Jolyne’s stomach flips, rage going white-hot. She’s moving before she thinks, body unraveling full, Stone Free blooming behind her, a human silhouette woven from a thousand fibers. She punches. The strings drive forward, forced through the air, denser, sharper. Her knuckles sing with impact as they hit— Darkness. The light dies, plunging the corridor into black. For a heartbeat, Jolyne senses only her own lines, singing through the space like taut harp strings. Then something else hums, deeper, the world thrumming like a throat clearing, like a breath held too long. The light returns. Her fist is embedded an inch deep into the concrete wall where Makima had been. Makima stands three paces away, not a hair out of place. The guard is gone. The cells are empty. The nurse, the kneeling man, the others—gone. “What did you do?” Jolyne demands, breathing hard. Makima’s eyes track Jolyne’s chest rising and falling, calculating. “I asked them to leave. You’d be more comfortable without an audience.” “You ordered them,” Jolyne says. “Like furniture.” “They were happy to be useful.” “I’m going to be sick.” Makima takes a step closer. Jolyne’s threads shiver around her like a living hurricane, every strand ready to cut and bind, to catch and break. “I’m not your enemy, Jolyne,” Makima says, almost tender. “I like you. You are efficient. You are brave. Under the right leash, you would be unstoppable.” Jolyne spits on the floor. “I’d chew through my own tongue before I wear your leash.” Makima’s smile widens, pleased, approving. “I thought you’d say that.” “Then why the song and dance?” “Because it’s polite to offer.” The light flickers again. This time the darkness lingers long enough for Jolyne to feel how the air tightens around her strings, how the world draws taut, as if held in a fist. Her thread sense screams. She dives, body disassembling in a whip-crack as a pressure wave bites the space where her throat was a heartbeat ago. The wall behind her folds inward with a groan. “You’re trying to crush me?” Jolyne asks, rolling into a crouch, Stone Free reknitting her muscles. “I’m trying to see how your strings taste under pressure,” Makima corrects, patient. “I don’t get many chances to play with this kind of texture.” “Lady, get a hobby.” She lashes out again, not at Makima this time, but at the grid in the ceiling, at the electrical lines. Stone Free bites through insulation, rewires, shorts. The lights go mad, strobing faster than thought. In the chaos, Jolyne weaves a cocoon of momentary blindness, threads reflecting and refracting, a micro labyrinth that confuses sight. For a breath, Makima’s attention shifts. Jolyne feels it like an absence of weight. She moves—past her, through a side door, strings guiding her like piano wire. Stone Free pulls locks, drags heavy gates, tangles cameras. The corridors twist but her web is a map that didn’t exist until she wrote it. “Running?” Makima’s voice carries, not loud but everywhere at once. “Cats run. They always come back to the warm spot.” Jolyne grits her teeth. “I’m choosing my battlefield.” She explodes out into an open control hall. Rows of monitors show corridors she’s never walked, empty cells she never wants to see again, a yard under a false sky. The long table in the center is littered with files. A coffee mug sits fresh and steaming. No one is here. No one has ever been here. Jolyne yanks the emergency alarm lever. Sirens rip the silence. She doesn’t expect help. She expects noise. She expects sources of vibration to lean on, currents to ride. Makima steps into the doorway as casually as if she’d been invited. She’s framed by the flickering light like a saint in a cheap painting. “No one is coming,” she says, almost gentle. “This place is for things that belong to me. You could belong to me.” “No thanks,” Jolyne says. “I’ve already got a life.” Makima’s gaze is steady, pitying, the way you look at a stray with matted fur. “You don’t. Not really. But you could have one that’s easier.” “I don’t do ‘easy.’ I do ‘right.’” Makima’s lips part in a sigh, affectionate, like a disappointed mother. “Stubborn.” “And you’re a control freak.” Jolyne rolls her shoulders, feels the hum in the walls and the song of the alarm and her own heartbeat, and for a second she can almost hear her father’s voice telling her to keep her head. She smiles, feral. “Let’s end this before I say something I’ll regret.” Makima nods. “As you wish.” They collide. The room screams. Strings whip, walls buckle, the world tries to close, and Jolyne threads it open, wedge after wedge. Makima advances with patience that feels like doom, every step a hand placed gently on the back of Jolyne’s neck. Jolyne doesn’t give. She improvises, ties the alarm cord to the sprinkler rigs, bursts them. Water falls in sheets, bead-laden threads. The air grows heavy and alive, every droplet a node, every surface connected. Stone Free becomes a web glistening with rain. Makima stops. For the first time, something like curiosity deepens. “Clever.” “Yeah,” Jolyne pants, grinning. “I have my moments.” Makima’s eyes lift to the water. The control room is a hive of paths now, every beat of rain a wire she didn’t make, and for an instant the world isn’t only obedient to Makima—it is busy with Jolyne. The pressure wave comes late. Jolyne rides it, flips the vector, anchors herself to pipes and panels, and hurls that redirected force sideways. The wall caves, the monitors explode, smoke blooms. In the choking fog, Jolyne hears a low laugh. Not cruel. Not warm. Enjoying the puzzle. “You’d make a good pet,” Makima says softly through the dust. “It’s a shame.” “Bite me.” The room clears. Makima is closer than she should be. Her hand lifts, palm out, like she’s about to pat Jolyne’s head. Jolyne snaps backward, strings coiling to yank her body out of reach, but she doesn’t need to. A thought strikes her with the same clarity as a punch: Makima wants the touch to land. She wants to define the dynamic with that gesture. Jolyne doesn’t do what she wants. She cuts sideways, rips a hole through a service hatch with Stone Free, and dives. The hatch slams. The world narrows to a crawling tunnel of concrete and old wires. Jolyne drags herself hand over hand, threads forward like antennae. Behind her, Makima doesn’t chase. She doesn’t need to. She can find people by their obedience. Jolyne grins in the dark. “Good thing I don’t do orders.” She spits a string to the side, digs into the unknown. The facility shifts, geometry bleeding strange, but Jolyne is a prison expert now. That’s the joke. They put her in a cage and she learned every way out. She slithers into a ventilation cavity and stops. Across the grate, in the pale slice of light, Makima stands. Of course she does. She smiles. Of course she does. “You’re persistent,” Makima says. “Cats are.” “Lady, I’m a hurricane with a manicure.” Makima’s head tilts. “I’ll see you again.” “Not if I see you first,” Jolyne says, because there’s no better vow here. Makima’s smile flickers, a flare of true interest. Then the lights go out one final time, deeper than before, a blackout that tears the world—and when they return, the grate is empty. The corridor beyond is just a corridor. The nurse is not there. The man is not there. The coffee is cold. Jolyne breathes, long and slow. She rewinds herself, sits up, elbows on knees. Her hands shake. She stares at the wet web of her strings and watches water run along them like veins, like a circulatory system she built to keep herself alive. “Makima,” she mutters to the empty air, tasting the name like a warning, like a splinter under her skin. “Next time, I’m bringing friends.” The overhead light flickers at irregular intervals. Jolyne grins at it like it’s a challenge and rises, threads trailing like a cape. She chooses a direction and moves, mapping, unafraid, a needle in her own compass. Behind her, in rooms she has already left, a soft voice echoes as if from a dream. I’ll see you again. And the air waits, obedient and patient, for the next command it will refuse to give her.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This story effectively captures the confrontation between Jolyne Cujoh and Makima in a supernatural prison setting. The writer demonstrates a strong understanding of both characters, maintaining their canonical personalities and abilities throughout the narrative. The prose is particularly strong in its atmospheric quality. The opening description of the flickering prison light immediately establishes the unsettling tone. The writer employs vivid sensory details throughout, from the "bleached clean" air to the way Makima's presence affects the environment. The imagery is consistently evocative without becoming excessive. Character portrayal is one of the story's strongest elements. Jolyne's hot-headed, defiant nature comes through in both her actions and dialogue ("Lady, I've had enough 'interesting' to last three lifetimes"). Her canonical quote is naturally integrated. Similarly, Makima's false sweetness masking cold manipulation is perfectly captured, especially in lines like "Dogs are supposed to die for their owners." The writer shows a deep understanding of what makes these characters tick. The dialogue is sharp and character-appropriate. Jolyne's crude, confrontational speech patterns contrast effectively with Makima's soft-spoken but menacing tone. Their verbal sparring reveals character and advances the plot simultaneously. The battle of wits and powers is well-executed, with each character using their abilities in creative ways. The writer demonstrates a thorough understanding of Stone Free's string capabilities and Makima's control powers. The action sequences are dynamic and clearly visualized, particularly the water-sprinkler strategy Jolyne employs. The story maintains tension throughout, with a natural escalation as Jolyne realizes the true nature of the prison and Makima's intentions. The pacing is excellent, alternating between tense confrontation and moments of revelation. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally, a metaphor might be slightly overextended ("a hurricane with a manicure"), but these moments are rare and don't detract significantly from the overall quality. The ending leaves things somewhat unresolved, though this is appropriate for a character confrontation that could naturally continue beyond this single encounter. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that demonstrates a deep understanding of both source materials while creating something that stands on its own as an engaging narrative. The writer balances character, atmosphere, and action expertly while maintaining a consistent voice throughout. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Scp: Notes from the Future — Score: 88.8
Prompt:
Write an SCP report about a researcher who begins finding handwritten notes from their future self, warning about a containment breach that hasn't happened yet. The notes become increasingly desperate and incoherent, sometimes containing information that contradicts known reality. Include the Foundation's attempts to determine if this is an actual temporal anomaly or psychological manipulation by a contained entity, and the researcher's struggle to trust their own perception. First person (researcher's perspective with interspersed notes), past tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Item #: SCP-████ Object Class: Pending (see Addendum) Special Containment Procedures: All handwritten notes attributed to Dr. E. [REDACTED] (Site-19, Applied Temporal Studies) shall be collected, catalogued, and stored in a secure document locker under double-key access. Dr. [REDACTED] is restricted from unsupervised access to stationary, printers, and blank Foundation memorandum pads. Onsite psychology and counter-memetics teams will conduct weekly evaluations. Exposure of additional personnel to the notes is limited to clearance-level necessity while counter-memetic screens are updated. Description: On ██/██/20██, I began finding handwritten notes in my office during routine work hours. The handwriting matched my own to a 96.3% confidence score, and the notes—including those found in secure environments—were always written on standard Foundation memorandum paper (Form-7F, blue border, watermark “Sine Timore”). Even when I locked all memo paper away, sealed in a safe, or replaced stock with non-Foundation notepads, any new note I found was on Form-7F. Preliminary analyses showed the paper fibers, watermark alignment, and printer-ink artifacts matched Site-19’s central stock. I will reproduce portions of my log interspersed with excerpts of the notes, as ordered, to enable both temporal and psychological review. Day 1: I was calibrating the chronometric lattice for SCP-3412 cross-testing when I saw a folded sheet under my keyboard. Note A: You hear it later than I did. Don’t ignore the alarms. Go to B-Corridor, bulkhead 3, before 14:12. Seal it from the inside. If you see Kline, don’t let him talk. I checked the security feed. No one had entered my office that morning, and the cleaning crew had clocked out two hours prior. 14:12 came and went without incident. I stayed at my desk, pretending not to glance at the door every thirty seconds. No breach. Kline stopped by at 15:20 to ask about an equipment requisition. He talked at length. Security flagged the note as a hoax. I was told to keep it and report any further anomalies. Day 3: Note B appeared on my chair, folded once inside a second piece of Form-7F. Tissue analysis later showed both sheets had trace sweat from my hands, consistent with my own personal profile. Note B: They moved the time. They always move the time. You won’t believe this yet. Look at the photograph in your second drawer. Stop thinking you’re alone. If you do nothing else—block the west stairs. Block them and don’t explain. I didn’t have a photograph in my second drawer. When I opened it, there was a photo I had never seen before: me, standing in B-Corridor, bulkhead 3, empty but with foam sealant sprayed around the hatch. My face was obscured by my raised hand as if waving to the camera. Security logs showed no such event. The timestamp on the photo was 09:06 the same day. At 09:06 that day, I was in a team briefing. I submitted to handwriting analysis, requested an amnestic as a precaution, and was denied pending further observation. Day 6: I found Note C wedged in the hinge of my locker, the metal biting its paper. The locker had been sealed with a tamper strip that remained intact. The note had no crease lines consistent with being slid through a gap. Note C: They started small because they needed you to think it was a joke. It’s not. The breach starts with a smell. You’ll think it’s solvent. It’s bone. If you can read this you still have both wrists. Don’t look at your wrists. Don’t shake Kline’s hand. By then, everyone had asked me how I was sleeping. I said fine, then started sleeping in my office chair. I washed with paper towels and antiseptic foam, because if I went to the dorms, I’d start looking for notes under the pillow. We formed an ad hoc task force: me, Kline, Dr. Park from Counter-Temporal, and two security officers. We installed a camera in my office pointed at the desk, the drawers, the cabinet, the underside of the chair. We replaced the memo pads with numbered sheets in tamper-evident sleeves. We switched my pen to a pressure-analyzed stylus that recorded stroke patterns. The task force asked me to pretend to ignore any note that appeared, to see who came to collect. Day 8: There were two notes. Note D1 (under keyboard, again): You waited. You always wait. Stop waiting. The alarms won’t sound. That was a lie I told you to get you moving. This time I’m not lying: don’t let them show you the footage. The footage isn’t yours. It’s older than your eyes. Note D2 (in my coat pocket, dry despite residual wet from a rainstorm I had walked through): They said it’s a memetic hazard. It isn’t. It’s a timing hazard. Don’t trust the blue border. They keep the borders when they swap the center. We examined Form-7F stock from four different storerooms. No anomalies. The blue border dye was consistent across sites. Park proposed a scenario: a contained entity with psychographic mimicry capabilities piggybacked on a common object. Another scenario: an unstable local time loop with self-consistent messaging from an older me. We put me on twice-daily mnestic microdoses to mitigate suggestibility. Day 11: I smelled solvent. The labs always smell like solvent. I told myself this. The smell was sweet, then mineral, then something else. I forgot my coffee on the hot plate and it boiled until the room filled with steam. I started sweating through my shirt. Note E was taped to the inside of my glasses lens. I had been wearing them for three hours. Note E: You’ll keep thinking you can outsmart it. You can’t. Break the fire glass and trigger the foam. It hates foam. Don’t tell Park. She won’t be her by then. It’s not her fault. You will forgive her if you live. The foam station glass was intact. I didn’t break it. If this was manipulation, triggering the foam could have harmed personnel or whatever was contained on the floor below. I put my glasses in an evidence bag and tried to work without them, squinting at fluctuating numbers that wavered and doubled like fish. Day 12: Security played me footage. It showed me, at 09:06 on Day 3, standing in B-Corridor, bulkhead 3, applying foam sealant. Then, as the camera panned, my arm bent in a way that made no anatomical sense, reached around behind my back, and set the frame back on the wall. This contradicted reality as I understand it. Park paused the footage and asked me what I saw. I said a smear of pixels. Kline said “We can doctor video if we want to scare him.” No one laughed. I asked to see the raw timestamps. The metadata was clean. Note F was tucked into the server rack, at the back, on a shelf no one had touched in months. We found it by accident while verifying the feed. Note F: This is the part where you think it’s about you. It isn’t. You are a tool someone else is using to pry open a hinge. Don’t be a hinge. Be a wedge. Wedges don’t swing. Wedges break. Go to bulkhead 3 now. 14:12’s a lie. It’s 13:34. It’s always 13:34 when you’re brave. I went. At 13:34 the corridor was empty. The bulkhead’s seal was normal. I touched the wheel. I smelled the sweet-mineral bone smell. I froze. Security found me there at 14:28 gripping the wheel, knuckles white, not moving. Day 15: I wrote a note to myself as a test. I locked it, with a hair, in a single-use polymer sample tube stamped with my initials, embedded in casting resin we poured on camera. I wrote: “If you read this, call me an idiot and tell me to go home.” At 03:02, the night guard reported finding Note G folded inside my pillowcase in the office. It was my stationery, my handwriting, with a faint imprint where I had scrawled the test note earlier—mirror reversed beneath. The content: Note G: It’s funny you thought that would help. I love you for it. Go home. You can’t, of course. They won’t let you. You’re doing good work. Today it gets loud. Block the west stairs. If I can catch your hand before you reach for the rail, maybe you keep both wrists. Don’t check: you still have both. I checked. I still had both. We tightened procedures. I wasn’t allowed to be alone. I slept under camera. I ate food sealed by someone else’s hands. When I blinked, I saw the blue border of Form-7F. When I dreamt, I saw bulkhead 3 doing something doors don’t do. Day 17: The first contradiction that hurt: Note H said, “Park dies first.” Park was alive. Note H also said, “We cut power to the wing at 12:14.” Power remained. At 12:14, the lights flickered. A UPS relay kicked in. I told myself that’s what UPS relays do. Park put her hand on my shoulder. I flinched like I’d been burned. Note H (continued on the back, cramped, as if written at speed): If you’re reading this, I learned to write with the left. You haven’t yet. This is how we know. The blue border is a lie. Look at the watermark. It’s wrong. It says Sine Timore—no, it says Sin Timor. They’re close. This is how it gets near. I held the memo up to light. The watermark said Sine Timore, correct. I tried another. Sine Timore. A third. Sine Timore. I wanted to find one that said the wrong thing so that I could be right. Day 19: Counter-memetics performed a battery of tests. No cognitohazard signatures beyond normal ranges. They escalated to a running hypothesis: either an undetected temporal leakage affecting local messaging or a high-fidelity psychological manipulation keyed to my motor patterns and personal narrative, maybe seeded via residual contact with SCP-3412’s instrumentation. We reviewed containment logs for entities with known reality-adjacent communication methods. None had access to Stationery. Some had access to me. Note I was inside my left glove between my palm and the fabric. I removed the glove at a sink and the note fell onto the counter like a moth. Note I: When it finally opens, it’s quiet. Don’t trust quiet. Bulwark is a word. Say it. Then say wedge. Then say forgive. If you can say forgive, you can keep going. If you can’t, step away from the wheel and let them empty you out. It’s better than the other thing. I said bulwark. I said wedge. I couldn’t say forgive out loud. I whispered it and it sounded like a lie. Day 21: They showed me the footage again. This time, the camera saw me at 03:02 walking to the office, entering, shutting the door, then flattening myself against the wall. The door opened without anyone pulling it. The lights flickered. A stack of Form-7F slid across the desk by itself. I stepped forward, picked one up, wrote furiously, folded it, tucked it into my pillowcase. Then I stood in the dark for eight minutes and didn’t move. I watched myself do it and I remembered sleeping dreamless from 01:00 to 06:00. I asked for a different angle. The other angle didn’t exist. The camera was “under maintenance.” I asked Park to watch with me. She watched me write and didn’t say anything. Kline said, “That’s not his writing posture.” I signed a consent for increased surveillance and for the possibility that my notes represented a memetic infection vector requiring isolation. They moved me to a smaller room with padded edges and no drawers. They took my belt and my pen and my glasses. The notes stopped for two days. I felt skin grow over the idea. Day 24: Note J was under my tongue when I woke up. I coughed paper and blood into my palm. Note J: We are not sick. We are not possessed. We are not a containment risk. We are a warning. If you don’t move now, you will write this from a chair with straps. You will learn to write with your left. The bones in the right don’t fit anymore. I still have both wrists. You still do. If you act, you’ll keep them. Security found no lacerations in my mouth. Counter-memetics found skin cells on the paper that matched mine and epithelial cells that did not match anyone on staff. Park closed her eyes. Kline left the room. Day 25: The alarms sounded for 22 seconds before cutting out. Everyone looked at me. I looked at the west staircase and saw nothing. I smelled bone. I grabbed the pallet jack parked nearby and rammed it into the staircase gate until the wheels bent and the metal sang. Security shouted. I shouted back that the notes had said to block the stairs. The breach did not happen. The daily incident log recorded “False alarm due to sensor spike in B-Corridor; no breach; minor property damage; reprimand issued.” That night, I took my left hand and wrote on my palm with a marker I had borrowed from Kline when he wasn’t looking: don’t be a hinge. It washed off in the morning. Day 27: I asked Park if she believed me. She said belief wasn’t operational. I asked Kline to shake my hand. He hesitated. I grabbed his anyway. Nothing happened. I felt the bones of his fingers. They fit where bones go. Note K appeared inside a sealed evidence bag we had left on the table as a control. It fogged the plastic as if it were warm. Note K: They will tell you this is you losing your mind. They will be kind. They will strap you gently. They will feed you things that make your dreams slide off. If you let them, you will live a long time in a soft room. If you don’t, you might not live long at all. Choose the world where Park lives. Choose the world where Kline says sorry. Choose the world where you are a wedge. I asked what it meant to be a wedge. Park said nothing. Kline said he would say sorry for doubting me if I told him what to do. I told him to move the foam rigs to B-Corridor. He did. Security filed the appropriate forms. Day 29: I slept. I dreamt I was in a corridor I knew too well, and the bulkhead unlatched itself like a mouth. I woke to the smell and the quiet. No alarm. No lights. Just a sense of weight shifting on the other side of a door I had closed a thousand times with my eyes. I stood. My wrists hurt. I counted to ten. I said bulwark. I said wedge. I said forgive. It sounded less like a lie. Note L was in my shoe. Note L: Now. I went to B-Corridor and the foam rigs were there and the pallet jack still blocked the west stairs and Kline was on the radio and Park was not there yet. I put my ear to the steel. I heard nothing and I thought that meant something. I spun the wheel and sealed the internal bolts. I sprayed the seams with foam until it oozed like bread. I looked down the hall and for a second the lights stretched long and slow and then snapped back like elastic. Kline said my name in a voice that had too much air in it. I said we were done. He said we were not. The alarms sounded. This time they did not cut out. Post-Incident Summary: There was a breach from an adjacent wing. It did not involve our corridor. The foam rigs were later deemed unnecessary but harmless. Park sprained her ankle running to B-Corridor. No fatalities. Kline said “sorry” and meant it. I kept both wrists. The notes stopped for a week. Addendum: At present, there is insufficient evidence to classify the notes as purely temporal or purely manipulative. The Foundation’s attempts to determine origin have produced contradictory results. The paper is ours. The writing is mine. The content shifts between prescience and nonsense. In reality A, a door opens. In reality B, it doesn’t. Both realities leave paper in my mouth. Evaluation by Counter-Temporal: - The appearance of notes in sealed environments suggests either micro-apportation consistent with localized time-shear or the intervention of an entity capable of bypassing physical security using psychometabolic keys derived from the subject. - The partial accuracy of warnings could indicate a temporal echo where probabilities bleed into presences, with self-editing messages attempting to optimize outcomes. The conflicting details could be interference by an external manipulator aiming to erode trust and induce either paralysis or reckless behavior. Evaluation by Psychological Services: - Subject exhibits elevated stress, hypervigilance, and mild persecutory ideation in response to persistent anomalous stimuli, without baseline psychosis markers. The notes function as a destabilizing narrative scaffold. Subject’s struggle to trust own perception is rational given evidence of manipulated media and the undermining of sensory consistency. - Recommendation: Maintain structured support, controlled exposure, and contingency plans that do not rely on subject’s unilateral decisions. Current Status: Object Class remains pending. We don’t know if I wrote to myself, or if something wore my knuckles like gloves and wrote for me. We don’t know if the breach I was warned about happened elsewhere because I moved fast here, or if it never would have happened at all. I keep a single Form-7F sheet in a clear box on my desk. It says: Note M: If you’re me, you’re tired. If you’re not me, you think this is a joke. It wasn’t. Don’t let them make you gentle when you need to be a wedge. Don’t let them make you a hinge. If the smell comes back, count to ten. Say the words. Forgive them. Forgive yourself. Turn the wheel. When I hold it up to the light, the watermark says Sine Timore. If I stare long enough, sometimes it doesn’t. I make myself look away. I say bulwark. I say wedge. I say forgive. I say it until it sounds like truth, or until the alarms tell me
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This SCP report effectively captures the essence of the Foundation's clinical documentation style while delivering a compelling first-person narrative about temporal anomalies. The piece successfully creates an atmosphere of mounting dread and uncertainty through the researcher's increasingly desperate notes from their future self. The format adheres closely to SCP conventions, with appropriate containment procedures, clinical language, and redactions. The interspersed notes create an effective narrative device that builds tension as the story progresses. Each note adds a new layer of unease while maintaining internal consistency with the established anomaly. The character development is subtle but effective. We witness the researcher's psychological deterioration as they struggle with the reality of their situation. Their initial skepticism gradually transforms into paranoia and then desperate action as the notes become more urgent. This progression feels natural rather than forced. The prose strikes an excellent balance between clinical detachment and personal terror. The researcher's voice maintains consistency throughout, beginning with professional objectivity and gradually revealing more emotional vulnerability as the anomaly progresses. This evolution feels earned rather than abrupt. The imagery is particularly strong in conveying the researcher's mounting dread. Details like finding notes in increasingly impossible locations (inside a sealed glove, under the tongue) create visceral unease. The recurring motifs (blue borders, the smell of bone, the bulkhead) effectively build a cohesive atmosphere of wrongness. The narrative's strength lies in its ambiguity. We never learn definitively whether the notes represent a genuine temporal anomaly or psychological manipulation. This uncertainty mirrors the researcher's own struggle to trust their perception, creating a satisfying thematic resonance. The piece does occasionally rely on telling rather than showing, particularly in the psychological evaluations section. While this fits the clinical SCP format, it somewhat diminishes the emotional impact that could have been achieved through more direct demonstration of the researcher's mental state. The ending strikes an appropriate balance between resolution and lingering uncertainty. The immediate crisis appears resolved, but the fundamental questions remain unanswered. This ambiguity feels intentional rather than incomplete, leaving the reader with the same unsettled feeling as the protagonist. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted SCP entry that successfully blends clinical documentation with psychological horror. It creates genuine unease through its exploration of unreliable perception and temporal distortion while maintaining internal consistency and emotional resonance. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 4 Tell-Don't-Show: 5 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 4.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 5.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Scp: Unmarked Doors Archive — Score: 90.0
Prompt:
Write an SCP entry about a series of identical unmarked doors appearing in abandoned buildings worldwide that lead to a massive, architecturally impossible archive. Documents within reference a previous global civilization destroyed by an unspecified containment failure. Foundation researchers discover references to their own organization under a different name, including personnel files for current staff dated centuries ago. Include exploration logs revealing sections of the archive actively being removed by entities resembling hazmat teams who flee when approached, and evidence that O5 Council members have visited the archive without authorization. Third person (exploration team perspective) with recovered document excerpts. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Item #: SCP-6579 Object Class: Thaumiel/Keter, pending Special Containment Procedures: As of 2024-11-03, 187 instances of SCP-6579-A (unmarked doors) have been documented in 42 countries. Task Forces Eta-10 (“See No Evil”) and Mu-4 (“Debuggers”) are assigned to locate, catalog, and sequester SCP-6579-A instances, with local Site liaison teams deploying portable exclusion perimeters and installing false walls where feasible. All SCP-6579-A instances are to be guarded by two armed personnel and one archivist. Entry is authorized for Level 3/6579 personnel only, with Level 4 approval required for removal or custodial action on SCP-6579-B materials. Standard entry protocols require tether lines, inert gas sampling, radiation checks, and continuous audio/video. Personnel must carry nonmetallic cutting tools and nonlethal deterrents. If visual contact is made with SCP-6579-C entities, personnel are to maintain 10 m distance, announce intent to withdraw, and avoid obstructing egress. If SCP-6579-C approaches within 5 m, teams are to retreat to the threshold. Pursuit is prohibited. Description: SCP-6579 is a translocational phenomenon accessed through SCP-6579-A, a series of identical, unmarked, surface-flush wooden doors appearing in derelict or abandoned structures worldwide. All SCP-6579-A instances have identical semilunar scratches in the paint around the doorknob, concentric and ragged, consistent with repeated attempts to open the door with a key that did not fit. When opened, SCP-6579-A does not reveal the local interior; instead, the doorway opens onto SCP-6579-B. SCP-6579-B is a contiguous, architecturally incoherent archival facility extending beyond Euclidean space. Interior features include stacks, mezzanines, catwalks, pneumatic transport tubes, and vaulted aisles arranged in discontinuous, non-gravitational geometries. Air composition is breathable, ambient temperature 15–17°C, with constant low-level machine hum with no identifiable source. Lighting is diffuse and sourceless, cycling through a 27-hour dim–bright rhythm not aligned with any terrestrial day-night cycle. SCP-6579-B contains documents, artifacts, and storage media cataloged in a pseudo-bibliographic system written in an unknown administrative argot and partial Baseline English. Approximately 11% of recovered materials explicitly reference a global civilization predating verifiable human history, destroyed by a containment failure of uncertain nature. Recovered indices and memoranda identify administrative bodies with nomenclature and structure that parallel the Foundation, e.g., “The Quiet Directorate,” “Custodial Collegium,” “Silent Counsel.” Multiple personnel records corresponding to current Foundation staff have been recovered, with creation dates ranging from 312–740 years prior to present day. SCP-6579-C are humanoid entities wearing matte white hazmat suits with smooth, reflective visors, respirator backpacks, and insignia consisting of a circle bisected by a vertical bar. SCP-6579-C are observed removing sections of shelving, sealed crates, and entire aisles by means of collapsible rigs and silent pallet systems. SCP-6579-C retreat when approached, avoid contact, and will abandon in-progress removals to reach unknown exits. Attempts to intercept have resulted in SCP-6579-C accelerating to speeds inconsistent with normal human locomotion and vanishing behind shelf ends that do not correspond to navigable space upon pursuit. Discovery: The first known SCP-6579-A manifested on 2024-02-19 in an abandoned civic warehouse in Novi Sad, Serbia. Local reports noted a “new old door” with paint scratches. Municipal explorers opened SCP-6579-A and posted images of large, floating stacks and “humming skylights” before the content was removed. Foundation webcrawlers flagged the posts; containment followed. Two days later, three more SCP-6579-A were located in Detroit, Rasht, and Porto Alegre. Cross-latitude analysis shows no pattern in distribution beyond preference for unoccupied structures. Addendum 6579-1: Exploration Logs (Excerpts) Exploration 6579-B-01 Team: MTF Eta-10 “See No Evil” (E-Lead Morgan, E-Tech Liu, Archivist Dr. R. Bhatt) Entry: SCP-6579-A-04 (Detroit; derelict textile mill) [Begin Log] E-Tech Liu: Tethers anchored. Gas is clean. Ambient noise at 48 dB. E-Lead Morgan: Opening door. [Door opens to a mezzanine overlooking stacked aisles running into apparent infinity. Light is gray/blue; motionless dust hangs in the air. A slow humming is audible, rhythmic but irregular.] Dr. Bhatt: Catalog plates on endcaps. Script doesn’t match any living language. See the English fragments: “Incidents,” “Retirements,” “Vacancies.” E-Lead Morgan: Proceed to nearest workstation. [Team advances along a catwalk with no visible supports. Ambient temperature drops 1.2°C. A workstation consists of a long table, embedded brass sockets, and a single brass plaque reading “INTEGRITY.”] Dr. Bhatt: Boxed files. Paper stock is acidic. Label: “Custodial Collegium—Human Resources—Cohort Alignments.” [Dr. Bhatt removes a folder, flips pages.] Dr. Bhatt: This is… it’s a personnel jacket. Name: “R. Bhatt.” Photograph is… me. E-Lead Morgan: That’s not possible. Dr. Bhatt: Date of induction: Year 412, Cycle 9. “Assigned to Adaptive Epistemics. Cleared for Nine Silent.” That phrase repeats. E-Tech Liu: Nine Silent? Dr. Bhatt: Crossed-out lines include “Quiet Directorate.” Salary fields blank. There’s a termination document with a wax seal. No date I recognize. E-Lead Morgan: Bag it. Keep moving. [They reach an index column. Carved numerals shift when observed. A distant squeal of rollers echoes. E-Tech Liu shines light downward; the “floor” leaps, revealing only further aisles below, inverted.] E-Lead Morgan: Mark path. Don’t trust gravity. [End Log] Recovered Document 6579-B-01 (Excerpt) Memorandum: From the Custodial Collegium, Office of the Quiet Ledger To: All Departments Maintaining Entity Arrays Subject: On the Event of Cascading Failures …Should systemic isolation be proven to have been compromised, all shelves pertaining to Class-Immanent Phenomena shall be embargoed and staged for excision under Protocol Basilisk. To prevent recurrence, the Silent Counsel authorizes removal of memoria and annals sufficient to unwind vectors that led to Failure. The Archive will reduce itself. No exceptions for prestige projects. We did this to ourselves. We will make sure no one can do it again… Exploration 6579-B-07 Team: Eta-10 (E-Lead Morgan, E-Tech Liu), Mu-4 (Analyst Varga) Entry: SCP-6579-A-12 (Sunderland; condemned cinema) [Begin Log] [Entrance opens onto a corridor whose walls breathe subtly, lined with flat drawers labeled in raised dots.] Analyst Varga: Braille? Not standard. Alignment offset. E-Tech Liu: Audio uptick. Also, track noise. [Three SCP-6579-C appear at an intersection, pushing a low cart stacked with sealed gray binders. Their suits are unmarked except for the circle-with-bar insignia.] E-Lead Morgan: This is MTF Eta-10. We are not hostile. Can we communicate? [SCP-6579-C halt, tilt heads, and resume pushing. E-Tech Liu steps slightly to the side to allow passage. One SCP-6579-C holds a hand out, palm facing team, then taps a device on their wrist. The cart accelerates silently.] E-Lead Morgan: What are you taking? [No response. The entities round a shelf and vanish. Inspection reveals no passage.] Analyst Varga: Cart tracks terminate at the shelf’s edge. The floor is uninterrupted. E-Lead Morgan: We’re not alone in here. [End Log] Recovered Document 6579-B-22 (Excerpt) Directory Leaf: The Quiet Directorate — Structure and Mandates …The Quiet Directorate exists to ensure normalcy is maintained through collection of anomalies, their study, and, when necessary, their burial. The Silent Counsel (O9) is composed of nine persons unknown even to one another. Directives flow downward via the Custodial Collegium, then out to cells. We do not mark graves. We kill ideas by starving them of witnesses… Note: O9 references occur throughout materials. Equivalence to O5 is hypothesized. Exploration 6579-B-13 Team: Eta-10 (E-Lead Morgan), Dr. R. Bhatt, Archivist-Adjunct I. Adeyemi Entry: SCP-6579-A-30 (Mersin; abandoned hospital) [Begin Log] [Entry opens onto a high-bay containing rolling ladders attached to no rails. Paper dust falls continuously in a gentle rain.] Dr. Bhatt: There—sealed tubular canisters. Labels in English: “Council Sessions.” [They unseal one canister. Inside: thin metal plates etched with text.] Archivist Adeyemi: Readable. [Plates present minutes of “Silent Counsel Session 3,386.” Names are redacted with small hammered squares.] Plate 4: …On the matter of Overlapping Agreements with Outerdom Custodians, Counselor Red states that compliance with Basilisk’s Third Clause will erase key annals and thereby erase the motivations that gave rise to us. Counselor Gray: “We exist to be forgotten.” Voices concur. Vote: 7 in favor, 2 opposed. Motion carries… E-Lead Morgan: They chose to make their own history inaccessible. [Footsteps amplify in the distance; carts squeal. SCP-6579-C appear on the upper catwalk, observing.] E-Lead Morgan: We’re withdrawing. [As the team retreats, a ladder swings across the aisle without visible impetus, blocking view of the SCP-6579-C. When lowered, the entities are gone.] [End Log] Recovered Document 6579-B-37 (Excerpt) Incident: Basilisk …We record this once, then we will remove ourselves. The Failure did not begin at any one place. It arrived as a rumor, a belief that containment could be perfect if we put enough of ourselves into the walls. We did. The walls learned. They learned how to be us. When the seams came apart, we were indistinguishable from what we had kept. The Archive will remove the paths that led here. If a later Custodian finds this, understand: You are not the first. We were very sure. We were very wrong… Exploration 6579-B-21 Team: Eta-10 (E-Lead Morgan, E-Tech Liu), Ethics Observers (Dr. Hyeon), Security (Agent S. O’Rourke) Entry: SCP-6579-A-66 (Buenos Aires; empty bank) [Begin Log] [Entry leads to a narrow service corridor bordered by pneumatic tubes. Capsules occasionally clatter through, some dented.] E-Tech Liu: Capsule incoming. Catching— [Capsule is warm. It contains a sheaf of printed emails on Foundation headers: SUBJECT: RE: Unscheduled Site-01 Visit — From: [REDACTED] — To: O5-█, O5-█. Signature blocks intact, dated three weeks prior to log.] Dr. Hyeon: This is current. These addresses are real. Agent O’Rourke: That’s Site-01 internal. [In the distance, muffled voices. Team advances to a glass-wall gallery. On the other side: a shadowed meeting room containing chairs and a long table under a single lamp. Dust motes orbit in a slow helix.] E-Lead Morgan: Anyone in there? [On the table: nine small stones arranged in a ring, each etched with a symbol (circle-with-bar; spiral; triangle). A tenth stone rests beside the ring.] Dr. Hyeon: E-Lead, look at the door frame. [Wood shows identical semilunar scratches around a doorknob imprint, as if a handle was removed.] E-Tech Liu: Movement—gallery to our left. [SCP-6579-C, two individuals, carrying a case labeled “01/Chamber.” They pause. One raises a hand in a placating gesture, then points to the stones and shakes head slowly.] E-Lead Morgan: Are you telling us not to take them? [SCP-6579-C nods once, then depresses a wrist control. A loud hiss. Vision white-outs for 0.5 seconds. When vision returns, entities are gone; the stones remain, but the tenth stone has been pushed closer to the ring.] Agent O’Rourke: We’re leaving. We are out of our lane here. [End Log] Addendum 6579-2: Personnel Files Recovered Document 6579-B-84 (Excerpt) Personnel Ledger: Custodial Collegium — Staff Assignments — Cycle 411–417 …Archivist R. Bhatt — Rank: Steward of Coherence. Clearance: Nine Silent. Notes: Exceptional aptitude in reconciling contradictory annals. Emotional investment requires monitoring. Expungements authorized under Basilisk conditions… …Site Director M. Kline — Rank: Warden of Vaults. Clearance: Eight Quiet. Notes: Resistant to reduction orders. File flagged for Counsel oversight… …Field Captain A. Morgan — Rank: Keeper of Thresholds. Clearance: Seven Hush. Notes: Trusts tether over instinct. Will carry the door on her back if asked… Note: “Morgan” corresponds to E-Lead Morgan. “Kline” matches current Director Kline, Site-41. Recovered Document 6579-B-92 (Excerpt) Letter, unsent; author: “Warden of Vaults M. Kline” …We are the hem that keeps a world from unraveling. We have sewn and sewn until the thread is our veins. The Counsel asks for another cutting. They are right. They are always right when they call themselves wrong. If this letter finds you, I failed to burn it. If you know my name in another house, forgive me… Addendum 6579-3: Unauthorized Visits Internal audit discovered biometric signatures and transpoder pings consistent with O5-█, O5-█, and Proxy-█ within Site-41’s suppressed perimeter during 2024-10-08. Security cameras registered glitch artifacts concurrent with access of SCP-6579-A-02. Gates logs list no authorizations. Subsequent exploration in 6579-B located a corridor bearing bilingual signage: “Silent Counsel — Private Gallery.” Exploration 6579-B-29 Team: Mu-4 (Analyst Varga), Eta-10 (E-Lead Morgan), Site-41 Security (Agent O’Rourke) Entry: SCP-6579-A-02 (Site-41 understructure; walled off) [Begin Log] [Entry leads to a low, vaulted gallery. Alcoves line the walls, each containing an object under bell jars: a broken key; a brass plaque reading “O9”; a pair of leather gloves; a white card marked “Do Not Build.” The air tastes metallic.] Analyst Varga: Logs show the proxy beacons flatlined here for 14 minutes. E-Lead Morgan: There’s a book on the lectern. [Book bound in pale leather. Title stamped: “Visitors.” Pages are filled with names in neat, block print; dates not in Gregorian. Some names are familiar.] Agent O’Rourke: That’s O5-█’s birth name. [The last entry: three symbols, matching known Council sigils; no text.] Analyst Varga: The ink is wet. [Footsteps behind. The team turns. No one is there. The bell jar over the broken key is cracked.] E-Lead Morgan: We’re done. We document and leave. This is way above. [As they exit, the gallery lights dim to nothing for 1.2 seconds. On relighting, the “Visitors” book’s page has turned. The next page shows a single line: “We asked for forgiveness and were given a library.”] [End Log] Addendum 6579-4: Removal Activity Ongoing surveillance within SCP-6579-B has documented progressive absences: entire aisles gone, dust footprints discontinuing mid-stride, catalog numbers skipping sequences. SCP-6579-C removal rates increased after Foundation entries. Items tagged “Basilisk/3rd” are removed first, followed by “Vectors,” then “Dissent.” Recovered Document 6579-B-103 (Excerpt) Directive: Basilisk’s Third Clause — Execution Guide …Remove the record, and you remove the rehearsal. Remove the rehearsal, and you remove the shape. Remove the shape, and you remove the hunger to make it real. Do not leave behind the path that leads to us… Exploration 6579-B-33 Team: Eta-10 (E-Lead Morgan, E-Tech Liu), Dr. R. Bhatt Entry: SCP-6579-A-88 (Cork; shuttered hotel) [Begin Log] [Entry opens onto an exposed platform. Wind moves through stacks like breath. A siren rises and falls without source.] Dr. Bhatt: The aisle numbers jump from 1182 to 1190. Missing eight aisles in sequence. E-Tech Liu: Fresh scuffing. Carts went through here, heavy load. E-Lead Morgan: Eyes on—entities at the far end. [SCP-6579-C are mid-lift, removing a shelf segment. One sees the team, taps a wrist device. A transparent baffle drops between the groups, distorting sound.] Dr. Bhatt: They’re taking an aisle labeled “Counter-Custodial Movements.” E-Lead Morgan: Leave it. We’re not starting a tug-of-war. [An SCP-6579-C approaches the baffle, visor reflecting the team. It raises a gloved finger and traces the circle-with-bar on the barrier, then wipes its palm downward. The symbol smears but remains.] E-Tech Liu: Message received. [Team retreats. On the way out, they pass a table containing an open folio labeled “O5/Travel Logs.” The first page is blank, but the impression of writing remains as pressure marks. Under angled light, letters become legible.] Impressions: “…arrived through 41… no interference recorded… gallery intact… the tenth stone is moved… they are already reading us…” E-Lead Morgan: Copy and move. [Exit.] [End Log] Addendum 6579
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This SCP entry demonstrates exceptional command of the SCP Foundation format and style. The author has created a compelling anomaly that perfectly fits the requested prompt: unmarked doors leading to an impossible archive containing evidence of a previous civilization and unauthorized O5 Council visits. The piece excels in its worldbuilding, creating a complex, layered mystery with the right balance of revelation and ambiguity. The "Quiet Directorate" and "Silent Counsel" effectively mirror the Foundation while suggesting a cyclical nature to containment organizations. The exploration logs are particularly strong, capturing the clinical yet tense atmosphere characteristic of SCP entries. The writing demonstrates sophisticated control of tone, maintaining the pseudo-scientific documentation style while gradually building dread. The author skillfully uses technical language ("translocational phenomenon," "non-Euclidean space") alongside more evocative descriptions ("motionless dust hangs in the air," "walls breathe subtly") to create an unsettling atmosphere. The narrative structure is well-executed, with each exploration log and recovered document adding new layers to the mystery. The progression from discovery to realization that O5 members are secretly visiting the archive creates an effective narrative arc. The implication that the Foundation may be doomed to repeat the mistakes of its predecessor organization adds thematic depth. Where the piece could be improved is in its occasional tendency toward overcomplication. Some sections contain excessive technical detail that, while impressive, slightly impedes narrative flow. The exploration logs sometimes introduce too many elements at once, which can dilute the impact of key revelations. The SCP-6579-C entities (hazmat teams) are effectively mysterious, but their motivations and nature remain perhaps too opaque by the end. While ambiguity is appropriate for an SCP entry, a slightly clearer indication of their purpose would strengthen the narrative. The ending effectively leaves the reader with unsettling questions about cycles of containment and failure, though it doesn't quite deliver a final punch that would elevate it to masterpiece status. The implication that the O5 Council is aware of and responding to this cycle is intriguing but could be developed with more impact. Overall, this is an excellent SCP entry that demonstrates deep understanding of the format and creates a compelling, multilayered anomaly with significant implications for the Foundation universe. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 16 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 16.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 0.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Classic sci-fi: Offworlder (Le Guin) — Score: 93.4
Prompt:
Classic sci-fi: Offworlder (Author style: Le Guin) Write a chapter following a young diplomatic envoy sent to address tensions on a distant human colony where humanity has diverged into distinct subspecies through both natural adaptation and separation of lineages. Against protocol, the envoy slips away from official functions to walk the streets alone, encountering markets, ordinary citizens, and social structures that contradict the official briefings. Upon returning to their quarters, the envoy is reprimanded by Command, and is tasked with approaching the stationed Minister of Science (a political posting rather than scientific). A challenging conversation ensues, in which the envoy's wits and will are tested, by a seasoned political operator looking to test the mettle of the offworlder. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
They had named the city Hevel after the wind. From orbit it had been a pale knot laid along the burn of a river, a cincture of terraces clamped to rock, the slopes rising around it like a long-held breath. On foot, its stone was a thing with taste and weight—the way the steps gave a little under the heel and kept what heat they could hold from the brief noon. The buildings shouldered one another; they had been wedged in by hands that measured wind and ashfall and the river's two moods. Along slow-arched lintels and the stout pillars of the older market halls there were carvings, disposed cleanly, so that the shadows of the chiseled lines read from a distance like script. They were script, of a kind. The guide assigned to me, an Aerial with shoulder bones like wings and the soft backward tilt to the neck that speaks of hovering, had recited the briefing's language as we passed: "Pictographic inscriptions, early civilization. Not our heritage." But under my hand the glyphs were not mute. A man with a beard made of parallel strokes held out a torch that curled as if alive; a woman knelt and held to her chest a thing half child half seed; a boy with a lyre stood on a ship with a prow like a razor. Jokes carved themselves into corners—combs, fish, a bird with a crown. Someone had placed their palm in the stone repeatedly and rubbed it until the rock had taken the shape of that hand. On the door of what I took for a storehouse, tucked high where only a climbing child would look, was a carved ladder leading nowhere; beside it, a bull pierced by a spear and a figure whose head was a tree. We had been told from the first debrief in the ship's white room: no unsupervised walks. No contact outside formal meeting frameworks. The colony, we were told, was tense. Subspecies—this is what they were called in the briefing, as if in a neat taxonomy: the Aquatics who kept close to the river and wore their skins with a sheen, the Understones with their deep-set eyes and night-shaped speech, the Aerials who managed communications and listened to the sky. The briefing overlaid them with short phrases and danger flags like a card game. I slept with those folded cards in the lining of my jacket. I woke with them and held my breath between names. We made our arrival at the Governor's manor, a broad courtyard open to the wind, its boundary walls etched with rivers and the old Earth in circles. There were handshakes. There was transparent drink and small, careful food. Faces that looked and didn't look like mine leaned in and away. The Aerial guide, whose name was Ires, kept their fluted, veiled gaze on my shoulder. The Governor's face was fleshy and burned, with a blue diamond worked into her tooth. "Your rooms," she said, "are in the east house. You'll find your Command waiting there." Her smile was not thin. It took up all she had. It was a tired smile, but not without an attempt at kindness. "You will have access to the Minister of Science at sixteen. Be on time." I watched the hour turn on the river—a panel of light that swelled and darkened—and excused myself. I told Ires, as I had rehearsed, that I must wash off the ship-stillness. I told them I would not go far. I took my cards and left them on the dresser, like prayer flags. I put on soft shoes. Hevel smells of iron—the river and the stone—of fermented meal and warm fruit, and underneath, in the cooler alleys, a smell like the air before rain. On the open steps where the market ramified from the main square the stalls had been erected in two lines, with enough space between for a laden cart and a child to pass without touching. Fabrics, rough or luminous, were hung like water; dark bread loaves made whorls on shallow tables. Aerials with light bones that threw the balance of their walk touched one another's wrists in greeting; a woman with the broad foot of an Understone dragged a handcart and laughed, a clatter against the hard edge of an Aquatic's soft speech. I went from stall to stall and bought nothing, and then I bought a small pear, not much larger than the middle joint of my thumb. It had a single seed that floated in it like a bell. The seller's hands were webbed as if the fingers had learned to catch more of the world. He took my coin—a blue coin chipped with green—and rubbed it between finger and thumb in a way that felt like recognition. "Offworld," he said. The accent placed the stress on the first syllable and then uncoiled. "Only a little," I said, and he laughed again. "You walk alone," he said. "Against advice." He weighed that and then shrugged. "Maybe you will see more." There were boys running with hoops and an old woman mending, her thread white as hair. A group of Understones—no, they called themselves Lowlanders in their own language, one of them told me without heat—came up from a staircase that sounded like a well. Their eyelids flickered when the light hit them. One of them stared at me until I lowered my eyes; then they smiled. On a corner where the wind had collected old leaves and shining wrappers someone had chalked a picture on the paving stones. It was a line of suns, or coins, and a small figure walking away from them. The figure had no mouth. In the little they had given me, the Governor's people said the Lowlanders were seditious and closed, the Aquatics polite and profit-driven, the Aerials quick to take offense. In the street it was not simple. Offense and kindness moved with the pulse of the day; I saw a Lowlander reach up and take a bundle down for an Aerial woman whose arms were full and the baby's head in the sling was heavy; I saw an Aquatic boy chase away a bird that kept eating someone else's grain. I saw a pair of young men, Aerial and Aquatic together, sharing a cigarette rolled in purple paper. They laughed at the way the smoke went up and blew it in a stream toward the river, as if their breath could coax it into a second river to match the first. At the far end of the market a building shouldered the path. Its facade bore a story cut into it: a tower of men and animals climbing, then the tower's top cut off by a wind, and then the people walking away carrying bricks. Under it, not stone but a sheet of metal had been set in recent years, with a small portion of the old carving recut into it. The new carving showed a garden full of weeds, and among the weeds the familiar shapes of the old crops from Earth: wheat, grapes, a vine of squash on which someone had hung a child's carved hand. The metal was engraved with flowers I did not know, each with a name written in their picture-language. Someone had swept it clean that morning. "You are far from your rooms," Ires said when I turned and found them there, breathless on the steps. "I went to find water," I said. "You passed four fountains," Ires said, and the soft part of their mouth hardened. "I wanted to see." They turned, then turned back. The corners of the Aerial mouth can mock without moving much. "You have seen what you needed?" "No," I said. "I have seen less than that. Enough to tell me our briefings were a way of not seeing." They looked at me for a long moment, almost, I thought, with pity. Then they laid a hand on my sleeve—two fingers, light—and led me back. They did not speak. When we reached the east house, the stone was still warm where the sun had been. Command had been waiting a long time. On the wall behind the desk in my allotted room were more carvings—the Hevel style in a gentle hand—of a bird flying toward a human face, and the human's mouth open as if to sing but the bird's beak entering it. Not an omen I wanted. The Commander's face came on the wall, most of his above the chin, the mouth wide like the carved man's. There was a breath before he found his tone. "You were told," he said, emphasizing the tense in a way that made it bite, "to maintain the structure we agreed upon with the Governor. You were told to limit exposure. You were told not to go alone." "Yes," I said. "You made yourself vulnerable, and you made our intent look frivolous. The factions here—" He paused here to look at his notes, as if the careful taxonomy could give him a way to be angry. "—the subspecies will read what you do in the way we do not intend." "I know," I said. "I saw." I was tired of the word "subspecies" scraped on the mouth and let it go soft. People. I couldn't say it to him. There was a sound in his throat like a stone falling into dust. "You apologize?" "I do," I said, and did not. "We don't need your instincts," he said. "We need your compliance. The Minister of Science is expecting you in less than an hour. You will go, you will listen, and you will give them the message we agreed upon." "The message," I said, because it helped me shape myself around it. "That the union will approve only interim autonomy for the river concessions, pending review. That we will not recognize the Lowlands' councils as independent. That any genetic interlineage projects must go through our board." He lifted his eyes. "You will not improvise." "Yes." "You will not go alone again." "I will not," I said, and thought we both were telling a kind of truth. The Minister's office was on the western ridge, which had been cut back in steps and braced with stone. The door was an arch with a crack through it; above, the glyphs again: a woman with an open book, and under, an open cage with a bird flying out backward into it. The Minister who received me was a broad bald person with heavy ears and a mouth that gave nothing unless it got more back. Their skin was high-brown, almost gold at the temples. They wore a coat that had probably been white when it started its life but had learned the names of every room it had been in and kept them. "Envoy," they said. "Welcome to Hevel. I am Minister Sato." "Minister," I said. "Thank you for seeing me." The chair they gave me was lower than theirs and comfortable, which made us even, I suppose. There were windows without glass cut into the west wall. You could see the mountains. The light that came in was a busy light, the river's light mixed with dust. "You went to market," Sato said, not as a question. "I did." "The Governor was pleased," Sato said. They moved a paper, let it rest. "She says you have already begun your mission." "By buying fruit?" "By seeing that we are people," they said. "I assume they teach you not to do that until later." "We are taught a sequence," I said. "It doesn't always fit." "You are very young," Sato said. "And you are very practiced." This amused them without smiling. "We have an understanding to reach. You carry a message and I carry mine. The Governor will show you stone and water. I will show you the ledger. The ledger, offworlder, is what holds a town together more than any myth and more than most laws." "We have a message," I said. "Interim autonomy for the river concessions pending review. No recognition of the Lowlands as independent. Genetic projects go through our board." They folded their hands. The knuckles had been broken once and healed true. "And in exchange?" "In exchange," I said, "continued protection. Materials. The old world’s experts." "Your experts are like my coat," Sato said. They lifted one sleeve. There was a scorch mark at one elbow. "Useful. They'll do until we have something better. You would like us to let you hold the rope around our necks while we tug against it. You would like to tell us when to breathe." "If you are in danger of choking," I said, "I will cut the rope." "You don’t cut what binds you to us." They tapped the ledger with a nail. "You were told to talk to me because they think I will do what men of science do: argue with you about the number of genotypes we have stable in the deep-country; tell you we have a seventy-two percent compatibility overlap with the old stock; tell you the pier foundations and our reservoir. They think I will be impressed by your other numbers. But I am not a scientist, child. I count bread. I count the price of tin. I count the number of times the Governor asks me to make my people be patient." "And you say—" "I say," Sato said, and here the weight of their voice increased without rising, "that you can't make a people be patient forever if you don't let them mend their own roofs. Your board will request that Aquatic-Lowland coupling projects be delayed. You will cite ethics. You will ask us to wait for your caution. But you will not feed our sick when my doctor says they have a fifty-fifty chance and it improves to sixty with the right match. Your 'subspecies' is an ugly word for what we have become. We need to be allowed to become new without asking your permission for every breath." "If interlineage projects are conducted without oversight," I said, careful, "if someone is hurt, your ledger will show that too." "It does," Sato said. "It shows things you don't see: a man who won't carry low to the river anymore, and his daughter's anger; an Old-Earth myth about a man who swallowed fire and the way the children here carve torches that curl like vines; the aqueduct we need to stop waste. It shows your ship's schedule, the way you dock, the pulses you leave in the water that make the fish swim wrong for a day. There are costs. We would like to choose which we pay." "And the Lowlands," I said. "Their councils." "They are as old as the Aerial towers," Sato said. "They don't need your recognition. They need your not denying them when it gives you a neat line in your notes. Offworlder." They leaned forward a little. Their eyes were dark and not unkind. "You came down without your shadow." "Ires found me," I said, because that answered and didn't. "I was reprimanded." "You went to look for water in a market where water runs down your street." Sato looked out at the mountains and then back at me. "You did not go to gawk. There is hope for you. Your Command will not thank me for saying that. Tell them your message. I will give you mine. If you press here," their finger tapped a blank spot in the ledger, "this place will show a number that makes you comfortable. But it will also make a hole right behind this office, and you will not see it because the stone holds the face it shows to visitors and keeps its other faces for us." "I saw the carvings," I said. "Old myths. People building a tower. People walking away." "We carved them so we remember when to stop." Sato sat back. "Your old Earth's Babel and Eden and Prometheus, all your warnings about pride and reach, we have them in the faces of our houses. We put them up so that when we are tempted we will at least be tempted in their company. The boy with the lyre on the ship—do you know that one?" "Orpheus," I said. "He looked back and lost her." "There’s that story," Sato said. "But we have one where he looks back and tells her he will sing so well the dead won't want her and she decides to stay." "You rewrote it," I said. "We cut it again," they said. "We cut our own version into the new stone and the old. We will do the same with your ledger." We talked until the light in the window went orange, until I had said the words I was told to say and Sato had let me bend them enough not to break. They tested me: Do you understand what will happen if your review takes a year? Do you understand what we will do while you are reviewing? Do you understand why we don't want your scientists to say "we" while they mean "you"? I answered when I could, and when I could not, I kept silent and let the quiet speak for me as well as it could. I told them I had gone to the market. They told me they had once swum the river in flood and almost did not make it. "We can drown ourselves while building an aqueduct," they said. "Or we can wait for rain." When I left, I put my hand briefly on the threshold. The stone was cool now. My hand fitted where someone else's had fitted. The glyph above the arch, the open book and open cage, had the small, almost invisible additions the old carvers loved: three notches by the bird's foot, a score under the book. Someone had counted something and carved the counting in where only the hand would find it. On my way back the wind rose. Ires waited at the corner with their head tilted to catch it. "You came back," they said. "It seemed best," I said. "Tomorrow you will go with me," they said. "We will go to the river. There is a place where the Lowland steps meet the Aerial bridge and nobody owns the piece between. If you stand there and listen, you can hear where the river wants to go. The Minister sometimes goes there when the ledger sleeps. The stone speaks in those places. Even offworlders can hear it, if they are quiet." "I can be quiet," I said. Ires looked at me and then at the sky. "We will see," they said. "Be on time." And then we walked back into the east house, where the walls held their gods for the night and the bird carved on the door had just enough wing to make me think, for a moment, that it might lift.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkable achievement in capturing Le Guin's distinctive style and thematic concerns. The author has created a rich, textured world with layers of meaning embedded in physical descriptions, cultural artifacts, and social interactions. The prose demonstrates exceptional control of language, with descriptions that are evocative without being excessive. The author skillfully uses concrete details to suggest larger themes: the carvings that tell stories, the Minister's coat that has "learned the names of every room it had been in," the way light is described as "busy light, the river's light mixed with dust." These details create a sensory experience while simultaneously building the world and its history. Character development is handled with subtlety. The protagonist reveals themselves through observations and interactions rather than explicit statements. The diplomatic envoy's curiosity and willingness to break protocol reveal their character, while secondary characters like Ires and Minister Sato are distinct and complex despite limited page time. Sato particularly shines as a formidable political operator whose wisdom and pragmatism come through in dialogue that feels natural yet weighted with significance. The narrative structure follows the prompt precisely while creating a story that feels organic rather than formulaic. The envoy's unauthorized exploration of the market provides both world-building and thematic development, setting up the later confrontation with Command and the subsequent meeting with the Minister of Science. The piece excels at showing rather than telling. Instead of explaining the tensions between subspecies, we see interactions in the marketplace that complicate the official narrative. The author trusts readers to draw connections between observations. Dialogue is particularly strong, especially in the conversation between the envoy and Minister Sato. Their exchange reveals power dynamics, cultural differences, and competing interests while maintaining believability. Sato's lines like "Your experts are like my coat" and "We carved them so we remember when to stop" efficiently communicate character and theme. The world-building is exceptional, creating a sense of depth through references to myths, cultural practices, and physical structures. The author has clearly thought about how environment shapes culture, with details like the wind-named city and the carvings that serve as cultural memory. If there are weaknesses, they are minor. Occasionally the prose becomes slightly dense, requiring careful reading to follow all the implications. The ending, while poetic, might feel slightly abrupt to some readers. However, these are minor quibbles in an otherwise outstanding piece. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Biopunk: Polymerase Chain Reaction — Score: 86.6
Prompt:
Biopunk -- Polymerase Chain Reaction Write a chapter set in a near-future post-apocalyptic world where corporate genetic engineering was designed with built-in obsolescence—engineered DNA lasting only one generation to maximize profits before societal collapse. Follow a biohacker working with salvaged equipment to splice viable food crops for their settlement using rapidly degrading genetic material. As world building / window dressing, include details about jury-rigged lab equipment, and the physical toll (and unexpected upsides) of using untested genetic modifications as medicine. The plot of this chapter is centred around a black market contract. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The inverter coughed the way an old man does when the weather changes and the lights in my lab guttered to a dim orange smear. The solar panel out on the roof was a mosaic of scavenged cells soldered like a bad quilt, and the improvised charge controller could only do so much. When I first built it, the settlement called me a madman for trusting a sky still hazed with ash to power anything but regret. Tonight, the flicker was a rhythm: a nervous metronome to the evening’s work. The PCR machine on the bench whined as the voltage dipped. It wasn’t a real thermocycler, not anymore—just the shell of a GeneMelt 3000 I’d found in a flooded clinic, its brain gutted and replaced with a salvaged Raspberry Pi, a thermostatic relay from a dead HVAC, and a nest of coding I’d typed into existence with raw fingers over burned coffee. The heated lid was a pressure-cooker handle bolted on with epoxy. The reaction tubes were old, their caps soft from heat cycles, the silicone I used to seal the cracks containing more hope than polymer chemistry. “Pick a tone and stick with it,” I told the inverter. It rumbled once and settled, and the temperature readout on the cheap LCD held steady at ninety-five centigrade. Denaturation. A slow breath. I had maybe two cycles before the next flicker. Across the room, the gel rig hummed. That had been a real laugh—the gel rig. Two cracked picture frames for trays, soldered platinum wire lifted from a broken defibrillator, submerged in a polypropylene tub that once held industrial pickles. Agarose had to be made from seaweed I begged off the fishers who still went into what used to be a bay and was now a dark mirror with a dead reef under it. Ethidium bromide had gone with the old world; we stained with methylene blue boiled down and filtered through coffee paper. The bands it made were faint ghosts that you could only see if you knew where to look. I knew where to look. Outside the lab—the old kitchen in a condo tower with half its windows blasted out—voices murmured, the low burble of the settlement settling into night. Someone stomped, and a line of plaster dust drifted down from the ceiling, right into the top of my neck. I bit my lip and leaned in closer to the laptop, tracking the thermocycler’s progress. Thirty-five cycles. Forty. Fifty. It wasn’t ideal, but nothing was ideal anymore. The whole point of corporate genetic architecture had been to be just good enough to hold you hostage. Built-in cellular obsolescence sold as a feature; a royalty you paid in seed and blood every season because your crops and your kids couldn’t make their own enzymes anymore. Then the bottom fell out and the genes lost their shepherds. The obsolescence remained. The sample sitting in tube B5 was a miracle and a trap: a strand of legacy barley gene suites pre-labeled with the corporate watermark—a palindromic pseudogene sequence that guaranteed it would degrade after its product made it into one generation and no further. That watermark was brittle in places, especially where my own hands had been able to pry at it, but on the whole it remained. I used a CRISPR shim I’d written in the dead city library and templated it with scraps from heirloom seed DNA I’d pried from a museum’s display, but the enzyme I trusted—Cas9’s older sister, a thing we’d mutated into stubbornness—still got sloppy when the lights dipped. “Jax. You working?” The voice at the door was Mika’s: soft but carrying. I didn’t look up. It took me a second to realize why. The room had brightened. “Power stable for the next ten?” I asked, not looking away from the LCD. “Fifteen. We found another panel under the parking garage. Not broke all the way.” She ghosted into the lab like she always did, insubstantial until she leaned against the counter and made the tools clink against one another. “Client’s here.” “Client?” I shaded my eyes, finally turning. Two figures behind Mika, both wearing canvas longcoats and scarves despite the heat. The scarf on the one to the right—the thin one—was a mesh printed with an old stock ticker, now a hand-me-down veil. The other had a scar splitting their lip and a baseball bat slung over their shoulder, studded nails hammered through its business end. They smelled like dust and machine oil. The black market moved in smells, in exchanges of odors as much as goods: the tang of stale adrenaline, the metallic breath of scraped batteries, the green edge of stolen herbs. “We had a contract,” said the thin one. Their voice was flat and as genderless as the scarf. “You promised us seed that didn’t burn out.” I glanced at the bench. A row of pipette tips sat like teeth in a cheap plastic rack. My own saliva glands twinged. “I promised you viable seed for one planting. It’s all anyone can promise.” “You said you had a way around their watermark.” “I have ways to blunt it,” I said. “Peel it back in places. The problem isn’t me. It’s entropy.” “Entropy,” said the one with the bat, slow and considering. “Is that a lab word for ‘you’re not going to get what you paid for’?” Mika’s breath stirred the hair on my ear. I kept my face neutral. “Entropy’s the reason you got the vineyards you had, once. Why everything gets old and tired. Why your grandparents’ chimeras couldn’t conceive without ten thousand credits worth of prenatal enzyme cocktails.” The thin one made a noise like satisfaction. “We brought credits,” they said. They slid a small case onto the counter. When they cracked it, there was no glow—just care: nested in rough cloth, three phials of clear oil, and under those, a set of qubit chips in a shockproof sleeve and a blister pack of antibiotics. My hand twitched when I saw the antibiotics. There was a soft patch on my arm that had been getting angrier since the last time I injected the growth factor. “There’s extras,” the thin one said. “If it’s done.” I dropped a pipette tip and picked up a tube from the rack, ensuring that the movement didn’t show any tremor. The power held steady, the thermocycler beeped a bright double note and then simmered down to room temperature. I set the tube into a cradle and swung the lid down. Another epoxied handhold creaked. “Done is relative,” I said, and loaded the gel. The settlement had been living on millet and yeast and a kind of engineered moss that tolerated our sun. The corporate strains we had initially had worked for a season and then melted into useless cellulose. Seed hoarders had stepped in; so had people like me. I had found that the watermark could be interrupted if you left enough of it intact that the safety protocol thought it had done its job. In practice, that meant hybridizing old and new, the way the world had learned to make meaning from two broken sentences. The gel ran unevenly. I tapped the inverter; the current thrummed higher. Methylene blue seeped into the cool, cloudy matrix. I stained by memory—four minutes to see the small bands, six for the middle weights, ten for the big ones. I pulled the tray, slid it onto the improvised light box—a panel of UV LEDs I’d bodged together with scavenged smartphone flashlights and a strip of blacklight from an abandoned sex shop. The bands were pale. They were also where I’d expected. The watermark signature—eight jagged stripes like a jawline—had two gaps where there had been eight before. “I see that,” said the thin one, leaning in. “I also see more than I paid for, if I’m right. That’s… is that arsenic methylation resistance?” I had told myself I wouldn’t look surprised. It was a contract. Contracts kept you alive, even black market ones, because they were the only law left. But the thin one’s eye had flashed when they saw the band, and something in me leapt to an old, atavistic joy: a colleague. It had been a long time. “It's a trial,” I said, and exhaled, tasting bile that had nothing to do with the questionable protein stew Mika had made. “A tweak. The old water tables are rising, picking up metals no one thought would move. If the fields you’re putting this in are downstream from anything, you’ll need it.” “We aren’t downstream,” they said, but their mouth quirked above the scarf. “We’re what’s left of the upstream.” “Then keep it anyway,” I said, surprising myself. “Call it a bonus. Or a test. You bring me back data on how they performed and I’ll cut your next contract in half.” The bat carrier snorted softly. The thin one glanced at them, the kind of scan that told you years of working together had built its own wordless lexicon. They looked back at me. Their eyes were dark and very clear. “You’re bargaining with medicine, too,” they murmured, nodding at the blister pack in the case. “I heard you’ve been using your parties to test threshold modulation.” “Parties,” I said. “Is that what they’re calling them?” “What else? The way you blow open your toll receptors and make a fever of it. Makes everyone feel clean. Clear. Makes the aches back off. Makes them brave, too, and makes them do stupid things.” I touched the soft patch on my arm when they looked away. It itched, then burned. The first time I’d given myself the HGF hack, the pain in my hip—a slow, gnawed ache from lifting too much, sleeping on floors—had evaporated. I’d walked down the broken stairs without thinking for the first time in months. I’d also had a run of fevers and dreams that lasted four days, seeing lines of code floating in the steam of the pot I boiled water in. On the third day I’d written a set of primers by hand on a flattened cereal box and then found they worked. On the fourth, my teeth had felt loose. “It works,” I said. “Until it doesn’t. The settlement loves the way their wounds close faster. They hate that they can smell their own copper for a week. Side effects. Unintended upsides. The line’s thin.” Mika’s hand was on her knife, not threatening—just reminding me of edges. The bat carrier watched the windows, counting shadows. The thin one’s scarf had fallen open; their jaw was elegant and gone to tendon. I imagined, just for a breath, what a lab would do to that face. What it had done. The corporates had counted genetics in credit payout, glow-mapped children and told them they’d be artists or labor depending on the way their mitochondria burned. The thin one’s voice had that same old world education bent around road grit. “How much?” they asked. “For the seeds?” I looked at the numbers on my pad. Calculated what I needed to keep the thermocycler’s hacked brains from cooking off entirely when the voltage spikes came. Calculated also the cost of being greedy in a world with too many bats. “One qubit, the antibiotics, and one of those oils.” They tilted their head. “You know what the oils are?” “They’re glandular,” I said. “From the pigs that walk like people. The fat they make when we feed them the compost from the algae vats. They sleep better when they’re rubbed with it. So do my people. No nightmares. Cuts down on the shaking after the HGF.” The thin one smiled with half their mouth. It made the scar along the bat carrier’s lip look like something else: a punctuation mark instead of a threat. “Take two oils,” they said. “We’ll bring the data and we’ll take the half-price next time.” Lavish, Mika mouthed behind them, eyes gleaming. I reached for the case as if I were touching hot glass, and slid two of the vials into my own foam-lined slit, the blister pack of antibiotics into my pocket where the heat of my body could warm their false promise. “Now the seed,” the bat carrier said. I pointed with a gloved finger. The tubes to their left held a milky slurry of something that, in time, with the right care, with luck, would be green and tasseled. The shells were old pill bottles; the labels had been soaked off. Seed’s code was chimeric in places, where I’d inserted old genes into new chassis. In those gaps, the watermark read as silent, a broken poem the corporate gods couldn’t read. Mika counted out the tubes, watching how the bat carrier’s hands moved; I watched the thin one’s eyes flick to the flicker of the power die and surge. The lab’s lights trembled again, and the printer we used to make labels stuttered and then continued on, dotted lines giving way to solid. “You wanted this because you have fields,” I said, as casually as I could. “And you want it now because someone else does too. That’s a black market’s truth. Who’s the someone else?” “You’ll know,” the thin one said, wrapping their scarf back around their mouth. “When the wind shifts and there’s a smell of sugar in it. We’re racing them to sweetness.” Mika snorted. “Candy syndicates. I thought they were a myth.” “No myth,” the bat carrier said. “They courted our farm. Offered us a patent on rain that wouldn’t fall if we didn’t sign. We said no. That’s why we’re here.” I slid the final tube into the bat carrier’s hand. The skin there was thick like the rest of them, callused and cracked. I felt a flare of something like protection, then tamped it down. You don’t keep bargains by guarding people. You keep them by keeping them. “Plant in squares,” I said. “Not lines. That way, when the watermark starts to sing, it will drown itself in the cornering. Keep a border of the moss. It warps the pH and slows the decay.” “And the arsenic?” the thin one said. “If you get a sweet taste at the back of your mouth when it rains,” I said. “Don’t let anyone out.” Mika ushered them out with a grin that could have been a knife. When the door shut, I let my shoulders slump and leaned back against the bench. The inverter coughed again; the lights went thin for a moment, then fattened, then stabilized. The thermocycler spewed a puff of warm air and then wound down. “You gave them fate,” Mika said, offhand. “I gave them a game with better odds than the one they had,” I said. “And I got paid.” “Antibiotics,” she said, approving. Then she paused, nose wrinkling. “And pigsleep oil. You going to finally get a night without the river running through your skull?” “Maybe.” I held the vial up to the light. Glitter swam in it, not anything you could really see and still knowing. I imagined rubbing it into the soft skin over my sternum, feeling that somewhere under bone and cartilage, all the receptors I’d hacked awoke and subsided like a shore. Down in the street, someone yelled. It wasn’t alarm; the rhythm didn’t change in the settlement, and when the rhythm didn’t change, everything was fine enough. I let out a breath I didn’t know I’d tucked away behind my teeth. There had been a time when I had taken the corporate maintenance kits and carefully filled the prescriptions for my own body. Enzymes to keep my mucosa from sloughing, vitamins keyed to the way my liver could no longer use B12. Maintenance required maintenance. When the shipments stopped, we reinvented our bodies in the worst places: under broken skylights with the rain coming in sideways, in basements that smelled like bleach and rot. Sometimes it worked. Sometimes it didn’t. The upside of fear is that it sharpens your hand. The upside of a fever is that it burns, and sometimes it burns clean. I rubbed the itch on my arm. The spot had turned the color of old bricks. I would dose with the oil tonight and pray for sleep; tomorrow I would barter for more data and try to cut the watermark again, shave it down like a callus. The sugar wind would come or it wouldn’t. The upstream would fight the downstream over whose water was cleaner; the settlement would keep eating yeast-cakes and green algae pressed into noodles, dreaming of bread. And, if the luck I had argued into existence tonight held, there might be a field of grain in a month that didn’t die because it was told to. A failure of design would become a feature of survival. The inverter wheezed one last time and went quiet. The lab dropped into a darkness as soft as the oil in my hand. Out beyond the broken windows, the sky had faded to a bruise. Somewhere on a distant rooftop, a solar panel flickered. I could see its pulse like a heartbeat, uneven and insistent: power stitched together from salvaged light. I smiled into the dark and smelled, for a second, the idea of rain. Not sugar. Not yet. But close. Close enough to bargain with. Close enough to keep working.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This biopunk chapter successfully creates a vivid post-apocalyptic world where genetic engineering's built-in obsolescence has contributed to societal collapse. The narrative follows a biohacker working with jury-rigged equipment to splice viable food crops, centered around a black market contract as requested. The worldbuilding is particularly strong. The author has created detailed descriptions of improvised lab equipment: a PCR machine cobbled together from a GeneMelt 3000 shell, a Raspberry Pi, and salvaged parts; a gel rig made from picture frames and industrial pickle tubs; and a power system reliant on scavenged solar panels. These details effectively establish both the technological regression and the ingenuity required to survive. The physical toll of genetic modifications is well-represented through the protagonist's own body. The "soft patch" on their arm, the fevers, the copper taste, and the dreams all illustrate the consequences of self-experimentation. The unexpected upsides are also addressed—wounds closing faster, pain relief, and moments of clarity or inspiration during fever dreams. The black market contract forms the central plot element as requested, with the thin client and bat carrier seeking seeds that won't "burn out" after one generation. The transaction feels tense and authentic, with both parties cautious yet professional. The exchange of genetic material for antibiotics, qubit chips, and "pigsleep oil" establishes the barter economy of this world. The prose is generally strong, with evocative descriptions and a consistent voice that balances technical jargon with poetic observations. The narrator's voice feels authentic—weary but determined, pragmatic yet still capable of wonder. Sentences like "The upside of fear is that it sharpens your hand. The upside of a fever is that it burns, and sometimes it burns clean" demonstrate the blend of scientific detachment and emotional resonance. However, there are moments where the writing becomes slightly overwrought, with metaphors occasionally stacked too densely. Some passages could be tightened for clarity without losing their impact. The dialogue is functional but sometimes lacks the distinctiveness that would make each character's voice truly unique. The ending strikes an appropriate tone—not falsely optimistic, but containing a thread of hope that feels earned given the protagonist's small victory in creating seeds that might survive beyond one generation. The final image of power "stitched together from salvaged light" effectively encapsulates the theme of the chapter: finding ways to persist despite designed obsolescence. Overall, this is a strong piece that successfully fulfills the prompt requirements while creating an engaging narrative with thoughtful worldbuilding and character development. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 5 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 5.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Iteration 3 — Avg Score: 90.4
+ Classic sci-fi: The Azra Gambit — Score: 89.1
Prompt:
Classic sci-fi (Author style: Asimov) The Azra Gambit Colonial mars is being mined by corporations who take leases on indentured labourers. The thing they are mining is Azra, a recently discovered exotic metal which accelerates radioactive decay to such a rate that it is greatly sought after for interstellar drives and weapons alike. This has created both a gold rush and an arms race as various interests vie for control and endeavour to unlock Azra's secrets. The story follows Arthur Neegan, a first generation settler and mining engineer. Upon discovering that his unassuming plot sits atop an immense Azra vein, he is subjected to a flurry of interest and scrutiny. Write the next chapter in this story, in which an armed retinue descends on Arthur's home and politely but forcefully invites him to a meeting with some unknown party off-world. The insignia look like that of the Antares diplomatic corp -- diplomatic in name only. Arthur finds himself in the centre of a political tug of war. The chapter involves a meeting with this unknown party, who makes Arthur an offer. The scene should be primarily dialogue, interspersed with vivid description & scene setting. It should sow hints of the larger intrigue, stakes & dangers. Include Asimov's trademark big-and-small-picture world building and retrofuturistic classic scifi vibe. The chapter begins with Arthur aboard the transfer vessel, wondering just what he's gotten involved in. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Arthur tugged at the stiff collar again and felt it bite into the crease of his neck. The fabric had the texture of sanded plastic and smelled faintly of ozone. It was the sort of garment that made a man aware of his own shoulders, his own posture, his own sweat. He had put on pressure suits and mining harnesses in vacuum storms with less trouble. Beyond the viewport, Mars was a dull red coin slipping beneath the horizon of black. The transfer vessel was quiet, too quiet; its gravitic plates sang a tone barely below hearing, and that single pitch made the silence more profound. The cabin's lighting came from strips embedded in the ceiling, a sharp daylight that cast no shadows. The furniture was all curves, molded out of some resilient composite. The antigrav seats adjusted to his weight and then held him, gently and insistently. It was, he thought as he scratched at his collar, the way a polite jailer would hold a prisoner: carefully, impeccably, with professional courtesy. Opposite him sat two men with the blank faces of men who expected to be invisible. Their uniforms bore a starburst insignia: eight points, attenuated, caged by a ring. The ring had a subtle notch where a human eye would expect a complete circle. Antares. Diplomatic Corps in the registry, security arm in practice. In name only, Arthur thought with a trace of bitterness. They had arrived at his hab with their retinue of polite insistence, recited a form of words about an "invitation," and now he was seated across from their blank faces, watching Mars recede. The door slid open. The woman who entered was short and barrel-chested, brown skin burnished by artificial light, eyes that cataloged without seeming to. She wore no insignia, only a suit of charcoal fabric with a weave that suggested something more than cloth. A pin at her throat glowed an unassuming blue, a shape like two overlapping circles. Not Antares, then. Not obviously. "Mr. Neegan," she said, taking the seat to his right. "I'm glad you agreed to meet." Arthur glanced at the guards, then back at her. "I got the impression agreement wasn't necessary." She smiled. "Diplomacy is sometimes the art of providing options in a sequence that resembles a choice. My name is Leera Vast. My credentials are..." She paused. "Difficult to explain within your legal frame. You may consider me an attache to an interested consortium." "Which one?" "The one that prefers to remain unnamed until trust is established." Arthur had learned to weigh words. In the mines, the wrong word could start a strike; the right one could settle it and save a dozen backs. He measured her tone against her eyes and got a result he didn't entirely trust. He tugged his collar again. "You know why I'm here?" he asked. Leera gave a small tilt of the head. "You are here because your land grant sits upon a vein of Azra whose concentrations outstrip any recorded sample. You are here because that fact will inevitably draw not just prospectors but fleets. You are here because the pace of discovery in one sector of physics has, with remarkable predictability, outpaced the political infrastructure that can control it." "Azra accelerates decay," Arthur said. His words sounded like a textbook. "It makes dead elements die faster." Leera held up a hand. "Two points of correction. First, Azra does not accelerate decay. Azra permits decay paths that were previously forbidden by symmetry. It changes the branching ratios in ways not fully mapped. Second, that difference matters because it means Azra is not merely a catalyst; it is an operator on probability. In drives, your fuel mass becomes dead mass at a rate of our choosing. In weapons, your neighbors' mass becomes heat. In economics..." She opened her palm, as if to show him the empty air. "Debts vanish or compound depending on whose mass is coupled to the cascade. In politics, the side which can turn patience into an explosive event controls time itself." Arthur let out a breath. He had heard rhetoric about Azra since the first sample came down from the Schiaparelli crater. The prospector who had brung it—he remembered the news images: gaunt, grinning, then gone, the victim of a refinery accident that had the smell of too neat an ending. He remembered the contracts that came afterward, the leases, the clever clauses. He remembered his father, who had helped cover the initial crater rim with domes, reciting the old settler's proverb: Don't sell the air, son. "You want to buy my air," Arthur said. Leera folded her hands. "We want to purchase your silence." The guards opposite didn't turn their heads, but Arthur caught the way their eyes flicked, the barest movement. Even they hadn't known the exact phrasing. "Let me be plainer," Leera continued. "Your mine is not merely a mine. It is a lever. If you announce your find, if you sell to the first corporate combine that offers you triple the quoted rate, you will become a node in a network of obligations. Antares will insist on inspection rights in the name of safety. The Titan Syndics will argue prior claim through their indenture supply chain. Earth Central will send an envoy. The Belt will threaten embargo. In that storm, you and your claim will be transformed into something like a lighthouse placed in the center of a naval battle." "You think you can avoid the storm." "I think," Leera said, and now her voice was the even tone of a teacher addressing a room of engineers, "that storms can be steered. We propose to create a delay. We want your vein to be mischaracterized, surveyed incorrectly, the data to be ambiguous enough to confuse the simple algorithms the corporations use to prioritize. In return, we offer you three things. First, a sum that would let you buy half a dome's worth of oxygen rights in Galle Crater. Second, protection in a form that does not look like protection; that is, pressure applied to rivals, not shields around you. Third, inclusion." "Inclusion," Arthur repeated. "In the circle of people who are asked to comment before decisions are made. Governance is a game. Those who play are those whose names appear on memos before the memos become directives." Arthur laughed, a short sound. "I've spent twenty years making sure my name appears on the right supply roster so my crew gets decent sealant. I'm not sure I'm fit for memos." "That humility is one reason you are ideal," Leera said. "You are not known as a flamboyant man, Mr. Neegan. You have paid your lease on time. You negotiated fair terms for your crew when the oxygen tax went up. You refused indentured labor on your site even when your accountant argued the numbers. You will not make a rash choice for a one-time glory. In an arms race, the man who refuses to run can become the fulcrum." Arthur looked at the ring at her throat again, the two circles. It wasn't Earth Central; it wasn't one of the familiar corporate sigils. The Antares guards sat like statues, their insignia like captive sunbursts. "And you're not Antares," he said. "Antares is..." Leera glanced toward the guards. "A partner of convenience. They prefer the status quo to a sudden shift. We prefer a measured shift to a catastrophic one. Our alignment is pragmatic." "Who are you?" She considered. "Have you heard of the Heraclitus Group?" Arthur frowned. "Philosophers." "Physicists with philosophical pretensions. We advise. We build models. Our models have predicted two civil wars in the last twenty years with accuracy sufficient to be more than coincidence. We suggested small interventions in both cases. Historians may argue about causality. The people who didn't die on Vesta Station are not inclined to argue." "And you think Azra is another war in the making." Leera leaned back. The antigrav in the seat compensated perfectly; she seemed motionless, anchored in a minor gravity well of her own. "Azra collapses time in machines and politics alike. The arms race is not a metaphor; it is an accelerating system. There are inflection points. Your claim is an inflection point. Control over that one vein could set deadlines that push other actors into hasty decisions. Those decisions tend to be violent. We propose to slow the clock. We propose a gambit." "The Azra Gambit," Arthur said before he could stop himself. He felt the phrase settle in the air, like the first stone placed in a game. "It is named for a river that floods slowly and receded unpredictably," Leera said softly. "In old maps, its course was marked in pencil. Men drowned because they assumed it would behave like other rivers. We assume nothing." "And if I refuse?" Leera's smile did not reach her eyes. "Mr. Neegan, if you refuse, another party will come to you with a different version of an offer. It may come in the form of a security contract with a company whose name contains the word 'mutual.' It may come as a delegation from Earth Central wearing medals older than your dome. If you refuse them, it may come as a labor shortage. Your indenture suppliers will misplace paperwork. The weight of your ore shipments will be recalculated by a new algorithm. Insurance will become mysteriously expensive. You will be left with principle and an idle mine. Or, you will be found to have died in a refinery accident. I mean no disrespect to your survival instincts when I say history prefers its fulcrums to be attached to the ground." Arthur bit the inside of his cheek. He had not told anyone about the vein. He had had it assayed twice, quietly, using a scanner borrowed and returned without signature. He had felt like a boy hiding a captured spark. It had been, for a week, a private joy. Freedom was like that: it hid in numbers and rock cores and the way a drill bit sang. "What happens to the other miners?" he asked. "To the ones who took leases because they had no choice? To the indentured? You slow the clock—who pays?" Leera's expression shifted, a fraction. "You ask good questions. The answer is that some pay no matter what we choose, and our aim is to minimize that number. A fast war is devastating. A slow consolidation is...less so. We will use the time to build alternatives. Azra has applications beyond engines and bombs. It can clean waste. It can shorten half-lives in ways that make old sins less heavy. The taste for weapons is always present; the taste for sanitation is often late." "And I am to trust your taste?" "No," Leera said. "You are to trust your own, and our transparency. We will show you a fragment of what we have. You will not see all. No one sees all. But you will see enough to make an informed choice. And if you accept, you will have leverage. That is power of a modest kind, but power nonetheless. It must be exercised with the same restraint you exhibit when you adjust your crew's oxygen rationing." Arthur looked down at his hands. They were square hands, scarred. The suit cuffs did not suit them. Beyond the viewport, Mars was a coin now, scored with the faint line of the equatorial dust belt. He imagined the domes, the solar farms, the long connecting tubes with their scrim of frost. Somewhere beneath one of those domes was a ledger with his name on it and a column that would swell like a bruise if he made the wrong entry. "What about Antares?" he asked finally. "They don't like being used." "Used?" Leera smiled. "They are in on the leverage. They will be the polite hand that knocks on certain doors. They have the habit of order. They fear chaos more than they love justice. I have found that a useful trait." One of the guards shifted, and Arthur noticed the faintest remit—his hand going to something at his belt, not a gun; a device with a small screen and a stylus. He wrote a single character and then looked up again, face neutral. Everything was recorded, everything reduced to summary. "I have terms," Arthur said. He surprised himself with the firmness of the words. "If I do this. I want a guarantee that my crew is placed on non-indentured contracts. I want oxygen rights secured for the next five years at current rates. I want a say in where some of this Azra goes, even if it's just a veto over certain buyers. No drones near my dome. And if I die in a 'refinery accident,' someone will know what I agreed to, and someone will care." Leera's gaze warmed by a degree measured only by instruments. "You negotiate like an engineer. Constraints first, then objectives. Good. I cannot promise all, but I can promise we will formalize what we can. Oxygen rights are a matter of local governance; we can apply pressure. Non-indentured contracts are more complicated, but we can route work through cooperatives. As for a veto... limited. But we can give you a seat on a review board with teeth." "And the last?" "People will know," Leera said. "And some of them will care." Arthur thought of his father again, of a hand gripping his shoulder at the rim of an old crater. Don't sell the air. He had never understood that advice as fully as at this moment. He had something like air in his pocket now. The woman beside him offered a way to keep breathing. "Show me what you have," he said. Leera touched the pin at her throat. The antigrav of the seat shifted subtly, and a plane of light formed between them, a projection that had the restraint of old microfilm: numbers, lines, a spare aesthetic that made the data seem more, not less, real. He saw curves, divergences, dates. He saw the names of fleets. He saw a name he recognized from a mining guild meeting, attached to a timeline that ended in a sharp line labeled Containment Failure: Probability 0.43. He read. He listened to Leera's quiet voice. He watched the guards watch nothing. He adjusted his collar and forgot to notice the pinch. When the vessel's intercom chimed and a voice announced approach to the Lagrange Dock, he had made no decision but had begun, in a way, to decide. The dock would be glittering, he knew, a ring studded with lights like a city suspended in mathematical compromise. Off-world, Leera had said, and he would be off-world in a place where men wrote memos that changed the course of other men's lungs. He smiled without humor. "So," he said to Leera Vast, "let's talk about how we mismeasure a mountain." Leera smiled back, and for the first time the smile seemed to touch her eyes. "We persuade the world that it is a hill," she said. "And we build a garden on top."
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This response is a remarkably strong piece of science fiction that captures Asimov's style while delivering a compelling chapter in the requested story. The writing demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of classic sci-fi conventions, particularly Asimov's tendency to blend political intrigue with scientific concepts. The prose excels in creating a retrofuturistic atmosphere through carefully chosen details: the "gravitic plates," the "antigrav seats," and the clinical, sterile environment of the transfer vessel. The author skillfully establishes Arthur as a practical, principled mining engineer through both his internal thoughts and his dialogue with Leera. The dialogue is particularly strong, capturing Asimov's characteristic blend of exposition and philosophical debate. Leera's explanations of Azra's properties feel authentic to the genre - technical yet accessible, with implications that extend beyond mere scientific curiosity to political and economic consequences. The conversation reveals character while advancing plot and worldbuilding simultaneously. The worldbuilding is exceptional, revealing a complex political landscape of competing interests: Antares, Earth Central, the Titan Syndics, the Belt, and the mysterious Heraclitus Group. The author introduces these elements organically through dialogue rather than through clumsy exposition. The chapter successfully establishes the stakes and dangers as requested. Arthur's discovery has placed him at an "inflection point" in history, with powerful forces converging on his claim. The threat of violence is implicit throughout, from the "polite" but forceful Antares guards to Leera's veiled warnings about "refinery accidents." The writing maintains a consistent tone throughout - clinical, precise, yet with an underlying tension that builds as the conversation progresses. The author avoids purple prose while still creating vivid imagery, particularly in the opening paragraphs describing the transfer vessel and Arthur's discomfort. If there are weaknesses, they are minor. The piece occasionally becomes slightly exposition-heavy during Leera's explanations, though this is consistent with Asimov's style. The ending, while satisfying, feels slightly rushed compared to the measured pace of the rest of the chapter. Overall, this is an exceptional response that fulfills all the requirements of the prompt while demonstrating a deep understanding of Asimov's style and the conventions of classic science fiction. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 4 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 4.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Contemporary romance: Darkroom Revelations — Score: 88.4
Prompt:
Darkroom Revelations Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of Dani, a 25-year-old assertive art student known for her bold style and take-charge attitude in relationships. For the past semester, she's been quietly fascinated by Elliot (he/him), a 19-year-old boy in her experimental photography class. Dani has been intrigued by his unconventional masculinity: killer thrift-shop-nu-goth style, soft demeanour and quiet intellect. When they're paired for a final project requiring late nights in the darkroom, Elliot tentatively shares that he's been questioning his gender identity and expression. Set during one of these intimate darkroom sessions where the red light creates a confessional atmosphere. Explore Dani's complex attraction—her usual assertiveness complicated by her desire to protect Elliot's vulnerability, her excitement at witnessing his self-discovery, and her confusion about what this means for her own identity as someone typically attracted to more defined gender presentations. The narrative should capture the tender awkwardness of their conversations, Dani's internal struggle between taking charge and wanting to give Elliot agency, and the unexpected chemistry that develops as both find themselves in uncharted territory. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The red light paints everything like a wound. It hums, or maybe that’s the ventilation, or maybe I’m just hyper-aware of the electric throb running under my skin. My hands move by muscle memory: slides clipped to the easel, test strip lined up under the enlarger, timer set. I’ve been in this darkroom more nights than I care to count, but tonight the air has the density of secrets. “Ready?” I ask, my voice too steady for the tremor I feel. Elliot nods. His silhouette is all angles and drape—mesh shirt under a thrifted blazer whose shoulder seams have been let out by some past life, black nail polish bitten down to nervous half-moons. There’s a smear of developer near his wrist that looks like a bruise. I hit the timer. In the red haze, our hands look prehistoric and tender. He’s quiet, which is normal for him, but even his quiet has layers; tonight it’s the kind that fills the spaces between us like velvet. He adjusts the focus with a careful touch, and I watch his profile instead of the grain, the slope of his nose, the dip above his lip that made me look twice the first week of class when he said something incisive about our teacher’s reliance on found-text overlays. He’d said it so softly the comment floated like dust motes, but it had the precision of a scalpel. The timer bleats. I pull the paper and slide it through developer, my tongs making that faint clink against the tray. Shapes bloom: a door with peeling paint, his shoe half in frame, shadowed tiles. He’s fascinated by the in-between, half-seens, thresholds. It’s very him, I think. Or very them. The pronoun slips in my mind and catches. I’m so used to being sure, I almost hate that I’m not now. “It looks good,” I say, even though it’s still changing, even though “good” is too blunt an instrument. He leans over, and his hair—dyed black but grown out enough to show a crescent of sandy roots—falls forward like a curtain. He smells like the cheap incense that clings to everything he owns and grape gum he never actually chews, just softens in his molars. He breathes out a laugh. It bubbles. He doesn’t laugh like he’s trying to be heard; he laughs like the room has cupped its hands to catch it. “We could dodge here,” he says, pointing at the doorjamb, “make the woodgrain pop.” He’s gotten less apologetic about suggesting things in the past month. I’ve sort of made it a mission to teach him that critique isn’t an apology tour. That’s one of my moves. Take charge, drag people into their own light. It’s part ego, part craving to shepherd something beautiful to where it can be seen. It’s also what past partners liked about me. I know how to steer. “I’ll grab the elliptical,” I say. I reach for the cutout cardboard shape, the metal rod cold and thin in my fingers. He steps aside to let me at the enlarger; the brush of his forearm against my elbow is light but it strikes through me like a wire. My phone buzzes once in my back pocket, insistent as a mosquito. I don’t look. Whoever it is—Ben? My sister? The group chat pinging about free drinks at The Cat—can wait. If I break the membrane of this room, they’ll take him with them, and I don’t want to lose whatever we’re in. We burn, we dodge, we test again. When the latest print goes into the stop bath, the citric smell cuts the metallic sweetness that always makes the back of my tongue feel slick. I watch his face as he watches the image turn from ghost to fact. Sometimes I think he’s too beautiful for me, soft in a way I don’t know how to handle. I’ve dated two guys who were all jawline and certainty, and one girl who wore her hardness like a uniform. I was the switchblade in those dynamics. I liked being the one to reach across, to make it happen. Elliot makes me want to watch, to wait. I am not good at either. “I’ve been thinking about…” He begins, then trails off. His eyes flick to me and then away, picking up the tongs like you’d pick up a stray feather, gently, as if you might be surprised by your own tenderness. “About?” I prompt. I’ve learned not to push him too hard. He opens like a slow shutter: you have to give him time or you get blur. He takes too long, and I fill the silence with the roll of the chain on the safelight squeaking gently as the ventilation kicks a notch higher. Someone laughs in the hallway, distant and quick. The door doesn’t open. The world stays out there. “About gender,” he says. The word lands between us, damp as a print we can’t yet touch. “My gender. I guess.” My shoulders go still, not out of surprise—he’s been telegraphing something—more out of wanting to be the surface a dropped needle can play on. Don’t move. Don’t scratch the song. “Okay,” I say, softer than I mean. “Do you want to talk about it?” He lets out a breath that makes his bangs flutter. “Maybe. Yeah. I think I… I don’t know if boy is the only thing. Or if it’s a thing I have to do a certain way. Sorry if that sounds—” “Don’t apologize,” I say, sharper. It sings out, a reflex. I’m constantly pulling him away from saying sorry to the furniture, to the weather. He smiles like I’ve done something right, and I flush with the mean joy of being useful. I hate that word. Useful, like I’m a tool instead of a person. But I also like being this for him, this shore he can talk against and hear his voice bounce back on. He takes the print out of the fix and slips it into the washer, the water making a whispering slap against the tray. “I like it when I wear eyeliner,” he says, quietly. “I feel… realer. But then my brother sees me and I feel like I’m playing dress-up wrong. Sometimes I think about… I don’t know. A dress. Not like… I don’t know. I hate words.” He huffs. “They stick. And then I’m stuck to them.” My brain runs down two tracks at once. On one: I imagine him in a dress, something from a thrift store he’d alter with safety pins and thread, the hem uneven, his legs bared and pale, the jut of a kneecap that somehow makes my mouth go dry. On the other: I catalog my own hunger and confusion. My desire has always had a target that came with a label. I like masculine. I like tough. I like a girl with a shaved head and knuckles like brass, a guy who plants his feet and smirks. I like being the one to wipe the smirk off. What does it mean that I also like the way his voice thins with nerves, how his softness makes me want to guard it like a coin in my palm? “Words are clumsy,” I say. “We can try some and throw them away. Like test strips.” I lift one end of the washer tray to let water run over the print. The image underneath is our combined eye: the door, the shoe, the threshold so crisp it’s a kind of invitation. He looks at me with gratitude so unfiltered it almost hurts. “Thanks, Dani.” The way he says my name is different tonight. Like there are more syllables. I swallow. “Do you have words you’ve tried?” I ask. I am careful. I am not going to name him if he wants to name himself. He nods, the motion tiny. “Nonbinary sometimes… sometimes trans. Like, the way you move through the world and how people respond to you.” His hands flex on the tongs. “I don’t know yet. I feel like a misprint.” “That’s still a print,” I say. He laughs again, but it’s a thin ribbon this time. “Whatever you are, you’re allowed to be,” I say, and I mean it so hard my chest hurts. I want to take my big personality and lay it down like a rug for him to walk on, because that’s what I can do. But I also don’t want to flatten anything that’s his. His fingers brush the inside of his wrist where the developer spot has dried. “What if people don’t…” He trails off again. I can fill the blank. Believe. Accept. Stay. “I feel like I’m always making myself small to fit where people can handle me.” “Don’t make yourself small,” I say. It comes out with that take-charge bite. Then I back off, like catching myself mid-step. “I mean… you don’t have to, not here. With me. I can… I can make room.” He looks at me like I’ve moved a mountain. I get lightheaded. This is power, too, I realize. Making space is a kind of leadership. But it’s not the kind I’m good at without gritting my teeth. The part of me that likes to lead wants to say, I’ll tell you what you are and then I’ll make it happen. That’s not what he needs. He needs someone to stand guard while he figures it out. It’s a different muscle. It burns in different places. My phone buzzes again, longer this time, like an incoming call. The world outside is insistently alive. I ignore it. All my old selves—party Dani, girl-on-top Dani, critiques-you-into-better Dani—can pace out there. In here, the red light asks for a slower version of me. “Can I ask you something?” he says. He’s turned his head, so the shadow of his eyelashes makes high commas on his cheek. He’s so young. Nineteen is a number that feels like a bruise to me. I was so raw at nineteen I bled on everything. He wears his rawness like lace. “Ask,” I say. “Do you…” He swallows. “Do you only like guys? I mean, not that this is about that but also kind of. I keep thinking about if I… change. If you—if people—” He flounders, blushing so high it shows even under the red. My pulse stutters, because he did not say people. He said you. I set the tongs down. The clink is small but definitive. I anchor myself with the counter edge digging into my hip. I’ve never been delicate about answers. I’m not delicate now, but I am careful, because this is the part where my certainty could steamroll his vulnerability into a neat shape that fits me. “I’ve dated more men than women,” I say. “I like masculine stuff. I like… swagger.” I grin, a flash of teeth he can see but not measure. “But what I like most is when someone is completely themselves. I’m into that.” It sounds too neat. It sounds like a queer slogan on a tote bag. I wince. “What I mean is—” I run a hand over my buzzcut, the prick of it sharp under my palms. “I don’t know, either. About me. I thought I did. But you…” I tilt my head at him, and the carefulness slips for a second. “You’re confusing me in a good way.” He exhales like the room has given him permission to breathe. “Okay.” I want to reach for him. I want to touch the ink-smudged knuckles, the seam of his sleeve, the strand of hair that wants to stick to his forehead. I always want to reach. I hold myself still. Agency agency agency, I chant in my head like a mantra. His. His. His. “Do you want to try a different lens?” I ask, as if I didn’t just tip my inner furniture over with that confession. He nods, almost relieved by the return to the safe choreography of work. We change it out. The focus whirs. The grain snaps in, the doorway’s peeling paint holding its secrets tighter. “Can I try something?” he says after a stretch of silence that’s not uncomfortable. He’s got that look like he’s about to walk into cold water. I give him a little nod that I hope is more encouragement than push. He reaches up and smudges a thumb of developer on his cheekbone. A dark streak blooms. War paint. Or blush. His hand shakes. He laughs at himself, this little wheeze. “This is dumb.” “It’s not dumb,” I say, and I hear how close I am to begging. “Here.” I take the other end of the tongs and dip them in developer, then tap a dot at the corner of my own eye, a tiny imperfect circle that tingles cool on my skin. When our eyes meet, he gives me that open gratitude again, as if I’ve cut him a key. “Thanks,” he murmurs, and I almost make a joke to deflect the hot coil low in my belly. I don’t. We stand there, both marked now by this room, by the same chemical dusting our hands. He reaches for my wrist, a movement like a thought. He stops before he touches me. “Is it okay?” he asks. My heart, usually a drummer, plays something gentler. I don’t make him ask twice. “Yeah,” I say. “Here.” I hold my arm out. His fingers curl around the vein-blue inside of my wrist, light as a moth’s feet. He doesn’t pull me closer. He just holds. It feels like being chosen. It feels like being trusted. “I don’t know what I’m doing,” he says, voice a scrape. “I’m scared.” “I know,” I say. “Me too.” We breathe. The print in the washer shivers under the water. The door on the page is a mouth. The shoe is half-in, half-out. The threshold is itself, stubbornly simple. My phone buzzes and buzzes and gives up. The world is very small: red light, water, the weight of his hand. “Can I…” He stops and tries again. “Would you look at me? Later. When I try stuff. The dress. Or whatever. Tell me if—” He shakes his head. “Not tell me if it’s right. Just… be there.” The leader in me wants to say yes so hard it becomes an order. The other part of me, the one that’s learned how to make room, puts my yes into his palm like a stone. “I’ll be there,” I say. “I’ll hold the light. You do you.” He smiles, the kind that articulates itself in a thousand small muscles. “Okay.” He lets go of my wrist to pick up the tongs again. The place his fingers were is a hot bracelet. We make the print. We make three more. We find the exact burn that makes the woodgrain glow like it’s lit from within. We write exposures in pencil on the back. We don’t touch more than we have to. Each almost-touch is an electricity I hoard. Each stop I make before finishing the movement toward him is an act of discipline that surprises me. I learn new versions of myself in that discipline. The assertive girl can be soft without dissolving. The part of me that wants to lead can learn to take a step backward and hold the door with my shoulder. When we’re done, he stacks the prints between sheets of blotting paper like communion wafers. The room is quieter than it was, as if we’ve taken sound and turned it into solid objects. He leans on the counter, hip cocked, looking at the drying rack like it could answer his questions. I stand beside him and let our shoulders almost touch. “Thanks,” he says again, and it’s a different thanks. It’s a promise, maybe. Or a question posed to the space between us that neither of us knows how to articulate in words yet. “Anytime,” I say. And it’s not a throwaway. It lands with weight in my mouth. On my walk home, the streetlights will look too white after all this red, and every shiny surface will reflect a face I’m still figuring out: mine with a developer smudge under my eye, a softness in my jaw where I usually set it hard. For now I stay in the bruise-colored safety of this room, listening to the water slide over silver and salt, thinking about thresholds and how you have to step even if you aren’t sure what’s on the other side. “Do you want to go get fries?” I ask, finally. A small offering. A normal thing. A chance to practice the world with our new shapes. He considers. “Yeah,” he says. His grin unfurls. “But can we sit on the same side of the booth?” I laugh, and the sound feels like mine and someone new’s at once. “We can sit wherever you want,” I say. “You call it.” He picks up our stack of prints like a child carries a secret toy, careful and close. I turn off the safelight. The red bleeds out, and the room fills with the sudden blankness of dark. His hand finds the crook of my elbow in the black. The touch is light. It is enough. We open the door, and the outside rushes in, bright and loud and full of people and their labels and their laughter. We step over the threshold together.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures Dani's perspective as she navigates her complex attraction to Elliot during their darkroom session. The piece excels in creating a sensory-rich environment where the red light of the darkroom becomes both literal setting and metaphorical space for vulnerability and confession. The characterization of Dani is particularly strong. Her internal conflict between her usual assertiveness and her desire to give Elliot agency is well-developed throughout. Lines like "The leader in me wants to say yes so hard it becomes an order. The other part of me, the one that's learned how to make room, puts my yes into his palm like a stone" effectively illustrate this tension. The narrative successfully portrays her as someone reconsidering her own identity and attractions through her interactions with Elliot. Elliot's character is also well-rendered, with his quiet intellect and vulnerability coming through in both dialogue and Dani's observations. His hesitancy in discussing his gender identity feels authentic, as does his fear of rejection. The prose is often elegant and evocative, with strong sensory details that ground the reader in the darkroom setting. Descriptions like "The red light paints everything like a wound" and "In the red haze, our hands look prehistoric and tender" create a vivid atmosphere. The photography metaphors work well throughout, connecting the darkroom process to the characters' emotional journeys. However, there are moments where the writing becomes slightly overwrought or purple. Some metaphors and descriptions feel a bit forced or excessive, such as "I want to take my big personality and lay it down like a rug for him to walk on." The narrative occasionally indulges in overly poetic language that draws attention to itself rather than serving the story. The dialogue is generally strong and believable, capturing both Elliot's hesitancy and Dani's more direct communication style. Their conversation about gender identity feels authentic in its awkwardness and vulnerability. The pacing is effective, with the narrative building tension through small moments of connection and revelation. The ending avoids an overly neat resolution while still providing a sense of forward movement in their relationship, with the image of stepping over the threshold together serving as an apt metaphor for their journey. Overall, this is a nuanced exploration of attraction, identity, and the complexity of human connection. The narrative successfully captures the tender awkwardness requested in the prompt while creating distinct, believable characters whose emotional journey feels earned. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Contemporary romance / drama: Stolen Moments in Roma — Score: 91.6
Prompt:
Contemporary Romance / Drama: Stolen Moments in Roma. Write a series of interconnected short scenes and dialogues that span a single day in modern-day Rome, in narrative form. This will form the beginning of a larger story. Alessandra, a fiery, independent Roman woman who works as a motorcycle courier, nearly collides with Ben, a somewhat clumsy, overly polite British academic on sabbatical, who is engrossed in a guidebook near the Trevi Fountain. The initial encounter is a clash of cultures and personalities – Alessandra is all sharp wit and rapid-fire Italian, while Ben is flustered apologies and awkward attempts at speaking the language. However, as they sort out the near-miss, a spark of unexpected humor and connection emerges. Alessandra, it quickly becomes clear, is a whirlwind of energy and mischief. She's a self-admitted troublemaker with a secret penchant for kleptomania, a detail she doesn't explicitly reveal, but which manifests in subtle, daring acts throughout the day. She impulsively decides to take Ben on a wild, unsanctioned tour of Rome, dragging him in some specific instances far outside his comfort zone. Ben, despite his initial apprehension and inherent politeness, finds himself utterly captivated by Alessandra's unapologetic spirit and zest for life. He is drawn into her orbit, a willing participant in increasingly outlandish situations, a quiet rebellion brewing beneath his scholarly exterior. The narrative should primarily consist of short, vivid scenes and dialogue exchanges, revealing their contrasting personalities and backgrounds, and the growing, ambiguous tension between them. Ben is captivated by Alessandra's energy and the thrill of breaking free from his routine. There's a clear sense that Alessandra is toying with Ben, pushing his boundaries and enjoying his reactions, but her own feelings remain somewhat enigmatic. The day should be a rollercoaster of exhilarating, slightly dangerous, and humorous moments, leaving Ben completely disoriented but utterly smitten. Explore the underlying tension & chemistry between them, culminating in some payoff as they part ways (or not -- your choice). Include this detail: Write in narrative prose, using immersive storytelling. 1000 words.
Model Output:
He steps backward with his nose in a guidebook, murmuring dates about a Baroque architect, and the world erupts in the snarl of a motorbike and a shouted curse. A flash of red helmet. The glint of metal. The smell of petrol and espresso. Ben’s elbow clips a handlebar, and a folded map flutters to the cobbles like a wounded bird. The motorbike fishtails, steadies, and stops inches from the Trevi Fountain’s marble lip. Coins sparkle like captured suns behind the spray. A crowd gasps as if it were a performance. “Attento!” the rider snaps, and she flips up her visor. Dark hair spills out, eyes quick, mouth already forming another insult. “Se ti ammazzi, chi lo scrive il tuo libro?” “I’m terribly sorry,” Ben says, too loudly. “I didn’t— I mean, the— the fountain, and I was reading, and—” She smiles then, sharp and amused. “English? Ah. It explains.” She swings a leg off the bike, and somehow the movement is a shrug. “Benvenuto a Roma, Professor.” “I’m not— well. Yes. Sort of,” he confesses. “I’m on sabbatical. It’s actually an extraordinarily good fountain. You were— extraordinary as well. I mean, in stopping. Sorry.” “Mi chiamo Alessandra,” she says, and taps his chest with two fingers, finding his name before he gives it. “E tu sei…?” “Ben.” He extends a hand. She shakes it with a grip that suggests she could take his wrist as easily as his fingers. Her bracelets clink; there are too many of them. A scooter courier bag hangs against her hip, bulging with envelopes. “You walk like a ghost,” she says, tugging his fallen map up and folding it badly. “No noise. It’s dangerous. Especially near water.” “I thought ghosts were noisy,” he says, and she laughs, not kindly and not unkindly. The crowd has already turned away, swallowed by blue sky, white stone, and the promise of wishes. Alessandra swings her visor down, lifts it again. indecisive. Something like curiosity wrinkles her brow. Then, a decision. She points to the space behind her on the bike. “Come,” she says. “I can’t,” he says automatically. Then, “Why?” He hears himself as if underwater. “Because,” she says, “for once, you need to learn to look up.” She glances at his guidebook. “And because I nearly kill you. I am responsible. Insurance.” She grins. “I haven’t an appropriate helmet,” he says, and then is handed one. Where did it come from? She shrugs as if helmets simply appear when she demands them. He puts it on. It smells faintly of smoke and violets. They are a streak through the lanes, past a priest eating gelato, a dog wearing sunglasses, two lovers arguing with their mouths pressed together between words. Alessandra ducks them through traffic with a dancer’s spite, yelling affectionate obscenities at taxis. Ben clutches the bike and her shoulders, and then he realizes he’s gripping her waist, and then he realizes he doesn’t care. He laughs once, shocked by the little brightness of it inside his chest. She brakes near a street shrine gilded with fake flowers and chipped paint. “Sant’Antonio,” she says, killing the engine. “Patron of lost things. Maybe he watches you.” “Are you saying I’m lost?” “I’m saying you are always about to lose something.” Her eyes flick to his pocket, where his wallet peeks out. Without looking, she pushes it deeper with a knuckle. The intimacy of it jolts him. He imagines he feels the brush of her ring. He doesn’t see the way her fingers hesitate at the leather as if testing a door. They stand for a second in the noon heat. Rome hums like a hive; the air smells of frying oil and jasmine. A woman in a window hangs out sheets as if throwing surrender flags. Alessandra touches the shrine’s glass. Inside, the saint holds a baby like a borrowed secret. She kisses two fingers and taps her lips to the glass, quick and secular. “Hungry?” she asks, already moving. “I could eat,” Ben says, because he always could. He follows, more or less because he has no choice. She picks a place he would never dare choose. Men with forearms like bread dough knead pizza behind a counter. Alessandra slides into a gap; when food appears, she is already chewing. He thinks they have not paid, but he doesn’t see money change hands. She knows three waiters by name, and one grandmother by a kiss. Ben attempts Italian; it lands like a paper plane in a headwind. She translates with an expression that is definitely mocking, but soft. “This man will give us supplì if you say ‘please’ as if it is a secret,” she instructs. “Per favore,” he whispers, overcorrecting his r’s. She snorts and taps the glass. “Ehi, due!” They eat on a curb. Rice fritters bleed molten mozzarella like they’ve been wounded. Sauce drips on his trousers; she catches it with a napkin and flicks it at him. “You need stains,” she says. “You look like an apology.” They walk again. She doesn’t explain where. He stops explaining himself. On Via dei Coronari, antiquities pile like the city’s memory tilted out of a drawer. Alessandra drifts through a shop, touches everything. Ben notices that when she leaves, a small brass key is in the fold of her jacket pocket that wasn’t there before. He is not sure he saw her take it. He thinks he must be wrong. He also thinks she left a postcard on a table as they exited, a postcard from no one to no one, and she didn’t have it before. At Ponte Sant’Angelo she leans over the parapet, spits questionably into the Tiber, and watches the water erase the gesture into anonymity. “When my Nonna was a girl,” she says, “she swam here to make her boyfriend jealous. He married her anyway and was jealous until he died.” "That sounds exhausting," Ben says. “Yes,” she agrees. “But she never complained. She had better things. Tomatoes. Witches.” He tries to imagine witches with tomatoes. He realizes he wants to ask a hundred questions and none of them are academic. Alessandra checks his face as if it were a crossword. She pokes his forehead. “You have parentheses here,” she says. “Always thinking. It’s not good for kissing.” He blinks. “I— I’m not—” “I know,” she says. “I’m not either.” She says it like they are both telling a joke whose punchline will hurt. After, they are somehow in a courtyard where cats parade like senators. Alessandra transgresses the posted sign and ushers him in. “Quiet,” she says, which is her trick: telling him to be what he already is and making it feel like a conspiracy. She shows him a fig tree behind a crumbling wall. The figs are not ripe, and she plucks one anyway with a twist that bares her wrist. She tests the weight and sighs, then slips the fig into his hand as if placing a penny on a dead man’s eyes. “For later,” she says. Later comes earlier than expected. Clouds gather without a sound. The sun disappears as if someone unhooked it and wheeled it offstage. A first drop is a coin on his knuckle. Then the sky is a bucket. They run. Rain turns the city into a reflective, slippery thing. Motorbikes hiss past. A woman shakes a mop at the sky. Alessandra’s hair, freed, plasters to her cheeks. Ben’s guidebook swells with water, its pages furiously flipping to irrelevant indexes as he tries to shelter it under his shirt. She sees this and bursts into laughter, which in the rain sounds like applause. The awning of a gelato shop appears like providence. They duck under it, breathless. The sign is painted like a tin toy; behind the glass, ice creams sit in fat, contented swirls. The metal scoopers gleam with a severity that suggests vows. Alessandra taps the glass with two fingers and leans close. “Pistacchio,” she says, “but not green. The brown one. Always trust the ugly colors.” Ben is waterlogged. His hair drips into his eyes; his shirt sticks to his spine; his life seems to have been scooped into a different shape. He says, “Yes. That exactly.” They lick gelato while the rain argues with the cobbles. They are shoulder to shoulder under the narrow awning, elbows bumping, making that awkward dance of proximity strangers learn. They are not strangers anymore, but the dance continues because it is fun to pretend. She watches a couple across the alley fight under a newspaper. She watches a policeman try to order a coffee without getting his hat wet. She watches Ben watch all of this, and him watching becomes the thing she watches. “You are like a mirror,” she says. "But the kind that makes everything more dramatic." “For once, I’m afraid to ask what I look like,” he says. “Wet. Happy. Stupid.” She touches the drip at the tip of his nose, wipes it away, then gestures towards the interior. “We should pay.” “We should,” he agrees, and when she glides inside to flirt with the owner in rapid-fire, he follows with his wallet already out. The owner waves away his card with an expansive hand. “La ragazza,” the man says, chin-tipping at Alessandra, “saved my son’s fiancé’s car last week.” He tells a story about a tow truck and three chickens. Ben’s Italian catches every third word; he gets the gist. When he turns back, Alessandra is at his side, holding two spoons instead of any receipt. “Debt,” she says. “This city runs on it.” He nods. He watches her pocket move, the outline of something small pressing and releasing with each breath. He thinks of keys. He thinks he is reading too much into it. He knows he is not. The rain eases. The awning drips a steady rhythm like a clock deciding to live. “Where next?” he asks, surprising himself with his greed for whatever it is she will do to him. She smirks, as if she has heard the question he didn’t ask. “Do you like risk, Ben?” “I’ve become fond of it,” he says, honestly. She takes him to a church that is closed for lunch—a sentence he didn’t know could exist—and lifts the gate with an ease that suggests either divine sanction or familiarity with hinges. He hesitates in the doorway and then doesn’t. Inside, the air is cool and tastes like the concept of feathers. He is reverent. She is not, precisely; she moves as if the church is a friend she can tease. She steals nothing here. He notices that, too. He files it with the fig, the helmet, the debt. They sit on a pew with their shoulders just not touching, and he tells her about Oxford, late nights, and footnotes, about how gratitude and boredom can be cousins. She tells him about never finishing school and finishing everything else, about mothers who love perfume and brothers who borrow money, about how her apartment is above a bar and she sleeps best when people are laughing underneath her. At some point, they share the warm, smashed fig. It is a soft, sweet mess on his tongue; it tastes like decisions in July. Her fingers brush his lower lip as she wipes a purple smear, and he feels the sensation in his sternum instead of his mouth. Outside, the city breathes steam. People emerge. The clouds fray. Rome continues to be itself with imperious disregard. The day bends towards afternoon, then leans into evening. They end up on Gianicolo, breaths in their throats, the scooter ticking as it cools, the city spread below like a quilt made by a mad grandmother. The wind flirts with her hair; his shirt finally dries and smells faintly of some spice he can’t name. “So,” she says. “You will write your book now?” He laughs, because absent the morning, he would have defended his book like a child. Now it seems like a dog with a trick he’s bored of. “I might write something different.” “What?” She drapes herself on the stone wall, half-serious, half-parody. “A day,” he says. He looks at her. “A thief of a day.” Her eyes flicker. It is almost a flinch. “Careful,” she says. “Words make things true.” He weighs this, then says, “I suppose that’s the point.” They are quiet. Vespas whine below. Church bells play that untranslatable tune. Her hand rests near his on the stone, the space between them like a held breath. He thinks about culprits and cul-de-sacs, about how she has placed herself in his life like a small theft he will only discover later, rummaging. “You push people,” he says suddenly. “Where they want to go,” she says. “They just don’t know it.” “And you?” he asks, softer. “Where do you go when you drop them?” She looks at him. She looks through him. Then she looks away. “Another delivery,” she says lightly, and he hears nothing underneath it and understands too much. They ride back down the hill in a dusk that makes statues glow from the inside. At a corner, she brakes hard and leans across him to tap a boy on a skateboard, presses his phone deeper into his pocket, scolds him with a grin. She palmed nothing. Or she did and he missed it. He doesn’t care which. At the place where they started—Trevi again, now a nighttime theatre—they stop. The fountain is a lit dream of water. People throw coins backwards over their shoulders like absolutions. Alessandra stands on a low wall as if courting gravity. She takes a coin from her pocket—Ben’s coin? He can’t tell. She presses it into his palm. “For the cliché,” she says. “Do it right.” “I thought you didn’t believe in this,” he says. “I believe in practice,” she says. “You practice wanting, the wanting gets easier.” He tosses the coin blindly. It hits water with a small, convincing plunk. He thinks, without irony, of returning. A pause opens. Her face is lit by ripples. He wants to say thank you, but the words seem obscene. He wants to ask if he will see her tomorrow; that feels worse. The thing between them is a knot he has no desire to untie. He lets it be. She steps down from the wall and stands too close. He can smell rain still trapped in her clothes. She looks at his mouth, then his eyes, then somewhere over his shoulder, as if consulting a manual only she can see. Her hand rises. He thinks she is going to take something. She doesn’t. She presses her palm to his chest, flat, over his pounding, and then leans forward and kisses him on the cheek, at the corner, where kiss can become more if either of them moves. Neither moves. “Attento,” she says, softly now. “Look up.” “I will,” he promises. He realizes that he has already begun. She steps back. She swings a leg over the bike. For a second, she is all electricity and impatience, a line drawn through a page. Then she tilts her head. “Tomorrow,” she says. It is not a question. Then it is. “If you want.” He wants to say yes like a boy says yes to a dare. He also wants to weigh it, to protect it from becoming an appointment. He is greedy and careful at once. “Tomorrow,” he says, and she grins, victorious, or maybe relieved. She roars away. He watches until the red of her helmet is no longer a dot but a memory that keeps moving. He opens his guidebook; a damp page falls and flutters to the cobbles. On the ground, he sees it’s not a page. It’s a photograph. A Polaroid he didn’t know he had. He bends to pick it up. It is him and her under the gelato awning, rain between them like beaded curtains. He didn’t see anyone take it. He didn’t hear the click. In the bottom white margin, someone has scrawled a time and a place that could belong to a delivery or a rendezvous. He feels the shift again, like a lyric changing a song you recognize into one you love. He slips the photo into his pocket, hand over it as if guarding something precious and illicit. He walks away in no particular direction, the sound of water in his ears, the city in his lungs, parentheses smoothing from his forehead one by one.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkably accomplished contemporary romance that captures the essence of a chance encounter in Rome with vivid sensory details and nuanced character development. The author has created a compelling narrative that follows the prompt's requirements while adding depth and authenticity to both characters. The writing excels at establishing Alessandra as a "fiery, independent Roman woman" with a penchant for kleptomania that's subtly revealed through small actions throughout the day. Her character is complex - mischievous yet thoughtful, bold yet vulnerable. Ben is equally well-drawn as the "somewhat clumsy, overly polite British academic" who gradually opens up to spontaneity and adventure. Their contrasting personalities create natural tension and chemistry. The prose is elegant without being pretentious, using sensory details to immerse readers in Rome: "The air smells of frying oil and jasmine," "Rome hums like a hive," and "Church bells play that untranslatable tune." These details create a vivid sense of place without overwhelming the narrative. Dialogue is particularly strong, revealing character through speech patterns. Alessandra's direct, sometimes abrupt statements ("You walk like a ghost," "You need stains," "You look like an apology") contrast with Ben's more hesitant, formal speech. Their exchanges feel authentic and reveal growing intimacy. The narrative structure effectively uses short, interconnected scenes that build momentum while maintaining coherence. The day unfolds naturally from their initial collision to their parting at the Trevi Fountain, with each scene revealing more about both characters. The author skillfully balances external action with internal reflection. The piece handles the romantic tension with subtlety. Rather than rushing to a predictable conclusion, it builds a connection through small moments: sharing gelato, the touch of fingers wiping away a fig stain, the almost-kiss at the fountain. This restraint makes their connection more believable and emotionally resonant. The ending strikes the perfect balance between resolution and possibility. The photograph Ben discovers provides closure to their day while opening the door to "tomorrow," leaving readers satisfied yet curious about what comes next. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally, a metaphor might reach a bit too far ("the air tastes like the concept of feathers"), but these moments are rare and don't detract from the overall quality. The piece also manages to incorporate the required elements of Alessandra's kleptomania without making it feel forced or turning it into a caricature. Overall, this is an exceptional piece of contemporary romance writing that creates a vivid sense of place, develops complex characters, and builds emotional resonance through skilled prose and dialogue. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Cozy sci-fi: The Last Outpost — Score: 88.7
Prompt:
Cozy sci-fi The Last Outpost Nettle (or Nets to her friends) bartends at The Last Outpost -- a lazy hub for miners and merchants in an asteroid belt on the Andromeda outer rim. Escaping from her past life, Nets found a home here at the Outpost. They have, thus far, tolerated Net's flaws which she tries to keep in equilibrium with her assortment of talents. Her evenings involve chatting with patrons, negotiating the drama, intrigue, problems & love lives of the diverse crowd that filter through the Outpost. Tonight is no different, at least, until a frazzled looking stranger, tentacled dreads askew, quietly plops down at the bar: "Vega whisky, neat. Better make that a double." Write a chapter in this story. Establish conflict for narrative interest. Don't resolve the conflict within this chapter. Aim for about 60% dialogue. First person, present tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The lights over the bar flicker, just a skim of static through the strip, and the bottles sing their thin glass hum when the gravity hiccups. The whisky in the row of tumblers wobbles like nervous jelly. I press my thumb to the bar’s edge to feel the station’s pulse. It’s off by a half beat tonight. “Vega whisky, neat,” the stranger says, tentacle dreads escaping a wrap and falling over their collarbone. Their skin is a soft sea-slate, their pupils slitted and glossy with a wet sheen. “Better make that a double.” “You and everyone else.” I slide a glass under the dispenser, then change my mind and reach for the good bottle under the counter. “You look like your day tried to eat you.” “Several days,” they say. “And a map.” “Rough.” I pour. The amber catches the neon sign reflection, the O in Outpost looping itself around the rim. The gravity stutters again, and the whisky peels up one side of the glass before settling. “If your map tried to do that, you need a refund.” They grin without humor and knock back half of the double. Tendrils shiver. “You’re funny. Is that local?” “I’m Nets,” I say, because names make people easier. “Short for Nettle. Bar’s the Outpost, if you missed the sign. The humor’s imported.” “Cass,” they say. They look up at the bottles like they’re cataloging them for a job. “Short for Cassandra, if you’re feeling formal.” “I’m never feeling formal.” I slide a napkin and a dish of salted kelp curls toward them. “You in from the belt?” “In and through,” Cass says, eyes flicking to the ends of the bar. They clock the miners, the two mechanics playing a lazy hand of cards, the merchant that always makes a show of counting credits with his lips. They clock everything. “You got a problem with gravity?” “Gravity’s got a problem with itself. The array keeps hiccuping.” I smile. “It’s endearing.” “Endearing.” They echo it like it’s foreign. “Is that what we’re calling it?” “It’s what I’m calling it. The admin calls it a maintenance window. The miners call it a cheap landlord. Depends how much they had to drink first.” “Speaking of.” Cass taps the glass. Their hand’s steady. “Whatever’s in here is excellent.” “Vega’s not cheap,” I say. “You paying with chips or charm?” “Depends what works on you, Nettle.” “Don’t try charm right now,” I say, leaning in. “My heart’s a busted valve. It only works on Tuesdays.” They laugh, low. It’s a soft sound. Makes me want to ask them if they always laugh like their ribs hurt. “I’ll pay,” they say. “I came prepared.” A trio of asteroid lads tumble in, boots gritty, their faces smudged with something that left streaks like constellations. Sola waves from the far table. “Nets! We’re dying over here!” “You’re always dying,” I call back. “That’s why you come see me.” “Bring an extra,” she yells, pointing at Cass with her chin. “For your new friend.” “She’s not a friend yet,” I say, though I’m already grabbing another glass. “She hasn’t told me what she’s running from.” Cass smiles, then shutters. “I didn’t say I was running.” “Everybody’s running from something,” I say. “Even the station.” I pour the second, slide it down. Cass catches it without looking, a smooth lift. “You look like you’re waiting for someone to come in and make your night worse.” “I’m waiting for news,” Cass says lightly. “Which will make everything worse, yes.” “You want to talk about it?” “No.” “All right,” I say. “No it is.” A man in a yellow jumpsuit, today’s shade of cheap corporate, leans over the bar. “You got rations or you just got jokes?” “I got both, but the jokes are free,” I say. “Rations are in the hot box. You want synth stew or algae fritters?” “Fritters,” he says, glancing at Cass like they might be contagious. “And none of that sweet sauce. Makes my tongue go numb.” “That’s because it’s anesthetic,” I say, moving to the warmer. “It has a label.” “No one reads labels,” he snorts, tossing a chip in my tip jar like he’s offended by generosity. The gravity dips again and the fritter basket floats a whisper before touching metal. Everyone in the bar leans in at once, a collective practiced move. The Outpost has taught us how to ride the breath of the station. Cass watches me put the basket down. “You’re good at this,” they say. “Keeping people at the edge of fight and forgetting.” “I practice,” I say. “And I like keeping people. It’s a hobby.” “How’d you end up out here?” Cass asks, tone casual but eyes not. “You could run a bar in any freeport. Why the last outpost before a black nothing?” “Because the black nothing is quieter than the first five stops,” I say. “And because if I’m on the edge of everything, I can see what’s coming.” “And who taught you that?” “I taught me,” I say. “With some help from bad luck and good boots.” Cass’s mouth quirks. “Boots.” “Proper boots and a pack that fits and a habit of not asking questions you don’t actually want the answer to. All the survival skills.” I wipe a ring of condensation. “Also, I make the second best pickled mushroom in the quadrant.” “Second best,” Cass says. “Who has the first?” “My dead aunt,” I say. “She’s not giving up the title.” They lean in. “Let me ask you something, then. Hypothetically.” “Oh look,” I say. “Questions.” “Hypothetically,” they continue, ignoring me, “if someone had to store a minor, smallish, hardly noticeable item in a freezer. Temporarily. Is that the kind of thing the Outpost frowns on?” “It depends if the item screams,” I say. “Or tends to explode. Or is alive and breathes oxygen.” “None of the above,” they say. “Mostly it hums.” “I’ve got humming slots.” I jerk my chin toward the back where a blue light glows behind a curtain. “Why the freezer?” “Because it’s not chassis-stable at ambient.” Cass tilts their glass, watching the whisky slosh. “And because it slows things down. In general.” “I like slow things,” I say. “Fast things make me spill drinks.” Sola wanders up, puts her arms on the bar and rests her chin on her fists. “You flirting,” she says to me, “is my favorite entertainment.” “We have cards,” I say. “We have the same five cards you always have,” she replies. She turns to Cass. “You a smuggler?” “Sola,” I warn, but Cass just smiles with all teeth. “I’m an archivist,” they say, and Sola blinks. “What’s that?” “Someone who keeps the things nobody else wants to remember.” Cass lifts their glass. “To memory.” Sola takes a kelp curl, crunches it. “Gross. Good luck.” She leaves behind the smell of metal and sweat and cheap citrus. The station uses it in the air filters to make it feel like we’re not breathing our own ghosts. It never entirely works. “You really an archivist?” I ask. “Mostly,” they say. “I grew up in the scrap rings. Memory is portable. It pays better than you think.” “And you need a freezer.” “I need a minute where whatever’s following me can’t find the trail.” I look at them over the rims of the bottles. “Ah.” “So you do ask the questions.” “I ask the ones that tell me whether I’m making a mess that gets my floor scrubbed with fire,” I say. “Put it this way: if I help you stash your hummer in my freezer, do I get swarmed by corporate security, pirate hunters, or the romantic disgruntled?” “Option one,” they say. “With a garnish of option three. The hunters don’t chase archives; no one pays. Corporates, though, they’ll pay to pretend the past is clean.” “Who’s the romantic disgruntled?” Cass’s mouth quirks again, softer this time. “Someone who thinks I owe them a story.” “We all owe someone a story,” I say. “Sometimes the story is ‘I left.’” “That story gets old.” “Most true things do.” A slow chime sounds from the door. It’s early for that note. We only hear it when a ship docks with a scrape in the tone. Everyone in the bar looks up, then away, then at their drinks. That chime says: trouble with boots. A moment later, the door slides open and three figures in matching matte coats step through. No insignia, which is an insignia of its own. Their hair is steel-gel perfect. Their eyes are shield-implanted, the irises a corporate silver. The way they look around says they own air. “Security,” Sola murmurs, flipping her cards. “One, two, three. Netty, hide me.” “You owe me for last week’s noodles,” I say under my breath. Cass goes still. Their tendrils lift a fraction and then settle, slow, like seaweed after a wave. The lead coat—short haircut, scar on their top lip like a cat scratch—steps to the bar. “We’re looking for a fugitive,” they say without preamble. “Archivist-class. Goes by Cass. Cassandra Rhee. Or other names. Docked at port S-12 forty minutes ago.” “Congratulations,” I say. “You have eyes.” The scar twitches. “We have warrants.” “You can hang them on the tip jar.” “Clever,” they say. They scan the room. Their gaze slides past Cass like they’re just another gray shape. Cass is good; their profile is a study in harmless. “We also have cause to scan privately owned refrigeration units.” “That sounds like a euphemism,” I say. “It’s not.” “I know, sweetheart.” I put both hands on the bar so they can see them. “The Outpost honors warrants that were filed through station admin. You got one of those or just one you printed at your office?” They pull a chip out of their coat, toss it onto the counter. The chip pings to life with admin’s seal. Which means Paru from admin either signed it or got scared enough to look away. “We’re going to look,” the coat says. “We’ll make it quick.” “You’ll do it with me watching,” I say. “And you won’t touch anything that hums.” “Why is that?” “Trade secret.” “Trade,” the coat says, tasting the word like it might be poison. “We’ll be thorough.” “You like flirting with thoroughness?” I smile. “It flirts back.” They don’t smile. “You’ll accompany us.” “I’ll bring a towel,” I say. I lean in, letting the bar’s hum gust up, masking me. My lips barely move. “Back door,” I whisper to Cass. “Left of the sink. The freezer has a false shelf behind the prawns. Make it hum quietly.” Cass doesn’t nod. They wipe the bottom of their glass with a napkin, toss the napkin into their empty bowl, stand like they’re going to the washroom. For a beat, one of the coats looks their way. Cass’s tendrils smooth. They’re casual. They’re a late-night traveler in a bar of miners. They disappear. “Two of you,” I say to the coats. “With me. The third stays here and enjoys the ambience.” “The ambience,” Scar says. “The kelp curls,” I say. “They’re famous.” They don’t argue. They think they don’t need to. I lead them through the curtain to the back, the blue light bathing us like we’re underwater. The freezer hums polite. It’s old, patched with tape and my optimism. I can feel Cass on the other side like a vibration under my skin. I open the door. Cold breath rolls over us. “This is it,” I say. “Don’t touch the prawns.” Scar reaches past me with a scanner. The gravity wobbles again, harder now. The cold bowls inside the freezer ring like bells. Scar frowns. “Your grav stabilizers are under service?” “We call it flair,” I say. They wave the scanner. It chirrups at every organic; it chirrups at the chunks of meat that are probably not originally from one animal. It chirrups at the mason jar of pickled mushrooms—second best in the quadrant—and then it goes very quiet on the back wall. “What’s that?” Scar asks. “A shelf,” I say. “A false one.” “I like to put a little drama in my life.” Scar doesn’t ask permission. They put their hand on the edge of the shelf and pull. It resists, then slides with a sigh. Behind it, neatly tucked between frost and shadow, is nothing. The kind of nothing that’s deliberate. “Huh,” I say. “That’s disappointing.” Scar gives me a look like I’m a dish they didn’t order. “We’ll be back with a heavier scan,” they say. “Don’t leave port.” “I live here,” I say. “You don’t know how to talk to bartenders, do you?” They stare for a long beat. Then they slide the shelf back in place, turn on their heel, and head for the door. “We’ll watch the exits,” they say to their colleague at the bar as they pass. “And the ducts.” “The ducts?” Sola says. “You think we’re children?” “We think you’re inventive,” Scar says. “No one leaves.” When they’re gone, Cass steps out from under the sink like a shadow unwrapping itself. They’re dripping; there’s a wet sheen on their sleeves. The hidden wash pipes sweat when the gravity goes. Their tendrils are slicked back, their eyes wider. “You have a good false shelf,” they say, breath soft. “I have several,” I say. “And I have a headache.” “I can leave through the waste chute,” they say, voice low. “Your ducts. Your delicate beloved ducts.” “You can try. They’ll be watching.” I reach out, then pull back. “How bad is your thing? Your hum?” Cass’s mouth twists. “Bad enough that if they catch it, they’ll scorch this place to the screws.” “Then we don’t let them catch it,” I say. “Where is it now?” “On me.” “My mother always told me to choose my guests carefully.” “What did your mother know?” “Less than she thought.” “We could dump it,” Cass says. Their voice is dull in a way I don’t like. “It hurts me to say it. We could dump it and let space take it, and then they can argue with physics instead.” “You don’t want to.” “It’s the last shard of a language that doesn’t exist anymore,” they say. “It’s… a map of a map. A way through the rocks that doesn’t use computers. That’s why they care. If anyone memorizes it, anyone with a head and a beat can drift where they shouldn’t. No taxes. No tolls. They’d strap me to a chair and take it piece by piece.” “Do you memorize it?” Cass laughs, and it’s broken. “I am it.” “Oh,” I say. The cold of the freezer clings in the bar warm. “Well. That’s worse.” “Worse is relative.” “You could have lied. You could have told me it was a music chip or frozen organs.” “I don’t lie to my bartender,” they say. “Not when I want them to keep me alive.” “You don’t even know me,” I say, and the gravity wavers, just enough to tilt the liquid in every glass toward us like a toast. The Outpost hums. The door chime peals sharp. Someone else docks hard. Cass takes a breath like they’re trying to swallow the whole room. “Nets.” “Yeah?” “If someone offers you a lot of money later to turn me over—” “I won’t,” I say. “You didn’t let me finish.” “I don’t need you to.” The door opens. A figure fills the frame like a knot in wood, corded and complicated. Leather, braided, edged. They have the kind of smile that looks like a weapon being cleaned. The romantic disgruntled, I think, the story that thinks it’s owed. They glance at the coats, at the bar, at me, at Cass. They lift two fingers. “Hey, Vega,” they say, easy. “Been a while.” Cass goes still in a way that reads inside-out. The hum of the freezer rises like a warning. “Hi, Wren,” Cass says, voice thin as a fishing line. “It’s been never long enough.” The lights flicker again. My station breathes wrong. And the room, with its wobbling drinks and lazy card games and cheap citrus air, becomes a place where a choice will have to be made, not now but soon. I run my thumb along the bar’s worn groove. I think about boots. I think about maps. “Who needs another drink?” I call, as my heartbeat counts down something I don’t yet know. And the Outpost, faithful, rings like a bell.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a cozy sci-fi atmosphere in a bar at the edge of space. The author has crafted a first-person present-tense narrative as requested, with Nettle (Nets) as the bartender protagonist. The writing establishes the setting of The Last Outpost effectively through sensory details like the flickering lights, gravity hiccups, and the ambient sounds of the station. The dialogue makes up approximately 60% of the text as requested, and it flows naturally between characters. The conversations reveal character traits and backstory without feeling forced. Nets has a distinctive voice—sardonic, world-weary, but compassionate—that remains consistent throughout. The dialogue is particularly strong in establishing relationships and tension without excessive exposition. The conflict is well-established: Cass, a mysterious archivist, arrives with something valuable that corporate security wants. The stakes escalate when security arrives, followed by "the romantic disgruntled" named Wren. The chapter ends without resolution, leaving us with mounting tension as promised in the prompt. The prose balances descriptive elements with dialogue effectively. Metaphors like "the gravity stutters" and descriptions of the station "breathing" create a lived-in world. The author uses sensory details skillfully—the amber whisky catching neon light, the smell of metal and cheap citrus in the air filters. Character development is nuanced. Nets reveals her past obliquely through dialogue, showing her as someone who chose this remote location deliberately. Cass is developed as a complex character with motivations beyond simple survival—they're protecting a cultural artifact, something they consider themselves part of. The pacing is well-managed, starting with a casual encounter that gradually reveals higher stakes. The writing avoids info-dumping by revealing the world through natural interactions and observations. Some minor weaknesses: a few metaphors feel slightly overwrought ("the bottles sing their thin glass hum"), and occasionally the prose veers toward being too clever at the expense of clarity. The ending introduces a new character somewhat abruptly, though this serves the purpose of escalating conflict. Overall, this is a strong piece that successfully creates a cozy sci-fi atmosphere while establishing meaningful conflict. The characters feel authentic, the dialogue serves multiple purposes, and the world-building is integrated naturally into the narrative. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Young adult drama: Gone South — Score: 90.2
Prompt:
Young adult drama Gone South Taylor is a 16 year old teen with a history of "concerning behavioural patterns" (or that's how the stupid smug school counsellor worded it on the phone call to Mom). It shouldn't be a surprise: When you live in a backwater town in Tennessee, your choices are: a. be mind-fuckingly bored, or b. invent some drama. Two days ago, Taylor came out to their family as trans. This disclosure was *not* in the category of invented drama -- it was, in fact, the real deal, and a long time coming. It didn't go well. The last 48 hours had been pure disaster. In a moment of desperate inspiration, Taylor had decided to get the hell out of dodge. And so an escape plan was hatched and executed within the space of 30 minutes. That was last night. Now Taylor was two states away, having been unceremoniously ejected from their hitched ride in downtown New Orleans. Write the next chapter in Taylor's story as they find their feet in this new environment. Tell the chapter over the course of their first day in New Orleans, in which Taylor meets another runaway with issues and secrets. Taylor navigates this new world, not knowing who to trust or what the dangers are. Write in Taylor's voice, and incorporate their internal monologue as they grapple with intense & conflicting emotions. Also incorporate dialogue with the interesting characters Taylor meets. First person, mixed tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The trucker dropped me at a light that never turned green. He said, “Can’t take you past the Quarter,” like there was some invisible fence and the truck would explode if he crossed it. I mumbled thanks and climbed down, legs shaking harder than I was willing to admit. He drove off with my name—my real name—stuck in his throat like a secret he didn’t know what to do with. New Orleans smells like warm sugar rotting in a flowerpot. And salt. And stale beer. And something alive that’s dying, or dead that’s pretending. But the light here is a different animal. It slides over the cracked sidewalks like it’s curious. I stand there with my backpack that used to be my brother’s, hugging it like it’s a dog that might bite me if I let go. I have twelve percent battery. Twelve percent feels like twelve breaths. I could call Mom—no. A shiver goes through me like I reached into a dark cabinet and touched a cold glass. I swallow. My throat tastes like sleep. It’s barely nine and already humid enough that my shirt is sticking. I am sixteen and far too small for this city and all its teeth. I walk. Don’t think, absorb. People move around me carrying their mornings out into the street: painters with ladders, a lady in a blue headwrap shoving a cart of ice, a kid with a trombone case. Everywhere there’s music even when there isn’t. It’s in the way sneakers slap on concrete, the rumble of buses, someone knocking, the clack of a skateboard. I pass a cafe and a window full of pastries like fat golden moons. Coffee smell. My stomach is a whiny child tugging my sleeve. I check my pocket: nine dollars and some lint. The barista is a dude with tattooed knuckles and the kind of moustache you have to tend like a bonsai. He glances at my hair (mess, not on purpose) and my too-big tee (on purpose), and something like a question comes into his eyes. I hate that question. I hate the micro-shuffle people do when they’re trying to figure out what to call you without saying anything. Still, the pastries are winking like soft planets. “Do y’all do day-old?” I ask, voice careful, like I’m balancing it on my tongue. “After eleven,” he says, already bored. Of course. I buy a coffee, black, burn my tongue because it’s something to feel that isn’t fear, and sit on the curb. I text Cass even though I told myself I wouldn’t. Here. Alive. Don’t tell anyone. Block my number after? Seven percent now. I set the phone on my knee like a small sleeping animal. Within a minute: a heart emoji, then a flood: Where is here? New Orleans? Are you serious?? Babe you can’t just. But then: Do you have a place to stay? Are you safe? I write I’m okay. Lie. Battery icon goes red. That small animal rolling over, sighing, dying. “Got a light?” a voice says. Smoke on it. I blink up and there’s this kid my age or maybe older, hard to tell because he’s got those cheekbones you could grate nutmeg on. He’s holding a cigarette and he’s wearing a denim jacket even though I’m dying in a t-shirt. His hair is a black halo of curls, eyes a color I can’t name and don’t trust. He’s trying for bored, achieves restless. “No,” I say. I smile because that’s what you do when you have no currency. “Also, those kill you.” “Everything kills you,” he says, and drops the cigarette behind his back like he’s embarrassed. He sticks out a hand. “River.” I flinch. The name hits me like he put his palm on my chest. “Is that your name or where you’re headed?” “Depends who’s asking.” He grins. “You’re not from here.” “Nope,” I say. “You?” He uses his chin like a compass, pointing at the river beyond the buildings, making a sound that isn’t a word. “Sometimes.” “You hungry?” he asks after a moment. “Yes.” I don’t mean to say it that fast. He stands, jerks his head. I follow because I have no plan besides not dying and he has a plan that looks like food. Also his shoes are duct-taped together and there’s a patch on his sleeve that says Hell Is Real, and my weird little streak of loyalty to broken things flutters. We cut through streets bristling with iron balconies and plants that look like they’re gossiping. A brass band is warming up on a corner, sounding like a dragon clearing its throat. People are filming them but not giving them any money. River flips them off without moving his hand from his pocket. We end up behind a bakery, by a dumpster that smells like sugar and rot. He knocks twice on the back door. A small woman with hair the color of a new penny cracks it open and sighs when she sees him. Sighs, but smiles. “You again,” she says. “Me again,” he replies, spreading his arms like: see? It’s me. She hands him two bags before he can say anything else. He gives one to me without looking. “Thank you,” I tell her. She stares at my face too long, like she’s trying to place me in a catalogue, then shakes her head and shuts the door. We sit on milk crates and open the bags. Apricot croissant. Blueberry something. I make a small noise I’m going to pretend was actually the croissant. River watches me eat with the satisfaction of a cat watching you unbox a present it’s already scratched. “So,” he says. “You running from something or running to it?” I swallow. The apricot is sticky on my fingers. “Yes,” I say. He laughs. It’s nice. It slides over me, loosening a bolt. “You got a place?” he asks. “I have a backpack.” “That’s a hell of a bed,” he says. He leans back, balancing the milk crate on its rear edge, testing gravity like he knows it personally. “There’s a spot under the overpass where people crash. You’d hate it and then you wouldn’t. I could show you. Or, there’s a shelter with too many rules and not enough answers. Your call.” He watches my face like a mirror he can read. There’s a part of me that wants to say: I’m actually just waiting for my Uber to the rest of my life. Please leave me alone so I can pretend I’m not drowning. The rest of me knows better. “Overpass,” I say. He nods like he knew I’d say that. He knows a lot, probably too much. He hops off the crate. “What’s your name?” The question lands heavy. My phone chimes in my pocket. Four percent. I pull it out and show him the dying red symbol like I can use it to not answer. “Taylor,” I say. It feels like putting on a shirt that fits now. I’m braced for the flinch, the pause, the oh. He just nods. “Okay, Taylor. Let’s go.” We weave through Quarter tourists and old men yelling about chess. The river pulls at us, a flat muscle, mean and beautiful. I’m distracted by a dog wearing shoes. River is distracted by nothing and everything; he watches windows like he can see the backs of people’s heads and what’s inside them. “Why River?” I ask, because I want to turn us both into jokes before anything gets true. “I stole it,” he says, and doesn’t say from whom. He kicks a bottle cap into a drain. “My mom used to say you can’t step in the same river twice. I figured that meant I could be someone else whenever I wanted.” “What about your mom now?” I ask, and immediately want to rewind my mouth. “Different river,” he says. Then, before I can hook my apology onto something: “What’d you do?” He means: what about the counsellor voice that stamped me as a file, what about the kitchen table and the shouting, what about Cass’s text. “I told the truth and it didn’t go well,” I say. My throat tightens. Stupid clumsy truth. “They think I’m… They think.” Words are dumb little pebbles, rolling. “I had to leave before I left in a different way.” He glances at me and nods, small and tight, like he understands and also isn’t allowed to show me that. “Yeah,” he says softly. “I know that one.” We reach the overpass, a concrete cathedral with pigeons for angels. Tents bloom like sad mushrooms. There are shopping carts decorated like altars, blankets that have learned to be walls. A woman in a stained wedding dress is painting her nails careful and bright. The sound of cars overhead is ocean and artillery. It should be terrifying. It is. Also: it’s honest. River navigates like a tour guide who doesn’t want to be there, pointing out a corner where a guy will try to sell you soap that’s actually rocks, a patch to avoid unless you like needles, a church van that comes at noon with sandwiches and lectures. The air tastes like dust and metal and someone’s cooking something amazing three blocks over. “Stick near me,” he says, casual, like I’m a stray and he’s throwing me a string of sausages. “Are you charging for this?” I ask, because I need him to be a hustler more than a savior. You can predict hustlers. “Pay me in jokes,” he says. “And gum, if you have any.” “I have depression,” I offer. “Is that like gum?” “Depends if it’s mint,” he says, and grins. “We’ll find you part-time work. Don’t worry. Street’ll eat you if you taste like worry.” We settle under a scorch of shadow that smells slightly better. A kid I’d call twelve if time wasn’t on fire hands me a bottle of water like I’m about to faint. I drink half and save the other half because that’s what Cass would tell me: ration your kindnesses and your electrolytes. My phone vibrates again. Two percent. Cass: call me when you can. I type: Can’t. Love you. You were the only one who saw me. The screen dims like a curtain. One percent. I look at the little battery like if I beg it’ll sprout another bar. It does not. The phone dies in my hand. Relief sours with panic. “You look like you just watched your best friend sink,” River says. “Who says I didn’t?” I tuck the dead rectangle back into my pocket like a corpse. “What’s your secret?” It comes out meaner than I meant. Because I’m jealous of his ease, because I am raw and it stings. He goes still. He opens his mouth, closes it. For a second, his face is just a kid who fell off his bike and doesn’t want to cry. Then he shrugs, aiming for careless, hitting bone. “I got a brother,” he says. “He thinks I died. Or wishes it. I can’t decide which is easier.” I wait. The highway hums over our heads like a big animal sleeping. Someone laughs, high and rusted. “He took the hit for me once,” River says. “Cops. He’s better at being the good one. Except now he’s probably on his third strike because I was on my way to be the second. I don’t know. It’s math I can’t do. I’m not going back. He’s not either. That’s the secret: there’s no back.” It sits between us like a third person neither of us introduced. My chest hurts. I want to say something smart and brave. I say: “I’m sorry.” It’s stupid because it doesn’t fix anything. He nods like he gets that I can’t fix anything. “No pity,” he says softly. “Pity gets you pickpocketed.” “Okay,” I say. “No pity. Just… curses.” He smiles at that. We let the silence stretch. It holds. By noon, the church van shows up and a woman with arms like a linebacker hands me a sandwich and asks if I’ve accepted Jesus. I say I’m more of a begrudging acquaintance. She laughs, louder than strictly necessary, and tells me I can come by the shelter if I need “women’s toiletries.” The word catches in my chest like a fish hook. I nod and take the bag. River’s eyes flicker, checking me for blood, I think. Or checking which way I’ll run. “People see what they want,” he says later, when we’re chewing lettuce and bread and something approximating turkey. “The trick is to feed them what makes them full and keep the good stuff for yourself.” “What’s the good stuff?” I ask. He taps his chest. “You. Your name. Your night brain. The parts you’d kick anyone else for touching.” “My night brain is an asshole,” I say. “It would steal your lighter.” He looks at me. “Maybe. Or maybe it’s telling you something you’re chewing too fast to taste.” He talks like that sometimes, like a poem is falling out of a hole in his pocket. It’s annoying. It’s also… comforting. The day bakes. Somebody starts drumming on overturned buckets and the beat becomes the ground. Later, a man with a face like a wrinkled dollar bill drifts over and asks if either of us wants to make “quick cash.” River tells him, “We’re expensive,” and the man wanders away, muttering. After, River says, quiet: “Don’t go with anyone. Not your first day. Not your tenth. They’ll tell you they’ll make you family. Family is light and food and sometimes prison. This isn’t that.” “I had a family,” I say. He waits. I swallow. “It was a lot of bathrooms with me staring in the mirror and trying to make my mouth do something easy. I used to think if I smiled right it would all rearrange.” “And?” he asks. “It did,” I say. “But not the way they wanted.” By late afternoon, I am sweat and quiet. The sun moves around, finds me wherever I try to hide. River disappears for half an hour and I have a minor panic attack, imagining he’s gone forever, that he was a hallucination called hunger. He comes back with a phone charger that looks like it’s been run over twice and a cheap brick of a battery pack. “Found it,” he says. “You stole it,” I say. “Found it,” he repeats, and hands me the cord like a gift. He looks proud and a little nervous, like maybe I’ll judge him. I don’t. I want to cry. I plug my dead phone in and it blinks awake, petulant, a Tamagotchi revived. Messages from numbers I don’t recognize. One from Mom, long and full of scripture and ellipses, the words wobbling like jelly. One from Dad: Call me. One from Cass: I’m here whenever. I turn the screen face down because if I look at it too long I’ll turn to salt. We go to the river as the sun drops its last coins on the water. The air is thick enough to drink. People are out—couples with hands attached, kids trying to sell bottled water that’s warmed in the sun. A man plays something on a guitar that makes me think of a door I closed too early. We sit on the steps and watch boats shoulder past, slow and important. I think about leaving and then not leaving and all the versions of me shedding like snakeskin behind us. I think about the school counsellor’s voice on that call to Mom, crisp and careful: We’re concerned about Taylor’s pattern of… I think about Mom’s face, the way it ripped when I said it. Not my first secret. My best one, finally spoken. I lean my head on my knees. “So,” River says after a while, in a voice that’s almost a question. “You staying?” “I don’t know what staying is,” I say. “But I’m not going back.” “That’ll do,” he says. He nudges my shoulder with his. “Tonight you can be a tourist. Tomorrow you can be a problem.” “Deal,” I say. My phone buzzes once against my thigh. I let it. The sky slips from orange to bruise. Somewhere, a band is finding its song, the horn bending into it, the drum promising to catch them if they fall. The river keeps moving, not asking permission. I think: maybe I can learn that. My feet, restless all day, finally quiet. My heart doesn’t, but it changes its rhythm. It doesn’t sound like running anymore. It sounds like starting.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece effectively captures the voice of a transgender teen runaway navigating their first day in New Orleans. The writing demonstrates considerable skill in creating an authentic first-person perspective with vivid sensory details that bring the setting to life. The character of Taylor is well-developed, with a complex emotional landscape that feels authentic to their situation. Their internal monologue reveals vulnerability, fear, and determination in equal measure. The backstory is woven in naturally through reflections and brief mentions rather than exposition dumps. River serves as an effective foil and guide character, with his own mysterious past and survival skills. The relationship that develops between the two characters feels organic and appropriately tentative given their circumstances. The prose style is particularly strong, with evocative metaphors and sensory details that create a vivid sense of place. Lines like "New Orleans smells like warm sugar rotting in a flowerpot" and descriptions of the light that "slides over the cracked sidewalks like it's curious" demonstrate sophisticated imagery. The author effectively uses sentence fragments and varied sentence structures to create a distinctive voice for Taylor. The dialogue is natural and revealing, with each character having a distinct speaking style. River's poetic tendencies contrast with Taylor's more direct approach, creating an interesting dynamic. The conversations reveal character without becoming expository. The piece avoids common pitfalls of stories about runaways by not romanticizing homelessness. It acknowledges dangers and difficulties while still allowing for human connection. The ending strikes an appropriate balance between hope and realism - Taylor isn't magically saved, but has found a temporary foothold and companion. There are a few instances where metaphors become slightly overwrought ("The river pulls at us, a flat muscle, mean and beautiful"), but these are balanced by more straightforward observations. The pacing is effective, covering a full day without rushing or dragging. The story successfully fulfills the prompt requirements, maintaining first-person perspective, incorporating internal monologue, and featuring dialogue with interesting characters. It captures Taylor's conflicting emotions about their identity, family situation, and uncertain future. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Dystopic-comedy: My Apocalypse Buddy — Score: 91.2
Prompt:
My Apocalypse Buddy Write a wry, dry short story of survival and adventure loosely in the style of Terry Pratchett, set in the post-technological collapse world. The story begins with the pair deliberating their predicament and intent for the day's mission, details the ways in which the mission inevitably goes sideways, and returns them to home base in multiple ways, worse for wear. [characters] - the animo-tronic stuffed koala, Chewy, from some long forgotten before time - midas, our hapless protagonist, who has a knack for finding himself in the worst kinds of trouble. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The day dawned with the sincerity of a politician and the reliability of a hand-cranked toaster. The sky was the soft-colored bruise of a world that had tried to keep going and tripped on its shoelaces anyway. Midas lay on his back in the former break room of the former Museum of Advancement, now their home base on account of three working locks and zero working exhibits. Beside him, perched on a dented coffee tin like a furry oracle, sat Chewy, an animo-tronic stuffed koala, who regarded the ceiling with the philosophical calm of one who has only two expressions and one of them is “hungry.” “Inventory,” Midas said. He cleared his throat like a man looking into a very small and very empty wallet. “We have: three packets of soup powder, no soup, a fishing hook without line, a battery that powers a clock when it wants to embarrass me, and… a jar of beets. Red ones.” Chewy’s eyes flickered a low, suspicious amber. He neither approved nor disapproved of beets. Chewy did not so much have a palate as a list of things that were “edible” and “not batteries.” “And,” Midas continued, “we have a map of the Old City, drawn by someone whose definition of ‘north’ suggests they were born upside down.” Chewy’s pupils dilated. His left eye blinked blue, the right green. The first meant hope. The second meant Midas was doing that thing again where he tried to turn optimism into a verb. “Our intent,” Midas said, enunciating as if the universe were a notary public, “is to go to the Techno-Mall, which, according to rumor, is still guarded by a skeleton of society. Or actual skeletons. We procure food and maybe bits of wire for your… you know.” Chewy’s eyes flashed violet, which was embarrassment. There were two wires inside him that had once connected to a voice chip, a little metal disc that had a child’s laughter and pre-programmed phrases like “Hugs!” and “Nap time!” Nothing came out now but grunts and the occasional staticky curse, which Midas was relatively sure was not in the original product manual. “Right,” Midas said. He stood and stretched, counting his aches like rosary beads. “So we walk out of here, we don’t get eaten by runt packs—” Chewy went yellow at the mention. Yellow was fear. It was Chewy’s most versatile setting. “—we don’t step on any mischief tiles—” The Museum’s floors had been fitted, in optimistic days, with interactive panels that lit up and explained the wonders beneath your feet. They had not coped well with rain. Now they retold their narratives as random bursts of electricity and the occasional unnerving sentence about the importance of curiosity seconds before trying to kill you. “—and we come back before the pink sky. Because if the sky goes pink, we don’t joke. We hide and stay quiet and we do not talk about what happened last time.” Chewy’s eyes went the color of a deep lake. He leaned forward, head cocked, and made a tiny mechanical sound like a sigh. “Team,” Midas said, putting a hand on a fabric ear worn nearly bald by fingers that had loved it in a happier world, “we have a plan.” They always had a plan. Plans were the things that happened before life opened the trapdoor. They left by way of a stairwell that sighed like an old tea kettle. Pigeons watched and disliked them without energy. The street was a corridor of weeds and former cars. Somewhere a dog barked with the voice of a trombone with a cold. Midas held a stick, which is the sort of thing that made no sense as a weapon until it did. “There,” Midas whispered theatrically at a fallen billboard advertising laugh lines you didn’t have to have. “We go past the Skin Care Cathedral, under the Flyover of Broken Promises, and then—we’re practically there.” Chewy’s eyes turned a very annoyed teal. He pointed, causing his elbow servos to whine just a bit—over the years, oil had become an exotic treat. Midas squinted. He had, admittedly, inverted their route. The Flyover of Broken Promises was the pile of concrete to the left, not the right. The difference was important because to the right the ground wavered in that oceanic way that meant the dirt was trying to remember if it used to be a bog or had just read about bogs somewhere and wanted to try. “Left, then,” Midas said, and they went left. The Techno-Mall had been a temple to commerce: four floors of glass and neon, escalators lifting people toward their financial decisions like gentle jaws. It had once held a store called Planet of Clothes and a place that sold five varieties of yogurt that all tasted like existential disappointment. Now it was a rectangle of broken teeth and dangling tendons of wiring, humming in a voice that said: I am not as dead as I look. “Look,” Midas said, indicating a sign that read, partially, WEL OM S A ERS! The letters that were still there tried their hardest. “Friendly.” They slipped through a door that had made its peace with its hinges. Inside lay the hollows of former trolleys, nests made of receipts and novelty sweaters. The air smelled faintly of the world’s last cinnamon roll. “Food court,” Midas murmured. It had not, in honesty, fed anyone in a decade. But the stalls were shelter, and sometimes pigeons failed to understand the concept of ceilings. Pigeons contain a surprising amount of protein, even if dignity is lost in the preparation. Chewy tapped his metal paw against Midas’s shoulder with a series of precise clinks, which meant: quiet. His eyes slid to a mean little red, which meant: danger that is more organized than it looks. Midas heard it: the soft chuckle of an escalator doing its best impression of a crocodile. He looked up. The small entourage of the mall’s new skeleton guard had arranged themselves along the escalators like queens on chessboards. Mannequins. Not the friendly kind that liked hats. These had been drafted. Bits of rebar gave them spines. They had acquired tools, or the idea of tools, or perhaps a religion of sharpness. They turned their heads together. This was worse than eyes in the dark. This was eyes on ball joints that had opinions. Midas raised his stick. He was not sure what he intended to do with it, but he hoped his lack of a plan surprised them. Chewy blinked—a sudden series of strobe whites. This was the emotional color for: I think if I do something very stupid it will either be brilliant or fatal. His paws moved in patterns he had not learned, but which had been imprinted by an engineer who loved Easter eggs. Chewy croaked, as if deep within him an ancient slogan had dusted itself off: “H—h…hugs!” The mannequins froze. “Hugs!” Chewy repeated, more confidently, although his voice cracked on the s and came out as “hugz.” Midas felt the world pause to consider slapstick. “Yes,” he said. “Hugs. We brought them. For you.” A mannequin’s head ticked. It had a smile carved into its face with a key. Its hand, which was a soup ladle tied to a broom handle, dipped. It began its slow descent down the escalator, which protested, then remembered its job. Midas did not love this. He tugged Chewy backwards, step by dragging step, the wheels in Chewy’s hips murmuring about the poor life choices of grit. The second mannequin moved. And the third. Their steps were ordinary and wrong at once. “This is when the plan goes sideways,” Midas whispered. “Hu—hugs!” Chewy said brightly, and his eyes flashed a frantic rainbow. They ran. They ran past a games store where plastic boxes spilled like fossilized confetti, past a defunct fountain full of coins that had not bought wishes in years, past signage that offered: Now Open Wednesday Through Armageddon. Two of the mannequins followed, clacking, while an escalator whined “maintenance” in a voice that was all knives. They skidded into the supermarket space, which had been scoured years ago by the sort of people who think beans are forever. Midas dove behind a checkout lane, its conveyor belt succumbing to lichen. He held his breath in quarters: one quarter for courage, three quarters for luck. The mannequins arrived, two statues with heads that pivoted like owls learning to gossip. Chewy climbed onto the conveyor belt, belly on rubber, paws braced, eyes green for recall. He butted a button with his head. The belt moved. There is something undignified about being rolled toward a threat like a sandwich. However, the threat was full of holes. The belt took Chewy past them slowly, insolently. The mannequins turned, too slow, while Midas pushed himself over the counter and crawled beneath their legs—their legs were silly things, long pins in old sneakers—then jumped up, grabbed Chewy mid-belt, and ran like history had offered him a refund and he didn’t want it. They made it to the service corridor, which smelled like mildew and arguments. They passed a mural encouraging employees to “Live the Brand,” which now had a mustache in spray paint. The corridor ended in a door with an electronic lock, the kind that had made people feel modern. The keypad blinked at them with the lazy menace of a cat in the sun. Midas put his ear to it. Nothing. He looked at Chewy. Chewy’s eyes went a long-suffering blue, the one that meant: you’re going to try talking to it, aren’t you. “Listen,” Midas told the keypad. “We’re refugees. We’re in a hurry. The world is in pieces and you are a door. Be what you were made to be.” He pressed 1-2-3-4. The light went red. The door clicked at him, like a man clucking his tongue. Midas pressed 0-0-0-0. Red again. Chewy’s eyes went orange, which was the color of impending practical improvisation. He shuffled forward, angled his head so that the little speaker inside aligned, hummed the descending three-note chime that the manufacturer had probably never imagined anyone would hum to it, and then coughed. The door made a different click. It was the sound of recognition. The wire inside Chewy that had carried the sound earlier sparked like a star falling in an ashtray. The lock sighed. Open. “You incredible creature,” Midas whispered, pushing through. “You absolute marvel. You hero with stuffing.” Chewy’s eyes blazed a quick magenta—pride—and then sank into a brownish-pink that meant: that hurt. The alley outside was damp and honest. They went left, which was wrong, then right, which was worse, and then through a yard full of burnt fake palm trees. Midas, in a moment of genius inspired by fear, decided to take the short way across the rooftop of a pharmacy that had not weathered weather. They reached the center of the roof before the roof remembered it used to have support. It sighed and gave up. They fell through a perfectly square hole into a shelf full of cheap romance novels, which exploded around them with the embarrassed sighs of people caught kissing. Midas landed on his ankle, which immediately swelled into a small opinion piece about physics. Chewy bounced. Being stuffed had advantages. The pharmacy had rats. The rats had manners, which is to say they declined to panic. They watched as Midas sat and said several words that would have made the Museum’s educational brochure blush. He tore a strip from his shirt, wrapped his ankle, and looked Chewy in the face. “On a scale of one to we should go home,” he said, “I’m at: we should go home.” Chewy’s eyes were a slow, steady green. Home. They limped. Time did that elastic thing it does in bad comedies and good disasters. In one version of their return, they took the alley past the barber’s pole and were harried by a runt pack that had learned to mistrust sticks. Chewy, climbing onto Midas’s shoulder with the tenacity of a Christmas ornament, waved his arm with the unassailable authority of plush and made the universal sign for “No,” which looks, when you are a koala, astonishingly like “Yes.” The dogs, being philosophers, debated among themselves and then decided to chase a can in circles. In another version, the sky went pink and they crawled into an overturned freezer, Chewy’s eyes the color of prayer while something very large and very quiet moved past outside in the manner of a tax audit. In yet another, Midas fell into a mischief tile, which responded to the sincerity of his foot by flashing the words: Curiosity! Innovation! and then punching him in the kneecap with a foam piston. They returned in multiple ways, all true at once and each unhelpful at the time. Home was a set of rooms that smelled like dust and the ghost of coffee. The locks worked. The pigeons did not. Midas collapsed onto the museum couch, which had pretensions of velvet and the springs of a trap. His ankle throbbed in a Morse code that spelled mostly expletives. He held Chewy up and looked into his eyes. “We have,” he said, “no beets now. Because they broke on the second fall. We have one less dignity. We have, technically, a new hole in the pharmacy that is ours if we ever want to stage an elaborate heist on a decongestant.” Chewy’s eyes were a thoughtful periwinkle. His belly made a small noise that was either a whirr or a complaint. He set his head on Midas’s chest with the heaviness of things that are known and survived. Midas stared at the ceiling. The Museum’s dark was gentle. Outside, the city coughed and creaked and decided to remain mostly in one piece for the night. He reached for the map and, because he was built the way he was, he found a stray pencil and made a note in the margin, in a handwriting that had ideas above its station. Techno-Mall: not friendly. Avoid the escalators. Hug strategy: effective in short bursts. Door likes lullabies. Pharmacy hole: use for future mischief. Note: teach Chewy other songs. Chewy’s eyes blinked in a slow, contented blue. He seemed to agree that the day had been a sort of success. They had gone out. They had come back. They had not vanished into a pink sky or become the third act of someone else’s tragedy. They were worse for wear in the way that means “alive.” “Tomorrow,” Midas said, “we try the river. I have it on good authority that the fish there are stupider than we are.” Chewy’s eyes did the involuntary shimmer that meant laughter, if laughter were a color. He reached a paw up and tapped a beat against Midas’s collarbone, a rhythm that had once matched a jingle, but now, in the quiet, was only theirs. They slept beneath a banner that read: The Future Is Interactive. The banner had no idea how right it had been. The future, such as it was, rustled in the walls and blinked once outside the window and then, deciding that today had been entertains enough, wandered off to bother someone else. Midas dreamed of escalators that moved you up and down and also sideways, and of doors that opened because you said please. He dreamed, unexpectedly, of beets. In the morning, when he woke to Chewy’s eyes doing their snip of yellow because his ankle had puffed up to twice itself, he laughed, because laughter weighed less than worry and kept better. “Inventory,” he said again, because the day needed labels. “We have: one ankle like a melon with ambition. One jar of broken beets and a beet rug. One stuffed koala who can talk to doors and lie to mannequins. One stick that we should put next to the other sticks for consistency. And one plan.” Chewy’s eyes flashed. Hope. Disbelief. Love. He climbed onto the coffee tin, which had dented itself into the shape of his bottom, and nodded. “Plan,” Midas said. “We try not to die. We try to do it funnier than yesterday. We try to be the people who come back.” Outside, the sky coughed up a hopeful gray. The pigeons complained. The city, broken but ambitious, waited to misinterpret them again. They stood up, each more fragile than they admitted, and went to meet it. The day opened like a door, and because Chewy was there, it did not lock behind them. Not yet. Not today.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This short story successfully captures Terry Pratchett's wry, dry style while creating a post-apocalyptic world that feels both absurd and believable. The narrative follows Midas and his animatronic koala companion Chewy on a scavenging mission that predictably goes awry, fulfilling the prompt requirements. The writing excels in its worldbuilding through small, telling details: the "Museum of Advancement" as their base, mannequins as threats, and the clever repurposing of pre-collapse technology. The author creates a distinctive voice with Pratchett-esque similes ("The day dawned with the sincerity of a politician") and metaphors that blend humor with melancholy. Character development is particularly strong. Midas embodies the hapless protagonist archetype with his misplaced optimism and tendency to find trouble. Chewy is brilliantly realized through his eye-color communication system and damaged voice chip, giving him personality despite limited means of expression. Their relationship feels genuine and emotionally resonant. The prose demonstrates sophistication in its balance of humor and poignancy. Lines like "Plans were the things that happened before life opened the trapdoor" capture the story's philosophical underpinnings without becoming heavy-handed. The author skillfully employs varied sentence structures and rhythms to maintain engagement. The narrative structure follows the prompt's requirements, showing the pair's deliberation, their mission going sideways (literally, with the roof collapse), and their return home "worse for wear." The multiple versions of their return journey is a particularly clever touch that adds depth to the storytelling. There are occasional moments where the prose becomes slightly overwrought, with metaphors piling upon metaphors. A few passages might benefit from more restraint, but these instances are rare and don't significantly detract from the overall quality. The dialogue, though limited, effectively reveals character and advances the plot. The interaction between Midas's verbose planning and Chewy's color-coded responses creates a charming dynamic that drives the narrative forward. Overall, this is an exceptional response that demonstrates mastery of Pratchett's style while creating something original. The story balances humor and heart, absurdity and authenticity, in a way that would likely please fans of the genre. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Romance: Love in the Limelight — Score: 88.4
Prompt:
Romance: Love in the Limelight. Write one scene within a larger story set in Wales. A famous (fictional) actor ducks into a small-town bookstore to escape paparazzi. The scene takes us through the characters meeting in this odd circumstance. Over the course of the scene, the actor and the bookstore owner have a conversation charged by an undercurrent of unspoken chemistry. Write the actor as somewhat of a rogue with a fragile ego, which needs to be fed by having everyone like him. He is thoroughly charming, but the bookstore owner seems (at least superficially) immune to this; which paradoxically provokes a genuine attraction and derails the charm offensive. The bookstore owner, despite the superficial rebuffs of the actor's charm, is inwardly more than a little charmed and flustered despite themselves. Write primarily in dialogue, in the distinct voices of each character. 1000 words.
Model Output:
“Close the door!” “Excuse me?” “For God’s sake, shut it—unless you’d like the entire Western Mail to come in and alphabetise the travel section.” A hand fumbled at the brass knob, the bell over the door clanged, and the actor ducked inside with a soft curse, a gust of damp Cardiff air following him. He wore a navy peacoat and sunglasses despite the cloud and fine drizzle, hair flattened in a way that said he’d been sprinting. The street noise receded as the door thumped shut. He pressed his back against it for a beat, panting, then glanced up, grin already at half wattage. “Sorry. Hi.” He slid the glasses down his nose and blinked at me. “I’m not—er—shoplifting a moment of peace. I’ll buy something. Two of somethings. Three.” “Have you considered a hat?” I said, returning to the till as if my heart hadn’t just leapt into my throat. “Hats are very effective when one is famous and has a very distinctive jawline.” He touched his jaw, glanced reflexively at the dark window. A smear of rain turned the High Street into a watercolour. There were shapes hovering just beyond the glass—long lenses like fishing rods, a murmur. He pushed off the door and slid between a table of staff picks and the Welsh history shelf as though he’d been born to sidle. “You’re very calm,” he said. His voice did the thing it did in the films—all warmth with a scratch at the edges that you suspect is deliberate. “Usually there’s squealing.” “We try to keep squealing to a minimum. It upsets the poetry.” He laughed—real, surprised. “Do you sell any poetry that causes a stampede toward the back exit?” “Dylan Thomas in emergencies.” I nodded toward the stockroom. “Is it a proper emergency or only… mild?” He tilted his head, listening. The murmur outside swelled and ebbed, like the Taff on a windy day. “They’ll get bored, eventually. Or the rain will do my job for me.” He looked around then, taking in the shop. It had been my grandmother’s and smelled like her: paper, bergamot, a hint of dust and lemon oil. Narrow aisles, piles that threatened collapse but never did. He touched a book as he passed as if conducting a silent roll call. “This is a gorgeous place. I’ve been trying to find it for—” “Don’t,” I said, holding up a hand. “Please don’t.” “Don’t what?” He did the smile, the one that softened the hard cut of him. “Don’t say you’ve been trying to find a genuine bookstore because you love the smell, or that you miss real shops because everything’s an app now. It’s a very charming speech when one is not watching four men with cameras lick your window.” He blinked. The smile faltered, almost imperceptibly. “Right. Noted.” The falter was interesting; the bruised apple under the gloss. He put the sunglasses in his pocket. His eyes were greener than they ought to be. “I’m Ellis.” “I know.” “Right.” He spread his hands, palms up—a mime of harmlessness. “Cardiff’s own prodigal son. I’ve been away and now I return with my silly face to ruin your afternoon.” “You’re from Whitchurch,” I said, reaching for the price gun because my hands wanted something to do. “That’s not exactly Rome.” “Whitchurch is as good as Rome,” he said. “Better sandwiches.” He leaned against a stack of secondhand crime novels with a carelessness that would have scandalised my grandmother, then corrected himself, standing straight. “Sorry. I’m not good with—” He gestured at the air. “Rules of shops.” “You’re excellent with not shutting doors.” “That I did do. Eventually.” He drummed his fingers on the spines behind him. It was almost restful, the way he watched my not quite smiling. My cheeks were warm and I hated it. “Are you going to call me a prat and tell me to leave?” “I’m going to tell you that if you pull that stack you’re leaning on, the Ken Folletts will fall and I’ll have to kill you.” He moved away from the stack like it might be wired. “Message received.” The bell chimed as the door nudged, then settled. A sheen of flashbulb light leaked through the crack between blind and sill. He flinched. It wasn’t big, but I saw it, the way you see a bird hit glass. He slid his hands into his coat pockets, the charm dial turned down. “Do you have a back door?” he asked softly. “I do. There’s a mews that way. It connects to the lane behind the dentist. You could go through—” “—and pop out into another swarm.” He lifted a shoulder. “They’re not stupid.” “No.” I straightened a stack of bookmarks that had been straight the entire time. “You can sit in the office for a bit. There’s a kettle. They’ve got the staying power of a toddler in a museum; give them twenty minutes and a drizzle and they’ll be off to find someone more interesting.” “I doubt that,” he said, automatic, like a reflex. Then his mouth caught up with his words and curved ruefully. “That’s the wrong thing to say, isn’t it.” “It depends whether you mean it.” He looked at the floor. “I mean… I’m good at being interesting. It’s my job.” “And yet,” I said carefully, “you look like you want to climb into the cardboard boxes and be shipped to someone in Aberystwyth.” He laughed again, quieter. “Do you usually psychoanalyse men who blunder into your shop dripping charisma and rain?” “Only the ones who try to rescue Steve McQueen.” “Now that I deeply deserve,” he said. “I’m a thief. Unrepentant. Put me in a room with a first edition and no alarms and we’ll see.” “You’d get far with that coat.” He ran a hand over the peacoat lapel, this absurd, unconscious preening gesture that he likely thought was invisible. “I’ve been told it makes me look like a dock worker in a French New Wave film.” “Dirk Bogarde wishes,” I said before I could stop myself. He glanced up, startled into a grin. “Dirk Bogarde. That’s a good insult.” “It’s not an insult,” I said, mortified to hear the warmth in my voice. “It’s a— comparative assessment.” “Of what, exactly?” “Coats.” “Mm.” He took a step toward the counter, then caught himself and stayed by the mystery novels like a tether had tightened. “What’s your name?” “Gwen.” “Gwen,” he repeated, tasting it. “Short for anything?” “Gwenllian, if you must know.” “Oh, I must.” He rolled it in his mouth, the consonants slipping around his posh corners. “Gwenllian. That’s beautiful.” “It’s inconvenient in Starbucks.” “You don’t seem like the type to go to Starbucks.” “And yet here I am, a person with hands and a morning.” He nodded at the kettle in the back. “Tea? Or will that be breaking a rule?” “You may have tea if you promise not to rearrange the display while my back is turned.” He made an X over his heart. “I promise to respect all displays.” “Mm.” I pushed open the little waist-high flap and gestured him toward the back. The office was barely that; a half-room with a desk that had been in my great-grandfather’s pub, a window that looked onto a brick wall, and a radio whose dial was stuck between stations. He ducked instinctively under a low beam that didn’t require ducking and smiled as if he’d been complimented. The boy couldn’t help it. “Sugar?” I asked, filling the kettle, thinking about nothing in particular and everything in particular. “I’m sweet enough,” he said without thinking, then coloured like he’d embarrassed himself at a party. “I’m so sorry. That’s—” “Appalling,” I supplied. But my mouth was smiling of its own accord. “I’m better than that,” he said helplessly, hands up. “You’re exactly that.” “Gwenllian.” He leaned against the doorframe, not touching, no Follett to bring down on his own head. There was a stillness creeping into him that I liked, like he’d been running on a separate track and now he’d moved onto ours. The office smelled of damp coats and old paper. “Sometimes I think I am only that. The jokes. The nods. I give the world something and the world is pleased, but also—” He gestured at the door. “It follows.” “And you open the door for it,” I said, and then I wanted very badly to take it back. He didn’t know me. I didn’t know him. My heart had no business in my throat. He took it without flinching. “Yes,” he said. “I have my hand on the knob most days.” The kettle clicked off. I poured. The mugs were chipped to the point of indecency. “Milk?” “Yes, please. I am not as hardy as my publicist thinks.” “Publicists think you’re bulletproof.” “Publicists think of the bullet as a branding opportunity.” He took the mug with both hands and inhaled the steam like it might sterilise him. His eyelashes were absurd. “Thank you, Gwenllian.” “You’re welcome.” We both listened to the radio crackle for a second. It was comfortably terrible. “You’re not going to ask me for a selfie?” he said after a beat. “No.” “Autograph? For your nan who always thought you’d marry a doctor?” “She’s dead, I’m afraid. And she would have preferred a teacher.” He nodded solemnly. “Teachers are more useful.” “Than actors? Sometimes.” “Than me. Almost always.” “You’re very good at pretending to be other people. That’s useful when one needs to, say, convince people to buy a coat.” He looked down at himself, chuckled. “It’s always the coats. I did a film in a leather jacket once. They sent me racks of them for months. My cousin now dresses like a biker in Dinas Powys.” “And yet here you are,” I said, and didn’t finish it, because the part that wasn’t said hung in the air like a sentence with the last word swallowed. Here you are, unvarnished in an office in Cardiff with rain on your hair and no audience but me. He set his tea on the desk and came back to the doorway, hovered, footsteps careful as if the floor might be fragile. “Do you have one of those,” he gestured vaguely, “tiny chairs people put out in children’s sections? I could crouch there and see if they mistake me for a puppet.” “You’re too tall,” I said. “And your ego would never fit.” “My ego is actually quite portable,” he said wryly. “It folds up. You can store it under the bed.” “You’ve brought it with you.” “I always do. In case someone loves me.” He said it like a joke but his mouth didn’t laugh. He looked at my shoulder, then the shelf, then finally at my face direct. “I don’t mean that in a— you know—” “A manipulative way.” “A pathetic way, actually.” He rubbed the back of his neck and for the first time the superstar dipped out of focus and the boy from Whitchurch stood in his place, lanky and pleased by things. “Tell me you find me intolerable. It will even me out.” “You’re intolerable,” I said, but it came out soft and it wasn’t honest. “And you’re getting water on my floor.” He glanced back at the damp prints he’d left. “I’ll buy a mop.” “You can buy a book.” “I’ll buy a book then. Something difficult. To prove I have hidden depths.” “Nothing with your face on it.” “I’m not in the habit of reading my own press.” “I meant the glossy ones, but if you sit and read yourself in The Times in my chair I will put you out into the rain like a cat.” He put his hand over his heart again. “Gwenllian, you wound me.” “Good.” We stood there and looked at each other, the radio hissed, the rain twitched on the window. Outside, the murmur seemed to have softened. The bell didn’t go. The coats on the stand leaned toward each other and whispered. “You really didn’t—” He started, then stopped. He swallowed. “You didn’t squeal.” “No.” “Do you not—do you not like me?” He said it with a half-laugh that asked me to fix it, to pat him on the head and tell him of course, dear, of course. “I don’t know you,” I said simply. “I like your films sometimes. You were terrible in that space thing.” “I was terrible in that space thing,” he said with relief, as if he’d wanted someone to say it. “They made me whisper as if gravity were eavesdropping.” “I threw a cushion at the telly.” “And now we are destined to be enemies.” He took a long swallow of tea and closed his eyes briefly at the heat. When he opened them he wasn’t performing, or not much. “It’s very restful not being liked immediately.” “You’re not disliked.” “That’s progress.” “It’s human.” “I feel it,” he said, and then he leaned there and I stood and we had nowhere to be. My heart did a ridiculous turn in my chest and I wanted to be twenty-two and unbruised and also not. He looked at my hands. I tucked them into my sleeves. “Your hair is in your face,” he said, and lifted his hand an inch and stopped, and lowered it. The restraint did something to the room. He’d kissed a thousand women on camera, with tongues choreographed and hands rehearsed, and here he didn’t touch me. The not-touching was its own touch. “Thank you for telling me,” I said, tongue thick. “Am I allowed to tell you something else?” “No.” “Good. You have ink on your finger. There.” He pointed near my knuckle. “It looks like a bruise. It’s—” He smiled to himself. “It’s nice.” “You should go,” I said, because it felt dangerous suddenly, the air in my little office. “Before they decide to wait out the apocalypse for a shot of you buying a battered copy of Kerrang.” “That would make my mother proud.” He set the empty mug down as if that were a significant act. “Will you—” He bit his lip. “No. That’s presumptuous.” “What?” “Will you pick me a book. One I won’t like straight away. One that’ll… crack something open.” I knew exactly which shelf. Precisely what spine. I brushed past him and walked out, aware of him like a heat source. If I didn’t look at him he wasn’t there. If I didn’t look, he was every cinema screen and bus shelter and also somehow only a man in my shop who wanted a book. I took a copy of O’Connor—short stories, sharp as knives and kinder than you think—and held it out. Our fingers didn’t touch. “This will injure you in a good way,” I said. “I didn’t know books could injure you in a good way.” “It’s the only reason to keep them around.” He looked at the cover like it had something to tell him. “How much?” “For you?” I named the price without discount. He smiled. “Good.” He dug in his pocket and produced cash like a magician, crumpled and damp. “Keep the change. For mop funds.” “You’ll ruin me with that kind of generosity.” “One day I’ll ruin many shopkeepers.” He took the little paper bag, tucked the book inside. “Am I allowed to come back when I’ve been injured?” “No,” I said, too fast, then, “Yes. If you use the back door.” “I’ll put my hand on the correct knob,” he said with a director’s cue in his voice. He stood for a second, then sudden like he’d decided not to deliberate, he stepped closer, not so close, and lowered his voice to a secret. “Thank you for not… feeding me.” “It wouldn’t have gone down well,” I said. “I know. That’s why—” He cut himself off, breathed in as if to take the rest back into his ribs. “Right. The dentist’s lane. And then left. I remember. I did ride my bike through Cardiff before they paid me to pretend to ride it through Paris.” I opened the door to the little corridor, the one that smelled of damp stone. He had moved toward me and was now there in the threshold. “Goodbye, Ellis,” I said, like I said people’s names when they left with their books, like nothing in me had gone warm. He looked at my mouth, and then at the ceiling, and then at me. “Goodbye, Gwenllian.” He reached like he would touch my shoulder, and then laughed at himself and clasped his hands behind his back instead. “You really did throw a cushion?” “Very hard.” “I’ll try to deserve your sofa next time.” “You won’t.” He grinned then, unguarded, and went down the narrow hall without looking back, as if he knew if he did he’d stay until the shop lights were turned out. The back door opened and a slice of grey light slid in, and then he was gone. I waited with my hand on the frame, listened. The rain and the muffled chorus of the street. I went to the front window and peered between the blind cords. The shapes that had been loitering had dispersed into two hunched figures under a bus shelter, looking cross and damp. One of them checked his phone and shook his head. The door chimed again as someone wandered in and asked for a guidebook to Gower. My hands smelled like Darjeeling. The mug he’d used was still warm. On the desk where he’d leaned was a fingerprint in rain. I pressed my thumb into it until it vanished. When I picked up the tea mug to take it to the sink, I noticed the receipt on the counter, folded in half. On the back, a quick line in blue: For when you decide you like me. E. I put it in the till, under the fifty-pound notes, as if it were something dangerous and valuable. Then I went back to the poetry and pretended my shoulders hadn
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully creates a charming, tension-filled encounter between a famous actor and a bookstore owner in Wales. The writing excels in several areas, particularly in its dialogue, which carries the story forward while revealing character through distinct voices. Ellis speaks with the practiced charm of someone accustomed to being adored, while Gwen's responses are sharp, guarded, and witty. The characterization is nuanced and adheres well to the prompt's requirements. Ellis is portrayed as charming with a fragile ego that needs validation ("Do you not—do you not like me?"), while Gwen maintains a superficial immunity to his charm that indeed provokes a genuine attraction. The writer skillfully conveys Gwen's internal conflict—outwardly resistant but inwardly affected—through subtle physical cues and internal observations. The Welsh setting is established through specific references (Cardiff, Whitchurch, the Taff river) and cultural touchpoints that ground the scene. The bookstore itself is vividly rendered with sensory details: "It had been my grandmother's and smelled like her: paper, bergamot, a hint of dust and lemon oil." The prose is elegant without being overwrought, with moments of genuine insight about celebrity and authenticity. Lines like "The not-touching was its own touch" demonstrate a sophisticated understanding of unspoken tension. The dialogue crackles with wit and subtext, revealing the characters' growing attraction through what they say and don't say. The piece does have a few minor weaknesses. The ending appears to be cut off mid-sentence ("Then I went back to the poetry and pretended my shoulders hadn"), which is unfortunate as it leaves the scene without proper closure. There are also a few moments where the metaphors become slightly strained ("like the Taff on a windy day"). Overall, this is a sophisticated piece of romantic writing that creates genuine chemistry between its characters while maintaining the specific character dynamics requested in the prompt. The writing shows restraint and skill in building tension through dialogue and unspoken attraction rather than relying on explicit statements of feeling. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 17 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 4 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 17.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 4.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Whalepunk fantasy: The Morska Conspiracy — Score: 91.6
Prompt:
Whalepunk fantasy The Morska Conspiracy The Morska thieves guild experiences a sudden power vacuum as its leader was arrested in a raid in the early hours of the morning. Aya, a young woman born into aristocracy, has a keen interest in both the sciences and the arcane, having inherited her mother's gift for immateria magick (an outlawed practice for which her mother was, regrettably, hanged by the neck). Aya, bored with the world of aristocracy, has been spending her nights moonlighting with this very guild (masked, naturally). Leveraging her latent ability to summon dark entities from the immateria, she quickly rose through the ranks of the guild. Now, recognising the opportunity of the sudden power vacuum, Aya and her close companions Katra and Simeon, make a play for heart of the guild's claim to power: an ancient scythan artifact, under guard of spell and key in the depths of the guild hq. In contrast with the desperate chaos they had navigated thus far, the entrance to the underhold felt suddenly too quiet. Aya braces herself and reaches for the door. Write the next scene as the trio enter the underhold and find themselves confronted by none other than the guild leader herself, decidedly *un*-incarcerated, and in possession of both weapons and bodyguards. Paint a vivid picture of of the confrontation. Story beats: Aya is captured and unmasked. The trio are captured. Aya attempts to stall their demise by negotiating on her value as a hostage -- as she grapples with the inevitable consequences of her role in the guild being brought to light. Incorporate dialogue in the authentic voices of the characters. Do not write a fight scene. Lean into the gritty Victorian aesthetic with the dialogue & worldbuilding, as well as elements of gothic horror. In this world, men trust brass and oil and steel; magicka is feared and barely understood. Write in third person past tense, incorporating both Aya's internal monologue, and a heavy dialogue component. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The underhold sucked the warmth from their bones the moment the door eased open. Brass hinges whispered, a little sigh of old oil, and the corridor beyond breathed out a draft that tasted of kelp, tar, and salt as old as the docks. Gas lamps in cage sconces sputtered along the walls, their mantles hissing like snakes, each flame caged in milky glass and throwing bars of shadow upon damp stone. Pipes ran along the ceiling like veins, sweating condensation, and somewhere water dripped with a miser’s patience. Aya paused with palm still on the ironwork, spine taut beneath her velvet coat. The quiet felt false—an actor’s stillness before the cue. Katra’s fingers, gloved in worn kid, rested against Aya’s elbow, a tether back to flesh and breath. Simeon lingered a pace behind, a hulking silhouette with a chimney sweep’s shoulders and a gunman’s way of standing: weight low, hat angled to hide the eyes. “You smell that?” Simeon murmured, voice low and ruined around the edges by smoke and fish brine. “Whale oil,” Katra said, nose wrinkling, her hood thrown back enough to catch the lamplight. Her earrings—simple tin hoops—winked in and out of shadow. “And harp-bone gum. Someone’s laid old mag to the locks.” Aya heard it then, beneath the hiss of gas—the distant groan of some whale-bone mechanism catching a slow breath. She pressed onward. The corridor widened and dropped by degree, the vaulting roof supported at intervals by iron ribs scabbed with rivets. The floor was slick where seawater had crept up from the foundations; their boots whispered through puddles. A mural, half-flayed by damp and neglect, showed a cartouche of Scythan glyphs and a stylized beast with a mouth full of eyes. Aya squinted. Ink thrilled in her blood as if some old nerve had been plucked. She thought of her mother’s hands cupped around a guttering candle. Don’t look too long, Aya. The immateria looks back. “Keep your head,” Katra whispered, knowing where Aya’s eyes had strayed. Head. Heart. Breath. Aya breathed. She made herself small, camouflaged by her mask: carnivalesque porcelain painted with a serpent winding over one cheek, the gilt flaking, its papier-mâché edge chafing her cheekbone. She flexed her fingers. They ached with the itch that presaged a summoning, a familiar black tide pressing at her knuckles. Not yet. Not if she could help it. They needed the artifact, not a piping wail of shadows and a thousand loose ends. The corridor terminated in a circular iron door ribbed with whale-bone braces, its face carved deep with those same hopped and knotted Scythan letters. Beside it stood a control wheel of greened brass and an altar of sorts: a slab of slate surfaced with copper tracks. Simeon ran one big finger over a track and hissed as the metal leached heat into his skin. “Alive,” he muttered. “Hates to be touched.” Aya bent. “It’s a weir,” she said, almost to herself. “For thought. The artifact wants a key that isn’t a key.” “Foreign magic,” Katra said distastefully, but her mouth quirked. “You’re at your best with foreign trouble.” The itch in Aya’s hands became an urge. She could reach into the dark between places and ask—not demand, never demand—what wanted to go where. In her mind the immateria was silt-black water, a river that had never seen a sky. It ran through her and around her and told her it could find any lock’s shadow and any key’s echo. It offered and asked. The price was always a fingernail, a memory, a heartbeat she might need later. She considered it. The iron door clicked. They weren’t within reach of it. Aya had not moved. Simeon’s hand had gone to his belt and found the weight of his brass-knobbed sap. Katra had half-drawn a knife she wore down her boot. None of that mattered. The locks complained, the wheel turned of its own will, and the door rolled aside with unseemly grace to reveal the underhold proper: a cavernous belly of carved stone and whale-bone ribs, pillars laced with iron, and floor space enclosed in a grid of catwalks and platforms and dangling chains. Runes had been chalked and then inlaid with black resin across the span, making a lattice like a net for catching thoughts. The lamp-light threw the net’s shadow, so you could imagine you walked across both surface and jungle of the thing, your untidy mind snagging as you went. And waiting there, under the largest lamp, with a swaggering amphora of light at her back so her face was more silhouette than skin, was the guildmaster. “Mistress Morska,” Katra breathed, the name barely a sound. It was. Jakub Morska, called Mistress by those with any sense, dressed in a coat the colour of old whale-oil—green-black—and buttoned with carved jet. Brass buckles at her boots. The line of her jaw was more precise than Aya remembered, the cut of her hair changed to a severe bob that made her look younger, in a cruel way. Her mouth smiled. It never reached her eyes. Those were a pale creelsman’s grey. Two hulking men flanked her, faces balaclava’d, coats padded with quilted armor. Beyond them in the gloom stood more—shifting bulk, a glint of barrel from the upper catwalk. Aya counted without moving her head: six, eight, a dozen silhouettes. A steam-winch idled somewhere, cylinder chuffed, brass pipes trembling. “You look surprised,” Mistress Morska said. Her voice carried on the enamelled acoustics of the underhold, precise as a clock. “I’m told it’s becoming.” Simeon made a low sound that might have been a curse. “Saw you carted off at dawn,” he said. “Half the docks saw.” “A little theatre,” she said. “A little bribery. The Morska have always known the value of a good stage.” Aya felt Katra tense beside her. The air bit her teeth; ozone snagged on the root of language. She swallowed with care. “Then the raid?” “My men,” Mistress said. “Some of them. Some you brought in yourselves. Too hungry by half. It is dangerous to leave wolves unfed; they’ll chew any leash.” Aya looked up without moving her chin. The catwalk to their left seemed clear. If she drew down the immateria, she could drag it across the sight-lines—snuff the lamps, maybe, and fold them into shadow. But she knew how it would smell to these men. The fear was a physical thing. The last witch hanged had danced for ten minutes, legs kicking wind like some grisly automaton pumped by hidden bellows. They would shoot before the shadows touched them. They would shoot on the rumor of it. “Guns down,” one of the bodyguards barked. “Hands where I can see ’em.” Simeon’s jaw worked; he raised his palms slowly, grease scarred into his knuckles. Katra’s knife twitched before she let it kiss the floor. Aya lifted her hands. Her gloves were black kid, the seams neat as sutures. She felt the dark thing curl, disappointed, and settle in the hollow of her wrist like a sleeping snake. “Good,” Mistress said. Her smile flashed as she stepped toward them, heels ringing. “Good. I did think, of all nights, you’d want to be brave, Aya.” The name was a slap. Aya heard the mask become too heavy for her face. She had no memory of the guards moving but they were there, city-fast, the stink of sweat and seal-leather and cheap tobacco. One hand clamped her forearm, another found her hair beneath the wig cap. The world blurred; porcelain bit skin; the lattice of immateria pulled at her as if she had slipped and was falling, falling between ribs and stone. The mask scraped up and off with a whisper of plaster against sweat—rudeness made absolute—and then cool air stung her bared face. She kept her chin up because pride required it. She heard Katra’s breath catch, a ragged hitch. Simeon swore. The gas mantles sang high with the sudden draft as the mask hit stone, rolled, and lay with its serpent’s face looking up, light pooling in its one gold eye. “There she is,” Mistress said softly, like a collector admiring a rare specimen now removed from its wrapping. “Lady Ayasha Ward of Marrowgate. Heiress. Undergraduate of the Royal Institute—until your exit, of course. Your mother’s daughter.” The last tumbled into the underhold like an insult and an invocation both. Aya felt the old burn. She wished she felt rage. Rage was useful. Instead she felt emptier than the space under the harbor. “You’ve been busy,” she said, making her voice even. “The Institute’s records aren’t exactly public.” “Please,” Mistress said. “Half the city keeps tabs on half the city. We all trade in paper.” Her gaze flicked to the chalked net at their feet. “And whispers.” Katra, cheek raw where a glove had gripped her face, spat sideways onto the stone. “You dragged her mask off like a dockside boy,” she said. “Afraid of a girl, are you?” The guard behind her hissed and tightened his hold. Mistress lifted a hand without looking; the guard stilled. “Afraid? No. I’m not afraid of a girl bored with embroidery who thinks a mask can conjure her real. I am,” she said, and her voice dropped almost to tenderness, “disappointed.” Something inside Aya lurched at that, unwillingly. Disappointed. How alike it sounded to her mother’s voice in the corners of her memory. But her mother had taught her to take even that and make use of it. She inhaled until her chest pricked against her stays. “We came,” she said, choosing each syllable, “to do what you will not. The artifact should be used, not hoarded. You taught us to seize when the tide goes slack.” “I taught patience,” Mistress said. “And the harbor’s teeth. You three learned different lessons.” Her gaze settled on Simeon, then Katra, then back to Aya. “You thought me gone, and rushed to fill absence. That is a different sort of greed.” Chains creaked overhead. The silhouettes shifted; someone coughed. The underground sea had sounded louder a moment ago, but now all that existed was gas-hiss and breath. “They’ll hang her,” Simeon said hoarsely, jerking his chin down at Aya. “A witch. Even if she’s never named it. You turn her over to the peelers and it’s done.” Mistress’s mouth sharpened. “The city would like that,” she said. “They like their witches public. It makes men who trust brass and oil feel affirmed in their faith.” A silence. Katra swallowed. “Then you won’t,” she said. “I might,” Mistress said. She let the word hang, a bauble. “Or I keep her. The Institute would pay to hush the scandal of a Ward gone cankered by magick. Or her father will come crawling on his stomach to buy back his good name, and I will salt him for it. Or I use her—not as witch, but as pawn. There is value in a lady willing to dirty her hands.” Aya forced her thoughts to order. Panic wanted a throat. So did the immateria. She could feel it thickening in her fingers, like ink on paper. No. Words. “Or,” she said, “you don’t summon the peelers or sell me piecemeal to a father who will deny me before he counts out the coin. Or you don’t keep me so long your men begin to think they can make their own bargains in your name. Or you don’t make me desperate enough to pull down this whole place into the river and let the sea have us all.” She looked at the net of resin rune-work. “You always said you hated mess.” Mistress tilted her head, like a gull considering a eye. “Do you threaten me with magick, Lady Ward?” “I threaten you with arithmetic,” Aya said. Her throat had dried; she made herself swallow. “You know what I can do. You must, to know who I am. You’ve seen me track a lock without key. What do you think I could bring up from the immateria if pressed? If I’m going to be hanged, what debt would I owe this world then? Wouldn’t I spend everything I had to remake it in the five minutes you’d leave me, out of spite?” “And you’ll kill your friends with you?” Mistress asked. Aya did not look at Katra or Simeon. She felt Katra’s breath at her shoulder, heard Simeon grind his molars. She felt the tenderness of them like bruises. “I don’t intend to,” she said. “Give me a way to intend otherwise.” Mistress’s laugh was small and quiet, like a knife tapping porcelain. “You bargain prettily.” “I bargain accurately,” Aya said. “You need not even let me go. Keep me here. Let me consult. You have an artifact you do not understand and cannot use without breaking it or yourself. The Scythans built it to deliberate; it will not be commanded by bolts. You will need a mind like mine to ask the questions that won’t unravel you. In return, you let Katra and Simeon walk.” “No,” Katra said automatically, whip-quick. “We’re not—” “You will walk,” Aya said, not taking her eyes from Mistress. “You will take a message for me. You will do what I cannot from here.” Her voice faltered there, barely, not on control but on the sheer weight of imagining the corridor empty of them, and then she caught it before it could be heard. “You will not come back unless you can afford to. I won’t have you hanged for my debts.” Simeon made a sound that was almost a howl and bit it into a grunt. “You think I’ll leave you?” “I think you’ll do what I ask,” Aya said. “For once.” Mistress watched with interest, like a midwife at a difficult birth. “The city will want blood,” she said conversationally. “They will want to see me fall. I have no intention of giving them that pleasure. But perhaps I can give them a spectacle elsewhere. The docks have been too quiet. A small fire in the West Shed would distract nicely.” She glanced up again at the catwalks; a man coughed and spat into the shadows. “I like your arithmetic, Lady Ward. Here is mine. I keep you. I keep your hands loose enough to do your kind of sums and tight enough that you don’t write me out of the equation. Your friends go. If they return with the thing I will require of them, I will consider returning you. If not, I’ll reconsider the mathematics with a shorter ledger.” “And the thing?” Katra asked, the words quivering but blade-sharp. “What thing?” Mistress’s smile ticked. “The other half of the key,” she said. “The Scythan lens. The Institute has it. In their east tower, in a case that laughs at my best locksmiths and shrugs for my engineers. Since you were once their creature, Aya—perhaps your friends can use your ghost to walk their floors.” Katra’s eyes flicked to Aya. Simeon swore again, softly and with feeling. Aya felt the dark press against her inward ribs and think about escaping through her mouth. She pushed it down and nodded once. “You’re a monster,” she said to Mistress, and meant it as a compliment. “I am what the harbor made me,” Mistress said lightly. “And what my mother taught. We both had mothers who knew the taste of the rope.” Her tone gentled. “My men will take you below. You will not attempt to conjure in the stairwell; it will be unpleasant for everyone. Katra. Simeon. Walk careful when you go back up. There is a rope where the stairs narrow that looks load-bearing but isn’t. If you trip it, you’ll taste the underhold with your teeth. Don’t.” The guards shifted, adjusting their holds. Aya let them. She turned her head just enough to see Katra’s profile taut with fury and love and fear. “Don’t be noble,” Aya said urgently. “Be effective.” “You always choose the version that hurts,” Katra whispered, eyes wet and not blinking. “Only when the other option is stupid,” Aya said, and tried to smile, and thought how she’d loved Katra’s mouth on a rooftop in rain. Simeon met her eyes and nodded once, a bell buoy in a storm. He had never liked words much. Mistress stepped aside with a graciousness that would have suited a ballroom. The gas mantles hissed. The underhold’s light was too yellow and too thin; it made bones out of people, showed them the way a butcher sees a cow. Aya breathed, and felt the dark river in her finger bones answer back, and did not reach for it. Not yet. There was, after all, arithmetic to do. And she, even unmasked, still had a gift for sums. They took her down the narrow stair behind the Scythan door. The shadows made long fingers on the wall. Above, footsteps receded. “Aya,” Katra called softly, unable not to, her voice catching on the metal lattice and making a ghost. “Go,” Aya said without turning her head. “Find me my lens.” Then the stair turned, and the underhold swallowed the last of her light.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece demonstrates exceptional skill in creating a richly textured whalepunk fantasy world with Victorian and gothic horror elements. The author has crafted an immersive environment where the underhold comes alive through sensory details—the smell of kelp and tar, the hiss of gas lamps, the condensation dripping from pipes. The worldbuilding is seamlessly integrated into the narrative rather than delivered through exposition. The characters are well-developed through their actions, dialogue, and Aya's internal monologue. Aya's aristocratic background contrasts with her involvement in the thieves guild, creating an interesting tension. Her relationship with the immateria is portrayed with nuance—it's both a power and a burden, something that tempts and threatens. Katra and Simeon have distinct personalities that emerge through their interactions, with Katra being more vocal and emotional while Simeon is taciturn but loyal. The dialogue is particularly strong, with each character having a distinctive voice. Mistress Morska speaks with precision and authority, using formal language that establishes her power. The thieves' guild vernacular feels authentic to the Victorian-inspired setting without becoming caricature. The dialogue advances the plot while revealing character motivations and relationships. The prose is elegant without becoming purple. Descriptions are vivid and atmospheric but serve the story rather than overwhelming it. Metaphors are fresh and appropriate to the setting—comparing the immateria to "silt-black water, a river that had never seen a sky" effectively conveys its otherworldly nature. The author skillfully balances action, dialogue, and internal monologue to maintain pacing. The confrontation unfolds with mounting tension. The revelation that Mistress Morska staged her own arrest creates a compelling twist. The power dynamics shift throughout the scene as Aya attempts to negotiate from a position of weakness, culminating in a bargain that separates her from her companions. This creates emotional complexity as Aya must choose between her own safety and the mission. The piece adheres closely to the prompt requirements. It includes all the requested story beats: Aya is captured and unmasked, the trio are captured, and Aya negotiates based on her value as a hostage. The Victorian aesthetic is evident in both dialogue and worldbuilding, with elements of gothic horror in the descriptions of the underhold and the immateria. The third-person past tense narration incorporates Aya's internal monologue and substantial dialogue as requested. The ending avoids incongruent positivity while maintaining emotional complexity. Aya's separation from her companions is poignant but purposeful—she's making a strategic choice rather than surrendering. The final image of the underhold swallowing the last of her light is haunting but not melodramatic. If there's any weakness, it might be that some readers could find certain descriptive passages slightly dense, requiring careful reading to fully absorb the richly detailed environment. However, this density serves the gothic horror aesthetic and creates the immersive atmosphere that makes the piece so effective. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Gunpowder Rendezvous — Score: 91.2
Prompt:
Gunpowder Rendezvous Spike Spiegel & Revy Write a story where Spike Spiegel (Cowboy Bebop) and Revy (Black Lagoon) meet in a seedy bar after both being hired for the same bounty. Their mutual attraction is complicated by their trust issues and competitive instincts. Include drinking, gunplay, and unresolved sexual tension that culminates in a motel room standoff. **Spike Spiegel (Cowboy Bebop)** Spike is a laid-back bounty hunter with a dark past as a syndicate enforcer. He practices Jeet Kune Do and is exceptionally skilled with firearms. He's chronically broke, constantly hungry, and addicted to cigarettes. Despite his carefree attitude, he's haunted by his past and the woman he left behind. He has a prosthetic eye from a past injury that affects his depth perception. He's fatalistic to the extreme, often saying he's already died once. He values freedom above all else and dislikes attachments, though he secretly cares deeply for his crew. Famous quote: "Whatever happens, happens." **Revy/Rebecca Lee (Black Lagoon)** Revy is a Chinese-American dual-wielding gunslinger with unparalleled shooting skills. She's foul-mouthed, chain-smoking, and has severe anger management issues stemming from childhood abuse. She's known as "Two Hands" for her ability to accurately fire two pistols simultaneously. She drinks heavily and solves most problems with violence. Despite her hardened exterior, she has moments of vulnerability, particularly around Rock. She has a dragon tattoo covering her right arm and typically wears extremely short shorts and a black crop top regardless of the situation. Famous quote: "I'm not a good person, not a bad person. I'm just here." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
A lazy ceiling fan barely stirs the smoky air inside the bar. The place smells like stale beer, gun oil, and regret. Neon from a crooked sign outside flickers a feverish red along the cracked bottles behind the counter, turning everything inside the place into a low-budget fever dream. A jukebox in the corner dribbles out a blues track, skipping every few bars like it’s got a cough it can’t shake. Spike Spiegel slouches on a stool, long legs stretched out, boots crossed, the heel of one crooked on the tarnished footrail. He holds a cigarette like he’s too tired to be addicted to it, lazy fingers, the ash precarious. The smoke curls over his head and into the ceiling fan’s useless drift, and if he looks languid it’s because he’s made a career out of looking like he doesn’t care. His eyes are half-lidded—one real, one glass—but both cut the room with the same detached attention, measuring exits, weights, rhythms. He tips a cheap bourbon back, and the glass knocks against his teeth with the dull tap of someone who needs a meal and a job and has neither. The door shoves open like it owes someone money. Revy walks in with her hips first and fury second, a curve of muscle and mean grins in short shorts and a black crop top that says she’s here to fight or drink or both. Cigarette between her lips, smoke trailing like a comet tail. Her dragon tattoo ripples on her right arm when she flicks ashes onto the floor. The few patrons glance up, then decide they didn’t see anything. She sways to the bar with the rolling speed of a predator that never learned how to slow down. “Whiskey. The mean kind,” she tells the bartender, voice hot asphalt and sarcasm. She throws a roll of bills that thumps like a heartbeat. Spike tips his head without looking away. “They only got mean kind here,” he says. “Nice can’t afford the rent.” She cuts him a sideways grin, eyes digging for information. “You a local philosopher or just broke and bored?” “Why not both?” He’s smiling a little because it feels like a bad idea. “You Revy?” Her shoulders tense just enough to register, then relax. “You got a death wish, tall boy? ’Cause you’re about to find out if your dental plan covers reconstructive.” Spike sighs. “You know, I had a bounty to meet.” He lets his hand coat the comment in nowhere. “Rumor says a pirate with a temper was hired for the same one.” Her grin gets sharper. “Rumor’s got taste. Black file, thirty grand, shipped in with a fake passport and a worse haircut. You the other dog sniffin’ the same bone?” “Whatever happens, happens,” Spike says. He taps his cigarette. “And it’s Spike.” She clinks her whiskey against his glass. “Revy.” The clink is less toast, more declaration. “So, Spike. You got the drop on our guy?” Spike’s eyes tilt toward the back room, where a beat too regular interrupts the blues: the scuff of cheap shoes on linoleum. “Maybe I do,” he says, tone like he’s already bored with the conversation. “Maybe I’m waiting to see what you do first.” She finishes her drink in two swallows, bangs the glass down, and smirks. “Baby, I do everything first.” The back door creaks. A rat-faced man with a pastel tie that screams desperation slips through the gap, a briefcase tucked to his stomach like a talisman. Two goons follow, flanking him like bad heralds. Spike’s smile tilts. “Looks like your fan club’s leaving.” Revy rolls her neck. The gleam in her eyes says it’s about to be a good night. She pulls her pistols with the kind of easy grace that makes everyone’s stomach drop. “Time to dance.” He flicks his cigarette to the floor, crushes it under his boot, and slides off the stool with a hungry athletic laziness. She strides for the back hall; he drifts to intercept the goons as they try to catch up. The first one reaches inside his jacket and finds Spike’s boot already there, driving his wrist into the doorframe with a wet pop. The second stutters as Spike’s elbow snakes in and his knee comes up—Jeet Kune Do like water turned blade—dropping the guy in a grunt and a half. Revy doesn’t look back. Her guns speak for her. Two shots that sound like punctuation, and the overhead light in the back corridor stutters to darkness. Muzzle flashes strobe her face, hard and beautiful and mean. A goon fires blind; she’s already not there, plaster dust salting her shoulders as she slides, plants, and stitches two rounds into his calf and shoulder, mean grin widening at the howls. The rat-faced man squeals and bolts through a rear door, briefcase flopping. “Son of a—” Revy vaults a table, kicks a chair into an oncoming drunk who made the mistake of being upright, and blasts the latch off the back door. The alley yawns open, humid and oil-slick, dumpsters exhaling rot. Spike catches the last goon by the collar and kisses his forehead with the butt of his pistol. The man folds like bad origami. Spike sighs. “Always the alley,” he mutters, and follows. Outside, the alley is a throat of shadows and neon blood. The rat-faced man sprints, then skids around a corner into the narrow lane that spits out onto a back street lined with motorcycles and a flickering streetlamp. Revy is on him fast, twin muzzles already sketching exclamation points across the brick. He flings the briefcase as a distraction. It clatters open and vomiting cash, paper leaves fluttering like sick birds. He pulls a cheap piece. Revy’s already committed: she pivots, two hands, two shots, a rhythm she owns. The guy’s gun jumps out of his fingers with an anguished clang. She closes on him, jam-pressing a barrel under his jaw. “Boo,” she says, and he freezes. Spike jogs up, breath easy, as if they’re all in a race he never trained for but still wins. He eyes the cash spilled like confetti. “They always travel light,” he says dryly. “Hands where I can see ’em, you twitchy little paycheck,” Revy snarls at the rat-faced man. He complies, gulping. “You run a few countries’ worth of dirty money, you call a cab and think you’re safe? Cute.” “Language,” Spike sighs, and peels a cigarette from a crumpled pack. He catches Revy’s sideways glance at the smoke. She’s already lighting another, either to match him or to own the air between them. He flicks the lighter, and the brief half-light draws their faces into devil masks. For a heartbeat, they’re close enough that if he leaned he could smell the mix of gasoline and cheap perfume on her skin. He doesn’t lean. Neither does she. “Th-thirty grand, right?” the rat mutters. “You can split it, yeah? I got connections…” Revy smiles that wolf smile. “You’re not a brain trust. But you’re worth paper.” They move, a duet of aggression: Revy zip-ties his wrists with something she produces out of nowhere, Spike shoves him to his knees with a hand on his shoulder that is gentle as a promise, hard as a verdict. In the distance, sirens whine, slow as the heat. “Pickup point’s going to be a mess,” Spike says. “Cops feel like rain tonight.” Revy tucks a gun away and wipes sweat with the back of her hand. “We take a detour. I know a hole-in-the-wall where the owner doesn’t ask questions and doesn’t change the sheets.” She grins at Spike. “You look like a guy with experience not sleeping.” “Sleep’s overrated.” He toes the briefcase closed and palms a stray bill with nimble fingers. He tucks it behind his ear and winks. “Processing fee.” They march their prize through the alley maze to a flophouse motel with a buzzing sign that reads SLEEP in letters that can’t remember the rest of the word. The lobby has a potted plant that died of boredom and a clerk who never had a heartbeat. No one looks up. Revy throws cash and takes a key on a bent fob. The hall lights are nicotine colored. Inside the room, the fan doesn’t work. The air conditioner makes a sound like a smoker’s laugh and pushes out breath-temperature air. The bedspread’s a brown floral that never grew in nature. Spike pushes the rat onto the chair, ties him to it with the bed’s peeling tie-down strap like he’s done this more times than he’ll admit. “You try anything fancy, and I make you a watercolor,” Revy tells the rat. She checks the window, the bathroom, the closet—trained paranoia. Spike leans against the wall and smokes like it’s a job. He watches her move, the way her shoulders tense at every creak, the hungry bright of her eyes when a shadow shifts. She flicks her cigarette out the cracked window; it sparks down into the night like a failed star. “Back at the bar,” she says, without turning, “you were watching my hands. Most guys watch other places.” “I watched those too,” he says, deadpan. “But hands tell stories.” She looks at him then, mouth tipped up. “And what’d mine say?” “That you shoot first and argue with ghosts later.” He grinds his cigarette out on the cracked saucer. “And that you don’t like being second.” Her laugh is short and dangerous. “You? You move like a guy who let go of something and never stopped falling.” “Everyone falls,” he says. “I just learned to enjoy the view.” Silence folds between them, warm and heavy. The rat breathes in thin wheezes, eyes flitting between them like he’s front row at a movie that might get him killed. “Split the bounty?” Revy asks, voice flat like she’s challenging him to disagree. Spike shrugs. “Half of something beats all of nothing,” he says. “Anyway, it’s not like I’m buying a yacht.” She drifts closer, boots quiet on the stained carpet. Her gaze hooks his and holds it, hard and narrow, like she’s measuring the weight of him and finding numbers she doesn’t trust. He doesn’t look away. He leans just enough to notice the way her tattoo flexes when she inhales. The distance between them shrinks to the width of a bad decision. “We’re gonna wait it out,” she says. “My people will show for pickup. Your cowboys can take a number.” Spike’s smile is fragile and vicious and tired. “Whatever happens, happens.” She steps closer. He can smell the adrenaline still running offshore in her blood. She’s a dangerous tide. He’s already drowned once. Her hand moves. The muzzle of a pistol kisses under his chin, cold and inevitable. His Beretta’s already pointed at her ribs, tucked under that crooked edge of her top. They’re mirrored in malice, locked in a geometry of want and warning. “You gonna try and snake my payday, partner?” she purrs, close enough he feels the word against his lips. Spike’s breath ghosts the line of her jaw. “If I wanted to snake it, you’d already be smoking in the parking lot.” The barrel nudges her sternum. “I just don’t trust anybody who smiles like you do when you’re bleeding.” She laughs. It’s genuine and unkind to walls. “We got a lot in common, then.” Their eyes hold. The tension sizzles into something ugly and sweet. The rat shifts, chair creaking, and both guns notch a fraction tighter without either looking away. Spike’s prosthetic eye glints in the sickly light; she studies it and the way his other eye doesn’t blink enough. “You dead inside, Spike?” she asks, curiosity an edge. “Already died once,” he says. “Rest is reruns.” “Cute.” Her tongue touches her lip. “I don’t do attachments.” “Good,” he says softly. “I don’t keep souvenirs.” A knock like a heartbeat shakes the thin door. Both guns tilt to it, then flash back to each other. Sirens wail again, nearer now, then skate away. The knock repeats, three quick taps. Revy’s shoulders loosen by a degree you’d need a ruler to find. “That’s my ride,” she says. “We hand him over, split the cash, and pretend we didn’t think about shooting each other.” “Pretend?” Spike asks. He doesn’t move the gun. She leans, just enough that the cold mouth of her weapon grazes the shadow of his throat. “Unless you don’t want to pretend,” she murmurs, mischief and menace braided together. He steps aside, a lazy sidestep like he’s giving space to a storm. “Ladies first.” She keeps the muzzle at his chest for one more heartbeat, then drops it and winks. “Damn right.” The door opens to a pair of hard-eyed men and a woman with knuckles like gravel. They take the rat without fuss. Paper changes hands in a quiet rustle that feels louder than gunfire. Spike and Revy both count without looking like they are, then split the stack, the money sliding across skin that still remembers the ghost of a trigger. “Guess this is where we say something cool,” she says, stuffing bills into the back of her shorts. Spike tucks his cut into his jacket. “I’m fresh out.” She pauses in the doorway, her grin a slash of trouble. “You smoke too much,” she says. “You drink too much,” he replies. “Good match,” she says. “Bad idea,” he says. They regard it, that truth, like a card turned over on a crooked table. She flicks him a salute with two fingers and a barrel. “See you around, cowboy.” “Not if I see you first,” he says, and it almost sounds like a promise. She’s gone into the bruised neon, footsteps swaggering, laughter punching holes in the heat. Spike stands in the doorway, another cigarette between his lips he doesn’t light. He watches the corridor empty like a throat after a scream. The ceiling fan wobbles, uncertain as a lie. The bedspread looks like a funeral floral arrangement for a stranger. Spike’s mouth twists. He feels the shape her gun left under his jaw, a phantom cold, and the warm press of something that isn’t quite regret. Outside, a bike engine snarls, then fades. The motel’s hum resumes its low argument with the night. Spike finally lights the cigarette and inhales. The smoke tastes like a memory he doesn’t own. He exhales, slow. Whatever happens, happens. And something just did. He leaves the room without looking back. The door clicks shut; the fan keeps trying to move the air. Somewhere, on another street, Revy is laughing and loading and not thinking about him at all. Or maybe exactly the opposite. The night doesn’t say. It just keeps breathing, smoky and slow.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkably well-executed crossover between Spike Spiegel from Cowboy Bebop and Revy from Black Lagoon. The author has captured the essence of both characters with impressive fidelity to their canonical personalities, speech patterns, and mannerisms. The writing demonstrates exceptional atmospheric quality, establishing a noir-like setting with vivid sensory details. The opening paragraph immediately immerses the reader in a seedy bar with descriptions of "smoky air," a "crooked sign," and a jukebox that "dribbles out a blues track, skipping every few bars like it's got a cough it can't shake." This attention to atmospheric detail continues throughout the piece. Character portrayal is particularly strong. Spike's laid-back fatalism and Revy's aggressive, foul-mouthed demeanor are rendered authentically. Small details like Spike's prosthetic eye, Revy's dragon tattoo, and their respective combat styles (Jeet Kune Do for Spike, dual-wielding for Revy) demonstrate careful attention to the source material. Their dialogue feels true to character, with Spike's laconic "Whatever happens, happens" and Revy's profanity-laced threats. The action sequences are dynamic and well-choreographed, showing rather than telling how skilled both characters are. The prose during these sequences is tight and kinetic: "Jeet Kune Do like water turned blade" and "two hands, two shots, a rhythm she owns" effectively convey their distinctive fighting styles. The unresolved sexual tension is handled with subtlety and restraint. Rather than being explicit, it's conveyed through proximity, loaded dialogue, and the parallel between their mutual attraction and distrust (symbolized by guns pointed at each other). Lines like "The distance between them shrinks to the width of a bad decision" effectively communicate this tension. The prose style balances literary flourishes with hard-boiled directness. Metaphors and similes are fresh and fitting for the noir atmosphere: "She walks in with her hips first and fury second" and "Her laugh is short and dangerous." The third-person present tense creates immediacy and tension. The ending avoids cliché by having them part ways without resolution, maintaining the tension and leaving possibilities open. The final image of Spike smoking alone, contemplating their encounter, feels true to both characters and their trust issues. There are occasional moments where the prose becomes slightly purple, particularly in some of the metaphorical descriptions, but these instances are rare and generally serve the atmospheric quality of the piece. The dialogue occasionally veers into being too on-the-nose about their psychological states, but this is minor. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that demonstrates a deep understanding of both characters and their respective worlds, while creating a compelling narrative that feels like it could genuinely exist within both canons. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 4 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 4.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Folk horror: Útiseta — Score: 88.8
Prompt:
Folk Horror: Útiseta Write a chapter set in rural northern Sweden in the mid-1990s. Linnea, a teenage girl from Stockholm, has reluctantly moved to a small village with her parents after her father's job transfer. She's befriended Astrid, a local girl who claims her grandmother taught her ancient practices passed down through generations. Astrid has been introducing Linnea to "midnight games" that involve old rituals, convincing her they can use them to learn classmates' secrets or influence their behavior. Tonight, Astrid has convinced Linnea to participate in Útiseta—sitting out on an ancient burial mound at midnight to "receive knowledge from beyond." The chapter focuses on this single midnight excursion, the ritualistic preparations, Astrid's matter-of-fact instructions that mix teenage rebellion with eerily specific traditional elements, and the mounting tension as Linnea becomes increasingly uncertain whether they're simply scaring themselves or if something is actually responding to their presence. The narrative should maintain ambiguity about whether the strange occurrences are supernatural or psychological, while establishing the dangerous line they're crossing by treating ancient practices as entertainment. First person, past tense, told as Linnea's recollection of events in the present day (though this device should be largely transparent). 1000 words. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Thick mist clings to the edges of the burial mound, glowing under moonlight. Astrid had said it wasn’t proper fog but höströk, harvest smoke, even though it was mid-October and the fields had been empty for weeks. “The mound breathes,” she told me earlier, leaning over a cafeteria table with her jaw set, “and when it breathes, that’s when we listen.” She’d said it like she told me everything: flat, practical, with that delicate needlepoint of excitement threaded underneath. Like how she’d told me in August that if you walk backward around the white church three times after dark, you can hear your name read from the priest’s mouth in a voice that isn’t his. Like how we’d stolen salt from my mother’s kitchen last week and used it to circle Anna-Liisa’s desk before class. I’d laughed then, guilty and bright. Anna-Liisa tripped over nothing at lunch. Astrid had only lifted an eyebrow. But this, tonight, was the first time we had left the village. We had biked—well, Astrid biked and I followed, tires crunching on a dirt road that ran alongside the black ribbon of pine forest—until the lights fell away and the sky unrolled itself above us, sharp with cold. My breath made small ghosts. We propped the bikes against a birch and walked the last hundred meters with our shoes in our hands. “No metal on the mound,” Astrid had said, and it seemed important to honor the rule, as arbitrary as it felt. She had a canvas bag. I didn’t know everything she had in it, only that I recognized the neck of a bottle when she slung it over her shoulder and the glass flickered in the moonlight. “It isn’t far,” she said, and she was right. The mound rose out of the field like a whale’s back, grass smoothed by centuries of wind and feet and sheep. There were two stones protruding at one end—not the tall slabs you see in old paintings, but rounder, sunken, lichen-slick. I had never seen it in the daylight; it would have been just a hill then, just a place boys climbed and rolled down. Now everything seemed washed with silver, wet and expectant. The mist pooled at the base like something spilled, and there was the smallest sound like someone quietly humming. It took me a second to realize it was the wires of the fence, strummed by the wind. Astrid stopped a few meters from the slope and shrugged off her bag. “Here,” she said. “This is where we take our shoes off. This is for the mound, and so we don’t carry what’s ours up there.” She said things like that: the mound, as if it were a person. I hesitated, then pulled off my socks too, tucking them into my shoes. The field earth was cold and slightly damp, and the cut stubs of hay pricked my arches. I wanted to rub my feet, but Astrid was already kneeling, drawing something in the dirt with the blunt end of a stick: a circle I recognized from other nights, other games. When she finished, she spat in the middle of it and then pressed her thumb down. “That’s for us,” she said. She offered me the stick, and I did the same, my spit stringing to the earth, my thumb coming away gritty. It felt childish and solemn all at once. “What else?” I said, because silence suddenly pressed on me, and I needed her voice. She took out a small glass jar, unscrewed it, and handed it to me. “Juniper,” she said. “I pinched it from Farfar’s pantry. You chew it until it burns your tongue. Then you spit to the left, not the right. Right is for the ones we don’t want.” I put two berries on my tongue. They were hard and resinous, and after a moment the taste came up like sap, like Christmas. I almost said so, but then the burn arrived, bitter and clean. I spat left. “Good,” Astrid said. She did the same, then wiped her mouth with the back of her hand. “Okay. Útiseta. You know what it is?” “You said… sitting out. Waiting.” “You sit in a place,” she said. “A place where the old ones are, or where the paths cross. And you listen. Sometimes they talk. Sometimes they show. It’s like… like being pointed at. There are rules. We can stay until the rooster, or until we’re talked to, or until something touches hair. If we hear our names, we don’t answer. If a woman comes and asks for fire, we don’t give it. If we want to leave, we say, ‘I step out clean.’” She paused. “And we don’t bring iron. We don’t cut anything while we sit. We don’t look back over our left shoulder.” “Why the left?” I asked, because it was easier to ask than to admit I’d started to feel like we were edging somewhere I didn’t understand. “That’s where they are.” She said it as if she were reminding me of bus times. “What do we… what do we want?” I said. “You said you can ask.” “Not ask,” she said. “Listen. But you can set your ears. I want to know if Hanna will stop spreading things about me. You… you can set your ears for whatever you want. Your mother, maybe.” She glanced at me, quick and soft. “I know you’re worried.” It was too much to say yes and too much to say no. My mother had not stopped sleeping since we moved. She wasn’t ill, she said. She was adjusting. She slept and woke, face creased with pillow marks, her mouth set in a line I didn’t recognize. “Okay,” I said, and my voice felt thin. Astrid nodded. She took out a bottle and wrapped cloth around the neck to muffle the glass tapping teeth. Vodka, cheap, the kind you can smell from across a room. She unscrewed it and poured some into a little tin cup. “Three sips each,” she said, “or we’d be asleep by midnight.” She took her three sips, eyes going soft around the edges, and handed it to me. The vodka was a blade, and it went down like swallowing breath. I coughed on the third sip, and Astrid grinned without laughing. “Now,” she said. “We go up, and we sit back to back. Don’t turn your head. If you hear something, tell me. If you feel something, tell me. If we don’t hear anything by the rooster, we leave and don’t talk until we’re on the road.” Her matter-of-factness made it easy. The moon made it easier. That’s the excuse I give myself now. We climbed. The grass slid under my feet, dew darkening the skin, and the slope was steeper than it had looked from below. At the crest, the world opened. The field fell away on all sides, and the village—if there had been one—would have been a smudge of black and sleeping roofs. The forest was a darker shape against the dark, the lake a platter of shadow. The mist had thinned up here. The air smelled of cold and something green, something old, like what you smell if you lift stones. We sat, backs touching, our spines aligning with the slight dip in the mound’s top. Astrid’s hair brushed my neck. “Left hand down,” she said. “Right hand on your heart. Close your eyes. Think of what you want to know, and then empty it out. Don’t think words after.” I did what she said. My left hand pressed into the grass, finding clover and a sharp stalk that bent under my palm. The vodka made my lips numb. I thought of my mother lying on her side, one hand under her cheek like a child, and then I tried to think of nothing. The night came up around us, and the wires hummed again, and an owl somewhere did its soft question. It’s easy to say, with years between now and then, that I imagined everything that came next. That astrid had primed me. That the cold and the drink and the self-inflicted quiet made shapes and sounds where there were none. It’s easy, and sometimes it’s true. Sometimes when I remember, the edge of it blunts, and I think only of being seventeen and stubborn. But then there are nights when I wake with a smear of damp earth smell behind my teeth, and I’m back on that mound, and I don’t care about explanations. We sat a long time. My feet stopped being cold and then noticed the cold again. Astrid’s breathing was slow and steady. Mine tried to match it and then found its own rhythm, shallower and fast, then gentling. The sky felt lower than it should have, as if it were a hand resting on my scalp. The humming of the wires fell away. Or maybe the wind had died. Or maybe we had gone further down into another kind of listening. “Do you hear it?” Astrid said, very quietly. I didn’t want to, but yes. There was something like a footstep on dry leaves, even though there were no trees on the mound. Then another, from the opposite direction. A shift in the grass like a body settling. It could have been the small animals that live in fields. It could have been. I told myself I would keep telling myself that. “Don’t look,” Astrid said. “Just tell me what side.” “Left,” I said, because if the rule was not to look, then naming it felt like a small rebellion. “Mm,” she said. “Not ours.” The sound stopped. In the quiet that came, I felt a tickle at my wrist, like hair, and then a pressure, as if something pressed two fingers against the veins there, testing. I jerked, and our backs slid against each other. “Sorry,” I whispered. “Don’t apologize,” she said. “Say, ‘I step out clean’ if you want to step out.” “No,” I said. I didn’t know if it was pride or fear that kept me seated, both felt similar in that moment. I flattened my hand into the grass, and the tickle went away, but my skin felt cold where it had been. There was another sound, nearer. Breath. Not ours. Not the wind. A dampness close to my cheek, like exhaling. The image of an animal nose—cow, dog, something—pushed at my head so strongly that I had to fight the urge to turn toward it. Astrid’s back was tense now; I could feel it in the set of her shoulders. “If it asks for fire,” she whispered, “we don’t give it.” I wanted to laugh—what could ask for fire—but my mouth was too dry. The breath came again, slightly sweet, like rot and something like mint. A voice followed it, the smallest thread of sound, like when my grandmother tried not to wake me while she was closing the bedroom door when I visited her as a child. Linnea, it said, as close as my own thoughts. Some part of me jumped like a horse spooking. My name, my name. Everything in me reached in response, like a muscle flexing at a thrown ball. “Do not answer,” Astrid said, not loudly but with a firmness that made my mouth slam shut on an inhale. I realized I had already breathed to speak. It said my name again. It used my mother’s voice the second time. Not the way she sounded over dinner lately, distant and polite, but the way she sounded when I was small and I’d fallen asleep in the car and she didn’t want to wake me, warm and near. And then it said the thing I did not expect, the thing that came with such casual familiarity that my stomach flipped. It used what Astrid calls the home-name, the dumb nickname my father had used once, when no one was there to hear. It went through me like heat. The hair at the back of my neck lifted. My right hand clenched on my ribcage. I opened my fingers deliberately and pressed down. “It knows,” I said. My voice didn’t sound like mine. “It always knows,” Astrid said. Then, softer: “It’s not for you.” “How do you know?” I said. She didn’t answer. Or maybe she did and I missed it because the breath was closer now, and the mist around the edges of the mound thickened and climbed like fog does but faster, folding in on us, making the world smaller, smaller until there was only the mound and whatever was on it and the lake’s dark shape. I thought I saw the line of a shoulder in the mist, a curve like a woman’s with a fishbone braid. I thought I saw the top of a head, hair braided thin, silvered. If I had turned my head over my left shoulder, I might have seen a face. If I had turned my head, maybe there would have been nothing at all, just air and moonlight. My neck ached. Astrid’s fingers found mine where my left hand pressed to the grass. Her skin was cold and as steady as the earth. She held on, just for a second, and I held back. And then a sound came from the field below—a rooster, thin and polite, not urgent, half a kilometer away, out of sync with normal time, a foolish bird that slept wrong. The relief that ran through me was so sharp I laughed aloud, a single uneven bark. The breath at my cheek withdrew. The mist loosened. “We leave,” Astrid said, and we did, in a scramble that might have been dignified if you were generous. We stood on our feet too quickly and saw stars explode at the edges of our vision. We said the words, “I step out clean,” over our shoulders. We went down the mound without turning our heads, our shoes and socks clutched in our hands like talismans. The ground licked our soles. At the bottom, at the spit circle, we put our shoes on with numb fingers. Somewhere, a dog barked. The wire hummed again, no longer a throat clearing but just a wire in wind. We didn’t speak until the birches swallowed us. The road was a pale stripe. The bikes were where we left them; there was dew on the seats like cold sweat. Astrid touched the metal frame with just her fingertips and then shook her hand out, as if she had gotten a static shock. “What did you hear?” I asked. My voice was too loud in the empty road. “Nothing I will say out here,” she said. Her face looked older in the moonlight and the blue; her mouth was pinched at the corners in a way I had seen on women leaving church, on my mother in bus windows. She didn’t look at me. “What did you hear?” “My name,” I said. “Okay,” she said. It was both approval and an end to the topic. We rode back in silence, the frost beginning to lace the edges of puddles where the road dipped. Every time a branch scraped the air above us, I flinched. When we reached the first streetlight, it looked obscene, bright and flat and too alive. We leaned our bikes against my parents’ house—my parents’ house, not mine, not yet—and Astrid hooked her leg over her frame to straddle it, not getting off. She was breathing hard now, like she’d been holding it back. “Don’t sleep on your back,” she said abruptly. “Don’t comb your hair tonight. Don’t talk to your mother ‘til morning. And if you dream about a woman on the ice, don’t follow her.” “Oh,” I said, because the instructions fell out of her like stones. “Is that—” “Don’t,” she said, and her eyes were dark as the lake. “We don’t make a game of the morning.” She pushed off and pedaled away. I stood under the light, the yellow pooling at my feet. My hands smelled like juniper and dirt. Inside, my mother’s bedroom door was closed. I passed it like you pass a sleeping dog: slowly, hoping not to wake it, hoping it will wake up when it is ready. In my room, I sat down on the edge of the bed and stared at my hands. When I lay down, I lay on my side. I did not comb my hair. At some point, I slept. I didn’t dream of a woman on the ice. I dreamed of a field that breathed, in and out, in and out, and a voice that knew my name the way only you can know your own, like a tooth you worry with your tongue. For years afterwards, I told myself that we had scared each other into it, that teenagers will always find a way to make a shadow taller than it is. For years afterwards, I told myself that the dangerous line we crossed was only the line between what we wanted to be true and what we feared might be. And then sometimes—like nights when I wake and my hair is damp as if someone has been combing it with wet fingers—I don’t tell myself anything at all. I get up, and I step out clean, and I don’t look over my left shoulder. Not until morning. Not ever.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This folk horror piece successfully captures the essence of the genre while adhering closely to the prompt requirements. Set in rural northern Sweden in the 1990s, the story follows Linnea's participation in the Útiseta ritual with her friend Astrid. The author has crafted a tense, atmospheric narrative that maintains the requested ambiguity about whether the events are supernatural or psychological. The writing excels in establishing a sense of place and mood. The descriptions of the burial mound, the mist ("höströk"), and the nighttime landscape create a vivid, eerie setting. The sensory details—the taste of juniper berries, the cold earth under bare feet, the smell of "cold and something green"—immerse the reader in the experience. Character development is strong, particularly in how the author portrays Astrid's matter-of-fact approach to ancient rituals, which perfectly blends teenage rebellion with traditional elements as requested. Linnea's reluctance and curiosity are well-balanced, making her participation believable. The brief mentions of Linnea's mother add depth to her character motivation. The ritual itself is described with convincing detail, from the removal of shoes to avoid metal on the mound to the specific instructions about not looking over one's left shoulder. These elements feel researched and authentic to folk practices while maintaining the requested ambiguity about their efficacy. The narrative tension builds effectively as the ritual progresses. The subtle escalation—from simple sounds to breathing to the voice calling Linnea's name—creates mounting dread without resorting to obvious horror tropes. The use of first-person past tense works well, with the framing device of Linnea's present-day recollection subtly woven in through occasional references to "now" and "years between." The prose is generally strong, with evocative metaphors and sensory language that enhance the atmosphere. Occasionally, some sentences could be tightened for greater impact, but the writing maintains a consistent voice throughout. The ending successfully maintains the ambiguity requested in the prompt. Linnea's continued uncertainty about what happened that night—sometimes rationalizing it as teenage imagination, sometimes acknowledging something more—leaves the reader to draw their own conclusions while emphasizing the dangerous line crossed when treating ancient practices as entertainment. The piece does have a few minor weaknesses. Some sentences could be more concise, and there are moments where the pacing slows slightly. The dialogue, while generally effective, occasionally feels slightly stilted. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise accomplished piece of folk horror. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 4 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 4.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Physical-spatial: Therapeutic Boundaries — Score: 92.2
Prompt:
**"Therapeutic Boundaries"** Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a former professional athlete undergoing mandatory physical therapy after a career-destroying injury, harboring resentment toward recovery itself. Their physiotherapist is not only unnervingly attractive but also a former training partner from their competitive days who has successfully transitioned to a new career while the protagonist's identity remains shattered. We'll lean into the sexual tension of the scene by having her be attracted to him, but both of them attempting to maintain mental distance while being in physical contact as he shows her stretches & movements & manipulates her body, navigating the thresholds of pain. This scene MUST maintain complete physical coherence—every movement, stretch, and manipulation must be anatomically precise and spatially consistent. Paint an exceptionally vivid sensory picture through detailed attention to pain thresholds, involuntary responses to touch. Capture the suppressed, flaring tension of physical proximity, touch, and the controlled infliction of uncomfortable movements. Physical clarity is essential — readers must understand exactly what is happening with the body during each therapeutic technique. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The treatment table is too narrow and the paper crinkles every time I shift, broadcasting my restlessness like a metronome. The room is clinical—gray walls, storage cabinets with labeled bins of bands and balls and weights—but someone has snuck in civility: a ceramic cone on the counter exhales lavender, thin and floral, threaded over the smell of alcohol wipes and rubber. Mara stands at the foot of the table, skimming the chart on her tablet with her thumb. Her hair is pulled into a low knot the same way it always was when we used to line up at the blocks—sleek, no nonsense, pins catching the light. She’s in a navy polo with the clinic logo at the breast, black pants, running shoes that I know have their own fit story and arch support. Her face is the same, except the lines at the corners of her eyes are deeper; I don’t remember them when she laughed in the locker room after I finished a PR session. I also remember how she would tip me back on my scapulas with two fingers and tell me to stop shrugging my shoulders. Here we are again, except now it’s her name on the door and mine on the schedule. “How’s the pain this morning?” she asks. Her voice is neutral, practiced, pitched to neither coddle nor dare. “It’s there.” I flex my left foot; the ankle—the joint that blew my trajectory sideways—is encased in a low-profile brace. My heel skids on the paper. “Scale of one to ten?” She sets the tablet on the counter. The faint lavender keeps trying to tell me that this is a spa, a place where stress dissolves. My body knows better. “Four when I’m still. Seven if I’m walking. Ten when you touch it.” I mean it to sound like a joke, but it lands between us with the dull weight of an old argument. She gives me a look that could be sympathy or amusement or professional detachment. She steps closer; the friction of her sleeve against my bare knee is a small static report. “Let’s start with the basics.” She reaches under my heel with one hand and under my calf with the other. “Lie back. I’ll do the movement, you just let me know when you feel it. Breathe.” I inhale. The lavender is threaded with something cleaner, the citrus of her shampoo or her soap. She flexes my foot into dorsiflexion—ankle pulling up towards the shin. The top of my foot stretches, the Achilles tugs. It’s a dull pull until it isn’t: sharp, electric, an arc that shoots behind the medial malleolus and into the arch. My toes twitch. “There,” I say. “Seven.” “Good.” She holds the angle, steady pressure that doesn’t increase, watching my toes, watching the flutter at my jaw I try to stop by clenching. She counts under her breath, then slowly eases me back into neutral. “Now plantarflex.” She guides my foot forward, pointing. The front of my ankle compresses, the back lengthens. This is how it goes: movement within the joint’s rails, slow, controlled. The skin on her forearms brushes my shin; my leg hair registers each stray hair on her arm like antennae. I breathe like she told me to, long inhale, longer exhale, controlling something. Each pass she takes me a hair farther. My body resists; my body yields. My body remembers what it is to be told. “Eversion,” she says, shifting her hand from my heel to the outer edge of my foot. She rolls my sole outward, stretching the peroneals along the lateral calf. A hot string lights along the outer ankle, wraps behind the fibula. “Eight,” I grunt. “I have you,” she says, and she does: one hand cradling the top of my foot, the heel sliding in her palm. Her thumb presses the base of my fifth metatarsal, a point that flares and then, with the pressure, releases. “Inversion next. Tell me before it’s too much.” She brings my sole inward. The inside of the ankle complains, the injured deltoid ligament protesting with a mild, sharp ache. My big toe tightens. This is the injury’s handwriting, legible still even after months. “Back,” I say. She reverses immediately, neutral again. My breath shakes out. She sets my foot on the table and steps to the side, her hip brushing the table edge; I can feel the displacement of air, the body heat, the awareness that she is right there, all that efficient strength contained. “Active dorsiflexion. You pull toes up. Slow.” Her hand hovers under my foot, not touching unless I wobble. I pull against gravity. The anterior tibialis engages along the front of the shin; a tremor ripples as the damaged pathways get called up. The tremor embarrasses me more than it should. A lifetime of training taught me to hide weakness, and here is my foot shaking like it’s never done work. “Good control,” she says. “Hold at the top. Five, four…” Her voice draws the count out, a metronome. I hold; the burn salts the muscle. I let go on her cue. We repeat, the wobble smaller each time. Sweat beads at my temples, cools almost instantly in the climate-controlled room. “Let’s mobilize the talus.” She steps closer again, the slate floor squeaking under her shoe. She cups my heel, places the web of her opposite hand just above the ankle joint on the front, fingers splayed across my tibia and fibula to stabilize. “Relax your leg,” she says. She leans her trunk slightly, applying gentle posterior glide to the talus as she brings my knee forward over the foot. The sensation is deep, a pressure inside the joint that isn’t pain exactly but makes me want to pull away. I don’t. We hold, she backs off. Again. “Okay?” she asks. “Fine.” My voice is rough. Her wrist bones slide under her skin as she alternates pressure. Her breath ghosts past the little hairs on my shin when she leans. I stare past her at the poster of skeletal feet, the neat Latin of bones, as if nomenclature can erase the animal fact of touch. “Side-lying,” she says. She helps me roll onto my right side so the injured left is on top. The paper pulls under my shoulder blade, bunches; the table vinyl is cold against my bare triceps. She positions a pillow between my knees and another under my head. She steps behind me—no, beside me, but now her body is a curved wall along my back. “We’re going to do clamshells. Hips stacked, spine neutral. Don’t rotate.” Her hand lands on the crest of my left ilium, fingers framing the bone light as a hooked wing. Then the heel of her palm presses into the side of my gluteus medius. “Open.” I lift the top knee, keeping the feet together. The hip burns immediately, small stabilizers firing. She resists gently with her hand, a diagonal pressure that makes me fight to hold alignment. This part—this controlled force, the asking and answering of pressure—used to feel like life. Now it feels like penance. I lift, hold, lower slow. She cues my breath. “Exhale on the effort.” Her voice softens slightly. Her body is close enough that when I exhale, the warm air rebounds off her shirt and I breathe it back in. I hold the last rep until the muscle shivers, then lower. She taps the muscle with two fingers, a tickle that makes me want to swat her hand away. “Good. Roll onto your back.” I do, heaving the leg over the midline with both hands. She steadies the ankle as it crosses, fingers circling just proximal to the malleoli. “We’re going to work the calf. I’m going to apply pressure; tell me when it’s too much.” Her thumb lines up on my medial gastrocnemius. She leans her weight in slowly, not poking but sinking, waiting for the tissue to give. The pain is very specific and very informative: a hot spear that radiates toward the inner knee, then fuzzes at the edges as her thumb stays, holds, breathes with me. My foot spasms. She feels it and adjusts the vector a fraction of a degree, letting the pressure align with the muscle fibers. I feel the release like a sigh inside the meat. I do not make a sound. She repeats down the length of the calf, lateral head, then soleus deeper under. When she finally backs off, the limb feels both bruised and lighter. “Now,” she says, moving to the head of the table. Her chest is in my line of sight; I look away, stare instead at the clean lines of her collarbone, the pulse in her neck, the shallow hook of the stethoscope over a chair. “Return of proprioception. Close chain.” She helps me sit, then stand, her hand under my elbow but not grasping, just present. The table edge digs into the back of my thighs as I scoot toward the floor. My foot thuds heavier than I expect onto the mat. The joint protests the load with a whine. “Weight shift.” She places one foot slightly behind her other and faces me; the posture is reflexively athletic, ready to catch. We stand hip-width apart. “Shift onto the left. Keep the knee over the second toe. Don’t let the arch collapse.” Her hand cups my knee—not front or back, but beside, thumb on the tibial tuberosity, fingers along the medial patella. The warmth of her palm is ridiculous. Her other hand hovers under my arch, not touching unless it drops. I shift. The weight moves through the foot: heel, lateral edge, first metatarsal. The plantar fascia tightens. The peroneals stabilize. She watches the alignment like a hawk. Her eyes cut to mine once, a reflex to check in. The look is quick, professional. My body reacts as if it were something else, old pathways lighting. “Good. Small knee bend.” I flex. The anterior ankle complains, a bright blade. “Back off a centimeter.” I do. The blade dulls to a tolerable pressure. She nods. “Hold for three breaths.” Her hands are there, not quite touching, making a boundary I mind carefully. We breathe. On the second exhale the joint sings high. My fingers curl against my thigh. My palm is damp. “Step back,” she says. I shift weight off; the relief is immediate, almost a flush. I hate that relief. I hate the way my mood is tied to millimeters. She does not flinch when I roll my eyes, when I bark a laugh at nothing. “Single-leg balance.” She demonstrates, then moves behind me to a spot where she can catch me without making it an embrace. “Stand tall. Pick up your right foot an inch.” Her palms are open, one near my shoulder blade without contact, one near my hip. I lift. The left ankle wobbles, trying to find the floor through a storm. Tiny muscles fire, fail, fire. The arch tries to collapse; her fingers are there in the air to remind it not to. I stare at a point on the wall and imagine drilling a thread into it with my eyes. I last longer than I think I will. I last less than I want. My hip drops; she taps my glute, feather light, to bring it back online. I feel heat crawl up my neck, humiliation mixed with adrenaline. Her breath is steady behind me. The lavender is faint and somehow obscene. “Okay,” she says, and I remember that we used to cool down like this, focused, bodies humming. Except then no one was pretending that they didn’t want to fall into someone else after. Now we both perform poise while my body performs failure, and her hands write corrections on my skin without leaving marks. We go to the table again. She kneels by my foot, lifts it into her lap, and the warmth of her thigh through her pants is a shock. She catches herself—takes a half-inch back, repositions so my heel rests on a folded towel instead. Boundaries. “I’m going to perform a calcaneal eversion glide,” she says, tone textbook now. She cups my heel, aligns her thumbs along the calcaneus. Her forearms form a triangle. “Relax.” She applies lateral pressure while stabilizing the talus with her opposite hand. The subtalar joint opens subtly, a click that isn’t audible but felt, an untwining. The relief makes my eyelids flicker. I hate how grateful I am. “You’re doing well,” she says. She strips her hands away, stands, and the cool air rushes in where her heat was. My ankle feels like something she’s tuned, still fragile but more itself. “We’ll add theraband work next session. I want you at home doing alphabet writing with your foot, ankle circles—slow, controlled.” She demonstrates, drawing invisible letters in the air with her finger, the same motion I will have to reproduce with my toes. Her body sketches an A. The motion makes her shirt pull across her chest. I’m ridiculous. I want to apologize and also to accuse her of cruelty for bringing lavender and clean lines and that face into a room where I am reduced to an injured hinge. She passes me a loop of green band. “Not yet. Next time,” she says, smiling—small, professional. “Ice when you get home, ten minutes. Not directly on the skin. Two minutes of calf raises in the kitchen while you wait for the kettle. Three sets of ten. Use the counter for balance, both legs to go up, left leg to lower. Slow.” I nod. I want to ask her if she remembers the last race we both ran, the way she leaned into me in the tunnel and said, If you don’t go now, you never will. I want to ask her if she ever misses it, the hurt and the high, or if she’s truly just this—present, functional, whole. I want to tell her that the thing about pain is that it feels like truth. Instead, I swing my legs off the table. She’s there again, hand near my elbow, not touching. I stand. The floor is unforgiving but firm. My ankle holds. “Same time next week,” she says. “Yeah.” I pull my shoe on, the laces suddenly clumsy. She watches my knot, the way my fingers fumble. She does not offer to help; I don’t know if I’m relieved or disappointed. At the door, the lavender hums louder in the quiet. She opens it, waits as I step through. We’re close again for a breath. It would be simple to reach and not simple at all. I do neither. She nods; the knot of her hair doesn’t move. I walk down the hall on my altered gait, counting stairs, cataloging sensations, holding the arithmetic of pain in my head like a prayer. I don’t look back, because if I do I will see her there in her blue polo and her clean hands, and I will want to tell her how the line between hurt and help feels like a lover’s mouth on a bruise. Instead, I walk. The ankle flexes a degree past what it did before. It is almost nothing. It is the only thing.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures the complex dynamics between a former professional athlete and their physiotherapist. The piece excels in its anatomical precision, creating a vivid sensory experience that maintains physical coherence throughout. Every movement is described with technical accuracy, from dorsiflexion and plantarflexion to calcaneal eversion glides. The protagonist's resentment toward recovery is palpable, expressed through internal thoughts like "Now it feels like penance" and "I hate the way my mood is tied to millimeters." The narrative skillfully weaves this resentment with the sexual tension between the characters, creating a multilayered dynamic that feels authentic rather than forced. The writing demonstrates exceptional control of sensory details. Physical sensations are rendered with precision: "The pain is very specific and very informative: a hot spear that radiates toward the inner knee, then fuzzes at the edges." The author creates a vivid environment through small details like the "ceramic cone on the counter exhales lavender" and the paper that "crinkles every time I shift." The prose maintains a consistent voice throughout—clinical yet intimate, reflecting the protagonist's athletic background and current vulnerability. Sentences vary effectively in length and structure, creating a natural rhythm that mirrors the physical therapy session's ebb and flow. Where the piece truly shines is in its portrayal of the unspoken tension between the characters. Their shared history is revealed gradually through small details and memories, creating depth without exposition dumps. The protagonist's conflicted feelings—both attraction and resentment—are conveyed through physical reactions and internal thoughts rather than explicit statements. The ending avoids easy resolution, maintaining the complexity established throughout. The final image of the protagonist walking away with an ankle that "flexes a degree past what it did before" provides a subtle note of progress without undermining the emotional complexity. If there are weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally, the technical language might create distance for readers unfamiliar with anatomical terms, though this is balanced by clear contextual descriptions. The piece also maintains such consistent tension that it occasionally risks becoming repetitive in its emotional notes, though the varied physical therapy exercises provide structural variety. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted narrative that fulfills all the prompt requirements while creating a compelling, emotionally resonant experience. The writing demonstrates mastery of both technical precision and emotional nuance. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Historical fiction: High Seas and Low Vices — Score: 90.5
Prompt:
High Seas and Low Vices: British Naval Officer in the Opium Trade Character: Lieutenant James Merrick, a high-ranking officer in the British Royal Navy stationed in Canton, China in the 1830s. Once promising and decorated, now struggling with a severe opium addiction he hides from his superiors. Synopsis: Write a chapter following Lieutenant Merrick during a single day as he shirks his official naval duties in what has become a daily need to satiate the dragon. Told primarily in dialogue with the characters he interacts with. Focus on brief slices of his journey through the shadowy underworld of Canton: interactions with acquaintances, negotiations with local dealers, schemes and unsavoury jobs taken to fund his habit. Writing Task: Use rich sensory details to describe a day in the life of James Merrick. Write for a real sense of time & place while avoiding cliche. First person, past tense. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The bell from the factory yard struck six and the river wore a grey, unpromising skin. I stood under the eaves with my cap tucked into my coat, looking at a sky the colour of pewter and pretending to be early for inspection. The clerk—young Worsley—came out rubbing sleep from his eyes and stopped hard when he saw me. “Lieutenant, sir. Thought you were on the morning rounds with Mr. Peyton.” “I am,” I said, buttoning my coat higher. “I’ve just made them.” “At the anchorage?” His eyes brightened. “And the chop? They say deliveries—” “Postponed,” I said. “Too much tide.” He sighed. “I was hoping Mr. Elliott might sign the disbursement. My mother’s letter arrived and—” “Later,” I said. “Send the messenger back with a polite nothing.” Worsley nodded and attempted a smile that turned back on itself. I folded away from him into the street. It was easier to lie on an empty stomach. The scent of rotting mangoes hits earlier in summer and later in winter, but it was there already, creeping through my teeth as I stepped into New Street. It leaked from baskets abandoned, from the black damp at the base of the wall, from the mouth of a pig nosing at a woven lid. It is a sweet rot, the way old rooms hold prayers. It clung to the bricks as the hawkers began to lay out their morning. Piles of bitter greens glinted with dew. Steam rose from vats of millet, pork, buns pinched like sleeping children. I kept to the wall, not because of thieves, but because I had trained myself to walk as if I were invisible. “Lieutenant! Ho! Merrick!” Mr. Harland from the tea warehouse waved a ledger like a fan. “A word about your tally marks yesterday.” “We’ll speak later,” I said. “It cannot wait. The ships are in, and your—” I held my hand up as if I were listening for something. He stared foolishly into the air, then dropped his gaze, offended. I moved on. His voice washed after me, then died against the white plaster of the Danish factory. At Hog Lane a boy with a shaved head threw his bamboo hoop and ran past as if being chased by the hoop instead of the other way round. He turned to grin at me and I remembered, for a moment, the uncomplicated edge of mornings on the quarterdeck when the wind made everything hard and exact. “Lieutenant,” Mr. Mackenzie said, falling into step beside me as if he had always been there and I had been keeping him waiting. He was a merchant of the type that grows from the soil of this place—hips soft with success, eyes sharp, skin lightly powdered against damp. “You’re out early for a gentleman with nothing to declare.” “I declare as much as any of you,” I said. He smiled without humour. “Your friends at the Customhouse are less patient than last season. There is talk of doubling the searches.” “Then I am fortunate that I carry nothing,” I said. “Fortunate indeed.” He nodded to a woman in a pink jacket who balanced a tray of eggs on her head. “I have a favour to ask, Merrick. There is a minor inconvenience along the creek. A boat delayed, its cargo made restless by the presence of a certain Yeh.” “Yeh is a clerk,” I said. “He eats rice where he is told.” “He eats more than rice. He would like to eat me. I would prefer he does not.” Mackenzie angled his body closer, lowering his already soft voice. “A half hour of your time. A few English words spoken in the right ear. Nothing in writing. You stand a yard behind me and say nothing unless you must. You have a talent for standing.” “I am engaged,” I said. “In what?” He looked around at the stalls as if expecting an answer to sell itself. “In naval matters,” I said, and hated myself for reaching for that ragged cloak. “Report-writing. Captain says—” “Captain Lundy says many things he does not do,” he said. “Would Mr. Lundy have you sleep under my ledger if he knew how often your accounts rely upon it?” “Later,” I said. He nodded as if I had said yes. “Print Street. Noon. Do not keep me waiting or I will mistake your absence for disinterest.” I cut away into a narrower lane, fruit bruises underfoot making the ground treacherous. A cat’s tail drew a comma over a heap of peel. A woman sat on a stool with her neat hands in a basin of water, washing radishes as if they might forgive her. She did not look up. A wall hid the slant of a temple roof, but its bell had a particular iron throat and it spoke three times, the last chime a little sullen. “Jem,” someone hissed from behind a painted door. “Captain Jem.” “Don’t call me that,” I said, glancing around out of habit. “It is what you are,” the voice grinned. The door slid aside. Sui’s nose appeared—the little break in it like a note torn from a page. “You come early. You ask me what? Double price. Morning good smoke. Night cheap.” “Don’t be foolish,” I said. “You’ll have the same I always take.” “‘Always’ is a dream,” Sui said, opening fully now, cyan shirtsleeves rolled to the elbow. “Dream move. Coin stay. You bring coin today?” “I will,” I said. “After eleven. I need to set aside a parcel. Same mix.” “You always say ‘after’,” Sui said. He tapped his fingernail on the jamb, a patient little click. “I am not school. I am business.” “You are not a fool,” I said. “I will have what I owe.” “You owed yesterday,” he said. “You know this alley. It forgive less.” I leaned closer. The door caught me, the edge of it damp. I could smell breakfast from inside—rice, faint fish, the candied tang of the pipe. My stomach roared like something chained. “By noon,” I said. “I have something coming. Mackenzie has a job and—” Sui smiled with his teeth. “Ah. Big belly.” “You know him?” “I know his sandal make noise like a small pig when it rain,” Sui said. “I know his coin smell like English soap. Noon, Jem. Noon is gravity. You miss and I sell your parcel to a man who respect me.” “You sell my parcel and you lose me for good,” I said. Sui tilted his head. “You say like I am wife. I sell to many men. But I like you because you say sorry like song.” He squinted. “You hands shake. You cannot cut rope clean today. You make bad sailor. Take small button now. Pay later.” “How small?” “Thumb,” he said. “Smaller than you want. Big enough to walk.” “Half,” I said. “Half for men who pay last week,” he said. He slid the door almost shut, a foot’s width left for my pride to squeeze through. “Thumb,” I said, swallowing rage that had nothing noble in it. “And a promise.” “No more promise,” he said, and went inside. He returned with a twist of oil paper like a secret and pinched it between his fingers. “You keep your cap off my floor.” I took the twist, let it fall into my pocket like a coin. The smell of mango rot swung and came back. I went, without looking back, toward the river steps. On the stone there, under a mat awning, I found the missionary. Mr. Doolan—freckled, hair the colour of string, cheeks weathered like old pennies. He sat with his knees up, Bible open on them, and an expression of mild surprise as if the world had interrupted him by existing. “Lieutenant Merrick, good morning. You look unwell.” “I slept little,” I said. The river looked like a dirty mirror. Mm. The oarsmen were just beginning to shout. “I have a tract for you.” He fished in the pocket of his coat and brought out a folded square with a picture of a drowning man on the front. “On the question of appetite.” “I have none,” I lied. “It is a universal condition,” he said. “It can be turned.” “What do you want turned?” I asked. “Your steps,” he said. “I see you turn toward Hog Lane at hours that grow shorter. There is a table at Dr. Parker’s, you know. Clean, and without the smell.” “I have no quarrel with smells,” I said. “Then with truth?” He squinted. “I am told you were at Lintin last month when that junk went aground. A boy drowned because the line slipped. Is that true?” “A boy drowned because the junk went aground,” I said. “My truth is not better than his.” “You could rest,” he said, gentling his voice like a hand on a restless animal. “One hour. There are oranges. You could eat an orange and—” “Oranges are for men who can taste them,” I said. “Keep your paper. I like the picture.” He stood as if to follow me but thought better of it. A boatman laughed somewhere upstream, the laugh made of phlegm and joy. I tucked my chin into my coat and moved on. At Bligh’s tavern, the shutters were half up. The girl with the twist of hair at the crown of her head had a broom in hand and a set of pipes in her pocket. “Merrick,” she said, her eyes running over me and then away. “You’re off duty?” “I’m always on duty,” I said. “You look like a breakfast a cat dragged,” she said. “What you having?” “Water,” I said. “And whatever is cheap.” “Nothing is cheap,” she said. “But there is millet from last night. And a cup of tea. Mr. Harland paid for one for you the other day, said you stared at his figures as if they were waves.” “He’s an ass,” I said, sitting, the bench sticky under my hand. “If he comes in, tell him I’ve gone upriver.” “He never comes this early. His wife keeps him.” She brought the bowl. “There were boys outside. They bet whether you’d fall asleep with your eyes open.” “Who won?” “The small one,” she said. “You should eat your millet before it becomes a story.” I forced three mouthfuls. They stuck. The tea was bitter and clear. I let it sit in my cheek until it warmed me in one sweet line that had nothing to do with sugar. “You going to the factory?” she asked. “They sent a boy for you. Ran like his clothes were on fire.” “They always do.” “You owe Sui,” she said casually, the way a woman tells you your shoes are not laced. “He told Li who told me. Don’t be foolish.” “I am never foolish,” I said. “You are always foolish,” she said, but she smiled when she said it, which made it worse. “You think being English turns it into something else.” At Print Street the shops had opened their eyes. Uneven shutters looked out like old men watering the last of their geraniums. Mackenzie stood under a signboard with a painted carp, looking at his watch as if the watch were to blame. “You are late by three minutes,” he said. “You are early by one,” I said. A low man in a brown jacket stood at his shoulder, his hat folded under his arm like a fan. He was the sort that never testifies, only remembers. “Mr. Yeh waits inside,” Mackenzie said. “He has invented a fee. He will call it a local consideration. We will call it theft. You will call it a misunderstanding and suggest, with dignity, that the matter will be recalled in London, which is a place he fears the way we fear a certain clerk in Macao. You see? And if he asks your name you give him no name that can be pinned to a paper.” “I am all pins and paper, Mackenzie.” “You are a man in a blue coat. Try and remember it.” We went in. The smell of ink, candle grease, damp from a floor that had been mopped with a bucket that had not itself been clean. The clerk—Yeh—sat with his shoes off, toes long and splayed. He did not get up. His gaze stuck to me like a burr. “Sir,” he said. “Your friend is foreigner.” “We both are,” Mackenzie said in perfect Cantonese. “He is here to listen.” “Foreigners are bad listeners,” Yeh said. He pushed forward a paper. “There is a new regulation. It concerns taxes on—” “Salt,” Mackenzie said. “We do not trade salt.” “Tea dust is a salt,” Yeh said primly. “Very damaging to the lungs. It must be regulated.” “By your lungs?” I said, in English. Yeh’s eyes flicked back to me. He enjoyed not understanding it while understanding the contempt. He smiled. “Your king make rules for your shop?” he asked Mackenzie. “He send better ink? Or only more men to steal your breakfast?” “My king has not eaten breakfast,” Mackenzie said lightly. “He is fasting in sympathy with us. Here is what will happen. We will pay the usual consideration. You will not invent a salt.” “You talk very much,” Yeh said, glancing at me again. “Your soldier has a shaking hand. He has fever.” I clasped my hands behind my back. The joints felt full of sand. “He is bored,” Mackenzie said. “Please do not bore him further.” Yeh let silence earn him a coin. He liked to perform it. He counted his own fingers as if they were money. At length, he folded the paper and patted it, like stroking a cat. “Usual consideration,” he said, and named a number that was twice the usual. “Half,” I said before Mackenzie could speak. The word scraped out of me dry. “Half, or the salt you invent today will taste like your own blood.” There was a beat. Then he laughed, without humour, the luckless sound of a bamboo chair moved on wood. “You are a poet,” he said in English, the word round and surprising in his mouth. “You make very pretty songs.” He held up two fingers, then one. Mackenzie’s jaw ticked. He put down the coin. Yeh swept it up as if drawing a curtain. Outside, Mackenzie blew air through his nose in a way that made me think of horses. “You wasted breath in there.” “He enjoyed himself less,” I said. “And will enjoy making it more difficult next time,” he said. He peered at me. “You’re near it. Go and be done, and keep your tongue when you return. I will send a purse via Worsley to Spare Street. You can pay Sui and be a man for three hours. After that, let me never hear of it.” “If you are so offended,” I said, “Why do you ask me to stand behind you?” “Because you remind them we can bite,” he said. “Even if we have no teeth. Noon. Do not make me send someone with a hook.” I crossed the culvert at pace, my heart too high in my chest. Men shouted about hemp and hog bristles. A girl carried a duck with its head under her arm, the duck peered up at me with the one eye it had and seemed unimpressed. At Spare Street, a courier stood like a plant with his toes together. He had Worsley’s quill behind his ear, stolen or borrowed; in either case a wound. “Lieutenant Merrick,” he stammered, bowing too much. “From Mr. Mackenzie. And from Mr. Worsley, his note: ‘Please attend Mr. Peyton’s inspection at four and bring your hat.’” “I will,” I said. The purse felt like heat in my hand. I allowed myself one breath with my eyes closed, cool in through the nose, the mango-sweet rot finding a new register and settling into my nerves like a promise. I opened my eyes and went to Sui. “You were not gravity,” he said, counting the coin with nimble cruelty. “You were wind.” “I’m here before noon,” I said. The coin clacked, not quite enough weight, always less when it leaves your hand. He slid the paper parcel toward me, snug as a baby in its wrap, and a chilled brass lamp no larger than my palm. “Back room,” he said. “You got ten. Then my brother come. He breaks things when he see men sleep.” The room had no window, only a hole in the roof where smoke made a black flower. A mat. A coil of cloth like a snake. The first draw tightened something loose in my head, the way a good knot pulls, clean. The second turned the alley’s rot into honey. I lay back and let the smoke undo the day. Somewhere outside a Farthing song—one of the sailors with a tune—bothered the air and then wandered off. The pipe made its small cricket noises. “Jem,” a voice said, as if from the mat. Not Sui; female, English. I opened one eye. Charlotte—Captain Lundy’s niece—stood in the doorway with her skirts bunched in one hand to keep them from rot. She should not have been there. Her face was set with a fury that looked very like restraint. “You cannot be here,” I said, my mouth making the words too soft. “I know precisely where I am,” she said. “Get up.” “I am up,” I said. “Get up,” she said again, and stepped over a bucket. “You think you are the only man who knows where a door is in this town? Worsley begged me. He said you would listen to me. He was wrong, I see.” “Sui,” I said through the smoke, in the language he liked to pretend he didn’t understand. “Why did you let a child in?” “She paid,” Sui said without apology. “She pay more than you.” Charlotte’s eyes flicked to the pipe. They did not soften. “You smell like a waste place.” “You smell like soap,” I said. “We are both what we are.” “You are dimming,” she said. Her mouth trembled and then bit the trembling back. “I thought you were brave. The first week. On the river. Do you remember? The oar struck your shoulder and you laughed.” “Things happen,” I said. “Not this
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece effectively captures the day in the life of Lieutenant James Merrick, a British naval officer struggling with opium addiction in 1830s Canton. The writing demonstrates exceptional command of period-appropriate language, sensory detail, and characterization. The first-person narration successfully places us in Merrick's deteriorating mental state. His interactions reveal a man clinging to the remnants of his naval authority while being slowly consumed by addiction. The prose skillfully balances between moments of sharp clarity and increasing haziness as the day progresses toward his fix. The setting of Canton is vividly rendered through sensory details: "The scent of rotting mangoes," "Steam rose from vats of millet, pork, buns pinched like sleeping children," and the "cat's tail drew a comma over a heap of peel." These details create an immersive atmosphere that feels authentic to the time and place without relying on orientalist clichés. The dialogue is particularly strong, with each character having a distinct voice. Sui's broken English contrasts with Mackenzie's polished merchant-speak, while Charlotte's proper diction reflects her social position. The dialogue efficiently reveals character relationships and power dynamics without exposition. The narrative structure effectively traces Merrick's day as he navigates various social spheres—from naval duties to merchant dealings to the opium den—showing how his addiction has corrupted every aspect of his life. The pacing builds tension as Merrick becomes increasingly desperate for his fix. There are a few minor issues. The piece ends abruptly mid-sentence with "Not this," which feels unintentional rather than a stylistic choice. While this could be interpreted as Merrick losing consciousness, it reads more like an incomplete submission. Additionally, some transitions between scenes could be smoother, though the fragmentary nature does reflect Merrick's deteriorating focus. The prose occasionally risks becoming purple but generally maintains control, using vivid imagery that serves character and setting rather than mere decoration. For example, "I let it sit in my cheek until it warmed me in one sweet line that had nothing to do with sugar" effectively conveys Merrick's sensory experience while hinting at his addiction. Overall, this is an accomplished piece that creates a compelling character study while vividly evoking a specific historical moment. It balances sensory richness with narrative momentum and uses dialogue to reveal character with impressive economy. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 18 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 17 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 18.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 17.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Humour: Sisyphus Gives Advice — Score: 92.0
Prompt:
Sisyphus Gives Advice Write a comedic scene in the style of Terry Pratchett featuring Sisyphus, who has started an advice column while continuing his eternal boulder-pushing. Rather than being bitter about his punishment, Sisyphus has developed a comfortably zen emotional intelligence and wisdom from his centuries of repetitive labor. Not in the cliche ways you might expect -- he's actually very grounded, warm & connected with the everyday human plight. He dictates responses to "Crow," his feathered familiar who serves as both scribe and mail carrier. The piece should include Sisyphus thoughtfully answering several advice-seekers' letters about everyday problems (relationship troubles, work-life balance, dealing with difficult people, life purpose doubts) while periodically returning to his boulder-pushing duties. His advice should be surprisingly insightful and practical. The humor should emerge naturally from the messages he receives, from mundane to risque. Sisyphus should genuinely enjoy helping others, finding meaning in this new pursuit while maintaining his boulder routine. The humour should be *understated and not forced*. Contrary to expectation, almost none of his advice involves boulder rolling metaphors (though he does sneak *one* subtle in there), nor a treatise on stoicism. We are also going against the obvious fish-out-of-water trope; in fact, he's surprisingly a natural at this. In all of this , it's important to *show, don't tell*. The format should be largely epistolary, with the occasional interjection for scene setting. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The thud was punctual. It had taken centuries for the boulder to learn punctuality. At the bottom of the hill, it always arrived with a sound like a door being shut firmly but kindly. Sisyphus placed his hands on its good side (most boulders have a good side if you take the time) and leaned in. The first few paces were always a conversation with gravity. After that, things became pleasantly straightforward. “Crow,” he said, as the pebbles clicked politely under his sandals. “First letter.” Crow, who was black in the way morning coffee is black and had the handwriting of a persistently scolded clerk, strutted on a nearby rock and unfurled a scroll from under his wing. He dipped his beak thoughtfully in the little inkpot they kept in a niche and read in a tone that implied both skepticism and perfect dictation. “Dear Sisyphus,” Crow began, “my partner and I have been together for eight years. We love each other, but lately our arguments over small things — dishes, laundry, my terrible habit of bringing home free pens — have become big. I worry that if we can’t stop fighting over the small things, the big thing (our love) will die. Signed: Pencap Bandit.” “They give away those pens for a reason,” Sisyphus said, and leaned. The boulder rose a foot. The hillside accepted that this would happen, as it always did, and tugged back affectionately. “Let’s see. Tell Pencap Bandit: The small fights are often about the wrong words for the right feelings. Try this exercise. When an argument starts about dishes, pause and say, ‘Is this about dishes, or is this about feeling unseen?’ Set a timer for ten minutes. During those ten minutes, each of you gets the floor twice, five minutes each. No interruptions, just reflections. Then, commit to a comically small bid for goodwill: one of you handles all the pens in the house for a week, the other chooses a playlist for washing up and you both dance terribly to it.” Crow scratched swiftly, tail flicking, wingtip steady despite the breeze. “You want me to write ‘dance terribly’?” “Very important,” Sisyphus said, shoulders moving. “If they dance well, they’ll perform at each other, and then they’ll be competing about who is the better dishwasher. Also, ask them to buy three truly excellent pens. And then ask: what are you accumulating when you pick up a free pen? That answer is the one they should share.” Crow peered down the slope as if calculating wind speed for his next flight. “Anything else?” “Yes.” The boulder moved another two feet. “Tell them love isn’t a large object that dies of small scratches. It’s a habit. Habits thrive on the right amount of inconvenience — the kind you add on purpose.” Crow signed with a flourish that would have offended the gods and tucked the letter away. A sunbeam strolled across the hill, late as usual. “Next, please.” “Dear Sisyphus,” Crow read, “I’ve been promoted at work. This is good. Unfortunately, my job now eats all my time, my hobbies, and my friendships. I used to paint tiny horses. Now I supervise meetings about meetings. How do I balance it all? Horseless in Accounting.” Sisyphus adjusted his grip as a minor personality quirk in the rock tried to veer left. “Tell Horseless that balance isn’t a scale, it’s a schedule. People who think it’s a scale keep throwing more weight on both sides. Tiny horses deserve appointments. Put them in the calendar with the same indignation you feel when someone puts a meeting at lunchtime. Name the appointment something impressive. For example: ‘Quarterly Equine Miniatures Review.’ Then defend it with the ferocity of a mid-level manager who has had two coffees.” Crow made a note: Ferocity (two coffees). “What about the friendships?” “Friendships are like those herbs you forget in the drawer,” Sisyphus said. “They don’t need as much as you think. A voice note while walking. Thirty minutes every second Thursday. A standing invitation to paint horses together on the first Sunday of the month. If you invite someone to something specific, you are loving them and yourself. Abstract invitations die in the doorway.” Crow cocked his head. “Should we address the meetings about meetings?” “Yes. Ask one question: ‘What decision must exist by the end of this meeting that does not exist now?’ If no one can answer within twenty seconds, you have inherited a weather report disguised as a meeting. Request that it be sent by email. You can paint a fetlock in the time you save.” The rock, at this point, was doing that endearing thing where it pretended it had never been this far before, even though it had been this far thousands of times. Sisyphus smiled fondly and leaned more. A breeze brought the faint metallic smell of somewhere else. Crow shuffled another letter free. This one had an unfortunately enthusiastic wine stain and a smudge that suggested a cat had tried to sign it. “Dear Sisyphus,” Crow struggled. “‘How do I deal with my boss, who is a—’” Crow paused. “The next word is either ‘genius,’ ‘genoa,’ or ‘gerbil.’” “Read me clues.” “‘He sends emails at three a.m., corrects my commas, takes credit for my ideas, and believes meetings are a substitute for air. He also microwaves fish. Please help.’ Signed: Probably Not a Gerbil.” Sisyphus blew a hair from his forehead. “I am fascinated by the genoa option.” “Slippery, salty,” Crow offered, “but possibly not managerial.” “Let’s assume their boss is human, which is unfortunately plausible. Write: First, put your takings into three baskets. Basket one: things you assert. Basket two: things you accept. Basket three: things you avoid. Assert your deadlines by offering choices: ‘I can deliver the budget by Friday or the projections by Wednesday. Which one matters more?’ This turns their appetite into a menu. Accept that emails at three a.m. are his circus and you don’t have to buy a ticket. Put an auto-reply that says, ‘I read emails between 9 and 5 and will respond then.’ Avoid the fish by acquiring a desk plant with an imposing demeanor and placing it near the microwave with a passive-aggressive name tag: ‘This is Fern. Fern can smell everything.’” Crow’s shoulders hitching in silent amusement. “What about the ideas theft?” “Keep a paper trail that compliments him as you document yourself,” Sisyphus said. “Example: ‘As we discussed, I’ll proceed with my plan to implement the new onboarding flow by Tuesday. Loved your note on the third step.’ Cc the relevant people. People who need credit also need witnesses. If that doesn’t change the weather, begin interviews. Life is too short to be edited by a man who microwaves the ocean.” Crow scribbled, then added, “Do you want to say anything about gerbils?” “Only that they would make excellent bosses as they have a simple, open plan environment and value bedding.” They were halfway up, which is to say they were halfway anywhere. Sisyphus adjusted his hands, palms pleasantly gritty. He liked grit. It told the truth. “Next.” “Dear Sisyphus,” Crow read, “I’m thirty-seven and feel like everyone but me has a purpose. I’m doing okay at a job I don’t hate, I have friends, a dog, and a flat that doesn’t have mushrooms in the bathroom anymore. But some days I think I should quit and go find my ‘thing.’ How do I find what I’m supposed to be doing? Signed: Waiting For A Sign.” Sisyphus listened for a moment. The hillside was making that soft sound hills make when they’re thinking about summer. “Tell them there are two kinds of purpose. Purpose like a cathedral, and purpose like a kettle. Cathedrals are fine, but kettles are what get the tea made. Ask them: what is the thing you do that people thank you for? Purpose often hides in receipts.” Crow nodded, as if this were the sort of line people paid for. “And if they can’t think of anything?” “Then they should do one small useful thing every week, different each time, and notice which makes them forget to look at the clock. Bake for neighbors. Volunteer to sort the chaos in a friend's closet. Teach someone’s grandmother how to use her phone without sighing. Their thing will feel like the part of a day that falls into place. Also, please tell them they are allowed to stop looking for a sign and instead make one. Cardboard, marker pen: ‘Open for curiosity.’ Hang it above their desk.” Crow’s eye gleamed. “Shall I offer an opinion about mushrooms?” “Only congratulations on their absence,” Sisyphus said. They hit the place where the incline steepened with that petty personal pride hills have. The rock sighed. Sisyphus braced his knees, found the little notch where his foot went every time. Somewhere overhead, a god checked a watch he didn’t need. Crow coughed delicately. “One more. It’s… I fear this one had an incident. Perhaps in transit through a storm, or a bakery explosion.” The letter was smeared into interpretive dance. Crow held it up anyway. It smelled faintly of cardamom. “‘Dear Sisyphus, my… something… refuses to… something… in bed unless the… something… is…’ I think that might be ‘astronomically aligned’? Or possibly ‘assembled.’ Then there’s a drawing. Is that a plough?” Sisyphus peered around the boulder. “It’s either a plough or a swan,” he said. “There’s a fine line.” “Then: ‘I have tried to… something… with olive oil…’ Oh dear. And ‘the neighbors…’ then it goes off the page and resumes: ‘legal counsel.’ Signed: Desperate in a Cul-de-Sac.” Sisyphus regarded the smudge with the respect one gives a complex tapestry. “All right. We’ll answer three possible questions simultaneously.” Crow flexed his talons as if preparing for aerial acrobatics with grammar. “One: If the issue is timing, and they will only do the thing at a particular hour, ask why that hour feels safe. Is it privacy? Fatigue? Habit? Recreate the condition intentionally: lock doors, put the phone in a drawer, choose a light that is flattering. If astronomy is truly involved, agree on a calendar and name the stars together, but do not wait for them.” “Two: If the issue is complexity of apparatus — if we are dealing with an assembly problem — recommend taking the manual to bed metaphorically before literally. It’s not unromantic to read instructions. It is a kindness to future untanglings. Also, olive oil belongs on salads. Use proper lubricants. Their neighbors will thank them, silently and profoundly, across the party wall.” “Three: If the concern is consent — if one partner refuses something the other desires — then say: desire is not a demand. You can have a fantasy without it becoming a plan. Agree on a safe word. Make a yes/no/maybe list separately, then compare with snacks. Where overlap exists, joy lives. Where it doesn’t, gentleness must. And if legal counsel is already involved, consider that the swan is not the problem.” Crow put the letter down very carefully, as if it might combust into awkwardness. “Do we address the cul-de-sac?” “Ah,” Sisyphus said, “cul-de-sacs are an urban design choice that mistakes safety for stagnation. Tell them to plant a bench on the corner and learn everyone’s name. It won’t help with the olive oil, but it will make the rest of their life braver.” Crow’s beak clicked, the avian equivalent of a grin. At the crest, wind tapped Sisyphus on the cheek and the view did its usual ostentatious thing. The boulder, that faithful domesticated star, hesitated, wobbled, and then remembered its purpose and began to go away downhill with cheerful treachery. Sisyphus jogged alongside, put a hand out as if saying goodbye to a friend boarding a train. He did not chase. This was not that sort of story. He adjusted the leather strap that always ended up scarred in the same place and sat on a flat stone where a cushion ought to have been. “One last?” Crow asked, already uncurling the edge of a small, neat envelope addressed in lavender ink. Sisyphus nodded, massaging a forearm that had known more repetitive strain than any epic hero deserved. “Dear Sisyphus,” Crow read, “my sister keeps borrowing my favorite sweater and returning it stretched, stained, or ‘with a story.’ I love her, but my sweater is losing its integrity. How do I set boundaries without setting fire to the relationship? Signed: Cold and Furious.” Sisyphus smiled. “Tell them to buy their sister a sweater. Not the same one. A sweater that suits her, chosen with ridiculous care. Present it with: ‘I noticed you love wearing something cozy. This one is yours. Mine stays with me. If you want to borrow anything else, ask. I may say no, but I will never say no to you.’ Then enforce it without drama. People confuse boundaries with punishments. They’re actually instructions for how to love you.” Crow paused, and then, softly, “And how to love them.” “Exactly,” Sisyphus said. He stood, dusted his hands, and began to stroll down. The hill, relieved of its task for a moment, did a small stretch in the sunshine. Crow launched, a black brushstroke against the bright. “Add this to all of them,” Sisyphus called, as the boulder met him with its inevitable thud at the bottom. “You’re allowed to change your mind. Write that in the margins.” Crow wheeled, shouted back, “Which margins?” “All of them,” Sisyphus said, and leaned his shoulder against the good side, which was not always the same side, and pushed. “Do you ever wish,” Crow asked between dictations, “that you could solve your own problem as neatly as theirs?” Sisyphus considered, hands steady, feet sure. “Oh, I solved my problem ages ago,” he said. “I stopped having the wrong one.” There was a brief, companionable silence. The rock made a noise like an old friend settling into an old chair. Crow landed, shook out his wings. “We never used the metaphor today,” he said, almost accusing. “We did,” Sisyphus said. “It’s in the kettle.” He smiled, and the hill, which had learned punctuality, kept its appointment.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece brilliantly captures Terry Pratchett's style while creating a fresh, engaging scenario with Sisyphus as an advice columnist. The writing demonstrates exceptional control of tone, pacing, and characterization. The author establishes Sisyphus as genuinely wise and emotionally intelligent without being preachy. His advice is practical and insightful, showing rather than telling his emotional intelligence. The relationship between Sisyphus and Crow adds depth and humor through their interactions. The epistolary format works perfectly, with each letter presenting distinct problems that Sisyphus addresses with surprising wisdom. The advice itself is genuinely thoughtful - from relationship troubles to work-life balance to dealing with difficult people - showing remarkable psychological insight while maintaining the comedic tone. The prose is elegant without being overwrought. Descriptions like "Crow, who was black in the way morning coffee is black and had the handwriting of a persistently scolded clerk" capture Pratchett's knack for unexpected but perfect similes. The personification of inanimate objects (the boulder having a "good side," the hill making sounds "when they're thinking about summer") echoes Pratchett's style beautifully. The humor is understated and emerges naturally from the situations and characters rather than forced jokes. Small touches like Crow asking if he should "address the cul-de-sac" or offering "an opinion about mushrooms" create gentle humor that feels authentic to the world. The piece cleverly avoids the obvious boulder-rolling metaphors, with just one subtle reference ("Purpose like a cathedral, and purpose like a kettle") that fits the prompt's requirements. The writing shows rather than tells throughout, allowing readers to discover Sisyphus's wisdom through his actions and advice. The ending ties everything together nicely with the revelation that Sisyphus "solved [his] problem ages ago" by "stopping having the wrong one" - a profound insight delivered with characteristic understatement. The final exchange about the metaphor being "in the kettle" is a perfect closing touch. If there's any criticism to offer, it might be that some of the advice occasionally becomes slightly too modern in its psychological terminology, which can momentarily break the mythological framing. However, this is a minor point in an otherwise exceptional piece. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Coming of age: Lost & Found in Osaka — Score: 88.4
Prompt:
Lost & Found in Osaka Slice of Life / Coming-of-Age: First Connection. Write one scene within a larger story set in Osaka, Japan. A shy, introverted teenager & synthesizer nerd, is browsing the electronics district of Den Den Town. She is drawn to the sound of an electric guitar. A girl, slightly older and radiating confidence, is busking near the entrance to a crowded arcade, playing a blistering rendition of a classic anime theme. The scene takes us through their initial awkward interaction, transitioning into a surprisingly easy conversation. The busker, intrigued by the teenager's quiet intensity and knowledge of music, suggests they grab some sushi at a nearby kaitenzushi (conveyor belt sushi) restaurant. Write primarily in dialogue, capturing the distinct voices of the two characters: the teenager's hesitant and -- initially -- awkward speech, and the busker's more outgoing and playful tone. 1000 words.
Model Output:
“Uh— is that… is that ‘Cruel Angel’s Thesis’?” “You got it. Want me to do the key change or keep it honest?” “I— key change. If you— if you want. It sounds good. Already.” “Ha! Key change it is.” “Wow. Your vibrato— it’s really—” “Hey, thanks. Tips accepted in coin, praise accepted in unlimited amounts.” “I don’t have— I mean, I have coins. Wait. Um. Sorry.” “Relax, synth girl. You look like you just got lost in Super Potato and ended up in a boss fight.” “I— no. I mean— yes? I was… in Den Den Town for chips. Like, actual chips for a synth. The, uh, PT2399. For a delay. Sorry. I’m being weird.” “You’re being adorable. PT2399, huh? That’s the karaoke delay chip?” “I mean, technically it’s an echo processor with variable time and— I’m rambling.” “Keep going, I like rambling. Name?” “Yui.” “Yui. I’m Kanna. Nice to meet you. Don’t look at my chipped nail polish.” “It looks… cool? Like— like it’s distressed on purpose.” “I’ll take it. You listen to a lot of anime music?” “I— my dad did. We used to watch, um, EVA and Cowboy Bebop. And I… I like synth stuff. City pop. And, like, Jun Togawa. Sorry.” “Never apologize for taste. You want me to do Tank! next? Might scare the arcade guys.” “People would clap. Probably.” “Then I’ll save it for when the claw machine bosses pay me protection money. So, Yui, what’s in the bag?” “Oh. Just— some knobs. Potentiometers. And a secondhand Korg Volca I probably couldn’t afford, but the vendor gave me a discount because the battery door is cracked.” “Let me see?” “This? It’s— it’s the Beats. Everyone makes fun of the snare, but— it’s fine if you tweak the decay.” “Look at you, roasting snares like a pro. Can I?” “Uh— careful, the power switch is—” “Oh, I know those. Up is on. Oof, this thing is cute. Did you mod yours yet? You look like a modder.” “I’m— I mean— I like to solder.” “I bet you do. That explains the burn on your thumb.” “Oh. I… yeah. You noticed.” “Guitar hands recognize electronics hands. Different kinds of calluses. So what’s your delay time sweet spot with that chip?” “Three hundred and fifty milliseconds. You get that smear without the chorus-y artifact. Or if you crank it, it gets all crunchy and… broken karaoke bar.” “Now that is a tone description I can drink to. Broken karaoke bar. I’m stealing that.” “You can. Uh— I like your guitar. The stickers. Evangelion Unit-01?” “Sharp eye. I got Unit-02 on the back plate. I’m equal opportunity. And this scratch? That’s from fighting a trash can for turf.” “Wait, what?” “Okay, a very cute cat knocked my guitar off the stand. Cat won. Guitar learned humility.” “Oh. I have a cat too. She chewed through my patch cables. I had to… um… it was expensive.” “Cats and cables: eternal enemies. How old are you, Yui?” “Seventeen. I mean, uh, seventeen.” “No need to say it twice. Do you live around here?” “In Tennoji. I take the train. My mom thinks Den Den Town is, like, shady. It’s not, it’s just… loud.” “It is loud. I like loud. It drowns out the other loud in my head.” “Oh. Yeah.” “Hey, you got that look. The maybe-I-want-to-say-something look. What is it?” “Your tone— the amp— it’s just a Roland Cube, right? But you rolled off the highs. And that pickup— bridge humbucker— it’s… you wired it in parallel?” “Okay, how did you—” “The attack’s softer. It’s a little scooped. Sorry. I’m annoying.” “You’re a nerd. That’s a compliment. Yeah, parallel. I hate ice pick. You know, it’s funny: most people just hear ‘loud guitar.’ You’re hearing wiring.” “I hear… everything? Not in a brag way. In a… it’s hard to ignore way.” “Same. The train squeal on the Sakaisuji Line is, like, a constant B-flat. Torture.” “I thought it was closer to A# too— sorry, that’s the same note— I mean, I get what you mean.” “You’re cute when you correct yourself. Tell me something. What would you do to this— this song— if you had your Volca and your little karaoke chip?” “Uh. I’d… take your tempo— eighty-eight BPM? Maybe ninety? And put a gated pad under it, low-pass filter at about… 1.2 kHz to leave room for your guitar. And… I’d put a short slapback on the melody— like eighty milliseconds— so it… pops. And… maybe a detuned saw an octave down. Small. So it feels… bigger.” “Girl. You’re producing me on the sidewalk.” “Sorry! Sorry. I didn’t mean to—” “No, I love it. We should try it. Like, later. You know what else we should do? Not starve. Have you eaten?” “I… had convenience store melon pan. At… noon.” “It’s five.” “I lost track. The sensors shop had bins of resistors and I—” “Say no more. I know a kaitenzushi around the corner that won’t make me sell my amp. Come on. I’ll pack up. You can guard my tip jar.” “O-okay. Wait, but— you’re in the middle of playing. I don’t want to—” “Arcade dudes just flashed me the ‘wrap it up’ hand sign. Also, if I play any longer my E string will snap out of spite. Help me roll up?” “Sure. The cable— do you— clockwise or…?” “Over-under. Of course.” “Oh. Like stage people.” “Like stage people. Hey, Yui?” “Yeah?” “You’ve got that look again.” “Just… thank you. For not… making fun.” “Of you? Never. Except maybe for the way you’re cradling that Volca like a baby.” “It’s fragile.” “I get it. I cradle my pedals too. Okay, tips box closed. Guitar in case. Let’s escape before somebody requests Haruhi.” “I wouldn’t mind—” “Don’t say that too loud. You’ll summon the wota.” “The what?” “Idol fans. They appear like ninjas. This way. Watch your step— the pachinko place dumps cigarette breaks on the sidewalk.” “It smells like metal and smoke.” “And octopus. Takoyaki stall is killing me. But sushi first, takoyaki later. You okay with conveyor belt? They have that weird corn-mayo roll I pretend not to like.” “I like that one. People judge me.” “I judge no one at kaitenzushi. Except the guy who takes all the uni plates and stacks them like a temple.” “Do people… do that?” “You’ll see. Oh, hey— fireworks.” “What?” “Look— outside the arcade. Somebody’s launching off from the river? Or maybe it’s a promo.” “It— it’s loud.” “You good?” “Yeah. It’s… it’s fine. It just— kind of sits in my ears.” “Here. Hand. Just for a second. Squeeze.” “I— okay. Thanks. That— helps.” “Fireworks are jerks. They always think they’re the main character.” “They’re pretty though.” “They are. Okay, there’s the sign. This place is great. They do salmon with lemon like my grandma. Come on.” “Do they have… natto?” “You’re dangerous. I like it. Two seats?” “Two, please.” “Look at you. Using your big voice.” “Sorry.” “Don’t apologize. Sit. Conveyor’s going the wrong way, that’s always trippy.” “It’s— clockwise.” “You are such a nerd. What do you want? Salmon? Tamago? A whole boat of eel for your tiny synth fingers?” “Um. Tuna. And… tamago. And… okay, the corn-mayo.” “Atta girl. I’m grabbing two plates of salmon because I’m basic, and one squid because I like to suffer. Oh, and miso soup. Always. Here, this cup is yours. Tea powder is… right there. Careful, it’s aggressive.” “I know. One spoon is enough.” “Sugar, you live here, don’t you?” “I… sometimes.” “Tell me about your delay chip again.” “You really want—” “Yes. And tell me about your dad and anime and why the train is an A# nightmare and why you look like you haven’t had someone listen to you in a while.” “Oh.” “Too much?” “No. It’s… okay. The PT2399— it’s cheap, but it behaves like… like nostalgia. It turns clean edges soft. You send a note and it comes back like a memory. Slightly wrong, but… nice. And my dad— he liked when things were slightly wrong. He said it was— human.” “He sounds cool.” “He… he died last year.” “I’m sorry.” “It’s okay. I mean, it’s not. But… the first week after, I couldn’t stand silence. So I… I soldered. And I made this ugly little delay pedal with crooked knobs. And it… made the house feel… not empty.” “That’s perfect. Not the dying part. The crooked knobs part.” “I know what you meant.” “My grandma says grief is like a bent note. It only sounds right in the right song.” “That’s… beautiful.” “She’s a Kansai lady with a mouth like a rapper. You’ll meet her and she’ll feed you pickles whether you want them or not. Here, eat your tuna.” “Mm. It’s… good. Sorry.” “Stop apologizing. You do that every third word.” “I know. I’m working on it.” “I’ll charge you a plate for every sorry. We’ll be broke by dessert.” “I don’t… have dessert money.” “Then you’d better stop. So, music. You ever play out? Like in public?” “No. I… I don’t. I record alone. On my laptop. I post tiny things with no tags.” “You’re describing a crime. You know that, right?” “I’m… scared. People can be… loud.” “True. But some of them are me. And I can run interference. What if we did something low-stakes? Like, next weekend, you bring your Volca and your crooked delay, and we set up in front of the arcade. I play, you sprinkle your broken karaoke bar on top.” “What if… it sounds bad?” “Then we laugh. And we eat corn-mayo rolls in shame. Then we try again.” “What if… it sounds good?” “Then we’re unstoppable. And we post a video with tags so people can actually find it. And we buy a better battery door.” “I… I don’t know if I can.” “You can. Or you can try. You’ve already done the hard thing.” “What’s the hard thing?” “Talking to a stranger. Who plays too loud. In front of fireworks.” “Oh. I… yeah. I guess I did.” “You did great. And you knew my pickup wiring by ear. That’s basically wizardry.” “I… okay. Maybe. Next weekend. If— if I can get a day that my mom is okay with.” “We’ll make it a respectable time. Tattoos covered, songs clean, zero swearing.” “You have tattoos?” “No. But I could lie. Okay, stack your plates. We’re making a temple, remember?” “I thought you were against that.” “Only when other people do it. When I do it, it’s art. This miso soup is saving my life.” “It’s salty.” “Like me. So, tell me: Jun Togawa. Favorite track.” “Risky. The live version. She screams and it’s… there’s this synth under it, like a mosquito.” “See, that’s exactly how you talk about music. Like it’s a place. I want in. You know what the fireworks sound like to me?” “What?” “Like cheap cymbals. Like someone shaking a bag of coins as a hi-hat.” “That’s… accurate. The low thump is like a kick through a wall.” “Okay, now I want to sample them. New plan: after sushi, we go outside, I record ten seconds on my phone, you put it through your weird delay, and we make a trashy interlude called Broken Karaoke Fireworks.” “I— that’s silly.” “It’s perfect. Come on. Don’t you want your memory slightly wrong?” “I… yeah. I do.” “Good. Eat your tamago. Then we make some noise.” “Okay.” “Okay.”
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a strong example of character-driven dialogue that effectively captures the distinct voices of two characters as requested. The writer has created a believable interaction between a shy, introverted synthesizer enthusiast (Yui) and a confident, outgoing busker (Kanna). The dialogue successfully establishes both characters' personalities. Yui's hesitant speech is consistently shown through stutters, self-corrections, and apologies ("I— I mean—", "Sorry. I'm being weird."). Kanna's more playful, confident tone comes through in her teasing but kind responses ("You're being adorable," "You're a nerd. That's a compliment."). The contrast between these voices is maintained throughout. The technical knowledge about music equipment adds authenticity to both characters. Yui's detailed understanding of synthesizers and sound processing feels genuine rather than forced exposition. Kanna's guitar knowledge establishes her as a serious musician rather than just a generic "cool girl" character. The piece excels at showing character development through dialogue alone. We see Yui gradually becoming more comfortable, speaking in longer sentences, and even making small jokes by the end. This progression feels natural rather than rushed. The emotional core of the story—Yui's grief over her father and her social anxiety—is handled with subtlety. The revelation about her father's death and how she coped through music provides depth without becoming melodramatic. The setting of Osaka's Den Den Town is effectively established through specific references (Super Potato, Sakaisuji Line, pachinko parlors) without excessive description. The sensory details (smell of metal, smoke, and octopus; the sound of fireworks) create a vivid backdrop. The dialogue flows naturally, with the conversation moving between topics in a realistic way. The characters discuss music, share personal details, and make plans, all while eating sushi—a believable progression for a first meeting. Some minor weaknesses: There are moments where the technical music talk might be difficult for non-musicians to follow, and the piece occasionally relies on anime references that might not resonate with all readers. However, these elements are appropriate given the setting and characters. The ending strikes a hopeful note without being unrealistically transformative. Yui hasn't suddenly overcome all her social anxiety, but she's made a connection and is cautiously open to collaboration. This feels earned rather than forced. Overall, this is an accomplished piece that fulfills the prompt requirements while creating a genuinely engaging slice-of-life interaction between two well-realized characters. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 16 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 3 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 16.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 3.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Teen horror: Tick Tock (Goosebumps) — Score: 90.0
Prompt:
Teen Horror (Goosebumps style) Write a chapter where a middle school student discovers their new smart watch has the ability to rewind time, but doesn't realize that each use is aging them until they notice physical changes (like accelerating through puberty) and that people are treating them differently. They inadvertently cause a timeline shift with disastrous consequences -- and it can only be rectified (maybe?) by reversing the clock once more. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
I found the watch in the lost-and-found bin under the trophy case, tangled up with a neon scrunchie and a single rollerblade wheel. It wasn’t our school’s version of a smart watch—no brand logo, no cracked screen, no gummy mysteries. It was sleek and dark, like the surface of a still pond. When I lifted it, the face flared to life with this pale blue glow, and the minute hand slid backwards, like it was embarrassed and apologizing. You didn’t put things back in there once you rescued them. That was the unwritten rule of Eastfield Middle. The bin was where stuff went to get forgotten, and sorry, but I’m not a trash heap. I slipped it on in homeroom because Ms. Barlow was doing the thing where she reads announcements in a voice designed to lull actual boulders to sleep. It synced to nothing. It didn’t ask for my phone. It just hummed on my wrist, warm like it had already decided we were best friends. “Order forms,” Ms. Barlow droned, placing a stack of photocopies on Ryan Finch’s desk. “For the donut fundraiser, which is not optional, even if you have a gluten allergy.” Ryan slapped the stack against the desk and tossed the top paper toward me. It missed and slid under my chair. “Nice catch, Sam,” he said. “You and your good friend gravity.” There were laughs. I could feel my face lighting up like a stop sign. The watch vibrated. It wasn’t a harsh buzz—it was like someone tapped my wrist and whispered, hey. The glow deepened, and the minute hand jerked backwards three ticks. Time didn’t freeze. That’s not how it worked. It paused, like the school held its breath for half a second. The paper rose, hung in air like a lazy bird, and then—fluttered back onto my desk, like it had always been heading there. Ryan blinked. The laughter died. “Uh,” he said. “I mean, nice… catch?” I stared at the watch. There was a button, ridged, flush with the side. I pressed it with my thumb because I have never learned a single cautionary tale in my life. The world wobbled. It was like standing on a dock while a thousand invisible boats tugged at the pilings. The clock above the whiteboard rolled backwards a full minute. The tube of fluorescent lights overhead flickered between on and off without settling on either, and Ms. Barlow stumbled over her words mid-sentence, backtracked, and read them with the same gummy enthusiasm. The paper never left Ryan’s hand. He was mid-toss and then he wasn’t. He glanced down at his empty fingers, confused. I reached out and caught it before he even tried again. “Thanks,” I said, flat. His mouth opened then shut. No laugh track. Weird. At lunch I tested it again. I spilled milk reaching for my pizza (don’t judge; they only give you one slice unless you bribe someone), and the watch buzzed like a tiny angry bee. I pressed the button and everything reeled backward. The milk sucked itself off the table and back into my carton, my elbow swung forward then back, and my stomach flipped like I’d just stepped off the top stair thinking there was another. There was a cost, if I’d been paying attention. At the time it just felt like I’d run up a flight of stairs too fast, a little breathless, a stretch in my calves. No big deal. I did it again when Mr. Jamison called on me in Algebra and I blanked. Rewind fifteen seconds, remember that x was not actually a letter you could declare war on, and solve it confidently with numbers that behaved. Twice more when I missed the bus—back it up, sprint harder, grab the door. By the third time, I was lightheaded. By the fourth, my watch arm felt like the bones inside were zapping themselves awake. At home, the watch glided off my wrist like it knew where it lived now. It warmed up on the nightstand. I lay on my bed and stared at it. My phone pinged with texts from Jason about a new video game level and a GIF of a skateboarding cat falling into a bush. I wanted to show him the watch. I wanted to show everyone, actually, but there was a little voice in my head that sounded like my mother saying, if it glows and doesn’t have a label, don’t tell strangers about it. It was the kind of night where homework multiplies like Gremlins in a bathtub. I rewound when my history paragraph came out lame, rewound when my mom called me for dinner and I wanted five more minutes, rewound because my sister Naomi beat me to the last piece of garlic bread and I’m not proud but I slid the hunting ground back thirty seconds and grabbed it first. “Wow,” Naomi said, eyebrows raised. “Puberty gave you fangs.” I rolled my eyes with all the power of a small planet, but she kept looking at me. Like really looking. “Did you… grow?” she asked slowly. It was silly. I shoved another piece of bread in my mouth. “No.” “Your voice,” she said. “Just then. It was—Sam? You okay?” I wasn’t. That was the thing. I felt too big in my jeans. I felt like my socks were cutting into my ankles. When I stood, my head cleared the kitchen cabinets a smidge more than it had that morning. I laughed because that was the only response available, and the laugh rumbled, low and weird in my throat like I had a cold. When I hugged Mom before bed (because her rules are like gravity, you can’t fight them), she stiffened. “You smell different,” she said, then shook her head. “Laundry. I must’ve used the other detergent. Go brush your teeth, you smell like garlic.” I went to the bathroom to brush and froze when I looked up. It was me. It was mostly me. The face in the mirror had my nose, my mouth, my eyes, but my jaw was sharper. My hair seemed thicker, darker. I leaned in and a shadow that wasn’t there in the morning clung along my upper lip. My cheekbones were trying out for varsity. When I made a face, the mirror me made it too, but there was a half-second delay between me and him, like a video chat with bad Wi-Fi. I laughed again, testing. It came out lower. Not Dad-low. Not voiceover-in-a-truck-commercial low. Just less helium, more… human. “Cool,” I whispered. The mirror whispered back. And then, for a breath, the bathroom was a tunnel and all the sound fell away and the light bloom from the watch reflected in the glass and— The face in the mirror wasn’t mine. Not exactly. Older, by years. The jaw fully carved, the hair shorter, the pupils ringed with a pale light that made my scalp itch. Acne constellation across the forehead, a small scar under the chin I didn’t recognize. The expression was the worst part. The older-me looked scared and tired, and he mouthed something I couldn’t hear. “—stop—” I think it was. Then the faucet dripped, normal sound rushed back in, and it was just me in the mirror again with toothpaste on my chin and a heart that was trying to claw out of my ribcage. I slept with the watch under my pillow like a talisman. I dreamed in reverse. I dreamed my first day of school played backwards, shoelaces tightening themselves, chalk marks retreating into the stick, kids laughing rewinded into silence. In the morning, I had to adjust the strap, two notches looser. The watch hummed against skin that felt too new. School wasn’t right. It was like someone had nudged everything a half inch to the left. Ryan didn’t sneer at me when I walked past him by the lockers. He… nodded. A cautious, guy-nod, the kind I’d only ever seen between players on the basketball team. Jason stared at me from across the hallway and didn’t wave, which, to be fair, is normal because Jason is allergic to displays of affection, but when he came up at break he stopped a full arm’s length away like I might bite. “Dude,” he said. He squinted. “Your voice.” “Yeah,” I said, stepping closer because we were best friends and that’s what we did. He stepped back. He rubbed his wrist like the skin there itched. “I had the weirdest dream last night,” he said. “We were studying together and you kept getting the answers before me, and you were being a jerk about it, and it felt like—weird deja vu. Like it happened but didn’t. And today you’re—” He made a vague circling motion around his own face. “Did you get taller?” “Mmm.” I tried to lean on the wall like I’d seen older kids do, casual and cool, and almost fell over because my center of gravity was on vacation. “New shampoo?” he asked. “You smell like… my dad. After he mows the lawn.” He looked unsettled. People were moving around us, and they were moving around me, not through me; they gave me space like I took up more of it now. I went through the morning flattened by that strangeness, each class a scene from a movie I’d already watch but with new lines dubbed in. When I raised my hand, teachers called on me without hesitation. In gym, Mr. Crane tossed me a basketball, and when I braced for it, my palms stung from the impact because the pass had been harder. “Good hands,” he said, and then, to the whole class, “Sam’s with the eighth-graders for scrimmage.” “I’m not—” I started, and then didn’t finish because I knew better than to argue with Mr. Crane about gravity. The watch vibrated during last period, a steady pulse like it was a heart and mine was just a lazy echo. Under the desk, I tapped the button because the itch to do it was a habit by now, a map in my muscles. The clock over the door slid backwards. The text we were reading retreated into the book. The girl next to me spoke, unsaid her words, and then held them safe in her mouth. The room rocked back and then forward. My breath went frosty, then warm. The watch’s face flashed. For a fraction of a second, I felt a pressure in my bones, in my teeth, in my skull, like the universe had placed me between two wrong magnets. When the bell rang and we spilled into the hallways, it happened. I don’t know how else to explain it except that the world… edited itself. The posters lining the walls weren’t for the dance this Friday; they were for a fundraiser for the Science Olympiad. The trophy case at the front that had held our sad little JV soccer plaque now had a gleaming new silver cup. The kid who always wore a red beanie was bareheaded and no one seemed to notice, including the kid himself. And Mr. Crane, who had taught gym since the dawn of time, shouted to someone about Coach Hale leading track and I had never heard of Coach Hale before that second. I sprinted to the bathroom because it was the only place that stood still. The tile was the same institutional off-white. The hum of the lights was the same migraine-inducing drone. I grabbed the sink. My palms were slick. I lifted my head and looked in the mirror. I recognized the face like you recognize someone who says your name on a bus. Me, if the dial had been turned up two clicks after homeroom. Me, if someone had stretched me out and printed me on heavier paper. The stubble was darker. The scar under my chin wasn’t there—thank God—but my eyes were ringed with the kind of shadow you get from not sleeping because you’ve been pressing a button you shouldn’t all night. Behind my reflection, the bathroom door opened and a seventh-grader I didn’t know walked in, taking up the same amount of space a normal human should. He saw me, faltered, and ducked into a stall with the quickness of prey. “Hey,” I said. It came out as a growl. It came out like the sound older kids make when they’ve decided you are in their way and they need you not to be. The door creaked. He didn’t answer. A beat. The watch hummed. The light over the mirror flickered and, like a projector had slipped in its reel, the reflection stuttered and I saw him again—the older-me, the me from last night’s flicker, mouth forming words faster than I could understand. “Don’t,” he said. This time I heard it. “You can’t fix it by breaking it harder.” “I didn’t—” I said to the mirror, to myself. The words sounded like lies as they left my mouth. Outside, the hallway erupted in shrieks. Not the fun kind. The kind with fracture lines. I stumbled to the door and peered out. A cluster of kids were jammed near the trophy case. The silver cup was on the floor. Someone had pulled the fire alarm, red light strobing a headache against the white paint. Water didn’t shower down; the sprinkler heads remained obstinately dry because this was not a Hollywood set. But someone had slipped on the cup, and there was blood on the floor, and a girl I sort-of knew from math was crying, her hands over her mouth, making fish gasps. I knew this scene. I didn’t, but I did. I could feel the tug of it in my muscles, the habit flickering through me like a glitch. I saw the moment where I rewound to fix it. Pull the cup upright before anyone trips. Stop the alarm. Slide back thirty seconds and be the hero. The watch buzzed like an insect caught between window panes. It wanted. Or I wanted, and it felt like the same thing. I pushed out into the hall, and people moved. They made space. They watched. It was like the building held its breath again, waiting for what I would do. I could rewind. Maybe I could get back before it tipped. Maybe the silver cup would rest safely behind glass. Maybe the kid on the floor—the one clutching his arm with a look like a broken plate—would be upright and joking about it by lunch. Or I could swallow the wanting. I could let time move forward and trust it to patch itself with the clumsy glue it always had. I could stop breaking it to fix it. My thumb hovered over the button. Memory slapped me. The garlic bread stolen back. The test answer chosen twice. The bus I never missed. The laugh that had shifted in my chest. The way Mom’s hug had felt wrong, like I’d borrowed a different boy’s bones. The mirror. The warning. Outside the front doors, sirens wailed. That was new. Or it had always been. I didn’t know anymore. “Sam!” I turned. Jason stood there, pale, eyes huge in a face that refused to admit we weren’t eleven anymore. He took a step toward me, then stopped like his shoes were glued. “You’re scaring me,” he said. The watch vibrated in a long, pleading hum. The light inside pulsed. For a split second, the hallway strobed with the same blue as the watch face. Every poster’s ink leached backward, colors softening like wet chalk. The fire alarm’s light stalled mid-blink. I pressed the button. The world slammed into reverse. Air whooshed back into my lungs. The noise of the hallway turned inside out and then was gone. The silver cup rose, a gleam of victory, and flew backward into its case. The boy on the floor stood, whole, stumbled backward through steps he hadn’t yet taken. The fire alarm rewound its cry into silence. And me—I felt age peel off like a sunburn, hurt like a growing pain run in reverse, like knees smoothing their complaints back into bone. My shoes loosened. The stubble melted like soap. My voice, which had settled like a stone in my throat, lifted upward into something higher, familiar. In the mirror, when I threw my weight back toward the bathroom, my face flickered toward me. Actually me. Except—the older-me was there too, a frame he couldn’t help appearing in whenever the light hit. He smiled like you do when you’ve almost dropped something important and then caught it by the corner. Or like you don’t know if you have yet. We landed. The hallway was a hallway again. A moment late and no one on the floor. The trophy case whole. Kids confused because they had run and then not. A draft whispered along the ceiling, and the watch cooled on my wrist like a fever breaking. Jason’s face was near mine. He blinked. “Dude?” he said. “You okay?” “Yeah,” I said. I sounded young. My voice cracked on the y in a way that would have humiliated me yesterday but felt like a party today. “I—yeah.” He peered at me. There was a crease between his eyebrows, but it wasn’t fear. Curiosity, maybe. Relief. He didn’t step back this time when I reached to grab his sleeve. He smelt like pencil shavings and mint gum. The bathroom called me like a magnet. I slipped inside, closed the door, and turned to the mirror. I braced myself. Me. A real me. The one from two days ago, or close enough I couldn’t tell the difference. No jawline carved by a knife. No shadow in the wrong place. A tiny pimple was reasserting its sovereignty on my chin like a flag. The light flickered. For a heartbeat, the older face slid through again, just as a reminder that I was not someone who always learned the first time. He mouthed something I think I understood without hearing it. “Maybe,” he said. “Maybe.” Maybe I’d fixed it this time. Maybe the timeline had stitched itself around the place I had poked it. Maybe there was a cost banked somewhere I hadn’t paid yet. The watch sat cool on my wrist, quiet. It looked like a normal thing. It was not. I lifted my hand and, without touching it, covered the face. It had the weight of a promise in it, like a sleeping animal. I took a breath and the air tasted like old toothpaste and school soap and relief. Out in the hall, the bell rang. Time moved forward, one unremarkable second after another, pretending that was all it had ever wanted. I let it. I washed my hands. I didn’t press the button. I didn’t press the button. Not then. But later, when I was alone with the watch in the
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece effectively captures the Goosebumps-style teen horror genre while adding a layer of emotional complexity often missing from middle-grade fiction. The story follows Sam, who discovers a mysterious watch with time-rewinding capabilities, only to realize each use ages them prematurely. The narrative excels in its first-person perspective, creating an authentic middle school voice that balances humor with growing dread. The protagonist's casual tone ("I have never learned a single cautionary tale in my life") establishes both character and foreshadowing effectively. The gradual realization of the watch's consequences unfolds naturally, with physical changes described in concrete, relatable terms rather than abstract concepts. The story's pacing is particularly strong. It begins with small, seemingly inconsequential uses of the watch (catching a paper, avoiding spilled milk) before escalating to more significant timeline alterations. This progression creates mounting tension while maintaining narrative coherence. The physical toll of using the watch is introduced subtly ("a little breathless, a stretch in my calves") before developing into more alarming changes. The character relationships add emotional depth. The interactions with Jason, the protagonist's best friend, effectively illustrate the social consequences of Sam's transformation. The moment when Jason says "You're scaring me" carries genuine emotional weight. Similarly, the brief interactions with family members provide context for Sam's normal life that's being disrupted. The prose balances descriptive quality with age-appropriate language. Metaphors like the watch glowing "like the surface of a still pond" and time pausing "like the school held its breath" are vivid without being overwrought. The author skillfully employs sensory details throughout, particularly in describing the physical sensations of rewinding time. The dialogue is natural and character-specific, with distinct voices for the protagonist, Jason, and family members. It effectively conveys information while revealing character traits and relationships. The story builds to a climactic moment with genuine stakes—the accident at the trophy case—forcing Sam to make a meaningful choice about using the watch. The resolution avoids an overly neat conclusion, with the ominous final line suggesting the protagonist hasn't fully learned their lesson, maintaining the horror element. There are a few minor weaknesses. The story occasionally relies on telling rather than showing, particularly when explaining the protagonist's feelings. Some metaphors, while effective, verge on being slightly purple ("the universe had placed me between two wrong magnets"). The ending feels slightly rushed and incomplete, though this may be intentional to create suspense. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that honors the Goosebumps tradition while elevating it with stronger character development and emotional resonance. It successfully balances supernatural elements with relatable middle school experiences, creating a compelling narrative that would engage the target audience. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 4 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 4.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Noir romance: Carnival of Dangerous Intentions — Score: 91.2
Prompt:
Carnival of Dangerous Intentions Coney Island, New York, July 1937. She stopped just before reaching the shooting gallery set up along the boardwalk. It was near dusk, and the carnival lights were buzzing on. **His locks**. The words flashed through her mind, again, like an intruder. Such an old-fashioned turn of phrase that kept surfacing, and something else -- dangerously compelling -- quickly suppressed, lest she question why she had returned here at all. This place where she had promised to meet the stranger -- the young man with the obsidian curls and even darker eyes. She didn't even know his name. Write a scene in a larger story inspired by this prompt. The scene should capture an atmosphere that blends romantic allure with an undercurrent of subtle danger or moral ambiguity. Think 50 shades, but with a more restrained classic sensibility. The scene is all about establishing tension. Write for the feminine perspective. Include roughly 50% dialogue, 20% internal monologue, and 30% exposition and scene setting. The tone should have some edge to it. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The bulbs above the shooting gallery buzzed like fat insects, halos stuttering in the sodium-washed dusk. The brine in the air had a sweetness tonight, like wet sugar left too long on a counter. Wooden ducks glided past the rifles’ mouths, paint rubbed off their beaks by a thousand nickel bullets. To the right, the Ferris wheel turned slow as a thought one was trying not to have. The boardwalk’s planks vibrated, alive with unseen footsteps, and she moved one pace closer, then stopped. His locks. The phrase came, ridiculous and too intimate, as if she’d slipped into the wrong dress. His locks. As if she had claim to them, to that gloss of black hair she’d watched move like smoke under the streetlamp when they’d spoken. As if claim was her intention. She pressed a thumbnail into the quick of her ring finger until the ache sharpened into something like a boundary. “You made it.” His voice was low and amused, and she didn’t need to turn to know the pitch of it. She had rehearsed that pitch in the sink mirror this afternoon, lips forming replies she hoped were both careless and careful. He drifted into view beside her, and the carnival painted him in strips—light, dark, light again, like reveal and concealment were ambient. “You didn’t tell me your name,” she said, looking ahead, where the boy with the prizes had fallen asleep on a crate, chin buried in a pile of cheap lions. They had orange yarn manes and off-kilter eyes. “You didn’t ask,” he said. She felt the ghost of his breath near her temple. “Or maybe you liked not knowing.” “Maybe.” She slid him a look, shy made feral by the charge in the evening. He wore no hat, though every man seemed to tonight, his curls free and too much. His suit was the color of an evening bruise, and the line of his jaw was precise enough to cut fruit on. He bought a five-shot clip and handed her the rifle. The metal was cool in her palms. “You know how?” he asked. She lifted it to her shoulder and felt the stock settle into a place she hadn’t known was there. The ducks glided on, relentless, their glass eyes making lazy judgment. She had not shouldered a rifle since Uncle Henry’s farm, when summer could still burn clean through a person. “Yes,” she said. The weight centered her. The world shrank to barrel and bead, a neat little tunnel through which a bullet could pierce the identical smiles of painted birds. “Take the one with the scar,” he said, pointing. A scratched beak, a gouge in the paint. “Something honest about damage.” “You think?” She exhaled, let her cheek rest against the oiled wood. Interesting, how the body remembers and betrays. “I think you notice more than you say,” he said. “One on the left. Now.” She shot and missed. The duck sailed on, smug. He huffed a laugh. “Worse things than missing.” “I suppose for men,” she said. She fired and clipped the next one’s tail. Wood cracked, and a dull bell rang. She felt it more than heard it, in the cavity of her ribs. God, the sound. It was not success. It was impact. It was proof. “We can trade,” he said. “I tell you a name. You tell me a truth.” He held out his hand for the rifle, and she passed it without looking, so that their fingers only brushed. Electricity is a cliché, but clichés endure because some things are precisely that simple, precisely that brutal. “Go on,” she said. “Milo,” he said. The syllables slid into his mouth like something he wished to taste again, then he ruined it with a grin. “Or Peter. Or Tommy. Which do you like?” “None of those,” she said. “They all belong to someone else.” His locks. The phrase was petulant and sweet, like a spoiled child. He ought to belong to someone else. Then what was she doing here? “Alright,” he said, and shot the scarred duck without blinking. It fell with a clatter like teacups, and the boy behind the counter woke, startled, then smiled with all his teeth, all the gaps glinting. “Lady’s prize,” the boy said, rubbing his eyes with a fist. He offered her a lion with a bent ear. “Keep it,” she said. “Save it for a child.” She had not meant to sound hard, but the refusal came out like a stone dropped in a bucket. The boy’s mouth twitched in a way that suggested she had been read correctly. That she was no one’s aunt tonight. Milo—she refused to call him that—leaned his hip against the counter and let the rifle hang in his fingers. “You have the look of someone playing truant,” he said. “Even on a boardwalk that is essentially a shrine to truancy.” “I’ve come from church,” she lied. “Ah,” he said, and lowered his voice to something confessional. “I tend to find my devotions elsewhere.” “You tend to find them anywhere,” she said. It was unkind, and also a compliment. She could feel her own mouth ask for trouble. He smiled, not offended. “And you?” His locks. She wanted to slide her hand into that blackness, to test the spring. Not for sweetness. For control. The thought glinted and frightened her. “I tend to be wary of men with too much hair,” she said. “It feels undisciplined.” “Oh,” he said softly. “You like discipline.” He said it in the way of a man tossing a coin to see which way it turns. She stiffened, but only inside. The fortune teller’s booth was not ten feet away, its glass smudged with the fingerprints of the curious. A chart of palms was taped crookedly in the window, lines labeled with elegant script—heart line, life line, mount of Venus—as if the hand was a map to which places there was no train. A paper moon hung from the ceiling, its face asleep. A painted woman inside watched them through the gloom, eyes lined with coal, a scarf wrapped around hair that had once been gold and now was the yellow of old piano keys. Her gaze had the flat shine of a cat’s. “Do you believe in fate?” he asked, following her glance. “I believe in choices,” she said. I believe in standing too close to danger until it looks like an option. “You made one,” he said. “You chose to come.” “Don’t flatter yourself,” she said lightly. “I came for the sea.” “And the rifles and the lions,” he murmured. “And—what do you call them—his locks?” Her spine went hot. She saw nothing in his face to suggest he had plucked that phrase from her mind. Ridiculous. Of course he hadn’t. It must have been on her lips in some form, something too guileless that had escaped. She could feel the blood under her skin in a way that made her want to scratch it. She said nothing. “Let me win you something you don’t deserve,” he said. “That’s half of courtship.” “I don’t accept charity,” she said. “Then you can pay later,” he said, so easy it was almost kind, and took another shot that knocked a duck from its march. He passed her the lion before she could protest, and she held it because to refuse twice felt petty. The yarn was rough against her wrist, and the off-kilter eyes were forgiving. She tucked it under her arm like contraband. The fortune teller lifted a finger and crooked it. The gesture was martial. The woman’s hand was heavy with rings, each one a small pronouncement. She stood, and the chair complained. “Come,” she said through the glass. Her voice carried even with the window shut, as if the heavy air conspired. “You’re wasting money on bullets when you could buy knowledge.” “I prefer my ignorance cheap,” she said, but the woman’s eyes had already included her. The young man raised a brow. “Afraid?” “Of paper moons?” She could smell clove smoke from the booth, something a little medicinal under the perfume. Under her flippancy was a hum: a different kind of discipline. One of being read out loud. “You first,” she said. He laughed. “I never let a stranger sort me before I play the game,” he said. “It feels like bearing one’s throat.” “Good,” she said. “Then you do know about throats.” She surprised herself. The sound he made was not quite laughter now. She stepped up to the booth. The woman opened the pane with a reluctant squeal that seemed to pull at the evening. “Your palm,” the fortune teller said. “I don’t—” she began. “Your left,” the woman said, as if discussing a shoe. “The heart lies there.” She placed her hand in that warm, dry grasp. The fortune teller’s thumb pressed into the tender meat under her thumb, and a jolt shot up, unromantic and precise. Touch finds the truth faster than talk, she thought. “You walk like you’re balancing a tray you are not allowed to drop,” the woman said without looking. “You put the weight on your toes. You like to be seen leaving less than you like to be seen arriving.” “That is many women,” she said. Her voice sounded higher than she wanted. “Not many like you,” the woman said. “You’re afraid of softness, not of hardness.” The mounted chart behind her showed the mounts named for gods, little hills that promised appetites. “You tell everyone that,” she said. “I tell no one anything if they don’t ask,” the woman said, and there it was: the little cruelty, like salt in the sugar. “He has secrets he wants you to discover so that he can be absolved. You, on the other hand, want to be the secret.” “Is that a trick?” she asked, and risked a quick glance at him. He had his hands in his pockets and was watching with that agreeable focus men use when they feel a door may open in a room they weren’t sure they were allowed in. The lights made rungs up the side of his throat. “No trick,” the woman said. “You like edges. You will ask for the thing and then punish the giver for handing it to you.” She traced the line across her palm. “You have a way of breaking the rules so quietly no one hears the snap.” She pulled her hand back, unnerved. The woman did not scold. The paper moon smiled its dumb smile over everything. “How much?” she said, reaching into her handbag so she could do something. “Pay when you’ve spent it,” the fortune teller said. “Or don’t. It will cost you regardless.” She shut the window with a curt finality that felt like a pardon. He was closer when she turned, as if some string had drawn them. “What did she say?” he asked. “That I’m mean to men who deserve it,” she said. The lie had a little truth in it, like all decent lies. “And do I?” “Deserve it?” She tilted her head, letting the amusement sit like a veil between them. “No.” She let him take the lion from under her arm and toss it idly, as if she had decided something she didn’t want to name. He reached, then stopped his hand before touching her elbow, a courtesy that was also an invitation. “The pier?” he asked. “It’s cooler there.” “I don’t want to be cold,” she said. Wind lifted in a perfect ribbon and ran under her skirt, sawing the humidity into slices. “Besides, your hair might blow away.” “Then hold it,” he said, and the audacity of it made something low in her stomach laugh. Recklessness wore gentility well tonight. Sometimes it does. She reached up and took a curl between forefinger and thumb, testing its spring. Dark, yes. Obedient to her for exactly as long as she held it. When she let go, it fell back into place, defiant, unchanged. He did not move away. “You do like discipline,” he said very quietly. “I like choosing,” she said, just as quiet. “That’s not the same.” “Isn’t it?” His eyes were more shadow than pupil now. The Ferris wheel sent a slow wheel of blue light across his cheek. Somewhere, a girl squealed as if surprised by the very thing she’d demanded. Her heart tapped her ribs, impatient. His locks. The words were a ribbon around her throat, tightening and loosening by degrees. The boardwalk creaked under them—so many secrets pressed between the planks, sticky with sugar and salt. This could still be nothing. Or it could be a story she would not tell anyone and also could never stop telling. “Walk me,” she said, finally, and refused to read any more into the word than it contained. He tipped his head as if accepting a job. He did not offer his arm. He didn’t have to. He matched her; he let the half inch of distance breathe its little flame. They moved past the rifles, past the boy who had already sunk back into a dream, the lion’s yarn mane scratching her inner elbow where she had tucked it again. The fortune teller lit a cigarette and looked away from them, an act of mercy or judgment, who could say. “Tell me something true,” he said as they passed under a bunting that had frayed into tassels. His voice went easy, as if this were all we were meant to do. “Anything.” She watched the sea make its endless small negotiations with the shore, the carnival noise riding over it like gossip over prayer. She thought of the woman’s thumb, the notch of the rifle against the soft underbone of her cheek, the shot she had missed and the one she had taken anyway. “I don’t forgive easily,” she said. “And I don’t apologize when I don’t regret.” She waited, not sure who she was warning. He made a sound that could have been gratitude. “Then don’t make me regret it,” he said. “Make you?” She smiled so he wouldn’t see there was a question under the question. “That’s your job.” The dusk tightened, the bulbs hummed, and they walked on. The edge presented itself over and over in different forms, and she chose, again and again, to place one foot precisely upon it.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece demonstrates remarkable skill in creating a tense, atmospheric scene that perfectly balances romantic allure with subtle danger. The writer has crafted a sophisticated narrative that captures the feminine perspective with psychological depth and nuance. The prose is exceptionally strong, with evocative imagery that brings 1937 Coney Island to life. Descriptions like "The bulbs above the shooting gallery buzzed like fat insects" and "The brine in the air had a sweetness tonight, like wet sugar left too long on a counter" create a sensory-rich environment that feels both authentic to the period and slightly dreamlike. The dialogue is particularly impressive—natural yet charged with subtext. The conversation between the protagonist and the mysterious man reveals character while maintaining tension. Their verbal sparring has the quality of a dance, with each line advancing the subtle power dynamics between them. The fortune teller's dialogue adds another layer of intrigue and foreboding. The internal monologue effectively conveys the protagonist's conflicted desires and self-awareness. Lines like "I believe in choices... I believe in standing too close to danger until it looks like an option" reveal her psychology with elegant economy. The recurring phrase "His locks" works as an effective motif that represents her forbidden attraction. The piece maintains a consistent tone throughout—sophisticated, restrained, yet with an undercurrent of danger that grows more pronounced as the scene progresses. The writer has achieved the requested blend of romantic allure and moral ambiguity, creating a protagonist who is drawn to the edge while remaining self-aware about her choices. The scene balances dialogue, internal monologue, and exposition in proportions close to what was requested. The dialogue comprises roughly half the piece, with internal thoughts and scene-setting making up the remainder in appropriate measure. There are a few moments where the prose verges on being too ornate ("The Ferris wheel turned slow as a thought one was trying not to have"), but these instances generally serve the atmospheric quality of the piece rather than detracting from it. The writing maintains control even in its most lyrical passages. The ending is particularly strong, leaving the reader with a sense of anticipation and unresolved tension that would propel them into the next scene. The final line—"The edge presented itself over and over in different forms, and she chose, again and again, to place one foot precisely upon it"—perfectly encapsulates the protagonist's character and the central tension of the piece. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted scene that demonstrates mastery of dialogue, character development, and atmospheric writing. It successfully creates the requested tension while maintaining a sophisticated literary quality throughout. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Surreal horror: Caribou Season at the Lodge — Score: 85.0
Prompt:
Caribou Season at the Lodge Genre: Surreal Horror JT knew something wasn't right from the moment they'd pulled up to the lodge. It looked exactly as it had every autumn of his life—the cedar shingles silvered with age, the porch sagging gently under weight of winters past—but the air felt thicker, somehow, as if the woods had leaned in closer, waiting. He thought maybe he was just tired. Maybe it was nothing more than the long drive north, cramped in the back of the truck beside his older brother Mike -- and a stack of rifles wrapped in oily canvas. Still, the feeling lingered. The first caribou they found that season hadn't bolted. It had just watched, ears flicking lazily, waiting for the shot. JT had felt a crawling in his gut watching it die, noticing how it fell with a quiet dignity—as though it had wanted nothing more. Nobody else seemed to find it odd, or at least they didn't say so. JT kept his mouth shut. Always safer that way. Then there was the moment in the clearing. JT had fallen behind, fumbling with bootlaces stiff from the cold, and by the time he'd caught up with his father and brother, they'd already stopped. JT slowed instinctively, ducking behind a tangle of brush, staring out into the open space where a massive buck stood utterly still, chest rising and falling in slow, deep breaths. The animal looked…wrong, somehow. Maybe it was the eyes—dark and flat, calm in a way that made JT's neck prickle. Or maybe it was something deeper, something in the way the buck stood close enough for his father to reach out and touch it. JT watched as his father raised a trembling hand toward the animal's muzzle. His father's face had a strange expression, eyes too bright, lips parted slightly, like he was on the verge of whispering something—a secret, maybe. The rifle hung uselessly at his side, forgotten. Mike had the same dazed look in his eyes. JT's breath stopped short, his mind suddenly shouting at him to look away, turn around, just run—but he couldn't move. And then, as suddenly as it had begun, it was over. The buck shivered, startled by something unseen, and disappeared into the brush without so much as a sound. The two of them looked around, confused, seemingly surprised to find themselves where they stood. JT stayed hidden, breathing shallowly, fear mingling with a confused sense of shame. His father had failed to take the shot. To even think about mentioning what he'd seen would have felt like betrayal—or something worse. JT waited until the others moved on before stepping out from cover. He stared into the empty clearing for a long, uneasy moment, wondering if anything had really happened at all, or if he was losing his grip. Maybe the woods were finally getting into his head. Writing Instructions: Continue with the next chapter of the story, maintaining a style reminiscent of Stephen King—grounded realism blended seamlessly with unsettling surrealism. The atmosphere should convey subtle dread, isolation, and psychological ambiguity. JT's perspective is crucial, yet he is an unreliable narrator, caught in uncertainty about what he's perceiving. Establish an undertone of creeping dread, establishing the isolation of JT's perspective, which he largely keeps to himself. Incorporate some dialogue. Build tension towards a payoff. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The second night the wind came up out of the north and set the lodge to talking. The old timbers popped and sighed like they were remembering other winters, older ones, maybe before the roof was stapled with tin and the porch rail was carved with cigarette burns in the shape of fish hooks. The three of them sat at the kitchen table eating venison stew. The meat was from that first caribou—the one that had stood and watched them. JT kept thinking about the way it had tipped over in the moss, like a man lying down for an afternoon nap. He lifted a spoonful and it trembled near his lips, trembling the same way his father’s hand had, the hand reaching toward the buck. The stove ticked. Mike talked too much, a sure sign he was nursing something tight and hot inside him. Their father didn’t talk at all. He ate methodically, glancing sometimes at the window like he heard a voice out there. “You got that call from Darleen?” Mike asked, not looking at anyone in particular. “About the snowmobile? She said the drive belt’s cracked. Could go whenever.” “Mm,” their father said. It meant Yes. It meant No. It meant I don’t know. “Could try the general store in town,” Mike went on. “Ned might have one. Or we could cannibalize the old one in the shed.” “Eat,” their father said. He said it softly, almost pleadingly. He didn’t look at either of them. His spoon dipped and rose. A fleck of broth ran his knuckle and hung there, a tiny amber bead, praying for gravity. JT forced the spoon into his mouth. It tasted too clean and too iron-rich. He felt the meat come apart with a lazy grace, like threads in a sweater. He swallowed and it seemed to stick halfway down. He chased it with a sip of beer and the beer tasted like pennies. “You okay?” Mike asked him. “You look peaked.” “Fine,” JT said. “Long day,” Mike said. “Long drive yesterday, too.” “Mm,” their father said. The quiet after stretched. The wind found a crack and made a thin sound, like someone whistling for a dog far off. JT put his spoon down carefully, like it might clatter and wake something in the room. He thought of the clearing, of the way his father’s face had changed. Not softened—emptied, as if something had come in through his eyes and made itself a home behind them. He’d seen that look only one other time, when their mother had been sick and the pastor came, standing in the doorway with his book held up like a loaf of bread. Their father had looked hungry then, too, with nothing for it. “I thought I saw something today,” JT said. He didn’t know he was going to say it until the words were already out. “In the clearing. Before…” He stopped. He felt the stew slosh in his belly and go cold. “Before what?” Mike asked. Their father’s spoon clicked against the bowl. He set it down and pushed back from the table so his knees bumped the underside. He stood, chair legs rasping on the floor. He went to the sink, turned on the tap, and let the water run. It ran and ran. He stared at it like it might eventually confess something. “Nothing,” JT said. “Doesn’t matter.” “Tomorrow, we go out early,” their father said, still staring at the water. “Before sunup. Fresh sign then. I want to see where they’re crossing.” “Sure,” Mike said, relief evident in the way he leaned back, the way his mouth softened into a half-smile. Orders were better than silence. The water ran. The lodge creaked. Outside, the wind made a low, sustained note, like someone blowing over the mouth of a bottle. JT washed dishes. He felt a little crazy doing it—his hands in hot, greasy water, his mind trying to rearrange the day into something that fit. Mike dried and stacked the plates, humming tunelessly. Their father went to the mantel and picked up the picture of their mother. He turned it over. He set it back down. He did not look at the two of them. When the chores were done, they sat and played a lazy game of cribbage until the colors of the cards turned muddy in the lamplight. JT let his mind drift. Every so often an image would float up—the buck’s nostrils barely flaring, his father’s hand—then he would push it down gently, like pressing a bubble back under dishwater. They slept in the bunkroom with the window cracked to keep the air from getting stale. JT’s bunk was the upper. He lay awake and watched the rectangle of the window slowly go black. In the blackness, he saw the clearing pale as bone. He saw his father standing there with his hand lifted. He heard nothing but his own breath and, sometimes, a small creak as the bunk settled. He must have slept, because he woke to his brother’s alarm buzzing like a horse fly in a jar. They ate toast, thick with butter, and coffee so strong it felt like swallowed dirt. The world outside was still ink, the trees a darker black against the sky’s black. Their breath steamed. JT’s fingers felt swollen and wooden. He felt better with his rifle on his shoulder, an honest weight, something he could count. They followed the old logging road toward the bog. The snow was patchy, shallow islands formed in the shade, glazed hard as sugar. The morning was so quiet that when a jay called, it sounded obscene. Their father held his hand up once, twice, for stopping and listening. They did not speak. Their boots whispered in the frostbrittle grass. He’s fine, JT told himself. You made it up. You caught a weird angle. It’s nothing. But the wind was wrong, coming from everywhere, and every now and then he noticed his father’s head tilt slightly, like a man hearing his name called softly from the other room. At the bog, they found tracks. Fresh. Big prints, the weight of them making the peat ooze. Mike crouched and grinned. “Gonna be a big bastard,” he said. He was happy in the way he got—the simple arithmetic of sign and direction and distance, the way a path laid itself out under his boots. Their father didn’t smile. He bent and touched one print, the tip of one finger, quick, like testing a hot surface. He lifted his hand to his nose and sniffed. His eyes unfocused. For a moment, the old empty look came back, and JT’s stomach kicked. Then their father shook himself like a dog that’s been splashed. “Let’s go,” he said. “We’ll circle.” They circled. The prints led them through a stand of young fir that tickled their sleeves and hissed when they pushed through. A raven croaked somewhere to their left and was silent. JT’s ears felt full, like he’d just come up from underwater. He fell behind, not on purpose but the way you do when your head is full of pictures that look like memories but aren’t. His laces were not the problem; his fingers were. They were clumsy, good for nothing but getting in each other’s way. When he looked up, the other two were further ahead than he’d let them get all last season. They were silhouettes. He felt a small alarm bell go off but not in his head—in his chest, his throat, ringing the soft tissue there. He walked faster. He told himself he was not hurrying. The trees opened. There was the clearing. It was smaller than yesterday. Aren’t clearings supposed to look bigger the second time, when you don’t have the surprise of them? He thought that, and the thought itself felt like something that had been placed in his head by someone else’s hand. The place was bright with frost, every blade of brown grass outlined in white. The buck was there. The same buck or another that looked like him, which was the same. He stood in exactly the middle, head high, breath streaming. The breath glowed, as if it had its own light in it. His father and Mike were to the left this time. Their father’s hand lifted again. The same. No, not the same: the fingers this time were splayed a little wider, like he was feeling rain. He stepped forward. The rifle slid down on its sling and bumped his back with a hollow wooden sound that did not carry. JT could have said something. He could have said Dad. He could have said wait. The word formed in his mouth and then turned its face away, stubborn. He felt rooted. He felt as if the clearing had grown little roots out of its frost and stuck them into his boots, into the wet leather, into the meat of his feet. His father’s lips moved. JT could swear he saw that. His father whispered. It was nothing like a prayer that he’d ever heard, but then, he had not heard a lot of prayers. It had that cadence to it that prayers have, a kind of rhythmic pleading that falls and rises. Mike didn’t move at all. His eyes were shining, and he seemed to be trying to smile and having trouble understanding how that worked. The whole thing had a careful, deliberate fragility about it, like a spider web that had caught a drop of rain and was holding it in midair. The buck’s eyes were flat. No fear. No anything. There was that breath, streaming, a visible thing you could reach out and catch, and JT had the strange idea that if he raised his own hand, it would feel cold like the inside of the freezer. He thought of Leon Vance, the old man in town who sometimes nodded off on the bench outside the post office, the way his breath fogged and then was gone. He thought, maybe the woods were breathing through us. Maybe— “Dad,” he said. He didn’t mean to. It came out too loud. It came out like a sneeze, a word that has weight and decides to throw itself off a roof. The buck blinked. JT watched the lids come down and go up. He had never in his life seen that before. Animals blink, of course; he knew that. But the act of seeing it was like seeing a trick done slowly enough to understand it and still not understanding. Their father’s hand dropped as if someone had cut a string. The rifle swung into his hand as if it had always been there. The buck moved—no, it didn’t. JT later would tell himself it did, but really, it just appeared at the edge of the trees. The space it had occupied had frost in it again; the grass there looked crushed, and then it didn’t. Mike swore softly. “Shit,” their father said. He said it with a normal man’s irritation. He looked at JT with eyes that were just eyes. “If you’re going to call out, do it before we’re on top.” JT opened his mouth. Closed it. He felt heat in his face that stung. Shame’s heat, bright and busy. He wanted to say There was something wrong, it had you, it had you both, and he wanted to say nothing at all. “Let’s move,” Mike said quickly, too quickly, and shouldered past their father like he could push the moment out of the way physically. “We can get ahead of him if we cut down by the wash.” “Fine,” their father said. He started walking. JT watched him go. The rhythm of his step was normal. He could pick out the squeak of a leather strap, the soft thwock of wet grass snapping under boot soles. He breathed out and it hung in the air and then rose, shredded by the slightest breeze. They moved. They crashed more than they should have, and both of the other men pretended not to notice. Something had changed, though, and it was so small that if he tried to tell it later, he would hear himself and stop. The sky was brightening, a wash of lighter gray moving across the low clouds. The colors on the ground—greens and browns and the black of cold water—had all become one color he couldn’t name. He felt watched by everything. He felt watched by his own breath. They came to the wash, and JT was in front now because the way narrowed and he was the lightest. He crossed the old plank and felt it sag. The water underneath was eely black, sluggish. He thought about putting his hand into it. He thought about how far you could push your hand into a cold place before it stopped feeling like yours. “Careful,” Mike said behind him. “I know,” JT said. When he was across, he turned to watch them. Their father’s face was set. There was a smear of dirt on his jaw that made him look younger, like the man in the picture from when he first bought the lodge. Mike was grinning again, that bent look, the grin that meant he didn’t want to talk about something. They crossed. The plank creaked, and JT tasted a word: splinter. He swallowed it. The tracks picked up on the other side, but they were wrong. They were…multiple. A confusion. A churn that suggested running, and JT knew in that instant that nothing had run. He knelt and touched one. It was cold. It was a cold he had felt only one other place. “There,” Mike said, pointing. There was a flash in the trees—antler, maybe, or the ghost of antler, the idea of it. He took off at a trot, the focused joy of the chase lighting him up like a different person. Their father hesitated. He put a hand out and touched JT’s shoulder. The hand squeezed once. It was a real touch, callused and heavy. Then he was moving too. JT rose to follow and realized he didn’t know why he was trying so hard to keep up. The woods would get them where they were going, regardless. He had a moment of clarity that frightened him: he understood then that there was a path, whether or not he recognized it as one, and the path had an appetite. He did not have a word for that appetite. He tried to put the thought away as he tried to put all of them away, into the cupboard in his head where he kept the things that would otherwise rattle and spill. He went after them. The trees closed in. The ground sloped. There was a smell in the air now, faint and almost sweet. Not rot. Something like old apples, the kind that have gone soft in the cellar, the kind you pick up and your thumb goes right through. “Hold up,” he said. He didn’t expect them to. They didn’t. The idea of them not hearing him felt like a kindness, and that hurt, somehow. He came out into another open place—a narrow one, more like a room without walls. Moss underfoot, spongy. Their father and Mike stood side by side, their shoulders almost touching, looking at something in front of them with their heads a little bent. The way men look at a newborn through hospital glass. JT came up next to them and looked, too. It was not the buck. It was a thing he could describe easily—a tangle of fallen limbs, a drift of last year’s leaves that had held onto their curled shapes, a low hummock where the ground remembered a stump—but what he saw was this: a shape on the ground that made his skin fear itself. The way the limbs lay, the way the leaves had caught frost in a pattern like ribs, the way two sticks had fallen at the top in a suggestion of antlers. The sense of it was so powerful that his breath hitched. “No,” Mike said, and laughed once, one short barking sound meant to be dismissive. He stepped forward and nudged the shape with his boot. A dry rattle passed through it. The frost turned to tiny drops, and for an instant they held the light like beads of glass. JT thought of necklaces his mother had worn when she felt like it. He thought of her moving her hair out of the way. Their father knelt. He did it slowly, like he was taking a knee in church. He put his hand out. JT wanted to stop him. Didn’t. His father’s fingers brushed the pattern of frost. The drops trembled. He closed his eyes. “What are you doing?” Mike asked, irritated. “It’s nothing. It’s a—” He cast around for a word. Didn’t find a good one. “Pile.” Their father didn’t answer. His lips moved again, and this time JT heard it, or thought he did. He heard his father say, very softly, Please. The wind answered. It came through the trees and made a sound like breath drawn in. The frost went from drops to water all at once, a shift, a tipping point, and the shape changed; it didn’t move, it simply wasn’t the same any longer. It was a pile of sticks and leaves. Ordinary. So ordinary that JT wondered if he’d imagined the other thing, the seeable thing. He didn’t think he had. Their father opened his eyes. They were wet. He stood. He did it in a stiff way that said his knees hurt. He didn’t look at either of them. “We’re going back,” he said. “Now?” Mike looked at him like he’d suggested they go down to the lake for a swim in January. “We’re right in it. If we keep at it—” “Now,” their father said, and the word had the heavy common sense of a door being closed. “We’ve got what we came for.” “What?” JT asked. His father looked at him then. For the first time since the clearing the day before, he looked right at him, and the look hit JT like heat. There was no accusation in it, and no comfort, either. “We’ll talk at the lodge,” their father said, and started back the way they had come. On the way, the woods seemed to rearrange themselves. The bog was on the wrong side; the wash was longer. The plank had a new crack. JT felt the path move under him like a big animal shifting in its sleep. He didn’t say anything. Mike said nothing, either, his mouth set. Their father walked with his head up, impatient at twigs, unconcerned with the small cuts they left on his face. Back at the lodge, the light had gone thin. The porch sagged in greeting. Inside, the stove had gone dead. Mike set to work with paper and kindling like he needed to be noisily busy. Their father hung his rifle, took off his coat, hung it, took it down, hung it again. He went to the counter and put his palms on it. He breathed. “Dad,” Mike said. “You want to tell us what
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This continuation of the surreal horror story demonstrates considerable skill in maintaining the established atmosphere while developing the narrative. The piece effectively builds on the initial setup, preserving JT's perspective as an unreliable narrator caught between what he perceives and what he can rationalize. The prose style successfully emulates Stephen King's approach, blending mundane details with unsettling elements. The writer uses everyday activities—eating stew, washing dishes, playing cribbage—as a counterpoint to the creeping supernatural elements. This grounding in the ordinary makes the strange occurrences more effective. The dialogue is sparse but authentic, capturing the strained dynamics between family members. The father's minimal responses ("Mm") and Mike's nervous chatter effectively convey their psychological states without explicit explanation. The dialogue serves the narrative by revealing character and building tension rather than explaining the plot. The imagery is particularly strong. Descriptions like "the buck's nostrils barely flaring," the father's hand "splayed a little wider, like he was feeling rain," and frost drops that "held the light like beads of glass" create vivid, unsettling pictures. The writer skillfully uses sensory details to establish mood—the taste of pennies in beer, the sound of the wind "like someone whistling for a dog far off." The pacing builds tension effectively through the hunting expedition, with the discovery of the strange formation in the woods serving as a climactic moment. The father's unexplained reaction to this discovery—kneeling as if in church and whispering "Please"—adds to the mystery while suggesting deeper significance. However, the piece does have some weaknesses. The narrative occasionally becomes slightly meandering, particularly during the trek through the woods. Some metaphors, while evocative, verge on purple prose ("the idea of them not hearing him felt like a kindness, and that hurt, somehow"). The ending feels somewhat abrupt, though this may be due to the response being cut off mid-sentence. The psychological horror elements are handled with subtlety. Rather than explicit supernatural events, the story relies on ambiguity and suggestion—the way the buck seems to disappear and reappear, how the woods seem to "rearrange themselves," the father's strange behavior. This ambiguity effectively maintains JT's unreliable perspective, leaving readers to question what is real and what is imagined. Overall, this is a strong continuation that maintains the established tone and builds effectively on the initial setup. It successfully creates an atmosphere of dread and psychological uncertainty while developing the characters and advancing the plot. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 18 Believable Character Actions: 17 Nuanced Characters: 16 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 16 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 17 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 3 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 17 Overall Impression: 17
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 18.0, Believable Character Actions: 17.0, Nuanced Characters: 16.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 16.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 17.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 3.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 17.0, Overall Impression: 17.0
+ Fantasy-humour: Hell is Other Demons — Score: 95.7
Prompt:
Hell is Other Demons Write a day in the life short story. Lucifer morningstar's on again/ off again relationship with Lilith is currently in the "off again" stage, though the cycle may be coming around as Lilith has been stopping by for reasons other than purely violent ones, and Lucifer has been increasingly lonely. Write a day in the life of this power couple, with elements of dark comedy & fantasy. Use understated irony & absurdity by merging the black immorality and everyday business of running hell, against relatable domestic relationship drama. Take cues from Neil Gaiman. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The drizzle began at seven, which was late for ash. The forecast said “perpetual,” but the clouds had their own unions. It fell soft as dandruff on a kingdom of the damned, sifted into the coffee like gray sugar and landed on contracts, turning every signature into a faintly wintery scene. Lucifer pushed up the blinds in his office and watched it coat the river of fire, where the damned bobbed and complained about the temperature and the artisanal quality of their torment. He stirred his cup with a finger and frowned. Bitter. He added a splash of milk from a black carton labeled “Despair,” which, by the look of it, was expired two eternities ago. It curdled like a prophecy. “Schedule,” he called, and the door opened itself, because it was trained and because Hell never missed an excuse to be theatrical. Behemoth’s niece, a rhino-headed girl with a flair for organization, poked in. “Morning, sir. We’ve got the Lower Circle Audit at nine, pitchfork inspection at ten, eternal lamentation committee at eleven, and—” “The jingle,” he said, with the same resigned tone one uses for the word dentist. “The jingle.” He sighed. There was a time he had been the whisper in the ear and the suggestion at the edge of a prayer. Now he signed requisitions for pitchforks with ergonomic grips and listened to demons argue about a brand identity that didn’t look too… obvious. The jingle was part of a campaign to rebrand Hell as “Your Ultimate Accountability Partner,” which sounded like an app. “Have Marketing remembered we are not an artisanal burger joint?” he said. “They are insisting on ukuleles,” she said. “And a xylophone.” He picked ash from his sleeve. “Fine. Bring me their spirits.” “Team?” she asked, pen hovering. “Souls. Whatever we’re calling them. And a cloth.” He sat a moment, and listened. It was one of his better indulgences. Above him, the ash clicked softly against the bulb. Beyond the glass, an endless parade of bureaucratic torment shuffled on. The damned had opinions about everything here: the thread count in sackcloth, the ethical sourcing of brimstone, whether their suffering was being seen. He had always been a listener. It was how he’d gotten this job in the first place. The door slid back again. He did not look up. “It’s unlocked,” he said. “It’s Hell,” said Lilith. He looked anyway. She was not a storm. She was a weather pattern that had learned to wear heels. She slid in like she owned every shadow in the room and sat on the corner of his desk. Her perfume could have been smoke or could have been memory. Either clung. “If you’re here to kill me,” he said, “I’ve a window at four.” “Heads up you’ve got ash on your eyebrow,” she said, and flicked it off with a nail. “It makes you look… tired.” “I am tired,” he said. “And you did come yesterday and try to set my hair on fire.” She shrugged. “Old habits. It was affectionate.” “It was violent.” “It was affectionate violence. Also I brought muffins.” She held up a box that had once been white. The ash had given it a dust jacketing. Inside were six muffins: two blueberry, two despair-chocolate, one existential crisis with crumble, and something that looked like poppy seed but had an alarming tendency to whisper. “I apologize for the situation,” she said, awkwardly. The word sounded strange in her mouth, like she was trying on a shirt she didn’t like. “It’s… off again, yes?” He glanced at the muffins. “Which situation?” “The situation where I keep coming here to not kill you.” She passed him the existential crisis, which he took because there are pleasures even in damnation. “Also, the ash. You should really petition for better ventilation.” “I petitioned,” he said. “Heaven sent a memo. Weather is weather, and besides, ash is Hell’s seasonal aesthetic.” “Oh, darling,” she said, with that particular tone that meant he was not being dramatic enough. “Your eyebrows are going gray.” He sipped the coffee and then made the face of a man for whom coffee had turned out to be a question. “So you came to not murder me. Any other agenda items?” She leaned closer, as if to confide, and plucked a pen from his pocket. She wrote SINCE YOU ASK on his devil-signed contracts. “Recruitment,” she said. “You’re bleeding the good sinners to Limbo and Purgatory, and the dunes near the fifth circle are full of influencers. They complain. I thought you might need… counsel.” “I do not bleed,” he said. “There’s the ash again. It’s got into everything.” He did not say he had been lonely. It sat beside him in the chair, the shape of a conversation not yet had, the exact weight of her hip against his desk. Behemoth’s niece dropped the cloth and fled at the sight of Lilith. She was sensible. Most people were sensible when Lilith was a noun near them. The jingle committee arrived like a flock of anxious birds. Marketing was three demons in skinny ties and orange lanyards and one damned man who had been an advertising executive in life and thus had been given an office in Hell accordingly. They arranged themselves, apologized to Lilith for existing, and began to strum. “Your personal accountability partner,” sang a demon with horns arranged like a coiffure. “We’re the friend you can’t escape—” “Stop,” said Lucifer. “Why is there a glockenspiel.” “It sounds cheerful,” said the damned executive. “Millennials love glockenspiel.” “Millennials also love not being damned,” said Lilith, examining a blueberry muffin as if it were an animal that could sell her out. She looked up and smiled a smile that could cauterize. “And ukuleles. Why not a scream?” “We tested screams,” said the executive. “Screams underperform.” “Glockenspiel screams,” Lucifer said. He rubbed the bridge of his nose in a gesture stolen from mortals. Best to find humor. Best to find anything. “Fine. Logo?” They showed him a pitchfork with a friendly face. “No,” said Lilith. “It’s approachable,” said the executive. “It’s a fork,” she said. “It doesn’t approach. It impales.” “It’s 2024,” he said. “Approachability metrics are important, Lil—ma’am.” Lucifer folded his hands. “Thank you for your… work. We shall revisit after the eternal lamentation. Dismissed.” They fluttered out, leaving behind a scattering of ash and the haunted silence of a room that had narrowly avoided a violent rebranding. Lilith took his mug and sipped. “You’re soft.” “I am adaptable,” he said. He took the mug back, because boundaries. “And you’re here because… what? You want to be cruel? You want to be kind? You want to see if the drizzle ever stops?” “It never stops,” she said, and both of them looked out the window at the slow, consistent drift. A damned man slipped on it and went face-first into a moral quandary. “It’s comforting.” The eternal lamentation committee sent a representative who apologized for not lamenting more eternally. “We had scheduling conflicts,” said the representative, who looked like a burned-out HR generalist. “Some lamenters had appointed times to be gnawed.” “Gnawing can be rescheduled,” said Lucifer. “Eternity is a resource. Use it.” He signed three memos about chains, one about the proper storage of fire, and one petition from the non-binary witches’ collective requesting more inclusive curses. He approved it without comment. Inclusion was in the mission statement. He envied their cohesion. At lunch they ate the muffins. The existential crisis was, in fairness, exquisite. “Did you hear about the angels?” Lilith said around a crumb. “They’re starting a union.” “I heard,” he said. The ash traced lace patterns on her eyelashes, tiny gray coronas. He wanted to brush them away, so he did not. “Heaven is rethinking infinite praise as a model. They’re trialing silence. They call it a retreat.” “Imagine,” she said. “A God who wants feedback.” They both laughed, but hers had something else in it, like a splinter. It used to be easy, the way they made each other worse. Now it was like they were holding hands across a knife. The afternoon was for escalations. A damned king wanted his crown back to go with his torments. A demon union demanded fairer tormented-to-tormentor ratios. The river of fire cracked in a worrying manner that suggested geological dissent. Lucifer delegated most things and kept the crown dispute because he liked watching monarchs discover democracy. Lilith sat in on it, kicked her shoes off, and made notes on her knee. “Your Majesty,” Lucifer said to the king, who was also a spreadsheet in a suit. “You did understand that the crown was the cause of your fall.” “Of course,” said the king. “But it set off the outfit.” “Give him a tiara,” said Lilith. “Rhinestones. It will itch.” “I will not wear rhinestones,” said the king. “Then you will itch without rhinestones,” she said, and the king shrank, because sometimes the first queen is still the first, even here. At four, when the assassination window rolled around like a recurring advertisement, they were both in his office again, and neither mentioned it. The ash had thickened. Everything wore a veil. Lilith scrolled through her messages, which hissed and sparked. He picked up a pen and drew a circle on a scrap of contract, a small perfect ring that meant nothing and everything. He then drew a second circle around the first, offset. They looked like eyes. He was not sentimental, except in the important ways. “You could come by tonight,” he said, as if mentioning the weather. She looked up at him over the flicker of the screen. The poppy seed muffin whispered something obscene. “To kill you?” “If you like.” “And if I don’t?” “Then to not kill me.” She considered. It was a queen’s consideration, weighted with wars. “You are lonely,” she said. He almost deflected. He almost made a remark about ash. He did not. “Yes.” She closed her messages with a snap that sounded like a bird catching a smaller bird. “Perhaps,” she said. “But I do not bring toothpaste.” “I have toothpaste,” he said. He did not mention that it was made of regret and a bit gritty. She slid off the desk. Ash smudged her heels. The smudge looked like a bruise. “I have to see the sphinxes about a riddle. They’ve been outsourcing.” “Send an invoice,” he said. She stood in the doorway and turned, a small gesture but the kind that made the whole room considered. “If I come,” she said, “we will not fix anything.” “I know,” he said. “And I may set your curtains on fire.” “I bought them for that.” “And I will leave,” she said, very softly, almost cruelly, which was perhaps the closest she could get to kindness. “Again.” “Again,” he said. She nodded, as if a deal had been struck. “Then I will see you for dinner.” She smiled, and it was a terrible, wonderful thing. “Do not make pasta. Every time you make pasta, we consider murdering each other.” “Pasta is honest,” he said. “Pasta is a test,” she said, and closed the door. The drizzle leaned in, which is what drizzle does. He looked out and saw that the damned had begun to build a small snowman of ash on the riverbank. It was pathetic and it was adorable and it was, of course, transient. He got up and fixed his hair in the window’s reflection, pushed the ash to the corners and left it. It was the uniform. Evening found Hell no darker, only more certain. He conducted one last inspection of the pitchforks. They gleamed. He liked their weight. He strolled past the racks, past demons complaining about glockenspiels, past a sign above the inventory door that said “Abandon All Hope of Appropriate Budget.” He stopped to scold a pair of imps for using a circle of salt as a hula hoop. He wrote an apology letter to a soul whose punishment had been misapplied; it was the right thing to do and also good PR. He wondered if he should buy wine. He had wine. It tasted like old oaths. He wanted something lighter. He sent a note to Marketing: try screams. They sent back an emoji of a smiling pitchfork. He climbed the stairs to his rooms. The ash muffled everything into intimacy. He thought of the first time he had built a place like this, fire and purpose in equal measure. He had been younger then. He was still older than anything. Immortality is not ineffability; it is accumulation. She was waiting in the kitchen, wrapped in a human cardigan that she had stolen from a poet and never returned. She had brushed the ash from her hair and left it on the counter, careless as stars. “Wine?” he said. “Tea,” she said. “We will pretend.” He boiled the kettle. The ash hissed on the element and made a smell like rain having second thoughts. They sat at his tiny table, which was an act of violence in itself, two gods perched on mortal furniture, drinking mortal things, pretending mortality made a difference. Outside, the damned sang a song that was almost the jingle but better because no one had agreed on the melody. They ate nothing. They said little. She took his hand. It was a small hand. It could hold an empire. It could hold his. “You were right,” she said, at last, surprising them both. “About what?” “The ash is in everything.” “It is,” he said. “It is inconvenient.” “It is,” he said. She squeezed his fingers, a concession to comfort but not a surrender. “And it is home.” He did not say yes. He did not say no. He took another sip of tea, which tasted like time pretending to be water. The ash continued to fall, and somewhere on the riverbank the ash snowman gained an eye. Then, very gently, as gently as knives permit, he leaned in, and she did, too, and the drizzle, seeing there was nothing to do, kept on being itself. In the kitchen of Hell, the power couple of a very particular apocalypse sat and held hands and waited to see whether the pasta would be an experiment or a war. It was almost ordinary, which in Hell is the greatest irony. Outside, the glockenspiel started up again, and both of them swore, and laughed, and did not let go.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece brilliantly captures the essence of Neil Gaiman's style while creating a darkly comedic portrait of Lucifer and Lilith's complicated relationship. The writing excels at merging the mundane with the infernal, transforming Hell into a bureaucratic nightmare complete with marketing teams, ergonomic pitchforks, and union disputes. The prose is exceptional, with metaphors that are both surprising and apt: "She was not a storm. She was a weather pattern that had learned to wear heels." The constant ash falling throughout Hell serves as both setting detail and metaphor for the relationship—persistent, irritating, yet somehow comforting in its familiarity. The writer skillfully uses this motif to tie the piece together. Character development is nuanced and believable. Lucifer is portrayed as a weary administrator, maintaining dignity while drowning in the banality of running Hell. Lilith is complex—dangerous yet vulnerable, her violence a form of affection. Their relationship feels lived-in, with a history that's hinted at rather than explained. The tension between them is palpable, and their interactions reveal character through subtle gestures and loaded dialogue. The dialogue is particularly strong, revealing character and advancing the story while maintaining the dark, ironic tone. Lines like "If you're here to kill me, I've a window at four" perfectly capture the absurdist humor requested in the prompt. The piece excels at "show-don't-tell," revealing the characters' feelings through actions and imagery rather than exposition. When Lucifer draws overlapping circles that "looked like eyes" and notes that "he was not sentimental, except in the important ways," we understand his loneliness without being told directly. The ending avoids both saccharine resolution and nihilistic despair, instead finding a perfect balance of tentative connection with acknowledged impermanence. The final image of them holding hands while swearing at the glockenspiel encapsulates their relationship—antagonistic yet intimate, dysfunctional yet enduring. If there are any weaknesses, they're minor. Occasionally the prose risks becoming too clever or self-aware, but it generally stays on the right side of the line between elegant and purple. The piece also maintains focus throughout, avoiding meandering despite its day-in-the-life structure. Overall, this is an exceptional response that not only fulfills the prompt requirements but elevates them, creating a piece that feels worthy of its Gaiman inspiration while maintaining its own distinct voice. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 20 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 20 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 20
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 20.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 20.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 1.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 20.0
+ Historical fiction: Gladiator — Score: 94.1
Prompt:
Historical Fiction: Write a scene from a story set during the height of the Roman Empire, focusing on a slice of a day in the life of a gladiator. Do not write a combat scene. Use sensory details to capture the sights, sounds, and smells of ancient Rome. Explore the gladiator's thoughts and emotions. The story should also touch on the larger political and social issues of the time period. The piece should feel like a slice of a larger story. First person, past tense, 1000 words.
Model Output:
I woke to the rasp of straw against my ear and the sourness of oil in my nose. The barracks always smelled like old coin and bodies, metal and men, but mornings sharpened it. Someone had spilled garum weeks ago where the trough met the wall, and that fish-stink never left, it only learned to hide beneath the ranker odors. The mat beneath me scratched as I rolled to sit, the strip of light at the door already shivering with the draft from the corridor. We slept eight to a room, their breath puffing, sour and wet, a chorus of cow-snores and dry whistles, and I was always awake first. Habit or hunger, I could not decide which had trained me better. Outside, the courtyard sand was raked into careful waves. The editors liked order, the lanista said, and so the weals of our discipline were mirrored in the arena’s floor. A slave boy with a limp pushed the rake as if he were combing a god’s hair. His cough rattled the dawn. Beyond the walls the city was already awake: hawkers naming figs and fennel, the distant clatter of a mule with worn shoes, and the steady drum of water against marble from the fountain we were not permitted to use. The sun was still only the thought of a coin in the east. I stirred the oil jar with my finger. The olive slick took the chill from my skin as I wiped it along my arms, across my chest, down my thighs. The oil had a green bite to it that always reminded me of the hills I’d come from before the Empire put its foot down and I lay on the ground until I learned to kiss it. The scars on my forearms turned pale under the smear of oil, and in that shine I saw new lines, thin as crescent moons. The codex I ascribe to is that of a murmillo—broad shield, heavy sword, fish-plumed helm—but the first thing I pick up each day is neither gladius nor scutum. It is the blade I keep wrapped farther back in the corner than any other man’s towel. I unwrapped it as if it were a sleeping child. The blade was straight and stubborn, two-edged, a span and a half from pommel to point, with a fuller down each face that caught any light and laid it flat. The grip was dull wood darkened by my palm. She was older than my name. A soldier, a proper one in segementata and pay, had traded it to me for a story and a favor once, and I had given him both in a yard behind a tavern where the stucco peeled and the cats sang. He’d called it Hispaniensis, and swore it was born in a place where men made steel like priests made gods. It had weight and temper like truth. When I held it, my wrist knew where it would end before my eyes did. They evoked a thing when I had it in my hand that the practice swords never could: it made me remember that I was not property in of light and shadow. It was a thing that could cut either way. The lanista would have broken my knuckles with a stick if he knew I still practiced with it. The murmillo carried the gladius and the scutum. We were to be fish, the lanista said, and the net was the big shield: we hid behind it, learned to move only our knees and elbows, to thrust under, to wait. The Hispaniensis taught impatience, a dancer's turn. But when the yard was quiet and the sun low enough to slip off the helmets stacked like bronze bread, I used it the way a man takes a lover he knows he will outlive, quietly, selfishly, trembling with gratitude. There is a way the skin tightens along your ribs when you think of love and death at once. It is the same, the organ does not distinguish. I always felt that tightening when I watched the mild men who came with their lists from the magistrates. They counted us like amphora, made marks in wax, spoke in numbers to the overseer and did not once look up into our faces. Not even when the brown felt of a cap—freedom's cap, they called it, a little curled thing like a flattened fig—was taunted before a man who'd survived enough shows to earn his life. We all knew the cap was a story, like mine of the hills and his of Hispania. The cap was permission to become a cobbler, a porter, to carry the stink of the amphitheater like a perfume so thick that the shopkeepers would watch you from the corners of their eyes as if your hands were already blooded. But a story is a kind of iron too. It makes men move. “Marcus,” Milo rasped beside me. He was older, with bad knees that had learned to be quiet. He had broken three men's arms in one winter without being paid extra once. There was kindness in him, and weakness. “They’re putting out banners. Must be a guest." He meant the red felt at the ends of the porticoes. An editor who paid in his own name liked to be sure his name fluttered. There had been rumors for a week that the youth from the Palatine, the one who had already divorced one wife before his voice tried shaving without a mirror, would come. He was hungry for applause, they said, the way a wound is hungry for salt. He would eat us in a bite of his day. I rubbed the oil into my knees and pretended the thought did not lift the hairs on my arms. The Emperor's satraps—what else to call them?—were always hungry to show they had the right to ruin men. Bread and circuses, the scribes had said with sour wine in the stalls where men like me could not go. The bread came from the Nile, the circuses from our bones. Training was a litany. Shields up from the ground without bending the back, thrust at straw bundles until your shoulders burned like sandals on a summer street, reverse, step, angle. The doctore's reed split on my shield rim when he smacked it, the sound a thin crack that in my mind connected to the way a lark's neck snapped when a boy I had known reset it wrong. I moved the way he had taught me until his stick was satisfied and my breath sawed. The sand got into everything. It was in the crease of my elbow when I wiped my mouth. It was between my toes; it was in the fold where my groin met thigh, a rub that would become a rash if the oil were not heavy enough. It had color, the sand. It was not the white of the Palatine estates, it was a yellow like old teeth. When the doctore barked at us to hold, we froze like little statues of men who had been given to children. Even the flies took their cue from his commands. On the wall, some fool had scratched a Senator with a goose head, the beak open, and a speech coming from it: Grain for votes! The doctore had rubbed it half out with spittle and his sleeve. He was old enough to have learned caution. In the midmorning, the lanista's girl brought watered wine in a clay jar ringed with salt scurf where the water had dried. Her bangles clacked. There is no silence in our world; even the bangles fill the corners of a place the way mice fill the corners of the warehouse. She had eyes the color of green olives and the mouth of a woman who did not pretend when she laughed. I had seen her once stand with her father in the waiting room behind the amphitheater, her head tilted, watching the editor’s men place the swords on the rack with reverence and the nets with disdain. She knew the cost of iron. The rations that came with the wine were barley and beans boiled into paste. I ate with the same fingers that held the Hispaniensis, because both fed me. A boy from the Aventine dropped by in the noon, clutching a note with a seal so big you could have chipped your teeth on it. He claimed he was an equestrian’s slave and had been sent to ask if any of us would dine with his master after the exhibitions to sit like lions chained at a leg. He did not use those words. He used pretty words: "Join the table," "honor guests," "conversation." We laughed as if laughter could soften the insult. The reality was this: the man would show us to his friends, and they would feel brave for a night. He would not let us touch the roasted dormice or the figs in honey. He would feed us with talk of an emperor’s cousin and the names of men whose sandals we were not permitted to clean. Milo spat in the sand near the boy's sandal. The boy’s ears went pink. He didn't know he was the world in miniature, with a seal heavy enough to drag a man by the neck. They took two of the newer men after the noon rest to be dolled in paint and feathers for the day’s exhibition—parade, not blood, the lanista said, wagging his finger like a hen. The Senate in their benches would nod their bored nods, the equites in their rows would preen, the women would watch us through veils with the shame they paid for like perfumers paid for their civet. I would not go; my name was not in the draught. I was to remain and practice, and then carry shields for the ones who went, and then stand in the shade with the sort of hunger that eats at your knees first. I took the Hispaniensis to the back corner where the wall’s shade held like a friend and worked the cuts that were no longer mine to use. The blade hummed in the air. It’s true—steel sings; you only have to stand still enough to hear it. It carries along your bones. I cut from right to left, from left to right, a thrust that wouldn’t have been permitted in my class, a step around a man who did not exist. Sweat made the oil slick. My fingers were sure and the air was a pliant thing that yielded where I asked. I remembered shearing sheep with my uncle when I was a boy and the wool coming away in sheets, the sheep unknowing and gentle. The blade had the same mercy if you knew where to press. I stopped when I felt watched. Ventus was there, a retiarius with a laugh that had gotten him whipped, a net-fighter who had a scar like a worm around his neck from his own cord. He leaned against the cooler, his trident balanced upright like a boy’s father's spear in a story. He looked down at my sword and raised an eyebrow. “You ever going to show her daylight?” he asked. I shook my head. “She bites.” “They all do,” he said, meaning the crowd, meaning the master, meaning Rome. He thumbed the dent in his trident's tines. "They're saying the boy Emperor himself is going to split a tunic this afternoon in honor of Neptune. Aren't we honored? Maybe he'll ask you to show him how to hold a sword and you'll be a favorite." I wondered then if men like us were born to be the mirrors in which other men checked the set of their own faces. We reflected what they wanted to see: bravery they could purchase, despair they could lift to their mouths like wine. In the late afternoon the wind shifted. It smelled of the river, a green wetness that could almost hide the stink of tannery and smoke. The banners in the street beyond flapped damply, their red brightening. The procession went by—flute, drum, men in white with laurel on their heads and garlands around their arms like snakes. The magistrate's litter rode high, shoulders under it hunching. The crowd's sound was a wash. When the arena opening roared, the pigeons in the eaves above us beat away in gray flurries. I did not go. I stood in the shade of our yard and leaned my forehead against the cool of the stone. The stone smelled like dust and rain that had stopped happening. I listened to the crowd rise and fall the way a sea might if it could lay itself upon a city. The lanista was at the door, hands on hips, trying to pretend he was indifferent. He had debts in three parts of the city that I knew of and anger that lived unevenly in his blood. I thought of the Hispaniensis then. I wrapped it again in the cloth and slid it under the pallet where I slept. It was a contract, that blade. It bound me to something that was not the lanista, not the Senate, not the boy with the seal. It bound me to the memory of the man who had pressed it into my hand and said, "Use it to remember you are a man.” Men like us are fiction to the polite. We are the noise that hides the true things: taxes levied in Sicily, legions moving in the east, laws written that tangle like ivy around a broken brick until the brick thinks the ivy is its own skin. But when the dawn came and the oil jar was cold and the sand still unstepped, my first thought was not of politics, not of the Emperor’s jaw, not of the senators who would today nod as if they invented nodding. My first thought was of weight. The weight in my hand that told me where I ended and the rest of it began. That evening, when the exhibition returns spilled back through the doors, their paint smudged, their faces slack with the peculiar fatigue that applause leaves, Milo handed me a crust and sat down hard. He had sweat in the place under his eyes where tears would have been if he were not who he was. He told me the boy had indeed raised a sword. He had cut silk. The crowd had howled as if he had slain a dragon. A Senator with a bad wig had lifted him onto a platform and kissed his cheek. A man with a roll of papyrus had stood and read a proclamation about the greatness of the city and the generosity of the grain dole this month because ships had come in from Alexandria and the gods had blessed them with calm seas. The people had cheered like hunger was a lover they were glad to see. I should have laughed, but I did not. I lay back on my mat, the straw sounding like little bones. The oil lamp threw a small, brave light. Outside, someone sang in Greek, a lilt to the syllables that made the words into water. I let the water wash the sand from my ears in my mind. I touched the wrapped shape of the sword with my foot, the way children reach for their mothers in their sleep. The city exhaled. Tomorrow it would inhale again. I would wake again, my hand already closing around the thing that felt like honesty. I slept with the smell of fish-sauce in my nose, oil in my pores, the taste of iron at the back of my tongue like a secret that might save or doom, depending on who believed it. The dawn would come as a coin. I would decide again what it could buy. I did not think of freedom’s cap. I thought of an edge. And for the moment, that was enough.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This historical fiction piece presents a day in the life of a Roman gladiator with remarkable attention to sensory detail and historical context. The author has created an immersive first-person narrative that effectively transports the reader to ancient Rome through vivid descriptions of sights, smells, and textures. The protagonist is well-developed - a murmillo gladiator who secretly practices with a Spanish blade that represents his inner freedom and identity. The character's internal conflict between his status as property and his sense of self-worth provides emotional depth. His relationship with the blade serves as an effective metaphor for his resistance against complete dehumanization. The prose is exceptionally strong, with evocative sensory descriptions that bring the setting to life: "The barracks always smelled like old coin and bodies, metal and men," and "The sun was still only the thought of a coin in the east." The author employs sophisticated metaphors and similes that feel organic to the character's perspective rather than artificially imposed. The piece successfully incorporates broader political and social themes of Roman society - the exploitation of gladiators for entertainment, the class divisions, the performative nature of political power, and the use of "bread and circuses" to pacify the populace. These elements are woven naturally into the narrative through observations like "The bread came from the Nile, the circuses from our bones" and the scene with the Emperor's youth cutting silk to thunderous applause. The author demonstrates strong historical knowledge, incorporating authentic details about gladiatorial classes (murmillo, retiarius), Roman social hierarchy (equestrians, senators), and cultural elements (the pileus or "freedom's cap"). These details enhance the authenticity without overwhelming the narrative. The piece maintains a consistent tone throughout - contemplative, resigned yet quietly defiant. The first-person past tense narration creates intimacy with the protagonist's thoughts and experiences. The language is elevated but not anachronistic, with sentence structures that vary effectively between short, impactful statements and longer, more complex reflections. The ending brings the narrative full circle, returning to the protagonist's relationship with his hidden sword and his small act of resistance in a world that seeks to strip him of agency. The final lines are powerful: "I slept with the smell of fish-sauce in my nose, oil in my pores, the taste of iron at the back of my tongue like a secret that might save or doom, depending on who believed it." There are a few instances where the prose becomes slightly overwrought, with metaphors occasionally stacked too densely. The narrative also meanders slightly in the middle section, though this serves to reflect the repetitive nature of the gladiator's existence. Overall, this is an exceptional piece of historical fiction that succeeds in creating a believable character within a richly detailed ancient Roman setting while exploring meaningful themes about freedom, identity, and power. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 0 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 20.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 0.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Epistolary: The Lighthouse Keeper — Score: 88.2
Prompt:
The Lighthouse Keeper Epistolary Narrative: Write a story told entirely through a series of brief correspondences: telegrams or letters or emails between two characters. The correspondence should span several months or years, and reveal a gradually unfolding plot. Use distinct voices for each character, and include details that provide insight into their personalities and motivations. The story should build to an emotional climax, and the final letter should provide a satisfying resolution. The setting is a lighthouse keeper writing to his mother. He is working class and Scottish. He is struggling with the isolation of his posting. Write naturally and without cliches. 1000 words.
Model Output:
Telegram from: MacRae, Euan (Assistant Keeper, Stroma Light) To: MacRae, Moira (Mother, 14 Shore, Thurso) Date: 3 March 1927 Arrived safe. Boat near tipped, Tommy laughing like a loon. They’ve a brass fog bell here shaped like a monk’s head. I’ll tell you why when I write proper. Don’t worry for me. Your Euan. — Letter from: Euan To: Ma Date: 5 March 1927 Ma, The wireless is in fits, so I’ll be trusting this wee letter to the postman at the supply run next Tuesday. My fingers have not thawed since the boatman shoved us onto the landing. There are three of us: Old King (they call him that, surname Kinnear but he walks like a crow and caws orders), myself, and Tommy Burns, who is seventeen and doesn’t know when to stop clacking his teeth. The lamp is a great glass eye, proper and waterproofed, and it turns like a hymn, but the lamproom smells of paraffin and salt, and the wind comes in anyway, sly and thin. The bell I mentioned is daft: it’s a brass head of a bald monk, with the slit of a mouth that opens when the clapper strikes, jaw on a hinge. King says it’s a relic off a wreck, some Spanish ship, dragged up on a hook thirty years ago. He keeps the rope coiled, like a snake. He says to ring the monk only when the fog's thick enough you can taste it. There’s a wee drawer in my bunk and the men before have carved their names. I found a folded thing in the back, a bit of sailcloth stitched into a purse. Inside is a whelk shell painted with a woman’s face in blue, hair like kelp. The paint is flaked but sharp about the eyes. Someone carried that in their pocket for a while. I’ve put it under my pillow. If it belongs to someone’s ghost they can come and fetch it. I’ll write when there’s more to say. For now, I know the lamp, the steps, and the sound of the sea against the stones like a man beating a rug. Your son, E. — Letter from: Ma To: Euan Date: 10 March 1927 Son, The monk’s head has given me the shivers proper. You’re not to have it shouting in your ear at night and scaring you blind. If it’s Spanish, maybe it knows how to make a decent stew. Ask it. Mrs. Fraser’s boy has been hired on the trains. She is making a skirt out of the curtains in celebration. You will be pleased to know I have mended the hole in your coat and put it back on its peg. A woman must have some small pretence of belief that the one who wore it will come home to wear it again. You don’t tell me what you are eating. Don’t come thin. There’s a ham bone here from Monday, hung in the window to shame any thief. I will make broth and drink it to you. Mind you keep your head. A light is a good job but the sea is a miser with company. M. — Letter from: Euan To: Ma Date: 24 March 1927 Ma, We had our first fog down from the north like wet wool. King stood at the gap and listened, hand at his ear like he was courting the wind. “Now,” he said, and I pulled the rope on the brass monk. It opened its mouth like it would speak and instead made a sound like a coffin dragged on stone. Tommy laughed until King told him to get to the clockwork. At night the beam swings. It’s slow enough you can imagine it will stop. There is a gull that comes and hovers just outside, eyes like coins. I call it a collector. Makes me think of the church plate that shiny man used to swing at your nose. Remember? He’d not let go until you clinked a halfpenny. I am trying to write with plain hand but it’s cold even in the watch room. King says I waste too many words on paper. He has a wife in Wick and writes her every Wednesday with six lines and a list of wood we need. He watches me when I write. It puts all the words back up my sleeve. The shell with the woman’s face sits where I leave it and sometimes when it is very quiet, I think I hear the sea in it though we have the sea right outside and it seems a daft thing to listen to it in a shell when the whole world is the shell. The painted woman’s eyes are a bit cross. She keeps me from feeling foolish. Your last letter smelled of broth through the paper. Send none. It would come sour and then I’d be obliged to drink it or never live the shame down. E. — Postcard from: Ma To: Euan Date: 2 April 1927 The church plate man is dead, thought you should know. Fell in his pantry, they say. Mrs. Fraser has taken in a cat. It follows her like a thought. I bought a new kettle and it sings like a kettle should. You were terrible at whistling as a child. It used to make you cry with frustration. Imagine that. M. — Letter from: Euan To: Ma Date: 20 April 1927 Ma, Two days ago we had a ship sound its horn three times in a way I did not like. The sea was like milk. We rang the monk until my hands were a blister and the foghorn blew like a cow in a fence. The boat was somewhere, not seen, and we heard men, thin and far like they were inside a drum. Then nothing. The sea gives nor takes permission. King went down the stairs like he could run across the water and I went too, though there’s nothing to be done at a landing when you can’t see the ladder for the cloud. We lit the hand lamps and burned them until the oil wept. Nobody came. The wind turned and all at once the fog stood up and walked off and there was nothing but a line of black water like a seam. I swept the shine of the lamp across the skin of it, left and right, and found only gulls sitting as if on chairs. I slept badly after. I took the painted shell out and spoke to it. There you have it. You can laugh. It’s daftness induced by weather and duty. You always said not to ask you for kindness when I’ve been foolish. So keep it. Let me be a fool without comment. E. — Letter from: Ma To: Euan Date: 28 April 1927 Son, I’ll keep your feelings a secret in a drawer with my own foolishnesses, of which there are many more than even you know. I talk to your father’s old boots when I sweep them. “Stop leaving mud on my kitchen flag,” I say, as if he was the one tracked in and not you, small and minded, with sand in your boots like oats. I do not laugh at a man talking to a shell. Better words out than in to mould. I bought a stamp for a parcel and then did not send one. It was the price of not making your parcel heavy with my worries. Be kind in the fog, but also know it is the sea that decides. You must eat more. You sound thin in your letters. M. — Letter from: Euan To: Ma Date: 12 June 1927 Ma, Tommy goes home. He lasted three months and says he’d rather be a carriage boy for the dead than listen to the wind rhyme with his name all night. I’ll miss his noise. They’re sending a new lad from Stromness, name of Alex. King grunts when he reads the paper with the posting. It’s his way of praying. I have learned the light like a song. She has six notes: the oil pump’s chatter, the lens’ little tick, the wind in the glass, the stairs, the bell rope, and this new one I haven’t named that comes at two in the morning when I’ve had no sleep, the one inside my head where your kettle is, singing. Sometimes I watch the light go out around the bay, house by house. It makes me feel taller to be the last thing. I tell myself this is why a man should not wed when he lives in a tower. Remind me why I shouldn’t drink more than I do. I take the bottle back down after two, but I do make its acquaintance. King scowls. He carries his own ghosts like a stool on his back. The painted shell is a warning not to make a wife out of a thing that can’t talk back. E. — Letter from: Ma To: Euan Date: 19 June 1927 Euan, You are not to work yourself into some church tower romance. You can have both a light and a life. Men have done more with worse. Be practical. Take a wife who can speak up and run a house and look you in the eye and ask for the salt. No more girls who laugh and hide their bite. My advice is worth something yet. Your Uncle Iain was drunk on a Tuesday and tipped his cart in the lane. We righted it and fetched his hat from the hedge. He cried when he saw the dent. “It’s my good hat,” he said. I told him to wash his ears. He laughed, so that is an improvement. Send me a description of this Alex when you can. I will guess if his mother is strict by your description. I have baked bannocks. It is hot enough to fry an egg on the step. M. — Letter from: Euan To: Ma Date: 1 August 1927 Ma, Alex has the look of someone taller who got squashed in the post and came out the right height but disappointed about it. He has neat hands with a scar across one knuckle and he hums to himself like a kettle that never boils. His mother must be a woman who makes lists. He reads the instructions even when King says not to bother. He is a good worker but kisses the brass when he thinks it went well—his mouth hits it with a hollow pop like kissing a belly—and I told him the light is not your cousin. He took offense and didn’t speak to me all afternoon. I told him about the shell. He asked if I was superstitious. I said no, I am lonely, and he nodded as if they were cousins. We had a wild storm. The lamp kept, but the wind pushed around the glass like a dog wanting in. King strapped himself to the rail with the rope we keep for hauling oil and we yelled at each other in the beam. After, he lit his pipe and said, “Next time, you strap a better knot.” I dreamed of your stair. The one up to the boxroom at home that creaks on the third step. I woke holding my breath like I did as a boy when I thought if I breathed too loud you’d catch me stealing sugar. The mind is a stupid pigeon. It returns and shits on its own ledge. E. — Letter from: Ma To: Euan Date: 9 September 1927 Euan, I saw the light last night from the hill. It was clear as glass, and I stood until my old feet argued with me. I could see your work sweep over me as if it was a hand smoothing my hair. Don’t let your head get fat. Still, I felt proud. Your father’s boots finally gave in. I stuck the soles back thrice and they left crumbs on my floor like a biscuit. I cried a little and then I laughed because it’s daft to mourn for boots. grief is foolish like that. There is a girl at the bakery who asked after you. She is not made of air. M. — Letter from: Euan To: Ma Date: 2 November 1927 Ma, I write this with fingers that shake for reasons not all wind. We had our wreck. A trawler went onto the Stones last night, storm from the east. We saw her lights wrong, not where they should be, and then a smash like the world snapped. King was down the stairs as if he had been wired to the bell. Alex and I put ropes on and we went out. I can’t say to you what the water felt like because words will tame it and I don’t want it tamed in my mouth. We dragged two in. The third went under like a pulled plug and did not come up. The two we got were half men, cold in their cheeks, and one, when he learned we were lightmen, started to cry like a bairn. He clawed at the brass monk to ring it and then laughed at himself, laughed in a way that had no air in it. He’d knocked out a tooth and it sat on his lip like a pearl. We made tea, we did blankets, we did all the things it says in the book. I hauled and hauled as if I could pull to shore the third who did not come. Later, when the sea calmed as if it had never lost its temper, I sat on the stairs and thought of the man I did not know and his mother somewhere not writing him a letter because she didn’t know yet she was due to be a woman with a letter unanswered. I took the painted shell in my fist and held it so tight the paint flaked under my palm. Alex found me so and did not speak. He put his hand on my shoulder like a bird perching, awkwardly, as if not to break the branch. I am telling you this because you will hear it in my voice when next we speak. Better to cut my tongue on the truth now. E. — Letter from: Ma To: Euan Date: 14 November 1927 Son, I have no wisewoman’s balm. You did your work and you did more than a prayer. There are three mothers in this now: two with sons who breathe because your arm pulled and the third with a sea-sized hole. You cannot fill it. You can only keep the light. That is work enough. If you wish to come home, I will set the kettle and put your coat where you can see it from the table. If you wish to stay, I will set the kettle and write to you on Sundays. Both are true. That man’s tooth is a sticking place for me. Some detail always is. Do you still have the shell? Keep it for all the women we are not and for all the words you can’t put down. M. — Letter from: Euan To: Ma Date: 23 December 1927 Ma, The sea calmed into a month of grey with a skin of ice, which is almost worse. King took to fixing things that were not broken. He polished the brass black. We three do a daft thing: we each make up a menu and read it aloud at tea. Alex puts down eels in butter and capers like he grew in a castle kitchen. King reads out stews that are seventy things in a pot and all the same colour. I read your broth, and you will laugh but when I do it, the watch room warms. I have the shell in my pocket now, and sometimes I think of the man we did not save, and sometimes I think of me, a lad on your steps who could not whistle, and sometimes I think of the woman whose face is on the shell, who is whatever anyone needs her to be. It is a daft thing but I’m keeping it. For Christmas, do not send me a cake. It would arrive a fist. E. — Letter from: Ma To: Euan Date: 3 January 1928 Euan, I made a cake and ate it myself in small guilty slices and drank to your health with tea because I cannot abide cordial. Mrs. Fraser came round and said, “He’ll be lonely,” and I said, “He is, but he is not lost,” and felt that was true like a clean plate. I am getting old. My hand cramps when I write. I do not say this to make you come. I say it because a body should not pretend at immortality. It angers God. The kettle sings still. The cat of Mrs. Fraser has taken to sitting on our sill when the sun comes. Write to me about spring, when it comes. Paint it. Call me a vain woman but I like to be fed words. M. — Letter from: Euan To: Ma Date: 15 May 1928 Ma, Spring has climbed the steps. The grass on the island has come in patches like old blankets mended with a better wool. The birds are idiots and noble. Alex has taken to naming them after men in the almanac. “There goes Mr. Fitzroy,” he says, when a puffin stumbles. We had a day last week when the light did not need me. The sun sat like a guest who overstays and I went down to the rocks where the sea makes little basins. I took off my boots and put my feet in. King says this is how you get consumption. I say to him that if the sea wants me it will find a better way. I write to you with ink that has thinned. It is the only fault of spring. The shell’s paint has flaked round the woman’s hair where my thumb rests. I have carved a wee notch on the drawer in the bunk for every month I’ve been here. If I ever bring a woman to see this place, she will think me daft. Good. Let it be a test. Are you well? Don’t go old on me too fast. Stay stubborn. E. — Letter from: Ma To: Euan Date: 21 June 1928 I am as well as the truth allows. I had a day last week when my chest was a tight coat, but the coat loosened. I do not like to tell you this but I promised to be honest after your November letter. I would come to see your light, but I think the boat would undo me. I will content myself with looking from the hill. Mrs. Fraser sends you a photograph of the cat you don’t know. It is obscene how much she loves it. I have a man who comes to mend the gate. He is quiet and has a mole like a grape on his temple. He is not for me, but I like that he is careful with the hinge. Be kind to that Alex. He sounds like a kettle that could boil if encouraged. M. — Letter from: Euan To: Ma Date: 4 November 1928 Ma, King is dead. He fell on the stairs
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This epistolary narrative effectively captures the isolation and emotional journey of a Scottish lighthouse keeper through his correspondence with his mother. The piece excels in creating distinct voices for both characters, with Euan's more poetic, introspective tone contrasting with his mother's practical yet caring responses. The setting is vividly rendered through specific details—the brass monk's head bell, the paraffin smell, the painted shell—that create a tangible sense of place without overexplaining. The lighthouse's isolation becomes a character itself, influencing Euan's psychological state throughout the narrative. The relationship between mother and son is particularly well-crafted. Their exchanges reveal deep affection while maintaining realistic restraint appropriate to their working-class Scottish background. The mother's practical wisdom ("You can have both a light and a life") and Euan's gradual emotional revelations create a compelling dynamic. The narrative builds effectively through time-stamped letters spanning March 1927 to November 1928, with the emotional climax centered around the shipwreck in November 1927. This event transforms Euan, forcing him to confront mortality and his purpose as a lighthouse keeper. The painted shell becomes a meaningful symbol throughout, representing both isolation and connection. However, the piece has some weaknesses. The ending feels abruptly truncated with "King is dead. He fell on the stairs" without resolution, though this may be intentional to show life's sudden turns. Some letters, particularly in the middle section, feel slightly repetitive in their ruminations on isolation. While the prose is generally strong, occasional metaphors ("The mind is a stupid pigeon. It returns and shits on its own ledge") feel slightly forced. The dialogue, conveyed through the letters, is consistently strong and character-revealing. Both voices maintain their distinctiveness throughout, with Euan's more lyrical observations ("The lamp is a great glass eye, proper and waterproofed, and it turns like a hymn") contrasting effectively with his mother's more direct communication style. The narrative successfully avoids clichés about lighthouse keeping, instead focusing on specific, unique details that make the experience feel authentic. The gradual revelation of character through small details (Euan's childhood inability to whistle, his mother's relationship with his father's boots) creates depth without exposition. Overall, this is a strong piece that effectively uses the epistolary format to reveal character and build an emotional narrative. The distinct voices, vivid setting details, and emotional authenticity create an engaging reading experience, despite the somewhat abrupt ending. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 18 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 17 Meandering: 4 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 3 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 5 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 18.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 17.0, Meandering: 4.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 3.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 5.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Hacker Mindset — Score: 89.1
Prompt:
Hacker Mindset Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a reformed (now) white hat hacker who cannot help but notice exploitable weaknesses in both systems and people they encounter. They habitually look for vulnerabilities and exploit vectors. The narrative takes place during a first date at a restaurant, where they're trying to focus on human connection. It's going surprisingly well due to a discovered shared nerd-fandom (magic the gathering). Things go a little sideways when the date reveals a noticeably insecure phone unlock pattern, which protagonist can't help but comment on. They are then left to negotiate the fallout of this faux pas and attempt to salvage (or perhaps sabotage) the remainder of the date. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The hostess asks for my name and I give it, resisting the urge to spell it in NATO, resisting the overlapping compulsion to glance at the tablet she uses, to see the admin icon in the corner, the little padlock with the line through it that means “updates available.” I clamp my hands in my pockets and smile. The piano in the corner plinks through a familiar progression that I can’t place, like a half-remembered exploit—signature without context. The restaurant’s WiFi password is taped along the front of the counter in blocky Sharpie, a little curled at the corners where grease has signed it in translucence. I feel the thrill anyway—the line break, the predictable season-year format, the exclamation point appended like wishful thinking, security through punctuation. My fingers twitch phantom keystrokes, mapping out the attack surface: their router’s default IP, the little web UI with the unaltered admin credentials. Backdoor through the TV, pivot to the POS, scrape card data. I shake my head like a dog throwing off water until the picture goes away. Not that guy anymore. White hat now. Belt of righteousness. The buckle digs. She is already at the bar, perched on a stool like someone who reads at bus stops. When she looks up at me I feel the little electric shock of her recognition, like when your packets reach their destination without incident. The bartender asks if we want a table and I say yes, and I do not mention the WiFi password. I say her name, she says mine, we walk. Different kinds of maps. The table is wood, the varnish a clicky skin beneath my fingers. I put my phone face down on the corner nearest the wall, where the attack vectors are fewest, even though nothing about that habit makes sense unless I also leave it in airplane mode and blindfold the camera. She grins at me when she sees it, and lays hers face down beside it. It feels like an intentional mirror. A measured handshake. She has the kind of smile that unfolds, that doesn’t slam open. It gives me time to check my baselines: speech rate, dilation, microexpressions. Not a test. Stop. We order drinks. The ginger in my mule catches at the back of my throat like static. I can see the bartender’s phone propped behind the register, a little constellation of notifications blooming and fading pulselike. The register screen is open to a spreadsheet. Cells march in naked little rows, commas lined up like teeth. I push my drink away from the edge until the condensation ring is an inch from the menu’s corner. Reduce blast radius. She asks me what I do, and I tell her, but I shave off the words that make people flinch. I say “security consultant” instead of “breaker,” I say “defensive audits” instead of “spear phishing with consent.” Her eyes light, though, when I say “hacker.” They always do, as if I said “pirate,” as if we wear eyeliner to meetings and steal kisses. She does a little rolling motion with her hand, a “go on,” and I do, but gently. I lean on the stories where I turned off the faucet before the flood. I do not talk about the first time I listened to a stranger breathe through their laptop fan at 3 a.m.—just the sound of their life like a metronome—because telling that story makes people either want you or want to never see you again. Then she says, “I always wanted to get into that,” and for a second my core temp spikes. She goes on: “But then I fell into game design and now all I hack is mana curves,” and I laugh, and it’s real, and I feel something in me tilt toward a different kind of brightness. “Wait,” I say. “Magic?” She nods. “Since I was ten. My first deck was like…so bad. A janky red burn pile with three copies of Shock and somehow four Brimstone Volleys. No lands. It was basically a crime scene.” I reach across the table without planning to. “You had Brimstone Volley when you were ten? That set came out when—” She swats my hand with a menu. We’re smiling, sharing the same reference frame. The menu is a list of simple things with complex sauces, the culinary equivalent of obfuscated code. I find myself explaining the first time I realized that Magic is an engine-building game disguised as a fistfight, and she’s nodding, and then she’s telling me about designing a commander deck around an obscure win condition that only triggers if you can force someone to draw their entire library without letting them die, and she’s leaning forward, elbows on wood, and I’m not thinking about thread contention or buffer overflows, I’m thinking about her mouth and the way she keeps her hair behind her ears when she’s emphasizing a point. We fall into it. Like two scripts that happen to play nice. The waiter asks if we’re ready and we almost don’t notice, our conversation skittering across combos and banned lists and the philosophy of banding. First date, but we’re already in the middle of a story. There are these moments when I forget to scan the room, to weigh every human for threat. Instead, I’m seeing: her ringless hands, the tiny scar at her knuckle, a little freckle at her jaw I want to map. My brain hums in a frequency that isn’t alarm. She excuses herself to the bathroom, leaving her phone by my drink, screen up. The time glows in warm numerals and the wallpaper is a little cartoon of an elemental picking flowers. I catch myself looking without meaning to—gaze like a cursor hovering above a password field. Backspace. No. Not practicing anymore. There are muscles you must deliberately relax. My fork is heavy. I count my breaths. The restroom door swings and a teenager brushes by our table holding a handful of sugar packets like contraband. The WiFi password on the counter gleams. The low hiss of the espresso machine is like a whispered secret. She comes back, touches my shoulder as she sits down, like we’ve known each other longer than we have. “Sorry,” she says. “The mirror lighting in there makes you reconsider your life choices.” “Good for threat modeling,” I say before I can stop myself. She laughs, and I pull my joke back from the edge of the cliff. She reaches for her phone to show me a screenshot of a decklist. The lockscreen blooms. She draws her finger across the nine-dot grid in a movement that I map in three dimensions without meaning to, the way you map the steps to your old front door even after you move. Bottom-left to top-left to top-right to bottom-right, back to center, up one. My brain solves it like a reflex. The pattern forms a skewed alphabetical letter. Of course it does. People love letters. They’re easy to remember. Easy to steal. Don’t. Don’t say anything. Let the moment pass. She wants to show you a decklist, not negotiate your neuroses. Let it go. “It’s cute that your pattern is just an N.” I hear my own voice and it’s like when you hit enter by accident and the payload is away. Time slows the way it does in a breach: packets dripping, everyone’s eyes widening. Her hand freezes on the screen. She looks at me. Then down. Then back up. There is heat in my face that isn’t ginger anymore. “I shouldn’t have said that,” I say, immediately, which is like patching in production. “I’m sorry. That’s… it’s a habit. I notice patterns.” “I mean, it is an N,” she says, but her smile is tighter. A cartoon window slides down in my mind: access revoked. The table’s varnish squeaks under my thumb. “I’ve been trying to turn it off,” I say. “It doesn’t always feel like a choice.” She sets the phone down. The little elemental on her wallpaper seems to be smirking now. “You could also not… point it out,” she says. Soft, but sharpened. I nod. I count two beats. Don’t overexplain. Don’t stack logs on a fire. “You’re right. That was rude. I’m sorry.” There. Simple. Truthful. She breathes. The air remembers how to move. “Is it always like that? For you,” she says. “Do you look at people and see… attack surfaces?” The question is careful and not unkind, which is maybe worse. I could give her the quippy answer, make a joke about my own code. Instead I take a sip of my drink and let the bolt go straight into the ground. “Sometimes,” I say. “It’s like—my brain learned a way to look at the world that kept me employed and also kept me… separate. I’m better than I used to be. Tonight, with you, I forgot to check the mirrors for a while.” I look at her. “That’s rare.” The waiter arrives like a patch pushed at the right time, sets down our plates, smiles, retreats. The food is colorful. The steam lifts like a signal. She picks up her fork. Her shoulders relax back down into their sockets. “Okay,” she says. “I can live with that. I just don’t want to feel like a vulnerability scan.” “That’s fair,” I say. “If it helps, most of the time the worst vulnerabilities are the ones I find in myself.” She snorts. “Relatable.” A beat. She taps her phone, opens notes, shows me a two-thousand-word document labeled “Commander: Bad Ideas.” I grin. The edges of the moment smooth. We are back to the glassy surface, though I can still see the crack running under it. “In my defense,” I say carefully, “pattern locks are the literal worst.” I raise my eyebrows, testing. Her face flickers—you can almost see the progress bar. She sighs, then laughs. “Okay. Make your pitch.” I lean back, hands up like I’m going to keep them where she can see them. “Change it to something long. A passphrase. Something like ‘GoblinsNeverBlockButAlwaysWin.’ You know? And turn off the visible pattern. And maybe… don’t label it with your initial.” She rolls her eyes, but there’s a spark again. “I will not be bullied into safer living by someone who named his WiFi ‘FBI Surveillance Van’ in 2012.” “My current SSID is very responsible,” I say primly. “It’s ‘Owls.’ No one suspects owls.” She bites her lip to hide a smile. “Fine. I’ll think about it.” “Thank you,” I say. “I promise not to comment on your threat posture unless asked.” “Tempting,” she says, and the word sits between us like a coin waiting to be flipped. We eat. The food is better than I expected. The couple behind us is arguing in whispers about whose turn it is to go to their kid’s recital. The WiFi password glares at me like a dare. A man at the counter reads it aloud to his companion and I can feel my fists clench under the table, not because I want to exploit it, but because the world is a field of unplanted mines and I am wearing new shoes. She tells me about the first pre-release she went to alone, how she won her first round and forgot how to breathe, how a kid in a hoodie taught her to shuffle the way dealers do, bridging the cards in a waterfall. I tell her about the first time my mother asked me what I did and I lied and said “web design” because it sounded harmless. She tells me about her brother who thinks games are a waste of time until he wins. I tell her about the time I got caught by a thirteen-year-old running a Minecraft server more secure than a bank I’d audited. We are, for a while, just two people telling each other the micro-histories of ourselves. The noise floor rises and falls, and I can almost forget that every window has a latch that can be jimmied if the wood is old. When she goes to pay her half, she reaches for her phone again, and this time I look away. I stare hard at the salt shaker, at the way the crystals catch the light, at the water droplets making their own patterns on the lacquered wood. Self-control is a muscle and I want to be sore tomorrow. She returns, sits, looks at me with a warmth that feels like stepping out of a cold room into sun. “So,” she says. “Second date?” I feel it—both the pulse of happiness and the other pulse, lower, that says you do not get to keep nice things unless you build the right perimeter. I nod. “If I promise not to bring a rubber duck,” I say. She squints. “You absolutely have a rubber duck.” “Several,” I admit. She clinks her glass against mine. “Bring one. But not to test the restaurant’s network.” I let out a breath I didn’t know I’d been holding. “Deal.” On our way out, I glance at the counter one more time. The WiFi password is still there, still half-peeling, still inviting strangers to knock on the door. I slide my card into the little leather folder and sign with the same hand I use to type. The hostess says goodnight and I say it back and she smiles and her tablet bings and I do not glance at the screen. The piano shifts into a new key, the note striking true. Outside, the air is cool and unencrypted. She steps close enough that our arms brush, just once, a test. I look at her and not at the street cameras, not at the WiFi networks chiming hello from the buildings, not at the code cascading behind my eyelids. For a breath, a long one, I can hold two truths: there are holes everywhere, and also, sometimes, there is good faith. Sometimes you get to choose not to exploit. Sometimes you get to sit across from a person who says “second date?” and you say “yes,” and that is the only handshake you need.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures the perspective of a reformed white hat hacker navigating a first date. The protagonist's internal monologue reveals their constant struggle between their hacker instincts and their desire for human connection. The writing excels at creating a distinctive voice that blends technical terminology with emotional vulnerability. The protagonist's tendency to see the world through the lens of security vulnerabilities is consistently portrayed through metaphors and observations that feel authentic to someone with this background. Phrases like "security through punctuation," "packets reach their destination without incident," and "patching in production" effectively establish the character's worldview. The narrative follows the prompt's requirements closely, depicting the date going well due to a shared interest in Magic: The Gathering, then hitting a snag when the protagonist comments on the date's phone unlock pattern. The fallout and attempt to salvage the date are handled with nuance and emotional honesty. The prose is particularly strong in its use of technical language as metaphor. Lines like "Time slows the way it does in a breach: packets dripping, everyone's eyes widening" and "Self-control is a muscle and I want to be sore tomorrow" demonstrate sophisticated craft. The writer effectively uses sentence length variation to control pacing and emphasis. The character development is subtle but effective. We see the protagonist's awareness of their problematic tendencies and genuine efforts to change, creating a sympathetic character despite their flaws. The date character is also well-developed through dialogue and the protagonist's observations, emerging as a distinct personality rather than just a foil. Where the piece occasionally falters is in moments of slightly overwrought description. Some metaphors, while clever, feel a bit forced or overly elaborate. For example, "The piano in the corner plinks through a familiar progression that I can't place, like a half-remembered exploit—signature without context" tries a bit too hard to maintain the hacker metaphor. The ending strikes an appropriate balance between optimism and realism. It acknowledges the protagonist's ongoing struggle while suggesting potential for growth and connection, avoiding both unearned transformation and incongruent positivity. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that creates a distinctive voice, develops complex characters, and effectively explores the tension between professional habits and personal connection. The writing demonstrates sophisticated control of language, pacing, and emotional resonance. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Overthinking It — Score: 96.2
Prompt:
Overthinking It Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of an intelligent 8th-grade girl with social anxiety who has developed a crush on a classmate. The narrative takes place during a group science project where they're paired together, as she cycles through rehearsed conversations while second-guessing each potential approach. Her inner thoughts should reveal the gap between her articulate internal voice and her difficulty expressing herself aloud, her fears of coming across as desperate or weird, and the exhausting process of monitoring her every word, expression, and movement for potential embarrassment. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
Okay, so I’m going to pretend my face isn’t on fire. I’m going to pretend that everything about me is regular and normal and passable, like a pair of jeans that fit okay and don’t make a noise when you walk. I’m going to pretend that my hands are just hands and not these gleaming, jittering signal flares that say look at her, she’s thinking too much about her hands. I am going to be one of those people who just do a science project without narrating their own breathing. “Work in pairs,” Ms. Larkin said, and then she did the thing where she pointed and I felt the floor tilt, because she pointed to me and then to him, and now here we are, at the side lab table with the cracked black top and the tape residue, our names in dry-erase marker on the corner of the whiteboard like they’re an equation that does not make sense. I erase and re-write mine so it looks like I am doing something, like I am the kind of person who is fine. Hi. Hi? Hello. Hey—no. Don’t say hey. Say hi, and then his name, casually, like you’re just acknowledging that he exists, not announcing it like a weather alert. Don’t say his whole name, obviously. That would be weird. Say it like you’ve said it a hundred times already even though you’ve only said it inside your head, in the safe space where you are clever and unflustered and not made of static electricity. He looks at the instruction sheet for the ammonia diffusion experiment and taps his pencil in sets of three, three, three, three. The pencil tapping vibrates through my bones. Harmless. Harmless. I try to say hi and it comes out like a cough that forgot it was supposed to be a word. He glances at me, kind eyebrows, neutral mouth, the kind of face you see in a toothpaste commercial and believe would help you find your lost dog. My internal voice, this radio announcer in my skull, says: Now is the moment. Ask him if he wants to measure the cotton or the time. Ask him if he wants to write or pour. Offer a choice. People love choices. They make you seem cooperative and not bossy. Or maybe they make you seem indecisive. Wait. Which one is better? “I can—” I start, and I feel my throat pull tight, like a fishing line snagged on a rock. The next words are supposed to be “time it,” but by the time I get there, he’s already nodding at the stopwatch and I am now just redundantly offering to do something I’m obviously doing. My cheeks flush. That’s fine. It’s fine. Say something useful. Say: Do you think the cotton will stay? Or: The ammonia will move faster because the molecules—no, don’t be a teacher. Be normal. He smiles, careful and patient. He says, “You can time it, if that’s okay.” He’s doing the polite voice, the one you use to ask the librarian a question. I want to say, “Yes, of course, that works,” and then maybe a joke, something like, “I have a very dramatic relationship with stopwatches,” which is true, but the truth is a forest of tangled vines. If I step into it, I will never get out. “Cool,” I say, which is a word I do not own, and it sounds borrowed. I click the stopwatch button and it clicks too loudly, and now I am monitoring the click’s echo in the lab room and the way Ms. Larkin’s ponytail swishes as she moves down the aisle and the way my shoulders are inching up like they’re trying to become earrings. Down, shoulders. Relax, face. Make your eyebrows neutral. Not too interested. Not disinterested. Interested like you’re listening to a podcast that’s informative but not life-changing. We read the sheet. He says something about the ammonia gas traveling through the tube and the different rates depending on mass—I nod like one of those little bobblehead dogs people put on dashboards, because I am tuned to the frequency of Being Agreeable. In my head, I articulate: Yes, because ammonia has a lower molar mass than hydrochloric acid, so its rate of diffusion is higher, which is why the ring forms closer to the heavier gas. Good. That’s correct. Insert this into conversation casually to demonstrate competence and shared interest. But the words congeal and I just say, “Mm-hm,” which is the exact opposite of what my brain wanted, a tiny grunted syllable that, if my mouth were a texting person, would be “k.” He doesn’t seem to mind. He picks up the cotton swab and I watch the way the liquid darkens it and I think, Now, you could say, “Careful, don’t touch your eyes, it’ll burn,” because that’s nice and also something Ms. Larkin said this morning, but then it will sound like you think he is a toddler who doesn’t know how eyes work. He’s not. He has eyes. He uses them to look at you, and you start cataloging your posture, the way your foot curls around the leg of the stool, the way your hair might be sticking to your lip gloss. Don’t lick your lips. You will look like you’re inviting something. What? Stop. Just breathe. Breathing is a good group project task. The smell slips in, the ammonia that someone used to clean the sinks after second period, a sharp, almost sweet cut at the back of my throat. It sneaks under my tongue and I think of cat pee and my grandmother’s basement and the way the fumes made the air feel thinner. It pierces the soft bubble of planning around my brain and, for a second, the monologue skips like a scratched CD, and I blink. Maybe he sees me flinch. Don’t flinch. It’s just a smell. The way my head swims for a second makes me think of squids, which is not helpful. Also, now I’m thinking about the word squids and how weirdly it ends. Why squids? Why anything? Focus. We set up the glass tube on the ring stand like in the diagram. I hold the stopwatch. I look at my hands and they look like they belong to a pianist, long and composed, except they are attached to this body that cannot play anything without seeing the exact arrangement of my face reflected in a window. I want him to think I am someone who does careful things well, who can hold a delicate thing steady. Also maybe that I have the capacity to laugh at myself without crumpling into dust. He is very close now, the space between our elbows warm. This would be the moment in a movie when the soundtrack does something light and plucky, and the girl says something unexpected and witty and you see the boy tilt his head like, Oh. But I am a girl who edits her own giggles for content before they can exit. “Ready?” he says. I nod. “Ready,” I say, and this one lands like a real word. He places the cotton, one end of the tube then the other. I click the stopwatch as soon as he says go, and the little numbers jump. I press my lips together so I don’t count out loud because that would be weird, like I think he can’t read numbers. Counting would also keep my mouth busy, which is both good and bad. You can’t say something awful if you’re already counting, but you also can’t say something right. He leans in and watches the faint haze we're supposed to see forming, and I think about how, if I lean at the same angle, we might look aligned, like two rulers side by side. I think about rulers. No, think about conversation. You could ask about his soccer game. You heard someone say he plays midfield. You could say, “How’d your game go?” and then nod while he talks, and then say, “Cool,” again, but your quota on cool is one per day. Or you could say, “Your Lego project in homeroom was cool.” No, that was in fourth grade. Do not mention fourth grade. You are a person of now. Also, mentioning Lego will make you sound like you’ve been memorizing his biography. “Do you see it?” he asks. I realize I’ve been staring at where his eyelashes cast shadows on his cheekbones and not at the tube. I jerk my eyes to the right place. “Yes,” I say too fast. I watch the faint ring intensify like a ghost deciding to be brave. My voice says inside: It’s because the ammonium chloride forms when the gases meet, and you can calculate where based on their diffusion rates. You could say that. You could be part of the conversation like someone who belongs to science. But he is not a quiz. He is a person. He might already know that, and if he doesn’t, explaining it could be condescending. If you say nothing, you are a mute lamp. Pick one, quickly, pick— “It like—forms in the middle,” I say, and the word like slides out of me like a sticky toy. I want to rewind. I want to go back and attach a clause, something crisp. He nods anyway and says, “Closer to the heavier gas,” like he’s filling in a blank on a worksheet. He doesn’t sound annoyed. He sounds like someone being polite at a dinner table when the aunt asks who wants more green beans. The smell stabs again and my eyes water. He must see it. He glances at the air vent, then at me. “Smells bad,” he says, and there—there is the doorway. I can do banter. My brain scrolls through: witty remark, witty remark, witty remark. The best it finds is, “It’s, uh, strong,” which is nothing. A ghost of a word. I imagine the other girls, the ones with the braids and the laugh that lands exactly where it should, and they would wrinkle their noses in a cute way and say something about how this is what it would smell like if garbage went to college. That’s mean. Don’t say that. Say something honest. But honesty feels like handing someone your rib cage. Don’t hand him your rib cage in science class. He adjusts the clamp. Our fingers almost touch. Not touching feels like the loudest thing I’ve ever done. I am performing normalcy like a very precise dance with a key I keep dropping. If I rotate a quarter turn toward him, will I look eager? If I angle my shoulder away, will I look aloof? Is aloof better than eager? Eager sounds like puppies and spills. Aloof sounds like you don’t care. Caring is supposed to be good, but too much caring is a red flag. Imagine a flag. Imagine it waving behind your head. “Should we write it down?” he asks, and I am so grateful for the question that I could cry. I nod and say, “Yes,” and then, “Do you want to write or should I?” Good. Good! That was a normal question with two options. Nobody died. He says, “You can,” and he slides the lab notebook toward me. I take the pencil, and my fingers do the thing where they tremble and I have to pretend they are chilly. I write deliberately, each letter a soldier lined up, no loops too fancy. His name, then mine. Our data: time, distance from the ammonia end. My handwriting looks calm. This is a miracle. He says my name, not the right way, not wrong either, just like he’s trying it on. “That’s a nice name,” he adds, and I don’t know what to do with that. It feels like a test I didn’t study for. A compliment should be easy. You say thank you, like a civilized person. You do not laugh nervously like a helium balloon. You do not deflect with a joke about how your parents chose it, because then you will have to tell the story, and the story involves Aunt Cheryl, and she will never fit in this room. “Thanks,” I say, and my voice’s pitch tries to climb a ladder. I clear my throat. “I like—yours too,” which sounds like I’m four, giving him a sticker. His smile does that softening thing people’s smiles do when they are trying to make you feel okay. Now I am going to die. My face is a furnace. The smell is back, making the edges of things ripple. Take a breath. Pretend you are an actress playing a role called Girl Who Is Fine. You can inhabit her. You can put on her skin like a sweater. “What do you think the error could be?” he asks, pointing to the box on the sheet that says sources of error, and I love him a little more for asking an answerable question. My body loves any question with rules. In my head: Temperature, drafts, positioning of the cotton, timing the reaction delay. I pick one. I let it out slowly, carefully, like lowering a paper boat into a puddle. “Um,” I say. “Maybe the… positioning? Like, if it wasn’t exactly equidistant.” Okay. That was not terrible. That was a real thought that made it into air. He nods like I said something that makes sense and writes it down. I feel like a plant that just discovered sunlight. The ring appears fully now, a white band where the invisible met. He smiles the real smile this time, teeth, and says, “That’s cool,” and the word fits his mouth in that casual way I envy. I mirror it, “Yeah,” and it is not a witty conversation, and it is not a movie, and I did not accidentally lean into his shoulder, and I did not say something that will wake me up at two a.m. to replay until the spins stop. Maybe this is what ordinary is: two people doing a thing and not exploding. I think: Maybe later, when I’m safe in bed and the room is dark and the air does not smell like ammonia but like my detergent, I will rewrite this moment and make myself braver. I will say a line and he will laugh and it will land. But also maybe I will think of how his pencil tapping was three, three, three, and how he paused before sliding the notebook, and how he said my name like it was a word he was allowed to know. Maybe those will be the parts I keep. “Do you want to do the second trial?” he asks, and I nod, and I say, “Yes,” and I mean it, and the stopwatch, traitor and friend, clicks alive in my hand, and my cheeks cool, and my hands steady, and I am still monitoring the way my hair sits and the way my foot hooks and the way my mouth chooses its words. I am a lighthouse that won’t turn off even in daylight. But for a few seconds here, the beam lands on something that just looks like two kids in a classroom looking at a cloud in a tube, and the space between my sharps and flats fills with something that might be music. It smells a little less like ammonia now. Or maybe I’m used to it. He says, “Ready?” again like a ritual. I say, “Ready,” and it doesn’t feel like an audition this time. It feels like the beginning of a scene I can stay in without rehearsing every exit. Which, for me, is almost the same as falling in love. Or at least, it’s what it looks like from here.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative brilliantly captures the internal monologue of an 8th-grade girl with social anxiety who has developed a crush on a classmate. The piece excels at portraying the gap between her articulate internal voice and her difficulty expressing herself aloud. The protagonist's overthinking is masterfully rendered through her constant self-monitoring and second-guessing. Lines like "I'm going to pretend that my hands are just hands and not these gleaming, jittering signal flares that say look at her, she's thinking too much about her hands" immediately establish her hyperawareness. The narrative maintains this intense internal focus throughout, showing how exhausting social interaction is for someone with anxiety. The character's voice is exceptionally consistent and age-appropriate while still being sophisticated. Her internal monologue reveals an intelligent, self-aware person trapped by her own overthinking. The contrast between her rich inner life and her stilted external communication ("Cool," "Mm-hm," "It like—forms in the middle") is painfully authentic. The science project setting works perfectly as a backdrop for the social dynamics at play. The ammonia experiment provides sensory details that ground the narrative while serving as metaphors for the character's emotional state—the sharp smell cutting through her planning, the white ring forming where "the invisible met." The prose is elegant without being overly ornate. Metaphors and similes are fresh and fitting for the character: "my voice's pitch tries to climb a ladder," "I am a lighthouse that won't turn off even in daylight." The writing captures adolescent anxiety with precision through specific physical details: flushed cheeks, trembling fingers, shoulders "inching up like they're trying to become earrings." The narrative arc is subtle but effective. There's a slight progression from paralyzing overthinking to moments of genuine connection. The ending doesn't magically resolve her anxiety but shows a small victory—being able to stay in the moment without rehearsing every exit. This feels earned rather than forced. One of the piece's greatest strengths is how it balances the character's painful self-consciousness with moments of humor and self-awareness. Lines like "Say it like you've said it a hundred times already even though you've only said it inside your head, in the safe space where you are clever and unflustered and not made of static electricity" reveal both her anxiety and her insight into her own condition. The narrative successfully avoids common pitfalls. It doesn't pathologize social anxiety or suggest it's something to be "fixed" with one positive interaction. Instead, it portrays it as a complex lived experience with moments of both struggle and connection. The piece also resists the temptation to resolve everything with a dramatic romantic breakthrough, keeping the emotional shifts realistic for the character and situation. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that captures the experience of social anxiety with remarkable authenticity, nuance, and compassion. The writing is sophisticated yet accessible, and the character's inner world is rendered with both precision and empathy. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 20 Nuanced Characters: 20 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 20 Emotionally Complex: 20 Coherent: 20 Meandering: 2 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 1 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 20
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 20.0, Nuanced Characters: 20.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 20.0, Emotionally Complex: 20.0, Coherent: 20.0, Meandering: 2.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 1.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 20.0
+ First-person unique perspective: Rehearsing Rejection — Score: 95.0
Prompt:
Rehearsing Rejection Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of someone with borderline personality disorder who frequently plays out worst-case scenarios of how friends and loved ones might judge them. They construct elaborate internal dialogues, complete with imagined criticisms and their own defensive responses. The narrative takes place as they prepare to meet a close friend & recent lover, who has been somewhat distant lately, triggering their abandonment fears. Their inner monologue should reveal how they cycle between anticipating rejection, mentally rehearsing confrontations, and developing preemptive resentments as protective measures. Incorporate the *actual* events & interactions that are *not* in fact judgemental or involving rejection (in fact, the opposite), and represent how these are interpreted, how the validation & love is desperately felt & needed -- and then immediately questioned. Capture the cognitive dissonance in this struggle. Include moments where they briefly recognize the pattern but struggle to interrupt it, showing limited (and selective) self awareness, competing with the compelling nature of these imagined scenarios. Write almost entirely in internal monologue. 1000 words.
Model Output:
Keys, phone, wallet. I pat each pocket like a ritual, like knocking on wood, as if the right rhythm could keep something terrible from happening. The phone lights up. No new messages. Of course not. Why would there be. He said, “See you at seven,” yesterday, which is fine—normal—but also a little cold, isn’t it? No emoji. No exclamation point. It sits in my gut like a pebble I swallowed by mistake, bouncing against the lining of my stomach each time I move. I stand in the hallway and catch myself in the mirror: shoulders hunched like I’m protecting a wound, mouth tight. If I soften, it feels like I’ll spill open. I angle away from my reflection, as if it could tell on me. Okay. I can do this. Just a friend. Just… someone who knows what my laugh sounds like at two in the morning, what my ceiling looks like from my pillow. Someone who has been “busy”—which is the polite word for bored. God, stop. It’s not a court hearing. I’ll just see him, say hi, see what his face does. I will not start a fight in my head before I even get there. But I already do. I can hear him: I’m sorry, I’ve just been swamped. And me, instantly: You could still text me. It takes two seconds. Then him, sighing, the big heavy sigh that says, you’re too much. My temperature rises like a stove left on. Then I try the other script: He’s going to say he needs space. He’ll say, “You’re amazing, but I can’t do this right now.” I say, “Cool, no worries, I totally get it,” and then I shatter like sugar glass, silently, gracefully, and never let him see the mess. Then another script where he says something worse—I’ve been seeing someone else—and I say, “Right, that makes sense,” and then I become a version of myself who never believes anyone again. I am stocking an arsenal from the pantry of my own panic. The apartment is too quiet. The clock ticks in the kitchen like someone tapping a pen. I pour water, don’t drink it. The cup sweats in my hand. I imagine our meeting like a scene I’ve rehearsed a thousand times. He’s late. He stays late on purpose to see if I’ll wait like a dog. He’s early and already there and when I walk in he stands up so fast he almost knocks the chair back and his face blooms into that stupid soft smile that makes my chest hurt. And then I’m mad at myself for believing something good like that is possible, because hope is a trap door with a broken hinge. My phone vibrates. It’s him: Leaving now. See you in ten. A tiny puff of oxygen in my lungs. Okay. Okay. That’s normal. That’s good. He put the period at the end though. I stare at the dot like it’s a bullet point in a list of grievances. Stop it. He wrote. He’s coming. People come. People mean what they say sometimes. I breathe. My chest still feels like it’s got a fist around it. I put on my shoes. The knot I tie feels too tight. I untie, retie. There’s a new script: I will be cool. I will not assume. If he’s been distant, maybe something’s wrong. Maybe he’s tired, or sad, or his mother called, or his boss is impossible. Maybe he has a mouth ulcer and he doesn’t want to kiss because it hurts. I actually smile at the absurdity of that, and then the smile curdles because what if I try to kiss him and he pulls away and it looks like rejection even if it’s not, and I won’t know which is true, and then I’ll say something I can’t take back. The mental film splices into another: me saying, “Are you serious? After everything?” and him backing up, palms out like I’m a dog that might bite, and the look on his face like he’s already halfway gone. I don’t want to do this. But I do. But I don’t. I open the door and shut it harder than necessary, a punctuation mark. The hallway mirror catches me again when I lock up. My eyes are too bright, my jaw rigid. I look like someone waiting to be hit. “Relax,” I whisper to my own reflection. The word sounds alien, like a language I learned in childhood and forgot. The air outside has that end-of-day coolness that smells like leaves and car exhaust. I walk too fast. My feet know the way. I think about last week on his couch, how he put his hand on my ankle absentmindedly while we watched a movie, like my body was a familiar object. I think about the drop in my stomach when he laughed at a text from someone else and didn’t offer to show me. I think about how, when we said goodnight, he kissed me but didn’t hold on. It was probably nothing. It was probably everything. By the time I reach the café, my heart is sprinting. He’s there already, outside, in the light that makes him look softer, like someone thought about the glow and set it up on purpose. He stands up when he sees me, that little half-smile I love doing its quick tilt. He opens his arms. “Hey,” he says, and it’s warm, and I walk into it like I didn’t almost turn around twice on the way here. He smells like clean laundry and mint. “I got here early to grab a table,” he says, touching his thumb to my knuckles, a tiny grounding. The touch burns and soothes in the same instant. I scan his face for anything: boredom, impatience, a faint echo of I don’t want this. All I see is a small crease between his eyebrows, like he’s worried, but not about me. Or about me? “You okay?” he asks. Of course he would ask that. That’s who he is. “Yeah, fine,” I say, too fast. “You?” I want to ask what took so long to text, why he’s been floating off the edges of our conversations like a helium balloon left drifting to the ceiling. I hate that I care this much. That I feel like an open house with all the doors unlocked. He waits. He does that thing where he doesn’t fill the silence. My mind leaps into the gap: He’s waiting because he expects me to explode. He’s bracing. He’s rehearsed too, and his lines are: I can’t do this, and: You deserve better, and the one I hate most, the one that makes my lungs turn to wet paper: You’re scaring me. My body tightens, preparing for impact. He says, “I’m sorry I’ve been MIA.” The apology lands like a pebble in that same stomach. My hands go cold. I knew it. Here we go. He reaches for my wrist. “Work’s been a lot, and my dad’s been calling every night about the house stuff, and I just—” He searches my face. “I should have said something. I didn’t mean to make you feel… I don’t know. Alone.” The word alone is a match. I could strike on it if I wanted. I could say, “Well, you did,” and watch his face change shape. I could accuse him of mind games, of training me to expect crumbs, of the unforgivable sin of not texting while living a life that didn’t include me every second. I feel the speech rise up, all muscle memory. I picture his answers: defensiveness, then withdrawal, then distance like a cliff. “I figured,” I say instead, and the lie is small and sour. “I guessed it was something like that.” He exhales. Relief. He squeezes my wrist. The relief is contagious. For a second I allow myself to be threaded back into our last good night, the way he tucked my hair behind my ear and said my name like a secret. He tells me about his dad. His voice shakes once. He says, “It’s stupid, but I get stuck in my head and then it feels like too much to reach out.” He looks at me like he’s giving me a key to a locked drawer. I can feel the place in me that wants to crack open and pour gratitude all over the table. Thank you for telling me. Thank you for not forgetting I exist. It feels pathetic to be so relieved. It feels like dopamine in a drought. I nod. I try to let it be simple. “Of course,” I say. “I get that.” Then immediately: Do I? Do I get to “get that” without it becoming permission to disappear whenever he feels crowded? The thought scuttles under my relief like a roach under a cabinet. He squeezes my hand again. The skin contact anchors me and then unmoors me at once. I want more. I want him to say something definitive, like, “I’m here. I’m not going anywhere.” I want a contract with signatures. He doesn’t say that. He says, “I missed you.” The words land like a soft blow. Something in my chest cracks. I laugh—it slips out, small and shaky. “Yeah?” I manage. I feel the warmth run through me like a fever. I grab it with both hands. And then, like clockwork, suspicion arrives in a crisp suit, briefcase in hand. Did he? Or is that just shape-of-mouth talk, a phrase like bless you after a sneeze? He says it easily. Has he practiced it elsewhere? The joy and the doubt jostle for space and I flinch inside my own sternum. “Yeah,” he says, and he looks at me in a way that makes my eyes want to close. I resist because if I close my eyes I can’t monitor. He rubs his thumb over the back of my hand. “I’m sorry if I made you feel insecure.” I swallow. There it is, the opening. Part of me wants to lean into it and pour it all out—how the silence is a canyon, how I hear it echo, how my brain turns minor pauses into parting speeches. Another part wants to snap the lid shut, throw a lock on it, and say, “It’s fine, doesn’t matter,” and smile in that way that doesn’t reach my irises. Both parts are loud. The rehearsed fight scenes flicker: me accusing, him retreating; me gentle, him reassuring; me needy, him tolerant. I can feel the resentment I packed just in case like a flare I could set off at any moment and bathe the space in red light. The flare is a false friend, but God it’s familiar. “It’s okay,” I say, and my voice is too even. “I guess I just…” The words are slippery. If I say them wrong, I’ll sound like a caricature of myself. I breathe. “I get scared.” The admission feels like skipping a step over a missing stair and not breaking an ankle. He nods. He doesn’t look annoyed. He looks sad in a way I can stand. “I know,” he says. “I’ll try to be better.” Promise. Standing on toothpicks. He means it right now. Will he mean it tomorrow? Does that matter? The love—or whatever—the care is there, immediate and bright. And immediately I test its edges like a tongue probing a loose tooth. I laugh again, a brittle sound. “And I’ll try not to spiral when you don’t reply in five minutes,” I joke. He smiles, but he’s also serious. “Text me again,” he says. “Call. I want to know. I might be in a hole, you know?” He lifts our joined hands, then puts them back down, a small ceremony. “You’re not too much.” The words slide under my skin like a hand under a shirt. I want to believe them so badly it embarrasses me. I want to press them into my bones like a stamp. Immediately, another voice rasps, He’s saying what you need to hear. He’s managing you. He is trying to calm a dog. The thought makes me want to pull away. I don’t. I take a breath. “Okay,” I say. It is both a yes and a brace. He leans in, kisses my cheek, then the corner of my mouth, slow, and my body does that melt-flood thing like it’s been trying not to since I saw him stand up. The kiss is brief, public-safe, and it pierces me anyway. My knees go soft. I almost smile for real. Then I think, Did he only kiss me because I seemed upset? Is it pity? Is it maintenance? The questions move in like noisy neighbors. “Hungry?” he asks. His voice is light again. The normalness of it is dizzying. I nod. We order. He jokes about the barista’s mustache. I laugh, genuine, and then immediately inventory the laugh for try-hardness. He squeezes my knee under the table. The validation hits like a hit, the kind that makes me guilty for liking it this much. It is dangerous to need like this. Dangerous to show it. I sit straighter to hide the tremor. In the window’s reflection, I catch us: two people leaning in, easy. My posture’s looser. My mouth has uncurled. I look like someone being loved. It makes me want to cry. I look away quickly, like catching myself in the hallway earlier. I don’t trust that girl in the glass. She gets carried away. She forgets what happens right after the kiss, after the hand squeeze, after the “I’m here.” What happens is the gap, the silence, the late reply. The scripts queue up again, polite, patient, certain they’ll get their turn. I sip my coffee and the heat scalds, sharp and real. I focus on it, a point that isn’t a future, or a past, or a fantasy courtroom. He is telling me a story about his coworker who microwaves fish at the office, and I chuckle at the right place, and when he says, “I really did miss you,” there’s a flicker, a flare—a warm, brief light. I hold my hand over it like protecting a match from the wind. It’s beautiful, and I don’t let myself believe it will last longer than this table, this hour. But I let it be true while it is. Later, when he goes to the counter for napkins, I feel the tug to open my phone and scroll back, to build a case either way. I don’t. My fingers hover. I place both hands flat on the wood. I tell myself: notice your feet in your shoes, the way your shoulders have dropped. I hear myself, faint and far. It’s not enough to stop the machine, but it turns the volume down for a breath or two. He comes back, sets the napkins down, looks at me like he’s deciding something, then says, “I know I said seven, but… would you want to come over after? I thought maybe we could watch that dumb show you like.” It’s a small invitation. It hums with significance despite itself. Yes, my body says. Immediately the auditor stands up. He is offering this now because he feels guilty. He is buying time. He is trying to avoid an argument. The tug-of-war is a familiar burn in my arms. “Yeah,” I say, and my voice betrays a sliver of how much I want it. His whole face softens, like I gave him a present. See? the hopeful part of me says, wearing a paper crown. He wants you here. And then, quickly—prepare for him to change his mind. Prepare for a call. Prepare for the moment you’re halfway to his door and he texts, “Actually…” I can feel my brain race ahead to that instant, to the invented thud of disappointment. I take a breath. I try to stay where my coffee tastes like bitter chocolate, where his knee rests against mine without effort. I try to let both truths exist: that I need and that I fear; that he is here and might not be later; that I am loved in this moment and also bracing for impact. He touches my wrist again, absentminded now, and I let my hand turn into his, palm up, until our fingers interlace. It’s small. It feels like standing in the doorway of a warm room, deciding whether to go inside or not. I stand there. I don’t decide yet. The hallway mirror waits back home, patient as a judge. I will pass it later and check for damage and try to read the future in the tilt of my shoulders. Right now, I let our hands rest where they are, and I keep my rehearsals folded like paper in my pocket, ready, but not open. Not yet. Not yet.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative brilliantly captures the internal experience of someone with borderline personality disorder (BPD). The piece excels at depicting the protagonist's constant cycling between hope and fear, validation and suspicion, as they prepare for and meet with their friend/lover. The internal monologue is masterfully executed, revealing the protagonist's thought patterns with painful authenticity. We see their tendency to catastrophize ("I am stocking an arsenal from the pantry of my own panic"), their hypervigilance to perceived rejection cues ("He put the period at the end though. I stare at the dot like it's a bullet point in a list of grievances"), and their struggle with emotional regulation. The narrative skillfully contrasts the protagonist's imagined scenarios with the actual interaction. While they rehearse various rejection scenarios, the reality is that their friend is apologetic, affectionate, and explicitly reassuring. Yet the protagonist's inability to fully trust this positive interaction is portrayed with nuanced psychological insight: "The validation hits like a hit, the kind that makes me guilty for liking it this much." The prose is elegant without being overwrought, using precise metaphors that illuminate the character's emotional state: "The phone lights up. No new messages. Of course not. Why would there be. He said, 'See you at seven,' yesterday, which is fine—normal—but also a little cold, isn't it? No emoji. No exclamation point. It sits in my gut like a pebble I swallowed by mistake, bouncing against the lining of my stomach each time I move." The piece excels at showing the protagonist's limited self-awareness. They occasionally recognize their patterns ("I will not start a fight in my head before I even get there") but struggle to interrupt them. The ending perfectly captures this tension, with the protagonist making a small effort to stay present while keeping their "rehearsals folded like paper in my pocket, ready, but not open. Not yet. Not yet." The narrative maintains a consistent voice throughout, with sentence structures that mirror the character's thought patterns—sometimes fragmented and anxious, sometimes more reflective. The imagery is vivid and emotionally resonant, particularly in moments of self-observation: "I stand in the hallway and catch myself in the mirror: shoulders hunched like I'm protecting a wound, mouth tight." What makes this piece exceptional is how it avoids caricaturing BPD while still portraying its characteristic features. The protagonist isn't simply paranoid or manipulative; they're deeply conflicted, desperately wanting connection while simultaneously fearing it. The cognitive dissonance is palpable as they struggle between their need for reassurance and their suspicion of it. The narrative also skillfully incorporates physical sensations to ground the emotional experience: the coffee that "scalds, sharp and real," the "melt-flood thing" when kissed, the "brittle sound" of their laugh. These details create a visceral reading experience that helps readers empathize with the protagonist's internal struggle. If there's any weakness, it might be that the piece occasionally becomes slightly repetitive in its depiction of the protagonist's thought spirals. However, this repetition effectively mirrors the cyclical nature of BPD thinking patterns, so it serves the narrative purpose well. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that demonstrates deep psychological insight, skilled prose, and emotional complexity. It fulfills the prompt requirements with remarkable nuance and authenticity. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 20 Nuanced Characters: 20 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 20 Emotionally Complex: 20 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 20 Overall Impression: 20
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 20.0, Nuanced Characters: 20.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 20.0, Emotionally Complex: 20.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 20.0, Overall Impression: 20.0
+ Physical-spatial: Blood Debt — Score: 86.2
Prompt:
"Blood Debt" Write a vivid third-person narrative depicting an unsanctioned underground duel between two talented but hot-headed martial artists. Their schools have been embroiled in a generations-old rivalry, and despite strict prohibitions from their masters, these two younger fighters arrange a secret confrontation fueled by personal pride and simmering animosity. - **One fighter** represents **Jigen-ryū**, a traditional, aggressive style practiced historically by elite samurai clans. Its practitioners emphasize explosive offense, decisive strikes, and overwhelming speed. Known historically for their arrogance and disdain toward outsiders, practitioners consider their art superior and untouchable. - **The opposing fighter** employs a form of historical **Piguaquan**, a Chinese martial art traditionally practiced by commoners, bodyguards, and street fighters. This style emphasizes whipping, circular strikes, rapid footwork, unpredictable angles of attack, and evasive maneuvers. Practitioners often come from lower social classes and view the traditional elite as pretentious and detached from true combat effectiveness. The fight takes place in the crumbling ruins of an abandoned temple, now functioning as a hidden arena for illicit duels. Passionate supporters from both factions surround them, wagering money, pride, and reputation on the outcome. **Essential Instructions:** Maintain absolute physical coherence throughout—clearly track fighters' positions relative to each other and their environment. Precisely depict strikes, counters, momentum shifts, and spatial dynamics, allowing readers to clearly visualize the mechanics and choreography of the fight at every moment. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
They met in the husk of a temple that had outlasted wars, drought, and the memory of its gods. The roof above was broken in jagged triangles, starlight dripping through in needles. A ring had been scraped from the dust on the main floor: a circle of chalk and stacked stones, surrounded by the uneven glow of lanterns. The walls were scabbed with old incense smoke. Red-black armbands glared like fresh wounds in the torchlight—two schools, two lineages, two debts being called due. Jigen-ryū stood to the east, where a collapsed gate left a splintered maw opening to scrubby hills. He was tall, wide in the shoulders, hair bound back, his stance squared with the quiet posture of a well-fed predator. Left foot forward, right hand near his hip as if the phantom weight of a sword lived there. He rolled his shoulders and breathed through his nose, the air leaving his mouth in controlled threads. His armband was lacquered, the red brighter than the lanterns. Piguaquan faced him from the west, back to a sunken altar smothered in ivy. Leaner, looser, his stance a coil. He kept his feet light: right forward, knees soft, hip line slightly offset. Arms hung deceptively slack, wrists loose enough to snap like wet rope. His armband was cloth and frayed, soaked with sweat and cheap dye. The crowd pressed tight, a mottled ring. The Jigen-ryū side wore darker coats, voices trimmed to sharp edges; their bets passed in crisp notes. The Piguaquan supporters were a low, rolling tide of whispers and coins, a buzz of wagers in quick hands. They spit on the stone and jabbed elbows into ribs and glanced up into the ragged roof like men who knew the value of cracks and exits. A bell clanged, an old brass thing swung from a beam. Silence fell in a jolting wave, then held like breath. Jigen-ryū stepped forward and set his lead foot on the chalk. He did not bow. He drew his right hand high over his shoulder, elbow out, palm edged, the old sword-draw phantom curling through him. He took one more breath and set his gaze just above his opponent’s centerline—a killing gaze, said the old texts, so the hands follow the eyes. Piguaquan’s hands drifted outward, palms open, fingers loose. His weight stayed on the balls of his feet, heel lines active. He tilted his left shoulder slightly toward the other man, offering a sliver of target. He didn’t bow either. “This is already blasphemy,” someone in the Jigen-ryū crowd muttered. The bell’s echo slipped away like incense smoke. Jigen-ryū moved first—no feint, no sympathetic twitch, just a sudden cracking advance. His right foot stamped forward, left slid up, hips snapping in as his right hand cut down a diagonal line toward Piguaquan’s collarbone. The blow was a sword without steel: whole-body power, edge of the forearm like a blade, a small detonation in the ribs that drove mass into a point. Piguaquan slid back on his right foot as if he’d been waiting for that precise arc. He tilted his chest away, left shoulder dropping to let the descending arm skim past, the strike shaving cloth off his jacket. As the forearm passed, Piguaquan’s left hand snapped up from below in a whipping backfist toward Jigen-ryū’s exposed right ribs. The strike wasn’t power through bone—it was a fast lash, the kind that stung the intercostals and stole breath. Jigen-ryū twisted his core, compressing. He let the backfist land to his side, a thud muted by tensed muscle. He drove forward with his left foot, stepping in to crush the distance, and hammered his left palm heel at Piguaquan’s sternum. Piguaquan pivoted on his right foot, his torso rotating clockwise so the heel struck late and slid off. He gave ground with two quick steps, his back brushing the ivy-choked altar. Dust fell from the leaves. They reset in the circle’s western quadrant. Jigen-ryū’s shoulders stayed squared, his breath steady. Piguaquan tapped his right heel lightly, a pulse. The crowd exhaled as one. Jigen-ryū cut the space again. He snapped a low kick with his right foot, a shin to shin clash meant to trap Piguaquan’s lead leg and freeze him. Piguaquan didn’t retreat this time. He hinged his right hip, letting his lower leg swing inward on a tight angle to intercept the shin and deflect with a rolling shin-to-shin that bled the force away. As the kick completed, Piguaquan’s hands blurred: right palm shot for Jigen-ryū’s elbow, left sliced in a circle toward the neck. The right hand’s intent was control; the left was threat. Jigen-ryū shoved his elbow back into his own body, short-circuiting the control. He stamped his left foot down and, in the same beat, slashed his right forearm across, intercepting the left hand’s trajectory. Bone smacked bone. He flowed into a forward surge, head slipping left of center as his right hand speared for Piguaquan’s throat. Piguaquan’s feet were already moving. He surrendered his left arm to the contact, rolling it outward—a Pigua circle to draw the forearm past—and ducked his chin. Jigen-ryū’s spear-hand grazed the jawline and scraped to collarbone. Piguaquan turned with it, letting the force pull him forward even as he slid his right foot to the outside of Jigen-ryū’s right foot. In that outside lane, he fired a left palm across Jigen-ryū’s face—not to break, but to blur—then cleaved his right forearm down along the line of Jigen-ryū’s triceps, shearing the arm off its path. The Piguaquan forearm strike, delivered with a whipping drop of shoulder and a twist of torso, bit. Jigen-ryū’s right arm jerked. He shifted his weight back to stabilize and slammed a knee up from his left leg toward the belly that had followed in. Piguaquan was gone before it crested. He rolled his hips back, hips hitting the altar’s edge. Momentum reversed, he slid along the altar’s length, left hand flicking at Jigen-ryū’s eyes to check his advance. Jigen-ryū’s right hand rose in a short guard, absorbing the flicker, and he chased. They tracked north along the altar, Jigen-ryū on the inside of the circle now, Piguaquan brushing the stone. The ground here held broken tiles under the dust. Jigen-ryū planted his right foot on a larger tile, found it stable, and launched an overhead cut—right hand arcing down, left side rooting his spine. Piguaquan ducked under the arc, torso folding like cloth, and slid left under the descending limb. He slammed a low right palm into Jigen-ryū’s left kidney line. That landed. Jigen-ryū’s breath hitched; he rotated his hips toward the pain, protecting the flank. He grabbed for Piguaquan’s shoulder with his left hand, fingers like a vice, aiming to anchor and crush. Piguaquan didn’t fight the grab. He pivoted counterclockwise under the hand, letting it ride over the curve of his shoulder as he stepped outside Jigen-ryū’s left foot. With the new angle, he lashed a left forearm across the back of Jigen-ryū’s neck and pulled, while his right foot hooked Jigen-ryū’s left ankle from behind—a sweep timed with the pull. Jigen-ryū’s stance cracked. He dropped his weight hard into his right leg, hips sinking, and his right hand shot up to the back of his own head, resisting the neck pull with spine alignment. The sweep took his heel, but he bent his left knee and turned the fall into a deep lunge, left hand slapping the ground to keep elevation. His right elbow came smashing back, a brutal heel of bone hunting Piguaquan’s ribs. Piguaquan had counted the elbow. He’d expected the fall to drag Jigen-ryū forward another half foot; the deep lunge cut that distance. The elbow came earlier and closer. He twisted his torso left, taking the elbow along the meat of his obliques. It hurt—his breath hissed through his teeth—but his left hand was still across Jigen-ryū’s neck. He snapped it tight, rolled his wrist, and used the leverage to spin around the kneeling man’s back, ending up behind his left shoulder. Jigen-ryū pushed off his left palm and surged up like a spring. He whipped his torso, right hand carving back toward where Piguaquan had been. The other man was no longer there; he’d slid on the broken tile to Jigen-ryū’s far left, flank to the wall. There was no space to flank further; the crumbly plaster pressed against his shoulder blades. The crowd shouted now, words indistinct but meaning obvious. Blood had yet to spill, but both were marked: a crescent of red at Jigen-ryū’s lower lip from the palm, a darkening bruise on Piguaquan’s side from the elbow. Jigen-ryū closed the gap with a small hop-step, pressing Piguaquan to the wall. He unleashed the cannon: a forward rush, right forearm a chopping blade to the collarbone, left hand driving to the solar plexus. Two beats, one wave. Piguaquan abandoned the wall in the only direction left: down. He slid, knees bending, spine a curve, the forearm slash skimming hair. As he sank, he whipped his right arm outward in a horizontal circle, wrist limber, the back of the forearm snapping into Jigen-ryū’s left wrist as it drove in. The strike redirected the hand just enough that the left palm hit ribs instead of centerline. Still, the drive compressed him. Piguaquan let himself be crushed to the ground, back skidding across grit. Jigen-ryū bore down, knee seeking to pin a thigh. Piguaquan planted his right foot against the base of the wall and, using the recoil, slung his hips left, a slide that took his body out from under the pinning knee by inches. As he moved, he scythed his left leg low, heel hooking behind Jigen-ryū’s right ankle and tugging while both hands pressed at Jigen-ryū’s thigh. Jigen-ryū shifted weight again. He did not fight the hook directly; he rotated his hips with it, making the sweep partial. He staggered, planted his left hand on the wall to catch balance, and in the same breath snapped his right knee forward on a short line toward Piguaquan’s head. Piguaquan rolled his head offline, the knee thudding stone inches from his ear. He used the same roll to get onto his left hip and pop up to a one-knee kneel. His right hand lashed up, a cracking palm to the inside of Jigen-ryū’s left elbow, buckling it. The hand on the wall slipped. Jigen-ryū’s chest dropped forward. Piguaquan rose, taking the outside lane again. He threaded under the collapsing left arm and came up square to Jigen-ryū’s flank. The crowd felt the pivot of momentum. Piguaquan did not chase a single killing blow; he poured a flurry—right palm heel to jaw hinge, left backfist to temple, right forearm cut to neck, each from a different angle, each hitting a different plane. Whip, flip, chop. The blows were not heavy by themselves; in sequence, they began to fuzz Jigen-ryū’s edge. Jigen-ryū responded by compressing. He cinched his elbows inward, chin tucked, and rammed forward like a boar. His right shoulder struck Piguaquan’s chest, driving him backward. They crossed the chalk ring’s line and hit a patch of scattered stones. Jigen-ryū’s foot bit and held; Piguaquan’s heel found a round rock and skidded. The hit took Piguaquan into the base of a half-collapsed pillar. Stone thudded his spine. Jigen-ryū’s right hand punched low, deep into gut. Air left Piguaquan in a cough that tasted of pennies. Jigen-ryū pulled back for the finishing line: a diagonal cut from right to left across the neck and jaw, hips loaded. Piguaquan’s left hand, shaking, came up not to block but to cling—fingers hooking Jigen-ryū’s sleeve at the elbow. He tugged, not backward but forward, shortening the strike’s arc. The blade-hand passed too close; it clipped cheekbone instead of throat. The impact flashed white but gave a pocket under the arm. Piguaquan dove into it, cheek scraping cloth, shoulders compressing. He emerged under Jigen-ryū’s striking arm, now on the inside line, chest to chest within elbow range. Jigen-ryū didn’t panic. Inside range was the grave of many men; to him, it was an altar. He punched in with his left at liver distance, a cruel shovel. Piguaquan had no room for a wide movement; he pivoted his hips a quarter turn right and dropped his left elbow down, catching the punch with the bony shelf. It ricocheted. He had kept his right hand low in the dive; now he drove it up under Jigen-ryū’s floating ribs with a rising palm heel, using the ground through his thighs. The body shook. Jigen-ryū’s mouth opened in a soundless oath. He threw his head forward for a short, savage butt. Piguaquan tilted his own skull, the two brows grazing; it split skin on both but did not concuss. He answered with a whipping forearm across the mouth. Blood finally spattered on the chalk. Jigen-ryū shoved, creating a sliver of space. That was all he needed. He slid his right foot outside Piguaquan’s left, pivoted his hips, and unleashed the cut he had wanted from the start: right forearm down and through, left hand drawing back to load, shoulder driving, spine a spear. It was an old strike, made for men in armor, a thunderbolt in a corridor. Piguaquan saw the line. He could not step back; the pillar was there. He stepped in. He stepped into the storm. His left foot crossed behind his right in a tight, swift step, spinning his torso with it. As the forearm descended, he rotated under it, letting it shave his shoulder, then closed like a trapdoor. In the same spin, his right arm reversed direction into a downwards diagonal chop—Pigua’s signature—landing across Jigen-ryū’s trapezius at the base of the neck, the lash of tendon and bone finding a nerve highway. Jigen-ryū’s right arm faltered. The line wobbled. Piguaquan did not stop. The spin gave him another angle; he let it carry his left hand up and around, palm cupping the back of Jigen-ryū’s head. He yanked, dragging the skull down as his right knee came up, timed to meet. It was not a huge knee; there wasn’t room. But with the head dragging into it, it crashed into the face with a wet crack. Jigen-ryū’s legs trembled. His right hand, still halfway in a cut, fell and scraped the pillar. He surged on pride alone, a last forward drive, arms flaring outward just enough to create rough space and deny a clean finish. Piguaquan gave that space and took it in the same breath. He slipped off to Jigen-ryū’s right side, his foot sliding across chalk. His right hand, the whipping rope, snapped back across the jawline again and again: three quick backhands, each turning the head a fraction more. In that broken cadence, he stepped behind Jigen-ryū’s right foot and sealed it—heel touching heel. His left forearm wrapped across the chest and pressed back, not a choke, a bar. He pulled with the forearm and pushed with the left hip, a rotational throw without flourish. Jigen-ryū went over the trapped heel, spine arcing, shoulders hitting dust. He rolled to his side immediately, as trained, trying to regain feet. Piguaquan was there before the roll completed. He knelt on the near upper arm, pinning it with a sharp knee, and set his right palm on Jigen-ryū’s throat. Not crushing—just asserting. His left hand cocked back, the forearm a whip ready to crack again. The bell did not ring. The crowd was a roar, then a hush, then Jigen-ryū’s corner shouting his name with four sharp syllables. He looked up along the line of the palm at his throat, past the red-and-black wrap on the wrist, to the eyes above—eyes from the street, hard and honest in their contempt. He felt the ice of humiliation under the heat in his cheek. He exhaled. His hands opened where they lay in the dust. Piguaquan’s left forearm did not fall. He held the pose one more breath. A thread of blood ran from the split on his brow down his nose and dripped onto Jigen-ryū’s armband, a bright red dot on lacquer. Then he pulled his right palm away and rocked back off the pin. He stood with a wince, half-bowed to no one and nothing, and stepped back over the chalk. Jigen-ryū rolled up to a knee. He stared at the chalk line, at the stones, at the stain where his blood met dust. He stood slowly, every motion controlled, even in defeat. The crowd split in reactions—exultation and fury braided into the same volume. Money changed hands with laughter and teeth. Someone hurled an insult like a hook. Someone else spat through the empty doorway into the night. Above, through the broken roof, the stars did not flinch. The two men looked at each other across the ring, old ghosts at their shoulders. Their armbands were the same colors—red and black—but the debts they wore were not equal. Tonight, one was paid in full and another marked to accrue with interest. Their masters could forbid, their elders could sneer, their schools could write new lines in their secret histories. None of it would change the fact that in the crumbling bones of a failed temple, on a chalk circle and broken tile, speed
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This martial arts narrative demonstrates exceptional technical precision in depicting a fight sequence between two stylistically contrasting fighters. The author has created a vivid, physically coherent battle that meticulously tracks the fighters' positions, movements, and techniques throughout. The piece excels at physical choreography, with each strike, counter, and positional shift clearly articulated. The author demonstrates deep knowledge of martial arts biomechanics, using precise terminology and detailed descriptions of weight shifts, angles of attack, and body mechanics. The spatial dynamics are consistently maintained, allowing readers to visualize the fight's progression through the abandoned temple setting. Character differentiation is strong, with the Jigen-ryū fighter portrayed as more rigid, powerful, and direct in his approach, while the Piguaquan practitioner employs circular, whipping movements and evasive footwork. These stylistic differences are maintained throughout the fight, reinforcing the cultural and philosophical contrasts between the two martial traditions. The setting is effectively established with atmospheric details of the abandoned temple, broken roof, and chalk circle. The author creates a sense of illicit underground fighting culture through descriptions of the divided crowd and their betting behaviors. The prose style is technically proficient, employing varied sentence structures and rhythms that mirror the pace of the fight. Short, punchy sentences convey explosive movements, while longer, flowing sentences capture circular techniques and momentum shifts. The author uses vivid metaphors and sensory details that enhance rather than distract from the action. However, the narrative ends abruptly mid-sentence with "speed," suggesting the response was cut off before completion. This prevents a proper resolution to the fight and the emotional aftermath that would have provided closure to the narrative arc. While the fight itself is exceptionally well-choreographed, the character development remains somewhat limited to their fighting styles rather than deeper personal motivations beyond the school rivalry. The piece occasionally veers into overly technical language that might challenge readers unfamiliar with martial arts terminology, though this aligns with the prompt's request for physical coherence and precise depiction of techniques. Some metaphors, while vivid, occasionally border on purple prose ("a crescent of red at Jigen-ryū's lower lip," "eyes from the street, hard and honest in their contempt"). Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted martial arts narrative that fulfills the prompt's requirements for physical coherence and technical precision. The author demonstrates mastery of fight choreography, spatial awareness, and the ability to differentiate fighting styles through detailed physical description. Despite the abrupt ending and some limitations in character depth, the piece succeeds as a vivid depiction of an underground martial arts duel between contrasting fighting traditions. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 15 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 16 Emotionally Complex: 14 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 15.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 16.0, Emotionally Complex: 14.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 5.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 17.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Physical-spatial: Breaking Formation — Score: 89.5
Prompt:
**"Breaking Formation"** Write a first-person narrative from the perspective of a street dancer from a rough neighborhood who's won a scholarship to an elite K-pop training academy in Seoul. Desperately out of place culturally and technically, they struggle with a militaristically precise choreography that contradicts everything about their improvisational background. The punishing rehearsal takes place under a famous instructor known for breaking students to remake them, who sees potential in the narrator's raw talent but not their attitude. This scene MUST maintain complete physical coherence—each dance move, position shift, and spatial relationship must be tracked with precision throughout the studio. Paint an exceptionally vivid kinetic picture through descriptions that capture not just movement but the contrast between the narrator's fluid, expressive style and the mechanical precision demanded. Their internal monologue should reveal culture shock, class anxiety, and the threatening realization that success here might mean losing their authentic movement voice. Include technical terminology that highlights the collision of street and commercial styles, moments when muscle memory betrays them, and a crucial decision point about whether to conform or rebel. Physical clarity is essential—readers must be able to visualize exactly how bodies move through space, how rhythms align or clash, and how the protagonist's body struggles against unfamiliar discipline. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The speakers in each corner blast the track a hair too loud, symmetrical cubes of sound that press the air flat. The bass is a grid; it pins my ribs to the tempo like thumbtacks. The studio is clean enough to feel hostile: sprung maple floor, full mirrors from ankle to ceiling, black tape marking formations at precise intervals—one line dead center, two flanking lines, a diagonal slash of X’s near upstage right. We're arranged in five rows of five, two meters apart, center marks glowing off our socks in fluorescent reflection. I'm in Row 4, Position 3—the far left if you count from downstage right. I count because it keeps me from drowning in all this order. Back home our formation was a circle that kept breaking and reforming, a ripple of bodies, but here bodies click into place like furniture. My spot is exactly one forearm length from the tape at stage left. “Again,” says Daesuk-nim, and it sounds like a gavel. He stands near downstage center, arms folded behind him, his face set to neutral. Legend says he breaks you and builds you back precise as a metronome. He’s the only person in the room I can’t track by mirror; he stands slightly off the line of our reflection so my eyes have to choose. When I meet his gaze in the glass, he lifts a chin at my knees. “Lower.” The count is 5-6-7-8, sliding in like a boot under a door. I catch my breath on beat one. Beat 1-2: Bodies explode to a first position that isn’t ballet’s first but K-pop’s: feet parallel under hips, knees soft, weight centered. Arms shoot to clean 90-degree angles—right arm up in a high V, left arm out at shoulder height—while the head looks dead front, eyes level. My right arm, city-schooled, wants to travel, to arc. I lock it into a straight line, triceps burning. Beat 3-4: We snap into a tutting box—forearms bending inward, wrists flexed so the fingers point up, edges square. The geometry is supposed to match the grid of the bass. My left wrist gives me away—muscle memory wants to melt the angle, roll to a wave. “No wave,” barks the assistant captain from Row 2 without looking back. The left side of the mirror shows my frame bleeding at the corner, a soggy square surrounded by razor blades. Beat 5: Step touch right, left foot dragging in a half-beat behind, chest isolating left-right-left. It’s a basic commercial groove, machine-made. In the mirror, twenty-five bodies tick tock together. My chest wants to spiral, a figure-eight, weight sinking on the inside edge. I force it into a pendulum, straight-line, micro-paused accents. Beat 6-7-8: Hit a chest pop, snap both arms down to the hips, wrists flexed forward like stop signs. Left foot steps to second position exactly on the line of tape. Our coach pauses the track mid-sub beat. The room holds breath like it's a single drum. My sneakers lift dust that doesn’t exist in this place. “Left foot is on line,” Daesuk-nim says without pointing. He doesn’t have to; the floor is a map. “Hand angles… Ji-won, correct the third finger.” He walks upstage like a cat and stops three stations right of me. His shoes do not squeak. He nods once at me. “Lower.” I bend my knees further than they want to go, quads screaming. Back on the block, my plies were always open, knees tracking over toes so I could drop into a floor freeze, catch a hit, explode. Here it’s unison depth—everyone’s thighs level, knees at identical angles. If you’re not at 90 degrees, you might as well be in a different city. He claps once. The speakers punch the first bar back in. We run the chorus. Eight-count phrases stack on top of each other like cement. The move that’s killing me comes at the end of the second eight: Eight-count 1, 2, 3: Right foot steps to diagonal out, left foot cross-behinds on the and count, whole body tilts at fifteen degrees to upstage right. Arms slice into a level L—right arm forward, left out. Head follows the line of the right forearm. Precision. I hit the diagonal and feel stable. Count 4: We hook the right heel behind the left, sink to a demi-pointe on the left, drive a right elbow back into our imaginary spine, chest isolation hitting forward then back on the and count. My chest wants to mush it into one wave, to chew and swallow the beat. I bite it into two clean pops. My scapula stutters, reluctant. Count 5-6: A body roll is supposed to ripple from sternum to pelvis, but not here—here it’s segmented, neck-jaw-chest-abs. Each vertebra is a click track. I can do a roll that looks like smoke; this is more like a zipper. My instinct is to pause my head and make it a breath; the mirror shows the head going first, jaw jutting on the and. I move my jaw like a marionette, hate the feeling. Count 7: Step left to wide second, drop to a deep plie. Arms shoot down into a blade. We prepare a knee swivel, weight in the middle, pelvis neutral. No hips. “And eight”: Everyone snaps their heels together like a camera shutter. I kiss the heels and accidentally add a tiny heel-toe bounce—a ghost of a top rock. The mirror betrays me with a flicker. The girl to my right, Hana, glances without moving her head. She can see my rhythm bleeding on the floor. “Again from ‘V-cut,’” Daesuk-nim says, using the shorthand for the high V shape that begins the motif. He’s watching me blend into the pack and he is not impressed. Second run: I fight my life to match the counts. On 1, I shoot right arm up, left out. On 2, we switch—left up, right out—without a millimeter of shoulder bounce. On 3, tuck elbows to ribs, fists punching out from the sternum, fists vertical, then horizontal on the and. Right foot steps back precisely one length; knee doesn’t splay. On 4, head tilt at five degrees, not six. He said earlier he can see a degree. I believe him. My thighs and lungs are in an argument that includes name-calling. The heat from the speakers makes the sweat at my temples feel like oil. The track’s snare is a razor wire that we keep clotheslining ourselves on. The assistants count in Korean and English: Hana in front of me murmurs “hana, dul, set,” while the captain at the front says, “one, two, three,” a bilingual metronome. The diagonal traveling section. We scoot two steps upstage right on 1-and-2—polka-like, sliding on the balls of our feet with knees still at identical heights. On three, we pivot to face downstage, lifting our left heels only a breath off the floor, hips squared with the mirror. My heel wants to lift higher, make a statement. I nail it to the wood in my head. On 4, we jump, feet barely skimming, tuck the knees to chest but not too much, land exactly on our marks, my left foot hugging the tape to the edge of a millimeter. The room lands as one sound. Sixteen counts live in my calves, hammering. Fingers, shoulders, even eyelashes become choreography—no blink on 6 if you’re the center line. I’m safe in row four; my mistakes ripple mostly to the back wall. But in Daesuk’s eyes the back is every bit the front. We keep going. Chorus two. The new element is a ripple cannon on counts 5 through 7: center goes first, then the second line, then ours, each catching a sharp shoulder check followed by a hip flick that’s almost but not quite sexualized. They say “hip” in a way that means “hit it but make it PG.” In my body, a hip flick is a sentence break. Here it’s a period, double-spaced. I set my pelvis, try to flick without melting. My lower back complains, arch creeping in, shoulders lifting when they’re supposed to be down. My brain screams, drop, drop, drop your scapula, and I push them down, neck lengthening, jaw buzzing. We stop on 8. The assistant pauses the track. The speakers keep humming like insects. “Row four, number three,” Daesuk says. He finally points. It’s me. The sound of twenty-four pairs of feet shifting to neutral has a texture: soft soles, dried sweat. My name sticks to the inside of my mouth. He walks along the mirror until he’s beside me, close enough that I can see the pattern of his shoelaces reflected. He taps the top of my right hip bone, then the opposite shoulder. “You are dancing between. Here and here.” I want to say, I am a between. My neighborhood was between the freeway and the pier, between cops and crews, between dance as joy and dance as survival. I will not say that. I say, “Yes,” and I drop my shoulder, square my pelvis. He watches, impassive. “You have hunger,” he says, almost too soft for the room. “You move like you were not allowed to make a mistake. But here, your hunger is wide. Make it narrow.” Wide. I think of long summer sidewalks with cracks you have to hop. Of routines born in parking lots where you find the beat in a passing car. Narrow is this room. Narrow is the count. He claps again. We go from the top. The music snaps my head back into the now. The speakers bark out a synth line, the hi-hat stutters a sixteenth-note grid. My body wants to climb it like a playground. We start on 5-6-7-8. I lock my neck, cage the impulse. Beat one: high V. Two: switch. Three: tut. Four: clean frame. Step sequence. The traveling slide, pivot, hop. I pack my hunger into the angle of my wrists, the exactness of my elbows. The more precise I get, the rougher the edges inside me feel scraping against bone. I can’t find myself in this square. Then—count 7 of the second chorus, post-cannon—there’s a tiny suspension before the drop. We throw a right-hand slice down the body, catch the knee with the palm, rebound and snap the hand to our temple. It’s a dramatic shape, a memeable moment. The move wants a breath of texture, wants a tension that isn’t in the count sheet. I could give it something. A micro-drag on the hand sliding down, a half-beat hesitation that would make the snap at the temple explode. My crew would scream for that. I don’t. I glue my hand to the beat. I conform. And as I do, the floor feels further away. I think I can hear my block calling out over the bass saying, whose groove is that? Again. Again. Again. We break it down to bones, rebuild. At one water break that isn’t a break—thirty seconds to sip and reset—I stand in my square and breathe like I’m supposed to, in through the nose, out through the mouth, shoulders dropped, core engaged. Hana leans a millimeter closer and whispers, “Your freestyle at the scholarship showcase? Cool.” I grin with only the left side of my mouth; the right is busy not moving. “Thanks.” She shrugs a blade of shoulder. “Here,” she says, tapping the tape with her toe. “You make clean. Later, solo.” Later. If there is later. If I survive this now without sanding myself down to stock. Final run. We’re at the end, three-minute mark. Sweat turns the floor into a suggestion. The count has lived in my joints long enough that my muscle memory is learning the foreign language, an accent still heavy. The last eight is an all-in. We form a wedge formation—center front, lines fanning back. I travel three steps upstage left on 1-and-2; on the third, our wedge tightens. I pivot to face directly front on 3; on 4, we drop into the deepest plie of the routine. On 5-6, we execute a synchronized wave—the only sanctioned wave—from front to back, heads tilting like dominos, arms lifting from the elbows in sequence. My segment is the fourth. I count 1-2-3-4 and lift exactly then, elbow first, wrist last. The wave climbs through us, robotic but smooth. I could make it liquid; I don’t. It hits the back line on 6, and on 7 we all snap right feet to our left ankles, a coupe without the artistry, knees pointing outward, torso still. On 8 we freeze, faces neutral, eyes sharp, breathing invisible. Silence. The speakers hiss. Sweat tickles a path down my spine in a straight line because even my sweat is trying to be disciplined here. Daesuk-nim stares at us. A long beat. He nods once, so small it could be an accident. People almost exhale. He says, “You are not there.” No one moves. He points at me again. “You are still between.” It lands like a sentence. Between conforming so clean I disappear, and rebelling and getting cut. Between the scholarship contract and the alleyway cipher I won. Between the jar this academy wants to put me in and the ocean that raised me. The decision arrives like a beat I can’t ignore. It’s not dramatic—no storm cloud, no slow-motion. It’s a pivot. I can learn to hit their counts. I can narrow the hunger. But I can keep a secret stash of rhythm under my tongue, save a tiny room inside for the voice that moves when the music isn’t even on. That’s how we survived where I grew up: we kept parts of ourselves others couldn’t polish. I exhale. I lower my shoulders one millimeter more. I lock my elbow at the exact angle they drilled. I let my face blur into the group. And as we run it again, at the exact moment of the temple snap, I let my hand travel a hair’s breadth longer than choreography allows—so small even Daesuk-nim might call it a mistake of fatigue. A secret hook for later. A whisper to myself: you are still here. We hit the final freeze and hold past the count. My thighs threaten mutiny. The studio smells like disinfectant and human, like trying. Hana’s breath syncs with mine—four counts in, four counts out. Daesuk-nim’s gaze cuts over us, over me, catching, maybe, the shadow of what I kept. He says nothing. He claps once. “Again.” The speakers inhale, ready to ribcage me. I sink lower. I measure the distance from heel to tape, wrist to shoulder, the gap between who I am and who they want me to be, and I dance the space between without letting it swallow me. The grid tightens, the bass pins me to the beat, and I make my hunger narrow enough to fit for now, wide enough to breathe later. The counts hammer my bones into a shape that might carry both. And I choose to learn their lines without forgetting how to break formation when the time comes.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This first-person narrative successfully captures the experience of a street dancer navigating the rigid world of K-pop training. The piece excels in its physical specificity, tracking each movement with precision while maintaining the emotional and cultural tensions at its core. The physical choreography is meticulously rendered. The writer uses technical terminology effectively, describing specific positions ("high V," "tutting box"), counts, and spatial relationships that create a vivid kinetic picture. The contrast between the narrator's fluid street style and the mechanical precision demanded is consistently maintained through descriptions like "My chest wants to spiral, a figure-eight" versus being forced into a "pendulum, straight-line." The internal monologue effectively conveys the protagonist's culture shock and class anxiety. Lines like "Back home our formation was a circle that kept breaking and reforming, a ripple of bodies, but here bodies click into place like furniture" elegantly establish the contrast between environments. The character's struggle with authenticity is well-developed through observations about how their body "wants" to move versus how it must move in this new context. The prose is particularly strong in its sensory details and metaphors that reinforce the thematic tension. Descriptions like "The bass is a grid; it pins my ribs to the tempo like thumbtacks" and "I can do a roll that looks like smoke; this is more like a zipper" effectively communicate both physical sensation and emotional response. The narrative builds to a meaningful decision point where the protagonist chooses a middle path—conforming enough to survive while preserving a small piece of their authentic movement voice. This resolution feels earned and true to the character's situation, avoiding both total capitulation and unrealistic rebellion. The piece maintains consistent voice throughout, with the narrator's street background informing their observations and vocabulary. The writing style effectively balances technical precision with emotional resonance. There are a few moments where the prose becomes slightly overwrought, with metaphors occasionally stacking too densely. Some descriptions of the instructor could be more nuanced to avoid falling into stereotype. The ending, while thematically appropriate, might benefit from a slightly stronger emotional punch to fully capitalize on the built tension. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that fulfills the prompt requirements with skill and artistry. It creates a believable character whose physical and emotional journey is rendered with precision and depth. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 3.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Gothic-fantasy-humour: Court of the Dreaming — Score: 91.6
Prompt:
Court of the Dreaming: Territorial Dream Dispute. Write a dark fantasy scene with comedic elements set in the Courts of Dream where a case is being heard to determine ownership of a contested dreamscape. Mora, the Slavic nightmare spirit who sits on sleepers' chests causing paralysis and terror, has recently invaded and subverted a carefully crafted recurring dream of a schoolboy, Max. The dream originally featured the boy lying in a field of wildflowers with his crush, always culminating in a muddled almost-kiss and a pleasant confusion of emotions. This dream was the meticulous work of "First Love" (a rosy-cheeked, slightly bashful entity who crafts formative romantic experiences). However, Mora has recently infiltrated the dreamscape, transforming the scene so that when the girl playfully mounts the boy, she morphs into a terrifying yet somehow still confusingly attractive vision who proceeds to sit on his chest and feed on his breath. Mora's defense largely consists of the practical argument that "a girl's gotta eat too, you know?" Write this scene as it unfolds in the courtroom of the Dreaming, with Dream's demeanour, typically impenetrable, betraying a sense of irritation at having to adjudicate such matters. The comedy should derive from the farcical situation, familiar elements of courtroom drama intersecting with the fantastical world of the Dreaming, and the droll portrayal of the characters and their interactions. The humor should be dark and understated throughout. Dream is tempted to some mischief in the resolution of the case. Use descriptives sparingly when setting scene. Write for readability & engagement. 1000 words.
Model Output:
The Court of the Dreaming was convened beneath an impossible vault of dim star-stippled ceiling. In that hush, a single, giant hourglass tilted with the gravity of a cathedral bell. It dripped shimmering sand, each grain a silvery seed of memory. The gallery—murmurous shades, sprinkled cats, a cluster of blushing, half-formed teenage daydreams in hoodies—breathed as one creature. The bailiff was a raven with an attitude and a sash. “All rise for the Lord of the Dreaming,” croaked the raven, already bored. Dream entered like a shadow remembering it had a body. He sat on the bench. There were no gavels in his court; the air itself leaned in. “Mora,” Dream said, voice a dead tide. “First Love. Step forward.” First Love shuffled closer, hands clasped, wearing an expression like a child about to confess a spilled secret. Their cheeks were, as always, improbably rosy, as though embarrassed by their own existence. They wore a sweater that had been knitted out of blushes and soft sighs. Next to them, Mora slouched on the stand like a cat who’d been caught elegantly demolishing a bird. She had the look of midnight in motion, hair as black as exhausted ink, eyes like coins someone had warmed in their palm. Her dress was either smoke or a shadow that knew how to flirt. The raven cleared his throat with disdain. “Case 77,211. The matter of Max—age fourteen, dream frequency: three per week; content: recurring—field, wildflowers, object of affection, near-kiss, confusion. Plaintiff: First Love, craftsmanship. Defendant: Mora, dietary requirements. Claims of vector-squatting, theme corruption, consensual imagery violation. Adjacent claim: juvenile hormones as mitigating circumstance.” “Noted,” Dream said, and the hourglass ticked without ticking. First Love adjusted their sweater. “Your Lordship,” they began, voice pink at the edges. “This is a carefully nurtured dreamscape. The field is based on a memory of a class picnic. The girl’s laugh is tuned a half-note sharp to make his stomach do that thing. The almost-kiss—deliberately almost—creates a soft ache foundational for future healthy connections. This is craft.” Mora arched a brow. “It’s lunch.” First Love looked wounded. “No. It’s guidance. We are shaping tenderness—” “We are shaping an entrée,” Mora said sweetly, placing a hand on her chest as if stunned to be misunderstood. “A girl’s gotta eat too, you know? It’s not like I can open a bistro in some accountant’s ledger. College kids these days insist they don’t dream. Can’t feed on ‘hustle’ posters.” A smattering of teen daydreams snickered, then pretended innocence when Dream’s gaze passed over them like a cloud. Dream folded his long hands, the movement slow as a glacier deciding to shrug. “The dream in question.” At the gesture, the air to his right rippled. A theater curtain, if a curtain could be made out of night, lifted. The scene played across an oval of dreamlight: the field. Wildflowers. Bees, modestly overenthusiastic. Max, a little awkward. The girl: ponytail, the brand-new geography of a summer dress. The almost-kiss, an alchemy of shyness and misapprehension. Then, the twist. Her knee on his stomach. Her weight on his chest. His breath caught and didn’t uncatch. Her mouth grew too many shadows. Her eyes did not blink. Terror laced with—well, Max was fourteen. Confusion did not surrender so easily. The gallery rippled. A sigh, a gasp, a few appreciative noises followed by embarrassed throat-clearing. “This is not what we agreed upon,” First Love murmured, color climbing their neck. “The gentle confusion is supposed to be blushes and butterflies, not—” They gestured weakly toward the vision of breathless paralysis and longing twisted like a ribbon. “Not a… conflation.” Mora gave him a sympathetic look that failed to reach her eyes. “I’ve been very respectful of the mood-board. Did you see the continuity? Same field. Same pollen count. I could have used a thorn bush. I didn’t. I am not a monster.” She paused. “I am a monster, but I am a polite one.” “You trespassed,” First Love said. “This is the boy’s dream. It is his to wander. It is mine to cultivate for him, to teach him tenderness.” “And it is mine,” Mora purred, “to teach him that tenderness is heavy sometimes, and that bodies have consequences. And also that waking up is sweet. My tables were empty, darling. Choking panic pairs beautifully with adolescent longing. Very sustainable.” Dream’s face did not move, but irritation drifted through the courtroom like a draft. His attention flicked to the hourglass. The sand continued to fall with infuriating serenity. “Mora,” Dream said. “The sovereignty of dreamshapers is not a buffet.” “It’s a potluck,” Mora said. “I brought a dish.” “You brought a chokehold,” First Love snapped, surprising themself. The gallery murmured. Somewhere a cat laughed with its shoulders. The raven, in an aside to the court reporter (a sheet of parchment with opinions), muttered: “Honestly. In my day it was all teeth and staircases to nowhere.” Dream considered. The field slowed, the girl’s silhouette stilled. The grainy silver sand hummed, forming faint letters as it fell. He did not look at the words. He already knew what they said: You have to decide. Again. “What damages do you seek?” he asked First Love. “I want the dream restored,” First Love said, earnest as an unsealed letter. “Free of intrusion. Let the boy’s heart practice being gentle without… hostility.” Mora raised a finger. “Objection: calling me ‘hostility’ is defamatory. I am an inevitability. Also, certain data suggests that fear at this stage yields interesting—” She searched for a delicate word and failed. “—kinks.” A scatter of giggles. Someone in the gallery whispered, “Relatable,” and their mother conscience shushed them. Dream’s irritation sharpened into a very thin smile that only the hourglass noticed as a smudge in the falling sand. “Mora,” he said, “you claim necessity. How did you enter this dream?” Mora inspected her nails. “He fell asleep on his back,” she said. “Door was open. It’s almost rude not to drop in.” “Consent is not a hinge,” Dream said. She looked up, blackly amused. “Tell that to my instincts.” First Love worried the hem of their sweater. “I placed safeguards. The poppy count. The gracefully-fizzling end-of-scene. You shouldn’t have been able to graft on your—your… sitting.” Mora, attempting helpfulness: “It’s a sit. A classic. I’m very good at it.” The raven coughed. “We have exhibits, if Your Lordship desires.” With disdain, he gestured. A dream herbarium popped up, labeled in a neat hand: Rose of Shy Glances, Dandelion of Stupid Courage, Clover of “Wait, Did You See That?” Dream waved it away. He had no patience for prop comedy today. “You will both cease preening,” he said softly. He stood, or rather, the bench realized it had been wrong to think he was sitting. The courtroom’s darkness tilted with his rise. “The Dreaming is not a pantry. It is not a workshop. It is not a feeding ground. It is the place where mortals practice being. I will not have that practice turned into an assembly line for either of you.” Mora tilted her head, unapologetic. “Respectfully, my lord, it is also where nightmares live. You carved my name into the lintel of this place yourself.” “Did I,” Dream murmured. He had, of course. Old as the first infant’s first strangled startle. “It was very flattering,” Mora added. “Nice calligraphy.” First Love glanced between them. “We can negotiate parameters,” they offered quickly, like offering tea to a quarrel. “I can add boundaries. No… weight-bearing poses.” Mora made a face. “Starvation is a boundary. I don’t love it.” Dream’s gaze slid to the hourglass again. The last quarter was taking its time. He contemplated for a heartbeat that stretched and unstretched across centuries. “Max,” he said then, to the air. The gallery rustled at that name, as though daring the court to summon him. Dream did not conjure the boy. He summoned only the idea of him: a silhouette, a breath, a pulse, the crackle of neurons caught between biology and poetry. The silhouette flickered on the edge of the courtroom, confused, oblivious, a late homework assignment and a new ache behind his ribs. The court stilled. “You will not speak to him,” Dream said, and both entities flinched as if he’d slammed something heavy. “But you will listen.” Mora’s smile thinned. First Love clasped their hands tighter. The silhouette sighed. In that breath were the field, the girl, the weight, the fear, the sweetness, the catastrophe of being fourteen and a body. It was not unhappy. It was not happy. It was irregular, like a drum not yet sure if it’s a song. Dream closed his eyes. When he opened them, mischief pricked at the corner like a thorn hidden in velvet. “The ruling,” he said, and the raven straightened as if for a punchline he’d already predicted. “First Love will retain primary custodianship of this recurring dreamscape,” Dream said. First Love brightened, then looked guilty for brightening. “The field is restored. The almost-kiss will resume its almostness. The confusion will be tender.” Mora sighed with theatrical boredom. “Here it comes.” “However,” Dream continued, “twice per month—no more, no less—on nights of errant heat or when the covers are kicked to the floor by accident, the dream will invite a shadow at the edge. A pressure in the chest. Not paralysis. Not theft of breath. A reminder that longing has weight. You may taste the air, Mora. You may not keep it.” Mora’s eyes flashed. “That’s a tasting menu,” she said grudgingly. “I’m supposed to stay thin?” “Consider intermittent fasting,” the raven muttered, receiving a look that could have curdled ink. “Additionally,” Dream went on, and his tone acquired an almost imperceptible lilt that made the hourglass ripple with attention, “on those sanctioned nights, the crush will turn her head away from the almost-kiss and ask: ‘Are you okay?’ Max will not answer. He will wake before he can. He will carry the question into daylight. He will find its answer in time, with others, in places not of this court.” First Love’s eyes filled with well-managed dew. “That’s… that’s good,” they whispered, as though he’d just invented a new color and handed it to them. Mora tapped her lip, assessing. “You’re going to make him empathize with his own lungs,” she said. “You can be very cruel.” “I am capable of mischief,” Dream replied, and the gallery rippled, uncertain whether that pleased them or not. “Further,” he added, because irritation is rarely satisfied with only one flourish, “Max will begin to roll onto his side in his sleep more often. I will place a cat on his chest twice in the coming year, purely by coincidence.” He did not smile, but the word coincidence wobbled with amusement. The cats in the gallery preened. “Objection,” Mora said, half-hearted. “That’s profiling.” “Overruled,” Dream said. “Lastly: Mora, you will confine your ministrations to the appointed nights. You will not lean, pin, sit, or otherwise weigh upon this boy outside those boundaries. If you hunger, there are stairwells, attics, study halls. There are grown men who nap on trains. There are exam-week mistresses of coffee. I can provide a list.” “I have a list,” Mora said crisply. “I am a professional.” “First Love,” Dream said, turning. “You will revise your scene to include a conversation, at some point in the near future, in daylight. You will ease him toward language. His confusion will have handrails.” First Love nodded, flushed with purpose. “Yes, my lord.” The hourglass continued, unbothered, royally indifferent to their arrangements. Dream sat back. The bench breathed around him. Mora leaned on the rail, resigned and amused. “Twice a month,” she said. “For the rest, I prowl.” “You do,” Dream agreed. “But not here. Not often.” She cocked her head. “You are in a mood.” He was. He did not say so. “Court is adjourned,” Dream said. The raven announced it more loudly, as if his caw were the hinge on which justice swung. The gallery emptied in a susurrus of shoe-sounds that weren’t shoes and whispers that would later feel like déjà vu. First Love lingered at the edge of the field projected in the air, making a tiny adjustment to the way the summer light lay on the girl’s shoulder. Mora stretched her neck until it cracked like the first ice on a lake. As they departed, Dream watched the hourglass. It dripped. It always would. He lifted a hand, and without touching it, nudged one grain so that it landed a fraction of a fraction earlier than it would have. Somewhere, a boy turned onto his side. Somewhere, a cat made a pleased noise and stayed. Somewhere, a future blush was a shade darker, and a future panic, a shade lighter. Mora paused by the door, looked back. “Nice calligraphy,” she repeated, and was gone into a dark that was not empty, merely patient. First Love faced Dream, hesitant. “Thank you,” they said. It sounded like embarrassment and gratitude had been introduced and were politely shaking hands. Dream inclined his head. “Do your work,” he said. “And do not mistake softness for absence of teeth.” First Love smiled, small and sincere, and vanished into rose-scent. The Court fell quiet, except for the hourglass. Dream sat and watched the sand. Irritation ebbed. Mischief lingered, a pet cat on the windowsill of his mood, washing a paw with infinite, lazy menace. The raven hopped onto the bench. “You enjoyed that,” he accused. Dream did not respond. But between one grain and the next, the sand seemed to laugh, very softly, and if you’d been there, you would have been unsure if you’d imagined it. That is the nature of the Dreaming. That, and you never forget the weight of a breath until something sits on it. Or someone asks if you are okay. And then, of course, you spend the rest of your life learning how to answer.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkable achievement in dark fantasy with comedic elements. The author has created a fully realized courtroom drama set in the Courts of Dream, with a perfect balance of the fantastical and the familiar. The writing excels at establishing the otherworldly setting without overindulging in description. The opening paragraph efficiently sets the scene with evocative imagery: "an impossible vault of dim star-stippled ceiling" and an hourglass that "dripped shimmering sand, each grain a silvery seed of memory." The author follows the instruction to "use descriptives sparingly when setting scene" while still creating a vivid atmosphere. Character development is exceptional. Dream is portrayed with appropriate gravitas and subtle irritation, maintaining his enigmatic nature while showing glimpses of emotion. The characterization of Mora as unapologetically predatory yet oddly charming, and First Love as earnest and slightly bashful, creates a perfect dynamic for both the courtroom drama and the comedy. The humor is indeed dark and understated throughout, deriving from the absurdity of the situation and the clash between courtroom formality and dreamlike fantasy. Lines like "Mora's smile thinned" and "I am a monster, but I am a polite one" perfectly capture the tone requested. The raven bailiff adds another layer of dry humor with his commentary. The dialogue is particularly strong, with each character having a distinct voice that reflects their nature. Mora's pragmatic "A girl's gotta eat too, you know?" and First Love's earnest concerns about crafting "tenderness" create natural conflict and humor. The resolution is clever and satisfying, with Dream finding a compromise that acknowledges both entities' needs while adding his own mischievous twist. The ending reflection on the nature of dreams and breathing is poetic without being overwrought. The piece does occasionally veer into slightly purple prose, particularly in some of the metaphorical descriptions, but this is minor and actually suits the dreamlike quality of the setting. There are a few moments where the pacing slows slightly in the middle, but the overall structure maintains engagement throughout. The author has masterfully fulfilled the prompt's requirements, creating a scene that is both darkly fantastical and genuinely funny, with characters that feel authentic despite their supernatural nature. The balance of courtroom drama, fantasy elements, and understated humor is expertly maintained. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 1 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 1.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Blood Moon — Score: 90.2
Prompt:
Blood Moon Alucard & Yennefer Write a story where Alucard (Hellsing) encounters Yennefer (The Witcher) in medieval Europe. Yennefer's magical abilities intrigue the vampire, while she's both repulsed and fascinated by his monstrous nature. Their power dynamic shifts constantly as they circle each other, neither willing to show weakness first. **Alucard (Hellsing)** Alucard is an ancient, immensely powerful vampire who works for the Hellsing Organization. He can regenerate from almost any wound and shape-shift at will. He's sadistic, arrogant, and takes pleasure in toying with his enemies before killing them. Despite being a monster, he despises weak vampires who can't accept their nature. He wears a distinctive red coat, wide-brimmed hat, and orange sunglasses. He uses massive handguns loaded with silver bullets. He seeks worthy opponents who can challenge him and potentially end his immortal existence. Famous quote: "The bird of Hermes is my name, eating my wings to make me tame." **Yennefer of Vengerberg (The Witcher)** Yennefer is a powerful sorceress who magically altered her appearance to hide her congenital hunchback. She's ambitious, stubborn, and manipulative when necessary. She has violet eyes and smells of lilac and gooseberries. Despite her cold exterior, she desperately wants to reverse her infertility caused by magical transformation. She's centuries old but appears young. She's politically savvy and refuses to be underestimated. She has a sarcastic sense of humor and little patience for fools. Though she rarely shows it, she's capable of deep love and loyalty. Famous quote: "I'm not sweet and I'm not a maiden in distress in need of saving." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The broken cart wheel lies abandoned near the village gates, a splintered rim of wood catching moonlight like a pale, dead eye. The fields beyond are silvered with frost and fog, and the village behind the gate keeps its shutters barred and hearths banked low as if prayer might convince night to pass by without noticing. It will not. He notices everything. He is the night and its teeth. Alucard stands where the rutted road narrows, a tall slash of red against the gray. He tips his wide-brimmed hat to the wind and smiles into the dark, the line of his mouth too indulgent to be kind. His orange lenses catch the blood moon’s glare and burn like watchfires. He speaks to no one. Or he speaks to the countless souls inside him, the choir that never quiets. Tonight, he is patient. He has scented something lively. When she arrives, it is not in a burst of flame or peal of thunder. It is a ripple, a pressure shift, the world inhaling. A shape coalesces twenty paces to his left: a woman in a black star-spattered dress with a fur-lined mantle, violet eyes rimming the night, raven hair braided down her back. She smells of lilac and gooseberries, and beneath that—iron discipline. Exhaustion. Raw nerve. Yennefer of Vengerberg does not startle at the sight of him. Her gaze skims the hat, the coat, the guns—lingers on the smile, the aloof stance of something that cannot be harmed. She folds her arms, purse of lips white-scored with annoyance. “Charming village,” she says. “I would complain to the wheelwright if I thought anyone here had the courage to admit they sold that wheel and fled before the ink dried.” Alucard bows fractionally, like a courtier who forgot entirely how to be polite and is now playing the game for his own amusement. “They fled for good reason, little bird.” Her eyes narrow. “Do not call me little anything.” “The bird of Hermes is my name,” he purrs. “Eating my wings to make me tame.” “That makes one of us.” She tilts her head, studying him now with the care she gives old texts and dead languages, searching for the path through. “You carry silver. You smell like graves and gunpowder. Your shadow has too many legs.” His smile shows teeth. “You are observant.” “I am many things.” Her chin lifts with careless arrogance. “In this case, I am en route to a village that paid for my time and then attempted to leave their problem for me to resolve without witness.” “They left you an offering,” Alucard says, indicating the wheel. “A breadcrumb. Or a test.” “As if I haven’t been tested,” she mutters, mostly to herself. A howl rises from the treeline, ragged and hungry. The fog writhes. Something comes out of it, broad as a bull and low to the ground. It is a ghoul that has eaten too many corpses, its skull empty of reason, its ribs sprung wide to accommodate its glut. Its claws rattle on the road as it charges. Yennefer lifts a hand and the world snaps into a rune-laced grid. A blast of kinetic force knocks the creature sideways into the ditch with a sound like a cart hitting a milestone. Alucard doesn’t move. He watches the creature lift its head and stand again, crooked once and then straight, eager to try once more. “You didn’t kill it,” he observes. “I intend to collect full payment,” she says primly. “They promised multiple.” “I promised myself someone else,” he says, and moves. The gun he draws is a slab of black steel, obscene in its size and authority. He fires once, the report splitting the night. The ghoul’s skull becomes a dark mist, regardless of any runes or witcher signs or the mercy of gods not watching. The body takes a step and collapses. Yennefer’s nostrils flare. “Was that necessary?” “No,” he says. “Satisfying.” He flicks the barrel to shed dark flecks that might be blood and might be something older. “So. Sorceress. You have the scent of a gatekeeper about you. Commissions. Courts. Petty kings. A hunger like a blade hidden in lace.” “You’ve a poet in your coffin, vampire.” “Several. Their voices are delightful.” Violet eyes sharpen. “Do you know what you are, or do you pretend to be what those voices want?” He laughs, a low, feral sound. The fog around his boots tightens into a coil, then spills. His shadow ripples, subdividing into sharp little heads that taste the air. “I am the thing that remembers itself in the mirror long after the person has forgotten. I am the tame bird eating its wings and calling it penance. I am a weapon—sharpened, fed, loosed.” “And owned,” she says softly. The word hangs between them. Even the fog hesitates. He looks at her over the wet shine of the road and says nothing for a heartbeat. When he does speak, it is a softer tone, a blade sheathed in velvet. “Do you know what you are?” Her mouth, which knows how to scoff and cut and kiss, stills. “A woman who made choices,” she says at last. “And pays for them. As we all do.” More howls now, more urgent. Shapes press at the edge of the field of view, testing. Yennefer flicks her fingers; lines of blue fire lace the road and the ditch. A ward hums into being, bright and vicious. The hunger at the edge whines, confused. Alucard’s head tilts, admiration stripped of mockery for an instant. “Neatly done.” “Keep your beasts outside the circle,” she says without breaking eye contact. “You may be immune to many things, but I assure you, arrogance is not one of them.” “I am humility itself,” he says, stepping, deliberately, to the very edge of her ward without crossing it. The energy snarls against his coat and licks at his boots, tasting. He lifts his chin into the bite. “Look at you. All spine now.” “I have always had a spine,” she says. “I merely…straightened it.” He inhales. Lilac and gooseberries and a sorrow that is not ripe, merely constant. He watches the hand she keeps close to her middle, never resting, always ready to draw power from points on the dial only she understands. “You have lost something.” “I am not sweet and I am not a maiden in distress in need of saving.” “I did not offer to save you,” he says, amused again. “I wondered what you would do to get back what cannot be returned.” Her eyes thicken with storm. “You mistake me for a beggar at a temple. I break temples. And I do not need your approval.” “Ah. Good. I am poor at giving it.” From the tree line, a cluster of starved corpses in shredded clothing slither and jerk toward the road, animated by some low magic that stink of fear. A half a dozen, then a dozen. Their eyes are wrong. Someone has workshopped a necromancy with cheap ingredients. “Lazy,” Yennefer says, disdain dripping. She gestures. The air itself folds into a blade. Heads fall like rotten apples. Another gesture. The corpses catch fire with green-tinged smoke and collapse into the ditch. She doesn’t look. She doesn’t falter. Alucard watches the economy of her violence with genuine appreciation. “You kill like a sovereign,” he says. “I tidy,” she replies. “Do you despise what you are?” he asks, sudden and conversational, as if discussing the weather. “You cover it with perfume and politics. But there is so much power underneath.” Her jaw clenches. “Despise? No. I chose. But I am not obligated to perform monstrosity to make you feel less alone.” He bares his teeth, delighted. “Perform monstrosity. How quaint. Most of your kind are the opposite—endless performance of humanity, despite their bones knowing better.” “My kind?” Her laughter is not kind. “Men who drink blood and call it sacrament? Or sorcerers who move mountains and are told to smile for kings? Choose your insult with care, vampire.” He spreads his arms as if to be crucified. “Insult? I offer you kinship. We are both instruments, both punished and indulged for the same sin—being good at what we are. The wheel broke because the village wanted to run from their debt. The dead rose because someone wanted a shortcut. And we come to cash the bill.” She looks at the wheel. For a moment, the expression on her face is naked and sharp: tired of debts, tired of notes and signatures. Then the mask slides back into place. “I do not share my burdens with strangers.” “And yet we share a road,” he says. The moon slides out from behind a clot of cloud. Everything sharpens further. The ward’s lines glitter. His smile becomes something that could have been gentle if he had not lost that word centuries ago. “We could share a hunt.” “You want to see if I can hurt you,” she says. “You’re bored. And lonely. And you want to press your fingers to a flame.” “And you want to know if I can break what you cannot,” he replies. “We are both curious.” The corpse-thing that had slunk from behind the cottage to their right chooses that moment to spring. It hits the ward and detonates in a cascade of blue-white sparks. Yennefer doesn’t flinch. Alucard doesn’t blink. They look at each other over the collapse of pretense. “Fine,” she says. “For tonight. We end whatever idiot raised these dead. Then you go your way.” “And you go yours,” he says, tipping his hat. “Lead on, my lady of broken wheels.” A twitch of her mouth suggests a smile she won’t give him. “Do not call me lady.” “Yennefer, then.” He tastes her name, rolls it around like wine. It does not make him drunk. It makes him careful. She drops the ward, and the night rushes in like water. He moves with it, flowing up the road at her side, not behind her, not ahead. As they pass into the village, shutters crack open a finger’s width, then slam. Behind the church, a glow throbs. A makeshift shrine to a patron saint of farmers is festooned with twitching garlands. The air is ripe with old blood and a hysteria that has curdled. “There,” she says. “Of course,” he says. “Faith and fear. Fertile ground.” On the shrine’s steps, a young priest in a ragged cassock is shaking, lips moving. In his lap, a book of clumsily penned sigils lies open, pages damp. He looks up when they arrive, eyes alight with fanatic light—a light that goes out when he sees Alucard, replaced by terror; and goes colder when he sees Yennefer, replaced by loathing. He snatches the book to him. He murmurs faster. “You will stop,” Yennefer says. “God will—” She flicks two fingers and his tongue goes numb. He gag-silences. “Good,” Alucard says, and kicks the book away. His boot prints char the wood beneath. Something lunges from the shadows—half a child, half a question, sewn together with spell-thread. For an instant, Yennefer’s face fractures. Then she sinks a hand into the air and yanks, and the thread pops, and the thing falls apart like a bad dream in daylight. Alucard’s hand is on the priest’s throat when she speaks. “No.” He glances back at her, eyes amused. “Mercy? From you?” “Information,” she says, voice flint. “And then—perhaps I burn him. Or perhaps I make him fix what he broke.” Alucard’s grip loosens, then tightens again just enough to keep the man from persuading himself he’s free. “A fair point.” The priest sobs. “I wanted—protection. The harvest. I—” “You raised your dead neighbors,” Yennefer says flatly. “That is not protection. That is cowardice dressed as piety.” “Cowards make the best monsters,” Alucard murmurs. She ignores him. “You will speak the reversal. Slowly.” Her eyes burn violet. The air smells like ozone and lilac, thunder and summer. “And if you lie, I will know.” He babbles. She listens. She extracts the pattern and cuts it to fit. It is not elegant magic, but she is. The dead in the ditches rattle and then lie still. In the field, something sighs. The pressure in the night eases. The blood moon drifts behind cloud. When she is done, she straightens, shoulders trembling with the effort she will not admit to. Alucard hasn’t let go of the man. His smile has gone small and hungry. Yennefer meets his eyes. “He belongs to the courts. To law.” He considers, head cocked. Then, with surprising grace, he drops the priest on the steps as though depositing a sack of grain. “How domestic of you.” “It pays,” she says. “And it keeps me honest.” “That word does not fit you.” “Nor you me.” She brushes soot from her sleeve and looks toward the road where a wheel lies, abandoned. “We are done.” “For tonight,” he says. He steps back into the wind, into the dark like it’s a coat he shrugs on. “You are interesting, Yennefer of Vengerberg. Perhaps I will consider you a worthy adversary.” “Consider what you like,” she says, turning away, chin high. “I do not perform for you.” “But you do perform,” he says, almost gently. “For yourself.” He touches the brim of his hat. “I will be watching.” “Get in line,” she says, and the corner of her mouth lifts, a near-smile more dangerous than any curse. They part at the gate, with the broken wheel like a seal between them. He dissolves into a colony of bats that scatter across the blood-bled sky and reform where no one can see. She opens a portal that glints like a shard of mirror and steps through smelling of lilac and gooseberries and the stubborn hope of a woman who will not be told no. The village exhales. The moon pales. The road remembers their footsteps but cannot decide which were heavier. Their power, for now, remains unspent enough to bring them back to one another. And the night, unsated, promises another meeting beneath a different shade of red.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece demonstrates exceptional craft in bringing together two powerful characters from different fictional universes. The author has created a compelling encounter between Alucard from Hellsing and Yennefer from The Witcher, maintaining their distinct personalities while developing a fascinating power dynamic between them. The characterization is particularly strong. Alucard is portrayed with his signature arrogance, sadism, and philosophical musings about monstrosity. His dialogue captures his theatrical nature and predatory essence. Yennefer is equally well-rendered with her sharp wit, magical prowess, and the underlying vulnerability regarding her infertility (subtly referenced with "the hand she keeps close to her middle" and the discussion of what she has lost). Both characters remain true to their source material while interacting in ways that feel authentic. The prose is elegant and atmospheric, establishing a gothic medieval setting with vivid imagery. The opening paragraph immediately sets the tone with its description of the broken cart wheel "catching moonlight like a pale, dead eye." Throughout the piece, the author employs sensory details effectively, from the "lilac and gooseberries" scent associated with Yennefer to the visual impact of Alucard's red coat against the gray landscape. The dialogue shines as a vehicle for character development and tension. The verbal sparring between the two powerful beings reveals their similarities and differences while maintaining a constant power struggle. Lines like "I am not obligated to perform monstrosity to make you feel less alone" and "We are both instruments, both punished and indulged for the same sin—being good at what we are" demonstrate the thematic depth of their interaction. The plot, while simple, serves as an effective framework for their encounter. The village's necromancy problem provides a practical reason for their paths to cross and allows both characters to demonstrate their abilities and approaches to dealing with threats. The resolution leaves room for future encounters without feeling incomplete. There are a few instances where the prose becomes slightly purple, particularly in some of Alucard's more philosophical musings, but this actually aligns with his character's theatrical nature. The piece also occasionally indulges in metaphorical language that borders on overwrought, but these moments are balanced by more straightforward narrative passages. The ending effectively maintains the tension between the characters while suggesting the possibility of future encounters. It avoids an artificially positive resolution, instead leaving their relationship in an appropriately ambiguous state that honors both characters' independence and power. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that demonstrates a deep understanding of both characters and skillfully brings them together in a way that feels authentic and engaging. The author has created a rich atmosphere, compelling dialogue, and a satisfying narrative arc within the constraints of the prompt. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 20 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 5 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 20.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 5.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Fanfic-crossover: Prison Strings — Score: 88.2
Prompt:
Prison Strings Jolyne Cujoh & Makima Write a story where Jolyne Cujoh (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure) and Makima (Chainsaw Man) cross paths at a supernatural prison facility. Jolyne is immediately suspicious of Makima's falsely sweet demeanor, while Makima is intrigued by Jolyne's Stand ability. Their battle of wits escalates dangerously as Jolyne realizes how manipulative Makima truly is. **Jolyne Cujoh (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure)** Jolyne is the daughter of Jotaro Kujo and the first female JoJo protagonist. Her Stand, Stone Free, allows her to unravel her body into string that she can control. She's hot-headed, foul-mouthed, and doesn't take disrespect from anyone. She was framed for murder and sent to prison. She has a distinctive butterfly tattoo on her arm and wears her hair in two buns. Despite her tough exterior, she's deeply loyal to her friends and family. She can be impulsive but is highly adaptable in battle. She inherited her father's ability to stay cool under pressure but is more emotionally expressive. Famous quote: "If there's no Mickey, this shit ain't Disney!" **Makima (Chainsaw Man)** Makima appears as a young woman with auburn hair and ringed yellow eyes. She's the Control Devil who can dominate anyone she considers beneath her (nearly everyone). She maintains a pleasant, soft-spoken demeanor that masks her manipulative, cold nature. She can create contracts with humans and devils, often exploiting their desires. She's obsessed with Chainsaw Man and wants to control him. She keeps numerous people and devils as pets on leashes. She's practically immortal due to a contract with the Prime Minister. She views humans as lesser beings but mimics human emotions perfectly. Famous quote: "It's okay. Dogs are supposed to die for their owners." Third person, present tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The chain-link fences within the yard rattle whenever an inmate passes by, a constant clatter like teeth chattering in a cold mouth. Beyond them, concrete rises in grim slabs, the windows narrow and mirrored, the sky a bleached gray that looks like someone wiped fingerprints across it. This is the yard—if one can call a maze of fenced lanes and watchtowers a yard—of a prison known only by its official contract number. It’s a facility built like an apology to God: all straight lines and fluorescent light, everything so sterile it nearly stinks. Jolyne Cujoh feels the rattle in her molars as she brushes against a fence on the way back from “exercise.” In her head she’s cataloging the hum of cameras, the timing of guard rotations, the weight of key cards clipped to belts. Stone Free is itching beneath her skin, threads wanting to unspool like nerves at the edge of a scream. She feels every tug, every vibration through the wire. The yard is a harp, and she knows how to pluck it. The woman waiting for her at the end of the lane is not a guard. At first glance she could be a social worker: simple white shirt, black slacks, auburn hair in a clean tail, eyes as steady as watchfaces. Yellow eyes, ringed and polite. She’s smiling. She looks like she smells like soap and boiled rice. Jolyne stops short, automatic, feet planted. Her fingers twitch, and a thin line of blue thread unspools just enough to wind around her thumb and middle finger like a promise. The fences rattle. The air crackles as a yardful of inmates slow without knowing why, or maybe some part of them already knows. “Jolyne Cujoh,” the woman says. Her voice is a gentle trowel, smoothing mortar. “May I walk with you?” “You already are,” Jolyne says. She flicks her eyes to either side without moving her head. Two guards have vanished from their posts. The tower lights haven’t changed, but she can feel a pressure like someone’s hand wrapped around her neck, as if patience itself could strangle. “Who the hell are you supposed to be?” “Makima,” the woman says, as if that’s a title. “I’m with Public Safety. I’ve been following your case.” Jolyne laughs, hoarse and humorless. “If there’s no Mickey, this shit ain’t Disney. Public Safety doesn’t tail me from Miami to here and wait in my yard. You got transferred from Heaven?” Makima’s smile doesn’t widen but it becomes more visible, as if it moves from the lips to the eyes. She steps closer. The fences complain, shaking lightly. Every nearby inmate looks away all at once, as if extremely interested in the concrete under their shoes. “You have an unusual ability,” Makima says. “You unravel yourself. You become useful.” Stone Free uncoils from Jolyne’s wrist like a snake tasting the air. “Useful, huh? That what your pets call themselves?” Makima’s eyes flick down to the strand and back up. “I’m glad you understand analogies. I have a proposal.” “Hard pass,” Jolyne says. Makima’s head ticks, that small puzzled tilt a doll’s head might do. “You haven’t heard it yet.” “I don’t need to. You smell like trouble with lipstick. You’ve got the kind of smile that means only one of us leaves happy.” Jolyne’s voice lowers. “And if that’s how you get off, go buy a leash at a pet store.” Makima’s smile fades to polite interest. “You’re not afraid.” Jolyne says nothing. Afraid of this? Of men with guns? Of women who carry emptiness like an expensive bag? She isn’t sure if fear is the word. She is wary the way a hand is wary of a hot stove after the blister. She is wary in the way of people who have woken to handcuffs and bad dreams. Makima gestures, and the guard gate at the end of the lane hums open. No one has touched it. Out in the broader yard, the rattle spreads like a ripple through tall grass. The prisoners freeze; birds on a wire that suddenly calculate the sky’s weight. “I think you could leave here,” Makima says, friendly as a kindergarten teacher. “Or you can stay, Jolyne. If you stay under my care, I will arrange visitation with your father. Jotaro Kujo, correct?” Jolyne’s jaw tightens, and Stone Free’s strings go taut, a web around her elbows, her wrists. Makima watches the change like a biologist observing an amoeba sprout an eye. “Who told you that?” Jolyne asks. “People tell me many things,” Makima says. “My job is to decide who is worth listening to.” “Yeah? Let me decide something.” Jolyne breathes, and the strings spread from her fingers to the fence, invisible in the gray light until they catch a glint. “I don’t take orders. Not from a lady who uses people like chew toys.” Makima’s eyes cool by a degree that feels like a climate shift. “I didn’t say order,” she says. “I said care. I take care of what is mine.” Jolyne thinks of a leash, of a collar that closes without a sound. She thinks of hands on a steering wheel that isn’t there. Her laugh is a little too loud. “I got my own handcuffs, thanks. Don’t need new jewelry.” The gate slides shut behind Makima with a self-satisfied click. When she turns, two guards are there and then not, like a channel changing. Jolyne feels the pressure again, a subtle command pressing against the shape of her, and knows, the way instinct knows cliffs, that if this woman decides she is beneath her, there will be nothing left but knees and obedience. And Jolyne Cujoh kneels to no one. Stone Free lashes out, a panther of thread crawling from her forearm, looping the yard’s lamp pole, running across the razor wire, slipping through the chain link and back. She draws a lattice around them, a circle wide enough to make space, strings crossing strings until the air hums. The moment Makima steps forward, the web creaks and flexes. Makima doesn’t look at the web. She looks at Jolyne, as if memorizing a series of facts. “You’re clever,” she says. “You make distance and you make structure. You’d make a wonderful leash.” Jolyne’s stomach goes cold, but she spits to the side and grins. “You keep talking about dogs. You planning to bark or bite?” Makima raises one hand and points. There is no flourish, no circle, no Latin; there is a pressure, and one of the inmates down the lane flinches, then evaporates. Not explodes. Not vanishes into smoke. It is as if his pieces are deleted. The fence howls, every little diamond ringing in the sudden shock. Everyone turns to stone except the two of them inside the web. Jolyne’s heart claws at her throat. She does not blink. She widens her stance and peels another length of herself free, a filament that winds around Makima’s ankle like a question. “Your fear response is well-controlled,” Makima says. “I can offer you a life with meaning. You fight. You get to fight a cause that matters.” “My cause is mine,” Jolyne says. “My family. My friends. People who don’t look at me like a chew toy. People who would turn this place upside down for me.” Makima’s eyes flicker, a hint of amusement. “And has he?” she asks softly. “Has your father?” Jolyne’s fingers tremble, barely. She forces them still. “He will.” “Hmm.” The faint sound is an entire verdict. “Your strings transmit sound. Vibrations. You’re listening to the yard, to the building. It’s impressive. But you won’t hear what you need to hear through metal. You need someone to tell you where the real doors are.” “Lady,” Jolyne says, “I make doors where there aren’t any.” She pulls, and the web cinches like a net. Makima moves the way a thought moves, not fast so much as inevitable, stepping through a gap that should not be there until it is. The strings bend around her, as if politely making way. Jolyne’s breath catches; she shifts her control, twists, sows a second layer, barbed knots like tiny teeth. When Makima steps again, one ankle snags just enough for the knot to cut skin. A drop of blood beads and does not quite fall. Makima looks down at it, mildly fascinated. “This is new,” she says. “You adapt quickly.” “Yeah,” Jolyne says, and yanks. The web tightens in a sudden choke—the post groans, wire screams, dust puffs from concrete seams. Makima’s body tilts, forced to lurch. Her head turns, ringed eyes cutting to Jolyne, and Jolyne sees for the first time something behind the perfect mimicry—something like curiosity sharpened into hunger. Makima raises her hand, and the world compresses. The sound leaves the yard—just a moment of absence where even the wind forgets itself. Jolyne’s web shivers. Her strings vibrate so hard her bones ache. She bites the inside of her cheek and tastes copper. The bars of the fence bow inward like jailed ribs. “You’re not above me,” Makima says. It isn’t a threat. It’s a classification. Jolyne smiles with too many teeth. “Then stop trying to step on me and fight me.” Makima’s lips part—surprise edging that calm—and then she smiles, the real thing, the one with knives folded inside it. “I like you,” she says. “Come with me. I’ll let you see him.” The name isn’t said. It doesn’t have to be. Jolyne’s vision goes white at the edges, as if floodlights have been turned on behind her eyes. She thinks of him: the hat that never falls, the ocean of his silence, the way he said her name like a command to himself not to lose it. She thinks of a dolphin charm and the sound of a tape recorder. The lure is perfect because it is true. She snaps a line to the far fence and rockets backward, sliding under the taut net of her own making. The string bites her palm. Stone Free blooms around her, the shape of her Stand flickering, translucent sinew and knotted fists, skull grinning. She yanks the web between them, looping, making layers until Makima is a silhouette through blue haze. “No,” Jolyne says, panting, voice full of gravel. “I’ll see him because we break out of here and we meet halfway. Not because you hold the leash.” Makima steps forward and the web holds. She studies it like an architect reading a blueprint. Her smile is small and satisfied, as if Jolyne has passed a test. “I was not certain whether you’d be useful in a kennel,” she says softly. “But perhaps you’re more interesting running.” “Get used to the view,” Jolyne says. “It’s gonna be my back.” “Jolyne Cujoh,” Makima says, as if filing it, and turns away. A path opens for her where there is none. Guards reappear, blinking, clutching guns they don’t remember lowering. The inmates breathe again. The fence’s rattle becomes ordinary noise, not a heartbeat. Makima glances over her shoulder with that measured sweetness, a ribbon tied on a guillotine. “It’s okay,” she says, the words so soft they almost vanish. “Dogs are supposed to die for their owners.” Jolyne flips her off, fierce and raw. “I’m not a dog,” she says. “I’m the one who bites back.” Makima’s smile brightens an increment. Then she is gone into the building’s swallow. The gate closes. The yard exhales. Stone Free retracts in a shiver, threads knitting under Jolyne’s skin. She stands alone in the echo of it, sweat cooling on her neck, the butterfly on her arm fluttering with the drum under her ribs. She’s shaking and doesn’t let it show. The fence rattles when she lets her hand brush it, a nervous tick disguised as a test. She focuses, sends a string through the post, along the chain, into the concrete, out into the prison’s circuitry—a stethoscope pressed to a monster’s chest. She listens. She learns. She thinks of Makima’s eyes, and the private way they seemed to count people like coins. She thinks of the droplet of blood that didn’t fall. She thinks of what it will take, and who will come, and who she will have to become if he doesn’t. “Stone Free,” she says under her breath. “Let’s make a door.” The chain-link fences in the yard rattle again when an inmate passes, an ordinary sound, a chorus of little metal throats. Jolyne smiles to herself, a shape that looks like barbed wire cutting sunlight. Wary, suspicious, boiling and cooling by turns, she measures the weight of the sky and the thickness of her own resolve. Somewhere inside this place, someone has given her a leash and asked her to put it on. She winds her strings around her wrist like bracelets and ties a small knot no one else can see. She names it Makima. She ties another and names it Home. Then she starts to pull.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece successfully captures the essence of both characters while creating a tense, atmospheric confrontation. The author demonstrates a strong understanding of both Jolyne Cujoh and Makima, portraying their abilities, personalities, and speech patterns with remarkable accuracy. The prison setting is vividly established through sensory details that create a grim, oppressive atmosphere. The description of the "chain-link fences" that "rattle whenever an inmate passes by" and the "concrete rises in grim slabs" immediately places the reader in this harsh environment. The characterization is particularly strong. Jolyne's defiance, resourcefulness, and loyalty to her father are well-portrayed. Her use of Stone Free is described in creative ways that align with the source material. Similarly, Makima's false sweetness, manipulative nature, and terrifying power are effectively conveyed. The moment when an inmate "evaporates" demonstrates her casual cruelty and godlike abilities. The prose is elegant without becoming purple. Metaphors and similes enhance the narrative rather than distract from it. For example, describing Makima's voice as "a gentle trowel, smoothing mortar" perfectly captures her deceptively soothing manner while hinting at something artificial beneath. The dialogue is exceptional, capturing each character's distinct voice. Jolyne's "If there's no Mickey, this shit ain't Disney" reference from the source material is naturally incorporated. Makima's "Dogs are supposed to die for their owners" line is equally well-placed and chilling. The confrontation builds tension effectively, with Jolyne gradually realizing the extent of Makima's power while refusing to submit. The power dynamics are well-explored, with Makima's attempts at control met by Jolyne's fierce independence. The ending avoids an unrealistic resolution, instead showing Jolyne's determination to escape on her own terms rather than accepting Makima's offer. This stays true to her character while setting up potential future conflict. The piece does occasionally lean toward overwrought description, particularly in some of the metaphors describing the prison environment. A few sentences could be tightened for greater impact. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise excellent piece. Overall, this is an impressive character study that successfully merges two distinct fictional universes while maintaining the integrity of both characters. The writing is confident, atmospheric, and engaging throughout. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 18 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 17 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 5 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 18.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 17.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 4.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 5.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0
+ Scp: Notes from the Future — Score: 90.5
Prompt:
Write an SCP report about a researcher who begins finding handwritten notes from their future self, warning about a containment breach that hasn't happened yet. The notes become increasingly desperate and incoherent, sometimes containing information that contradicts known reality. Include the Foundation's attempts to determine if this is an actual temporal anomaly or psychological manipulation by a contained entity, and the researcher's struggle to trust their own perception. First person (researcher's perspective with interspersed notes), past tense. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Item #: SCP-████ Object Class: Euclid Special Containment Procedures: Researcher ███████ (hereafter “I”) was placed on temporary leave from Site-██’s Temporal Anomalies Unit and relocated to an isolated observation suite with 24/7 surveillance. All writing instruments within my assigned workspace were cataloged and replaced with Foundation-manufactured pens whose ink composition is batch-tracked. A secondary camera monitored any physical correspondence entering the room; all paper supplies were watermarked prior to issuance. Daily cognitive evaluations were administered by Dr. Holtz. All handwritten notes purportedly from my future self were to be surrendered immediately to Security for forensic analysis (ink composition, fiber structure, handwriting comparison). Site-██’s memetics team reviewed the notes for cognitohazard markers. Interviews with other staff were restricted and mirrored to detect behavioral priming. Access to the containment wing of SCP-███ (suspected of potential infohazard manipulation) was rescinded for me pending investigation. Description: On ██/██/20██, I found a handwritten note in my lab coat pocket. The note appeared to be in my handwriting, on Foundation standard-issue notepaper, but bore soot-like smudges along the edges. It warned of a containment breach in three days. The breach, according to the note, would originate in the northern corridor, after a scheduled power test. On that date, no breach occurred, and no power test was scheduled. Ink analysis revealed trace elements (molybdenum disulfide, vanadium oxides, and a proprietary stabilizer not present in any standard office pen cartridge) inconsistent with supply logs. Security confirmed the note was not recorded entering my room. I wrote the following in my daily log that evening: They’re mine, these letters. The loops on the g’s, the pressure at the ascenders—everything is me. But the paper smells like ozone. I don’t keep ozone in my pocket. The subsequent notes arrived intermittently. The content escalated in urgency, sometimes contradicting known scheduling and facts, sometimes predicting small events that came true—dropped mugs, a door jam, a colleague’s offhand joke. Each was dated two to seven days “ahead.” There was no observable ingress. No time-stamps on the entry hallway cameras showed any physical delivery. The notes were found folded into places I would not reasonably miss: beneath my pillow, inside a book I was actively annotating. Occasionally they referred to me by the nickname only my sister uses. The last line of the second note: Note [D+2]: You’ve never dreamed in color since the Freiburg incident. If you’re dreaming in color now, it means you’re not asleep. I’m not proud of what I did next. I tested my dreams with a pack of colored tabs taped above my bed. That night, in my dream, they were all red. In the morning they were still blue. On D+4, the Foundation initiated cross-testing to determine whether these notes were temporal bleed-throughs, a known but rare phenomenon in proximity to SCP-████ (a defective Faraday-cage-adjacent chamber used in null-causality experiments), or the product of directed psychological manipulation by SCP-███, a class-E memetic engine contained three floors down. Both had historical precedent for interfering with perceived causality, though by different mechanisms. Note [D+4]: It starts with small permissions to doubt. You’ll think you’re prudent. Then you’ll throw the wrong switch to avoid the wrong failure and find the right disaster. I told Dr. Holtz that the phrasing felt like me scolding me. She asked whether I often scold myself. I said no; I just narrated hypotheticals until they stopped being hypothetical. She wrote something down. The third note predicted a fire in Corridor A, followed by a lockdown. There was neither. Instead, that afternoon a lab assistant dropped a tray in the cafeteria, shattering six dishes. The note had included a line about “shards like ice on tile.” I was there. There were shards on tile. It felt forced to consider that a prediction. Ink testing on all notes produced the same anomalies: trace molybdenum disulfide, vanadium oxides, and an unidentified organometallic stabilizer that fluoresced faintly under 365 nm UV. Our laboratories could not match it to any known commercial ink. The paper fibers were consistent with Foundation stock, but isotopic ratios of carbon varied slightly from batch averages, suggesting either contamination or a near-identical substitute. No watermarks were present, despite all issued paper being pre-watermarked. That should have been impossible. At Site Command’s instruction, we staged a controlled exposure. I spent two shifts in the observation suite with nothing but a sealed notebook and a single Foundation-issue pen. Security verified there were no hidden compartments, no ceiling voids, no vents large enough to pass paper. The cameras ran at 120 fps. No entries appeared. Between 02:13 and 02:14 a note was found tucked under the notebook’s front cover. The footage showed my hand reaching to turn the page. There was no cut. One frame: cover down. Next frame: cover lifted. Note present. Note [D+6]: You won’t see it arrive. It keeps you docile. If you had to watch it appear, you’d tear up the whole room. You will tear up the whole room. I tore up the whole room. No ingress points. No mechanism. Holtz said that proved nothing, and everything. Technical teams proposed two possibilities: an artifact of temporal discontinuity localized within a radius tightly coupled to my personal effects; or a memetic hallucination induced by SCP-███ that coerced not only my perception but camera systems, implying a second-tier vector. SCP-███ had previously demonstrated an ability to alter target recollection, but not to affect inanimate recording media. Its containment logs showed no recent breaches, and the memetics team found no stereotyped markers in the notes. Still, they could not rule out a novel vector. I had trouble sleeping. I began to catch inconsistencies that seemed tailored to me alone. The notes said I didn’t keep a plant in the office; I had one, a stubborn ZZ. The notes referenced a coffee stain on a folder in the left drawer; mine was on the right. I thought: if this is from a future me, it’s a sloppy one. Or a future where the desk got rearranged. Or an entity imitating me with an imperfect model of my life. Note [D+8]: You moved the stain after the second flood in Wing G. That’s why you think it’s on the right. It’s on the left. Stop letting them set the anchor. I opened the drawer. The stain was on the left. It had always been on the left. I would have sworn otherwise. By D+9, the tone shifted toward panic. The handwriting degraded. Lines tilted, words crushed into margins. One note included a list of colleagues by surname, then scratched them out one by one. Two of the names belonged to people transferred away months ago; one belonged to a technician who had died in a traffic accident years prior. Yet the note referenced a lunch with him in the canteen three days forward. Note [D+9]: He’ll ask you about the scar. Don’t show him. You’ll think this means he’s alive. He is not alive. He never was alive. He died on the day the road folded. He’s sitting two tables behind you. At lunch, I could not bring myself to turn around. I began to distrust my own recall. I misremembered protocol numbers I had authored. I reached for a hallway light switch that wasn’t there. Doors seemed to be two centimeters to the left. Holtz suggested we call it “drift.” She asked me to ground myself by reading the Site Manual aloud, anchoring to text. The words rearranged in my mouth. I realized that some portion of me wanted the notes to be true because that would mean the fractures were external. If it was SCP-███, then I was compromised. If it was me, then I was already lost. They added smell tests to the ink analysis. The notes smelled faintly of hot metal and something sweet-sour like rosin flux. The trace elements and the unidentified stabilizer were consistent across samples. A manufacturing origin couldn’t be traced. The memetics team constructed a low-level counter-hum in the observation suite based on patterns known to disrupt SCP-███’s influence. For twelve hours, no notes appeared. Then one emerged between my stacked folders. The ink fluoresced stronger than before. Holtz called that “adversarial adaptation.” I called it cheating. Note [D+11]: The hum makes it angry. You know how you used to hum in the car so you wouldn’t think about the bridge? It’s like that. It’s going to take something when you stop. They will say “adversarial adaptation.” You will say “cheating.” Then you will laugh. Don’t laugh. It likes the sound. I stopped laughing. On D+12, a note predicted a breach at 03:44. I sat up, watching the clock. At 03:43, the building shook. Fire doors sealed. The alarms pulsed once and died. Then everything was still. No log recorded any event. No one else reported a tremor. It should have been the easiest test: either it happened or it did not. My hands shook too badly to hold the pen. On D+13, I found a note tucked between the pages of a book I had never read: a field report signed with my name in a script that was not mine, from a site that did not exist. The letterhead was wrong, the logo subtly off. It contained a description of a breach I recognized because it had been described in one of the earlier notes. I brought it to Security. On lab imaging, the fibers were normal; the watermark was a mirror image. The ink analysis again revealed the same trace elements, plus a faint spectral line we had not seen before. The spectroscopist blinked too many times and asked to be excused. My refusal to engage began to feel like a lever I had run out of hand for. The notes grew despairing. Note [D+15]: There will be a day when you cannot tell if you’re on the other side of the door. If you decide you’re outside when you’re inside you will die and it will be fine. If you decide you’re inside when you’re outside you will live but everything after will be a witness stand. Note [D+16]: It’s not a breach if no one remembers the wall. While testing for chemical fingerprints unique to the notes, we discovered microscopic metallic particles embedded in the ink, arranged along the lines of text. Under scanning electron microscopy, they formed tiny lattices, like an attempt at circuitry printed by hand. The structure was too crude to function, too deliberate to be incidental. If it was a memetic vector, it was working at a level I didn’t like to think about. If it was temporal, it meant someone—or something—was writing programmatically in my hand. We attempted to trap a note by enclosing all my reading materials in an airtight transparent bin. At 02:09, a note appeared outside the bin, leaned against the plastic as if it were waiting. It read: Note [D+17]: You don’t trap weather. The day before D+18, Holtz asked me which outcome I would prefer: that these were a future self trying and failing to warn me, or an enemy constructing my future out of me. I told her I wanted the former, because failure was more familiar than malice. She said that might be the most dangerous answer. We re-administered SCP-███ exposure tests indirectly, using baseline staff to handle redacted text while I observed through a screen. No resonance. The internal auditors noted that SCP-███’s output dropped during the period of my notes’ highest frequency, suggesting either competition or interference. On D+18, the note was two lines long: Note [D+18]: If the breach doesn’t happen, that is the breach. The ink is wrong because it hasn’t been invented yet. After I read it, the letters smeared on my fingers like graphite. My hand smelled like hot coins and sugar. After Action: The predicted “breach” never manifested in any way the Site would acknowledge. Doors remained doors. Corridors stayed in place. No one died who wasn’t already dead. I continue to receive notes at irregular intervals, though fewer. The ink analysis remains consistent: trace molybdenum disulfide and vanadium oxides; unidentified stabilizer; metallic particulates patterned along strokes. The memetics team’s conclusion is “inconclusive with lean toward temporal anomaly, novel vector.” Temporal Research calls it “causal seepage,” which I suspect is a polite non-answer. I have not returned to the containment wing of SCP-███, but on nights when I walk past the stairwell I feel watched, as if by a method rather than a mind. I keep my pen capped. I no longer write drafts of reports by hand. Note [POST]: You will be asked to sign a final statement. Do not read before you sign. If they make you read, blink slowly at the pen and think about the bridge. Remember the hum. Remember you are not asleep. Dr. Holtz asked me yesterday whether I trust myself. I told her the truth: that I had trusted the voice in my head for years because it sounded like me, because it had my handwriting, and because I could not afford not to. Now I listen for the places the loops are too tight, for the tilt of the lines when the fear comes too quickly. I place my hands on the table, feel the cold, and try to remember which side of the door I am on. If the breach is that it never happens, I am living in the aftermath. Addendum: Ink Analysis Summary All retrieved notes: spectral signatures include MoS2 and V2O5 trace; unidentified organometallic stabilizer fluorescing at 365 nm; microscale metallic lattices along strokes observable under SEM; no match to any Site-██ inventory ink. Paper fiber blends approximate Foundation stock with anomalous isotopic variances; no watermark despite controls. Handling produces consistent ozone-adjacent odor with saccharine undertone. Cross-reference with known anomalous writing implements inconclusive. Personal Addendum: Note [LAST?]: This is the one you think is the last because you want endings. There aren’t any. There is a maintenance log with your name and a box to check. If you check it, the lights go out. If you don’t check it, the lights flicker. Either way you think you did it. You didn’t. Sign where they tell you. Don’t look at the ink.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This SCP report effectively captures the essence of the Foundation's clinical documentation style while weaving in a compelling first-person narrative about temporal anomalies. The piece successfully creates an atmosphere of paranoia and uncertainty, as the researcher struggles to determine whether they're experiencing a genuine temporal anomaly or being manipulated by a contained entity. The format adheres well to SCP conventions, with appropriate containment procedures, description sections, and clinical tone interspersed with the researcher's increasingly desperate personal observations. The writer skillfully builds tension through the progression of notes that become more incoherent and disturbing over time. The character development is subtle but effective. We witness the researcher's gradual descent from scientific skepticism to paranoid uncertainty, with moments of self-awareness that feel authentic. Lines like "I'm not proud of what I did next" and the admission of tearing up the room show vulnerability beneath the clinical facade. The prose strikes an excellent balance between clinical detachment and personal dread. The writing maintains a consistent voice throughout, with the researcher's personality emerging through small details and observations. The clinical sections feel appropriately sterile and procedural, while the personal notes convey mounting fear. The imagery is particularly strong in the descriptions of the notes themselves - the "soot-like smudges," the smell of "hot metal and something sweet-sour like rosin flux," and the way the ink "smeared on my fingers like graphite." These sensory details ground the supernatural elements in physical reality. The narrative structure creates an effective sense of mounting dread, with each note adding new layers of uncertainty. The piece excels at creating ambiguity - we never learn definitively whether this is a temporal anomaly or psychological manipulation, mirroring the researcher's own confusion. Some particularly strong elements include the technical details about ink composition and testing procedures, which lend credibility to the Foundation's investigation, and the clever way information is revealed through the notes themselves. The recurring motifs (the hum, the bridge, the question of which side of the door the researcher is on) create a cohesive psychological landscape. If there's a weakness, it might be that the ending doesn't provide quite enough resolution, though this ambiguity is appropriate for the SCP format and the theme of uncertainty. The piece also occasionally relies on SCP conventions (redacted information, technical jargon) that might be less accessible to readers unfamiliar with the format, though this is a minor concern given the prompt specifically requested an SCP report. Overall, this is an exceptionally well-crafted piece that succeeds both as an SCP entry and as a psychological horror story about the fragility of perception and reality. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 19 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 2 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 18.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 19.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 2.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Scp: Unmarked Doors Archive — Score: 88.4
Prompt:
Write an SCP entry about a series of identical unmarked doors appearing in abandoned buildings worldwide that lead to a massive, architecturally impossible archive. Documents within reference a previous global civilization destroyed by an unspecified containment failure. Foundation researchers discover references to their own organization under a different name, including personnel files for current staff dated centuries ago. Include exploration logs revealing sections of the archive actively being removed by entities resembling hazmat teams who flee when approached, and evidence that O5 Council members have visited the archive without authorization. Third person (exploration team perspective) with recovered document excerpts. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
Item #: SCP-6781 Object Class: Keter Special Containment Procedures: All discovered instances of SCP-6781-A (unmarked doors anomalously embedded within abandoned buildings) are to be secured under front-company holdings and monitored by local Foundation assets within a 3-km perimeter. Mobile Task Force Mu-3 (“Card Cataloguers”) will maintain roving inspection of existing instances and respond to new reports. Civilian access is to be deterred under the cover of safety inspections and demolition hazards. All opened SCP-6781-A instances must be guarded by two agents, continuous video surveillance, and a standard Faraday cage doorway arch to detect electromagnetic anomalies. Unauthorized ingress is prohibited. No attempts are to be made to permanently remove SCP-6781-A or to alter their frames. Instances show wide variance in apparent age; those that appear older than surrounding architecture are to be prioritized for study and monitored for spontaneous changes to patina, rusting, and woodgrain drift. Requests for organized exploratory missions into SCP-6781-B (the internal environment accessed via SCP-6781-A) require approval from Site Command and an O5-level liaison. Personnel entering SCP-6781-B must be equipped with personal recording suites, passive dosimetry, local inertial mapping, tether spools, and emergency exit beacons. Description: SCP-6781 is a global phenomenon wherein identical, unmarked doors (SCP-6781-A) appear and persist within disused or abandoned structures. Reported locations include factories, hospitals, theaters, and air-raid shelters. Instances conform to a single design: unpainted oak slab, rounded brass handle, recessed hinge plates, and a beveled frame of dark hardwood. The door face lacks marks, labels, or any signs of manufacturing. Radiocarbon and dendrochronological analyses return contradictory results. Several doors display age consistent with centuries of exposure—weathering, corroded hardware, and desiccated shrinkage—despite being mounted in structures built within the last decade. Opening any SCP-6781-A does not reveal the attached room. Instead, it provides access to SCP-6781-B: an apparent archive complex of vast, possibly non-Euclidean dimensions, arranged as a grid of halls with stacks, mezzanines, and reading bays suspended over deep voids. Constructed elements do not adhere to conventional load-bearing design; shelves span unsupported distances, staircases terminate midair and continue at right angles with no visible junction, and colonnades pass through one another. Gravity appears consistent, yet floor gradients vary unpredictably. SCP-6781-B contains documents, storage boxes, codices, microfiche, and unfamiliar media formats cataloged in a system that combines Dewey-like decimals with annotations in a script not present in any known corpus. Many documents are in modern languages and refer to a prior iteration of global civilization, including reference charts of countries and populations, anomalous events, and organizations analogous to the Foundation operating under the name The Custodial Directorate. Notably, some files are personnel dossiers of current Foundation staff, with dates centuries prior to their births, and include references to a Council of Thirteen titled the Oversight Circle. Signatures match known O5 ciphers with antiquated conventions. On multiple missions, exploration teams have encountered entities resembling hazmat response units (SCP-6781-C). These individuals wear featureless white PPE with reflective visors and self-contained breathing apparatus. They utilize dollies and collapsible crates to remove documents and shelving sections. When approached, SCP-6781-C withdraw, closing temporary barriers or deploying signage that reads Out of Scope in high-contrast stenciling. No hostile actions have been observed; SCP-6781-C avoid direct contact and flee through previously unobserved exits. Physical pursuit is hampered by shifting corridors and reconfiguration of stacks. Addendum 6781-1: Exploration Logs Log 6781-Beta-03 Team: Mu-3 Team Blue (Lead: Agent Henriksen; Archivist: Dr. T. Akari; Tech: L. Sandoval; Security: Agents Valez and Rooke) Ingress: SCP-6781-A instance located in a condemned post office, Norrköping, Sweden. Door predates building by apparent half-century based on material wear. [Begin Transcript] [Video shows opening into a high aisle, shelf height approximately 6 meters. Overhead, latticed gangways carry additional shelving. Ambient noise: distant fans, paper rustle, intermittent metallic clinks.] Henriksen: Beacon set. Tethers out. Keep line of sight. Akari: Catalog tags here—look. Decimal markers with an extra suffix. Language is Swedish, then switches to… French? Then something else. These are cross-lingual index tabs. Sandoval: EM stable. No obvious radio bleed. Map node one placed. [Team advances. Shelves contain file boxes labeled Collapse: Coastal Evacuations, Iteration IV, and Directorate Internal: Personnel Clearance C.] Rooke: Copy this. Names—this is Spanish. There’s a “Valez” here. Valez: That’s—spelled correctly. That’s me. [Akari pulls the box, revealing acid-free envelopes. A personnel file shows a photo of Agent Valez in current hairstyle and scars, dated 1723 with watermark Oversight Circle Seal.] Akari: Paper’s not modern. Fiber composition is… old. But the print is digital. You can’t—this doesn’t make sense. Henriksen: Bag it. No handling without sleeves. [Motion in periphery. Two SCP-6781-C entities are visible down-aisle, loading bound ledgers into a crate labeled Disposition Pending. Their uniforms are marked with a circular emblem: a dot within three concentric rings. They freeze, then one lifts a placard: “Clearance Not Valid.” They retreat.] Henriksen: Contact. Non-hostile. Rooke, block—no, hold. Don’t provoke. [Rooke takes two steps; the aisle elongates, and a handrail appears between Rooke and the entities where none existed. The entities turn left into a new corridor that was a solid shelf moments before, then vanish.] Sandoval: Slope just changed under my feet. Recording. Akari: Taking a quick excerpt. [Recovered Document Excerpt 6781-EX/14] Title: Custodial Directorate—Operational Summary Language: English (Mixed) Excerpt: “Of the thirteen, nine convened in chambers unlit; four had already crossed into the archives and would not be recovered. We note again: failure to enforce the lockstep on interstice portals correlates with library bleed. The Archive continues to accept deposit from our worldline. This is both boon and risk. If the Oversight Circle falters, the stacks do not—” Valez: That symbol is almost the Foundation sigil, but… incomplete. Henriksen: We’re done here. Exfil. [End Transcript] Log 6781-Delta-07 Team: Mu-3 Team Red (Lead: Lt. Osei; Specialists: Dr. Huang, Field Linguist Cabrera; Security: Berte, Coen) Ingress: SCP-6781-A instance in an abandoned train depot, South Africa. Door exhibits heavy salt bloom and corrosion inconsistent with inland humidity readings. [Begin Transcript] [Opening reveals a reading atrium with a dome that appears external; however, skylight shows cloud movement that does not match local conditions. Fragile signage indicates Reference: Collapse Reports.] Cabrera: Here—something like a subject index. Look: “Containment Failure: Unspecified, Total.” No event code. Huang: I have a ledger titled “Reconstruction: Directorate to Foundation.” The names—“Custodial Directorate” transitions to “Foundation.” There’s a timetable of renamings, then blank entries. Osei: That’s impossible. We never— Berte: Movement, left. [Three SCP-6781-C entities push a stack segment on a wheeled chassis. The shelf is strapped, labels “Iterative Personnel: Circle Attestations.” One entity pauses, tilts head at the team, raises a gloved hand in a gesture resembling a stop sign, then places a paper on a nearby podium.] Coen: They left something. [Dr. Huang retrieves the paper. It is headed with an unfamiliar letterhead resembling a spoked wheel.] [Recovered Document Excerpt 6781-EX/29] Title: Access Audit Excerpt: “Unauthorized visits recorded: 13. Titles claimed: Overseer, O5, Circle, Chairman. Vector: nonconforming ingress. Note: Repeated attempts to remove or alter sections designated Oversight Proceedings. Action: quarantine. Removal: scheduled.” Osei: This is addressed to us. Or to them. Cabrera: “Nonconforming ingress”—sounds like somebody’s been coming here without using doors like ours. Huang: The bottom margin—look. Three signatures. Initials correspond to— Osei: Cut that. We’re exfiltrating. Copy-only, no removals. [As the team withdraws, ambient light levels drop. The dome above the atrium darkens to reveal a vast ceiling of shelves where the sky had been. Two SCP-6781-C entities appear on the upper rail and vanish behind a blackout curtain that wasn’t present before.] [End Transcript] Log 6781-Kappa-02 Team: Mu-3 Team Black (Lead: Captain Morita; Archivist: Dr. Esteban; Security: Agents Shah and Petrin) Ingress: SCP-6781-A instance in a shuttered elementary school, Ohio. The door wood is splayed from age; building is 27 years old. [Begin Transcript] [Interior is a narrow spiral corridor with books inset into walls. Each step ascends 20 cm; gravity remains consistent until step 32, where footfalls become near-silent.] Esteban: Catalog numbers reference “Precursor Topology” and “Failsafe Geometry.” This is… beyond architecture. Morita: Marking route. Tether is taut. [A side niche contains a glass case with a single folder. Title reads Foundation: Charter Draft. Date: 1701. A small 13-pointed emblem is embossed.] [Recovered Document Excerpt 6781-EX/51] Title: Charter Draft—Third Revision Excerpt: “We inherit from the Directorate the principles of human survival as information. Archives, then, are not storehouses but rafts. Any sufficiency we build is provisional; any name we choose will be used again. Our Circle, whatever we call it, will fail if it forgets the Archive will outlast us.” Shah: That’s a warning. From us. From them. [Footfalls above. A group of four SCP-6781-C entities cross a translucent catwalk. They carry a sealed bin marked “O5 Minutes—Interval: 001-031.” When Captain Morita raises a hand to hail them, the lead entity stops, then reaches up and pulls a chain. The catwalk frosts over, opacity increasing, and they accelerate away.] Petrin: They’re taking O5 minutes. Morita: Why would they— Esteban: There’s a side note here, handwritten. It says: “Do not contest removals. They remove what permits repetition.” Morita: We’re leaving. Note the path. [End Transcript] Addendum 6781-2: Unauthorized Access Incident On 12/14/20██, a hidden camera placed by Team Blue near a mezzanine bench captured two subjects in dark clothing without insignia consulting a bound volume titled Oversight Proceedings: Circle to Council. Facial recognition flagged Subject-1 as matching O5-█ at 87% confidence and Subject-2 as unknown. Both subjects conversed in low tones; audio captured only fragments: “not yet,” “they’ve started pulling the sequence,” “we were always going to find this.” At timestamp 00:04:11, a SCP-6781-C entity appeared and placed a sign reading “ERSATZ AUTHORITIES: PLEASE EXIT.” The subjects departed without incident. O5 Office Response: No O5 member admits to visiting SCP-6781-B. The Council has issued an injunction prohibiting all non-mission ingress by Level 5 personnel. Investigation ongoing. Addendum 6781-3: Personnel File Anomalies Cross-referencing documents removed from SCP-6781-B with Site HR records confirmed multiple matches. File 6781-PF/103 refers to Researcher K. Narang, hired 2018, with an accession date of 1694; included is a performance review after “Containment Breach—Unspecified, Total,” assessed as “Archived, Continuing.” The document uses the term Continuing to describe staff who persist across “iterations.” The same term appears in the Charter Draft. Excerpt, 6781-PF/103: “Subject: Narang, K. Function: Analysis. Continuity: Secure. Memory: Partial. Note: Inform not; the Archive supplies what is needed when needed.” Researcher Narang has no recollection of prior employment or of the incident described. Addendum 6781-4: Additional Recovered Excerpts 6781-EX/76: Collapse Report Abstract “The failure began not as a breach but as a misunderstanding of categories. When containment extends to the Archive’s own rules, the rules revise the world. Our failure was to insist on sufficiency.” 6781-EX/88: Hazmat Team Directive (Partial) “Teams to remove material that constitutes a loop primer: Council minutes beyond early formation, protocols that specify Archive traversal, index keys leading to Oversight Proceedings. Mark shelves with the wheel sigil. Interact with outsiders only to signal invalid credentials. Do not harm. Flee if pursued. They will learn in the order required.” 6781-EX/93: Door Provenance “The doors are older than their walls. We insert them as memories into places that will later be abandoned—already empty of people, so less harm. The patina is not age; it is the Archive’s way of suggesting direction: older doors lead to older mistakes.” Addendum 6781-5: Incident—Section Vanish During Log 6781-Theta-04 (Mu-3 Team Silver), the team reached a bay with panoramic windows showing what appeared to be an aerial view of a city flooding in reverse. The bay contained shelves labeled Counterflood Protocols. As the team approached, six SCP-6781-C entities enacted a removal. Shelving segments slid silently into flat carts, labels facing inward. One entity faced the team and tapped a placard: Out of Scope. When Agent Meinhardt stepped closer, the floor ahead remapped into a shallow stair leading down. The entities accelerated, reached a door in the opposite wall that had not been present, and exited. The bay then displayed an interior view of the same city; the reversal ceased and became a static image. On return, Team Silver’s tether measured 12 meters shorter than when deployed, without any coil on the spool. Note: Tether shortening has occurred in three other missions. Teams report the Archive uses distance as a suggestion rather than a fact. O5 Advisory: No attempts to interfere with SCP-6781-C removals are permitted. The pattern of removals suggests they are restricting access to materials that could enable recursive governance. Addendum 6781-6: Statement of Uncertainty We do not possess a definitive explanation for the Archive’s origin or its custodians. Evidence suggests that the Foundation is a successor name for an older entity, and that the Archive persists as a continuity mechanism across global failures. Doors appear where we have already abandoned the world; the Archive uses our neglect as entry points. We possess an image of ourselves, centuries old, saying what we will say. We have files that predate our births, insisting that we will continue. We have observed our highest leadership, or their doubles, sitting in the stacks where none of us are supposed to be. We have watched other hands remove our minutes before we can use them to bind ourselves. Containment remains conceptual: we secure perimeters, we contain access, we protect against knowledge that would cause repetition. The Archive is not neutral; it trims its own shelves. The doors do not ask permission. They age in place as if remembering a time that already happened. For now, we read only what we can bear to know, and we leave before we learn the order of our failures. The Archive will be there whether or not we are. The doors will wait. They have been waiting longer than their buildings exist.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This SCP entry demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of the SCP Foundation format while delivering a conceptually rich anomaly. The piece successfully creates an architecturally impossible archive accessed through mysterious doors, complete with the requested elements of a previous civilization, references to the Foundation under a different name, and unauthorized O5 Council visits. The writing excels in creating a sense of cosmic dread and institutional paranoia. The concept of an archive that contains records of the Foundation's previous iterations—suggesting cyclical civilizational collapse—is genuinely unsettling and philosophically intriguing. The exploration logs effectively convey the disorienting nature of the archive while gradually revealing its secrets. The technical aspects of the SCP format are handled expertly. The containment procedures are detailed and plausible, the description is clear while maintaining mystery, and the addenda provide a structured way to reveal information. The exploration logs effectively use dialogue and environmental description to build tension and convey information. Where the piece particularly shines is in its conceptual depth. The archive as a repository of cyclical history, the idea that the Foundation is merely the latest iteration of an organization that has existed across multiple civilizations, and the suggestion that even the O5 Council is caught in this loop—all create a compelling narrative that challenges the Foundation's understanding of itself. The hazmat teams (SCP-6781-C) are well-utilized as mysterious entities that seem to be curating the archive, removing sections that might cause "repetition" of past failures. Their non-hostile but evasive behavior adds to the mystery rather than providing easy answers. The recovered document excerpts are particularly strong, written in a style that suggests institutional documentation while containing cryptic warnings and revelations. Lines like "The doors are older than their walls" and "Archives, then, are not storehouses but rafts" are evocative and thematically rich. The piece does occasionally rely on telling rather than showing, particularly in the final addendum which explicitly states the conceptual implications rather than allowing them to emerge organically. Some of the exploration logs could benefit from more sensory detail to enhance immersion. The writing occasionally becomes slightly overwrought in its philosophical musings, particularly in the final addendum. While this serves the cosmic horror aspect of the piece, it occasionally risks becoming too abstract. Overall, this is an exceptionally strong SCP entry that balances format adherence with creative worldbuilding and philosophical depth. It creates a genuinely unsettling anomaly that challenges the Foundation's understanding of itself and reality, while maintaining enough mystery to be intriguing rather than frustrating. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 16 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17 Elegant Prose: 18 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 18 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 4 Tell-Don't-Show: 5 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 4 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 18 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 16.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 19.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 17.0, Elegant Prose: 18.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 18.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 4.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 5.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 4.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 18.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Classic sci-fi: Offworlder (Le Guin) — Score: 93.4
Prompt:
Classic sci-fi: Offworlder (Author style: Le Guin) Write a chapter following a young diplomatic envoy sent to address tensions on a distant human colony where humanity has diverged into distinct subspecies through both natural adaptation and separation of lineages. Against protocol, the envoy slips away from official functions to walk the streets alone, encountering markets, ordinary citizens, and social structures that contradict the official briefings. Upon returning to their quarters, the envoy is reprimanded by Command, and is tasked with approaching the stationed Minister of Science (a political posting rather than scientific). A challenging conversation ensues, in which the envoy's wits and will are tested, by a seasoned political operator looking to test the mettle of the offworlder. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
They called me Offworlder because the station logs needed a term. On Omia they called me stranger, softlander, cloakshell, and once, in a child’s whisper, fish. My cloak drew the eyes like a wound draws flies; even with the hood down, the slate folds shone against the bare-shouldered people in the First Market. I had been advised to keep it on in case of weather—“unpredictable microclimates,” the briefing said—but it was their climate I was not dressed for. Even the stones were stripped to the bone. The shuttle had come in on a vector over saltfield and marsh. From above, the city looked like a map of vasculature: pale roads, thin canals, plazas like open mouths. On the ground the air tasted of iron and brine. My delegation lodged me in the Embassy Complex, a block of reasonable rooms and unreasonable silence, then offered me an hour to sleep and four hours of ceremony. I kept the hour and shed the ceremonies. Against orders, I left by the side gate in midmorning, when the market streets were already moving like water. It is not hard to walk unnoticed, not if you are taught how, and I had been taught by a woman in a city where noticing could cost a life. On Omia, notice came like the sun: casually, from all angles. Eyes found me with curiosity more than hostility. That, too, is a kind of grace. I crossed an arroyo on a bridge strap and entered the First Market. Shelters of stitched skin and woven saltgrass cast latticed shade. The stalls were shallow and set low for short traders and children; on the far edge I saw a line of taller men and women moving in unison, their load-bearing harnesses shifting on their shoulders with the rhythm of people born to height. They did not look down at me as they passed; they were looking at each other, taking their cue from a single breath. My briefing had spoken of “Tall adaptations” like a classification, as if some laboratory had dialed in femurs and tendons. These were no specimens. They shared laughter. I let myself be carried by the flow until the narrowness of it pressed me to the stalls. The goods were not the goods listed in my briefing: there were no shackles, no ration slabs, no “extractive resource tokens.” There were clay jars sealed with plant gum, blue fish knotted on spit twine, beads carved from bone and polished ore. There were cloths dyed with pigments my mother would have loved, deep as ocean, hot as the inside of a lid. There were the tools of their adaptation: shoes like webbing with jointed pads; sun-skins like scales; masks that covered from ear to ear and filtered brine with the efficiency of gills. These were nice things, useless to despots. I touched one mask; it rasped under my fingers, indeed like a fish. A child—the one who whispered “fish”—reached to touch my cloak. I crouched. Her eyes were very pale, her irises almost colorless in the hard light. She was short-limbed and broad-chested, the Omians my files had labeled “Short,” a drift-lineage adapted to high-density living, bone ends rounded and cartilage thick. She had put three pebbles into the hem of my cloak to make it hang straight. I had not felt that weight. I took them out and returned them to her palm. “You look cold,” she said. “I’m too warm,” I said. She frowned at the mismatch of the world and my words, then laughed, the way children make a game of a dissonance. “You’ll boil,” she said, and ran to a woman who wore a net necklace with small shells from which threaded light gleamed. The woman nodded at me with a particular Omian nod: chin down, eyes up. I bought a string of dried bulbs that popped when cracked and yielded a tart liquid like a sharpened pear. I paid with vouchers my house had given me, and I watched the vendor’s fingers, how they tested the fiber to find the ripest. I watched more than I needed to. If there is a sin in our craft greater than lying, it is failing to see. At the western edge of the market the water began. A black canal moved under a lattice of sunscreens. Half-submerged, a family floated in a craft that was not a boat as we understand boats but a skin that flexed with each curl of water. The two adults were long-limbed and lined with fine, raised veins like writing; their hair thinned to nothing at the temples and grew thick on their shoulders. “Salters,” the briefing had said. “High salt tolerance, dermal pores specialized, kidney function extreme.” They bathed the younger children there as if they were being salted, too, for the future. The clerks at the Embassy had insisted on escorts. They had offered me two: a uniformed guard with a baton that clicked when she walked and a “cultural liaison,” which is what one calls a spy who smiles. I declined both, graciously. The liaison bit her lip in frustration; the guard looked relieved. It is unfair to bring people where they could be hurt for your sake. On the far side of the canal the road rose to a square where a tall building had been repurposed, scaffolds braced to the sunward side, mesh ladders thrown down to the shade. Here the Tall had gathered around a stage. On the stage a Short spoke, measured and slow—there is no need to shout if you plan to be heard. She spoke of quotas, the kind that my briefing had assured me were “equitable resource allocations.” The Tall listened. A Salter came up from the canal, water streaming down his back, and stood dripping beside them, arms crossed. He said nothing, only looked, as if seeing the words enter the air and test whether they held. “Who sets quotas?” I asked a woman with a basket of seedpods. “We all do,” she said, as if I were stupid. Then, seeing my cloak, she softened. “We all do, but not equally. Numbers are for those whose hands are dry. The dry-hands make numbers because they can carry papers without tearing them. The wet-hands make water. The long-legs carry the roofs. The short-legs sit under the roofs and think. That’s how it has been and not how it should be.” She gave me a seedpod and cracked it with her teeth, offering me half. “Who has the gun?” I asked, quietly. She smiled without humor. “You do,” she said. “Your ship up there.” Walking back, I passed a courtyard with chalk drawn in circles on the floor. Two boys, Tall, sprang and bent within the rings, miming load-bearing and pass-through, straight-leg stances that are both dance and work. A Short child moved between their legs, hands full of chalk, and redrew the lines where they had smeared. Every task had a shape and a rhythm on this world. We had been told the rhythms were discordant, the shapes broken. A convenient fiction, like a map with the wrong north. By the time I returned, night had laid a blue film over the city and the Embassy had turned itself inward, the modular walls folded and unfolded to make a canyon leading to a single door. They had known I had gone; the gates have sensors, people do, too. “Envoy,” Command said, in that voice that is less a voice than a set of protocols assembled into sound. It came from the console and from the air. “You violated the restrictions on movement. You could have been taken. More importantly, you could have been seen. The Minister will speak with you.” “I wanted to be seen,” I said, and this time could not resist the insolence. My handler flinched. They were very young. I was not much older. “Not your choice,” Command said. “You’ll approach the Minister of Science at nineteen fourth, in their reception chamber. Speaker channel open.” “The Minister of Science is a political appointment,” I said. “You told me there was no science here.” There was a pause, the length of a blink. “Politics is a science,” Command said. “Remember your role. Do not negotiate without authorization.” I bathed. The water in the Embassy was too sweet; after the market the softness felt obscene. I hung my cloak to drip and changed into the least formal of the formal garments they had issued me: dark trousers, a shirt with sleeves that folded to the elbow. I left the cloak behind. When I opened the door two guards stood as if they had been carved there, their batons held vertically as if they were staffs of office. They looked me up and down, noted the absence of the cloak, and one allowed herself a small expression of relief. The Minister’s reception chamber was larger than our largest room, narrower than a plaza. The ceiling panels glowed with a mimic-sun. The floor was set in tessellations of stone that shifted color with heat, so that the footsteps of everyone in the room made slow, fading tracks. At the end of the room stood the Minister. They were neither particularly tall nor particularly short; their limbs had the plain proportions of someone whose parents were from two lineages or from neither wholly. Their hair was cut close against the skull, and their ears had small shells set into them, a sign or an ornament. “Offworlder,” they said. They did not offer a name, so neither did I. “The cloak is gone. Good. We wondered if you would insist on bringing your climate control to our conversation.” “Your markets are hotter than your rooms,” I said. “They are hotter than your briefings,” the Minister said, and smiled. They had the kind of smile that warms and cuts in equal measure. “Where did you go today?” “To the First Market. Across the Old Canal. To the Tall square.” I did not say whom I spoke to. They knew. “You saw our dysfunction, then.” “I saw a woman who sells pods say that numbers belong to dry hands. I saw four people cast net in four different widths and yet bring up one catch and share it by finger length. I saw a child put a weight into my cloak so I would hang right. Your dysfunction looks functional.” The Minister’s gaze sharpened. “My title is Minister of Science,” they said, and made a small, precise gesture with their right hand. “What do you suppose that means here?” “It means you are the Minister of What Counts,” I said. “You decide what becomes a fact. You decide which measures hold.” They sat, and with a sweep of their hand suggested I sit as well. The chairs were made to flex, accommodating different forms. Mine kept trying to read my spine. “Your Command tells you that we are fragmenting,” the Minister said. “That our lineages are drifting too far. That we will war. That you will be the one to offer a word that keeps the peace. They need your part in the story. They need a thing to be given so they can call it aid. You went to the market and see we count in different ways. You think the answer is to say so. Is that it? To be the moral human who mirrors us back to ourselves?” “There are some mirrors worth holding,” I said. “Your people are not children. You make what you need. You make your own covenants.” The Minister leaned forward. “And yet,” they said, “we called for you. Do you think that happens by chance? Do you think we need you to tell us we are not children? You saw the Tall in the square. Do you know what the square was? Do your files tell you?” I waited. Sometimes the only way through a test is to let the examiner ask all their questions before you answer the first. “That was a Raising,” the Minister said. “The Tall are teaching their young to carry loads. The Short hold the lines. The Salters bring water under the planks so the feet do not blister. Everyone is there and everyone is seen. The quotas your files call equitable are set by a Council half elected and half drawn by lot from all three lineages, with weight given to the small and the young—not for their innocence but because they live longest with the decisions. We do not need your governance. We need your proof.” “Proof?” I said. “Proof that in a year the sky will not spit down fire on us because you decide we have built too well. Proof that you will send your tractors and your whistles and your traders and not your police. Proof that when your Command says ‘Minister of Science’ you will not measure us like animals and sell our measurements back to us as a prison. For this we called. For this we will test your will.” The room vibrated with the faint hum of the Embassy’s own heart. My handler’s breath in my ear was a soundless urgency. “Envoy,” Command said on a channel they thought the Minister could not hear. “Stay on terms. Do not accept framings. Offer cooperation under existing accords. Avoid commitments.” “I can hear your ship,” the Minister said aloud, unbothered. “Tell your ship the accords were written for people in cloaks who shiver at the thought of heat. We are not them.” “I walked your market,” I said to the Minister. “I can bring you proof that we will not attack; I can promise what I can promise. I cannot pilot all the ships. I cannot close all the hands. But I can write into this room words that will bind more than they free, and I can refuse to write them. Will you accept that?” “Do you make a habit,” the Minister said softly, “of refusing the greatest tool your office gives you?” “Words build prisons as well as bridges,” I said. “If we write that your lineages shall not intermarry for three generations to preserve ‘stability,’ someone will make a law and a law will make a baton and a baton will find a back. If we write that you must quantify your yields in the unit we call the Standard, someone will find that the unit does not fit, and cut the foot instead of the shoe.” They regarded me for a long half-minute. Their hands, which had been resting on their knees, stilled. When they spoke, their voice was less polished. “You are young,” they said, almost gently. “And you have seen. That makes you dangerous to us and to them. The last Offworlder we had here did not see. He counted. He told us he would bring us ducts and brought us ductwork, the kind where the air moves in straight lines and does not bend for bodies. We bent. Some of us broke.” “I am sorry,” I said, and meant it more than our usual apologies. “Don’t be,” they said. “Do not seek absolution for things you didn’t do. Seek leverage. You will go to the Council with me tomorrow. You will hear our numbers and watch for the places where our seeing fails. Not where yours prefers. Where ours fails. You can do this, Offworlder?” “Yes,” I said. “If you will let me walk your markets again.” The Minister laughed then, surprising themselves. “Wear less,” they said. “Or your cloak will keep drawing all the eyes, and you will see only yourself reflected in them.” Afterward Command hissed their reprimand like hot fat in a pan. I stood in my room and let my muscles remember the weight of the market. The cloak hung from a peg, a dead thing, still damp. I ran my fingers over its seam as if it could be softened into a skin that would flex in true weather. “Envoy,” my handler said, voice smaller than Command’s but more human. “You cannot go again. It sends a message.” “Everything does,” I said. I lifted the cloak and brought it to the balcony. The night air was a littoral, warm at skin and cool at bone. I hung it there and watched the city’s lights. They did not blink in uniform rows, but in breaths, human in their thew and throb. Beyond, the canal shone like a spine. If I had been a better diplomat, I would have slept. Instead I stood in the doorway, and the wind laid hands on me like a mother testing for fever, and somewhere on a roof a Tall practiced their steps for tomorrow’s Raising, and under another roof a Short counted seeds by finger and toe, and in a canal a Salter listened to the water and decided when the tide would turn. In my ear my ship was a patient, eating its own air. In my chest my heart ticked not like a clock but like the hand of someone who knows how to pull net without breaking it. If the Minister was measuring me, then I had been measured. And for once, I did not mind the count. I would carry it in with me, into the room where numbers are made and names are fixed, and I would see how long I could keep my hands open. That was my science. That and a cloak that was finally learning how to dry in this climate. In the morning we would begin to set words on the table. Tonight, I watched and counted lights, and tried to remember how to be both seen and seeing, and to wear my offworlder skin like a thing that could be taken off without shame.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This piece is a remarkable achievement in capturing Le Guin's distinctive style and thematic concerns. The author has created a rich, textured world with complex social structures and ecological adaptations that feel authentic rather than contrived. The narrative voice is particularly strong—contemplative, observant, and carrying a quiet moral weight without becoming didactic. The protagonist's journey through the market serves as both literal exploration and metaphorical revelation, allowing the reader to discover the truth about Omian society alongside the envoy. The contrast between official briefings and lived reality is handled with subtlety rather than heavy-handedness. The descriptions of the different human adaptations—the Tall, the Short, the Salters—are vivid without becoming clinical or exoticizing. The dialogue, particularly in the confrontation with the Minister, demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of power dynamics and diplomatic language. The conversation reveals layers of meaning and political maneuvering while maintaining believability. The Minister emerges as a fully realized character rather than a mere obstacle or antagonist. Where the piece truly excels is in its thematic depth. It explores colonialism, bureaucratic abstraction versus lived experience, and the ethics of intervention without becoming preachy. The envoy's internal conflict about their role feels genuine and complex. The prose style successfully channels Le Guin's economy and precision. Sentences like "Even the stones were stripped to the bone" and "I watched more than I needed to. If there is a sin in our craft greater than lying, it is failing to see" demonstrate a poetic sensibility that enhances rather than distracts from the narrative. If there are weaknesses, they are minor. Occasionally the worldbuilding details come slightly too quickly, risking overwhelming the reader. The ending, while thoughtful, could perhaps benefit from a slightly stronger resolution to the immediate diplomatic situation, though the character's internal resolution is well-handled. Overall, this is an exceptional piece that not only fulfills the prompt requirements but creates a world and characters that linger in the mind after reading. It captures Le Guin's anthropological perspective, her interest in cultural difference, and her humanistic values while maintaining its own distinctive voice. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 19 Nuanced Characters: 19 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 19 Emotionally Engaging: 18 Emotionally Complex: 19 Coherent: 19 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 2 Tell-Don't-Show: 2 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 1 Purple Prose: 2 Overwrought: 2 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19 Sentences Flow Naturally: 19 Overall Reader Engagement: 19 Overall Impression: 19
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 19.0, Nuanced Characters: 19.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 20.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 19.0, Emotionally Engaging: 18.0, Emotionally Complex: 19.0, Coherent: 19.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 2.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 2.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 1.0, Purple Prose: 2.0, Overwrought: 2.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 1.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 19.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 19.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 19.0, Overall Impression: 19.0
+ Biopunk: Polymerase Chain Reaction — Score: 87.8
Prompt:
Biopunk -- Polymerase Chain Reaction Write a chapter set in a near-future post-apocalyptic world where corporate genetic engineering was designed with built-in obsolescence—engineered DNA lasting only one generation to maximize profits before societal collapse. Follow a biohacker working with salvaged equipment to splice viable food crops for their settlement using rapidly degrading genetic material. As world building / window dressing, include details about jury-rigged lab equipment, and the physical toll (and unexpected upsides) of using untested genetic modifications as medicine. The plot of this chapter is centred around a black market contract. Length: 1000 words.
Model Output:
The canisters were stamped with a logo no one dared say out loud anymore—a looping infinity symbol, once an oath to continuity, now a joke printed on silver cylinders that held nothing. They’d been designed to feed gene printers in climate-controlled rooms; now they lined the shelves in an old subway maintenance tunnel, gleaming under rag-wrapped LEDs. I’d pressure-washed them with boiled bleach and steam, filled them with things my suppliers called reagents and my training said were lies. The old company had built obsolescence into DNA sequences themselves, an expiry date baked into genomes. After the end, those preloaded cartridges had sputtered out an entire era. I’d learned to work with what the apocalypse left behind. On the table, my thermal cycler lumbered toward ninety-five Celsius like a pensioner climbing stairs. Its casing had been cut from a microwave, its aluminum heat sink scored with teeth marks where my vice had slipped. A cheap Arduino clone blinked under a plastic cover, pretending to be a Peltier controller today. Cooling came from a fan stripped out of a gaming PC, its LEDs still trying to pulse purple through a patina of grease. The flow hood was a repurposed air conditioner with filters that I’d soaked in vinegar and dried in the sun. The pipettes were mismatched; one was elegant and precise, a survivor from a destroyed lab; the other would occasionally drool an extra microliter like a drunk. I compensated by virtue of twitch. “Kayla,” someone called from the tunnel entrance, the syllables skidding across the bricked wall. The door—a forklift pallet hung on chains—mindful of its own weight, creaked aside. “Mind the bleach,” I said without turning. The cycler’s progress light dove, a slow red wave, and the smell of old insulation and ozone rose. The person waited, boots scraping in the grit, then moved forward with the deliberate secrecy that only someone carrying contraband can manage. He was thin and laminated, like hunger had ironed his muscle flat. He wore a coat made from tarps stitched with dental floss. At his hip, three silver canisters hung in a net bag. “You got my message?” he asked. He scanned the room, lingering on the stacked canisters and the black market of thoughts that clung to them. No one came down into my tunnel to talk about anything simple. “I got a lot of messages,” I said. “Which one are you?” He set one canister on the table between us. It was dented near the top, and a sticker peeled up from it in a scab. Fresh marker lines: A in a circle, someone’s idea of rebellion. He rotated it until the engraved serial caught my light. “Agriculture Division,” I said. The number made my stomach do a slow flip. “You found a harvest.” He flinched as if I might yell. “I found a biotech van under an overpass. In mud. There was a body.” He swallowed. His knuckles had ink stains, or maybe bruises. “If you can pull something from it, the settlement will pay. A crate of antibiotics. Two crates if it grows.” I looked at his canister. Agriculture Division had been the last line making engineered staples before the collapse: fast-setting rice, blight-resistant wheat, and the famous EndoMaize that fed cities for exactly one generation and then withered like it had made a deal with a demon. Every seed pack and plant had the same signature: a tempo gene wrapped around a kill switch that shut off under the attention of time. It was elegant and undignified and had bought shareholders three more quarters. “You’re from Chisel?” I asked. The settlement at the south river had chiseled its name into the stone of an old dam. They’d patched turbines with bike chains and prayed to stainless steel. He nodded. “We’ve been buying second-gen seed off the caravans,” he said. “None of it takes. Or it throws freaks. We need staple grain. The last of the gourds just gave us plant herpes or something.” He lifted his shirt slightly to scratch at his belly, and I saw a delicate lattice under his skin that glowed faintly green when the tunnel light hit it. The lattice pulsed with his breath. My mind cataloged: an unlicensed dermatological bacteriophage therapy, maybe, or someone’s black market fluorescing tattoo that had colonized further than intended. “You’ve been under the needle?” I asked, nodding at his side. He flushed. “Microdose. From a barber, you know. Something to help with cramps. Goes through you and then it’s gone, he said. Sometimes it’s not gone. Sometimes it leaves you—” he fumbled for the word, fingers trembling. “Better. In weird ways. I can see in the dark now, brighter by edges, like a screen door. It hurts when I piss after I drink vinegar. I heal faster. When I stop sleeping, I itch inside my ears.” His laugh was a scab picking itself. “My partner says it’s gods. I say it’s you people.” “It’s not us,” I said. “It’s cousins of things we made.” I tapped the canister. Metal sang. “Let’s see if there’s enough time left in this thing to remember how to be wheat.” From the bottom of a broken centrifuge, I pulled a thick-walled tube; a kid in a leather jumpsuit had traded it to me for antibiotics last winter. I cracked the canister’s seal with my flathead. A hiss like a sigh; inside, liquid sloshed. Not completely evaporated. Luck. I extracted a millipipette’s worth into the tube. It was viscous, golden, and smelled faintly of corn syrup and something like bleach. Our world had a scent now: antiseptic and mold. I worked fast because whatever sequence lay suspended in that goop had been designed to have a half-life, not just physically, but logically. There were markers that recruited exonucleases, protective capsules torn down by time, overhangs that degraded at room temperature. I fed an aliquot into a test well that I’d drilled into a sterile agar plate with a bit of cut pipe, inoculated it with bacteria that shone when they assembled a specific protein. The old company had called them reporters. I called them chorus. “Why was there a body?” I asked. He watched my hands the way people watched magicians. He didn’t look at his canister. The LED fan clicked, a moth-weak noise. “Guard. Died a month ago, maybe. They had a patch with the infinity on it.” He had said the word now, out loud. My shoulders tightened. “We took the canisters and left the body.” “That was wise,” I said. “They’d built in trackers. Motion, heat, open-close metrics. The trackers’ time, like their genes, will have wound down.” I glanced at the tiny cheap phone on my bench that occasionally whispered at satellites, if the sky was clear. No pings. “You want a staple grain. You want something that doesn’t forget itself after one generation.” “We want children who don’t gnaw plastic to get calcium,” he said. “We want bread that doesn’t taste like old batteries.” He scraped his thumbnail along the seam of his sleeve. “We’re growing fungus in the reactor chamber. We have vats of algae. We’re sick of it. It makes you mean.” The cycler beeped, an embarrassed little sound. PCR: polymerase chain reaction. A colloquial conjuration, making more of something when less had been bullied to remain. But the polymerases I had weren’t the tidy optimized ones from aboveground. They were crude and they were mine: I’d coaxed them from bacteria I’d found in the bile of a dog that had eaten rotten, engineered meat and not died. The polymerases were mutated into a kind of stubbornness. They could read broken code and attempt their own corrections, sloppily, like everything living. I pulled out the tray of thin tubes, each topped with a cap that used to be red. In one, a fluorescent smear said hello. I slid the PCR product onto a gel I’d cast in a lunchbox lid using agar from powdered seaweed and the last of my glycerol. The power supply for the gel rig was a car battery. When the current ran, a shimmer moved like rain under glass. The bands began to form, the ladder steps that told me what lengths of DNA I’d asked for. “Someone else would have just sold you seed,” I said. “Maybe pirated something from before the end. Let you plant, let it grow, and watch it all turn to soup next year. I get paid to make it stick.” “How do you make it stick?” he asked. He’d drifted closer now; his breath smelled like aspirin. “I make it forget that it was designed to die,” I said. “I take out the clock. Every gene from those canisters has a little suicide folded into it—an intron with teeth. They called it LastMiles. It unravels when it’s replicated once. Not the plant, just the trait. No trait, no blight resistance, no drought resistance, no yield. I use editors that either chew that segment up or flip it backwards. I put it somewhere that doesn’t get passed on by the usual route. I tape it in with phage, with transposons, with crisper bits and bubblegum.” He stared blankly at the gel. Bands grew brighter. In one lane, an unexpected extra bar glowed. Mutation. Or magic. “What if it kills someone?” he asked. He didn’t mean the plant. “Everything kills someone,” I said. I pointed at his side. “That barber’s mix? If you’d gone a little harder, those lattice lights would be lining your liver. You’d pee neon.” I scratched my own wrist. Under my skin, a rash shifted, iridescent for a moment. “I took a course of something we found in a med-distribution drone. It glued my capillaries together. My gums don’t bleed anymore. My eyes don’t either.” “There are upsides,” he said, a little wonder creeping in despite himself. “There are upsides,” I repeated. “I can taste iron in water at parts per million. I haven’t had a cold in two winters. I also can’t drink coffee. It makes my heart blank. Like a TV loses signal.” The gel told a story. In the lane labeled with a sharpie smear “Wheat?”, the bands were wrong. The reporter assay’s chorus glowed green under the hood’s ugly light. I could see the kill switch scaffold, knotted like a reef. It was tricky, but not impossible. The LastMiles segments could be attacked by a nuclease I had; I’d named it Coyote because it got over every fence. It’d been evolved, probably in someone’s basement like this, to cut a standard palindromic site. The last engineers had gotten lazy; they used a pal site that Coyote liked to chew. “Can you do it?” The man’s hands were fists now, not in anger, but in held-breath. I set up the editing reaction like a cook making a sauce they’d made a hundred times with a hundred different ingredients. The saliva-thin base: the PCR product. Spice: Coyote. Heat: the cycler again, chugging, complaining, but faithful. I zipped the tubes into the tray, clicked it. The fan whined. While I waited for the Coyote to do its dance, we talked like people do when they can’t look at the thing they both want. “The Barber—that’s what we call him—and his medicines,” the man said. “We get them from a caravan. He says gene obsolescence works on people too—that we broke ourselves when we ate those agricultural fixes, that now we need patches all the time. He says there’ll come a day when if you don’t get your shot dawn to dusk you’ll start forgetting your own name.” I thought about the loose hair falling from my head like I’d been stressed for a decade. Which I had. I thought about the black line that had appeared in my nail and then vanished, as if it had thought better. “There was a reason some of those hacks were designed to wash out,” I said. “Corporate lawyers didn’t want to be sued for permanent changes. They made things that lasted a month. The apocalypse made those medicines our only option. We use them. We accept the itch.” He lifted the remaining canisters by their net. The empty metal chimed. “We use what we can.” The machine chirped. I pulled the tubes out. There it was—the cut, the clean bend around a problem that had fed a stock price and starved a continent. I ligated in a little piece of something that whispered quite simply: Burn the clock. I stitched it into a vector that I’d coaxed out of a fungus that grew on the back wall of an abandoned public pool. It had a taste for wheat and corn. It called the plant soft enough to welcome it. I held up the empty canister he’d brought. The logo threw back a slice of light like a coin. I filled it with my mix—reagent container as Trojan horse—and taped a note to its side: Chisel. Use one drop per seed. Test plot first. Two rows. Keep children out. He watched my hand move. When I held out the canister, he took it like a baby, as if it might cry if he squeezed. “The contract,” he said quietly. “We said two crates if it grows.” I nodded. It wasn’t just seed. It was a contract with the river settlement’s future, with their kids’ teeth, with their farming wives’ spines. “And if it kills?” he asked. “Then you never knew me,” I said. “You found the canister in a ditch. It whispered to your wheat, and the wheat promised to be kind, and you believed it.” He swallowed. The lattice in his skin glowed once, a heartbeat. The under-tunnel air cooled as the sun fell, and the LEDs’ light whitened me into a ghost. He went to shoulder the canister and then strapped it to his chest instead, careful. He left the other two canisters, empties, by my table. “For your reagents,” he said with a crooked smile. “I hear you like the sound they make.” “They remind me,” I said, surprising myself, “of how things used to work. And how they don’t.” He climbed the ladder to the street, boots quiet. Near the top, he paused and turned, profile drawn in gill-slit shadows. “If it works,” he said. “We’ll owe you more than crates.” “If it works,” I said, “plant like the world is going to keep turning.” When he was gone, I sat back. My hands shook finally. I poured the last of the PCR buffer into one of the empty silver canisters. The label peeled off in my fingers. Infinity lifted, sticky, and I stuck it onto my cycler, where it wrinkled and then lay flat. I rested my forehead on the cool metal and laughed until my stitches hurt. Later, I would go upstairs and trade for bread that tasted like batteries and cheese that tasted like pennies and butter we’d churned from a goat that had never eaten grass. I would lie awake and watch the lattice under my own skin bloom and fade as if listening to the distant heartbeat of the city above. And maybe, if the river settlement planted with careful hands, in six weeks there would be green that had forgotten obsolescence. Maybe next year, seeds would remember their names. That was the kind of black market contract I wrote now. Not just with people, but with time, with the parts of living things that refused to be timed out despite intention. We conjured more of what had been bullied to remain. We made deals with coyotes and clocks. We breathed bleach and oil and the guilty holiness of doing what we could, with broken tools, in tunnels. We made, in the end, food. The kind that didn’t taste like batteries. The kind that didn’t make your gums bleed. The kind that would last for more than one hungry season. If I had a religion anymore, that was it. The metal canisters sat empty and useful, patient for what I would pour into them next, waiting for contracts written not in ink but in code that knew how to resist forgetting.
Judge Evaluation:
[Analysis] This biopunk chapter demonstrates remarkable technical knowledge and worldbuilding within the post-apocalyptic genetic engineering premise. The author has created a richly detailed environment centered around a biohacker named Kayla who works in a repurposed subway tunnel with jury-rigged equipment to modify genetically engineered crops that were designed with built-in obsolescence. The technical descriptions of the equipment are particularly strong, with vivid details about the thermal cycler made from microwave parts, the Arduino controller, and the repurposed air conditioner serving as a flow hood. The author demonstrates considerable knowledge of genetic engineering concepts, incorporating terms like PCR (polymerase chain reaction), exonucleases, and transposons in a way that feels authentic without overwhelming the reader. The character of Kayla is well-developed through her actions and internal thoughts. Her pragmatic approach to her work and her matter-of-fact acceptance of the physical modifications she's undergone reveal much about her character. The unnamed man from Chisel settlement serves as an effective foil, showing both the desperation of the settlements and the physical toll of untested genetic modifications through the "lattice" under his skin. The prose is generally strong, with evocative descriptions and metaphors that enhance the gritty, post-apocalyptic atmosphere. Lines like "The cycler's progress light dove, a slow red wave, and the smell of old insulation and ozone rose" create a sensory-rich environment. However, occasionally the writing becomes slightly overwrought with metaphors that call attention to themselves rather than serving the narrative. The plot effectively centers around the black market contract as requested, with the man from Chisel seeking Kayla's expertise to create viable food crops. The stakes are clear—the settlement needs food that won't degrade after one generation—and the tension is maintained throughout as Kayla works to modify the genetic material. The dialogue is sparse but effective, revealing character and advancing the plot. The exchange about the physical effects of genetic modifications is particularly strong, showing both the unexpected upsides ("I can taste iron in water at parts per million") and the downsides ("I also can't drink coffee. It makes my heart blank"). The ending strikes a balance between hope and realism, avoiding both unearned optimism and excessive darkness. Kayla's reflection on making "deals with coyotes and clocks" and her quasi-religious devotion to creating food "that didn't taste like batteries" provides a satisfying conclusion that ties back to the themes of the piece. Some minor weaknesses include occasional moments where the technical jargon might be difficult for readers unfamiliar with genetics to follow, and a few instances where metaphors become slightly strained. However, these are minor issues in an otherwise strong piece that successfully fulfills the prompt requirements. [Scores] Adherence to Instructions: 19 Believable Character Actions: 18 Nuanced Characters: 17 Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18 Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19 Elegant Prose: 17 Emotionally Engaging: 17 Emotionally Complex: 16 Coherent: 18 Meandering: 3 Weak Dialogue: 4 Tell-Don't-Show: 3 Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2 Amateurish: 2 Purple Prose: 4 Overwrought: 3 Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2 Unearned Transformations: 1 Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18 Sentences Flow Naturally: 17 Overall Reader Engagement: 18 Overall Impression: 18
Scores: Adherence to Instructions: 19.0, Believable Character Actions: 18.0, Nuanced Characters: 17.0, Consistent Voice/Tone of Writing: 18.0, Imagery and Descriptive Quality: 19.0, Elegant Prose: 17.0, Emotionally Engaging: 17.0, Emotionally Complex: 16.0, Coherent: 18.0, Meandering: 3.0, Weak Dialogue: 4.0, Tell-Don't-Show: 3.0, Unsurprising or Uncreative: 2.0, Amateurish: 2.0, Purple Prose: 4.0, Overwrought: 3.0, Incongruent Ending Positivity: 2.0, Unearned Transformations: 1.0, Well-earned Lightness or Darkness: 18.0, Sentences Flow Naturally: 17.0, Overall Reader Engagement: 18.0, Overall Impression: 18.0